Title: Their Pilgrimage
Subject:
Author: Charles Dudley Warner
Keywords:
Creator:
PDF Version: 1.2
Page No 1
Their Pilgrimage
Charles Dudley Warner
Page No 2
Table of Contents
Their Pilgrimage.................................................................................................................................................1
Charles Dudley Warner ............................................................................................................................1
I. FORTRESS MONROE .......................................................................................................................1
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY .......................................................................................................9
III. THE CATSKILLS ..........................................................................................................................18
IV. NEWPORT .....................................................................................................................................27
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND
PLYMOUTH ........................................................................................................................................40
VI. MANCHESTERBYTHESEA, ISLES OF SHOALS ..............................................................50
VII. BAR HARBOR .............................................................................................................................55
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR ...................................................................................66
IX. OLD SWEET AND WHITE SULFUR ..........................................................................................73
X. LONG BRANCH, OCEAN GROVE ..............................................................................................77
XI. SARATOGA ...................................................................................................................................80
XII. LAKE GEORGE, AND SARATOGA AGAIN ............................................................................86
XIII. RICHFIELD SPRINGS, COOPERSTOWN ...............................................................................89
XIV. NIAGARA ...................................................................................................................................94
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES ............................................................................................................99
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX ...........................................................................................106
Their Pilgrimage
i
Page No 3
Their Pilgrimage
Charles Dudley Warner
I. FORTRESS MONROE
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY
III. THE CATSKILLS
IV. NEWPORT
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH
VI. MANCHESTERBYTHESEA, ISLES OF SHOALS
VII. BAR HARBOR
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR
IX. OLD SWEET AND WHITE SULFUR
X. LONG BRANCH, OCEAN GROVE
XI. SARATOGA
XII. LAKE GEORGE, AND SARATOGA AGAIN
XIII. RICHFIELD SPRINGS, COOPERSTOWN
XIV. NIAGARA
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX
I. FORTRESS MONROE
When Irene looked out of her stateroom window early in the morning of the twentieth of March, there was a
softness and luminous quality in the horizon clouds that prophesied spring. The steamboat, which had left
Baltimore and an arctic temperature the night before, was drawing near the wharf at Fortress Monroe, and the
passengers, most of whom were seeking a mild climate, were crowding the guards, eagerly scanning the long
facade of the Hygeia Hotel.
"It looks more like a conservatory than a hotel," said Irene to her father, as she joined him.
"I expect that's about what it is. All those long corridors above and below enclosed in glass are to protect the
hothouse plants of New York and Boston, who call it a Winter Resort, and I guess there's considerable winter
in it."
"But how charming it isthe soft sea air, the low capes yonder, the sails in the opening shining in the haze,
and the peaceful old fort! I think it's just enchanting."
"I suppose it is. Get a thousand people crowded into one hotel under glass, and let 'em buzz aroundthat
seems to be the present notion of enjoyment. I guess your mother'll like it."
And she did. Mrs. Benson, who appeared at the moment, a little flurried with her hasty toilet, a stout,
matronly person, rather overdressed for traveling, exclaimed: "What a homelike looking place! I do hope the
Stimpsons are here!"
Their Pilgrimage 1
Page No 4
"No doubt the Stimpsons are on hand," said Mr. Benson. "Catch them not knowing what's the right thing to
do in March! They know just as well as you do that the Reynoldses and the Van Peagrims are here."
The crowd of passengers, alert to register and secure rooms, hurried up the windy wharf. The interior of the
hotel kept the promise of the outside for comfort. Behind the glassdefended verandas, in the spacious office
and general loungingroom, seacoal fires glowed in the wide grates, tables were heaped with newspapers
and the illustrated pamphlets in which railways and hotels set forth the advantages of leaving home; luxurious
chairs invited the lazy and the tired, and the hotelbureau, telegraphoffice, railwayoffice, and postoffice
showed the newcomer that even in this resort he was still in the centre of activity and uneasiness. The
Bensons, who had fortunately secured rooms a month in advance, sat quietly waiting while the crowd filed
before the register, and took its fate from the courteous autocrat behind the counter. "No room," was the
nearly uniform answer, and the travelers had the satisfaction of writing their names and going their way in
search of entertainment. "We've eight hundred people stowed away," said the clerk, "and not a spot left for a
hen to roost."
At the end of the file Irene noticed a gentleman, clad in a perfectly fitting rough traveling suit, with the
inevitable crocodile handbag and tightlyrolled umbrella, who made no effort to enroll ahead of any one
else, but having procured some letters from the postoffice clerk, patiently waited till the rest were turned
away, and then put down his name. He might as well have written it in his hat. The deliberation of the man,
who appeared to be an old traveler, though probably not more than thirty years of age, attracted Irene's
attention, and she could not help hearing the dialogue that followed.
"What can you do for me?"
"Nothing," said the clerk.
"Can't you stow me away anywhere? It is Saturday, and very inconvenient for me to go any farther."
"Cannot help that. We haven't an inch of room."
"Well, where can I go?"
"You can go to Baltimore. You can go to Washington; or you can go to Richmond this afternoon. You can go
anywhere."
"Couldn't I," said the stranger, with the same deliberation"wouldn't you let me go to Charleston?"
"Why," said the clerk, a little surprised, but disposed to accommodate "why, yes, you can go to Charleston.
If you take at once the boat you have just left, I guess you can catch the train at Norfolk."
As the traveler turned and called a porter to reship his baggage, he was met by a lady, who greeted him with
the cordiality of an old acquaintance and a volley of questions.
"Why, Mr. King, this is good luck. When did you come? have you a good room? What, no, not going?"
Mr. King explained that he had been a resident of Hampton Roads just fifteen minutes, and that, having had a
pretty good view of the place, he was then making his way out of the door to Charleston, without any
breakfast, because there was no room in the inn.
"Oh, that never'll do. That cannot be permitted," said his engaging friend, with an air of determination.
"Besides, I want you to go with us on an excursion today up the James and help me chaperon a lot of young
Their Pilgrimage
Their Pilgrimage 2
Page No 5
ladies. No, you cannot go away."
And before Mr. Stanhope Kingfor that was the name the traveler had inscribed on the registerknew
exactly what had happened, by some mysterious power which women can exercise even in a hotel, when they
choose, he found himself in possession of a room, and was gayly breakfasting with a merry party at a little
round table in the dining room.
"He appears to know everybody," was Mrs. Benson's comment to Irene, as she observed his greeting of one
and another as the guests tardily came down to breakfast. "Anyway, he's a genteellooking party. I wonder if
he belongs to Sotor, King and Co., of New York?"
"Oh, mother," began Irene, with a quick glance at the people at the next table; and then, "if he is a genteel
party, very likely he's a drummer. The drummers know everybody."
And Irene confined her attention strictly to her breakfast, and never looked up, although Mrs. Benson kept
prattling away about the young man's appearance, wondering if his eyes were dark blue or only dark gray,
and why he didn't part his hair exactly in the middle and done with it, and a full, close beard was becoming,
and he had a good, frank face anyway, and why didn't the Stimpsons come down; and, "Oh, there's the Van
Peagrims," and Mrs. Benson bowed sweetly and repeatedly to somebody across the room.
To an angel, or even to that approach to an angel in this world, a person who has satisfied his appetite, the
spectacle of a crowd of people feeding together in a large room must be a little humiliating. The fact is that
no animal appears at its best in this necessary occupation. But a hotel breakfastroom is not without interest.
The very way in which people enter the room is a revelation of character. Mr. King, who was put in good
humor by falling on his feet, as it were, in such agreeable company, amused himself by studying the guests as
they entered. There was the portly, florid man, who "swelled" in, patronizing the entire room, followed by a
meek little wife and three timid children. There was the broad, dowager woman, preceded by a meek,
shrinking little man, whose whole appearance was an apology. There was a modest young couple who looked
exceedingly selfconscious and happy, and another couple, not quite so young, who were not conscious of
anybody, the gentleman giving a curt order to the waiter, and falling at once to reading a newspaper, while
his wife took a listless attitude, which seemed to have become second nature. There were two very tall, very
graceful, very highbred girls in semimourning, accompanied by a nice lad in tight clothes, a model of
propriety and slender physical resources, who perfectly reflected the gracious elevation of his sisters. There
was a preponderance of women, as is apt to be the case in such resorts. A fact explicable not on the theory
that women are more delicate than men, but that American men are too busy to take this sort of relaxation,
and that the care of an establishment, with the demands of society and the worry of servants, so draw upon
the nervous energy of women that they are glad to escape occasionally to the irresponsibility of hotel life. Mr.
King noticed that many of the women had the unmistakable air of familiarity with this sort of life, both in the
diningroom and at the office, and were not nearly so timid as some of the men. And this was very
observable in the case of the girls, who were chaperoning their mothers shrinking women who seemed a
little confused by the bustle, and a little awed by the machinery of the great caravansary.
At length Mr. King's eye fell upon the Benson group. Usually it is unfortunate that a young lady should be
observed for the first time at table. The act of eating is apt to be disenchanting. It needs considerable
infatuation and perhaps true love on the part of a young man to make him see anything agreeable in this
performance. However attractive a girl may be, the man may be sure that he is not in love if his admiration
cannot stand this test. It is saying a great deal for Irene that she did stand this test even under the observation
of a stranger, and that she handled her fork, not to put too fine a point upon it, in a manner to make the
fastidious Mr. King desirous to see more of her. I am aware that this is a very unromantic view to take of one
of the sweetest subjects in life, and I am free to confess that I should prefer that Mr. King should first have
seen Irene leaning on the balustrade of the gallery, with a rose in her hand, gazing out over the sea with "that
Their Pilgrimage
Their Pilgrimage 3
Page No 6
faraway look in her eyes." It would have made it much easier for all of us. But it is better to tell the truth,
and let the girl appear in the heroic attitude of being superior to her circumstances.
Presently Mr. King said to his friend, Mrs. Cortlandt, "Who is that cleverlooking, graceful girl over there?"
"That," said Mrs. Cortlandt, looking intently in the direction indicated "why, so it is; that's just the thing,"
and without another word she darted across the room, and Mr. King saw her in animated conversation with
the young lady. Returning with satisfaction expressed in her face, she continued, "Yes, she'll join our
partywithout her mother. How lucky you saw her!"
"Well! Is it the Princess of Paphlagonia?"
"Oh, I forgot you were not in Washington last winter. That's Miss Benson; just charming; you'll see. Family
came from Ohio somewhere. You'll see what they arebut Irene! Yes, you needn't ask; they've got money,
made it honestly. Began at the bottomas if they were in training for the presidency, you knowthe mother
hasn't got used to it as much as the father. You know how it is. But Irene has had every advantagethe best
schools, masters, foreign travel, everything. Poor girl! I'm sorry for her. Sometimes I wish there wasn't any
such thing as education in this country, except for the educated. She never shows it; but of course she must
see what her relatives are."
The Hotel Hygeia has this advantage, which is appreciated, at least by the young ladies. The United States
fort is close at hand, with its quota of young officers, who have the leisure in times of peace to prepare for
war, domestic or foreign; and there is a naval station across the bay, with vessels that need fashionable
inspection. Considering the acknowledged scarcity of young men at wateringplaces, it is the duty of a
paternal government to place its military and naval stations close to the fashionable resorts, so that the young
women who are studying the german [(dance) D.W.] and other branches of the life of the period can have
agreeable assistants. It is the charm of Fortress Monroe that its heroes are kept from ennui by the company
assembled there, and that they can be of service to society.
When Mrs. Cortlandt assembled her party on the steamtug chartered by her for the excursion, the army was
very well represented. With the exception of the chaperons and a bronzed veteran, who was inclined to direct
the conversation to his Indian campaigns in the Black Hills, the company was young, and of the age and
temper in which everything seems fair in love and war, and one that gave Mr. King, if he desired it, an
opportunity of studying the girl of the periodthe girl who impresses the foreigner with her extensive
knowledge of life, her fearless freedom of manner, and about whom he is apt to make the mistake of
supposing that this freedom has not perfectly welldefined limits. It was a delightful day, such as often
comes, even in winter, within the Capes of Virginia; the sun was genial, the bay was smooth, with only a
light breeze that kept the water sparkling brilliantly, and just enough tonic in the air to excite the spirits. The
little tug, which was pretty well packed with the merry company, was swift, and danced along in an
exhilarating manner. The bay, as everybody knows, is one of the most commodious in the world, and would
be one of the most beautiful if it had hills to overlook it. There is, to be sure, a tranquil beauty in its wooded
headlands and long capes, and it is no wonder that the early explorers were charmed with it, or that they lost
their way in its inlets, rivers, and bays. The company at first made a pretense of trying to understand its
geography, and asked a hundred questions about the batteries, and whence the Merrimac appeared, and where
the Congress was sunk, and from what place the Monitor darted out upon its big antagonist. But everything
was on a scale so vast that it was difficult to localize these petty incidents (big as they were in consequences),
and the party soon abandoned history and geography for the enjoyment of the moment. Song began to take
the place of conversation. A couple of banjos were produced, and both the facility and the repertoire of the
young ladies who handled them astonished Irene. The songs were of love and summer seas, chansons in
French, minor melodies in Spanish, plain declarations of affection in distinct English, flung abroad with
classic abandon, and caught up by the chorus in lilting strains that partook of the bounding, exhilarating
Their Pilgrimage
Their Pilgrimage 4
Page No 7
motion of the little steamer. Why, here is material, thought King, for a troupe of bacchantes, lighthearted
leaders of a summer festival. What charming girls, quick of wit, dashing in repartee, who can pick the strings,
troll a song, and dance a brando!
"It's like sailing over the Bay of Naples," Irene was saying to Mr. King, who had found a seat beside her in
the little cabin; "the guitar strumming and the impassioned songs, only that always seems to me a
manufactured gayety, an attempt to cheat the traveler into the belief that all life is a holiday. This is
spontaneous."
"Yes, and I suppose the ancient Roman gayety, of which the Neapolitan is an echo, was spontaneous once. I
wonder if our society is getting to dance and frolic along like that of old at Baiae!"
"Oh, Mr. King, this is an excursion. I assure you the American girl is a serious and practical person most of
the time. You've been away so long that your standards are wrong. She's not nearly so knowing as she seems
to be."
The boat was preparing to land at Newport Newsa sand bank, with a railway terminus, a big elevator, and
a hotel. The party streamed along in laughing and chatting groups, through the warehouse and over the tracks
and the sandy hillocks to the hotel. On the way they captured a novel conveyance, a cart with an ox harnessed
in the shafts, the property of an aged negro, whose white hair and variegated raiment proclaimed him an
ancient Virginian, a survival of the war. The company chartered this establishment, and swarmed upon it till
it looked like a Neapolitan 'calesso', and the procession might have been mistaken for a harvest homethe
harvest of beauty and fashion. The hotel was captured without a struggle on the part of the regular occupants,
a dance extemporized in the diningroom, and before the magnitude of the invasion was realized by the
garrison, the dancing feet and the laughing girls were away again, and the little boat was leaping along in the
Elizabeth River towards the Portsmouth Navyyard.
It isn't a model war establishment this Portsmouth yard, but it is a pleasant resort, with its stately barracks and
open square and occasional trees. In nothing does the American woman better show her patriotism than in her
desire to inspect naval vessels and understand drydocks under the guidance of naval officers. Besides some
old war hulks at the station, there were a couple of trainingships getting ready for a cruise, and it made one
proud of his country to see the interest shown by our party in everything on board of them, patiently listening
to the explanation of the breechloading guns, diving down into the between decks, crowded with the
schoolboys, where it is impossible for a man to stand upright and difficult to avoid the stain of paint and tar,
or swarming in the cabin, eager to know the mode of the officers' life at sea. So these are the little places
where they sleep? and here is where they dine, and here is a librarya haphazard case of books in the
saloon.
It was in running her eyes over these that a young lady discovered that the novels of Zola were among the
nautical works needed in the navigation of a ship of war.
On the returnand the twenty miles seemed short enoughlunch was served, and was the occasion of a
good deal of hilarity and innocent badinage. There were those who still sang, and insisted on sipping the
heeltaps of the morning gayety; but was King mistaken in supposing that a little seriousness had stolen upon
the partya serious intention, namely, between one and another couple? The wind had risen, for one thing,
and the little boat was so tossed about by the vigorous waves that the skipper declared it would be imprudent
to attempt to land on the Rip Raps. Was it the thought that the day was over, and that underneath all chaff
and hilarity there was the question of settling in life to be met some time, which subdued a little the high
spirits, and gave an air of protection and of tenderness to a couple here and there? Consciously, perhaps, this
entered into the thought of nobody; but still the old story will go on, and perhaps all the more rapidly under a
mask of raillery and merriment.
Their Pilgrimage
Their Pilgrimage 5
Page No 8
There was great bustling about, hunting up wraps and lost parasols and mislaid gloves, and a chorus of
agreement on the delight of the day, upon going ashore, and Mrs. Cortlandt, who looked the youngest and
most animated of the flock, was quite overwhelmed with thanks and congratulations upon the success of her
excursion.
"Yes, it was perfect; you've given us all a great deal of pleasure, Mrs. Cortlandt," Mr. King was saying, as he
stood beside her, watching the exodus.
Perhaps Mrs. Cortlandt fancied his eyes were following a particular figure, for she responded, "And how did
you like her?"
"Like herMiss Benson? Why, I didn't see much of her. I thought she was very intelligentseemed very
much interested when Lieutenant Green was explaining to her what made the drydock drybut they were all
that. Did you say her eyes were gray? I couldn't make out if they were not rather blue after alllarge,
changeable sort of eyes, long lashes; eyes that look at you seriously and steadily, without the least bit of
coquetry or worldliness; eyes expressing simplicity and interest in what you are sayingnot in you, but in
what you are saying. So few women know how to listen; most women appear to be thinking of themselves
and the effect they are producing."
Mrs. Cortlandt laughed. "Ah; I see. And a little 'sadness' in them, wasn't there? Those are the most dangerous
eyes. The sort that follow you, that you see in the dark at night after the gas is turned off."
"I haven't the faculty of seeing things in the dark, Mrs. Cortlandt. Oh, there's the mother!" And the shrill
voice of Mrs. Benson was heard, "We was getting uneasy about you. Pa says a storm's coming, and that you'd
be as sick as sick."
The weather was changing. But that evening the spacious hotel, luxurious, perfectly warmed, and well
lighted, crowded with an agreeable if not a brilliant companyfor Mr. King noted the fact that none of the
gentlemen dressed for dinnerseemed all the more pleasant for the contrast with the weather outside. Thus
housed, it was pleasant to hear the waves dashing against the breakwater. Just by chance, in the ballroom, Mr.
King found himself seated by Mrs. Benson and a group of elderly ladies, who had the perfunctory air of
liking the mild gayety of the place. To one of them Mr. King was presented, Mrs. Stimpsona stout woman
with a broad red face and fishy eyes, wearing an elaborate head dress with purple flowers, and attired as if
she were expecting to take a prize. Mrs. Stimpson was loftily condescending, and asked Mr. King if this was
his first visit. She'd been coming here years and years; never could get through the spring without a few
weeks at the Hygeia. Mr. King saw a good many people at this hotel who seemed to regard it as a home.
"I hope your daughter, Mrs. Benson, was not tired out with the rather long voyage today."
"Not a mite. I guess she enjoyed it. She don't seem to enjoy most things. She's got everything heart can wish
at home. I don't know how it is. I was tellin' pa, Mr. Benson, today that girls ain't what they used to be in my
time. Takes more to satisfy 'em. Now my daughter, if I say it as shouldn't, Mr. King, there ain't a better
appearin,' nor smarter, nor more dutiful girl anywherewell, I just couldn't live without her; and she's had
the best schools in the East and Europe; done all Europe and Rome and Italy; and after all, somehow, she
don't seem contented in Cyrusvillethat's where we live in Ohioone of the smartest places in the state;
grown right up to be a city since we was married. She never says anything, but I can see. And we haven't
spared anything on our house. And societythere's a great deal more society than I ever had."
Mr. King might have been astonished at this outpouring if he had not observed that it is precisely in hotels
and to entire strangers that some people are apt to talk with less reserve than to intimate friends.
Their Pilgrimage
Their Pilgrimage 6
Page No 9
"I've no doubt," he said, "you have a lovely home in Cyrusville."
"Well, I guess it's got all the improvements. Pa, Mr. Benson, said that he didn't know of anything that had
been left out, and we had a man up from Cincinnati, who did all the furnishing before Irene came home."
"Perhaps your daughter would have preferred to furnish it herself?"
"Mebbe so. She said it was splendid, but it looked like somebody else's house. She says the queerest things
sometimes. I told Mr. Benson that I thought it would be a good thing to go away from home a little while and
travel round. I've never been away much except in New York, where Mr. Benson has business a good deal.
We've been in Washington this winter."
"Are you going farther south?"
"Yes ; we calculate to go down to the New Orleans Centennial. Pa wants to see the Exposition, and Irene
wants to see what the South looks like, and so do I. I suppose it's perfectly safe now, so long after the war?"
"Oh, I should say so."
"That's what Mr. Benson says. He says it's all nonsense the talk about what the South 'll do now the
Democrats are in. He says the South wants to make money, and wants the country prosperous as much as
anybody. Yes, we are going to take a regular tour all summer round to the different places where people go.
Irene calls it a pilgrimage to the holy places of America. Pa thinks we'll get enough of it, and he's determined
we shall have enough of it for once. I suppose we shall. I like to travel, but I haven't seen any place better
than Cyrusville yet.
As Irene did not make her appearance, Mr. King tore himself away from this interesting conversation and
strolled about the parlors, made engagements to take early coffee at the fort, to go to church with Mrs.
Cortlandt and her friends, and afterwards to drive over to Hampton and see the copper and other colored
schools, talked a little politics over a late cigar, and then went to bed, rather curious to see if the eyes that
Mrs. Cortlandt regarded as so dangerous would appear to him in the darkness.
When he awoke, his first faint impressions were that the Hygeia had drifted out to sea, and then that a dense
fog had drifted in and enveloped it. But this illusion was speedily dispelled. The window ledge was piled
high with snow. Snow filled the air, whirled about by a gale that was banging the windowshutters and
raging exactly like a Northern tempest.
It swirled the snow about in waves and dark masses interspersed with rifts of light, dark here and luminous
there. The RipRaps were lost to view. Out at sea black clouds hung in the horizon, heavy reinforcements for
the attacking storm. The ground was heaped with the still fast falling snowten inches deep he heard it
said when he descended. The Baltimore boat had not arrived, and could not get in. The waves at the wharf
rolled in, black and heavy, with a sullen beat, and the sky shut down close to the water, except when a sudden
stronger gust of wind cleared a luminous space for an instant. Stormbound: that is what the Hygeia wasa
winter resort without any doubt.
The hotel was put to a test of its qualities. There was no getting abroad in such a storm. But the Hygeia
appeared at its best in this emergency. The long glass corridors, where no one could venture in the arctic
temperature, gave, nevertheless, an air of brightness and cheerfulness to the interior, where big fires blazed,
and the company were exalted into goodfellowship and gayetya decorous Sunday gayety by the
elemental war from which they were securely housed.
Their Pilgrimage
Their Pilgrimage 7
Page No 10
If the defenders of their country in the fortress mounted guard that morning, the guests at the Hygeia did not
see them, but a good many of them mounted guard later at the hotel, and offered to the young ladies there that
protection which the brave like to give the fair. Notwithstanding this, Mr. Stanhope King could not say the
day was dull. After a morning presumably spent over works of a religious character, some of the young
ladies, who had been the life of the excursion the day before, showed their versatility by devising serious
amusements befitting the day, such as twenty questions on Scriptural subjects, palmistry, which on another
day is an aid to mild flirtation, and an exhibition of mindreading, not publicoh, dear, nobut with a
favored group in a private parlor. In none of these groups, however, did Mr. King find Miss Benson, and
when he encountered her after dinner in the readingroom, she confessed that she had declined an invitation
to assist at the mind reading, partly from a lack of interest, and partly from a reluctance to dabble in such
things.
"Surely you are not uninterested in what is now called psychical research?" he asked.
"That depends," said Irene. "If I were a physician, I should like to watch the operation of the minds of
'sensitives' as a pathological study. But the experiments I have seen are merely exciting and unsettling,
without the least good result, with a haunting notion that you are being tricked or deluded. It is as much as I
can do to try and know my own mind, without reading the minds of others."
"But you cannot help the endeavor to read the mind of a person with whom you are talking."
"Oh, that is different. That is really an encounter of wits, for you know that the best part of a conversation is
the things not said. What they call mindreading is a vulgar business compared to this. Don't you think so, Mr.
King?"
What Mr. King was actually thinking was that Irene's eyes were the most unfathomable blue he ever looked
into, as they met his with perfect frankness, and he was wondering if she were reading his present state of
mind; but what he said was, "I think your sort of mindreading is a good deal more interesting than the
other," and he might have added, dangerous. For a man cannot attempt to find out what is in a woman's heart
without a certain disturbance of his own. He added, "So you think our society is getting too sensitive and
nervous, and inclined to make dangerous mental excursions?"
"I'm afraid I do not think much about such things," Irene replied, looking out of the window into the storm.
"I'm content with a very simple faith, even if it is called ignorance."
Mr. King was thinking, as he watched the clear, spirited profile of the girl shown against the white tumult in
the air, that he should like to belong to the party of ignorance himself, and he thought so long about it that the
subject dropped, and the conversation fell into ordinary channels, and Mrs. Benson appeared. She thought
they would move on as soon as the storm was over. Mr. King himself was going south in the morning, if
travel were possible. When he said goodby, Mrs. Benson expressed the pleasure his acquaintance had given
them, and hoped they should see him in Cyrusville. Mr. King looked to see if this invitation was seconded in
Irene's eyes; but they made no sign, although she gave him her hand frankly, and wished him a good journey.
The next morning he crossed to Norfolk, was transported through the snow covered streets on a sledge, and
took his seat in the cars for the most monotonous ride in the country, that down the coastline.
When next Stanhope King saw Fortress Monroe it was in the first days of June. The summer which he had
left in the interior of the Hygeia was now outofdoors. The winter birds had gone north; the summer birds
had not yet come. It was the interregnum, for the Hygeia, like Venice, has two seasons, one for the
inhabitants of colder climes, and the other for natives of the country. No spot, thought our traveler, could be
more lovely. Perhaps certain memories gave it a charm, not well defined, but still gracious. If the house had
Their Pilgrimage
Their Pilgrimage 8
Page No 11
been empty, which it was far from being, it would still have been peopled for him. Were they all such
agreeable people whom he had seen there in March, or has one girl the power to throw a charm over a whole
wateringplace? At any rate, the place was full of delightful repose. There was movement enough upon the
water to satisfy one's lazy longing for life, the waves lapped soothingly along the shore, and the broad bay,
sparkling in the sun, was animated with boats, which all had a holiday air. Was it not enough to come down
to breakfast and sit at the low, broad windows and watch the shifting panorama? All about the harbor slanted
the white sails; at intervals a steamer was landing at the wharf or backing away from it; on the wharf itself
there was always a little bustle, but no noise, some pretense of business, and much actual transaction in the
way of idle attitudinizing, the colored man in castoff clothes, and the colored sister in sunbonnet or turban,
lending themselves readily to the picturesque; the scene changed every minute, the sail of a tiny boat was
hoisted or lowered under the window, a dashing cutter with its uniformed crew was pulling off to the German
manofwar, a puffing little tug dragged along a line of barges in the distance, and on the horizon a fleet of
coasters was working out between the capes to sea. In the open window came the fresh morning breeze, and
only the softened sounds of the life outside. The ladies came down in cool muslin dresses, and added the
needed grace to the picture as they sat breakfasting by the windows, their figures in silhouette against the blue
water.
No wonder our traveler lingered there a little! Humanity called him, for one thing, to drive often with
humanely disposed young ladies round the beautiful shore curve to visit the schools for various colors at
Hampton. Then there was the evening promenading on the broad verandas and out upon the miniature pier, or
at sunset by the waterbatteries of the old fort such a peaceful old fortress as it is. All the morning there
were "inspections" to be attended, and nowhere could there be seen a more agreeable mingling of war and
love than the spacious, treeplanted interior of the fort presented on such occasions. The shifting figures of
the troops on parade; the martial and daring manoeuvres of the regimental band; the groups of ladies seated
on benches under the trees, attended by gallants in uniform, momentarily off duty and full of information, and
by gallants not in uniform and never off duty and desirous to learn; the ancient guns with French arms and
English arms, reminiscences of Yorktown, on one of which a pretty girl was apt to be perched in the act of
being photographedall this was enough to inspire any man to be a countryman and a lover. It is beautiful to
see how fearless the gentle sex is in the presence of actual war; the prettiest girls occupied the front and most
exposed seats; and never flinched when the determined columns marched down on them with drums beating
and colors flying, nor showed much relief when they suddenly wheeled and marched to another part of the
parade in search of glory. And the officers' quarters in the casemateswhat will not women endure to serve
their country! These quarters are mere tunnels under a dozen feet of earth, with a door on the parade side and
a casement window on the outsidea damp cellar, said to be cool in the height of summer. The only excuse
for such quarters is that the women and children will be comparatively safe in case the fortress is bombarded.
The hotel and the fortress at this enchanting season, to say nothing of other attractions, with laughing eyes
and slender figures, might well have detained Mr. Stanhope King, but he had determined upon a sort of
roving summer among the resorts of fashion and pleasure. After a long sojourn abroad, it seemed becoming
that he should know something of the floating life of his own country. His determination may have been
strengthened by the confession of Mrs. Benson that her family were intending an extensive summer tour. It
gives a zest to pleasure to have even an indefinite object, and though the prospect of meeting Irene again was
not definite, it was nevertheless alluring. There was something about her, he could not tell what, different
from the women he had met in France. Indeed, he went so far as to make a general formula as to the
impression the American women made on him at Fortress Monroethey all appeared to be innocent.
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY
Of course you will not go to Cape May till the season opens. You might as well go to a racetrack the day
there is no race." It was Mrs. Cortlandt who was speaking, and the remonstrance was addressed to Mr.
Stanhope King, and a young gentleman, Mr. Graham Forbes, who had just been presented to her as an artist,
Their Pilgrimage
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY 9
Page No 12
in the railway station at Philadelphia, that comfortable home of the tired and bewildered traveler. Mr. Forbes,
with his fresh complexion, closely cropped hair, and London clothes, did not look at all like the traditional
artist, although the sharp eyes of Mrs. Cortlandt detected a small sketchbook peeping out of his side pocket.
"On the contrary, that is why we go," said Mr. King. "I've a fancy that I should like to open a season once
myself."
"Besides," added Mr. Forbes, "we want to see nature unadorned. You know, Mrs. Cortlandt, how people
sometimes spoil a place."
"I'm not sure," answered the lady, laughing, "that people have not spoiled you two and you need a rest.
Where else do you go?"
"Well, I thought," replied Mr. King, "from what I heard, that Atlantic City might appear best with nobody
there."
"Oh, there's always some one there. You know, it is a winter resort now. And, by the way But there's my
train, and the young ladies are beckoning to me." (Mrs. Cortlandt was never seen anywhere without a party of
young ladies.) "Yes, the Bensons passed through Washington the other day from the South, and spoke of
going to Atlantic City to tone up a little before the season, and perhaps you know that Mrs. Benson took a
great fancy to you, Mr. King. Goodby, au revoir," and the lady was gone with her bevy of girls, struggling
in the stream that poured towards one of the wicketgates.
"Atlantic City? Why, Stanhope, you don't think of going there also?"
"I didn't think of it, but, hang it all, my dear fellow, duty is duty. There are some places you must see in order
to be well informed. Atlantic City is an important place; a great many of its inhabitants spend their winters in
Philadelphia."
"And this Mrs. Benson?"
"No, I'm not going down there to see Mrs. Benson."
Expectancy was the word when our travelers stepped out of the car at Cape May station. Except for some
people who seemed to have business there, they were the only passengers. It was the ninth of June.
Everything was readythe sea, the sky, the delicious air, the long line of graycolored coast, the omnibuses,
the array of hotel tooters. As they stood waiting in irresolution a grave man of middle age and a disinterested
manner sauntered up to the travelers, and slipped into friendly relations with them. It was impossible not to
incline to a person so obliging and well stocked with local information. Yes, there were several good hotels
open. It didn't make much difference; there was one near at hand, not pretentious, but probably as
comfortable as any. People liked the table; last summer used to come there from other hotels to get a meal.
He was going that way, and would walk along with them. He did, and conversed most interestingly on the
way. Our travelers felicitated themselves upon falling into such good hands, but when they reached the hotel
designated it had such a gloomy and in fact boardinghouse air that they hesitated, and thought they would
like to walk on a little farther and see the town before settling. And their friend appeared to feel rather grieved
about it, not for himself, but for them. He had moreover, the expression of a fisherman who has lost a fish
after he supposed it was securely hooked. But our young friends had been angled for in a good many waters,
and they told the landlord, for it was the landlord, that while they had no doubt his was the best hotel in the
place, they would like to look at some not so good. The one that attracted them, though they could not see in
what the attraction lay, was a tall building gay with fresh paint in many colors, some pretty window
balconies, and a portico supported by high striped columns that rose to the fourth story. They were fond of
Their Pilgrimage
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY 10
Page No 13
color, and were taken by six little geraniums planted in a circle amid the sand in front of the house, which
were waiting for the season to open before they began to grow. With hesitation they stepped upon the newly
varnished piazza and the newly varnished office floor, for every step left a footprint. The chairs, disposed in a
long line on the piazza, waiting for guests, were also varnished, as the artist discovered when he sat in one of
them and was held fast. It was all fresh and delightful. The landlord and the clerks had smiles as wide as the
open doors; the waiters exhibited in their eagerness a good imitation of unselfish service.
It was very pleasant to be alone in the house, and to be the firstfruits of such great expectations. The first
man of the season is in such a different position from the last. He is like the King of Bavaria alone in his
royal theatre. The ushers give him the best seat in the house, he hears the tuning of the instruments, the
curtain is about to rise, and all for him. It is a very cheerful desolation, for it has a future, and everything
quivers with the expectation of life and gayety. Whereas the last man is like one who stumbles out among the
empty benches when the curtain has fallen and the play is done. Nothing is so melancholy as the shabbiness
of a wateringplace at the end of the season, where is left only the echo of past gayety, the last guests are
scurrying away like leaves before the cold, rising wind, the varnish has worn off, shutters are put up, booths
are dismantled, the shows are packing up their tawdry ornaments, and the autumn leaves collect in the corners
of the gaunt buildings.
Could this be the Cape May about which hung so many traditions of summer romance? Where were those
crowds of Southerners, with slaves and chariots, and the haughtiness of a caste civilization, and the belles
from Baltimore and Philadelphia and Charleston and Richmond, whose smiles turned the heads of the last
generation? Had that gay society danced itself off into the sea, and left not even a phantom of itself behind?
As he sat upon the veranda, King could not rid himself of the impression that this must be a mocking dream,
this appearance of emptiness and solitude. Why, yes, he was certainly in a delusion, at least in a reverie. The
place was alive. An omnibus drove to the door (though no sound of wheels was heard); the waiters rushed
out, a fat man descended, a little girl was lifted down, a pretty woman jumped from the steps with that little
extra bound on the ground which all women confessedly under forty always give when they alight from a
vehicle, a large woman lowered herself cautiously out, with an anxious look, and a file of men stooped and
emerged, poking their umbrellas and canes in each other's backs. Mr. King plainly saw the whole party hurry
into the office and register their names, and saw the clerk repeatedly touch a bell and throw back his head and
extend his hand to a servant. Curious to see who the arrivals were, he went to the register. No names were
written there. But there were other carriages at the door, there was a pile of trunks on the veranda, which he
nearly stumbled over, although his foot struck nothing, and the chairs were full, and people were strolling up
and down the piazza. He noticed particularly one couple promenadinga slender brunette, with a brilliant
complexion; large dark eyes that made constant playcould it be the belle of Macon?and a gentleman of
thirtyfive, in black frockcoat, unbuttoned, with a widebrimmed soft hatclothes not quite the latest
stylewho had a good deal of manner, and walked apart from the young lady, bending towards her with an
air of devotion. Mr. King stood one side and watched the endless procession up and down, up and down, the
strollers, the mincers, the languid, the nervous steppers; noted the eyeshots, the flashing or the languishing
look that kills, and never can be called to account for the mischief it does; but not a sound did he hear of the
repartee and the laughter. The place certainly was thronged. The avenue in front was crowded with vehicles
of all sorts; there were groups strolling on the broad beachchildren with their tiny pails and shovels digging
pits close to the advancing tide, nurserymaids in fast colors, boys in knickerbockers racing on the beach,
people lying on the sand, resolute walkers, whose figures loomed tall in the evening light, doing their
constitutional. People were passing to and fro on the long iron pier that spiderlegged itself out into the sea;
the two rooms midway were filled with sitters taking the evening breeze; and the large ball and music room at
the end, with its spacious outside promenadeyes, there were dancers there, and the band was playing. Mr.
King could see the fiddlers draw their bows, and the corneters lift up their horns and get red in the face, and
the lean man slide his trombone, and the drummer flourish his sticks, but not a note of music reached him. It
might have been a performance of ghosts for all the effect at this distance. Mr. King remarked upon this
dumbshow to a gentleman in a blue coat and white vest and gray hat, leaning against a column near him.
Their Pilgrimage
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY 11
Page No 14
The gentleman made no response. It was most singular. Mr. King stepped back to be out of the way of some
children racing down the piazza, and, half stumbling, sat down in the lap of a dowagerno, not quite; the
chair was empty, and he sat down in the fresh varnish, to which his clothes stuck fast. Was this a delusion?
No. The tables were filled in the diningroom, the waiters were scurrying about, there were ladies on the
balconies looking dreamily down upon the animated scene below; all the movements of gayety and hilarity in
the height of a season. Mr. King approached a group who were standing waiting for a carriage, but they did
not see him, and did not respond to his trumpedup question about the next train. Were these, then, shadows,
or was he a spirit himself? Were these empty omnibuses and carriages that discharged ghostly passengers?
And all this promenading and flirting and languishing and lovemaking, would it come to nothingnothing
more than usual? There was a charm about it allthe movement, the color, the gray sand, and the rosy blush
on the seaa lovely place, an enchanted place. Were these throngs the guests that were to come, or those
that had been herein other seasons? Why could not the former "materialize" as well as the latter? Is it not as
easy to make nothing out of what never yet existed as out of what has ceased to exist? The landlord, by faith,
sees all this array which is prefigured so strangely to Mr. King; and his comely young wife sees it and is
ready for it; and the fat son at the supper tablea living example of the good eating to be had hereis
serene, and has the air of being polite and knowing to a houseful. This scrap of a child, with the aplomb of a
man of fifty, wise beyond his fatness, imparts information to the travelers about the wine, speaks to the waiter
with quiet authority, and makes these mature men feel like boys before the gravity of our perfect flower of
American youth who has known no childhood. This boy at least is no phantom; the landlord is real, and the
waiters, and the food they bring.
"I suppose," said Mr. King to his friend, "that we are opening the season. Did you see anything outdoors?"
"Yes; a horseshoecrab about a mile below here on the smooth sand, with a long dotted trail behind him, a
couple of girls in a ponycart who nearly drove over me, and a tall young lady with a red parasol,
accompanied by a big blackandwhite dog, walking rapidly, close to the edge of the sea, towards the sunset.
It's just lovely, the silvery sweep of coast in this light."
"It seems a refined sort of place in its outlines, and quietly respectable. They tell me here that they don't want
the excursion crowds that overrun Atlantic City, but an Atlantic City man, whom I met at the pier, said that
Cape May used to be the boss, but that Atlantic City had got the bulge on it nowhad thousands to the
hundreds here. To get the bulge seems a desirable thing in America, and I think we'd better see what a place
is like that is popular, whether fashion recognizes it or not."
The place lost nothing in the morning light, and it was a sparkling morning with a fresh breeze. Nature, with
its love of simple, sweeping lines, and its feeling for atmospheric effect, has done everything for the place,
and bad taste has not quite spoiled it. There is a sloping, shallow beach, very broad, of fine, hard sand,
excellent for driving or for walking, extending unbroken three miles down to Cape May Point, which has
hotels and cottages of its own, and lifesaving and signal stations. Off to the west from this point is the long
sand line to Cape Henlopen, fourteen miles away, and the Delaware shore. At Cape May Point there is a little
village of painted wood houses, mostly cottages to let, and a permanent population of a few hundred
inhabitants. From the pier one sees a mile and a half of hotels and cottages, fronting south, all flaming,
tasteless, carpenter's architecture, gay with paint. The sea expanse is magnificent, and the sweep of beach is
fortunately unencumbered, and vulgarized by no bathhouses or showshanties. The bathhouses are in front
of the hotels and in their enclosures; then come the broad drive, and the sand beach, and the sea. The line is
broken below by the lighthouse and a point of land, whereon stands the elephant. This elephant is not
indigenous, and he stands alone in the sand, a wooden sham without an explanation. Why the hotelkeeper's
mind along the coast regards this grotesque structure as a summer attraction it is difficult to see. But when
one resort had him, he became a necessity everywhere. The travelers walked down to this monster, climbed
the stairs in one of his legs, explored the rooms, looked out from the saddle, and pondered on the problem.
This beast was unfinished within and unpainted without, and already falling into decay. An elephant on the
Their Pilgrimage
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY 12
Page No 15
desert, fronting the Atlantic Ocean, had, after all, a picturesque aspect, and all the more so because he was a
deserted ruin.
The elephant was, however, no emptier than the cottages about which our friends strolled. But the cottages
were all ready, the rows of new chairs stood on the fresh piazzas, the windows were invitingly open, the
pathetic little patches of flowers in front tried hard to look festive in the dry sands, and the stout landladies in
their rockingchairs calmly knitted and endeavored to appear as if they expected nobody, but had almost a
houseful.
Yes, the place was undeniably attractive. The sea had the blue of Nice; why must we always go to the
Mediterranean for an aqua marina, for poetic lines, for delicate shades? What charming gradations had this
picture gray sand, blue waves, a line of white sails against the pale blue sky! By the pier railing is a bevy of
little girls grouped about an ancient colored man, the very ideal old Uncle Ned, in ragged, baggy, and
disreputable clothes, lazy goodnature oozing out of every pore of him, kneeling by a telescope pointed to a
bunch of white sails on the horizon; a dainty little maiden, in a stiff white skirt and golden hair, leans against
him and tiptoes up to the objectglass, shutting first one eye and then the other, and making nothing out of it
all. " Why, ov co'se you can't see nuffln, honey," said Uncle Ned, taking a peep, "wid the 'scope p'inted up in
the sky."
In order to pass from Cape May to Atlantic City one takes a long circuit by rail through the Jersey sands.
Jersey is a very prolific State, but the railway traveler by this route is excellently prepared for Atlantic City,
for he sees little but sand, stunted pines, scrub oaks, small frame houses, sometimes trying to hide in the
clumps of scrub oaks, and the villages are just collections of the same small frame houses hopelessly
decorated with scrollwork and obtrusively painted, standing in lines on sandy streets, adorned with lean
shadetrees. The handsome Jersey people were not traveling that daythe two friends had a theory about the
relation of a sandy soil to female beautyand when the artist got out his pencil to catch the types of the
country, he was well rewarded. There were the fat old women in holiday market costumes, strongfeatured,
positive, who shook their heads at each other and nodded violently and incessantly, and all talked at once; the
old men in rusty suits, thin, with a deprecatory manner, as if they had heard that clatter for fifty years, and
perky, sharpfaced girls in vegetable hats, all longnosed and thinlipped. And though the day was cool,
mosquitoes had the bad taste to invade the train. At the junction, a small collection of wooden shanties, where
the travelers waited an hour, they heard much of the glories of Atlantic City from the postmistress, who was
waiting for an excursion some time to go there (the passion for excursions seems to be a growing one), and
they made the acquaintance of a cow tied in the room next the ticketoffice, probably also waiting for a
passage to the city by the sea.
And a city it is. If many houses, endless avenues, sand, paint, make a city, the artist confessed that this was
one. Everything is on a large scale. It covers a large territory, the streets run at right angles, the avenues to the
ocean take the names of the states. If the town had been made to order and sawed out by one man, it could not
be more beautifully regular and more satisfactorily monotonous. There is nothing about it to give the most
commonplace mind in the world a throb of disturbance. The hotels, the cheap shops, the cottages, are all of
wood, and, with three or four exceptions in the thousands, they are all practically alike, all ornamented with
scrollwork, as if cut out by the jigsaw, all vividly painted, all appealing to a primitive taste just awakening
to the appreciation of the gaudy chromo and the illuminated and consoling household motto. Most of the
hotels are in the town, at considerable distance from the ocean, and the majestic old sea, which can be
monotonous but never vulgar, is barricaded from the town by five or six miles of starknaked plank walk,
rows on rows of bath closets, leagues of flimsy carpentrywork, in the way of cheapJohn shops, tintype
booths, peepshows, gorounds, shootinggalleries, popbeer and cigar shops, restaurants, barber shops,
photograph galleries, summer theatres. Sometimes the plank walk runs for a mile or two, on its piles, between
rows of these shops and booths, and again it drops off down by the waves. Here and there is a gaylypainted
wooden canopy by the shore, with chairs where idlers can sit and watch the frolicking in the water, or a space
Their Pilgrimage
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY 13
Page No 16
railed off, where the select of the hotels lie or lounge in the sand under red umbrellas. The calculating mind
wonders how many million feet of lumber there are in this unpicturesque barricade, and what gigantic forests
have fallen to make this timber front to the sea. But there is one thing man cannot do. He has made this show
to suit himself, he has pushed out several iron piers into the sea, and erected, of course, a skating rink on the
end of one of them. But the sea itself, untamed, restless, shining, dancing, raging, rolls in from the southward,
tossing the white sails on its vast expanse, green, blue, leaden, whitecapped, manycolored, never two
minutes the same, sounding with its eternal voice I knew not what rebuke to man.
When Mr. King wrote his and his friend's name in the book at the Mansion House, he had the curiosity to
turn over the leaves, and it was not with much surprise that he read there the names of A. J. Benson, wife, and
daughter, Cyrusville, Ohio.
"Oh, I see!" said the artist; "you came down here to see Mr. Benson!"
That gentleman was presently discovered tilted back in a chair on the piazza, gazing vacantly into the vacant
street with that air of endurance that fathers of families put on at such resorts. But he brightened up when Mr.
King made himself known.
"I'm right glad to see you, sir. And my wife and daughter will be. I was saying to my wife yesterday that I
couldn't stand this sort of thing much longer."
"You don't find it lively?"
"Well, the livelier it is the less I shall like it, I reckon. The town is well enough. It's one of the smartest places
on the coast. I should like to have owned the ground and sold out and retired. This sand is all gold. They say
they sell the lots by the bushel and count every sand. You can see what it is, boards and paint and sand. Fine
houses, too; miles of them."
"And what do you do?"
"Oh, they say there's plenty to do. You can ride around in the sand; you can wade in it if you want to, and go
down to the beach and walk up and down the plank walkwalk up and downwalk up and down. They
like it. You can't bathe yet without getting pneumonia. They have gone there now. Irene goes because she
says she can't stand the gayety of the parlor."
From the parlor came the sound of music. A young girl who had the air of not being afraid of a public parlor
was drumming out waltzes on the piano, more for the entertainment of herself than of the halfdozen ladies
who yawned over their worstedwork. As she brought her piece to an end with a bang, a pretty, sentimental
miss with a novel in her hand, who may not have seen Mr. King looking in at the door, ran over to the player
and gave her a hug. "That's beautiful! that's perfectly lovely, Mamie!" " This," said the player, taking up
another sheet, "has not been played much in New York." Probably not, in that style, thought Mr. King, as the
girl clattered through it.
There was no lack of people on the promenade, tramping the boards, or hanging about the booths where the
carpenters and painters were at work, and the shop men and women were unpacking the corals and the
seashells, and the cheap jewelry, and the Swiss woodcarving, the toys, the tinsel brooches, and agate
ornaments, and arranging the soda fountains, and putting up the shelves for the permanent pie. The sort of
preparation going on indicated the kind of crowd expected. If everything had a cheap and vulgar look, our
wandering critics remembered that it is never fair to look behind the scenes of a show, and that things would
wear a braver appearance by and by. And if the women on the promenade were homely and illdressed, even
the bonnes in unpicturesque costumes, and all the men were slouchy and stolid, how could any one tell what
Their Pilgrimage
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY 14
Page No 17
an effect of gayety and enjoyment there might be when there were thousands of such people, and the sea was
full of bathers, and the flags were flying, and the bands were tooting, and all the theatres were opened, and
acrobats and spangled women and painted redmen offered those attractions which, like government, are for
the good of the greatest number? What will you have? Shall vulgarity be left just vulgar, and have no
apotheosis and glorification? This is very fine of its kind, and a resort for the million. The million come here
to enjoy themselves. Would you have an artgallery here, and highpriced New York and Paris shops lining
the way?
"Look at the town," exclaimed the artist, "and see what money can do, and satisfy the average taste without
the least aid from art. It's just wonderful. I've tramped round the place, and, taking out a cottage or two, there
isn't a picturesque or pleasing view anywhere. I tell you people know what they want, and enjoy it when they
get it."
"You needn't get excited about it," said Mr. King. "Nobody said it wasn't commonplace, and glaringly vulgar
if you like, and if you like to consider it representative of a certain stage in national culture, I hope it is not
necessary to remind you that the United States can beat any other people in any direction they choose to
expand themselves. You'll own it when you've seen wateringplaces enough."
After this defense of the place, Mr. King owned it might be difficult for Mr. Forbes to find anything
picturesque to sketch. What figures, to be sure! As if people were obliged to be shapely or picturesque for the
sake of a wandering artist! "I could do a tree," growled Mr. Forbes, "or a pile of boards; but these shanties!"
When they were well away from the booths and bathhouses, Mr. King saw in the distance two ladies. There
was no mistaking one of themthe easy carriage, the grace of movement. No such figure had been afield all
day. The artist was quick to see that. Presently they came up with them, and found them seated on a bench,
looking off upon Brigantine Island, a low sand dune with some houses and a few trees against the sky, the
most pleasing object in view.
Mrs. Benson did not conceal the pleasure she felt in seeing Mr. King again, and was delighted to know his
friend; and, to say the truth, Miss Irene gave him a very cordial greeting.
"I'm 'most tired to death," said Mrs. Benson, when they were all seated. "But this air does me good. Don't you
like Atlantic City?"
"I like it better than I did at first." If the remark was intended for Irene, she paid no attention to it, being
absorbed in explaining to Mr. Forbes why she preferred the deserted end of the promenade.
"It's a place that grows on you. I guess it's grown the wrong way on Irene and father; but I like the airafter
the South. They say we ought to see it in August, when all Philadelphia is here."
"I should think it might be very lively."
"Yes; but the promiscuous bathing. I don't think I should like that. We are not brought up to that sort of thing
in Ohio."
"No? Ohio is more like France, I suppose?"
"Like France!" exclaimed the old lady, looking at him in amazement"like France! Why, France is the
wickedest place in the world."
"No doubt it is, Mrs. Benson. But at the sea resorts the sexes bathe separately."
Their Pilgrimage
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY 15
Page No 18
"Well, now! I suppose they have to there."
"Yes; the older nations grow, the more selfconscious they become."
"I don't believe, for all you say, Mr. King, the French have any more conscience than we have."
"Nor do I, Mrs. Benson. I was only trying to say that they pay more attention to appearances."
"Well, I was brought up to think it's one thing to appear, and another thing to be," said Mrs. Benson, as
dismissing the subject. "So your friend's an artist? Does he paint? Does he take portraits? There was an artist
at Cyrusville last winter who painted portraits, but Irene wouldn't let him do hers. I'm glad we've met Mr.
Forbes. I've always wanted to have"
"Oh, mother," exclaimed Irene, who always appeared to keep one ear for her mother's conversation, "I was
just saying to Mr. Forbes that he ought to see the art exhibitions down at the other end of the promenade, and
the pictures of the people who come here in August. Are you rested?"
The party moved along, and Mr. King, by a movement that seemed to him more natural than it did to Mr.
Forbes, walked with Irene, and the two fell to talking about the last spring's trip in the South.
"Yes, we enjoyed the exhibition, but I am not sure but I should have enjoyed New Orleans more without the
exhibition. That took so much time. There is nothing so wearisome as an exhibition. But New Orleans was
charming. I don't know why, for it's the flattest, dirtiest, dampest city in the world; but it is charming. Perhaps
it's the people, or the Frenchiness of it, or the tumbledown, picturesque old creole quarter, or the roses; I
didn't suppose there were in the world so many roses; the town was just wreathed and smothered with them.
And you did not see it?"
"No; I have been to exhibitions, and I thought I should prefer to take New Orleans by itself some other time.
You found the people hospitable?"
"Well, they were not simply hospitable; they were that, to be sure, for father had letters to some of the leading
men; but it was the general air of friendliness and goodnature everywhere, of agreeablenessit went along
with the roses and the easygoing life. You didn't feel all the time on a strain. I don't suppose they are any
better than our people, and I've no doubt I should miss a good deal there after a while a certain tonic and
purpose in life. But, do you know, it is pleasant sometimes to be with people who haven't so many corners as
our people have. But you went south from Fortress Monroe?"
"Yes; I went to Florida."
"Oh, that must be a delightful country!"
"Yes, it's a very delightful land, or will be when it is finished. It needs advertising now. It needs somebody to
call attention to it. The modest Northerners who have got hold of it, and staked it all out into city lots, seem to
want to keep it all to themselves."
"How do you mean 'finished'?"
"Why, the State is big enough, and a considerable portion of it has a good foundation. What it wants is
building up. There's plenty of water and sand, and palmetto roots and palmetto trees, and swamps, and a
perfectly wonderful vegetation of vines and plants and flowers. What it needs is landat least what the
Yankees call land. But it is coming on. A good deal of the State below Jacksonville is already ten to fifteen
Their Pilgrimage
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY 16
Page No 19
feet above the ocean."
"But it's such a place for invalids!"
"Yes, it is a place for invalids. There are two kinds of people there invalids and speculators. Thousands of
people in the bleak North, and especially in the Northwest, cannot live in the winter anywhere else than in
Florida. It's a great blessing to this country to have such a sanitarium. As I said, all it needs is building up,
and then it wouldn't be so monotonous and malarious."
"But I had such a different idea of it!"
"Well, your idea is probably right. You cannot do justice to a place by describing it literally. Most people are
fascinated by Florida: the fact is that anything is preferable to our Northern climate from February to May."
"And you didn't buy an orange plantation, or a town?"
"No; I was discouraged. Almost any one can have a town who will take a boat and go off somewhere with a
surveyor, and make a map."
The truth isthe present writer had it from Major Blifill, who runs a little steamboat upon one of the inland
creeks where the alligator is still numerous enough to be an entertainmentthat Mr. King was no doubt
malarious himself when he sailed over Florida. Blifill says he offended a whole boatful one day when they
were sailing up the St. John's. Probably he was tired of water, and swamp and water, and scraggy trees and
water. The captain was on the bow, expatiating to a crowd of listeners on the fertility of the soil and the
salubrity of the climate. He had himself bought a piece of ground away up there somewhere for two hundred
dollars, cleared it up, and put in orangetrees, and thousands wouldn't buy it now. And Mr. King, who
listened attentively, finally joined in with the questioners, and said, "Captain, what is the average price of
land down in this part of Florida by thegallon?"
They had come down to the booths, and Mrs. Benson was showing the artist the shells, piles of conchs, and
other outlandish seafabrications in which it is said the roar of the ocean can be heard when they are
hundreds of miles away from the sea. It was a pretty thought, Mr. Forbes said, and he admired the open shells
that were painted on the inside painted in bright blues and greens, with dabs of white sails and a lighthouse,
or a boat with a barearmed, resolute young woman in it, sending her bark spinning over waves
mountainhigh.
Yes," said the artist, "what cheerfulness those works of art will give to the little parlors up in the country,
when they are set up with other shells on the whatnot in the corner! These shells always used to remind me
of missionaries and the cause of the heathen; but when I see them now I shall think of Atlantic City."
"But the representative things here," interrupted Irene, "are the photographs, the tintypes. To see them is just
as good as staying here to see the people when they come."
"Yes," responded Mr. King, "I think art cannot go much further in this direction."
If there were not miles of these showcases of tintypes, there were at least acres of them. Occasionally an
instantaneous photograph gave a lively picture of the beach, when the water was full of bathersmen,
women, children, in the most extraordinary costumes for revealing or deforming the human figureall
tossing about in the surf. But most of the pictures were taken on dry land, of single persons, couples, and
groups in their bathing suits. Perhaps such an extraordinary collection of humanity cannot be seen elsewhere
in the world, such a uniformity of one depressing type reduced to its last analysis by the seatoilet.
Their Pilgrimage
II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY 17
Page No 20
Sometimes it was a young man and a maiden, handed down to posterity in dresses that would have caused
their arrest in the street, sentimentally reclining on a canvas rock. Again it was a maiden with flowing hair,
raised hands clasped, eyes upturned, on top of a crag, at the base of which the waves were breaking in foam.
Or it was the same stalwart maiden, or another as good, in a boat which stood on end, pulling through the surf
with one oar, and dragging a drowning man (in a bathing suit also) into the boat with her free hand. The
legend was, "Saved." There never was such heroism exhibited by young women before, with such raiment, as
was shown in these rare works of art.
As they walked back to the hotel through a sandy avenue lined with jig saw architecture, Miss Benson
pointed out to them some things that she said had touched her a good deal. In the patches of sand before each
house there was generally an oblong little mound set about with a rim of stones, or, when something more
artistic could be afforded, with shells. On each of these little graves was a flower, a sickly geranium, or a
humble marigold, or some other floral token of affection.
Mr. Forbes said he never was at a wateringplace before where they buried the summer boarders in the front
yard. Mrs. Benson didn't like joking on such subjects, and Mr. King turned the direction of the conversation
by remarking that these seeming trifles were really of much account in these days, and he took from his
pocket a copy of the city newspaper, 'The Summer SeaSong,' and read some of the leading items: "S., our
eye is on you." "The Slopers have come to their cottage on Q Street, and come to stay." "Mr. E. P. Borum has
painted his front steps." "Mr. Diffendorfer's marigold is on the blow." And so on, and so on. This was
probably the marigold mentioned that they were looking at.
The most vivid impression, however, made upon the visitor in this walk was that of paint. It seemed unreal
that there could be so much paint in the world and so many swearing colors. But it ceased to be a dream, and
they were taken back into the hard, practical world, when, as they turned the corner, Irene pointed out her
favorite sign:
Silas Lapham, mineral paint.
Branch Office.
The artist said, a couple of days after this morning, that he had enough of it. "Of course," he added, "it is a
great pleasure to me to sit and talk with Mrs. Benson, while you and that pretty girl walk up and down the
piazza all the evening; but I'm easily satisfied, and two evenings did for me."
So that, much as Mr. King was charmed with Atlantic City, and much as he regretted not awaiting the arrival
of the originals of the tintypes, he gave in to the restlessness of the artist for other scenes; but not before he
had impressed Mrs. Benson with a notion of the delights of Newport in July.
III. THE CATSKILLS
The view of the Catskills from a certain hospitable mansion on the east side of the Hudson is better than any
mew from those delectable hills. The artist said so one morning late in June, and Mr. King agreed with him,
as a matter of fact, but would have no philosophizing about it, as that anticipation is always better than
realization; and when Mr. Forbes went on to say that climbing a mountain was a good deal like marriage
the world was likely to look a little flat once that cerulean height was attainedMr. King only remarked that
that was a low view to take of the subject, but he would confess that it was unreasonable to expect that any
rational object could fulfill, or even approach, the promise held out by such an exquisite prospect as that
before them.
The friends were standing where the Catskill hills lay before them in echelon towards the river, the ridges
lapping over each other and receding in the distance, a gradation of lines most artistically drawn, still further
Their Pilgrimage
III. THE CATSKILLS 18
Page No 21
refined by shades of violet, which always have the effect upon the contemplative mind of either religious
exaltation or the kindling of a sentiment which is in the young akin to the emotion of love. While the artist
was making some memoranda of these outlines, and Mr. King was drawing I know not what auguries of hope
from these purple heights, a young lady seated upon a rock near bya young lady just stepping over the
borderline of womanhoodhad her eyes also fixed upon those dreamy distances, with that look we all
know so well, betraying that shy expectancy of life which is unconfessed, that tendency to maidenly reverie
which it were cruel to interpret literally. At the moment she is more interesting than the Catskillsthe brown
hair, the large eyes unconscious of anything but the most natural emotion, the shapely waist just beginning to
respond to the call of the futureit is a pity that we shall never see her again, and that she has nothing
whatever to do with our journey. She also will have her romance; fate will meet her in the way some day, and
set her pure heart wildly beating, and she will know what those purple distances mean. Happiness, tragedy,
anguishwho can tell what is in store for her? I cannot but feel profound sadness at meeting her in this
casual way and never seeing her again. Who says that the world is not full of romance and pathos and regret
as we go our daily way in it? You meet her at a railway station; there is the flutter of a veil, the gleam of a
scarlet bird, the lifting of a pair of eyesshe is gone; she is entering a drawingroom, and stops a moment
and turns away; she is looking from a window as you passit is only a glance out of eternity; she stands for
a second upon a rock looking seaward; she passes you at the church dooris that all? It is discovered that
instantaneous photographs can be taken. They are taken all the time; some of them are never developed, but I
suppose these impressions are all there on the sensitive plate, and that the plate is permanently affected by the
impressions. The pity of it is that the world is so full of these undeveloped knowledges of people worth
knowing and friendships worth making.
The comfort of leaving same things to the imagination was impressed upon our travelers when they left the
narrowgauge railway at the mountain station, and identified themselves with other tourists by entering a
two horse wagon to be dragged wearily up the hill through the woods. The ascent would be more tolerable if
any vistas were cut in the forest to give views by the way; as it was, the monotony of the pull upward was
only relieved by the society of the passengers. There were two bright little girls off for a holiday with their
Western uncle, a big, good natured man with a diamond breastpin, and his voluble son, a lad about the age
of his little cousins, whom he constantly pestered by his rude and dominating behavior. The boy was a
product which it is the despair of all Europe to produce, and our travelers had great delight in him as an
epitome of American "smartness." He led all the conversation, had confident opinions about everything,
easily put down his deferential papa, and pleased the other passengers by his selfsufficient, knowit all air.
To a boy who had traveled in California and seen the Alps it was not to be expected that this humble
mountain could afford much entertainment, and he did not attempt to conceal his contempt for it. When the
stage reached the Rip Van Winkle House, halfway, the shy schoolgirls were for indulging a little sentiment
over the old legend, but the boy, who concealed his ignorance of the Irving romance until his cousins had
prattled the outlines of it, was not to be taken in by any such chaff, and though he was a little staggered by
Rip's own cottage, and by the sight of the cave above it which is labeled as the very spot where the vagabond
took his long nap, he attempted to bully the attendant and drinkmixer in the hut, and openly flaunted his
incredulity until the bartender showed him a long bunch of Rip's hair, which hung like a scalp on a nail, and
the rusty barrel and stock of the musket. The cabin is, indeed, full of old guns, pistols, locks of hair, buttons,
cartridge boxes, bullets, knives, and other undoubted relics of Rip and the Revolution. This cabin, with its
facilities for slaking thirst on a hot day, which Rip would have appreciated, over a hundred years old
according to information to be obtained on the spot, is really of unknown antiquity, the old boards and timber
of which it is constructed having been brought down from the Mountain House some forty years ago.
The old Mountain House, standing upon its ledge of rock, from which one looks down upon a map of a
considerable portion of New York and New England, with the lake in the rear, and heights on each side that
offer charming walks to those who have in contemplation views of nature or of matrimony, has somewhat
lost its importance since the vast Catskill region has come to the knowledge of the world. A generation ago it
was the centre of attraction, and it was understood that going to the Catskills was going there. Generations of
Their Pilgrimage
III. THE CATSKILLS 19
Page No 22
searchers after immortality have chiseled their names in the rock platform, and one who sits there now falls to
musing on the vanity of human nature and the transitoriness of fashion. Now New York has found that it has
very convenient to it a great mountain pleasureground; railways and excellent roads have pierced it, the
varied beauties of rocks, ravines, and charming retreats are revealed, excellent hotels capable of entertaining
a thousand guests are planted on heights and slopes commanding mountain as well as lowland prospects,
great and small boardinghouses cluster in the high valleys and on the hillsides, and cottages more thickly
every year dot the wild region. Year by year these accommodations will increase, new roads around the
gorges will open more enchanting views, and it is not improbable that the species of American known as the
"summer boarder" will have his highest development and apotheosis in these mountains.
Nevertheless Mr. King was not uninterested in renewing his memories of the old house. He could recall
without difficulty, and also without emotion now, a scene on this upper veranda and a moonlight night long
ago, and he had no doubt he could find her name carved on a beechtree in the wood near by; but it was
useless to look for it, for her name had been changed. The place was, indeed, full of memories, but all
chastened and subdued by the indoor atmosphere, which impressed him as that of a faded Sunday. He was
very careful not to disturb the decorum by any frivolity of demeanor, and he cautioned the artist on this point;
but Mr. Forbes declared that the diningroom fare kept his spirits at a proper level. There was an oldtime
satisfaction in wandering into the parlor, and resting on the haircloth sofa, and looking at the haircloth
chairs, and pensively imagining a meeting there, with songs out of the Moody and Sankey book; and he did
not tire of dropping into the reposeful receptionroom, where he never by any chance met anybody, and
sitting with the melodeon and big Bible Society edition of the Scriptures, and a chance copy of the Christian
at Play. These amusements were varied by sympathetic listening to the complaints of the proprietor about the
vandalism of visitors who wrote with diamonds on the windowpanes, so that the glass had to be renewed, or
scratched their names on the pillars of the piazza, so that the whole front had to be repainted, or broke off the
azalea blossoms, or in other ways desecrated the premises. In order to fit himself for a sojourn here, Mr. King
tried to commit to memory a placard that was neatly framed and hung on the veranda, wherein it was stated
that the owner cheerfully submits to all necessary use of the premises, "but will not permit any unnecessary
use, or the exercise of a depraved taste or vandalism." There were not as yet many guests, and those who
were there seemed to have conned this placard to their improvement, for there was not much exercise of any
sort of taste. Of course there were two or three brides, and there was the inevitable English nice middleclass
tourist with his wife, the latter ramroddy and uncompromising, in big boots and botanical, who, in response
to a gentleman who was giving her information about travel, constantly ejaculated, in broad English, "Yas,
yas; ow, ow, ow, really!"
And there was the young bride from Kankazoo, who frightened Mr. King back into his chamber one morning
when he opened his door and beheld the vision of a woman going towards the breakfastroom in what he
took to be a robe de nuit, but which turned out to be one of the "MotherHubbards" which have had a certain
celebrity as street dresses in some parts of the West. But these gayeties palled after a time, and one afternoon
our travelers, with their vandalism all subdued, walked a mile over the rocks to the Kaaterskill House, and
took up their abode there to watch the opening of the season. Naturally they expected some difficulty in
transferring their two trunks round by the road, where there had been nothing but a wilderness forty years
ago; but their change of base was facilitated by the obliging hotelkeeper in the most friendly manner, and
when he insisted on charging only four dollars for moving the trunks, the two friends said that, considering
the wear and tear of the mountain involved, they did not see how he could afford to do it for such a sum, and
they went away, as they said, well pleased.
It happened to be at the Kaaterskill Houseit might have been at the Grand, or the Overlookthat the
young gentlemen in search of information saw the Catskill season get under way. The phase of American life
is much the same at all these great caravansaries. It seems to the writer, who has the greatest admiration for
the military genius that can feed and fight an army in the field, that not enough account is made of the greater
genius that can organize and carry on a great American hotel, with a thousand or fifteen hundred guests, in a
Their Pilgrimage
III. THE CATSKILLS 20
Page No 23
short, sharp, and decisive campaign of two months, at the end of which the substantial fruits of victory are in
the hands of the landlord, and the guests are allowed to depart with only their personal baggage and
sidearms, but so well pleased that they are inclined to renew the contest next year. This is a triumph of mind
over mind. It is not merely the organization and the management of the army under the immediate command
of the landlord, the accumulation and distribution of supplies upon this mountaintop, in the uncertainty
whether the garrison on a given day will be one hundred or one thousand, not merely the lodging, rationing
and amusing of this shifting host, but the satisfying of as many whims and prejudices as there are people who
leave home on purpose to grumble and enjoy themselves in the exercise of a criticism they dare not indulge in
their own houses. Our friends had an opportunity of seeing the machinery set in motion in one of these great
establishments. Here was a vast balloon structure, founded on a rock, but built in the air, and anchored with
cables, with towers and a high pillared veranda, capable, with its annex, of lodging fifteen hundred people.
The army of waiters and chambermaids, of bellboys, and scullions and porters and laundryfolk, was
arriving; the stalwart scrubbers were at work, the storerooms were filled, the big kitchen shone with its
burnished coppers, and an array of whitecapped and aproned cooks stood in line under their chef; the
telegraph operator was waiting at her desk, the drug clerk was arranging his bottles, the newspaper stand was
furnished, the postoffice was open for letters. It needed but the arrival of a guest to set the machinery in
motion. And as soon as the guest came the band would be there to launch him into the maddening gayety of
the season. It would welcome his arrival in triumphant strains; it would pursue him at dinner, and drown his
conversation; it will fill his siesta with martial dreams, and it would seize his legs in the evening, and entreat
him to caper in the parlor. Everything was ready. And this was what happened. It was the evening of the
opening day. The train wagons might be expected any moment. The electric lights were blazing. All the
clerks stood expectant, the porters were by the door, the trim, uniformed bellboys were all in waiting line,
the register clerk stood fingering the leaves of the register with a gracious air. A noise is heard outside, the
big door opens, there is a rush forward, and four people flock in a man in a linen duster, a stout woman, a lad
of ten, a smartly dressed young lady, and a dog. Movement, welcome, ringing of bells, tramping of feetthe
whole machinery has started. It was adjusted to crack an eggshell or smash an ironbound trunk. The few
drops presaged a shower. The next day there were a hundred on the register; the day after, two hundred; and
the day following, an excursion.
With increasing arrivals opportunity was offered for the study of character. Away from his occupation, away
from the cares of the household and the demands of society, what is the selfsustaining capacity of the
ordinary American man or woman? It was interesting to note the enthusiasm of the first arrival, the delight in
the viewRound Top, the deep gorges, the charming vista of the lowlands, a world and wilderness of
beauty; the inspiration of the air, the alertness to explore in all directions, to see the lake, the falls, the
mountain paths. But is a mountain sooner found out than a valley, or is there a want of internal resources,
away from business, that the men presently become rather listless, take perfunctory walks for exercise, and
are so eager for mealtime and mailtime? Why do they depend so much upon the newspapers, when they all
despise the newspapers? Mr. King used to listen of an evening to the commonplace talk about the fire, all of
which was a dilution of what they had just got out of the newspapers, but what a lively assent there was to a
glib talker who wound up his remarks with a denunciation of the newspapers! The man was no doubt quite
right, but did he reflect on the public loss of his valuable conversation the next night if his newspaper should
chance to fail? And the women, after their first feeling of relief, did they fall presently into petty gossip,
complaints about the table, criticisms of each other's dress, small discontents with nearly everything? Not all
of them.
An excursion is always resented by the regular occupants of a summer resort, who look down upon the
excursionists, while they condescend to be amused by them. It is perhaps only the common attitude of the
wholesale to the retail dealer, although it is undeniable that a person seems temporarily to change his nature
when he becomes part of an excursion; whether it is from the elation at the purchase of a day of gayety below
the market price, or the escape from personal responsibility under a conductor, or the love of being
conspicuous as a part of a sort of organization, the excursionist is not on his ordinary behavior.
Their Pilgrimage
III. THE CATSKILLS 21
Page No 24
An excursion numbering several hundreds, gathered along the river towns by the benevolent enterprise of
railway officials, came up to the mountain one day. The officials seemed to have run a dragnet through
factories, workshops, Sundayschools, and churches, and scooped in the weary workers at homes and in
shops unaccustomed to a holiday. Our friends formed a part of a group on the hotel piazza who watched the
straggling arrival of this band of pleasure. For by this time our two friends had found a circle of
acquaintances, with the facility of wateringplace life, which in its way represented certain phases of
American life as well as the excursion. A great many writers have sought to classify and label and put into a
paragraph a description of the American girl. She is not to be disposed of by any such easy process.
Undoubtedly she has some common marks of nationality that distinguish her from the English girl, but in
variety she is practically infinite, and likely to assume almost any form, and the characteristics of a dozen
nationalities. No one type represents her. What, indeed, would one say of this little group on the hotel piazza,
making its comments upon the excursionists? Here is a young lady of, say, twentythree years, inclining
already to stoutness, domestic, placid, with matron written on every line of her unselfish face, capable of
being, if necessity were, a notable housekeeper, learned in preserves and jellies and cordials, sure to have her
closets in order, and a place for every remnant, piece of twine, and all odds and ends. Not a person to read
Browning with, but to call on if one needed a nurse, or a good dinner, or a charitable deed. Beside her, in an
invalid's chair, a young girl, scarcely eighteen, of quite another sort, pale, slight, delicate, with a lovely face
and large sentimental eyes, all nerves, the product, perhaps, of a fashionable school, who in one season in
New York, her first, had utterly broken down into what is called nervous prostration. In striking contrast was
Miss Nettie Sumner, perhaps twentyone, who corresponded more nearly to what the internationalists call the
American type; had evidently taken school education as a duck takes water, and danced along in society into
apparent robustness of person and knowledge of the world. A handsome girl, she would be a comely woman,
goodnatured, quick at repartee, confining her knowledge of books to popular novels, too natural and frank
to be a flirt, an adept in all the nice slang current in fashionable life, caught up from collegians and brokers,
accustomed to meet men in public life, in hotels, a very "jolly" companion, with a fund of good sense that
made her entirely capable of managing her own affairs. Mr. King was at the moment conversing with still
another young lady, who had more years than the lastnamedshort, compact figure, round girlish face, good,
strong, dark eyes, modest in bearing, selfpossessed in manner, sensiblewho made ready and incisive
comments, and seemed to have thought deeply on a large range of topics, but had a sort of downright
practicality and cool independence, with all her femininity of bearing, that rather, puzzled her interlocutor. It
occurred to Mr. King to guess that Miss Selina Morton might be from Boston, which she was not, but it was
with a sort of shock of surprise that he learned later that this young girl, moving about in society in the
innocent panoply of girlhood, was a young doctor, who had no doubt looked through and through him with
her keen eyes, studied him in the light of heredity, constitutional tendencies, habits, and environment, as a
possible patient. It almost made him ill to think of it. Here were types enough for one morning; but there was
still another.
The artist had seated himself on a rock a little distance from the house, and was trying to catch some of the
figures as they appeared up the path, and a young girl was looking over his shoulder with an amused face,
just as he was getting an elderly man in a long flowing duster, straggling gray hair, hat on the back of his
head, large ironrimmed spectacles, with a baggy umbrella, who stopped breathless at the summit, with a
wild glare of astonishment at the view. This young girl, whom the careless observer might pass without a
second glance, was discovered on better acquaintance to express in her face and the lines of her figure some
subtle intellectual quality not easily interpreted. Marion Lamont, let us say at once, was of Southern origin,
born in London during the temporary residence of her parents there, and while very young deprived by death
of her natural protectors. She had a small, low voice, fine hair of a light color, which contrasted with dark
eyes, waved back from her forehead, delicate, sensitive featuresindeed, her face, especially in conversation
with any one, almost always had a wistful, appealing look; in figure short and very slight, lithe and graceful,
full of unconscious artistic poses, fearless and surefooted as a gazelle in climbing about the rocks, leaping
from stone to stone, and even making her way up a tree that had convenient branches, if the whim took her,
using her hands and arms like a gymnast, and performing whatever feat of. daring or dexterity as if the
Their Pilgrimage
III. THE CATSKILLS 22
Page No 25
exquisitely molded form was all instinct with her indomitable will, and obeyed it, and always with an air of
refinement and spirited breeding. A child of nature in seeming, but yet a woman who was not to be fathomed
by a chance acquaintance.
The old man with the spectacles was presently overtaken by a stout, elderly woman, who landed in the
exhausted condition of a porpoise that has come ashore, and stood regardless of everything but her own
weight, while member after member of the party straggled up. No sooner did this group espy the artist than
they moved in his direction. "There's a painter." "I wonder what he's painting." "Maybe he'll paint us." "Let's
see what he's doing." "I should like to see a man paint." And the crowd flowed on, getting in front of the
sketcher, and creeping round behind him for a peep over his shoulder. The artist closed his sketch book and
retreated, and the stout woman, balked of that prey, turned round a moment to the view, exclaimed, "Ain't
that elegant!" and then waddled off to the hotel.
"I wonder," Mr. King was saying, "if these excursionists are representative of general American life?"
"If they are," said the artist, "there's little here for my purpose. A good many of them seem to be foreigners,
or of foreign origin. Just as soon as these people get naturalized, they lose the picturesqueness they had
abroad."
"Did it never occur to your highness that they may prefer to be comfortable rather than picturesque, and that
they may be ignorant that they were born for artistic purposes?" It was the low voice of Miss Lamont, and
that demure person looked up as if she really wanted information.
"I doubt about the comfort," the artist began to reply.
"And so do I," said Miss Sumner. "What on earth do you suppose made those girls come up here in white
dresses, blowing about in the wind, and already drabbled? Did you ever see such a lot of cheap millinery? I
haven't seen a woman yet with the least bit of style."
"Poor things, they look as if they'd never had a holiday before in their lives, and didn't exactly know what to
do with it," apologized Miss Lamont.
"Don't you believe it. They've been to more church and Sundayschool picnics than you ever attended. Look
over there!"
It was a group seated about their lunchbaskets. A young gentleman, the comedian of the patty, the life of the
church sociable, had put on the hat of one of the girls, and was making himself so irresistibly funny in it that
all the girls tittered, and their mothers looked a little shamefaced and pleased.
"Well," said Mr. King, "that's the only festive sign I've seen. It's more like a funeral procession than a
pleasure excursion. What impresses me is the extreme gravity of these peopleno fun, no hilarity, no letting
themselves loose for a good time, as they say. Probably they like it, but they seem to have no capacity for
enjoying themselves; they have no vivacity, no gayetywhat a contrast to a party in France or Germany off
for a day's pleasureno devices, no resources."
"Yes, it's all sad, respectable, confoundedly uninteresting. What does the doctor say?" asked the artist.
"I know what the doctor will say," put in Miss Summer, "but I tell you that what this crowd needs is
missionary dressmakers and tailors. If I were dressed that way I should feel and act just as they do. Well,
Selina?"
Their Pilgrimage
III. THE CATSKILLS 23
Page No 26
"It's pretty melancholy. The trouble is constant grinding work and bad food. I've been studying these people.
The women are all"
"Ugly," suggested the artist.
"Well, illfavored, scrimped; that means illnurtured simply. Out of the three hundred there are not half a
dozen wellconditioned, filled out physically in comfortable proportions. Most of the women look as if they
had been dragged out with indoor work and little intellectual life, but the real cause of physical degeneration
is bad cooking. If they lived more outofdoors, as women do in Italy, the food might not make so much
difference, but in our climate it is the prime thing. This poor physical state accounts for the want of gayety
and the lack of beauty. The men, on the whole, are better than the women, that is, the young men. I don't
know as these people are overworked, as the world goes. I dare say, Nettie, there's not a girl in this crowd
who could dance with you through a season. They need to be better fed, and to have more elevating
recreationssomething to educate their taste."
"I've been educating the taste of one excursionist this morning, a good faced workman, who was prying
about everywhere with a curious air, and said he never'd been on an excursion before. He came up to me in
the office, deferentially asked me if I would go into the parlor with him, and, pointing to something hanging
on the wall, asked, 'What is that?' 'That,' I said, 'is a view from Sunset Rock, and a very good one.' 'Yes,' he
continued, walking close up to it, 'but what is it?' 'Why, it's a painting.' 'Oh, it isn't the place?' 'No, no; it's a
painting in oil, done with a brush on a piece of canvasdon't you see, made to look like the view over
there from the rock, colors and all.' ' Yes, I thought, perhapsyou can see a good ways in it. It's pooty.'
'There's another one,' I said'falls, water coming down, and trees.' 'Well, I declare, so it is! And that's jest a
makebelieve? I s'pose I can go round and look?' 'Certainly.' And the old fellow tiptoed round the parlor,
peering at all the pictures in a confused state of mind, and with a guilty look of enjoyment. It seems
incredible that a person should attain his age with such freshness of mind. But I think he is the only one of the
party who even looked at the paintings."
"I think it's just pathetic," said Miss Lamont. "Don't you, Mr. Forbes?"
"No; I think it's encouraging. It's a sign of an art appreciation in this country. That man will know a painting
next time he sees one, and then he won't rest till he has bought a chromo, and so he will go on."
"And if he lives long enough, he will buy one of Mr. Forbes's paintings."
"But not the one that Miss Lamont is going to sit for."
When Mr. King met the party at the dinnertable, the places of Miss Lamont and Mr. Forbes were still
vacant. The other ladies looked significantly at them, and one of them said, "Don't you think there's
something in it? don't you think they are interested in each other?" Mr. King put down his soupspoon, too
much amazed to reply. Do women never think of anything but mating people who happen to be thrown
together? Here were this young lady and his friend, who had known each other for three days, perhaps, in the
most casual way, and her friends had her already as good as married to him and off on a wedding journey. All
that Mr. King said, after apparent deep cogitation, was, "I suppose if it were here it would have to be in a
travelingdress," which the women thought frivolous.
Yet it was undeniable that the artist and Marion had a common taste for hunting out picturesque places in the
woodpaths, among the rocks, and on the edges of precipices, and they dragged the rest of the party many a
mile through wildernesses of beauty. Sketching was the object of all these expeditions, but it always
happenedthere seemed a fatality in it that whenever they halted anywhere for a rest or a view, the Lamont
girl was sure to take an artistic pose, which the artist couldn't resist, and his whole occupation seemed to be
Their Pilgrimage
III. THE CATSKILLS 24
Page No 27
drawing her, with the Catskills for a background. "There," he would say, "stay just as you are; yes, leaning a
little so"it was wonderful how the lithe figure adapted itself to any background" and turn your head this
way, looking at me." The artist began to draw, and every time he gave a quick glance upwards from his book,
there were the wistful face and those eyes. "Confound it! I beg your pardonthe light. Will you please turn
your eyes a little off, that wayso." There was no reason why the artist should be nervous, the face was
perfectly demure; but the fact is that art will have only one mistress. So the drawing limped on from day to
day, and the excursions became a matter of course. Sometimes the party drove, extending their explorations
miles among the hills, exhilarated by the sparkling air, excited by the succession of lovely changing
prospects, bestowing their compassion upon the summer boarders in the smartly painted boarding houses,
and comparing the other big hotels with their own. They couldn't help looking down on the summer boarders,
any more than cottagers at other places can help a feeling of superiority to people in hotels. It is a natural
desire to make an aristocratic line somewhere. Of course they saw the Kaaterskill Falls, and bought
twentyfive cents' worth of water to pour over them, and they came very near seeing the Haines Falls, but
were a little too late.
"Have the falls been taken in today?" asked Marion, seriously.
"I'm real sorry, miss," said the proprietor, "but there's just been a party here and taken the water. But you can
go down and look if you want to, and it won't cost you a cent."
They went down, and saw where the falls ought to be. The artist said it was a sort of dryplate process, to be
developed in the mind afterwards; Mr. King likened it to a dry smoke without lighting the cigar; and the
doctor said it certainly had the sanitary advantage of not being damp. The party even penetrated the
Platerskill Cove, and were well rewarded by its exceeding beauty, as is every one who goes there. There are
sketches of all these lovely places in a certain artist's book, all looking, however, very much alike, and
consisting principally of a graceful figure in a great variety of unstudied attitudes.
"Isn't this a nervous sort of a place?" the artist asked his friend, as they sat in his chamber overlooking the
world.
"Perhaps it is. I have a fancy that some people are born to enjoy the valley, and some the mountains."
"I think it makes a person nervous to live on a high place. This feeling of constant elevation tires one; it gives
a fellow no such sense of bodily repose as he has in a valley. And the wind, it's constantly nagging, rattling
the windows and banging the doors. I can't escape the unrest of it." The artist was turning the leaves and
contemplating the poverty of his sketchbook. "The fact is, I get better subjects on the seashore."
"Probably the sea would suit us better. By the way, did I tell you that Miss Lamont's uncle came last night
from Richmond? Mr. De Long, uncle on the mother's side. I thought there was French blood in her."
"What is he like?"
"Oh, a comfortable bachelor, past middle age; business man; Southern; just a little touch of the 'cyar' for 'car.'
Said he was going to take his niece to Newport next week. Has Miss Lamont said anything about going
there?"
"Well, she did mention it the other day."
The house was filling up, and, King thought, losing its family aspect. He had taken quite a liking for the
society of the pretty invalid girl, and was fond of sitting by her, seeing the delicate color come back to her
cheeks, and listening to her shrewd little society comments. He thought she took pleasure in having him push
Their Pilgrimage
III. THE CATSKILLS 25
Page No 28
her wheelchair up and down the piazza at least she rewarded him by grateful looks, and complimented him
by asking his advice about reading and about being useful to others. Like most young girls whose career of
gayety is arrested as hers was, she felt an inclination to coquet a little with the serious side of life. All this had
been pleasant to Mr. King, but now that so many more guests had come, he found himself most of the time
out of business. The girl's chariot was always surrounded by admirers and sympathizers. All the young men
were anxious to wheel her up and down by the hour; there was always a strife for this sweet office; and at
night, when the vehicle had been lifted up the first flight, it was beautiful to see the eagerness of sacrifice
exhibited by these young fellows to wheel her down the long corridor to her chamber. After all, it is a kindly,
unselfish world, full of tenderness for women, and especially for invalid women who are pretty. There was all
day long a competition of dudes and elderly widowers and bachelors to wait on her. One thought she needed
a little more wheeling; another volunteered to bring her a glass of water; there was always some one to pick
up her fan, to recover her handkerchief (why is it that the fans and handkerchiefs of ugly women seldom go
astray?), to fetch her shawlwas there anything they could do? The charming little heiress accepted all the
attentions with most engaging sweetness. Say what you will, men have good hearts.
Yes, they were going to Newport. King and Forbes, who had not had a Fourth of July for some time, wanted
to see what it was like at Newport. Mr. De Long would like their company. But before they went the artist
must make one more trial at a sketchmust get the local color. It was a large party that went one morning to
see it done under the famous ledge of rocks on the Red Path. It is a fascinating spot, with its coolness, sense
of seclusion, mosses, wild flowers, and ferns. In a small grotto under the frowning wall of the precipice is
said to be a spring, but it is difficult to find, and lovers need to go a great many times in search of it. People
not in love can sometimes find a damp place in the sand. The question was where Miss Lamont should pose.
Should she nestle under the great ledge, or sit on a projecting rock with her figure against the sky? The artist
could not satisfy himself, and the girl, always adventurous, kept shifting her position, climbing about on the
jutting ledge, until she stood at last on the top of the precipice, which was some thirty or forty feet high.
Against the top leaned a dead balsam, just as some tempest had cast it, its dead branches bleached and
scraggy. Down this impossible ladder the girl announced her intention of coming. "No, no," shouted a chorus
of voices; "go round; it's unsafe; the limbs will break; you can't get through them; you'll break your neck."
The girl stood calculating the possibility. The more difficult the feat seemed, the more she longed to try it.
"For Heaven's sake don't try it, Miss Lamont," cried the artist.
"But I want to. I think I must. You can sketch me in the act. It will be something new."
And before any one could interpose, the resolute girl caught hold of the balsam and swung off. A boy or a
squirrel would have made nothing of the feat. But for a young lady in long skirts to make her way down that
balsam, squirming about and through the stubs and dead limbs, testing each one before she trusted her weight
to it, was another affair. It needed a very cool head and the skill of a gymnast. To transfer her hold from one
limb to another, and work downward, keeping her skirts neatly gathered about her feet, was an achievement
that the spectators could appreciate; the presence of spectators made it much more difficult. And the
lookerson were a good deal more excited than the girl. The artist had his book ready, and when the little
figure was halfway down, clinging in a position at once artistic and painful, he began. "Work fast," said the
girl. "It's hard hanging on." But the pencil wouldn't work. The artist made a lot of wild marks. He would have
given the world to sketch in that exquisite figure, but every time he cast his eye upward the peril was so
evident that his hand shook. It was no use. The danger increased as she descended, and with it the excitement
of the spectators. All the young gentlemen declared they would catch her if she fell, and some of them
seemed to hope she might drop into their arms. Swing off she certainly must when the lowest limb was
reached. But that was ten feet above the ground and the alightingplace was sharp rock and broken bowlders.
The artist kept up a pretense of drawing. He felt every movement of her supple figure and the strain upon the
slender arms, but this could not be transferred to the book. It was nervous work. The girl was evidently
getting weary, but not losing her pluck. The young fellows were very anxious that the artist should keep at his
Their Pilgrimage
III. THE CATSKILLS 26
Page No 29
work; they would catch her. There was a pause; the girl had come to the last limb; she was warily meditating
a slide or a leap; the young men were quite ready to sacrifice themselves; but somehow, no one could tell
exactly how, the girl swung low, held herself suspended by her hands for an instant, and then dropped into
the right placetrust a woman for that; and the artist, his face flushed, set her down upon the nearest flat
rock. Chorus from the party, "She is saved!"
"And my sketch is gone up again."
"I'm sorry, Mr. Forbes." The girl looked full of innocent regret. "But when I was up there I had to come down
that tree. I couldn't help it, really."
IV. NEWPORT
On the Fourth of July, at five o'clock in the morning, the porters called the sleepers out of their berths at
Wickford Junction. Modern civilization offers no such test to the temper and to personal appearance as this
early preparation to meet the inspection of society after a night in the stuffy and luxuriously upholstered
tombs of a sleepingcar. To get into them at night one must sacrifice dignity; to get out of them in the
morning, clad for the day, gives the proprietors a hard rub. It is wonderful, however, considering the twisting
and scrambling in the berth and the miscellaneous and ludicrous presentation of humanity in the washroom at
the end of the car, how presentable people make themselves in a short space of time. One realizes the debt of
the ordinary man to clothes, and how fortunate it is for society that commonly people do not see each other in
the morning until art has done its best for them. To meet the public eye, cross and tousled and disarranged,
requires either indifference or courage. It is disenchanting to some of our cherished ideals. Even the trig,
irreproachable commercial drummer actually looks bangedup, and nothing of a man; but after a few
moments, bootblacked and papercollared, he comes out as fresh as a daisy, and all ready to drum.
Our travelers came out quite as well as could be expected, the artist sleepy and a trifle disorganized, Mr. King
in a sort of facetious humor that is more dangerous than grumbling, Mr. De Long yawning and stretching and
declaring that he had not slept a wink, while Marion alighted upon the platform unruffled in plumage,
greeting the morning like a bird. There were the usual early loafers at the station, hands deep in pockets,
ruminant, listlessly observant. No matter at what hour of day or night a train may arrive or depart at a country
station in America, the loafers are so invariably there in waiting that they seem to be a part of our railway
system. There is something in the life and movement that seems to satisfy all the desire for activity they have.
Even the most sleepy tourist could not fail to be impressed with the exquisite beauty of the scene at Wickford
Harbor, where the boat was taken for Newport. The slow awaking of morning life scarcely disturbed its
tranquillity. Sky and sea and land blended in a tone of refined gray. The shores were silvery, a silvery light
came out of the east, streamed through the entrance of the harbor, and lay molten and glowing on the water.
The steamer's deck and chairs and benches were wet with dew, the noises in transferring the baggage and
getting the boat under way were all muffled and echoed in the surrounding silence. The sail boats that lay at
anchor on the still silver surface sent down long shadows, and the slim masts seemed driven down into the
water to hold the boats in place. The little village was still asleep. It was such a contrast; the artist was saying
to Marion, as they leaned over the taff rail, to the new raw villages in the Catskills. The houses were large,
and looked solid and respectable, many of them were shingled on the sides, a spire peeped out over the green
trees, and the hamlet was at once homelike and picturesque. Refinement is the note of the landscape. Even the
old warehouses dropping into the water, and the decaying piles of the wharves, have a certain grace. How
graciously the water makes into the land, following the indentations, and flowing in little streams, going in
and withdrawing gently and regretfully, and how the shore puts itself out in low points, wooing the embrace
of the seaa lovely union. There is no haze, but all outlines are softened in the silver light. It is like a dream,
and there is no disturbance of the repose when a family party, a woman, a child, and a man come down to the
shore, slip into a boat, and scull away out by the lighthouse and the rocky entrance of the harbor, off, perhaps,
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 27
Page No 30
for a day's pleasure. The artist has whipped out his sketchbook to take some outlines of the view, and his
comrade, looking that way, thinks this group a pleasing part of the scene, and notes how the salt, dewy
morning air has brought the color into the sensitive face of the girl. There are not many such hours in a
lifetime, he is also thinking, when nature can be seen in such a charming mood, and for the moment it
compensates for the night ride.
The party indulged this feeling when they landed, still early, at the Newport wharf, and decided to walk
through the old town up to the hotel, perfectly well aware that after this no money would hire them to leave
their beds and enjoy this novel sensation at such an hour. They had the street to themselves, and the
promenade was one of discovery, and had much the interest of a landing in a foreign city.
"It is so English," said the artist.
"It is so colonial," said Mr. King, "though I've no doubt that any one of the sleeping occupants of these
houses would be wideawake instantly, and come out and ask you to breakfast, if they heard you say it is so
English."
"If they were not restrained," Marion suggested, "by the feeling that that would not be English. How fine the
shade trees, and what brilliant banks of flowers!"
"And such lawns! We cannot make this turf in Virginia," was the reflection of Mr. De Long.
"Well, colonial if you like," the artist replied to Mr. King. "What is best is in the colonial style; but you notice
that all the new houses are built to look old, and that they have had Queen Anne pretty bad, though the colors
are good."
"That's the way with some towns. Queen Anne seems to strike them all of a sudden, and become epidemic.
The only way to prevent it is to vaccinate, so to speak, with two or three houses, and wait; then it is not so
likely to spread."
Laughing and criticising and admiring, the party strolled along the shaded avenue to the Ocean House. There
were as yet no signs of life at the Club, or the Library, or the Casino; but the shops were getting open, and the
richness and elegance of the goods displayed in the windows were the best evidence of the wealth and
refinement of the expected customers culture and taste always show themselves in the shops of a town.
The long graybrown front of the Casino, with its shingled sides and hooded balconies and galleries, added
to the already strong foreign impression of the place. But the artist was dissatisfied. It was not at all his idea
of Independence Day; it was like Sunday, and Sunday without any foreign gayety. He had expected firing of
cannon and ringing of bellsthere was not even a flag out anywhere; the celebration of the Fourth seemed to
have shrunk into a dull and decorous avoidance of all excitement. "Perhaps," suggested Miss Lamont, "if the
NewEnglanders keep the Fourth of July like Sunday, they will by and by keep Sunday like the Fourth of
July. I hear it is the day for excursions on this coast."
Mr. King was perfectly well aware that in going to a hotel in Newport he was putting himself out of the pale
of the best society; but he had a fancy for viewing this society from the outside, having often enough seen it
from the inside. And perhaps he had other reasons for this eccentric conduct. He had, at any rate, declined the
invitation of his cousin, Mrs. Bartlett Glow, to her cottage on the Point of Rocks. It was not without regret
that he did this, for his cousin was a very charming woman, and devoted exclusively to the most exclusive
social life. Her husband had been something in the oil line in New York, and King had watched with interest
his evolution from the business man into the full blown existence of a man of fashion. The process is
perfectly charted. Success in business, membership in a good club, tandem in the Park, introduction to a good
house, marriage to a pretty girl of family and not much money, a yacht, a fourinhand, a Newport villa. His
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 28
Page No 31
name had undergone a like evolution. It used to be written on his business card, Jacob B. Glow. It was
entered at the club as J. Bartlett Glow. On the wedding invitations it was Mr. Bartlett Glow, and the dashing
pair were always spoken of at Newport as the BartlettGlows.
When Mr. King descended from his room at the Ocean House, although it was not yet eight o'clock, he was
not surprised to see Mr. Benson tilted back in one of the chairs on the long piazza, out of the way of the
scrubbers, with his air of patient waiting and observation. Irene used to say that her father ought to write a
book"Life as Seen from Hotel Piazzas." His only idea of recreation when away from business seemed to
be sitting about on them.
"The womenfolks," he explained to Mr. King, who took a chair beside him, "won't be down for an hour yet.
I like, myself, to see the show open."
"Are there many people here?"
"I guess the house is full enough. But I can't find out that anybody is actually stopping here, except ourselves
and a lot of schoolmarms come to attend a convention. They seem to enjoy it. The rest, those I've talked with,
just happen to be here for a day or so, never have been to a hotel in Newport before, always stayed in a
cottage, merely put up here now to visit friends in cottages. You'll see that none of them act like they
belonged to the hotel. Folks are queer.
At a place we were last summer all the summer boarders, in boarding houses round, tried to act like they
were staying at the big hotel, and the hotel people swelled about on the fact of being at a hotel. Here you're
nobody. I hired a carriage by the week, driver in buttons, and all that. It don't make any difference. I'll bet a
gold dollar every cottager knows it's hired, and probably they think by the drive."
"It's rather stupid, then, for you and the ladies."
"Not a bit of it. It's the nicest place in America: such grass, such horses, such women, and the drive round the
islandthere's nothing like it in the country. We take it every day. Yes, it would be a little lonesome but for
the ocean. It's a good deal like a funeral procession, nobody ever recognizes you, not even the hotel people
who are in hired hacks. If I were to come again, Mr. King, I'd come in a yacht, drive up from it in a box on
two wheels, with a man clinging on behind with his back to me, and have a cottage with an English gardener.
That would fetch 'em. Money won't do it, not at a hotel. But I'm not sure but I like this way best. It's an
occupation for a man to keep up a cottage."
"And so you do not find it dull?"
"No. When we aren't out riding, she and Irene go on to the cliffs, and I sit here and talk real estate. It's about
all there is to talk of."
There was an awkward moment or two when the two parties met in the lobby and were introduced before
going in to breakfast. There was a little putting up of guards on the part of the ladies. Between Irene and
Marion passed that rapid glance of inspection, that one glance which includes a study and the passing of
judgment upon family, manners, and dress, down to the least detail. It seemed to be satisfactory, for after a
few words of civility the two girls walked in together, Irene a little dignified, to be sure, and Marion with her
wistful, halfinquisitive expression. Mr. King could not be mistaken in thinking Irene's manner a little
constrained and distant to him, and less cordial than it was to Mr. Forbes, but the mother righted the family
balance.
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 29
Page No 32
"I'm right glad you've come, Mr. King. It's like seeing somebody from home. I told Irene that when you came
I guess we should know somebody. It's an awful fashionable place."
"And you have no acquaintances here?"
"No, not really. There's Mrs. Peabody has a cottage here, what they call a cottage, but there no such house in
Cyrusville. We drove past it. Her daughter was to school with Irene. We've met 'em out riding several times,
and Sally (Miss Peabody) bowed to Irene, and pa and I bowed to everybody, but they haven't called. Pa says
it's because we are at a hotel, but I guess it's been company or something. They were real good friends at
school."
Mr. King laughed. "Oh, Mrs. Benson, the Peabodys were nobodys only a few years ago. I remember when
they used to stay at one of the smaller hotels."
"Well, they seem nice, stylish people, and I'm sorry on Irene's account."
At breakfast the party had topics enough in common to make conversation lively. The artist was sure he
should be delighted with the beauty and finish of Newport. Miss Lamont doubted if she should enjoy it as
much as the freedom and freshness of the Catskills. Mr. King amused himself with drawing out Miss Benson
on the contrast with Atlantic City. The dining room was full of members of the Institute, in attendance upon
the annual meeting, graybearded, longfaced educators, devotees of theories and systems, known at a glance
by a certain earnestness of manner and intensity of expression, middleaged women of a resolute, intellectual
countenance, and a great crowd of youthful schoolmistresses, just on the dividing line between domestic life
and selfsacrifice, still full of sentiment, and still leaning perhaps more to Tennyson and Lowell than to
mathematics and Old English.
"They have a curious, mingled air of primness and gayety, as if gayety were not quite proper," the artist
began. "Some of them look downright interesting, and I've no doubt they are all excellent women."
"I've no doubt they are all good as gold," put in Mr. King. "These women are the salt of New England."
(Irene looked up quickly and appreciatively at the speaker.) "No fashionable nonsense about them. What's in
you, Forbes, to shy so at a good woman?"
"I don't shy at a good womanbut three hundred of them! I don't want all my salt in one place. And see
hereI appeal to you, Miss Lamont why didn't these girls dress simply, as they do at home, and not
attempt a sort of illfitting finery that is in greater contrast to Newport than simplicity would be?"
"If you were a woman," said Marion, looking demurely, not at Mr. Forbes, but at Irene, "I could explain it to
you. You don't allow anything for sentiment and the natural desire to please, and it ought to be just pathetic to
you that these girls, obeying a natural instinct, missed the expression of it a little."
"Men are such critics," and Irene addressed the remark to Marion, "they pretend to like intellectual women,
but they can pardon anything better than an illfitting gown. Better be frivolous than badly dressed."
"Well," stoutly insisted Forbes, "I'll take my chance with the well dressed ones always; I don't believe the
frumpy are the most sensible."
"No; but you make out a prima facie case against a woman for want of taste in dress, just as you jump at the
conclusion that because a woman dresses in such a way as to show she gives her mind to it she is of the right
sort. I think it's a relief to see a convention of women devoted to other things who are not thinking of their
clothes."
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 30
Page No 33
"Pardon me; the point I made was that they are thinking of their clothes, and thinking erroneously."
"Why don't you ask leave to read a paper, Forbes, on the relation of dress to education?" asked Mr. King.
They rose from the table just as Mrs. Benson was saying that for her part she liked these girls, they were so
homelike; she loved to hear them sing college songs and hymns in the parlor. To sing the songs of the
students is a wild, reckless dissipation for girls in the country.
When Mr. King and Irene walked up and down the corridor after breakfast the girl's constraint seemed to
have vanished, and she let it be seen that she had sincere pleasure in renewing the acquaintance. King himself
began to realize how large a place the girl's image had occupied in his mind. He was not in lovethat would
be absurd on such short acquaintancebut a thought dropped into the mind ripens without consciousness,
and he found that he had anticipated seeing Irene again with decided interest. He remembered exactly how
she looked at Fortress Monroe, especially one day when she entered the parlor, bowing right and left to
persons she knew, stopping to chat with one and another, tall, slender waist swelling upwards in symmetrical
lines, brown hair, dark gray eyeshe recalled every detail, the highbred air (which was certainly not
inherited), the unconscious perfect carriage, and his thinking in a vague way that such ease and grace meant
good living and leisure and a sound body. This, at any rate, was the image in his mind a sufficiently
distracting thing for a young man to carry about with him; and now as he walked beside her he was conscious
that there was something much finer in her than the image he had carried with him, that there was a charm of
speech and voice and expression that made her different from any other woman he had ever seen. Who can
define this charm, this difference? Some women have it for the universal manthey are desired of every
man who sees them; their way to marriage (which is commonly unfortunate) is over a causeway of prostrate
forms, if not of cracked hearts; a few such women light up and make the romance of history. The majority of
women fortunately have it for one man only, and sometimes he never appears on the scene at all! Yet every
man thinks his choice belongs to the first class; even King began to wonder that all Newport was not raving
over Irene's beauty. The present writer saw her one day as she alighted from a carriage at the Ocean House,
her face flushed with the sea air, and he remembers that he thought her a fine girl. "By George, that's a fine
woman!" exclaimed a New York bachelor, who prided himself on knowing horses and women and all that;
but the country is full of fine womenthis to him was only one of a thousand.
What were this couple talking about as they promenaded, basking in each other's presence? It does not
matter. They were getting to know each other, quite as much by what they did not say as by what they did
say, by the thousand little exchanges of feeling and sentiment which are all important, and never appear
even in a stenographer's report of a conversation. Only one thing is certain about it, that the girl could recall
every word that Mr. King said, even his accent and look, long after he had forgotten even the theme of the
talk. One thing, however, he did carry away with him, which set him thinking. The girl had been reading the
"Life of Carlyle," and she took up the cudgels for the old curmudgeon, as King called him, and declared that,
when all was said, Mrs. Carlyle was happier with him than she would have been with any other man in
England. "What woman of spirit wouldn't rather mate with an eagle, and quarrel half the time, than with a
humdrum barnyard fowl?" And Mr. Stanhope King, when he went away, reflected that he who had fitted
himself for the bar, and traveled extensively, and had a moderate competence, hadn't settled down to any sort
of career. He had always an intention of doing something in a vague way; but now the thought that he was
idle made him for the first time decidedly uneasy, for he had an indistinct notion that Irene couldn't approve
of such a life.
This feeling haunted him as he was making a round of calls that day. He did not return to lunch or dinnerif
he had done so he would have found that lunch was dinner and that dinner was supperanother vital
distinction between the hotel and the cottage. The rest of the party had gone to the cliffs with the artist, the
girls on a pretense of learning to sketch from nature. Mr. King dined with his cousin.
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 31
Page No 34
"You are a bad boy, Stanhope," was the greeting of Mrs. Bartlett Glow, "not to come to me. Why did you go
to the hotel?"
"Oh, I thought I'd see life; I had an unaccountable feeling of independence. Besides, I've a friend with me, a
very clever artist, who is reseeing his country after an absence of some years. And there are some other
people."
"Oh, yes. What is her name?"
"Why, there is quite a party. We met them at different places. There's a very bright New York girl, Miss
Lamont, and her uncle from Richmond." ("Never heard of her," interpolated Mrs. Glow.) "And a Mr. and
Mrs. Benson and their daughter, from Ohio. Mr. Benson has made money; Mrs. Benson, goodhearted old
lady, rather plain and"
"Yes, I know the sort; had a fallingout with Lindley Murray in her youth and never made it up. But what I
want to know is about the girl. What makes you beat about the bush so? What's her name?"
"Irene. She is an uncommonly clever girl; educated; been abroad a good deal, studying in Germany; had all
advantages; and she has cultivated tastes; and the fact is that out in Cyrusvillethat is where they live
You know how it is here in America when the girl is educated and the old people are not"
"The long and short of it is, you want me to invite them here. I suppose the girl is plain, tootakes after her
mother?"
"Not exactly. Mr. Forbesthat's my friendsays she's a beauty. But if you don't mind, Penelope, I was
going to ask you to be a little civil to them."
"Well, I'll admit she is handsomea very strikinglooking girl. I've seen them driving on the Avenue day
after day. Now, Stanhope, I don't mind asking them here to a five o'clock; I suppose the mother will have to
come. If she was staying with somebody here it would be easier. Yes, I'll do it to oblige you, if you will make
yourself useful while you are here. There are some girls I want you to know, and mind, my young friend, that
you don't go and fall in love with a country girl whom nobody knows, out of the set. It won't be comfortable."
"You are always giving me good advice, Penelope, and I should be a different man if I had profited by it."
"Don't be satirical, because you've coaxed me to do you a favor."
Late in the evening the gentlemen of the hotel party looked in at the skatingrink, a great American
institution that has for a large class taken the place of the ball, the social circle, the evening meeting. It
seemed a little incongruous to find a great rink at Newport, but an epidemic is stronger than fashion, and even
the most exclusive summer resort must have its rink. Rollerskating is said to be fine exercise, but the benefit
of it as exercise would cease to be apparent if there were a separate rink for each sex. There is a certain
exhilaration in the lights and music and the lively crowd, and always an attraction in the freedom of
intercourse offered. The rink has its world as the opera has, its romances and its heroes. The frequenters of
the rink know the young women and the young men who have a national reputation as adepts, and their
exhibitions are advertised and talked about as are the appearances of celebrated 'prime donne' and 'tenori' at
the opera. The visitors had an opportunity to see one of these exhibitions. After a weary watching of the
monotonous and clattering round and round of the swinging couples or the stumbling single skaters, the floor
was cleared, and the darling of the rink glided upon the scene. He was a slender, handsome fellow, graceful
and expert to the nicest perfection in his profession. He seemed not so much to skate as to float about the
floor, with no effort except volition. His rhythmic movements were followed with pleasure, but it was his
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 32
Page No 35
feats of dexterity, which were more wonderful than graceful, that brought down the house. It was evident that
he was a hero to the female part of the spectators, and no doubt his charming image continued to float round
and round in the brain of many a girl when she put her, head on the pillow that night. It is said that a good
many matches which are not projected or registered in heaven are made at the rink.
At the breakfasttable it appeared that the sketchingparty had been a great successfor everybody except
the artist, who had only some rough memoranda, like notes for a speech, to show. The amateurs had made
finished pictures.
Miss Benson had done some rocks, and had got their hardness very well. Miss Lamont's effort was more
ambitious; her picture took in no less than miles of coast, as much sea as there was room for on the paper, a
navy of sailboats, and all the rocks and figures that were in the foreground, and it was done with a great deal
of naivete and conscientiousness. When it was passed round the table, the comments were very flattering.
"It looks just like it," said Mr. Benson.
"It's very comprehensive," remarked Mr. Forbes.
"What I like, Marion," said Mr. De Long, holding it out at arm'slength, "is the perspective; it isn't an easy
thing to put ships up in the sky."
"Of course," explained Irene, "it was a kind of hazy day."
"But I think Miss Lamont deserves credit for keeping the haze out of it." King was critically examining it,
turning his head from side to side. "I like it; but I tell you what I think it lacks: it lacks atmosphere. Why don't
you cut a hole in it, Miss Lamont, and let the air in?"
"Mr. King," replied Miss Lamont, quite seriously, "you are a real friend, I can only repay you by taking you
to church this morning."
"You didn't make much that time, King," said Forbes, as he lounged out of the room.
After church King accepted a seat in the Benson carriage for a drive on the Ocean Road. He who takes this
drive for the first time is enchanted with the scene, and it has so much variety, deliciousness in curve and
winding, such graciousness in the union of sea and shore, such charm of color, that increased acquaintance
only makes one more in love with it. A good part of its attraction lies in the fickleness of its aspect. Its serene
and soft appearance might pall if it were not now and then, and often suddenly, and with little warning,
transformed into a wild coast, swept by a tearing wind, enveloped in a thick fog, roaring with the noise of the
angry sea slapping the rocks and breaking in foam on the fragments its rage has cast down. This elementary
mystery and terror is always present, with one familiar with the coast, to qualify the gentleness of its lovelier
aspects. It has all moods. Perhaps the most exhilarating is that on a brilliant day, when shore and sea sparkle
in the sun, and the waves leap high above the cliffs, and fall in diamond showers.
This Sunday the shore was in its most gracious mood, the landscape as if newly created. There was a light,
luminous fog, which revealed just enough to excite the imagination, and refined every outline and softened
every color. Mr. King and Irene left the carriage to follow the road, and wandered along the sea path. What
softness and tenderness of color in the gray rocks, with the browns and reds of the vines and lichens! They
went out on the iron fishingstands, and looked down at the shallow water. The rocks under water took on
the most exquisite shadespurple and malachite and brown; the barnacles clung to them; the long
seaweeds, in half a dozen varieties, some in vivid colors, swept over them, flowing with the restless tide,
like the long locks of a drowned woman's hair. King, who had dabbled a little in natural history, took great
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 33
Page No 36
delight in pointing out to Irene this varied and beautiful life of the sea; and the girl felt a new interest in
science, for it was all pure science, and she opened her heart to it, not knowing that love can go in by the door
of science as well as by any other opening. Was Irene really enraptured by the dear little barnacles and the
exquisite seaweeds? I have seen a girl all of a flutter with pleasure in a laboratory when a young chemist
was showing her the retorts and the crooked tubes and the glass wool and the freaks of color which the
alkalies played with the acids. God has made them so, these women, and let us be thankful for it.
What a charm there was about everything! Occasionally the mist became so thin that a long line of coast and
a great breadth of sea were visible, with the white sails drifting.
"There's nothing like it," said King"there's nothing like this island. It seems as if the Creator had
determined to show man, once for all, a landscape perfectly refined, you might almost say with the beauty of
highbreeding, refined in outline, color, everything softened into loveliness, and yet touched with the wild
quality of picturesqueness."
" It's just a dream at this moment," murmured Irene. They were standing on a promontory of rock. "See those
figures of people there through the mistsilhouettes only. And look at that vesseltherenoit has
gone."
As she was speaking, a sailvessel began to loom up large in the mysterious haze. But was it not the ghost of
a ship? For an instant it was coming, coming; it was distinct; and when it was plainly in sight it faded away,
like a dissolving view, and was gone. The appearance was unreal. What made it more spectral was the bell on
the reefs, swinging in its triangle, always sounding, and the momentary scream of the fog whistle. It was
like an enchanted coast. Regaining the carriage, they drove out to the end, Agassiz's Point, where, when the
mist lifted, they saw the sea all round dotted with sails, the irregular coasts and islands with headlands and
lighthouses, all the picture still, land and water in a summer swoon.
Late that afternoon all the party were out upon the cliff path in front of the cottages. There is no more lovely
sea stroll in the world, the way winding over the cliff edge by the turquoise sea, where the turf, close cut and
green as Erin, set with flower beds and dotted with noble trees, slopes down, a broad pleasure park, from the
stately and picturesque villas. But it was a social mistake to go there on Sunday. Perhaps it is not the height
of good form to walk there any day, but Mr. King did not know that the fashion had changed, and that on
Sunday this lovely promenade belongs to the butlers and the upper maids, especially to the butlers, who make
it resplendent on Sunday afternoons when the weather is good. As the weather had thickened in the late
afternoon, our party walked in a dumbshow, listening to the soft swish of the waves on the rocks below, and
watching the figures of other promenaders, who were good enough ladies and gentlemen in this friendly mist.
The next day Mr. King made a worse mistake. He remembered that at high noon everybody went down to the
first beach, a charming sheltered place at the bottom of the bay, where the rollers tumble in finely from the
south, to bathe or see others bathe. The beach used to be lined with carriages at that hour, and the surf, for a
quarter of a mile, presented the appearance of a line of picturesquely clad skirmishers going out to battle with
the surf. Today there were not half a dozen carriages and omnibuses altogether, and the bathers were
fewnursery maids, fragments of a dayexcursion, and some of the fair conventionists. Newport was not
there. Mr. King had led his party into another social blunder. It has ceased to be fashionable to bathe at
Newport.
Strangers and servants may do so, but the cottagers have withdrawn their support from the ocean. Saltwater
may be carried to the house and used without loss of caste, but bathing in the surf is vulgar. A gentleman may
go down and take a dip aloneit had better be at an early hourand the ladies of the house may be heard to
apologize for his eccentricity, as if his fondness for the water were abnormal and quite out of experience. And
the observer is obliged to admit that promiscuous bathing is vulgar, as it is plain enough to be seen when it
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 34
Page No 37
becomes unfashionable. It is charitable to think also that the cottagers have made it unfashionable because it
is vulgar, and not because it is a cheap and refreshing pleasure accessible to everybody.
Nevertheless, Mr. King's ideas of Newport were upset. "It's a little off color to walk much on the cliffs; you
lose caste if you bathe in the surf. What can you do?"
"Oh," explained Miss Lamont, "you can make calls; go to teas and receptions and dinners; belong to the
Casino, but not appear there much; and you must drive on the Ocean Road, and look as English as you can.
Didn't you notice that Redfern has an establishment on the Avenue? Well, the London girls wear what
Redfern tells them to wearmuch to the improvement of their appearanceand so it has become possible for
a New Yorker to become partially English without sacrificing her native taste."
Before lunch Mrs. Bartlett Glow called on the Bensons, and invited them to a fiveo'clock tea, and Miss
Lamont, who happened to be in the parlor, was included in the invitation. Mrs. Glow was as gracious as
possible, and especially attentive to the old lady, who purred with pleasure, and beamed and expanded into
familiarity under the encouragement of the woman of the world. In less than ten minutes Mrs. Glow had
learned the chief points in the family history, the state of health and habits of pa (Mr. Benson), and all about
Cyrusville and its wonderful growth. In all this Mrs. Glow manifested a deep interest, and learned, by
observing out of the corner of her eye, that Irene was in an agony of apprehension, which she tried to conceal
under an increasing coolness of civility. "A nice lady," was Mrs. Benson's comment when Mrs. Glow had
taken herself away with her charminglyscented air of frank cordiality"a real nice lady. She seemed just
like our, folks."
Irene heaved a deep sigh. "I suppose we shall have to go."
"Have to go, child? I should think you'd like to go. I never saw such a girlnever. Pa and me are just
studying all the time to please you, and it seems as if" And the old lady's voice broke down.
"Why, mother dear"and the girl, with tears in her eyes, leaned over her and kissed her fondly, and stroked
her hair"you are just as good and sweet as you can be; and don't mind me; you know I get in moods
sometimes."
The old lady pulled her down and kissed her, and looked in her face with beseeching eyes.
"What an old frump the mother is!" was Mrs. Glow's comment to Stanhope, when she next met him; "but she
is immensely amusing."
"She is a kindhearted, motherly woman," replied King, a little sharply.
"Oh, motherly! Has it come to that? I do believe you are more than half gone. The girl is pretty; she has a
beautiful figure; but my gracious! her parents are impossiblejust impossible. And don't you think she's a
little too intellectual for society? I don't mean too intellectual, of course, but too mental, don't you
knowshows that first. You know what I mean."
"But, Penelope, I thought it was the fashion now to be intellectualgo in for reading, and literary clubs,
Dante and Shakespeare, and political economy, and all that."
"Yes, I belong to three clubs. I'm going to one tomorrow morning. We are going to take up the
'Disestablishment of the English Church.' That's different; we make it fit into social life somehow, and it
doesn't interfere. I'll tell you what, Stanhope, I'll take Miss Benson to the Town and County Club next
Saturday."
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 35
Page No 38
"That will be too intellectual for Miss Benson. I suppose the topic will be Transcendentalism?"
"No; we have had that. Professor Spor, of Cambridge, is going to lecture on Bacteriaif that's the way you
pronounce itthose mites that get into everything."
"I should think it would be very improving. I'll tell Miss Benson that if she stays in Newport she must
improve her mind,
"You can make yourself as disagreeable as you like to me, but mind you are on your good behavior at dinner
tonight, for the Misses Pelham will be here."
The fiveo'clock at Mrs. Bartlett Glow's was probably an event to nobody in Newport except Mrs. Benson.
To most it was only an incident in the afternoon round and drive, but everybody liked to go there, for it is one
of the most charming of the moderatesized villas. The lawn is planted in exquisite taste, and the gardener
has set in the open spaces of green the most ingenious devices of flowers and foliage plants, and nothing
could be more enchanting than the view from the wide veranda on the sea side. In theory, the occupants
lounge there, read, embroider, and swing in hammocks; in point of fact, the breeze is usually so strong that
these occupations are carried on indoors.
The rooms were well filled with a moving, chattering crowd when the Bensons arrived, but it could not be
said that their entrance was unnoticed, for Mr. Benson was conspicuous, as Irene had in vain hinted to her
father that he would be, in his evening suit, and Mrs. Benson's beaming, extragracious manner sent a little
shiver of amusement through the polite civility of the room.
"I was afraid we should be too late," was Mrs. Benson's response to the smiling greeting of the hostess, with a
most friendly look towards the rest of the company. "Mr. Benson is always behindhand in getting dressed for
a party, and he said he guessed the party could wait, and"
Before the sentence was finished Mrs. Benson found herself passed on and in charge of a certain general,
who was charged by the hostess to get her a cup of tea. Her talk went right on, however, and Irene, who was
still standing by the host, noticed that wherever her mother went there was a lull in the general conversation,
a slight pause as if to catch what this motherly old person might be saying, and such phrases as, "It doesn't
agree with me, general; I can't eat it," "Yes, I got the rheumatiz in New Orleans, and he did too," floated over
the hum of talk.
In the introduction and movement that followed Irene became one of a group of young ladies and gentlemen
who, after the first exchange of civilities, went on talking about matters of which she knew nothing, leaving
her wholly out of the conversation. The matters seemed to be very important, and the conversation was
animated: it was about soandso who was expected, or was or was not engaged, or the last evening at the
Casino, or the new trap on the Avenuethe delightful little chitchat by means of which those who are in
society exchange good understandings, but which excludes one not in the circle. The young gentleman next
to Irene threw in an explanation now and then, but she was becoming thoroughly uncomfortable. She could
not be unconscious, either, that she was the object of polite transient scrutiny by the ladies, and of glances of
interest from gentlemen who did not approach her. She began to be annoyed by the staring (the sort of stare
that a woman recognizes as impudent admiration) of a young fellow who leaned against the mantel a youth
in English clothes who had caught very successfully the air of an English groom. Two girls near her, to whom
she had been talking, began speaking in lowered voices in French, but she could not help overhearing them,
and her face flushed hotly when she found that her mother and her appearance were the subject of their
foreign remarks.
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 36
Page No 39
Luckily at the moment Mr. King approached, and Irene extended her hand and said, with a laugh, "Ah,
monsieur," speaking in a very pretty Paris accent, and perhaps with unnecessary distinctness, "you were quite
right: the society here is very different from Cyrusville; there they all talk about each other."
Mr. King, who saw that something had occurred, was quickwitted enough to reply jestingly in French, as
they moved away, but he asked, as soon as they were out of earshot, "What is it?"
"Nothing," said the girl, recovering her usual serenity. "I only said something for the sake of saying
something; I didn't mean to speak so disrespectfully of my own town. But isn't it singular how local and
provincial society talk is everywhere? I must look up mother, and then I want you to take me on the veranda
for some air. What a delightful house this is of your cousin's!"
The two young ladies who had dropped into French looked at each other for a moment after Irene moved
away, and one of them spoke for both when she exclaimed: "Did you ever see such rudeness in a
drawingroom! Who could have dreamed that she understood?" Mrs. Benson had been established very
comfortably in a corner with Professor Slem, who was listening with great apparent interest to her accounts
of the early life in Ohio. Irene seemed relieved to get away into the open air, but she was in a mood that Mr.
King could not account for. Upon the veranda they encountered Miss Lamont and the artist, whose natural
enjoyment of the scene somewhat restored her equanimity. Could there be anything more refined and
charming in the world than this landscape, this hospitable, smiling house, with the throng of easymannered,
pleasantspeaking guests, leisurely flowing along in the conventional stream of social comity. One must be a
churl not to enjoy it. But Irene was not sorry when, presently, it was time to go, though she tried to extract
some comfort from her mother's enjoyment of the occasion. It was beautiful. Mr. Benson was in a calculating
mood. He thought it needed a great deal of money to make things run so smoothly.
Why should one inquire in such a paradise if things do run smoothly? Cannot one enjoy a rose without
pulling it up by the roots ? I have no patience with those people who are always looking on the seamy side. I
agree with the commercial traveler who says that it will only be in the millennium that all goods will be alike
on both sides. Mr. King made the acquaintance in Newport of the great but somewhat philosophical Mr.
Snodgrass, who is writing a work on "The Discomforts of the Rich," taking a view of life which he says has
been wholly overlooked. He declares that their annoyances, sufferings, mortifications, envies, jealousies,
disappointments, dissatisfactions (and so on through the dictionary of disagreeable emotions), are a great deal
more than those of the poor, and that they are more worthy of sympathy. Their troubles are real and
unbearable, because they are largely of the mind. All these are set forth with so much powerful language and
variety of illustration that King said no one could read the book without tears for the rich of Newport, and he
asked Mr. Snodgrass why he did not organize a society for their relief. But the latter declared that it was not a
matter for levity. The misery is real. An imaginary case would illustrate his meaning. Suppose two persons
quarrel about a purchase of land, and one builds a stable on his lot so as to shut out his neighbor's view of the
sea. Would not the one suffer because he could not see the ocean, and the other by reason of the revengeful
state of his mind? He went on to argue that the owner of a splendid villa might have, for reasons he gave, less
content in it than another person in a tiny cottage so small that it had no spare room for his motherinlaw
even, and that in fact his satisfaction in his own place might be spoiled by the more showy place of his
neighbor. Mr. Snodgrass attempts in his book a philosophical explanation of this. He says that if every man
designed his own cottage, or had it designed as an expression of his own ideas, and developed his grounds
and landscape according to his own tastes, working it out himself, with the help of specialists, he would be
satisfied. But when owners have no ideas about architecture or about gardening, and their places are the
creation of some experimenting architect and a foreign gardener, and the whole effort is not to express a
person's individual taste and character, but to make a show, then discontent as to his own will arise whenever
some new and more showy villa is built. Mr. Benson, who was poking about a good deal, strolling along the
lanes and getting into the rears of the houses, said, when this book was discussed, that his impression was that
the real object of these fine places was to support a lot of English gardeners, grooms, and stableboys. They
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 37
Page No 40
are a kind of aristocracy. They have really made Newport (that is the summer, transient Newport, for it is
largely a transient Newport). "I've been inquiring," continued Mr. Benson, "and you'd be surprised to know
the number of people who come here, buy or build expensive villas, splurge out for a year or two, then fail or
get tired of it, and disappear."
Mr. Snodgrass devotes a chapter to the parvenues at Newport. By the parvenuhis definition may not be
scientifiche seems to mean a person who is vulgar, but has money, and tries to get into society on the
strength of his money alone. He is more to be pitied than any other sort of rich man. For he not only works
hard and suffers humiliation in getting his place in society, but after he is in he works just as hard, and with
bitterness in his heart, to keep out other parvenues like himself. And this is misery.
But our visitors did not care for the philosophizing of Mr. Snodgrass you can spoil almost anything by
turning it wrong side out. They thought Newport the most beautiful and finished wateringplace in America.
Nature was in the loveliest mood when it was created, and art has generally followed her suggestions of
beauty and refinement. They did not agree with the cynic who said that Newport ought to be walled in, and
have a gate with an inscription, "None but Millionaires allowed here." It is very easy to get out of the
artificial Newport and to come into scenery that Nature has made after artistic designs which artists are
satisfied with. A favorite drive of our friends was to the Second Beach and the Purgatory Rocks overlooking
it. The photographers and the watercolor artists have exaggerated the Purgatory chasm into a Colorado
canon, but anybody can find it by help of a guide. The rock of this locality is a curious study. It is an
agglomerate made of pebbles and cement, the pebbles being elongated as if by pressure. The rock is
sometimes found in detached fragments having the form of tree trunks. Whenever it is fractured, the fracture
is a clean cut, as if made by a saw, and through both pebbles and cement, and the ends present the appearance
of a composite cake filled with almonds and cut with a knife. The landscape is beautiful.
"All the lines are so simple," the artist explained. "The shore, the sea, the gray rocks, with here and there the
roof of a quaint cottage to enliven the effect, and few trees, only just enough for contrast with the long,
sweeping lines."
"You don't like trees?" asked Miss Lamont.
"Yes, in themselves. But trees are apt to be in the way. There are too many trees in America. It is not often
you can get a broad, simple effect like this."
It happened to be a day when the blue of the sea was that of the Mediterranean, and the sky and sea melted
into each other, so that a distant sailboat seemed to be climbing into the heavens. The waves rolled in blue
on the white sand beach, and broke in silver. Three young girls on horseback galloping in a race along the
hard beach at the moment gave the needed animation to a very pretty picture.
North of this the land comes down to the sea in knolls of rock breaking off suddenlyrocks gray with lichen,
and shaded with a touch of other vegetation. Between these knifeback ledges are plots of seagreen grass and
sedge, with little ponds, black, and mirroring the sky. Leaving this wild bit of nature, which has got the name
of Paradise (perhaps because few people go there), the road back to town sweeps through sweet farm land;
the smell of hay is in the air, loads of hay encumber the roads, flowers in profusion half smother the farm
cottages, and the trees of the appleorchards are gnarled and picturesque as olives.
The younger members of the party climbed up into this paradise one day, leaving the elders in their carriages.
They came into a new world, as unlike Newport as if they had been a thousand miles away. The spot was
wilder than it looked from a distance. The high ridges of rock lay parallel, with bosky valleys and ponds
between, and the sea shining in the south all in miniature. On the way to the ridges they passed clean pasture
fields, bowlders, gray rocks, aged cedars with flat tops like the stonepines of Italy. It was all wild but
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 38
Page No 41
exquisite, a refined wildness recalling the pictures of Rousseau.
Irene and Mr. King strolled along one of the ridges, and sat down on a rock looking off upon the peaceful
expanse, the silver lines of the curving shores, and the blue sea dotted with white sails.
"Ah," said the girl, with an inspiration, "this is the sort of five o'clock I like."
"And I'm sure I'd rather be here with you than at the Blims' reception, from which we ran away."
"I thought," said Irene, not looking at him, and jabbing the point of her parasol into the ground, "I thought
you liked Newport."
"So I do, or did. I thought you would like it. But, pardon me, you seem somehow different from what you
were at Fortress Monroe, or even at lovely Atlantic City," this with a rather forced laugh.
"Do I? Well, I suppose I am; that is, different from what you thought me. I should hate this place in a week
more, beautiful as it is."
"Your mother is pleased here?"
The girl looked up quickly. "I forgot to tell you how much she thanked you for the invitation to your cousin's.
She was delighted there."
"And you were not?"
"I didn't say so; you were very kind."
"Oh, kind; I didn't mean to be kind. I was purely selfish in wanting you to go. Cannot you believe, Miss
Benson, that I had some pride in having my friends see you and know you?"
"Well, I will be as frank as you are, Mr. King. I don't like being shown off. There, don't look displeased. I
didn't mean anything disagreeable."
"But I hoped you understood my motives better by this time."
"I did not think about motives, but the fact is" (another jab of the parasol), "I was made desperately
uncomfortable, and always shall be under such circumstances, and, my friendI should like to believe you
are my friendyou may as well expect I always will be."
"I cannot do that. You under"
"I just see things as they are," Irene went on, hastily. "You think I am different here. Well, I don't mind
saying that when I made your acquaintance I thought you different from any man I had met." But now it was
out, she did mind saying it; and stopped, confused, as if she had confessed something. But she continued,
almost immediately: "I mean I liked your manner to women; you didn't appear to flatter, and you didn't talk
complimentary nonsense."
"And now I do?"
"No. Not that. But everything is somehow changed here. Don't let's talk of it. There's the carriage."
Their Pilgrimage
IV. NEWPORT 39
Page No 42
Irene arose, a little flushed, and walked towards the point. Mr. King, picking his way along behind her over
the rocks, said, with an attempt at lightening the situation, " Well, Miss Benson, I'm going to be just as
different as ever a man was."
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S
VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH
We have heard it said that one of the charms, of Narragansett Pier is that you can see Newport from it. The
summer dwellers at the Pier talk a good deal about liking it better than Newport; it is less artificial and more
restful. The Newporters never say anything about the Pier. The Pier people say that it is not fair to judge it
when you come direct from Newport, but the longer you stay there the better you like it; and if any too frank
person admits that he would not stay in Narragansett a day if he could afford to live in Newport, he is
suspected of aristocratic proclivities.
In a calm summer morning, such as our party of pilgrims chose for an excursion to the Pier, there is no
prettier sail in the world than that out of the harbor, by Conanicut Island and Beavertail Light. It is a holiday
harbor, all these seas are holiday seasthe yachts, the sail vessels, the puffing steamers, moving swiftly from
one headland to another, or loafing about the blue, smiling sea, are all on pleasure bent. The vagrant vessels
that are idly watched from the rocks at the Pier may be coasters and freight schooners engaged seriously in
trade, but they do not seem so. They are a part of the picture, always to be seen slowly dipping along in the
horizon, and the impression is that they are manoeuvred for show, arranged for picturesque effect, and that
they are all taken in at night.
The visitors confessed when they landed that the Pier was a contrast to Newport. The shore below the landing
is a line of broken, ragged, slimy rocks, as if they had been dumped there for a riprap wall. Fronting this
unkempt shore is a line of barracklike hotels, with a few cottages of the cheap sort. At the end of this row of
hotels is a fine granite Casino, spacious, solid, with wide verandas, and a tenniscourtsuch a building as
even Newport might envy. Then come more hotels, a cluster of cheap shops, and a long line of bathhouses
facing a lovely curving beach. Bathing is the fashion at the Pier, and everybody goes to the beach at noon.
The spectators occupy chairs on the platform in front of the bathhouses, or sit under tents erected on the
smooth sand. At high noon the scene is very lively, and even picturesque, for the ladies here dress for bathing
with an intention of pleasing. It is generally supposed that the angels in heaven are not edified by this
promiscuous bathing, and by the spectacle of a crowd of women tossing about in the surf, but an impartial
angel would admit that many of the costumes here are becoming, and that the effect of the red and yellow
caps, making a color line in the flashing rollers, is charming. It is true that there are odd figures in the shifting
meleeone solitary old gentleman, who had contrived to get his bathingsuit on hindside before, wandered
along the ocean margin like a lost Ulysses; and that fat woman and fat man were never intended for this sort
of exhibition; but taken altogether, with its colors, and the silver flash of the breaking waves, the scene was
exceedingly pretty. Not the least pretty part of it was the fringe of children tumbling on the beach, following
the retreating waves, and flying from the incoming rollers with screams of delight. Children, indeed, are a
characteristic of Narragansett Pierchildren and mothers. It might be said to be a family place; it is a good
deal so on Sundays, and occasionally when the "business men" come down from the cities to see how their
wives and children get on at the hotels.
After the bathing it is the fashion to meet again at the Casino and take lunchsometimes through a
strawand after dinner everybody goes for a stroll on the cliffs. This is a noble seapromenade; with its
handsome villas and magnificent rocks, a fair rival to Newport. The walk, as usually taken, is two or three
miles along the bold, rocky shore, but an ambitious pedestrian may continue it to the light on Point Judith.
Nowhere on this coast are the rocks more imposing, and nowhere do they offer so many studies in color. The
visitor's curiosity is excited by a massive granite tower which rises out of a mass of tangled woods planted on
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 40
Page No 43
the crest of the hill, and his curiosity is not satisfied on nearer inspection, when he makes his way into this
thick and gloomy forest, and finds a granite cottage near the tower, and the signs of neglect and wildness that
might mark the home of a recluse. What is the object of this noble tower? If it was intended to adorn the
landscape, why was it ruined by piercing it irregularly with square windows like those of a factory?
One has to hold himself back from being drawn into the history and romance of this Narragansett shore.
Down below the bathing beach is the pretentious wooden pile called Canonchet, that already wears the air of
tragedy. And here, at this end, is the mysterious tower, and an ugly unfinished dwellinghouse of granite,
with the legend "Druid's Dream" carved over the entrance door; and farther inland, in a sandy and shrubby
landscape, is Kendall Green, a private cemetery, with its granite monument, surrounded by heavy granite
posts, every other one of which is hollowed in the top as a receptacle for food for birds. And one reads there
these inscriptions: "Whatever their mode of faith, or creed, who feed the wandering birds, will themselves be
fed." "Who helps the helpless, Heaven will help." This inland region, now apparently deserted and neglected,
was once the seat of colonial aristocracy, who exercised a princely hospitality on their great plantations,
exchanged visits and ran horses with the planters of Virginia and the Carolinas, and were known as far as
Kentucky, and perhaps best known for their breed of Narragansett pacers. But let us get back to the shore.
In wandering along the cliff path in the afternoon, Irene and Mr. King were separated from the others, and
unconsciously extended their stroll, looking for a comfortable seat in the rocks. The day was perfect. The sky
had only a few fleecy, highsailing clouds, and the great expanse of sea sparkled under the hectoring of a
light breeze. The atmosphere was not too clear on the horizon for dreamy effects; all the headlands were
softened and tinged with opalescent colors. As the light struck them, the sails which enlivened the scene were
either dark spots or shining silver sheets on the delicate blue. At one spot on this shore rises a vast mass of
detached rock, separated at low tide from the shore by irregular bowlders and a tiny thread of water. In search
of a seat the two strollers made their way across this rivulet over the broken rocks, passed over the summit of
the giant mass, and established themselves in a cavernous place close to the sea. Here was a natural seat, and
the bulk of the seamed and colored ledge, rising above their heads and curving around them, shut them out of
sight of the land, and left them alone with the dashing sea, and the gulls that circled and dipped their silver
wings in their eager pursuit of prey. For a time neither spoke. Irene was looking seaward, and Mr. King, who
had a lower seat, attentively watched the waves lapping the rocks at their feet, and the fine profile and trim
figure of the girl against the sky. He thought he had never seen her looking more lovely, and yet he had a
sense that she never was so remote from him. Here was an opportunity, to be sure, if he had anything to say,
but some fine feeling of propriety restrained him from taking advantage of it. It might not be quite fair, in a
place so secluded and remote, and with such sentimental influences, shut in as they were to the sea and the
sky.
"It seems like a world by itself," she began, as in continuation of her thought. "They say you can see Gay
Head Light from here."
"Yes. And Newport to the left there, with its towers and trees rising out of the sea. It is quite like the Venice
Lagoon in this light."
"I think I like Newport better at this distance. It is very poetical. I don't think I like what is called the world
much, when I am close to it."
The remark seemed to ask for sympathy, and Mr. King ventured: "Are you willing to tell me, Miss Benson,
why you have not seemed as happy at Newport as elsewhere? Pardon me; it is not an idle question." Irene,
who seemed to be looking away beyond Gay Head, did not reply. "I should like to know if I have been in any
way the cause of it. We agreed to be friends, and I think I have a friend's right to know." Still no response.
"You must seeyou must know," he went on, hurriedly, "that it cannot be a matter of indifference to me."
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 41
Page No 44
"It had better be," she said, as if speaking deliberately to herself, and still looking away. But suddenly she
turned towards him, and the tears sprang to her eyes, and the words rushed out fiercely, "I wish I had never
left Cyrusville. I wish I had never been abroad. I wish I had never been educated. It is all a wretched
mistake."
King was unprepared for such a passionate outburst. It was like a rift in a cloud, through which he had a
glimpse of her real life. Words of eager protest sprang to his lips, but, before they could be uttered, either her
mood had changed or pride had come to the rescue, for she said: "How silly I am! Everybody has
discontented days. Mr. King, please don't ask me such questions. If you want to be a friend, you will let me
be unhappy now and then, and not say anything about it."
"But, Miss BensonIrene"
"There'Miss Benson' will do very well."
"Well, MissIrene, then, there was something I wanted to say to you the other day in Paradise"
"Look, Mr. King. Did you see that wave? I'm sure it is nearer our feet than when we sat down here."
"Oh, that's just an extra lift by the wind. I want to tell you. I must tell you that lifehas all changed since I
met youIrene, I"
"There! There's no mistakeabout that. The last wave came a foot higher than the other!"
King sprang up. "Perhaps it is the tide. I'll go and see." He ran up the rock, leaped across the fissures, and
looked over on the side they had ascended. Sure enough, the tide was coming in. The stones on which they
had stepped were covered, and a deep stream of water, rising with every pulsation of the sea, now, where
there was only a rivulet before. He hastened back. "There is not a moment to lose. We are caught by the tide,
and if we are not off in five minutes we shall be prisoners here till the turn."
He helped her up the slope and over the chasm. The way was very plain when they came on, but now he
could not find it. At the end of every attempt was a precipice. And the water was rising. A little girl on the
shore shouted to them to follow along a ledge she pointed out, then descend between two bowlders to the
ford. Precious minutes were lost in accomplishing this circuitous descent, and then they found the stepping
stones under water, and the seaweed swishing about the slippery rocks with the incoming tide. It was a
ridiculous position for lovers, or even "friends"ridiculous because it had no element of danger except the
ignominy of getting wet. If there was any heroism in seizing Irene before she could protest, stumbling with
his burden among the slimy rocks, and depositing her, with only wet shoes, on the shore, Mr. King shared it,
and gained the title of "Lifepreserver." The adventure ended with a laugh.
The day after the discovery and exploration of Narragansett, Mr. King spent the morning with his cousin at
the Casino. It was so pleasant that he wondered he had not gone there oftener, and that so few people
frequented it. Was it that the cottagers were too strong for the Casino also, which was built for the recreation
of the cottagers, and that they found when it came to the test that they could not with comfort come into any
sort of contact with popular life? It is not large, but no summer resort in Europe has a prettier place for
lounging and reunion. None have such an air of refinement and exclusiveness. Indeed, one of the chief
attractions and entertainments in the foreign casinos and conversationhalls is the mingling there of all sorts
of peoples, and the animation arising from diversity of conditions. This popular commingling in pleasure
resorts is safe enough in aristocratic countries, but it will not answer in a republic.
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 42
Page No 45
The Newport Casino is in the nature of a club of the best society. The building and grounds express the most
refined taste. Exteriorly the house is a long, low Queen Anne cottage, with brilliant shops on the
groundfloor, and above, behind the wooded balconies, is the clubroom. The tint of the shingled front is
brown, and all the colors are low and blended. Within, the court is a mediaeval surprise. It is a miniature
castle, such as might serve for an opera scene. An extension of the galleries, an ombre, completes the circle
around the plot of close clipped green turf. The house itself is all balconies, galleries, odd windows half
overgrown and hidden by ivy, and a large gilt clockface adds a touch of piquancy to the antique charm of
the facade. Beyond the first court is a more spacious and less artificial lawn, set with fine trees, and at the
bottom of it is the brown building containing ballroom and theatre, bowlingalley and closed tenniscourt,
and at an angle with the second lawn is a pretty field for lawntennis. Here the tournaments are held, and on
these occasions, and on ball nights, the Casino is thronged.
If the Casino is then so exclusive, why is it not more used as a rendezvous and loungingplace? Alas! it must
be admitted that it is not exclusive. By an astonishing concession in the organization any person can gain
admittance by paying the sum of fifty cents. This tax is sufficient to exclude the deserving poor, but it is only
an inducement to the vulgar rich, and it is even broken down by the prodigal excursionist, who commonly
sets out from home with the intention of being reckless for one day. It is easy to see, therefore, why the charm
of this delightful place is tarnished.
The band was playing this morningnot rink musicwhen Mrs. Glow and King entered and took chairs on
the ombre. It was a very pretty scene; more people were present than usual of a morning. Groups of half a
dozen had drawn chairs together here and there, and were chatting and laughing; two or three exceedingly
wellpreserved old bachelors, in the smart rough morning suits of the period, were entertaining their lady
friends with club and horse talk; several old gentlemen were reading newspapers; and there were some
dowagerlooking mammas, and seated by them their cold, beautiful, highbred daughters, who wore their
visible exclusiveness like a garment, and contrasted with some other young ladies who were promenading
with Englishlooking young men in flannel suits, who might be described as lawntennis young ladies
conscious of being in the mode, but wanting the indescribable atmosphere of highbreeding. Doubtless the
most interesting persons to the student of human life were the young fellows in lawntennis suits. They had
the languid air which is so attractive at their age, of having found out life, and decided that it is a bore.
Nothing is worth making an exertion about, not even pleasure. They had come, one could see, to a just
appreciation of their value in life, and understood quite well the social manners of the mammas and girls in
whose company they condescended to dawdle and make, languidly, cynical observations. They had, in truth,
the manner of playing at fashion and elegance as in a stage comedy. King could not help thinking there was
something theatrical about them altogether, and he fancied that when he saw them in their "traps" on the
Avenue they were going through the motions for show and not for enjoyment. Probably King was mistaken
in all this, having been abroad so long that he did not understand the evolution of the American gilded youth.
In a pause of the music Mrs. Bartlett Glow and Mr. King were standing with a group near the steps that led
down to the inner lawn. Among them were the Postlethwaite girls, whose beauty and audacity made such a
sensation in Washington last winter. They were bantering Mr. King about his Narragansett excursion, his
cousin having maliciously given the party a hint of his encounter with the tide at the Pier. . . Just at this
moment, happening to glance across the lawn, he saw the Bensons coming towards the steps, Mrs. Benson
waddling over the grass and beaming towards the group, Mr. Benson carrying her shawl and looking as if he
had been hired by the day, and Irene listlessly following. Mrs. Glow saw them at the same moment, but gave
no other sign of her knowledge than by striking into the banter with more animation. Mr. King intended at
once to detach himself and advance to meet the Bensons. But he could not rudely break away from the
unfinished sentence of the younger Postlethwaite girl, and the instant that was concluded, as luck would have
it, an elderly lady joined the group, and Mrs. Glow went through the formal ceremony of introducing King to
her. He hardly knew how it happened, only that he made a hasty bow to the Bensons as he was shaking hands
with the ceremonious old lady, and they had gone to the door of exit. He gave a little start as if to follow
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 43
Page No 46
them, which Mrs. Glow noticed with a laugh and the remark, "You can catch them if you run," and then he
weakly submitted to his fate. After all, it was only an accident which would hardly need a word of
explanation. But what Irene saw was this: a distant nod from Mrs. Glow, a cool survey and stare from the
Postlethwaite girls, and the failure of Mr. King to recognize his friends any further than by an indifferent bow
as he turned to speak to another lady. In the raw state of her sensitiveness she felt all this as a terrible and
perhaps intended humiliation.
King did not return to the hotel till evening, and then he sent up his card to the Bensons. Word came back that
the ladies were packing, and must be excused. He stood at the office desk and wrote a hasty note to Irene,
attempting an explanation of what might seem to her a rudeness, and asked that he might see her a moment.
And then he paced the corridor waiting for a reply. In his impatience the fifteen minutes that he waited
seemed an hour. Then a bellboy handed him this note:
"MY DEAR MR. KING,No explanation whatever was needed. We never
shall forget your kindness. Goodby.
IRENE BENSON"
He folded the note carefully and put it in his breast pocket, took it out and reread it, lingering over the fine
and dainty signature, put it back again, and walked out upon the piazza. It was a divine night, soft and
sweetscented, and all the rustling trees were luminous in the electric light. From a window opening upon a
balcony overhead came the clear notes of a barytone voice enunciating the oldfashioned words of an English
ballad, the refrain of which expressed hopeless separation.
The eastern coast, with its ragged outline of bays, headlands, indentations, islands, capes, and sandspits,
from Watch Hill, a favorite breezy resort, to Mount Desert, presents an almost continual chain of hotels and
summer cottages. In fact, the same may be said of the whole Atlantic front from Mount Desert down to Cape
May. It is to the traveler an amazing spectacle. The American people can no longer be reproached for not
taking any summer recreation. The amount of money invested to meet the requirements of this vacation
idleness is enormous. When one is on the coast in July or August it seems as if the whole fifty millions of
people had come down to lie on the rocks, wade in the sand, and dip into the sea. But this is not the case.
These crowds are only a fringe of the pleasureseeking population. In all the mountain regions from North
Carolina to the Adirondacks and the White Hills, along the St. Lawrence and the lakes away up to the
Northwest, in every elevated village, on every mountainside, about every pond, lake, and clear stream, in
the wilderness and the secluded farmhouse, one encounters the traveler, the summer boarder, the vacation
idler, one is scarcely out of sight of the American flag flying over a summer resort. In no other nation,
probably, is there such a general summer hejira, no other offers on such a vast scale such a variety of
entertainment, and it is needless to say that history presents no parallel to this general movement of a people
for a summer outing. Yet it is no doubt true that statistics, which always upset a broad generous statement
such as I have made, would show that the majority of people stay at home in the summer, and it is undeniable
that the vexing question for everybody is where to go in July and August.
But there are resorts suited to all tastes, and to the economical as well as to the extravagant. Perhaps the
strongest impression one has in visiting the various wateringplaces in the summertime, is that the
multitudes of everyday folk are abroad in search of enjoyment. On the New Bedford boat for Martha's
Vineyard our little party of tourists sailed quite away from Newport lifeStanhope with mingled depression
and relief, the artist with some shrinking from contact with anything common, while Marion stood upon the
bow beside her uncle, inhaling the salt breeze, regarding the lovely fleeting shores, her cheeks glowing and
her eyes sparkling with enjoyment. The passengers and scene, Stanhope was thinking, were typically New
England, until the boat made a landing at Naushon Island, when he was reminded somehow of Scotland, as
much perhaps by the wild furzy appearance of the island as by the "gentlefolks" who went ashore.
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 44
Page No 47
The boat lingered for the further disembarkation of a number of horses and carriages, with a piano and a cow.
There was a farmer's lodge at the landing, and over the rocks and amid the trees the picturesque roof of the
villa of the sole proprietor of the island appeared, and gave a feudal aspect to the domain. The sweet grass
affords good picking for sheep, and besides the sheep the owner raises deer, which are destined to be chased
and shot in the autumn.
The artist noted that there were several distinct types of women on board, besides the common,
straightwaisted, flatchested variety. One girl who was alone, with a city air, a neat, firm figure, in a
traveling suit of elegant simplicity, was fond of taking attitudes about the rails, and watching the effect
produced on the spectators. There was a blueeyed, sharpfaced, rather loosejointed young girl, who had
the manner of being familiar with the boat, and talked readily and freely with anybody, keeping an eye
occasionally on her sister of eight years, a child with a serious little face in a pokebonnet, who used the
language of a young lady of sixteen, and seemed also abundantly able to take care of herself. What this mite
of a child wants of all things, she confesses, is a pugfaced dog. Presently she sees one come on board in the
arms of a young lady at Wood's Holl. "No," she says," I won't ask her for it; the lady wouldn't give it to me,
and I wouldn't waste my breath;" but she draws near to the dog, and regards it with rapt attention. The owner
of the dog is a very pretty blackeyed girl with banged hair, who prattles about herself and her dog with
perfect freedom. She is staying at Cottage City, lives at Worcester, has been up to Boston to meet and bring
down her dog, without which she couldn't live another minute. "Perhaps," she says, "you know Dr. Ridgerton,
in Worcester; he's my brother. Don't you know him? He's a chiropodist."
These girls are all types of the skatingrinkan institution which is beginning to express itself in American
manners.
The band was playing on the pier when the steamer landed at Cottage City (or Oak Bluff, as it was formerly
called), and the pier and the gallery leading to it were crowded with spectators, mostly women a pleasing
mingling of the skatingrink and sewingcircle varietiesand gayety was apparently about setting in with
the dusk. The rink and the, ground opposite the hotel were in full tilt. After supper King and Forbes took a
cursory view of this strange encampment, walking through the streets of fantastic tiny cottages among the
scrub oaks, and saw something of family life in the painted little boxes, whose wideopen front doors gave to
view the whole domestic economy, including the bed, centretable, and melodeon. They strolled also on the
elevated plank promenade by the beach, encountering now and then a couple enjoying the lovely night.
Music abounded. The circuspumping strains burst out of the rink, calling to a gay and perhaps dissolute life.
The band in the nearly empty hotel parlor, in a mournful mood, was wooing the guests who did not come to a
soothing tune, something like China"Why do we mourn departed friends?" A procession of lasses coming
up the broad walk, advancing out of the shadows of night, was heard afar off as the stalwart singers strode on,
chanting in high nasal voices that lovely hymn, which seems to suit the rink as well as the night promenade
and the campmeeting:
"We shall meum umwe shall meeet, meeetum um
we shall meet,
In the sweet byamby, byambyum umbyamby.
On the buuuuon the buuuuon the buteful shore."
In the morning this fairylike settlement, with its flimsy and eccentric architecture, took on more the
appearance of reality. The season was late, as usual, and the hotels were still waiting for the crowds that seem
to prefer to be late and make a rushing carnival of August, but the tiny cottages were nearly all occupied. At
10 A.M. the band was playing in the threestory pagoda sort of tower at the bathingplace, and the three
stories were crowded with female spectators. Below, under the bank, is a long array of bathhouses, and the
shallow water was alive with floundering and screaming bathers. Anchored a little out was a raft, from which
men and boys and a few venturesome girls were diving, displaying the human form in graceful curves. The
crowd was an immensely goodhumored one, and enjoyed itself. The sexes mingled together in the water,
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 45
Page No 48
and nothing thought of it, as old Pepys would have said, although many of the tightlyfitting costumes left
less to the imagination than would have been desired by a poet describing the scene as a phase of the
'comedie humaine.' The band, having played out its hour, trudged back to the hotel pier to toot while the noon
steamboat landed its passengers, in order to impress the new arrivals with the mad joyousness of the place.
The crowd gathered on the high gallery at the end of the pier added to this effect of reckless holiday
enjoyment. Miss Lamont was infected with this gayety, and took a great deal of interest in this peripatetic
band, which was playing again on the hotel piazza before dinner, with a sort of mechanical hilariousness. The
rink band opposite kept up a lively competition, grinding out goround music, imparting, if one may say so, a
glamour to existence. The band is on hand at the pier at four o'clock to toot again, and presently off, tramping
to some other hotel to satisfy the serious pleasure of this people.
While Mr. King could not help wondering how all this curious life would strike Irenehe put his
lonesomeness and longing in this wayand what she would say about it, he endeavored to divert his mind
by a study of the conditions, and by some philosophizing on the change that had come over American
summer life within a few years. In his investigations he was assisted by Mr. De Long, to whom this social life
was absolutely new, and who was disposed to regard it as peculiarly Yankeethe staid dissipation of a
seriousminded people. King, looking at it more broadly, found this pasteboard city by the sea one of the
most interesting developments of American life. The original nucleus was the Methodist campmeeting,
which, in the season, brought here twenty thousand to thirty thousand people at a time, who camped and
picnicked in a somewhat primitive style. Gradually the people who came here ostensibly for religious
exercises made a longer and more permanent occupation, and, without losing its ephemeral character, the
place grew and demanded more substantial accommodations. The spot is very attractive. Although the shore
looks to the east, and does not get the prevailing southern breeze, and the beach has little surf, both water and
air are mild, the bathing is safe and agreeable, and the view of the illimitable sea dotted with sails and
fishingboats is always pleasing. A crowd begets a crowd, and soon the world's people made a city larger
than the original one, and still more fantastic, by the aid of paint and the jigsaw. The tent, however, is the
type of all the dwellinghouses. The hotels, restaurants, and shops follow the usual order of flamboyant
seaside architecture. After a time the Baptists established a camp, ground on the bluffs on the opposite side of
the inlet. The world's people brought in the commercial element in the way of fancy shops for the sale of all
manner of cheap and bizarre "notions," and introduced the common amusements. And so, although the
campmeetings do not begin till late in August, this city of playhouses is occupied the summer long. The
shops and shows represent the taste of the million, and although there is a similarity in all these popular coast
wateringplaces, each has a characteristic of its own. The foreigner has a considerable opportunity of
studying family life, whether he lounges through the narrow, sometimes circular, streets by night, when it
appears like a fairy encampment, or by daylight, when there is no illusion. It seems to be a point of etiquette
to show as much of the interiors as possible, and one can learn something of cooking and bedmaking and
mending, and the art of doing up the back hair. The photographer revels here in pictorial opportunities. The
pictures of these bizarre cottages, with the family and friends seated in front, show very serious groups. One
of the Tabernaclea vast iron hood or dome erected over rows of benches that will seat two or three
thousand peoplerepresents the building when it is packed with an audience intent upon the preacher. Most
of the faces are of a grave, severe type, plain and good, of the sort of people ready to die for a notion. The
impression of these photographs is that these people abandon themselves soberly to the pleasures of the sea
and of this packed, gregarious life, and get solid enjoyment out of their recreation.
Here, as elsewhere on the coast, the greater part of the population consists of women and children, and the
young ladies complain of the absence of menand, indeed, something is desirable in society besides the
superannuated and the boys in roundabouts.
The artist and Miss Lamont, in search of the picturesque, had the courage, although the thermometer was in
the humor to climb up to ninety degrees, to explore the Baptist encampment. They were not rewarded by
anything new except at the landing, where, behind the bathhouses, the bathing suits were hung out to dry,
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 46
Page No 49
and presented a comical spectacle, the humor of which seemed to be lost upon all except themselves. It was
such a caricature of humanity! The suits hanging upon the line and distended by the wind presented the
appearance of headless, bloated forms, fat men and fat women kicking in the breeze, and vainly trying to
climb over the line. It was probably merely fancy, but they declared that these images seemed larger, more
bloated, and much livelier than those displayed on the Cottage City side. When travelers can be entertained
by trifles of this kind it shows that there is an absence of more serious amusement. And, indeed, although
people were not wanting, and music was in the air, and the bicycle and tricycle stable was well patronized by
men and women, and the noon bathing was well attended, it was evident that the life of Cottage City was not
in full swing by the middle of July.
The morning on which our tourists took the steamer for Wood's Holl the sea lay shimmering in the heat, only
stirred a little by the land breeze, and it needed all the invigoration of the short ocean voyage to brace them
up for the intolerably hot and dusty ride in the cars through the sandy part of Massachusetts. So long as the
train kept by the indented shore the route was fairly picturesque; all along Buzzard Bay and Onset Bay and
Monument Beach little cottages, gay with paint and fantastic saw work explained, in a measure, the design
of Providence in permitting this part of the world to be discovered; but the sandy interior had to be reconciled
to the deeper divine intention by a trial of patience and the cultivation of the heroic virtues evoked by a
struggle for existence, of fitting men and women for a better country. The travelers were confirmed, however,
in their theory of the effect of a sandy country upon the human figure. This is not a juicy land, if the
expression can be tolerated, any more than the sandy parts of New Jersey, and its unsympathetic dryness is
favorable to the productionone can hardly say development of the lean, enduring, flatchested, and angular
style of woman.
In order to reach Plymouth a wait of a couple of hours was necessary at one of the sleepy but historic
villages. There was here no tavern, no restaurant, and nobody appeared to have any license to sell anything
for the refreshment of the travelers. But at some distance from the station, in a tworoomed dwellinghouse,
a good woman was found who was willing to cook a meal of victuals, as she explained, and a sign on her
front door attested, she had a right to do. What was at the bottom of the local prejudice against letting the
wayfaring man have anything to eat and drink, the party could not ascertain, but the defiant air of the woman
revealed the fact that there was such a prejudice. She was a noble, robust, gigantic specimen of her sex, well
formed, strong as an ox, with a resolute jaw, and she talked, through tightlyclosed teeth, in an aggressive
manner. Dinner was ordered, and the party strolled about the village pending its preparation; but it was not
ready when they returned. "I ain't goin' to cook no victuals," the woman explained, not ungraciously, "till I
know folks is goin' to eat it." Knowledge of the world had made her justly cautious. She intended to set out a
good meal, and she had the true housewife's desire that it should be eaten, that there should be enough of it,
and that the guests should like it. When she waited on the table she displayed a pair of arms that would
discourage any approach to familiarity, and disincline a timid person to ask twice for pie; but in point of fact,
as soon as the party became her bonafide guests, she was royally hospitable, and only displayed anxiety lest
they should not eat enough.
"I like folks to be up and down and square," she began saying, as she vigilantly watched the effect of her
culinary skill upon the awed little party. "Yes, I've got a regular hotel license; you bet I have. There's been
folks lawed in this town for sellin' a meal of victuals and not having one. I ain't goin' to be taken in by
anybody. I warn't raised in New Hampshire to be scared by these Massachusetts folks. No, I hain't got a girl
now. I had one a spell, but I'd rather do my own work. You never knew what a girl was doin' or would do.
After she'd left I found a broken plate tucked into the ashbarrel. Sho! you can't depend on a girl. Yes, I've
got a husband. It's easier to manage him. Well, I tell you a husband is better than a girl. When you tell him to
do anything, you know it's going to be done. He's always about, never loafin' round; he can take right hold
and wash dishes, and fetch water, and anything."
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 47
Page No 50
King went into the kitchen after dinner and saw this model husband, who had the faculty of making himself
generally useful, holding a baby on one arm, and stirring something in a pot on the stove with the other. He
looked hot but resigned. There has been so much said about the position of men in Massachusetts that the
travelers were glad of this evidence that husbands are beginning to be appreciated. Under proper training they
are acknowledged to be "better than girls."
It was late afternoon when they reached the quiet haven of Plymoutha place where it is apparently always
afternoon, a place of memory and reminiscences, where the whole effort of the population is to hear and to
tell some old thing. As the railway ends there, there is no danger of being carried beyond, and the train slowly
ceases motion, and stands still in the midst of a great and welcome silence. Peace fell upon the travelers like a
garment, and although they had as much difficulty in landing their baggage as the early Pilgrims had in
getting theirs ashore, the circumstance was not able to disquiet them much. It seemed natural that their trunks
should go astray on some of the inextricably interlocked and branching railways, and they had no doubt that
when they had made the tour of the State they would be discharged, as they finally were, into this
culdesac.
The Pilgrims have made so much noise in the world, and so powerfully affected the continent, that our
tourists were surprised to find they had landed in such a quiet place, and that the spirit they have left behind
them is one of such tranquillity. The village has a charm all its own. Many of the houses are oldfashioned
and square, some with colonial doors and porches, irregularly aligned on the main street, which is arched by
ancient and stately elms. In the spacious dooryards the lindens have had room and time to expand, and in
the beds of bloom the flowers, if not the very ones that our grandmothers planted, are the sorts that they
loved. Showing that the town has grown in sympathy with human needs and eccentricities, and is not the
work of a surveyor, the streets are irregular, forming picturesque angles and open spaces.
Nothing could be imagined in greater contrast to a Western town, and a good part of the satisfaction our
tourists experienced was in the absence of anything Western or "Queen Anne" in the architecture.
In the Pilgrim Halla stone structure with an incongruous wooden pillared frontthey came into the very
presence of the early worthies, saw their portraits on the walls, sat in their chairs, admired the solidity of their
shoes, and imbued themselves with the spirit of the relics of their heroic, uncomfortable lives. In the town
there was nothing to disturb the serenity of mind acquired by this communion. The Puritan interdict of
unseemly excitement still prevailed, and the streets were silent; the artist, who could compare it with the
placidity of Holland towns, declared that he never walked in a village so silent; there was no loud talking; and
even the children played without noise, like little Pilgrims. . . God bless such children, and increase their
numbers! It might have been the approach of Sundayif Sunday is still regarded in eastern
Massachusettsthat caused this hush, for it was now towards sunset on Saturday, and the inhabitants were
washing the fronts of the houses with the hose, showing how cleanliness is next to silence.
Possessed with the spirit of peace, our tourists, whose souls had been vexed with the passions of many
wateringplaces, walked down Leyden Street (the first that was laid out), saw the site of the first house, and
turned round Carver Street, walking lingeringly, so as not to break the spell, out upon the hillCole's
Hillwhere the dead during the first fearful winter were buried. This has been converted into a beautiful
esplanade, grassed and graveled and furnished with seats, and overlooks the old wharves, some coal
schooners, and shabby buildings, on one of which is a sign informing the reckless that they can obtain there
clam chowder and icecream, and the ugly, heavy granite canopy erected over the "Rock." No reverent
person can see this rock for the first time without a thrill of excitement. It has the date of 1620 cut in it, and it
is a good deal cracked and patched up, as if it had been much landed on, but there it is, and there it will
remain a witness to a great historic event, unless somebody takes a notion to cart it off uptown again. It is
said to rest on another rock, of which it formed a part before its unfortunate journey, and that lower rock as
everybody knows, rests upon the immutable principle of selfgovernment. The stone lies too far from the
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 48
Page No 51
water to enable anybody to land on it now, and it is protected from vandalism by an iron grating. The
sentiment of the hour was disturbed by the advent of the members of a baseball nine, who wondered why the
Pilgrims did not land on the wharf, and, while thrusting their feet through the grating in a commendable
desire to touch the sacred rock, expressed a doubt whether the feet of the Pilgrims were small enough to slip
through the grating and land on the stone. It seems that there is nothing safe from the irreverence of American
youth.
Has any other coast town besides Plymouth had the good sense and taste to utilize such an elevation by the
waterside as an esplanade? It is a most charming feature of the village, and gives it what we call a foreign
air. It was very lovely in the afterglow and at moonrise. Staid citizens with their families occupied the
benches, groups were chatting under the spreading lindentree at the north entrance, and young maidens in
white muslin promenaded, looking seaward, as was the wont of Puritan maidens, watching a receding or
coming Mayflower. But there was no loud talking, no laughter, no outbursts of merriment from the children,
all ready to be transplanted to the Puritan heaven! It was high tide, and all the bay was silvery with a tinge of
color from the glowing sky. The long, curved sandspitwhich was heavily wooded when the Pilgrims
landedwas silvery also, and upon its northern tip glowed the white sparkle in the lighthouse like the
eveningstar. To the north, over the smooth pink water speckled with white sails, rose Captain Hill, in
Duxbury, bearing the monument to Miles Standish. Clarke's Island (where the Pilgrims heard a sermon on the
first Sunday), Saguish Point, and Gurnett Headland (showing now twin white lights) appear like a long island
intersected by thin lines of blue water. The effect of these ribbons of alternate sand and water, of the lights
and the ocean (or Great Bay) beyond, was exquisite.
Even the unobtrusive tavern at the rear of the esplanade, ancient, feebly lighted, and inviting, added
something to the picturesqueness of the scene. The old tree by the gatean English lindenilluminated by
the street lamps and the moon, had a mysterious appearance, and the tourists were not surprised to learn that
it has a romantic history. The story is that the twig or sapling from which it grew was brought over from
England by a lover as a present to his mistress, that the lovers quarreled almost immediately, that the girl in a
pet threw it out of the window when she sent her lover out of the door, and that another man picked it up and
planted it where it now grows. The legend provokes a good many questions. One would like to know whether
this was the first case of female rebellion in Massachusetts against the commonlaw right of a man to correct
a woman with a stick not thicker than his little finger a rebellion which has resulted in the position of man
as the tourists saw him where the New Hampshire Amazon gave them a meal of victuals; and whether the girl
married the man who planted the twig, and, if so, whether he did not regret that he had not kept it by him.
This is a world of illusions. By daylight, when the tide was out, the pretty silver bay of the night before was a
mud flat, and the tourists, looking over it from Monument Hill, lost some of their respect for the Pilgrim
sagacity in selecting a landingplace. They had ascended the hill for a nearer view of the monument, King
with a reverent wish to read the name of his Mayflower ancestor on the tablet, the others in a spirit of cold,
New York criticism, for they thought the structure, which is still unfinished, would look uglier near at hand
than at a distance. And it does. It is a pile of granite masonry surmounted by symbolic figures.
"It is such an unsympathetic, tastelesslooking thing!" said Miss Lamont.
"Do you think it is the worst in the country?"
"I wouldn't like to say that," replied the artist, "when the competition in this direction is so lively. But just
look at the drawing" (holding up his pencil with which he had intended to sketch it). "If it were quaint, now,
or rude, or archaic, it might be in keeping, but bad drawing is just vulgar. I should think it had been designed
by a carpenter, and executed by a stonemason."
Their Pilgrimage
V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH 49
Page No 52
"Yes," said the little Lamont, who always fell in with the most abominable opinions the artist expressed; "it
ought to have been made of wood, and painted and sanded."
"You will please remember," mildly suggested King, who had found the name he was in search of, "that you
are trampling on my ancestral sensibilities, as might be expected of those who have no ancestors who ever
landed or ever were buried anywhere in particular. I look at the commemorative spirit rather than the
execution of the monument."
"So do I," retorted the girl; "and if the Pilgrims landed in such a vulgar, ostentatious spirit as this, I'm glad my
name is not on the tablet."
The party were in a better mood when they had climbed up Burial Hill, back of the meetinghouse, and sat
down on one of the convenient benches amid the ancient gravestones, and looked upon the wide and
magnificent prospect. A soft summer wind waved a little the long gray grass of the ancient restingplace, and
seemed to whisper peace to the weary generation that lay there. What struggles, what heroisms, the names on
the stones recalled! Here had stood the first fort of 1620, and here the watchtower of 1642, from the top of
which the warder espied the lurking savage, or hailed the expected ship from England. How much of history
this view recalled, and what pathos of human life these graves made real. Read the names of those buried a
couple of centuries agocaptains, elders, ministers, governors, wives well beloved, children a span long,
maidens in the blush of womanhoodhalf the tender inscriptions are illegible; the stones are broken, sunk,
slanting to fall. What a pitiful attempt to keep the world mindful of the departed!
VI. MANCHESTERBYTHESEA, ISLES OF SHOALS
Mr. Stanhope King was not in very good spirits. Even Boston did not make him cheerful. He was half
annoyed to see the artist and Miss Lamont drifting along in such laughing goodhumor with the world, as if a
summer holiday was just a holiday without any consequences or responsibilities. It was to him a serious affair
ever since that unsatisfactory note from Miss Benson; somehow the summer had lost its sparkle. And yet was
it not preposterous that a girl, just a single girl, should have the power to change for a man the aspect of a
whole coastby her presence to make it iridescent with beauty, and by her absence to take all the life out of
it? And a simple girl from Ohio! She was not by any means the prettiest girl in the Newport Casino that
morning, but it was her figure that he remembered, and it was the look of hurt sensibility in her eyes that
stayed with him. He resented the attitude of the Casino towards her, and he hated himself for his share in it.
He would write to her..... He composed letter after letter in his mind, which he did not put on paper. How
many millions of letters are composed in this way! It is a favorite occupation of imaginative people; and as
they say that no thoughts or mental impressions are ever lost, but are all registered made, as it were, on a
"dryplate," to be developed hereafterwhat a vast correspondence must be lying in the next world, in the
Deadletter Office there, waiting for the persons to whom it is addressed, who will all receive it and read it
some day! How unpleasant and absurd it will be to read, much of it! I intend to be careful, for my part, about
composing letters of this sort hereafter. Irene, I dare say, will find a great many of them from Mr. King,
thought out in those days. But he mailed none of them to her. What should he say? Should he tell her that he
didn't mind if her parents were what Mrs. Bartlett Glow called "impossible"? If he attempted any explanation,
would it not involve the offensive supposition that his social rank was different from hers? Even if he
convinced her that he recognized no caste in American society, what could remove from her mind the
somewhat morbid impression that her education had put her in a false position? His love probably could not
shield her from mortification in a society which, though indefinable in its limits and code, is an entity more
vividly felt than the government of the United States.
"Don't you think the whole social atmosphere has changed," Miss Lamont suddenly asked, as they were
running along in the train towards ManchesterbytheSea, "since we got north of Boston? I seem to find it
so. Don't you think it's more refined, and, don't you know, sort of cultivated, and subdued, and Boston? You
Their Pilgrimage
VI. MANCHESTERBYTHESEA, ISLES OF SHOALS 50
Page No 53
notice the gentlemen who get out at all these stations, to go to their countryhouses, how highly civilized
they look, and ineffably respectable and intellectual, all of them presidents of colleges, and substantial bank
directors, and possible ambassadors, and of a social cult (isn't that the word?) uniting brains and gentle
manners."
"You must have been reading the Boston newspapers; you have hit the idea prevalent in these parts, at any
rate. I was, however, reminded myself of an afternoon train out of London, say into Surrey, on which you are
apt to encounter about as high a type of civilized men as anywhere."
"And you think this is different from a train out of New York?" asked the artist.
"Yes. New York is more mixed. No one train has this kind of tone. You see there more of the broker type and
politician type, smarter apparel and nervous manners, but, dear me, not this high moral and intellectual
respectability."
"Well," said the artist, "I'm changing my mind about this country. I didn't expect so much variety. I thought
that all the wateringplaces would be pretty much alike, and that we should see the same people everywhere.
But the people are quite as varied as the scenery."
"There you touch a deep questionthe refining or the vulgarizing influence of man upon nature, and the
opposite. Now, did the summer Bostonians make this coast refined, or did this coast refine the Bostonians
who summer here?"
"Well, this is primarily an artistic coast; I feel the influence of it; there is a refined beauty in all the lines, and
residents have not vulgarized it much. But I wonder what Boston could have done for the Jersey coast?"
In the midst of this high and useless conversation they came to the Masconomo House, a sort of concession,
in this region of noble villas and private parks, to the popular desire to get to the sea. It is a long, low house,
with very broad passages below and above, which give lightness and cheerfulness to the interior, and each of
the four corners of the entrance hall has a fireplace. The pillars of the front and back piazzas are pine stems
stained, with the natural branches cut in unequal lengths, and look like the stumps for the bears to climb in
the pit at Berne. Set up originally with the bark on, the worms worked underneath it in secret, at a novel sort
of decoration, until the bark came off and exposed the stems most beautifully vermiculated, giving the effect
of fine carving. Back of the house a meadow slopes down to a little beach in a curved bay that has rocky
headlands, and is defended in part by islands of rock. The whole aspect of the place is peaceful. The hotel
does not assert itself very loudly, and if occasionally transient guests appear with flash manners, they do not
affect the general tone of the region.
One finds, indeed, nature and social life happily blended, the exclusiveness being rather protective than
offensive. The special charm of this piece of coast is that it is bold, much broken and indented, precipices
fronting the waves, promontories jutting out, high rocky points commanding extensive views, wild and
picturesque, and yet softened by color and graceful shore lines, and the forest comes down to the edge of the
sea. And the occupants have heightened rather than lessened this picturesqueness by adapting their villas to a
certain extent to the rocks and inequalities in color and form, and by means of roads, allies, and vistas
transforming the region into a lovely park.
Here, as at Newport, is cottage life, but the contrast of the two places is immense. There is here no attempt at
any assembly or congregated gayety or display. One would hesitate to say that the drives here have more
beauty, but they have more variety. They seem endless, through odorous pine woods and shady lanes, by
private roads among beautiful villas and exquisite grounds, with evidences everywhere of wealth to be sure,
but of individual taste and refinement. How sweet and cool are these winding ways in the wonderful woods,
Their Pilgrimage
VI. MANCHESTERBYTHESEA, ISLES OF SHOALS 51
Page No 54
overrun with vegetation, the bayberry, the sweetfern, the wild roses, woodlilies, and ferns! and it is ever a
fresh surprise at a turn to find one's self so near the sea, and to open out an entrancing coast view, to emerge
upon a promontory and a sight of summer isles, of lighthouses, cottages, villagesMarblehead, Salem,
Beverly. What a lovely coast! and how wealth and culture have set their seal on it.
It possesses essentially the same character to the north, although the shore is occasionally higher and bolder,
as at the picturesque promontory of Magnolia, and Cape Ann exhibits more of the hotel and popular life. But
to live in one's own cottage, to choose his calling and dining acquaintances, to make the long season
contribute something to cultivation in literature, art, musicto live, in short, rather more for one's self than
for societyseems the increasing tendency of the men of fortune who can afford to pay as much for an acre
of rock and sand at Manchester as would build a decent house elsewhere. The tourist does not complain of
this, and is grateful that individuality has expressed itself in the great variety of lovely homes, in cottages
very different from those on the Jersey coast, showing more invention, and good in form and color.
There are NewYorkers at Manchester, and Bostonians at Newport; but who was it that said New York
expresses itself at Newport, and Boston at Manchester and kindred coast settlements? This may be only
fancy. Where intellectual life keeps pace with the accumulation of wealth, society is likely to be more natural,
simpler, less tied to artificial rules, than where wealth runs ahead. It happens that the quiet social life of
Beverly, Manchester, and that region is delightful, although it is a home rather than a public life. Nowhere
else at dinner and at the chance evening musicale is the foreigner more likely to meet sensible men who are
good talkers, brilliant and witty women who have the gift of being entertaining, and to have the events of the
day and the social and political problems more cleverly discussed. What is the good of wealth if it does not
bring one back to freedom, and the ability to live naturally and to indulge the finer tastes in vacationtime?
After all, King reflected, as the party were on their way to the Isles of Shoals, what was it that had most
impressed him at Manchester? Was it not an evening spent in a cottage amid the rocks, close by the water, in
the company of charming people? To be sure, there were the magical reflection of the moonlight and the bay,
the points of light from the cottages on the rocky shore, the hum and swell of the sea, and all the mystery of
the shadowy headlands; but this was only a congenial setting for the music, the witty talk, the free play of
intellectual badinage, and seriousness, and the simple human cordiality that were worth all the rest.
What a kaleidoscope it is, this summer travel, and what an entertainment, if the tourist can only keep his
"impression plates" fresh to take the new scenes, and not sink into the state of chronic grumbling at hotels
and minor discomforts! An interview at a ticketoffice, a whirl of an hour on the rails, and to Portsmouth,
anchored yet to the colonial times by a few old houses, and resisting with its respectable provincialism the
encroachments of modern smartness, and the sleepy wharf in the sleepy harbor, where the little steamer is
obligingly waiting for the last passenger, for the very last woman, running with a bandbox in one hand, and
dragging a jerked, fretting child by the other hand, to make the hour's voyage to the Isles of Shoals.
(The shrewd reader objects to the bandbox as an anachronism: it is no longer used. If I were writing a novel,
instead of a veracious chronicle, I should not have introduced it, for it is an anachronism. But I was
powerless, as a mere narrator, to prevent the woman coming aboard with her bandbox. No one but a trained
novelist can make a long striding, resolute, downEast woman conform to his notions of conduct and
fashion.)
If a young gentleman were in love, and the object of his adoration were beside him, he could not have chosen
a lovelier day nor a prettier scene than this in which to indulge his happiness; and if he were in love, and the
object absent, he could scarcely find a situation fitter to nurse his tender sentiment. Doubtless there is a stage
in love when scenery of the very best quality becomes inoperative. There was a couple on board seated in
front of the pilothouse, who let the steamer float along the pretty, long, landlocked harbor, past the Kittery
Navyyard, and out upon the blue sea, without taking the least notice of anything but each other. They were
Their Pilgrimage
VI. MANCHESTERBYTHESEA, ISLES OF SHOALS 52
Page No 55
on a voyage of their own, Heaven help them! probably without any chart, a voyage of discovery, just as fresh
and surprising as if they were the first who ever took it. It made no difference to them that there was a
personally conducted excursion party on board, going, they said, to the Oceanic House on Star Island, who
had out their maps and guidebooks and operaglasses, and wrung the last drop of the cost of their tickets out
of every foot of the scenery. Perhaps it was to King a more sentimental journey than to anybody else, because
he invoked his memory and his imagination, and as the lovely shores opened or fell away behind the steamer
in evershifting forms of beauty, the scene was in harmony with both his hope and his longing. As to Marion
and the artist, they freely appropriated and enjoyed it. So that mediaeval structure, all tower, growing out of
the rock, is Stedman's Castlejust like him, to let his art spring out of nature in that way. And that is the
famous Kittery Navyyard!
"What do they do there, uncle?" asked the girl, after scanning the place in search of drydocks and vessels
and the usual accompaniments of a navyyard.
"Oh, they make 'repairs,' principally just before an election. It is very busy then."
"What sort of repairs?"
"Why, political repairs; they call them naval in the department. They are always getting appropriations for
them. I suppose that this country is better off for naval repairs than any other country in the world."
"And they are done here?"
"No; they are done in the department. Here is where the voters are. You see, we have a political navy. It costs
about as much as those navies that have ships and guns, but it is more in accord with the peaceful spirit of the
age. Did you never hear of the leading case of 'repairs' of a government vessel here at Kittery? The 'repairs'
were all done here, at Portsmouth, New Hampshire; the vessel lay all the time at Portsmouth, Virginia. How
should the department know that there were two places of the same name? It usually intends to have 'repairs'
and the vessel in the same navyyard."
The steamer was gliding along over smooth water towards the seven blessed isles, which lay there in the sun,
masses of rock set in a sea sparkling with diamond points. There were two pretty girls in the pilothouse, and
the artist thought their presence there accounted for the serene voyage, for the masts of a wrecked schooner
rising out of the shallows to the north reminded him that this is a dangerous coast. But he said the passengers
would have a greater sense of security if the usual placard (for the benefit of the captain) was put up: "No
flirting with the girl at the wheel."
At a distance nothing could be more barren than these islands, which Captain John Smith and their native
poet have enveloped in a halo of romance, and it was not until the steamer was close to it that any
landingplace was visible on Appledore, the largest of the group.
The boat turned into a pretty little harbor among the rocks, and the settlement was discovered: a long, low,
oldfashioned hotel with piazzas, and a few cottages, perched on the ledges, the dooryards of which were
perfectly ablaze with patches of flowers, masses of red, yellow, purple poppies, marigolds, nasturtiums,
bachelor'sbuttons, lovely splashes of color against the gray lichencovered rock. At the landing is an
interior miniature harbor, walled in, and safe for children to paddle about and sail on in tiny boats. The
islands offer scarcely any other opportunity for bathing, unless one dare take a plunge off the rocks.
Talk of the kaleidoscope! At a turn of the wrist, as it were, the elements of society had taken a perfectly novel
shape here. Was it only a matter of grouping and setting, or were these people different from all others the
tourists had seen? There was a lively scene in the hotel corridor, the spacious office with its long counters and
Their Pilgrimage
VI. MANCHESTERBYTHESEA, ISLES OF SHOALS 53
Page No 56
postoffice, when the noon mail was opened and the letters called out. So many pretty girls, with pet dogs of
all degrees of ugliness (dear little objects of affection overflowing and otherwise running to wasteone of
the most pathetic sights in this sad world), jaunty suits with a nautical cut, for boating and rockclimbing,
family groups, so much animation and excitement over the receipt of letters, so much wellbred chaffing and
friendliness, such an air of refinement and "style," but withal so homelike. These people were "guests " of the
proprietors, who nevertheless felt a sort of proprietorship themselves in the little island, and were very much
like a company together at sea. For living on this island is not unlike being on shipboard at sea, except that
this rock does not heave about in a nauseous way.
Mr. King discovered by the register that the Bensons had been here (of all places in the world, he thought this
would be the ideal one for a few days with her), and Miss Lamont had a letter from Irene, which she did not
offer to read.
"They didn't stay long," she said, as Mr. King seemed to expect some information out of the letter, " and they
have gone on to Bar Harbor. I should like to stop here a week; wouldn't you?"
"Yees," trying to recall the mood he was in before he looked at the register; "butbut" (thinking of the
words "gone on to Bar Harbor") "it is a place, after all, that you can see in a short time go all over it in half
a day."
"But you want to sit about on the rocks, and look at the sea, and dream."
"I can't dream on an islandnot on a small island. It's too cooped up; you get a feeling of being a prisoner."
"I suppose you wish 'that little isle had wings, and you and I within its shady'"
"There's one thing I will not stand, Miss Lamont, and that's Moore.
Come, let's go to Star Island."
The party went in the tug Pinafore, which led a restless, fussy life, puffing about among these islands, making
the circuit of Appledore at fixed hours, and acting commonly as a ferry. Star Island is smaller than Appledore
and more barren, but it has the big hotel (and a different class of guests from those on Appledore), and
several monuments of romantic interest. There is the ancient stone church, rebuilt some time in this century;
there are some gravestones; there is a monument to Captain John Smith, the only one existing anywhere to
that interesting adventurera triangular shaft, with a long inscription that could not have been more
eulogistic if he had composed it himself. There is something pathetic in this lonely monument when we recall
Smith's own touching allusion to this naked rock, on which he probably landed when he once coasted along
this part of New England, as being his sole possession in the world at the end of his adventurous career:
"No lot for me but Smith's Isles, which are an array of barren
rocks, the most overgrown with shrubs and sharpe whins you can
hardly pass them; without either grasse or wood, but three or foure
short shrubby old cedars."
Every tourist goes to the south end of Star Island, and climbs down on the face of the precipice to the "Chair,"
a niche where a schoolteacher used to sit as long ago as 1848. She was sitting there one day when a wave
came up and washed her away into the ocean. She disappeared. But she who loses her life shall save it. That
one thoughtless act of hers did more for her reputation than years of faithful teaching, than all her beauty,
grace, and attractions. Her "Chair" is a point of pilgrimage. The tourist looks at it, guesses at its height above
the water, regards the hungry sea with aversion, reenacts the drama in his imagination, sits in the chair, has
his wife sit in it, has his boy and girl sit in it together, wonders what the teacher's name was, stops at the hotel
Their Pilgrimage
VI. MANCHESTERBYTHESEA, ISLES OF SHOALS 54
Page No 57
and asks the photograph girl, who does not know, and the proprietor, who says it's in a book somewhere, and
finally learns that it was Underhill, and straightway forgets it when he leaves the island.
What a delicious place it is, this Appledore, when the elements favor! The party were lodged in a little
cottage, whence they overlooked the hotel and the little harbor, and could see all the life of the place, looking
over the bank of flowers that draped the rocks of the dooryard. How charming was the miniature pond, with
the children sailing round and round, and the girls in pretty costumes bathing, and sunlight lying so warm
upon the greenishgray rocks! But the night, following the glorious afterglow, the red sky, all the level sea,
and the little harbor burnished gold, the rocks purpleoh! the night, when the moon came! Oh, Irene! Great
heavens! why will this world fall into such a sentimental fit, when all the sweetness and the light of it are
away at Bar Harbor!
Love and moonlight, and the soft lapse of the waves and singing? Yes, there are girls down by the landing
with a banjo, and young men singing the songs of love, the modern songs of love dashed with college slang.
The banjo suggests a little fastness; and this new generation carries off its sentiment with some bravado and a
mocking tone. Presently the tug Pinafore glides up to the landing, the engineer flings open the furnace door,
and the glowing fire illumines the interior, brings out forms and faces, and deepens the heavy shadows
outside. It is like a cavern scene in the opera. A party of ladies in white come down to cross to Star. Some of
these insist upon climbing up to the narrow deck, to sit on the roof and enjoy the moonlight and the cinders.
Girls like to do these things, which are more unconventional than hazardous, at wateringplaces.
What a wonderful effect it is, the masses of rock, water, sky, the night, all details lost in simple lines and
forms! On the piazza of the cottage is a group of ladies and gentlemen in poses more or less graceful; one
lady is in a hammock; on one side is the moonlight, on the other come gleams from the curtained windows
touching here and there a white shoulder, or lighting a lovely head; the vines running up on strings and half
enclosing the piazza make an exquisite tracery against the sky, and cast delicate shadow patterns on the floor;
all the time music within, the piano, the violin, and the sweet waves of a woman's voice singing the songs of
Schubert, floating out upon the night. A soft wind blows out of the west.
The northern part of Appledore Island is an interesting place to wander. There are no trees, but the plateau is
far from barren. The gray rocks crop out among bayberry and huckleberry bushes, and the wild rose, very
large and brilliant in color, fairly illuminates the landscape, massing its great bushes. Amid the chaotic desert
of broken rocks farther south are little valleys of deep green grass, gay with roses. On the savage precipices at
the end one may sit in view of an extensive sweep of coast with a few hills, and bf other rocky islands, sails,
and oceangoing steamers. Here are many nooks and hidden corners to dream in and make love in, the soft
sea air being favorable to that softhearted occupation.
One could easily get attached to the place, if duty and Irene did not call elsewhere. Those who dwell here the
year round find most satisfaction when the summer guests have gone and they are alone with freaky nature.
"Yes," said the woman in charge of one of the cottages," I've lived here the year round for sixteen years, and I
like it. After we get fixed up comfortable for winter, kill a critter, have pigs, and make my own sassengers,
then there ain't any neighbors comin' in, and that's what I like."
VII. BAR HARBOR
The attraction of Bar Harbor is in the union of mountain and sea; the mountains rise in granite majesty right
out of the ocean. The traveler expects to find a repetition of Mount Athos rising six thousand feet out of the
AEgean.
The BarHarborers made a mistake in killingif they did killthe stranger who arrived at this resort from
the mainland, and said it would be an excellent seaandmountain place if there were any mountains or any
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 55
Page No 58
sea in sight. Instead, if they had taken him in a rowboat and pulled him out through the islands, far enough,
he would have had a glimpse of the ocean, and if then he had been taken by the cograilway seventeen
hundred feet to the top of Green Mountain, he would not only have found himself on firm, rising ground, but
he would have been obliged to confess that, with his feet upon a solid mountain of granite, he saw
innumerable islands and, at a distance, a considerable quantity of ocean. He would have repented his hasty
speech. In two days he would have been a partisan of the place, and in a week he would have been an owner
of real estate there.
There is undeniably a public opinion in Bar Harbor in favor of it, and the visitor would better coincide with it.
He is anxiously asked at every turn how he likes it, and if he does not like it he is an object of compassion.
Countless numbers of people who do not own a foot of land there are devotees of the place. Any number of
certificates to its qualities could be obtained, as to a patent medicine, and they would all read pretty much
alike, after the wellknown formula: "The first bottle I took did, me no good, after the second I was worse,
after the third I improved, after the twelfth I walked fifty miles in one day; and now I never do without it, I
take never less than fifty bottles a year." So it would be: "At first I felt just as you do, shutin place, foggy,
stayed only two days. Only came back again to accompany friends, stayed a week, foggy, didn't like it. Can't
tell how I happened to come back again, stayed a month, and I tell you, there is no place like it in America.
Spend all my summers here."
The genesis of Bar Harbor is curious and instructive. For many years, like other settlements on Mount Desert
Island; it had been frequented by people who have more fondness for nature than they have money, and who
were willing to put up with wretched accommodations, and enjoyed a mild sort of "roughing it." But some
society people in New York, who have the reputation of setting the mode, chanced to go there; they declared
in favor of it; and instantly, by an occult law which governs fashionable life, Bar Harbor became the fashion.
Everybody could see its preeminent attractions. The word was passed along by the Boudoir Telephone from
Boston to New Orleans, and soon it was a matter of necessity for a debutante, or a woman of fashion, or a
man of the world, or a blase boy, to show themselves there during the season. It became the scene of summer
romances; the student of manners went there to study the "American girl." The notion spread that it was the
finest sanitarium on the continent for flirtations; and as trade is said to follow the flag, so in this case
realestate speculation rioted in the wake of beauty and fashion.
There is no doubt that the "American girl" is there, as she is at divers other seaandland resorts; but the
present peculiarity of this watering place is that the American young man is there also. Some philosophers
have tried to account for this coincidence by assuming that the American girl is the attraction to the young
man. But this seems to me a misunderstanding of the spirit of this generation. Why are young men quoted as
"scarce" in other resorts swarming with sweet girls, maidens who have learned the art of being agreeable, and
interesting widows in the vanishing shades of an attractive and consolable grief? No. Is it not rather the cold,
luminous truth that the American girl found out that Bar Harbor, without her presence, was for certain
reasons, such as unconventionality, a bracing air, opportunity for boating, etc., agreeable to the young man?
But why do elderly people go there? This question must have been suggested by a foreigner, who is ignorant
that in a republic it is the young ones who know what is best for the elders.
Our tourists passed a weary, hot day on the coast railway of Maine. Notwithstanding the high temperature,
the country seemed cheerless, the sunlight to fall less genially than in more fertile regions to the south, upon a
landscape stripped of its forests, naked, and unpicturesque. Why should the little white houses of the
prosperous little villages on the line of the rail seem cold and suggest winter, and the land seem scrimped and
without an atmosphere? It chanced so, for everybody knows that it is a lovely coast. The artist said it was the
Maine Law. But that could not be, for the only drunken man encountered on their tour they saw at the Bangor
Station, where beer was furtively sold.
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 56
Page No 59
They were plunged into a cold bath on the steamer in the halfhour's sail from the end of the rail to Bar
Harbor. The wind was fresh, whitecaps enlivened the scene, the spray dashed over the huge pile of baggage
on the bow, the passengers shivered, and could little enjoy the islands and the picturesque shore, but fixed
eyes of hope upon the electric lights which showed above the headlands, and marked the site of the hotels and
the town in the hidden harbor. Spits of rain dashed in their faces, and in some discomfort they came to the
wharf, which was alive with vehicles and tooters for the hotels. In short, with its lights and noise, it had every
appearance of being an important place, and when our party, holding on to their seats in a buckboard, were
whirled at a gallop up to Rodick's, and ushered into a spacious office swarming with people, they realized
that they were entering upon a lively if somewhat haphazard life. The first confused impression was of a
bewildering number of slim, pretty girls, nonchalant young fellows in lawntennis suits, and indefinite
opportunities in the halls and parlors and wide piazzas for promenade and flirtations.
Rodick's is a sort of big boardinghouse, hesitating whether to be a hotel or not, no bells in the rooms, no
bills of fare (or rarely one), no winelist, a goasyouplease, helpyourself sort of place, which is popular
because it has its own character, and everybody drifts into it first or last. Some say it is an acquired taste; that
people do not take to it at first. The big office is a sort of assemblyroom, where new arrivals are scanned
and discovered, and it is unblushingly called the "fishpond" by the young ladies who daily angle there. Of
the unconventional ways of the establishment Mr. King had an illustration when he attempted to get some
washing done. Having read a notice that the hotel had no laundry, he was told, on applying at the office, that
if he would bring his things down there they would try to send them out for him. Not being accustomed to
carrying about soiled clothes, he declined this proposal, and consulted a chambermaid. She told him that
ladies came to the house every day for the washing, and that she would speak to one of them. No result
following this, after a day King consulted the proprietor, and asked him point blank, as a friend, what course
he would pursue if he were under the necessity of having washing done in that region. The proprietor said
that Mr. King's wants should be attended to at once. Another day passed without action, when the
chambermaid was again applied to. "There's a lady just come in to the hall I guess will do it."
"Is she trustworthy?"
"Don't know, she washes for the woman in the room next to you." And the lady was at last secured.
Somebody said that those who were accustomed to luxury at home liked Rodick's, and that those who were
not grumbled. And it was true that fashion for the moment elected to be pleased with unconventionality,
finding a great zest in freedom, and making a joke of every inconvenience. Society will make its own rules,
and although there are several other large hotels, and good houses as wateringplace hotels go, and
cottagelife here as elsewhere is drawing away its skirts from hotel life, society understood why a person
might elect to stay at Rodick's. Bar Harbor has one of the most dainty and refined little hotels in the
worldthe Malvern. Any one can stay there who is worth two millions of dollars, or can produce a certificate
from the Recorder of New York that he is a direct descendant of Hendrick Hudson or Diedrich
Knickerbocker. It is needless to say that it was built by a Philadelphianthat is to say one born with a genius
for hotelkeeping. But though a guest at the Malvern might not eat with a friend at Rodick's, he will meet
him as a man of the world on friendly terms.
Bar Harbor was indeed an interesting society study. Except in some of the cottages, it might be said that
society was on a lark. With all the manners of the world and the freemasonry of fashionable life, it had
elected to be unconventional. The young ladies liked to appear in nautical and lawntennis toilet, carried so
far that one might refer to the "cut of their jib," and their minds were not much given to any elaborate
dressing for evening. As to the young gentlemen, if there were any dresscoats on the island, they took pains
not to display them, but delighted in appearing in the evening promenade, and even in the ballroom, in the
nondescript suits that made them so conspicuous in the morning, the favorite being a dress of stripes, with
striped jockey cap to match, that did not suggest the penitentiary uniform, because in stateprisons the stripes
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 57
Page No 60
run round. This neglige costume was adhered to even in the ballroom. To be sure, the ballroom was little
frequented, only an adventurous couple now and then gliding over the floor, and affording scant amusement
to the throng gathered on the piazza and about the open windows. Mrs. Montrose, a stately dame of the old
school, whose standard was the court in the days of Calhoun, Clay, and Webster, disapproved of this laxity,
and when a couple of young fellows in striped array one evening whirled round the room together, with
brierwood pipes in their mouths, she was scandalized. If the young ladies shared her sentiments they made
no resolute protests, remembering perhaps the scarcity of young men elsewhere, and thinking that it is better
to be loved by a lawntennis suit than not to be loved at all. The daughters of Mrs. Montrose thought they
should draw the line on the brierwood pipe.
Dancing, however, is not the leading occupation at Bar Harbor, it is rather neglected. A cynic said that the
chief occupation was to wait at the "fishpond" for new arrivalsthe young ladies angling while their mothers
and chaperonshow shall we say it to complete the figure?held the bait. It is true that they did talk in
fisherman's lingo about this, asked each other if they had a nibble or a bite, or boasted that they had hauled
one in, or complained that it was a poor day for fishing. But this was all chaff, born of youthful spirits and the
air of the place. If the young men took airs upon themselves under the impression they were in much demand,
they might have had their combs cut if they had heard how they were weighed and dissected and imitated,
and taken off as to their peculiarities, and known, most of them, by sobriquets characteristic of their
appearance or pretentions. There was one young man from the West, who would have been flattered with the
appellation of "dude," so attractive in the fit of his clothes, the manner in which he walked and used his cane
and his eyeglass, that Mr. King wanted very much to get him and bring him away in a cage. He had no doubt
that he was a favorite with every circle and wanted in every group, and the young ladies did seem to get a
great deal of entertainment out of him. He was not like the young man in the Scriptures except that he was
credited with having great possessions.
No, the principal occupation at Bar Harbor was not fishing in the house. It was outdoor exercise, incessant
activity in driving, walking, boating, rowing and sailingbowling, tennis, and flirtation. There was always
an excursion somewhere, by land or sea, watermelon parties, races in the harbor in which the girls took part,
drives in buckboards which they organizedindeed, the canoe and the buckboard were in constant demand.
In all this there was a pleasing freedomof course under proper chaperonage. And such delightful chaperons
as they were, their business being to promote and not to hinder the intercourse of the sexes!
This activity, this desire to row and walk and drive and to become acquainted, was all due to the air. It has a
peculiar quality. Even the skeptic has to admit this. It composes his nerves to sleep, it stimulates to unwonted
exertion. The fanatics of the place declare that the fogs are not damp as at other resorts on the coast. Fashion
can make even a fog dry. But the air is delicious. In this latitude, and by reason of the hills, the atmosphere is
pure and elastic and stimulating, and it is softened by the presence of the sea. This union gives a charming
effect. It is better than the Maine Law. The air being like wine, one does not need stimulants. If one is
addicted to them and is afraid to trust the air, he is put to the trouble of sneaking into masked places, and
becoming a party to petty subterfuges for evading the law. And the wretched man adds to the misdemeanor of
this evasion the moral crime of consuming bad liquor.
"Everybody" was at Bar Harbor, or would be there in course of the season. Mrs. Cortlandt was there, and
Mrs. Pendragon of New Orleans, one of the most brilliant, amiable, and charming of women. I remember her
as far back as the seventies. A young man like Mr. King, if he could be called young, could not have a safer
and more sympathetic social adviser. Why are not all handsome women cordial, goodtempered, and
wellbred! And there were the Ashleysclever mother and three daughters, aufait girls, racy and witty
talkers; I forget whether they were last from Paris, Washington, or San Francisco. Family motto: "Don't be
dull." All the Van Dams from New York, and the Sleiderheifers and Mulligrubs of New Jersey, were there
for the season, some of them in cottages. These families are intimate, even connected by marriage, with the
Bayardiers of South Carolina and the Lontoons of Louisiana. The girls are handsome, dashing women,
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 58
Page No 61
without much information, but rattling talkers, and so exclusive! and the young men, with a Piccadilly air,
fancy that they belong to the "Prince of Wales set," you know. There is a good deal of monarchical simplicity
in our heterogeneous society.
Mrs. Cortlandt was quite in her element here as directorgeneral of expeditions and promoter of social
activity. "I have been expecting you," she was kind enough to say to Mr. King the morning after his arrival.
"Kitty Van Sanford spied you last night, and exclaimed, 'There, now, is a real reinforcement!" You see that
you are mortgaged already."
"It's very kind of you to expect me. Is there anybody else here I know?"
"Several hundreds, I should say. If you cannot find friends here, you are a subject for an orphanasylum. And
you have not seen anybody?"
"Well, I was late at breakfast."
"And you have not looked on the register?"
"Yes, I did run my eye over the register."
"And you are standing right before me and trying to look as if you did not know that Irene Benson is in the
house. I didn't think, Mr. King, it had gone that farindeed I didn't. You know I'm in a manner responsible for
it. And I heard all about you at Newport. She's a heart of gold, that girl."
"Did shedid Miss Benson say anything about Newport?"
"No. Why?"
"Oh, I didn't know but she might have mentioned how she liked it."
"I don't think she liked it as much as her mother did. Mrs. Benson talks of nothing else. Irene said nothing
special to me. I don't know what she may have said to Mr. Meigs," this wily woman added, in the most
natural manner.
"Who is Mr. Meigs?"
"Mr. Alfred Meigs, Boston. He is a rich widower, about fortythe most fascinating age for a widower, you
know. I think he is conceited, but he is really a most entertaining man; has traveled all over the world
Egypt, Persialived in Japan, prides himself a little on never having been in Colorado or Florida."
"What does he do?"
"Do? He drives Miss Benson to Otter Cliffs, and out on the Cornice Road, about seven days in the week, and
gets up sailingparties and all that in the intervals."
"I mean his occupation."
"Isn't that occupation enough? Well, he has a library and a little archaeological museum, and prints
monographs on art now and then. If he were a NewYorker, you know, he would have a yacht instead of a
library. There they are now."
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 59
Page No 62
A carriage with a pair of spirited horses stood at the bottom of the steps on the entrance side. Mrs. Cortlandt
and King turned the corner of the piazza and walked that way. On the back seat were Mrs. Benson and Mrs.
Simpkins. The gentleman holding the reins was just helping Irene to the high seat in front. Mr. King was
running down the long flight of steps. Mrs. Benson saw him, bowed most cordially, and called his name.
Irene, turning quickly, also bowedhe thought there was a flush on her face. The gentleman, in the act of
starting the horses, raised his hat. King was delighted to notice that he was bald. He had a round head,
snuglytrimmed beard slightly dashed with gray, was short and a trifle stoutKing thought dumpy. "I
suppose women like that kind of man," he said to Mrs. Cortlandt when the carriage was out of sight.
Why not? He has perfect manners; he knows the worldthat is a great point, I can tell you, in the
imagination of a girl; he is rich; and he is no end obliging."
"How long has he been here?"
"Several days. They happened to come up from the Isles of Shoals together. He is somehow related to the
Simpkinses. There! I've wasted time enough on you. I must go and see Mrs. Pendragon about a watermelon
party to Jordan Pond. You'll see, I'll arrange something."
King had no idea what a watermelon party was, but he was pleased to think that it was just the sort of thing
that Mr. Meigs would shine in. He said to himself that he hated dilettante snobs. His bitter reflections were
interrupted by the appearance of Miss Lamont and the artist, and with them Mr. Benson. The men shook
hands with downright heartiness. Here is a genuine man, King was thinking.
"Yes. We are still at it," he said, with his humorous air of resignation. "I tell my wife that I'm beginning to
understand how old Christian felt going through Vanity Fair. We ought to be pretty near the Heavenly Gates
by this time. I reckoned she thought they opened into Newport. She said I ought to be ashamed to ridicule the
Bible. I had to have my joke. It's queer how different the world looks to women."
"And how does it look to men?" asked Miss Lamont.
"Well, my dear young lady, it looks like a good deal of fuss, and tolerably large bills."
"But what does it matter about the bills if you enjoy yourself?"
"That's just it. Folks work harder to enjoy themselves than at anything else I know. Half of them spend more
money than they can afford to, and keep under the harrow all the time, just because they see others spend
money."
"I saw your wife and daughter driving away just now," said King, shifting the conversation to a more
interesting topic.
"Yes. They have gone to take a ride over what they call here the Cornneechy. It's a pretty enough road along
the bay, but Irene says it's about as much like the road in Europe they name it from as Green Mountain is like
Mount Blanck. Our folks seem possessed to stick a foreign name on to everything. And the road round
through the scrub to Eagle Lake they call Norway. If Norway is like that, it's pretty short of timber. If there
hadn't been so much lumbering here, I should like it better. There is hardly a decent pinetree left. Mr.
Meigsthey have gone riding with Mr. Meigssays the Maine government ought to have a Maine law that
amounts to somethingone that will protect the forests, and start up some trees on the coast."
"Is Mr. Meigs in the lumber business?" asked King.
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 60
Page No 63
"Only for scenery, I guess. He is great on scenery. He's a Boston man. I tell the women that he is what I call a
bricerbrac man. But you come to set right down with him, away from women, and he talks just as sensible
as anybody. He is shrewd enough. It beats all how men are with men and with women."
Mr. Benson was capable of going on in this way all day. But the artist proposed a walk up to Newport, and
Mr. King getting Mrs. Pendragon to accompany them, the party set out. It is a very agreeable climb up
Newport, and not difficult; but if the sun is out, one feels, after scrambling over the rocks and walking home
by the dusty road, like taking a long pull at a cup of shandygaff. The mountain is a solid mass of granite, bare
on top, and commands a noble view of islands and ocean, of the gorge separating it from Green Mountain,
and of that respectable hill. For this reason, because it is some two or three hundred feet lower than Green
Mountain, and includes that scarred eminence in its view, it is the most picturesque and pleasing elevation on
the island. It also has the recommendation of being nearer to the sea than its sister mountain. On the south
side, by a long slope, it comes nearly to the water, and the longing that the visitor to Bar Harbor has to see the
ocean is moderately gratified. The prospect is at once noble and poetic.
Mrs. Pendragon informed Mr. King that he and Miss Lamont and Mr. Forbes were included in the
watermelon party that was to start that afternoon at five o'clock. The plan was for the party to go in
buckboards to Eagle Lake, cross that in the steamer, scramble on foot over the "carry" to Jordan Pond, take
rowboats to the foot of that, and find at a farmhouse there the watermelons and other refreshments, which
would be sent by the shorter road, and then all return by moonlight in the buckboards.
This plan was carried out. Mrs. Cortlandt, Mrs. Pendragon, and Mrs. Simpkins were to go as chaperons, and
Mr. Meigs had been invited by Mrs. Cortlandt, King learned to his disgust, also to act as a chaperon. All the
proprieties are observed at Bar Harbor. Half a dozen long buckboards were loaded with their merry freight.
At the last Mrs. Pendragon pleaded a headache, and could not go. Mr. King was wandering about among the
buckboards to find an eligible seat. He was not put in good humor by finding that Mr. Meigs had ensconced
himself beside Irene, and he was about crowding in with the Ashley girlsnot a bad fatewhen word was
passed down the line from Mrs. Cortlandt, who was the autocrat of the expedition, that Mr. Meigs was to
come back and take a seat with Mrs. Simpkins in the buckboard with the watermelons. She could not walk
around the "carry"; she must go by the direct road, and of course she couldn't go alone. There was no help for
it, and Mr. Meigs, looking as cheerful as an undertaker in a healthy season, got down from his seat and
trudged back. Thus two chaperons were disposed of at a stroke, and the young men all said that they hated to
assume so much responsibility. Mr. King didn't need prompting in this emergency; the wagons were already
moving, and before Irene knew exactly what had happened, Mr. King was begging her pardon for the change,
and seating himself beside her. And he was thinking, "What a confoundedly clever woman Mrs. Cortlandt
is!"
There is an informality about a buckboard that communicates itself at once to conduct. The exhilaration of
the long springboard, the necessity of holding on to something or somebody to prevent being tossed
overboard, put occupants in a larkish mood that they might never attain in an ordinary vehicle. All this was
favorable to King, and it relieved Irene from an embarrassment she might have felt in meeting him under
ordinary circumstances. And King had the tact to treat himself and their meeting merely as accidents.
"The American youth seem to have invented a novel way of disposing of chaperons," he said. "To send them
in one direction and the party chaperoned in another is certainly original."
"I'm not sure the chaperons like it. And I doubt if it is proper to pack them off by themselves, especially when
one is a widow and the other is a widower."
"It's a case of chaperon eat chaperon. I hope your friend didn't mind it. I had nearly despaired of finding a
seat."
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 61
Page No 64
"Mr. Meigs? He did not say he liked it, but he is the most obliging of men."
"I suppose you have pretty well seen the island?"
"We have driven about a good deal. We have seen Southwest Harbor, and Somes's Sound and Schooner
Head, and the Ovens and Otter Cliffsthere's no end of things to see; it needs a month. I suppose you have
been up Green Mountain?"
"No. I sent Mr. Forbes."
"You ought to go. It saves buying a map. Yes, I like the place immensely. You mustn't judge of the variety
here by the table at Rodick's. I don't suppose there's a place on the coast that compares with it in interest; I
mean variety of effects and natural beauty. If the writers wouldn't exaggerate so, talk about 'the sublimity of
the mountains challenging the eternal grandeur of the sea'!"
"Don't use such strong language there on the back seat," cried Miss Lamont. "This is a pleasure party. Mr.
Van Dusen wants to know why Maud S. is like a salamander?"
"He is not to be gratified, Marion. If it is conundrums, I shall get out and walk."
Before the conundrum was guessed, the volatile Van Dusen broke out into, "Here's a how d'e do! "One of the
Ashley girls in the next wagon caught up the word with, "Here's a state of things!" and the two buckboards
went rattling down the hill to Eagle Lake in a "Mikado" chorus.
"The Mikado troupe seems to have got over here in advance of Sullivan," said Mr. King to Irene. "I happened
to see the first representation."
"Oh, half these people were in London last spring. They give you the impression that they just run over to the
States occasionally. Mr. Van Dusen says he keeps his apartments in whatever street it is off Piccadilly, it's so
much more convenient."
On the steamer crossing the lake, King hoped for an opportunity to make an explanation to Irene. But when
the opportunity came he found it very difficult to tell what it was he wanted to explain, and so blundered on
in commonplaces.
"You like Bar Harbor so well," he said, " that I suppose your father will be buying a cottage here?"
"Hardly. Mr. Meigs" (King thought there was too much Meigs in the conversation) "said that he had once
thought of doing so, but he likes the place too well for that. He prefers to come here voluntarily. The trouble
about owning a cottage at a wateringplace is that it makes a duty of a pleasure. You can always rent, father
says. He has noticed that usually when a person gets comfortably established in a summer cottage he wants to
rent it."
"And you like it better than Newport?"
"On some accountsthe air, you know, and"
"I want to tell you," he said breaking in most illogically" I want to tell you, Miss Benson, that it was all a
wretched mistake at Newport that morning. I don't suppose you care, but I'm afraid you are not quite just to
me."
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 62
Page No 65
"I don't think I was unjust." The girl's voice was low, and she spoke slowly. "You couldn't help it. We can't
any of us help it. We cannot make the world over, you know." And she looked up at him with a faint little
smile.
"But you didn't understand. I didn't care for any of those people. It was just an accident. Won't you believe
me? I do not ask much. But I cannot have you think I'm a coward."
"I never did, Mr. King. Perhaps you do not see what society is as I do. People think they can face it when
they cannot. I can't say what I mean, and I think we'd better not talk about it."
The boat was landing; and the party streamed up into the woods, and with jest and laughter and feigned
anxiety about danger and assistance, picked its way over the rough, stony path. It was such a scramble as
young ladies enjoy, especially if they are city bred, for it seems to them an achievement of more magnitude
than to the country lasses who see nothing uncommon or heroic in following a cowpath. And the young men
like it because it brings out the trusting, dependent, clinging nature of girls. King wished it had been five
miles long instead of a mile and a half. It gave him an opportunity to show his helpful, considerate spirit. It
was necessary to take her hand to help her over the bad spots, and either the bad spots increased as they went
on, or Irene was deceived about it. What makes a path of this sort so perilous to a woman's heart? Is it
because it is an excuse for doing what she longs to do? Taking her hand recalled the day on the rocks at
Narragansett, and the nervous clutch of her little fingers, when the footing failed, sent a delicious thrill
through her lover. King thought himself quite in love with Forbesthere was the warmest affection between
the twobut when he hauled the artist up a Catskill cliff there wasn't the least of this sort of a thrill in the
grip of hands. Perhaps if women had the ballot in their hands all this nervous fluid would disappear out of the
world.
At Jordan Pond boats were waiting. It is a pretty freshwater pond between high sloping hills, and twin peaks
at the north end give it even picturesqueness. There are a good many trout in itat least that is the
supposition, for the visitors very seldom get them out. When the boats with their chattering passengers had
pushed out into the lake and accomplished a third of the voyage, they were met by a skiff containing the
faithful chaperons Mrs. Simpkins and Mr. Meigs. They hailed, but Mr. King, who was rowing his boat, did
not slacken speed. "Are you much tired, Miss Benson?" shouted Mr. Meigs. King didn't like this assumption
of protection. "I've brought you a shawl."
"Hang his paternal impudence!" growled King, under his breath, as he threw himself back with a jerk on the
oars that nearly sent Irene over the stern of the boat.
Evidently the boatload, of which the Ashley girls and Mr. Van Dusen were a part, had taken the sense of
this little comedy, for immediately they struck up:
"For he is going to marry YumYum
YumYum!
For he is going to marry YumYum
YumYum!"
This pleasantry passed entirely over the head of Irene, who had not heard the "Mikado," but King accepted it
as a good omen, and forgave its impudence. It set Mr. Meigs thinking that he had a rival.
At the landing, however, Mr. Meigs was on hand to help Irene out, and a presentation of Mr. King followed.
Mr. Meigs was polite even to cordiality, and thanked him for taking such good care of her. Men will make
such blunders sometimes.
"Oh, we are old friends," she said carelessly.
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 63
Page No 66
Mr. Meigs tried to mend matters by saying that he had promised Mrs. Benson, you know, to look after her.
There was that in Irene's manner that said she was not to be appropriated without leave. But the
consciousness that her look betrayed this softened her at once towards Mr. Meigs, and decidedly improved
his chances for the evening. The philosopher says that women are cruelest when they set out to be kind.
The supper was an 'al fresco' affair, the party being seated about on rocks and logs and shawls spread upon
the grass near the farmer's house. The scene was a very pretty one, at least the artist thought so, and Miss
Lamont said it was lovely, and the Ashley girls declared it was just divine. There was no reason why King
should not enjoy the chaff and merriment and the sunset light which touched the group, except that the one
woman he cared to serve was enveloped in the attentions of Mr. Meigs. The drive home in the moonlight was
the best part of the excursion, or it would have been if there had not been a general change of seats ordered,
altogether, as Mr. King thought, for the accommodation of the Boston man. It nettled him that Irene let
herself fall to the escort of Mr. Meigs, for women can always arrange these things if they choose, and he had
only a melancholy satisfaction in the college songs and conundrums that enlivened the festive buckboard in
which he was a passenger. Not that he did not join in the hilarity, but it seemed only a poor imitation of
pleasure. Alas, that the tone of one woman's voice, the touch of her hand, the glance of her eye, should
outweigh the world!
Somehow, with all the opportunities, the suit of our friend did not advance beyond a certain point. Irene was
always cordial, always friendly, but he tried in vain to ascertain whether the middleaged man from Boston
had touched her imagination. There was a boating party the next evening in Frenchman's Bay, and King had
the pleasure of pulling Miss Benson and Miss Lamont out seaward under the dark, frowning cliffs until they
felt the ocean swell, and then of making the circuit of Porcupine Island. It was an enchanting night, full of
mystery. The rock face of the Porcupine glistened white in the moonlight as if it were encrusted with salt, the
waves beat in a continuous roar against its base, which is honeycombed by the action of the water, and when
the boat glided into its shadow it loomed up vast and wonderful. Seaward were the harbor lights, the
phosphorescent glisten of the waves, the dim forms of other islands; all about in the bay rowboats darted in
and out of the moonlight, voices were heard calling from boat to boat, songs floated over the water, and the
huge Portland steamer came plunging in out of the night, a blazing, trembling monster. Not much was said in
the boat, but the impression of such a night goes far in the romance of real life.
Perhaps it was this impression that made her assent readily to a walk next morning with Mr. King along the
bay. The shore is nearly all occupied by private cottages, with little lawns running down to the granite edge of
the water. It is a favorite place for strolling; couples establish themselves with books and umbrellas on the
rocks, children are dabbling in the coves, sails enliven the bay, rowboats dart about, the cawing of crows is
heard in the still air. Irene declared that the scene was idyllic. The girl was in a most gracious humor, and
opened her life more to King than she had ever done before. By such confidences usually women invite
avowals, and as the two paced along, King felt the moment approach when there would be the most natural
chance in the world for him to tell this woman what she was to him; at the next turn in the shore, by that rock,
surely the moment would come. What is this airy nothing by which women protect themselves in such
emergencies, by a question, by a tone, an invisible strong barrier that the most impetuous dare not attempt to
break?
King felt the subtle restraint which he could not define or explain. And before he could speak she said: "We
are going away tomorrow." "We? And who are we?" "Oh, the Simpkinses and our whole family, and Mr.
Meigs." "And where?"
"Mr. Meigs has persuaded mother into the wildest scheme. It is nothing less than to leap from, here across all
the intervening States to the White Sulphur Springs in Virginia. Father falls into the notion because he wants
to see more of the Southerners, Mrs. Simpkins and her daughter are crazy to go, and Mr. Meigs says he has
been trying to get there all his life, and in August the season is at its height. It was all arranged before I was
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 64
Page No 67
consulted, but I confess I rather like it. It will be a change."
"Yes, I should think it would be delightful," King replied, rather absentmindedly. "It's a long journey, a very
long journey. I should think it would be too long a journey for Mr. Meigsat his time of life."
It was not a fortunate remark, and still it might be; for who could tell whether Irene would not be flattered by
this declaration of his jealousy of Mr. Meigs. But she passed it over as not serious, with the remark that the
going did not seem to be beyond the strength of her father.
The introduction of Mr. Meigs in the guise of an accepted family friend and traveling companion chilled
King and cast a gloom over the landscape. Afterwards he knew that he ought to have dashed in and scattered
this encompassing network of Meigs, disregarded the girl's fence of reserve, and avowed his love. More
women are won by a single charge at the right moment than by a whole campaign of strategy.
On the way back to the hotel he was absorbed in thought, and he burst into the room where Forbes was
touching up one of his sketches, with a fullyformed plan. "Old fellow, what do you say to going to
Virginia?"
Forbes put in a few deliberate touches, moving his head from side to side, and with aggravating slowness
said, "What do you want to go to Virginia for?"
"Why White Sulphur, of course; the most characteristic wateringplace in America. See the whole Southern
life there in August; and there's the Natural Bridge."
"I've seen pictures of the Natural Bridge. I don't know as I care much" (still contemplating the sketch from
different points of view, and softly whistling) "for the whole of Southern life."
"See here, Forbes, you must have some deep design to make you take that attitude."
"Deep design!" replied Forbes, facing round. "I'll be hanged if I see what you are driving at. I thought it was
Saratoga and Richfield, and mild things of that sort."
"And the little Lamont. I know we talked of going there with her and her uncle; but we can go there
afterwards. I tell you what I'll do: I'll go to Richfield, and stay till snow comes, if you will take a dip with me
down into Virginia first. You ought to do it for your art. It's something new, picturesquenegroes, Southern
belles, oldtime manners. You cannot afford to neglect it."
"I don't see the fun of being yanked all over the United States in the middle of August."
"You want shaking up. You've been drawing seashores with one figure in them till your pictures all look
likewell, like Lamont and water."
"That's better," Forbes retorted, "than Benson and gruel."
And the two got into a huff. The artist took his sketchbook and went outdoors, and King went to his room to
study the guidebooks and the map of Virginia. The result was that when the friends met for dinner, King
said:
"I thought you might do it for me, old boy."
And Forbes replied: "Why didn't you say so? I don't care a rap where I go. But it's Richfield afterwards."
Their Pilgrimage
VII. BAR HARBOR 65
Page No 68
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR
What occurred at the parting between the artist and the little Lamont at Bar Harbor I never knew. There was
that good comradeship between the two, that frank enjoyment of each other's society, without any sentimental
nonsense, so often seen between two young people in America, which may end in a friendship of a summer,
or extend to the cordial esteem of a lifetime, or result in marriage. I always liked the girl; she had such a
sunny temper, such a flow of originality in her mental attitude towards people and things without being a wit
or a critic, and so much piquancy in all her little ways. She would take to matrimony, I should say, like a
duck to water, with unruffled plumage, but as a wife she would never be commonplace, or anything but
engaging, and, as the saying is, she could make almost any man happy. And, if unmarried, what a delightful
sisterinlaw she would be, especially a deceased wife's sister!
I never imagined that she was capable of a great passion, as was Irene Benson, who under a serene exterior
was moved by tides of deep feeling, subject to moods, and full of aspirations and longings which she herself
only dimly knew the meaning of. With Irene marriage would be either supreme happiness or extreme
wretchedness, no halfway acceptance of a conventional life. With such a woman life is a failure, either
tragic or pathetic, without a great passion given and returned. It is fortunate, considering the chances that
make unions in society, that for most men and women the "grand passion" is neither necessary nor possible. I
did not share King's prejudice against Mr. Meigs. He seemed to me, as the world goes, a 'bon parti,' cultivated
by travel and reading, wellbred, entertaining, amiable, possessed of an ample fortune, the ideal husband in
the eyes of a prudent mother. But I used to think that if Irene, attracted by his many admirable qualities,
should become his wife, and that if afterwards the Prince should appear and waken the slumbering woman's
heart in her, what a tragedy would ensue. I can imagine their placid existence if the Prince should not appear,
and I can well believe that Irene and Stanhope would have many a tumultuous passage in the passionate
symphony of their lives. But, great heavens, is the ideal marriage a Holland!
If Marion had shed any tears overnight, say on account of a little lonesomeness because her friend was
speeding away from her southward, there were no traces of them when she met her uncle at the breakfast
table, as bright and chatty as usual, and in as high spirits as one can maintain with the Rodick coffee.
What a world of shifting scenes it is! Forbes had picked up his traps and gone off with his unreasonable
companion like a soldier. The day after, when he looked out of the window of his sleepingcompartment at
halfpast four, he saw the red sky of morning, and against it the spires of Philadelphia.
At ten o'clock the two friends were breakfasting comfortably in the car, and running along down the
Cumberland Valley. What a contrast was this rich country, warm with color and suggestive of abundance, to
the pale and scrimped coast land of Maine denuded of its trees! By afternoon they were far down the east
valley of the Shenandoah, between the Blue Ridge and the Massanutten range, in a country broken,
picturesque, fertile, so attractive that they wondered there were so few villages on the route, and only now
and then a cheap shanty in sight; and crossing the divide to the waters of the James, at sundown, in the midst
of a splendid effect of mountains and clouds in a thunderstorm, they came to Natural Bridge station, where a
coach awaited them.
This was old ground to King, who had been telling the artist that the two natural objects east of the Rocky
Mountains that he thought entitled to the epithet "sublime" were Niagara Falls and the Natural Bridge; and as
for scenery, he did not know of any more noble and refined than this region of the Blue Ridge. Take away the
Bridge altogether, which is a mere freak, and the place would still possess, he said, a charm unique. Since the
enlargement of hotel facilities and the conversion of this princely domain into a grand park, it has become a
favorite summer resort. The gorge of the Bridge is a botanical storehouse, greater variety of evergreens
cannot be found together anywhere else in the country, and the hills are still clad with stately forests. In
opening drives, and cutting roads and vistas to give views, the proprietor has shown a skill and taste in
Their Pilgrimage
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR 66
Page No 69
dealing with natural resources, both in regard to form and the development of contrasts of color in foliage,
which are rare in landscape gardening on this side of the Atlantic. Here is the highest part of the Blue Ridge,
and from the gentle summit of Mount Jefferson the spectator has in view a hundred miles of this remarkable
range, this ribbed mountain structure, which always wears a mantle of beauty, changeable purple and violet.
After supper there was an illumination of the cascade, and the ancient gnarled arborvita: trees that lean over
itperhaps the largest known specimens of this speciesof the gorge and the Bridge. Nature is apt to be
belittled by this sort of display, but the noble dignity of the vast arch of stone was superior to this trifling, and
even had a sort of mystery added to its imposing grandeur. It is true that the flaming bonfires and the colored
lights and the tiny figures of men and women standing in the gorge within the depth of the arch made the
scene theatrical, but it was strange and weird and awful, like the fantasy of a Walpurgis' Night or a midnight
revel in Faust.
The presence of the colored brother in force distinguished this from provincial resorts at the North, even
those that employ this color as servants. The flavor of Old Virginia is unmistakable, and life drops into an
easygoing pace under this influence. What fine manners, to be sure! The waiters in the diningroom, in white
ties and dresscoats, move on springs, starting even to walk with a complicated use of all the muscles of the
body, as if in response to the twang of a banjo; they do nothing without excessive motion and flourish. The
gestures and good humored vitality expended in changing plates would become the leader of an orchestra.
Many of them, besides, have the expression of class leadersof a worldly sort. There were the aristocratic
chambermaid and porter, who had the air of never having waited on any but the first families. And what
clever flatterers and readers of human nature! They can tell in a moment whether a man will be
complimented by the remark, "I tuk you for a Richmond gemman, never shod have know'd you was from de
Norf," or whether it is best to say, "We depen's on de gemmen frum de Norf; folks down hyer never gives
noflin; is too pore." But to a Richmond man it is always, "The Yankee is mighty keerful of his money; we
depen's on the old sort, marse." A fine specimen of the "Richmond darkey" of the old schoolpolite,
flattering, with a venerable head of gray wool, was the bartender, who mixed his juleps with a flourish as if
keeping time to music. "Haven't I waited on you befo', sah? At Capon Springs? Sorry, sah, but tho't I knowed
you when you come in. Sorry, but glad to know you now, sah. If that julep don't suit you, sah, throw it in my
face."
A friendly, restful, family sort of place, with music, a little mild dancing, mostly performed by children, in
the pavilion, driving and ridingin short, peace in the midst of noble scenery. No display of fashion, the artist
soon discovered, and he said he longed to give the pretty girls some instruction in the art of dress. Forbes was
a missionary of "style." It hurt his sense of the fitness of things to see women without it. He used to say that
an illdressed woman would spoil the finest landscape. For such a man, with an artistic feeling so sensitive,
the White Sulphur Springs is a natural goal. And he and his friend hastened thither with as much speed as the
Virginia railways, whose timetables are carefully adjusted to miss all connections, permit.
"What do you think of a place," he wrote Miss Lamontthe girl read me a portion of his lively letter that
summer at Saratoga" into which you come by a belated train at halfpast eleven at night, find friends
waiting up for you in evening costume, are taken to a champagne supper at twelve, get to your quarters at
one, and have your baggage delivered to you at two o'clock in the morning?" The friends were lodged in
"Paradise Row"a whimsical name given to one of the quarters assigned to single gentlemen. Put into these
singleroom barracks, which were neat but exceedingly primitive in their accommodations, by hilarious
negro attendants who appeared to regard life as one prolonged lark, and who avowed that there was no time
of day or night when a mintjulep or any other necessary of life would not be forthcoming at a moment's
warning, the beginning of their sojourn at "The White" took on an air of adventure, and the two strangers had
the impression of having dropped into a garrison somewhere on the frontier. But when King stepped out upon
the gallery, in the fresh summer morning, the scene that met his eyes was one of such peaceful dignity, and so
different from any in his experience, that he was aware that he had come upon an original development of
Their Pilgrimage
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR 67
Page No 70
wateringplace life.
The White Sulphur has been for the better part of a century, as everybody knows, the typical Southern resort,
the rendezvous of all that was most characteristic in the society of the whole South, the meetingplace of its
politicians, the haunt of its belles, the arena of gayety, intrigue, and fashion. If tradition is to be believed, here
in years gone by were concocted the measures that were subsequently deployed for the government of the
country at Washington, here historic matches were made, here beauty had triumphs that were the talk of a
generation, here hearts were broken at a ball and mended in Lovers' Walk, and here fortunes were nightly lost
and won. It must have been in its material conditions a primitive place in the days of its greatest fame.
Visitors came to it in their carriages and unwieldy fourhorse chariots, attended by troops of servants,
making slow but most enjoyable pilgrimages over the mountain roads, journeys that lasted a week or a
fortnight, and were every day enlivened by jovial adventure. They came for the season. They were all of one
social order, and needed no introduction; those from Virginia were all related to each other, and though life
there was somewhat in the nature of a picnic, it had its very welldefined and ceremonious code of etiquette.
In the memory of its old habitues it was at once the freest and the most aristocratic assembly in the world.
The hotel was small and its arrangements primitive; a good many of the visitors had their own cottages, and
the rows of these cheap structures took their names from their occupants. The Southern presidents, the
senators, and statesmen, the rich planters, lived in cottages which still have an historic interest in their
memory. But cottage life was never the exclusive affair that it is elsewhere; the society was one body, and the
hotel was the centre.
Time has greatly changed the White Sulphur; doubtless in its physical aspect it never was so beautiful and
attractive as it is today, but all the modern improvements have not destroyed the character of the resort, which
possesses a great many of its primitive and oldtime peculiarities. Briefly the White is an elevated and
charming mountain region, so cool, in fact, especially at night, that the "season" is practically limited to July
and August, although I am not sure but a quiet person, who likes invigorating air, and has no daughters to
marry off, would find it equally attractive in September and October, when the autumn foliage is in its glory.
In a green rolling interval, planted with noble trees and flanked by moderate hills, stands the vast white
caravansary, having wide galleries and big pillars running round three sides. The front and two sides are
elevated, the galleries being reached by flights of steps, and affording room underneath for the large billiard
and barrooms. From the hotel the ground slopes down to the spring, which is surmounted by a round canopy
on white columns, and below is an opening across the stream to the racetrack, the servants' quarters, and a
fine view of receding hills. Three sides of this charming park are enclosed by the cottages and cabins, which
back against the hills, and are more or less embowered in trees. Most of these cottages are built in blocks and
rows, some single rooms, others large enough to accommodate a family, but all reached by flights of steps, all
with verandas, and most of them connected by galleries. Occasionally the forest trees have been left, and the
galleries built around them. Included in the premises are two churches, a gamblinghouse, a couple of
country stores, and a post office. There are none of the shops common at wateringplaces for the sale of
fancy articles, and, strange to say, flowers are not systematically cultivated, and very few are ever to be had.
The hotel has a vast diningroom, besides the minor eatingrooms for children and nurses, a large ballroom,
and a drawingroom of imposing dimensions. Hotel and cottages together, it is said, can lodge fifteen
hundred guests.
The natural beauty of the place is very great, and fortunately there is not much smart and fantastic
architecture to interfere with it. I cannot say whether the knowledge that Irene was in one of the cottages
affected King's judgment, but that morning, when he strolled to the upper part of the grounds before
breakfast, he thought he had never beheld a scene of more beauty and dignity, as he looked over the mass of
hotel buildings, upon the park set with a wonderful variety of dark green foliage, upon the elevated rows of
galleried cottages marked by colonial simplicity, and the soft contour of the hills, which satisfy the eye in
their delicate blending of every shade of green and brown. And after an acquaintance of a couple of weeks
the place seemed to him ravishingly beautiful.
Their Pilgrimage
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR 68
Page No 71
King was always raving about the White Sulphur after he came North, and one never could tell how much his
judgment was colored by his peculiar experiences there. It was my impression that if he had spent those two
weeks on a barren rock in the ocean, with only one fair spirit for his minister, he would have sworn that it
was the most lovely spot on the face of the earth. He always declared that it was the most friendly, cordial
society at this resort in the country. At breakfast he knew scarcely any one in the vast diningroom, except
the New Orleans and Richmond friends with whom he had a seat at table. But their acquaintance sufficed to
establish his position. Before dinnertime he knew half a hundred; in the evening his introductions had run
up into the hundreds, and he felt that he had potential friends in every Southern city; and before the week was
over there was not one of the thousand guests he did not know or might not know. At his table he heard Irene
spoken of and her beauty commented on. Two or three days had been enough to give her a reputation in a
society that is exceedingly sensitive to beauty. The men were all ready to do her homage, and the women
took her into favor as soon as they saw that Mr. Meigs, whose social position was perfectly well known, was
of her party. The society of the White Sulphur seems perfectly easy of access, but the ineligible will find that
it is able, like that of Washington, to protect itself. It was not without a little shock that King heard the good
points, the style, the physical perfections, of Irene so fully commented on, and not without some alarm that he
heard predicted for her a very successful career as a belle.
Coming out from breakfast, the Benson party were encountered on the gallery, and introductions followed. It
was a trying five minutes for King, who felt as guilty, as if the White Sulphur were private property into
which he had intruded without an invitation. There was in the civility of Mr. Meigs no sign of an invitation.
Mrs. Benson said she was never so surprised in her life, and the surprise seemed not exactly an agreeable one,
but Mr. Benson looked a great deal more pleased than astonished. The slight flush in Irene's face as she
greeted him might have been wholly due to the unexpectedness of the meeting. Some of the gentlemen
lounged off to the office region for politics and cigars, the elderly ladies took seats upon the gallery, and the
rest of the party strolled down to the benches under the trees.
"So Miss Benson was expecting you!" said Mrs. Farquhar, who was walking with King. It is enough to
mention Mrs. Farquhar's name to an habitue of the Springs. It is not so many years ago since she was a
reigning belle, and as noted for her wit and sparkling raillery as for her beauty. She was still a very handsome
woman, whose original cleverness had been cultivated by a considerable experience of social life in this
country as well as in London and Paris.
"Was she? I'm sure I never told her I was coming here."
"No, simple man. You were with her at Bar Harbor, and I suppose she never mentioned to you that she was
coming here?"
"But why did you think she expected me?"
"You men are too aggravatingly stupid. I never saw astonishment better feigned. I dare say it imposed upon
that other admirer of hers also. Well, I like her, and I'm going to be good to her." This meant a good deal.
Mrs. Farquhar was related to everybody in Virginiathat is, everybody who was anybody before the
warand she could count at that moment seventyfive cousins, some of them first and some of them
double first cousins, at the White Sulphur. Mrs. Farquhar's remark meant that all these cousins and all their
friends the South over would stand by Miss Benson socially from that moment.
The morning german had just begun in the ballroom. The gallery was thronged with spectators, clustering
like bees about the large windows, and the notes of the band came floating out over the lawn, bringing to the
groups there the lulling impression that life is all a summer holiday.
Their Pilgrimage
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR 69
Page No 72
"And they say she is from Ohio. It is right odd, isn't it? but two or three of the prettiest women here are from
that State. There is Mrs. Martin, sweet as a jacqueminot. I'd introduce you if her husband were here. Ohio!
Well, we get used to it. I should have known the father and mother were cornfed. I suppose you prefer the
cornfeds to the Confeds. But there's homespun and homespun. You see those under the trees yonder?
Georgia homespun! Perhaps you don't see the difference. I do."
"I suppose you mean provincial."
"Oh, dear, no. I'm provincial. It is the most difficult thing to be in these leveling days. But I am not going to
interest you in myself. I am too unselfish. Your Miss Benson is a fine girl, and it does not matter about her
parents. Since you Yankees upset everything by the war, it is really of no importance who one's mother is.
But, mind, this is not my opinion. I'm trying to adjust myself. You have no idea how reconstructed I am."
And with this Mrs. Farquhar went over to Miss Benson, and chatted for a few moments, making herself
particularly agreeable to Mr. Meigs, and actually carried that gentleman off to the spring, and then as an
escort to her cottage, shaking her fan as she went away at Mr. King and Irene, and saying, "It is a waste of
time for you youngsters not to be in the german."
The german was just ended, and the participants were grouping themselves on the gallery to be photographed,
the usual custom for perpetuating the memory of these exercises, which only take place every other morning.
And since something must be done, as there are only six nights for dancing in the week, on the off mornings
there are champagne and fruit parties on the lawn.
It was not about the german, however, that King was thinking. He was once more beside the woman he loved,
and all the influences of summer and the very spirit of this resort were in his favor. If I cannot win her here,
he was saying to himself, the Meigs is in it. They talked about the journey, about Luray, where she had been,
and about the Bridge, and the abnormal gayety of the Springs.
"The people are all so friendly," she said, "and strive so much to put the stranger at his ease, and putting
themselves out lest time hang heavy on one's hands. They seem somehow responsible."
"Yes," said King, "the place is unique in that respect. I suppose it is partly owing to the concentration of the
company in and around the hotel."
"But the sole object appears to me to be agreeable, and make a real social life. At other like places nobody
seems to care what becomes of anybody else."
"Doubtless the cordiality and good feeling are spontaneous, though something is due to manner, and a habit
of expressing the feeling that arises. Still, I do not expect to find any wateringplace a paradise. This must be
vastly different from any other if it is not full of cliques and gossip and envy underneath. But we do not go to
a summer resort to philosophize. A market is a market, you know."
"I don't know anything about markets, and this cordiality may all be on the surface, but it makes life very
agreeable, and I wish our Northerners would catch the Southern habit of showing sympathy where it exists."
"Well, I'm free to say that I like the place, and all its easygoing ways, and I have to thank you for a new
experience."
"Me? Why so?"
Their Pilgrimage
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR 70
Page No 73
"Oh, I wouldn't have come if it had not been for your suggestionI mean for youryour saying that you
were coming here reminded me that it was a place I ought to see."
"I'm glad to have served you as a guidebook."
"And I hope you are not sorry that I"
At this moment Mrs. Benson and Mr. Meigs came down with the announcement of the dinner hour, and the
latter marched off with the ladies with a "oneofthefamily" air.
The party did not meet again till evening in the great drawingroom. The business at the White Sulphur is
pleasure. And this is about the order of proceedings: A few conscientious people take an early glass at the
spring, and later patronize the baths, and there is a crowd at the postoffice; a late breakfast; lounging and
gossip on the galleries and in the parlor; politics and oldfogy talk in the readingroom and in the piazza
corners; flirtation on the lawn; a german every other morning at eleven; wineparties under the trees;
morning calls at the cottages; servants running hither and thither with cooling drinks; the barroom not
absolutely deserted and cheerless at any hour, day or night; dinner from two to four; occasionally a
ridingparty; some driving; though there were charming drives in every direction, few private carriages, and
no display of turnouts; strolls in Lovers' Walk and in the pretty hill paths; supper at eight, and then the
fulldress assembly in the drawingroom, and a "walk around" while the children have their hour in the
ballroom; the nightly dance, witnessed by a crowd on the veranda, followed frequently by a private german
and a supper given by some lover of his kind, lasting till all hours in the morning; and while the majority of
the vast encampment reposes in slumber, some resolute spirits are fighting the tiger, and a light gleaming
from one cottage and another shows where devotees of science are backing their opinion of the relative value
of chance bits of pasteboard, in certain combinations, with a liberality and faith for which the world gives
them no credit. And lest their life should become monotonous, the enterprising young men are continually
organizing entertainments, mock races, comical games. The idea seems to prevail that a summer resort ought
to be a place of enjoyment.
The White Sulphur is the only wateringplace remaining in the United States where there is what may be
called an "assembly," such as might formerly be seen at Saratoga or at Ballston Spa in Irving's young days.
Everybody is in the drawingroom in the evening, and although, in the freedom of the place, full dress is not
exacted, the habit of parade in full toilet prevails. When King entered the room the scene might well be called
brilliant, and even bewildering, so that in the maze of beauty and the babble of talk he was glad to obtain the
services of Mrs. Farquhar as cicerone. Between the rim of people near the walls and the elliptical centre was
an open space for promenading, and in this beauty and its attendant cavalier went round and round in
unending show. This is called the "treadmill." But for the seriousness of this frank display, and the
unflagging interest of the spectators, there would have been an element of high comedy in it. It was an
education to join a wall group and hear the free and critical comments on the style, the dress, the physical
perfection, of the charming procession. When Mrs. Farquhar and King had taken a turn or two, they stood on
one side to enjoy the scene.
"Did you ever see so many pretty girls together before? If you did, don't you dare say so."
"But at the North the pretty women are scattered in a thousand places. You have here the whole South to
draw on. Are they elected as representatives from the various districts, Mrs. Farquhar?"
"Certainly. By an election that your clumsy device of the ballot is not equal to. Why shouldn't beauty have a
reputation? You see that old lady in the corner? Well, forty years ago the Springs just raved over her;
everybody in the South knew her; I suppose she had an average of seven proposals a week; the young men
went wild about her, followed her, toasted her, and fought duels for her possessionyou don't like duels?
Their Pilgrimage
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR 71
Page No 74
why, she was engaged to three men at one time, and after all she went off with a worthless fellow."
"That seems to me rather a melancholy history."
"Well, she is a most charming old lady; just as entertaining! I must introduce you. But this is history. Now
look! There's the belle of Mobile, that tall, stately brunette. And that superb figure, you wouldn't guess she is
the belle of Selma. There is a fascinating girl. What a mixture of languor and vivacity! Creole, you know; full
blood. She is the belle of New Orleansor one of them. Oh! do you see that Paris dress? I must look at it
again when it comes around; she carries it well, toobelle of Richmond. And, see there; there's one of the
prettiest girls in the Southbelle of Macon. And that handsome woman Nashville?Louisville? See,
that's the newcomer from Ohio." And so the procession went on, and the enumerationbelle of
Montgomery, belle of Augusta, belle of Charleston, belle of Savannah, belle of Atlanta always the belle of
some place.
"No, I don't expect you to say that these are prettier than Northern women; but just between friends, Mr.
King, don't you think the North might make a little more of their beautiful women? Yes, you are right; she is
handsome" (King was bowing to Irene, who was on the arm of Mr. Meigs), "and has something besides
beauty. I see what you mean" (King had not intimated that he meant anything), "but don't you dare to say it."
"Oh, I'm quite subdued."
"I wouldn't trust you. I suppose you Yankees cannot help your critical spirit."
"Critical? Why, I've heard more criticism in the last halfhour from these spectators than in a year before.
AndI wonder if you will let me say it?"
"Say on."
"Seems to me that the chief topic here is physical beautyabout the shape, the style, the dress, of women,
and whether this or that one is well made and handsome."
"Well, suppose beauty is worshiped in the Southwe worship what we have; we haven't much money now,
you know. Would you mind my saying that Mr. Meigs is a very presentable man?"
"You may say what you like about Mr. Meigs."
"That's the reason I took him away this morning."
"Thank you."
"He is full of information, and so unobtrusive"
"I hadn't noticed that."
"And I think he ought to be encouraged. I'll tell you what you ought to do, Mr. King: you ought to give a
german. If you do not, I shall put Mr. Meigs up to itit is the thing to do here."
"Mr. Meigs give a german!" [Dance, cotillionalways lively. D.W.]
"Why not? You see that old beau there, the one smiling and bending towards her as he walks with the belle of
Macon? He does not look any older than Mr. Meigs. He has been coming here for fifty years; he owns up to
Their Pilgrimage
VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR 72
Page No 75
sixtyfive and the Mexican war; it's my firm belief that he was out in 1812. Well, he has led the german here
for years. You will find Colonel Fane in the ballroom every night. Yes, I shall speak to Mr. Meigs."
The room was thinning out. King found himself in front of a row of dowagers, whose tongues were still
going about the departing beauties. "No mercy there," he heard a lady say to her companion; "that's a jury for
conviction every time." What confidential communication Mrs. Farquhar made to Mr. Meigs, King never
knew, but he took advantage of the diversion in his favor to lead Miss Benson off to the ballroom.
IX. OLD SWEET AND WHITE SULFUR
The days went by at the White Sulphur on the wings of incessant gayety. Literally the nights were filled with
music, and the only cares that infested the day appeared in the anxious faces of the mothers as the campaign
became more intricate and uncertain. King watched this with the double interest of spectator and player. The
artist threw himself into the melee with abandon, and pacified his conscience by an occasional letter to Miss
Lamont, in which he confessed just as many of his conquests and defeats as he thought it would be good for
her to know.
The colored people, who are a conspicuous part of the establishment, are a source of neverfailing interest
and amusement. Every morning the mammies and nurses with their charges were seated in a long, shining
row on a part of the veranda where there was most passing and repassing, holding a sort of baby show, the
social consequence of each one depending upon the rank of the family who employed her, and the dress of
the children in her charge. Hightoned conversation on these topics occupied these dignified and faithful
mammies, upon whom seemed to rest to a considerable extent the maintenance of the aristocratic social
traditions. Forbes had heard that while the colored people of the South had suspended several of the ten
commandments, the eighth was especially regarded as nonapplicable in the present state of society. But he
was compelled to revise this opinion as to the White Sulphur. Nobody ever locked a door or closed a window.
Cottages most remote were left for hours open and without guard, miscellaneous articles of the toilet were
left about, trunks were not locked, waiters, chambermaids, porters, washerwomen, were constantly coming
and going, having access to the rooms at all hours, and yet no guest ever lost so much as a hairpin or a cigar.
This fashion of trust and of honesty so impressed the artist that he said he should make an attempt to have it
introduced elsewhere. This sort of esprit de corps among the colored people was unexpected, and he
wondered if they are not generally misunderstood by writers who attribute to them qualities of various kinds
that they do not possess. The negro is not witty or consciously humorous, or epigrammatic. The humor of his
actions and sayings lies very much in a certain primitive simplicity. Forbes couldn't tell, for instance, why he
was amused at a remark he heard one morning in the store. A colored girl sauntered in, looking about
vacantly. "You ain't got no cotton, is you?" "Why, of course we have cotton." "Well" (the girl only wanted an
excuse to say something), "I only ast, is you?"
Sports of a colonial and old English flavor that have fallen into disuse elsewhere varied the life at the White.
One day the gentlemen rode in a mulerace, the slowest mule to win, and this feat was followed by an
exhibition of negro agility in climbing the greased pole and catching the greased pig; another day the
cavaliers contended on the green field surrounded by a brilliant array of beauty and costume, as two Amazon
baseball nines, the one nine arrayed in yellow cambric frocks and sun bonnets, and the other in bright red
gownsthe whiskers and big boots and trousers adding nothing whatever to the illusion of the female battle.
The two tables, King's and the Benson's, united in an expedition to the Old Sweet, a drive of eighteen miles.
Mrs. Farquhar arranged the affair, and assigned the seats in the carriages. It is a very picturesque drive, as are
all the drives in this region, and if King did not enjoy it, it was not because Mrs. Farquhar was not even more
entertaining than usual. The truth is that a young man in love is poor company for himself and for everybody
else. Even the object of his passion could not tolerate him unless she returned it. Irene and Mr. Meigs rode in
the carriage in advance of his, and King thought the scenery about the tamest he had ever seen, the roads bad,
Their Pilgrimage
IX. OLD SWEET AND WHITE SULFUR 73
Page No 76
the horses slow. His illhumor, however, was concentrated on one spot; that was Mr. Meigs's back; he
thought he had never seen a more disagreeable back, a more conceited back. It ought to have been a
delightful day; in his imagination it was to be an eventful day. Indeed, why shouldn't the opportunity come at
the Old Sweet, at the end of the drive?there was something promising in the name. Mrs. Farquhar was in a
mocking mood all the way. She liked to go to the Old Sweet, she said, because it was so intolerably dull; it
was a sensation. She thought, too, that it might please Miss Benson, there was such a fitness in the thingthe
old sweet to the Old Sweet. "And he is not so very old either," she added; "just the age young girls like. I
should think Miss Benson in dangerseriously, nowif she were three or four years younger."
The Old Sweet is, in fact, a delightful oldfashioned resort, respectable and dull, with a pretty park, and a
crystal pond that stimulates the bather like a glass of champagne, and perhaps has the property of restoring
youth. King tried the spring, which he heard Mrs. Farquhar soberly commending to Mr. Meigs; and after
dinner he manoeuvred for a halfhour alone with Irene. But the fates and the women were against him. He
had the mortification to see her stroll away with Mr. Meigs to a distant part of the grounds, where they
remained in confidential discourse until it was time to return.
In the rearrangement of seats Mrs. Farquhar exchanged with Irene. Mrs. Farquhar said that it was very much
like going to a funeral each way. As for Irene, she was in high, even feverish spirits, and rattled away in a
manner that convinced King that she was almost too happy to contain herself.
Notwithstanding the general chaff, the singing, and the gayety of Irene, the drive seemed to him intolerably
long. At the halfway house, where in the moonlight the horses drank from a shallow stream, Mr. Meigs
came forward to the carriage and inquired if Miss Benson was sufficiently protected against the chilliness of
the night. King had an impulse to offer to change seats with him; but no, he would not surrender in the face of
the enemy. It would be more dignified to quietly leave the Springs the next day.
It was late at night when the party returned. The carriage drove to the Benson cottage; King helped Irene to
alight, coolly bade her goodnight, and went to his barracks. But it was not a good night to sleep. He tossed
about, he counted every step of the late night birds on his gallery; he got up and lighted a cigar, and tried
dispassionately to think the matter over. But thinking was of no use. He took pen and paper; he would write a
chill letter of farewell; he would write a manly avowal of his passion; he would make such an appeal that no
woman could resist it. She must know, she did knowwhat was the use of writing? He sat staring at the
blank prospect. Great heavens! what would become of his life if he lost the only woman in the world?
Probably the world would go on much the same. Why, listen to it! The band was playing on the lawn at four
o'clock in the morning. A party was breaking up after a night of german and a supper, and the revelers were
dispersing. The lively tunes of "Dixie," "Marching through Georgia," and "Home, Sweet Home," awoke the
echoes in all the galleries and corridors, and filled the whole encampment with a sad gayety. Dawn was
approaching. Good nights and farewells and laughter were heard, and the voice of a wanderer explaining to
the trees, with more or less broken melody, his fixed purpose not to go home till morning.
Stanhope King might have had a better though still a sleepless night if he had known that Mr. Meigs was
packing his trunks at that hour to the tune of "Home, Sweet Home," and if he had been aware of the scene at
the Benson cottage after he bade Irene goodnight. Mrs. Benson had a light burning, and the noise of the
carriage awakened her. Irene entered the room, saw that her mother was awake, shut the door carefully, sat
down on the foot of the bed, said, "It's all over, mother," and burst into the tears of a longrepressed nervous
excitement.
"What's over, child?" cried Mrs. Benson, sitting boltupright in bed.
"Mr. Meigs. I had to tell him that it couldn't be. And he is one of the best men I ever knew."
Their Pilgrimage
IX. OLD SWEET AND WHITE SULFUR 74
Page No 77
"You don't tell me you've gone and refused him, Irene?"
"Please don't scold me. It was no use. He ought to have seen that I did not care for him, except as a friend. I'm
so sorry!"
"You are the strangest girl I ever saw." And Mrs. Benson dropped back on the pillow again, crying herself
now, and muttering, "I'm sure I don't know what you do want."
When King came out to breakfast he encountered Mr. Benson, who told him that their friend Mr. Meigs had
gone off that morninghad a sudden business call to Boston. Mr. Benson did not seem to be depressed about
it. Irene did not appear, and King idled away the hours with his equally industrious companion under the
trees. There was no german that morning, and the hotel band was going through its repertoire for the benefit
of a champagne party on the lawn. There was nothing melancholy about this party; and King couldn't help
saying to Mrs. Farquhar that it hardly represented his idea of the destitution and depression resulting from the
war; but she replied that they must do something to keep up their spirits.
"And I think," said the artist, who had been watching, from the little distance at which they sat, the table of
the revelers, "that they will succeed. Twentysix bottles of champagne, and not many more guests! What a
happy people, to be able to enjoy champagne before twelve o'clock!"
"Oh, you never will understand us!" said Mrs. Farquhar; "there is nothing spontaneous in you."
"We do not begin to be spontaneous till after dinner," said King.
"And then it is all calculated. Think of Mr. Forbes counting the bottles! Such a dreadfully mercenary spirit!
Oh, I have been North. Because you are not so open as we are, you set up for being more virtuous."
"And you mean," said King, "that frankness and impulse cover a multitude of"
"I don't mean anything of the sort. I just mean that conventionality isn't virtue. You yourself confessed that
you like the Southern openness right much, and you like to come here, and you like the Southern people as
they are at home."
"Well?"
"And now will you tell me, Mr. Prim, why it is that almost all Northern people who come South to live
become more Southern than the Southerners themselves; and that almost all Southern people who go North to
live remain just as Southern as ever?"
"No. Nor do I understand any more than Dr. Johnson did why the Scotch, who couldn't scratch a living at
home, and came up to London, always kept on bragging about their native land and abused the metropolis."
This sort of sparring went on daily, with the result of increasing friendship between the representatives of the
two geographical sections, and commonly ended with the declaration on Mrs. Farquhar's part that she should
never know that King was not born in the South except for his accent; and on his part that if Mrs. Farquhar
would conceal her delightful Virginia inflection she would pass everywhere at the North for a Northern
woman.
"I hear," she said, later, as they sat alone, "that Mr. Meigs has beat a retreat, saving nothing but his personal
baggage. I think Miss Benson is a great goose. Such a chance for an establishment and a position! You didn't
half appreciate him."
Their Pilgrimage
IX. OLD SWEET AND WHITE SULFUR 75
Page No 78
"I'm afraid I did not."
"Well, it is none of my business; but I hope you understand the responsibility of the situation. If you do not, I
want to warn you about one thing: don't go strolling off before sunset in the Lovers' Walk. It is the most
dangerous place. It is a fatal place. I suppose every turn in it, every tree that has a knoll at the foot where two
persons can sit, has witnessed a tragedy, or, what is worse, a comedy. There are legends enough about it to
fill a book. Maybe there is not a Southern woman living who has not been engaged there once at least. I'll tell
you a little story for a warning. Some years ago there was a famous belle here who had the Springs at her
feet, and half a dozen determined suitors. One of them, who had been unable to make the least impression on
her heart, resolved to win her by a stratagem. Walking one evening on the hill with her, the two stopped just
at a turn in the walkI can show you the exact spot, with a chaperonand he fell into earnest discourse
with her. She was as cool and repellant as usual. Just then he heard a party approaching; his chance had come.
The moment the party came in sight he suddenly kissed her. Everybody saw it. The witnesses discreetly
turned back. The girl was indignant. But the deed was done. In half an hour the whole Springs would know it.
She was compromised. No explanations could do away with the fact that she had been kissed in Lovers'
Walk. But the girl was game, and that evening the engagement was announced in the drawingroom. Isn't
that a pretty story?"
However much Stanhope might have been alarmed at this recital, he betrayed nothing of his fear that evening
when, after walking to the spring with Irene, the two sauntered along and unconsciously, as it seemed, turned
up the hill into that winding path which has been trodden by generations of lovers with loitering stepssteps
easy to take and so hard to retrace! It is a delightful forest, the walk winding about on the edge of the hill, and
giving charming prospects of intervales, stream, and mountains. To one in the mood for a quiet hour with
nature, no scene could be more attractive.
The couple walked on, attempting little conversation, both apparently prepossessed and constrained. The
sunset was spoken of, and when Irene at length suggested turning back, that was declared to be King's object
in ascending the hill to a particular point; but whether either of them saw the sunset, or would have known it
from a sunrise, I cannot say. The drive to the Old Sweet was pleasant. Yes, but rather tiresome. Mr. Meigs
had gone away suddenly. Yes; Irene was sorry his business should have called him away. Was she very
sorry? She wouldn't lie awake at night over it, but he was a good friend. The time passed very quickly here.
Yes; one couldn't tell how it went; the days just melted away; the two weeks seemed like a day. They were
going away the next day. King said he was going also.
"And," he added, as if with an effort, "when the season is over, Miss Benson, I am going to settle down to
work."
"I'm glad of that," she said, turning upon him a face glowing with approval.
"Yes, I have arranged to go on with practice in my uncle's office. I remember what you said about a dilettante
life."
"Why, I never said anything of the kind."
"But you looked it. It is all the same."
They had come to the crown of the hill, and stood looking over the intervales to the purple mountains. Irene
was deeply occupied in tying up with grass a bunch of wild flowers. Suddenly he seized her hand.
"Irene!"
Their Pilgrimage
IX. OLD SWEET AND WHITE SULFUR 76
Page No 79
"No, no," she cried, turning away. The flowers dropped from her hand.
"You must listen, Irene. I love youI love you."
She turned her face towards him; her lips trembled; her eyes were full of tears; there was a great look of
wonder and tenderness in her face.
"Is it all true?"
She was in his arms. He kissed her hair, her eyesah me! it is the old story. It had always been true. He
loved her from the first, at Fortress Monroe, every minute since. And shewell, perhaps she could learn to
love him in time, if he was very good; yes, maybe she had loved him a little at Fortress Monroe. How could
he? what was there in her to attract him? What a wonder it was that she could tolerate him! What could she
see in him?
So this impossible thing, this miracle, was explained? No, indeed! It had to be inquired into and explained
over and over again, this absolutely new experience of two people loving each other.
She could speak now of herself, of her doubt that he could know his own heart and be stronger than the social
traditions, and would not mind, as she thought he did at Newportjust a little bitthe opinions of other
people. I do not by any means imply that she said all this bluntly, or that she took at all the tone of apology;
but she contrived, as a woman can without saying much, to let him see why she had distrusted, not the
sincerity, but the perseverance of his love. There would never be any more doubt now. What a wonder it all
is.
The two partedalas! alas! till suppertime!
I don't know why scoffers make so light of these partingsat the foot of the main stairs of the hotel gallery,
just as Mrs. Farquhar was descending. Irene's face was radiant as she ran away from Mrs. Farquhar.
"Bless you, my children! I see my warning was in vain, Mr. King. It is a fatal walk. It always was in our
family. Oh, youth! youth! "A shade of melancholy came over her charming face as she turned alone towards
the spring.
X. LONG BRANCH, OCEAN GROVE
Mrs. Farquhar, Colonel Fane, and a great many of their first and second cousins were at the station the
morning the Bensons and King and Forbes departed for the North. The gallant colonel was foremost in his
expressions of regret, and if he had been the proprietor of Virginia, and of the entire South added thereto, and
had been anxious to close out the whole lot on favorable terms to the purchaser, he would not have exhibited
greater solicitude as to the impression the visitors had received. This solicitude was, however, wholly in his
mannerand it is the traditionalmanner that has nearly passed awayfor underneath all this humility it
was plain to be seen that the South had conferred a great favor, sir, upon these persons by a recognition of
their merits.
"I am not come to give you goodby, but au revoir," said Mrs. Farquhar to Stanhope and Irene, who were
standing apart. "I hate to go North in the summer, it is so hot and crowded and snobbish, but I dare say I shall
meet you somewhere, for I confess I don't like to lose sight of so much happiness. No, no, Miss Benson, you
need not thank me, even with a blush; I am not responsible for this state of things. I did all I could to warn
you, and I tell you now that my sympathy is with Mr. Meigs, who never did either of you any harm, and I
think has been very badly treated."
Their Pilgrimage
X. LONG BRANCH, OCEAN GROVE 77
Page No 80
"I don't know any one, Mrs. Farquhar, who is so capable of repairing his injuries as yourself," said King.
"Thank you; I'm not used to such delicate elephantine compliments. It is just like a man, Miss Benson, to try
to kill two birds with one stone get rid of a rival by sacrificing a useless friend. All the same, au revoir."
"We shall be glad to see you," replied Irene, "you know that, wherever we are; and we will try to make the
North tolerable for you."
"Oh, I shall hide my pride and go. If you were not all so rich up there! Not that I object to wealth; I enjoy it. I
think I shall take to that old prayer: 'May my lot be with the rich in this world, and with the South in the
next!'"
I suppose there never was such a journey as that from the White Sulphur to New York. If the Virginia scenery
had seemed to King beautiful when he came down, it was now transcendently lovely. He raved about it, when
I saw him afterwardsthe Blue Ridge, the wheat valleys, the commercial advantages, the mineral resources
of the State, the grand old traditional Heaven knows what of the Old Dominion; as to details he was obscure,
and when I pinned him down, he was not certain which route they took. It is my opinion that the most costly
scenery in the world is thrown away upon a pair of newly plighted lovers.
The rest of the party were in good spirits. Even Mrs. Benson, who was at first a little bewildered at the failure
of her admirably planned campaign, accepted the situation with serenity.
"So you are engaged!" she said, when Irene went to her with the story of the little affair in Lovers' Walk. "I
suppose he'll like it. He always took a fancy to Mr. King. No, I haven't any objections, Irene, and I hope
you'll be happy. Mr. King was always very polite to meonly he didn't never seem exactly like our folks.
We only want you to be happy." And the old lady declared with a shaky voice, and tears streaming down her
cheeks, that she was perfectly happy if Irene was.
Mr. Meigs, the refined, the fastidious, the man of the world, who had known how to adapt himself perfectly
to Mrs. Benson, might nevertheless have been surprised at her implication that he was "like our folks."
At the station in Jersey Citya place suggestive of love and romance and full of tender associationsthe
party separated for a few days, the Bensons going to Saratoga, and King accompanying Forbes to Long
Branch, in pursuance of an agreement which, not being in writing, he was unable to break. As the two friends
went in the early morning down to the coast over the level salt meadows, cut by bayous and intersected by
canals, they were curiously reminded both of the Venice lagoons and the plains of the Teche; and the artist
went into raptures over the colors of the landscape, which he declared was Oriental in softness and blending.
Patriotic as we are, we still turn to foreign lands for our comparisons.
Long Branch and its adjuncts were planned for New York excursionists who are content with the ocean and
the salt air, and do not care much for the picturesque. It can be described in a phrase: a straight line of sandy
coast with a high bank, parallel to it a driveway, and an endless row of hotels and cottages. Knowing what the
American seaside cottage and hotel are, it is unnecessary to go to Long Branch to have an accurate picture of
it in the mind. Seen from the end of the pier, the coast appears to be all built upa thin, straggling city by the
sea. The line of buildings is continuous for two miles, from Long Branch to Elberon; midway is the West
End, where our tourists were advised to go as the best post of observation, a medium point of respectability
between the excursion medley of one extremity and the cottage refinement of the other, and equally
convenient to the races, which attract crowds of metropolitan betting men and betting women. The fine toilets
of these children of fortune are not less admired than their fashionable race course manners. The satirist who
said that Atlantic City is typical of Philadelphia, said also that Long Branch is typical of New York. What
Mr. King said was that the satirist was not acquainted with the good society of either place.
Their Pilgrimage
X. LONG BRANCH, OCEAN GROVE 78
Page No 81
All the summer resorts get somehow a certain character, but it is not easy always to say how it is produced.
The Long Branch region was the resort of politicians, and of persons of some fortune who connect politics
with speculation. Society, which in America does not identify itself with politics as it does in England, was
not specially attracted by the newspaper notoriety of the place, although, fashion to some extent declared in
favor of Elberon.
In the morning the artist went up to the pier at the bathing hour. Thousands of men, women, and children
were tossing about in the lively surf promiscuously, revealing to the spectators such forms as Nature had
given them, with a modest confidence in her handiwork. It seemed to the artist, who was a student of the
human figure, that many of these people would not have bathed in public if Nature had made them
selfconscious. All down the shore were pavilions and bathhouses, and the scene at a distance was not
unlike that when the water is occupied by schools of leaping mackerel. An excursion steamer from New York
landed at the pier. The passengers were not of any recognized American type, but mixed foreign races a
crowd of respectable people who take their rare holidays rather seriously, and offer little of interest to an
artist. The boats that arrive at night are said to bring a less respectable cargo.
It is a pleasant walk or drive down to Elberon when there is a sea breeze, especially if there happen to be a
dozen yachts in the offing. Such elegance as this wateringplace has lies in this direction; the Elberon is a
refined sort of hotel, and has near it a group of pretty cottages, not too fantastic for holiday residences, and
even the "greeny yellowy" ones do not much offend, for eccentricities of color are toned down by the sea
atmosphere. These cottages have excellent lawns set with brilliant beds of flowers; and the turf rivals that of
Newport; but without a tree or shrub anywhere along the shore the aspect is too unrelieved and
photographically distinct. Here as elsewhere the cottage life is taking the place of hotel life.
There were few handsome turnouts on the main drive, and perhaps the popular character of the place was
indicated by the use of omnibuses instead of carriages. For, notwithstanding Elberon and such fashion as is
there gathered, Long Branch lacks "style." After the White Sulphur, it did not seem to King alive with gayety,
nor has it any society. In the hotel parlors there is music in the evenings, but little dancing except by children.
Large women, offensively dressed, sit about the veranda, and give a heavy and "company" air to the
drawingrooms. No, the place is not gay. The people come here to eat, to bathe, to take the air; and these are
reasons enough for being here. Upon the artist, alert for social peculiarities, the scene made little impression,
for to an artist there is a limit to the interest of a crowd showily dressed, though they blaze with diamonds.
It was in search of something different from this that King and Forbes took the train and traveled six miles to
Asbury Park and Ocean Grove. These great summer settlements are separated by a sheet of fresh water
threequarters of a mile long; its sloping banks are studded with pretty cottages, its surface is alive with boats
gay with awnings of red and blue and green, and seats of motley color, and is altogether a fairy spectacle.
Asbury Park is the worldly correlative of Ocean Grove, and esteems itself a notch above it in social tone.
Each is a city of small houses, and each is teeming with life, but Ocean Grove, whose centre is the
campmeeting tabernacle, lodges its devotees in tents as well as cottages, and copies the architecture of Oak
Bluffs. The inhabitants of the two cities meet on the twomilelong plank promenade by the sea. Perhaps
there is no place on the coast that would more astonish the foreigner than Ocean Grove, and if he should
describe it faithfully he would be unpopular with its inhabitants. He would be astonished at the crowds at the
station, the throngs in the streets, the shops and stores for supplying the wants of the religious pilgrims, and
used as he might be to the promiscuous bathing along our coast, he would inevitably comment upon the
freedom existing here. He would see women in their bathing dresses, wet and clinging, walking in the streets
of the town, and he would read notices posted up by the campmeeting authorities forbidding women so clad
to come upon the tabernacle ground. He would also read placards along the beach explaining the reason why
decency in bathing suits is desirable, and he would wonder why such notices should be necessary. If,
however, he walked along the shore at bathing times he might be enlightened, and he would see besides a
certain simplicity of social life which sophisticated Europe has no parallel for. A peculiar custom here is
Their Pilgrimage
X. LONG BRANCH, OCEAN GROVE 79
Page No 82
sandburrowing. To lie in the warm sand, which accommodates itself to any position of the body, and listen
to the dash of the waves, is a dreamy and delightful way of spending a summer day. The beach for miles is
strewn with these sandburrowers in groups of two or three or half a dozen, or single figures laid out like the
effigies of Crusaders. One encounters these groups sprawling in all attitudes, and frequently asleep in their
promiscuous beds. The foreigner is forced to see all this, because it is a public exhibition. A couple in bathing
suits take a dip together in the sea, and then lie down in the sand. The artist proposed to make a sketch of one
of these primitive couples, but it was impossible to do so, because they lay in a trench which they had
scooped in the sand two feet deep, and had hoisted an umbrella over their heads. The position was novel and
artistic, but beyond the reach of the artist. It was a great pity, because art is never more agreeable than when it
concerns itself with domestic life.
While this charming spectacle was exhibited at the beach, afternoon service was going on in the tabernacle,
and King sought that in preference. The vast audience under the canopy directed its eyes to a man on the
platform, who was violently gesticulating and shouting at the top of his voice. King, fresh from the scenes of
the beach, listened a long time, expecting to hear some close counsel on the conduct of life, but he heard
nothing except the vaguest emotional exhortation. By this the audience were apparently unmoved, for it was
only when the preacher paused to get his breath on some word on which he could dwell by reason of its
vowels, like wor1d or and, that he awoke any response from his hearers. The spiritual exercise of
prayer which followed was even more of a physical demonstration, and it aroused more response. The
officiating minister, kneeling at the desk, gesticulated furiously, doubled up his fists and shook them on high,
stretched out both arms, and pounded the pulpit. Among people of his own race King had never before seen
anything like this, and he went away a sadder if not a wiser man, having at least learned one lesson of
charitynever again to speak lightly of a negro religious meeting.
This vast city of the sea has many charms, and is the resort of thousands of people, who find here health and
repose. But King, who was immensely interested in it all as one phase of American summer life, was glad
that Irene was not at Ocean Grove.
XI. SARATOGA
It was the 22d of August, and the height of the season at Saratoga. Familiar as King had been with these
Springs, accustomed as the artist was to foreign Spas, the scene was a surprise to both. They had been told
that fashion had ceased to patronize it, and that its oldtime character was gone. But Saratoga is too strong
for the whims of fashion; its existence does not depend upon its decrees; it has reached the point where it
cannot be killed by the inroads of Jew or Gentile. In ceasing to be a society centre, it has become in a manner
metropolitan; for the season it is no longer a provincial village, but the meetingplace of as mixed and
heterogeneous a throng as flows into New York from all the Union in the autumn shopping period.
It was race week, but the sporting men did not give Saratoga their complexion. It was convention time, but
except in the hotel corridors politicians were not the feature of the place. One of the great hotels was almost
exclusively occupied by the descendants of Abraham, but the town did not at all resemble Jerusalem.
Innumerable boardinghouses swarmed with city and country clergymen, who have a wellfounded
impression that the waters of the springs have a beneficent relation to the bilious secretions of the year, but
the resort had not an oppressive air of sanctity. Nearly every prominent politician in the State and a good
many from other States registered at the hotels, but no one seemed to think that the country was in danger.
Hundreds of men and women were there because they had been there every year for thirty or forty years
back, and they have no doubt that their health absolutely requires a week at Saratoga; yet the village has not
the aspect of a sanitarium. The hotel diningrooms and galleries were thronged with large, overdressed
women who glittered with diamonds and looked uncomfortable in silks and velvets, and Broadway was gay
with elegant equipages, but nobody would go to Saratoga to study the fashions. Perhaps the most impressive
spectacle in this lowly world was the row of millionaires sunning themselves every morning on the piazza of
Their Pilgrimage
XI. SARATOGA 80
Page No 83
the States, solemn men in black broadcloth and white hats, who said little, but looked rich; visitors used to
pass that way casually, and the townspeople regarded them with a kind of awe, as if they were the kingpins
of the whole social fabric; but even these magnates were only pleasing incidents in the kaleidoscopic show.
The first person King encountered on the piazza of the Grand Union was not the one he most wished to see,
although it could never be otherwise than agreeable to meet his fair cousin, Mrs. Bartlett Glow. She was in a
fresh morning toilet, dainty, comme il faut, radiant, with that unobtrusive manner of "society" which made
the present surroundings, appear a trifle vulgar to King, and to his selfdisgust forced upon him the image of
Mrs. Benson.
"You here?" was his abrupt and involuntary exclamation.
"Yeswhy not?" And then she added, as if from the Newport point of view some explanation were
necessary: "My husband thinks he must come here for a week every year to take the waters; it's an old habit,
and I find it amusing for a few days. Of course there is nobody here. Will you take me to the spring? Yes,
Congress. I'm too old to change. If I believed the pamphlets the proprietors write about each other's springs I
should never go to either of them."
Mrs. Bartlett Glow was not alone in saying that nobody was there. There were scores of ladies at each hotel
who said the same thing, and who accounted for their own presence there in the way she did. And they were
not there at all in the same way they would be later at Lenox. Mrs. Pendragon, of New Orleans, who was at
the United States, would have said the same thing, remembering the time when the Southern colony made a
very distinct impression upon the social life of the place; and the Ashleys, who had put up at the Congress
Hall in company with an old friend, a returned foreign minister, who stuck to the old traditionseven the
Ashleys said they were only lookerson at the pageant.
Paying their entrance, and passing through the turnstile in the pretty pavilion gate, they stood in the Congress
Spring Park. The band was playing in the kiosk; the dew still lay on the flowers and the green turf; the
miniature lake sparkled in the sun. It is one of the most pleasing artificial scenes in the world; to be sure,
nature set the great pinetrees on the hills, and made the graceful little valley, but art and exquisite taste have
increased the apparent size of the small plot of ground, and filled it with beauty. It is a gem of a place with a
character of its own, although its prettiness suggests some foreign Spa. Groups of people, having taken the
water, were strolling about the graveled paths, sitting on the slopes overlooking the pond, or wandering up
the glen to the tiny deer park.
"So you have been at the White Sulphur?" said Mrs. Glow. "How did you like it?"
"Immensely. It's the only place left where there is a congregate social life."
"You mean provincial life. Everybody knows everybody else."
"Well," King retorted, with some spirit, "it is not a place where people pretend not to know each other, as if
their salvation depended on it."
"Oh, I see; hospitable, frank, cordialall that. Stanhope, do you know, I think you are a little demoralized this
summer. Did you fall in love with a Southern belle? Who was there?"
"Well, all the South, pretty much. I didn't fall in love with all the belles; we were there only two weeks. Oh!
there was a Mrs. Farquhar there."
Their Pilgrimage
XI. SARATOGA 81
Page No 84
"Georgiana Randolph! Georgie! How did she look? We were at Madame Sequin's together, and a couple of
seasons in Paris. Georgie! She was the handsomest, the wittiest, the most fascinating woman I ever saw. I
hope she didn't give you a turn?"
"Oh, no. But we were very good friends. She is a very handsome woman perhaps you would expect me to
say handsome still; but that seems a sort of treason to her mature beauty."
"And who else?"
"Oh, the Storbes from New Orleans, the Slifers from Mobileno end of peoplesome from
Philadelphiaand Ohio."
"Ohio? Those Bensons!" said she, turning sharply on him.
"Yes, those Bensons, Penelope. Why not?"
"Oh, nothing. It's a free country. I hope, Stanhope, you didn't encourage her. You might make her very
unhappy."
"I trust not," said King stoutly. "We are engaged."
"Engaged!" repeated Mrs. Glow, in a tone that implied a whole world of astonishment and improbability.
"Yes, and you are just in time to congratulate us. There they are!" Mr. Benson, Mrs. Benson, and Irene were
coming down the walk from the deer park. King turned to meet them, but Mrs. Glow was close at his side,
and apparently as pleased at seeing them again as the lover. Nothing could be more charming than the grace
and welcome she threw into her salutations. She shook hands with Mr. Benson; she was delighted to meet
Mrs. Benson again, and gave her both her little hands; she almost embraced Irene, placed a hand on each
shoulder, kissed her on the cheek, and said something in a low voice that brought the blood to the girl's face
and suffused her eyes with tenderness.
When the party returned to the hotel the two women were walking lovingly arm in arm, and King was
following after, in the more prosaic atmosphere of Cyrusville, Ohio. The good old lady began at once to treat
King as one of the family; she took his arm, and leaned heavily on it, as they walked, and confided to him all
her complaints. The White Sulphur waters, she said, had not done her a mite of good; she didn't know but
she'd oughter see a doctor, but he said that it warn't nothing but indigestion. Now the White Sulphur agreed
with Irene better than any other place, and I guess that I know the reason why, Mr. King, she said, with a
faintly facetious smile. Meantime Mrs. Glow was talking to Irene on the one topic that a maiden is never
weary of, her lover; and so adroitly mingled praises of him with flattery of herself that the girl's heart went
out to her in entire trust.
"She is a charming girl," said Mrs. Glow to King, later. "She needs a little forming, but that will be easy when
she is separated from her family. Don't interrupt me. I like her. I don't say I like it. But if you will go out of
your set, you might do a great deal worse. Have you written to your uncle and to your aunt?"
"No; I don't know why, in a matter wholly personal to myself, I should call a family council. You represent
the family completely, Penelope."
"Yes. Thanks to my happening to be here. Well, I wouldn't write to them if I were you. It's no use to disturb
the whole connection now. By the way, Imogene Cypher was at Newport after you left; she is more beautiful
than everjust lovely; no other girl there had half the attention."
Their Pilgrimage
XI. SARATOGA 82
Page No 85
"I am glad to hear it," said King, who did not fancy the drift their conversation was taking. "I hope she will
make a good match. Brains are not necessary, you know."
"Stanhope, I never said thatnever. I might have said she wasn't a bas bleu. No more is she. But she has
beauty, and a good temper, and money. It isn't the cleverest women who make the best wives, sir."
"Well, I'm not objecting to her being a wife. Only it does not follow that, because my uncle and aunts are in
love with her, I should want to marry her."
"I said nothing about marriage, my touchy friend. I am not advising you to be engaged to two women at the
same time. And I like Irene immensely."
It was evident that she had taken a great fancy to the girl. They were always together; it seemed to happen so,
and King could hardly admit to himself that Mrs. Glow was de trop as a third. Mr. Bartlett Glow was very
polite to King and his friend, and forever had one excuse and another for taking them off with himthe races
or a lounge about town. He showed them one night, I am sorry to say, the inside of the Temple of Chance and
its decorous society, its splendid buffet, the quiet tables of rouge et noir, and the highly respectable
attendantsaged men, whitehaired, in evening costume, devout and almost godly in appearance, with faces
chastened to resignation and patience with a wicked world, sedate and venerable as the deacons in a
Presbyterian church. He was lonesome and wanted company, and, besides, the women liked to be by
themselves occasionally.
One might be amused at the Saratoga show without taking an active part in it, and indeed nobody did seem to
take a very active part in it. Everybody was looking on. People drove, visited the springsin a vain
expectation that excessive drinking of the medicated waters would counteract the effect of excessive
gormandizing at the hotelssat about in the endless rows of armchairs on the piazzas, crowded the heavily
upholstered parlors, promenaded in the corridors, listened to the music in the morning, and again in the
afternoon, and thronged the stairways and passages, and blocked up the entrance to the ballrooms. Balls?
Yes, with dress de rigueur, many beautiful women in wonderful toilets, a few debutantes, a scarcity of young
men, and a delicious bandmuch better music than at the White Sulphur.
And yet no society. But a wonderful agglomeration, the artist was saying. It is a robust sort of place. If
Newport is the queen of the wateringplaces, this is the king. See how well fed and fat the people are, men
and women large and expansive, richly dressed, prosperous looking! What a contrast to the family sort of
life at the White Sulphur! Here nobody, apparently, cares for anybody elsenot much; it is not to be
expected that people should know each other in such a heterogeneous concern; you see how comparatively
few greetings there are on the piazzas and in the parlors. You notice, too, that the types are not so
distinctively American as at the Southern resortfull faces, thick necksmore like Germans than
Americans. And then the everlasting white hats. And I suppose it is not certain that every man in a tall white
hat is a politician, or a railway magnate, or a sporting man.
These big hotels are an epitome of expansive, gorgeous American life. At the Grand Union, King was No.
1710, and it seemed to him that he walked the length of the town to get to his room after ascending four
stories. He might as well, so far as exercise was concerned, have taken an apartment outside. And the
diningroom. Standing at the door, he had a vista of an eighth of a mile of small tables, sparkling with
brilliant service of glass and porcelain, chandeliers and frescoed ceiling. What perfect appointments! what
welltrained waiters!perhaps they were not waiters, for he was passed from one "officer" to another
"officer" down to his place. At the tables silent couples and restrained family parties, no hilarity, little talking;
and what a contrast this was to the happygolucky service and jollity of the White Sulphur! Then the
interior parks of the United States and the Grand Union, with corridors and cottages, closeclipped turf,
banks of flowers, forest trees, fountains, and at night, when the band filled all the air with seductive strains,
Their Pilgrimage
XI. SARATOGA 83
Page No 86
the electric and the colored lights, gleaming through the foliage and dancing on fountains and greensward,
made a scene of enchantment. Each hotel was a village in itself, and the thousands of guests had no more in
common than the frequenters of New York hotels and theatres. But what a paradise for lovers!
"It would be lonesome enough but for you, Irene," Stanhope said, as they sat one night on the inner piazza of
the Grand Union, surrendering themselves to all the charms of the scene.
"I love it all," she said, in the full tide of her happiness.
On another evening they were at the illumination of the Congress Spring Park. The scene seemed the creation
of magic. By a skillful arrangement of the colored globes an illusion of vastness was created, and the little
enclosure, with its glowing lights, was like the starry heavens for extent. In the mass of white globes and
colored lanterns of paper the eye was deceived as to distances. The allies stretched away interminably, the
pines seemed enormous, and the green hillsides mountainous. Nor were charming single effects wanting.
Down the winding walk from the hill, touched by a distant electric light, the loitering people, in couples and
in groups, seemed no more in real life than the supernumeraries in a scene at the opera. Above, in the
illuminated foliage, were doubtless a castle and a broad terrace, with a row of statues, and these gay
promenaders were ladies and cavaliers in an old time masquerade. The gilded kiosk on the island in the
centre of the miniature lake and the fairy bridge that leads to it were outlined by colored globes; and the lake,
itself set about with brilliants, reflected kiosk and bridge and lights, repeating a hundredfold the fantastic
scene, while from their island retreat the band sent out through the illumined night strains of sentiment and
gayety and sadness. In the intervals of the music there was silence, as if the great throng were too deeply
enjoying this feast of the senses to speak. Perhaps a foreigner would have been impressed with the decorous
respectability of the assembly; he would have remarked that there were no little tables scattered about the
ground, no boys running about with foaming mugs of beer, no noise, no loud talking; and how restful to all
the senses!
Mrs. Bartlett Glow had the whim to devote herself to Mrs. Benson, and was repaid by the acquisition of a
great deal of information concerning the social and domestic, life in Cyrusville, Ohio, and the maternal
ambition for Irene. Stanhope and Irene sat a little apart from the others, and gave themselves up to the
witchery of the hour. It would not be easy to reproduce in type all that they said; and what was most
important to them, and would be most interesting to the reader, are the things they did not saythe half
exclamations, the delightful silences, the tones, the looks that are the sign language of lovers. It was Irene
who first broke the spell of this delightful mode of communication, and in a pause of the music said, "Your
cousin has been telling me of your relatives in New York, and she told me more of yourself than you ever
did."
"Very likely. Trust your friends for that. I hope she gave me a good character."
"Oh, she has the greatest admiration for you, and she said the family have the highest expectations of your
career. Why didn't you tell me you were the child of such hopes? It half frightened me."
"It must be appalling. What did she say of my uncle and aunts?"
"Oh, I cannot tell you, except that she raised an image in my mind of an awful vision of ancient family and
exclusiveness, the most fastidious, delightful, conventional people, she said, very old family, looked down
upon Washington Irving, don't you know, because he wrote. I suppose she wanted to impress me with the
value of the prize I've drawn, dear. But I should like you just as well if your connections had not looked down
on Irving. Are they so very high and mighty?"
Their Pilgrimage
XI. SARATOGA 84
Page No 87
"Oh, dear, no. Much like other people. My aunts are the dearest old ladies, just a little nearsighted, you know,
about seeing people that are notwell, of course, they live in a rather small world. My uncle is a bachelor,
rather particular, not what you would call a genial old man; been abroad a good deal, and moved mostly in
our set; sometimes I think he cares more for his descent than for his position at the bar, which is a very
respectable one, by the way. You know what an old bachelor is who never has had anybody to shake him out
of his contemplation of his family?"
"Do you think," said Irene, a little anxiously, letting her hand rest a moment upon Stanhope's, "that they will
like poor little me? I believe I am more afraid of the aunts than of the uncle. I don't believe they will be as
nice as your cousin."
"Of course they will like you. Everybody likes you. The aunts are just a little oldfashioned, that is all. Habit
has made them draw a social circle with a small radius. Some have one kind of circle, some another. Of
course my aunts are sorry for any one who is not descended from the Van Schlovenhovensthe old Van
Schlovenhoven had the first brewery of the colony in the time of Peter Stuyvesant. In New York it's a family
matter, in Philadelphia it's geographical. There it's a question whether you live within the lines of Chestnut
Street and Spruce Streetoutside of these in the city you are socially impossible: Mrs. Cortlandt told me that
two Philadelphia ladies who had become great friends at a summer resortone lived within and the other
without the charmed lineswent back to town together in the autumn. At the station when they parted, the
'inside' lady said to the other: 'Goodby. It has been such a pleasure to know you! I suppose I shall see you
sometimes at Moneymaker's!' Moneymaker's is the Bon Marche of Philadelphia."
The music ceased; the band were hurrying away; the people all over the grounds were rising to go, lingering a
little, reluctant to leave the enchanting scene. Irene wished, with a sigh, that it might never end; unreal as it
was, it was more native to her spirit than that future which her talk with Stanhope had opened to her
contemplation. An illdefined apprehension possessed her in spite of the reassuring presence of her lover and
her perfect confidence in the sincerity of his passion; and this feeling was somehow increased by the
appearance of Mrs. Glow with her mother; she could not shake off the uneasy suggestion of the contrast.
At the hour when the ladies went to their rooms the day was just beginning for a certain class of the habitues.
The parlors were nearly deserted, and few chairs were occupied on the piazzas, but the ghosts of another
generation seemed to linger, especially in the offices and barroom. Flitting about were to be seen the social
heroes who had a notoriety thirty and forty years ago in the newspapers. This driedup old man in a bronze
wig, scuffling along in list slippers, was a famous criminal lawyer in his day; this gentleman, who still wears
an air of gallantry, and is addressed as General, had once a reputation for successes in the drawingroom as
well as on the field of Mars; here is a genuine old beau, with the unmistakable selfconsciousness of one who
has been a favorite of the sex, but who has slowly decayed in the midst of his cosmetics; here saunter along a
couple of actors with the air of being on the stage. These people all have the "nightcap" habit, and drift along
towards the barroomthe last brilliant scene in the drama of the idle day, the necessary portal to the realm
of silence and sleep.
This is a large apartment, brightly lighted, with a bar extending across one end of it. Modern taste is
conspicuous here, nothing is gaudy, colors are subdued, and its decorations are simple even the bar itself is
refined, substantial, decorous, wanting entirely the meretricious glitter and barbarous ornamentation of the
old structures of this sort, and the attendants have wholly laid aside the smart antics of the former bartender,
and the customers are swiftly and silently served by the deferential waiters. This is one of the most striking
changes that King noticed in American life.
There is a certain sort of lifewhether it is worth seeing is a question that we can see nowhere else, and for an
hour Mr. Glow and King and Forbes, sipping their raspberry shrub in a retired corner of the bar room, were
interested spectators of the scene. Through the padded swinging doors entered, as in a play, character after
Their Pilgrimage
XI. SARATOGA 85
Page No 88
character. Each actor as he entered stopped for a moment and stared about him, and in this act revealed his
characterhis conceit, his slyness, his bravado, his selfimportance. There was great variety, but practically
one prevailing type, and that the New York politician. Most of them were from the city, though the country
politician apes the city politician as much as possible, but he lacks the exact air, notwithstanding the black
broadcloth and the white hat. The city men are of two varietiesthe smart, perkynosed, vulgar young ward
worker, and the heavyfeatured, gross, fat old fellow. One after another they glide in, with an always
conscious air, swagger off to the bar, strike attitudes in groups, one with his legs spread, another with a foot
behind on tiptoe, another leaning against the counter, and so pose, and drink "My respects"all rather
solemn and stiff, impressed perhaps by the decorousness of the place, and conscious of their good clothes.
Enter together three stout men, a yard across the shoulders, each with an enormous development in front,
waddle up to the bar, attempt to form a triangular group for conversation, but find themselves too far apart to
talk in that position, and so arrange themselves side by sidea most distinguishedlooking party, like a
portion of a swellfront street in Boston. To them swaggers up a young sport, like one of Thackeray's figures
in the "Irish SketchBook"short, in a white hat, poor face, impudent manner, poses before the swell fronts,
and tosses off his glass. About a little table in one corner are three excessively "ugly mugs," leering at each
other and pouring down champagne. These men are all dressed as nearly like gentlemen as the tailor can
make them, but even he cannot change their hard, brutal faces. It is not their fault that money and clothes do
not make a gentleman; they are well fed and vulgarly prosperous, and if you inquire you will find that their
women are in silks and laces. This is a good place to study the rulers of New York; and impressive as they are
in appearance, it is a relief to notice that they unbend to each other, and hail one another familiarly as "Billy"
and "Tommy." Do they not ape what is most prosperous and successful in American life? There is one who in
makeup, form, and air, even to the cut of his sidewhiskers, is an exact counterpart of the great railway
king. Here is a heavyfaced young fellow in evening dress, perhaps endeavoring to act the part of a
gentleman, who has come from an evening party unfortunately a little "slewed," but who does not know how
to sustain the character, for presently he becomes very familiar and confidential with the dignified colored
waiter at the buffet, who requires all his native politeness to maintain the character of a gentleman for two.
If these men had millions, could they get any more enjoyment out of life? To have fine clothes, drink
champagne, and pose in a fashionable barroom in the height of the seasonis not this the apotheosis of the
"heeler" and the ward "worker"? The scene had a fascination for the artist, who declared that he never tired
watching the evolutions of the foreign element into the full bloom of American citizenship.
XII. LAKE GEORGE, AND SARATOGA AGAIN
The intimacy between Mrs. Bartlett Glow and Irene increased as the days went by. The woman of society
was always devising plans for Irene's entertainment, and winning her confidence by a thousand evidences of
interest and affection. Pleased as King was with this at first, he began to be annoyed at a devotion to which he
could have no objection except that it often came between him and the enjoyment of the girl's society alone;
and latterly he had noticed that her manner was more grave when they were together, and that a little
something of reserve mingled with her tenderness.
They made an excursion one day to Lake Georgea poetical pilgrimage that recalled to some of the party
(which included some New Orleans friends) the romance of early days. To the Bensons and the artist it was
all new, and to King it was seen for the first time in the transforming atmosphere of love. To men of
sentiment its beauties will never be exhausted; but to the elderly and perhaps rheumatic tourist the draughty
steamboats do not always bring back the remembered delight of youth. There is no pleasanter place in the
North for a summer residence, but there is a certain element of monotony and weariness inseparable from an
excursion: travelers have been known to yawn even on the Rhine. It was a gray day, the country began to
show the approach of autumn, and the view from the landing at Caldwell's, the head of the lake, was never
more pleasing. In the marshes the cattails and the faint flush of color on the alders and soft maples gave a
character to the low shore, and the gentle rise of the hills from the water's edge combined to make a sweet
Their Pilgrimage
XII. LAKE GEORGE, AND SARATOGA AGAIN 86
Page No 89
and peaceful landscape.
The tourists find the steamer waiting for them at the end of the rail, and if they are indifferent to the war
romances of the place, as most of them are, they hurry on without a glance at the sites of the famous old forts
St. George and William Henry. Yet the head of the lake might well detain them a few hours though they do
not care for the scalping Indians and their sometime allies the French or the English. On the east side the lake
is wooded to the shore, and the jutting points and charming bays make a pleasant outline to the eye.
Crosbyside is the ideal of a summer retreat, nestled in foliage on a pretty point, with its great trees on a
sloping lawn, boathouses and innumerable row and sail boats, and a lovely view, over the blue waters, of a
fine range of hills. Caldwell itself, on the west side, is a pretty treeplanted village in a break in the hills, and
a point above it shaded with great pines is a favorite rendezvous for pleasure parties, who leave the ground
strewn with egg shells and newspapers. The Fort William Henry Hotel was formerly the chief resort on the
lake. It is a long, handsome structure, with broad piazzas, and low evergreens and flowers planted in front.
The view from it, under the great pines, of the lake and the northern purple hills, is lovely. But the tide of
travel passes it by, and the few people who were there seemed lonesome. It is always so. Fashion demands
novelty; one class of summer boarders and tourists drives out another, and the people who want to be
sentimental at this end of the lake now pass it with a call, perhaps a sigh for the past, and go on to fresh
pastures where their own society is encamped.
Lake George has changed very much within ten years; hotels and great boardinghouses line the shores; but
the marked difference is in the increase of cottage life. As our tourists sailed down the lake they were
surprised by the number of pretty villas with red roofs peeping out from the trees, and the occupation of every
island and headland by gay and often fantastic summer residences. King had heard this lake compared with
Como and Maggiore, and as a patriot he endeavored to think that its wild and sylvan loveliness was more
pleasing than the romantic beauty of the Italian lakes. But the effort failed. In this climate it is impossible that
Horicon should ever be like Como. Pretty hills and forests and temporary summer structures cannot have the
poetic or the substantial interest of the ancient villages and towns clinging to the hills, the old stone houses,
the vines, the ruins, the atmosphere of a long civilization. They do the lovely Horicon no service who
provoke such comparisons.
The lake has a character of its own. As the traveler sails north and approaches the middle of the lake, the
gems of green islands multiply, the mountains rise higher, and shouldering up in the sky seem to bar a further
advance; toward sunset the hills, which are stately but lovely, a silent assembly of round and sharp peaks,
with long, graceful slopes, take on exquisite colors, violet, bronze, and green, and now and again a bold rocky
bluff shines like a ruby in the ruddy light. Just at dusk the steamer landed midway in the lake at Green Island,
where the scenery is the boldest and most romantic; from the landing a parklike lawn, planted with big trees,
slopes up to a picturesque hotel. Lights twinkled from many a cottage window and from boats in the bay, and
strains of music saluted the travelers. It was an enchanting scene.
The genius of Philadelphia again claims the gratitude of the tourist, for the Sagamore Hotel is one of the most
delightful hostelries in the world. A peculiar, interesting building, rambling up the slope on different levels,
so contrived that all the rooms are outside, and having a delightful irregularity, as if the house had been a
growth. Naturally a hotel so dainty in its service and furniture, and so refined, was crowded to its utmost
capacity. The artist could find nothing to complain of in the morning except that the incandescent electric
light in his chamber went out suddenly at midnight and left him in blank darkness in the most exciting crisis
of a novel. Green Island is perhaps a mile long. A bridge connects it with the mainland, and besides the hotel
it has a couple of picturesque stone and timber cottages. At the north end are the remains of the English
intrenchments of 1755signs of war and hate which kindly nature has almost obliterated with sturdy trees.
With the natural beauty of the island art has little interfered; near the hotel is the most stately grove of white
birches anywhere to be seen, and their silvery sheen, with occasional patches of sedge, and the tender sort of
foliage that Corot liked to paint, gives an exceptional refinement to the landscape. One needs, indeed, to be
Their Pilgrimage
XII. LAKE GEORGE, AND SARATOGA AGAIN 87
Page No 90
toned up by the glimpses, under the trees, over the blue water, of the wooded craggy hills, with their shelf
like ledges, which are full of strength and character. The charm of the place is due to this combination of
loveliness and granitic strength.
Irene long remembered the sail of that morning, seated in the bow of the steamer with King, through scenes
of everchanging beauty, as the boat wound about the headlands and made its calls, now on one side and now
on the other, at the pretty landings and decorated hotels. On every hand was the gayety of summer lifea
striped tent on a rocky point with a platform erected for dancing, a miniature bark but on an island, and a
rustic arched bridge to the mainland, gaudy little hotels with winding paths along the shore, and at all the
landings groups of pretty girls and college lads in boating costume. It was wonderful how much these holiday
makers were willing to do for the entertainment of the passing travelers. A favorite pastime in this peaceful
region was the broom drill, and its execution gave an operatic character to the voyage. When the steamer
approaches, a band of young ladies in military ranks, clad in light marching costume, each with a broom in
place of a musket, descend to the landing and delight the spectators with their warlike manoeuvres. The
march in the broomdrill is two steps forward and one step back, a mode of progression that conveys the
notion of a pleasing indecision of purpose, which is foreign to the character of these handsome Amazons,
who are quite able to hold the wharf against all comers. This act of war in fancy, dress, with its two steps
forward and one back, and the singing of a song, is one of the most fatal to the masculine peace of mind in
the whole history of carnage.
Mrs. Bartlett Glow, to be sure, thought it would be out of place at the Casino; but even she had to admit that
the American girl who would bewitch the foreigner with her one, two, and one, and her flourish of broom on
Lake George, was capable of freezing his ardor by her cool good breeding at Newport.
There was not much more to be done at Saratoga. Mrs. Benson had tried every spring in the valley, and thus
anticipated a remedy, as Mr. Benson said, for any possible "complaint" that might visit her in the future. Mr.
Benson himself said that he thought it was time for him to move to a new piazza, as he had worn out half the
chairs at the Grand Union. The BartlettGlows were already due at Richfield; in fact, Penelope was impatient
to go, now that she had persuaded the Bensons to accompany her; and the artist, who had been for some time
grumbling that there was nothing left in Saratoga to draw except corks, reminded King of his agreement at
Bar Harbor, and the necessity he felt for rural retirement after having been dragged all over the continent.
On the last day Mr. Glow took King and Forbes off to the races, and Penelope and the Bensons drove to the
lake. King never could tell why he consented to this arrangement, but he knew in a vague way that it is
useless to attempt to resist feminine power, that shapes our destiny in spite of all our roughhewing of its
outlines. He had become very uneasy at the friendship between Irene and Penelope, but he could give no
reason for his suspicion, for it was the most natural thing in the world for his cousin to be interested in the
girl who was about to come into the family. It seemed also natural that Penelope should be attracted by her
nobility of nature. He did not know till afterwards that it was this very nobility and unselfishness which
Penelope saw could be turned to account for her own purposes. Mrs. Bartlett Glow herself would have said
that she was very much attached to Irene, and this would have been true; she would have said also that she
pitied her, and this would have been true; but she was a woman whose world was bounded by her own social
order, and she had no doubt in her own mind that she was loyal to the best prospects of her cousin, and, what
was of more importance, that she was protecting her little world from a misalliance when she preferred
Imogene Cypher to Irene Benson. In fact, the Bensons in her set were simply an unthinkable element. It
disturbed the established order of things. If any one thinks meanly of Penelope for counting upon the heroism
of Irene to effect her unhappiness, let him reflect of how little consequence is the temporary happiness of one
or two individuals compared with the peace and comfort of a whole social order. And she might also well
make herself believe that she was consulting the best interests of Irene in keeping her out of a position where
she might be subject to so many humiliations. She was capable of crying over the social adventures of the
heroine of a love story, and taking sides with her against the world, but as to the actual world itself, her
Their Pilgrimage
XII. LAKE GEORGE, AND SARATOGA AGAIN 88
Page No 91
practical philosophy taught her that it was much better always, even at the cost of a little heartache in youth,
to go with the stream than against it.
The lake at Saratoga is the most picturesque feature of the region, and would alone make the fortune of any
other wateringplace. It is always a surprise to the stranger, who has bowled along the broad drive of five
miles through a pleasing but not striking landscape, to come suddenly, when he alights at the hotel, upon
what seems to be a "fault," a sunken valley, and to look down a precipitous, grassy, treeplanted slope upon a
lake sparkling at the bottom and reflecting the enclosing steep shores. It is like an aquamarine gem
countersunk in the green landscape. Many an hour had Irene and Stanhope passed in dreamy contemplation
of it. They had sailed down the lake in the little steamer, they had whimsically speculated about this and that
couple who took their ices or juleps under the trees or on the piazza of the hotel, and the spot had for them a
thousand tender associations. It was here that Stanhope had told her very fully the uneventful story of his life,
and it was here that she had grown into full sympathy with his aspirations for the future.
It was of all this that Irene thought as she sat talking that day with Penelope on a bench at the foot of the hill
by the steamboat landing. It was this very future that the woman of the world was using to raise in the mind
of Irene a morbid sense of her duty. Skillfully with this was insinuated the notion of the false and
contemptible social pride and exclusiveness of Stanhope's relations, which Mrs. Bartlett Glow represented as
implacable while she condemned it as absurd. There was not a word of opposition to the union of Irene and
Stanhope: Penelope was not such a bungler as to make that mistake. It was not her cue to definitely suggest a
sacrifice for the welfare of her cousin. If she let Irene perceive that she admired the courage in her that could
face all these adverse social conditions that were conjured up before her, Irene could never say that Penelope
had expressed anything of the sort. Her manner was affectionate, almost caressing; she declared that she felt a
sisterly interest in her. This was genuine enough. I am not sure that Mrs. Bartlett Glow did not sometimes
waver in her purpose when she was in the immediate influence of the girl's genuine charm, and felt how
sincere she was. She even went so far as to wish to herself that Irene had been born in her own world.
It was not at all unnatural that Irene should have been charmed by Penelope, and that the latter should
gradually have established an influence over her. She was certainly kindhearted, amiable, bright, engaging. I
think all those who have known her at Newport, or in her New York home, regard her as one of the most
charming women in the world. Nor is she artificial, except as society requires her to be, and if she regards the
conventions of her own set as the most important things in life, therein she does not differ from hosts of
excellent wives and mothers. Irene, being utterly candid herself, never suspected that Penelope had at all
exaggerated the family and social obstacles, nor did it occur to her to doubt Penelope's affection for her. But
she was not blind. Being a woman, she comprehended perfectly the indirection of a woman's approaches, and
knew well enough by this time that Penelope, whatever her personal leanings, must feel with her family in
regard to this engagement. And that she, who was apparently her friend, and who had Stanhope's welfare so
much at heart, did so feel was an added reason why Irene was drifting towards a purpose of selfsacrifice.
When she was with Stanhope such a sacrifice seemed as impossible as it would be cruel, but when she was
with Mrs. Bartlett Glow, or alone, the subject took another aspect. There is nothing more attractive to a noble
woman of tender heart than a duty the performance of which will make her suffer. A false notion of duty has
to account for much of the misery in life.
It was under this impression that Irene passed the last evening at Saratoga with Stanhope on the piazza of the
hotelan evening that the latter long remembered as giving him the sweetest and the most contradictory and
perplexing glimpses of a woman's heart.
XIII. RICHFIELD SPRINGS, COOPERSTOWN
After weeks of the din of Strauss and Gungl, the soothing strains of the Pastoral Symphony. Now no more the
kettledrum and the ceaseless promenade in showy corridors, but the oaten pipe under the spreading maples,
Their Pilgrimage
XIII. RICHFIELD SPRINGS, COOPERSTOWN 89
Page No 92
the sheep feeding on the gentle hills of Otsego, the carnival of the hoppickers. It is time to be rural, to adore
the country, to speak about the dew on the upland pasture, and the exquisite view from Sunset Hill. It is quite
English, is it not? this passion for quiet, refined country life, which attacks all the summer revelers at certain
periods in the season, and sends them in troops to Richfield or Lenox or some other peaceful retreat, with
their simple apparel bestowed in modest fourstory trunks. Come, gentle shepherdesses, come, sweet youths in
white flannel, let us tread a measure on the greensward, let us wander down the lane, let us pass under the
festoons of the hopvines, let us saunter in the paths of sentiment, that lead to love in a cottage and a house in
town.
Every wateringplace has a character of its own, and those who have given little thought to this are surprised
at the endless variety in the American resorts. But what is even more surprising is the influence that these
places have upon the people that frequent them, who appear to change their characters with their
surroundings. One woman in her season plays many parts, dashing in one place, reserved in another, now gay
and active, now listless and sentimental, not at all the same woman at Newport that she is in the Adirondack
camps, one thing at Bar Harbor and quite another at Saratoga or at Richfield. Different tastes, to be sure, are
suited at different resorts, but fashion sends a steady procession of the same people on the round of all.
The charm of Richfield Springs is in the character of the landscape. It is a limestone region of gentle slopes
and fine lines; and although it is elevated, the general character is refined rather than bold, the fertile valleys
in pleasing irregularity falling away from rounded wooded hills in a manner to produce the impression of
peace and repose. The lay of the land is such that an elevation of a few hundred feet gives a most extensive
prospect, a view of meadows and upland pastures, of lakes and ponds, of forests hanging in dark masses on
the limestone summits, of fields of wheat and hops, and of distant mountain ranges. It is scenery that one
grows to love, and that responds to one's every mood in variety and beauty. In a whole summer the pedestrian
will not exhaust the inspiring views, and the drives through the gracious land, over hills, round the lakes, by
woods and farms, increase in interest as one knows them better. The habitues of the place, year after year, are
at a loss for words to convey their peaceful satisfaction.
In this smiling country lies the pretty village of Richfield, the rural character of which is not entirely lost by
reason of the hotels, cottages, and boardinghouses which line the broad principal street. The centre of the
town is the old Spring House and grounds. When our travelers alighted in the evening at this mansion, they
were reminded of an English inn, though it is not at all like an inn in England except in its atmosphere of
comfort. The building has rather a colonial character, with its long corridors and pillared piazzas; built at
different times, and without any particular plans except to remain oldfashioned, it is now a big, rambling
white mass of buildings in the midst of mapletrees, with so many stairs and passages on different levels, and
so many nooks and corners, that the stranger is always getting lost in it turning up in the luxurious
smokingroom when he wants to dine, and opening a door that lets him out into the park when he is trying to
go to bed. But there are few hotels in the country where the guests are so well taken care of.
This was the unbought testimony of Miss Lamont, who, with her uncle, had been there long enough to
acquire the common anxiety of sojourners that the newcomers should be pleased, and who superfluously
explained the attractions of the place to the artist, as if in his eyes, that rested on her, more than one attraction
was needed. It was very pleasant to see the good comradeship that existed between these two, and the frank
expression of their delight in meeting again. Here was a friendship without any reserve, or any rueful
misunderstandings, or necessity for explanations. Irene's eyes followed them with a wistful look as they went
off together round the piazza and through the parlors, the girl playing the part of the hostess, and inducting
him into the mild gayeties of the place.
The height of the season was over, she said; there had been tableaux and charades, and broomdrills, and
readings and charity concerts. Now the season was on the sentimental wane; every night the rooms were full
of whistplayers, and the days were occupied in quiet strolling over the hills, and excursions to Cooperstown
Their Pilgrimage
XIII. RICHFIELD SPRINGS, COOPERSTOWN 90
Page No 93
and Cherry Valley and "points of view," and visits to the fields to see the hoppickers at work. If there were a
little larking about the piazzas in the evening, and a group here and there pretending to be merry over tall
glasses with ice and straws in them, and lingering goodnights at the stairways, why should the aged and
rheumatic make a note of it? Did they not also once prefer the dance to hobbling to the spring, and the taste of
ginger to sulphur?
Of course the raison d'etre of being here is the sulphur spring. There is no doubt of its efficacy. I suppose it is
as unpleasant as any in the country. Everybody smells it, and a great many drink it. The artist said that after
using it a week the blind walk, the lame see, and the dumb swear. It renews youth, and although the analyzer
does not say that it is a "love philter," the statistics kept by the colored autocrat who ladles out the fluid show
that there are made as many engagements at Richfield as at any other summer fair in the country.
There is not much to chronicle in the peaceful flow of domestic life, and, truth to say, the charm of Richfield
is largely in its restfulness. Those who go there year after year converse a great deal about their liking for it,
and think the time well spent in persuading new arrivals to take certain walks and drives. It was impressed
upon King that he must upon no account omit a visit to Rum Hill, from the summit of which is had a noble
prospect, including the Adirondack Mountains. He tried this with a walking party, was driven back when near
the summit by a thunder, storm, which offered a series of grand pictures in the sky and on the hills, and took
refuge in a farmhouse which was occupied by a band of hoppickers. These adventurers are mostly young
girls and young men from the cities and factory villages, to whom this is the only holiday of the year. Many
of the pickers, however, are veterans. At this season one meets them on all the roads, driving from farm to
farm in lumber wagons, carrying into the dull rural life their slang, and "Captain Jinks" songs, and shocking
free manners. At the great hop fields they lodge all together in big barracks, and they make lively for the time
whatever farmhouse they occupy. They are a "rough lot," and need very much the attention of the poet and
the novelist, who might (if they shut their eyes) make this season as romantic as vintagetime on the Rhine,
or "moonshining " on the Southern mountains. The hop field itself, with its tall poles draped in graceful vines
which reach from pole to pole, and hang their yellowing fruit in pretty festoons and arbors, is much more
picturesque than the vineclad hills.
Mrs. Bartlett Glow found many acquaintances here from New York and Philadelphia and Newport, and, to do
her justice, she introduced Irene to them and presently involved her in so many pleasure parties and
excursions that she and King were scarcely ever alone together. When opportunity offered for a stroll a deux,
the girl's manner was so constrained that King was compelled to ask the reason of it. He got very little
satisfaction, and the puzzle of her conduct was increased by her confession that she loved him just the same,
and always should.
"But something has come between us," he said. "I think I have the right to be treated with perfect frankness."
"So you have," she replied. "There is nothingnothing at least that changes my feeling towards you."
"But you think that mine is changed for you?"
"No, not that, either, never that;" and her voice showed excitement as she turned away her head. "But don't
you know, Stanhope, you have not known me very long, and perhaps you have been a little hasty, andhow
shall I say it?if you had more time to reflect, when you go back to your associates and your active life, it
might somehow look differently to you, and your prospects"
"Why, Irene, I have no prospects without you. I love you; you are my life. I don't understand. I am just yours,
and nothing you can do will ever make it any different for me; but if you want to be free"
Their Pilgrimage
XIII. RICHFIELD SPRINGS, COOPERSTOWN 91
Page No 94
"No, no," cried the girl, trying in vain to restrain her agitation and her tears, "not that. I don't want to be free.
But you will not understand. Circumstances are so cruel, and if, Stanhope, you ever should regret when it is
too late! It would kill me. I want you to be happy. And, Stanhope, promise me that, whatever happens, you
will not think ill of me."
Of course he promised, he declared that nothing could happen, he vowed, and he protested against this
ridiculous phantom in her mind. To a man, used to straightforward cuts in love as in any other object of his
desire, this feminine exaggeration of conscientiousness is wholly incomprehensible. How under heavens a
woman could get a kink of duty in her mind which involved the sacrifice of herself and her lover was past his
fathoming.
The morning after this conversation, the most of which the reader has been spared, there was an excursion to
Cooperstown. The early start of the tallyho coaches for this trip is one of the chief sensations of the quiet
village. The bustle to collect the laggards, the importance of the conductors and drivers, the scramble up the
ladders, the ruses to get congenial seatneighbors, the fine spirits of everybody evoked by the fresh morning
air, and the elevation on top of the coaches, give the start an air of jolly adventure. Away they go, the big
redandyellow arks, swinging over the hills and along the wellwatered valleys, past the twin lakes to
Otsego, over which hangs the romance of Cooper's tales, where a steamer waits. This is one of the most
charming of the little lakes that dot the interior of New York; without bold shores or anything sensational in
its scenery, it is a poetic element in a refined and lovely landscape. There are a few fishinglodges and
summer cottages on its banks (one of them distinguished as "Sinners' Rest"), and a hotel or two famous for
dinners; but the traveler would be repaid if there were nothing except the lovely village of Cooperstown
embowered in maples at the foot. The town rises gently from the lake, and is very picturesque with its church
spires and trees and handsome mansions; and nothing could be prettier than the foreground, the gardens, the
allees of willows, the long boat wharves with hundreds of rowboats and sailboats, and the exit of the
Susquehanna River, which here swirls away under drooping foliage, and begins its long journey to the sea.
The whole village has an air of leisure and refinement. For our tourists the place was pervaded by the spirit of
the necromancer who has woven about it a spell of romance; but to the ordinary inhabitants the long
residence of the novelist here was not half so important as that of the very distinguished citizen who had
made a great fortune out of some patent, built here a fine house, and adorned his native town. It is not so very
many years since Cooper died, and yet the boatmen and loungers about the lake had only the faintest
impression of the manthere was a writer by that name, one of them said, and some of his family lived near
the house of the great man already referred to. The magician who created Cooperstown sleeps in the old
Englishlooking churchyard of the Episcopal church, in the midst of the graves of his relations, and there is
a wellworn path to his headstone. Whatever the common people of the town may think, it is that grave that
draws most pilgrims to the village. Where the hillside cemetery now is, on the bank of the lake, was his farm,
which he visited always once and sometimes twice a day. He commonly wrote only from ten to twelve in the
morning, giving the rest of the time to his farm and the society of his family. During the period of his libel
suits, when the newspapers represented him as morose and sullen in his retirement, he was, on the contrary,
in the highest spirits and the most genial mood. "Deerslayer" was written while this contest was at its height.
Driving one day from his farm with his daughter, he stopped and looked long over his favorite prospect on
the lake, and said, "I must write one more story, dear, about our little lake. At that moment the "Deerslayer "
was born. He was silent the rest of the way home, and went immediately to his library and began the story.
The party returned in a moralizing vein. How vague already in the village which his genius has made known
over the civilized world is the fame of Cooper! To our tourists the place was saturated with his presence, but
the new generation cares more for its smart prosperity than for all his romance. Many of the passengers on
the boat had stopped at a lakeside tavern to dine, preferring a good dinner to the associations which drew our
sentimentalists to the spots that were hallowed by the necromancer's imagination. And why not? One cannot
live in the past forever. The people on the boat who dwelt in Cooperstown were not talking about Cooper,
perhaps had not thought of him for a year. The ladies, seated in the bow of the boat, were comparing notes
Their Pilgrimage
XIII. RICHFIELD SPRINGS, COOPERSTOWN 92
Page No 95
about their rheumatism and the measles of their children; one of them had been to the funeral of a young girl
who was to have been married in the autumn, poor thing, and she told her companion who were at the
funeral, and how they were dressed, and how little feeling Nancy seemed to show, and how shiftless it was
not to have more flowers, and how the bridegroom bore upwell, perhaps it's an escape, she was so weakly.
The day lent a certain pensiveness to all this; the season was visibly waning; the soft maples showed color,
the orchards were heavy with fruit, the mountainash hung out its red signals, the hopvines were yellowing,
and in all the fence corners the goldenrod flamed and made the meanest highroad a way of glory. On Irene
fell a spell of sadness that affected her lover. Even Mrs. BartlettGlow seemed touched by some regret for
the fleeting of the gay season, and the top of the coach would have been melancholy enough but for the high
spirits of Marion and the artist, whose gayety expanded in the abundance of the harvest season. Happy
natures, unrestrained by the subtle melancholy of a decaying year!
The summer was really going. On Sunday the weather broke in a violent storm of wind and rain, and at
sunset, when it abated, there were portentous gleams on the hills, and threatening clouds lurking about the
sky. It was time to go. Few people have the courage to abide the breaking of the serenity of summer, and
remain in the country for the more glorious autumn days that are to follow. The Glows must hurry back to
Newport. The Bensons would not be persuaded out of their fixed plan to "take in," as Mr. Benson expressed
it, the White Mountains. The others were going to Niagara and the Thousand Islands; and when King told
Irene that he would much rather change his route and accompany her, he saw by the girl's manner that it was
best not to press the subject. He dreaded to push an explanation, and, foolish as lovers are, he was wise for
once in trusting to time. But he had a miserable evening. He let himself be irritated by the lightheartedness of
Forbes. He objected to the latter's whistling as he went about his room packing up his traps. He hated a fellow
that was always in high spirits. "Why, what has come over you, old man?" queried the artist, stopping to take
a critical look at his comrade. "Do you want to get out of it? It's my impression that you haven't taken sulphur
water enough."
On Monday morning there was a general clearing out. The platform at the station was crowded. The
palacecars for New York, for Niagara, for Albany, for the West, were overflowing. There was a pile of
trunks as big as a city dwellinghouse. Babycarriages cumbered the way; dogs were under foot, yelping and
rending the tender hearts of their owners; the porters staggered about under their loads, and shouted till they
were hoarse; farewells were said; rendezvous madealas! how many half fledged hopes came to an end on
that platform! The artist thought he had never seen so many pretty girls together in his life before, and each
one had in her belt a bunch of goldenrod. Summer was over, sure enough.
At Utica the train was broken up, and its cars despatched in various directions. King remembered that it was
at Utica that the younger Cato sacrificed himself. In the presence of all the world Irene bade him goodby. "It
will not be for long," said King, with an attempt at gayety. "Nothing is for long," she said with the same
manner. And then added in a low tone, as she slipped a note into his hand," Do not think ill of me."
King opened the note as soon as he found his seat in the car, and this was what he read as the train rushed
westward towards the Great Fall:
"MY DEAR FRIEND,How can I ever say it? It is best that we
separate. I have thought and thought; I have struggled with myself.
I think that I know it is best for you. I have been happyah me!
Dear, we must look at the world as it is. We cannot change itif
we break our hearts, we cannot. Don't blame your cousin. It is
nothing that she has done. She has been as sweet and kind to me as
possible, but I have seen through her what I feared, just how it is.
Don't reproach me. It is hard now. I know it. But I believe that
you will come to see it as I do. If it was any sacrifice that I
could make, that would be easy. But to think that I had sacrificed
Their Pilgrimage
XIII. RICHFIELD SPRINGS, COOPERSTOWN 93
Page No 96
you, and that you should some day become aware of it! You are free.
I am not silly. It is the future I am thinking of. You must take
your place in the world where your lot is cast. Don't think I have
a foolish pride. Perhaps it is pride that tells me not to put
myself in a false position; perhaps it is something else. Never
think it is want of heart in IRENE
"Goodby."
As King finished this he looked out of the window.
The landscape was black.
XIV. NIAGARA
In the car for Niagara was an Englishman of the receptive, guileless, thin type, inquisitive and overflowing
with approval of everything Americana type which has now become one of the common features of travel
in this country. He had light hair, sandy sidewhiskers, a face that looked as if it had been scrubbed with soap
and sandpaper, and he wore a sickly yellow travelingsuit. He was accompanied by his wife, a stout, resolute
matron, in heavy boots, a sensible stuff gown, with a lot of cotton lace fudged about her neck, and a broad
brimmed hat with a vegetable garden on top. The little man was always in pursuit of information, in his
guidebook or from his fellowpassengers, and whenever he obtained any he invariably repeated it to his
wife, who said "Fancy!" and "Now, really!" in a rising inflection that expressed surprise and expectation.
The conceited American, who commonly draws himself into a shell when he travels, and affects indifference,
and seems to be losing all natural curiosity, receptivity, and the power of observation, is pretty certain to
undervalue the intelligence of this class of English travelers, and get amusement out of their peculiarities
instead of learning from them how to make everyday of life interesting. Even King, who, besides his national
crust of exclusiveness, was today wrapped in the gloom of Irene's letter, was gradually drawn to these simple,
unpretending people. He took for granted their ignorance of Americaignorance of America being one of
the branches taught in the English schoolsand he soon discovered that they were citizens of the world.
They not only knew the Continent very well, but they had spent a winter in Egypt, lived a year in India, and
seen something of China and much of Japan. Although they had been scarcely a fortnight in the United
States, King doubted if there were ten women in the State of New York, not professional teachers, who knew
as much of the flora of the country as this plainfeatured, rich voiced woman. They called King's attention
to a great many features of the landscape he had never noticed before, and asked him a great many questions
about farming and stock and wages that he could not answer. It appeared that Mr. Stanley Stubbs,
StokeCrudenfor that was the name and address of the present discoverers of Americahad a herd of
short horns, and that Mrs. Stubbs was even more familiar with the herdbook than her husband. But before
the fact had enabled King to settle the position of his new acquaintance satisfactorily to himself, Mrs. Stubbs
upset his estimate by quoting Tennyson.
"Your great English poet is very much read here," King said, by way of being agreeable.
"So we have heard," replied Mrs. Stubbs. "Mr. Stubbs reads Tennyson beautifully. He has thought of giving
some readings while we are here. We have been told that the Americans are very fond of readings."
"Yes," said King, "they are devoted to them, especially readings by Englishmen in their native tongue. There
is a great rage now for everything English; at Newport hardly anything else is spoken."
Mrs. Stubbs looked for a moment as if this might be an American joke; but there was no smile upon King's
face, and she only said, "Fancy! You must make a note of Newport, dear. That is one of the places we must
see. Of course Mr. Stubbs has never read in public, you know. But I suppose that would make no difference,
Their Pilgrimage
XIV. NIAGARA 94
Page No 97
the Americans are so kind and so appreciative."
"Not the least difference," replied King. "They are used to it."
"It is a wonderful country," said Mr. Stubbs.
"Most interesting," chimed in Mrs. Stubbs; "and so odd!
"You know, Mr. King, we find some of the Americans so clever. We have been surprised, really. It makes us
feel quite at home. At the hotels and everywhere, most obliging."
"Do you make a long stay?"
"Oh, no. We just want to study the people and the government, and see the principal places. We were told
that Albany is the capital, instead of New York; it's so odd, you know. And Washington is another capital.
And there is Boston. It must be very confusing." King began to suspect that he must be talking with the editor
of the Saturday Review. Mr. Stubbs continued: "They told us in New York that we ought to go to Paterson on
the Island of Jersey, I believe. I suppose it is as interesting as Niagara. We shall visit it on our return. But we
came over more to see Niagara than anything else. And from there we shall run over to Chicago and the
Yosemite. Now we are here, we could not think of going back without a look at the Yosemite."
King said that thus far he had existed without seeing the Yosemite, but he believed that next to Chicago it
was the most attractive place in the country.
It was dark when they came into the station at Niagaradark and silent. Our American tourists, who were
accustomed to the clamor of the hackmen here, and expected to be assaulted by a horde of wild Comanches
in plain clothes, and torn limb from baggage, if not limb from limb, were unable to account for this silence,
and the absence of the common highwaymen, until they remembered that the State had bought the Falls, and
the agents of the government had suppressed many of the old nuisances. It was possible now to hear the roar
of the cataract.
This unaccustomed human stillness was ominous to King. He would have welcomed a Niagara of
importunity and imprecations; he was bursting with impatience to express himself; it seemed as if he would
die if he were silent an hour longer under that letter. Of course the usual American relief of irritability and
impatience suggested itself. He would telegraph; only electricity was quick enough and fiery enough for his
mood. But what should he telegraph? The telegraph was not invented for lovemaking, and is not adapted to
it. It is ridiculous to make love by wire. How was it possible to frame a message that should be commercial
on its face, and yet convey the deepest agony and devotion of the sender's heart? King stood at the little
telegraph window, looking at the despatcher who was to send it, and thought of this. Depressed and intent as
he was, the whimsicality of the situation struck him. What could he say? It illustrates our sheeplike habit of
expressing ourselves in the familiar phrase or popular slang of the day that at the instant the only thing King
could think of to send was this: "Hold the fort, for I am coming." The incongruity of this made him smile, and
he did not write it. Finally he composed this message, which seemed to him to have a businesslike and
innocent aspect: "Too late. Impossible for me to change. Have invested everything. Expect letter."
Mechanically he counted the words when he had written this. On the fair presumption that the company
would send "everything" as one word, there were still two more than the conventional ten, and, from force of
habit, he struck out the words " for me." But he had no sooner done this than he felt a sense of shame. It was
contemptible for a man in love to count his words, and it was intolerable to be haggling with himself at such a
crisis over the expense of a despatch. He got cold over the thought that Irene might also count them, and see
that the cost of this message of passion had been calculated. And with recklessness he added: "We reach the
Profile House next week, and I am sure I can convince you I am right."
Their Pilgrimage
XIV. NIAGARA 95
Page No 98
King found Niagara pitched to the key of his lacerated and tumultuous feelings. There were few people at the
Cataract House, and either the bridal season had not set in, or in America a bride has been evolved who does
not show any consciousness of her new position. In his present mood the place seemed deserted, the figures
of the few visitors gliding about as in a dream, as if they too had been subdued by the recent commission
which had silenced the drivers, and stopped the mills, and made the park free, and was tearing down the
presumptuous structures along the bank. In this silence, which emphasized the quaking of the earth and air,
there was a sense of unknown, impending disaster. It was not to be borne indoors, and the two friends went
out into the night.
On the edge of the rapids, above the hotel, the old bathhouse was in process of demolition, its shaking
piazza almost overhanging the flood. Not much could be seen from it, but it was in the midst of an elemental
uproar. Some electric lamps shining through the trees made high lights on the crests of the rapids, while the
others near were in shadow and dark. The black mass of Goat Island appeared under the lightning flashes in
the northwest sky, and whenever these quick gleams pierced the gloom the frail bridge to the island was
outlined for a moment, and then vanished as if it had been swept away, and there could only be seen sparks of
light in the houses on the Canadian shore, which seemed very near. In this unknown, which was rather felt
than seen, there was a sense of power and of mystery which overcame the mind; and in the black night the
roar, the cruel haste of the rapids, tossing white gleams and hurrying to the fatal plunge, begat a sort of terror
in the spectators. It was a power implacable, vengeful, not to be measured. They strolled down to Prospect
Park. The gate was closed; it had been the scene of an awful tragedy but a few minutes before. They did not
know it, but they knew that the air shuddered, and as they skirted the grounds along the way to the
footbridge the roar grew in their stunned ears. There, projected out into the night, were the cables of steel
holding the frail platform over the abyss of night and terror. Beyond was Canada. There was light enough in
the sky to reveal, but not to dissipate, the appalling insecurity. What an impious thing it seemed to them, this
trembling structure across the chasm! They advanced upon it. There were gleams on the mill cascades below,
and on the mass of the American Fall. Below, down in the gloom, were patches of foam, slowly circling
around in the eddy no haste now, just sullen and black satisfaction in the awful tragedy of the fall. The
whole was vague, fearful. Always the roar, the shuddering of the air. I think that a man placed on this bridge
at night, and ignorant of the cause of the aerial agitation and the wild uproar, could almost lose his reason in
the panic of the scene. They walked on; they set foot on Her Majesty's dominions; they entered the Clifton
Housequite American, you know, with its new bar and office. A subdued air about everybody here also,
and the same quaking, shivering, and impending sense of irresponsible force. Even "two fingers," said the
artist, standing at the bar, had little effect in allaying the impression of the terror out there. When they
returned the moon was coming up, rising and struggling and making its way slowly through ragged masses of
colored clouds. The river could be plainly seen now, smooth, deep, treacherous; the falls on the American
side showed fitfully like patches of light and foam; the Horseshoe, mostly hidden by a cold silver mist,
occasionally loomed up a white and ghostly mass. They stood for a long time looking down at the foot of the
American Fall, the moon now showing clearly the plunge of the heavy columna column as stiff as if it
were melted silverhushed and frightened by the weird and appalling scene. They did not know at that
moment that there where their eyes were riveted, there at the base of the fall, a man's body was churning
about, plunged down and cast up, and beaten and whirled, imprisoned in the refluent eddy. But a body was
there. In the morning a man's overcoat was found on the parapet at the angle of the fall. Someone then
remembered that in the evening, just before the park gate closed, he had seen a man approach the angle of the
wall where the overcoat was found. The man was never seen after that. Night first, and then the hungry water,
swallowed him. One pictures the fearful leap into the dark, the midway repentance, perhaps, the despair of
the plunge. A body cast in here is likely to tarry for days, eddying round and round, and tossed in that terrible
maelstrom, before a chance current ejects it, and sends it down the fierce rapids below. King went back to the
hotel in a terror of the place, which did not leave him so long as he remained. His room quivered, the roar
filled all the air. Is not life real and terrible enough, he asked himself, but that brides must cast this experience
also into their honeymoon?
Their Pilgrimage
XIV. NIAGARA 96
Page No 99
The morning light did not efface the impressions of the night, the dominating presence of a gigantic, pitiless
force, a blind passion of nature, uncontrolled and uncontrollable. Shut the windows and lock the door, you
could not shut out the terror of it. The town did not seem safe; the bridges, the buildings on the edge of the
precipices with their shaking casements, the islands, might at any moment be engulfed and disappear. It was a
thing to flee from.
I suspect King was in a very sensitive mood; the world seemed for the moment devoid of human sympathy,
and the savageness and turmoil played upon his bare nerves. The artist himself shrank from contact with this
overpowering display, and said that he could not endure more than a day or two of it. It needed all the
sunshine in the face of Miss Lamont and the serenity of her cheerful nature to make the situation tolerable,
and even her sprightliness was somewhat subdued. It was a day of big, broken, highsailing clouds, with a
deep blue sky and strong sunlight. The slight bridge to Goat Island appeared more presumptuous by daylight,
and the sharp slope of the rapids above it gave a new sense of the impetuosity of the torrent. As they walked
slowly on, past the now abandoned papermills and the other human impertinences, the elemental turmoil
increased, and they seemed entering a world the foundations of which were broken up. This must have been a
good deal a matter of impression, for other parties of sightseers were coming and going, apparently unawed,
and intent simply on visiting every point spoken of in the guidebook, and probably unconscious of the
allpervading terror. But King could not escape it, even in the throng descending and ascending the stairway
to Luna Island. Standing upon the platform at the top, he realized for the first time the immense might of the
downpour of the American Fall, and noted the pale green color, with here and there a violet tone, and the
white cloud mass spurting out from the solid color. On the foamcrested river lay a rainbow forming nearly a
complete circle. The little steamer Maid of the Mist was coming up, riding the waves, dashed here and there
by conflicting currents, but resolutely steaming onsuch is the audacity of manand poking her
venturesome nose into the boiling foam under the Horseshoe. On the deck are pigmy passengers in oilskin
suits, clumsy figures, like arctic explorers. The boat tosses about like a chip, it hesitates and quivers, and
then, slowly swinging, darts away down the current, fleeing from the wrath of the waters, and pursued by the
angry roar.
Surely it is an island of magic, unsubstantial, liable to go adrift and plunge into the canon. Even in the forest
path, where the great tree trunks assure one of stability and long immunity, this feeling cannot be shaken off.
Our party descended the winding staircase in the tower, and walked on the shelf under the mighty ledge to the
entrance of the Cave of the Winds. The curtain of water covering this entrance was blown back and forth by
the wind, now leaving the platform dry and now deluging it. A woman in the pathway was beckoning
frantically and calling to a man who stood on the platform, entirely unconscious of danger, looking up to the
green curtain and down into the boiling mist. It was Mrs. Stubbs; but she was shouting against Niagara, and
her husband mistook her pantomime for gestures of wonder and admiration. Some moments passed, and then
the curtain swung in, and tons of water drenched the Englishman, and for an instant hid him from sight. Then,
as the curtain swung back, he was seen clinging to the handrail, sputtering and astonished at such treatment.
He came up the bank dripping, and declaring that it was extraordinary, most extraordinary, but he wouldn't
have missed it for the world. From this platform one looks down the narrow, slippery stairs that are lost in the
boiling mist, and wonders at the daring that built these steps down into that hell, and carried the frail walk of
planks over the bowlders outside the fall. A party in oilskins, making their way there, looked like lost men
and women in a Dante Inferno. The turbulent waters dashed all about them; the mist occasionally wrapped
them from sight; they clung to the rails, they tried to speak to each other; their gestures seemed motions of
despair. Could that be Eurydice whom the rough guide was tenderly dragging out of the hell of waters, up the
stony path, that singular figure in oilskin trousers, who disclosed a pretty face inside her hood as she
emerged? One might venture into the infernal regions to rescue such a woman; but why take her there? The
group of adventurers stopped a moment on the platform, with the opening into the misty cavern for a
background, and the artist said that the picture was, beyond all power of the pencil, strange and fantastic.
There is nothing, after all, that the human race will not dare for a new sensation.
Their Pilgrimage
XIV. NIAGARA 97
Page No 100
The walk around Goat Island is probably unsurpassed in the world for wonder and beauty. The Americans
have every reason to be satisfied with their share of the fall; they get nowhere one single grand view like that
from the Canada side, but infinitely the deepest impression of majesty and power is obtained on Goat Island.
There the spectator is in the midst of the war of nature. From the point over the Horseshoe Fall our friends,
speaking not much, but more and more deeply moved, strolled along in the lovely forest, in a rural solemnity,
in a local calm, almost a seclusion, except for the everpresent shuddering roar in the air. On the shore above
the Horseshoe they first comprehended the breadth, the great sweep, of the rapids. The white crests of the
waves in the west were coming out from under a black, lowering sky; all the foreground was in bright
sunlight, dancing, sparkling, leaping, hurrying on, converging to the angle where the water becomes a deep
emerald at the break and plunge. The rapids above are a series of shelves, bristling with jutting rocks and
lodged trunks of trees, and the wildness of the scene is intensified by the ragged fringe of evergreens on the
opposite shore.
Over the whole island the mist, rising from the caldron, drifts in spray when the wind is rable; but on this day
the forest was bright and cheerful, and as the strollers went farther away from the Great Fall; the beauty of the
scene began to steal away its terror. The roar was still dominant, but far off and softened, and did not crush
the ear. The triple islands, the Three Sisters, in their picturesque wildness appeared like playful freaks of
nature in a momentary relaxation of the savage mood. Here is the finest view of the river; to one standing on
the outermost island the great flood seems tumbling out of the sky. They continued along the bank of the
river. The shallow stream races by headlong, but close to the edge are numerous eddies, and places where one
might step in and not be swept away. At length they reached the point where the river divides, and the water
stands for an instant almost still, hesitating whether to take the Canadian or American plunge. Out a little way
from the shore the waves leap and tumble, and the two currents are like racehorses parted on two ways to
the goal. Just at this point the water swirls and lingers; having lost all its fierceness and haste, and spreads
itself out placidly, dimpling in the sun. It may be a treacherous pause, this water may be as cruel as that
which rages below and exults in catching a boat or a man and bounding with the victim over the cataract; but
the calm was very grateful to the stunned and buffeted visitors; upon their jarred nerves it was like the peace
of God.
"The preacher might moralize here," said King. "Here is the parting of the ways for the young man; here is a
moment of calm in which he can decide which course he will take. See, with my hand I can turn the water to
Canada or to America! So momentous is the easy decision of the moment."
"Yes," said the artist, "your figure is perfect. Whichever side the young man takes, he goes to destruction."
"Or," continued King, appealing to Miss Lamont against this illogical construction, "this is the maiden at the
crucial instant of choosing between two impetuous suitors."
"You mean she will be sorry, whichever she chooses?"
"You two practical people would spoil any illustration in the world. You would divest the impressive drop of
water on the mountain summit, which might go to the Atlantic or to the Pacific, of all moral character by
saying that it makes no difference which ocean it falls into."
The relief from the dread of Niagara felt at this point of peace was only temporary. The dread returned when
the party approached again the turmoil of the American Fall, and fell again under the influence of the
merciless haste of the flood. And there every islet, every rock, every point, has its legend of terror; here a
boat lodged with a man in it, and after a day and night of vain attempts to rescue him, thousands of people
saw him take the frightful leap, throwing up his arms as he went over; here a young woman slipped, and was
instantly whirled away out of life; and from that point more than one dazed or frantic visitor had taken the
suicidal leap. Death was so near here and so easy!
Their Pilgrimage
XIV. NIAGARA 98
Page No 101
One seems in less personal peril on the Canadian side, and has more the feeling of a spectator and less that of
a participant in the wild uproar. "Perhaps there is more sense of force, but the majesty of the scene is relieved
by a hundred shifting effects of light and color. In the afternoon, under a broken sky, the rapids above the
Horseshoe reminded one of the seashore on a very stormy day. Impeded by the rocks, the flood hesitated and
even ran back, as if reluctant to take the final plunge! The sienna color of the water on the table contrasted
sharply with the emerald at the break of the fall. A rainbow springing out of the centre of the caldron arched
clear over the American cataract, and was one moment bright and the next dimly seen through the mist,
which boiled up out of the foam of waters and swayed in the wind. Through this veil darted adventurous
birds, flashing their wings in the prismatic colors, and circling about as if fascinated by the awful rush and
thunder. With the shifting wind and the passing clouds the scene was in perpetual change; now the American
Fall was creamy white, and the mist below dark, and again the heavy mass was gray and sullen, and the mist
like silver spray. Perhaps nowhere else in the world is the force of nature so overpowering to the mind, and as
the eye wanders from the chaos of the fall to the far horizon, where the vast rivers of rapids are poured out of
the sky, one feels that this force is inexhaustible and eternal.
If our travelers expected to escape the impression they were under by driving down to the rapids and
whirlpool below, they were mistaken. Nowhere is the river so terrible as where it rushes, as if maddened by
its narrow bondage, through the canon. Flung down the precipice and forced into this contracted space, it
fumes and tosses and rages with vindictive fury, driving on in a passion that has almost a human quality in it.
Restrained by the walls of stone from being destructive, it seems to rave at its own impotence, and when it
reaches the whirlpool it is like a hungry animal, returning and licking the shore for the prey it has missed. But
it has not always wanted a prey. Now and again it has a wreck or a dead body to toss and fling about.
Although it does not need the human element of disaster to make this canon grewsome, the keepers of the
show places make the most of the late Captain Webb. So vivid were their narratives that our sympathetic
party felt his presence continually, saw the strong swimmer tossed like a chip, saw him throw up his hands,
saw the agony in his face at the spot where he was last seen. There are several places where he disappeared,
each vouched for by credible witnesses, so that the horror of the scene is multiplied for the tourist. The late
afternoon had turned gray and cold, and dashes of rain fell as our party descended to the whirlpool. As they
looked over the heapedup and foaming waters in this eddy they almost expected to see Captain Webb or the
suicide of the night before circling round in the maelstrom. They came up out of the gorge silent, and drove
back to the hotel full of nervous apprehension.
King found no telegram from Irene, and the place seemed to him intolerable. The artist was quite ready to go
on in the morning; indeed, the whole party, although they said it was unreasonable, confessed that they were
almost afraid to stay longer; the roar, the trembling, the pervading sense of a blind force and rage, inspired a
nameless dread. The artist said, the next morning at the station, that he understood the feelings of Lot.
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES
The occupation of being a red man, a merchant of baskets and beadwork, is taken up by so many traders with
a brogue and a twang at our watering places that it is difficult for the traveler to keep alive any sentiment
about this race. But at a station beyond Lewiston our tourists were reminded of it, and of its capacity for
adopting our civilization in its most efflorescent development. The train was invaded by a band of Indians, or,
to speak correctly, by an Indian band. There is nothing in the world like a brass band in a country town; it
probably gives more pleasure to the performers than any other sort of labor. Yet the delight it imparts to the
listeners is apt to be tempered by a certain sense of incongruity between the peaceful citizens who compose it
and the bellicose din they produce. There is a note of barbarism in the brassy jar and clamor of the
instruments, enhanced by the bewildering ambition of each player to force through his piece the most noise
and jangle, which is not always covered and subdued into a harmonious whole by the whang of the bass
drum.
Their Pilgrimage
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES 99
Page No 102
There was nothing of this incongruity between this band of Tuscaroras and their occupation. Unaccustomed
to associate the North American Indian with music, the traveler at once sees the natural relation of the Indians
with the brass band. These Tuscaroras were stalwart fellows, broad faced, biglimbed, serious, and they
carried themselves with a clumsy but impressive dignity. There was no uniformity in their apparel, yet each
one wore some portion of a martial and resplendent dressan ornamented kepi, or a scarlet sash, or big
golden epaulets, or a military coat braided with yellow. The leader, who was a giant, and carried the smallest
instrument, outshone all the others in his incongruous splendor. No sooner had they found seats at one end of
the car than they unlimbered, and began through their various reluctant instruments to deploy a tune.
Although the tune did not get well into line, the effect was marvelous. The car was instantly filled to bursting.
Miss Lamont, who was reading at the other end of the car, gave a nervous start, and looked up in alarm. King
and Forbes promptly opened windows, but this gave little relief. The trombone pumped and growled, the
trumpet blared, the big brass instrument with a calyx like the monstrous tropical water lily quivered and
howled, and the drum, banging into the discord, smashed every tympanum in the car. The Indians looked
pleased. No sooner had they broken one tune into fragments than they took up another, and the car roared and
rattled and jarred all the way to the lonely station where the band debarked, and was last seen convoying a
straggling OddFellows' picnic down a country road.
The incident, trivial in itself, gave rise to serious reflections touching the capacity and use of the red man in
modern life. Here is a peaceful outlet for all his wild instincts. Let the government turn all the hostiles on the
frontier into brass bands, and we shall hear no more of the Indian question.
The railway along the shore of Lake Ontario is for the most part monotonous. After leaving the picturesque
highlands about Lewiston, the country is flat, and although the view over the lovely sheet of blue water is
always pleasing, there is something bleak even in summer in this vast level expanse from which the timber
has been cut away. It may have been mere fancy, but to the tourists the air seemed thin, and the scene,
artistically speaking, was cold and colorless. With every desire to do justice to the pretty town of Oswego,
which lies on a gentle slope by the lake, it had to them an outofdoors, unprotected, remote aspect. Seen
from the station, it did not appear what it is, the handsomest city on Lake Ontario, with the largest starch
factory in the world.
It was towards evening when the train reached Cape Vincent, where the steamer waited to transport
passengers down the St. Lawrence. The weather had turned cool; the broad river, the low shores, the long
islands which here divide its lakelike expanse, wanted atmospheric warmth, and the tourists could not
escape the feeling of lonesomeness, as if they were on the other side of civilization, rather than in one of the
great streams of summer frolic and gayety. It was therefore a very agreeable surprise to them when a
traveling party alighted from one of the cars, which had come from Rome, among whom they recognized
Mrs. Farquhar.
"I knew my education never could be complete," said that lady as she shook hands, "and you never would
consider me perfectly in the Union until I had seen the Thousand Islands; and here I am, after many Yankee
tribulations."
"And why didn't you come by Niagara?" asked Miss Lamont.
"My dear, perhaps your uncle could tell you that I saw enough of Niagara when I was a young lady, during
the war. The cruelest thing you Yankees did was to force us, who couldn't fight, to go over there for
sympathy. The only bearable thing about the fall of Richmond was that it relieved me from that Fall. But
where," she added, turning to King, "are the rest of your party?"
"If you mean the Bensons," said he, with a rather rueful countenance, "I believe they have gone to the White
Mountains."
Their Pilgrimage
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES 100
Page No 103
"Oh, not lost, but gone before. You believe? If you knew the nights I have lain awake thinking about you two,
or you three! I fear you have not been wideawake enough yourself."
"I knew I could depend on you, Mrs. Farquhar, for that."
The steamer was moving off, taking a wide sweep to follow the channel. The passengers were all engaged in
ascertaining the names of the islands and of the owners of the cottages and clubhouses. "It is a kind of
information I have learned to dispense with," said Mrs. Farquhar. And the tourists, except three or four
resolutely inquisitive, soon tired of it. The islands multiplied; the boat wound in and out among them in
narrow straits. To sail thus amid rocky islets, hirsute with firs, promised to be an unfailing pleasure. It might
have been, if darkness had not speedily fallen. But it is notable how soon passengers on a steamer become
indifferent and listless in any sort of scenery. Where the scenery is monotonous and repeats itself mile after
mile and hour after hour, an intolerable weariness falls upon the company. The enterprising group who have
taken all the best seats in the bow, with the intention of gormandizing the views, exhibit little staying power;
either the monotony or the wind drives them into the cabin. And passengers in the cabin occupying chairs and
sofas, surrounded by their baggage, always look bored and melancholy.
"I always think," said Mrs. Farquhar, "that I am going to enjoy a ride on a steamer, but I never do. It is
impossible to get out of a draught, and the progress is so slow that variety enough is not presented to the eye
to keep one from ennui." Nevertheless, Mrs. Farquhar and King remained on deck, in such shelter as they
could find, during the three hours' sail, braced up by the consciousness that they were doing their duty in
regard to the enterprise that has transformed this lovely stream into a highway of display and enjoyment.
Miss Lamont and the artist went below, frankly confessing that they could see all that interested them from
the cabin windows. And they had their reward; for in this little cabin, where supper was served, a drama was
going on between the cook and the two waitingmaids and the cabin boy, a drama of love and coquetry and
jealousy and hope deferred, quite as important to those concerned as any of the wateringplace comedies, and
played with entire unconsciousness of the spectators.
The evening was dark, and the navigation in the tortuous channels sometimes difficult, and might have been
dangerous but for the lighthouses. The steamer crept along in the shadows of the low islands, making
frequent landings, and never long out of sight of the illuminations of hotels and cottages. Possibly by reason
of these illuminations this passage has more variety by night than by day. There was certainly a fascination
about this alternating brilliancy and gloom. On nearly every island there was at least a cottage, and on the
larger islands were great hotels, campmeeting establishments, and houses and tents for the entertainment of
thousands of people. Late as it was in the season, most of the temporary villages and solitary lodges were
illuminated; colored lamps were set about the grounds, Chinese lanterns hung in the evergreens, and on half a
dozen lines radiating from the belfry of the hotel to the ground, while all the windows blazed and scintillated.
Occasionally as the steamer passed these places of irrepressible gayety rockets were let off, Bengallights
were burned, and once a cannon attempted to speak the joy of the sojourners. It was like a continued Fourth
of July, and King's heart burned within him with national pride. Even Mrs. Farquhar had to admit that it was
a fairy spectacle. During the months of July and August this broad river, with its fantastic islands, is at night
simply a highway of glory. The worldlings and the campmeeting gatherings vie with each other in the
display of colored lights and fireworks. And such places as the Thousand Islands Park, Wellesley and Wesley
parks, and so on, twinkling with lamps and rosy with pyrotechnics, like sections of the sky dropped upon the
earth, create in the mind of the steamer pilgrim an indescribable earthly and heavenly excitement. He does
not look upon these displays as advertisements of rival resorts, but as generous contributions to the hilarity of
the world.
It is, indeed, a marvelous spectacle, this view for thirty or forty miles, and the simple traveler begins to
realize what American enterprise is when it lays itself out for pleasure. These miles and miles of cottages,
hotels, parks, and campmeetings are the creation of only a few years, and probably can scarcely be
Their Pilgrimage
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES 101
Page No 104
paralleled elsewhere in the world for rapidity of growth. But the strongest impression the traveler has is of the
public spirit of these summer sojourners, speculators, and religious enthusiasts. No man lives to himself
alone, or builds his cottage for his selfish gratification. He makes fantastic carpentry, and paints and decorates
and illuminates and shows fireworks, for the genuine sake of display. One marvels that a person should come
here for rest and pleasure in a spirit of such devotion to the public weal, and devote himself night after night
for months to illuminating his house and lighting up his island, and tearing open the sky with rockets and
shaking the air with powder explosions, in order that the river may be continually en fete.
At halfpast eight the steamer rounded into view of the hotels and cottages at Alexandria Bay, and the
enchanting scene drew all the passengers to the deck.
The Thousand Islands Hotel, and the Crossman House, where our party found excellent accommodations,
were blazing and sparkling like the spectacular palaces in an opera scene. Rows of colored lamps were set
thickly along the shore, and disposed everywhere among the rocks on which the Crossman House stands;
lights glistened from all the islands, from a thousand row boats, and in all the windows. It was very like
Venice, seen from the lagoon, when the Italians make a galanight.
If Alexandria Bay was less enchanting as a spectacle by daylight, it was still exceedingly lovely and
picturesque; islands and bays and winding waterways could not be better combined for beauty, and the
structures that taste or ambition has raised on the islands or rocky points are well enough in keeping with the
general holiday aspect. One of the prettiest of these cottages is the Bonnicastle of the late Dr. Holland, whose
spirit more or less pervades this region. It is charmingly situated on a projecting point of gray rocks veined
with color, enlivened by touches of scarlet bushes and brilliant flowers planted in little spots of soil,
contrasting with the evergreen shrubs. It commands a varied and delicious prospect, and has an air of repose
and peace.
I am sorry to say that while Forbes and Miss Lamont floated, so to speak, in all this beauty, like the
lighthearted revelers they were, King was scarcely in a mood to enjoy it. It seemed to him fictitious and a
little forced. There was no message for him at the Crossman House. His restlessness and absentmindedness
could not escape the observation of Mrs. Farquhar, and as the poor fellow sadly needed a confidante, she was
soon in possession of his story.
"I hate slang," she said, when he had painted the situation black enough to suit Mrs. Bartlett Glow even, "and
I will not give my sex away, but I know something of feminine doubtings and subterfuges, and I give you my
judgment that Irene is just fretting herself to death, and praying that you may have the spirit to ride
roughshod over her scruples. Yes, it is just as true in this prosaic time as it ever was, that women like to be
carried off by violence. In their secret hearts, whatever they may say, they like to see a knight batter down the
tower and put all the garrison except themselves to the sword. I know that I ought to be on Mrs. Glow's side.
It is the sensible side, the prudent side; but I do admire recklessness in love. Probably you'll be
uncomfortable, perhaps unhappy you are certain to be if you marry to please society and not yourself
but better a thousand times one wild rush of real passion, of self forgetting love, than an age of stupid,
conventional affection approved by your aunt. Oh, these calculating young people!" Mrs. Farquhar's voice
trembled and her eyes flashed. "I tell you, my friend, life is not worth living in a conventional stagnation.
You see in society how nature revenges itself when its instincts are repressed."
Mrs. Farquhar turned away, and King saw that her eyes were full of tears. She stood a moment looking away
over the sparkling water to the soft islands on the hazy horizon. Was she thinking of her own marriage?
Death had years ago dissolved it, and were these tears, not those of mourning, but for the great experience
possible in life, so seldom realized, missed forever? Before King could frame, in the tumult of his own
thoughts, any reply, she turned towards him again, with her usual smile, half of badinage and half of
tenderness, and said:
Their Pilgrimage
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES 102
Page No 105
"Come, this is enough of tragedy for one day; let us go on the Island Wanderer, with the other excursionists,
among the isles of the blest."
The little steamer had already its load, and presently was under way, puffing and coughing, on its usual
afternoon trip among the islands. The passengers were silent, and appeared to take the matter seriously a
sort of linenduster congregation, of the class who figure in the homely dialect poems of the Northern bards,
Mrs. Farquhar said. They were chiefly interested in knowing the names of the successful people who had
built these fantastic dwellings, and who lived on illuminations. Their curiosity was easily gratified, for in
most cases the owners had painted their names, and sometimes their places of residence, in staring white
letters on conspicuous rocks. There was also exhibited, for the benefit of invalids, by means of the same
white paint, here and there the name of a medicine that is a household word in this patentright generation.
So the little steamer sailed, comforted by these remedies, through the strait of Safe Nervine, round the bluff
of Safe Tonic, into the open bay of Safe Liver Cure. It was a healing voyage, and one in which enterprise was
so allied with beauty that no utilitarian philosopher could raise a question as to the market value of the latter.
The voyage continued as far as Gananoque, in Canada, where the passengers went ashore, and wandered
about in a disconsolate way to see nothing. King said, however, that he was more interested in the place than
in any other he had seen, because there was nothing interesting in it; it was absolutely without character, or a
single peculiarity either of Canada or of the United States. Indeed, this north shore seemed to all the party
rather bleak even in summertime, and the quality of the sunshine thin.
It was, of course, a delightful sail, abounding in charming views, up "lost channels," through vistas of
gleaming water overdrooped by tender foliage, and now and then great stretches of sea, and always islands,
islands.
"Too many islands too much alike," at length exclaimed Mrs. Farquhar, "and too many tasteless cottages and
temporary camping structures."
The performance is, indeed, better than the prospectus. For there are not merely the poetical Thousand
Islands; by actual count there are sixteen hundred and ninetytwo. The artist and Miss Lamont were trying to
sing a fine song they discovered in the Traveler's Guide, inspired perhaps by that sentimental ditty, "The Isles
of Greece, the Isles of Greece," beginning,
"O Thousand Isles! O Thousand Isles!"
It seemed to King that a poem might be constructed more in accordance with the facts and with the scientific
spirit of the age. Something like this:
"O Sixteen Hundred Ninetytwo Isles!
O Islands 1692!
Where the fisher spreads his wiles,
And the muskallonge goes through!
Forever the cottager gilds the same
With nightly pyrotechnic flame;
And it's O the Isles!
The 1692!"
Aside from the pyrotechnics, the chief occupations of this place are boating and fishing. Boats
aboundrowboats, sailboats, and steam launches for excursion parties. The river consequently presents
an animated appearance in the season, and the prettiest effects are produced by the white sails dipping about
among the green islands. The favorite boat is a canoe with a small sail stepped forward, which is steered
without centreboard or rudder, merely by a change of position in the boat of the man who holds the sheet.
Their Pilgrimage
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES 103
Page No 106
While the fishermen are here, it would seem that the long, snaky pickerel is the chief game pursued and
caught. But this is not the case when the fishermen return home, for then it appears that they have been
dealing mainly with muskallonge, and with bass by the way. No other part of the country originates so many
excellent fish stories as the Sixteen Hundred and Ninetytwo Islands, and King had heard so many of them
that he suspected there must be fish in these waters. That afternoon, when they returned from Gananoque he
accosted an old fisherman who sat in his boat at the wharf awaiting a customer.
"I suppose there is fishing here in the season?"
The man glanced up, but deigned no reply to such impertinence.
"Could you take us where we would be likely to get any muskallonge?"
"Likely?" asked the man. "What do you suppose I am here for?"
"I beg your pardon. I'm a stranger here. I'd like to try my hand at a muskallonge. About how do they run here
as to size?"
"Well," said the fisherman, relenting a little, "that depends upon who takes you out. If you want a little sport,
I can take you to it. They are running pretty well this season, or were a week ago."
"Is it too late?"
"Well, they are scarcer than they were, unless you know where to go. I call forty pounds light for a
muskallonge; fifty to seventy is about my figure. If you ain't used to this kind of fishing, and go with me,
you'd better tie yourself in the boat. They are a powerful fish. You see that little island yonder? A
muskallonge dragged me in this boat four times round that island one day, and just as I thought I was tiring
him out he jumped clean over the island, and I had to cut the line."
King thought he had heard something like this before, and he engaged the man for the next day. That evening
was the last of the grand illuminations for the season, and our party went out in the Crossman steamlaunch
to see it. Although some of the cottages were vacated, and the display was not so extensive as in August, it
was still marvelously beautiful, and the night voyage around the illuminated islands was something long to be
remembered.
There were endless devices of colored lamps and lanterns, figures of crosses, crowns, the Seal of Solomon,
and the most strange effects produced on foliage and in the water by red and green and purple fires. It was a
night of enchantment, and the hotel and its grounds on the dark background of the night were like the stately
pleasurehouse in "Kubla Khan."
But the season was drawing to an end. The hotels, which could not find room for the throngs on Saturday
night, say, were nearly empty on Monday, so easy are pleasureseekers frightened away by a touch of cold,
forgetting that in such a resort the most enjoyable part of the year comes with the mellow autumn days. That
night at ten o'clock the band was scraping away in the deserted parlor, with not another person in attendance,
without a single listener. Miss Lamont happened to peep through the windowblinds from the piazza and
discover this residuum of gayety. The band itself was half asleep, but by sheer force of habit it kept on, the
fiddlers drawing the perfunctory bows, and the melancholy clarionet men breathing their expressive sighs. It
was a dismal sight. The next morning the band had vanished.
The morning was lowering, and a steady rain soon set in for the day. No fishing, no boating; nothing but
drop, drop, and the reminiscence of past pleasure. Mist enveloped the islands and shut out the view. Even the
Their Pilgrimage
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES 104
Page No 107
spirits of Mrs. Farquhar were not proof against this, and she tried to amuse herself by reconstructing the
season out of the specimens of guests who remained, who were for the most part young ladies who had duty
written on their faces, and were addicted to spectacles.
"It could not have been," she thought, "ultrafashionable or madly gay. I think the good people come here;
those who are willing to illuminate."
"Oh, there is a fast enough life at some of the hotels in the summer," said the artist.
"Very likely. Still, if I were recruiting for schoolmarms, I should come here. I like it thoroughly, and mean to
be here earlier next year. The scenery is enchanting, and I quite enjoy being with 'Proverbial Philosophy'
people."
Late in the gloomy afternoon King went down to the office, and the clerk handed him a letter. He took it
eagerly, but his countenance fell when he saw that it bore a New York postmark, and had been forwarded
from Richfield. It was not from Irene. He put it in his pocket and went moodily to his room. He was in no
mood to read a homily from his uncle.
Ten minutes after, he burst into Forbes's room with the open letter in his hand.
"See here, old fellow, I'm off to the Profile House. Can you get ready?"
"Get ready? Why, you can't go anywhere tonight."
"Yes I can. The proprietor says he will send us across to Redwood to catch the night train for Ogdensburg."
"But how about the Lachine Rapids? You have been talking about those rapids for two months. I thought that
was what we came here for."
"Do you want to run right into the smallpox at Montreal?"
"Oh, I don't mind. I never take anything of that sort."
"But don't you see that it isn't safe for the Lamonts and Mrs. Farquhar to go there?"
"I suppose not; I never thought of that. You have dragged me all over the continent, and I didn't suppose there
was any way of escaping the rapids. But what is the row now? Has Irene telegraphed you that she has got
over her chill?"
"Read that letter."
Forbes took the sheet and read:
"NEW YORK, September 2, 1885.
"MY DEAR STANHOPE,We came back to town yesterday, and I find a considerable arrears of business
demanding my attention. A suit has been brought against the Lavalle Iron Company, of which I have been the
attorney for some years, for the possession of an important part of its territory, and I must send somebody to
Georgia before the end of this month to look up witnesses and get ready for the defense. If you are through
your junketing by that time, it will be an admirable opportunity for you to learn the practical details of the
business . . . . Perhaps it may quicken your ardor in the matter if I communicate to you another fact. Penelope
Their Pilgrimage
XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES 105
Page No 108
wrote me from Richfield, in a sort of panic, that she feared you had compromised your whole future by a rash
engagement with a young lady from Cyrusville, Ohioa Miss Bensonand she asked me to use my
influence with you. I replied to her that I thought that, in the language of the street, you had compromised
your future, if that were true, for about a hundred cents on the dollar. I have had business relations with Mr.
Benson for twenty years. He is the principal owner in the Lavalle Iron Mine, and he is one of the most
sensible, sound, and upright men of my acquaintance. He comes of a good old New England stock, and if his
daughter has the qualities of her father and I hear that she has been exceedingly well educated besides she is
not a bad match even for a Knickerbocker.
"Hoping that you will be able to report at the office before the end of the month,
I am affectionately yours,
"SCHUYLER BREVOORT."
"Well, that's all right," said the artist, after a pause. "I suppose the world might go on if you spend another
night in this hotel. But if you must go, I'll bring on the women and the baggage when navigation opens in the
morning."
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX
The White Mountains are as high as ever, as fine in sharp outline against the sky, as savage, as tawny; no
other mountains m the world of their height so well keep, on acquaintance, the respect of mankind. There is a
quality of refinement in their granite robustness; their desolate, bare heights and skyscraping ridges are rosy
in the dawn and violet at sunset, and their profound green gulfs are still mysterious. Powerful as man is, and
pushing, he cannot wholly vulgarize them. He can reduce the valleys and the show "freaks" of nature to his
own moral level, but the vast bulks and the summits remain for the most part haughty and pure.
Yet undeniably something of the romance of adventure in a visit to the White Hills is wanting, now that the
railways penetrate every valley, and all the physical obstacles of the journey are removed. One can never
again feel the thrill that he experienced when, after a weary allday jolting in the stagecoach, or plodding
hour after hour on foot, he suddenly came in view of a majestic granite peak. Never again by the new rail can
he have the sensation that he enjoyed in the ascent of Mount Washington by the old bridlepath from
Crawford's, when, climbing out of the woods and advancing upon that marvelous backbone of rock, the
whole world opened upon his awed vision, and the pyramid of the summit stood up in majesty against the
sky. Nothing, indeed, is valuable that is easily obtained. This modern experiment of putting us through the
worldthe world of literature, experience, and travelat excursion rates is of doubtful expediency.
I cannot but think that the White Mountains are cheapened a little by the facilities of travel and the
multiplication of excellent places of entertainment. If scenery were a sentient thing, it might feel indignant at
being vulgarly stared at, overrun and trampled on, by a horde of tourists who chiefly value luxurious hotels
and easy conveyance. It would be mortified to hear the talk of the excursionists, which is more about the
quality of the tables and the beds, and the rapidity with which the "whole thing can be done," than about the
beauty and the sublimity of nature. The mountain, however, was made for man, and not man for the
mountain; and if the majority of travelers only get out of these hills what they are capable of receiving, it may
be some satisfaction to the hills that they still reserve their glories for the eyes that can appreciate them.
Perhaps nature is not sensitive about being run after for its freaks and eccentricities. If it were, we could
account for the catastrophe, a few years ago, in the Franconia Notch flume. Everybody went there to see a
bowlder which hung suspended over the stream in the narrow canon. This curiosity attracted annually
thousands of people, who apparently cared more for this toy than for anything else in the region. And one
day, as if tired of this misdirected adoration, nature organized a dam on the side of Mount Lafayette, filled it
Their Pilgrimage
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX 106
Page No 109
with water, and then suddenly let loose a flood which tore open the canon, carried the bowlder away, and
spread ruin far and wide. It said as plainly as possible, you must look at me, and not at my trivial accidents.
But man is an ingenious creature, and nature is no match for him. He now goes, in increasing number, to see
where the bowlder once hung, and spends his time in hunting for it in the acres of wreck and debris. And in
order to satisfy reasonable human curiosity, the proprietors of the flume have been obliged to select a
bowlder and label it as the one that was formerly the shrine of pilgrimage.
In his college days King had more than once tramped all over this region, knapsack on back, lodging at
chance farmhouses and secondclass hotels, living on viands that would kill any but a robust climber, and
enjoying the life with a keen zest only felt by those who are abroad at all hours, and enabled to surprise
Nature in all her varied moods. It is the chance encounters that are most satisfactory; Nature is apt to be
whimsical to him who approaches her of set purpose at fixed hours. He remembered also the jolting
stagecoaches, the scramble for places, the exhilaration of the drive, the excitement of the arrival at the
hotels, the sociability engendered by this juxtaposition and jostle of travel. It was therefore with a sense of
personal injury that, when he reached Bethlehem junction, he found a railway to the Profile House, and
another to Bethlehem. In the interval of waiting for his train he visited Bethlehem Street, with its mile of
caravansaries, big boardinghouses, shops, and city veneer, and although he was delighted, as an American,
with the "improvements" and with the air of refinement, he felt that if he wanted retirement and rural life, he
might as well be with the hordes in the depths of the Adirondack wilderness. But in his impatience to reach
his destination he was not sorry to avail himself of the railway to the Profile House. And he admired the
ingenuity which had carried this road through nine miles of shabby firs and balsams, in a way absolutely
devoid of interest, in order to heighten the effect of the surprise at the end in the sudden arrival at the
Franconia Notch. From whichever way this vast white hotel establishment is approached, it is always a
surprise. Midway between Echo Lake and Profile Lake, standing in the very jaws of the Notch, overhung on
the one side by Cannon Mountain and on the other by a bold spur of Lafayette, it makes a contrast between
the elegance and order of civilization and the untouched ruggedness and sublimity of nature scarcely
anywhere else to be seen.
The hotel was still full, and when King entered the great lobby and office in the evening a very animated
scene met his eye. A big fire of logs was blazing in the ample chimneyplace; groups were seated about at
ease, chatting, reading, smoking; couples promenaded up and down; and from the distant parlor, through the
long passage, came the sound of the band. It was easy to see at a glance that the place had a distinct character,
freedom from conventionality, and an air of reposeful enjoyment. A large proportion of the assembly being
residents for the summer, there was so much of the family content that the transient tourists could little
disturb it by the introduction of their element of worry and haste.
King found here many acquaintances, for fashion follows a certain routine, and there is a hidden law by
which the White Mountains break the transition from the seacoast to Lenox. He was therefore not surprised
to be greeted by Mrs. Cortlandt, who had arrived the day before with her usual train.
"At the end of the season," she said, "and alone?"
"I expect to meet friends here."
"So did I ; but they have gone, or some of them have."
"But mine are coming tomorrow. Who has gone?"
"Mrs. Pendragon and the Bensons. But I didn't suppose I could tell you any news about the Bensons."
"I have been out of the way of the newspapers lately. Did you happen to hear where they have gone?"
Their Pilgrimage
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX 107
Page No 110
"Somewhere around the mountains. You need not look so indifferent; they are coming back here again. They
are doing what I must do; and I wish you would tell me what to see. I have studied the guidebooks till my
mind is a blank. Where shall I go?"
"That depends. If you simply want to enjoy yourselves, stay at this hotelthere is no better placesit on the
piazza, look at the mountains, and watch the world as it comes round. If you want the best panoramic view of
the mountains, the Washington and Lafayette ranges together, go up to the Waumbec House. If you are after
the best single limited view in the mountains, drive up to the top of Mount Willard, near the Crawford
Housea delightful place to stay in a region full of associations, Willey House, avalanche, and all that. If
you would like to take a walk you will remember forever, go by the carriage road from the top of Mount
Washington to the Glen House, and look into the great gulfs, and study the tawny sides of the mountains. I
don't know anything more impressive hereabouts than that. Close to, those granite ranges have the color of
the hide of the rhinoceros; when you look up to them from the Glen House, shouldering up into the sky, and
rising to the cloudclapped summit of Washington, it is like a purple highway into the infinite heaven. No,
you must not miss either Crawford's or the Glen House; and as to Mount Washington, that is a duty."
"You might personally conduct us and expound by the way."
King said he would like nothing better. Inquiry failed to give him any more information of the whereabouts
of the Bensons; but the clerk said they were certain to return to the Profile House. The next day the party
which had been left behind at Alexandria Bay appeared, in high spirits, and ready for any adventure. Mrs.
Farquhar declared at once that she had no scruples about going up Washington, commonplace as the trip was,
for her sympathies were now all with the common people. Of course Mount Washington was of no special
importance, now that the Black Mountains were in the Union, but she hadn't a bit of prejudice.
King praised her courage and her patriotism. But perhaps she did not know how much she risked. He had
been talking with some habitue's of the Profile, who had been coming here for years, and had just now for the
first time been up Mount Washington, and they said that while the trip was pleasant enough, it did not pay for
the exertion. Perhaps Mrs. Farquhar did not know that mountainclimbing was disapproved of here as
seabathing was at Newport. It was hardly the thing one would like to do, except, of course, as a mere lark,
and, don't you know, with a party.
Mrs. Farquhar said that was just the reason she wanted to go. She was willing to make any sacrifice; she
considered herself just a missionary of provincialism up North, where people had become so cosmopolitan
that they dared not enjoy anything. She was an enemy of the Boston philosophy. What is the Boston
philosophy? Why, it is not to care about anything you do care about.
The party that was arranged for this trip included Mrs. Cortlandt and her bevy of beauty and audacity, Miss
Lamont and her uncle, Mrs. Farquhar, the artist, and the desperate pilgrim of love. Mrs. Farquhar vowed to
Forbes that she had dragged King along at the request of the proprietor of the hotel, who did not like to send a
guest away, but he couldn't have all the trees at Profile Lake disfigured with his cutting and carving. People
were running to him all the while to know what it meant with "I. B.," " I. B.," " I. B.," everywhere, like a
grove of Baal.
From the junction to Fabyan's they rode in an observation car, all open, and furnished with movable chairs,
where they sat as in a balcony. It was a picturesque load of passengers. There were the young ladies in trim
travelingsuits, in what is called compact fighting trim; ladies in mourning; ladies in winter wraps; ladies in
Scotch wraps; young men with shawlstraps and operaglasses, standing, legs astride, consulting maps and
imparting information; the usual sweet pale girl with a bundle of cattails and a decorative intention; and the
nonchalant young man in a striped English boating cap, who nevertheless spoke American when he said
anything.
Their Pilgrimage
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX 108
Page No 111
As they were swinging slowly along the engine suddenly fell into a panic, puffing and sending up shrill
shrieks of fear in rapid succession. There was a sedate cow on the track. The engine was agitated, it shrieked
more shrilly, and began backing in visible terror. Everybody jumped and stood up, and the women clung to
the men, all frightened. It was a beautiful exhibition of the sweet dependence of the sex in the hour of danger.
The cow was more terrible than a lion on the track. The passengers all trembled like the engine. In fact, the
only calm being was the cow, which, after satisfying her curiosity, walked slowly off, wondering what it was
all about.
The cogwheel railway is able to transport a large number of excursionists to the top of the mountain in the
course of the morning. The tourists usually arrive there about the time the mist has crept up from the valleys
and enveloped everything. Our party had the common experience. The Summit House, the Signal Station, the
old Tiptop House, which is lashed down with cables, and rises ten feet higher than the highest crag, were all
in the clouds. Nothing was to be seen except the dim outline of these buildings.
"I wonder," said Mrs. Farquhar, as they stumbled along over the slippery stones, "what people come here
for."
"Just what we came for," answered Forbes to say they have been on top of the mountain."
They took refuge in the hotel, but that also was invaded by the damp, chill atmosphere, wrapped in and
pervaded by the clouds. From the windows nothing more was to be seen than is visible in a Russian steam
bath. But the tourists did not mind. They addressed themselves to the business in hand. This was registering
their names. A daily newspaper called Among the Clouds is published here, and every person who gets his
name on the register in time can see it in print before the train goes. When the train descends, every passenger
has one of these twocent certificates of his exploit. When our party entered, there was a great run on the
register, especially by women, who have a repugnance, as is well known, to seeing their names in print. In the
room was a hot stove, which was more attractive than the cold clouds, but unable to compete in interest with
the register. The artist, who seemed to be in a sardonic mood, and could get no chance to enter his name,
watched the scene, while his friends enjoyed the view of the stove. After registering, the visitors all bought
notepaper with a chromo heading, "Among the Clouds," and a natural wildflower stuck on the corner, and
then rushed to the writingroom in order to indite an epistle "from the summit." This is indispensable.
After that they were ready for the Signal Station. This is a great attraction. The sergeant in charge looked
bored to death, and in the mood to predict the worst kind of weather. He is all day beset with a crowd craning
their necks to look at him, and bothered with ten thousand questions. He told King that the tourists made his
life miserable; they were a great deal worse than the blizzards in the winter. And the government, he said,
does not take this into account in his salary.
Occasionally there was an alarm that the mist was getting thin, that the clouds were about to break, and a rush
was made outofdoors, and the tourists dispersed about on the rocks. They were all on the qui vine to see
the hotel or the boardinghouse they had left in the early morning. Excursionists continually swarmed in by
rail or by carriage road. The artist, who had one of his moods for wanting to see nature, said there were too
many women; he wanted to know why there were always so many women on excursions. "You can see
nothing but excursionists; whichever way you look, you see their backs." These backs, looming out of the
mist, or discovered in a rift, seemed to enrage him.
At length something actually happened. The curtain of cloud slowly lifted, exactly as in a theatre; for a
moment there was a magnificent view of peaks, forests, valleys, a burst of sunshine on the lost world, and
then the curtain dropped, amid a storm of "Ohs!" and "Ahs!" and intense excitement. Three or four times, as
if in response to the call of the spectators, this was repeated, the curtain lifting every time on a different
scene, and then it was all over, and the heavy mist shut down on the registered and the unregistered alike. But
Their Pilgrimage
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX 109
Page No 112
everybody declared that they preferred it this way; it was so much better to have these wonderful glimpses
than a full view. They would go down and brag over their goodfortune.
The excursionists byandby went away out of the clouds, gliding breathlessly down the rails. When snow
covers this track, descent is sometimes made on a toboggan, but it is such a dangerous venture that all except
the operatives are now forbidden to try it. The velocity attained of three and a half miles in three minutes may
seem nothing to a locomotive engineer who is making up time; it might seem slow to a lover whose
sweetheart was at the foot of the slide; to ordinary mortals a mile a minute is quite enough on such an incline.
Our party, who would have been much surprised if any one had called them an excursion, went away on foot
down the carriage road to the Glen House. A descent of a few rods took them into the world of light and sun,
and they were soon beyond the little piles of stones which mark the spots where tourists have sunk down
bewildered in the mist and died of exhaustion and cold. These little mounds help to give Mount Washington
its savage and implacable character. It is not subdued by all the roads and rails and scientific forces. For days
it may lie basking and smiling in the sun, but at any hour it is liable to become inhospitable and pitiless, and
for a good part of the year the summit is the area of elemental passion.
How delightful it was to saunter down the winding road into a region of peace and calm; to see from the safe
highway the great giants in all their majesty; to come to vegetation, to the company of familiar trees, and the
haunts of men! As they reached the Glen House all the line of rugged mountainpeaks was violet in the
reflected rays. There were people on the porch who were looking at this spectacle. Among them the eager
eyes of King recognized Irene.
"Yes, there she is," cried Mrs. Farquhar; "and thereoh, what a treacherous North is Mr. Meigs also."
It was true. There was Mr. Meigs, apparently domiciled with the Benson family. There might have been a
scene, but fortunately the porch was full of loungers looking at the sunset, and other pedestrians in couples
and groups were returning from afternoon strolls. It might be the crisis of two lives, but to the spectator
nothing more was seen than the everyday meeting of friends and acquaintances. A couple say goodnight at
the door of a drawingroom. Nothing has happenednothing except a look, nothing except the want of
pressure of the hand. The man lounges off to the smokingroom, cool and indifferent; the woman, in her
chamber, falls into a passion of tears, and at the end of a wakeful night comes into a new world, hard and cold
and uninteresting. Or the reverse happens. It is the girl who tosses the thing off with a smile, perhaps with a
sigh, as the incident of a season, while the man, wounded and bitter, loses a degree of respect for woman, and
pitches his life henceforth on a lower plane.
In the space of ten steps King passed through an age of emotions, but the strongest one steadied him. There
was a general movement, exclamations, greetings, introductions. King was detained a moment by Mr. and
Mrs. Benson; he even shook hands with Mr. Meigs, who had the tact to turn immediately from the group and
talk with somebody else; while Mrs. Farquhar and Miss Lamont and Mrs. Cortlandt precipitated themselves
upon Irene in a little tempest of cries and caresses and delightful feminine fluttering. Truth to say, Irene was
so overcome by these greetings that she had not the strength to take a step forward when King at length
approached her. She stood with one hand grasping the back of the chair. She knew that that moment would
decide her life. Nothing is more admirable in woman, nothing so shows her strength, as her ability to face in
public such a moment. It was the critical moment for Kinghow critical the instant was, luckily, he did not
then know. If there had been in his eyes any doubt, any wavering, any timidity, his cause would have been
lost. But there was not. There was infinite love and tenderness, but there was also resolution, confidence,
possession, mastery. There was that that would neither be denied nor turned aside, nor accept any subterfuge.
If King had ridden up on a fiery steed, felled Meigs with his "mailed hand," and borne away the fainting girl
on his saddle pommel, there could have been no more doubt of his resolute intention. In that look all the mists
of doubt that her judgment had raised in Irene's mind to obscure love vanished. Her heart within her gave a
Their Pilgrimage
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX 110
Page No 113
great leap of exultation that her lover was a man strong enough to compel, strong enough to defend. At that
instant she knew that she could trust him against the world. In that moment, while he still held her hand, she
experienced the greatest joy that woman ever knowsthe bliss of absolute surrender.
"I have come," he said, "in answer to your letter. And this is my answer."
She had it in his presence, and read it in his eyes. With the delicious sense thrilling her that she was no longer
her own master there came a new timidity. She had imagined that if ever she should meet Mr. King again, she
should defend her course, and perhaps appear in his eyes in a very heroic attitude. Now she only said,
falteringly, and looking down, "II hoped you would come."
That evening there was a little dinner given in a private parlor by Mr. Benson in honor of the engagement of
his daughter. It was great larks for the young ladies whom Mrs. Cortlandt was chaperoning, who behaved
with an elaboration of restraint and propriety that kept Irene in a flutter of uneasiness. Mr. Benson, in
mentioning the reason for the "little spread," told the story of Abraham Lincoln's sole response to Lord
Lyons, the bachelor minister of her majesty, when he came officially to announce the marriage of the Prince
of Wales"Lord Lyons, go thou and do likewise; " and he looked at Forbes when he told it, which made
Miss Lamont blush, and appear what the artist had described her to Kingthe sweetest thing in life. Mrs.
Benson beamed with motherly content, and was quite as tearful as ungrammatical, but her mind was practical
and forecasting. "There'll have to be," she confided to Miss Lamont, "more curtains in the parlor, and I don't
know but new paper." Mr. Meigs was not present. Mrs. Farquhar noticed this, and Mrs. Benson remembered
that he had said something about going down to North Conway, which gave King an opportunity to say to
Mrs. Farquhar that she ought not to despair, for Mr. Meigs evidently moved in a circle, and was certain to
cross her path again. "I trust so," she replied. " I've been his only friend through all this miserable business."
The dinner was not a great success. There was too much selfconsciousness all round, and nobody was witty
and brilliant.
The next morning King took Irene to the Crystal Cascade. When he used to frequent this pretty spot as a
college boy, it had seemed to him the ideal place for a love scenemuch better than the steps of a hotel. He
said as much when they were seated at the foot of the fall. It is a charming cascade fed by the water that
comes down Tuckerman's Ravine. But more beautiful than the fall is the stream itself, foaming down through
the bowlders, or lying in deep limpid pools which reflect the sky and the forest. The water is as cold as ice
and as clear as cut glass; few mountain streams in the world, probably, are so absolutely without color. "I
followed it up once," King was saying, by way of filling in the pauses with personal revelations, "to the
source. The woods on the side are dense and impenetrable, and the only way was to keep in the stream and
climb over the bowlders. There are innumerable slides and cascades and pretty falls, and a thousand beauties
and surprises. I finally came to a marsh, a thicket of alders, and around this the mountain closed in an
amphitheatre of naked perpendicular rock a thousand feet high. I made my way along the stream through the
thicket till I came to a great bank and arch of snowit was the last of Julyfrom under which the stream
flowed. Water dripped in many little rivulets down the face of the precipicesafter a rain there are said to be
a thousand cascades there. I determined to climb to the summit, and go back by the Tiptop House. It does
not look so from a little distance, but there is a rough, zigzag sort of path on one side of the amphitheatre, and
I found this, and scrambled up. When I reached the top the sun was shining, and although there was nothing
around me but piles of granite rocks, without any sign of a path, I knew that I had my bearings so that I could
either reach the house or a path leading to it. I stretched myself out to rest a few moments, and suddenly the
scene was completely shut in by a fog. [Irene put out her hand and touched King's.] I couldn't tell where the
sun was, or in what direction the hut lay, and the danger was that I would wander off on a spur, as the lost
usually do. But I knew where the ravine was, for I was still on the edge of it."
"Why," asked Irene, trembling at the thought of that danger so long ago "why didn't you go back down the
ravine?"
Their Pilgrimage
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX 111
Page No 114
"Because," and King took up the willing little hand and pressed it to his lips, and looked steadily in her
eyes"because that is not my way. It was nothing. I made what I thought was a very safe calculation,
starting from the ravine as a base, to strike the Crawford bridlepath at least a quarter of a mile west of the
house. I hit itbut it shows how little one can tell of his course in a fog I struck it within a rod of the house!
It was lucky for me that I did not go two rods further east."
Ah me! how real and still present the peril seemed to the girl! "You will solemnly promise me, solemnly, will
you not, Stanhope, never to go there againneverwithout me?"
The promise was given. "I have a note," said King, after the promise was recorded and sealed, "to show you.
It came this morning. It is from Mrs. Bartlett Glow."
"Perhaps I'd rather not see it," said Irene, a little stiffly.
"Oh, there is a message to you. I'll read it."
It was dated at Newport.
"MY DEAR STANHOPE,The weather has changed. I hope it is more
congenial where you are. It is horrid here. I am in a bad humor,
chiefly about the cook. Don't think I'm going to inflict a letter
on you. You don't deserve it besides. But I should like to know
Miss Benson's address. We shall be at home in October, late, and I
want her to come and make me a little visit. If you happen to see
her, give her my love, and believe me your affectionate cousin,
PENELOPE."
The next day they explored the wonders of the Notch, and the next were back in the serene atmosphere of the
Profile House. How lovely it all was; how idyllic; what a bloom there was on the hills; how amiable
everybody seemed; how easy it was to be kind and considerate! King wished he could meet a beggar at every
turn. I know he made a great impression on some elderly maiden ladies at the hotel, who thought him the
most gentlemanly and good young man they had ever seen. Ah! if one could always be in love and always
young!
They went one day by invitation, Irene and Marion and King and the artistas if it made any difference
where they wentto Lonesome Lake, a private pond and fishinglodge on the mountaintop, under the
ledge of Cannon. There, set in a rim of forest and crags, lies a charming little lakewhich the mountain
holds like a mirror for the sky and the clouds and the sailing hawksfull of speckled trout, which have had
to be educated by skillful sportsmen to take the fly. From this lake one sees the whole upper range of
Lafayette, gray and purple against the sky. On the bank is a log cabin touched with color, with great
chimneys, and as luxuriously comfortable as it is picturesque.
While dinner was preparing, the whole party were on the lake in boats, equipped with fishing apparatus, and
if the trout had been in half as willing humor as the fisher, it would have been a bad day for them. But
perhaps they apprehended that it was merely a bridal party, and they were leaping all over the lake, flipping
their tails in the sun, and scorning all the visible wiles. Fish, they seemed to say, are not so easily caught as
men.
There appeared to be a good deal of excitement in the boat that carried the artist and Miss Lamont. It was
flyfishing under extreme difficulties. The artist, who kept his flies a good deal of the time out of the boat,
frankly confessed that he would prefer an honest worm and hook, or a net, or even a grapplingiron. Miss
Lamont, with a great deal of energy, kept her line whirling about, and at length, on a successful cast, landed
Their Pilgrimage
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX 112
Page No 115
the artist's hat among the waterlilies. There was nothing discouraging in this, and they both resumed
operations with cheerfulness and enthusiasm. But the result of every other cast was entanglement of each
other's lines, and King noticed that they spent most of their time together in the middle of the boat, getting out
of snarls. And at last, drifting away down to the outlet, they seemed to have given up fishing for the more
interesting occupation. The clouds drifted on; the fish leaped; the butcherbird called from the shore; the sun
was purpling Lafayette. There were kinks in the leader that would not come out, the lines were inextricably
tangled. The cook made the signals for dinner, and sent his voice echoing over the lake time and again before
these devoted anglers heard or heeded. At last they turned the prow to the landing, Forbes rowing, and
Marion dragging her hand in the water, and looking as if she had never cast a line. King was ready to pull the
boat on to the float, and Irene stood by the landing expectant. In the bottom of the boat was one poor little
trout, his tail curled up and his spots faded.
"Whose trout is that?" asked Irene.
"It belongs to both of us," said Forbes, who seemed to have some difficulty in adjusting his oars.
"But who caught it?"
"Both of us," said Marion, stepping out of the boat; "we really did." There was a heightened color in her face
and a little excitement in her manner as she put her arm round Irene's waist and they walked up to the cabin.
"Yes, it is true, but you are not to say anything about it yet, dear, for Mr. Forbes has to make his way, you
know."
When they walked down the mountain the sun was setting. Halfway down, at a sharp turn in the path, the
trees are cut away just enough to make a frame, in which Lafayette appears like an idealized picture of a
mountain. The sun was still on the heights, which were calm, strong, peaceful. They stood gazing at this
heavenly vision till the rose had deepened into violet, and then with slow steps descended through the
fragrant woods.
In October no region in the North has a monopoly of beauty, but there is a certain refinement, or it may be a
repose, in the Berkshire Hills which is in a manner typical of a distinct phase of American fashion. There is
here a note of country life, of retirement, suggestive of the old fashioned "countryseat." It is differentiated
from the caravansary or the cottage life in the great wateringplaces. Perhaps it expresses in a sincerer way
an innate love of rural existence. Perhaps it is only a whim of fashion. Whatever it may be, there is here a
moment of pause, a pensive air of the closing scene. The estates are ample, farms in fact, with a sort of villa
and park character, woods, pastures, meadows. When the leaves turn crimson and brown and yellow, and the
frequent lakes reflect the tender sky and the glory of the autumn foliage, there is much driving over the hills
from country place to country place; there are lawntennis parties on the high lawns, whence the players in
the pauses of the game can look over vast areas of lovely country; there are open air fetes, chance meetings
at the clubhouse, chats on the highway, walking excursions, leisurely dinners. In this atmosphere one is on
the lookout for an engagement, and a wedding here has a certain eclat. When one speaks of Great Barrington
or Stockbridge or Lenox in the autumn, a certain idea of social position is conveyed.
Did Their Pilgrimage end on these autumn heights? To one of them, I know, the colored landscape, the
dreamy atmosphere, the unique glory that comes in October days, were only ecstatic suggestions of the life
that opened before her. Love is victorious over any mood of nature, even when exquisite beauty is used to
heighten the pathos of decay. Irene raved about the scenery. There is no place in the world beautiful enough
to have justified her enthusiasm, and there is none ugly enough to have killed it.
I do not say that Irene's letters to Mr. King were entirely taken up with descriptions of the beauty of Lenox.
That young gentleman had gone on business to Georgia. Mr. and Mrs. Benson were in Cyrusville. Irene was
Their Pilgrimage
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX 113
Page No 116
staying with Mrs. Farquhar at the house of a friend. These letters had a great deal of Lovers' Latin in
themenough to have admitted the writer into Yale College if this were a qualification. The letters she
received were equally learned, and the fragments Mrs. Farquhar was permitted to hear were so interrupted by
these cabalistic expressions that she finally begged to be excused. She said she did not doubt that to be in
love was a liberal education, but pedantry was uninteresting. Latin might be convenient at this stage; but later
on, for little tiffs and reconciliations, French would be much more useful.
One of these letters southward described a wedding. The principals in it were unknown to King, but in the
minute detail of the letter there was a personal flavor which charmed him. He would have been still more
charmed could he have seen the girl's radiant face as she dashed it off. Mrs. Farquhar watched her with a
pensive interest awhile, went behind her chair, and, leaning over, kissed her forehead, and then with slow step
and sad eyes passed out to the piazza, and stood with her face to the valley and the purple hills. But it was a
faded landscape she saw.
Their Pilgrimage
XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX 114
Bookmarks
1. Table of Contents, page = 3
2. Their Pilgrimage, page = 4
3. Charles Dudley Warner, page = 4
4. I. FORTRESS MONROE , page = 4
5. II. CAPE MAY, ATLANTIC CITY , page = 12
6. III. THE CATSKILLS , page = 21
7. IV. NEWPORT , page = 30
8. V. NARRAGANSETT PIER AND NEWPORT AGAIN; MARTHA'S VINEYARD AND PLYMOUTH , page = 43
9. VI. MANCHESTER-BY-THE-SEA, ISLES OF SHOALS , page = 53
10. VII. BAR HARBOR , page = 58
11. VIII. NATURAL BRIDGE, WHITE SULFUR , page = 69
12. IX. OLD SWEET AND WHITE SULFUR , page = 76
13. X. LONG BRANCH, OCEAN GROVE , page = 80
14. XI. SARATOGA , page = 83
15. XII. LAKE GEORGE, AND SARATOGA AGAIN , page = 89
16. XIII. RICHFIELD SPRINGS, COOPERSTOWN , page = 92
17. XIV. NIAGARA , page = 97
18. XV. THE THOUSAND ISLES , page = 102
19. XVI. WHITE MOUNTAINS, LENNOX , page = 109