Title: Dr Thorne
Subject:
Author: Anthony Trollope
Keywords:
Creator:
PDF Version: 1.2
Page No 1
Dr Thorne
Anthony Trollope
Page No 2
Table of Contents
Dr Thorne............................................................................................................................................................1
Anthony Trollope .....................................................................................................................................1
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY.....................................................................2
CHAPTER II. LONG, LONG AGO ......................................................................................................10
CHAPTER III. DR THORNE ................................................................................................................16
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE .......................................................................23
CHAPTER V. FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH .......................................................................36
CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES .....................................................................42
CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN .......................................................................................49
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS...............................................................................56
CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD........................................................................................65
CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL .....................................................................................................72
CHAPTER XI. THE DOCTOR DRINKS HIS TEA .............................................................................79
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR................84
CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES .................................................................................................92
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE............................................................................................99
CHAPTER XV. COURCY ..................................................................................................................109
CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE...............................................................................................113
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION ....................................................................................................120
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS.......................................................................................................129
CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE OF OMNIUM.....................................................................................138
CHAPTER XX. THE PROPOSAL.....................................................................................................144
CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE..............................................................150
CHAPTER XXII. SIR ROGER IS UNSEATED................................................................................157
CHAPTER XXIII. RETROSPECTIVE ...............................................................................................162
CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD ..........................................................................................168
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES .................................................................................................175
CHAPTER XXVI. WAR .....................................................................................................................186
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT.................................................................192
CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE ....................201
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE..........................................................................................208
CHAPTER XXX. POST PRANDIAL .................................................................................................217
CHAPTER XXXI. THE SMALL EDGE OF THE WEDGE ..............................................................221
CHAPTER XXXII. MR ORIEL ..........................................................................................................227
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT.........................................................................................233
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY ..................241
CHAPTER XXXV. SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER ...............................................................252
CHAPTER XXXVI. WILL HE COME AGAIN? ...............................................................................258
CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY .....................................................263
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE.......................270
CHAPTER XXXIX. WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD..............................................278
CHAPTER XL. THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS ........................................................284
CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE ............................................................290
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? ...............................................................297
CHAPTER XLIII. THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT .......................................306
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING .......................................312
CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON ............................................................................320
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL ...........................................................................327
Dr Thorne
i
Page No 3
Table of Contents
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO
THE WEDDING ..................................................................................................................................335
Dr Thorne
ii
Page No 4
Dr Thorne
Anthony Trollope
I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY
II LONG, LONG AGO
III DR THORNE
IV LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE
V FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH
VI FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES
VII THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN
VIII MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS
IX SIR ROGER SCATCHERD
X SIR ROGER'S WILL
XI THE DOCTOR DRINKS HIS TEA
XII WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR
XIII THE TWO UNCLES
XIV SENTENCE OF EXILE
XV COURCY
XVI MISS DUNSTABLE
XVII THE ELECTION
XVIII THE RIVALS
XIX THE DUKE OF OMNIUM
XX THE PROPOSAL
XXI MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE
XXII SIR ROGER IS UNSEATED
XXIII RETROSPECTIVE
XXIV LOUIS SCATCHERD
XXV SIR ROGER DIES
XXVI WAR
XXVII MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT
XXVIII THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE
XXIX THE DONKEY RIDE
XXX POST PRANDIAL
XXXI THE SMALL END OF THE WEDGE
XXXII MR ORIEL
XXXIII A MORNING VISIT
XXXIV A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY
XXXV SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER
XXXVI WILL HE COME AGAIN?
XXXVII SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY
XXXVIII DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE
XXXIX WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD
XL THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS
XLI DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE
XLII WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN?
XLIII THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT
XLIV SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING
XLV LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON
XLVI OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL
Dr Thorne 1
Page No 5
XLVII HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY
Before the reader is introduced to the modest country medical practitioner who is to be the chief personage of
the following tale, it will be well that he should be made acquainted with some particulars as to the locality in
which, and the neighbours among whom, our doctor followed his profession.
There is a county in the west of England not so full of life, indeed, nor so widely spoken of as some of its
manufacturing leviathan brethren in the north, but which is, nevertheless, very dear to those who know it
well. Its green pastures, its waving wheat, its deep and shady andlet us adddirty lanes, its paths and
stiles, its tawnycoloured, wellbuilt rural churches, its avenues of beeches, and frequent Tudor mansions, its
constant county hunt, its social graces, and the general air of clanship which pervades it, has made it to its
own inhabitants a favoured land of Goshen. It is purely agricultural; agricultural in its produce, agricultural in
its poor, and agricultural in its pleasures. There are towns in it, of course; depots from whence are brought
seeds and groceries, ribbons and fireshovels; in which markets are held and county balls are carried on;
which return members to Parliament, generallyin spite of Reform Bills, past, present, and comingin
accordance with the dictates of some neighbouring land magnate; from whence emanate the country postmen,
and where is located the supply of posthorses necessary for county visitings. But these towns add nothing to
the importance of the county; dull, all but deathlike single streets. Each possesses two pumps, three hotels,
ten shops, fifteen beerhouses, a beadle, and a marketplace.
Indeed, the town population of the county reckons for nothing when the importance of the county is
discussed, with the exception, as before said, of the assize town, which is also a cathedral city. Herein a
clerical aristocracy, which is certainly not without its due weight. A resident bishop, a resident dean, an
archdeacon, three or four resident prebendaries, and all their numerous chaplains, vicars, and ecclesiastical
satellites, do make up a society sufficiently powerful to be counted as something by the county squirearchy.
In other respects the greatness of Barsetshire depends wholly on the landed powers.
Barsetshire, however, is not now so essentially one whole as it was before the Reform Bill divided it. There is
in these days an East Barsetshire, and there is a West Barsetshire; and people conversant with Barsetshire
doings declare that they can already decipher some difference of feeling, some division of interests. The
eastern moiety of the county is more purely Conservative than the western; there is, or was, a taint of Peelism
in the latter; and then, too, the residence of two such great Whig magnates as the Duke of Omnium and the
Earl De Courcy in that locality in some degree overshadows and renders less influential the gentlemen who
live near them.
It is to East Barsetshire that we are called. When the division above spoken of was first contemplated, in
those stormy days in which gallant men were still combatting reform ministers, if not with hope, still with
spirit, the battle was fought by none more bravely than by John Newbold Gresham of Greshamsbury, the
member for Barsetshire. Fate, however, and the Duke of Wellington were adverse, and in the following
Parliament John Newbold Gresham was only member for East Barsetshire.
Whether or not it was true, as stated at the time, that the aspect of the men with whom he was called on to
associate at St Stephen's broke his heart, it is not for us now to inquire. It is certainly true that he did not live
to see the first year of the reformed Parliament brought to a close. The then Mr Gresham was not an old man
at the time of his death, and his eldest son, Francie Newbold Gresham, was a very young man; but,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY 2
Page No 6
notwithstanding his youth, and notwithstanding other grounds of objection which stood in the way of such
preferment, and which, it must be explained, he was chosen in his father's place. The father's services had
been too recent, too well appreciated, too thoroughly in unison with the feelings of those around him to allow
of any other choice; and in this way young Frank Gresham found himself member for East Barsetshire,
although the very men who elected him knew that they had but slender ground for trusting him with their
suffrages.
Frank Gresham, though then only twenty four years of age, was a married man, and a father. He had already
chosen a wife, and by his choice had given much ground of distrust to the men of East Barsetshire. He had
married no other than Lady Arabella De Courcy, the sister of the great Whig earl who lived at Courcy Castle
in the west; that earl who not only had voted for the Reform Bill, but had been infamously active in bringing
over other young peers so to vote, and whose name therefore stank in the nostrils of the staunch Tory squires
of the county.
Not only had Frank Gresham so wedded, but having thus improperly and unpatriotically chosen a wife, he
had added to his sins by becoming recklessly intimate with his wife's relations. It is true that he still called
himself a Tory, belonged to the club of which his father had been one of the most honoured members, and in
the days of the great battle got his head broken in a row, on the right side; but, nevertheless, it was felt by the
good men, true and blue, of East Barsetshire, that a constant sojourner at Courcy Castle could not be regarded
as a consistent Tory. When, however, his father died, that broken head served him in good stead: his
sufferings in the cause were made the most of; these, in unison with his father's merits, turned the scale, and it
was accordingly decided, at a meeting held at the George and Dragon, at Barchester, that Frank Gresham
should fill his father's shoes.
But Frank Gresham could not fill his father's shoes; they were too big for him. He did become member for
East Barsetshire, but he was such a memberso lukewarm, so indifferent, so prone to associate with the
enemies of the good cause, so little willing to fight the good fight, that he soon disgusted those who most
dearly loved the memory of the old squire.
De Courcy Castle in those days had great allurements for a young man, and all those allurements were made
the most of to win over young Gresham. His wife, who was a year or two older than himself, was a
fashionable woman, with thorough Whig tastes and aspirations, such as became the daughter of a great Whig
earl; she cared for politics, or thought that she cared for them, more than her husband did; for a month or two
previous to her engagement she had been attached to the Court, and had been made to believe that much of
the policy of England's rulers depended on the political intrigues of England's women. She was one who
would fain be doing something if she only knew how, and the first important attempt she made was to turn
her respectable young Tory husband into a secondrate Whig bantling. As this lady's character will, it is
hoped, show itself in the following pages, we need not now describe it more closely.
It is not a bad thing to be soninlaw to a potent earl, member of Parliament for a county, and a possessor of
a fine old English seat, and a fine old English fortune. As a very young man, Frank Gresham found the life to
which he was thus introduced agreeable enough. He consoled himself as best he might for the blue looks with
which he was greeted by his own party, and took his revenge by consorting more thoroughly than ever with
his political adversaries. Foolishly, like a foolish moth, he flew to the bright light, and, like the moths, of
course he burnt his wings. Early in 1833 he had become a member of Parliament, and in the autumn of 1834
the dissolution came. Young members of three had fourandtwenty do not think much of dissolutions,
forget the fancies of their constituents, and are too proud of the present to calculate much as to the future. So
it was with Mr Gresham. His father had been member for Barsetshire all his life, and he looked forward to
similar prosperity as though it was part of his inheritance; but he failed to take any of the steps which had
secured his father's seat.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY 3
Page No 7
In the autumn of 1834 the dissolution came, and Frank Gresham, with his honourable lady wife and all the De
Courcys at his back, found that he had mortally offended the county.
To his great disgust another candidate was brought forward as a fellow to his late colleague, and though he
manfully fought the battle, and spent ten thousand pounds in the contest, he could not recover his position. A
high Tory, with a great Whig interest to back him, is never a popular person in England. No one can trust
him, though there may be those who are willing to place him, untrusted, in high positions. Such was the case
with Mr Gresham. There were many who were willing, for family considerations, to keep him in Parliament;
but no one thought that he was fit to be there. The consequences were, that a bitter and expensive contest
ensued. Frank Gresham, when twitted with being a Whig, foreswore the De Courcy family; and then, when
ridiculed as having been thrown over by the Tories, foreswore his father's old friends. So between the two
stools he fell to the ground, and, as a politician, he never again rose to his feet.
He never again rose to his feet; but twice again he made violent efforts to do so. Elections in East Barsetshire,
from various causes, came quick upon each other in those days, and before he was eightandtwenty years of
age Mr Gresham had three times contested the county and been three times beaten. To speak the truth of him,
his own spirit would have been satisfied with the loss of the first ten thousand pounds; but Lady Arabella was
made of higher mettle. She had married a man with a fine place and a fine fortune; but she had nevertheless
married a commoner and had in so far derogated from her high birth. She felt that her husband should be by
rights a member of the House of Lords; but, if not, that it was at least essential that he should have a seat in
the lower chamber. She would be degrees sink into nothing if she allowed herself to sit down, the mere wife
of a county squire.
Thus instigated, Mr Gresham repeated the useless contest three times, and repeated it each time at a serious
cost. He lost his money, Lady Arabella lost her temper, and things at Greshamsbury went on by no means as
prosperously as they had done in the days of the old squire.
In the first twelve years of their marriage, children came fast into the nursery at Greshamsbury. The first that
was born was a boy; and in those happy halcyon days, when the old squire was still alive, great was the joy at
the birth of an heir to Greshamsbury; bonfires gleamed through the countryside, oxen were roasted whole,
and the customary paraphernalia of joy, usual to rich Britons on such occasions were gone through with
wondrous eclat. But when the tenth baby, and the ninth little girl, was brought into the world, the outward
show of joy was not so great.
Then other troubles came. Some of these little girls were sickly, some very sickly. Lady Arabella had her
faults, and they were such as were extremely detrimental to her husband's happiness and her own; but that of
being an indifferent mother was not among them. She had worried her husband daily for years because he
was not in Parliament, she had worried him because he would not furnish his house in Portman Square, she
had worried him because he objected to have more people carried every winter at Greshamsbury Park than
the house would hold; but now she changed her tune and worried him because Selina coughed, because
Helena was hectic, because poor Sophy's spine was weak, and Matilda's appetite was gone.
Worrying from such causes was pardonable it will be said. So it was; but the manner was hardly pardonable.
Selina's cough was certainly not fairly attributable to the oldfashioned furniture in Portman Square; nor
would Sophy's spine have been materially benefited by her father having a seat in Parliament; and yet, to
have heard Lady Arabella discussing those matters in family conclave, one would have thought that she
would have expected such results.
As it was, her poor weak darlings were carried about from London to Brighton, from Brighton to some
German baths, from the German baths back to Torquay, and thenceas regarded the four we have
namedto that bourne from whence no further journey could be made under Lady Arabella's directions.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY 4
Page No 8
The one son and heir to Greshamsbury was named as his father, Francis Newbold Gresham. He would have
been the hero of our tale had not that place been preoccupied by the village doctor. As it is, those who
please may regard him. It is he who is to be our favourite young man, to do the love scenes, to have his trials
and his difficulties, and to win through them or not, as the case may be. I am too old now to be a
hardhearted author, and so it is probable that he may not die of a broken heart. Those who don't approve of a
middleaged bachelor country doctor as a hero, may take the heir to Greshamsbury in his stead, and call the
book, if it so please them, 'The Loves and Adventures of Francis Newbold Gresham the Younger.'
And Master Frank Gresham was not ill adapted for playing the part of a hero of this sort. He did not share his
sisters' illhealth, and though the only boy of the family, he excelled all his sisters in personal appearance.
The Greshams from time immemorial had been handsome. They were broad browed, blueeyed, fair haired,
born with dimples in their chins, and that pleasant, aristocratic dangerous curl of the upper lip which can
equally express good humour or scorn. Young Frank was every inch a Gresham, and was the darling of his
father's heart.
The De Courcys had never been plain. There was too much hauteur, too much pride, we may perhaps even
fairly say, too much nobility in their gait and manners, and even in their faces, to allow of their being
considered plain; but they were not a race nurtured by Venus or Apollo. They were tall and thin, with high
cheekbones, high foreheads, and large, dignified, cold eyes. The De Courcy girls all had good hair; and, as
they also possessed easy manners and powers of talking, they managed to pass in the world for beauties till
they were absorbed in the matrimonial market, and the world at large cared no longer whether they were
beauties or not. The Misses Gresham were made in the De Courcy mould, and were not on this account the
less dear to their mother.
The two eldest, Augusta and Beatrice, lived, and were apparently likely to live. The four next faded and died
one after anotherall in the same sad yearand were laid in the neat, new cemetery at Torquay. Then came
a pair, born at one birth, weak, delicate, frail little flowers, with dark hair and dark eyes, and thin, long, pale
faces, with long, bony hands, and long bony feet, whom men looked on as fated to follow their sisters with
quick steps. Hitherto, however, they had not followed them, nor had they suffered as their sisters had
suffered; and some people at Greshamsbury attributed this to the fact that a change had been made in the
family medical practitioner.
Then came the youngest of the flock, she whose birth we have said was not heralded with loud joy; for when
she came into the world, four others with pale temples, wan, worn cheeks, and skeleton, white arms, were
awaiting permission to leave it.
Such was the family when, in the year 1854, the eldest son came of age. He had been educated at Harrow,
and was now still at Cambridge; but, of course, on such a day as this he was at home. That coming of age
must be a delightful time to a young man born to inherit broad acres and wide wealth. Those fullmouthed
congratulations; those warm prayers with which his manhood is welcomed by the greyhaired seniors of the
county; the affectionate, all but motherly caresses of neighbouring mothers who have seen him grow up from
his cradle, of mothers who have daughters, perhaps, fair enough, and good enough, and sweet enough even
for him; the softspoken, halfbashful, but tender greetings of the girls, who now, perhaps for the first time,
call him by his stern family name, instructed by instinct rather than precept that the time has come when the
familiar Charles or familiar John must by them be laid aside; the 'lucky dogs', and hints of silver spoons
which are poured into his ears as each young compeer slaps his back and bids him live a thousand years and
then never die; the shouting of the tenantry, the good wishes of the old farmers who come up to wring his
hand, the kisses which he gets from the farmers' wives, and the kisses which he gives to the farmers'
daughters; all these things must make the twentyfirst birthday pleasant enough to a young heir. To a youth,
however, who feels that he is now liable to arrest, and that he inherits no other privilege, the pleasure may
very possibly not be quite so keen.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY 5
Page No 9
The case with young Frank Gresham may be supposed to much nearer the former than the latter; but yet the
ceremony of his coming of age was by no means like that which fate had accorded to his father. Mr Gresham
was not an embarrassed man, and though the world did not know it, or, at any rate, did not know that he was
deeply embarrassed, he had not the heart to throw open his mansion and receive the county with a free hand
as though all things were going well for him.
Nothing was going well with him. Lady Arabella would allow nothing near him or around him to be well.
Everything with him was now turned to vexation; he was no longer a joyous, happy man, and the people of
East Barsetshire did not look for gala doings on a grand scale when young Gresham came of age.
Gala doings, to a certain extent, there were there. It was in July, and tables were spread under the oaks for the
tenants. Tables were spread, and meat and beer, and wine were there, and Frank, as he walked round and
shook his guests by the hand, expressed a hope that their relations with each other might be long, close, and
mutually advantageous.
We must say a few words now about the place itself. Greshamsbury Park was a fine old Englishman's
seatwas and is; but we can assert it more easily in past tense, as we are speaking of it with reference to a
past time. We have spoken of Greshamsbury Park; there was a park so called, but the mansion itself was
generally known as Greshamsbury House, and did not stand in the park. We may perhaps best describe it by
saying that the village of Greshamsbury consisted of one long, straggling street, a mile in length, which in the
centre turned sharp round, so that one half of the street lay directly at right angles to the other. In this angle
stood Greshamsbury House, and the gardens and grounds around it filled up the space so made. There was an
entrance with large gates at each end of the village, and each gate was guarded by the effigies of two huge
pagans with clubs, such being the crest borne by the family; from each entrance a broad road, quite straight,
running through a majestic avenue of limes, led up to the house. This was built in the richest, perhaps we
should rather say in the purest, style of Tudor architecture; so much so that, though Greshamsbury is less
complete than Longleat, less magnificent than Hatfield, it may in some sense be said to be the finest
specimen of Tudor architecture of which the country can boast.
It stands amid a multitude of trim gardens and stonebuilt terraces, divided one from another: these to our
eyes are not so attractive as that broad expanse of lawn by which our country houses are generally
surrounded; but the gardens of Greshamsbury have been celebrated for two centuries, and any Gresham who
would have altered them would have been considered to have destroyed one of the wellknown landmarks of
the family.
Greshamsbury Parkproperly so calledspread far away on the other side of the village. Opposite to the
two great gates leading up to the mansion were two smaller gates, the one opening onto the stables, kennels,
and farmyard, and the other to the deer park. This latter was the principal entrance to the demesne, and a
grand and picturesque entrance it was. the avenue of limes which on one side stretched up to the house, was
on the other extended for a quarter of a mile, and then appeared to be terminated only by an abrupt rise in the
ground. At the entrance there were four savages and four clubs, two to each portal, and what with the massive
iron gates, surmounted by a stone wall, on which stood the family arms supported by two other clubbearers,
the stonebuilt lodges, the Doric, ivycovered columns which surrounded the circle, the four grim savages,
and the extent of the space itself through which the high road ran, and which just abutted on the village, the
spot was sufficiently significant of old family greatness.
Those who examined it more closely might see that under the arms was a scroll bearing the Gresham motto,
and that the words were repeated in smaller letters under each of the savages. 'Gardez Gresham', had been
chosen in the days of mottochoosing probably by some heraldatarms as an appropriate legend for
signifying the peculiar attributes of the family. Now, however, unfortunately, men were not of one mind as to
the exact idea signified. Some declared, with much heraldic warmth, that it was an address to the savages,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY 6
Page No 10
calling on them to take care of their patron; while others, with whom I myself am inclined to agree, averred
with equal certainty that it was an advice to the people at large, especially to those inclined to rebel against
the aristocracy of the county, that the should 'beware the Gresham'. The latter signification would betoken
strengthso said the holders of the doctrine; the former weakness. Now the Greshams were ever a strong
people, and never addicted to humility.
We will not pretend to decide the question. Alas! either construction was not equally unsuited to the family
fortunes. Such changes had taken place in England since the Greshams had founded themselves that no
savage could any longer in any way protect them; they must protect themselves like common folk, or live
unprotected. Nor now was it necessary that any neighbour should shake in his shoes when the Gresham
frowned. It would have been to be wished that the present Gresham himself could have been as indifferent to
the frowns of some of his neighbours.
But the old symbols remained, and may such symbols long remain among us; they are still lovely and fit to
be loved. They tell us of the true and manly feelings of other times; and to him who can read aright, they
explain more fully, more truly than any written history can do, how Englishmen have become what they are.
England is not yet a commercial country in the sense that epithet is used for her; and let us still hope that she
will not soon become so. She might surely as well be called feudal England, or chivalrous England. If in
western civilized Europe, there does exist a nation among whom there are high signors, and with whom the
owners of the land are the true aristocracy, the aristocracy is trusted as being best and fittest to rule, that
nation is the English. Choose out the ten leading men of each great European people. Choose them in France,
in Austria, Sardinia, Prussia, Russia, Sweden, Denmark, Spain (?), and then select the ten in England whose
names are best known as those of leading statesmen; the result will show in which country there still exists
the closest attachment to, the sincerest trust in, the old feudal and now socalled landed interests.
England a commercial country! Yes; as Venice was. She may excel other nations in commerce, but yet it is
not that in which she most prides herself, in which she most excels. Merchants as such are not the first men
among us; though it perhaps be open, barely open, to a merchant to become one of them. Buying and selling
is good and necessary; it is very necessary, and may, possibly, be very good; but it cannot be the noblest work
of man; and let us hope that it may not be in your time be esteemed the noblest work of any Englishman.
Greshamsbury Park was very large; it lay on the outside of the angle formed by the village street, and
stretched away on two sides without apparent limit or boundaries visible from the village road or house.
Indeed, the ground on this side was so broken up into abrupt hills, and conicalshaped, oakcovered
excrescences, which were seen peeping up through and over each other, that the true extent of the park was
much magnified to the eye. It was very possible for a stranger to get into it and to find some difficulty in
getting out again by any of its known gates; and such was the beauty of the landscape, that a lover or scenery
would be tempted thus to lose himself.
I have said that on one side lay the kennels, and this will give me an opportunity of describing here one
especial episode, a long episode, in the life of the existing squire.
He had once represented his county in Parliament, and when he ceased to do so he still felt an ambition to be
connected in some peculiar way with that county's greatness; he still desired that a Gresham of Greshamsbury
should be something more in East Barsetshire, than Jackson of the Grange, or Baker of Mill Hill, or Bateson
of Annesgrove. They were all his friends, and very respectable country gentlemen; but Mr Gresham of
Greshamsbury should be more than this: even he had enough ambition to be aware of such a longing.
Therefore, when an opportunity occurred he took to hunting the county.
For this employment he was in every way well suited;unless it was in the matter of finance. Though he had
in his very earliest manly years given such great offence by indifference to his family politics, and had in a
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY 7
Page No 11
certain degree fostered the illfeeling by contesting the county in opposition to the wishes of his brother
squires, nevertheless, he bore a loved and popular name. Men regretted that he should not have been what
they wished him to be, that he should not have been such as was the old squire; but when they found that
such was the case, that he could not be great among them as a politician, they were still willing that he should
be great in any other way if there were county greatness for which he was suited. Now he was known as an
excellent horseman, as a thorough sportsman, as one knowing in dogs, and tenderhearted as a sucking
mother to a litter of young foxes; he had ridden in the county since he was fifteen, and had a fine voice for a
view hallo, knew every hound by name, and could wind a horn with sufficient music for all hunting purposes;
moreover, he had come to his property, as was well known through all Barsetshire, with a clear income of
fourteen thousand a year.
Thus, when some old wornout master of hounds was run to ground, about a year after Mr Gresham's last
contest for the county, it seemed to all parties to be a pleasant and rational arrangement that the hounds
should go to Greshamsbury. Pleasant, indeed, to all except the Lady Arabella; and rational, perhaps, to all
except the squire himself.
All this time he was already considerable encumbered. He had spent much more than he should have done,
and so indeed had his wife, in those two splendid years in which they had figured as great among the great
ones of the earth. Fourteen thousand a year ought to have been enough to allow a member of Parliament with
a young wife and two or three children to live in London and keep up their country family mansion; but then
the De Courcys were very great people, and Lady Arabella chose to live as she had been accustomed to do,
and as her sisterinlaw the countess lived; now Lord de Courcy had much more than fourteen thousand a
year. Then came the three elections, with their vast attendant cost, and then those costly expedients to which
gentlemen are forced to have recourse who have lived beyond their income and find it impossible to reduce
their establishments as to live much below it. Thus when the hounds came to Greshamsbury, Mr Gresham
was already a poor man.
Lady Arabella said much to oppose their coming; but Lady Arabella, though it could hardly be said of her
that she was under her husband's rule, certainly was not entitled to boast that she had made him under hers.
She then made her first grand attack as to the furniture in Portman Square; and was then for the first time
specially informed that the furniture there was not matter of much importance, as she would not in future be
required to move her family to that residence during the London seasons. The sort of conversation which
grew from such a commencement may be imagined. Had Lady Arabella worried her lord less, he might
perhaps have considered with more coolness the folly of encountering so prodigious an increase to the
expense of his establishment; had he not spent so much money in a pursuit which his wife did not enjoy, she
might perhaps have been more sparing in her rebukes as to his indifference to her London pleasures. As it
was, the hounds came to Greshamsbury, and Lady Arabella did go to London for some period in each year,
and the family expenses were by no means lessened.
The kennels, however, were now again empty. Two years previous to the time at which our story begins, the
hounds had been carried off to the seat of some richer sportsman. This was more felt by Mr Gresham than
any other misfortune which he had yet incurred. He had been master of hounds for ten years, and that work
he had at any rate done well. The popularity among his neighbours which he had lost as a politician he had
regained as a sportsman, and he would fain have remained autocratic in the hunt, had it been possible. But he
so remained much longer than he should have done, and at last they went away, not without signs and sounds
of visible joy on the part of Lady Arabella.
But we have kept the Greshamsbury tenancy waiting under the oaktrees by far too long. Yes; when young
Frank came of age there was still enough left at Greshamsbury, still means enough at the squire's disposal, to
light one bonfire, to roast, whole in its skin, one bullock. Frank's virility came on him not quite unmarked, as
that of the parson's sons might do, or the son of a neighbouring attorney. It could still be reported in the
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY 8
Page No 12
Barsetshire Conservative "Standard" that 'The beards waggled all,' at Greshamsbury, now as they had done
for many centuries on similar festivals. Yes; it was so reported. But this, like so many other such reports, had
but a shadow of truth in it. 'They poured the liquor in,' certainly, those who were there; but the beards did not
wag as they had been wont to wag in former years. Beards won't wag for the telling. The squire was at his
wits' end for money, and the tenants one and all had so heard. Rents had been raised on them; timber had
fallen fast; the lawyer on the estate was growing rich; tradesmen in Barchester, nay, in Greshamsbury itself,
were beginning to mutter; and the squire himself would not be merry. Under such circumstances the throats
of the tenantry will still swallow, but their beards will not wag.
'I minds well,' said Farmer Oaklerath to his neighbour, 'when the squire hisself comed of age. Lord love 'ee!
There was fun going that day. There was more yale dranke then than's been brewed at the big house these two
years. T'old squoire was a one'er.'
'And I minds when the squoire was borned; minds it well,' said an old farmer sitting opposite. 'Them was the
days! It an't that long age neither. Squoire a'nt come o' fifty yet; no, nor an't nigh it, though he looks it. Things
be altered at Greemsbury'such was the rural pronunciation'altered sadly, neebor Oaklerath. Well, well;
I'll soon be gone, I will, and so it an't no use talking; but arter paying one pound fifteen for them acres for
more nor fifty year, I didn't think I'd ever be axed for forty shilling.'
Such was the style of conversation which went on at the various tables. It had certainly been of a very
different tone when the squire was born, when he came of age, and when, just two years subsequently, his son
had been born. On each of these events similar rural fetes had been given, and the squire himself had on these
occasions been frequent among his guests. On the first, he had been carried round by his father, a whole train
of ladies and nurses following. On the second, he had himself mixed in all the sports, the gayest of the gay,
and each tenant had squeezed his way up to the lawn to get a sight of the Lady Arabella, who, as was already
known, was to come from Courcy Castle to Greshamsbury to be their mistress. It was little they any of them
cared now for the Lady Arabella. On the third, he himself had borne him; his child in his arms as his father
had before borne him; he was in the zenith of his pride, and though the tenantry had whispered that he was
somewhat less familiar with them than of yore, that he had put on somewhat too much of the De Courcy airs,
still he was their squire, their master, the rich man in whose hand they lay. The old squire was then gone, and
they were proud of the young member and his lady bride in spite of a little hauteur. None of them were proud
of him now.
He walked once round among the guests, and spoke a few words of welcome at each table; and as he did so
the tenants got up and bowed and wished health to the old squire, happiness to the young one, and prosperity
to Greshamsbury; but, nevertheless, it was but a tame affair.
There were also other visitors, of the gentle sort, to do honour to the occasion; but not such swarms, not such
a crowd at the mansion itself and at the houses of the neighbouring gentry as had always been collected on
these former gala doings. Indeed, the party at Greshamsbury was not a large one, and consisted chiefly of
Lady de Courcy and her suite. Lady Arabella still kept up, as far as she was able, her close connexion with
Courcy Castle. She was there as much as possible, to which Mr Gresham never objected; and she took her
daughters there whenever she could, though, as regarded the two elder girls, she was interfered with by Mr
Gresham, and not unfrequently by the girls themselves. Lady Arabella had a pride in her son, though he was
by no means her favourite child. He was, however, the heir of Greshamsbury, of which fact she was disposed
to make the most, and he was also a fine openhearted young man, who could not but be dear to any mother.
Lady Arabella did love him dearly, though she felt a sort of disappointment in regard to him, seeing that he
was not so much like a De Courcy as he should have been. She did love him dearly; and, therefore, when he
came of age she got her sisterinlaw and all the Ladies Amelia, Rosina etc. to come to Greshamsbury; and
she also, with some difficulty, persuaded the Honourable Georges and the Honourable Johns to be equally
condescending. Lord de Courcy himself was in attendance at the Courtor said that he wasand Lord
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY 9
Page No 13
Porlock, the eldest son, simply told his aunt when he was invited that he never bored himself with those sort
of things.
Then there were the Bakers, and the Batesons, and the Jacksons, who all lived near and returned home at
night; there was the Reverend Caleb Oriel, the HighChurch rector, with his beautiful sister Patience Oriel;
there was Mr Yates Umbleby, the attorney and agent; and there was Dr Thorne, and the doctor's modest,
quietlooking little niece, Miss Mary.
CHAPTER II. LONG, LONG AGO
As Dr Thorne is our heroor I should rather say my hero, a privilege of selecting for themselves in this
respect being left to all my readersand as Miss Mary Thorne is to be our heroine, a point on which no
choice whatsoever is left to any one, it is necessary that they shall be introduced and explained and described
in a proper, formal manner. I feel quite an apology is due for beginning a novel with two long dull chapters
full of description. I am perfectly aware of the danger of such a course. In so doing I sin against the golden
rule which requires us all to put our best foot foremost, the wisdom of which is fully recognized by novelists,
myself among the number. It can hardly be expected that any one will consent to go through with a fiction
that offers so little allurement in its first pages; but twist it as I will I cannot do otherwise. I find that I cannot
make poor Mr Gresham hem and haw and turn himself uneasily in his armchair in a natural manner till I
have said why he is uneasy. I cannot bring my doctor speaking his mind freely among the bigwigs till I have
explained that it is in accordance with his usual character to do so. This is unartistic on my part, and shows
want of imagination as well as want of skill. Whether or not I can atone for these faults by straightforward,
simple, plain storytellingthat, indeed, is very doubtful.
Dr Thorne belonged to a family in one sense as good, and at any rate as old, as that of Mr Gresham; and
much older, he was apt to boast, than that of the De Courcys. This trait in his character is mentioned first, as
it was the weakness for which he was most conspicuous. He was second cousin to Mr Thorne of Ullathorne, a
Barsetshire squire living in the neighbourhood of Barchester, and who boasted that his estate had remained in
his family, descending from Thorne to Thorne, longer than had been the case with any other estate or any
other family in the county.
But Dr Thorne was only a second cousin; and, therefore, though he was entitled to talk of the blood as
belonging to some extent to himself, he had no right to lay claim to any position in the county other than such
as he might win for himself if he chose to locate himself in it. This was a fact of which no one was more fully
aware than our doctor himself. His father, who had been first cousin of a former Squire Thorne, had been a
clerical dignitary in Barchester, but had been dead now many years. He had had two sons; one he had
educated as a medical man, but the other, and the younger, whom he had intended for the Bar, had not
betaken himself in any satisfactory way to any calling. This son had been first rusticated from Oxford, and
then expelled; and thence returning to Barchester, had been the cause to his father and brother of much
suffering.
Old Dr Thorne, the clergyman, died when the two brothers were yet young men, and left behind him nothing
but some household and other property of the value of about two thousand pounds, which he bequeathed to
Thomas, the elder son, much more than that having been spent in liquidating debts contracted by the younger.
Up to that time there had been close harmony between the Ullathorne family and that of the clergyman; but a
month or two before the doctor's deaththe period of which we are speaking was about twoandtwenty
years before the commencement of our storythe then Mr Thorne of Ullathorne had made it understood that
he would no longer receive at his house his cousin Henry, whom he regarded as a disgrace to the family.
Fathers are apt to be more lenient to their sons than uncles to their nephews, or cousins to each other. Dr
Thorne still hoped to reclaim his black sheep, and thought that the head of his family showed an unnecessary
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER II. LONG, LONG AGO 10
Page No 14
harshness in putting an obstacle in his way of doing so. And if the father was warm in support of his
profligate son, the young medical aspirant was warmer in support of his profligate brother. Dr Thorne, junior,
was no roue himself, but perhaps, as a young man, he had not sufficient abhorrence of his brother's vices. At
any rate, he stuck to him manfully; and when it was signified in the Close that Henry's company was not
considered desirable at Ullathorne, Dr Thomas Thorne sent word to the squire that under such circumstances
his visits there would also cease.
This was not very prudent, as the young Galen had elected to establish himself in Barchester, very mainly in
expectation for the help which his Ullathorne connexion would give him. This, however, in his anger he
failed to consider; he was never known, either in early or in middle life, to consider in his anger those points
which were probably best worth his consideration. This, perhaps, was of the less moment as his anger was of
an unenduring kind, evaporating frequently with more celerity than he could get angry words out of his
mouth. With the Ullathorne people, however, he did establish a quarrel sufficiently permanent to be of vital
injury to his medical prospects.
And then the father died, and the two brothers were left living together with very little means between them.
At this time there was living in Barchester, people of the name of Scatcherd. Of that family, as then existing,
we have only to do with two, a brother and a sister. They were in a low rank of life, the one being a
journeyman stonemason, and the other an apprentice to a strawbonnet maker; but they were, nevertheless,
in some sort remarkable people. The sister was reputed in Barchester to be a model of female beauty of the
strong and robuster cast, and had also a better reputation as being a girl of good character and honest,
womanly conduct. Both of her beauty and of her reputation her brother was exceedingly proud, and he was
the more so when he learnt that she had been asked in marriage by a decent mastertradesman in the city.
Roger Scatcherd had also a reputation, but not for beauty or propriety of conduct. He was known for the best
stonemason in the four counties, and as the man who could, on occasion, drink the most alcohol in a given
time in the same localities. As a workman, indeed, he had higher reputation even than this: he was not only a
good and very quick stonemason, but he had also a capacity for turning other men into good stonemasons:
he had a gift of knowing what a man could and should do; and, by degrees, he taught himself what five, and
ten, and twentylatterly, what a thousand and two thousand men might accomplish among them: this, also,
he did with very little aid from pen and paper, with which he was not, and never became, very conversant. He
had also other gifts and other propensities. He could talk in a manner dangerous to himself and to others; he
could persuade without knowing that he did so; and being himself an extreme demagogue, in those noisy
times just prior to the Reform Bill, he created a hubbub in Barchester of which he himself had had no
previous conception.
Henry Thorne among his other bad qualities had one which his friends regarded as worse than all the others,
and which perhaps justified the Ullathorne people in their severity. He loved to consort with low people. He
not only drank in taprooms with vulgar drinkers; so said his friends, and so said his enemies. He denied the
charge as being made in the plural number, and declared that his only low coreveller was Roger Scatcherd.
With Roger Scatcherd, at any rate, he associated, and became as democratic as Roger himself. Now the
Thornes of Ullathorne were of the very highest order of Tory excellence.
Whether or not Mary Scatcherd at once accepted the offer of the respectable tradesman, I cannot say. After
the occurrence of certain events which must here shortly be told, she declared that she had never done so. Her
brother averred that she most positively had. The respectable tradesman himself refused to speak on the
subject.
It is certain, however, that Scatcherd, who had hitherto been silent enough about his sister in those social
hours which he passed with his gentleman friend, boasted of the engagement when it was, as he said, made;
and then boasted also of the girl's beauty. Scatcherd, in spite of his occasional intemperance, looked up in the
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER II. LONG, LONG AGO 11
Page No 15
world, and the coming marriage of his sister was, he thought, suitable to his own ambition for his family.
Henry Thorne had already heard of, and already seen, Mary Scatcherd; but hitherto she had not fallen in the
way of his wickedness. Now, however, when he heard that she was to be decently married, the devil tempted
him to tempt her. It boots not to tell all the tale. It came out clearly enough when all was told, that he made
her most distinct promises of marriage; he even gave her such in writing; and having in this way obtained
from her her company during some of her little holidaysher Sundays or summer eveningshe seduced
her. Scatcherd accused him openly of having intoxicated her with drugs; and Thomas Thorne, who took up
the case, ultimately believed the charge. It became known in Barchester that she was with child, and that the
seducer was Henry Thorne.
Roger Scatcherd, when the news first reached him, filled himself with drink, and then swore that he would
kill them both. With manly wrath, however, he set forth, first against the man, and that with manly weapons.
He took nothing with him but his fists and a big stick as he went in search of Henry Thorne.
The two brothers were then lodging together at a farmhouse close abutting on the town. This was not an
eligible abode for a medical practitioner; but the young doctor had not been able to settle himself eligibly
since his father's death; and wishing to put what constraint he could upon his brother, had so located himself.
To this farmhouse came Roger Scatcherd one sultry summer evening, his anger gleaming from his
bloodshot eyes, and his rage heightened to madness by the rapid pace at which he had run from the city, and
by the ardent spirits which were fermenting within him.
At the very gate of the farmyard, standing placidly with his cigar in his mouth, he encountered Henry
Thorne. He had thought of searching for him through the whole premises, of demanding his victim with loud
exclamations, and making his way to him through all obstacles. In lieu of that, there stood the man before
him.
'Well, Roger, what's in the wind?' said Henry Thorne.
They were the last words he ever spoke. He was answered by a blow from the blackthorn. A contest ensued;
which ended in Scatcherd keeping his wordat any rate, as regarded the worst offender. How the fatal blow
on the temple was struck was never exactly determined; one medical man said it might have been done in a
fight with a heavyheaded stick; another thought that a stone had been used; a third suggested a
stonemason's hammer. It seemed, however, to be proved subsequently that no hammer was taken out, and
Scatcherd himself persisted in declaring that he had taken in his hand no weapon but the stick. Scatcherd,
however, was drunk; and even though he intended to tell the truth, may have been mistaken. There were,
however, the facts that Thorne was dead; that Scatcherd had sworn to kill him about an hour previously; and
that he had without delay accomplished the threat. He was arrested and tried with murder, all the distressing
circumstances of the case came out on the trial: he was found guilty of manslaughter, and sentenced to be
imprisoned for six months. Our readers will probably think that the punishment was too severe.
Thomas Thorne and the farmer were on the spot soon after Henry Thorne had fallen. The brother was at first
furious for vengeance against his brother's murderer; but, as the facts came out, as he learnt what had been
the provocation given, what had been the feelings of Scatcherd when he left the city, determined to punish
him who had ruined his sister, his heart was changed. Those were trying days for him. It behoved him to do
what in him lay to cover his brother's memory from the obloquy which it deserved; it behoved him also to
save, or to assist to save, from undue punishment the unfortunate man who had shed his brother's blood; and
it behoved him also, at least so he thought, to look after that poor fallen one whose misfortunes were less
merited than those either of his brother or of hers.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER II. LONG, LONG AGO 12
Page No 16
And he was not the man to get through these things lightly, or with as much ease as he perhaps might
conscientiously have done. He would pay for the defence of the prisoner; he would pay for the defence of his
brother's memory; and he would pay for the poor girl's comforts. He would do this, and he would allow no
one to help him. He stood alone in the world, and insisted on so standing. Old Mr Thorne of Ullathorne
offered again to open his arms to him; but he had conceived a foolish idea that his cousin's severity had
driven his brother on to his bad career, and he would consequently accept no kindness from Ullathorne. Miss
Thorne, the old squire's daughtera cousin considerably older than himself, to whom he had at one time
been much attachedsent him money; and he returned it to her under a blank cover. He had still enough for
those unhappy purposes which he had in hand. As to what might happen afterwards, he was then mainly
indifferent.
The affair made much noise in the county, and was inquired into closely by many of the county magistrates;
by none more closely than by John Newbold Gresham, with the energy and justice shown by Dr Thorne on
the occasion; and when the trial was over, he invited him to Greshamsbury. The visit ended in the doctor
establishing himself in the village.
We must return for a moment to Mary Scatcherd. She was saved from the necessity of encountering her
brother's wrath, for that brother was under arrest for murder before he could get at her. Her immediate lot,
however, was a cruel one. Deep as was her cause for anger against the man who had so inhumanly used her,
still it was natural that she should turn to him with love rather than with aversion. To whom else could she in
such plight look for love? When, therefore, she heard that he was slain, her heart sank within her; she turned
her face to the wall, and laid herself down to die; to die a double death, for herself and the fatherless babe that
was now quick within her.
But, in fact, life had still much to offer, both to her and her child. For her it was still destined that she should,
in a distant land, be the worthy wife of a good husband, and the happy mother of many children. For that
embryo one it was destinedbut that may not be so quickly told: to describe her destiny this volume has yet
to be written.
Even in those bitterest days God tempered the wind to the shorn lamb. Dr Thorne was by her bedside soon
after the bloody tidings had reached her, and did for her more than either her lover or her brother could have
done. When the baby was born, Scatcherd was still in prison, and had still three months' more confinement to
undergo. The story of her great wrongs and cruel usage as much talked of, and men said that one who had
been so injured should be regarded as having in nowise sinned at all.
One man, at any rate, so thought. At twilight, one evening, Thorne was surprised by a visit from a demure
Barchester hardware dealer, whom he did not remember ever to have addressed before. This was the former
lover of the poor Mary Scatcherd. He had a proposal to make and it was this:if Mary would consent to
leave the country at once, to leave it without notice from her brother, or talk or eclat on the matter, he would
sell all that he had, marry her, and emigrate. There was but one condition; she must leave her baby behind
her. The hardwareman could find it in his heart to be generous, to be generous and true to his love; but he
could not be generous enough to father the seducer's child.
'I could never abide it, sir, if I took it,' said he; 'and she,why in course she would always love it the best.'
In praising his generosity, who can mingle any censure for such manifest prudence? He would still make her
the wife of his bosom, defiled in the eyes of the world as she had been; but she must be to him the mother of
his own children, not the mother of another's child.
And now again our doctor had a hard task to win through. He saw at once that it was his duty to use his
utmost authority to induce the poor girl to accept such an offer. She liked the man; and here was opened to
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER II. LONG, LONG AGO 13
Page No 17
her a course which would have been most desirable, even before her misfortune. But it is hard to persuade a
mother to part with her first babe; harder, perhaps, when the babe had been so fathered and so born than when
the world has shone brightly on its earliest hours. She at first refused stoutly: she sent a thousand loves, a
thousand thanks, profusest acknowledgements for his generosity to the man who showed her that he loved her
so well; but Nature, she said, would not let her leave her child.
'And what will you do for her here, Mary?' said the doctor. Poor Mary replied to him with a deluge of tears.
'She is my niece,'said the doctor, taking up the tiny infant in his huge hands; 'she is already the nearest thing,
the only thing that I have in the world. I am her uncle, Mary. If you will go with this man I will be father to
her and mother to her. Of what bread I eat, she shall eat; of what cup I drink, she shall drink. See, Mary, here
is the Bible;' and he covered the book with his hand, 'Leave her to me, and by this word she shall be my
child.'
The mother consented at last; left her baby with the doctor, married, and went to America. All this was
consummated before Roger Scatcherd was liberated from jail. Some conditions the doctor made. The first
was, that Scatcherd should not know his sister's child was thus disposed of. Dr Thorne, in undertaking to
bring up the baby, did not choose to encounter any girl's relations on the other side. Relations she would
undoubtedly have had none had she been left to live or die as a workhouse bastard; but should the doctor
succeed in life, should he ultimately be able to make this girl the darling of his own house, and then the
darling of some other house, should she live and win the heart of some man whom the doctor might delight to
call his friend and nephew; then relations might spring up whose ties would not advantageous.
No man plumed himself on good blood more than Dr Thorne; no man had greater pride in his genealogical
tree, and his hundred and thirty clearly descendant from MacAdam; no man had a stronger theory as to the
advantage held by men who have grandfathers over those who have none, or have none worth talking about.
Let it not be thought that our doctor was a perfect character. No, indeed; most far from perfect. He had within
him an inner, stubborn, selfadmiring pride, which made him believe himself to be better and higher than
those around him, and this from some unknown cause which he could hardly explain to himself. He had a
pride in being a poor man of a high family; he had a pride in repudiating the very family of which he was
proud; and he had a special pride in keeping his pride silently to himself. His father had been a Thorne, his
mother a Thorold. There was no better blood to be had in England. It was in the possession of such properties
as these that he condescended to rejoice; this man, with a man's heart, a man's courage, and a man's
humanity! Other doctors round the county had ditchwater in their veins; he could boast of a pure ichor, to
which that of the great Omnium family was but a muddy puddle. It was thus that he loved to excel his brother
practitioners, he who might have indulged in the pride of excelling them both in talent and in energy! We
speak now of his early days; but even in his maturer life, the man, though mellowed, was the same.
This was the man who now promised to take to his bosom as his own child a poor bastard whose father was
already dead, and whose mother's family was such as the Scatcherds! It was necessary that the child's history
should be known to none. Except to the mother's brother it was an object of interest to no one. The mother
had for some short time been talked of; but now that the ninedays' wonder was a wonder no longer. She
went off to her faraway home; her husband's generosity was duly chronicled in the papers, and the babe was
left untalked of and unknown.
It was easy to explain to Scatcherd that the child had not lived. There was a parting interview between the
brother and sister in the jail, during which with real tears and unaffected sorrow, the mother thus accounted
for the offspring of her shame. Then she started, fortunate in her coming fortunes; and the doctor took with
him his charge to the new country in which they were both to live. There he found for her a fitting home till
she should be old enough to sit at his table and live in his bachelor house; and no one but old Mr Gresham
knew who she was, or whence she had come.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER II. LONG, LONG AGO 14
Page No 18
Then Roger Scatcherd, having completed his six months' confinement, came out of prison.
Roger Scatcherd, though his hands were now red with blood, was to be pitied. A short time before the days of
Henry Thorne's death he had married a young wife in his own class of life, and had made many resolves that
henceforward his conduct should be such as might become a married man, and might not disgrace the
respectable brotherinlaw he was about to have given him such was his condition when he first heard of his
sister's plight. As has been said, he filled himself with drink and started off on the scent of blood.
During his prison days his wife had to support herself as she might. The decent articles of furniture which
they had put together were sold; she gave up their little house, and, bowed down by misery, she also was
brought near to death. When he was liberated he at once got work; but those who have watched the lives of
such people know how hard it is for them to recover lost ground. She became a mother immediately after his
liberation, and when her child was born they were in direst want; for Scatcherd was again drinking, and his
resolves were blown to the wind.
The doctor was then living at Greshamsbury. He had gone over there before the day on which he undertook
the charge of poor Mary's baby, and soon found himself settled as the Greshamsbury doctor. This occurred
very soon after the birth of the young heir. His predecessor in this career had 'bettered' himself, or
endeavoured to do so, by seeking the practice of some large town, and Lady Arabella, at a very critical time,
was absolutely left with no other advice than that of a stranger, picked up, as she declared to Lady de Courcy,
somewhere between Barchester jail, or Barchester courthouse, she did not know which.
Of course Lady Arabella could not suckle the young heir herself. Ladies Arabella never can. They are gifted
with the powers of being mothers, but not nursingmothers. Nature gives them bosoms for show, but not for
use. So Lady Arabella had a wetnurse. At the end of six months the new doctor found Master Frank was not
doing quite so well as he should do; and after a little trouble it was discovered that the very excellent young
woman who had been sent express from Courcy Castle to Greshamsburya supply being kept up on the
lord's demesne for the family usewas fond of brandy. She was at once sent back to the castle, of course;
and, as Lady de Courcy was too much in dudgeon to send another, Dr Thorne was allowed to procure one. He
thought of the misery of Roger Scatcherd's wife, though also of her health and strength, and active habits; and
thus Mrs Scatcherd became the fostermother to young Gresham.
One other episode we must tell of past times. Previous to his father's death, Dr Thorne was in love. Nor had
he altogether sighed and pleaded in vain; though it had not quite come to that, the young lady's friends, or
even the young lady herself, had actually accepted his suit. At that time his name stood well in Barchester.
His father was a prebendary; his cousins and his best friends were the Thornes of Ullathorne, and the lady,
who shall be nameless, was not thought to be injudicious in listening to the young doctor. But when Henry
Thorne went so far astray, when the old doctor died, when the young doctor quarrelled with Ullathorne, when
the brother was killed in a disgraceful quarrel, and it turned out that the physician had nothing but his
profession and no settled locality in which to exercise it; then, indeed, the young lady's friends thought that
she was injudicious, and the young lady herself had not spirit enough, or love enough, to be disobedient. In
those stormy days of the trial she told Dr Thorne, that perhaps it would be wise that they should not see each
other any more.
Dr Thorne, so counselled, at such a moment,so informed then, when he most required comfort from his
love, at once swore loudly that he agreed with her. He rushed forth with a bursting heart, and said to himself
that the world was bad, all bad. He saw the lady no more; and, if I am rightly informed, never again made
matrimonial overtures to any one.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER II. LONG, LONG AGO 15
Page No 19
CHAPTER III. DR THORNE
And thus Dr Thorne became settled for life in the little village of Greshamsbury. As was then the wont with
many country practitioners, and as should be the wont with them all if they consulted their own dignity a little
less and the comforts of their customers somewhat more, he added the business of a dispensing apothecary to
that of a physician. In doing so, he was of course much reviled. Many people around him declared that he
could not truly be a doctor, or, at any rate, a doctor to be so called; and his brethren in the art living round
him, though they knew that his diplomas, degrees, and certificates were all en regle, rather countenanced the
report. There was much about this newcomer which did not endear him to his own profession. In the first
place he was a newcomer, and, as such, was of course to be regarded by other doctors as being de trop.
Greshamsbury was only fifteen miles from Barchester, where there was a regular depot of medical skill, and
but eight from Silverbridge, where a properly established physician had been in residence for the last forty
years. Dr Thorne's predecessor at Greshamsbury had been a humbleminded general practitioner, gifted with
a due respect for the physicians of the county; and he, though he had been allowed to physic the servants, and
sometimes the children of Greshamsbury, had never had the presumption to put himself on a par with his
betters.
Then also, Dr Thorne, though a graduated physician, though entitled beyond all dispute to call himself a
doctor, according to all the laws of the colleges, made it known to the East Barsetshire world, very soon after
he had seated himself at Greshamsbury, that his rate of pay was to be sevenandsixpence a visit within a
circuit of five miles, with a proportionally increased charge at proportionally increased distances. Now there
was something low, mean, unprofessional, and democratic in this; so, at least, said the children of
AEsculapius gathered together in conclave at Barchester. In the first place, it showed that this Thorne was
always thinking of his money, like an apothecary, as he was; whereas, it would have behoved him, as a
physician, had he had the feelings of a physician under his hat, to have regarded his own pursuits in a purely
philosophical spirit, and to have taken any gain which might have accrued as an accidental adjunct to his
station in life. A physician should take his fee without letting his left hand know what his right hand was
doing; it should be taken without a thought, without a look, without a move of the facial muscles; the true
physician should hardly be aware that the last friendly grasp of the hand had been more precious by the touch
of gold. Whereas, that fellow Thorne would lug out half a crown from his breeches pocket and give it in
change for a ten shilling piece. And then it was clear that this man had no appreciation of the dignity of a
learned profession. He might constantly be seen compounding medicines in the shop, at the left hand of his
front door; not making experiments philosophically in materials medica for the benefit of coming
ageswhich, if he did, he should have done in the seclusion of his study, far from profane eyesbut
positively putting together common powders for rural bowels, or spreading vulgar ointments for agricultural
ailments.
A man of this sort was not fit for society for Dr Fillgrave of Barchester. That must be admitted. And yet he
had been found to be fit society for the old squire of Greshamsbury, whose shoeribbons Dr Fillgrave would
not have objected to tie; so high did the old squire stand in the county just previous to his death. But the spirit
of the Lady Arabella was known by the medical profession of Barsetshire, and when that good man died it
was felt that Thorne's short tenure of Greshamsbury favour was already over. The Barsetshire regulars were,
however, doomed to disappointment. Our doctor had already contrived to endear himself to the heir; and
though there was not even much personal love between him and the Lady Arabella, he kept his place at the
great house unmoved, not only in the nursery and in the bedrooms, but also at the squire's diningtable.
Now there was in this, it must be admitted, quite enough to make him unpopular with his brethren; and this
feeling was soon shown in a marked and dignified manner. Dr Fillgrave, who had certainly the most
respectable professional connexion in the county, who had a reputation to maintain, and who was accustomed
to meet, on almost equal terms, the great medical baronets from the metropolis at the houses of the
nobilityDr Fillgrave declined to meet Dr Thorne in consultation. He exceedingly regretted, he said, most
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER III. DR THORNE 16
Page No 20
exceedingly, the necessity he felt of doing so: he had never before had to perform so painful a duty; but, as a
duty which he owed to his profession, he must perform it. With every feeling of respect of Lady ,a sick
guest at Greshamsbury,and for Mr Gresham, he must decline to attend in conjunction with Dr Thorne. If
his services could be made available under any other circumstances, he would go to Greshamsbury as fast as
posthorses could carry him.
Then, indeed, there was war in Barsetshire. If there was on Dr Thorne's cranium one bump more developed
than another, it was that of combativeness. Not that the doctor was a bully, or even pugnacious, in the usual
sense of the word; he had no disposition to provoke a fight, no propense love of quarrelling; but there was
that in him which would allow him to yield to no attack. Neither in argument nor in contest would he ever
allow himself to be wrong; never at least to anyone but himself; and on behalf of his special hobbies, he was
ready to meet the world at large.
It will therefore be understood, that when such a gauntlet was thus thrown in his very teeth by Dr Fillgrave,
he was not slow to take it up. He addressed a letter to the Barsetshire Conservative Standard, in which he
attacked Dr Fillgrave with some considerable acerbity. Dr Fillgrave responded in four lines, saying that on
mature consideration he had made up his mind not to notice any remarks that might be made on him by Dr
Thorne in the public press. The Greshamsbury doctor then wrote another letter, more witty and much more
severe than the last; and as this was copied into the Bristol, Exeter, and Gloucester papers, Dr Fillgrave found
it very difficult to maintain the magnanimity of his reticence. It is sometimes becoming enough for a
Mediterranean to wrap himself in the dignified toga of silence, and proclaim himself indifferent to public
attacks; but it is a sort of dignity which it is very difficult to maintain. As well might a man, when stung to
madness by wasps, endeavour to sit in his chair without moving a muscle, as endure with patience and
without reply the courtesies of a newspaper opponent. Dr Thorne wrote a third letter which was too much for
medical flesh and blood to bear. Dr Fillgrave answered it, not, indeed, in his own name, but in that of a
brother doctor; and then the war raged merrily. It is hardly too much to say that Dr Fillgrave never knew
another happy hour. Had he dreamed of what materials was made that young compounder of doses at
Greshamsbury he would have met him in consultation, morning, noon, and night, without objection; but
having begun the war, he was constrained to go on with it: his brethren would allow him no alternative. Thus
he was continually being brought up to the fight, as a prizefighter may be seen to be, who is carried up
round after round, without any hope on his own part, and who, in each round, drops to the ground before the
very wind of his opponent's blows.
But Dr Fillgrave, though thus weak himself, was backed in practice and in countenance by nearly all his
brethren in the county. The guinea fee, the principle of giving advice and of selling no medicine, the great
resolve to keep a distinct barrier between the physician and the apothecary, and, above all, the hatred of the
contamination of a bill, were strong in the medical mind of Barsetshire. Dr Thorne had the provincial medical
world against him, and so he appealed to the metropolis. The Lancet took the matter up in his favour, but the
Journal of Medical Science was against him; the Weekly Chirurgeon, noted for its medical democracy,
upheld him as a medical prophet, but the Scalping Knife, a monthly periodical got up in dead opposition to
the Lancet, showed him no mercy. So the war went on, and our doctor, to a certain extent, became a noted
character.
He had, moreover, other difficulties to encounter in his professional career. It was something in his favour
that he understood his business; something that he was willing to labour at it with energy; and resolved to
labour at it conscientiously. He had also other gifts, such as conversational brilliancy, and aptitude for true
good fellowship, firmness in friendship, and general honesty of disposition, which stood him in stead as he
advanced in life. But, at his first starting, much that belonged to himself personally was against him. Let him
enter what house he would, he entered it with a conviction, often expressed to himself, that he was equal as a
man to the proprietor, equal as a human being to the proprietress. To age he would allow deference, and to
special recognized talentat least so he said; to rank also, he would pay that respect which was its clear and
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER III. DR THORNE 17
Page No 21
recognized prerogative; he would let a lord walk out of a room before him if he did not happen to forget it; in
speaking to a duke he would address him as His Grace; and he would in no way assume a familiarity with
bigger men than himself, allowing to the bigger man the privilege of making the first advances. But beyond
this he would admit that no man should walk the earth with his head higher than his own.
He did not talk of these things much; he offended no rank by boasts of his own equality; he did not absolutely
tell the Earl de Courcy in words, that the privilege of dining at Courcy Castle was to him no greater than the
privilege of dining at Courcy Parsonage; but there was that in his manner that told it. The feeling in itself was
perhaps good, and was certainly much justified by the manner in which he bore himself to those below him in
rank; but there was folly in the resolution to run counter to the world's recognized rules on such matters; and
much absurdity in his mode of doing so, seeing that at heart he was a thorough Conservative. It is hardly too
much to say that he naturally hated a lord at first sight; but, nevertheless, he would have expended his means,
his blood, and spirit, in fighting for the upper house of Parliament.
Such a disposition, until it was thoroughly understood, did not tend to ingratiate him with the wives of the
country gentlemen among whom he had to look for practice. And then, also, there was not much in his
individual manner to recommend him to the favour of ladies. He was brusque, authoritative, given to
contradiction, rough though never dirty in his personal belongings, and inclined to indulge in a sort of quiet
raillery, which sometimes was not thoroughly understood. People did not always know whether he was
laughing at them or with them; and some people were, perhaps, inclined to think that a doctor should not
laugh at all when called in to act doctorially.
When he was known, indeed, when the core of the fruit had been reached, when the huge proportion of that
loving trusting heart had been learned, and understood, and appreciated, when that honesty had been
recognized, that manly, almost womanly tenderness had been felt, then, indeed, the doctor was acknowledged
to be adequate in his profession.
To trifling ailments he was too often brusque. Seeing that he accepted money for the cure of such, he should,
we may say, have cured them without an offensive manner. So far he is without defence. But to real suffering
no one found him brusque; no patient lying painfully on a bed of sickness ever thought him rough.
Another misfortune was, that he was a bachelor. Ladies think, and I, for one, think that ladies are quite right
in so thinking, that doctors should be married men. All the world feels that a man when married acquires
some of the attributes of the old womanhe becomes, to a certain extent, a motherly sort of being; he
acquires a conversance with women's ways and women's wants, and loses the wilder and offensive sparks of
his virility. It must be easier to talk to such a one about Matilda's stomach, and the growing pains in Fanny's
legs, than to a young bachelor. This impediment also stood much in Dr Thorne's way during his first years at
Greshamsbury.
But his wants were not at first great; and though his ambition was perhaps high, it was not of an impatient
nature. The world was his oyster; but, circumstanced as he was, he knew that it was not for him to open it
with his lancet all at once. He had bread to earn, which he must earn wearily; he had a character to make,
which must come slowly; it satisfied his soul, that in addition to his immortal hopes, he had a possible future
in this world to which he could look forward with clear eyes, and advance with his heart that would know no
fainting.
On his first arrival at Greshamsbury he had been put by the squire into a house, which he still occupied when
that squire's grandson came of age. There were two decent, commodious, private houses in the
villagealways excepting the rectory, which stood grandly in its own grounds, and, therefore, was
considered as ranking above the village residencesof these two Dr Thorne had the smaller. They stood
exactly at the angle before described, on the outer side of it, and at right angles to each other. They possessed
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER III. DR THORNE 18
Page No 22
good stables and ample gardens; and it may be as well to specify, that Mr Umbleby, the agent and lawyer to
the estate, occupied the larger one.
Here Dr Thorne lived for eleven or twelve years, all alone; and then for ten or eleven more with his niece,
Mary Thorne. Mary was thirteen when she came to take up permanent abode as mistress of the
establishmentor, at any rate, to act as the only mistress which the establishment possessed. This advent
greatly changed the tenor of the doctor's ways. He had been before pure bachelor; not a room in his house had
been comfortably furnished; he at first commenced in a makeshift sort of way, because he had not at his
command the means of commencing otherwise; and he had gone on in the same fashion, because the exact
time had never come at which it was imperative in him to set his house in order. He had had no fixed hour for
his meals, no fixed place for his books, no fixed wardrobe for his clothes. He had a few bottles of good wine
in his cellar, and occasionally asked a brother bachelor to take a chop with him; but beyond this he had
touched very little on the cares of housekeeping. A slopbowl full of strong tea, together with bread, and
butter, and eggs, was produced for him in the morning, and he expected that at whatever hour he might arrive
in the evening, some food should be presented to him wherewith to satisfy the cravings of nature; if, in
addition to this, he had another slopbowl of tea in the evening, he got all that he ever required, or all, at
least, that he ever demanded.
But when Mary came, or rather, when she was about to come, things were altogether changed at the doctor's.
People had hitherto wonderedand especially Mrs Umblebyhow a gentleman like Dr Thorne could
continue to live in so slovenly a manner; and how people again wondered, and again especially Mrs
Umbleby, how the doctor could possibly think it necessary to put such a lot of furniture into a house because
a little chit of a girl of twelve years was coming to live with him.
Mrs Umbleby had great scope for her wonder. The doctor made a thorough revolution in his household, and
furnished his house from the ground to the roof completely. He paintedfor the first time since the
commencement of his tenancyhe papered, he carpeted, as though a Mrs Thorne with a good fortune were
coming home tomorrow; and all for a girl of twelve years old. 'And now,' said Mrs Umbleby, to her friend
Miss Gushing, 'how did he find out what to buy?' as though the doctor had been brought up like a wild beast,
ignorant of the nature of tables and chairs, and with no more developed ideas of drawingroom drapery than
an hippopotamus.
To the utter amazement of Mrs Umbleby and Miss Gushing, the doctor did it very well. He said nothing
about it to any onehe never did say much about such thingsbut he furnished his house well and
discreetly; and when Mary Thorne came home from her school at Bath, to which she had been taken some six
years previously, she found herself called upon to be the presiding genius of a perfect paradise.
It has been said that the doctor had managed to endear himself to the new squire before the old squire's death,
and that, therefore, the change at Greshamsbury had had no professional ill effects upon him. Such was the
case at the time; but, nevertheless, all did not go smoothly in the Greshamsbury medical department. There
was six or seven years' difference in age between Mr Gresham and the doctor, and moreover, Mr Gresham
was young for his age, and the doctor old; but, nevertheless, there was a very close attachment between them
early in life. This was never thoroughly sundered, and, backed by this the doctor did maintain himself for
some years before the artillery of Lady Arabella's artillery. But drops falling, if they fall constantly, will bore
through a stone.
Dr Thorne's pretensions, mixed with his subversive professional democratic tendencies, his
sevenandsixpenny visits, added to his utter disregard of Lady Arabella's airs, were too much for her spirit.
He brought Frank through his first troubles, and that at first ingratiated her; he was equally successful with
the early dietary of Augusta and Beatrice; but, as his success was obtained in direct opposition to the Courcy
Castle nursery principles, this hardly did much in his favour. When the third daughter was born, he at once
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER III. DR THORNE 19
Page No 23
declared that she was a very weakly flower, and sternly forbade the mother to go to London. The mother,
loving her babe, obeyed; but did not the less hate the doctor for the order, which she firmly believed was
given at the instance and express dictation of Mr Gresham. Then another little girl came into the world, and
the doctor was more imperative than ever as to the nursery rules and the excellence of country air. Quarrels
were thus engendered, and Lady Arabella was taught to believe that this doctor of her husband's was after all
no Solomon. In her husband's absence she sent for Dr Fillgrave, giving very express intimation that he would
not have to wound either his eyes or dignity by encountering his enemy; and she found Dr Fillgrave a great
comfort to her.
Then Dr Thorne gave Mr Gresham to understand that, under such circumstances, he could not visit
professionally at Greshamsbury any longer. The poor squire saw there was no help for it, and though he
maintained his friendly connexion with his neighbour, the sevenandsixpenny visits were at an end. Dr
Fillgrave from Barchester, and the gentleman at Silverbridge, divided the responsibility between them, and
the nursery principles of Courcy Castle were again in vogue at Greshamsbury.
So things went on for years, and those years were years of sorrow. We must not ascribe to our doctor's
enemies the sufferings and sickness, and deaths that occurred. The four frail little ones that died would
probably have been taken had Lady Arabella been more tolerant of Dr Thorne. But the fact was, that they did
die; and that the mother's heart then got the better of the woman's pride, and Lady Arabella humbled herself
before Dr Thorne. She humbled herself, or would have done so, had the doctor permitted her. But he, with his
eyes full of tears, stopped the utterance of her apology, took her two hands in his, pressed them warmly, and
assured her that his joy in returning would be great, for the love that he bore to all that belonged to
Greshamsbury. And so the sevenandsixpenny visits were recommenced; and the great triumph of Dr
Fillgrave came to an end.
Great was the joy in the Greshamsbury nursery when the second change took place. Among the doctor's
attributes, not hitherto mentioned, was an aptitude for the society of children. He delighted to talk to children,
and to play with them. He would carry them on his back, three or four at a time, roll with them on the ground,
race with them in the garden, invent games for them, contrive amusements in circumstances which seemed
quite adverse to all manner of delight; and, above all, his physic was not nearly so nasty as that which came
from Silverbridge.
He had a great theory as to the happiness of children; and though he was not disposed altogether to throw
over the precepts of Solomonalways bargaining that he should, under no circumstances, be himself the
executionerhe argued that the principal duty which a parent owed to a child was to make him happy. Not
only was the man to be made happythe future man, if that might be possiblebut the existing boy was to
be treated with equal favour; and his happiness, so said the doctor, was of much easier attainment.
'Why struggle after future advantage at the expense of the present pain, seeing that the results were so very
doubtful?'
Many an opponent of the doctor had thought to catch him on the hip when so singular a doctrine was
broached; but they were not always successful. 'What!' said his sensible enemies, 'is Johnny not to be taught
to read because he does not like it?' 'Johnny must read by all means,' would the doctor answer; 'but is it
necessary that he should not like it? If the preceptor have it in him, may not Johnny learn not only to read, but
to like to learn to read?'
'But,' would say his enemies, 'children must be controlled.'
'And so must men also,' would say the doctor. 'I must not steal your peaches, nor make love to your wife, nor
libel your character. Much as I might wish through my natural depravity to indulge in such vices, I am
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER III. DR THORNE 20
Page No 24
debarred from them without pain, and I may almost say without unhappiness.'
And so the argument went on, neither party convincing the other. But, in the meantime, the children of the
neighbourhood became very fond of Dr Thorne.
Dr Thorne and the squire were still fast friends, but circumstances had occurred, spreading themselves now
over a period of many years, which almost made the poor squire uneasy in the doctor's company. Mr
Gresham owed a large sum of money, and he had, moreover, already sold a portion of his property.
Unfortunately it had been the pride of the Greshams that their acres had descended from one another without
an entail, so that each possessor of Greshamsbury had had the full power to dispose of the property as he
pleased. Any doubt as to its going to the male heir had never hitherto been felt. It had occasionally been
encumbered by charges for younger children; but these charges had been liquidated, and the property had
come down without any burden to the present squire. Now a portion of this land had been sold, and it had
been sold to a certain degree through the agency of Dr Thorne.
This made the squire an unhappy man. No man loved his family name and honour, his old family blazon and
standing more thoroughly than he did; he was every whit a Gresham at heart; but his spirit had been weaker
than that of his forefathers; and, in his days, for the first time, the Greshams were going to the wall! Ten years
before the beginning of our story it had been necessary to raise a large sum of money to meet and pay off
pressing liabilities, and it was found that this could be done with more material advantage by selling a portion
of the property than in any other way. A portion of it, about a third of the whole in value, was accordingly
sold.
Boxall Hill lay half between Greshamsbury and Barchester, and was known as having the best partridge
shooting in the county; as having on it also a celebrated fox cover, Boxall Gorse, held in very high repute by
Barsetshire sportsmen. There was no residence on the immediate estate, and it was altogether divided from
the remained of the Greshamsbury property. This, with many inward and outward groans, Mr Gresham
permitted to be sold.
It was sold, and sold well, by private contract to a native of Barchester, who, having risen from the world's
ranks, had made for himself great wealth. Somewhat of this man's character must hereafter be told; it will
suffice to say that he relied for advice in money matters upon Dr Thorne, and that at Dr Thorne's suggestion
he had purchased Boxall Hill, partridgeshooting and gorse cover all included. He had not only bought
Boxall Hill, but had subsequently lent the squire large sums of money on mortgage, in all which transactions
the doctor had taken part. It had therefore come to pass that Mr Gresham was not infrequently called upon to
discuss his money affairs with Dr Thorne, and occasionally to submit to lectures and advice which might
perhaps as well have been omitted.
So much for Dr Thorne. A few words must still be said about Miss Mary Thorne before we rush into our
story; the crust will then have been broken, and the pie will be open to the guests. Little Miss Mary was kept
at a farmhouse till she was six; she was then sent to school at Bath, and transplanted to the doctor's newly
furnished house, a little more than six years after that. It must not be supposed that he had lost sight of his
charge during her earlier years. He was much too well aware of the nature of the promise which he had made
to the departing mother to do that. He had constantly visited his little niece, and long before the first twelve
years of her life were over had lost consciousness of his promise, and of his duty to the mother, in the
stronger ties of downright personal love for the only creature that belonged to him.
When Mary came home the doctor was like a child in his glee. He prepared surprises for her with as much
forethought and trouble as though he were contriving mines to blow up an enemy. He took her first into the
shop, and then into the kitchen, thence to the diningrooms, after that to his and her bedrooms, and so on till
he came to the full glory of the new drawingroom, enhancing the pleasure by little jokes, and telling her that
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER III. DR THORNE 21
Page No 25
he should never dare to come into the last paradise without her permission, and not then till he had taken off
his boots. Child as she was, she understood the joke, and carried it on like a little queen; and so they soon
became the firmest of friends.
But though Mary was queen, it was still necessary that she should be educated. Those were the earlier days in
which Lady Arabella had humbled herself, and to show her humility she invited Mary to share the
musiclessons of Augusta and Beatrice at the great house. A musicmaster from Barchester came over three
times a week, and remained for three hours, and if the doctor chose to send his girl over, she could pick up
what was going on without doing any harm. So said the Lady Arabella. The doctor with many thanks and
with no hesitation, accepted the offer, merely adding, that he had perhaps better settle separately with Signor
Cantabili, the musicmaster. He was very much obliged to Lady Arabella for giving his little girl permission
to join her lessons to those of the Miss Greshams.
It need hardly be said that the Lady Arabella was on fire at once. Settle with Signor Cantabili! No, indeed;
she would do that; there must be no expense whatever incurred in such an arrangement on Miss Thorne's
account! But here, as in most things, the doctor carried his point. It being the time of the lady's humility, she
could not make as good a fight as she would otherwise have done; and thus she found, to her great disgust,
that Mary Thorne was learning music in her schoolroom on equal terms, as regarded payment, with her own
daughters. The arrangement having been made could not be broken, especially as the young lady in nowise
made herself disagreeable; and more especially as the Miss Greshams themselves were very fond of her.
And so Mary Thorne learnt music at Greshamsbury, and with her music she learnt other things also; how to
behave herself among girls of her own age; how to speak and talk as other young ladies do; how to dress
herself, and how to move and walk. All which, she being quick to learn without trouble at the great house.
Something also she learnt of French, seeing that the Greshamsbury French governess was always in the room.
And then some few years later, there came a rector, and a rector's sister; and with the latter Mary studied
German and French also. From the doctor himself she learnt much; the choice, namely, of English books for
her own reading, and habits of thought somewhat akin to his own, though modified by the feminine softness
of her individual mind.
And so Mary Thorne grew up and was educated. Of her personal appearance it certainly is my business as an
author to say something. She is my heroine, and, as such, must necessarily be very beautiful; but, in truth, her
mind and inner qualities are more clearly distinct to my brain than her outward form and features. I know that
she was far from being tall, and far from being showy; that her feet and hands were small and delicate; that
her eyes were bright when looked at, but not brilliant so as to make their brilliancy palpably visible to all
around her; her hair was dark brown, and worn very plainly brushed from her forehead; her lips were thin,
and her mouth, perhaps, in general inexpressive, but when she was eager in conversation it would show itself
to be animated with curves of wondrous energy; and, quiet as she was in manner, sober and demure as was
her usual settled appearance, she could talk, when the fit came on her, with an energy which in truth surprised
those who did not know her; aye, and sometimes those who did. Energy! nay, it was occasionally a
concentration of passion, which left her for the moment perfectly unconscious of all other cares but solicitude
for that subject which she might then be advocating.
All her friends, including the doctor, had at times been made unhappy by this vehemence of character; but yet
it was to that very vehemence that she owed it that all her friends loved her. It had once nearly banished her
in early years from the Greshamsbury schoolroom; and yet it ended in making her claim to remain there so
strong, that Lady Arabella could no longer oppose it, even when she had the wish to do so.
A new French governess had lately come to Greshamsbury, and was, or was to be, a great pet with Lady
Arabella, having all the great gifts with which a governess can be endowed, and being also a protege from the
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER III. DR THORNE 22
Page No 26
castle. The castle, in Greshamsbury parlance, always meant that of Courcy. Soon after this a valued little
locket belonging to Augusta Gresham was missing. The French governess had objected to its being worn in
the schoolroom, and it had been sent up to the bedroom by a young servantgirl, the daughter of a small
farmer on the estate. The locket was missing, and after a while, a considerable noise in the matter having
been made, was found, by the diligence of the governess, somewhere among the belongings of the English
servant. Great was the anger of Lady Arabella, loud were the protestations of the girl, mute the woe of her
father, piteous the tears of her mother, inexorable the judgment of the Greshamsbury world. But something
occurred, it matters now not what, to separate Mary Thorne in opinion from that world at large. Out she then
spoke, and to her face accused the governess of the robbery. For two days Mary was in disgrace almost as
deep as that of the farmer's daughter. But she was neither quiet or dumb in her disgrace. When Lady Arabella
would not hear her, she went to Mr Gresham. She forced her uncle to move in the matter. She gained over to
her side, one by one, the potentates of the parish, and ended by bringing Mam'selle Larron down on her knees
with a confession of the facts. From that time Mary Thorne was dear to the tenantry of Greshamsbury; and
specially dear to one small household, where a roughspoken father of a family was often heard to declare,
that for Miss Mary Thorne he'd face man or magistrate, duke or devil.
And so Mary Thorne grew up under the doctor's eye, and at the beginning of our tale she was one of the
guests assembled at Greshamsbury on the coming of age of the heir, she herself having then arrived at the
same period of her life.
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE
It was the first of July, young Frank Gresham's birthday, and the London season was not yet over;
nevertheless, Lady de Courcy had managed to get down into the country to grace the coming of age of the
heir, bringing with her all the Ladies Amelia, Rosina, Margaretta, and Alexandrina, together with such of the
Honourable Johns and Georges as could be collected for the occasion.
The Lady Arabella had contrived this year to spend ten weeks in town, which, by a little stretching, she made
to pass for the season; and had managed, moreover, at last to refurnish, not ingloriously, the Portman Square
drawingroom. She had gone up to London under the pretext, imperatively urged, of Augusta's teethyoung
ladies' teeth are not infrequently of value in this way;and having received authority for a new carpet, which
was really much wanted, had made such dexterous use of that sanction as to run up an upholsterer's bill of six
or seven hundred pounds. She had of course had her carriage and horses; the girls of course had gone out; it
had been positively necessary to have a few friends in Portman Square; and, altogether, the ten weeks had not
been unpleasant, and not inexpensive.
For a few confidential minutes before dinner, Lady de Courcy and her sisterinlaw sate together in the
latter's dressingroom, discussing the unreasonableness of the squire, who had expressed himself with more
than ordinary bitterness as to the follyhe had probably used some stronger wordof these London
proceedings.
'Heavens!,' said the countess, with much eager animation; 'what can the man expect? What does he wish you
to do?'
'He would like to sell the house in London, and bury us all here for ever. Mind, I was there only for ten
weeks.'
'Barely time for the girls to get their teeth properly looked at! But Arabella, what does he say?' Lady de
Courcy was very anxious to learn the exact truth of the matter, and ascertain, if she could, whether Mr
Gresham was really as poor as he pretended to be.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 23
Page No 27
'Why, he said yesterday that he would have no more going to town at all; that he was barely able to pay the
claims made on him, and keep up the house here, and that he would not'
'Would not what?' asked the countess.
'Why, he said that he would not utterly ruin poor Frank.'
'Ruin Frank!'
'That's what he said.'
'But, surely, Arabella, it is not so bad as that? What possible reason can there be for him to be in debt?'
'He is always talking of those elections.'
'But, my dear, Boxall Hill paid all that off. Of course Frank will not have such an income as there was when
you married into the family; we all know that. And whom will he have to thank but his father? But Boxall
Hill paid all those debts, and why should there be any difficulty now?'
'It was those nasty dogs, Rosina,' said the Lady Arabella.
'Well, I for one never approved of the hounds coming to Greshamsbury. When a man has once involved his
property he should not incur any expenses that are not absolutely necessary. That is a golden rule which Mr
Gresham ought to have remembered. Indeed, I put it to him nearly in those very words; but Mr Gresham
never did, and never will receive with common civility anything that comes from me.'
'I know, Rosina, he never did; and yet where would he have been but for the De Courcys?' So exclaimed, in
her gratitude, the Lady Arabella; to speak the truth, however, but for the De Courcys, Mr Gresham might
have been at this moment on the top of Boxall Hill, monarch of all he surveyed.
'As I was saying,' continued the countess, 'I never approved of the hounds coming to Greshamsbury; but yet,
my dear, the hounds can't have eaten up everything. A man with ten thousand a year ought to be able to keep
hounds; particularly as he had a subscription.'
'He says the subscription was little or nothing.'
'That's nonsense, my dear. Now, Arabella, what does he do with his money? That's the question. Does he
gamble?'
'Well,' said Lady Arabella, very slowly, 'I don't think he does.' If the squire did gamble he must have done it
very slyly, for he rarely went away from Greshamsbury, and certainly very few men looking like gamblers
were in the habit of coming thither as guests. 'I don't think he does gamble.' Lady Arabella put her emphasis
on the word gamble, as though her husband, if he might perhaps be charitably acquitted of that vice, was
certainly guilty of every other known in the civilized world.
'I know he used,' said Lady de Courcy, looking very wise, and rather suspicious. She certainly had sufficient
domestic reasons for disliking the propensity; 'I know he used; and when a man begins, he is hardly ever
cured.'
'Well, if he does, I don't know it,' said the Lady Arabella.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 24
Page No 28
'The money, my dear, must go somewhere. What excuse does he give when you tell him you want this and
thatall the common necessaries of life, that you have always been used to?'
'He gives no excuse; sometimes he says the family is so large.'
'Nonsense! Girls cost nothing; there's only Frank, and he can't have cost anything yet. Can he be saving
money to buy back Boxall Hill?'
'Oh no!' said the Lady Arabella, quickly. 'He is not saving anything; he never did, and never will save, though
he is so stingy to me. He is hard pushed for money, I know that.'
'Then where has it gone?' said the Countess de Courcy, with a look of stern decision.
'Heaven only knows! Now, Augusta is to be married. I must of course have a few hundred pounds. You
should have heard how he groaned when I asked him for it. Heaven only knows where the money goes!' And
the injured wife wiped a piteous tear from her eye with her fine dress cambric handkerchief. 'I have all the
sufferings and privations of a poor man's wife, but I have none of the consolations. He has no confidence in
me; he never tells me anything; he never talks to me about his affairs. If he talks to any one it is to that horrid
doctor.'
'What, Dr Thorne?' Now the Countess de Courcy hated Dr Thorne with a holy hatred.
'Yes; Dr Thorne. I believe that he knows everything; and advises everything, too. Whatever difficulties poor
Gresham may have, I do believe Dr Thorne has brought them about. I do believe it, Rosina.'
'Well, that is surprising. Mr Gresham with all his faults is a gentleman; and how he can talk about his affairs
with a low apothecary like that I, for one, cannot imagine. Lord de Courcy has not always been to me all that
he should have been; far from it.' And Lady de Courcy thought over in her mind injuries of a much graver
description than any that her sisterinlaw had ever suffered; 'but I have never known anything like that at
Courcy Castle. Surely Umbleby knows all about it, doesn't he?'
'Not half so much as the doctor,' said Lady Arabella.
The countess shook her head slowly; the idea of Mr Gresham, a country gentleman of good estate like him,
making a confidant of a country doctor was too great a shock for her nerves; and for a while she was
constrained to sit silent before she could recover herself.
'One thing at any rate is certain, Arabella,' said the countess, as soon as she found herself again sufficiently
composed to offer counsel in a properly dictatorial manner. 'One thing at any rate is certain; if Mr Gresham
be involved so deeply as you say, Frank has but only one duty before him. He must marry money. The heir of
fourteen thousand a year may indulge himself in looking for blood, as Mr Gresham did, my dear'it must be
understood that there was very little compliment in this, as the Lady Arabella had always conceived herself to
be a beauty'or for beauty, as some men do,' continued the countess, thinking of the choice that the present
Earl de Courcy had made; 'but Frank must marry money. I hope he will understand this early; do make him
understand this before he makes a fool of himself: when a man thoroughly understands this, when he knows
what his circumstances require, why, the matter becomes easy to him. I hope that Frank understands that he
has no alternative. In his position he must marry money.'
But, alas! alas! Frank Gresham had already made a fool of himself.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 25
Page No 29
'Well, my boy, I wish you joy with all my heart,' said the Honourable John, slapping his cousin on the back,
as he walked round to the stableyard with him before dinner, to inspect a setter puppy of peculiarly fine
breed which had been sent to Frank as a birthday present. 'I wish I were an elder son; but we can't all have
that luck.'
'Who wouldn't sooner be the younger son of an earl than the eldest son of a plain squire?' said Frank, wishing
to say something civil in return for his cousin's civility.
'I wouldn't for one,' said the Honourable John. 'What chance have I? There's Porlock as strong as a horse; and
then George comes next. And the governor's good for these twenty years.' And the young man sighed as he
reflected what small hope there was that all those who were nearest and dearest to him should die out of his
way, and leave him to the sweet enjoyment of an earl's coronet and fortune. 'Now, you're sure of your game
some day; and as you've no brothers, I suppose the squire'll let you do pretty well what you like. Besides, he's
not so strong as my governor, though he's younger.'
Frank had never looked at his fortune in this light before, and was so slow and green that he was not much
delighted at the prospect now that it was offered to him. He had always, however, been taught to look to his
cousins, the De Courcys, as men with whom it would be very expedient that he should be intimate; he
therefore showed no offence, but changed the conversation.
'Shall you hunt with the Barsetshire this season, John? I hope you will; I shall.'
'Well, I don't know. It's very slow. It's all tillage here, or else woodland. I rather fancy I shall go to
Leicestershire when the partridgeshooting is over. What sort of a lot do you mean to come out with, Frank?'
Frank became a little red as he answered, 'Oh, I shall have two,' he said; 'that is, the mare I have had these
two years, and the horse my father gave me this morning.'
'What! only those two? and the mare is nothing more than a pony.'
'She is fifteen hands,' said Frank, offended.
'Well, Frank, I certainly would not stand that,' said the Honourable John. 'What, go out before the county with
one untrained horse and a pony; and you the heir to Greshamsbury!'
'I'll have him trained before November,' said Frank, 'that nothing in Barsetshire will stop him. Peter
says'Peter was the Greshamsbury studgroom'that he tucks up his legs beautifully.'
'But who the deuce would think of going to work with one horse; or two either, if you insist on calling the old
pony a huntress? I'll put you up to a trick, my lad: if you stand that you'll stand anything; and if you don't
mean to go in leadingstrings all your life, now is the time to show it. There's young BakerHarry Baker,
you knowhe came of age last year, and he has as pretty a string of nags as any one would wish to set eyes
on; four hunters and a hack. Now, if old Baker has four thousand a year it's every shilling he has got.'
This was true, and Frank Gresham, who in the morning had been made so happy by his father's present of a
horse, began to feel that hardly enough had been done for him. It was true that Mr Baker had only four
thousand a year; but it was also true that he had no other child than Harry Baker; that he had no great
establishment to keep up; that he owed a shilling to no one; and, also, that he was a great fool in encouraging
a mere boy to ape all the caprices of a man of wealth. Nevertheless, for a moment, Frank Gresham did feel
that, considering his position, he was being treated rather unworthily.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 26
Page No 30
'Take the matter in your own hands, Frank,' said the Honourable John, seeing the impression that he had
made. 'Of course the governor knows very well that you won't put up with such a stable as that. Lord bless
you! I have heard that when he married my aunt, and that was when he was about your age, he had the best
stud in the whole county; and then he was in Parliament before he was threeandtwenty.'
'His father, you know, died when he was very young,' said Frank.
'Yes; I know he had a stroke of luck that doesn't fall to everyone; but'
Young Frank's face grew dark now instead of red. When his cousin submitted to him the necessity of having
more than two horses for his own use he could listen to him; but when the same monitor talked of the chance
of a father's death as a stroke of luck, Frank was too much disgusted to be able pass it over with indifference.
What! was he thus to think of his father, whose face was always lighted up with pleasure when his boy came
near to him, and so rarely bright at any other time? Frank had watched his father closely enough to be aware
of this; he knew how his father delighted in him; he had had cause to guess that his father had many troubles,
and that he strove hard to banish the memory of them when his son was with him. He loved his father truly,
purely, and thoroughly, liked to be with him, and would be proud to be his confidant. Could he listen quietly
while his cousin spoke of the chance of his father's death as a stroke of luck?
'I shouldn't think it a stroke of luck, John. I should think it the greatest misfortune in the world.'
It is so difficult for a young man to enumerate sententiously a principle of morality, or even an expression of
ordinary good feeling, without giving himself something of a ridiculous air, without assuming something of a
mock grandeur!
'Oh, of course, my dear fellow,' said the Honourable John, laughing; 'that's a matter of course. We all
understand that without saying it. Porlock, of course, would feel exactly the same about the governor; but if
the governor were to walk, I think Porlock would console himself with the thirty thousand a year.'
'I don't know what Porlock would do; he's always quarrelling with my uncle, I know. I only spoke of myself;
I never quarrelled with my father, and I hope I never shall.'
'All right, my lad of wax, all right. I dare say you won't be tried; but it you are, you'll find before six months
are over, that it's a very nice thing to master of Greshamsbury.'
'I'm sure I shouldn't find anything of the kind.'
'Very well, so be it. You wouldn't do as young Hatherly did, at Hatherly Court, in Gloucestershire, when his
father kicked the bucket. You know Hatherly, don't you?'
'No; I never saw him.'
'He's Sir Frederick now, and has, or had, one of the finest fortunes in England, for a commoner; the most of it
is gone now. Well, when he heard of his governor's death, he was in Paris, but he went off to Hatherly as fast
as special train and posthorses would carry him, and got there just in time for the funeral. As he came back
to Hatherly Court from the church, they were putting up the hatchment over the door, and Master Fred saw
that the undertakers had put at the bottom "Resurgam". You know what that means?'
'Oh, yes,' said Frank.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 27
Page No 31
'"I'll come back again."' said the Honourable John, construing the Latin for the benefit of his cousin. '"NO,"
said Fred Hatherly, looking up at the hatchment; "I'm blessed if you do, old gentleman. That would be too
much of a joke; I'll take care of that." So he got up at night, and he got some fellows with him, and they
climbed up and painted out "Resurgam", and they painted into its place, "Requiescat in pace"; which means,
you know, "you'd a great deal better stay where you are". Now I call that good. Fred Hatherly did that as sure
asas sure asas sure as anything.'
Frank could not help laughing at the story, especially at his cousin's mode of translating the undertaker's
mottoes; and then they sauntered back from the stables into the house to dress for dinner.
Dr Thorne had come to the house somewhat before dinnertime, at Mr Gresham's request, and was now
sitting with the squire in his own bookroomso calledwhile Mary was talking to some of the girls
upstairs.
'I must have ten or twelve thousand pounds; ten at the very least,' said the squire, who was sitting in his usual
armchair, close to his littered table, with his head supported on his hand, looking very unlike the father of an
heir of a noble property, who had that day come of age.
It was the first of July, and of course there was no fire in the grate; but, nevertheless, the doctor was standing
with his back to the fireplace, with his coattails over his arms, as though he were engaged, now in summer
as he so often was in winter, in talking, and roasting his hinder person at the same time.
'Twelve thousand pounds! It's a very large sum of money.'
'I said ten,' said the squire.
'Ten thousand pounds is a very large sum of money. There is no doubt he'll let you have it. Scatcherd will let
you have it; but I know he'll expect to have the title deeds.'
'What! for ten thousand pounds?' said the squire. 'There is not a registered debt against the property but his
own and Armstrong's.'
'But his own is very large already.'
'Armstrong's is nothing; about fourandtwenty thousand pounds.'
'Yes; but he comes first, Mr Gresham.'
'Well, what of that? To hear you talk, one would think that there was nothing left of Greshamsbury. What's
fourandtwenty thousand pounds? Does Scatcherd know what rentroll is?'
'Oh, yes, he knows it well enough: I wish he did not.'
'What he means is, that he must have ample security to cover what he has already advanced before he goes
on. I wish to goodness you had no further need to borrow. I did think that things were settled last year.'
'Oh if there's any difficulty, Umbleby will get it for me.'
'Yes; and what will you have to pay for it?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 28
Page No 32
'I'd sooner pay double that be talked to in this way,' said the squire, angrily, and, as he spoke, he got up
hurriedly from his chair, thrust his hands into his trouserspockets, walked quickly to the window, and
immediately walking back again, threw himself once more into his chair.
'There are some things a man cannot bear, doctor,' said he, beating the devil's tattoo on the floor with one of
his feet, 'though God knows I ought to be patient now, for I am made to bear a good many things. You had
better tell Scatcherd that I am obliged to him for his offer, but that I will not trouble him.'
The doctor during this little outburst had stood quite silent with his back to the fireplace and his coattails
hanging over his arms; but though his voice said nothing, his face said much. He was very unhappy; he was
greatly grieved to find that the squire was so soon again in want of money, and greatly grieved also to find
that this want had made him so bitter and unjust. Mr Gresham had attacked him; but as he was determined
not to quarrel with Mr Gresham, he refrained from answering.
The squire also remained silent for a few minutes; but he was not endowed with the gift of silence, and was
soon, as it were, compelled to speak agaain.
'Poor Frank!' said he. 'I could yet be easy about everything if it were not for the injury I have done him. Poor
Frank!'
The doctor advanced a few paces from off the rug, and taking his hand out of his pocket, he laid it gently on
the squire's shoulder. 'Frank will do very well yet,' said the he. 'It is not absolutely necessary that a man
should have fourteen thousand pounds a year to be happy.'
'My father left me the property entire, and I should leave it entire to my son;but you don't understand this.'
The doctor did understand the feeling fully. The fact, on the other hand, was that, long as he had known him,
the squire did not understand the doctor.
'I would you could, Mr Gresham,' said the doctor, 'so that your mind might be happier; but that cannot be,
and, therefore, I say again, that Frank will do very well yet, although he will not inherit fourteen thousand
pounds a year; and I would have you say the same thing to yourself.'
'Ah! you don't understand it,' persisted the squire. 'You don't know how a man feels when heAh, well! it's
no use my troubling you with what cannot be mended. I wonder whether Umbleby is about the place
anywhere?'
The doctor was again standing with his back against the chimneypiece, and with his hands in his pockets.
'You did not see Umbleby as you came in?' again asked the squire.
'No, I did not; and if you will take my advice you will not see him now; at any rate with reference to this
money.'
'I tell you I must get it from someone; you say Scatcherd won't let me have it.'
'No, Mr Gresham; I did not say that.'
'Well, you said what was as bad. Augusta is to be married in September, and the money must be had. I have
agreed to give Moffat six thousand pounds, and he is to have the money down in hard cash.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 29
Page No 33
'Six thousand pounds,' said the doctor. 'Well, I suppose that is not more than your daughter should have. But
then, five times six are thirty; thirty thousand pounds will be a large sum to make up.'
The father thought to himself that his younger girls were but children, and that the trouble of arranging their
marriage portions might well be postponed a while. Sufficient for the day is the evil thereof.
'That Moffat is a gripping, hungry fellow,'said the squire. 'I suppose Augusta likes him; and, as regards
money, it is a good match.'
'If Miss Gresham loves him, that is everything. I am not in love with him myself; but then, I am not a young
lady.'
'The De Courcys are very fond of him. Lady de Courcy says that he is a perfect gentleman, and thought very
much of in London.'
'Oh! if Lady de Courcy says that, of course, it's all right,' said the doctor, with a quiet sarcasm, that was
altogether thrown away on the squire.
The squire did not like any of the De Courcys; especially, he did not like Lady de Courcy; but still he was
accessible to a certain amount of gratification in the near connexion which he had with the earl and countess;
and when he wanted to support his family greatness, would sometimes weakly fall back upon the grandeur of
Courcy Castle. It was only when talking to his wife that he invariably snubbed the pretensions of his noble
relatives.
The two men after this remained silent for a while; and then the doctor, renewing the subject for which he had
been summoned into the bookroom, remarked that as Scatcherd was now in the countryhe did not say,
was now at Boxall Hill, as he did not wish to wound the squire's earsperhaps he had better go and see him,
and ascertain in what way this affair of the money might be arranged. There was no doubt, he said, that
Scatcherd would supply the sum required at a lower rate of interest than that which it could be procured
through Umbleby's means.
'Very well,' said the squire. 'I'll leave it in your hands, then. I think ten thousand pounds will do. And now I'll
dress for dinner.' And then the doctor left him.
Perhaps the reader will suppose after this that the doctor had some pecuniary interest of his own in arranging
the squire's loans; or, at any rate, he will think that the squire must have so thought. Not in the least; neither
had he any such interest, nor did the squire think that he had any. What Dr Thorne did in this matter the
squire well knew was done for love. But the squire of Greshamsbury was a great man at Greshamsbury; and
it behoved him to maintain the greatness of his squirehood when discussing his affairs with the village doctor.
So much he had at any rate learnt from his contact with the De Courcys.
And the doctorproud, arrogant, contradictory, headstrong as he waswhy did he bear to be thus snubbed?
Because he knew that the squire of Greshamsbury, when struggling with debt and poverty, required an
indulgence for his weakness. Had Mr Gresham been in easy circumstances, the doctor would by no means
have stood so placidly with his hands in his pockets, and have had Mr Umbleby thus thrown in his teeth. The
doctor loved the squire, loved him as his own oldest friend; but he loved him ten times better as being in
adversity than he could ever done had things gone well at Greshamsbury in his time.
While this was going on downstairs, Mary was sitting upstairs with Beatrice Gresham in the schoolroom. The
old schoolroom, so called, was now a sittingroom, devoted to the use of the grownup ladies of the family,
whereas one of the old nurseries was now the modern schoolroom. Mary well knew her way to the sanctum,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 30
Page No 34
and, without asking any questions, walked up to it when her uncle went to the squire. On entering the room
she found that Augusta and the Lady Alexandrina were also there, and she hesitated for a moment at the door.
'Come in, Mary,' said Beatrice, 'you know my cousin Alexandrina.' Mary came in, and having shaken hands
with her two friends, was bowing to the lady, when the lady condescended, put out her noble hand, and
touched Miss Thorne's fingers.
Beatrice was Mary's friend, and many heartburnings and much mental solicitude did that young lady give to
her mother by indulging in such a friendship. But Beatrice, with some faults, was true at heart, and she
persisted in loving Mary Thorne in spite of the hints which her mother so frequently gave as to the
impropriety of such an affection.
Nor had Augusta any objection to the society of Miss Thorne. Augusta was a strongminded girl, with much
of the De Courcy arrogance, but quite as well inclined to show it in opposition to her mother as in any other
form. To her alone in the house did Lady Arabella show much deference. She was now going to make a
suitable match with a man of large fortune, who had been procured for her as an eligible parti by her aunt, the
countess. She did not pretend, had never pretended, that she loved Mr Moffat, but she knew, she said, that in
the present state of her father's affairs such a match was expedient. Mr Moffat was a young man of very large
fortune, in Parliament, and inclined to business, and in every way recommendable. He was not a man of birth,
to be sure; that was to be lamented;in confessing that Mr Moffat was not a man of birth, Augusta did not
go so far as to admit that he was the son of a tailor; such, however, was the rigid truth in this matterhe was
not a man of birth, that was to be lamented; but in the present state of affairs at Greshamsbury, she
understood well that it was her duty to postpone her own feelings in some respect. Mr Moffat would bring
fortune; she would bring blood and connexion. And as she so said, her bosom glowed with strong pride to
think that she would be able to contribute so much more towards the proposed future partnership than her
husband would do.
'Twas thus that Miss Gresham spoke of her match to her dear friends, her cousins the De Courcys for
instance, to Miss Oriel, her sister Beatrice, and even to Mary Thorne. She had no enthusiasm, she admitted,
but she thought she had good judgment. She thought she had shown good judgment in accepting Mr Moffat's
offer, though she did not pretend to any romance of affection. And, having so said, she went to work with
considerable mental satisfaction, choosing furniture, carriages, and clothes, not extravagantly as her mother
would have done, not in deference to sterner dictates of the latest fashion as her aunt would have done, with
none of the girlish glee in new purchases which Beatrice would have felt, but with sound judgment. She
bought things that were rich, for her husband was to be rich, and she meant to avail herself of his wealth; she
bought things that were fashionable, for she meant to live in the fashionable world; but she bought what was
good, and strong, and lasting, and worth its money.
Augusta Gresham had perceived early in life that she could not obtain success either as an heiress, or as a
beauty, nor could she shine as a wit; she therefore fell back on such qualities as she had, and determined to
win the world as a strongminded, useful woman. That which she had of her own was blood; having that, she
would in all ways do what in her lay to enhance its value. Had she not possessed it, it would to her mind have
been the vainest of pretences.
When Mary came in, the wedding preparations were being discussed. The number and names of the
bridesmaids were being settled, the dresses were on the tapis, the invitations to be given were talked over.
Sensible as Augusta was, she was not above such feminine cares; she was, indeed, rather anxious that the
wedding should go off well. She was a little ashamed of her tailor's son, and therefore anxious that things
should be as brilliant as possible.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 31
Page No 35
The bridesmaid's names had just been written on a card as Mary entered the room. There were the Ladies
Amelia, Rosina, Margaretta, and Alexandrina of course at the head of it; then came Beatrice and the twins;
then Miss Oriel, who, though only a parson's sister, was a person of note, birth and fortune. After this there
had been here a great discussion whether or not there should be any more. If there were to be one more there
must be two. Now Miss Moffat had expressed a direct wish, and Augusta, though she would much rather
have done without her, hardly knew how to refuse. Alexandrinawe hope we may be allowed to drop the
'lady' for the sake of brevity, for the present scene onlywas dead against such an unreasonable request. 'We
none of us know her, you know; and it would not be comfortable.' Beatrice strongly advocated the future
sisterinlaw's acceptance into the bevy; she had her own reasons; she was pained that Mary Thorne should
not be among the number, and if Miss Moffat were accepted, perhaps Mary might be brought in as her
colleague.
'If you have Miss Moffat,' said Alexandrina, 'you must have dear Pussy too; and I really think that Pussy is
too young; it will be troublesome.' Pussy was the youngest Miss Gresham, who was now only eight years old,
and whose real name was Nina.
'Augusta,' said Beatrice, speaking with some slight hesitation, some soupcon of doubt before the highest
authority of her noble cousin, 'if you do have Miss Moffat would you mind asking Mary Thorne to join her? I
think Mary would like it, because, you see, Patience Oriel is to be one; and we have known Mary much
longer than we have known Patience.'
Then out and spake the Lady Alexandrina.
'Beatrice, dear, if you think of what you are asking, I am sure you will see that it would not do; would not do
at all. Miss Thorne is a very nice girl, I am sure; and, indeed, what little I have seen of her I highly approve.
But, after all, who is she? Mamma, I know, thinks that Aunt Arabella has been wrong to let be here so much,
but'
Beatrice became rather red in the face, and, in spite of the dignity of her cousin, was preparing to defend her
friend.
'Mind, I am not saying a word against Miss Thorne.'
'If I am married before her, she shall be one of my bridesmaids,' said Beatrice.
'That will probably depend on circumstances,' said the Lady Alexandrina; I find that I cannot bring my
courteous pen to drop the title. 'But Augusta is very peculiarly situated. Mr Moffat, is, you see, not of the
very highest birth; and, therefore, she should take care that on her side every one about her is well born.'
'Then you cannot have Miss Moffat,' said Beatrice.
'No; I would not if I could help it,' said the cousin.
'But the Thornes are as good a family as the Greshams,' said Beatrice. She had not quite the courage to say, as
good as the De Courcys.
'I dare say they are; and if this was Miss Thorne of Ullathorne, Augusta probably would not object to her. But
can you tell me who Miss Mary Thorne is?'
'She is Dr Thorne's niece.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 32
Page No 36
'You mean that she is called so; but do you know who her father was, or who her mother was? I, for one,
must own that I do not. Mamma, I believe, does, but'
At this moment the door opened gently and Mary Thorne entered the room.
It may easily be conceived, that while Mary was making her salutations the three other young ladies were a
little cast aback. The Lady Alexandrina, however, quickly recovered herself, and, by her inimitable presence
of mind and facile grace of manner, soon put the matter on a proper footing.
'We were discussing Miss Gresham's marriage,' said she; 'I am sure I may mention to an acquaintance of so
long standing as Miss Thorne, that the first of September has been now fixed for the wedding.'
Miss Gresham! Acquaintance of so long standing! Why, Mary and Augusta Gresham had for years, we will
hardly say for how many, passed their mornings together in the same schoolroom; had quarrelled, and
squabbled, and caressed and kissed, and been all but sisters to each other. Acquaintance indeed! Beatrice felt
that her ears were tingling, and even Augusta was a little ashamed. Mary, however, knew that the cold words
had come from a De Courcy, and not from a Gresham, and did not, therefore, resent them.
'So it's settled, Augusta, is it?' said she; 'the first of September. I wish you joy with all my heart,' and, coming
round, she put her arm over Augusta's shoulder and kissed her. The Lady Alexandrina could not but think that
the doctor's niece uttered her congratulations very much as though she were speaking to an equal; very much
as though she had a father and mother of her own.
'You will have delicious weather,' continued Mary. 'September, and the beginning of October, is the nicest
time of the year. If I were going honeymooning it is just the time of year I would choose.'
'I wish you were, Mary,' said Beatrice.
'So do not I, dear, till I have found some decent sort of a body to honeymoon along with me. I won't stir out
of Greshamsbury till I have sent you off before me, at any rate. And where will you go, Augusta?'
'We have not settled that,' said Augusta. 'Mr Moffat talks of Paris.'
'Who ever heard of going to Paris in September?' said the Lady Alexandrina.
The Lady Alexandrina was not pleased to find how completely the doctor's niece took upon herself to talk,
and sit, and act at Greshamsbury as though she was on a par with the young ladies of the family. That
Beatrice should have allowed this would not have surprised her; but it was to be expected that Augusta would
have shown better judgment.
'These things require some tact in their management; some delicacy when high interests are at stake,' said she;
'I agree with Miss Thorne in thinking that, in ordinary circumstances, with ordinary people, perhaps, the lady
should have her way. Rank, however, has its drawbacks, Miss Thorne, as well as its privileges.'
'I should not object to the drawbacks,' said the doctor's niece, 'presuming them to be of some use; but I fear I
might fail in getting on so well with the privileges.'
The Lady Alexandrina looked at her as though not fully aware whether she intended to be pert. In truth, the
Lady Alexandrina was rather in the dark on the subject. It was almost impossible, it was incredible, that a
fatherless, motherless, doctor's niece should be pert to an earl's daughter at Greshamsbury, seeing that that
earl's daughter was the cousin of the miss Greshams. And yet the Lady Alexandrina hardly knew what other
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 33
Page No 37
construction to put on the words she had just heard.
It was at any rate clear to her that it was not becoming that she should just then stay any longer in that room.
Whether she intended to be pert or not, Miss Mary Thorne was, to say the least, very free. The De Courcy
ladies knew what was due to themno ladies better; and, therefore, the Lady Alexandrina made up her mind
at once to go to her own bedroom.
'Augusta,' she said, rising slowly from her chair with much stately composure, 'it is nearly time to dress; will
you come with me? We have a great deal to discuss, you know.'
So she swam out of the room, and Augusta, telling Mary that she would see her again at dinner, swamno,
tried to swimafter her. Miss Gresham had had great advantages; but she had not been absolutely brought
up at Courcy Castle, and could not as yet quite assume the Courcy style of swimming.
'There,' said Mary, as the door closed behind the rustling muslins of the ladies. 'There, I have made an enemy
for ever, perhaps two; that's satisfactory.'
'And why have you done it, Mary? When I am fighting your battles behind your back, why do you come and
upset it all by making the whole family of the De Courcys dislike you? In such a matter as that, they'll all go
together.'
'I am sure they will,' said Mary; 'whether they would be equally unanimous in a case of love and charity, that,
indeed, is another question.'
'But why should you try to make my cousin angry; you that ought to have so much sense? Don't you
remember that you were saying yourself the other day, of the absurdity of combatting pretences which the
world sanctions?'
'I do, Trichy, I do; don't scold me now. It is so much easier to preach than to practise. I do so wish I was a
clergyman.'
'But you have done so much harm, Mary.'
'Have I?' said Mary, kneeling down on the ground at her friend's feet. 'If I humble myself very low; if I kneel
through the whole evening in a corner; if I put my neck down and let all your cousins trample on it, and then
your aunt, would not that make atonement? I would not object to wearing sackcloth, either; and I'd eat a little
ashesor, at any rate, I'd try.'
'I know you're clever, Mary; but still I think you're a fool. I do, indeed.'
'I am a fool, Trichy, I do confess it; and am not a bit clever; but don't scold me; you see how humble I am; not
only humble but umble, which I look upon to be the comparative, or, indeed, superlative degree. Or perhaps
there are four degrees; humble, umble, stumble, tumble; and then, when one is absolutely in the dirt at their
feet, perhaps these big people won't wish one to stoop any further.'
'Oh, Mary!'
'And, oh, Trichy! you don't mean to say I mayn't speak out before you. There, perhaps you'd like to put your
foot on my neck.' And then she put her head down to the footstool and kissed Beatrice's feet.
'I'd like, if I dared, to put my hand on your cheek and give you a good slap for being such a goose.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 34
Page No 38
'Do; do, Trichy: you shall tread on me, or slap me, or kiss me; whichever you like.'
'I can't tell you how vexed I am,' said Beatrice; 'I wanted to arrange something.'
'Arrange something! What? arrange what? I love arranging. I fancy myself qualified to be an
arrangergeneral in female matters. I mean pots and pans, and such like. Of course I don't allude to
extraordinary people and extraordinary circumstances that require tact, and delicacy, and drawbacks, and that
sort of thing.'
'Very well, Mary.'
'But it's not very well; it's very bad if you look like that. Well, my pet, there I won't. I won't allude to the
noble blood of your noble relatives either in joke or in earnest. What is it you want to arrange, Trichy?'
'I want you to be one of Augusta's bridesmaids.'
'Good heavens, Beatrice! Are you mad? What! Put me, even for a morning, into the same category of finery
as the noble blood from Courcy Castle!'
'Patience is to be one.'
'But that is no reason why Impatience should be another, and I should be very impatient under such honours.
No, Trichy; joking apart, do not think of it. Even if Augusta wished it I would refuse. I should be obliged to
refuse. I, too, suffer from pride; a pride quite as unpardonable as that of others: I could not stand with your
four ladycousins behind your sister at the altar. In such a galaxy they would be the stars and I'
'Why, Mary, all the world knows that you are prettier than any of them!'
'I am all the world's very humble servant. But, Trichy, I should not object if I were as ugly as the veiled
prophet and they all as beautiful as Zuleika. The glory of that galaxy will be held to depend not on its beauty;
but on its birth. You know how they would look at me; now they would scorn me; and there, in church, at the
altar, with all that is solemn round us, I could not return their scorn as I might do elsewhere. In a room I'm not
a bit afraid of them at all.' And Mary was again allowing herself to be absorbed by that feeling of indomitable
pride, of antagonism to the pride of others, which she herself in her cooler moments was the first to blame.
'You often say, Mary, that that sort of arrogance should be despised and passed over without notice.'
'So it should, Trichy. I tell you that as a clergyman tells you to hate riches. But though the clergyman tells
you so, he is not the less anxious to be rich himself.'
'I particularly wish you to be one of Augusta's bridesmaids.'
'And I particularly wish to decline the honour; which honour has not been, and will not be, offered to me. No,
Trichy. I will not be Augusta's bridesmaid, butbutbut'
'But what, dearest?'
'But, Trichy, when some one else is married, when the new wing has been built to a house that you know
of'
'Now, Mary, hold your tongue, or you know you'll make me angry.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE 35
Page No 39
'I do so like to see you angry. And when that time comes, when that wedding does take place, then I will be a
bridesmaid, Trichy. Yes! even though I am not invited. Yes! though all the De Courcys in Barsetshire should
tread upon me and obliterate me. Though I should be dust among the stars, though I should creep up in calico
among their satins and lace, I will nevertheless be there; close, close to the bride; to hold something for her,
to touch her dress, to feel that I am near to her, tototo' and she threw her arms round her companion,
and kissed her over and over again. 'No, Trichy; I won't be Augusta's bridesmaid; I'll bide my time for
bridesmaiding.'
What protestations Beatrice made against the probability of such an event as foreshadowed in her friend's
promise we will not repeat. The afternoon was advancing, and the ladies also had to dress for dinner, to do
honour to the young heir.
CHAPTER V. FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH
We have said, that over and above those assembled in the house, there came to the Greshamsbury dinner on
Frank's birthday the Jacksons of the Grange, consisting of Mr and Mrs Jackson; the Batesons from
Annesgrove, viz., Mr and Mrs Bateson, and Miss Bateson, their daughteran unmarried lady of about fifty;
the Bakers of Mill Hill, father and son; and Mr Caleb Oriel, the rector, with his beautiful sister, Patience. Dr
Thorne, and his niece Mary, we count among those already assembled at Greshamsbury.
There was nothing very magnificent in the number of the guests thus brought together to do honour to young
Frank; but he, perhaps, was called on to take a more prominent part in the proceedings, to be made more of a
hero than would have been the case had half the county been there. In that case the importance of the guests
would have been so great that Frank would have got off with a halfmuttered speech or two; but now he had
to make a separate oration to every one, and very weary work he found it.
The Batesons, Bakers, and Jacksons were very civil; no doubt the more so from an unconscious feeling on
their part, that as the squire was known to a little out at elbows as regards money, any deficiency on their part
might be considered as owing to the present state of affairs at Greshamsbury. Fourteen thousand a year will
receive honour; in that case there is no doubt, and the man already possessing it is not apt to be suspicious as
to the treatment he may receive; but the ghost of fourteen thousand a year is not always so selfassured. Mr
Baker, with his moderate income, was a very much richer man than the squire; and, therefore, he was
peculiarly forward in congratulating Frank on the brilliancy of his prospects.
Poor Frank had hardly anticipated what there would be to do, and before dinner was announced he was very
tired of it. He had no warmer feeling for any of the grand cousins than a very ordinary cousinly love; and he
had resolved, forgetful of birth and blood, and all those gigantic considerations which now that manhood had
come upon him, he was bound always to bear in mind,he had resolved to sneak out to dinner comfortably
with Mary Thorne if possible; and if not with Mary, then with his other love, Patience Oriel.
Great, therefore, was his consternation at finding that, after being kept continually in the foreground for half
an hour before dinner, he had to walk out to the diningroom with his aunt the countess, and take his father's
place for the day at the bottom of the table.
'It will now depend altogether upon yourself, Frank, whether you maintain or lose that high position in the
county which has been held by the Greshams for so many years,' said the countess, as she walked through the
spacious hall, resolving to lose no time in teaching to her nephew that great lesson which it was so imperative
that he should learn.
Frank took this as an ordinary lecture, meant to inculcate general good conduct, such as old bores of aunts are
apt to inflict on youthful victims in the shape of nephews and nieces.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER V. FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH 36
Page No 40
'Yes,' said Frank; 'I suppose so; and I mean to go along all square, aunt, and no mistake. When I get back to
Cambridge, I'll read like bricks.'
His aunt did not care two straws about his reading. It was not by reading that the Greshams of Greshamsbury
had held their heads up in the county, but by having high blood and plenty of money. The blood had come
naturally to this young man; but it behoved him to look for the money in a great measure himself. She, Lady
de Courcy, could doubtless help him; she might probably be able to fit him with a wife who would bring her
money onto his birth. His reading was a matter in which she could in no way assist him; whether his taste
might lead him to prefer books or pictures, or dogs and horses, or turnips in drills, or old Italian plates and
dishes, was a matter which did not much signify; with which it was not at all necessary that his noble aunt
should trouble herself.
'Oh! you are going to Cambridge again, are you? Well, if your father wishes it;though very little is ever
gained now by a university connexion.'
'I am to take my degree in October, aunt; and I am determined, at any rate, that I won't be plucked.'
'Plucked!'
'No; I won't be plucked. Baker was plucked last year, and all because he got into the wrong set at John's. He's
an excellent fellow if you knew him. He got among a set of men who did nothing but smoke and drink beer.
Malthusians, we call them.'
'Malthusians!'
'"Malt", you know, aunt, and "use"; meaning that they drink beer. So poor Harry Baker got plucked. I don't
know that a fellow's any the worse; however, I won't get plucked.'
By this time the party had taken their place round the long board, Mr Gresham sitting at the top, in the place
usually occupied by Lady Arabella. She, on the present occasion, sat next to her son on the one side, as the
countess did on the other. If, therefore, Frank now went astray, it would not be from want of proper leading.
'Aunt, will you have some beef?' said he, as soon as the soup and fish had been disposed of, anxious to
perform the rites of hospitality now for the first time committed to his charge.
'Do not be in a hurry, Frank,' said his mother; 'the servants will'
'Oh! ah! I forgot; there are cutlets and those sort of things. My hand is not yet in for this work, aunt. Well, as I
was saying about Cambridge'
'Is Frank to go back to Cambridge, Arabella?' said the countess to her sisterinlaw, speaking across her
nephew.
'So his father seems to say.'
'Is it not a waste of time?' asked the countess.
'You know I never interfere,' said the Lady Arabella; 'I never liked the idea of Cambridge myself at all. All
the De Courcys were Christchurch men; but the Greshams, it seems, were always at Cambridge.'
'Would it not be better to send him abroad at once?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER V. FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH 37
Page No 41
'Much better, I would think,' said the Lady Arabella; 'but you know, I never interfere: perhaps you would
speak to Mr Gresham.'
The countess smiled grimly, and shook her head with a decidedly negative shake. Had she said out loud to the
young man, 'Your father is such an obstinate, pigheaded, ignorant fool, that it is no use speaking to him; it
would be wasting fragrance on the desert air,' she could not have spoken more plainly. The effect on Frank
was this: that he said to himself, speaking quite as plainly as Lady De Courcy had spoken by her shake of the
face, 'My mother and aunt are always down on the governor, always; but the more they are down on him the
more I'll stick to him. I certainly will take my degree: I will read like bricks; and I'll begin tomorrow.'
'Now will you take some beef, aunt?' This was said out loud.
The Countess de Courcy was very anxious to go on with her lesson without loss of time; but she could not,
while surrounded by guests and servants, enunciate the great secret: 'You must marry money, Frank; that is
your one great duty; that is the matter to be borne steadfastly in your mind.' She could not now, with
sufficient weight and impress of emphasis, pour this wisdom into his ears; the more especially as he was
standing up to his work of carving, and was deep to his elbows in horseradish, fat and gravy. So the
countess sat silent while the banquet proceeded.
'Beef, Harry?' shouted the young heir to his friend Baker. 'Oh! but I see it isn't your turn yet. I beg your
pardon, Miss Bateson,' and he sent to that lady a pound and a half of excellent meat, cut out with great energy
in one slice, about half an inch thick.
And so the banquet went on.
Before dinner Frank had found himself obliged to make numerous small speeches in answer to the numerous
individual congratulations of his friends; but these were as nothing to the one great accumulated onus of an
oration which he had long known that he should have to sustain after the cloth was taken away. Some one of
course would propose his health, and then there would be a clatter of voices, ladies and gentlemen, men and
girls; and when that was done he would find himself standing on his legs, with the room about him, going
round and round and round.
Having had a previous hint of this, he had sought advice from his cousin, the Honourable George, whom he
regarded as a dab at speaking; at least, so he had heard the Honourable George say of himself.
'What the deuce is a fellow to say, George, when he stands up after the clatter is done?'
'Oh, it's the easiest thing in life,' said the cousin. 'Only remember this: you mustn't get astray; that is what
they call presence of mind, you know. I'll tell you what I do, and I'm often called up, you know; at our
agriculturals I always propose the farmers' daughters: well, what I do is thisI keep my eye steadfastly fixed
on one of the bottles, and never move it.'
'On one of the bottles!' said Frank; 'wouldn't it be better if I made a mark of some old covey's head? I don't
like looking at the table.'
'The old covey'd move, and then you'd be done; besides thee isn't the least use in the world in looking up. I've
heard people say, who go to those sort of dinners every day of their lives, that whenever anything witty is
said; the fellow who says it is sure to be looking at the mahogany.'
'Oh, you know I shan't say anything witty; I'll be quite the other way.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER V. FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH 38
Page No 42
'But there's no reason you shouldn't learn the manner. That's the way I succeed. Fix your eye on one of the
bottles; put your thumbs in your waistcoat pockets; stick out your elbows, bend your knees a little, and then
go ahead.'
'Oh, ah! go ahead; that's all very well; but you can't go ahead if you haven't got any steam.'
'A very little does it. There can be nothing so easy as your speech. When one has to say anything new every
year about the farmers' daughters, why one has to use one's brains a bit. Let's see: how will you begin? Of
course, you'll say that you are not accustomed to this sort of thing; that the honour conferred upon you is too
much for your feelings; that the bright array of beauty and talent around you quite overpowers your tongue,
and all that sort of thing. Then declare you're a Gresham to the backbone.'
'Oh, they know that.'
'Well, tell them again. Then of course you must say something about us; or you'll have the countess as black
as old Nick.'
'Abut my aunt, George? What on earth can I say about her when she's there herself before me?'
'Before you! of course; that's just the reason. Oh, say any lie you can think of; you must say something about
us. You know we've come down from London on purpose.'
Frank, in spite of the benefit of receiving from his cousin's erudition, could not help wishing in his heart that
they had al remained in London; but this he kept to himself. He thanked his cousin for his hints, and though
he did not feel that the trouble of his mind was completely cured, he began to hope that he might go through
the ordeal without disgracing himself.
Nevertheless, he felt rather sick at heart when Mr Baker got up to propose the toast as soon as the servants
were gone. The servants, that is, were gone officially; but they were there in a body, men and women, nurses,
cooks, and ladies' maids, coachmen, grooms, and footmen, standing in two doorways to hear what Master
Frank would say. The old housekeeper headed the maids at one door, standing boldly inside the room; and
the butler controlled the men at the other, marshalling them back with a drawn corkscrew.
Mr Baker did not say much; but what he did say, he said well. They had all seen Frank Gresham grow up
from a child; and were now required to welcome as a man amongst them one who was well qualified to carry
on the honour of that loved and respected family. His young friend, Frank, was every inch a Gresham. Mr
Baker omitted to make mention of the infusion of De Courcy blood, and the countess, therefore, drew herself
up on her chair and looked as though she were extremely bored. He then alluded tenderly to his own long
friendship with the present squire, Francis Newbold Gresham the elder; and sat down, begging them to drink
health, prosperity, long life, and excellent wife to their dear friend Francis Newbold Gresham the younger.
There was a great jingling of glasses, of course; made the merrier and the louder by the fact that the ladies
were still there as well as the gentlemen. Ladies don't drink toasts frequently; and, therefore, the occasion
coming rarely was the more enjoyed. 'God bless you, Frank!' 'Your good health, Frank!' 'And especially a
good wife, Frank!' 'Two or three of them, Frank!' 'Good health and prosperity to you, Mr Gresham!' 'More
power to you, Frank, my boy!' 'May God bless you and preserve you, my dear boy!' and then a merry, sweet,
eager voice from the far end of the table, 'Frank! Frank! Do look at me, pray do Frank; I am drinking your
health in real wine; ain't I, papa?' Such were the addresses which greeted Mr Francis Newbold Gresham the
younger as he essayed to rise up on his feet for the first time since he had come to man's estate.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER V. FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH 39
Page No 43
When the clatter was at an end, and he was fairly on his legs, he cast a glance before him on the table, to look
for a decanter. He had not much liked his cousin's theory of sticking to the bottle; nevertheless, in the
difficulty of the moment, it was well to have any system to go by. But, as misfortune would have it, though
the table was covered with bottles, his eye could not catch one. Indeed, his eye first could catch nothing, for
the things swam before him, and the guests all seemed to dance in their chairs.
Up he got, however, and commenced his speech. As he could not follow his preceptor's advice, as touching
the bottle, he adopted his own crude plan of 'making a mark on some old covey's head,' and therefore looked
dead at the doctor.
'Upon my word, I am very much obliged to you, gentlemen and ladies, ladies and gentlemen, I should say, for
drinking my health, and doing me so much honour, and all that sort of thing. Upon my word I am. Especially
to you, Mr Baker. I don't mean you, Harry, you're not Mr Baker.'
'As much as you're Mr Gresham, Master Frank.'
'But I am not Mr Gresham; and I don't mean to be for many a long year if I can help it; not at any rate till we
have had another coming of age here.'
'Bravo, Frank; and whose will that be?'
'That will be my son, and a very fine lad he will be; and I hope he'll make a better speech than his father. Mr
Baker said I was every inch a Gresham. Well, I hope I am.' Here the countess began to look cold and angry. 'I
hope the day will never come when my father won't own me for one.'
'There's no fear, no fear,' said the doctor, who was almost put out of countenance by the orator's intense gaze.
The countess looked colder and more angry, and muttered something to herself about a beargarden.
'Gardez Gresham; eh? Harry! mind that when you're sticking in a gap I'm coming after you. Well, I am sure I
am very obliged to you for the honour you have all done me, especially the ladies who don't do this sort of
things on ordinary occasions. I wish they did; don't you, doctor? And talking of the ladies, my aunty and
cousins have come all the way from London to hear me take this speech which certainly is not worth the
trouble; but, all the same I am very much obliged to them.' And he looked round and made a little bow at the
countess. 'And so I am to Mr and Mrs Jackson, and Mr and Mrs and Miss Bateson, and Mr BakerI'm not at
all obliged to you, Harryand to Mr Oriel and Miss Oriel, and to Mr Umbleby, and to Dr Thorne, and to
MaryI beg her pardon, I mean Miss Thorne.' And then he sat down, amid the loud plaudits of the company,
and a string of blessings which came from the servants behind him.
After this the ladies rose and departed. As she went, Lady Arabella, kissed her son's forehead, and then his
sisters kissed him, and one or two of his ladycousins; and then Miss Bateson shook him by the hand. 'Oh,
Miss Bateson,' said he, 'I though the kissing was to go all round.' So Miss Bateson laughed and went her way;
and Patience Oriel nodded at him, but Mary Thorne, as she quietly left the room, almost hidden among the
extensive draperies of the grander ladies, hardly allowed her eyes to meet his.
He got up to hold the door for them as the passed; and as they went, he managed to take Patience by the hand;
he took her hand and pressed it for a moment, but dropped it quickly, in order that he might go through the
same ceremony with Mary, but Mary was too quick for him.
'Frank,' said Mr Gresham, as soon as the door was closed, 'bring your glass here, my boy;' and the father
made room for his son close beside himself. 'The ceremony is now over, so you may have your place of
dignity.' Frank sat himself down where he was told, and Mr Gresham put his hand on his son's shoulder and
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER V. FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH 40
Page No 44
half caressed him, while the tears stood in his eyes. 'I think the doctor is right, Baker, I think he'll never make
us ashamed of him.'
'I am sure he never will,' said Baker.
'I don't think he ever will,' said Dr Thorne.
The tones of the men's voices were very different. Mr Baker did not care a straw about it; why should he? He
had an heir of his own as well as the squire; one also who was the apple of his eye. But the doctor,he did
care; he had a niece, to be sure, whom he loved, perhaps as well as these men loved their sons; but there was
room in his heart also for young Frank Gresham.
After this small expose of feeling they sat silent for a moment or two. But silence was not dear to the heart of
the Honourable John, and so he took up the running.
'That's a niceish nag you gave Frank this morning,' he said to his uncle. 'I was looking at him before dinner.
He is a Monsoon, isn't he?'
'Well I can't say I know how he was bred,' said the squire. 'He should a good deal of breeding.'
'He's a Monsoon, I'm sure,' said the Honourable John. 'They've all those ears, and that peculiar dip in the
back. I suppose you gave a goodish figure for him?'
'Not so very much,' said the squire.
'He's a trained hunter, I suppose?'
'If not, he soon will be,' said the squire.
'Let Frank alone for that,' said Harry Baker.
'He jumps beautifully, sir,' said Frank. 'I haven't tried him myself, but Peter made him go over the bar two or
three times this morning.'
The Honourable John was determined to give his cousin a helping hand, as he considered it. He thought that
Frank was very ill used in being put off with so incomplete stud, and thinking also that the son had not spirit
enough to attack his father himself on the subject, the Honourable John determined to do it for him.
'He's the making of a very nice horse, I don't doubt. I wish you had a string like him, Frank.'
Frank felt the blood rush to his face. He would not for worlds have his father think that he was discontented,
or otherwise than pleased with the present he had received that morning. He was heartily ashamed of himself
in that he had listened with a certain degree of complacency to his cousin's tempting; but he had no idea that
the subject would be repeatedand then repeated, too, before his father, in a manner to vex him on such a
day as this, before such people as were assembled here. He was very angry with his cousin, and for a moment
forgot all his hereditary respect for a De Courcy.
'I tell you what, John,' said he, 'do you choose your day, some day early in the season, and come out on the
best thing you have, and I'll bring, not the black horse, but my old mare; and then do you try to keep near me.
If I don't leave you at the back of Godspeed before long, I'll give you the mare and the horse too.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER V. FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH 41
Page No 45
The Honourable John was not known in Barsetshire as one of the most forward of its riders. He was a man
much addicted to hunting, as far as the getup of the thing was concerned; he was great in boots and
breeches; wondrously conversant with bits and bridles; he had quite a collection of saddles; and patronized
every newest invention for carrying spare shoes, sandwiches, and flasks of sherry. He was prominent at the
cover side;some people, including the master of hounds, thought him perhaps a little too loudly prominent;
he affected a familiarity with the dogs, and was on speaking acquaintance with every man's horse. But when
the work was cut out, when the pace began to be sharp, when it behoved a man either to ride or visibly to
decline to ride, thenso at least said they who had not the De Courcy interest quite closely at heartthen, in
those heartstirring moments, the Honourable John was too often found deficient.
There was, therefore, a considerable laugh at his expense when Frank, instigated to this innocent boast by a
desire to save his father, challenged his cousin to a trial of prowess. The Honourable John was not, perhaps,
as much accustomed to the ready use of his tongue as was his honourable brother, seeing that it was not his
annual business to depict the glories of the farmers' daughters; at any rate, on this occasion he seemed to be at
some loss for words; he shut up, as the slang phrase goes, and made no further allusion to the necessity of
supplying young Gresham with a proper stream of hunters.
But the old squire had understood it all; had understood the meaning of his nephew's attack; had thoroughly
understood the meaning of his son's defence, and the feeling which actuated it. He also had thought of the
stableful of horses which had belonged to himself when he became of age; and of the much more humble
position which his son would have to fill than that which his father had prepared for him. He thought of this,
and was sad enough, though he had sufficient spirit to hide from his friends around him the fact, that the
Honourable John's arrow had not been discharged in vain.
'He shall have Champion,' said the father to himself. 'It is time for me to give up.'
Now Champion was one of the two fine old hunters which the squire kept for his own use. And it might have
been said of him now, at the period of which we are speaking, that the only really happy moments of his life
were those which he spent in the field. So much as to its being time for him to give up.
CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES
It was, we have said, the first of July, and such being the time of the year, the ladies, after sitting in the
drawingroom for half an hour or so, began to think that they might as well go through the drawingroom
windows on to the lawn. First one slipped out a little way, and then another; and then they got on to the lawn;
and then they talked of their hats; till, by degrees, the younger ones of the party, and the last of the elder also,
found themselves dressed for walking.
The windows, both of the drawingroom, and the diningroom, looked out on to the lawn; and it was only
natural that the girls should walk from the former to the latter. It was only natural that they, being there,
should tempt their swains to come to them by the sight of their broadbrimmed hats and evening dresses; and
natural, also, that the temptation should not be resisted. The squire, therefore, and the elder male guests soon
found themselves alone round their wine.
'Upon my word, we were enchanted by your eloquence, Mr Gresham, were we not?' said Miss Oriel, turning
to one of the De Courcy girls who was with her.
Miss Oriel was a very pretty girl; a little older than Frank Gresham,perhaps a year or so. She had dark hair,
large round dark eyes, a nose a little too broad, a pretty mouth, a beautiful chin, and, as we have said before, a
large fortune;that is, moderately largelet us say twenty thousand pounds, there or thereabouts. She and
her brother had been living at Greshamsbury for the last two years, the living having been purchased for
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES 42
Page No 46
himsuch were Mr Gresham's necessitiesduring the lifetime of the last old incumbent. Miss Oriel was in
every respect a nice neighbour; she was goodhumoured, ladylike, lively, neither too clever nor too stupid,
belonging to a good family, sufficiently fond of this world's good things, as became a pretty young lady so
endowed, and sufficiently fond, also, of the other world's good things, as became the mistress of a
clergyman's house.
'Indeed, yes;' said the Lady Margaretta. 'Frank is very eloquent. When he described our rapid journey from
London, he nearly moved me to tears. But well as he talks, I think he carves better.'
'I wish you'd had to do it, Margaretta; both the carving and the talking.'
'Thank you, Frank; you're very civil.'
'But there's one comfort, Miss Oriel; it's over now, and done. A fellow can't be made to come of age twice.'
'But you'll take your degree, Mr Gresham; and then, of course, there'll be another speech; and then you'll get
married, and there will be two or three more.'
'I'll speak at your wedding, Miss Oriel, before I do at my own.'
'I shall not have the slightest objection. It will be so kind of you to patronize my husband.'
'But, by Jove, will he patronize me? I know you'll marry some awful bigwig, or some terribly clever fellow;
won't she, Margaretta?'
'Miss Oriel was saying so much in praise of you before you came out,' said Margaretta, 'that I began to think
that her mind was intent at remaining at Greshamsbury all her life.'
Frank blushed, and Patience laughed. There was but a year's difference in their age; but Frank, however, was
still a boy, though Patience was fully a woman.
'I am ambitious, Lady Margaretta,' said she. 'I own it; but I am moderate in my ambition. I do love
Greshamsbury, and if Mr Gresham had a younger brother, perhaps, you know'
'Another just like myself, I suppose,' said Frank.
'Oh, yes. I could not possibly wish for any change.'
'Just as eloquent as you are, Frank,' said the Lady Margaretta.
'And as good a carver,' said Patience.
'Miss Bateson has lost her heart to him for ever, because of his carving,' said the Lady Margaretta.
'But perfection never repeats itself,' said Patience.
'Well, you see, I have not got any brothers,' said Frank; 'so all I can do is to sacrifice myself.'
'Upon my word, Mr Gresham, I am under more than ordinary obligations to you; I am indeed,' said Miss
Oriel, stood still in the path, and made a very graceful curtsy. 'Dear me! only think, Lady Margaretta, that I
should be honoured with an offer from the heir the very moment he is legally entitled to make one.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES 43
Page No 47
'And done with so much true gallantry, too,' said the other; 'expressing himself quite willing to postpone any
views of his own for your advantage.'
'Yes;' said Patience; 'that's what I value so much: had he loved me now, there would have been no merit on
his part; but a sacrifice you know'
'Yes, ladies are so fond of such sacrifices, Frank, upon my word, I had no idea you were so very excellent at
making speeches.'
'Well,' said Frank, 'I shouldn't have said sacrifice, that was a slip; what I meant was'
'Oh, dear me,' said Patience, 'wait a minute; now we are going to have a regular declaration. Lady Margaretta,
you haven't a scentbottle, have you? And if I should faint, where's the gardenchair?'
'Oh, but I'm not going to make a declaration at all,' said Frank.
'Are you not? Oh! Now, Lady Margaretta, I appeal to you; did you not understand him to say something very
particular?'
'Certainly, I thought nothing could be plainer,' said the Lady Margaretta.
'And so, Mr Gresham, I am to be told, that after all it means nothing,' said Patience, putting her handkerchief
up to her eyes.
'It means that you are an excellent hand at quizzing a fellow like me.'
'Quizzing! No; but you are an excellent hand at deceiving a poor girl like me. Well, remember, I have got a
witness; here is Lady Margaretta, who heard it all. What a pity it is that my brother is a clergyman. You
calculated on that, I know; or you would never had served me so.'
She said so just as her brother joined them, or rather just as he had joined Lady Margaretta de Courcy; for her
ladyship and Mr Oriel walked on in advance by themselves. Lady Margaretta had found it rather dull work,
making a third in Miss Oriel's flirtation with her cousin; the more so as she was quite accustomed to take a
principal part herself in all such transactions. She therefore not unwillingly walked on with Mr Oriel. Mr
Oriel, it must be conceived, was not a common, everyday parson, but had points about him which made him
quite fit to associate with an earl's daughter. And as it was known that he was not a marrying man, having
very exalted ideas on that point connected with his profession, the Lady Margaretta, of course, had the less
objection to trust herself alone with him.
But directly she was gone, Miss Oriel's tone of banter ceased. It was very well making a fool of a lad of
twentyone when others were by; but there might be danger in it when they were alone together.
'I don't know any position on earth more enviable than yours, Mr Gresham,' said she, quite soberly and
earnestly; 'how happy you ought to be.'
'What, in being laughed at by you, Miss Oriel, for pretending to be a man, when you choose to make out that
I am only a boy? I can bear to be laughed at pretty well generally, but I can't say that your laughing at me
makes me feel so happy as you say I ought to be.'
Frank was evidently of an opinion totally different from that of Miss Oriel. Miss Oriel, when she found
herself teteatete with him, thought it was time to give over flirting; Frank, however, imagined that it was
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES 44
Page No 48
just the moment for him to begin. So he spoke and looked very languishing, and put on him quite the airs of
an Orlando.
'Oh, Mr Gresham, such good friends as you and I may laugh at each other, may we not?'
'You may do what you like, Miss Oriel: beautiful women I believe always may; but you remember what the
spider said to the fly, "That which is sport to you, may be death to me."' Anyone looking at Frank's face as he
said that, might well have imagined that he was breaking his very heart for love of Miss Oriel. Oh, Master
Frank! Master Frank! if you act thus in the green leaf, what will you do in the dry?
While Frank Gresham was thus misbehaving himself, and going on as though to him belonged the privilege
of falling in love with pretty faces, as it does to ploughboys and other ordinary people, his great interests were
not forgotten by those guardian saints who were so anxious to shower down on his head all manner of
temporal blessings.
Another conversation had taken place in the Greshamsbury gardens, in which nothing light had been allowed
to present itself; nothing frivolous had been spoken. The countess, the Lady Arabella, and Miss Gresham had
been talking over Greshamsbury affairs, and they had latterly been assisted by the Lady Amelia, than whom
no De Courcy ever born was more wise, more solemn, more prudent, more proud. The ponderosity of her
qualifications for nobility was sometimes too much even for her mother, and her devotion for the peerage was
such, that she would certainly have declined a seat in heaven if offered to her without the promise that it
should be in the upper house.
The subject first discussed had been Augusta's prospects. Mr Moffat had been invited to Courcy Castle, and
Augusta had been taken thither to meet him, with the express intention on the part of the countess, that they
should be man and wife. The countess had been careful to make it intelligible to her sisterinlaw and niece,
that though Mr Moffat would do excellently well for a daughter of Greshamsbury, he could not be allowed to
raise his eyes to a female scion of Courcy Castle.
'Not that we personally dislike him,' said the Lady Amelia; 'but rank has its drawbacks, Augusta.' As the Lady
Amelia was now somewhat nearer forty than thirty, and was still allowed to walk,
'In maiden meditation, fancy free,'
it may be presumed that in her case rank had been found to have serious drawbacks.
To this Augusta said nothing in objection. Whether desirable by a De Courcy or not, the match was to be
hers, and there was no doubt whatever as to the wealth of the man whose name she was to take; the offer had
been made, not to her, but to her aunt; the acceptance had been expressed, not by her, but by her aunt. Had
she thought of recapitulating in her memory all that had ever passed between Mr Moffat and herself, she
would have found that it did not amount to more than the most ordinary conversation between chance
partners in a ballroom. Nevertheless, she was to be Mrs Moffat. All that Mr Gresham knew of him was, that
when he met the young man for the first and only time in his life, he found him extremely hard to deal with in
the matter of money. He had insisted on having ten thousand pounds with his wife, and at last refused to go
on with the match unless he got six thousand pounds. This latter sum the poor squire had undertaken to pay
him.
Mr Moffat had been for a year or two MP for Barchester; having been assisted in his views on that ancient
city by all the De Courcy interest. He was a Whig, of course. Not only had Barchester, departing from the
light of other days, returned a Whig member of Parliament, but it was declared, that at the next election, now
near at hand, a Radical would be sent up, an man pledged to the ballot, to economies of all sorts, one who
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES 45
Page No 49
would carry out Barchester politics in all their abrupt, obnoxious, pestilent virulence. This was one Scatcherd,
a great railway contractor, a man who was a native of Barchester, who had bought property in the
neighbourhood, and who had achieved a sort of popularity there and elsewhere by the violence of his
democratic opposition to the aristocracy. According to this man's political tenets, the Conservatives should be
laughed at as fools, but the Whigs should be hated as knaves.
Mr Moffat was now coming down to Courcy Castle to look after his electioneering interests, and Miss
Gresham was to return with her aunt to meet him. The countess was very anxious that Frank should also
accompany them. Her great doctrine, that he must marry money, had been laid down with authority, and
received without doubt. She now pushed it further, and said that no time should be lost; that he should not
only marry money, but do so very early in life; there was always a danger in delay. The Greshamsof
course she alluded only to the males of the familywere foolishly softhearted; no one could say what
might happen. There was that Miss Thorne always at Greshamsbury.
This was more than Lady Arabella could stand. She protested that there was at least no ground for supposing
that Frank would absolutely disgrace his family.
Still the countess continued: 'Perhaps not,' she said; 'but when young people of perfectly different ranks were
allowed to associate together, there was no saying what danger might arise. They all know that old Mr
Batesonthe present Mr Bateson's fatherhad gone off with the governess; and young Mr Everbeery, near
Taunton, had only the other day married a cookmaid.'
'But Mr Everbeery was always drunk, aunt,' said Augusta, feeling called upon to say something for her
brother.
'Never mind, my dear; these things do happen, and they are very dreadful.'
'Horrible!' said the Lady Amelia; 'diluting the best blood of the country, and paving the way for revolution.'
This was very grand; but, nevertheless, Augusta could not but feel that she perhaps might be about to dilute
the blood of her coming children in marrying the tailor's son. She consoled herself by trusting that, at any
rate, she paved the way for no revolution.
'When a thing is so necessary,' said the countess, 'it cannot be done too soon. Now, Arabella, I don't say that
anything will come of it; but it may; Miss Dunstable is coming down to us next week. Now, we all know that
when old Dunstable died last year, he left over two hundred thousand to his daughter.'
'It is a great deal of money, certainly,' said Lady Arabella.
'It wold pay off everything, and a great deal more,' said the countess.
'It was ointment, was it not, aunt?' said Augusta.
'I believe so, my dear; something called the ointment of Lebanon, or something of that sort: but there's no
doubt about the money.'
'But how old is she, Robina?' asked the anxious mother.
'About thirty, I suppose; but I don't think that much signifies.'
'Thirty,' said Lady Arabella, rather dolefully. 'And what is she like? I think that Frank already begins to like
girls that are young and pretty.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES 46
Page No 50
'But surely, aunt,' said the Lady Amelia, 'now that he has come to man's discretion, he will not refuse to
consider all that he owes to his family. A Mr Gresham of Greshamsbury has a position to support.' The De
Courcy scion spoke these last words in the sort of tone that a parish clergyman would use, in warning some
young farmer's son that he should not put himself on an equal footing with the ploughboys.
It was at last decided that the countess should herself convey to Frank a special invitation to Courcy Castle,
and that when she got him there, she should do all that lay in her power to prevent his return to Cambridge,
and to further the Dunstable marriage.
'We did think of Miss Dunstable for Porlock, once,' she said, naively; 'but when we found that it wasn't much
over two hundred thousand, why that idea fell to the ground.' The terms on which the De Courcy blood might
be allowed to dilute itself were, it must be presumed, very high indeed.
Augusta was sent off to find her brother, and to send him to the countess in the small drawingroom. Here
the countess was to have her tea, apart from the outer common world, and her, without interruption, she was
to teach her great lesson to her nephew.
Augusta did find her brother, and found him in the worst of bad societyso at least the stern De Courcys
would have thought. Old Mr Bateson and the governess, Mr Everbeery and his cook's diluted blood, and
ways paved for revolutions, all presented themselves to Augusta's mind when she found her brother walking
with no other company than Mary Thorne, and walking with her, too, in much too close proximity.
How he had contrived to be off with the old love and so soon on with the new, or rather, to be off with the
new love and again on with the old, we will not stop to inquire. Had Lady Arabella, in truth, known all her
son's doings in this way, could she have guessed how very nigh he had approached the iniquity of old Mr
Bateson, and to the folly of young Mr Everbeery, she would in truth have been in a hurry to send him off to
Courcy Castle and Miss Dunstable. Some days before the commencement of our story, young Frank had
sworn in sober earnestin what he intended for his most sober earnest, his most earnest sobrietythat he
loved Mary Thorne with a love for which words could find no sufficient expressionwith a love that could
never die, never grow dim, never become less, which no opposition on the part of others could extinguish,
which no opposition on her part could repel; that he might, could, would, and should have her for his wife,
and that if she told him she didn't love him, he would
'Oh, oh! Mary; do you love me? Don't you love me? Won't you love me? Say you will. Oh, Mary, dearest
Mary, will you? won't you? do you? don't you? Come now, you have a right to give a fellow an answer.'
With such eloquence had the heir of Greshamsbury, when not yet twentyone years of age, attempted to
possess himself of the affections of the doctor's niece. And yet three days afterwards he was quite ready to
flirt with Miss Oriel.
If such things are done in the green wood, what will be done in the dry?
And what had Mary said when those fervent protestations of an undying love had been thrown at her feet?
Mary, it must be remembered, was very nearly of the same age as Frank; but, as I an others have so often said
before, 'Women grow on the sunny side of the wall.' Though Frank was only a boy, it behoved Mary to be
something more than a girl. Frank might be allowed, without laying himself open to much reproach, to throw
all of what he believed to be his heart into a protestation of what he believed to be love; but Mary was in duty
bound to be more thoughtful, more reticent, more aware of the facts of their position, more careful of her own
feelings, and more careful also of his.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES 47
Page No 51
And yet she could not put him down as another young lady might put down another young gentleman. It is
very seldom that a young man, unless he be tipsy, assumes an unwelcome familiarity in his early
acquaintance with any girl; but when acquaintance has been long and intimate, familiarities must follow as a
matter of course. Frank and Mary had been so much together in his holidays, had so constantly consorted
together as boys and girls, that, as regarded her, he had not that innate fear of a woman which represses a
young man's tongue; and she was so used to his goodhumour, his fun, and high jovial spirits, and was,
withal, so fond of them and him, that it was very difficult for her to mark with accurate feeling, and stop with
reserved brow, the shade of change from a boy's liking to a man's love.
And Beatrice, too, had done harm in this matter. With a spirit painfully unequal to that of her grand relatives,
she had quizzed Mary and Frank about their early flirtations. This she had done; but had instinctively avoided
doing so before her mother and sister, and had thus made a secret of it, as it were, between herself, Mary, and
her brother;had given currency, as it were, to the idea that there might be something serious between the
two. Not that Beatrice had ever wished to promote a marriage between them, or had even thought of such a
thing. She was girlish, thoughtless, imprudent, inartistic, and very unlike a De Courcy. Very unlike a De
Courcy she was in all that; but, nevertheless, she had the De Courcy veneration for blood, and, more than
that, she had the Gresham feeling joined to that of the De Courcys. The Lady Amelia would not for worlds
have had the De Courcy blood defiled; but gold she thought could not defile. Now Beatrice was ashamed of
her sister's marriage, and had often declared, within her own heart, that nothing could have made her marry a
Mr Moffat.
She had said so also to Mary, and Mary had told her that she was right. Mary was also proud of blood, was
proud of her uncle's blood, and the two girls talked together in all the warmth of girlish confidence, of the
great glories of family traditions and family honours. Beatrice had talked in utter ignorance as to her friend's
birth; and Mary, poor Mary, she had talked, being as ignorant; but not without a strong suspicion that, at
some future time, a day of sorrow would tell her some fearful truth.
On one point Mary's mind was strongly made up. No wealth, no mere worldly advantage could make any one
her superior. If she were born a gentlewoman, then was she fit to match with any gentleman. Let the most
wealthy man in Europe pour all his wealth at her feet, she could, if so inclined, give him back at any rate
more than that. That offered at her feet she knew she would never tempt her to yield up the fortress of her
heart, the guardianship of her soul, the possession of her mind; not that alone, nor that, even, as any possible
slightest fraction of a makeweight.
If she were born a gentlewoman! And then came to her mind those curious questions; what makes a
gentleman? what makes a gentlewoman? What is the inner reality, the spiritualised quintessence of that
privilege in the world which men call rank, which forces the thousands and hundreds of thousands to bow
down before the few elect? What gives, or can give it, or should give it?'
And she answered the question. Absolute, intrinsic, acknowledged, individual merit must give it to its
possessor, let him be whom, and what, and whence he might. So far the spirit of democracy was strong with
her. Beyond this it could be had but by inheritance, received as it were secondhand, or twentysecond hand.
And so far the spirit of aristocracy was strong within her. All this she had, as may be imagined, learnt in early
years from her uncle; and all this she was at great pains to teach Beatrice Gresham, the chosen of her heart.
When Frank declared that Mary had a right to give him an answer, he meant that he had a right to expect one.
Mary acknowledged this right, and gave it to him.
'Mr Gresham,' she said.
'Oh, Mary; Mr Gresham!'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES 48
Page No 52
'Yes, Mr Gresham. It must be Mr Gresham, after that. And, moreover, it must be Miss Thorne as well.'
'I'll be shot if it shall, Mary.'
'Well; I can't say that I shall be shot if it be not so; but if it be not so, if you do not agree that it shall be so, I
shall be turned out of Greshamsbury.'
'What! you mean my mother?' said Frank.
'Indeed! I mean no such thing,' said Mary, with a flash from her eye that made Frank almost start. 'I mean no
such thing. I mean you, not your mother. I am not in the least afraid of Lady Arabella; but I am afraid of you.'
'Afraid of me, Mary!'
'Miss Thorne; pray, pray, remember. It must be Miss Thorne. Do not turn me out of Greshamsbury. Do not
separate me from Beatrice. It is you that will drive me out; no one else. I could stand my ground against your
motherI feel I could; but I cannot stand against you if you treat me otherwise thanthan'
'Otherwise than what? I want to treat you as the girl I have chosen from all the world as my wife.'
'I am sorry you should so soon have found it necessary to make a choice. But, Mr Gresham, we must not joke
about this at present. I am sure you would not willingly injure me; but if you speak to me, or of me, again in
that way, you will injure me, injure me so much that I shall be forced to leave Greshamsbury, in my own
defence. I know you are too generous to drive me to that.'
And so the interview had ended. Frank, of course, went upstairs to see if his new pocketpistols were all
ready, properly cleaned, loaded, and capped, should he find, after a few days' experience, that prolonged
existence was unendurable.
However, he managed to live through the subsequent period; doubtless with a view of preventing any
appointment to his father's guests.
CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN
Mary had contrived to quiet her lover with considerable propriety of demeanour. Then came on her the
somewhat harder task of quieting herself. Young ladies, on the whole, are perhaps quite as susceptible of the
after feelings as young gentlemen are. Now Frank Gresham, was handsome, amiable, by no means a fool in
intellect, excellent in heart; and he was, moreover, a gentleman, being the son of Mr Gresham of
Greshamsbury. Mary had been, as it were, brought up to love him. Had aught but good happened to him, she
would have cried as for a brother. It must not therefore be supposed that when Frank Gresham told her that he
loved her, she had heard it altogether unconcerned.
He had not, perhaps, made his declaration with that propriety of language in which such scenes are generally
described as being carried on. Ladies may perhaps think that Mary should have been deterred, by the very
boyishness of his manner, from thinking at all seriously on the subject. His 'will you, won't youdo you,
don't you?' does not sound like the poetic raptures of a highly inspired lover. But, nevertheless, there had
been warmth, and a reality in it not in itself repulsive; and Mary's angeranger? no, not angerher
objections to the declarations were probably not based on the absurdity of her lover's language.
We are inclined to think that these matters are not always discussed by mortal lovers in the poetically
passionate phraseology which is generally thought to be appropriate for their description. A man cannot well
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN 49
Page No 53
describe that which he has never seen or heard; but the absolute words and acts of one such scene did once
come to the author's knowledge. The couple were by no means plebeian, or below the proper standard of high
bearing and high breeding; they were a handsome pair, living among educated people, sufficiently given to
mental pursuits, and in every way what a pair of polite lovers ought to be. The allimportant conversation
passed in this wise. The site of the passionate scene was the seashore, on which they were walking, in
autumn.
Gentleman. 'Well, Miss , the long and short of it is this: here I am; you can take me or leave me.'
Ladyscratching a gutter on the sand with her parasol, so as to allow a little salt water to run out of one hole
into another. 'Of course, I know that's all nonsense.'
Gentleman. 'Nonsense! By Jove, it isn't nonsense at all: come, Jane; here I am: come, at any rate you can say
something.'
Lady. 'Yes, I suppose I can say something.'
Gentleman. 'Well, which is it to be; take me or leave me?'
Ladyvery slowly, and with a voice perhaps hardly articulate, carrying on, at the same time, her engineering
works on a wider scale. 'Well, I don't exactly want to leave you.'
And so the matter was settled: settled with much propriety and satisfaction; and both the lady and gentleman
would have thought, had they ever thought about the matter at all, that this, the sweetest moment of their
lives, had been graced by all the poetry by which such moments ought to be hallowed.
When Mary had, as she thought, properly subdued young Frank, the offer of whose love she, at any rate,
knew was, at such a period of his life, an utter absurdity, then she found it necessary to subdue herself. What
happiness on earth could be greater than the possession of such a love, had the true possession been justly and
honestly within her reach? What man could be more lovable than such a man as would grow from such a
boy? And then, did she not love himlove him already, without waiting for any change? Did she not feel
that there was that about him, about him and about herself, too, which might so well fit them for each other?
It would be so sweet to be the sister of Beatrice, the daughter of the squire, to belong to Greshamsbury as a
part and parcel of itself.
But though she could not restrain these thoughts, it never for a moment occurred to her to take Frank's offer
in earnest. Though she was a grown woman, he was still a boy. He would have to see the world before he
settled in it, and would change his mind about woman half a score of times before he married. Then, too,
though she did not like the Lady Arabella, she felt that she owed something, if not to her kindness, at least to
her forbearance; and she knew, felt inwardly certain, that she would be doing wrong, that the world would
say that she was doing wrong, that her uncle would think her wrong, if she endeavoured to take advantage of
what had passed.
She had not for an instant doubted; not for a moment had she contemplated it as possible that she should ever
become Mrs Gresham because Frank had offered to make her so; but, nevertheless, she could not help
thinking of what had occurredof thinking of it, most probably much more than Frank did himself.
A day or two afterwards, on the evening before Frank's birthday, she was alone with her uncle, walking in the
garden behind their house, and she then essayed to question him, with the object of learning if she were fitted
by her birth to be the wife of such a one as Frank Gresham. They were in the habit of walking there together
when he happened to be at home of a summer's evening. This was not often the case, for his hours of labour
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN 50
Page No 54
extended much beyond those usual to the upper working world, the hours, namely, between breakfast and
dinner; but those minutes that they did thus pass together, the doctor regarded as perhaps the pleasantest of
his life.
'Uncle,' said she, after a while, 'what do you think of this marriage of Miss Gresham's?'
'Well, Minnie'such was his name of endearment for her'I can't say I have thought much about it, and I
don't suppose anybody else has either.'
'She must think about it, of course; and so must he, I suppose.'
'I'm not so sure of that. Some folks would never get married if they had to trouble themselves with thinking
about it.'
'I suppose that's why you never got married, uncle?'
'Either that, or thinking of it too much. One is as bad as the other.'
'Well, I have been thinking about it, at any rate, uncle.'
'That's very good of you; that will save me the trouble; and perhaps save Miss Gresham too. If you have
thought it over thoroughly, that will do for all.'
'I believe Mr Moffat is a man of no family.'
'He'll mend in that point, no doubt, when he has got a wife.'
'Uncle, you're a goose; and what is worse, a very provoking goose.'
'Niece, you're a gander; and what is worse, a very silly gander. What is Mr Moffat's family to you, and me?
Mr Moffat has that which ranks above family honours. He is a very rich man.'
'Yes,' said Mary, 'I know he is rich; and a rich man I suppose can buy anythingexcept a woman that is
worth having.'
'A rich man can buy anything,' said the doctor; 'not that I meant to say that Mr Moffat has bought Miss
Gresham. I have no doubt that they will suit each other very well,' he added with an air of decisive authority,
as though he had finished the subject.
But his niece was determined not to let him pass so. 'Now, uncle,'said she, 'you know you are pretending to a
great deal of worldly wisdom, which, after all, is not wisdom at all in your eyes.'
'Am I?'
'You know you are: and as for the impropriety of discussing Miss Gresham's marriage'
'I did not say it was improper.'
'Oh, yes, you did; of course such things must be discussed. How is one to have an opinion if one does not get
it by looking at the things that happen around us?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN 51
Page No 55
'Now I am going to be blown up,' said Dr Thorne.
'Dear uncle, do be serious with me.'
'Well, then, seriously, I hope Miss Gresham will be very happy as Mrs Moffat.'
'Of course you do: so do I. I hope it as much as I can hope what I don't at all see ground for expecting.'
'People constantly hope without any such ground.'
'Well, then, I'll hope in this case. But, uncle'
'Well, my dear?'
'I want your opinion, truly and really. If you were a girl'
'I am perfectly unable to give any opinion founded on so strange an hypothesis.'
'Well; but if you were a marrying man.'
'The hypothesis is quite as much out of my way.'
'But, uncle, I am a girl, and perhaps I may marry;or at any rate think of marrying some day.'
'The latter alternative is certainly possible enough.'
'Therefore, in seeing a friend taking such a step, I cannot but speculate on the matter as though I were myself
in her place. If I were Miss Gresham, should I be right?'
'But, Minnie, you are not Miss Gresham.'
'No, I am Mary Thorne; it is a very different thing, I know. I suppose I might marry any one without
degrading myself.'
It was almost illnatured of her to say this; but she had not meant to say it in the sense which the sounds
seemed to bear. She had failed in being able to bring her uncle to the point she wished by the road she had
planned, and in seeking another road, she had abruptly fallen into unpleasant places.
'I should be very sorry that my niece should think so,' said he; 'and am sorry, too, that she should say so. But,
Mary, to tell the truth, I hardly know at what you are driving. You are, I think, not so clear
mindedcertainly, not so clear wordedas is usual with you.'
'I will tell you, uncle;' and, instead of looking up into his face, she turned her eyes down on to the green lawn
beneath her feet.
'Well, Minnie, what is it?' and he took both her hands in his.
'I think that Miss Gresham should not marry Mr Moffat. I think so because her family is high and noble, and
because he is low and ignoble. When one has an opinion on such matters, one cannot but apply it to things
and people around one; and having applied my opinion to her, the next step naturally is to apply it to myself.
Were I Miss Gresham, I would not marry Mr Moffat though he rolled in gold. I know where to rank Miss
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN 52
Page No 56
Gresham. What I want to know is, where I ought to rank myself?'
They had been standing when she commenced he last speech; but as she finished it, the doctor moved on
again, and she moved with him. He walked on very slowly without answering her; and she, out of her full
mind, pursued aloud the tenor of her thoughts.
'That does not follow,' said the doctor quickly. 'A man raises a woman to his own standard, but a woman must
take that of her husband.'
Again they were silent, and again they walked on, Mary holding her uncle's arm with both her hands. She was
determined, however, to come to the point, and after considering for a while how best she might do it, she
ceased to beat any longer about the bush, and asked him a plain question.
'The Thornes are as good a family as the Greshams are they not?'
'In absolute genealogy they are, my dear. That is, when I choose to be an old fool and talk of such matters in a
sense different from that in which they are spoken of by the world at large, I may say that the Thornes are as
good, or perhaps better, than the Greshams, but I should be sorry to say so seriously to any one. The
Greshams now stand much higher in the county than the Thornes do.'
'But they are of the same class.'
'Yes, yes; Wilfred Thorne of Ullathorne, and our friend the squire here, are of the same class.'
'But, uncle, I and Augusta Greshamare we of the same class?'
'Well, Minnie, you would hardly have me boast that I am the same class with the squireI, a poor country
doctor?'
'You are not answering me fairly, dear uncle; dearest uncle, do you not know that you are not answering me
fairly? You know what I mean. Have I a right to call the Thornes of Ullathorne my cousins?'
'Mary, Mary, Mary!' said he after a minute's pause, still allowing his arm to hang loose, that she might hold it
with both her hands. 'Mary, Mary, Mary! I would that you had spared me this!'
'I could not have spared it to you for ever, uncle.'
'I would that you could have done so; I would that you could!'
'It is over now, uncle: it is told now. I will grieve you no more. Dear, dear, dearest! I should love you more
than ever now; I would, I would, I would if that were possible. What should I be but for you? What must I
have been but for you?' And she threw herself on his breast, and clinging with her arms round his neck,
kissed his forehead, cheeks, and lips.
There was nothing more said then on the subject between them. Mary asked no further question, nor did the
doctor volunteer further information. She would have been most anxious to ask about her mother's history
had she dared to do so; but she did not dare to ask; she could not bear to be told that her mother had been,
perhaps was, a worthless woman. That she was truly a daughter of a brother of the doctor, that she did know.
Little as she had heard of her relatives in her early youth, few as had been the words which had fallen from
her uncle in her hearing as to her parentage, she did know this, that she was the daughter of Henry Thorne, a
brother of the doctor, and a son of the old prebendary. Trifling little things that had occurred, accidents which
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN 53
Page No 57
could not be prevented, had told her this; but not a word had ever passed any one's lips as to her mother. The
doctor, when speaking of his youth, had spoken of her father; but no one had spoken of her mother. She had
long known that she was the child of a Thorne; now she knew also that she was no cousin of the Thornes of
Ullathorne; no cousin, at least, in the world's ordinary language, no niece indeed of her uncle, unless by his
special permission that she should be so.
When the interview was over, she went up alone to the drawingroom, and there she sat thinking. She had
not been there long before her uncle came up to her. He did not sit down, or even take off the hat which he
still wore; but coming close to her, and still standing, he spoke thus:
'Mary, after what has passed I should be very unjust and very cruel to you not to tell you one thing more than
you have now learned. Your mother was unfortunate in much, not in everything; but the world, which is very
often stern in such matters, never judged her to have disgraced herself. I tell you this, my child, in order that
you may respect her memory;' and so saying, he again left her without giving her time to speak a word.
What he then told her he had told in mercy. He felt what must be her feelings when she reflected that she had
to blush for her mother; that not only could she not speak of her mother, but that she might hardly think of
her with innocence; and to mitigate such sorrow as this, and also to do justice to the woman whom his brother
had so wronged, he had forced himself to reveal so much as is stated above.
And then he walked slowly by himself, backwards and forwards through the garden, thinking of what he had
done with reference to this girl, and doubting whether he had done wisely and well. He had resolved, when
first the little infant was given over to his charge, that nothing should be known of her or by her as to her
mother. He was willing to devote himself to this orphan child of his brother, this last seedling of his father's
house; but he was not willing so to do this as to bring himself in any manner into familiar contact with the
Scatcherds. He had boasted to himself that he, at any rate, was a gentleman; and that she, if she were to live
in his house, sit at his table, and share his hearth, must be a lady. He would tell no lie about her; he would not
to any one make her out to be aught other or aught better than she was; people would talk about her of course,
only let them not talk to him; he conceived of himselfand the conception was not without due
groundthat should any do so, he had that within him which would silence them. He would never claim for
this little creaturethus brought into the world without a legitimate position in which to standhe would
never claim for her any station that would not properly be her own. He would make for her a station as best
he could. As he might sink or swim, so should she.
So he had resolved; but things had arranged themselves, as they often do, rather than been arranged by him.
During ten or twelve years no one had heard of Mary Thorne; the memory of Henry Thorne and his tragic
death had passed away; the knowledge that an infant had been born whose birth was connected with that
tragedy, a knowledge never widely spread, had faded down into utter ignorance. At the end of these twelve
years, Dr Thorne had announced, that a young niece, a child of a brother long since dead, was coming to live
with him. As he had contemplated, no one spoke to him; but some people did no doubt talk among
themselves. Whether or not the exact truth was surmised by any, it matters not to say; with absolute
exactness, probably not; with great approach to it, probably yes. By one person, at any rate, no guess
whatever was made; no thought relative to Dr Thorne's niece ever troubled him; no idea that Mary Scatcherd
had left a child in England ever occurred to him; and that person was Roger Scatcherd, Mary's brother.
To one friend, and only one, did the doctor tell the whole truth, and that was to the old squire. 'I have told
you,' said the doctor, 'partly that you may know that the child has no right to mix with your children if you
think much of such things. Do you, however, see to this. I would rather that no one else should be told.'
No one else had been told; and the squire had 'seen to it,' by accustoming himself to look at Mary Thorne
running about the house with his own children as though she were of the same brood. Indeed, the squire had
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN 54
Page No 58
always been fond of Mary, had personally noticed her, and, in the affair of Mam'selle Larron, had declared
that he would have her placed at once on the bench of magistrates;much to the disgust of the Lady
Arabella.
And so things had gone on and on, and had not been thought of with much downright thinking; till now,
when she was oneandtwenty years of age, his niece came to him, asking as to her position, and inquiring in
what rank of life she was to find a husband.
And so the doctor walked, backwards and forwards through the garden, slowly, thinking now with some
earnestness what if, after all, he had been wrong about his niece? What if by endeavouring to place her in the
position of a lady, he had falsely so placed her, and robbed her of her legitimate position? What if there was
no rank of life in which she could now properly attach herself?
And then, how had it answered, that plan of his of keeping her all to himself? He, Dr Thorne, was still a poor
man; the gift of saving money had not been his; he had ever a comfortable house for her to live in, and, in
spite of Doctors Fillgrave, Century, Rerechild, and others, had made from his profession an income sufficient
for their joint wants; but he had not done as others do: he had no three or four thousand pounds in the Three
per Cents., on which Mary might live in some comfort when he should die. Late in life he had insured his life
for eight hundred pounds; and to that, and that only, had he to trust for Mary's future maintenance. How had
it answered, then, this plan of letting her be unknown to, and undreamed of, by, those who were as near to her
on her mother's side as he was on the father's? On that side, though there had been utter poverty, there was
now absolute wealth.
But when he took her to himself, had he not rescued her from the very depths of the lowest misery: from the
degradation of the workhouse; from the scorn of honestborn charitychildren; from the lowest of the world's
low conditions? Was she not now the apple of his eye, his one great sovereign comforthis pride, his
happiness, his glory? Was he to make her over, to make any portion of her over to others, if, by doing so, she
might be able to share the wealth, as well as the coarse manners and uncouth society of her at present
unknown connexions? He, who had never worshipped wealth on his own behalf; he, who had scorned the idol
of the gold, and had ever been teaching her to scorn it; was he now to show that his philosophy had all been
false as soon as the temptation to do so was put in his way?
But yet, what man would marry this bastard child, without a sixpence, and bring not only poverty, but ill
blood also on his own children? It might be very well for him, Dr Thorne; for him whose career was made,
whose name, at any rate, was his own; for him who had a fixed standingground in the world; it might be
well for him to indulge in large views of a philosophy antagonistic to the world's practice; but had he a right
to do it for his niece? What man would marry a girl so placed? For those among whom she might have
legitimately found a level, education had now utterly unfitted her. And then, he well knew that she would
never put out her hand in token of love to any one without telling all she knew and all she surmised as to her
own birth.
And that question of this evening; had it not been instigated by some appeal on her part? Was there not
already within her breast some cause for disquietude which had made her so pertinacious? Why else had she
told him then, for the first time, that she did not know where to rank herself? If such an appeal had been made
to her, it must have come from young Frank Gresham. What, in such case, would it behove him to do?
Should he pack up his all, his lancetcase, pestle and mortar, and seek anew fresh ground in a new world,
leaving behind a huge triumph to those learned enemies of his, Fillgrave, Century, and Rerechild? Better that
than remain at Greshamsbury at the cost of the child's heart and pride.
And so he walked slowly backwards and forwards through his garden, meditating these things painfully
enough.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN 55
Page No 59
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS
It will of course be remembered that Mary's interview with the other girls at Greshamsbury took place some
two or three days subsequently to Frank's generous offer of his hand and heart. Mary had quite made up her
mind that the whole thing was to be regarded as a folly, and that it was not to be spoken of to any one; but yet
her heart was sore enough. She was full of pride, and yet she knew she must bow her neck to the pride of
others. Being, as she was herself, nameless, she could not but feel a stern, unflinching antagonism, the
antagonism of a democrat, to the pretensions of others who were blessed with that of which she had been
deprived. She had this feeling; and yet, of all the things that she coveted, she most coveted that, for glorying
in which, she was determined to heap scorn on others. She said to herself, proudly, that God's handiwork was
the inner man, the inner woman, the naked creature animated by a living soul; that all other adjuncts were but
man's clothing for the creature; all others, whether stitched by tailors or contrived by kings. Was it not within
her capacity to do as nobly, to love as truly, to worship her God in heaven with as perfect a faith, and her god
on earth with as leal a troth, as though blood had descended to her purely through scores of purely born
progenitors? So to herself she spoke; and yet, as she said it, she knew that were she a man, such a man as the
heir of Greshamsbury should be, nothing would tempt her to sully her children's blood by mating herself with
any one that was base born. She felt that were she Augusta Gresham, no Mr Moffat, let his wealth be what it
might, should win her hand unless he too could tell of family honours and a line of ancestors.
And so, with a mind at war with itself, she came forth armed to do battle against the world's prejudices, those
prejudices she herself loved so well.
And was she thus to give up her old affections, her feminine loves, because she found that she was a cousin to
nobody? Was she no longer to pour out her heart to Beatrice Gresham with all the girlish volubility of an
equal? Was she to be severed from Patience Oriel, and banishedor rather was she to banish herselffrom
the free place she had maintained in the various youthful female conclaves within that parish of
Greshamsbury?
Hitherto, what Mary Thorne would say, what Miss Thorne suggested in such and such a matter, was quite as
frequently asked as any opinion from Augusta Greshamquite as frequently, unless when it chanced that
any of the De Courcy girls were at the house. Was this to be given up? These feelings had grown up among
them since they were children, and had not hitherto been questioned among them. Now they were questioned
by Mary Thorne. Was she in fact to find that her position had been a false one, and must be changed?
Such had been her feelings when she protested that she would not be Augusta Gresham's bridesmaid, and
offered to put her neck beneath Beatrice's foot; when she drove the Lady Margaretta out of the room, and
gave her own opinion as to the proper grammatical construction of the word humble; such also had been her
feelings when she kept her hand so rigidly to herself while Frank held the diningroom door open for her to
pass through.
'Patience Oriel,' said she to herself, 'can talk to him of her father and mother: let Patience take his hand; let
her talk to him;' and then, not long afterwards, she saw that Patience did talk to him; and seeing it, she walked
along silent, among some of the old people, and with much effort did prevent a tear from falling down her
cheek.
But why was the tear in her eye? Had she not proudly told Frank that his lovemaking was nothing but a
boy's silly rhapsody? Had she not said so while she had yet reason to hope that her blood was as good as his
own? Had she not seen at a glance that his love tirade was worthy of ridicule, and of no other notice? And yet
there was a tear now in her eye because this boy, whom she had scolded from her, whose hand, offered in
pure friendship, she had just refused, because he, so rebuffed by her, had carried his fun and gallantry to one
who would be less cross to him!
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS 56
Page No 60
She could hear as she was walking, that while Lady Margaretta was with them, their voices were loud and
merry; and her sharp ear could also hear, when Lady Margaretta left them, that Frank's voice became low and
tender. So she walked on, saying nothing, looking straight before her, and by degrees separating herself from
all the others.
The Greshamsbury grounds were on one side somewhat too closely hemmed in by the village. On this side
was a path running the length of one of the streets of the village; and far down the path, near the extremity of
the gardens, and near also to a wicketgate which led out into the village, and which could be opened from
the inside, was a seat, under a big yewtree, from which, through a breach in the houses, might be seen the
parish church, standing in the park on the other side. Hither Mary walked alone, and here she seated herself,
determined to get rid of her tears and their traces before she again showed herself to the world.
'I shall never be happy here again,' said she to herself; 'never. I am no longer one of them, and I cannot live
among them unless I am so.' And then an idea came across her mind that she hated Patience Oriel; and then,
instantly another idea followedquick as such thoughts are quickthat she did not hate Patience Oriel at
all; that she liked her, nay, loved her; that Patience Oriel was a sweet girl; and that she hoped the time would
come when she might see her the lady of Greshamsbury. And then the tear, which had been no whit
controlled, which indeed had now made itself master of her, came to a head, and, bursting through the
floodgates of the eye, came rolling down, and in its fall, wetted her hand as it lay on her lap. 'What a fool!
what an idiot! what an emptyheaded cowardly fool I am!' said she, springing up from the bench on her feet.
As she did so, she heard voices close to her, at the little gate. They were those of her uncle and Frank
Gresham.
'God bless you, Frank!' said the doctor, as he passed out of the grounds. 'You will excuse a lecture, won't you,
from so old a friend?though you are a man now, and discreet of course, by Act of Parliament.'
'Indeed I will, doctor,' said Frank. 'I will excuse a longer lecture than that from you.'
'At any rate it won't be tonight,' said the doctor, as he disappeared. 'And if you see Mary, tell her that I am
obliged to go; and that I will send Janet down to fetch her.'
Now Janet was the doctor's ancient maidservant.
Mary could not move on, without being perceived; she therefore stood still till she heard the click of the door,
and then began walking rapidly back to the house by the path which had brought her thither. The moment,
however, that she did so, she found that she was followed; and in a very few moments Frank was alongside of
her.
'Oh, Mary!' said he, calling to her, but not loudly, before he quite overtook her, 'how odd that I should come
across you just when I have a message for you! and why are you all alone?'
Mary's first impulse was to reiterate her command to him to call her no more by her Christian name; but her
second impulse told her that such an injunction at the present moment would not be prudent on her part. The
traces of her tears were still there; and she well knew that a very little, the slightest show of tenderness on his
part, the slightest effort on her own to appear indifferent, would bring down more than one other such
intruder. It would, moreover, be better for her to drop all outward sign that she remembered what had taken
place. So long, then, as he and she were at Greshamsbury together, he should call her Mary if he pleased. He
would soon be gone; and while he remained, she would keep out of his way.
'Your uncle has been obliged to go away to see an old woman at Silverbridge.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS 57
Page No 61
'At Silverbridge! why, he won't be back all night. Why could not the old woman send for Dr Century?'
'I suppose she thought two old women could not get on well together.'
Mary could not help smiling. She did not like her uncle going off so late on such a journey; but it was always
felt a triumph when he was invited into the strongholds of the enemies.
'And Janet is to come over for you. However, I told him it was quite unnecessary to disturb another old
woman, for that I should see you home.'
'Oh, no, Mr Gresham; indeed you'll not do that.'
'Indeed, and indeed, I shall.'
'What! on this great day, when every lady is looking for you, and talking of you. I suppose you want to set the
countess against me for ever. Think, too, how angry Lady Arabella will be if you are absent on such and
errand as this.'
'To hear you talk, Mary, one would think that you were going to Silverbridge yourself.'
'Perhaps I am.'
'If I did not go with you, some of the other fellows would. John, or George'
'Good gracious, Frank! Fancy either of the Mr De Courceys walking home with me!'
She had forgotten herself, and the strict propriety on which she had resolved, in the impossibility of forgoing
her little joke against the De Courcy grandeur; she had forgotten herself, and had called him Frank in her old,
former, eager, free tone of voice; and then, remembering she had done so, she drew herself up, but her lips,
and determined to be doubly on her guard in the future.
'Well, it shall be either one of them, or I,' said Frank: 'perhaps you would prefer my cousin George to me?'
'I should prefer Janet to either, seeing that with her I should not suffer the extreme nuisance of knowing that I
was a bore.'
'A bore! Mary, to me?'
'Yes, Mr Gresham, a bore to you. Having to walk home through the mud with village young ladies is boring.
All gentlemen feel it so.'
'There is no mud; if there were you would not be allowed to walk at all.'
'Oh! village young ladies never care for such things, though fashionable gentlemen do.'
'I would carry you home, Mary, if it would do you a service,' said Frank, with considerable pathos in his
voice.
'Oh, dear me! pray do not, Mr Gresham. I should not like it at all,' said she: 'a wheelbarrow would be
preferable to that.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS 58
Page No 62
'Of course. Anything would be preferable to my arm, I know.'
'Certainly; anything in the way of a conveyance. If I were to act baby; and you were to act nurse, it really
would not be comfortable for either of us.'
Frank Gresham felt disconcerted, though he hardly knew why. He was striving to say something tender to his
ladylove; but every word that he spoke she turned into joke. Mary did not answer him coldly or unkindly;
but, nevertheless, he was displeased. One does not like to have one's little offerings of sentimental service
turned into burlesque when one is in love in earnest. Mary's jokes had appeared so easy too; they seemed to
come from a heart so little troubled. This, also, was cause of vexation to Frank. If he could but have known it
all, he would, perhaps, have been better pleased.
He determined not to be absolutely laughed out of his tenderness. When, three days ago, he had been
repulsed, he had gone away owning to himself that he had been beaten; owning so much, but owning it with
great sorrow and much shame. Since that he had come of age; since that he had made speeches, and speeches
had been made to him; since that he had gained courage by flirting with Patience Oriel. No faint heart ever
won a fair lady, as he was well aware; he resolved, therefore, that his heart should not be faint, and that he
would see whether the fair lady might not be won by becoming audacity.
'Mary,' said he, stopping in the pathfor they were now near the spot where it broke out upon the lawn, and
they could already hear the voices of the guests'Mary, you are unkind to me.'
'I am not aware of it, Mr Gresham; but if I am, do not you retaliate. I am weaker than you, and in your power;
do not you, therefore, be unkind to me.'
'You refused my hand just now,' continued he. 'Of all the people here at Greshamsbury, you are the only one
that has not wished me joy; the only one'
'I do wish you joy; I will wish you joy: there is my hand,' and she frankly put out her ungloved hand. 'You are
quite man enough to understand me: there is my hand; I trust you use it only as it is meant to be used.'
He took it in his hand and pressed it cordially, as he might have done that of any other friend in such a case;
and thendid not drop it as he should have done. He was not a St Anthony, and it was most imprudent in
Miss Thorne to subject him to such a temptation.
'Mary,' said he; 'dear Mary! dearest Mary! if you did but know how I love you!'
As he said this, holding Miss Thorne's hand he stood on the pathway with his back towards the lawn and
house, and, therefore, did not at first see his sister Augusta, who had just at that moment come upon them.
Mary blushed up to her straw hat, and, with a quick jerk, recovered her hand. Augusta saw the motion, and
Mary saw that Augusta had seen it.
From my tedious way of telling it, the reader will be led to imagine that the handsqueezing had been
protracted to a duration quite incompatible with any objection to such an arrangement on the part of the lady;
but the fault is mine: in no part hers. Were I possessed of a quick spasmodic style of narrative, I should have
been able to include it allFrank's misbehaviour, Mary's immediate anger, Augusta's arrival, and keen,
Arguseyed inspection, and then Mary's subsequent miseryin five words and half a dozen dashes and
inverted commas. The thing would have been so told; for, to do Mary justice, she did not leave her hand in
Frank's a moment longer than she could help herself.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS 59
Page No 63
Frank, feeling the hand withdrawn, and hearing, when it was too late, the step on the gravel, turned sharply
round. 'Oh, it's you, is it, Augusta? Well, what do you want?'
Augusta was not naturally very illnatured, seeing that in her veins the high De Courcy blood was somewhat
tempered by an admixture of the Gresham attributes; nor was she predisposed to make her brother her enemy
by publishing to the world any of his little tender peccadilloes; but she could not but bethink herself of what
her aunt had been saying as to the danger of any such encounters as that she just now had beheld; she could
not but start at seeing her brother thus, on the very brink of the precipice of which the countess had specially
forewarned her mother. She, Augusta, was, as she well knew, doing her duty by her family by marrying a
tailor's son for whom she did not care a chip, seeing that the tailor's son was possessed of untold wealth. Now
when one member of a household is making a struggle for a family, it is painful to see the benefit of that
struggle negatived by the folly of another member. The future Mrs Moffat did feel aggrieved by the fatuity of
the young heir, and, consequently, took upon herself to look as much like her Aunt De Courcy as she could
do.
'Well, what is it?' said Frank, looking rather disgusted. 'What makes you stick your chin up and look in that
way?' Frank had hitherto been rather a despot among his sisters, and forgot that the eldest of them was now
passing altogether from under his sway to that of the tailor's son.
'Frank,' said Augusta, in a tone of voice which did honour to the great lessons she had lately received. 'Aunt
De Courcy wants to see you immediately in the small drawingroom;' and, as she said so, she resolved to say
a few words of advice to Miss Thorne as soon as her brother should have left them.
'In the small drawingroom, does she? Well, Mary, we may as well go together, for I suppose it is teatime
now.'
'You had better go at once, Frank,' said Augusta; 'the countess will be angry if you keep her waiting. She has
been expecting you these twenty minutes. Mary Thorne and I can return together.'
There was something in the tone in which the word, 'Mary Thorne', were uttered, which made Mary at once
draw herself up. 'I hope,' said she, 'that Mary Thorne will never be a hindrance to either of you.'
Frank's ear had also perceived that there was something in the tone of his sister's voice not boding comfort to
Mary; he perceived that the De Courcy blood in Augusta's veins was already rebelling against the doctor's
niece on his part, though it had condescended to submit itself to the tailor's son on her own part.
'Well, I am going,' said he; 'but look here Augusta, if you say one word of Mary'
Oh, Frank! Frank! you boy, you very boy! you goose, you silly goose! Is that the way you make love,
desiring one girl not to tell another, as though you were three children, tearing your frocks and trousers in
getting through the same hedge together? Oh, Frank! Frank! you, the fullblown heir of Greshamsbury? You,
a man already endowed with a man's discretion? You, the forward rider, that did but now threaten young
Harry Baker and the Honourable John to eclipse them by prowess in the field? You, of age? Why, thou canst
not as yet have left thy mother's apronstring.
'If you say one word of Mary'
So far had he got in his injunction to his sister, but further than that, in such a case, was he never destined to
proceed. Mary's indignation flashed upon him, striking him dumb long before the sound of her voice reached
his ears; and yet she spoke as quick as the words would come to her call, and somewhat loudly too.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS 60
Page No 64
'Say one word of Mary, Mr Gresham! And why should she not say as many words of Mary as she may
please? I must tell you all now, Augusta! and I must also beg you not to be silent for my sake. As far as I am
concerned, tell it to whom you please. This was the second time your brother'
'Mary, Mary,' said Frank, deprecating her loquacity.
'I beg your pardon, Mr Gresham; you have made it necessary that I should tell your sister all. He has now
twice thought it well to amuse himself by saying to me words which it was illnatured in him to speak,
and'
'Illnatured, Mary!'
'Illnatured in him to speak,' continued Mary, 'and to which it would be absurd for me to listen. He probably
does the same to others,' she added, being unable in heart to forget that sharpest of her wounds, that flirtation
of his with Patience Oriel; 'but to me it is almost cruel. Another girl might laugh at him, or listen to him, as he
would choose; but I can do neither. I shall now keep away from Greshamsbury, at any rate till he has left it;
and, Augusta, I can only beg you to understand, that, as far as I am concerned, there is nothing which may not
be told to all the world.'
And, so saying, she walked on a little in advance of them, as proud as a queen. Had Lady de Courcy herself
met her at this moment, she would almost have felt herself forced to shrink out of the pathway. 'Not say a
word of me!' she repeated to herself, but still out loud. 'No word need be left unsaid on my account; none,
none.'
Augusta followed her, dumfounded at her indignation; and Frank also followed, but not in silence. When his
first surprise at Mary's great anger was over, he felt himself called upon to say some word that might
exonerate his ladylove; and some word also of protestation as to his own purpose.
'There is nothing to be told, at least of Mary,' he said, speaking to his sister; 'but of me, you may tell this, if
you choose to disoblige your brotherthat I love Mary Thorne with all my heart; and that I will never love
anyone else.'
By this time they had reached the lawn, and Mary was able to turn away from the path which led up to the
house. As she left them she said in a voice, now low enough, 'I cannot prevent him from talking nonsense,
Augusta; but you will bear me witness, that I do not willingly hear it.' And, so saying, she started off almost
in a run towards the distant part of the gardens, in which she saw Beatrice.
Frank, as he walked up to the house with his sister, endeavoured to induce her to give him a promise that she
would tell no tales as to what she had heard and seen.
'Of course, Frank, it must be all nonsense,' she had said; 'and you shouldn't amuse yourself in such a way.'
'Well, but, Guss, come, we have always been friends; don't let us quarrel just when you are going to be
married.' But Augusta would make no promise.
Frank, when he reached the house, found the countess waiting for him, sitting in the little drawingroom by
herself,somewhat impatiently. As he entered he became aware that there was some peculiar gravity
attached to the coming interview. Three persons, his mother, one of his younger sisters, and the Lady Amelia,
each stopped him to let him know that the countess was waiting; and he perceived that a sort of guard was
kept upon the door to save her ladyship from any undesirable intrusion.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS 61
Page No 65
The countess frowned at the moment of his entrance, but soon smoothed her brow, and invited him to take a
chair ready prepared for him opposite to the elbow of the sofa on which she was leaning. She had a small
table before her, on which was her teacup, so that she was able to preach at him nearly as well as though she
had been ensconced in a pulpit.
'My dear Frank,' said she, in a voice thoroughly suitable to the importance of the communication, 'you have
today come of age.'
Frank remarked that he understood that such was the case, and added that 'that was the reason for all the fuss.'
'Yes; you have today come of age. Perhaps I should have been glad to see such an occasion noticed at
Greshamsbury with some more suitable signs of rejoicing.'
'Oh, aunt! I think we did it all very well.'
'Greshamsbury, Frank, is, or at any rate ought to be, the seat of the first commoner in Barsetshire.
'Well; so it is. I am quite sure there isn't a better fellow than father anywhere in the county.'
The countess sighed. Her opinion of the poor squire was very different from Frank's. 'It is no use now,' said
she, 'looking back to that which cannot be cured. The first commoner in Barsetshire should hold a
positionI will not of course say equal to that of a peer.'
'Oh dear no; of course not,' said Frank; and a bystander might have thought that there was a touch of satire in
his tone.
'No, not equal to that of a peer; but still of very paramount importance. Of course my first ambition is bound
up in Porlock.'
'Of course,' said Frank, thinking how very weak was the staff on which his aunt's ambition rested; for Lord
Porlock's youthful career had not been such as to give unmitigated satisfaction to his parents.
'Is bound up in Porlock:' and then the countess plumed herself; but the mother sighed. 'And next to Porlock,
my anxiety is about you.'
'Upon my honour, aunt, I am very much obliged. I shall be all right, you know.'
'Greshamsbury, my dear boy, is not now what it used to be.'
'Isn't it?' asked Frank.
'No, Frank; by no means. I do not wish to say a word against your father. It may, perhaps have been his
misfortune, rather than his fault'
'She is always down on the governor; always,' said Frank to himself; resolving to stick bravely to the side of
the house to which he had elected to belong.
'But there is the fact, Frank, too plain to us all; Greshamsbury is not what it was. It is your duty to restore it to
its former importance.'
'My duty!' said Frank, rather puzzled.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS 62
Page No 66
'Yes, Frank, your duty. It all depends on you now. Of course you know that your father owes a great deal of
money.'
Frank muttered something. Tidings had in some shape reached his ear that his father was not comfortably
circumstances as regards money.
'And then, he has sold Boxall Hill. It cannot be expected that Boxall Hill shall be purchased, as some horrid
man, a railwaymaker, I believe'
'Yes; that's Scatcherd.'
'Well, he has built a house there, I'm told; so I presume that it cannot be bought back: but it will be your duty,
Frank, to pay all the debts that there are on the property, and to purchase what, at any rate, will be equal to
Boxall Hill.'
Frank opened his eyes wide and stared at his aunt, as though doubting much whether or no she were in her
right mind. He pay off the family debts! He buy up property of four thousand pounds a year! He remained,
however, quite quiet, waiting the elucidation of the mystery.
'Frank, of course you understand me.'
Frank was obliged to declare, that just at the present moment he did not find his aunt so clear as usual.
'You have but one line of conduct left you, Frank: your position, as heir to Greshamsbury, is a good one; but
your father has unfortunately so hampered you with regard to money, that unless you set the matter right
yourself, you can never enjoy that position. Of course you must marry money.'
'Marry money!' said he, considering for the first time that in all probability Mary Thorne's fortune would not
be extensive. 'Marry money!'
'Yes, Frank. I know no man whose position so imperatively demands it; and luckily for you, no man can have
more facility for doing so. In the first place you are very handsome.'
Frank blushed like a girl of sixteen.
'And then, as the matter is made plain to you at so early an age, you are not of course hampered by any
indiscreet tie; by any absurd engagement.'
Frank blushed again; and then saying to himself, 'How much the old girl knows about it!' felt a little proud of
his passion for Mary Thorne, and of the declaration he had made to her.
'And your connexion with Courcy Castle,' continued the countess, now carrying up the list of Frank's
advantages to its greatest climax, 'will make the matter so easy for you, that really, you will hardly have any
difficulty.'
Frank could not but say how much obliged he felt to Courcy Castle and its inmates.
'Of course I would not wish to interfere with you in any underhand way, Frank; but I will tell you what has
occurred to me. You have heard, probably, of Miss Dunstable?'
'The daughter of the ointment of Lebanon man?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS 63
Page No 67
'And of course you know that her fortune is immense,' continued the countess, not deigning to notice her
nephew's allusion to the ointment. 'Quite immense when compared with the wants and any position of any
commoner. Now she is coming to Courcy Castle, and I wish you to come and meet her.'
'But, aunt, just at this moment I have to read for my degree like anything. I go up, you know, to Oxford.'
'Degree!' said the countess. 'Why, Frank, I am talking to you of your prospects in life, of your future position,
of that on which everything hangs, and you tell me of your degree!'
Frank, however, obstinately persisted that he must take his degree, and that he should commence reading hard
at six a.m. tomorrow morning.
'You can read just as well at Courcy Castle. Miss Dunstable will not interfere with that,' said his aunt, who
knew the expediency of yielding occasionally; 'but I must beg you will come over and meet her. You will
find her a most charming young woman, remarkably well educated I am told, and'
'How old is she?' asked Frank.
'I really cannot say exactly,' said the countess; 'but it is not, I imagine, a matter of much moment.'
'Is she thirty?' asked Frank, who looked upon an unmarried woman of that age as quite an old maid.
'I dare say she may be about that age,' said the countess, who regarded the subject from a very different point
of view.
'Thirty!' said Frank out loud, but speaking, nevertheless as though to himself.
'It is a matter of no moment,' said his aunt, almost angrily. 'When a subject itself is of such vital importance,
objections of no real weight should not be brought into view. If you wish to hold up your head in the country;
if you wish to represent your county in Parliament, as has been done by your father, your grandfather, and
your greatgrandfathers; if you wish to keep a house over your head, and to leave Greshamsbury to your son
after you, you must marry money. What does it signify whether Miss Dunstable be twentyeight or thirty?
She has got money; and if you marry her, you may then consider that your position in life is made.'
Frank was astonished at his aunt's eloquence; but, in spite of that eloquence, he made up his mind that he
would not marry Miss Dunstable. How could he, indeed, seeing that his troth was already plighted to Mary
Thorne in the presence of his sister? This circumstance, however, he did not choose to plead to his aunt, so he
recapitulated any other objections that presented themselves to his mind.
In the first place, he was so anxious about his degree that he could not think of marrying at present; then he
suggested that it might be better to postpone the question till the season's hunting should be over; he declared
that he could not visit Courcy Castle till he got a new suit of clothes home from the tailor; and ultimately
remembered that he had a particular engagement to go flyfishing with Mr Oriel on that day week.
None, however, of these valid reasons were sufficiently potent to turn the countess from her point.
'Nonsense, Frank,' said she, 'I wonder that you can talk of flyfishing when the property of Greshamsbury is
at stake. You will go with Augusta and myself to Courcy Castle tomorrow.'
'Tomorrow, aunt!' he said, in the tone which a condemned criminal might make his ejaculation on hearing
that a very near day had been named for his execution. 'Tomorrow!'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS 64
Page No 68
'Yes, we return tomorrow, and shall be happy to have your company. My friends, including Miss Dunstable,
come on Thursday. I am quite sure you will like Miss Dunstable. I have settled all that with your mother, so
we need say nothing further about it. And now, goodnight, Frank.'
Frank, finding that there was nothing more to be said, took his departure, and went out to look for Mary. But
Mary had gone home with Janet half an hour since, so he betook himself to his sister Beatrice.
'Beatrice,' said he, 'I am to go to Courcy Castle tomorrow.'
'So I heard mamma say.'
'Well; I only came of age today, and I will not begin by running counter to them. But I tell you what, I won't
stay above a week at Courcy Castle for all the De Courcys in Barsetshire. Tell me, Beatrice, did you ever hear
of a Miss Dunstable?'
CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD
Enough has been said in this narrative to explain to the reader that Roger Scatcherd, who was whilom a
drunken stonemason in Barchester, and who had been so prompt to avenge the injury done to his sister, had
become a great man in the world. He had become a contractor, first for little things, such as half a mile or so
of a railway embankment, or three or four canal bridges, and then a contractor for great things, such as
Government hospitals, locks, docks, and quays, and had latterly had in his hands the making of whole lines of
railway.
He had been occasionally in partnership with one man for one thing, and then with another for another; but
had, on the whole, kept his interests to himself, and now at the time of our story, he was a very rich man.
And he had acquired more than wealth. There had been a time when the Government wanted the immediate
performance of some extraordinary piece of work, and Roger Scatcherd had been the man to do it. There had
been some extremely necessary bit of a railway to be made in half the time that such work would properly
demand, some speculation to be incurred requiring great means and courage as well, and Roger Scatcherd
had been found to be the man for the time. He was then elevated for the moment to the dizzy pinnacle of a
newspaper hero, and became one of those 'whom the king delighteth to honour'. He went up one day to kiss
Her Majesty's hand, and come down to his new grand house at Boxall Hill, Sir Roger Scatcherd, Bart.
'And now, my lady,' said he, when he explained to his wife the high state to which she had been called by his
exertions and the Queen's prerogative, 'let's have a bit of dinner, and a drop of som'at hot.' Now the drop of
som'at hot signified a dose of alcohol sufficient to send three ordinary men very drunk to bed.
While conquering the world Roger Scatcherd had not conquered his old bad habits. Indeed, he was the same
man at all points that he had been when formerly seen about the streets of Barchester with his stonemason's
apron tucked up round his waist. The apron he had abandoned, but not the heavy prominent thoughtful brow,
with the wildly flashing eye beneath it. He was still the same good companion, and still also the same
hardworking hero. In this only had he changed, that now he would work, and some said equally well,
whether he were drunk or sober. Those who were mostly inclined to make a miracle of himand there was a
school of worshippers ready to adore him as their idea of a divine, superhuman, miraclemoving, inspired
prophetdeclared that his wondrous work was best done, his calculations most quickly and most truly made,
that he saw with most accurate eye into the fardistant balance of profit and loss, when he was under the
influence of the rosy god. To these worshippers his breakingsout, as his periods of intemperance were called
in his own set, were his moments of peculiar inspirationhis divine frenzies, in which he communicated
most closely with those deities who preside over trade transactions; his Eleusinian mysteries, to approach him
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD 65
Page No 69
in which was permitted only a few of the most favoured.
'Scatcherd has been drunk this week past,' they would say one to another, when the moment came at which it
was to be decided whose offer should be accepted for constructing a harbour to hold all the commerce of
Lancashire, or to make a railway from Bombay to Canton. 'Scatcherd has been drunk this week past; I am
told that he has taken over three gallons of brandy.' And then they felt sure that none but Scatcherd would be
called upon to construct the dock or make the railway.
But be this as it may, be it true or false that Sir Roger was most efficacious when in his cups, there can be no
doubt that he could not wallow for a week in brandy, six or seven times every year, without in a great
measure injuring, and permanently injuring, the outward man. Whatever immediate effect such symposiums
might have on the inner mind symposiums indeed they were not; posiums I will call them, if I may be
allowed; for in latter life, when he drank heavily, he drank alonehowever little for evil, or however much
for good the working of his brain might be affected, his body suffered greatly. It was not that he became
feeble or emaciated, oldlooking or inactive, that his hand shook, or that his eye was watery; but that in the
moments of his intemperance his life was often worth a day's purchase. The frame which God had given to
him was powerful beyond the power of ordinary men; powerful to act in spite of these violent perturbations;
powerful to repress and conquer the qualms and headaches and inward sicknesses to which the votaries of
Bacchus are ordinarily subject; but this power was not without its limit. If encroached on too far, it would
break and fall and come asunder, and then the strong man would at once become a corpse.
Scatcherd had but one friend in the world. And, indeed, this friend was not friend in the ordinary acceptance
of the word. He neither ate with him nor drank with him, nor even frequently talked with him. Their pursuits
in life were wide asunder. Their tastes were all different. The society in which they moved very seldom came
together. Scatcherd had nothing in unison with this solitary friend; but he trusted him, and he trusted no other
living creature in God's earth.
He trusted this man; but even him he did not trust thoroughly; not at least as one friend should trust another.
He believed that this man would not rob him; would probably not lie to him; would not endeavour to make
money of him; would not count him up or speculate on him, and make out a balance of profit and loss; and,
therefore, he determined to use him. But he put no trust whatever in his friend's counsel, in his modes of
thought; none in his theory, and none in his practice. He disliked his friend's counsel, and, in fact, disliked his
society, for his friend was somewhat apt to speak to him in a manner approaching to severity. Now Roger
Scatcherd had done many things in the world, and made much money; whereas his friend had done but few
things, and made no money. It was not to be endured that the practical, efficient man should be taken to task
by the man who proved himself to be neither practical nor efficient; not to be endured, certainly, by Roger
Scatcherd, who looked on men of his own class as the men of the day, and on himself as by no means the
least among them.
The friend was our friend Dr Thorne.
The doctor's first acquaintance with Scatcherd has been already explained. He was necessarily thrown into
communication with the man at the time of the trial, and Scatcherd then had not only sufficient sense, but
sufficient feeling also to know that the doctor behaved very well. This communication had in different ways
been kept up between them. Soon after the trial Scatcherd had begun to rise, and his first savings had been
entrusted to the doctor's care. This had been the beginning of a pecuniary connexion which had never wholly
ceased, and which had led to the purchase of Boxall Hill, and to the loan of large sums of money to the
squire.
In another way also there had been a close alliance between them, and one not always of a very pleasant
description. The doctor was, and long had been, Sir Roger's medical attendant, and, in his unceasing attempts
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD 66
Page No 70
to rescue the drunkard from the fate which was so much to be dreaded, he not unfrequently was driven to
quarrel with his patient.
One thing further must be told of Sir Roger. In politics he was as violent a Radical as ever, and was very
anxious to obtain a position in which he could bring his violence to bear. With this view he was about to
contest his native borough of Barchester, in the hope of being returned in opposition to the De Courcy
candidate; and with this object he had now come down to Boxall Hill.
Nor were his claims to sit for Barchester such as could be despised. If money were to be of no avail, he had
plenty of it, and was prepared to spend it; whereas, rumour said that Mr Moffat was equally determined to do
nothing so foolish. Then again, Sir Roger had a sort of rough eloquence, and was bold to address the men of
Barchester in language that would come home to their hearts, in words that would endear him to one party
while they made him offensively odious to the other; but Mr Moffat could make neither friends nor enemies
by his eloquence. The Barchester roughs called him a dumb dog that could not bark, and sometimes
sarcastically added that neither could he bite. The De Courcy interest, however, was at his back, and he had
also the advantage of possession. Sir Roger, therefore, knew that the battle was not to be won without a
struggle.
Dr Thorne got safely back from Silverbridge that evening, and found Mary waiting to give him his tea. He
had been called there to a consultation with Dr Century, that amiable old gentleman having so far fallen away
from the high Fillgrave tenets as to consent to the occasional endurance of such degradation.
The next morning he breakfasted early, and, having mounted his strong irongrey cob, started for Boxall Hill.
Not only had he there to negotiate the squire's further loan, but also to exercise his medical skill. Sir Roger
having been declared contractor for cutting a canal from sea to sea, through the isthmus of Panama, had been
making a week of it; and the result was that Lady Scatcherd had written rather peremptorily to her husband's
medical friend.
The doctor consequently trotted off to Boxall Hill on his irongrey cob. Among his other merits was that of
being a good horseman, and he did much of his work on horseback. The fact that he occasionally took a day
with the East Barsetshires, and that when he did so he thoroughly enjoyed it, had probably not failed to add
something to the strength of the squire's friendship.
'Well, my lady, how is he? Not much the matter, I hope?' said the doctor, as he shook hands with the titled
mistress of Boxall Hill in a small breakfastparlour in the rear of the house. The showrooms of Boxall Hill
were furnished most magnificently, but they were set apart for company; and as the company never
cameseeing that they were never invitedthe grand rooms and the grand furniture were not of much
material use to Lady Scatcherd.
'Indeed then, doctor, he's just bad enough,' said her ladyship, not in a very happy tone of voice; 'just bad
enough. There's been some'at the back of his head, rapping, and rapping, and rapping; and if you don't do
something, I'm thinking it will rap him too hard yet.'
'Is he in bed?'
'Why, yes, he is in bed; for when he was first took he couldn't very well help hisself, so we put him to bed.
And then, he don't seem to be quite right yet about the legs, so he hasn't got up; but he's got that Winterbones
with him to write for him, and when Winterbones is there, Scatcherd might as well be up for any good that
bed'll do him.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD 67
Page No 71
Mr Winterbones was confidential clerk to Sir Roger. That is to say, he was a writingmachine of which Sir
Roger made use to do certain work which could not well be adjusted without some contrivance. He was a
little, withered, dissipated, brokendown man, whom gin and poverty had nearly burnt to a cinder, and dried
to an ash. Mind he had none left, nor care for earthly things, except the smallest modicum of substantial food,
and the largest allowance of liquid sustenance. All that he had ever known he had forgotten, except how to
count up figures and to write: the results of his counting and his writing never stayed with him from one hour
to another; nay, not from one folio to another. Let him, however, be adequately screwed up with gin, and
adequately screwed down by the presence of his master, and then no amount of counting and writing would
be too much for him. This was Mr Winterbones, confidential clerk to the great Sir Roger Scatcherd.
'We must send Winterbones away, I take it,' said the doctor.
'Indeed, doctor, I wish you would. I wish you'd send him to Bath, or anywhere else out of the way. There is
Scatcherd, he takes brandy; and there is Winterbones, he takes gin; and it'd puzzle a woman to say which is
worst, master or man.'
It will seem from this, that Lady Scatcherd and the doctor were on very familiar terms as regarded her little
domestic inconveniences.
'Tell Sir Roger I am here, will you?' said the doctor.
'You'll take a drop of sherry before you go up?' said the lady.
'Not a drop, thank you,' said the doctor.
'Or, perhaps a little cordial?'
'Not of drop of anything, thank you; I never do, you know.'
'Just a thimbleful of this?' said the lady, producing from some recess under a sideboard a bottle of brandy;
'just a thimbleful? It's what he takes himself.'
When Lady Scatcherd found that even this argument failed, she led the way to the great man's bedroom.
'Well doctor! well doctor!, well, doctor!' was the greeting with which our son of Galen was saluted some time
before he entered the sickroom. His approaching step was heard, and thus the cidevant Barchester
stonemason saluted his coming friend. The voice was loud and powerful, but not clear and sonorous. What
voice that is nurtured on brandy can ever be clear? It had about it a peculiar huskiness, a dissipated guttural
tone, which Thorne immediately recognized, and recognized as being more marked, more guttural, and more
husky than heretofore.
'So you've smelt me out, have you, and come for your fee? Ha! ha! ha! Well, I have had a sharpish bout of it,
as her ladyship there no doubt has told you. Let her alone to make the worst of it. But, you see, you're too
late, man. I've bilked the old gentleman again without troubling you.'
'Anyway, I'm glad you're something better, Scatcherd.'
'Something! I don't know what you call something. I never was better in my life. Ask Winterbones here.'
'Indeed, now, Scatcherd, you ain't; you're bad enough if you only knew it. And as for Winterbones, he has no
business here up in your bedroom, which stinks of gin so, it does. Don't you believe him, doctor; he ain't well,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD 68
Page No 72
nor yet nigh well.'
Winterbones, when the above illnatured allusion was made to the aroma coming from his libations, might be
seen to deposit surreptitiously beneath the little table at which he sat, the cup with which he had performed
them.
The doctor, in the meantime, had taken Sir Roger's hand on the pretext of feeling his pulse, but was drawing
quite as much information from the touch of the sick man's skin, and the look of the sick man's eye.
'I think Mr Winterbones had better go back to the London office,' said he. 'Lady Scatcherd will be your best
clerk for some time, Sir Roger.'
'Then I'll be d if Mr Winterbones does anything of the kind,' said he; 'so there's an end of that.'
'Very well,' said the doctor. 'A man can die but once. It is my duty to suggest measures for putting off the
ceremony as long as possible. Perhaps, however, you may wish to hasten it.'
'Well, I am not anxious about it, one way or the other,' said Scatcherd. And as he spoke there came a fierce
gleam from his eye, which seemed to say'If that's the bugbear with which you wish to frighten me, you
will be mistaken.'
'Now, doctor, don't let him talk that way, don't,' said Lady Scatcherd, with her handkerchief to her eyes.
'Now, my lady, do you cut it; cut at once,' said Sir Roger, turning hastily round to his betterhalf; and his
betterhalf, knowing that the province of a woman is to obey, did cut it. But as she went she gave the doctor
a pull by the coat's sleeve, so that thereby his healing faculties might be sharpened to the very utmost.
'The best woman in the world, doctor; the very best,' said he, as the door closed behind the wife of his bosom.
'I'm sure of it,' said the doctor.
'Yes, till you find a better one,' said Scatcherd. 'Ha! ha! ha! but for good or bad, there are some things which a
woman can't understand, and some things which she ought not to be let to understand.'
'It's natural she should be anxious about your health, you know.'
'I don't know that,' said the contractor. 'She'll be very well off. All that whining won't keep a man alive, at any
rate.'
There was a pause, during which the doctor continued his medical examination. To this the patient submitted
with a bad grace; but still he did submit.
'We must turn over a new leaf, Sir Roger; indeed we must.'
'Bother,' said Sir Roger.
'Well, Scatcherd; I must do my duty to you, whether you like it or not.'
'That is to say, I am to pay you for trying to frighten me.'
'No human nature can stand such shocks as those much longer.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD 69
Page No 73
'Winterbones,' said the contractor, turning to his clerk, 'go down, go down, I say; but don't be out of the way.
If you go to the publichouse, by G you may stay there for me. When I take a drop,that is if I ever do, it
does not stand in the way of work.' So Mr Winterbones, picking up his cup again, and concealing it in some
way beneath his coat flap, retreated out of the room, and the two friends were alone.
'Scatcherd,' said the doctor, 'you have been as near your God, as any man ever was who afterwards ate and
drank in this world.'
'Have I, now?' said the railway here, apparently somewhat startled.
'Indeed you have; indeed you have.'
'And now I'm all right again?'
'All right! How can you be all right, when you know that your limbs refuse to carry you? All right! why the
blood is still beating round you brain with a violence that would destroy any other brain but yours.'
'Ha! ha! ha!,' laughed Scatcherd. He was very proud of thinking himself to be differently organized from
other men. 'Ha! ha! ha! Well and what am I to do now?'
The whole of the doctor's prescription we will not give at length. To some of his ordinances Sir Roger
promised obedience; to others he objected violently, and to one or two he flatly refused to listen. The great
stumblingblock was this, that total abstinence from business for two weeks was enjoined; and that it was
impossible, so Sir Roger said, that he should abstain for two days.
'If you work,' said the doctor, 'in your present state, you will certainly have recourse to the stimulus of drink;
and if you drink, most assuredly will die.'
'Stimulus! Why do you think I can't work without Dutch courage?'
'Scatcherd, I know that there is brandy in this room at the moment, and that you have been taking it within
these two hours.'
'You smell that fellow's gin,' said Scatcherd.
'I feel the alcohol working within your veins,' said the doctor, who still had his hand on his patient's arm.
Sir Roger turned himself roughly in the bed so as to get away from his Mentor, and then he began to threaten
in his turn.
'I'll tell you what it is, doctor; I've made up my mind, and I'll do it. I'll send for Fillgrave.'
'Very well,' said he of Greshamsbury, 'send for Fillgrave. Your case is one in which even he can hardly go
wrong.'
'You think you can hector me, and do as you like because you had me under your thumb in other days. You're
a very good fellow, Thorne, but I ain't sure that you are the best doctor in all England.'
'You may be sure I am not; you may take me for the worst if you will. But while I am here as your medical
adviser, I can only tell you the truth to the best of my thinking. Now the truth is, that another bout of drinking
will in all probability kill you; and any recourse to stimulus in your present condition may do so.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD 70
Page No 74
'I'll send for Fillgrave'
'Well, send for Fillgrave, only do it at once. Believe me at any rate in this, that whatever you do, you should
do at once. Oblige me in this; let Lady Scatcherd take away that brandy bottle till Dr Fillgrave comes.'
'I'm d if I do. Do you think I can't have a bottle of brandy in my room without swigging?'
'I think you'll be less likely to swig if you can't get at it.'
Sir Roger made another angry turn in his bed as well as his halfparalysed limbs would let him; and then,
after a few moments' peace, renewed his threats with increased violence.
'Yes; I'll have Fillgrave over here. If a man be ill, really ill, he should have the best advice he can get. I'll have
Fillgrave, and I'll have that other fellow from Silverbridge to meet him. What's his name?Century.'
The doctor turned his head away; for though the occasion was serious, he could not help smiling at the
malicious vengeance with which his friend proposed to gratify himself.
'I will; and Rerechild too. What's the expense? I suppose five or six pounds apiece will do it; eh, Thorne?'
'Oh, yes; that will be liberal I should say. But, Sir Roger, will you allow me to suggest what you ought to do?
I don't know how far you may be joking'
'Joking!' shouted the baronet; 'you tell a man he's dying and joking in the same breath. You'll find I'm not
joking.'
'Well I dare say not. But if you have not full confidence in me'
'I have no confidence in you at all.'
'Then why not send to London? Expense is no object to you.'
'It is an object; a great object.'
'Nonsense! Send to London for Sir Omicron Pie: send for some man whom you will really trust when you see
him.
'There's not one of the lot I'd trust as soon as Fillgrave. I've known Fillgrave all my life and I trust him. I'll
send for Fillgrave and put my case in his hands. If any one can do anything for me, Fillgrave is the man.'
'Then in God's name send for Fillgrave,' said the doctor. 'And now, goodbye, Scatcherd; and as you do send
for him, give him a fair chance. Do not destroy yourself by more brandy before he comes.'
'That's my affair, and his; not yours,' said the patient.
'So be it; give me your hand, at any rate, before I go. I wish you well through it, and when you are well, I'll
come and see you.'
'Goodbyegoodbye; and look here, Thorne, you'll be talking to Lady Scatcherd downstairs I know; now,
no nonsense. You understand me, eh? no nonsense.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD 71
Page No 75
CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL
Dr Thorne left the room and went downstairs, being fully aware that he could not leave the house without
having some communication with Lady Scatcherd. He was not sooner within the passage than he heard the
sick man's bell ring violently; and then the servant, passing him on the staircase, received orders to send a
mounted messenger immediately to Barchester. Dr Fillgrave was to be summoned to come as quickly as
possible to the sick man's room, and Mr Winterbones was to be sent up to write the note.
Sir Roger was quite right in supposing that there would be some words between the doctor and her ladyship.
How, indeed, was the doctor to get out of the house without such, let him wish it ever so much? There were
words; and these were protracted, while the doctor's cob was being ordered round, till very many were uttered
which the contractor would probably have regarded as nonsense.
Lady Scatcherd was no fit associate for the wives of English baronets;was no doubt by education and
manners much better fitted to sit in their servants' halls; but not on that account was she a bad wife or a bad
woman. She was painfully, fearfully, anxious for that husband of hers, whom she honoured and worshipped,
as it behoved her to do, above all other men. She was fearfully anxious as to his life, and faithfully believed,
that if any man could prolong it, it was that old and faithful friend whom she had known to be true to her lord
since their early married troubles.
When, therefore, she found that she had been dismissed, and that a stranger was to be sent for in his place, her
heart sank below within her.
'But, doctor,' she said, with her apron up to her eyes, 'you ain't going to leave him, are you?'
Dr Thorne did not find it easy to explain to her ladyship that medical etiquette would not permit him to
remain in attendance on her husband after he had been dismissed and another physician called in his place.
'Etiquette!' said she, crying. 'What's etiquette to do with it when a man is akilling hisself with brandy?'
'Fillgrave will forbid that quite as strongly as I can do.'
'Fillgrave!' said she. 'Fiddlesticks! Fillgrave, indeed!'
Dr Thorne could almost have embraced her for the strong feeling of thorough confidence on the one side, and
thorough distrust on the other, which she contrived to throw into those few words.
'I'll tell you what, doctor; I won't let that messenger go. I'll bear the brunt of it. He can't do much now he ain't
up, you know. I'll stop the boy; we won't have no Fillgrave here.'
This, however, was a step to which Dr Thorne would not assent. He endeavoured to explain to the anxious
wife, that after what had passed he could not tender his medical services till they were again asked for.
'But you can slip in as a friend, you know; and then by degrees you can come round him, eh? can't you now,
doctor? And as to payment'
All that Dr Thorne said on the subject may easily be imagined. And in this way, and in partaking of the lunch
which was forced upon him, an hour had nearly passed between his leaving Sir Roger's bedroom and putting
his foot in the stirrup. But no sooner had the cob begun to move on the gravelsweep before the house than
one of the upper windows opened, and the doctor was summoned to another conference with the sick man.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL 72
Page No 76
'He says you are to come back, whether or no,' said Mr Winterbones, screeching out of the window, and
putting all his emphasis on the last words.
'Thorne! Thorne! Thorne!' shouted the sick man from his sickbed, so loudly that the doctor heard him,
seated as he was on horseback out before the house.
'You're to come back, whether or no,' repeated Winterbones, with more emphasis, evidently conceiving that
there was a strength of injunction in that 'whether or no' which would be found quite invincible.
Whether actuated by these magic words, or by some internal process of thought, we will not say; but the
doctor did slowly, and as though unwillingly, dismount again from his steed, and slowly retrace his steps into
the house.
'It is no use,' he said to himself, 'for that messenger has already gone to Barchester.'
'I have sent for Dr Fillgrave,' were the first words which the contractor said to him when he again found
himself by the bedside.
'Did you call me back to tell me that?' said Thorne, who now felt really angry at the impertinent petulance of
the man before him: 'you should consider, Scatcherd, that my time may be of value to others, if not to you.'
'Now don't be angry, old fellow,' said Scatcherd, turning to him, and looking at him with a countenance quite
different from any that he had shown that day; a countenance in which there was a show of manhood,some
show also of affection. 'You ain't angry now because I've sent for Fillgrave?'
'Not in the least,' said the doctor very complacently. 'Not in the least. Fillgrave will do as much good as I can
do.'
'And that's none at all, I suppose; eh, Thorne?'
'That depends on yourself. He will do you good if you will tell him the truth, and will then be guided by him.
Your wife, your servant, any one can be as good a doctor to you as either he or I; as good, that is, in the main
point. But you have sent for Fillgrave now; and of course you must see him. I have much to do, and you must
let me go.'
Scatcherd, however, would not let him go, but held his hand fast. 'Thorne,' said he, 'if you like it, I'll make
them put Fillgrave under the pump directly he comes here. I will indeed, and pay all the damage myself.'
This was another proposition to which the doctor could not consent; but he was utterly unable to refrain from
laughing. There was an earnest look of entreaty about Sir Roger's face as he made the suggestion; and, joined
to this, there was a gleam of comic satisfaction in his eye which seemed to promise, that if he received the
least encouragement he would put his threat into execution. Now our doctor was not inclined to taking any
steps towards subjecting his learned brother to pump discipline; but he could not but admit to himself that the
idea was not a bad one.
'I'll have it done, I will, by heavens! if you'll only say the word,' protested Sir Roger.
But the doctor did not say the word, and so the idea was passed off.
'You shouldn't be so testy with a man when he is ill,' said Scatcherd, still holding the doctor's hand, of which
he had again got possession; 'specially not an old friend; and specially again when you're been ablowing
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL 73
Page No 77
him up.'
It was not worth the doctor's while to aver that the testiness had all been on the other side, and that he had
never lost his goodhumour; so he merely smiled, and asked Sir Roger if he could do anything further for
him.
'Indeed you can, doctor; and that's why I sent for you,why I sent for you yesterday. Get out of the room,
Winterbones,' he then said gruffly, as though he were dismissing from his chamber a dirty dog. Winterbones,
not a whit offended, again hid his cup under his coattail and vanished.
'Sit down, Thorne, sit down,' said the contractor, speaking in quite a different manner from any that he had
yet assumed. 'I know you're in a hurry, but you must give me half an hour. I may be dead before you can give
me another; who knows?'
The doctor of course declared that he hoped to have many a halfhour's chat with him for many a year to
come.
'Well, that's as may be. You must stop now, at any rate. You can make the cob pay for it, you know.'
The doctor took a chair and sat down. Thus entreated to stop, he had hardly any alternative but to do so.
'It wasn't because I'm ill that I sent for you, or rather let her ladyship send for you. Lord bless you, Thorne; do
you think I don't know what it is that makes me like this? When I see that poor wretch Winterbones, killing
himself with gin, do you think I don't know what's coming to myself as well as him?
'Why do you take it then? Why do you do it? Your life is not like his. Oh, Scatcherd! Scatcherd!' and the
doctor prepared to pour out the flood of his eloquence in beseeching this singular man to abstain from his
wellknown poison.
'Is that all you know of human nature, doctor? Abstain. Can you abstain from breathing, and live like a fish
does under water?'
'But Nature has not ordered you to drink, Scatcherd.'
'Habit is second nature, man; and a stronger nature than the first. And why should I not drink? What else has
the world given me for all that I have done for it? What other resource have I? What other gratification?'
'Oh, my God! Have you not unbounded wealth? Can you not do anything you wish? be anything you choose?'
'No,' and the sick man shrieked with an energy that made him audible all through the house. 'I can do nothing
that I would choose to do; be nothing that I would wish to be! What can I do? What can I be? What
gratification can I have except the brandy bottle? If I go among gentlemen, can I talk to them? If they have
anything to say about a railway, they will ask me a question: if they speak to me beyond that, I must be
dumb. If I go among my workmen, can they talk to me? No; I am their master, and a stern master. They bob
their heads and shake in their shoes when they see me. Where are my friends? Here!' said he, and he dragged
a bottle from under his very pillow. 'Where are my amusements? Here!' and he brandished the bottle almost
in the doctor's face. 'Where is my one resource, my one gratification, my only comfort after all my toils. Here,
doctor; here, here, here!' and, so saying, he replaced his treasure beneath his pillow.
There was something so horrifying in this, that Dr Thorne shrank back amazed, and was for a moment unable
to speak.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL 74
Page No 78
'But, Scatcherd,' he said at last; 'surely you would not die for such a passion as that?' 'Die for it? Aye, would I.
Live for it while I can live; and die for it when I can live no longer. Die for it! What is that for a man to do?
What is a man the worse for dying? What can I be the worse for dying? A man can die but once, you said just
now. I'd die ten times for this.'
'You are speaking now either in madness, or else in folly, to startle me.'
'Folly enough, perhaps, and madness enough, also. Such a life as mine makes a man a fool, and makes him
mad too. What have about me that I should be afraid to die? I'm worth three hundred thousand pounds; and
I'd give it all to be able to go to work tomorrow with a hod and mortar, and have a fellow clap his hand upon
my shoulder, and say: "Well, Roger, shall us have that 'ere other halfpint this morning?" I'll tell you what,
Thorne, when a man has made three hundred thousand pounds, there's nothing left for him but to die. It's all
he's good for then. When money's been made, the next thing is to spend it. Now the man who makes it has
not the heart to do that.'
The doctor, of course, in hearing all this, said something of a tendency to comfort and console the mind of his
patient. Not that anything he could say would comfort or console the man; but that it was impossible to sit
there and hear such fearful truthsfor as regarded Scatcherd they were truthswithout making some
answer.'
'This is as good as a play, isn't, doctor?' said the baronet. 'You didn't know how I could come out like one of
those actor fellows. Well, now, come; at last I'll tell you why I have sent for you. Before that last burst of
mine I made my will.'
'You had made a will before that.'
'Yes, I had. That will is destroyed. I burnt it with my own hand, so that there should be no mistake about it. In
that will I had named two executors, you and Jackson. I was then partner with Jackson in the York and
Yeovil Grand Central. I thought a deal of Jackson then. He's not worth a shilling now.'
'Well, I'm exactly in the same category.'
'No, you're not. Jackson is nothing without money; but money'll never make you.'
'No, nor I shan't make money,' said the doctor.
'No, you never will. Nevertheless, there's my other will, there, under that desk there; and I've put you in as
sole executor.'
'You must alter that, Scatcherd; you must indeed; with three hundred thousand pounds to be disposed of, the
trust is far too much for any one man: besides you must name a younger man; you and I are of the same age,
and I may die first.'
'Now, doctor, no humbug; let's have no humbug from you. Remember this; if you're not true, you're nothing.'
'Well, but, Scatcherd'
'Well, but doctor, there's the will, it's already made. I don't want to consult you about that. You are named as
executor, and if you have the heart to refuse to act when I'm dead, why, of course, you can do so.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL 75
Page No 79
The doctor was not lawyer, and hardly knew whether he had any means of extricating himself from this
position in which his friend was determined to place him.
'You'll have to see that will carried out, Thorne. Now I'll tell you what I have done.'
'You're not going to tell me how you have disposed of your property?'
'Not exactly; at least not all of it. One hundred thousand I've in legacies, including, you know, what Lady
Scatcherd will have.'
'Have you not left the house to Lady Scatcherd?'
'No; what the devil would she do with a house like this? She doesn't know how to live in it now she has got it.
I have provided for her; it matters not how. The house and the estate, and the remainder of my money I have
left to Louis Philippe.'
'What! two hundred thousand pounds?' said the doctor.
'And why shouldn't I leave two hundred thousand pounds to my son, even to my eldest son if I have more
than one? Does not Mr Gresham leave all his property to his heir? Why should not I make an eldest son as
well as Lord de Courcy or the Duke of Omnium? I suppose a railway contractor ought not to be allowed an
eldest son by Act of Parliament! Won't my son have a title to keep up? And that's more than the Greshams
have among them.'
The doctor explained away what he said as well as he could. He could not explain that what he had really
meant was this, that Sir Roger Scatcherd's son was not a man fit to be trusted with the entire control of an
enormous fortune.
Sir Roger Scatcherd had but one child; that child which had been born in the days of his early troubles, and
had been dismissed from his mother's breast in order that the mother's milk might nourish the young heir of
Greshamsbury. The boy had grown up, but had become strong neither in mind nor body. His father had
determined to make a gentleman of him, and had sent to Eton and Cambridge. But even this receipt, generally
as it is recognized, will not make a gentleman. It is hard, indeed, to define what receipt will do so, though
people do have in their own minds some certain undefined, but yet tolerably correct ideas on the subject. Be
that as it may, two years at Eton, and three terms at Cambridge, did not make a gentleman of Louis Philippe
Scatcherd.
Yes; he was christened Louis Philippe, after the King of the French. If one wishes to look out in the world for
royal nomenclature, to find children who have been christened after kings and queens, or the uncles and aunts
of kings and queens, the search should be made in the families of democrats. None have so servile a
deference for the very nailparings of royalty; none feel so wondering an awe at the exaltation of a crowned
head; none are so anxious to secure themselves some shred or fragment that has been consecrated by the
royal touch. It is the distance which they feel to exist between themselves, and the throne which makes them
covet the crumbs of majesty, the odds and ends and chance splinters of royalty.
There was nothing royal about Louis Philippe Scatcherd but his name. He had now come to man's estate, and
his father, finding the Cambridge receipt to be inefficacious, had sent him abroad to travel with a tutor. The
doctor had from time to time heard tidings of this youth; he knew that he had already shown symptoms of his
father's vices, but no symptoms of his father's talents; he knew that he had begun life by being dissipated,
without being generous; and that at the age of twentyone he had already suffered from delirium tremens.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL 76
Page No 80
It was on this account that he had expressed disapprobation, rather than surprise, when he heard that his
father intended to bequeath the bulk of his large fortune to the uncontrolled will of this unfortunate boy.
'I have toiled for my money hard, and I have a right to do as I like with it. What other satisfaction can it give
me?'
The doctor assured him that he did not at all mean to dispute this.
'Louis Philippe will do well enough, you'll find,' continued the baronet, understanding what was passing
within his companion's breast. 'Let a young fellow sow his wild oats while he is young, and he'll be steady
enough when he grows old.'
'But what if he never lives to get through the sowing?' thought the doctor to himself. 'What if the wildoats
operation is carried on in so violent a manner as to leave no strength in the soil for the product of a more
valuable crop?' It was of no use saying this, however, so he allowed Scatcherd to continue.
'If I'd had a free fling when I was a youngster, I shouldn't have been so fond of the brandy bottle now. But
any way, my son shall be my heir. I've had the gumption to make the money, but I haven't the gumption to
spend it. My son, however, shall be able to ruffle it with the best of them. I'll go bail he shall hold his head
higher than ever young Gresham will be able to hold his. They are much of the same age, as well I have cause
to remember;and so has her ladyship here.'
Now the fact was, that Sir Roger Scatcherd felt in his heart no special love for young Gresham; but with her
ladyship it might almost be a question whether she did not love the youth whom she had nursed almost as
well as that other one who was her own proper offspring.
'And will you not put any check on thoughtless expenditure? If you live ten or twenty years, as we hope you
may, it will become unnecessary; but in making a will, a man should always remember he may go off
suddenly.'
'Especially if he goes to bed with a brandy bottle under his head; eh, doctor? But, mind, that's a medical
secret, you know; not a word of that out of the bedroom.'
Dr Thorne could but sigh. What could he say on such a subject to such a man as this?
'Yes, I have put a check on his expenditure. I will not let his daily bread depend on any man; I have therefore
let him five hundred a year at his own disposal, from the day of my death. Let him make what ducks and
drakes of that he can.'
'Five hundred a year is certainly not much,'said the doctor.
'No; nor do I want to keep him to that. Let him have whatever he wants if he sets about spending it properly.
But the bulk of the propertythis estate of Boxall Hill, and the Greshamsbury mortgage, and those other
mortgagesI have tied up in this way: they shall be all his at twentyfive; and up to that age it shall be in
your power to give him what he wants. If he shall die without children before he shall be twentyfive years
of age, they are all to go to Mary's eldest child.'
Now Mary was Sir Roger's sister, the mother, therefore, of Miss Thorne, and, consequently, the wife of the
respectable ironmonger who went to America, and the mother of a family there.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL 77
Page No 81
'Mary's eldest child!' said the doctor, feeling that the perspiration had nearly broken out on his forehead, and
that he could hardly control his feelings. 'Mary's eldest child! Scatcherd, you should be more particular in
your description, or you will leave your best legacy to the lawyers.'
'I don't know, and never heard the name of one of them.'
'But do you mean a boy or a girl?'
'They may be all girls for what I know, or all boys; besides, I don't care which it is. A girl would probably do
best with it. Only you'd have to see that she married some decent fellow; you'd be her guardian.'
'Pooh, nonsense,' said the doctor. 'Louis will be fiveandtwenty in a year or two.'
'In about four years.'
'And for all that's come and gone yet, Scatcherd, you are not going to leave us yourself quite so soon as all
that.'
'Not if I can help it; but that's as may be.'
'The chances are ten to one that such a clause in your will will never come to bear.'
'Quite so, quite so. If I die, Louis Philippe won't, but I thought it right to put in something to prevent his
squandering it all before he comes to his senses.'
'Oh! quite right, quite right. I think I would have named a later age than twentyfive.'
'So would not I. Louis Philippe will be all right by that time. That's my lookout. And now, doctor, you know
my will; and if I die tomorrow, you will know what I want you to do for me.'
'You have merely said the eldest child, Scatcherd?'
'That's all; give it here; and I'll read it to you.'
'No; no; never mind. The eldest child! You should be more particular, Scatcherd; you should, indeed.
Consider what an enormous interest may have to depend on those words.'
'Why, what the devil could I say? I don't know their names; never even heard them. But the eldest is the
eldest, all the world over. Perhaps I ought to say the youngest, seeing that I am only a railway contractor.'
Scatcherd began to think that the doctor might now as well go away and leave him to the society of
Winterbones and the brandy; but, much as our friend had before expressed himself in a hurry, he now seemed
inclined to move very leisurely. He sat there by the bedside, resting his hands on his knees and gazing
unconsciously at the counterpane. At last he gave a deep sigh, and then he said, 'Scatcherd, you must be more
particular in this. If I am to have anything to do with it, you must, indeed, be more explicit.'
'Why, how the deuce can I be more explicit? Isn't her eldest living child plain enough, whether he be Jack, or
she be Gill?'
'What did your lawyer say to this, Scatcherd?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL 78
Page No 82
'Lawyer! You don't suppose I let my lawyer know what I was putting. No; I got the form and the paper, and
all that from him, and I did it in another. It's all right enough. Though Winterbones wrote it, he did it in such
a way he did not know what he was writing.'
The doctor sat a while longer, still looking at the counterpane, and then got up to depart. 'I'll see you again
soon,' said he; 'tomorrow, probably.'
'Tomorrow!' said Sir Roger, not at all understanding why Dr Thorne should talk of returning so soon.
'Tomorrow! why I ain't so bad as that, man, am I? If you come so often as that you will ruin me.'
'Oh, not as a medical man; not as that; but about this will, Scatcherd. I must think if over; I must, indeed.'
'You need not give yourself the least trouble in the world about my will till I'm dead; not the least. And who
knowsmay be, I may be settling your affairs yet; eh, doctor? looking after your niece when you're dead and
gone, and getting a husband for her, eh? Ha! ha! ha!'
And then, without further speech, the doctor went his way.
CHAPTER XI. THE DOCTOR DRINKS HIS TEA
The doctor got on his cob and went his way, returning duly to Greshamsbury. But, in truth, as he went he
hardly knew whither he was going, or what he was doing. Sir Roger had hinted that the cob would be
compelled to make up for lost time by extra exertion on the road; but the cob had never been permitted to
have his own way as to pace more satisfactorily than on the present occasion. The doctor, indeed, hardly
knew that he was on horseback, so completely was he enveloped in the cloud of his own thoughts.
In the first place, that alternative which it had become him to put before the baronet as one unlikely to
occurthat of the speedy death of both father and sonwas one which he felt in his heart of hearts might
very probably come to pass.
'The chances are ten to one that such a clause will never be brought to bear.' This he had said partly to
himself, so as to ease the thoughts which came crowding on his brain; partly, also, in pity for the patient and
the father. But now that he thought the matter over, he felt that there were no such odds. Were not the odds
the other way? Was it not almost probable that both these men might be gathered to their long account within
the next four years? One, the elder, was a strong man, indeed; one who might yet live for years to come if he
could but give himself fair play. But then, he himself protested, and protested with a truth too surely
grounded, that fair play to himself was beyond his own power to give. The other, the younger, had everything
against him. Not only was he a poor, puny creature, without physical strength, one of whose life a friend
could never feel sure under any circumstances, but he also was already addicted to his father's vices; he also
was already killing himself with alcohol.
And then, if these two men did die within the prescribed period, if this clause of Sir Roger's will were brought
to bear, it should become his, Dr Thorne's, duty to see that clause carried out, how would he be bound to act?
That woman's eldest child was his own niece, his adopted bairn, his darling, the pride of his heart, the
cynosure of his eye, his child also, his own Mary. Of all his duties on this earth, next to that one great duty to
his God and conscience, was his duty to her. What, under these circumstances, did his duty to her require of
him?
But then, that one great duty, that duty which she would be the first to expect from him; what did that
demand of him? Had Scatcherd made his will without saying what its clauses were, it seemed to Thorne that
Mary must have been the heiress, should that clause become necessarily operative. Whether she were so or
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XI. THE DOCTOR DRINKS HIS TEA 79
Page No 83
not would at any rate be for lawyers to decide. But now the case was very different. This rich man had
confided in him, and would it not be a breach of confidence, an act of absolute dishonestyan act of
dishonesty both to Scatcherd and to that fardistant American family, to that father, who, in former days, had
behaved so nobly, and to that eldest child of his, would it not be gross dishonesty to them all if he allowed
this man to leave a will by which his property might go to a person never intended to be his heir?
Long before he had arrived at Greshamsbury his mind on this point had been made up. Indeed, it had been
made up while sitting there by Scatcherd's bedside. It had not been difficult to make up his mind to so much;
but then, his way out of this dishonesty was not so easy for him to find. How should he set this matter right to
as to inflict no injury on his niece, and no sorrow to himselfif that indeed could be avoided?
And then other thoughts crowded on his brain. He had always professedprofessed at any rate to himself
and to herthat of all the vile objects of a man's ambition, wealth, wealth merely for its own sake, was the
vilest. They, in their joint school of inherent philosophy, had progressed to ideas which they might find it not
easy to carry out, should they be called on by events to do so. And if this would have been difficult to either
when acting on behalf of self alone, how much more difficult when one might have to act for the other! This
difficulty had now come to the uncle. Should he, in this emergency, take upon himself to fling away the
golden chance which might accrue to his niece if Scatcherd should be encouraged to make her partly his heir?
'He'd want her to go and live thereto live with him and his wife. All the money in the Bank of England
would not pay her for such misery,' said the doctor to himself, as he slowly rode into is own yard.
On one point, and one only, had he definitely made up his mind. On the following day he would go over
again to Boxall Hill, and would tell Scatcherd the whole truth. Come what might, the truth must be best. And
so, with some gleam of comfort, he went into the house, and found his niece in the drawingroom with
Patience Oriel.
'Mary and I have been quarrelling,' said Patience. 'She says the doctor is the greatest man in a village; and I
say the parson is of course.'
'I only say that the doctor is the most looked after,' said Mary. 'There's another horrid message for you to go
to Silverbridge, uncle. Why can't that Dr Century manage his own people?'
'She says,' continued Miss Oriel, 'that if a parson was away for a month, no one would miss him; but that a
doctor is so precious that his very minutes are counted.'
'I am sure uncle's are. They begrudge him his meals. Mr Oriel never gets called away to Silverbridge.'
'No; we in the Church manage our parish arrangements better than you do. We don't let strange practitioners
in among our flocks because the sheep may chance to fancy them. Our sheep have to put up with our spiritual
doses whether they like them or not. In that respect we are much the best off. I advise you, Mary, to marry a
clergyman, by all means.'
'I will when you marry a doctor,' said she.
'I am sure nothing on earth would give me greater pleasure,' said Miss Oriel, getting up and curtseying very
low to Dr Thorne; 'but I am not quite prepared for the agitation of an offer this morning, so I'll run away.'
And so she went; and the doctor, getting to his other horse, started again for Silverbridge, wearily enough.
'She's happy now where she is,' said he to himself, as he rode along. 'They all treat her there as an equal at
Greshamsbury. What though she be no cousin to the Thornes of Ullathorne. She has found her place there
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XI. THE DOCTOR DRINKS HIS TEA 80
Page No 84
among them all, and keeps it on equal terms with the best of them. There is Miss Oriel; her family is high;
she is rich, fashionable, a beauty, courted by every one; but yet she does not look down on Mary. They are
equal friends together. But how would it be if she were taken to Boxall Hill, even as a recognized niece of the
rich man there? Would Patience Oriel and Beatrice Gresham go there after her? Could she be happy there as
she is in my house here, poor though it be? It would kill her to pass a month with Lady Scatcherd and put up
with that man's humours, to see his mode of life, to be dependent on him, to belong to him.' And then the
doctor, hurrying on to Silverbridge, again met Dr Century at the old lady's bedside, and having made his
endeavours to stave off the inexorable coming of the grim visitor, again returned to his own niece and his
own drawingroom.
'You must be dead, uncle,' said Mary, as she poured out his tea for him, and prepared the comforts of that
most comfortable mealtea, dinner, and supper, all in one. 'I wish Silverbridge was fifty miles off.'
'That would only make the journey worse; but I am not dead yet, and, what is more to the purpose, neither is
my patient.' And as he spoke he contrived to swallow a jorum of scalding tea, containing in measure
somewhat near a pint. Mary, not a whit amazed at this feat, merely refilled the jorum without any
observation; and the doctor went on stirring the mixture with his spoon, evidently oblivious that any
ceremony had been performed by either of them since the first supply had been administered to him.
When the clatter of knives and forks was over, the doctor turned himself to the hearthrug, and putting one leg
over the other, he began to nurse it as he looked with complacency at his third cup of tea, which stood
untasted beside him. The fragments of the solid banquet had been removed, but no sacrilegious hand had
been laid on the teapot and the creamjug.
'Mary,' said he, 'suppose you were to find out tomorrow morning that, by some accident, you had become a
great heiress, would you be able to suppress your exultation?'
'The first thing I'd do, would be to pronounce a positive edict that you should never go to Silverbridge again;
at least without a day's notice.'
'Well, and what next? what would you do next?'
'The next thingthe next thing would be to send to Paris for a French bonnet exactly like the one Patience
Oriel had on. Did you see it?'
'Well I can't say I did; bonnets are invisible now; besides I never remark anybody's clothes, except yours.'
'Oh! do look at Miss Oriel's bonnet the next time you see her. I cannot understand why it should be so, but I
am sure of thisno English fingers put together such a bonnet as that; and I am nearly sure that no French
fingers could do it in England.'
'But you don't care so much about bonnets, Mary!' This the doctor said as an assertion; but there was,
nevertheless, somewhat of a question involved in it.
'Don't I though?' said she. 'I do care very much about bonnets; especially since I saw Patience this morning. I
asked how much it costguess.'
'Oh! I don't knowa pound?'
'A pound, uncle!'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XI. THE DOCTOR DRINKS HIS TEA 81
Page No 85
'What! a great deal more? Ten pounds?'
'Oh, uncle.'
'What! more than ten pounds? Then I don't think even Patience Oriel ought to give it.'
'No, of course she would not; but, uncle, it really cost a hundred francs!'
'Oh! a hundred francs; that's four pounds, isn't it? Well, and how much did your last new bonnet cost?'
'Mine! oh, nothingfive and ninepence, perhaps; I trimmed it myself. If I were left a great fortune, I'd send
to Paris tomorrow; no, I'd go myself to Paris to buy a bonnet, and I'd take you with me to choose it.'
The doctor sat silent for a while meditating about this, during which he unconsciously absorbed the tea beside
him; and Mary again replenished his cup.
'Come, Mary,' he said at last, 'I'm in a generous mood; and as I am rather more rich than usual, we'll send to
Paris for a French bonnet. The going for it must wait a while longer I am afraid.'
'You're joking.'
'No, indeed. If you know the way to sendthat I must confess would puzzle me; but if you'll manage the
sending, I'll manage the paying; and you shall have a French bonnet.'
'Uncle!' said she, looking up at him.
'Oh, I'm not joking; I owe you a present, and I'll give you that.'
'And if you do, I'll tell you what I'll do with it. I'll cut it into fragments, and burn them before your face. Why,
uncle, what do you take me for? You're not a bit nice tonight to make such an offer as that to me; not a bit,
not a bit.' And then she came over from her seat at the teatray and sat down on a footstool close at his
knee. 'Because I'd have a French bonnet if I had a large fortune, is that a reason why I should like one now? if
you were to pay four pounds for a bonnet for me, it would scorch my head every time I put it on.'
'I don't see that: four pounds would not ruin me. However, I don't think you'd look a bit better if you had it;
and, certainly, I should not like to scorch these locks,' and putting his hand upon her shoulders, he played
with her hair.
'Patience has a ponyphaeton, and I'd have one if I were rich; and I'd have all my books bound as she does;
and, perhaps, I'd give fifty guineas for a dressingcase.'
'Fifty guineas!'
'Patience did not tell me; but so Beatrice says. Patience showed it to me once, and it is a darling. I think I'd
have the dressingcase before the bonnet. But, uncle'
'Well?'
'You don't suppose I want such things?'
'Not improperly. I am sure you do not.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XI. THE DOCTOR DRINKS HIS TEA 82
Page No 86
'Not properly, or improperly; not much, or little. I covet many things; but nothing of that sort. You know, or
should know, that I do not. Why do you talk of buying a French bonnet for me?'
Dr Thorne did not answer this question, but went on nursing his leg.
'After all,' said he, 'money is a fine thing.'
'Very fine, when it is well come by,' she answered; 'that is, without detriment to the heart and soul.'
'I should be a happier man if you were provided for as Miss Oriel. Suppose, now, I could give you up to a
rich man who would be able to insure you against all wants?'
'Insure me against all wants! Oh, that would be a man. That would be selling me, wouldn't it, uncle? Yes,
selling me; and the price you would receive would be freedom from future apprehensions as regards me. It
would be a cowardly sale for you to make; and then, as to meme the victim. No, uncle; you must bear the
misery of having to provide for mebonnets and all. We are in the same boat, and you shan't turn me
overboard.'
'But if I were to die, what would you do then?'
'And if I were to die, what would you do? People must be bound together. They must depend on each other.
Of course, misfortunes may come; but it is cowardly to be afraid of them beforehand. You and I are bound
together, uncle; and though you say these things to tease me, I know you do not wish to get rid of me.'
'Well, well; we shall win through, doubtless; if not in one way, then in another.'
'Win through! Of course we shall; who doubts our winning? but, uncle'
'But, Mary.'
'Well?'
'You haven't got another cup of tea, have you?'
'Oh, uncle! you have had five.'
'No, my dear! not five; only fouronly four. I assure you; I have been very particular to count. I had one
while I was'
'Five uncle; indeed and indeed.'
'Well, then, as I hate the prejudice which attaches luck to an odd number, I'll have the sixth to show that I am
not superstitious.'
While Mary was preparing the sixth jorum, there came a knock at the door. Those late summonses were
hateful to Mary's ear, for they were usually forerunners of a midnight ride through the dark lanes to some
farmer's house. The doctor had been in the saddle all day, and, as Janet brought the note into the room, Mary
stood up as though to defend her uncle from any further invasion on his rest.
'A note from the house, miss,' said Janet: now 'the house', in Greshamsbury parlance, always meant the
squire's mansion.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XI. THE DOCTOR DRINKS HIS TEA 83
Page No 87
'No one ill at the house, I hope,' said the doctor, taking the note from Mary's hand. 'Ohahyes; it's from
the squirethere's nobody ill: wait a minute, Janet, and I'll write a line. Mary, lend me your desk.'
The squire, anxious as usual for money, had written to ask what success the doctor had had in negotiating the
new loan with Sir Roger. That fact, however, was, that in his visit to Boxall Hill, the doctor had been
altogether unable to bring on the carpet the matter of this loan. Subjects had crowded themselves in too
quickly during that interviewthose two interviews at Sir Roger's bedside; and he had been obliged to leave
without even alluding to the question.
'I must at any rate go back now,' he said to himself. So he wrote to the squire, saying that he was to be at
Boxall Hill again on the following day, and that he would call at the house on his return.
'That's all settled, at any rate,' said he.
'What's settled?' said Mary.
'Why, I must go to Boxall Hill again tomorrow. I must go early, too, so we'd better both be off to bed. Tell
Janet I must breakfast at halfpast seven.'
'You couldn't take me, could you? I should so like to see that Sir Roger.'
'To see Sir Roger! Why, he's ill in bed.'
'That's an objection, certainly; but some day, when he's well, could you not take me over? I have the greatest
desire to see a man like that; a man who began with nothing and now has more than enough to buy the whole
parish of Greshamsbury.'
'I don't think you'd like him at all.'
'Why not? I am sure I should; I am sure I should like him, and Lady Scatcherd too. I've heard you say that she
is an excellent woman.'
'Yes, in her way; and he, too, is good in his way; but they are neither of them in your way: they are extremely
vulgar'
'Oh! I don't mind that; that would make them more amusing; one doesn't go to those sort of people for
polished manners.'
'I don't think you'd find the Scatcherds pleasant acquaintances at all,' said the doctor, taking his bedcandle,
and kissing his niece's forehead as he left the room.
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG
OF WAR
The doctor, that is our doctor, had thought nothing more of the message which had been sent to that other
doctor, Dr Fillgrave; nor in truth did the baronet. Lady Scatcherd had thought of it, but her husband during
the rest of the day was not in a humour which allowed her to remind him that he would soon have a new
physician on his hands; so she left the difficulty to arrange itself, waiting in some little trepidation till Dr
Fillgrave should show himself.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR 84
Page No 88
It was well that Sir Roger was not dying for want of his assistance, for when the message reached Barchester,
Dr Fillgrave was some five or six miles out of town, at Plumstead; and as he did not get back till late in the
evening, he felt himself necessitated to put off his visit to Boxall Hill till next morning. Had he chanced to
have been made acquainted with that little conversation about the pump, he would probably have postponed it
even yet a while longer.
He was, however, by no means sorry to be summoned to the bedside of Sir Roger Scatcherd. It was well
known at Barchester, and very well known to Dr Fillgrave, that Sir Roger and Dr Thorne were old friends. It
was very well known to him also, that Sir Roger, in all his bodily ailments, had hitherto been contented to
entrust his safety to the skill of his old friend. Sir Roger was in his way a great man, and much talked of in
Barchester, and rumour had already reached the ears of the Barchester Galen, that the great railway contractor
was ill. When, therefore, he received a peremptory summons to go over to Boxall Hill, he could not but think
that some pure light had broken in upon Sir Roger's darkness, and taught him at last where to look for true
medical accomplishment.
And then, also, Sir Roger was the richest man in the county, and to county practitioners a new patient with
large means is a godsend; how much greater a godsend when not only acquired, but taken also from some
rival practitioner, need hardly be explained.
Dr Fillgrave, therefore, was somewhat elated when, after an early breakfast, he stepped into the postchaise
which was to carry him to Boxall Hill. Dr Fillgrave's professional advancement had been sufficient to justify
the establishment of a brougham, in which he paid his ordinary visits round Barchester; but this was a special
occasion, requiring special speed, and about to produce no doubt a special guerdon, and therefore a pair of
posthorses were put into request.
It was hardly yet nine when the postboy somewhat loudly rang the bell at Sir Roger's door; and then Dr
Fillgrave, for the first time, found himself in the new grand hall of Boxall Hill house.
'I'll tell my lady,' said the servant, showing him into the grand diningroom; and there for some fifteen
minutes or twenty minutes Dr Fillgrave walked up and down the length of the Turkey carpet all alone.
Dr Fillgrave was not a tall man, and was perhaps rather more inclined to corpulence than became his height.
In his stockingfeet, according to the usually received style of measurement, he was five feet five; and he had
a little round abdominal protuberance, which an inch and a half added to the heels of his boots hardly enabled
him to carry off as well as he himself would have wished. Of this he was apparently conscious, and it gave to
him an air of not being entirely at his ease. There was, however, a personal dignity in his demeanour, a
propriety in his gait, and an air of authority in his gestures which should prohibit one from stigmatizing those
efforts at altitude as a failure. No doubt he did achieve much; but, nevertheless, the effort would occasionally
betray itself, and the story of the frog and the ox would irresistibly force itself into one's mind at those
moments when it most behoved Dr Fillgrave to be magnificent.
But if the bulgy roundness of his person and the shortness of his legs in any way detracted from his personal
importance, these trifling defects were, he was well aware, more than atoned for by the peculiar dignity of his
countenance. If his legs were short, his face was not; if there was any undue preponderance below the
waistcoat, all was in due symmetry above the necktie. His hair was grey, not grizzled, nor white, but properly
grey; and stood up straight from his temples on each side, with an unbending determination of purpose. His
whiskers, which were of an admirable shape, coming down and turning gracefully at the angle of his jaw,
were grey also, but somewhat darker than his hair. His enemies in Barchester declared that their perfect shade
was produced by a leaden comb. His eyes were not brilliant, but were very effective, and well under
command. He was rather shortsighted, and a pair of eyeglasses was always on his nose, or in his hand. His
nose was long, and well pronounced, and his chin, also, was sufficiently prominent; but the great feature of
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR 85
Page No 89
his face was his mouth. The amount of secret medical knowledge of which he could give assurance by the
pressure of those lips was truly wonderful. By his lips, also, he could be most exquisitely courteous, or most
sternly forbidding. And not only could he be either the one or the other; but he could at his will assume any
shade of difference between the two, and produce any mixture of sentiment.
When Dr Fillgrave was first shown into Sir Roger's diningroom, he walked up and down the room for a
while with easy, jaunty step, with his hands joined together behind his back, calculating the price of the
furniture, and counting the heads which might be adequately entertained in a room of such noble proportions;
but in seven or eight minutes an air of impatience might have been seen to suffuse his face. Why could he not
be shown into the sick man's room? What necessity could there be for keeping him there, as though he were
some apothecary with a box of leeches in his pocket? He then rang the bell, perhaps a little violently. 'Does
Sir Roger know that I am here?' he said to the servant. 'I'll tell my lady,' said the man, again vanishing.
For five minutes more he walked up and down, calculating no longer the value of the furniture, but rather that
of his own importance. He was not wont to be kept waiting in this way; and though Sir Roger Scatcherd was
at present a great and rich man, Dr Fillgrave had remembered him a very small and a very poor man. He now
began to think of Sir Roger as the stonemason, and to chafe somewhat more violently at being so kept by
such a man.
When one is impatient, five minutes is as the duration of all time, and a quarter of an hour is eternity. At the
end of twenty minutes the step of Dr Fillgrave up and down the room had become very quick, and he had just
made up his mind that he would not stay there all day to the serious detriment, perhaps fatal injury, of his
other expectant patients. His hand was again on the bell, and was about to be used with vigour, when the door
opened and Lady Scatcherd entered.
'Oh, laws!' Such had been her first exclamation on hearing that the doctor was in the diningroom. She was
standing at the time with her housekeeper in a small room in which she kept her linen and jam, and in which,
in company with the same housekeeper, she spent the happiest moments of her life.
'Oh laws! now, Hannah, what shall we do?'
'Send 'un up at once to master, my lady! let John take 'un up.'
'There'll be such a row in the house, Hannah; I know there will.'
'But surely didn't he send for 'un? Let the master have the row himself, then; that's what I'd do, my lady,'
added Hannah, seeing that her ladyship still stood trembling in doubt, biting her thumbnail.
'You couldn't go up to the master yourself, could now, Hannah?' said Lady Scatcherd in her most persuasive
tone.
'Why no,' said Hannah, after a little deliberation; 'no, I'm afeard I couldn't.'
'Then I must just face it myself.' And up went the wife to tell her lord that the physician for whom he had sent
had come to attend his bidding.
In the interview which then took place the baronet had not indeed been violent, but he had been very
determined. Nothing on earth, he said, should induce him to see Dr Fillgrave and offend his dear old friend
Dr Thorne.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR 86
Page No 90
'But Roger,' said her ladyship, half crying, or rather pretending to cry in vexation, 'what shall I do with the
man? How shall I get him out of the house?'
'Put him under the pump,' said the baronet; and he laughed his peculiar low guttural laugh, which told so
plainly of the havoc which brandy had made in his throat.
'That's nonsense, Roger; you know I can't put him under the pump. Now you are ill, and you'd better see him
just for five minutes. I'll make it right with Dr Thorne.'
'I'll be d if I do, my lady.' All the people about Boxall Hill called poor Lady Scatcherd 'my lady' as if
there was some excellent joke in it; and, so, indeed, there was.
'You know you needn't mind nothing he says, nor yet take nothing he sends: and I'll tell him not to come no
more. Now do 'ee see him, Roger.'
But there was not coaxing Roger over now, indeed ever: he was a wilful, headstrong, masterful man; a tyrant
always though never a cruel one; and accustomed to rule his wife and household as despotically as he did his
gangs of workmen. Such men it is not easy to coax over.
'You go down and tell him I don't want him, and won't see him, and that's an end of it. If he chose to earn his
money, why didn't he come yesterday when he was sent for? I'm well now, and don't want him; and what's
more, I won't have him. Winterbones, lock the door.'
So Winterbones, who during this interview had been at work at his little table, got up to lock the door, and
Lady Scatcherd had no alternative but to pass through it before the last edict was obeyed.
Lady Scatcherd, with slow step, went downstairs and again sought counsel with Hannah, and the two, putting
their heads together, agreed that the only cure for the present evil was to found in a good fee. So Lady
Scatcherd, with a fivepound note in her hand, and trembling in every limb, went forth to encounter the
august presence of Dr Fillgrave.
As the door opened, Dr Fillgrave dropped the bellrope which was in his hand, and bowed low to the lady.
Those who knew the doctor well, would have known from his bow that he was not well pleased; it was as
much as though he said, 'Lady Scatcherd, I am your most obedient servant; at any rate it appears that it is
your pleasure to treat me as such.'
Lady Scatcherd did not understand all this; but she perceived at once that he was angry.
'I hope Sir Roger does not find himself worse,' said the doctor. 'The morning is getting on; shall I step up and
see him?'
'Hem! ha! oh! Why, you see, Dr Fillgrave, Sir Roger finds hisself vastly better this morning, vastly so.'
'I'm very glad to hear it; but as the morning is getting on, shall I step up to see Sir Roger?'
'Why, Dr Fillgrave, sir, you see, he finds hisself so much hisself this morning, that he a'most thinks it would
be a shame to trouble you.'
'A shame to trouble me!' This was the sort of shame which Dr Fillgrave did not at all comprehend. 'A shame
to trouble me! Why Lady Scatcherd'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR 87
Page No 91
Lady Scatcherd saw that she had nothing for it but to make the whole matter intelligible. Moreover, seeing
that she appreciated more thoroughly the smallness of Dr Fillgrave's person more thoroughly than she did the
peculiar greatness of his demeanour, she began to be a shade less afraid of him than she had thought she
should have been.
'Yes, Dr Fillgrave; you see, when a man like he gets well, he can't abide the idea of doctors: now, yesterday,
he was all for sending for you; but today he comes to hisself, and don't seem to want no doctor at all.'
Then did Dr Fillgrave seem to grow out of his boots, so suddenly did he take upon himself sundry modes of
expansive attitude;to grow out of his boots and to swell upwards, till his angry eyes almost looked down
on Lady Scatcherd, and each erect hair bristled up towards the heavens.
'This is very singular, very singular, Lady Scatcherd; very singular indeed; very singular; quite unusual. I
have come here from Barchester, at some considerable inconvenience, at some very considerable
inconvenience, I may say, to my regular patients; andandandI don't know that anything so very
singular ever occurred to me before.' And then Dr Fillgrave, with a compression of his lips which almost
made the poor woman sink into the ground, moved towards the door.
Then Lady Scatcherd bethought of her great panacea. 'It isn't about the money, you know, doctor,' said she;
'of course Sir Roger don't expect you to come here with posthorses for nothing.' In this, by the by, Lady
Scatcherd did not stick quite close to veracity, for Sir Roger, had he known it, would by no means have
assented to any payment; and the note which her ladyship held in her hand was taken from her own private
purse. 'It ain't about the money, doctor;' and then she tendered the banknote, which she thought would
immediately make all things smooth.
Now Dr Fillgrave dearly loved a fivepound fee. What physician is so unnatural as not to love it? He dearly
loved a fivepound fee; but he loved his dignity better. He was angry also; and like all angry men, he loved
his grievance. He felt that he had been badly treated; but if he took the money he would throw away his right
to indulge in any such feeling. At that moment his outraged dignity and cherished anger were worth more
than a fivepound note. He looked at it with wishful but still averted eyes, and then sternly refused the tender.
'No, madam,' said he; 'no, no;' and with his right hand raised with his eyeglasses in it, he motioned away the
tempting paper. 'No; I should have been happy to have given Sir Roger the benefit of any medical skill I may
have, seeing that I was specially called in'
'But, doctor; if the man's well, you know'
'Oh, of course; if he's well, and does not choose to see me, there's an end of it. Should he have any relapse, as
my time is valuable, he will perhaps oblige me by sending elsewhere. Madam, good morning. I will, if you
will allow me, ring for my carriagethat is, postchaise.'
'But, doctor, you'll take the money; you must take the money; indeed you'll take the money,' said Lady
Scatcherd, who had now become really unhappy at the idea of her husband's unpardonable whim had brought
this man with posthorses all the way from Barchester, and that he was to be paid nothing for his time or
costs.
'No, madam, no. I could not think of it. Sir Roger, I have no doubt, will know better another time. It is not a
question of money; not at all.'
'But it is a question of money, doctor; and you really shall, you must.' And poor Lady Scatcherd, in her
anxiety to acquit herself at any rate of any pecuniary debt to the doctor, came to personal close quarters with
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR 88
Page No 92
him, with a view of forcing the note into his hands.
'Quite impossible, quite impossible,' said the doctor, still cherishing his grievance, and valiantly rejecting the
root of all evil. 'I shall not do anything of the kind, Lady Scatcherd.'
'Now doctor, do 'ee; to oblige me.'
'Quite out of the question.' And so, with his hands and hat behind his back, in token of his utter refusal to
accept any pecuniary accommodation of his injury, he made his way backwards to the door, her ladyship
perseveringly pressing him in front. So eager had been the attack on him, that he had not waited to give his
order about the postchaise, but made his way at once towards the hall.
'Now, do 'ee take it, do 'ee,' pressed Lady Scatcherd.
'Utterly out of the question,' said Dr Fillgrave, with great deliberation, as he backed his way into the hall. As
he did so, of course he turned round,and he found himself almost in the arms of Dr Thorne.
As Burley might have glared at Bothwell when they rushed together in the dread encounter on the mountain
side; as Achilles may have glared at Hector when at last they met, each resolved to test in fatal conflict the
prowess of the other, so did Dr Fillgrave glare at his foe from Greshamsbury, when, on turning round on his
exalted heel, he found his nose on a level with the top button of Dr Thorne's waistcoat.
And here, if it be not too tedious, let us pause a while to recapitulate and add up the undoubted grievances of
the Barchester practitioner. He had made no effort to ingratiate himself into the sheepfold of that other
shepherddog; it was not by his seeking that he was not at Boxall Hill; much as he hated Dr Thorne, full sure
as he felt of that man's utter ignorance, of his incapacity to administer properly even a black dose, of his
murdering propensities and his low, mean, unprofessional style of practice; nevertheless, he had done nothing
to undermine him with these Scatcherds. Dr Thorne might have sent every mother's son at Boxall Hill to his
long account, and Dr Fillgrave would not have interfered;would not have interfered unless specially and
duly called upon to do so.
But he had been and duly called on. Before such a step was taken some words must undoubtedly have passed
on the subject between Thorne and Scatcherds. Thorne must have known what was to be done. Having been
so called, Dr Fillgrave had comehad come all the way in a postchaisehad been refused admittance to
the sick man's room, on the plea that the sick man was no longer sick; and just as he was about to retire
feelessfor the want of the fee was not the less a grievance from the fact of its having been tendered and
refusedfeeless, dishonoured, and in dudgeon, he encountered this other doctorthis very rival whom he
had bee sent to supplant; he encountered him in the very act of going to the sick man's room.
What mad fanatic Burley, what godsuccoured insolent Achilles, ever had such cause to swell with wrath as
at that moment had Dr Fillgrave? Had I the pen of Moliere, I could fitly tell of such medical anger, but with
no other pen can it be fitly told. He did swell, and when the huge bulk of his wrath was added to his natural
proportions, he loomed gigantic before the eyes of the surrounding followers of Sir Roger.
Dr Thorne stepped back three steps and took his hat from his head, having, in the passage from the halldoor
to the diningroom, hitherto omitted to do so. It must be borne in mind that he had to conception whatever
that Sir Roger had declined to see the physician for whom he had sent; none whatever that the physician was
not about to return, feeless, to Barchester.
Dr Thorne and Dr Fillgrave were doubtless wellknown enemies. All the world of Barchester, and all that
portion of the world of London which is concerned with the lancet and the scalpingknife, were well aware
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR 89
Page No 93
of this: they were continually writing against each other; continually speaking against each other; but yet they
had never hitherto come to that positive personal collision which is held to justify a cut direct. They very
rarely saw each other; and when they did meet, it was in some casual way in the streets of Barchester or
elsewhere, and on such occasions their habit had been to bow with very cold propriety.
On the present occasion, Dr Thorne of course felt that Dr Fillgrave had the whiphand of him; and, with a
sort of manly feeling on such a point, he conceived it to be most compatible with his own dignity to show,
under such circumstances, more than his usual courtesysomething, perhaps, amounting almost to
cordiality. He had been supplanted, quoad doctor, in the house of this rich, eccentric, railway baronet, and he
would show that he bore no malice on that account.
So he smiled blandly as he took off his hat, and in a civil speech he expressed a hope that Dr Fillgrave had
not found his patient to be in any very unfavourable state.
Here was an aggravation to the already lacerated feelings of the injured man. He had been brought thither to
be scoffed at and scorned at, that he might be a laughingstock to his enemies, and food for mirth to the
vileminded. He swelled with noble anger till he would have burst, had it not been for the opportune padding
of his frockcoat.
'Sir,' said he; 'sir:' and he could hardly get his lips open to give vent to the tumult of his heart. Perhaps he was
not wrong; for it may be that his lips were more eloquent than would have been his words.
'What's the matter?' said Dr Thorne, opening his eyes wide, and addressing Lady Scatcherd over his head and
across the hairs of the irritated man below him. 'What on earth is the matter? Is anything wrong with Sir
Roger?'
'Oh, laws, doctor!' said her ladyship. 'Oh, laws; I'm sure it ain't my fault. Here's Dr Fillgrave, in a taking, and
I'm quite ready to pay himquite. If a man gets paid, what more can he want?' And she again held out the
fivepound note over Dr Fillgrave's head.
What more, indeed, Lady Scatcherd, can any of us want, if only we could keep our tempers and feelings a
little in abeyance? Dr Fillgrave, however, could not so keep his; and, therefore, he did want something more,
though at the present moment he could hardly have said what.
Lady Scatcherd's courage was somewhat resuscitated by the presence of her ancient trusty ally; and,
moreover, she began to conceive that the little man before her was unreasonable beyond all conscience with
his anger, seeing that that for which he was ready to work had been offered him without any work at all.
'Madam,' said he, again turning round at Lady Scatcherd, 'I was never before treated in such a way in any
house in Barchesternevernever.'
'Good heavens, Dr Fillgrave!' said he of Greshamsbury, 'what is the matter?'
'I'll let you know what is the matter, sir,' said he, turning round again as quickly as before. 'I'll let you know
what is the matter. I'll publish this, sir, to the medical world;' and as he shrieked out the words of the threat,
he stood on tiptoes and brandished his eyeglasses up almost into his enemy's face.
'Don't be angry with Dr Thorne,' said Lady Scatcherd. 'Any ways, you needn't be angry with him. If you must
be angry with anybody'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR 90
Page No 94
'I shall be angry with him, madam,' ejaculated Dr Fillgrave, making another sudden demipirouette. 'I am
angry with himor, rather, I despise him;' and completing the circle, Dr Fillgrave again brought himself
round in full front of his foe.
Dr Thorne raised his eyebrows and looked inquiringly at Lady Scatcherd; but there was a quiet sarcastic
motion round his mouth which by no means had the effect of throwing oil on the troubled waters.
'I'll publish the whole of this transaction to the medical world, Dr Thornethe whole of it; and if that has not
the effect of rescuing the people of Greshamsbury out of your hands, thenthenthen, I don't know what
will. Is my carriagethat is, the postchaise there?' and Dr Fillgrave, speaking very loudly, turned
majestically to one of the servants.
'What have I done to you, Dr Fillgrave,' said Dr Thorne, now absolutely laughing, 'that you should
determined to take the bread out of my mouth? I am not interfering with your patient. I have come here
simply with reference to money matters appertaining to Sir Roger.'
'Money matters! Very wellvery well; money matters. That is your idea of medical practice. Very
wellvery well. Is my postchaise at the door? I'll publish it all to the medical worldevery wordevery
word of it, every word of it.'
'Publish what, you unreasonable man?'
'Man! sir; whom do you call a man? I'll let you know whether I'm a manpostchaise there!'
'Don't 'ee call him names now, doctor; don't 'ee pray don't 'ee,' said Lady Scatcherd.
By this time they had all got somewhere nearer the halldoor; but the Scatcherd retainers were too fond of
the row to absent themselves willingly at Dr Fillgrave's bidding, and it did not appear that any one went in
search of the postchaise.
'Man! sir; I'll let you know what it is to speak to me in that style. I think, sir, you hardly know who I am.'
'All that I know of you at present is, that you are my friend Sir Roger's physician, and I cannot conceive what
has occurred to make you so angry.' And as he spoke, Dr Thorne looked carefully at him to see whether that
pumpdiscipline had in truth been applied. There were no signs whatever that cold water had been thrown
upon Dr Fillgrave.
'My postchaiseis may postchaise there? The medical world shall know all; you may be sure, sir, the
medical world shall know it all;' and thus, ordering his postchaise and threatening Dr Thorne with the
medical world, Dr Fillgrave made his way to the door.
But the moment he put on his hat he returned. 'No, madam,' said he. 'No; quite out of the question: such an
affair is not to be arranged by such means. I'll publish it all to the medical worldpostchaise there!' and
then, using all his force, he flung as far as he could into the hall a light bit of paper. It fell at Dr Thorne's feet,
who, raising it, found that it was a fivepound note.
'I put it into his hat just while he was in his tantrum,' said Lady Scatcherd. 'And I thought that perhaps he
would not find it till he got to Barchester. Well I wish he'd been paid, certainly, although Sir Roger wouldn't
see him;' and in this manner Dr Thorne got some glimpse of understanding into the cause of the great offence.
'I wonder whether Sir Roger will see me,' said he, laughing.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR 91
Page No 95
CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES
'Ha! ha! ha! Ha! ha! ha!' laughed Sir Roger, lustily, as Dr Thorne entered the room. 'Well, if that ain't rich, I
don't know what is. Ha! ha! ha! But why didn't they put him under the pump, doctor?'
The doctor, however, had too much tact, and too many things of importance to say, to allow of his giving up
much time to the discussion of Dr Fillgrave's wrath. He had come determined to open the baronet's eyes as to
what would be the real effect of his will, and he had also to negotiate a loan for Mr Gresham, if that might be
possible. Dr Thorne therefore began about the loan, that being the easier subject, and found that Sir Roger
was quite clearheaded as to his many money concerns, in spite of his illness. Sir Roger was willing enough
to lend Mr Gresham more moneysix, eight, ten, twenty thousand; but then, in doing so, he should insist on
possession of the titledeeds.
'What! the titledeeds of Greshamsbury for a few thousand pounds?' said the doctor.
'I don't know whether you call ninety thousand pounds a few thousands; but the debt will about amount to
that.'
'Ah! that's the old debt.'
'Old and new together, of course; every shilling I lend more weakens my security for what I have lent before.'
'But you have the first claim, Sir Roger.'
'It ought to be first and last to cover such a debt as that. If he wants further accommodation, he must part with
his deeds, doctor.'
The point was argued backwards and forwards for some time without avail, and the doctor then thought it
well to introduce the other subject.
'Sir Roger, you're a hard man.'
'No I ain't,' said Sir Roger; 'not a bit hard; that is, not a bit too hard. Money is always hard. I know I found it
hard to come by; and there is no reason why Squire Gresham should expect to find me so very soft.'
'Very well; there is an end of that. I thought you would have done as much to oblige me, that is all.'
'What! take bad security too oblige you?'
'Well, there's an end of that.'
'I'll tell you what; I'll do as much to oblige a friend as any one. I'll lend you five thousand pounds, you
yourself, without security at all, if you want it.'
'But you know I don't want it; or, at any rate, shan't take it.'
'But to ask me to go on lending money to a third party, and he over head and ears in debt, by way of obliging
you, why, it's a little too much.'
'Well, there's and end of it. Now I've something to say to you about that will of yours.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES 92
Page No 96
'Oh! that's settled.'
'No, Scatcherd; it isn't settled. It must be a great deal more settled before we have done with it, as you'll find
when you hear what I have to tell you.'
'What you have to tell me!' said Sir Roger, sitting up in bed; 'and what have you to tell me?'
'Your will says you sister's eldest child.'
'Yes; but that's only in the event of Louis Philippe dying before he is twentyfive.'
'Exactly; and now I know something about your sister's eldest child, and, therefore, I have come to tell you.'
'You know something about Mary's eldest child?'
'I do, Scatcherd; it is a strange story, and maybe it will make you angry. I cannot help it if it does so. I should
not tell you this if I could avoid it; but as I do tell you, for your sake, as you will see, and not for my own, I
must implore you not to tell my secret to others.'
Sir Roger now looked at him with an altered countenance. There was something in his voice of the
authoritative tone of other days, something in the doctor's look which had on the baronet the same effect
which in former days it had sometimes had on the stonemason.
'Can you give me a promise, Scatcherd, that what I am about to tell you shall not be repeated?'
'A promise! Well, I don't know what it's about, you know. I don't like promises in the dark.'
'Then I must leave it to your honour; for what I have to say must be said. You remember my brother,
Scatcherd?'
Remember his brother! thought the rich man to himself. The name of the doctor's brother had not been
alluded to between them since the days of that trial; but still it was impossible but that Scatcherd should well
remember him.
'Yes, yes; certainly. I remember your brother,' said he. 'I remember him well; there's no doubt about that.'
'Well, Scatcherd,' and, as he spoke, the doctor laid his hand with kindness on the other's arm. 'Mary's eldest
child was my brother's child as well.
'But there is no such child living,' said Sir Roger; and, in his violence, as he spoke he threw from off him the
bedclothes, and tried to stand up on the floor. He found, however, that he had no strength for such an effort,
and was obliged to remain leaning on the bed and resting on the doctor's arm.
'There was no such child ever lived,' said he. 'What do you mean by this?'
Dr Thorne would say nothing further till he had got the man into bed again. This he at last affected, and then
he went on with the story in his own way.
'Yes, Scatcherd, that child is alive; and for fear that you should unintentionally make her your heir, I have
thought it right to tell you this.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES 93
Page No 97
'A girl, is it?'
'Yes, a girl.'
'And why should you want to spite her? If she is Mary's child, she is your brother's child also. If she is my
niece, she must be your niece also. Why should you want to spite her? Why should you try to do her such a
terrible injury?'
'I do not want to spite her.'
'Where is she? Who is she? What is she called? Where does she live?'
The doctor did not at once answer all these questions. He had made up his mind that he would tell Sir Roger
that this child was living, but he had not as yet resolved to make known all the circumstances of her history.
He was not even yet quite aware whether it would be necessary to say that this foundling orphan was the
cherished darling of his own house.
'Such a child, is, at any rate, living,' said he; 'of that I give you my assurance; and under your will, as now
worded, it might come to pass that that child should be your heir. I do not want to spite her, but I should be
wrong to let you make your will without such knowledge, seeing that I am in possession of it myself.'
'But where is the girl?'
'I do not know that that signifies.'
'Signifies! Yes; it does signify, a great deal. But, Thorne, Thorne, now that I remember it, now that I can
think of things, it waswas it not you yourself who told me that the baby did not live?'
'Very possibly.'
'And was it a lie that you told me?'
'If so, yes. But it is no lie that I tell you now.'
'I believed you then, Thorne; then, when I was a poor, brokendown daylabourer, lying in jail, rotting there;
but I tell you fairly, I do not believe you now. You have some scheme in this.'
'Whatever scheme I may have, you can frustrate by making another will. What can I gain by telling you this?
I only do so to induce you to be more explicit in naming your heir.'
They both remained silent for a while, during which the baronet poured out from his hidden resource a glass
of brandy and swallowed it.
'When a man is taken aback suddenly by such tidings as these, he must take a drop of something, eh, doctor?'
Dr Thorne did not seen the necessity; but the present, he felt, was no time for arguing the point.
'Come, Thorne, where is the girl? You must tell me that. She is my niece, and I have a right to know. She
shall come here, and I will do something for her. By the Lord! I would as soon she had the money as anyone
else, if she's anything of a good 'un;some of it, that is. Is she a good 'un?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES 94
Page No 98
'Good!' said the doctor, turning away his face. 'Yes; she is good enough.'
'She must be grown up by now. None of your light skirts, eh?'
'She is a good girl,' said the doctor somewhat loudly and sternly. He could hardly trust himself to say much
on this point.
'Mary was a good girl, a very good girl, till'and Sir Roger raised himself up in his bed with his fist
clenched, as though he were again about to strike that fatal blow at the farmyard gate. 'But come, it's no
good thinking of that; you behaved well and manly, always. And so poor Mary's child is alive; at least, you
say so.'
'I say so, and you may believe it. Why should I deceive you?'
'No, no; I don't see why. But then why did you deceive me before?'
To this the doctor chose to make no answer, and again there was silence for a while.
'What do you call her, doctor?'
'Her name is Mary.'
'The prettiest women's name going; there's no name like it,' said the contractor, with an unusual tenderness in
his voice. 'Maryyes; but Mary what? What other name does she go by?'
Here the doctor hesitated.
'Mary Scatcherdeh?'
'No. Not Mary Scatcherd.'
'Not Mary Scatcherd! Mary what, then? you, with your d pride, wouldn't let her be called Mary Thorne, I
know.'
This was too much for the doctor. He felt that there were tears in his eyes, so he walked away to the window
to dry them, unseen. He had fifty names, each more sacred than the other, the most sacred of them all would
hardly have been good enough for her.
'Mary what, doctor? Come, if the girl is to belong to me, if I am to provide for her, I must know what to call
her, and where to look for her.'
'Who talked of your providing for her?,' said the doctor, turning round at the rival uncle. 'Who said that she
was to belong to you? She will be no burden to you; you are only told of this that you may not leave your
money to her without knowing it. She is provided forthat is, she wants nothing; she will do well enough;
you need not trouble yourself about her.'
'But is she's Mary's child, Mary's child in real truth, I will trouble myself about her. Who else should do so?
For the matter of that, I'd soon say her as any of those others in America. What do I care about blood? I shan't
mind her being a bastard. That is to say, of course, if she's decently good. Did she ever get any kind of
teaching; booklearning, or anything of that sort?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES 95
Page No 99
Dr Thorne at this moment hated his friend the baronet with almost a deadly hatred; that he, rough brute as he
wasfor he was a rough brutethat he should speak in such language of the angel who gave to that home
in Greshamsbury so many of the joys of Paradisethat he should speak of her as in some degree his own,
that he should inquire doubtingly as to her attributes and her virtues. And then the doctor thought of her
Italian and French readings, of her music, of her nice books, and sweet lady ways, of her happy
companionship with Patience Oriel, and her dear, bosom friendship with Beatrice Gresham. He thought of
her grace, and winning manners, and soft, polished feminine beauty; and, as he did so, he hated Sir Roger
Scatcherd, and regarded him with loathing, as he might have regarded a wallowinghog.
At last a light seemed to break in upon Sir Roger's mind. Dr Thorne, he perceived, did not answer his last
question. He perceived, also, that the doctor was affected with some more than ordinary emotion. Why
should it be that this subject of Mary Scatcherd's child moved him so deeply? Sir Roger had never been at the
doctor's house at Greshamsbury, had never seen Mary Thorne, but he had heard that there lived with the
doctor some young female relative; and thus a glimmering light seemed to come in upon Sir Roger's bed.
He had twitted the doctor with his pride; had said that it was impossible that the girl should be called Mary
Thorne. What if she were so called? What if she were now warming herself at the doctor's hearth?
'Well, come, Thorne, what is it you call her? Tell it out, man. And, look you, if it's your name she bears, I
shall think more of you, a deal more than ever I did yet. Come, Thorne, I'm her uncle too. I have a right to
know. She is Mary Thorne, isn't she?'
The doctor had not the hardihood nor the resolution to deny it. 'Yes,' said he, 'that is her name; she lives with
me.'
'Yes, and lives with all those grand folks at Greshamsbury too. I have heard of that.'
'She lives with me, and belongs to me, and is as my daughter.'
'She shall come over here. Lady Scatcherd shall have her to stay with her. She shall come to us. And as for
my will, I'll make another. I'll'
'Yes, make another willor else alter that one. But as to Miss Thorne coming here'
'What! Mary'
'Well, Mary. As to Mary Thorne coming here, that I fear will not be possible. She cannot have two homes.
She has cast her lot with one of her uncles, and she must remain with him now.'
'Do you mean to say that she must have any relation but one?'
'But one such as I am. She would not be happy over here. She does not like new faces. You have enough
depending on you; I have but her.'
'Enough! why, I have only Louis Philippe. I could provide for a dozen girls.'
'Well, well, well, we will not talk about that.'
'Ah! but, Thorne, you have told me of this girl now, and I cannot but talk of her. If you wished to keep the
matter dark, you should have said nothing about it. She is my niece as much as yours. And, Thorne, I loved
my sister Mary quite as well as you loved your brother; quite as well.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES 96
Page No 100
Any one who might have heard and seen the contractor would have hardly thought him to be the same man
who, a few hours before, was urging that the Barchester physician should be put under the pump.
'You have your son, Scatcherd. I have no one but that girl.'
'I don't want to take her from you. I don't want to take her; but surely there can be no harm in her coming here
to see us? I can provide for her, Thorne, remember that. I can provide for her without reference to Louis
Philippe. What are ten or fifteen thousand pounds to me? Remember that, Thorne.'
Dr Thorne did remember it. In that interview he remembered many things, and much passed through his mind
on which he felt himself compelled to resolve somewhat too suddenly. Would he be justified in rejecting, on
behalf of Mary, the offer of pecuniary provision which this rich relative would be so well inclined to make?
Or, if he accepted ti, would be in truth be studying her interests? Scatcherd was a selfwilled, obstinate
mannow indeed touched by unwonted tenderness; but he was one of those whose lasting tenderness Dr
Thorne would be very unwilling to trust his darling. He did resolve, that on the whole he should best
discharge his duty, even to her, by keeping her to himself, and rejecting, on her behalf, any participation in
the baronet's wealth. As Mary herself had said, 'some people must be bound together;' and their destiny, that
of himself and his niece, seemed to have so bound them. She had found her place at Greshamsbury, her place
in the world; and it would be better for her now to keep it, than to go forth and seek another that would be
richer, but at the same time less suited to her.
'No, Scatcherd,' he said at last, 'she cannot come here; she would not be happy here, and, to tell the truth I do
not wish her to know that she has other relatives.'
'Ah! she would be ashamed of her mother, you mean, and of her mother's brother too, eh? She's too fine a
lady, I suppose, to take me by the hand and give me a kiss, and call me her uncle? I and Lady Scatcherd
would not be grand enough for her, eh?'
'You may say what you please, Scatcherd: I of course cannot stop you.'
'But I don't know how you'll reconcile what you are doing with your conscience. What right can you have to
throw away the girl's chance, now that she has a chance? What fortune can you give her?'
'I have done what little I could,' said Thorne, proudly.
'Well, well, well, well, I never heard such a thing in my life; never. Mary's child, my own Mary's child, and
I'm not to see her! But, Thorne, I tell you what; I will see her. I'll go over to her, I'll go to Greshamsbury, and
tell her who I am, and what I can do for her. I tell you fairly I will. You shall not keep her away from those
who belong to her, and can do her a good turn. Mary's daughter; another Mary Scatcherd! I almost wish she
were called Mary Scatcherd. Is she like her, Thorne? Come tell me that; is she like her mother.'
'I do not remember her mother; at least not in health.'
'Not remember her! ah, well. She was the handsomest girl in Barchester, anyhow. That was given up to her.
Well, I didn't think to be talking of her again. Thorne, you cannot but expect that I shall go over and see
Mary's child?'
'Now, Scatcherd, look here,' and the doctor, coming away from the window, where he had been standing, sat
himself down by the bedside, 'you must not come over to Greshamsbury.'
'Oh! but I shall.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES 97
Page No 101
'Listen to me, Scatcherd. I do not want to praise myself in any way; but when that girl was an infant, six
months old, she was like to be a thorough obstacle to her mother's fortune in life. Tomlinson was willing to
marry your sister, but he would not marry the child too. Then I took the baby, and I promised her mother that
I would be to her as a father. I have kept my word as fairly as I have been able. She has sat at my hearth, and
drunk of my cup, and been to me as my own child. After that, I have the right to judge what is best for her.
Her life is not like your life, and her ways are not as your ways'
'Ah, that is just it; we are too vulgar for her.'
'You may take it as you will,' said the doctor, who was too much in earnest to be in the least afraid of
offending his companion. 'I have not said so; but I do say that you and she are unlike in the way of living.'
'She wouldn't like an uncle with a brandy bottle under his head, eh?'
'You could not see her without letting her know what is the connexion between you; of that I wish to keep her
in ignorance.'
'I never knew any one yet who is ashamed of a rich connexion. How do you mean to get a husband for her,
eh?'
'I have told you of her existence,' continued the doctor, not appearing to notice what the baronet had last said,
'because I found it necessary that you should know the fact of your sister having left a child behind her; you
would otherwise have made a will different from that intended, and there might have been a lawsuit, and
mischief, and misery when we are gone. You must perceive that I have done this in honesty to you; and you
yourself are too honest to repay me by taking advantage of this knowledge to make me unhappy.'
'Oh, very well, doctor. At any rate, you are a brick, I will say that. But I'll think of this, I'll think of it; but it
does startle me to find that poor Mary has a child living so near to me.'
'And now, Scatcherd, I will say goodbye. We part as friends, don't we?'
'Oh, but doctor, you ain't going to leave me so. What am I to do? What doses shall I take? How much brandy
may I drink? May I have a grill for dinner? D me, doctor, you have turned Fillgrave out of the house.
You mustn't go and desert me.'
Dr Thorne laughed, and then, sitting himself down to write medically, gave such prescriptions and ordinances
as he found to be necessary. They announced but to this: that the man was to drink, if possible, no brandy;
and if that were not possible, then as little as might be.
This having been done, the doctor again proceeded to take his leave; but when he got to the door he was
called back. 'Thorne! Thorne! About that money for Mr Gresham; do what you like, do just what you like.
Ten thousand is it? Well, he shall have it. I'll make Winterbones write about it at once. Five per cent., isn't it?
No, four and a half. Well, he shall have ten thousand more.'
'Thank you, Scatcherd, thank you, I am really very much obliged to you, I am indeed. I wouldn't ask it if I
was not sure your money is safe. Goodbye, old fellow, and get rid of that bedfellow of yours,' and again he
was at the door.
'Thorne,' said Sir Roger once more. 'Thorne, just come back for a minute. You wouldn't let me send a present
would youfifty pounds or so,just to buy a few flounces?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES 98
Page No 102
The doctor contrived to escape without giving a definite answer to this question; and then, having paid his
compliments to Lady Scatcherd, remounted his cob and rode back to Greshamsbury.
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE
Dr Thorne did not at once go home to his own house. When he reached the Greshamsbury gates, he sent his
horse to its own stable by one of the people at the lodge, and then walked on to the mansion. He had to see
the squire on the subject of the forthcoming loan, and he had also to see the Lady Arabella.
The Lady Arabella, though she was not personally attached to the doctor with quite so much warmth as some
others of her family, still had reasons of her own for not dispensing with his visits to the house. She was one
of his patients, and a patient fearful of the disease with which she was threatened. Though she thought the
doctor to be arrogant, deficient as to properly submissive demeanour towards herself, an instigator to marital
parsimony in her lord, one altogether opposed to herself and her interest in Greshamsbury politics,
nevertheless she did feel trust in him as a medical man. She had no wish to be rescued out of his hands by any
Dr Fillgrave, as regarded that complaint of hers, much as she may have desired, and did desire, to sever him
from all Greshamsbury councils in all matters not touching the healing art.
Now the complaint of which the Lady Arabella was afraid, was cancer: and her only present confidant in this
matter was Dr Thorne.
The first of the Greshamsbury circle whom he saw was Beatrice, and he met her in the garden.
'Oh, doctor,' said she, 'where has Mary been this age? She has not been up here since Frank's birthday.'
'Well, that was only three days ago. Why don't you go down and ferret her out in the village?'
'So I have done. I was there just now, and found her out. She was out with Patience Oriel. Patience is all and
all with her now. Patience is all very well, but if they throw me over'
'My dear Miss Gresham, Patience is and always was a virtue.'
'A poor, beggarly, sneaking virtue after all, doctor. They should have come up, seeing how deserted I am
here. There's absolutely nobody left.'
'Has Lady de Courcy gone?'
'Oh, yes! All the De Courcys have gone. I think, between ourselves, Mary stays away because she does not
love them too well. They have all gone, and taken Augusta and Frank with them.'
'Has Frank gone to Courcy Castle?'
'Oh, yes; did you not hear? There was rather a fight about it. Master Frank wanted to get off, and was as hard
to catch as an eel, and then the countess was offended; and papa said he didn't see why Frank was to go if he
didn't like it. Papa is very anxious about his degree, you know.'
The doctor understood it all as well as though it had been described to him at full length. The countess had
claimed her prey, in order that she might carry him off to Miss Dunstable's golden embrace. The prey, not yet
old enough and wise enough to connect the worship of Plutus with that of Venus, had made sundry futile
feints and dodges in the vain hope of escape. Then the anxious mother had enforced the De Courcy behests
with all a mother's authority. But the father, whose ideas on the subject of Miss Dunstable's wealth had
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 99
Page No 103
probably not been consulted, had, as a matter of course, taken exactly the other side of the question. The
doctor did not require to be told all this in order to know how the battle had raged. He had not yet heard of the
great Dunstable scheme; but he was sufficiently acquainted with Greshamsbury tactics to understand that the
war had been carried on somewhat after this fashion.
As a rule, when the squire took a point warmly to heart, he was wont to carry his way against the De Courcy
interest. He could be obstinate enough when it so pleased him, and had before now gone so far as to tell his
wife, that her thricenoble sisterinlaw might remain at home at Courcy Castleor, at any rate, not come
to Greshamsburyif she could not do so without striving to rule him and every one else when she got here.
This had of course been repeated to the countess, who had merely replied to it by a sisterly whisper, in which
she sorrowfully intimated that some men were born brutes, and always would remain so.
'I think they all are,' the Lady Arabella had replied; wishing, perhaps, to remind her sisterinlaw that the
breed of brutes was as rampant in West Barsetshire as in the eastern division of that county.
The squire, however, had not fought on this occasion with all his vigour. There had, of course, been some
passages between him and his son, and it had been agreed that Frank should go for a fortnight to Courcy
Castle.
'We mustn't quarrel with them, you know, if we can help it,' said the father; 'and, therefore, you must go
sooner or later.'
'Well, I suppose so; but you don't know how dull it is, governor.'
'Don't I!' said Gresham.
'There's a Miss Dunstable to be there; did you ever hear of her, sir?'
'No, never.'
'She's a girl whose father used to make ointment, or something of that sort.'
'Oh, yes, to be sure; the ointment of Lebanon. He used to cover all the walls of London. I haven't heard of
him this year past.'
'No; that is because he's dead. Well, she carries on the ointment now, I believe; at any rate, she has got all the
money. I wonder what she's like?'
'You'd better go and see,' said the father, who now began to have some inkling of an idea why the two ladies
were so anxious to carry his son off to Courcy Castle at this exact time. And so Frank had packed up his best
clothes, given a last fond look at the new black horse, repeated his last special injunctions to Peter, and had
then made one of the stately cortege which proceeded through the county from Greshamsbury to Courcy
Castle.
'I am very glad of that, very,' said the squire, when he heard that the money was to be forthcoming. 'I shall get
it on easier terms from him than elsewhere; and it kills me to have continual bother about such things.' And
Mr Gresham, feeling that that difficulty was tided over for a time, and that the immediate pressure of little
debts would be abated, stretched himself on his easy chair as though he were quite comfortable;one may
say almost elated.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 100
Page No 104
How frequent it is that men on their road to ruin feel elation such as this! A man signs away moiety of his
substance; nay, that were nothing; but a moiety of the substance of his children; he puts his pen to the paper
that ruins him and them; but in doing so he frees himself from a source of immediate little pestering, stinging
troubles: and, therefore, feels as though fortune has been almost kind to him.
The doctor felt angry with himself for what he had done when he saw how easily the squire adapted himself
to this new loan. 'It will make Scatcherd's claim upon you very heavy,' said he.
Mr Gresham at once read all that was passing through the doctor's mind. 'Well, what else can I do?' said he.
'You wouldn't have me allow my daughter to lose this match for the sake of a few thousand pounds? It will be
well at any rate to have one of them settled. Look at that letter from Moffat.'
The doctor took the letter and read it. It was a long, wordy, illwritten rigmarole, in which that amorous
gentleman spoke with much rapture of his love and devotion for Miss Gresham; but at the same time
declared, and most positively swore, that the adverse cruelty of his circumstances was such, that it would not
allow him to stand up like a man at the hymeneal altar until six thousand pounds hard cash had been paid
down at his banker's.
'It may be all right,' said the squire; 'but in my time gentlemen were not used to write such letters as that to
each other.'
The doctor shrugged his shoulders. He did not know how far he would be justified in saying much, even to
his friend the squire, in dispraise of his future soninlaw.
'I told him that he should have the money; and one would have thought that that would have been enough for
him. Well: I suppose Augusta likes him. I suppose she wishes the match; otherwise, I would give him such an
answer to that letter as would startle him a little.'
'What settlement is he to make?' said Thorne.
'Oh, that's satisfactory enough; couldn't be more so; a thousand a year and the house at Wimbledon for her;
that's all very well. But such a lie, you know, Thorne. He's rolling in money, and yet he talks of this beggarly
sum as though he couldn't possibly stir without it.'
'If I might venture to speak my mind,' said Thorne.
'Well?' said the squire, looking at him earnestly.
'I should be inclined to say that Mr Moffat wants to cry off, himself.'
'Oh, impossible; quite impossible. In the first place, he was so very anxious for the match. In the next place, it
is such a great thing for him. And then, he would never dare; you see, he is dependent on the De Courcys for
his seat.'
'But suppose he loses his seat?'
'But there is not much fear of that, I think. Scatcherd may be a very fine fellow, but I think they'll hardly
return him at Barchester.'
'I don't understand much about it,' said Thorne; 'but such things do happen.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 101
Page No 105
'And you believe that this man absolutely wants to get off the match; absolutely thinks of playing such a trick
as that on my daughter;on me?'
'I don't say he intends to do it; but it looks to me as though he were making a door for himself, or trying to
make a door: if so, your having the money will stop him there.'
'But, Thorne, don't you think he loves the girl? If I thought not'
The doctor was silent for a moment, and then he said, 'I am not a lovemaking man myself, but I think that if
I were much in love with a young lady, I should not write such a letter as that to her father.'
'By heavens! If I thought so,' said the squire'but, Thorne, we can't judge of those fellows as one does of
gentlemen; they are so used to making money, and seeing money made, that they have an eye to business in
everything.'
'Perhaps so, perhaps so,' muttered the doctor, showing evidently that he still doubted the warmth of Mr
Moffat's affection.
'The match was none of my making, and I cannot interfere now to break it off: it will give her a good position
in the world; for, after all, money goes a great way, and it is something to be in Parliament. I can only hope
she likes him. I do truly hope she likes him;' and the squire also showed by the tone of his voice that, though
he might hope that his daughter was in love with her intended husband, he hardly conceived it to be possible
that she should be so.
And what was the truth of the matter? Miss Gresham was no more in love with Mr Moffat than you areoh,
sweet, young, blooming beauty! Not a whit more; not, at least, in your sense of the word, nor in mine. She
had by no means resolved within her heart that of all the men whom she had ever seen, or ever could see, he
was far away the nicest and the best. That is what you will do when you are in love, if you be good for
anything. She had no longing to sit near to himthe nearer the better; she had no thought of his taste and his
choice when she bought her ribbons and bonnets; she had not indescribable desire that all her female friends
should be ever talking to her about him. When she wrote to him, she did not copy her letters again and again,
so that she might be, as it were, ever speaking to him; she took no special pride in herself because he had
chosen her to be his life's partner. In point of fact, she did not care one straw about him.
And yet she thought she loved him; was, indeed, quite confident that she did so; told her mother that she was
sure Gustavus would wish this, she knew Gustavus would like that, and so on; but as for Gustavus himself,
she did not care one chip about him.
She was in love with her match just as farmers are in love with wheat and eighty shillings a quarter; or
shareholdersinnocent gudgeonswith seven and half per cent interest on their paid up capital. Eighty
shillings a quarter, and seven and half per cent interest, such were the returns which she had been taught to
look for in exchange for her young heart; and, having obtained them, or being thus about to obtain them, why
should not her young heart be satisfied? Had she not sat herself down obediently at the feet of her lady
Gamaliel, and should she not be rewarded? Yes, indeed, she shall be rewarded.
And then the doctor went to the lady. On their medical secrets we will not intrude; but there were other
matters bearing on the course of our narrative, as to which Lady Arabella found it necessary to say a word of
so to the doctor; and it is essential that we should know what was the tenor of those few words so spoken.
How the aspirations, and instincts, and feelings of a household become changed as the young birds begin to
flutter those feathered wings, and have halfformed thoughts of leaving the parental nest! A few months
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 102
Page No 106
back, Frank had reigned almost autocratic over the lesser subjects of the kingdom of Greshamsbury. The
servants, for instance, always obeyed him, and his sisters never dreamed of telling anything which he directed
should not be told. All his mischief, all his troubles, and all his loves were confided to them, with the sure
conviction that they would never be made to stand in evidence against him.
Trusting to this wellascertained state of things, he had not hesitated to declare his love for Miss Thorne
before his sister Augusta. But his sister Augusta had now, as it were, been received into the upper house;
having duly profited by the lessons of her great instructress, she was now admitted to sit in conclave with the
higher powers: her sympathies, of course, became changed, and her confidence was removed from the young
and giddy and given to the ancient and discreet. She was as a schoolboy, who, having finished his schooling,
and being fairly forced by necessity into the stern breadearning world, undertakes the new duties of tutoring.
Yesterday he was taught, and fought, of course, against the schoolmaster; today he teaches, and fights as
keenly for him. So it was with Augusta Gresham, when, with careful brow, she whispered to her mother that
there was something wrong between Frank and Mary Thorne.
'Stop it at once, Arabella: stop it at once,' the countess had said; 'that, indeed, will be the ruin. If he does not
marry money, he is lost. Good heavens! the doctor's niece! A girl that nobody knows where she comes from!'
'He's going with you tomorrow, you know,' said the anxious mother.
'Yes; and that is so far well: if he will be led by me, the evil may be remedied before he returns; but it is very,
very hard to lead young men. Arabella, you must forbid that girl to come to Greshamsbury again on any
pretext whatever. The evil must be stopped at once.'
'But she is here so much as a matter of course.'
'Then she must be here as a matter of course no more: there has been folly, very great folly, in having her
here. Of course she would turn out to be a designing creature with such temptation before her; with such a
prize within her reach, how could she help it?'
'I must say, aunt, she answered him very properly,' said Augusta.
'Nonsense,' said the countess; 'before you of course she did. Arabella, the matter must not be left to the girl's
propriety. I never knew the propriety of a girl of that sort to be fit to be depended on yet. If you wish to save
the whole family from ruin, you must take steps to keep her away from Greshamsbury now at once. Now is
the time; now that Frank is going away. Where so much, so very much depends on a young man's marrying
money, not one day ought to be lost.'
Instigated in this manner, Lady Arabella resolved to open her mind to the doctor, and to make it intelligible to
him, that under present circumstances, Mary's visits at Greshamsbury had better be discontinued. She would
have given much, however, to have escaped this business. She had in her time tried one or two falls with the
doctor, and she was conscious that she had never yet got the better of him: and then she was in a slight degree
afraid of Mary herself. She had a presentiment that it would not be so easy to banish Mary from
Greshamsbury: she was not sure that that young lady would not boldly assert her right to her place in the
schoolroom; appeal loudly to the squire, and perhaps, declare her determination of marrying the heir, out
before them all. The squire would be sure to uphold her in that, or in anything else.
And then, too, there would be the greatest difficulty in wording her request to the doctor; and Lady Arabella
was sufficiently conscious of her own weakness to know that she was not always very good at words. But the
doctor, when hard pressed, was never at fault: he could say the bitterest things in the quietest tone, and Lady
Arabella had a great dread of these bitter things. What, also, if he should desert her himself; withdraw from
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 103
Page No 107
her his skill and knowledge of her bodily wants and ailments now that he was so necessary to her? She had
once before taken that measure of sending to Barchester for Dr Fillgrave, but it had answered with her hardly
better than with Sir Roger and Lady Scatcherd.
When, therefore, Lady Arabella found herself alone with the doctor, and called upon to say out in what best
language she could select for the occasion, she did not feel to very much at her ease. There was that about the
man before her which cowed her, in spite of her being the wife of the squire, the sister of an earl, a person
quite acknowledged to be of the great world, and the mother of a very important young man whose affections
were now about to be called in question. Nevertheless, there was the task to be done, and with a mother's
courage she essayed it.
'Dr Thorne,' said she, as soon as their medical conference was at an end, 'I am very glad you came over
today, for I have something special which I wanted to say to you:' so far she got, and then stopped; but, as
the doctor did not seem inclined to give her any assistance, she was forced to flounder on as best she could.
'Something very particular indeed. You know what a respect and esteem, and I may say affection, we all have
for you,'here the doctor made a low bow'and I may say for Mary also;' here the doctor bowed himself
again. 'We have done what little we could to be pleasant neighbours, and I think you'll believe me when I say
that I am a true friend to you and dear Mary'
The doctor knew that something very unpleasant was coming, but he could not at all guess what might be its
nature. He felt, however, that he must say something; so he expressed a hope that he was duly sensible of all
the acts of kindness he had ever received from the squire and the family at large.
'I hope, therefore, my dear doctor, you won't take amiss what I am going to say.'
'Well, Lady Arabella, I'll endeavour not to do so.'
'I am sure I would not give any pain if I could help it, much less to you. But there are occasions, doctor, in
which duty must be paramount; paramount to all other considerations, you know, and, certainly, this occasion
is one of them.'
'But what is the occasion, Lady Arabella?'
'I'll tell you, doctor. You know what Frank's position is?'
'Frank's position?'
'Why his position in life; an only son, you know.'
'Oh, yes; I know his position in that respect; an only son, and his father's heir; and a very fine fellow, he is.
You have but one son, Lady Arabella, and you may well be proud of him.'
Lady Arabella sighed. She did not wish at the present moment to express herself as being in any way proud of
Frank. She was desirous rather, on the other hand, of showing that she was a good deal ashamed of him; only
not quite so much ashamed of him as it behoved the doctor to be of his niece.'
'Well, perhaps so; yes,' said Lady Arabella, 'he is, I believe, a very good young man, with an excellent
disposition; but, doctor, his position is very precarious; and he is just at that time of life when caution is
necessary.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 104
Page No 108
To the doctor's ears, Lady Arabella was now talking of her son as a mother might of her infant when
whoopingcough was abroad our croup imminent. 'There is nothing on earth the matter with him, I should
say,' said the doctor. 'He has every possible sign of perfect health.'
'Oh yes; his health! Yes, thank God, his health is good; that is a great blessing.' And Lady Arabella thought of
her four flowerets that had already faded. 'I am sure I am most thankful to see him growing up so strong. But
it is not that I mean, doctor.'
'Then what is it, Lady Arabella?'
'Why, doctor, the squire's position with regard to money matters.'
Now the doctor undoubtedly did know the squire's position with regard to money matters,knew it much
better than Lady Arabella; but he was by no means inclined to talk on that subject to her ladyship. He
remained quite silent, therefore, although Lady Arabella's last speech had taken the form of a question. Lady
Arabella was a little offended at this want of freedom on his part, and become somewhat sterner in her
tonea thought less condescending in her manner.
'The squire has unfortunately embarrassed the property, and Frank must look forward to inherit it with very
heavy encumbrances; I fear very heavy indeed, though of what exact nature I am kept in ignorance.'
Looking at the doctor's face, she perceived that there was no probability whatever that her ignorance would
be enlightened by him.
'And, therefore, it is highly necessary that Frank should be very careful.'
'As to his private expenditure, you mean?' said the doctor.
'No; not exactly that: though of course he must be careful as to that, too; that's of course. But that is not what
I mean, doctor; his only hope of retrieving his circumstances is by marrying money.'
'With every other conjugal blessing that a man can have, I hope he may have that also.' So the doctor replied
with imperturbable face; but not the less did he begin to have a shade of suspicion of what might be the
coming subject of the conference. It would be untrue to say that he had ever thought it probable that the
young heir should fall in love with his niece; that he had ever looked forward to such a chance, either with
complacency or with fear; nevertheless, the idea had of late passed through his mind. Some word had fallen
from Mary, some closely watched expression of her eye, or some quiver in her lip when Frank's name was
mentioned, had of late made him involuntarily think that such a thing might not be impossible; and then,
when the chance of Mary becoming the heiress to so large a fortune had been forced upon his consideration,
he had been unable to prevent himself from building happy castles in the air, as he rode slowly home from
Boxall Hill. But not a whit the more on that account was he prepared to be untrue to the squire's interest or to
encourage a feeling which must be distasteful to all the squire's friends.
'Yes, doctor; he must marry money.'
'And worth, Lady Arabella; and a pure feminine heart; and youth and beauty. I hope he will marry them all.'
Could it be possible, that in speaking of a pure feminine heart, and youth and beauty, and such like gewgaws,
the doctor was thinking of his niece? Could it be that he had absolutely made up his mind to foster and
encourage this odious match?
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 105
Page No 109
The bare idea made Lady Arabella wrathful, and her wrath gave her courage. 'He must marry money, or he
will be a ruined man. Now, doctor, I am informed that thingswords that ishave passed between him and
Mary which never ought to have been allowed.'
And now the doctor was wrathful. 'What things? what words?' said he, appearing to Lady Arabella as though
he rose in his anger nearly a foot in altitude before her eyes. 'What has passed between them? and who says
so?'
'Doctor, there have been lovemakings, you may take my word for it; lovemakings of a very, very advanced
description.'
This, the doctor could not stand. No, not for Greshamsbury and its heir; not for the squire and all his
misfortunes; not for Lady Arabella and the blood of the De Courcys could he stand quiet and hear Mary
accused. He sprang up another foot in height, and expanded equally in width as he flung back the insinuation.
'Who says so? Whoever says so, whoever speaks of Miss Thorne in such language, says what is not true. I
will pledge my word'
'My dear doctor, my dear doctor, what took place was quite clearly heard; there was no mistake about it,
indeed.'
'What took place? What was heard?'
'Well, then, I don't want, you know, to make more of it than can be helped. The thing must be stopped, that is
all.'
'What thing? Speak out, Lady Arabella. I will not have Mary's conduct impugned by innuendoes. What is that
eavesdroppers have heard?'
Dr Thorne, there have been no eavesdroppers.'
'And not talebearers either? Will you ladyship oblige me by letting me know what is this accusation which
you bring against my niece?'
'There has been most positively an offer made, Dr Thorne.'
'And who made it?'
'Oh, of course I am not going to say but what Frank must have been very imprudent. Of course he has been to
blame. There has been fault on both sides, no doubt.'
'I utterly deny it. I positively deny it. I know nothing of the circumstances; have heard nothing about it'
'Then of course you can't say,' said Lady Arabella.
'I know nothing of the circumstance; have heard nothing about it,' continued Dr Thorne; 'but I do know my
niece, and am ready to assert that there has not been fault on both sides. Whether there has been any fault on
any side, that I do not know.'
'I can assure you, Dr Thorne, that an offer was made by Frank; such an offer cannot be without its
allurements to a young lady circumstanced like your niece.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 106
Page No 110
'Allurements!' almost shouted the doctor, and, as he did so, Lady Arabella stepped back a pace or two,
retreating from the fire which shot out of his eyes. 'But the truth is, Lady Arabella, you do not know my
niece. If you will have the goodness to let me understand what it is that you desire I will tell you whether I
can comply with your wishes.'
'Of course it will be very inexpedient that the young people should be thrown together again;for the
present, I mean.'
'Well!'
'Frank has now gone to Courcy Castle; and he talks of going from thence to Cambridge. But he will doubtless
be here, backwards and forwards; and perhaps it will be better for all partiessafer, that is, doctorif Miss
Thorne were to discontinue her visits to Greshamsbury for a while.'
'Very well!' thundered out the doctor. 'Her visits to Greshamsbury shall be discontinued.'
'Of course, doctor, this won't change intercourse between us; between you and the and the family.'
'Not change it!' said he. 'Do you think that I will break bread in a house from whence she has been
ignominiously banished? Do you think that I can sit in friendship with those who have spoken of her as you
have now spoken? You have many daughters; what would you say if I accused them one of them as you have
accused her?'
'Accused, doctor! No, I don't accuse her. But prudence, you know, does sometimes require us'
'Very well; prudence requires you to look after those who belong to you. And prudence requires me to look
after my one lamb. Good morning, Lady Arabella.'
'But, doctor, you are not going to quarrel with us? You will come when we want you; eh! won't you?'
Quarrel! quarrel with Greshamsbury! Angry as he was, the doctor felt that he could ill bear to quarrel with
Greshamsbury. A man past fifty cannot easily throw over the ties that have taken twenty years to form, and
wrench himself away from the various close ligatures with which, in such a period, he has become bound. He
could not quarrel with the squire; he could ill bear to quarrel with Frank; though he now began to conceive
that Frank had used him badly, he could not do so; he could not quarrel with the children, who had almost
been born into his arms; nor even with the very walls, and trees, and grassy knolls with which he was so
dearly intimate. He could not proclaim himself an enemy to Greshamsbury; and yet he felt that fealty to Mary
required of him that, for the present, he should put on an enemy's guise.
'If you want me, Lady Arabella, and send for me, I will come to you; otherwise, if you please, share the
sentence which has been passed on Mary. I will now wish you good morning.' And then bowing low to her,
he left the room and the house, and sauntered slowly away to his own home.
What was he to say to Mary? He walked very slowly, down the Greshamsbury avenue with his hands clasped
behind his back, thinking over the whole matter; thinking of it, or rather trying to think of it. When a man's
heart is warmly concerned in any matter, it is almost useless for him to endeavour to think of it. Instead of
thinking, he gives play to his feelings, and feeds his passion by indulging it. 'Allurements!' he said to himself,
repeating Lady Arabella's words. 'A girl circumstanced like my niece! How utterly incapable is such a
woman as that to understand the mind, and the heart, and soul of such a one as Mary Thorne!' And then his
thoughts recurred to Frank. 'It has been ill done of him; ill done of him: young as he is, he should have had
feeling enough to spared me this. A thoughtless word has been spoken which will now make her miserable!'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 107
Page No 111
And then, as he walked on, he could not divest his mind of the remembrance of what had passed between him
and Sir Roger. What, if after all, Mary should become the heiress to all that money? What, if she should
become, in fact, the owner of Greshamsbury? for, indeed it seemed too possible that Sir Roger's heir would
be the owner of Greshamsbury.
The idea was one which he disliked to entertain, but it would recur to him again and again. It might be, that a
marriage between his niece and the nominal heir to the estate might be of all the matches the best for young
Gresham to make. How sweet would be the revenge, how glorious the retaliation on Lady Arabella, if, after
what had now been said, it should come to pass that all the difficulties of Greshamsbury should be made
smooth by Mary's love, and Mary's hand! It was a dangerous subject on which to ponder. And, as he
sauntered down the road, the doctor did his best to banish it from his mindnot altogether successfully.
But as he went he again encountered Beatrice. 'Tell Mary I went up to her today,' said she, 'and that I expect
her up here tomorrow. If she does not come here, I shall be savage.'
'Do not be savage,' said he, putting out his hand, 'even though she should not come.'
Beatrice immediately saw that his manner with her was not playful, and that his face was serious. 'I was only
in joke,' said she; 'of course I was only joking. But is anything the matter? Is Mary ill?'
'Oh, no; not ill at all; but she will not be here tomorrow, nor probably for some time. But, Miss Gresham,
you must not be savage with her.'
Beatrice tried to interrogate him, but he would not wait to answer her questions. While she was speaking he
bowed to her in his usual oldfashioned courteous way, and passed on out of hearing. 'She will not come up
for some time,' said Beatrice to herself. 'Then mamma must have quarrelled with her.' And at once in her
heart she acquitted her friend of all blame in the matter, whatever it might be, and condemned her mother
unheard.
The doctor, when he arrived in his own house, had in nowise made up his mind as to the manner in which he
would break the matter to Mary; but by the time that he had reached the drawingroom, he had made up his
mind to this, that he would put off the evil hour till the morrow. He would sleep on the matterlie awake on
it, more probablyand then at breakfast, as best he could, tell her what had been said of her.
Mary that evening was more than usually inclined to be playful. She had not been quite certain till the
morning, whether Frank had absolutely left Greshamsbury, and had, therefore, preferred the company of Miss
Oriel to going up to the house. There was a peculiar cheerfulness about her friend Patience, a feeling of
satisfaction with the world and those in it, which Mary always shared with her; and now she had brought
home to the doctor's fireside, in spite of her young troubles, a smiling face, if not a heart altogether happy.
'Uncle,' she said at last, 'what makes you so sombre? Shall I read to you?'
'No; not tonight, dearest.'
'Why, uncle; what is the matter?'
'Nothing, nothing.'
'Ah, but it is something, and you shall tell me;' getting up, she came over to his armchair, and leant over his
shoulder.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE 108
Page No 112
He looked up at her for a minute in silence, and then, getting up from his chair, passed his arm round her
waist, and pressed her closely to his heart.
'My darling!' he said, almost convulsively. 'My best own, truest darling!' and Mary looked up into his face,
saw that big tears were running down his cheeks.
But still he told her nothing that night.
CHAPTER XV. COURCY
When Frank Gresham expressed to his father an opinion that Courcy Castle was dull, the squire, as may be
remembered, did not pretend to differ from him. To men such as the squire, and such as the squire's son,
Courcy Castle was dull. To what class of men it would not be dull the author is not prepared to say; but it
may be presumed that the De Courcys found it to their liking, or they would have made it other than it was.
The castle itself was a huge brick pile, built in the days of William III, which, though they were grand for
days of the construction of the Constitution, were not very grand for architecture of a more material
description. It had, no doubt, a perfect right to be called a castle, as it was entered by a castlegate which led
into a court the porter's lodge for which was built as it were into the wall; there were attached to it also two
round, stumpy adjuncts, which were, perhaps properly, called towers, though they did not do much in the way
of towering; and, moreover, along one side of the house, over what would otherwise have been the cornice,
there ran a castellated parapet, through the assistance of which, the imagination no doubt was intended to
supply the muzzles of defiant artillery. But any artillery which would have so presented its muzzle must have
been very small, and it may be doubted whether even a bowman could have obtained shelter there.
The grounds about the castle were not very inviting, nor, as grounds, very extensive; though, no doubt, the
entire domain was such as suited the importance of so puissant a nobleman as Earl de Courcy. What, indeed,
should have been the park was divided out into various large paddocks. The surface was flat and unbroken;
and though there were magnificent elmtrees standing in straight lines, like hedgerows, the timber had not
that beautiful, wild, scattered look which generally gives the great charm to English scenery.
The town of Courcyfor the place claimed to rank as a townwas in many particulars like the castle. It
was built of dingyred brickalmost more brown than redand was solid, dulllooking, ugly and
comfortable. It consisted of four streets, which were formed by two roads crossing each other, making at the
point of junction a centre for the town. Here stood the Red Lion; had it been called the brown lion, the
nomenclature would have been more strictly correct; and here, in the old days of coaching, some life had
been wont to stir itself at those house in the day and night when the Freetraders, Tallyhoes, and Royal Mails
changed their horses. But now there was a railway station a mile and a half distant, and the moving life of the
town of Courcy was confined to the Red Lion omnibus, which seemed to pass its entire time in going up and
down between the town and the station, quite unembarrassed by any great weight of passengers.
There were, so said the Courcyites when away from Courcy, excellent shops in the place; but they were not
the less accustomed, when at home among themselves, to complain to each other of the vile extortion with
which they were treated by their neighbours. The ironmonger, therefore, though he loudly asserted that he
could beat Bristol in the quality of his wares in one direction, and undersell Gloucester in another, bought his
tea and sugar on the sly in one of those larger towns; and the grocer, on the other hand equally distrusted the
pots and pans of home production. Trade, therefore, at Courcy, had not thriven since the railway opened: and,
indeed, had any patient inquirer stood at the cross through one entire day, counting customers who entered
the neighbouring shops, he might well have wondered that any shops in Courcy could be kept open.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XV. COURCY 109
Page No 113
And how changed has been the bustle of that once noisy inn to the present deathlike silence of its green
courtyard! There, a lame ostler crawls about with the hands thrust into the capacious pockets of his jacket,
feeding on memory. That weary pair of omnibus jades, and three sorry posters are all that now grace those
stables where horses used to be stalled in close contiguity by the dozen; where twenty grains apiece,
abstracted from every feed of oats consumed during the day, would have afforded a daily quart to the lucky
pilferer.
Come, my friend, and discourse with me. Let us know what are thy ideas of the inestimable benefits which
science has conferred on us in these, our latter days. How dost thou, among others, appreciate railways and
the power of steam, telegraphs, telegrams, and our new expresses? But indifferently, you say. 'Time was I've
zeed vifteen pair o' 'osses go out of this 'ere yard in vourandtwenty hour; and now there be'ant vifteen, no,
not ten, in vourandtwenty days! There was the duiknot this 'un; he be'ant no gude; but this 'un's
vatherwhy, when he'd come down the road, the cattle did be agoing, vour days an eend. Here'd be the
tooter and the young gen'lmen, and the governess and the young leddies, and then the servantsthey'd be
al'ays the grandest folk of alland then the duik and doochessLord love 'ee, zur; the money did fly in
them days! But now' and the feeling of scorn and contempt which the lame ostler was enabled by his
native talent to throw into the word 'now', was quite as eloquent against the power of steam as anything that
has been spoken at dinners, or written in pamphlets by the keenest admirers of latterday lights.
'Why, luke at this 'ere town,' continued he of the sieve, 'the grass be agrowing in the very streets;that can't
be no gude. Why, luke 'ee here, zur; I do be astanding at this 'ere gateway, just this way, hour arter hour, and
my heyes is hopen mostly;I zees who's acoming and who's agoing. Nobody's acoming and nobody's
agoing; that can't be no gude. Luke at that there homnibus; why, darn me' and now, in his eloquence at
this peculiar point, my friend became more loud and powerful than ever'why, darn me, if maister harns
enough with that there bus to put hiron on them osses' feet, I'llbeblowed!' And as he uttered this
hypothetical denunciation on himself he spoke very slowly, bringing out every word as it were separately,
and lowering himself at his knees at every sound, moving at the same time his right hand up and down. When
he had finished, he fixed his eyes upon the ground, pointing downwards, as if there was to be the site of his
doom if the curse that he had called down upon himself should ever come to pass; and then, waiting no
further converse, he hobbled away, melancholy, to his deserted stables.
Oh, my friend! my poor lame friend! it will avail nothing to tell thee of Liverpool and Manchester; of the
glories of Glasgow, with her flourishing banks; of London, with its third millions of inhabitants; of the great
things which commerce is doing for this nation of thine! What is commerce to thee, unless it be commerce in
posting on that wornout, all but useless great western turnpikeroad? There is nothing left for thee but to be
carted away as rubbishfor thee and for many of us in these now prosperous days; oh, my melancholy,
careridden friend!
Courcy Castle was certainly a dull place to look at, and Frank, in his former visits, had found that the
appearance did not belie the reality. He had been but little there when the earl had been at Courcy; and as he
had always felt from his childhood a peculiar taste to the governance of his aunt the countess, this perhaps
may have added to his feeling of dislike. Now, however, the castle was to be fuller than he had ever before
known it; the earl was to be at home; there was some talk of the Duke of Omnium coming for a day or two,
though that seemed doubtful; there was some faint doubt of Lord Porlock; Mr Moffat, intent on the coming
electionand also, let us hope, on his coming blisswas to be one of the guests; and there was also to be
the great Miss Dunstable.
Frank, however, found that those grandees were not expected quite immediately. 'I might go back to
Greshamsbury for three or four days as she is not to be here,' he said naively to his aunt, expressing, with
tolerable perspicuity, his feeling, that he regarded his visit to Courcy Castle quite as a matter of business. But
the countess would hear of no such arrangement. Now that she had got him, she was not going to let him fall
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XV. COURCY 110
Page No 114
back into the perils of Miss Thorne's intrigues, or even of Miss Thorne's propriety. 'It is quite essential,' she
said, 'that you should be here a few days before her, so that she may see that you are at home.' Frank did not
understand the reasoning; but he felt himself unable to rebel, and he therefore, remained there, comforting
himself, as best he might, with the eloquence of the Honourable George, and the sporting humours of the
Honourable John.
Mr Moffat was the earliest arrival of any importance. Frank had not hitherto made the acquaintance of his
future brotherinlaw, and there was, therefore, some little interest in the first interview. Mr Moffat was
shown into the drawingroom before the ladies had gone up to dress, and it so happened that Frank was there
also. As no one else was in the room but his sister and two of his cousins, he had expected to see the lovers
rush into each other's arms. But Mr Moffat restrained his ardour, and Miss Gresham seemed contented that he
should do so.
He was a nice, dapper man, rather above the middle height, and goodlooking enough had he had a little
more expression in his face. He had dark hair, very nicely brushed, small black whiskers, and a small black
moustache. His boots were excellently well made, and his hands were very white. He simpered gently as he
took hold of Augusta's fingers, and expressed a hope that she had been quite will since last he had the
pleasure of seeing her. Then he touched the hands of the Lady Rosina and the Lady Margaretta.
'Mr Moffat, allow me to introduce you to my brother?'
'Most happy, I'm sure,' said Mr Moffat, again putting out his hand, and allowing it to slip through Frank's
grasp, as he spoke in a pretty, mincing voice: 'Lady Arabella quite well?and your father, and sisters? Very
warm isn't it?quite hot in town, I do assure you.'
'I hope Augusta likes him,' said Frank to himself, arguing on the subject exactly as his father had done; 'but
for an engaged lover he seems to me to have a very queer way with him.' Frank, poor fellow! who was of a
coarser mould, would, under such circumstances, have been all for kissingsometimes, indeed, even under
other circumstances.
Mr Moffat did not do much towards improving the conviviality of the castle. He was, of course, a good deal
intent upon his coming election, and spent much of his time with Mr Nearthewinde, the celebrated
parliamentary agent. It behoved him to be a good deal at Barchester, canvassing the electors and
undermining, by Mr Nearthewinde's aid, the mines for blowing him out of his seat, which were daily being
contrived by Mr Closerstil, on behalf of Sir Roger. The battle was to be fought on the internecine principle,
no quarter being given or taken on either side; and of course this gave Mr Moffat as much as he knew how to
do.
Mr Closerstil was well known to be the sharpest man at his business in all England, unless the palm should be
given to his great rival Mr Nearthewinde; and in this instance he was to be assisted in the battle by a very
clever young barrister, Mr Romer, who was an admirer of Sir Roger's career in life. Some people in
Barchester, when they saw Sir Roger, Closerstil and Mr Romer saunter down the High Street, arm in arm,
declared that it was all up with poor Moffat; but others, in whose head the bump of veneration was strongly
pronounced, whispered to each other that great shibboleththe name of the Duke of Omniumand mildly
asserted it to be impossible that the duke's nominee should be thrown out.
Our poor friend the squire did not take much interest in the matter except in so far that he liked his
soninlaw to be in Parliament. Both the candidates were in his eye equally wrong in their opinions. He had
long since recanted those errors of his early youth, which had cost him his seat for the county, and had
abjured the De Courcy politics. He was staunch enough as a Tory now that his being so would no longer be
of the slightest use to him; but the Duke of Omnium, and Lord de Courcy, and Mr Moffat were all Whigs;
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XV. COURCY 111
Page No 115
Whigs, however, differing altogether in politics from Sir Roger, who belonged to the Manchester school, and
whose pretensions, through some of those inscrutable twists in modern politics which are quite unintelligible
to the minds of ordinary men outside the circle, were on this occasion secretly favoured by the high
Conservative party.
How Mr Moffat, who had been brought into the political world by Lord de Courcy, obtained the weight of the
duke's interest I never could exactly learn. For the duke and the earl did not generally act as twinbrothers on
such occasions.
There is a great difference in Whigs. Lord de Courcy was a Court Whig, following the fortunes, and
enjoying, when he could get it, the sunshine of the throne. He was a sojourner at Windsor, and a visitor at
Balmoral. He delighted in gold sticks, and was never so happy as when holding some cap of maintenance or
spur of precedence with due dignity and acknowledged grace in the presence of all the Court. His means had
been somewhat embarrassed by early extravagance; and, therefore, as it was to his taste to shine, it suited him
to shine at the cost of the Court rather than at his own.
The Duke of Omnium was a Whig of a very different calibre. He rarely went near the presence of majesty,
and when he did so, he did it merely as a disagreeable duty incident to his position. He was very willing that
the Queen should be queen so long as he was allowed to be Duke of Omnium. Nor had he begrudged Prince
Albert any of his honours till he was called Prince Consort. Then, indeed, he had, to his own intimate friends,
made some remark in three words not flattering to the discretion of the Prime Minister. The Queen might be
queen so long as he was Duke of Omnium. Their revenues were about the same, with the exception, that the
duke's were his own, and he could do what he liked with them. This remembrance did not unfrequently
present itself to the duke's mind. In person, he was a plain, thin man, tall, but undistinguished in appearance,
except that there was a gleam of pride in his eye which seemed every moment to be saying, 'I am the Duke of
Omnium'. He was unmarried, and, if report said true, a great debauchee; but if so he had always kept his
debaucheries decently away from the eyes of the world, and was not, therefore, open to that loud
condemnation which should fall like a hailstorm round the ears of some more open sinners.
Why these two mighty nobles put their heads together in order that the tailor's son should represent
Barchester in Parliament, I cannot explain. Mr Moffat, was, as has been said, Lord de Courcy's friend; and it
may be that Lord de Courcy was able to repay the duke for his kindness, as touching Barchester, with some
little assistance in the county representation.
The next arrival was that of the Bishop of Barchester. A meek, good, worthy man, much attached to his wife,
and somewhat addicted to his ease. She, apparently, was made in a different mould, and by her energy and
diligence atoned for any want of those qualities which might be observed in the bishop himself. When asked
his opinion, his lordship would generally reply by saying'Mrs Proudie and I think so and so.' But before
that opinion was given, Mrs Proudie would take up the tale, and she, in her more concise manner, was not
wont to quote the bishop as having at all assisted in the consideration of the subject. It was well known in
Barsetshire that no married pair consorted more closely or more tenderly together; and the example of such
conjugal affection among persons in the upper classes is worth mentioning, as it is believed by those below
them, and too often with truth, that the sweet bliss of connubial reciprocity is not so common as it should be
among the magnates of the earth.
But the arrival even of the bishop and his wife did not make the place cheerful to Frank Gresham, and he
began to long for Miss Dunstable, in order that he might have something to do. He could not get on at all with
Mr Moffat. He had expected that the man would at once have called him Frank, and that he would have
called the man Gustavus; but they did not even get beyond Mr Moffat and Mr Gresham. 'Very hot in
Barchester, today, very,' was the nearest approach to conversation which Frank could attain with him; and as
far as he, Frank, could see, Augusta never got much beyond it. There might be teteatete meetings between
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XV. COURCY 112
Page No 116
them, but, if so, Frank could not detect when they took place; and so, opening his heart at last to the
Honourable George, for the want of a better confidant, he expressed his opinion that his future
brotherinlaw was a muff.
'A muffI believe you too. What do you think now? I have been with him and Nearthewinde in Barchester
these three days past, looking up the electors' wives and daughters, and that kind of thing.'
'I say, if there is any fun in it you might as well take me with you.'
'Oh, there is not much fun; they are mostly so slobbered and dirty. A sharp fellow in Nearthewinde, and
knows what he is about well.'
'Does he look up the wives and daughters too?'
'Oh, he goes on every tack just as it's wanted. But there was Moffat, yesterday, in a room behind the milliner's
shop near Cuthbert's Gate; I was with him. The woman's husband is one of the choristers and an elector, you
know, and Moffat went to look for his vote. Now, there was no one there when we got there but the three
young women, the wife, that is, and her two girlsvery pretty women they are too.'
'I say, George, I'll go and get the chorister's vote for Moffat; I ought to do it as he's to be my brotherinlaw.'
'But what do you think Moffat said to the women?'
'Can't guesshe didn't kiss them, did he?'
'Kiss any of them? No; but he begged to give them his positive assurance as a gentleman that if he was
returned to Parliament he would vote for an extension of the franchise, and the admission of the Jews into the
Parliament.'
'Well, he is a muff,' said Frank.
CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE
At last the great Miss Dunstable came. Frank, when he heard that the heiress had arrived, felt some slight
palpitation at his heart. He had not the remotest idea in the world of marrying her; indeed, during the last
week past, absence had so heightened his love for Mary Thorne that he was more than ever resolved that he
would never marry any one but her. He knew that he had made her a formal offer for her hand, and that it
behoved him to keep to it, let the charms of Miss Dunstable be what they might; but, nevertheless, he was
prepared to go through a certain amount of courtship, in obedience to his aunt's behests, and he felt a little
nervous at being brought up in that way, face to face, to do battle with two hundred thousand pounds.
'Miss Dunstable has arrived,' said his aunt to him, with great complacency, on his return from an
electioneering visit to the beauties of Barchester which he made with his cousin George on the day after the
conversation which was repeated at the end of the last chapter. 'She has arrived, and is looking remarkably
well; she has quite a distingue air, and will grace any circle to which she may be introduced. I will introduce
you before dinner, and you can take her out.'
'I couldn't propose to her tonight, I suppose?' said Frank, maliciously.
'Don't talk nonsense, Frank,' said the countess angrily. 'I am doing what I can for you, and taking on an
infinity of trouble to endeavour to place you in an independent position; and now you talk nonsense to me.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE 113
Page No 117
Frank muttered some sort of apology, and then went to prepare himself for the encounter.
Miss Dunstable, though she had come by train, had brought with her her own carriage, her own horses, her
own coachman and footman, and her own maid, of course. She had also brought with her half a score of
trunks, full of wearing apparel; some of them nearly as rich as that wonderful box which was stolen a short
time since from the top of a cab. But she brought these things, not in the least because she wanted them
herself, but because she had been instructed to do so.
Frank was a little more than ordinarily careful in dressing. He spoilt a couple of white neckties before he was
satisfied, and was rather fastidious as the set of his hair. There was not much of the dandy about him in the
ordinary meaning of the word. But he felt that it was incumbent on him to look his best, seeing what it was
expected he should now do. He certainly did not mean to marry Miss Dunstable; but as he was to have a
flirtation with her, it was well that he should do so under the best possible auspices.
When he entered the drawingroom he perceived at once that the lady was there. She was seated between the
countess and Mrs Proudie; and mammon, in her person, was receiving worship from the temporalities and
spiritualities of the land. He tried to look unconcerned, and remained in the farther part of the room, talking
with some of his cousins; but he could not keep his eye off the future possible Mrs Frank Gresham; and it
seemed as though she was as much constrained to scrutinize him as he felt to scrutinize her.
Lady de Courcy had declared that she was looking extremely well, and had particularly alluded to her
distingue appearance. Frank at once felt that he could not altogether go along with his aunt in this opinion.
Miss Dunstable might be very well; but her style of beauty was one which did not quite meet with his
warmest admiration.
In age she was about thirty; but Frank, who was no great judge in these matters, and who was accustomed to
have very young girls round him, at once put her down as being ten years older. She had a very high colour,
very red cheeks, a large mouth, big white teeth, a broad nose, and bright, small, black eyes. Her hair also was
black and bright, but very crisp, and strong, and was combed close round her face in small crisp black
ringlets. Since she had been brought out into the fashionable world some of her instructors in fashion had
given her to understand that curls were not the thing. 'They'll always pass muster,' Miss Dunstable had
replied, 'when they are done up with banknotes.' It may therefore be presumed that Miss Dunstable had a
will of her own.
'Frank,' said the countess, in the most natural and unpremeditated way, as soon as she caught her nephew's
eye, 'come here. I want to introduce you to Miss Dunstable.' The introduction was then made. 'Mrs Proudie,
would you excuse me? I must positively go and say a few words to Mrs Barlow, or the poor woman will feel
herself huffed'; and so saying, she moved off, leaving the coast clear for Master Frank.
He of course slipped into his aunt's place, and expressed a hope that Miss Dunstable was not fatigued by her
journey.
'Fatigued!' said she, in a voice rather loud, but very goodhumoured, and not altogether unpleasing; 'I am not
to be fatigued by such a thing as that. Why, in May we came through all the way from Rome to Paris without
sleepingthat is, without sleeping in a bedand we were upset three times out of the sledges coming over
the Simpton. It was such fun! Why, I wasn't to say tired even then.'
'All the way from Rome to Paris!' said Mrs Proudiein a tone of astonishment, meant to flatter the
heiress'and what made you in such a hurry?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE 114
Page No 118
'Something about money matters,' said Miss Dunstable, speaking rather louder than usual. 'Something to do
with the ointment. I was selling the business just then.'
Mrs Proudie bowed, and immediately changed the conversation. 'Idolatry is, I believe, more rampant than
ever in Rome,' said she; 'and I fear there is no such thing at all as Sabbath observance.'
'Oh, not in the least,' said Miss Dunstable, with rather a joyous air; 'Sundays and weekdays are all the same
there.'
'How very frightful!' said Mrs Proudie.
'But it's a delicious place. I do like Rome, I must say. And as for the Pope, if he wasn't quite so fat he would
be the nicest old fellow in the world. Have you been in Rome, Mrs Proudie?'
Mrs Proudie sighed as she replied in the negative, and declared her belief that danger was apprehended from
such visits.
'Oh!ah!the malariaof courseyes; if you go at the wrong time; but nobody is such a fool as that
now.'
'I was thinking of the soul, Miss Dunstable,' said the ladybishop, in her peculiar grave tone. 'A place where
there are no Sabbath observances'
'And have you been at Rome, Mr Gresham?' said the young lady, turning almost abruptly round to Frank, and
giving a somewhat uncivilly cold shoulder to Mrs Proudie's exhortation. She, poor lady, was forced to finish
her speech to the Honourable George, who was standing near to her. He having an idea that bishops and all
their belongings, like other things appertaining to religion, should, if possible, be avoided; but if that were not
possible, should be treated with much assumed gravity, immediately put on a long face, and remarked
that'it was a deuced shame: for his part he always liked to see people go quiet on Sundays. The parsons
had only one day out of seven, and he thought they were fully entitled to that.' Satisfied with which, or not
satisfied, Mrs Proudie had to remain silent till dinnertime.
'No,' said Frank; 'I never was in Rome. I was in Paris once, that's all.' And then, feeling not unnatural anxiety
as to the present state of Miss Dunstable's worldly concerns, he took an opportunity of falling back on that
part of her conversation which Mrs Proudie had exercised so much tact in avoiding.
'And was it sold?' said he.
'Sold! what sold?'
'You were saying about the businessthat you came back without going to bed because of selling the
business.'
'Oh!the ointment. No; it was not sold. After all, the affair did not come off, and I might have remained and
had another roll in the snow. Wasn't it a pity?'
'So,' said Frank to himself, 'if I should do it, I should be owner of the ointment of Lebanon: how odd!' And
then he gave her his arm and handed her down to dinner.
He certainly found that his dinner was less dull than any other he had sat down to at Courcy Castle. He did
not fancy that he should ever fall in love with Miss Dunstable; but she certainly was an agreeable companion.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE 115
Page No 119
She told him of her tour, and the fun she had in her journeys; how she took a physician with her for the
benefit of her health, whom she generally was forced to nurse; of the trouble it was to her to look after and
wait upon her numerous servants; of the tricks she played to bamboozle people who came to stare at her; and,
lastly, she told him of a lover who followed her from country to country, and was now in hot pursuit of her,
having arrived in London the evening before she left.
'A lover?' said Frank, somewhat startled by the suddenness of the confidence.
'A loveryesMr Gresham; why should I not have a lover?'
'Oh!noof course not. I dare say you have had a good many.'
'Only three or four, upon my word; that is, only three or four that I favour. One is not bound to reckon the
others, you know.'
'No, they'd be too numerous. And so you have three whom you favour, Miss Dunstable;' and Frank sighed, as
though he intended to say that the number was too many for his peace of mind.
'Is not that quite enough? But of course I change them sometimes;' and she smiled on him very
goodnaturedly. 'It would be very dull if I were always to keep the same.'
'Very dull indeed,' said Frank, who did not quite know what to say.
'Do you think the countess would mind my having or two of them here if I were to ask her?'
'I am quite sure she would,' said Frank, very briskly. 'She would not approve of it; nor should I.'
'Youwhy, what have you to do with it?'
'A great dealso much so that I positively forbid it; but, Miss Dunstable'
'Well, Mr Gresham?'
'We will contrive to make up for the deficiency as well as possible, if you will permit us to do so. Now for
myself'
'Well, for yourself?'
At this moment the countess gleamed her accomplished eye round the table, and Miss Dunstable rose from
her chair as Frank was preparing his attack, and accompanied the other ladies into the drawingroom.
His aunt, as she passed him, touched his arm lightly with her fan, so lightly that the action was perceived by
no one else. But Frank well understood the meaning of the touch, and appreciated the approbation which it
conveyed. He merely blushed however at his own dissimulation; for he felt more certain that ever that he
would never marry Miss Dunstable, and he felt nearly equally sure that Miss Dunstable would never marry
him.
Lord de Courcy was now at home; but his presence did not add much hilarity to the claretcup. The young
men, however, were very keen about the election, and Mr Nearthewinde, who was one of the party, was full
of the most sanguine hopes.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE 116
Page No 120
'I have done a good one at any rate,' said Frank; 'I have secured the chorister's vote.'
'What! Bagley?' said Neathewinde. 'The fellow kept out of my way, and I couldn't see him.'
'I haven't exactly seen him,' said Frank; 'but I've got his vote all the same.'
'What! by a letter?' said Mr Moffat.
'No, not by letter,' said Frank, speaking rather low as he looked at the bishop and the earl; 'I got a promise
from his wife: I think he's a little in the henpecked line.'
'Hahaha!' laughed the good bishop, who, in spite of Frank's modulation of voice, had overheard what
had passed. 'Is that the way you manage electioneering matters in our cathedral city?' The idea of one of his
choristers being in the henpecked line was very amusing to the bishop.
'Oh, I got a distinct promise,' said Frank, in his pride; and then added incautiously, 'but I had to order bonnets
for the whole family.'
'Hushhhh!' said Mr Nearthewinde, absolutely flabbergasted by such imprudence on the part of one of his
client's friends. 'I am quite sure that you order had no effect, and was intended to have no effect on Mr
Bagley's vote.'
'Is that wrong?' said Frank; 'upon my word I thought it was quite legitimate.'
'One should never admit anything in electioneering matters, should one?' said George, turning to Mr
Nearthewinde.
'Very little, Mr de Courcy; very little indeedthe less the better. It's hard to say in these days what is wrong
and what is not. Now, there's Reddypalm, the publican, the man who has the Brown Bear. Well, I was there,
of course: he's a voter, and if any man in Barchester ought to feel himself bound to vote for a friend of the
duke's he ought. Now, I was so thirsty when I was in that man's house, that I was dying for a glass of beer;
but for the life of me I didn't dare order one.'
'Why not?' said Frank, whose mind was only just beginning to be enlightened by the great doctrine of purity
of election as practised in English provincial towns.
'Oh, Closerstil had some fellow looking at me; why, I can't walk down that town without having my very
steps counted. I like sharp fighting myself, but I never go so sharp as that.'
'Nevertheless I got Bagley's vote,' said Frank, persisting in praise of his own electioneering prowess; 'and you
may be sure of this, Mr Nearthewinde, none of Closerstil's men were looking at me when I got it.'
'Who'll pay for the bonnets, Frank?' said George.
'Oh, I'll pay for them if Moffat won't. I think I shall keep an account there; they seem to have good gloves and
those sort of things.'
'Very good, I have no doubt,' said George.
'I suppose your lordship will be in town soon after the meeting of Parliament?' said the bishop, questioning
the earl.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE 117
Page No 121
'Oh! yes; I suppose I must be there. I am never allowed to remain very long in the quiet. It is a great nuisance;
but it is too late to think of that now.'
'Men in high places, my lord, never were, and never will be, allowed to consider themselves. They burn their
torches not in their own behalf,' said the bishop, thinking, perhaps, as much of himself as he did of his noble
friend. 'Rest and quiet are the comforts of those who have been content to remain in obscurity.'
'Perhaps so,' said the earl, finishing his glass of claret with an air of virtuous resignation. 'Perhaps so.' His
own martyrdom, however, had not been severe, for the rest and quiet of home had never been peculiarly
satisfactory to his tastes. Soon after this they went to the ladies.
It was some little time before Frank could find an opportunity of recommencing his allotted task with Miss
Dunstable. She got into conversation with the bishop and with some other people, and, except that he took
her teacup and nearly managed to squeeze one of her fingers as she did so, he made very little further
progress till towards the close of the evening.
At last he found her so nearly alone as to admit of his speaking to her in a low confidential voice.
'Have you managed that matter with my aunt?'
'What matter?' said Miss Dunstable; and her voice was not low, nor particularly confidential.
'About those three or four gentlemen whom you wish to invite here?'
'Oh! my attendant knights! no, indeed; you gave me such very slight hope of success; besides, you said
something about my not wanting them.'
'Yes I did; I really think they'd be quite unnecessary. If you should want any one to defend you'
'At these coming elections, for instance.'
'Then, or at any other time, there are plenty here who will be ready to stand up for you.'
'Plenty! I don't want plenty: one good lance in the olden days was always worth more than a score of ordinary
menatarms.'
'But you talked about three or four.'
'Yes; but then you see, Mr Gresham, I have never yet found the one good lanceat least, not good enough to
suit my ideas of true prowess.'
What could Frank do but declare that he was ready to lay his own in rest, now and always in her behalf?
His aunt had been quite angry with him, and had thought that he turned her into ridicule, when he spoke of
making an offer to her guest that very evening; and yet here he was so placed that he had hardly an
alternative. Let his inward resolution to abjure the heiress be ever so strong, he was now in a position which
allowed him no choice in the matter. Even Mary Thorne could hardly have blamed him for saying, that so far
as his own prowess went, it was quite at Miss Dunstable's service. Had Mary been looking on, she perhaps,
might have thought that he could have done so with less of that look of devotion which he threw into his
eyes.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE 118
Page No 122
'Well, Mr Gresham, that's very civilvery civil indeed,' said Miss Dunstable. 'Upon my word, if a lady
wanted a true knight she might do worse than trust to you. Only I fear that your courage is of so exalted a
nature that you would be ever ready to do battle for any beauty that might be in distressor, indeed, who
might not. You could never confine your valour to the protection of one maiden.'
'Oh, yes! but I would though if I liked her,' said Frank. 'There isn't a more constant fellow in the world than I
am in that wayyou try me, Miss Dunstable.'
'When young ladies make such trials as that, they sometimes find it too late to go back if the trial doesn't
succeed, Mr Gresham.'
'Oh, of course, there's always some risk. It's like hunting; there would be no fun if there was no danger.'
'But if you get a tumble one day you can retrieve your honour the next; but a poor girl if she once trusts a man
who says that he loves her, has no such chance. For myself, I would never listen to a man unless I'd known
him for seven years at least.'
'Seven years!' said Frank, who could not help thinking that in seven years' time Miss Dunstable would be
almost an old woman. 'Seven days is enough to know any person.'
'Or perhaps seven hours; eh, Mr Gresham?'
'Seven hourswell, perhaps seven hours, if they happen to be a good deal together during that time.'
'There's nothing after all like love at first sight, is there, Mr Gresham?'
Frank knew well enough that she was quizzing him, and could not resist the temptation he felt to be revenged
on her. 'I am sure it's very pleasant,' said he; 'but as for myself, I have never experienced it.'
'Ha, ha, ha!' laughed Miss Dunstable. 'Upon my word, Mr Gresham, I like you amazingly. I didn't expect to
meet anybody down here that I could like half so much. You must come and see me in London, and I'll
introduce you to my three knights,' and so saying, she moved away and fell into conversation with some of
the higher powers.
Frank felt himself to be rather snubbed, in spite of the strong expression which Miss Dunstable had made in
his favour. It was not quite clear to him that she did not take him for a boy. He was, to be sure, avenged on
her for that by taking her for a middleaged woman; but, nevertheless, he was hardly satisfied with himself;
'and she might find afterwards that she was left in the lurch with all her money.' And so he retired, solitary,
into a far part of the room, and began to think of Mary Thorne. As he did so, and as his eyes fell upon Miss
Dunstable's stiff curls, he almost shuddered.
And then the ladies retired. His aunt, with a goodnatured smile on her face, come to him as she was leaving
the room, the last of the bevy, and putting her hand on his arm, led him out into a small unoccupied chamber
which opened from the grand saloon.
'Upon my word, Master Frank,' said she, 'you seem to be losing no time with the heiress. You have quite
made an impression already.'
'I don't know much about that, aunt,' said he, looking rather sheepish.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE 119
Page No 123
'Oh, I declare you have; but, Frank, my dear boy, you should not precipitate these sort of things too much. It
is well to take a little more time: it is more valued; and perhaps, you know, on the whole'
Perhaps Frank might know; but it was clear that Lady de Courcy did not: at any rate, she did not know how to
express herself. Had she said out her mind plainly, she would probably have spoken thus: 'I want you to make
love to Miss Dunstable, certainly; or at any rate to make an offer to her; but you need not make a show of
yourself and of her, by doing it so openly as all that.' The countess, however, did not want to reprimand her
obedient nephew, and therefore did not speak out her thoughts.
'Well?' said Frank, looking up into her face.
'Take a leetle more timethat is all, my dear boy; slow and sure, you know,' so the countess again patted his
arm and went away to bed.
'Old fool!' muttered Frank to himself, as he returned to the room where the men were still standing. He was
right in this: she was an old fool, or she would have seen that there was no chance whatever that her nephew
and Miss Dunstable should become man and wife.
'Well Frank,' said the Honourable John; 'so you're after the heiress already.'
'He won't give any of us a chance,' said the Honourable George. 'If he goes on in that way she'll be Mrs
Gresham before a month is over. But, Frank, what will she say of your manner of looking for Barchester
votes?'
'Mr Gresham is certainly an excellent hand at canvassing,' said Mr Nearthewinde; 'only a little too open in his
manner of proceeding.'
'I got that chorister for you at any rate,' said Frank. 'And you would never have had him without me.'
'I don't think half so much of the chorister's vote as that of Miss Dunstable,' said the Honourable George:
'that's the interest that is really worth looking after.'
'But, surely,' said Mr Moffat, 'Miss Dunstable has not property in Barchester?' Poor man! his heart was so
intent on his election that he had no a moment to devote to the claims of love.
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION
And now the important day of the election had arrived, and some men's hearts beat quickly enough. To be or
not to a member of the British Parliament is a question of very considerable moment in a man's mind. Much
is often said of the great penalties which the ambitious pay for enjoying this honour; of the tremendous
expenses of election; of the long, tedious hours of unpaid labour: of the weary days passed in the House; but,
nevertheless, the prize is one very well worth the price paid for itwell worth any price that can be paid for
it short of wading through dirt and dishonour.
No other great European nation has anything like it to offer to the ambition of its citizens; for in no other
great country of Europe, not even in those which are free, has the popular constitution obtained, as with us,
true sovereignty and power of rule. Here it is so; and when a man lays himself out to be a member of
Parliament, he plays the highest game and for the highest stakes which the country affords.
To some men, born silverspooned, a seat in Parliament comes as a matter of course. From the time of their
early manhood they hardly know what it is not to sit there; and the honour is hardly appreciated, being too
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION 120
Page No 124
much a matter of course. As a rule, they never know how great a thing it is to be in Parliament; though, when
reverse comes, as reverses occasionally will come, they fully feel how dreadful it is to be left out.
But to men aspiring to be members, or to those who having been once fortunate have again to fight the battle
without assurance of success, the coming election must be matter of dread concern. Of, how delightful to hear
that the longtalked of rival has declined the contest, and that the course is clear! or to find by a short canvass
that one's majority is safe, and the pleasures of crowing over an unlucky, friendless foe quite secured!
No such gratification as this filled the bosom of Mr Moffat on the morning of the Barchester election. To him
had been brought no positive assurance of success by his indefatigable agent, Mr Nearthewinde. It was
admitted on all sides that the contest would be a very close one; and Mr Nearthewinde would not do more
than assert that they ought to win unless things went wrong with them.
Mr Nearthewinde had other elections to attend to, and had not been remaining at Courcy Castle ever since the
coming of Miss Dunstable: but he had been there, and at Barchester, as often as possible, and Mr Moffat was
made greatly uneasy by reflecting how very high the bill would be.
The two parties had outdone each other in the loudness of their assertions, that each would on his side
conduct the election in strict conformity to law. There was to be no bribery. Bribery! who indeed in these
days would dare to bribe; to give absolute money for an absolute vote, and pay for such an article in
downright palpable sovereigns? No. Purity was much too rampant for that, and the means of detection too
well understood. But purity was to be carried much further than this. There should be no treating; no hiring of
two hundred votes to act as messengers at twenty shillings a day in looking up some four hundred other
voters; no bands were to be paid for; no carriages furnished; no ribbons supplied. British voters were to vote,
if vote they would, for the love and respect they bore to their chosen candidate. If so actuated, they would not
vote, they might stay away; no other inducement would be offered.
So much was said loudlyvery loudlyby each party; but, nevertheless, Mr Moffat, early in these election
days, began to have some misgivings about the bill. The proclaimed arrangement had been one exactly
suitable to his taste; for Mr Moffat loved his money. He was a man in whose breast the ambition of being
great in the world, and of joining himself to aristocratic people was continually at war with the great cost
which such tastes occasioned. His last election had not been a cheap triumph. In one way or another money
had been dragged from him for purposes which had been to his mind unintelligible; and when, about the
middle of his first session, he had, with much grumbling, settled all demands, he had questioned with himself
whether his whistle was worth its cost.
He was therefore a great stickler for purity of election; although, had he considered the matter, he should
have known that with him money was his only passport into that Elysium in which he had now lived for two
years. He probably did not consider it; for when, in those canvassing days immediately preceding the
election, he had seen that all the beerhouses were open, and half the population was drunk, he had asked Mr
Nearthewinde whether this violation of the treaty was taking place only on the part of the opponent, and
whether, in such case, it would not by duly noticed with a view to a possible petition.
Mr Nearthewinde assured him triumphantly that half at least of the wallowing swine were his own especial
friends; and that somewhat more than half of the publicans of the town were eagerly engaged in fighting his,
Mr Moffat's battle. Mr Moffat groaned, and would have expostulated had Mr Nearthewinde been willing to
hear him. But that gentleman's services had been put into requisition by Lord De Courcy rather than by the
candidate. For the candidate he cared but little. To pay the bill would be enough for him. He, Mr
Nearthewinde, was doing his business as he well knew how to do it; and it was not likely that he should
submit to be lectured by such as Mr Moffat on a trumpery score of expense.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION 121
Page No 125
It certainly did appear on the morning of the election as though some great change had been made in that
resolution of the candidates to be very pure. From and early hour rough bands of music were to be heard in
every part of the usually quiet town; carts and gigs, omnibuses and flys, all the old carriages from all the
innyards, and every vehicle of any description which could be pressed into the service were in motion; if the
horses and postboys were not to be paid for by the candidates, the voters themselves were certainly very
liberal in their mode of bringing themselves to the poll. The election district of the city of Barchester
extended for some miles on each side of the city, so that the omnibuses and flys had enough to do. Beer was
to be had at the publichouses, almost without question, by all who chose to ask for it; and rum and brandy
were dispensed to select circles within the bars with equal profusion. As for ribbons, the mercers' shops must
have been emptied of that article, as far as scarlet and yellow were concerned. Scarlet was Sir Roger's colour,
while the friends of Mr Moffat were decked with yellow. Seeing what he did see, Mr Moffat might well ask
whether there had not been a violation of the treaty of purity!
At the time of this election there was some question whether England should go to war with all her energy; or
whether it would not be better for her to save her breath to cool her porridge, and not meddle more than could
be helped with foreign quarrels. The last view of the matter was advocated by Sir Roger, and his motto of
course proclaimed the merits of domestic peace and quiet. 'Peace abroad and a big loaf at home', was
consequently displayed on four or five huge scarlet banners, and carried waving over the heads of the people.
But Mr Moffat was a staunch supporter of the Government, who were already inclined to be belligerent, and
'England's honour' was therefore the legend under which he selected to do battle. It may, however, be doubted
whether there was in all Barchester one inhabitantlet alone one electorso fatuous to suppose that
England's honour was in any special manner dear to Mr Moffat; or that he would be whit more sure of a big
loaf than he was now, should Sir Roger happily become a member of the legislature.
And then the fine arts were resorted to, seeing that language fell short in telling all that was found necessary
to be told. Poor Sir Roger's failing as regards the bottle were too well known; and it was also known that, in
acquiring this title, he had not quite laid aside the rough mode of speech which he had used in his early years.
There was, consequently, a great daub painted up on sundry walls, on which a navvy, with a pimply, bloated
face, was to be seen standing on a railway bank, leaning on a spade holding a bottle in one hand, while he
invited a comrade to drink. 'Come, Jack, shall us have a drop of some'at short?' were the words coming out of
the navvy's mouth; and under this was painted in huge letters,
THE LAST NEW BARONET
But Mr Moffat hardly escaped on easier terms. The trade by which his father had made his money was as
well known as that of the railway contractor; and every possible symbol of tailordom was displayed in
graphic portraiture on the walls and hoardings of the city. He was drawn with his goose, his scissors, with his
needle, with his tapes; he might be seen measuring, cutting, pressing, carrying home his bundle and
presenting his little bill; and under each of these representations was repeated his own motto: 'England's
honour'.
Such were the pleasant little amenities with which the people of Barchester greeted the two candidates who
were desirous of the honour of serving them in Parliament.
The polling went briskly and merrily. There were somewhat above nine hundred registered voters, of whom
the greater portion recorded their votes early in the day. At two o'clock, according to Sir Roger's committee,
the numbers were as follows:
Scatcherd 275
Moffat 268
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION 122
Page No 126
Whereas, by the light afforded by Mr Moffat's people, they stood in a slightly different ratio to each other,
being written thus:
Moffat 277
Scatcherd 269
This naturally heightened the excitement, and gave additional delight to the proceedings. At halfpast two it
was agreed by both sides that Mr Moffat was ahead; the Moffatites claiming a majority of twelve, and the
Scatcherdites allowing a majority of one. But by three o'clock sundry good men and true, belonging to the
railway interest, had made their way to the booth in spite of the efforts of a band of roughs from Courcy, and
Sir Roger was again leading, by ten or a dozen, according to his own showing.
One little transaction which took place in the earlier part of the day deserves to be recorded. There was in
Barchester an honest publicanhonest as the world of publicans goeswho not only was possessed of a
vote, but possessed of a son who was a voter. He was one Reddypalm in earlier days, before he had learned to
appreciate the full value of an Englishman's franchise, he had been a declared Liberal and a friend of Roger
Scatcherd's. In latter days he had governed his political feelings with more decorum, and had not allowed
himself to be carried away by such foolish fervour as he had evinced in his youth. On this special occasion,
however, his line of conduct was so mysterious as for a while to baffle even those who knew him best.
His house was apparently open in Sir Roger's interest. Beer, at any rate, was flowing there as elsewhere; and
scarlet ribbons going innot perhaps, in a state of perfect steadinesscame out more unsteady than before.
Still had Mr Reddypalm been deaf to the voice of that charmer, Closerstil, though he had charmed with all his
wisdom. Mr Reddypalm had stated, first his unwillingness to vote at all:he had, he said, given over
politics, and was not inclined to trouble his mind again with the subject; then he had spoken of his great
devotion to the Duke of Omnium, under whose grandfathers his grandfather had been bred: Mr Nearthewinde
had, as he said, been with him, and proved to him beyond a shadow of a doubt that it would show the deepest
ingratitude on his part to vote against the duke's candidate.
Mr Closerstil thought he understood all this, and sent more, and still more men to drink beer. He even
causedtaking infinite trouble to secure secrecy in the matterthree gallons of British brandy to be ordered
and paid for as the best French. But, nevertheless, Mr Reddypalm made no sign to show that he considered
that the right thing had been done. On the evening before the election, he told one of Mr Closerstil's
confidential men, that he had thought a good deal about it, and that he believed he should be constrained by
his conscience to vote for Mr Moffat.
We have said that Mr Closerstil was accompanied by a learned friend of his, one Mr Romer, a barrister, who
was greatly interested in Sir Roger, and who, being a strong Liberal, was assisting in the canvass with much
energy. He, hearing how matters were likely to go with this conscientious publican, and feeling himself
peculiarly capable of dealing with such delicate scruples, undertook to look into the case in hand. Early,
therefore, on the morning of the election, he sauntered down the cross street in which hung out the sign of the
Brown Bear, and, as he expected, found Mr Reddypalm near his own door.
Now it was quite an understood thing that there was to be no bribery. This was understood by no one better
than Mr Romer, who had, in truth, drawn up many of the published assurances to that effect. And, to give him
his due, he was fully minded to act in accordance with these assurances. The object of all the parties was to
make it worth the voters' while to give their votes; but to do so without bribery. Mr Romer had repeatedly
declared that he would have nothing to do with any illegal practising; but he had also declared that, as long as
all was done according to law, he was ready to lend his best efforts to assist Sir Roger. How he assisted Sir
Roger, and adhered to the law, will now be seen.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION 123
Page No 127
Oh, Mr Romer! Mr Romer! is it not the case with thee that thou 'wouldst not play false, and yet wouldst
wrongly win?' Not in electioneering, Mr Romer, any more than in any other pursuits, can a man touch pitch
and not be defiled; as thou, innocent as thou art, wilt soon learn to thy terrible cost.
'Well, Reddypalm,' said Mr Romer, shaking hands with him. Mr Romer had not been equally cautious as
Neatherwinde, and had already drunk sundry glasses of ale at the Brown Bear, in the hope of softening the
stern Bearwarden. 'How is it today? Which is to be the man?'
'If any one knows that, Mr Romer, you must be the man. A poor numbskull like me knows nothing of them
matters. How should I? All I looks to, Mr Romer, is selling a trifle of drink now and thenselling it, and
getting paid for it, you know, Mr Romer.'
'Yes, that's important, no doubt. But come, Reddypalm, such an old friend as Sir Roger as you are, a man he
speaks of as one of his intimate friends, I wonder how you can hesitate about it? Now with another man, I
should think that he wanted to be paid for voting'
'Oh, Mr Romer! fiefiefie!'
'I know it's not the case with you. It would be an insult to offer you money, even if money were going. I
should not mention this, only as money is not going, neither, on our side nor on the other, no harm can be
done.'
'Mr Romer, if you speak of such a thing, you'll hurt me. I know the value of an Englishman's franchise too
well to wish to sell it. I would not demean myself so low; no, not though fiveandtwenty pound a vote was
going, as there was in the good old timesand that's not so long either.'
'I am sure you wouldn't, Reddypalm; I'm sure you wouldn't. But an honest man like you should stick to old
friends. Now, tell me,' and putting his arm through Reddypalm's, he walked with him into the passage of his
own house; 'Now, tell meis there anything wrong? It's between friends, you know. Is there anything
wrong?'
'I wouldn't sell my vote for untold gold,' said Reddypalm, who was perhaps aware that untold gold would
hardly be offered to him for it.
'I am sure you would not,' said Mr Romer.
'But,' said Reddypalm, 'a man likes to be paid his little bill.'
'Surely, surely,' said the barrister.
'And I did say two years since, when your friend Mr Closerstil brought a friend of his down to stand hereit
wasn't Sir Roger thenbut when he brought a friend of his down, and when I drew two or three hogsheads
of ale on their side, and when my bill was questioned, and only halfsettled, I did say that I wouldn't interfere
with no election no more. And no more I will, Mr Romerunless it be to give a quiet vote for the nobleman
under whom I and mine always lived respectable.'
'Oh!' said Mr Romer.
'A man do like to have his bill paid, you know, Mr Romer.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION 124
Page No 128
Mr Romer could not but acknowledge that this was a natural feeling on the part of an ordinary mortal
publican.
'It goes agin the grain with a man not to have his little bill paid, and specially at election time,' again urged
Mr Reddypalm.
Mr Romer had not much time to think about it; but he knew well that matters were so nearly balanced, that
the votes of Mr Reddypalm and his son were of inestimable value.
'If it's only about your bill,' said Mr Romer, 'I'll see to have it settled. I'll speak to Closerstil about that.'
'All right!' said Reddypalm, seizing the young barrister's hand, and shaking it warmly; 'all right!' And late in
the afternoon when a vote or two became matter of intense interest, Mr Reddypalm and his son came up to
the hustings and boldly tendered theirs for their old friend Sir Roger.
There was a great deal of eloquence heard in Barchester on that day. Sir Roger had by this time so far
recovered as to be able to go through the dreadfully hard work of canvassing and addressing the electors from
eight in the morning till near sunset. A very perfect recovery, most men will say. Yes; a perfect recovery as
regarded the temporary use of his faculties, both physical and mental; though it may be doubted whether
there can be any permanent recovery from such a disease as his. What amount of brandy he consumed to
enable him to perform this election work, and what lurking evil effect the excitement have on himof these
matters no record was kept in the history of those proceedings.
Sir Roger's eloquence was of a rough kind; but not perhaps the less operative on those for whom it was
intended. The aristocracy of Barchester consisted chiefly of clerical dignitaries, bishops, deans, prebendaries,
and such like: on them and theirs it was not probable that anything said by Sir Roger would have much effect.
Those men would either abstain from voting, or vote for the railway hero, with the view of keeping out the
De Courcy candidate. Then came the shopkeepers, who might also be regarded as a stiffnecked generation,
impervious to electioneering eloquence. They would, generally, support Mr Moffat. But there was an inferior
class of voters, tenpound freeholders, and such like, who, at this period, were somewhat given to have an
opinion of their own, and over them it was supposed that Sir Roger did obtain some power by his gift of
talking.
'Now, gentlemen, will you tell me this,' said he, bawling at the top of his voice from the portico which graced
the door of the Dragon of Wantley, at which celebrated inn Sir Roger's committee sat:'Who is Mr Moffat,
and what has he done for us? There have been some picturemakers about the town this week past. The Lord
knows who they are; I don't. These clever fellows do tell you who I am, and what I've done. I ain't very proud
of the way they've painted me, though there's something about it I ain't ashamed of either. See here,' and he
held up on one side of him one of the great daubs oh himself'just hold it there till I can explain it,' and, he
handed the paper to one of his friends. 'That's me,' said Sir Roger, putting up his stick, and pointing to the
pimplynosed representation of himself.
'Hurrah! Hurrrah! more power to youwe all know who you are, Roger. You're the boy! When did you
get drunk last?' Suchlike greetings, together with a dead cat which was flung at him from the crowd, and
which he dexterously parried with his stick, were the answers which he received to this exordium.
'Yes,' said he, quite undismayed by this little missile which had so nearly reached him: 'that's me. And look
here; this brown, dirtylooking broad streak here is intended for a railway; and that thing in my handnot
the right hand; I'll come to that presently'
'How about the brandy, Roger?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION 125
Page No 129
'I'll come to that presently. I'll tell you about the brandy in good time. But that thing in my left hand is a
spade. Now, I never handled a spade, and never could; but, boys, I handled a chisel and mallet; and many a
hundred block of stone has come out smooth from under that hand;' and Sir Roger lifted up his great broad
palm wide open.
'So you did, Roger, and well we minds it.'
'The meaning, however, of that spade is to show that I made the railway. Now I'm very much obliged to those
gentlemen over at the White Horse for putting up this picture of me. It's a true picture, and it tells you who I
am. I did make that railway. I have made thousands of miles of railway; I am making thousands of miles
railwayssome in Europe, some in Asia, some in America. It's a true picture,' and he poked his stick right
through it and held it up to the crowd. 'A true picture: but for that spade and that railway, I shouldn't be now
here asking your votes; and, when next February comes, I shouldn't be sitting in Westminster to represent
you, as by God's grace, I certainly will do. That tells you who I am. But now, will you tell me who Mr Moffat
is?'
'How about the brandy, Roger?'
'Oh, yes, the brandy! I was forgetting that and the little speech that is coming out of my moutha deal
shorter speech, and a better one than what I am making now. Here, in the right hand you see a brandy bottle.
Well, boys, I am not ashamed of that; as long as a man does his workand the spade shows thatit's only
fair he should have something to comfort him. I'm always able to work, and few men work much harder. I'm
always able to work, and no man has a right to expect more of me. I never expect more than that from those
who word with me.'
'No more you don't, Roger: a little drop's very good, ain't it, Roger? Keeps the cold from the stomach, eh,
Roger?'
'Then as to this speech, "Come, Jack, let's have a drop of some'at short". Why, that's a good speech too. When
I do drink I like to share with a friend; and I don't care how humble that friend is.'
'Hurrah! more power. That's true too, Roger; may you never be without a drop to wet your whistle.'
'They say I'm the last new baronet. Well, I ain't ashamed of that; not a bit. When will Mr Moffat get himself
made a baronet? No man can truly say I'm too proud of it. I have never stuck myself up; no, nor stuck my
wife up either: but I don't see much to be ashamed of because the bigwigs chose to make a baronet of me.'
'Nor, no more thee h'ant, Roger. We'd all be barrownites if so be we knew the way.'
'But now, having polished off this bit of picture, let me ask you who Mr Moffat is? There are pictures enough
about him, too; though Heaven knows where they all come from. I think Sir Edwin Landseer must have done
this one of the goose; it is so deadly natural. Look at it; there he is. Upon my word, whoever did that ought to
make his fortune at some of these exhibitions. Here he is again, with a big pair of scissors. He calls himself
"England's honour"; what the deuce England's honour has to do with tailoring, I can't tell you: perhaps Mr
Moffat can. But mind you, my friends, I don't say anything against tailoring: some of you are tailors, I dare
say.'
'Yes, we be,' said a little squeaking voice from out of the crowd.
'And a good trade it is. When I first know Barchester there were tailors here could lick any stonemason in
the trade; I say nothing against tailors. But it isn't enough for a man to be a tailor unless he's something else
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION 126
Page No 130
along with it. You're not so fond of tailors that you'll send one up to Parliament merely because he is a tailor.'
'We won't have no tailors. No; nor yet no cabbaging. Take a go of brandy, Roger; you're blown.'
'No, I'm not blown yet. I've a deal more to say about Mr Moffat before I shall be blown. What has he done to
entitle him to come here before you and ask you to send him to Parliament? Why; he isn't even a tailor. I wish
he were. There's always some good in a fellow who knows how to earn his own bread. But he isn't a tailor; he
can't even put a stitch in towards mending England's honour. His father was a tailor; not a Barchester tailor,
mind you, so as to give him any claim on your affections; but a London tailor. Now the question is, do you
want to send the son of a London tailor up to Parliament to represent you?'
'No, we don't; nor yet we won't either.'
'I rather think not. You've had him once, and what has he done for you? has he said much for you in the
House of Commons? Why, he's so dumb a dog that he can't bark even for a bone. I'm told it's quite painful to
hear him fumbling and mumbling and trying to get up a speech there over at the White Horse. He doesn't
belong to the city; he hasn't done anything for the city; and he hasn't the power to do anything for the city.
Then, why on earth does he come here? I'll tell you. The Earl de Courcy brings him. He's going to marry the
Earl de Courcy's niece; for they say he's very richthis tailor's sononly they do say also that he doesn't
much like to spend his money. He's going to marry Lord de Courcy's niece, and Lord de Courcy wishes that
his nephew should be in Parliament. There, that's the claim which Mr Moffat has here on the people of
Barchester. He's Lord de Courcy's nominee, and those who feel themselves bound hand and foot, heart and
soul, to Lord de Courcy, had better vote for him. Such men have my leave. If there are enough of such at
Barchester to send him to Parliament, the city in which I was born must be very much altered since I was a
young man.'
And so finishing his speech, Sir Roger retired within, and recruited himself in the usual manner.
Such was the flood of eloquence at the Dragon of Wantly. At the White Horse, meanwhile, the friends of the
De Courcy interest were treated perhaps to sounder political views; though not expressed in periods so
intelligibly fluent as those of Sir Roger.
Mr Moffat was a young man, and there was no knowing to what proficiency in the Parliamentary gift of
public talking he might yet attain; but hitherto his proficiency was not great. He had, however, endeavoured
to make up by study for any want of readiness of speech, and had come to Barchester daily, for the last four
days, fortified with a very pretty harangue, which he had prepared for himself in the solitude of his chamber.
On the three previous days matters had been allowed to progress with tolerable smoothness, and he had been
permitted to deliver himself of his elaborate eloquence with few other interruptions than those occasioned by
his own want of practice. But on this, the day of days, the Barchesterian roughs were not so complaisant. It
appeared to Mr Moffat, when he essayed to speak, that he was surrounded by enemies rather than friends; and
in his heart he gave great blame to Mr Nearthewinde for not managing matters better for him.
'Men of Barchester,' he began, in a voice which was every now and then preternaturally loud, but which, at
each fourth or fifth word, gave way from want of power, and descended to its natural weak tone. 'Men of
Barchesterelectors and nonelectors'
'We is hall electors; hall on us, my young kiddy.'
'Electors and nonelectors, I now ask your suffrages, not for the first time'
'Oh! we've tried you. We know what you're made on. Go on, Snip; don't you let 'em put you down.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION 127
Page No 131
'I've had the honour of representing you in Parliament for the last two years and'
'And a deuced deal you did for us, didn't you?'
'What could you expect from the ninth part of a man? Never mind, Snipgo on; don't you be out by any of
them. Stick to your wax and thread like a manlike the ninth part of a mango on a little faster, Snip.'
'For the last two yearsandand' Here Mr Moffat looked round to his friends for some little support, and
the Honourable George, who stood close behind him, suggested that he had gone through it like a brick.
'Andand I went through it like a brick,' said Mr Moffat, with the gravest possible face, taking up in his
utter confusion the words that were put into his mouth.
'Hurray!so you didyou're the real brick. Well done, Snip; go it again with the wax and thread!'
'I am a thoroughpaced reformer,' continued Mr Moffat, somewhat reassured by the effect of the opportune
words which his friend had whispered into his ear. 'A thoroughpaced reformera thoroughpaced
reformer'
'Go on, Snip. We all know what that means.'
'A thoroughpaced reformer'
'Never mind your paces, man; but get on. Tell us something new. We're all reformers, we are.'
Poor Mr Moffat was a little thrown back. It wasn't so easy to tell these gentlemen anything new, harnessed as
he was at this moment; so he looked back at his honourable supporter for some further hint. 'Say something
about their daughters,' whispered George, whose own flights of oratory were always on that subject. Had he
counselled Mr Moffat to way a word or two about the tides, his advice would not have been less to the
purpose.
'Gentlemen,' he began again'you all know that I am a thoroughpaced reformer'
'Oh, drat your reform. He's a dumb dog. Go back to your goose, Snippy; you never were made for this work.
Go to Courcy Castle and reform that.'
Mr Moffat, grieved in his soul, was becoming inextricably bewildered by such facetiae as these, when an
eggand it may be feared not a fresh eggflung with unerring precision, struck him on the open part of his
wellplaited shirt, and reduced him to speechless despair.
An egg is a means of delightful support when properly administered; but it is not calculated to add much
spirit to a man's eloquence, or to ensure his powers of endurance, when supplied in the manner above
described. Men there are, doubtless, whose tongues would not be stopped even by such an argument as this;
but Mr Moffat was not one of them. As the insidious fluid trickled down beneath his waistcoat, he felt that all
further powers of coaxing the electors out of their votes, by words flowing from his tongue sweeter than
honey, was for that occasion denied him. He could not be selfconfident, energetic, witty, and
goodhumoured with a rotten egg, drying through his clothes. He was forced, therefore, to give way, and
with sadly disconcerted air retired from the open window at which he had been standing.
It was in vain that the Honourable George, Mr Nearthewinde, and Frank endeavoured again to bring him to
the charge. He was like a beaten prizefighter, whose pluck has been cowed out of him, and who, if he stands
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION 128
Page No 132
up, only stands up to fall. Mr Moffat got sulky also, and when he was pressed, said that Barchester and the
people in it might be d. 'With all my heart,' said Mr Nearthewinde. 'That wouldn't have any effect on their
votes.'
But, in truth, it mattered very little whether Mr Moffat spoke, or whether he didn't speak. Four o'clock was
the hour for closing the poll, and that was now fast coming. Tremendous exertions had been made about
halfpast three, by a safe emissary sent from Nearthewinde, to prove to Mr Reddypalm that all manner of
contingent advantages would accrue to the Brown Bear if it should turn out that Mr Moffat should take his
seat for Barchester. No bribe was, of course offered or even hinted at. The purity of Barchester was not
contaminated during the day by one such curse as this. But a man, and a publican, would be required to do
some great deed in the public line. To open some colossal tapp to draw beer for the million; and no one
would be so fit as Mr Reddypalmif only it might turn out that Mr Moffat should, in the coming February,
take his seat as member for Barchester.
But Mr Reddypalm was a man of humble desires, whose ambitions scored no higher than thisthat his little
bills should be duly settled. It was wonderful what love an innkeeper has for his bill in its entirety. An
account, with a respectable total of five or six pounds, is brought to you, and you complain but of one article;
that fire in the bedroom was never lighted; or that second glass of brandy and water was never called for. You
desire to have the shilling expunged, and all your host's pleasure in the whole transaction is destroyed. Oh!
my friends, pay for the brandy and water, though you never drank it; suffer the fire to pass, though it never
warmed you. Why make a good man miserable for such a trifle?
It became notified to Reddypalm with sufficient clearness that his bill for the past election should be paid
without further question; and therefore, at five o'clock the Mayor of Barchester proclaimed the results of the
contests in the following figures:
Scatcherd 378
Moffat 376
Mr Reddypalm's two votes had decided the question. Mr Nearthewinde immediately went up to town; and the
dinner party at Courcy Castle that evening was not a particularly pleasant meal.
This much, however, had been absolutely decided before the yellow committee concluded their labour at the
White Horse: there should be a petition. Mr Nearthewinde had not been asleep, and already knew something
of the manner in which Mr Reddypalm's mind had been quieted.
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS
The intimacy between Frank and Miss Dunstable grew and prospered. That is to say, it prospered as an
intimacy, though perhaps hardly as a love affair. There was a continued succession of jokes between them,
which no one else in the castle understood; but the very fact of there being such a good understanding
between them rather stood in the way of, than assisted, that consummation which the countess desired.
People, when they are in love with each other, or even when they pretend to be, do not generally show it by
loud laughter. Nor is it frequently the case that a wife with two hundred thousand pounds can be won without
some little preliminary despair.
Lady de Courcy, who thoroughly understood that portion of the world in which she herself lived, saw that
things were not going quite as they should do, and gave much and repeated advice to Frank on the subject.
She was the more eager in doing this, because she imagined Frank had done what he could to obey her first
precepts. He had not turned up his nose at Miss Dunstable's curls, nor found fault with her loud voice: he had
not objected to her as ugly, nor even shown any dislike to her age. A young man who had been so amenable
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS 129
Page No 133
to reason was worthy of further assistance; and so Lady de Courcy did what she could to assist him.
'Frank, my dear boy,' she would say, 'you are a little too noisy, I think. I don't mean for myself, you know; I
don't mind it. But Miss Dunstable would like it better if you were a little more quiet with her.'
'Would she, aunt?' said Frank, looking demurely up into the countess's face. 'I rather think she likes fun and
noise, and that sort of thing. You know she's not very quiet herself.'
'Ah!but, Frank, there are times, you know, when that sort of thing should be laid aside. Fun, as you call it,
is all very well in its place. Indeed, no one likes it better than I do. But that's not the way to show admiration.
Young ladies like to be admired; and if you'll be a little more softmannered with Miss Dunstable, I'm sure
you'll find it will answer better.'
And so the old bird taught the young bird how to flyvery needlesslyfor in this matter of flying, Nature
gives her own lessons thoroughly; and the ducklings will take the water, even though the maternal hen warn
them against the perfidious element never so loudly.
Soon after this, Lady de Courcy began to be not very well pleased in the matter. She took it into her head that
Miss Dunstable was sometimes almost inclined to laugh at her; and on one or two occasions it almost seemed
as though Frank was joining Miss Dunstable in doing so. The fact indeed was, that Miss Dunstable was fond
of fun; and, endowed as she was with all the privileges which two hundred thousand pounds may be supposed
to give to a young lady, did not very much care at whom she laughed. She was able to make a tolerably
correct guess at Lady De Courcy's plan towards herself; but she did not for a moment think that Frank had
any intention of furthering his aunt's views. She was, therefore, not at all illinclined to have her revenge on
the countess.
'How very fond your aunt is of you!' she said to him one wet morning, as he was sauntering through the
house; now laughing, and almost romping with herthen teasing his sister about Mr Moffatand then
bothering his ladycousins out of all their propriety.
'Oh, very!' said Frank: 'she is a dear, good woman, is my Aunt De Courcy.'
'I declare she takes more notice of you and your doings than of any of your cousins. I wonder they aren't
jealous.'
'Oh! they're such good people. Bless me, they'd never be jealous.'
'You are so much younger than they are, that I suppose she thinks you want more of her care.'
'Yes; that's it. You see she is fond of having a baby to nurse.'
'Tell me, Mr Gresham, what was it she was saying to you last night? I know we have been misbehaving
ourselves dreadfully. It was all your fault; you would make me laugh so.'
'That's just what I said to her.'
'She was talking about it, then?'
'How on earth should she talk of any one else as long as you are here? Don't you know that all the world is
talking about you?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS 130
Page No 134
'Is it?dear me, how kind! But I don't care a straw about any world at present but Lady de Courcy's world.
What did she say?'
'She said you were very beautiful'
'Did she?how good of her!'
'No; I forgot. Itit was I that said that; and she saidwhat was it she said? She said, that after all, beauty
was but skin deepand that she valued you for your virtues and prudence rather than your good looks.'
'Virtues and prudence! She said I was prudent and virtuous?'
'Yes.'
'And you talked of my beauty? That was so kind of you. You didn't either of you say anything about other
matters?'
'What other matters?'
'Oh! I don't know. Only some people are sometimes valued rather for what they've got than for any good
qualities belonging to themselves intrinsically.'
'That can never be the case with Miss Dunstable; especially not at Courcy Castle,' said Frank, bowing easily
from the corner of the sofa over which he was leaning.
'Of course not,' said Miss Dunstable; and Frank at once perceived that she spoke in a tone of voice differing
much from that halfbantering, halfgoodhumoured manner that was customary with her. 'Of course not:
any such idea would be quite out of the question with Lady de Courcy.' She paused for a moment, and then
added in a tone different again, and unlike any that he had yet heard from her:'It is, at any rate, out of the
question with Mr Frank Greshamof that I am quite sure.'
Frank ought to have understood her, and have appreciated the good opinion which she intended to convey;
but he did not entirely do so. He was hardly honest himself towards her; and he could not at first perceive that
she intended to say that she thought him so. He knew very well that she was alluding to her own huge
fortune, and was alluding also to the fact that people of fashion sought her because of it; but he did not know
that she intended to express a true acquittal as regarded him of any such baseness.
And did he deserve to be acquitted? Yes, upon the whole he did;to be acquitted of that special sin. His
desire to make Miss Dunstable temporarily subject to his sway arose, not from a hankering after her fortune,
but from an ambition to get the better of a contest in which other men around him seemed to be failing.
For it must not be imagined that, with such a prize to be struggled for, all others stood aloof and allowed him
to have his own way with the heiress, undisputed. The chance of a wife with two hundred thousand pounds is
a godsend, which comes in a man's life too seldom to be neglected, let that chance be never so remote.
Frank was the heir to a large embarrassed property; and, therefore, the heads of families, putting their
wisdoms together, had thought it most meet that this daughter of Plutus should, if possible, fall to his lot. But
not so thought the Honourable George; and not so thought another gentleman who was at that time an inmate
of Courcy Castle.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS 131
Page No 135
These suitors perhaps somewhat despised their young rival's efforts. It may be that they had sufficient
worldly wisdom to know that so important a crisis of life is not settled among quips and jokes, and that Frank
was too much in jest to be in earnest. But be that as it may, his lovemaking did not stand in the way of their
lovemaking; nor his hopes, if he had any, in the way of their hopes.
The Honourable George had discussed the matter with the Honourable John in a properly fraternal manner. It
may be that John had also an eye to the heiress; but, if so, he had ceded his views to his brother's superior
claims; for it came about that they understood each other very well, and John favoured George with salutary
advice on the occasion.
'If it is to be done at all, it should be done very sharp,' said John.
'As sharp as you like,' said George. 'I'm not the fellow to be studying three months in what attitude I'll fall at a
girl's feet.'
'No: and when you are there you mustn't take three months more to study how you'll get up again. If you do it
at all, you must do it sharp,' repeated John, putting great stress on his advice.
'I have said a few soft words to her already, and she didn't seem to take them badly,' said George.
'She's no chicken, you know,' remarked John; 'and with a woman like that, beating about the bush never does
any good. The chances are she won't have youthat's of course; plums like that don't fall into a man's mouth
merely for shaking the tree. But it's possible she may; and if she will, she's as likely to take you today as this
day six months. If I were you I'd write her a letter.'
'Write her a lettereh?' said George, who did not altogether dislike the advice, for it seemed to take from his
shoulders the burden of preparing a spoken address. Though he was so glib in speaking about the farmers'
daughters, he felt that he should have some little difficulty in making known his passion to Miss Dunstable,
by word of mouth.
'Yes; write a letter. If she'll take you at all, she'll take you that way; half the matches going are made up by
writing letters. Write her a letter and get it put on her dressingtable.' George said that he would, and so he
did.
George spoke quite truly when he hinted that he had said a few soft things to Miss Dunstable. Miss
Dunstable, however, was accustomed to hear soft things. She had been carried much about in society among
fashionable people since, on the settlement of her father's will, she had been pronounced heiress to all the
ointment of Lebanon; and many men had made calculations respecting her similar to those which were now
animating the brain of the Honourable George de Courcy. She was already quite accustomed to being a target
at which spendthrifts and the needy rich might shoot their arrows: accustomed to being shot at, and tolerably
accustomed to protect herself without making scenes in the world, or rejecting the advantageous
establishments offered to her with any loud expressions of disdain. The Honourable George, therefore, had
been permitted to say soft things very much as a matter of course.
And very little more outward fracas arose from the correspondence which followed than had arisen from the
soft things so said. George wrote the letter, and had it duly conveyed to Miss Dunstable's bedchamber. Miss
Dunstable duly received it, and had her answer conveyed back discreetly to George's hands. The
correspondence ran as follows:
'Courcy Castle, Aug. , 185. 'MY DEAREST MISS DUNSTABLE,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS 132
Page No 136
'I cannot but flatter myself that you must have perceived from my manner that you are not indifferent to me.
Indeed, indeed, you are not. I may truly say, and swear' (these last strong words had been put in by the special
counsel of the Honourable John), 'that if ever a man loved a woman truly, I truly love you. You may think it
very odd that I should say this in a letter instead of speaking it out before your face; but your powers of
raillery are so great' ('touch her up about her wit' had been the advice of the Honourable John) 'that I am all
but afraid to encounter them. Dearest, dearest Marthaoh do not blame me for so addressing you!if you
will trust your happiness to me you shall never find that you have been deceived. My ambition shall be to
make you shine in that circle which you are so well qualified to adorn and to see you firmly fixed in that
sphere of fashion for which your tastes adapt you.
'I may safely assertand I do assert it with my hand on my heartthat I am actuated by no mercenary
motives. Far be it from me to marry any womanno, not a princesson account of her money. No marriage
can be happy without mutual affection; and I do fully trustno, not trust, but hopethat there may be such
between you and me, dearest Miss Dunstable. Whatever settlements you might propose I would accede to. It
is you, your sweet person, that I love, not your money.
'For myself, I need not remind you that I am the second son of my father; and that, as such, I hold no
inconsiderable station in the world. My intention is to get into Parliament, and to make a name for myself, if I
can, among those who shine in the House of Commons. My elder brother, Lord Porlock, is, you are aware,
unmarried; and we all fear that the family honours are not likely to be perpetuated by him, as he has all
manner of troublesome liaisons which will probably prevent his settling in life. There is nothing at all of that
kind in my way. It will indeed be a delight to place a coronet on the head of my lovely Martha: a coronet
which can give no fresh grace to her, but which will be so much adorned by her wearing it.
'Dearest, Miss Dunstable, I shall wait with the utmost impatience for your answer; and now, burning with
hope that it may not be altogether unfavourable to my love, I beg permission to sign myself
'Your own most devoted, 'GEORGE DE COURCY'
The ardent lover had not to wait long for an answer from his mistress. She found this letter on her toilettable
one night as she went to bed. The next morning she came down to breakfast and met her swain with the most
unconcerned air in the world; so much so that he began to think, as he munched his toast with rather a
shamefaced look, that the letter on which so much was to depend had not yet come safely to hand. But his
suspense was not of a prolonged duration. After breakfast, as was his wont, he went out to the stables with his
brother and Frank Gresham; and while there, Miss Dunstable's man, coming up to him, touched his hat, and
put a letter into his hand.
Frank, who knew the man, glanced at the letter and looked at his cousin; but he said nothing. He was,
however, a little jealous, and felt that an injury was done to him by any correspondence between Miss
Dunstable and his cousin George.
Miss Dunstable's reply was as follows; and it may be remarked that it was written in a very clear and
wellpenned hand, and one which certainly did not betray much emotion of the heart:
'MY DEAR MR DE COURCY,
'I am sorry to say that I had not perceived from your manner that you entertained any peculiar feelings
towards me; as, had I done so, I should at once have endeavoured to put an end to them. I am much flattered
by the way in which you speak of me; but I am in too humble a position to return your affection; and can,
therefore, only express a hope that you may be soon able to eradicate it from your bosom. A letter is a very
good way of making an offer, and as such I do not think it at all odd; but I certainly did not expect such an
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS 133
Page No 137
honour last night. As to my raillery, I trust it has never yet hurt you. I can assure you that it never shall. I
hope you will soon have a worthier ambition than that to which you allude; for I am well aware that no
attempt will ever make me shine anywhere.
'I am quite sure you have had no mercenary motives: such motives in marriage are very base, and quite below
your name and lineage. Any little fortune that I may have must be a matter of indifference to one who looks
forward, as you do, to put a coronet on his wife's brow. Nevertheless, for the sake of the family, I trust that
Lord Porlock, in spite of his obstacles, may live to do the same for a wife of his own some of these days. I am
glad to hear that there is nothing to interfere with your own prospects of domestic felicity.
'Sincerely hoping that you may be perfectly successful in your proud ambition to shine in Parliament, and
regretting extremely that I cannot share that ambition with you, I beg to subscribe myself, with very great
respect,
'Your sincere wellwisher, 'MARTHA DUNSTABLE'
The Honourable George, with that modesty which so well became him, accepted Miss Dunstable's reply as a
final answer to his little proposition, and troubled her with no further courtship. As he said to his brother
John, no harm had been done, and he might have better luck next time. But there was an intimate of Courcy
Castle who was somewhat more pertinacious in his search after love and wealth. This was no other than Mr
Moffat: a gentleman whose ambition was not satisfied by the cares of his Barchester contest, or the
possession of one affianced bride.
Mr Moffat was, as we have said, a man of wealth; but we all know, from the lessons of early youth, how the
love of money increases and gains strength by its own success. Nor was he a man of so mean a spirit as to be
satisfied with mere wealth. He desired also place and station, and gracious countenance among the great ones
of the earth. Hence had come his adherence to the De Courcys; hence his seat in Parliament; and hence, also,
his perhaps illconsidered match with Miss Gresham.
There is no doubt but that the privilege of matrimony offers opportunities to moneyloving young men which
ought not to be lightly abused. Too many young men marry without giving any consideration to the matter
whatever. It is not that they are indifferent to money, but that they recklessly miscalculate their own value,
and omit to look around and see how much is done by those who are more careful. A man can be young but
once, and, except in cases of a special interposition of Providence, can marry but once. The chance once
thrown away may be said to be irrevocable! How, in afterlife, do men toil and turmoil through long years to
attain some prospect of doubtful advancement! Half that trouble, half that care, a tithe of that circumspection
would, in early youth, have probably secured to them the enduring comfort of a wife's wealth.
You will see men labouring night and day to become bank directors; and even a bank direction may only be
the road to ruin. Others will spend years in degrading subserviency to obtain a niche in a will; and the niche,
when at last obtained and enjoyed, is but a sorry payment for all that has been endured. Others again, struggle
harder still, and go through even deeper waters: they make wills for themselves, forge stockshares, and fight
with unremitting, painful labour to appear to be the thing they are not. Now, in many of these cases, all this
might have been spared had the men made adequate use of those opportunities which youth and youthful
charms afford onceand once only. There is no road to wealth so easy and respectable as that of matrimony;
that, is of course, provided that the aspirant declines the slow course to honest work. But then, we can so
seldom put old heads on young shoulders!
In the case of Mr Moffat, we may perhaps say that a specimen was produced of this bird, so rare in the land.
His shoulders were certainly young, seeing that he was not yet sixandtwenty; but his head had ever been
old. From the moment when he was first put forth to go aloneat the age of twentyonehis life had been
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS 134
Page No 138
one calculation how he could make the most of himself. He had allowed himself to be betrayed into folly by
an unguarded heart; no youthful indiscretion had marred his prospects. He had made the most of himself.
Without wit or depth, or any mental giftwithout honesty of purpose or industry for good workhe had
been for two years sitting member for Barchester; was the guest of Lord de Courcy; was engaged to the eldest
daughter of one of the best commoners' families in England; and was, when he first began to think of Miss
Dunstable, sanguine that his reelection to Parliament was secure.
When, however, at this period he began to calculate what his position in the world really was, it occurred to
him that he was doing an illjudged thing in marrying Miss Gresham. Why marry a penniless girlfor
Augusta's trifle of a fortune was not a penny in his estimationwhile there was Miss Dunstable in the world
to be won? His own six or seven thousand a year, quite unembarrassed as it was, was certainly a great thing;
but what might he not do if to that he could add the almost fabulous wealth of the great heiress? Was she not
here, put absolutely in his path? Would it not be a wilful throwing away of a chance not to avail himself of it?
He must, to be sure, lose the De Courcy friendship; but if he should then have secured his Barchester seat for
the usual term of parliamentary session, he might be able to spare that. He would also, perhaps, encounter
some Gresham enmity: this was a point on which he did think more than once: but what will a man not
encounter for the sake of two hundred thousand pounds?
It was thus that Mr Moffat argued with himself, with much prudence, and brought himself to resolve that he
would at any rate become the candidate for the great prize. He also, therefore, began to say soft things; and it
must be admitted that he said them with more considerate propriety than had the Honourable George. Mr
Moffat had an idea that Miss Dunstable was not a fool, and that in order to catch her he must do more than
endeavour to lay salt on her tail, in the guise of flattery. It was evident to him that she was a bird of some
cunning, not to be caught by an ordinary gin, such as those commonly in use with the Honourable Georges of
Society.
It seemed to Mr Moffat, that though Miss Dunstable was so sprightly, so full of fun, and so ready to chatter
on all subjects, she well knew the value of her own money, and of her position as dependent on it: he
perceived that she never flattered the countess, and seemed to be no whit absorbed by the titled grandeur of
her host's family. He gave her credit, therefore, for an independent spirit: and an independent spirit in his
estimation was one that placed its sole dependence on a respectable balance at its banker's.
Working on these ideas, Mr Moffat commenced operations in such manner that his overtures to the heiress
should not, if unsuccessful, interfere with the Greshamsbury engagement. He began by making common
cause with Miss Dunstable: their positions in the world, he said to her, were closely similar. They had both
risen from the lower classes by the strength of honest industry: they were both now wealthy, and had both
hitherto made such use of their wealth as to induce the highest aristocracy in England to admit them into their
circles.
'Yes, Mr Moffat,' had Miss Dunstable remarked; 'and if all that I hear be true, to admit you into their very
families.'
At this Mr Moffat slightly demurred. He would not affect, he said, to misunderstand what Miss Dunstable
meant. There had been something said on the probability of such an event; but he begged Miss Dunstable not
to believe all that she heard on such subjects.
'I do not believe much,' said she; 'but I certainly did think that that might be credited.'
Mr Moffat went on to show how it behoved them both, in holding out their hands halfway to meet the
aristocratic overtures that were made to them, not to allow themselves to be made use of. The aristocracy,
according to Mr Moffat, were people of a very nice sort; the best acquaintance in the world; a portion of
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS 135
Page No 139
mankind to be noticed by whom should be one of the first objects in the life of the Dunstables and the
Moffats. But the Dunstables and Moffats should be very careful to give little or nothing in return. Much, very
much in return, would be looked for. The aristocracy, said Mr Moffat, were not a people to allow in the light
of their countenance to shine forth without looking for a quid pro quo, for some compensating value. In all
their intercourse with the Dunstables and Moffats, they would expect a payment. It was for the Dunstables
and Moffats to see that, at any rate, they did not pay more for the article they got than its market value.
They way in which she, Miss Dunstable, and he, Mr Moffat, would be required to pay would be by taking
each of them some poor scion of the aristocracy in marriage; and thus expending their hardearned wealth in
procuring highpriced pleasures for some wellborn pauper. Against this, peculiar caution was to be used. Of
course, the further induction to be shown was this: that people so circumstanced should marry among
themselves; the Dunstables and the Moffats each with the other and not tumble into the pitfalls prepared for
them.
Whether these great lessons had any lasting effect on Miss Dunstable's mind may be doubted. Perhaps she
had already made up her mind on the subject which Mr Moffat so well discussed. She was older than Mr
Moffat, and, in spite of his two years of parliamentary experience, had perhaps more knowledge of the world
with which she had to deal. But she listened to what he said with complacency; understood his object as well
as she had that of his aristocratic rival; was no whit offended; but groaned in her spirit as she thought of the
wrongs of Augusta Gresham.
But all this good advice, however, would not win the money for Mr Moffat without some more decided step;
and that step he soon decided on taking, feeling assured that what he had said would have its due weight with
the heiress.
The party at Courcy Castle was now soon about to be broken up. The male De Courcys were going down to a
Scotch mountain. The female De Courcys were to be shipped off to an Irish castle. Mr Moffat was to go up to
town to prepare his petition. Miss Dunstable was again about to start on a foreign tour in behalf of her
physician and attendants; and Frank Gresham was at last to be allowed to go to Cambridge; that is to say,
unless his success with Miss Dunstable should render such a step on his part quite preposterous.
'I think you may speak now, Frank,' said the countess. 'I really think you may: you have known her now for a
considerable time; and, as far as I can judge, she is very fond of you.'
'Nonsense, aunt,' said Frank; 'she doesn't care a button for me.'
'I think differently; and lookerson, you know, always understand the game best. I suppose you are not afraid
to ask her.'
'Afraid!' said Frank, in a tone of considerable scorn. He almost made up his mind that he would ask her to
show that he was not afraid. His only obstacle to doing so was, that he had not the slightest intention of
marrying her.
There was to be but one other great event before the party broke up, and that was a dinner at the Duke of
Omnium's. The duke had already declined to come to Courcy; but he had in a measure atoned for this by
asking some of the guests to join a great dinner which he was about to give to his neighbours.
Mr Moffat was to leave Courcy Castle the day after the dinnerparty, and he therefore determined to make
his great attempt on the morning of that day. It was with some difficulty that he brought about an opportunity;
but at last he did so, and found himself alone with Miss Dunstable in the walks of Courcy Park.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS 136
Page No 140
'It is a strange thing, is it not,' said he, recurring to his old view of the same subject, 'that I should be going to
dine with the Duke of Omniumthe richest man, they say, among the whole English aristocracy?'
'Men of that kind entertain everybody, I believe, now and then,' said Miss Dunstable, not very civilly.
'I believe they do; but I am not going as one of the everybodies. I am going from Lord de Courcy's house with
some of his own family. I have no pride in thatnot the least; I have more pride in my father's honest
industry. But it shows what money does in this country of ours.'
'Yes, indeed; money does a great deal many queer things.' In saying this Miss Dunstable could not but think
that money had done a very queer thing in inducing Miss Gresham to fall in love with Mr Moffat.
'Yes; wealth is very powerful: here we are, Miss Dunstable, the most honoured guests in the house.'
'Oh! I don't know about that; you may be, for you are a member of Parliament, and all that'
'No; not a member now, Miss Dunstable.'
'Well, you will be, and that's all the same; but I have no such title to honour, thank God.'
They walked on in silence for a little while, for Mr Moffat hardly knew who to manage the business he had in
hand. 'It is quite delightful to watch these people,' he said at last; 'now they accuse us of being tufthunters.'
'Do they?' said Miss Dunstable. 'Upon my word I didn't know that anybody ever so accused me.'
'I didn't mean you and me personally.'
'Oh! I'm glad of that.'
'But that is what the world says of persons of our class. Now it seems to me that toadying is all on the other
side. The countess here does toady you, and so do the young ladies.'
'Do they? if so, upon my word I didn't know it. But, to tell the truth, I don't think much of such things. I live
mostly to myself, Mr Moffat.'
'I see that you do, and I admire you for it; but, Miss Dunstable, you cannot always live so,' and Mr Moffat
looked at her in a manner which gave her the first intimation of his coming burst of tenderness.
'That's as may be, Mr Moffat,' said she.
He went on beating about the bush for some timegiving her to understand now necessary it was that
persons situated as they were should live either for themselves or for each other, and that, above all things,
they should beware of falling into the mouths of voracious aristocratic lions who go about looking for
preytill they came to a turn in the grounds; at which Miss Dunstable declared her intention of going in. She
had walked enough, she said. As by this time Mr Moffat's immediate intentions were becoming visible she
thought it prudent to retire. 'Don't let me take you in, Mr Moffat; but my boots are a little damp, and Dr
Easyman will never forgive me if I do not hurry in as fast as I can.'
'Your feet damp?I hope not: I do hope not,' said he, with a look of the greatest solicitude.
'Oh! it's nothing to signify; but it's well to be prudent, you know. Good morning, Mr Moffat.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS 137
Page No 141
'Miss Dunstable!'
'Ehyes!' and Miss Dunstable stopped in the grand path. 'I won't let you return with me, Mr Moffat, because
I know you were coming in so soon.'
'Miss Dunstable; I shall be leaving here tomorrow.'
'Yes; and I go myself the day after.'
'I know it. I am going to town and you are going abroad. It may be longvery longbefore we meet again.'
'About Easter,' said Miss Dunstable; 'that is, if the doctor doesn't known up on the road.'
'And I had, had wish to say something before we part for so long a time. Miss Dunstable'
'Stop!Mr Moffat. Let me ask you one question. I'll hear anything that you have got to say, but on one
condition: that is, that Miss Augusta Gresham shall be by while you say it. Will you consent to that?'
'Miss Augusta Gresham,' said he, 'has no right to listen to my private conversation.'
'Has she not, Mr Moffat? then I think she should have. I, at any rate, will not so far interfere with what I look
on as her undoubted privileges as to be a party to any secret in which she may not participate.'
'But, Miss Dunstable'
And to tell you fairly, Mr Moffat, any secret that you do tell me, I shall most undoubtedly repeat to her before
dinner. Good morning, Mr Moffat; my feet are certainly a little damp, and if I stay a moment longer, Dr
Easyman will put off my foreign trip for at least a week.' And so she left him standing alone in the middle of
the gravelwalk.
For a moment or two, Mr Moffat consoled himself in his misfortune by thinking how he might avenge
himself on Miss Dunstable. Soon, however, such futile ideas left his brain. Why should he give over the
chase because the rich galleon had escaped him on this, his first cruise in pursuit of her? Such prizes were not
to be won so easily. His present objection clearly consisted in his engagement to Miss Gresham, and in that
only. Let that engagement be at an end, notoriously and publicly broken off, and this objection would fall to
the ground. Yes; ships so richly freighted were not to be run down in one summer morning's plain sailing.
Instead of looking for his revenge on Miss Dunstable, it would be more prudent in himmore in keeping
with his characterto pursue his object, and overcome such difficulties as he might find his way.
CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE OF OMNIUM
The Duke of Omnium was, as we have said, a bachelor. Not the less on that account did he on certain rare
gala days entertain the beauty of the county in his magnificent rural seat, or the female fashion of London in
Belgrave Square; but on this occasion the dinner at Gatherum Castlefor such was the name of his
mansionwas to be confined to the lords of the creation. It was to be one of those days on which he
collected round his board all the notables of the county, in order that his popularity might not wane, or the
established glory of his hospitable house become dim.
On such an occasion it was not probable that Lord de Courcy would be one of the guests. They party, indeed,
who went from Courcy Castle was not large, and consisted of the Honourable George, Mr Moffat, and Frank
Gresham. They went in a taxcart, with a tandem horse, driven very knowingly by George de Courcy; and
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE OF OMNIUM 138
Page No 142
the fourth seat on the back of the vehicle was occupied by a servant, who was to look after the horses at
Gatherum.
The Honourable George drove either well or luckily, for he reached the duke's house in safety; but he drove
very fast. Poor Miss Dunstable! what would have been her lot had anything but good happened to that
vehicle, so richly freighted with her three lovers! They did not quarrel as to the prize, and all reached
Gatherum Castle in goodhumour with each other.
The castle was new building of white stone, lately erected at an enormous cost by one of the first architects of
the day. It was an immense pile, and seemed to cover ground enough for a moderatesized town. But,
nevertheless, report said that when it was completed, the noble owner found that he had no rooms to live in;
and that, on this account, when disposed to study his own comfort, he resided in a house of perhaps onetenth
of the size, built by his grandfather in another county.
Gatherum Castle would probably be called Italian in its style of architecture; though it may, I think, be
doubted whether any such edifice, or anything like it, was ever seen in any part of Italy. It was a vast edifice;
irregular in heightor it appeared to behaving long wings on each side too high to be passed over by the
eye as mere adjuncts to the mansion, and a portico so large as to make the house behind it look like another
building of a greater altitude. This portico was supported by Ionic columns, and was in itself doubtless a
beautiful structure. It was approached by a flight of steps, very broad and very grand; but, as an approach, by
a flight of steps hardly suits an Englishman's house, to the immediate entrance of which it is necessary that
his carriage should drive, there was another front door in one of the wings which was commonly used. A
carriage, however, could on very stupendously grand occasionsthe visits, for instance, of queens and kings,
and royal dukesbe brought up under the portico; as the steps had been so constructed as to admit of a road,
with a rather stiff ascent, being made close in front of the wing up into the very porch.
0pening from the porch was the grand hall, which extended up to the top of the house. It was magnificent,
indeed; being decorated with manycoloured marbles, and hung round with various trophies of the house of
Omnium; banners were there, and armour; the sculptured busts of many noble progenitors; fulllength
figures of marble of those who had been especially prominent; and every monument of glory and wealth,
long years, and great achievements could bring together. If only a man could but live in his hall and be for
ever happy there! But the Duke of Omnium could not live happily in his hall; and the fact was, that the
architect, in contriving this magnificent entrance for his own honour and fame, had destroyed the duke's
house as regards most of the ordinary purposes of residence.
Nevertheless, Gatherum Castle is a very noble pile; and, standing as it does an eminence, has a very fine
effect when seen from many a distant knoll and verdantwooded hill.
At seven o'clock, Mr de Courcy and his friends got down from their drag at the smaller doorfor this was no
day on which to mount up under the portico; nor was that any suitable vehicle to have been entitled to such
honour. Frank felt some excitement a little stronger than that usual to him at such moments, for he had never
yet been in company with the Duke of Omnium; and he rather puzzled himself to think on what points he
would talk to the man who was the largest landowner in that county in which he himself had so great an
interest. He, however, made up his mind that he would allow the duke to choose his own subjects; merely
reserving to himself the right of pointing out how deficient in gorse covers was West Barsetshirethat being
the duke's division.
They were soon divested of their coats and hats, and, without entering on the magnificence of the great hall,
were conducted through rather a narrow passage into rather a small drawingroomsmall, that is, in
proportion to the number of gentlemen there assembled. There might be about thirty, and Frank was inclined
to think that they were almost crowded. A man came forward to greet them when their names were
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE OF OMNIUM 139
Page No 143
announced; but our hero at once knew that he was not the duke; for this man was fat and short, whereas the
duke was thin and tall.
There was a great hubbub going on; for everybody seemed to be talking to his neighbour; or, in default of a
neighbour, to himself. It was clear that the exalted rank of their host had put very little constraint on his
guests' tongues, for they chatted away with as much freedom as farmers at an ordinary.
'Which is the duke?' at last Frank contrived to whisper to his cousin.
'Oh;he's not here,' said George; 'I suppose he'll be in presently. I believe he never shows till just before
dinner.'
Frank, of course, had nothing further to say; but he already began to feel himself a little snubbed: he thought
that the duke, duke though he was, when he asked people to dinner should be there to tell them that he was
glad to see them.
More people flashed into the room, and Frank found himself rather closely wedged in with a stout clergyman
of his acquaintance. He was not badly off, for Mr Athill was a friend of his own, who had held a living near
Greshamsbury. Lately, however, at the lamented decease of Dr Stanhopewho had died of apoplexy at his
villa in ItalyMr Athill had been presented with the better preferment of Eiderdown, and had, therefore,
removed to another part of the county. He was somewhat of a bonvivant, and a man who thoroughly
understood dinnerparties; and with much good nature he took Frank under his special protection.
'You stick to me, Mr Gresham,' he said, 'when we go into the diningroom. I'm an old hand at the duke's
dinners, and know how to make a friend comfortable as well as myself.'
'But why doesn't the duke come in?' demanded Frank.
'He'll be here as soon as dinner is ready,' said Mr Athill. 'Or, rather, the dinner will be ready as soon as he is
here. I don't care, therefore, how soon he comes.'
He was beginning to be impatient, for the room was now nearly full, and it seemed evident that no other
guests were coming; when suddenly a bell rang, and a gong was sounded, and at the same instant a door that
had not yet been used flew open, and a very plainly dressed, plain, tall man entered the room. Frank at once
knew that he was at last in the presence of the Duke of Omnium.
But his grace, late as he was in commencing the duties as host, seemed in no hurry to make up for lost time.
He quietly stood on the rug, with his back to the empty grate, and spoke one or two words in a very low voice
to one or two gentlemen who stood nearest to him. The crowd, in the meanwhile, became suddenly silent.
Frank, when he found that the duke did not come and speak to him, felt that he ought to go and speak to the
duke; but no one else did so, and when he whispered his surprise to Mr Athill, that gentleman told him that
this was the duke's practice on all such occasions.
'Fothergill,' said the dukeand it was the only word he had yet spoken out loud'I believe we are ready for
dinner.' Now Mr Fothergill was the duke's landagent, and he it was who had greeted Frank and his friends at
their entrance.
Immediately the gong was again sounded, and another door leading out of the drawingroom into the
diningroom was opened. The duke led the way, and then the guests followed. 'Stick close to me, Mr
Gresham,' said Athill, 'we'll get about the middle of the table, where we shall be cosyand on the other side
of the room, out of this dreadful draughtI know the place well, Mr Gresham; stick to me.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE OF OMNIUM 140
Page No 144
Mr Athill, who was a pleasant, chatty companion, had hardly seated himself, and was talking to Frank as
quickly as he could, when Mr Fothergill, who sat at the bottom of the table, asked him to say grace. It seemed
to be quite out of the question that the duke should take any trouble over his guests whatever. Mr Athill
consequently dropped the word he was speaking, and uttered a prayerif it was a prayerthat they might
all have grateful hearts for which God was about to give them.
If it was a prayer! As far as my own experience goes, such utterances are seldom prayers, seldom can be
prayers. And if not prayers, what then? To me it is unintelligible that the full tide of glibbest chatter can be
stopped at a moment in the midst of profuse good living, and the Given thanked becomingly in words of
heartfelt praise. Setting aside for the moment what one daily hears and sees, may not one declare that a
change so sudden is not within the compass of the human mind? But then, to such reasoning one cannot but
add what one does hear and see; one cannot but judge of the ceremony by the manner in which one sees it
performeduttered, that isand listened to. Clergymen there areone meets them now and thenwho
endeavour to give to the dinnertable grace some of the solemnity of a church ritual, and what is the effect?
Much the same as though one were to be interrupted for a minute in the midst of one of our church liturgies
to hear a drinkingsong.
And it will be argued, that a man need be less thankful because, at the moment of receiving, he utters not
thanksgiving? or will it be thought that a man is made thankful because what is called a grace is uttered after
dinner? It can hardly be imagined that any one will so argue, or so think.
Dinnergraces are, probably, the last remaining relic of certain daily services which the Church in olden days
enjoined: nones, complines, and vespers were others. Of the nones and complines we have happily got quit;
and it might be well if we could get rid of the dinnergrace also. Let any man ask himself whether, on his
own part, they are acts of prayer and thanksgivingand if not that, what then? It is, I know, alleged that
graces are said before dinner, because our Saviour uttered a blessing before his last supper. I cannot say that
the idea of such analogy is pleasing to me.
When the large party entered the diningroom one or two gentlemen might be seen to come in from some
other door and set themselves at the table near to the duke's chair. These were guests of his own, who were
staying in the house, his particular friends, the men with whom he lived: the others were strangers whom he
fed, perhaps once a year, in order that his name might be known in the land as that of one who distributed
food and wine hospitably through the county. The food and wine, the attendance also, and the view of the
vast repository of plate he vouchsafed willingly to his county neighbours;but it was beyond his good
nature to talk to them. To judge by the present appearance of most of them, they were quite as well satisfied
to be left alone.
Frank was altogether a stranger there, but Mr Athill knew every one at the table.
'That's Apjohn,' said he: 'don't you know, Mr Apjohn, the attorney from Barchester? he's always here; he does
some of Fothergill's law business, and makes himself useful. If any fellow knows the value of a good dinner,
he does. You'll see that the duke's hospitality will not be thrown away on him.'
'It's very much thrown away on me, I know,' said Frank, who could not at all put up with the idea of sitting
down to dinner without having been spoken to by his host.
'Oh, nonsense!' said his clerical friend; 'you'll enjoy yourself amazingly by and by. There is not much
champagne in any other house in Barsetshire; and then the claret' And Mr Athill pressed his lips together,
and gently shook his head, meaning to signify by the motion that the claret of Gatherum Castle was sufficient
atonement for any penance which a man might have to go through in his mode of obtaining it.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE OF OMNIUM 141
Page No 145
'Who is that funny little man sitting there, next but one to Mr de Courcy? I never saw such a queer fellow in
my life.'
'Don't you know old Bolus? Well, I thought every one in Barsetshire knew Bolus; you especially should do
so, as he is such a dear friend of Dr Thorne.'
'A dear friend of Dr Thorne?'
'Yes; he was apothecary at Scarington in the old days, before Dr Fillgrave came into vogue. I remember when
Bolus was thought to be a very good sort of doctor.'
'Is heis he' whispered Frank, 'is he by way of a gentleman?'
'Ha! ha! ha! Well, I suppose we must be charitable, and say that he is quite as good, at any rate, as many
others there are here' and Mr Athill, as he spoke, whispered into Frank's ear, 'You see there's Finnie here,
another Barchester attorney. Now, I really think where Finnie goes, Bolus may go too.'
'The more the merrier, I suppose,' said Frank.
'Well, something a little like that. I wonder why Thorne is not here? I'm sure he was asked.'
'Perhaps he did not particularly wish to meet Finnie and Bolus. Do you know, Mr Athill, I think he was quite
right not to come. As for myself, I wish I was anywhere else.'
'Ha! ha! ha! You don't know the duke's ways yet; and what's more, you're young, you happy fellow! But
Thorne should have more sense; he ought to show himself here.'
The gormandizing was now going on at a tremendous rate. Though the volubility of their tongues had been
for a while stopped by the first shock of the duke's presence, the guests seemed to feel no such constraint
upon their teeth. They fed, one may almost say, rabidly, and gave their orders to the servants in an eager
manner; much more impressive than that usual at smaller parties. Mr Apjohn, who sat immediately opposite
to Frank, had, by some wellplanned manoeuvre, contrived to get before him the jowl of a salmon; but,
unfortunately, he was not for a while equally successful in the article of sauce. A very limited portionso at
least thought Mr Apjohnhad been put on his plate; and a servant, with a huge sauce tureen, absolutely
passed behind his back inattentive to his audible requests. Poor Mr Apjohn in his despair turned round to
arrest the man by his coattails; but he was a moment too late, and all but fell backwards on the floor. As he
righted himself he muttered an anathema, and looked with a face of anguish at his plate.
'Anything the matter, Apjohn?' said Mr Fothergill, kindly, seeing the utter despair written on the poor man's
countenance; 'can I get anything for you?'
'The sauce!' said Mr Apjohn, in a voice that would have melted a hermit; and as he looked at Mr Fothergill,
he point at the now distant sinner, who was dispensing his melted ambrosia at least ten heads upwards, away
from the unfortunate supplicant.
Mr Fothergill, however, knew where to look for balm for such wounds, and in a minute or two, Mr Apjohn
was employed quite to his heart's content.
'Well,' said Frank to his neighbour, 'it may be very well once in a way; but I think that on the whole Dr
Thorne is right.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE OF OMNIUM 142
Page No 146
'My dear Mr Gresham, see the world on all sides,' said Mr Athill, who had also been somewhat intent on the
gratification of his own appetite, though with an energy less evident than that of the gentleman opposite. 'See
the world on all sides if you have an opportunity; and, believe me, a good dinner now and then is a very good
thing.'
'Yes; but I don't like eating with hogs.'
'Whishh! softly, softly, Mr Gresham, or you'll disturb Mr Apjohn's digestion. Upon my word, he'll want it
all before he has done. Now, I like this kind of thing once in a way.'
'Do you?' said Frank, in a tone that was almost savage.
'Yes; indeed I do. One sees so much character. And after all, what harm does it do?'
'My idea is that people should live with those whose society is pleasant to them.'
'Liveyes, Mr GreshamI agree with you there. It wouldn't do for me to live with the Duke of Omnium; I
shouldn't understand, or probably approve, his ways. Nor should I, perhaps, much like the constant presence
of Mr Apjohn. But now and thenonce in a year or soI do own I like to see them both. Here's the cup;
now, whatever you do, Mr Gresham, don't pass the cup without tasting it.'
And so the dinner passed on, slowly enough as Frank thought, but all too quickly for Mr Apjohn. It passed
away, and the wine came circulating freely. The tongues again were loosed, the teeth being released from
their labours, and under the influence of the claret the duke's presence was forgotten.
But very speedily the coffee was brought. 'This will soon be over now,' said Frank, to himself, thankfully; for,
though he be no means despised good claret, he had lost his temper too completely to enjoy it at the present
moment. But he was much mistaken; the farce as yet was only at its commencement. The duke took his cup
of coffee, and so did the few friends who sat close to him; but the beverage did not seem to be in great
request with the majority of the guests. When the duke had taken his modicum, he rose up and silently
retired, saying no word and making no sign. And then the farce commenced.
'Now, gentlemen,' said Mr Fothergill, cheerily, 'we are all right. Apjohn, is there claret there? Mr Bolus, I
know you stick to the Madeira; you are quite right, for there isn't too much of it left, and my belief is there'll
never be more like it.'
And so the duke's hospitality went on, and the duke's guests drank merrily for the next two hours.
'Shan't we see any more of him?' asked Frank.
'Any more of whom?' said Mr Athill.
'Of the duke?'
'Oh, no; you'll see no more of him. He always goes when the coffee comes. It's brought in as an excuse.
We've had enough of the light of his countenance to last till next year. The duke and I are excellent friends;
and have been so these fifteen years; but I never see more of him than that.'
'I shall go away,' said Frank.
'Nonsense. Mr de Courcy and your other friend won't stir for this hour yet.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE OF OMNIUM 143
Page No 147
'I don't care. I shall walk on, and they may catch me. I may be wrong; but it seems to me that a man insults
me when he asks me to dine with him and never speaks to me. I don't care if he be ten times Duke of
Omnium; he can't be more than a gentleman, and as such I am his equal.' And then, having thus given vent to
his feelings in somewhat highflown language, he walked forth and trudged away along the road towards
Courcy.
Frank Gresham had been born and bred a Conservative, whereas the Duke of Omnium was well known as a
consistent Whig. There is no one so devoutly resolved to admit of no superior as your Conservative, born and
bred, no one so inclined to high domestic despotism as your thoroughgoing consistent old Whig.
When he had proceeded about six miles, Frank was picked up by his friends; but even then his anger had
hardly cooled.
'Was the duke as civil as ever when you took your leave of him?' said he to his cousin George, as he took his
seat on the drag.
'The juke was jeuced jude winelem me tell you that, old fella,' hiccupped out the Honourable George, as he
touched up the leader under the flank.
CHAPTER XX. THE PROPOSAL
And now the departure from Courcy Castle came rapidly one after the other, and there remained but one more
evening before Miss Dunstable's carriage was to be packed. The countess, in the early moments of Frank's
courtship, had controlled his ardour and checked the rapidity of his amorous professions; but as days, and at
last weeks, wore away, she found that it was necessary to stir the fire which she had before endeavoured to
slacken.
'There will be nobody here tonight but our own circle,' said she to him, 'and I really think you should tell
Miss Dunstable what your intentions are. She will have fair ground to complain of you if you don't.'
Frank began to feel that he was in a dilemma. He had commenced making love to Miss Dunstable partly
because he liked the amusement, and partly from a satirical propensity to quiz his aunt by appearing to fall
into her scheme. But he had overshot the mark, and did not know what answer to give when he was thus
called upon to make a downright proposal. And then, although he did not care two rushes about Miss
Dunstable in the way of love, he nevertheless experienced a sort of jealousy when he found that she appeared
to be indifferent to him, and that she corresponded the meanwhile with his cousin George. Though all their
flirtations had been carried on on both sides palpably by way of fun, though Frank had told himself ten times
a day that his heart was true to Mary Thorne, yet he had an undefined feeling that it behoved Miss Dunstable
to be a little in love with him. He was not quite at ease in that she was not a little melancholy now that his
departure was so nigh; and, above all, he was anxious to know what were the real facts about that letter. He
had in his own breast threatened Miss Dunstable with a heartache; and now, when the time for their
separation came, he found that his own heart was the more likely to ache of the two.
'I suppose I must say something to her, or my aunt will never be satisfied,' said he to himself as he sauntered
into the little drawingroom on that last evening. But at the very time he was ashamed of himself, for he
knew he was going to ask badly.
His sister and one of his cousins were in the room, but his aunt, who was quite on the alert, soon got them out
of it, and Frank and Miss Dunstable were alone.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XX. THE PROPOSAL 144
Page No 148
'So all our fun and all our laughter is come to an end,' said she, beginning the conversation. 'I don't know how
you feel, but for myself I really am a little melancholy at the idea of parting;' and she looked up at him with
her laughing black eyes, as though she never had, and never could have a care in the world.
'Melancholy! oh, yes; you look so,' said Frank, who really did feel somewhat lackadaisically sentimental.
'But how thoroughly glad the countess must be that we are both going,' continued she. 'I declare we have
treated her most infamously. Ever since we've been here we've had the amusement to ourselves. I've
sometimes thought she would turn me out of the house.'
'I wish with all my heart she had.'
'Oh, you cruel barbarian! why on earth should you wish that?'
'That I might have joined you in your exile. I hate Courcy Castle, and should have rejoiced to
leaveandand'
'And what?'
'And I love Miss Dunstable, and should have doubly, trebly rejoiced to leave it with her.'
Frank's voice quivered a little as he made this gallant profession; but still Miss Dunstable only laughed the
louder. 'Upon my word, of all my knights you are by far the best behaved,' said she, 'and say much the
prettiest things.' Frank became rather red in the face, and felt that he did so. Miss Dunstable was treating him
like a boy. While she pretended to be so fond of him she was only laughing at him, and corresponding the
while with his cousin George. Now Frank Gresham already entertained a sort of contempt for his cousin,
which increased the bitterness of his feelings. Could it really be possible that George had succeeded while he
had utterly failed; that his stupid cousin had touched the heart of the heiress while she was playing with him
as with a boy?
'Of all your knights! Is that the way you talk to me when we are going to part? When was it, Miss Dunstable,
that George de Courcy became one of them?'
Miss Dunstable for a while looked serious enough. 'What makes you ask that?' said she. 'What makes you
inquire about Mr de Courcy?'
'Oh, I have eyes, you know, and can't help seeing. Not that I see, or have seen anything that I could possibly
help.'
'And what have you seen, Mr Gresham?'
'Why, I know you have been writing to him.'
'Did he tell you so?'
'No; he did not tell me; but I know it.'
For a moment she sat silent, and then her face again resumed its usual happy smile. 'Come, Mr Gresham, you
are not going to quarrel with me, I hope, even if I did write a letter to your cousin. Why should I not write to
him? I correspond with all manner of people. I'll write to you some of these days if you'll let me, and will
promise to answer my letters.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XX. THE PROPOSAL 145
Page No 149
Frank threw himself back on the sofa on which he was sitting, and, in doing so, brought himself somewhat
nearer to his companion than he had been; he then drew his hand slowly across his forehead, pushing back his
thick hair, and as he did so he sighed somewhat plaintively.
'I do not care,' said he, 'for the privilege of correspondence on such terms. If my cousin George is to be a
correspondent of yours also, I will give up my claim.'
And then he sighed again, so that it was piteous to hear him. He was certainly an arrant puppy, and an
egregious ass into the bargain; but then, it must be remembered in his favour that he was only twentyone,
and that much had been done to spoil him. Miss Dunstable did remember this, and therefore abstained from
laughing at him.
'Why, Mr Gresham, what on earth do you mean? In all human probability I shall never write another line to
Mr de Courcy; but, if I did, what possible harm could it do you?'
'Oh, Miss Dunstable! you do not in the least understand what my feelings are.'
'Don't I? Then I hope I never shall. I thought I did. I thought they were the feelings of a good, truehearted
friend; feelings that I could sometimes look back upon with pleasure as being honest when so much that one
meets is false. I have become very fond of you, Mr Gresham, and I should be sorry to think that I did not
understand your feelings.'
This was almost worse and worse. Young ladies like Miss Dunstablefor she was still to be numbered in the
category of young ladiesdo not usually tell young gentlemen that they are very fond of them. To boys and
girls they may make such a declaration. Now Frank Gresham regarded himself as one who had already fought
his battles, and fought them not without glory; he could not therefore endure to be thus openly told by Miss
Dunstable that she was very fond of him.
'Fond of me, Miss Dunstable! I wish you were.'
'So I amvery.'
'You little know how fond I am of you, Miss Dunstable,' and he put out his hand to take hold of hers. She
then lifted up her own, and slapped him lightly on the knuckles.
'And what can you have to say to say to Miss Dunstable that can make it necessary that you should pinch her
hand? I tell you fairly, Mr Gresham, if you make a fool of yourself, I shall come to a conclusion that you are
all fools, and that it is hopeless to look out for any one worth caring for.'
Such advice as this, so kindly given, so wisely meant, so clearly intelligible he should have taken and
understood, young as he was. but even yet he did not do so.
'A fool of myself! Yes; I suppose I must be a fool if I have so much regard for Miss Dunstable as to make it
painful for me to know that I am to see her no more: a fool: yes, of course I am a foola man is always a
fool when he loves.'
Miss Dunstable could not pretend to doubt his meaning any longer; and was determined to stop him, let it
cost what it would. She now put out her hand, not over white, and, as Frank soon perceived, gifted with a
very fair allowance of strength.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XX. THE PROPOSAL 146
Page No 150
'Now, Mr Gresham,' said she, 'before you go any further you shall listen to me. Will you listen to me for a
moment without interrupting me?'
Frank was of course obliged to promise that he would do so.
'You are goingor rather you were going, for I shall stop youto make a profession of love.'
'A profession!' said Frank making a slight unsuccessful effort to get his hand free.
'Yes; a professiona false profession, Mr Gresham,a false profession a false profession. Look into
your heartinto your heart of hearts. I know you at any rate have a heart; look into it closely. Mr Gresham,
you know you do not love me; not as a man should love the woman he swears to love.'
Frank was taken aback. So appealed to he found that he could not any longer say that he did love her. He
could only look into her face with all his eyes, and sit there listening to her.
'How is it possible that you should love me? I am Heaven knows how many years your senior. I am neither
young nor beautiful, nor have I been brought up as she should be whom you in time will really love and make
your wife. I have nothing that should make you love me; butbut I am rich.'
'It is not that,' said Frank, stoutly, feeling himself imperatively called upon to utter something in his own
defence.
'Ah, Mr Gresham, I fear it is that. For what other reason can you have laid your plans to talk in this way to
such a woman as I am?'
'I have laid no plans,' said Frank, now getting his hand to himself. 'At any rate, you wrong me there, Miss
Dunstable.'
'I like you so wellnay, love you, if a woman may talk of love in the way of friendshipthat if money,
money alone would make you happy, you should have it heaped on you. If you want it, Mr Gresham, you
shall have it.'
'I have never thought of your money,' said Frank, surlily.
'But it grieves me,' continued she, 'it does grieve me, to think that you, you, youso young and gay, so
brightthat you should have looked for it in this way. From others I have taken it just as the wind that
whistles;' and now two big slow tears escaped from her eyes, and would have rolled down her rosy cheeks
were it not that she brushed them off with the back of her hand.
'You have utterly mistaken me, Miss Dunstable,' said Frank.
'If I have, I will humbly beg your pardon,' said she, 'butbutbut'
Frank had nothing further to say in his own defence. He had not wanted Miss Dunstable's moneythat was
true; but he could not deny that he had been about to talk that absolute nonsense of which she spoke with so
much scorn.
'You would almost make me think that there are none honest in this fashionable world of yours. I well know
why Lady de Courcy has had me here: how could I help knowing it? She has been so foolish in her plans that
ten times a day she has told me her own secret. But I have said to myself twenty times, that if she were crafty,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XX. THE PROPOSAL 147
Page No 151
you were honest.'
'And am I dishonest?'
'I have laughed in my sleeve to see how she played her game, and to hear others around playing theirs; all of
them thinking that they could get the money of the poor fool who had come at their beck and call; but I was
able to laugh at them as long as I thought that I had one true friend to laugh with me. But one cannot laugh
with all the world against one.'
'I am not against you, Miss Dunstable.'
'Sell yourself for money! why, if I were a man I would not sell one jot of liberty for mountains of gold. What!
tie myself in the heyday of my youth to a person I could never love, for a price! perjure myself, destroy
myselfand not only myself, but her also, in order that I might live idly! Oh, heavens! Mr Gresham! can it
be that the words of such a woman as your aunt have sunk so deeply in your heart; have blackened you so
foully as this? Have you forgotten your soul, your spirit, your man's energy, the treasure of your heart? And
you, so young! For shame, Mr Gresham! for shamefor shame.'
Frank found the task before him by no means an easy one. He had to make Miss Dunstable understand that he
had never had the slightest idea of marrying her, and that he had made love to her merely with the object of
keeping his hand in for the work as it were; with that object, and the other equally laudable one of interfering
with his cousin George.
And yet there was nothing for him but to get through this task as best he might. He was goaded to it by the
accusations which Miss Dunstable brought against him; and he began to feel, that though her invective
against him might be bitter when he had told the truth, they could not be so bitter as those she now kept
hinting at under her mistaken impression as to his views. He had never had any strong propensity for
moneyhunting; but now that offence appeared in his eyes abominable, unmanly, and disgusting. Any
imputation would be better than that.
'Miss Dunstable, I never for a moment thought of doing what you accuse me of; on my honour, I never did. I
have been very foolishvery wrongidiotic, I believe; but I have never intended that.'
'Then, Mr Gresham, what did you intend?'
This was rather a difficult question to answer; and Frank was not very quick in attempting it. 'I know you will
not forgive me,' he said at last; 'and, indeed, I do not see how you can. I don't know how it came about; but
this is certain, Miss Dunstable; I have never for a moment thought about your fortune; that is, thought about it
in the way of coveting it.'
'You never thought of making me your wife, then?'
'Never,' said Frank, looking boldly into her face.
'You never intended really to propose to go with me to the altar, and then make yourself rich by one great
perjury?'
'Never for a moment,' said he.
'You have never gloated over me as the bird of prey gloats over the poor beast that is soon to become carrion
beneath its claws? You have not counted me out as equal to so much land, and calculated on me as a balance
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XX. THE PROPOSAL 148
Page No 152
at your banker's? Ah, Mr Gresham,' she continued, seeing that he stared as though struck almost with awe by
her strong language; 'you little guess what a woman situated as I am has to suffer.'
'I have behaved badly to you, Miss Dunstable, and I beg your pardon; but I have never thought of your
money.'
'Then we will be friends again, Mr Gresham, won't we? It is so nice to have a friend like you. There, I think I
understand it now; you need not tell me.'
'It was half by way of making a fool of my aunt,' said Frank, in an apologetic tone.
'There is merit in that, at any rate,' said Miss Dunstable. 'I understand it all now; you thought to make a fool
of me in real earnest. Well, I can forgive that; at any rate it is not mean.'
It may be, that Miss Dunstable did not feel much acute anger at finding that this young man had addressed
her with words of love in the course of an ordinary flirtation, although that flirtation had been unmeaning and
silly. This was not the offence against which her heart and breast had found peculiar cause to arm itself; this
was not the injury from which she had hitherto experienced suffering.
At any rate, she and Frank again became friends, and, before the evening was over, they perfectly understood
each other. Twice during this long teteatete Lady de Courcy came into the room to see how things were
going on, and twice she went out almost unnoticed. It was quite clear to her that something uncommon had
taken place, was taking place, or would take place; and that should this be for weal or for woe, no good could
not come from her interference. On each occasion, therefore, she smiled sweetly on the pair of turtledoves,
and glided out of the room as quietly as she had glided into it.
But at last it became necessary to remove them; for the world had gone to bed. Frank, in the meantime, had
told to Miss Dunstable all his love for Mary Thorne, and Miss Dunstable had enjoined him to be true to his
vows. To her eyes there was something of heavenly beauty in young, true loveof beauty that was heavenly
because it had been unknown to her.
'Mind you let me hear, Mr Gresham,' said she. 'Mind you do; and, Mr Gresham, never, never forget her for
one moment; not for one moment, Mr Gresham.'
Frank was about to swear that he never wouldagain, when the countess, for the third time, sailed into the
room.
'Young people,' said she, 'do you know what o'clock it is?'
'Dear me, Lady de Courcy, I declare it is past twelve; I really am ashamed of myself. How glad you will be to
get rid of me tomorrow!'
'No, no, indeed we shan't; shall we, Frank?' and so Miss Dunstable passed out.
Then once again the aunt tapped her nephew with her fan. It was the last time in her life that she did so. He
looked up in her face, and his look was enough to tell her that the acres of Greshamsbury were not to be
reclaimed by the ointment of Lebanon.
Nothing further on the subject was said. On the following morning Miss Dunstable took her departure, not
much heeding the rather cold words of farewell which her hostess gave her; and on the following day Frank
started for Greshamsbury.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XX. THE PROPOSAL 149
Page No 153
CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE
We will now, with the reader's kind permission, skip over some months in our narrative. Frank returned from
Courcy Castle to Greshamsbury, and having communicated to his mothermuch in the same manner as he
had to the countessthe fact that his mission had been unsuccessful, he went up after a day or two to
Cambridge. During his short stay at Greshamsbury he did not even catch a glimpse of Mary. He asked for
her, of course, and was told that it was not likely that she would be at the house just at present. He called at
the doctor's, but she was denied to him there; 'she was out,' Janet said,'probably with Miss Oriel.' He went
to the parsonage and found Miss Oriel at home; but Mary had not been seen that morning. He then returned to
the house; and, having come to the conclusion that she had not thus vanished into air, otherwise than by
preconcerted arrangement, he boldly taxed Beatrice on the subject.
Beatrice looked very demure; declared that no one in the house had quarrelled with Mary; confessed that it
had been thought prudent that she should for a while stay away from Greshamsbury; and, of course, ended by
telling her brother everything, including all the scenes that had passed between Mary and herself.
'It is out of the question your thinking of marrying her, Frank,' said she. 'You must know that nobody feels it
more strongly than poor Mary herself;' and Beatrice looked the very personification of domestic prudence.
'I know nothing of the kind,' said he, with the headlong imperative air that was usual with him in discussing
matters with his sisters. 'I know nothing of the kind. Of course I cannot say what Mary's feelings may be: a
pretty life she must have had of it among you. But you may be sure of this, Beatrice, and so may my mother,
that nothing on earth shall make me give her upnothing.' And Frank, as he made this protestation,
strengthened his own resolution by thinking of all the counsel that Miss Dunstable had given him.
The brother and sister could hardly agree, as Beatrice was dead against the match. Not that she would not
have liked Mary Thorne for a sisterinlaw, but that she shared to a certain degree the feeling which was
now common to all the Greshamsthat Frank must marry money. It seemed, at any rate, to be imperative
that he should either do that or not marry at all. Poor Beatrice was not very mercenary in her views: she had
no wish to sacrifice her brother to any Miss Dunstable; but yet she felt, as they all feltMary Thorne
includedthat such as a match as that, of the young heir with the doctor's niece, was not to be thought
of;not to be spoken of as a thing that was in any way possible. Therefore, Beatrice, though she was Mary's
great friend, though she was her brother's favourite sister, could give Frank no encouragement. Poor Frank!
circumstances had made but one bride possible to him: he must marry money.
His mother said nothing to him on the subject: when she learnt that the affair with Miss Dunstable was not to
come off, she merely remarked that it would perhaps be best for him to return to Cambridge as soon as
possible. Had she spoken her mind out, she would probably have also advised him to remain there as long as
possible. The countess had not omitted to write to her when Frank had left Courcy Castle; and the countess's
letter certainly made the anxious mother think that her son's education had hardly yet been completed. With
this secondary object, but with that of keeping him out of the way of Mary Thorne in the first place, Lady
Arabella was now quite satisfied that her son should enjoy such advantages as an education completed at the
university might give him.
With his father Frank had a long conversation; but, alas! the gist of his father's conversation was this, that it
behoved him, Frank, to marry money. The father, however, did not put it to him in the cold, callous way in
which his ladyaunt had done, and his ladymother. He did not bid him go and sell himself to the first female
he could find possessed of wealth. It was with inward selfreproaches, and true grief of spirit, that the father
told the son that it was not possible for him to do as those who may do who are born really rich, or really
poor.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE 150
Page No 154
'If you marry a girl without a fortune, Frank, how are you to live?' the father asked, after having confessed
how deep he himself had injured his own heir.
'I don't care about money, sir,' said Frank. 'I shall be just as happy if Boxall Hill had never been sold. I don't
care a straw about that sort of thing.'
'Ah! my boy; but you will care: you will soon find that you do care.'
'Let me go into some profession. Let me go to the Bar. I am sure I could earn my own living. Earn it! of
course I could, why not I as well as others? I should like of all things to be a barrister.'
There was much more of the same kind, in which Frank said all that he could think of to lessen his father's
regrets. In their conversation not a word was spoken about Mary Thorne. Frank was not aware whether or no
his father had been told of the great family danger which was dreaded in that quarter. That he had been told,
we may surmise, as Lady Arabella was not wont to confine the family dangers to her own bosom. Moreover,
Mary's presence had, of course, been missed. The truth was, that the squire had been told, with great
bitterness, of what had come to pass, and all the evil had been laid at his door. He it had been who hand
encouraged Mary to be regarded almost as a daughter of the house of Greshamsbury: he it was who taught
that odious doctorodious on all but his aptitude for good doctoringto think himself a fit match for the
aristocracy of the county. It had been his fault, this great necessity that Frank should marry money; and now
it was his fault that Frank was absolutely talking of marrying a pauper.
By no means in quiescence did the squire hear these charges brought against him. The Lady Arabella, in each
attack, got quite as much as she gave, and, at last, was driven to retreat in a state of headache, which she
declared to be chronic; and which, so she assured her daughter Augusta, must prevent her from having any
more lengthened conversations with her lordat any rate for the next three months. But though the squire
may be said to have come off on the whole as the victor in these combats, they did not perhaps have, on that
account, the less effect upon him. He knew it was true that he had done much towards ruining his son; and he
also could think of no other remedy than matrimony. It was Frank's doom, pronounced even by the voice of
his father, that he must marry money.
And so, Frank went off again to Cambridge, feeling himself, as he went, to be a much lesser man in
Greshamsbury estimation than he had been some two months earlier, when his birthday had been celebrated.
Once during his short stay at Greshamsbury he had seen the doctor; but the meeting had been anything but
pleasant. He had been afraid to ask after Mary; and the doctor had been too diffident of himself to speak of
her. They had met casually on the road, and, though each in his heart loved the other, the meeting had been
anything but pleasant.
And so Frank went to Cambridge; and, as he did so, he stoutly resolved that nothing should make him untrue
to Mary Thorne. 'Beatrice,' said he, on the morning he went away, when she came into his room to
superintend his packing'Beatrice, if she ever talks about me'
'Oh, Frank, my darling Frank, don't think of itit is madness; she knows it is madness.'
'Never mind; if she ever talks about me, tell her that the last word I said was, that I would never forget her.
She can do as she likes.'
Beatrice made no promise, never hinted that she would give the message; but it may be taken for granted that
she had not been long in company with Mary Thorne before she did give it.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE 151
Page No 155
And then there were other troubles at Greshamsbury. It had been decided that Augusta's marriage was to take
place in September; but Mr Moffat had, unfortunately, been obliged to postpone the happy day. He himself
had told Augustanot, of course, without protestations as to his regretand had written to this effect to Mr
Gresham, 'Electioneering matters, and other troubles had,' he said, 'made this peculiarly painful postponement
absolutely necessary.'
Augusta seemed to bear her misfortune with more equanimity than is, we believe, usual with young ladies
under such circumstances. She spoke of it to her mother in a very matteroffact way, and seemed almost
contented at the idea of remaining at Greshamsbury till February; which was the time now named for the
marriage. But Lady Arabella was not equally well satisfied, nor was the squire.
'I half believe that fellow is not honest,' he had once said out loud before Frank, and this set Frank athinking
of what dishonesty in the matter it was probable that Mr Moffat might be guilty, and what would be the
fitting punishment for such a crime. Nor did he think on the subject in vain; especially after a conference on
the matter which he had with his friend Harry Baker. This conference took place during the Christmas
vacation.
It should be mentioned, that the time spent by Frank at Courcy Castle had not done much to assist him in his
views as to an early degree, and that it had at last been settled that he should stay up at Cambridge another
year. When he came home at Christmas he found that the house was not peculiarly lively. Mary was absent
on a visit with Miss Oriel. Both these young ladies were staying with Miss Oriel's aunt, in the neighbourhood
of London; and Frank soon learnt that there was no chance that either of them would be home before his
return. No message had been left for him by Marynone at least had been left with Beatrice; and he began
in his heart to accuse her of coldness and perfidy;not, certainly, with much justice, seeing that she had
never given him the slightest encouragement.
The absence of Patience Oriel added to the dullness of the place. It was certainly hard upon Frank that all the
attraction of the village should be removed to make way and prepare for his returnharder, perhaps, on
them; for, to tell the truth, Miss Oriel's visit had been entirely planned to enable her to give Mary a
comfortable way of leaving Greshamsbury during the time that Frank should remain at home. Frank thought
himself cruelly used. But what did Mr Oriel think when doomed to eat his Christmas pudding alone, because
the young squire would be unreasonable in his love? What did the doctor think, as he sat solitary by his
deserted hearththe doctor, who no longer permitted himself to enjoy the comforts of the Greshamsbury
diningtable? Frank hinted and grumbled; talked to Beatrice of the determined constancy of his love, and
occasionally consoled himself by a stray smile from some of the neighbouring belles. The black horse was
made perfect; the old grey pony was by no means discarded; and much that was satisfactory was done in the
sporting line. But still the house was dull, and Frank felt that he was the cause of its being so. Of the doctor
he saw but little: he never came to Greshamsbury, unless to see Lady Arabella as doctor, or to be closeted
with the squire. There were no special evenings with him; no animated confabulations at the doctor's house;
no discourses between them, as there was wont to be, about the merits of the different covers, and the
capacities of the different hounds. These were dull days on the whole for Frank; and sad enough, we may say,
for our friend the doctor.
In February Frank again went back to college; having settled with Harry Baker certain affairs which weighed
on his mind. He went back to Cambridge, promising to be home on the twentieth of the month, so as to be
present at his sister's wedding. A cold and chilling time had been named for these hymeneal joys, but one not
altogether unsuited to the feelings of the happy pair. February is certainly not a warm month; but with the
rich it is generally a cosy, comfortable time. Good fires, winter cheer, groaning tables, and warm blankets,
make a fictitious summer, which, to some tastes, is more delightful than the long days and the hot sun. And
some marriages are especially winter matches. They depend for their charm on the same substantial
attractions: instead of heart beating to heart in sympathetic unison, purse chinks to purse. The rich new
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE 152
Page No 156
furniture of the new abode is looked to instead of the rapture of a pure embrace. The new carriage is
depended on rather than the new heart's companion; and the first bright gloss, prepared by the upholsterer's
hands, stands in lieu of the rosy tints which young love lends to his true votaries.
Mr Moffat had not spent his Christmas at Greshamsbury. That eternal election petition, those eternal lawyers,
the eternal care of his wellmanaged wealth, forbade him the enjoyment of any such pleasures. He could not
come to Greshamsbury for Christmas, nor yet for the festivities of the new year; but now and then he wrote
prettily worded notes, sending occasionally a silvergilt pencilcase, or a small brooch, and informed Lady
Arabella that he looked forward to the twentieth of February with great satisfaction. But, in the meanwhile,
the squire became anxious, and at last went up to London; and Frank, who was at Cambridge, bought the
heaviestcutting whip to be found in that town, and wrote a confidential letter to Harry Baker.
Poor Mr Moffat! It is well known that none but the brave deserve the fair; but thou, without much excuse for
bravery, had secured for thyself one who, at any rate, was fair enough for thee. Would it not have been well
hadst thou looked to thyself to see what real bravery might be in thee, before thou hadst prepared to desert
this fair one thou hadst already won? That last achievement, one may say, did require some special courage.
Poor Mr Moffat! It is wonderful that as he sat in that gig, going to Gatherum Castle, planning how he would
be off with Miss Gresham and afterwards on with Miss Dunstable, it is wonderful that he should not then
have cast his eye behind him, and looked at that stalwart pair of shoulders which were so close to his own
back. As he afterwards pondered on his scheme while sipping the duke's claret, it is odd that he should not
have observed the fiery pride of purpose and power of wrath which was so plainly written on that young
man's brow: or, when he matured, and finished, and carried out his purpose, that he did not think of that keen
grasp which had already squeezed his own hand with somewhat too warm a vigour, even in the way of
friendship.
Poor Mr Moffat! it is probable that he forgot to think of Frank at all as connected with his promised bride; it
is probable that he looked forward only to the squire's violence and the enmity of the house of Courcy; and
that he found from enquiry at his heart's pulses, that he was man enough to meet these. Could he have
guessed what a whip Frank Gresham would have bought at Cambridgecould he have divined what a letter
would have been written to Harry Bakerit is probable, nay, we think we may say certain, that Miss
Gresham would have become Mrs Moffat.
Miss Gresham, however, never did become Mrs Moffat. About two days after Frank's departure for
Cambridgeit is just possible that Mr Moffat was so prudent as to make himself aware of the factbut just
two days after Frank's departure, a very long, elaborate, and clearly explanatory letter was received at
Greshamsbury. Mr Moffat was quite sure that Miss Gresham and her very excellent parents would do him the
justice to believe that he was not actuated, The long and the short of this was, that Mr Moffat signified his
intention of breaking off the match without offering any intelligible reason.
Augusta again bore her disappointment well: not, indeed, without sorrow and heartache, and inward, hidden
tears; but still well. She neither raved, nor fainted, nor walked about by moonlight alone. She wrote no
poetry, and never once thought of suicide. When, indeed, she remembered the rosytinted lining, the
unfathomable softness of that Longacre carriage, her spirit did for one moment give way; but, on the whole,
she bore it as a strongminded woman and a De Courcy should do.
But both Lady Arabella and the squire were greatly vexed. The former had made the match, and the latter,
having consented to it, had incurred deeper responsibilities to enable him to bring it about. The money which
was to have been given to Mr Moffat was still to the fore; but alas! how much, how much that he could ill
spare, had been thrown away in bridal preparations! It is, moreover, an unpleasant thing for a gentleman to
have his daughter jilted; perhaps peculiarly so to have her jilted by a tailor's son.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE 153
Page No 157
Lady Arabella's woe was really piteous. It seemed to her as though cruel fate were heaping misery after
misery upon the wretched house of Greshamsbury. A few weeks since things were going so well with her!
Frank then was still all but the accepted husband of almost untold wealthso, at least, she was informed by
her sisterinlawwhereas, Augusta, was the accepted wife of wealth, not indeed untold, but of dimensions
quite sufficiently respectable to cause much joy in the telling. Where now were her golden hopes? Where
now the splendid future of her poor duped children? Augusta was left to pine alone; and Frank, in a still
worse plight, insisted on maintaining his love for a bastard and a pauper.
For Frank's affairs she had received some poor consolation by laying all the blame on the squire's shoulders.
What she had then said was now repaid to her with interest; for not only had she been the maker of Augusta's
match, but she had boasted of the deed with all a mother's pride.
It was from Beatrice that Frank had obtained his tidings. This last resolve on the part of Mr Moffat had not
altogether been unsuspected by some of the Greshams, though altogether unsuspected by the Lady Arabella.
Frank had spoken of it as a possibility to Beatrice, and was not quite unprepared when the information
reached him. He consequently bought his cuttingwhip, and wrote his confidential letter to Harry Baker.
On the following day Frank and Harry might have been seen, with their heads nearly close together, leaning
over one of the tables in the large breakfastroom at the Tavistock Hotel in Covent Garden. The ominous
whip, to the handle of which Frank had already made his hand well accustomed, was lying on the table
between them; and ever and anon Harry Baker would take it up and feel its weight approvingly. Oh, Mr
Moffat! poor Mr Moffat! go not out into the fashionable world today; above all, go not to that club of thine
in Pall Mall; but, oh! especially go not there, as is thy wont to do, at three o'clock in the afternoon!
With much care did those two young generals lay their plans of attack. Let it not for a moment be thought
that it was ever in the minds of either of them that two men should attack one. But it was thought that Mr
Moffat might be rather coy in coming out from his seclusion to meet the proffered hand of his once intended
brotherinlaw when he should see that hand armed with a heavy whip. Baker, therefore, was content to act
as a decoy duck, and remarked that he might no doubt make himself useful in restraining the public mercy,
and, probably, in controlling the interference of policemen.
'It will be deuced hard if I can't get five or six shies at him,' said Frank, again clutching his weapon almost
spasmodically. Oh, Mr Moffat! five or six shies with such a whip, and such an arm! For myself, I would
sooner join the second Balaclava gallop than encounter it.
At ten minutes before four these two heroes might be seen walking up Pall Mall, towards the Club.
Young Baker walked with an eager disengaged air. Mr Moffat did not know his appearance; he had,
therefore, no anxiety to pass along unnoticed. But Frank had in some mysterious way drawn his hat very far
over his forehead, and had buttoned his shootingcoat up round his chin. Harry had recommended to him a
greatcoat, in order that he might the better conceal his face; but Frank had found the greatcoat was an
encumbrance to his arm. He put it on, and when thus clothed he had tried the whip, he found that he cut the
air with much less potency than in the lighter garment. He contented himself, therefore, with looking down
on the pavement as he walked along, letting the long point of the whip stick up from his pocket, and flattering
himself that even Mr Moffat would not recognise him at the first glance. Poor Mr Moffat! If he had but had
the chance!
And now, having arrived at the front of the club, the two friends for a moment separate: Frank remains
standing on the pavement, under the shade of the high stone arearailing, while Harry jauntily skips up three
steps at a time, and with a very civil word of inquiry of the hall porter, sends his card to Mr Moffat
'MR HARRY BAKER'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE 154
Page No 158
Mr Moffat, never having heard of such a gentleman in his life, unwittingly comes out into the hall, and Harry,
with the sweetest smile, addresses him.
Now the plan of the campaign had been settled in this wise: Baker was to send into the club for Mr Moffat,
and invite that gentleman down into the street. It was probable that the invitation might be declined; and it
had been calculated in such case the two gentlemen would retire for parley into the strangers' room, which
was known to be immediately opposite the hall door. Frank was to keep his eye on the portals, and if he
found that Mr Moffat did not appear as readily as might be desired, he also was to ascend the steps and hurry
into the strangers' room. Then, whether he met Mr Moffat there or elsewhere, or wherever, he might meet
him, he was to greet him with all the friendly vigour in his power, while Harry disposed of the club porters.
But fortune, who ever favours the brave, specially favoured Frank Gresham on this occasion. Just as Harry
Baker had put his card into the servant's hand, Mr Moffat, with his hat on, prepared for the street, appeared in
the hall; Mr Baker addressed him with his sweetest smile, and begged the pleasure of saying a word or two as
they descended into the street. Had not Mr Moffat been going thither it would have been very improbable that
he should have done so at Harry's instance. But, as it was, he merely looked rather solemn at his visitorit
was his wont to look solemnand continued the descent of the steps.
Frank, his heart leaping the while, saw his prey, and retreated two steps behind the arearailing, the dread
weapon already well poised in his hand. Oh! Mr Moffat! Mr Moffat! if there be any goddess to interfere in
thy favour, let her come forward now without delay; let her now bear thee off on a cloud if there be one to
whom thou art sufficiently dear! But there is no such goddess.
Harry smiled blandly till they were well on the pavement, saying some nothing, and keeping the victim's face
averted from the avenging angel; and then, when the raised hand was sufficiently nigh, he withdrew two steps
towards the nearest lamppost. Not for him was the honour of the interview;unless, indeed, succouring
policemen might give occasion for some gleam of glory.
But succouring policemen were no more to be come by than goddesses. Where were ye, men, when that
savage whip fell about the ears of the poor exlegislator? In Scotland Yard, sitting dozing on your benches,
or talking soft nothings to the housemaids round the corner; for ye were not walking on your beats, nor
standing at coign of vantage, to watch the tumults of the day. Had Sir Richard himself been on the spot Frank
Gresham would still, we may say, have had his five shies at that unfortunate one.
When Harry Baker quickly seceded from the way, Mr Moffat at once saw the fate before him. His hair
doubtless stood on end, and his voice refused to give the loud screech with which he sought to invoke the
club. An ashy paleness suffused his cheeks, and his tottering steps were unable to bear him away in flight.
Once, and twice, the cutting whip came well down across his back. Had he been wise enough to stand still
and take his thrashing in that attitude, it would have been well for him. But men so circumstanced have never
such prudence. After two blows he made a dash at the steps, thinking to get back into the club; but Harry,
who had by no means reclined in idleness against the lamppost, here stopped him: 'You had better go back
into the street,' said Harry; 'indeed you had,' giving him a shove from off the second step.
Then of course Frank could do no other than hit him anywhere. When a gentleman is dancing about with
much energy it is hardly possible to strike him fairly on his back. The blows, therefore, came now on his legs
and now on his head; and Frank unfortunately got more than his five or six shies before he was interrupted.
The interruption however came, all too soon for Frank's idea of justice. Though there be no policeman to take
part in a London row, there are always others ready enough to do so; amateur policemen, who generally
sympathize with the wrong side, and, in nine cases out of ten, expend their generous energy in protecting
thieves and pickpockets. When it was seen with what tremendous ardour that dread weapon fell about the
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE 155
Page No 159
ears of the poor undefended gentleman, interference was at last, in spite of Harry Baker's best endeavours,
and loudest protestations.
'Do not interrupt them, sir,' said he; 'pray do not. It is a family affair, and they will neither of them like it.'
In the teeth, however, of these assurances, rude people did interfere, and after some nine or ten shies Frank
found himself encompassed by the arms, and encumbered by the weight of a very stout gentleman, who hung
affectionately about his neck and shoulders; whereas, Mr Moffat was already sitting in a state of syncope on
the goodnatured knees of a fishmonger's apprentice.
Frank was thoroughly out of breath: nothing came from his lips but halfmuttered expletives and
unintelligible denunciations of the iniquity of his foe. But still he struggled to be at him again. We all know
how dangerous is the taste of blood; now cruelly it will become a custom even with the most tenderhearted.
Frank felt that he had hardly fleshed his virgin lash: he thought, almost with despair, that he had not yet at all
succeeded as became a man and a brother; his memory told him of but one or two of the slightest touches that
had gone well home to the offender. He made a desperate effort to throw off that incubus round his neck and
rush again to the combat.
'HarryHarry; don't let him godon't let him go,' he barely articulated.
'Do you want to murder the man, sir; to murder him?' said the stout gentleman over his shoulder, speaking
solemnly into his very ear.
'I don't care,' said Frank, struggling manfully but uselessly. 'Let me out, I say; I don't caredon't let him go,
Harry, whatever you do.'
'He has got it prettily tidily,' said Harry; 'I think that will perhaps do for the present.'
By this time there was a considerable concourse. The club steps were crowded with members; among whom
there were may of Mr Moffat's acquaintance. Policemen now flocked up, and the question arose as to what
should be done with the originators of the affray. Frank and Harry found that they were to consider
themselves under a gentle arrest, and Mr Moffat, in a fainting state, was carried into the interior of the club.
Frank, in his innocence, had intended to have celebrated this little affair when it was over by a light repast
and a bottle of claret with his friend, and then to have gone back to Cambridge by the mail train. He found,
however, that his schemes in this respect were frustrated. He had to get bail to attend at Marlborough Street
policeoffice should he be wanted within the next two or three days; and was given to understand that he
would be under the eye of the police, at any rate until Mr Moffat should be out of danger.
'Out of danger!' said Frank to his friend with a startled look. 'Why I hardly got at him.' Nevertheless, they did
have their slight repast, and also their bottle of claret.
On the second morning after this occurrence, Frank was again sitting in that public room at the Tavistock,
and Harry was again sitting opposite to him. The whip was not now so conspicuously produced between
them, having been carefully packed up and put away among Frank's other travelling properties. They were so
sitting, rather glum, when the door swung open, and a heavy quick step was heard advancing towards them. It
was the squire; whose arrival there had been momentarily expected.
'Frank,' said he'Frank, what on earth is all this?' and as he spoke he stretched out both hands, the right to
his son and the left to his friend.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE 156
Page No 160
'He has given a blackguard a licking, that is all,' said Harry.
Frank felt that his hand was held with a peculiarly warm grasp; and he could not but think that his father's
face, raised though his eyebrows werethough there was on it an intended expression of amazement and,
perhaps, regretnevertheless he could not but think that his father's face looked kindly at him.
'God bless my soul, my dear boy! what have you done to the man?'
'He's not a ha'porth the worse, sir,' said Frank, still holding his father's hand.
'Oh, isn't he!' said Harry, shrugging his shoulders. 'He must be made of some very strong article then.'
'But my dear boys, I hope there's no danger. I hope there's no danger.'
'Danger!' said Frank, who could not yet induce himself to believe that he had been allowed a fair chance with
Mr Moffat.
'Oh, Frank! Frank! how could you be so rash? In the middle of Pall Mall, too. Well! well! well! All the
women down at Greshamsbury will have it that you have killed him.'
'I almost wish I had,' said Frank.
'Oh, Frank! Frank! But now tell me'
And then the father sat well pleased while he heard, chiefly from Harry Baker, the full story of his son's
prowess. And then they did not separate without another slight repast and another bottle of claret.
Mr Moffat retired to the country for a while, and then went abroad; having doubtless learnt that the petition
was not likely to give him a seat for the city of Barchester. And this was the end of the wooing with Miss
Gresham.
CHAPTER XXII. SIR ROGER IS UNSEATED
After this, little occurred at Greshamsbury, or among Greshamsbury people, which it will be necessary for us
to record. Some notice was, of course, taking of Frank's prolonged absence from his college; and tidings,
perhaps exaggerated tidings, of what had happened at Pall Mall were not slow to reach the High Street of
Cambridge. But that affair was gradually hushed up; and Frank went on with his studies.
He went back to his studies: it then being an understood arrangement between him and his father that he
should not return to Greshamsbury till the summer vacation. On this occasion, the squire and Lady Arabella
had, strange to say, been of the same mind. They both wished to keep their son away from Miss Thorne; and
both calculated, that at his age and with his disposition, it was not probable that any passion would last out a
six month absence. 'And when that summer comes it will be an excellent opportunity for us to go abroad,'
said Lady Arabella. 'Poor Augusta will require some change to renovate her spirits.'
To this last proposition the squire did not assent. It was, however, allowed to pass over; and this much was
fixed, that Frank was not to return till midsummer.
It will be remembered that Sir Roger Scatcherd had been elected as sitting member for the city of Barchester;
but it will also be remembered that a petition against his return was threatened. Had the petition depended
solely on Mr Moffat, Sir Roger's seat no doubt would have been saved by Frank Gresham's cutting whip. But
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXII. SIR ROGER IS UNSEATED 157
Page No 161
such was not the case. Mr Moffat had been put forward by the De Courcy interest; and that noble family with
its dependants was not to go to the wall because Mr Moffat had had a thrashing. No; the petition was to go
on; and Mr Nearthewinde declared, that no petition in his hands had half so good a chance of success.
'Chance, no, but certainty,' said Mr Nearthewinde; for Mr Nearthewinde had learnt something with reference
to that honest publican and the payment of his little bill.
The petition was presented and duly backed; the recognisances were signed, and all the proper formalities
formally executed; and Sir Roger found that his seat was in jeopardy. His return had been a great triumph to
him; and, unfortunately, he had celebrated that triumph as he had been in the habit of celebrating most of the
very triumphant occasions of his life. Though he was than hardly yet recovered from the effects of his last
attack, he indulged in another violent drinking bout; and, strange to say, did so without any immediate visible
bad effects.
In February he took his seat amidst the warm congratulations of all men of his own class, and early in the
month of April his case came on for trial. Every kind of electioneering sin known to the electioneering world
was brought to his charge; he was accused of falseness, dishonesty, and bribery of every sort: he had, it was
said in the paper of indictment, bought votes, obtained them by treating, carried them off by violence,
conquered them by strong drink, polled them twice over, counted those of dead men, stolen them, forged
them, and created them by every possible, fictitious contrivance: there was no description of wickedness
appertaining to the task of procuring votes of which Sir Roger had not been guilty, either by himself or by his
agents. He was quite horrorstruck at the list of his own enormities. But he was somewhat comforted when
Mr Closerstil told him that the meaning of it all was that Mr Romer, the barrister, had paid a former bill due
to Mr Reddypalm, the publican.
'I fear he was indiscreet, Sir Roger; I really fear he was. Those young mean always are. Being energetic, they
work like horses; but what's the use of energy without discretion, Sir Roger?'
'But, Mr Closerstil, I knew nothing of it from first to last.'
'The agency can be proved, Sir Roger,' said Mr Closerstil, shaking his head. And then there was nothing
further to be said on the matter.
In these days of snowwhite purity all political delinquency is abominable in the eyes of British politicians;
but no delinquency is so abominable than the venality at elections. The sin of bribery is damnable. It is the
one sin for which, in the House of Commons, there can be no forgiveness. When discovered, it should render
the culprit liable to political death, without hope of pardon. It is treason against a higher throne than that on
which the Queen sits. It is a heresy which requires an autodafe. It is a pollution to the whole House, which
can only be cleansed by a great sacrifice. Anathema maranatha! out with it from amongst us, even though
half of our heart's blood be poured from the conflict! Out with it, and for ever!
Such is the language of patriotic members with regard to bribery; and doubtless, if sincere, they are in the
right. It is a bad thing, certainly, that a rich man should buy votes; bad also that a poor man should sell them.
By all means let us repudiate such a system with heartfelt disgust.
With heartfelt disgust, if we can do so, by all means; but not with disgust pretended only and not felt in the
heart at all. The laws against bribery at elections are now so stringent that an unfortunate candidate may
easily become guilty, even though actuated by the purest intentions. But not the less on that account does any
gentleman, ambitious of the honour of serving his country in Parliament, think it necessary as a preliminary
measure to provide a round sum of money at his banker's. A candidate must pay for no treating, no
refreshments, no band of music; he must give neither ribbons to the girls nor ale to the men. If a huzza be
uttered in his favour, it is at his peril; it may be necessary for him to prove before a committee that it was the
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXII. SIR ROGER IS UNSEATED 158
Page No 162
spontaneous result of British feeling in his favour, and not the purchased result of British beer. He cannot
safely ask any one to share his hotel dinner. Bribery hides itself now in the most impalpable shapes, and may
be effected by the offer of a glass of sherry. But not the less on this account does a poor man find that he is
quite unable to overcome the difficulties of a contested election.
We strain at our gnats with a vengeance, but we swallow our camels with ease. For what purpose is it that we
employ those peculiarly safe men of businessMessrs Nearthewinde and Closerstilwhen we wish to win
our path through all obstacles into that sacred recess? Alas! the money is still necessary, is still prepared, or at
any rate, expended. The poor candidate of course knows nothing of the matter till the attorney's bill is laid
before him, when all danger of petitions has passed away. He little dreamed till then, not he, that there had
been banquetings and junketings, secret doings and deep drinkings at his expense. Poor candidate! Poor
member! Who was so ignorant as he! 'Tis true he has paid bills before; but 'tis equally true that he specially
begged his managing friend Mr Nearthewinde, to be very careful that all was done according to law! He pays
the bill, however, and on the next election will again employ Mr Nearthewinde.
Now and again, at rare intervals, some glimpse into the inner sanctuary does reach the eyes of ordinary
mortal men without; some slight accidental peep into those mysteries from when all corruption has been so
thoroughly expelled; and then, how delightfully refreshing is the sight, when, perhaps, some exmember,
hurled from his paradise like a fallen peri, reveals the secret of that pure heaven, and, in the agony of his
despair, tells us all that it cost him to sit forthrough those few halcyon years!
But Mr Nearthewinde is a safe man, and easy to be employed with but little danger. All these stringent
bribery laws only enhance the value of such very safe men as Mr Nearthewinde. To him, stringent laws
against bribery are the strongest assurance of valuable employment. Were these laws of a nature to be evaded
with ease, any indifferent attorney might manage a candidate's affairs and enable him to take his seat with
security.
It would have been well for Sir Roger if he had trusted solely to Mr Closerstil; well also for Mr Romer had he
never fished in those troubled waters. In due process of time the hearing of the petition came on, and then
who so happy, sitting at his ease in the London inn, blowing his cloud from a long pipe, with measureless
content, as Mr Reddypalm? Mr Reddypalm was the one great man of the contest. All depended on Mr
Reddypalm; and well he did his duty.
The result of the petition was declared by the committee to be read as follows:that Sir Roger's election was
null and voidthat Sir Roger had, by his agent, been guilty of bribery in obtaining a vote, by the payment of
a bill alleged to have been previously refused paymentthis is always a matter of course;but that Sir
Roger's agent, Mr Romer, had been willingly guilty of bribery with reference to the transaction above
declared. Poor Sir Roger! Poor Mr Romer.
Poor Mr Romer indeed! His fate was perhaps as sad as well might be, and as foul a blot to the purism of these
very pure times in which we live. Not long after those days, it so happening that some considerable amount of
youthful energy and quidnunc ability were required to set litigation afloat at Hong Kong, Mr Romer was sent
thither as the fittest man for such work, with rich assurance of future guerdon. Who are so happy then as Mr
Romer! But even among the pure there is room for envy and detraction. Mr Romer had not yet ceased to
wonder at new worlds, as he skimmed among the islands of that southern ocean, before the edict had gone
forth for his return. There were men sitting in that huge court of Parliament on whose breasts it lay as an
intolerable burden, that England should be represented among the antipodes by one who had tampered with
the purity of the franchise. For them there was no rest till this great disgrace should be wiped out and atoned
for. Men they were of that calibre, that the slightest reflection on them of such a stigma seemed to themselves
to blacken their own character. They could not break bread with satisfaction till Mr Romer was recalled. He
was recalled, and of course ruinedand the minds of those just men were then at peace.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXII. SIR ROGER IS UNSEATED 159
Page No 163
To any honourable gentleman who really felt his brow suffused with a patriotic blush, as he thought of his
country dishonoured by Mr Romer's presence at Hong Kongto any such gentleman, if any such there were,
let all honour be given, even though the intensity of his purity may create amazement to our less finely
organized souls. But if no such blush suffused the brow of any honourable gentleman; if Mr Romer was
recalled from quite other feelingswhat then in lieu of honour shall we allot to those honourable gentlemen
who were most concerned?
Sir Roger, however, lost his seat, and, after three months of the joys of legislation, found himself reduced by
a terrible blow to the low level of private life.
And the blow to him was very heavy. Men but seldom tell the truth of what is in them, even to their dearest
friends; they are ashamed of having feelings, or rather of showing that they are troubled by any intensity of
feeling. It is the practice of the time to treat all pursuits as though they were only half important to us, as
though in what we desire we were only half in earnest. To be visibly eager seems childish, and is always bad
policy; and men, therefore, nowadays, though they strive as hard as ever in the service of ambitionharder
than ever in that of mammonusually do so with a pleasant smile on, as though after all they were but
amusing themselves with the little matter in hand.
Perhaps it had been so with Sir Roger in those electioneering days when he was looking for votes. At any
rate, he had spoken of his seat in Parliament as but a doubtful good. 'He was willing, indeed, to stand, having
been asked; but the thing would interfere wonderfully with his business; and then, what did he know about
Parliament? Nothing on earth: it was the maddest scheme, but nevertheless, he was not going to hang back
when called uponhe had always been rough and ready when wantedand there he was now ready as ever,
and rough enough too, God knows.'
'Twas thus that he had spoken of his coming parliamentary honours; and men had generally taken him at his
word. He had been returned, and this success had been hailed as a great thing for the cause and class to which
he belonged. But men did not know that his inner heart will swelling with triumph, and that his bosom could
hardly contain his pride as he reflected that the poor Barchester stonemason was now the representative of
his native city. And so, when his seat was attacked, he still laughed and joked. 'They were welcome to it for
him,' he said; 'he could keep it or want it; and of the two, perhaps, the want of it would come most convenient
to him. He did not exactly think that he had bribed any one; but if the bigwigs chose to say so, it was all one
to him. He was rough and ready, now as ever,' c
But when the struggle came, it was to him a fearful one; not the less fearful because there was no one, no, not
one friend in all the world, to whom he could open his mind and speak out honestly what was in his heart. To
Dr Thorne he might perhaps have done so had his intercourse with the doctor been sufficiently frequent; but
it was only now and then when he was ill, or when the squire wanted to borrow money, that he saw Dr
Thorne. He had plenty of friends, heaps of friends in the parliamentary sense; friends who talked about him,
and lauded him at public meetings; who shook hands with him on platforms and drank his health at dinners;
but he had no friends who could sit with him over his own hearth, in true friendship, and listen to, and
sympathize with, and moderate the sighings of the inner man. For him there was no sympathy; no tenderness
of love; no retreat, save into himself, from the loud brass band of the outer world.
The blow hit him terribly hard. It did not come altogether unexpectedly, and yet, when it did come, it was all
but unendurable. He had made so much of the power of walking into that august chamber, and sitting
shoulder to shoulder in legislative equality with the sons of dukes and the curled darlings of the nation.
Money had given him nothing, nothing but the mere feeling of brute power: with his three hundred thousand
pounds he had felt himself to be no more palpably near to the goal of his ambition than when he had chipped
stones for three shillings and sixpence a day. But when he was led up and introduced at that table, when he
shook the old premier's hand on the floor of the House of Commons, when he heard the honourable member
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXII. SIR ROGER IS UNSEATED 160
Page No 164
for Barchester alluded to in grave debate as the greatest living authority on railway matters, then, indeed, he
felt that he had achieved something.
And now this cup was ravished from his lips, almost before it was tasted. When he was first told as a
certainty that the decision of the committee was against him, he bore up against the misfortune like a man. He
laughed heartily, and declared himself well rid of a very profitless profession; cut some little joke about Mr
Moffat and his thrashing, and left on those around him an impression that he was a man so constituted, so
strong in his own resolves, so steadily pursuant of his own work, that no little contentions of this kind could
affect him. Men admired his easy laughter, as, shuffling his halfcrowns with both his hands in his
trouserpockets, he declared that Messrs Romer and Reddypalm were the best friends he had known for
many a day.
But not the less did he walk out from the room in which he was standing a brokenhearted man. Hope could
not buoy him up as she may do other exmembers in similarly disagreeable circumstances. He could not
afford to look forward to what further favours parliamentary future have in store for him after a lapse of five
or six years. Five or six years! Why, his life was not worth four years' purchase; of that he was perfectly
aware: he could not now live without the stimulus of brandy; and yet, while he took it, he knew he was
killing himself. Death he did not fear; but he would fain have wished, after his life of labour, to have lived,
while yet he could live, in the blaze of that high world to which for a moment he had attained.
He laughed loud and cheerily as he left his parliamentary friends, and, putting himself into the train, went
down to Boxall Hill. He laughed loud and cheerily; but he never laughed again. It had not been his habit to
laugh much at Boxall Hill. It was there he kept his wife, and Mr Winterbones, and the brandy bottle behind
his pillow. He had not often there found it necessary to assume that loud and cheery laugh.
On this occasion he was apparently well in health when he got home; but both Lady Scatcherd and Mr
Winterbones found him more than ordinarily cross. He made an affectation at sitting very hard to business,
and even talked of going abroad to look at some of his foreign contracts. But even Winterbones found that his
patron did not work as he had been wont to do; and at last, with some misgivings, he told Lady Scatcherd that
he feared that everything was not right.
'He's always at it, my lady, always,' said Mr Winterbones.
'Is he?' said Lady Scatcherd, well understanding what Mr Winterbones's allusion meant.
'Always, my lady. I never saw nothing like it. Now, there's meI can always go my halfhour when I've had
my drop; but he, why, he don't go ten minutes, not now.'
This was not cheerful to Lady Scatcherd; but what was the poor woman to do? When she spoke to him on any
subject he only snarled at her; and now that the heavy fit was on him, she did not dare even to mention the
subject of his drinking. She had never known him so savage in his humour as he was now, so bearish in his
habits, so little inclined to humanity, so determined to rush headlong down, with his head between his legs,
into the bottomless abyss.
She thought of sending for Dr Thorne; but she did not know under what guise to send for him,whether as
doctor or as friend: under neither would he now be welcome; and she well knew that Sir Roger was not the
man to accept in good part either a doctor or a friend who might be unwelcome. She knew that this husband
of hers, this man, who, with all his faults, was the best of her friends whom she loved bestshe knew that he
was killing himself, and yet she could do nothing. Sir Roger was his own master, and if kill himself he would,
kill himself he must.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXII. SIR ROGER IS UNSEATED 161
Page No 165
And kill himself he did. Not indeed by one sudden blow. He did not take one huge dose of his consuming
poison, and then fall dead upon the floor. It would perhaps have been better for himself, and better for those
around him, had he done so. No; the doctors had time to congregate round his bed; Lady Scatcherd was
allowed a period of nursetending; the sick man was able to say his last few words and bid his adieu to his
portion of the lower world with dying decency. As these last words will have some lasting effect upon the
surviving personages of our story, the reader must be content to stand for a short while by the side of Sir
Roger's sickbed, and help us bid him Godspeed on the journey which lies before him.
CHAPTER XXIII. RETROSPECTIVE
It was declared in the early pages of this work that Dr Thorne was to be our hero; but it would appear very
much as though he had latterly been forgotten. Since that evening when he retired to rest without letting Mary
share the grievous weight which was on his mind, we have neither seen nor heard aught of him.
It was then full midsummer, and it now early spring: and during the intervening months the doctor had not
had a happy time of it. On that night, as we have before told, he took his niece to his heart; but he could not
then bring himself to tell her that which it was so imperative that she should know. Like a coward, he would
put off the evil hour, till the next morning, and thus robbed himself of his night's sleep.
But when the morning came the duty could not be postponed. Lady Arabella had given him to understand
that his niece would no longer be a guest at Greshamsbury; and it was quite out of the question that Mary,
after this, should be allowed to put her foot within the gate of the domain without having learnt what Lady
Arabella had said. So he told it before breakfast, walking round their little garden, she with her hand in his.
He was perfectly thunderstruck by the collectednay, cool way in which she received his tidings. She turned
pale, indeed; he felt also that her hand somewhat trembled in his own, and he perceived that for a moment her
voice shook; but no angry word escaped her lip, nor did she even deign to repudiate the charge, which was, as
it were, conveyed in Lady Arabella's request. The doctor knew, or thought he knewnay, he did knowthat
Mary was wholly blameless in the matter: that she had at least given no encouragement to any love on the
part of the young heir; but, nevertheless, he had expected that she would avouch her own innocence. This,
however, she by no means did.
'Lady Arabella is quite right,' she said, 'quite right; if she has any fear of that kind, she cannot be too careful.'
'She is a selfish, proud woman,' said the doctor; 'quite indifferent to the feelings of others; quite careless how
deeply she may hurt her neighbours, if, in doing so, she may possibly benefit herself.'
'She will not hurt me, uncle, nor yet you. I can live without going to Greshamsbury.'
'But it is not to be endured that she should dare to cast an imputation on my darling.'
'On me, uncle? She casts no imputation on me. Frank has been foolish: I have said nothing of it, for it was not
worth while to trouble you. But as Lady Arabella chooses to interfere, I have no right to blame her. He has
said what he should not have said; he has been foolish. Uncle, you know I could not prevent it.'
'Let her send him away then, not you; let her banish him.'
'Uncle, he is her son. A mother can hardly send her son away so easily: could you send me away, uncle?'
He merely answered her by twining his arm round her waist and pressing her to his side. He was well sure
that she was badly treated; and yet now that she so unaccountably took Lady Arabella's part, he hardly knew
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIII. RETROSPECTIVE 162
Page No 166
how to make this out plainly to be the case.
'Besides, uncle, Greshamsbury is in a manner his own; how can he be banished from his father's house? No,
uncle; there is an end of my visits there. They shall find that I will not thrust myself in their way.'
And then Mary, with a calm brow and steady gait, went in and made the tea.
And what might be the feelings of her heart when she so sententiously told her uncle that Frank had been
foolish? She was of the same age with him; as impressionable, though more powerful in hiding such
impressions,as all women should be; her heart was as warm, her blood as full of life, her innate desire for
the companionship of some muchloved object as strong as his. Frank had been foolish in avowing his
passion. No such folly as that could be laid at her door. But had she been proof against the other folly? Had
she been able to walk heartwhole by his side, while he chatted his commonplaces about love? Yes, they are
commonplaces when we read them in novels; common enough, too, to some of us when we write them; but
they are by no means commonplace when first heard by a young girl in the rich, balmy fragrance of July
evening stroll.
Nor are they commonplaces when so uttered for the first or second time at least, or perhaps the third. 'Tis a
pity that so heavenly a pleasure should pall upon the senses.
If it was so that Frank's folly had been listened to with a certain amount of pleasure, Mary did not even admit
so much to herself. But why should it have been otherwise? Why should she have been less prone to love
than he was? Had he not everything which girls do love? which girls should love? which God created noble,
beautiful, all but godlike, in order that women, all but goddesslike, might love? To love thoroughly, truly,
heartily, with her whole body, soul, heart, and strength; should not that be counted for a merit in a woman?
And yet we are wont to make a disgrace of it. We do so most unnaturally, most unreasonably; for we expect
our daughters to get themselves married off our hands. When the period of that step comes, then love is
proper enough; but up to thatbefore thatas regards all those preliminary passages which must, we
suppose, be necessaryin all those it becomes a young lady to be icyhearted as a rivergod in winter.
'O whistle and I'll come to you my lad!
O whistle and I'll come to you my lad!
Tho' father and mither and a'should go mad
O whistle and I'll come to you my lad!'
This is the kind of love which a girl should feel before she puts her hand proudly in that of her lover, and
consents that they two shall be made one flesh.
Mary felt no such love as this. She, too, had some inner perception of that dread destiny by which it behoved
Frank Gresham to be forewarned. She, toothough she had never heard so much said in wordshad an
almost instinctive knowledge that his fate required him to marry money. Thinking over this in her own way,
she was not slow to convince herself that it was out of the question that she should allow herself to love
Frank Gresham. However well her heart might be inclined to such a feeling, it was her duty to repress it. She
resolved, therefore, to do so; and she sometimes flattered herself that she had kept her resolution.
These were bad times for the doctor, and bad times for Mary too. She had declared that she could live without
going to Greshamsbury; but she did not find it so easy. She had been going to Greshambury all her life, and it
was customary with her to be there as at home. Such old customs are not broken without pain. Had she left
the place it would have been far different; but, as it was, she daily passed the gates, daily saw and spoke to
some of the servants, who knew her as well as they did the young ladies of the familywas in hourly
contact, as it were, with Greshamsbury. It was not only that she did not go there, but that every one knew that
she had suddenly discontinued doing so. Yes, she could live without going to Greshamsbury; but for some
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIII. RETROSPECTIVE 163
Page No 167
time she had but a poor life of it. She felt, nay, almost heard, that every man and woman, boy and girl in the
village was telling his and her neighbour that Mary Thorne no longer went to the house because of Lady
Arabella and the young squire.
But Beatrice, of course, came to her. What was she to say to Beatrice? The truth! Nay, but it is not always so
easy to say the truth, even to one's dearest friends.
'But you'll come up now he has gone?' said Beatrice.
'No, indeed,' said Mary; 'that would hardly be pleasant to Lady Arabella, nor to me either. No, Trichy,
dearest; my visits to dear old Greshamsbury are done, done, done: perhaps in some twenty years' time I may
be walking down the lawn with your brother, and discussing the childish daysthat is, always, if the then
Mrs Gresham shall have invited me.'
'How can Frank have been so wrong, so unkind, so cruel?' said Beatrice.
This, however, was a light in which Miss Thorne did not take any pleasure, in discussing the matter. Her
ideas of Frank's fault, and unkindness and cruelty, were doubtless different from those of her sister. Such
cruelty was not unnaturally excused in her eyes by many circumstances which Beatrice did not fully
understand. Mary was quite ready to go hand in hand with Lady Arabella and the rest of Greshamsbury fold
in putting an end, if possible, to Frank's passion: she would give not one a right to accuse her of assisting to
ruin the young heir; but she could hardly bring herself to admit that he was so very wrongno, nor yet even
so very cruel.
And then the squire came to see her, and this was a yet harder trial than the visit of Beatrice. It was so
difficult for her to speak to him that she could not but wish him away; and yet, had he not come, had he
altogether neglected her, she would have felt it to be unkind. She had ever been his pet, had always received
kindness from him.
'I am sorry for all this, Mary; very sorry,' said he, standing up, and holding both her hands in his.
'It can't be helped, sir,' said she, smiling.
'I don't know,' said he; 'I don't knowit ought to be helped somehowI am quite sure you have not been to
blame.'
'No,' said she, very quietly, as though the position was one quite a matter of course. 'I don't think I have been
very much to blame. There will be misfortunes sometimes when nobody is to blame.'
'I do not quite understand it all,' said the squire; 'but if Frank'
'Oh! we will not talk about him,' said she, still laughing gently.
'You can understand, Mary, how dear he must be to me; but if'
'Mr Gresham, I would not for worlds be the cause of any unpleasantness between you and him.'
'But I cannot bear to think that we have banished you, Mary.'
'It cannot be helped. Things will all come right in time.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIII. RETROSPECTIVE 164
Page No 168
'But you will be lonely here.'
'Oh! I shall got over all that. Here, you know, Mr Gresham, "I am monarch of all I survey"; and there is a
great deal in that.'
The squire did not catch her meaning, but a glimmering of it did reach him. It was competent to Lady
Arabella to banish her from Greshamsbury; it was within the sphere of the squire's duties to prohibit his son
from an imprudent match; it was for the Greshams to guard their Greshamsbury treasure as best they could
within their own territories: but let them beware that they did not attack her on hers. In obedience to the first
expression of their wishes, she had submitted herself to this public mark of their disapproval because she had
seen at once, with her clear intellect, that they were only doing that which her conscience must approve.
Without a murmur, therefore, she consented to be pointed at as the young lady who had been turned out of
Greshamsbury because of the young squire. She had no help for it. But let them take care that they did not go
beyond that. Outside those Greshamsbury gates she and Frank Gresham, she and Lady Arabella met on equal
terms; let them each fight their own battle.
The squire kissed her forehead affectionately and took his leave, feeling somehow, that he had been excused
and pitied, and made much of; whereas he had called on his young neighbour with the intention of excusing,
and pitying, and making much of her. He was not quite comfortable as he left the house; but, nevertheless, he
was sufficiently honesthearted to own to himself that Mary Thorne was a fine girl. Only that it was so
absolutely necessary that Frank should marry moneyand only, also, that poor Mary was such a birthless
foundling in the world's esteemonly, but for these things, what a wife she would have made for that son of
his!
To one person only did she talk freely on the subject, and that one was Patience Oriel; and even with her the
freedom was rather of the mind than of the heart. She never said a word of her feeling with reference to
Frank, but she said much of her position in the village, and of the necessity she was under to keep out of the
way.
'It is very hard,' said Patience, 'that the offence should be all with him, and the punishment all with you.'
'Oh! as for that,' said Mary, laughing, 'I will not confess to any offence, not yet to any punishment; certainly
not to any punishment.'
'It comes to the same thing in the end.'
'No, not so, Patience; there is always some little sting of disgrace in punishment: now I am not going to hold
myself in the least disgraced.'
'But, Mary, you must meet the Greshams sometimes.'
'Meet them! I have not the slightest objection on earth to meet all, or any of them. They are not a whit
dangerous to me, my dear. 'Tis that I am the wild beast, and 'tis that they must avoid me,' and then she added,
after a pauseslightly blushing'I have not the slightest objection even to meet him if chance brings him in
my way. Let them look to that. My undertaking goes no further than this, that I will not be seen within their
gates.'
But the girls so far understood each other that Patience undertook, rather than promised, to give Mary what
assistance she could; and, despite Mary's bravado, she was in such a position that she much wanted the
assistance of such a friend as Patience Oriel.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIII. RETROSPECTIVE 165
Page No 169
After an absence of some six weeks, Frank, as we have seen, returned home. Nothing was said to him, except
by Beatrice, as to those new Greshamsbury arrangements; and he, when he found Mary was not at the place,
went boldly to the doctor's house to seek her. But it has been seen, also, that she discreetly kept out of his
way. This she had thought fit to do when the time came, although she had been so ready with her boast that
she had no objection on earth to meet him.
After that there had been the Christmas vacation, and Mary had again found discretion the better part of
valour. This was doubtless disagreeable enough. She had no particular wish to spend her Christmas with Miss
Oriel's aunt instead of at her uncle's fireside. Indeed, her Christmas festivities had hitherto been kept at
Greshamsbury, the doctor and herself having a part of the family circle there assembled. This was out of the
question now; and perhaps the absolute change to old Miss Oriel's house was better for her than the lesser
change to her uncle's drawingroom. Besides, how could she have demeaned herself when she met Frank in
their parish church? All this had been fully understood by Patience, and, therefore, had this Christmas visit
been planned.
And then this affair of Frank and Mary Thorne ceased for a while to be talked of at Greshamsbury, for that
other affair of Mr Moffat and Augusta monopolized the rural attention. Augusta, as we have said, bore it
well, and sustained the public gaze without much flinching. Her period of martyrdom, however, did not last
long, for soon the news arrived of Frank's exploit in Pall Mall; and then the Greshamburyites forgot to think
much more of Augusta, being fully occupied in thinking of what Frank had done.
The tale, as it was first told, declared the Frank had followed Mr Moffat up into his club; had dragged him
thence into the middle of Pall Mall, and had then slaughtered him on the spot. This was by degrees modified
till a sobered fiction became generally prevalent, that Mr Moffat was lying somewhere, still alive, but with all
his bones in a state of compound fracture. This adventure again brought Frank into the ascendant, and
restored to Mary her former position as the Greshamsbury heroine.
'One cannot wonder at his being very angry,' said Beatrice, discussing the matter with Maryvery
imprudently.
'Wonderno; the wonder would have been if he had not been angry. One might have been quite sure that he
would have been angry enough.'
'I suppose it was not absolutely right for him to beat Mr Moffat,' said Beatrice, apologetically.
'Not right, Trichy? I think he was very right.'
'Not to beat him so much, Mary!'
'Oh, I suppose a man can't exactly stand measuring how much he does these things. I like your brother for
what he has done, and I may say so franklythough I suppose I ought to eat my tongue out before I should
say such a thing, eh Trichy?'
'I don't know that there's any harm in that,' said Beatrice, demurely. 'If you both liked each other there would
be no harm in thatif that were all.'
'Wouldn't there?' said Mary, in a low tone of bantering satire; 'that is so kind, Trichy, coming from
youfrom one of the family, you know.'
'You are well aware, Mary, that if I could have my wishes'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIII. RETROSPECTIVE 166
Page No 170
'Yes: I am well aware what a paragon of goodness you are. If you could have your way I should be admitted
into heaven again; shouldn't I? Only with this proviso, that if a stray angel should ever whisper to me with
bated breath, mistaking me, perchance, for one of his own class, I should be bound to close my ears to his
whispering, and remind him humbly that I was only a poor mortal. You would trust me so far, wouldn't you,
Trichy?'
'I would trust you in any way, Mary. But I think you are unkind in saying such things to me.'
'Into whatever heaven I am admitted, I will go only on this understanding: that I am to be as good an angel as
any of those around me.'
'But, Mary dear, why do you say this to me?'
'Becausebecausebecauseah me! Why, indeed, but because I have no one else to say it to. Certainly
not because you have deserved it.'
'It seems as if you were finding fault with me.'
'And so I am; how can I do other than find fault? How can I help being sore? Trichy, you hardly realize my
position; you hardly see how I am treated; how I am forced to allow myself to be treated without a sign of
complaint. You don't see it all. If you did, you would not wonder that I should be sore.'
Beatrice did not quite see it all; but she saw enough of it to know that Mary was to be pitied; so, instead of
scolding her friend for being cross, she threw her arms round her and kissed her affectionately.
But the doctor all this time suffered much more than his niece did. He could not complain out loudly; he
could not aver that his pet lamb had been ill treated; he could not even have the pleasure of openly quarrelling
with Lady Arabella; but not the less did he feel it to be most cruel that Mary should have to live before the
world as an outcast, because it had pleased Frank Gresham to fall in love with her.
But his bitterness was not chiefly against Frank. That Frank had been very foolish he could not but
acknowledge; but it was a kind of folly for which the doctor was able to find excuse. For Lady Arabella's
cold propriety he could find no excuse.
With the squire he had spoken no word on the subject up to this period of which we are now writing. With
her ladyship he had never spoken on it since that day when she had told him that Mary was to come no more
to Greshamsbury. He never now dined or spent his evenings at Greshamsbury, and seldom was to be seen at
the house, except when called in professionally. The squire, indeed, he frequently met; but he either did so in
the village, or out on horseback, or at his own house.
When the doctor first heard that Sir Roger had lost his seat, and had returned to Boxall Hill, he resolved to go
over and see him. But the visit was postponed from day to day, as visits are postponed which may be made
any day, and he did not in fact go till summoned there somewhat peremptorily. A message was brought to
him one evening to say that Sir Roger had been struck by paralysis, and that not a moment was to be lost.
'It always happens at night,' said Mary, who had more sympathy for the living uncle whom she did know,
than for the other dying uncle whom she did not know.
'What matters?therejust give me my scarf. In all probability I may not be home tonightperhaps not
till late tomorrow. God bless you, Mary!' and away the doctor went on his cold bleak ride to Boxall Hill.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIII. RETROSPECTIVE 167
Page No 171
'Who is to be his heir?' As the doctor rode along, he could not quite rid his mind of the question. The poor
man now about to die had wealth enough to make many heirs. What if his heart should have softened towards
his sister's child! What if Mary should be found to be possessed of such wealth that the Greshams should be
again be happy to welcome her at Greshamsbury!
The doctor was not a lover of moneyand he did his best to get rid of such pernicious thoughts. But his
longings, perhaps, were not so much that Mary should be rich, as that she should have the power of heaping
coals of fire upon the heads of those people who had so injured her.
CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD
When Dr Thorne reached Boxall Hill he found Mr Rerechild from Barchester there before him. Poor Lady
Scatcherd, when her husband was stricken by the fit, hardly knew in her dismay what adequate steps to take.
She had, as a matter of course, sent for Dr Thorne; but she had thought it so grave a peril that the medical
skill of no one man could suffice. It was, she knew, quite out of the question for her to invoke the aid of Dr
Fillgrave, whom no earthly persuasion could have brought to Boxall Hill; and as Mr Rerechild was supposed
in the Barchester world to be secondthough at a long intervalto that great man, she had applied for his
assistance.
Now Mr Rerechild was a follower and humble friend of Dr Fillgrave; and was wont to regard anything that
came from the Barchester doctor as sure as light from the lamp of Aesculapius. He could not therefore be
other than an enemy of Dr Thorne. But he was a prudent, discreet man, with a long family, averse to
professional hostilities, as knowing that he could make more by medical friends than medical foes, and not at
all inclined to take up any man's cudgel to his own detriment. He had, of course, heard of that dreadful affront
which had been put upon his friend, as had all the 'medical world'and all the medical world at least of
Barsetshire; and he had often expressed sympathy with Dr Fillgrave and his abhorrence of Dr Thorne's
antiprofessional practices. But now that he found himself about to be brought in contact with Dr Thorne, he
reflected that the Galen of Greshamsbury was at any rate equal in reputation to him of Barchester; that the
one was probably on the rise, whereas the other was already considered by some as rather antiquated; and he
therefore wisely resolved that the present would be an excellent opportunity for him to make a friend of Dr
Thorne.
Poor Lady Scatcherd had an inkling that Dr Fillgrave and Mr Rerechild were accustomed to row in the same
boat, and she was not altogether free from fear that there might be an outbreak. She therefore took an
opportunity before Dr Thorne's arrival to deprecate any wrathful tendency.
'Oh, Lady Scatcherd! I have the greatest respect for Dr Thorne,' said he; 'the greatest possible respect; a most
skilful practitionersomething brusque, certainly, and perhaps a little obstinate. But what then? we have all
our faults, Lady Scatcherd.'
'Ohyes; we all have, Mr Rerechild; that's a certain.'
'There's my friend FillgraveLady Scatcherd. He cannot bear anything of that sort. Now I think he's wrong;
and so I tell him.' Mr Rerechild was in error here; for he had never yet ventured to tell Dr Fillgrave that he
was wrong in anything. 'We must bear and forbear, you know. Dr Thorne is an excellent manin his way
very excellent, Lady Scatcherd.'
This little conversation took place after Mr Rerechild's first visit to his patient: what steps were immediately
taken for the relief of the sufferer we need not describe. They were doubtless well intended, and were,
perhaps, as well adapted to stave off the coming evil day as any that Dr Fillgrave, or even the great Sir
Omicron Pie might have used.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD 168
Page No 172
And then Dr Thorne arrived.
'Oh, doctor! doctor!' exclaimed Lady Scatcherd, almost hanging round his neck in the hall. 'What are we to
do? What are we to do? He's very bad.'
'Has he spoken?'
'No; nothing like a word: he has made one or two muttered sounds; but, poor soul, you could make nothing of
itoh, doctor! doctor! he has never been like this before.
It was easy to see where Lady Scatcherd placed any such faith as she might still have in the healing art. 'Mr
Rerechild is here and has seen him,' she continued. 'I thought it best to send for two, for fear of accidents. He
has done somethingI don't know what. But, doctor, do tell the truth now; I look to you to tell me the truth.'
Dr Thorne went up and saw his patient; and had he literally complied with Lady Scatcherd's request, he might
have told her at once that there was no hope. As, however, he had not the heart to do this, he mystified the
case as doctors so well know how to do, and told her that 'there was cause to fear, great cause for fear; he was
sorry to say, very great cause for much fear.'
Dr Thorne promised to stay the night there, and, if possible, the following night also; and then Lady
Scatcherd became troubled in her mind as to what she should do with Mr Rerechild. He also declared, with
much medical humanity, that, let the inconvenience be what it might, he too would stay the night. 'The loss,'
he said, 'of such a man as Sir Roger Scatcherd was of such paramount importance as to make other matters
trivial. He would certainly not allow the whole weight to fall on the shoulders of his friend Dr Thorne: he also
would stay at any rate that night by the sick man's bedside. By the following morning some change might be
excpected.'
'I say, Dr Thorne,' said her ladyship, calling the doctor into the housekeepingroom, in which she and
Hannah spent any time that they were not required upstairs; 'just come in, doctor: you wouldn't tell him we
don't want him no more, could you?'
'Tell whom?' said the doctor.
'WhyMr Rerechild: mightn't he go away, do you think?'
Dr Thorne explained that Mr Rerechild might go away if he pleased; but that it would by no means be proper
for one doctor to tell another to leave the house. And so Mr Rerechild was allowed to share the glories of the
night.
In the meantime the patient remained speechless; but it soon became evident that Nature was using all her
efforts to make one final rally. From time to time he moaned and muttered as though he was conscious, and it
seemed as though he strove to speak. He gradually became awake, at any rate to suffering, and Dr Thorne
began to think that the last scene would be postponed for yet a while longer.
'Wonderful constitutioneh, Dr Thorne? wonderful!' said Mr Rerechild.
'Yes; he has been a strong man.'
'Strong as a horse, Dr Thorne. Lord, what that man would have been if he had given himself a chance! You
know his constitution of course.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD 169
Page No 173
'Yes; pretty well. I've attended him for many years.'
'Always drinking, I suppose; always at iteh?'
'He has not been a temperate man, certainly.'
'The brain, you see, clean goneand not a particle of coating left to the stomach; and yet what a struggle he
makesan interesting case, isn't it?'
'It's very sad to see such an intellect so destroyed.'
'Very sad, very sad indeed. How Fillgrave would have liked to have seen this case. He is a very clever man, is
Fillgravein his way, you know.'
'I'm sure he is,' said Dr Thorne.
'Not that he'd make anything of a case like this nowhe's not, you know, quitequiteperhaps not quite
up to the new time of day, one might say so.'
'He has had a very extensive provincial practice,' said Dr Thorne.
'Oh, veryvery; and made a tidy lot of money too, has Fillgrave. He's worth six thousand pounds, I suppose;
now that's a good deal of money to put by in a little town like Barchester.'
'Yes, indeed.'
'What I say to Fillgrave iskeep your eyes open; one should never be too old to learnthere's always
something new worth picking up. But nohe won't believe that. He can't believe that any new ideas can be
worth anything. You know a man must go to the wall in that wayeh, doctor?'
And then again they were called to their patient. 'He's doing finely, finely,' said Mr Rerechild to Lady
Scatcherd. 'There's fair ground to hope he'll rally; fair ground, is there not, doctor?'
'Yes; he'll rally; but how long that may last, that we can hardly say.'
'Oh, no, certainly not, certainly notthat is not with any certainty; but still he's doing finely, Lady Scatcherd,
considering everything.'
'How long will you give him, doctor?' said Mr Rerechild to his new friend, when they were again alone. 'Ten
days? I dare say ten days, or from that to a fortnight.'
'Perhaps so,' said the doctor. 'I should not like to say exactly to a day.'
'No, certainly not. We cannot say exactly to a day; but I say ten days; as for anything like a recovery, that you
know'
'Is out of the question,' said Dr Thorne, gravely.
'Quite so; quite so; coating of the stomach clean gone, you know; brain destroyed: did you observe the
periporollida? I never saw them so swelled before: now when the periporollida are swollen like that'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD 170
Page No 174
'Yes, very much; it's always the case when paralysis has been brought about by intemperance.'
'Always, always; I have remarked that always; the periporollida in such cases are always extended; most
interesting case, isn't it? I do wish Fillgrave could have seen it. But, I believe you and Dr Fillgrave don't
quiteeh?'
'No, not quite,'said Dr Thorne; who, as he thought of his last interview with Dr Fillgrave, and of that
gentleman's exceeding anger as he stood in the hall below, could not keep himself from smiling, sad as the
occasion was.
Nothing would induced Lady Scatcherd to go to bed; but the two doctors agreed to lie down, each in a room
on one side of the patient. How was it possible that anything but good should come to him, being so guarded?
'He's going on finely, Lady Scatcherd, quite finely,' were the last words Mr Rerechild said as he left the room.
And then Dr Thorne, taking Lady Scatcherd's hand and leading her out into another chamber, told her the
truth.
'Lady Scatcherd,' said he, in his tenderest voiceand his voice could be very tender when occasion required
it'Lady Scatcherd, do not hope; you must not hope; it would be cruel to bid you to do so.'
'Oh, doctor! oh, doctor!'
'My dear friend, there is no hope.'
'Oh, Dr Thorne!' said the wife, looking wildly up into her companion's face, though she hardly yet realized
the meaning of what he said, although her senses were half stunned by the blow.
'Dear Lady Scatcherd, is it not better that I should tell you the truth?'
'Oh, I suppose so; oh yes, oh yes; ah me! ah me! ah me!' And then she began rocking herself backwards and
forwards on her chair, with her apron up to her eyes.
'Look to Him, Lady Scatcherd, who only can make such grief endurable.'
'Yes, yes, yes; I suppose so. Ah me! ah me! But, Dr Thorne, there must be some chanceisn't there any
chance? That man says he's going on so well.'
'I fear there is no chanceas far as my knowledge goes there is no chance.'
'Then why does that chattering magpie tell such lies to a woman? Ah me! ah me! oh, doctor! doctor! what
shall I do? what shall I do?' and poor Lady Scatcherd, fairly overcome by her sorrow, burst out crying like a
great schoolgirl.
And yet what had her husband done for her that she should thus weep for him? Would not her life be much
more blessed when this cause of all her troubles should be removed from her? Would she not then be a free
woman instead of a slave? Might she not then expect to begin to taste the comforts of life? What had that
harsh tyrant of hers done that was good or serviceable for her? Why should she thus weep for him in
paroxysms of truest grief?
We hear a good deal of jolly widows; and the slanderous raillery of the world tell much of conjugal
disturbances as a cure for which women will look forward to a state of widowhood with not unwilling eyes.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD 171
Page No 175
The raillery of the world is very slanderous. In our daily jests we attribute to each other vices of which neither
we, nor our neighbours, nor our friends, nor even our enemies are ever guilty. It is our favourite parlance to
talk of the family troubles of Mrs Green on our right, and to tell now Mrs Young on our left is strongly
suspected of having raised her hand to her lord and master. What right have we to make these charges? What
have we seen in our own personal walks through life to make us believe that women are devils? There may
possibly have been Xantippe here and there, but Imogenes are to be found in every bush. Lady Scatcherd, in
spite of the life she had led, was one of them.
'You should send a message up to London for Louis,' said the doctor.
'We did that, doctor; we did that todaywe sent up a telegraph. Oh me! oh me! poor boy, what will he do?
I shall never know what to do with him, never! never!' And with such sorrowful wailings she sat rocking
herself through the long night, every now and then comforting herself by the performance of some menial
service in the sick man's room.
Sir Roger passed the night much as he had passed the day, except that he appeared gradually to be growing
nearer to a state of consciousness. On the following morning they succeeded at last in making Mr Rerechild
understand that they were not desirous of keeping him longer from his Barchester practice; and at about
twelve o'clock Dr Thorne also went, promising that he would return in the evening, and again pass the night
at Boxall Hill.
In the course of the afternoon Sir Roger once more awoke to his senses, and when he did so his son was
standing at his bedside. Louis Philippe Scatcherdor as it may be more convenient to call him, Louiswas
a young man just of the age of Frank Gresham. But there could hardly be two youths more different in their
appearance. Louis, though his father and mother were both robust persons, was short and slight, and now of a
sickly frame. Frank was a picture of health and strength; but, though manly in disposition, was by no means
precocious either in appearance or manners. Louis Scatcherd looked as though he was four years the other's
senior. He had been sent to Eton when he was fifteen, his father being under the impression that this was the
most ready and bestrecognized method of making him a gentleman. Here he did not altogether fail as
regarded the coveted object of his becoming the companion of gentlemen. He had more pocketmoney than
any other lad in the school, and was possessed of a certain effrontery which carried him ahead among boys of
his own age. He gained, therefore, a degree of eclat, even among those who knew, and very frequently said to
each other, that young Scatcherd was not fit to be their companion except on such open occasions as those of
cricketmatches and boat races. Boys, in this respect, are at least as exclusive as men, and understand as
well the difference between an inner and outer circle. Scatcherd had many companions at school who were
glad enough to go up to Maidenhead with him his boat; but there was not one among them who would have
talked to him of his sister.
Sir Roger was vastly proud of his son's success, and did his best to stimulate it by lavish expenditure at the
Christopher, whenever he could manage to run down to Eton. But this practice, though sufficiently
unexceptionable to the boys, was not held in equal delight by the masters. To tell the truth, neither Sir Roger
nor his son were favourites with these stern custodians. At last it was felt necessary to get rid of them both;
and Louis was not long in giving them an opportunity, by getting tipsy twice in one week. On the second
occasion he was sent away, and he and Sir Roger, though long talked of, were seen no more at Eton.
But the universities were still open to Louis Philippe, and before he was eighteen he was entered as a
gentlemancommoner at Trinity. As he was, moreover, the eldest son of a baronet, and had almost unlimited
command of money, here also he was enabled for a while to shine.
To shine! but very fitfully; and one may say almost with a ghastly glare. The very lads who had eaten his
father's dinners at Eton, and shared his fouroar at Eton, knew much better than to associate with him at
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD 172
Page No 176
Cambridge now that they had put on the toga virilis. They were still as prone as ever to fun, frolic, and
devilryperhaps more so than ever, seeing that more was in their power; but they acquired an idea that it
behoved them to be somewhat circumspect as to the men with whom their pranks were perpetrated. So, in
those days, Louis Scatcherd was coldly looked on by his whilom Eton friends.
But young Scatcherd did not fail to find companions at Cambridge also. There are few places indeed in which
a rich man cannot buy companionship. But the set with whom he lived, were the worst of the place. They
were fast, slang men, who were fast and slang, and nothing elsemen who imitated grooms in more than
their dress, and who looked on the customary heroes of racecourses as the highest lords of the ascendant
upon earth. Among those at college young Scatcherd did shine as long as such lustre was permitted him.
Here, indeed, his father, who had striven only to encourage him at Eton, did strive somewhat to control him.
But that was not now easy. If he limited his son's allowance, he only drove him to do his debauchery on
credit. There were plenty to lend money to the son of a great millionaire; and so, after eighteen months' trial
of a university education, Sir Roger had no alternative but to withdraw his son from his alma mater.
What was he to do with him? Unluckily it was considered quite unnecessary to take any steps towards
enabling him to earn his bread. Now nothing on earth can be more difficult than bringing up well a young
man who has not to earn his own bread, and who has no recognized station among other men similarly
circumstanced. Juvenile dukes, and sprouting earls, find their duties and their places as easily as embryo
clergymen and sucking barristers. Provision is made for their peculiar positions: and, though they may
possibly go astray, they have a fair chance given to them of running within the posts. The same may be said
of such youths as Frank Gresham. There are enough of them in the community to have made it necessary that
their wellbeing should be a matter of care and forethought. But there are but few men turned out in the
world in the position of Louis Scatcherd; and, of those few, but very few enter the real battle of life under
good auspices.
Poor Sir Roger though he had hardly time with all his multitudinous railways to look into this thoroughly,
had a glimmering of it. When he saw his son's pale face, and paid his wine bills, and heard of his doings in
horseflesh, he did know that things were not going well; he did understand that the heir to a baronetcy and a
fortune of some ten thousand a year might be doing better. But what was he to do? he could not watch over
his boy himself; so he took a tutor for him and sent him abroad.
Louis and the tutor got as far as Berlin, with what mutual satisfaction to each other need not be specially
described. But from Berlin Sir Roger received a letter in which the tutor declined to go any further in the task
which he had undertaken. He found that he had no influence over his pupil, and he could not reconcile it to
his conscience to be the spectator of such a life as that which Mr Scatcherd led. He had no power in inducing
Mr Scatcherd to leave Berlin; but he would remain there himself till he should hear from Sir Roger. So Sir
Roger had to leave the huge Government works which he was then erecting on the southern coast, and hurry
off to Berlin to see what could be done with young Hopeful.
The young Hopeful was by no means a fool; and in some matters was more than a match for his father. Sir
Roger, in his anger, threatened to cast him off without a shilling. Louis, with mixed penitence and effrontery,
reminded him that he could not change the descent of the title; promised amendment; declared that he had
done only as do other young men of fortune; and hinted that the tutor was a straitlaced ass. The father and
the son returned together to Boxall Hill, and three months afterwards Mr Scatcherd set up for himself in
London.
And now his life, if not more virtuous, was more crafty than it had been. He had no tutor to watch his doings
and complain of them, and he had sufficient sense to keep himself from absolute pecuniary ruin. He lived, it
is true, where sharpers and blacklegs had too often opportunities of plucking him; but, young as he was, he
had been sufficiently long about the world to take care he was not openly robbed; and as he was not openly
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD 173
Page No 177
robbed, his father, in a certain sense, was proud of him.
Tidings, however, camecame at least in those last dayswhich cut Sir Roger to the quick; tidings of vice
in the son which the father could not but attribute to his own example. Twice his mother was called up to the
sickbed of her only child, while he lay raving in that horrid madness by which the outraged mind avenges
itself on the body! Twice he was found raging in delirium tremens, and twice the father was told that a
continuance of such life must end in early death.
It may easily be conceived that Sir Roger was not a happy man. Lying there with that brandy bottle beneath
his pillow, reflecting in his moments of rest that that son of his had his brandy bottle beneath his pillow, he
could hardly have been happy. But he was not a man to say much about his misery. Though he could restrain
neither himself nor his heir, he could endure in silence; and in silence he did endure, till, opening his eyes to
the consciousness of death, he at last spoke a few words to the only friend he knew.
Louis Scatcherd was not a fool, nor was he naturally, perhaps, of a depraved disposition; but he had to reap
the fruits of the worst education which England was able to give him. There were moments in his life when
he felt that a better, a higher, nay, a much happier career was open to him than that which he had prepared
himself to lead. Now and then, he would reflect what money and rank might have done for him; he would
look with wishful eyes to the proud doings of others of his age; would dream of quiet joys, of a sweet wife, a
house to which might be asked friends who were neither jockeys nor drunkards; he would dream of such
things in his short intervals of constrained sobriety; but the dream would only serve to make him moody.
This was the best side of his character; the worst, probably, was that which was brought into play by the fact
that he was not a fool. He would have a better chance of redemption in this worldperhaps also in
anotherhad he been a fool. As it was, he was no fool: he was not to be done, not he; he knew, no one
better, the value of a shilling; he knew, also, how to keep his shillings, and how to spend them. He consorted
much with blacklegs and suchlike because blacklegs were to his taste. But he boasted daily, nay, hourly to
himself, and frequently to those around him, that the leeches who were stuck round him could draw but little
blood from him. He could spend his money freely; but he would so spend it that he himself might reap the
gratification of the expenditure. He was acute, crafty, knowing, and up to every damnable dodge practised by
men of the class with whom he lived. At oneandtwenty he was that most odious of all odious charactersa
closefisted reprobate.
He was a small man, not illmade by Nature, but reduced to unnatural tenuity by dissipationa corporeal
attribute of which he was apt to boast, as it enabled him, as he said, to put himself up at 7st 7lb without any
'd nonsense of not eating and drinking'. The power, however, was one of which he did not often avail
himself, as his nerves were seldom in a fit state for riding. His hair was dark red, and he wore red
moustaches, and a great deal of red beard beneath his chin, cut in a manner to make him look like an
American. His voice also had a Yankee twang, being a cross between that of an American trader and an
English groom; and his eyes were keen and fixed, and cold and knowing.
Such was the son whom Sir Roger saw standing at his bedside when first he awoke to his consciousness. It
must not be supposed that Sir Roger looked at him with our eyes. To him he was an only child, the heir of his
wealth, the future bearer of his title; the most heartstirring remembrancer of those days, when he had been
so much a poorer, and so much a happier man. Let that boy be bad or good, he was all Sir Roger had; and the
father was still able to hope, when others thought that all ground for hope was gone.
The mother also loved her son with a mother's natural love; but Louis had ever been ashamed of his mother,
and had, as far as possible, estranged himself from her. Her heart, perhaps, fixed itself almost with almost a
warmer love on Frank Gresham, her fosterson. Frank she saw but seldom, but when she did see him he
never refused her embrace. There was, too, a joyous, genial lustre about Frank's face which always endeared
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD 174
Page No 178
him to women, and made his former nurse regard him as the pet creation of the age. Though she but seldom
interfered with any monetary arrangement of her husband's, yet once or twice she had ventured to hint that a
legacy left to the young squire would make her a happy woman. Sir Roger, however, on these occasions had
not appeared very desirous of making his wife happy.
'Ah, Louis! is that you?' ejaculated Sir Roger, in tones hardly more than halfformed: afterwards in a day or
two that is, he fully recovered his voice; but just then he could hardly open his jaws, and spoke almost
through his teeth. He managed, however, to put out his hand and lay it on the counterpane, so that his son
could take it.
'Why, that's well, governor,' said the son; 'you'll be as right as a trivet in a day or twoeh, governor?'
The 'governor' smiled with a ghastly smile. He already pretty well knew that he would never again be 'right'
as his son called it, on that side of the grave. It did not, moreover, suit him to say much just at that moment,
so he contented himself with holding his son's hand. He lay still in this position for a moment, and then,
turning round painfully on his side, endeavoured to put his hand to the place where his dire enemy usually
was concealed. Sir Roger, however, was too weak now to be his own master; he was at length, though too
late, a captive in the hands of nurses and doctors, and the bottle had now been removed.
Then Lady Scatcherd came in, and seeing that her husband was not longer unconscious, she could not but
believe that Dr Thorne had been wrong; she could not but think that there must be some ground for hope. She
threw herself on her knees at the bedside bursting into tears as she did so, and taking Sir Roger's hand in hers
and covered it with kisses.
'Bother!' said Sir Roger.
She did not, however, long occupy herself with the indulgence of her feelings; but going speedily to work,
produced such sustenance as the doctors had ordered to be given when the patient might awake. A
breakfastcup was brought to him, and a few drops were put into his mouth; but he soon made it manifest
that he would take nothing more of a description so perfectly innocent.
'A drop of brandyjust a little drop,' said he, halfordering, halfentreating.
'Ah, Roger,' said Lady Scatcherd.
'Just a little drop, Louis,' said the sick man, appealing to his son.
'A little will be good for him; bring the bottle, mother,' said the son.
After some altercation the brandy bottle was brought, and Louis, with what a thought a very sparing hand,
proceeded to pour about half a wineglass into the cup. As he did so, Sir Roger, weak as he was, contrived
to shake his son's arm, so as greatly to increase the dose.
'Ha! ha! ha!' laughed the sick man, and then greedily swallowed the dose.
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES
That night the doctor stayed at Boxall Hill, and the next night; so that it became a customary thing for him to
sleep there during the latter part of Sir Roger's illness. He returned home to Greshamsbury; for he had his
patients there, to whom he was as necessary as to Sir Roger, the foremost of whom was Lady Arabella. He
had, therefore, no slight work on his hands, seeing that his nights were by no means wholly devoted to rest.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 175
Page No 179
Mr Rerechild had not been much wrong as to the remaining space of life which he had allotted to the dying
man. Once or twice Dr Thorne had thought that the great original strength of his patient would have enabled
him to fight against death for a somewhat longer period; but Sir Roger would give himself no chance.
Whenever he was strong enough to have a will of his own, he insisted on having his very medicine mixed
with brandy; and in the hours of the doctor's absence, he was too often successful in his attempts.
'It does not much matter,' Dr Thorne had said to Lady Scatcherd. 'Do what you can to keep down the quantity,
but do not irritate him by refusing to obey. It does not much signify now.' So Lady Scatcherd still
administered the alcohol, and he from day to day invented little schemes for increasing the amount, over
which he chuckled with ghastly laughter.
Two or three times these days Sir Roger essayed to speak seriously to his son; but Louis always frustrated
him. He either got out of the room on some excuse, or made his mother interfere on the score that so much
talking would be bad for his father. He already knew with tolerable accuracy what was the purport of his
father's will, and by no means approved of it; but as he could not now hope to induce his father to alter it so
as to make it more favourable to himself, he conceived that no conversation on matters of business could be
of use to him.
'Louis,' said Sir Roger, one afternoon to his son; 'Louis, I have not done by you as I ought to have doneI
know that now.'
'Nonsense, governor; never mind about it now; I shall do well enough I dare say. Besides, it isn't too late; you
can make it twentythree years instead of twentyfive.'
'I do not mean as to money, Louis. There are things besides money which a father ought to look to.'
'Now, father, don't fret yourselfI'm all right; you may be sure of that.'
'Louis, it's that accursed brandyit's that that I'm afraid of: you see me here, my boy, I'm lying here now.'
'Don't you be annoying yourself, governor; I'm all rightquite right; and as for you, why, you'll be up and
about yourself in another month or so.'
'I shall never be off this bed, my boy, till I'm carried into my coffin, on those chairs there. But I'm not
thinking of myself, Louis, but you; think what you may have before you if you can't avoid that accursed
bottle.'
'I'm all right, governor; right as a trivet. It's very little I take, except at an odd time or two.'
'Oh, Louis! Louis!'
'Come, father, cheer up; this sort of thing isn't the thing for you at all. I wonder where mother is: she ought to
be here with the broth; just let me go, and I'll see for her.'
The father understood it all. He saw that it was now much beyond his faded powers to touch the heart or
conscience of such a youth as his son had become. What now could he do for his boy except die? What else,
what other benefit, did his son require of him but to die; to die so that his means of dissipation might be
unbounded? He let go the unresisting hand which he held, and, as the young man crept out of the room, he
turned his face to the wall. He turned his face to the wall, and held bitter commune with his own heart. To
what had he brought himself? To what had he brought his son? Oh, how happy would it have been for him
could he have remained all his days a working stonemason in Barchester! How happy could he have died as
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 176
Page No 180
such, years ago! Such tears as those which wet the pillow are the bitterest which human eyes can shed.
But while they were dropping, the memoir of his life was in quick course of preparation. It was, indeed,
nearly completed, with considerable detail. He had lingered on four days longer than might have been
expected, and the author had thus had more than usual time for the work. In these days a man is nobody
unless his biography is kept so far posted up that it may be ready for the national breakfasttable on the
morning after his demise. When it chances that the dead hero is one who is taken in his prime of life, of
whose departure from among us the most farseeing, biographical scribe can have no prophetic inkling, this
must be difficult. Of great men, full of years, who are ripe of the sickle, who in the course of Nature must
soon fall, it is of course comparatively easy for an active compiler to have his complete memoir ready in his
desk. But in order that the idea of omnipresent and omniscient information may be kept up, the young must
be chronicled as quickly as the old. In some cases this task must, one would say, be difficult. Nevertheless it
is done.
The memoir of Sir Roger Scatcherd was progressing favourably. In this it was told how fortunate had been
his life; now, in his case, industry and genius combined had triumphed over the difficulties which humble
birth and deficient education had thrown in his way; how he had made a name among England's great men;
how the Queen had delighted to honour him, and nobles had been proud to have him as a guest at their
mansions. Then followed a list of all the great works which he had achieved, of the railroads, canals, docks,
harbours, jails, and hospitals which he had constructed. His name was held up as an example to the labouring
classes of his countrymen, and he was pointed at as one who had lived and died happyever happy, said the
biographer, because ever industrious. And so a great moral question was inculcated. A short paragraph was
devoted to his appearance in Parliament; and unfortunate Mr Romer was again held up for disgrace, for the
thirtieth time, as having been the means of depriving our legislative councils of the great assistance of Sir
Roger's experience.
'Sir Roger,' said the biographer in his concluding passage, 'was possessed of an iron frame; but even iron will
yield to the repeated blows of the hammer. In the latter years of his life he was known to overtask himself;
and at length the body gave way, though the mind remained firm to the last. The subject of this memoir was
only fiftynine when he was taken from us.'
And thus Sir Roger's life was written, while the tears were yet falling on his pillow at Boxall Hill. It was a
pity that a proofsheet could not have been sent to him. No man was vainer of his reputation, and it would
have greatly gratified him to know that posterity was about to speak of him in such termsto speak of him
with a voice that would be audible for twentyfour hours.
Sir Roger made no further attempt to give counsel to his son. It was too evidently useless. The old dying lion
felt that the lion's power had already passed from him, and that he was helpless in the hands of the young cub
who was so soon to inherit the wealth of the forest. But Dr Thorne was more kind to him. He had something
yet to say as to his worldly hopes and worldly cares; and his old friend did not turn a deaf ear to him.
It was during the night that Sir Roger was most anxious to talk, and most capable of talking. He would lie
through the day in a state halfcomatose; but towards evening would rouse himself, and by midnight he
would be full of fitful energy. One night, as he lay wakeful and full of thought, he thus poured forth his whole
heart to Dr Thorne.
'Thorne,' said he, 'I told you about my will, you know.'
'Yes,' said the other; 'and I have blamed myself greatly that I have not again urged you to alter it. Your illness
came too suddenly, Scatcherd; and then I was averse to speak of it.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 177
Page No 181
'Why should I alter it? It is a good will; as good as I can make. Not but that I have altered it since I spoke to
you. I did it that day after you left me.'
'Have you definitely named your heir in default of Louis?'
'Nothat isyesI had done that before; I have said Mary's eldest child: I have not altered that.'
'But, Scatcherd, you must alter it.'
'Must! well then, I won't; but I'll tell you what I have done. I have added a postscripta codicil they call
itsaying that you, and you only, know who is her eldest child. Winterbones and Jack Martin have
witnessed that.'
Dr Thorne was going to explain how very injudicious such an arrangement appeared to be; but Sir Roger
would not listen to him. It was not about that that he wished to speak to him. To him it was a matter of but
minor interest who might inherit his money if his son should die early; his care was solely for his son's
welfare. At twentyfive the heir might make his own willmight bequeath all this wealth according to his
own fancy. Sir Roger would not bring himself to believe that his son could follow him to the grave in so short
a time.
'Never mind that, doctor, now; but about Louis; you will be his guardian, you know.'
'Not his guardian. He is more than of age.'
'Ah! but doctor, you will be his guardian. The property will not be his till he be twentyfive. You will not
desert him?'
'I will not desert him; but I doubt whether I can do much for himwhat can I do, Scatcherd?'
'Use the power that a strong man has over a weak one. Use the power that my will will give you. Do for him
as you would for a son of your own if you saw him going in bad courses. Do as a friend should do for a friend
that is dead and gone. I would do so for you, doctor, if our places were changed.'
'What can I do, that I will do,' said Thorne, solemnly, taking as he spoke the contractor's own in his own with
a tight grasp.
'I know you will; I know you will. Oh! doctor, may you never feel as I do now! May you on your deathbed
have no dread as I have, as to the fate of those you will leave behind you!'
Doctor Thorne felt that he could not say much in answer to this. The future fate of Louis Scatcherd was, he
could not but own to himself, greatly to be dreaded. What good, what happiness, could be presaged for such a
one as he was? What comfort could he offer to the father? And then he was called on to compare, as it were,
the prospects of this unfortunate with those of his own darling; to contrast all that was murky, foul, and
disheartening, with all that was perfectfor to him she was all but perfect; to liken Louis Scatcherd to the
angel who brightened his own hearthstone. How could he answer to such an appeal?
He said nothing; but merely tightened his grasp of the other's hand, to signify that he would do, as best he
could, all that was asked of him. Sir Roger looked up sadly into the doctor's face, as though expecting some
word of consolation. There was no comfort, no consolation.
'For three or four years, he must greatly depend on you,' continued Sir Roger.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 178
Page No 182
'I will do what I can,' said the doctor. 'What I can do I will do. But he is not a child, Scatcherd: at his age he
must stand or fall mainly by his own conduct. The best thing for him will be to marry.'
'Exactly; that's just it, Thorne: I was coming to that. If he would marry, I think he would do well yet, for all
that has come and gone. If he married, of course you would let him have the command of his own income.'
'I will be governed entirely by your wishes: under any circumstances his income will, as I understand, be
quite sufficient for him, married or single.'
'Ah!but, Thorne, I should like to think he should shine with the best of them. For what I have made the
money for if not for that? Now if he marriesdecently, that issome woman you know that can assist him
in the world, let him have what he wants. It is not to save the money that I have put it into your hands.'
'No, Scatcherd; not to save the money, but to save him. I think that while you are yet with him you should
advise him to marry.'
'He does not care a straw for what I advise, not one straw. Why should he? How can I tell him to be sober
when I have been a beast all my life? How can I advise him? That's where it is! It is that that now kills me.
Advise! Why, when I speak to him he treats me like a child.'
'He fears that you are too weak, you know: he thinks that you should not be allowed to talk.'
'Nonsense! he knows better; you know better. Too weak! what signifies? Would I not give all that I have of
strength at one blow if I could open his eyes to see as I see but for one minute?' And the sick man raised
himself in his bed as though he were actually going to expend all that remained to him of vigour in the energy
of the moment.
'Gently, Scatcherd; gently. He will listen to you yet; but do not be so unruly.'
'Thorne, you see that bottle there? Give me half a glass of brandy.'
The doctor turned round in his chair; but he hesitated in doing as he was desired.
'Do as I ask you, doctor. It can do no harm now; you know that well enough. Why torture me now?'
'No, I will not torture you; but you will have water with it?'
'Water! No; the brandy by itself. I tell you I cannot speak without it. What's the use of canting now? You
know it can make no difference.'
Sir Roger was right. It could make no difference; and Dr Thorne gave him the half glass of brandy.
'Ah, well; you've a stingy hand, doctor; confounded stingy. You don't measure your medicines out in such
light doses.'
'You will be wanting more before morning, you know.'
'Before morning! indeed I shall; a pint or two before that. I remember the time, doctor, when I have drunk to
my own cheek above two quarts between dinner and breakfast! aye, and worked all day after it!'
'You have been a wonderful man, Scatcherd, very wonderful.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 179
Page No 183
'Aye, wonderful! well, never mind. It's over now. But what was I saying?about Louis, doctor; you'll not
desert him?'
'Certainly not.'
'He's not strong; I know that. How should he be strong, living as he has done? Not that it seemed to hurt me
when I was his age.'
'You had the advantage of hard work.'
'That's it. Sometimes I wish that Louis had not a shilling in the world; that he had to trudge about with an
apron round his waist as I did. But it's too late now to think of that. If he would marry, doctor.'
Dr Thorne again expressed an opinion that no step would be so likely to reform the habits of the young heir
as marriage; and repeated his advice to the father to implore his son to take a wife.
'I'll tell you what, Thorne,' said he. And then, after a pause, he went on. 'I have not half told you as yet what is
on my mind; and I'm nearly afraid to tell it; though, indeed, I don't know what I should be.'
'I never knew you afraid of anything yet,' said the doctor, smiling gently.
'Well, then, I'll not end by turning coward. Now, doctor, tell the truth to me; what do you expect me to do for
that girl of yours that we were talking ofMary's child?'
There was a pause for a moment, for Thorne was slow to answer him.
'You would not let me see her, you know, though she is my niece as truly as yours.'
'Nothing,' at last said the doctor, slowly. 'I expect nothing. I would not let you see her, and therefore, I expect
nothing.'
'She will have it all if poor Louis should die,' said Sir Roger.
'If you intend it so you should put her name into the will,' said the other. 'Not that I ask you or wish you to do
so. Mary, thank God, can do without wealth.'
'Thorne, on one condition I will put her name into it. I will alter it on one condition. Let the two cousins be
man and wifelet Louis marry poor Mary's child.'
The proposition for a moment took away the doctor's breath, and he was unable to answer. Not for all the
wealth of India would he have given up his lamb to that young wolf, even though he had had the power to do
so. But that lamblamb though she washad, as he well knew, a will of her own on such a matter. What
alliance could be more impossible, thought he to himself, than one between Mary Thorne and Louis
Scatcherd?
'I will alter it all if you will give me your hand upon it that you will do your best to bring about this marriage.
Everything shall be his on the day he marries her; and should he die unmarried, it shall all then be hers by
name. Say the word, Thorne, and she shall come here at once. I shall yet have time to see her.'
But Dr Thorne did not say the word; just at the moment he said nothing, but he slowly shook his head.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 180
Page No 184
'Why not, Thorne?'
'My friend, it is impossible.'
'Why impossible?'
'Her hand is not mine to dispose of, nor is her heart.'
'Then let her come over herself.'
'What! Scatcherd, that the son might make love to her while the father is so dangerously ill! Bid her come to
look for a rich husband! That would not be seemly, would it?'
'No; not for that: let her come merely that I may see her; that we may all know her. I will leave the matter
then in your hands if you will promise me to do your best.'
'But, my friend, in this matter I cannot do my best. I can do nothing. And, indeed, I may say at once, that it is
altogether out of the question. I know'
'What do you know?' said the baronet, turning on him almost angrily. 'What can you know to make you say
that it is impossible? Is she a pearl of such price that a man may not win her?'
'She is a pearl of great price.'
'Believe me, doctor, money goes far in winning such pearls.'
'Perhaps so; I know little about it. But this I do know, that money will not win her. Let us talk of something
else; believe me, it is useless for us to think of this.'
'Yes; if you set your face against it obstinately. You must think very poorly of Louis if you suppose that no
girl can fancy him.'
'I have not said so, Scatcherd.'
'To have the spending of ten thousand a year, and be a baronet's lady! Why, doctor, what is it you expect for
this girl?'
'Not much, indeed; not much. A quiet heart and a quiet home; not much more.'
'Thorne, if you will be ruled by me in this, she shall be the most topping woman in this county.'
'My friend, my friend, why thus grieve me? Why should you thus harass yourself? I tell you it is impossible.
They have never seen each other; they have nothing, and can have nothing in common; their tastes, and
wishes, and pursuits are different. Besides, Scatcherd, marriages never answer that are so made; believe me, it
is impossible.'
The contractor threw himself back on his bed, and lay for some ten minutes perfectly quiet; so much so that
the doctor began to think that he was sleeping. So thinking, and wearied by the watching, Dr Thorne was
beginning to creep quietly from the room, when his companion again roused himself, almost with
vehemence.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 181
Page No 185
'You won't do this thing for me, then?' said he.
'Do it! It is not for you or me to do such things as that. Such things must be left to those concerned
themselves.'
'You will not even help me?'
'Not in this thing, Sir Roger.'
'Then by , she shall not under any circumstances ever have a shilling of mine. Give me some of that stuff
there,' and he again pointed to the brandy bottle which stood ever within his sight.'
The doctor poured out and handed to him another small modicum of spirit.
'Nonsense, man; fill the glass. I'll stand no nonsense now. I'll be master of my own house to the last. Give it
here, I tell you. Ten thousand devils are tearing me within. Youyou could have comforted me; but you
would not. Fill the glass I tell you.'
'I should be killing you were I to do it.'
'Killing me! killing me! you are always talking of killing me. Do you suppose that I am afraid to die? Do not
I know how soon it is coming? Give me the brandy, I say, or I will be out across the room to fetch it.'
'No, Scatcherd. I cannot give it to you; not while I am here. Do you remember how you were engaged this
morning?'he had that morning taken the sacrament from the parish clergyman'you would not wish to
make me guilty of murder, would you?'
'Nonsense! You are talking nonsense; habit is second nature. I tell you I shall sink without it. Why, you
know, I always get it directly your back it turned. Come, I will not be bullied in my own house; give me that
bottle, I say!'and Sir Roger essayed, vainly enough, to raise himself from the bed.
'Stop, Scatcherd; I will give it to youI will help you. It may be that habit is second nature.' Sir Roger in his
determined energy had swallowed, without thinking of it, the small quantity which the doctor had before
poured out for him, and still held the empty glass within his hand. This the doctor now took and filled nearly
to the brim.
'Come, Thorne, a bumper; a bumper for this once. "Whatever the drink, it a bumper must be." You stingy
fellow! I would not treat you so. Wellwell.'
'It's about as full as you can hold it, Scatcherd.'
'Try me; try me! my hand is a rock; at least at holding liquor.' And then he drained the contents of the glass,
which were in sufficient quantity to have taken away the breath of any ordinary man.
'Ah, I'm better now. But, Thorne, I do love a full glass, ha! ha! ha!'
There was something frightful, almost sickening, in the peculiar hoarse guttural tone of his voice. The sounds
came from him as though steeped in brandy, and told, all too plainly, the havoc which the alcohol had made.
There was a fire too about his eyes which contrasted with his sunken cheeks: his hanging jaw, unshorn beard,
and haggard face were terrible to look at. His hands and arms were hot and clammy, but so thin and wasted!
Of his lower limbs the lost use had not returned to him, so that in all his efforts at vehemence he was
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 182
Page No 186
controlled by his own want of vitality. When he supported himself, halfsitting against the pillows, he was in
a continual tremor; and yet, as he boasted, he could still lift his glass steadily to his mouth. Such now was the
hero of whom that ready compiler of memoirs had just finished his correct and succinct account.
After he had had his brandy, he sat glaring a while at vacancy, as though he was dead to all around him, and
was thinkingthinkingthinking of things in the infinite distance of the past.
'Shall I go now,' said the doctor, 'and send Lady Scatcherd to you?'
'Wait a while, doctor; just one minute longer. So you will do nothing for Louis, then?'
'I will do everything for him that I can do.'
'Ah, yes! everything but the one thing that will save him. Well, I will not ask you again. But remember,
Thorne, I shall alter my will tomorrow.'
'Do so, by all means; you may well alter it for the better. If I may advise you, you will have down your own
business attorney from London. If you will let me send he will be here before tomorrow night.'
'Thank you for nothing, Thorne: I can manage that matter myself. Now leave me; but remember, you have
ruined that girl's fortune.'
The doctor did leave him, and went not altogether happy to his room. He could not but confess to himself that
he had, despite himself as it were, fed himself with hope that Mary's future might be made more secure, aye,
and brighter too, by some small unheeded fraction broken off from the huge mass of her uncle's wealth. Such
hope, if it had amounted to hope, was now all gone. But this was not all, nor was this the worst of it. That he
had done right in utterly repudiating all idea of a marriage between Mary and her cousinof that he was
certain enough; that no earthly consideration would have induced Mary to plight her troth to such a
manthat, with him, was as certain as doom. But how far had he done right in keeping her from the sight of
her uncle? How could he justify it to himself if he had thus robbed her of her inheritance, seeing that he had
done so from a selfish fear lest she, who was now all his own, should be known to the world as belonging to
others rather than to him? He had taken upon him on her behalf to reject wealth as valueless; and yet he had
no sooner done so than he began to consume his hours with reflecting how great to her would be the value of
wealth. And thus, when Sir Roger told him, as he left the room, that he had ruined Mary's fortune, he was
hardly able to bear the taunt with equanimity.
On the next morning, after paying his professional visit to his patient, and satisfying himself that the end was
now drawing near with steps terribly quickened, he went down to Greshamsbury.
'How long is this to last, uncle?' said his niece, with sad voice, as he again prepared to return to Boxall Hill.
'Not long, Mary; do not begrudge him a few more hours of life.'
'No, I do not, uncle. I will say nothing more about it. Is his son with him?' And then, perversely enough, she
persisted in asking numerous questions about Louis Scatcherd.
'Is he likely to marry, uncle?'
'I hope so, my dear.'
'Will he be so very rich?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 183
Page No 187
'Yes; ultimately he will be very rich.'
'He will be a baronet, will he not?'
'Yes, my dear.'
'What is he like, uncle?'
'LikeI never know what a young man is like. He is like a man with red hair.'
'Uncle, you are the worst hand in describing I ever knew. If I'd seen him for five minutes, I'd be bound to
make a portrait of him; and you, if you were describing a dog, you'd only say what colour his hair was.'
'Well, he's a little man.'
'Exactly, just as I should say that Mrs Umbleby had a redhaired little dog. I wish I had known these
Scatcherds, uncle. I do admire people that can push themselves in the world. I wish I had known Sir Roger.'
'You will never know him, Mary.'
'I suppose not. I am so sorry for him. Is Lady Scatcherd nice?'
'She is an excellent woman.'
'I hope I may know her some day. You are so much there now, uncle; I wonder whether you ever mention me
to them. If you do, tell her from me how much I grieve for her.'
That same night, Dr Thorne again found himself alone with Sir Roger. The sick man was much more tranquil,
and apparently more at ease than he had been on the preceding night. He said nothing about his will, and not
a word about Mary Thorne; but the doctor knew that Winterbones and a notary's clerk from Barchester had
been in the bedroom a great part of the day; and, as he knew also that the great man of business was
accustomed to do his most important work by the hands of such tools as these, he did not doubt but that the
will had been altered and remodelled. Indeed, he thought it more than probable, that when it was opened it
would be found to be wholly different in its provisions from that which Sir Roger had already described.
'Louis is clever enough,' he said, 'sharp enough, I mean. He won't squander the property.'
'He has good natural abilities,' said the doctor.
'Excellent, excellent,' said the father. 'He may do well, very well, if he can only be kept from this;' and Sir
Roger held up the empty wineglass which stood by his bedside. 'What a life he may have before him!and
to throw it away for this!' and as he spoke he took the glass and tossed it across the room. 'Oh, doctor! would
that it were all to begin again!'
'We all wish that, I dare say, Scatcherd.'
'No, you don't wish it. You ain't worth a shilling, and yet you regret nothing. I am worth half a million in one
way or another, and I regret everythingeverythingeverything!'
'You should not think that way, Scatcherd; you need not think so. Yesterday you told Mr Clarke that you
were comfortable in your mind.' Mr Clarke was the clergyman who had visited him.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 184
Page No 188
'Of course I did. What else could I say when he asked me? It wouldn't have been civil to have told him that
his time and words were all thrown away. But, Thorne, believe me, when a man's heart is sadsadsad to
the core, a few words from a parson at the last moment will never make it right.'
'May He have mercy on you, my friend!if you will think of Him, and look to Him, He will have mercy on
you.'
'WellI will try, doctor; but would that it were all to do again. You'll see to the old woman for my sake,
won't you?'
'What, Lady Scatcherd?'
'Lady Devil! If anything angers me now it is that "ladyship"her to be my lady! Why, when I came out of
jail that time, the poor creature had hardly a shoe to her foot. But it wasn't her fault, Thorne; it was none of
her doing. She never asked for such nonsense.'
'She has been an excellent wife, Scatcherd; and what is more, she is an excellent woman. She is, and ever will
be, one of my dearest friends.'
'Thank'ee, doctor, thank'ee. Yes; she has been a good wifebetter for a poor man than a rich one; but then,
that was what she was born to. You won't let her be knocked about by them, will you, Thorne?'
Dr Thorne again assured him, that as long as he lived Lady Scatcherd should never want one true friend; in
making this promise, however, he managed to drop all allusion to the obnoxious title.
'You'll be with him as much as possible, won't you?' again asked the baronet, after lying quite silent for a
quarter of an hour.
'With whom?' said the doctor, who was then all but asleep.
'With my poor boy, Louis.'
'If he will let me, I will,' said the doctor.
'And, doctor, when you see a glass at his mouth, dash it down; thrust it down, though you thrust out the teeth
with it. When you see that, Thorne, tell him of his fathertell him what his father might have been but for
that; tell him how his father died like a beast, because he could not keep himself from drink.'
These, reader, were the last words spoken by Sir Roger Scatcherd. As he uttered them he rose up in bed with
the same vehemence which he had shown on the former evening. But in the very act of doing so he was again
struck by paralysis, and before nine on the following morning all was over.
'Oh, my manmy own, own man!' exclaimed the widow, remembering in the paroxysm of her grief nothing
but the loves of their early days; 'the best, the brightest, the cleverest of them all!'
Some weeks after this Sir Roger was buried, with much pomp and ceremony, within the precincts of
Barchester Cathedral; and a monument was put up to him soon after, in which he was portrayed, as
smoothing a block of granite with a mallet and chisel; while his eagle eye, disdaining such humble work, was
fixed upon some intricate mathematical instrument above him. Could Sir Roger have seen it himself, he
would probably have declared, that no workman was ever worth his salt who looked one way while he rowed
another.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES 185
Page No 189
Immediately after the funeral the will was opened, and Dr Thorne discovered that the clauses of it were
exactly identical with those his friend had described to him some months back. Nothing had been altered; nor
had the document been unfolded since that strange codicil had been added, in which it was declared that Dr
Thorne knewand only Dr Thornewho was the eldest child of the testator's only sister. At the same time,
however, a joint executor with Dr Thorne had been namedone Mr Stock, a man of railway fameand Dr
Thorne himself was made a legatee to the humble extent of a thousand pounds. A life income of a thousand
pounds a year was left to Lady Scatcherd.
CHAPTER XXVI. WAR
We need not follow Sir Roger to his grave, nor partake of the baked meats which were furnished for his
funeral banquet. Such men as Sir Roger Scatcherd are always well buried, and we have already seen that his
glories were duly told to posterity in the graphic diction of his sepulchral monument. In a few days the doctor
had returned to his quite home and Sir Louis found himself reigning at Boxall Hill in his father's steadwith,
however, a much diminished sway, and, as he thought it, but a poor exchequer. We must soon return to him
and say something of his career as a baronet; but for the present, we may go back to our more pleasant friends
at Greshamsbury.
But our friends at Greshamsbury had not been making themselves pleasantnot so pleasant to each other as
circumstances would have admitted. In those days which the doctor had felt himself bound to pass, if not
altogether at Boxall Hill, yet altogether away from his own home, so as to admit of his being as much as
possible with his patient, Mary had been thrown more than ever with Patience Oriel, and, also, almost more
than ever with Beatrice Gresham. As regarded Mary, she would doubtless have preferred the companionship
of Patience, though she loved Beatrice far the best; but she had no choice. When she went to the parsonage
Beatrice came there also, and when Patience came to the doctor's house Beatrice either accompanied or
followed her. Mary could hardly have rejected their society, even had she felt it wise to do so. She would in
such case have been all alone, and her severance from the Greshamsbury house and household, from the big
family in which she had for so many years been almost at home, would have made such solitude almost
unendurable.
And then these two girls both knewnot her secret; she had no secretbut the little history of her
illtreatment. They knew that though she had been blameless in this matter, yet she had been the one to bear
the punishment; and, as girls and bosom friends, they could not but sympathize with her, and endow her with
heroic attributes; make her, in fact, as we are doing, their little heroine for the nonce. This was, perhaps, not
serviceable for Mary; but it was far from being disagreeable.
The tendency to finding matter for heroworship in Mary's endurance was much stronger with Beatrice than
with Miss Oriel. Miss Oriel was the elder, and naturally less afflicted with the sentimentation of romance.
She had thrown herself into Mary's arms because she had seen that it was essentially necessary for Mary's
comfort that she should do so. She was anxious to make her friend smile, and to smile with her. Beatrice was
quite as true in her sympathy; but she rather wished that she and Mary might weep in unison, shed mutual
tears, and break their hearts together.
Patience had spoken of Frank's love as a misfortune, of his conduct as erroneous, and to be excused only by
his youth, and had never appeared to surmise that Mary also might be in love as well as he. But to Beatrice
the affair was a tragic difficulty, admitting of no solution; a Gordian knot, not to be cut; a misery now and for
ever. She would always talk about Frank when she and Mary were alone; and, to speak the truth, Mary did
not stop her as she perhaps should have done.
As for a marriage between them, that was impossible; Beatrice was well sure of that: it was Frank's
unfortunate destiny that he must marry moneymoney, and, as Beatrice sometimes thoughtlessly added,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVI. WAR 186
Page No 190
cutting Mary to the quick,money and family also. Under such circumstances a marriage between them was
quite impossible; but not the less did Beatrice declare, that she would have loved Mary as her sisterinlaw
had it been possible; and how worthy Frank was of a girl's love, had such love been possible.
'It is so cruel,' Beatrice would say; 'so very, very, cruel. You would have suited him in every way.'
'Nonsense, Trichy; I should have suited him in no possible way at all; nor he me.'
'Oh, but you wouldexactly. Papa loves you so well.'
'And mamma; that would have been so nice.'
'Yes; and mamma, toothat is, had you had a fortune,' said the daughter, naively. 'She always liked you
personally, always.'
'Did she?'
'Always. And we all love you so.'
'Especially Lady Alexandrina.'
'That would not have signified, for Frank cannot endure the De Courcys himself.'
'My dear, it does not matter one straw whom your brother can endure or not endure just at present. His
character is to be formed, and his tastes, and his heart also.'
'Oh, Mary!his heart.'
'Yes, his heart; not the fact of his having a heart. I think he has a heart; but he himself does not yet understand
it.'
'Oh, Mary! you do not know him.'
Such conversations were not without danger to poor Mary's comfort. It came soon to be the case that she
looked rather for this sort of sympathy from Beatrice, than for Miss Oriel's pleasant but less piquant gaiety.
So the days of the doctor's absence were passed, and so also the first week after his return. During this week
it was almost daily necessary that the squire should be with him. The doctor was now the legal holder of Sir
Roger's property, and, as such, the holder also of all the mortgages on Mr Gresham's property; and it was
natural that they should be much together. The doctor would not, however, go up to Greshamsbury on any
other than medical business; and it therefore became necessary that the squire should be a good deal at the
doctor's house.
Then the Lady Arabella became unhappy in her mind. Frank, it was true, was away at Cambridge, and had
been successfully kept out of Mary's way since the suspicion of danger had fallen upon Lady Arabella's mind.
Frank was away, and Mary was systematically banished, with due acknowledgement from all the powers in
Greshamsbury. But this was not enough for Lady Arabella as long as her daughter still habitually consorted
with the female culprit, and as long as her husband consorted with the male culprit. It seemed to Lady
Arabella at this moment as though, in banishing Mary from the house, she had in effect banished herself from
the most intimate of the Greshamsbury social circles. She magnified in her own mind the importance of the
conferences between the girls, and was not without some fear that the doctor might be talking the squire over
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVI. WAR 187
Page No 191
into very dangerous compliance.
Her object was to break of all confidential intercourse between Beatrice and Mary, and to interrupt, as far as
she could do it, that between the doctor and the squire. This, it may be said, could be more easily done by
skilful management within her own household. She had, however, tried that and failed. She had said much to
Beatrice as to the imprudence of her friendship with Mary, and she had done this purposely before the squire;
injudiciously howeverfor the squire had immediately taken Mary's part, and had declared that he had no
wish to see a quarrel between his family and that of the doctor; that Mary Thorne was in every way a good
girl, and an eligible friend for his own child; and had ended by declaring, that he would not have Mary
persecuted for Frank's fault. This had not been the end, nor nearly the end of what had been said on the matter
at Greshamsbury; but the end, when it came, came in this wise, that Lady Arabella determined to say a few
words to the doctor as to the expediency of forbidding familiar intercourse between Mary and any of the
Greshamsbury people.
With this view Lady Arabella absolutely bearded the lion in his den, the doctor in his shop. She had heard
that both Mary and Beatrice were to pass a certain afternoon at the parsonage, and took that opportunity of
calling at the doctor's house. A period of many years had passed since she had last so honoured that abode.
Mary, indeed, had been so much one of her own family that the ceremony of calling on her had never been
thought necessary; and thus, unless Mary had been absolutely ill, there would have been nothing to bring her
ladyship to the house. All this she knew would add to the importance of the occasion, and she judged it
prudent to make the occasion as important as it might well be.
She was so far successful that she soon found herself teteatete with the doctor in his own study. She was
no whit dismayed by the pair of human thighbones which lay close to his hand, and which, when he was
talking in that den of his own, he was in the constant habit of handling with much energy; nor was she
frightened out of her propriety even by the little child's skull which grinned at her from off the
chimneypiece.
'Doctor,' she said, as soon as the first complimentary greetings were over, speaking in her kindest and most
wouldbeconfidential tone. 'Doctor, I am still uneasy about that boy of mine, and I have thought it best to
come and see you at once, and tell you freely what I think.'
The doctor bowed, and said that he was very sorry that she should have any cause for uneasiness about his
young friend Frank.
'Indeed, I am very uneasy, doctor; and having, as I do have, such reliance on your prudence, and such perfect
confidence in your friendship, I have thought it best to come and speak to you openly:' thereupon the Lady
Arabella paused, and the doctor bowed again.
'Nobody knows so well as you do the dreadful state of the squire's affairs.'
'Not so dreadful; not so very dreadful,' said the doctor, mildly: 'that is, as far as I know.'
'Yes they are, doctor; very dreadful; very dreadful indeed. You know how much he owes to this young man: I
do not, for the squire never tells anything to me; but I know that it is a very large sum of money; enough to
swamp the estate and ruin Frank. Now I call that very dreadful.'
'No, not ruin him, Lady Arabella; not ruin him, I hope.'
'However, I did not come to talk to you about that. As I said before, I know nothing of the squire's affairs,
and, as a matter of course, I do not ask you to tell me. But I am sure you will agree with me in this that, as a
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVI. WAR 188
Page No 192
mother, I cannot but be interested about my only son,' and Lady Arabella put her cambric handkerchief to her
eyes.
'Of course you are; of course you are,' said the doctor; 'and, Lady Arabella, my opinion of Frank is such, that
I feel sure that he will do well;' and, in his energy, Dr Thorne brandished one of the thighbones almost in the
lady's face.
'I hope he will; I am sure I hope he will. But, doctor, he has such dangers to contend with; he is so warm and
impulsive that I fear his heart will bring him into trouble. Now, you know, unless Frank marries money he is
lost.'
The doctor made no answer to this last appeal, but as he sat and listened a slight frown came across his brow.
'He must marry money, doctor. Now we have, you see, with your assistance, contrived to separate him from
dear Mary'
'With my assistance, Lady Arabella! I have given no assistance, nor have I meddled in the matter; nor will I.'
'Well, doctor, perhaps not meddled; but you agreed with me, you know, that the two young people had been
imprudent.'
'I agreed to no such thing, Lady Arabella; never, never. I not only never agreed that Mary had been
imprudent, but I will not agree to it now, and will not allow any one to assert it in my presence without
contradicting it:' and then the doctor worked away at the thighbones in a manner that did rather alarm her
ladyship.
'At any rate, you thought that the young people had better be kept apart.'
'No; neither did I think that: my niece, I felt sure, was safe from danger. I knew that she would do nothing
that would bring either her or me to shame.'
'Not to shame,' said the lady apologetically, as it were, using the word perhaps not exactly in the doctor's
sense.
'I felt no alarm for her,' continued the doctor, 'and desired no change. Frank is your son, and it is for you to
look to him. You thought proper to do so by desiring Mary to absent herself from Greshamsbury.'
'Oh, no, no, no!' said Lady Arabella.
'But you did, Lady Arabella; and as Greshamsbury is your home, neither I nor my niece had any ground of
complaint. We acquiesced, not without much suffering, but we did acquiesce; and you, I think, can have no
ground of complaint against me.'
Lady Arabella had hardly expected that the doctor would reply to her mild and conciliatory exordium with so
much sternness. He had yielded so easily to her on the former occasion. She did not comprehend that when
she uttered her sentence of exile against Mary, she had given an order which she had the power of enforcing;
but that obedience to that order had now placed Mary altogether beyond her jurisdiction. She was, therefore,
a little surprised, and for a few moments overawed by the doctor's manner; but she soon recovered herself,
remembering, doubtless, that fortune favours none but the brave.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVI. WAR 189
Page No 193
'I make no complaint, Dr Thorne,' she said, after assuming a tone more befitting a De Courcy than that
hitherto used, 'I make no complaint either as regards you or Mary.'
'You are very kind, Lady Arabella.'
'But I think that it is my duty to put a stop, a peremptory stop to anything like a love affair between my son
and your niece.'
'I have not the least objection in life. If there is such a love affair, put a stop to itthat is, if you have the
power.'
Here the doctor was doubtless imprudent. But he had begun to think that he had yielded sufficiently to the
lady; and he had begun to resolve, also, that though it would not become him to encourage even the idea of
such a marriage, he would make Lady Arabella understand that he thought his niece quite good enough for
her son, and that the match, if regarded as imprudent, was to be regarded as equally imprudent on both sides.
He would not suffer that Mary and her heart and feelings and interest should be altogether postponed to those
of the young heir; and, perhaps, he was unconsciously encouraged in this determination by the reflection that
Mary herself might perhaps become a young heiress.
'It is my duty,' said Lady Arabella, repeating her words with even a stronger De Courcy intonation; 'and your
duty also, Dr Thorne.'
'My duty!' said he, rising from his chair and leaning on the table with the two thighbones. 'Lady Arabella,
pray understand at once, that I repudiate any such duty, and will have nothing whatever to do with it.'
'But you do not mean to say that you will encourage this unfortunate boy to marry your niece?'
'The unfortunate boy, Lady Arabellawhom, by the by, I regard as a very fortunate young manis your
son, not mine. I shall take no steps about his marriage, either one way or the other.'
'You think it right, then, that your niece should throw herself in his way?'
'Throw herself in his way! What would you say if I came up to Greshamsbury, and spoke of your daughters
in such language? What would my dear friend, Mr Gresham say, if some neighbour's wife should come and
so speak to him? I will tell you what he would say: he would quietly beg her to go back to her own home and
meddle only with her own matters.'
This was dreadful to Lady Arabella. Even Dr Thorne had never before dared thus to lower her to the level of
common humanity, and liken her to any other wife in the countryside. Moreover, she was not quite sure
whether he, the parish doctor, was not desiring her, the earl's daughter, to go home and mind her own
business. On this first point, however, there seemed to be no room for doubt, of which she gave herself the
benefit.
'It would not become me to argue with you, Dr Thorne,' she said.
'Not at least on this subject,' said he.
'I can only repeat that I mean nothing offensive to our dear Mary; for whom, I think I may say, I have always
shown almost a mother's care.'
'Neither am I, nor is Mary, ungrateful for the kindness she has received at Greshamsbury.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVI. WAR 190
Page No 194
'But I must do my duty: my own children must be my first consideration.'
'Of course they must, Lady Arabella; that's of course.'
'And, therefore, I have called on you to say that I think it is imprudent that Beatrice and Mary should be so
much together.'
The doctor had been standing during the latter part of this conversation, but now he began to walk about, still
holding the two bones like a pair of dumbbells.
'God bless my soul!' he said; 'God bless my soul! Why, Lady Arabella, do you suspect your own daughter as
well as your own son? Do you think that Beatrice is assisting Mary in preparing this wicked clandestine
marriage? I tell you fairly, Lady Arabella, the present tone of your mind is such that I cannot understand it.'
'I suspect nobody, Dr Thorne; but young people will be young.'
'And old people must be old, I suppose; the more's the pity. Lady Arabella, Mary is the same to me as my
own daughter, and owes me the obedience of a child; but as I do not disapprove of your daughter Beatrice as
an acquaintance for her, but rather, on the other hand, regard with pleasure their friendship, you cannot expect
that I should take any steps to put an end to it.'
'But suppose it should lead to renewed intercourse between Frank and Mary?'
'I have no objection. Frank is a very nice young fellow, gentlemanlike in his manners, and neighbourly in his
disposition.'
'Dr Thorne'
'Lady Arabella'
'I cannot believe that you really intend to express a wish'
'You are quite right. I have not intended to express any wish; nor do I intend to do so. Mary is at liberty,
within certain boundswhich I am sure she will not passto choose her own friends. I think she has not
chosen badly as regards Miss Beatrice Gresham; and should she even add Frank Gresham to the number'
'Friends! why they were more than friends; they were declared lovers.'
'I doubt that, Lady Arabella, because I have not heard of it from Mary. But even if it were so, I do not see
why I should object.'
'Not object!'
'As I said before, Frank is, to my thinking, an excellent young man. Why should I object?'
'Dr Thorne!' said her ladyship, now also rising from her chair in a state of too evident perturbation.
'Why should I object? It is for you, Lady Arabella, to look after your lambs; for me to see that, if possible, no
harm shall come to mine. If you think that Mary is an improper acquaintance for your children, it is for you to
guide them; for you and their father. Say what you think fit to your own daughter; but pray understand, once
for all, that I will allow no one to interfere with my niece.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVI. WAR 191
Page No 195
'Interfere!' said Lady Arabella, now absolutely confused by the severity of the doctor's manner.
'I will allow no one to interfere with her; no one, Lady Arabella. She has suffered very greatly from
imputations which you have most unjustly thrown on her. It was, however, your undoubted right to turn her
out of your house if you thought fit;though, as a woman who had known her for so many years, you might,
I think, have treated her with more forbearance. That, however, was your right, and you exercised it. There
your privilege stops; yes, and must stop, Lady Arabella. You shall not persecute her here, on the only spot of
ground she can call her own.'
'Persecute her, Dr Thorne! You do not mean to say that I have persecuted her?'
'Ah! but I do mean to say so. You do persecute her, and would continue to do so did I not defend her. It is not
sufficient that she is forbidden to enter your domainand so forbidden with the knowledge of all the country
roundbut you must come here also with the hope of interrupting all the innocent pleasures of her life.
Fearing lest she should be allowed even to speak to your son, to hear of word of him through his own sister,
you would put her in prison, tie her up, keep her from the light of day'
'Dr Thorne! how can you'
But the doctor was not to be interrupted.
'It never occurs to you to tie him up, to put him in prison. No; he is the heir of Greshamsbury; he is your son,
an earl's grandson. It is only natural, after all, that he should throw a few foolish words at the doctor's niece.
But she! it is an offence not to be forgiven on her part that she should, however, unwillingly, have been
forced to listen to them! Now understand me, Lady Arabella; if any of your family come to my house I shall
be delighted to welcome them; if Mary should meet any of them elsewhere I shall be delighted to hear of it.
Should she tell me tomorrow that she was engaged to marry Frank, I should talk the matter over with her,
quite coolly, solely with a view to her interest, as would be my duty; feeling, at the same time, that Frank
would be lucky in having such a wife. Now you know my mind, Lady Arabella. It is so I should do my
duty;you can do yours as you may think fit.'
Lady Arabella had by this time perceived that she was not destined, on this occasion to gain any great victory.
She, however, was angry as well as the doctor. It was not the man's vehemence that provoked her so much as
his evident determination to break down the prestige of her rank, and place her on a footing in no respect
superior to his own. He had never before been so audaciously arrogant; and, as she moved towards the door,
she determined in her wrath that she would never again have confidential intercourse with him in any relation
of life whatsoever.
'Dr Thorne,' said she. 'I think you have forgotten yourself. You must excuse me if I say that after what has
passed III'
'Certainly,' said he, fully understanding what she meant; and bowing low as he opened first the studydoor,
then the frontdoor, then the gardengate.
And then the Lady Arabella stalked off, not without full observation from Mrs Yates Umbleby and her friend
Miss Gustring, who lived close by.
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT
And now began the unpleasant things at Greshamsbury of which we have here told. When Lady Arabella
walked away from the doctor's house she resolved that, let it cost what it might, there should be war to the
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT 192
Page No 196
knife between her and him. She had been insulted by himso at least she said to herself, and so she was
prepared to say to others alsoand it was not to be borne that a De Courcy should allow her parish doctor to
insult her with impunity. She would tell her husband with all the dignity that she could assume, that it had
now become absolutely necessary that he should protect his wife by breaking entirely with his unmannered
neighbour; and, as regarded the young members of her family, she would use the authority of a mother, and
absolutely forbid them to hold any intercourse with Mary Thorne. So resolving, she walked quickly back to
her own house.
The doctor, when left alone, was not quite satisfied with the part he had taken in the interview. He had spoken
from impulse rather than from judgement, and, as is generally the case with men who do so speak, he had
afterwards to acknowledge to himself that he had been imprudent. He accused himself probably with more
violence than he had really used, and was therefore unhappy; but, nevertheless, his indignation was not at
rest. He was angry with himself; but not on that account the less angry with Lady Arabella. She was cruel of
manners, so he thought; but not on that account was he justified in forgetting the forbearance due from a
gentleman to a lady. Mary, moreover, had owed much to the kindness of this woman, and, therefore, Dr
Thorne felt that he should have forgiven much.
Thus the doctor walked about his room, much disturbed; now accusing himself for having been so angry with
Lady Arabella, and then feeding his own anger by thinking of her misconduct.
The only immediate conclusion at which he resolved was this, that it was unnecessary that he should say
anything to Mary on the subject of her ladyship's visit. There was no doubt, sorrow enough in store for his
darling; why should he aggravate it? Lady Arabella would doubtless not stop now in her course; but why
should he accelerate the evil which she would doubtless be able to effect?
Lady Arabella, when she returned to the house, allowed no grass to grow under her feet. As she entered the
house she desired that Miss Beatrice should be sent to her directly she returned; and she desired also, that as
soon as the squire should be in his room a message to that effect might be immediately brought to her.
'Beatrice,' she said, as soon as the young lady appeared before her, and in speaking she assumed her firmest
tone of authority, 'Beatrice, I am sorry, my dear, to say anything that is unpleasant to you, but I must make it
a positive request that you will for the future drop all intercourse with Dr Thorne's family.'
Beatrice, who had received Lady Arabella's message immediately on entering the house, and had run upstairs
imagining that some instant haste was required, now stood before her mother rather out of breath, holding her
bonnet by the strings.
'Oh, mamma!' she exclaimed, 'what on earth has happened?'
'My dear,' said the mother, 'I cannot really explain to you what has happened; but I must ask you to give me
positive your assurance that you will comply with my request.'
'You don't mean that I am not to see Mary any more?'
'Yes, I do, my dear; at any rate, for the present. When I tell you that your brother's interest imperatively
demands it, I am sure that you will not refuse me.'
Beatrice did not refuse, but she did not appear too willing to comply. She stood silent, leaning against the end
of a sofa and twisting her bonnetstrings in her hand.
'Well, Beatrice'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT 193
Page No 197
'But, mamma, I don't understand.'
Lady Arabella had said that she could not exactly explain: but she found it necessary to attempt to do so.
'Dr Thorne has openly declared to me that a marriage between poor Frank and Mary is all he could desire for
his niece. After such unparalleled audacity as that, even your father will see the necessity of breaking with
him.'
'Dr Thorne! Oh, mamma, you must have misunderstood him.'
'My dear, I am not apt to misunderstand people; especially when I am so much in earnest as I was in talking
to Dr Thorne.'
'But, mamma, I know so well what Mary herself thinks about it.'
'And I know what Dr Thorne thinks about it; he, at any rate, has been candid in what he said; there can be no
doubt on earth that he has spoken his true thoughts; there can be no reason to doubt him; of course such a
match would be all that he could wish.'
'Mamma, I feel sure that there is some mistake.'
'Very well, my dear. I know that you are infatuated about these people, and that you are always inclined to
contradict what I say to you; but, remember, I expect that you will obey me when I tell you not to go to Dr
Thorne's house any more.'
'But, mamma'
'I expect you to obey me, Beatrice. Though you are so prone to contradict, you have never disobeyed me; and
I fully trust that you will not do so now.'
Lady Arabella had begun by exacting, or trying to exact a promise, but as she found that this was not
forthcoming, she thought it better to give up the point without a dispute. It might be that Beatrice would
absolutely refuse to pay this respect to her mother's authority, and then where would she have been?
At this moment a servant came up to say that the squire was in his room, and Lady Arabella was opportunely
saved the necessity of discussing the matter further with her daughter. 'I am now,' she said, 'going to see your
father on the same subject; you may be quite sure, Beatrice that I should not willingly speak to him on any
matter relating to Dr Thorne did I not find it absolutely necessary to do so.'
This Beatrice knew was true, and she did therefore feel convinced that something terrible must have
happened.
While Lady Arabella opened her budget the squire sat quite silent, listening to her with appropriate respect.
She found it necessary that her description to him should be much more elaborate than that which she had
vouchsafed to her daughter, and, in telling her grievance, she insisted most especially on the personal insult
which had been offered to herself.
'After what has now happened,' said she, not quite able to repress a tone of triumph as she spoke, 'I do expect,
Mr Gresham, that you willwill'
'Will what, my dear?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT 194
Page No 198
'Will at least protect me from the repetition of such treatment.'
'You are not afraid that Dr Thorne will come here and attack you? As far as I can understand, he never comes
near the place, unless you send for him.'
'No; I do not think that he will come to Greshamsbury any more. I believe I have put a stop to that.'
'Then what is it, my dear, that you want me to do?'
Lady Arabella paused a minute before she replied. The game which she now had to play was not very easy;
she knew, or thought she knew, that her husband, in his heart of hearts, much preferred his friend to the wife
of his bosom, and that he would, if he could, shuffle out of noticing the doctor's iniquities. It behoved her,
therefore, to put them forward in such a way that they must be noticed.
'I suppose, Mr Gresham, you do not wish that Frank should marry the girl?'
'I do not think there is the slightest chance of such a thing; and I am quite sure that Dr Thorne would not
encourage it.'
'But I tell you, Mr Gresham, that he says he will encourage it.'
'Oh, you misunderstand him.'
'Of course; I always misunderstand everything. I know that. I misunderstood it when I told you how you
would distress yourself if you took those nasty hounds.'
'I have had other troubles more expensive than the hounds,' said the poor squire, sighing.
'Oh, yes; I know what you mean; a wife and family are expensive, of course. It is a little too late to complain
of that.'
'My dear, it is always too late to complain of any troubles when they are no longer to be avoided. We need
not, therefore, talk any more about hounds at present.'
'I do not wish to speak of them, Mr Gresham.'
'Nor I.'
'But I hope you will not think me unreasonable if I am anxious to know what you intend to do about Dr
Thorne.'
'To do?'
'Yes; I suppose you will do something: you do not wish to see your son marry such a girl as Mary Thorne.'
'As far as the girl herself is concerned,' said the squire, turning rather red, 'I am not sure that he could do
much better. I know nothing whatever against Mary. Frank, however, cannot afford to make such a match. It
would be his ruin.'
'Of course it would; utter ruin; he never could hold up his head again. Therefore it is I ask, What do you
intend to do?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT 195
Page No 199
The squire was bothered. He had no intention whatever of doing anything, an no belief in his wife's assertion
as to Dr Thorne's iniquity. But he did not know how to get her out of the room. She asked him the same
question over and over again, and on each occasion urged on him the heinousness of the insult to which she
personally had been subjected; so that at last he was driven to ask her what it was she wished him to do.
'Well, then, Mr Gresham, if you ask me, I must say, that I think you should abstain from any intercourse with
Dr Thorne whatever.'
'Break off all intercourse with him?'
'Yes.'
'What do you mean? He has been turned out of this house, and I'm not to go to see him at his own.'
'I certainly think that you ought to discontinue your visits to Dr Thorne altogether.'
'Nonsense, my dear; absolute nonsense.'
'Nonsense! Mr Gresham; it is no nonsense. As you speak in that way, I must let you know plainly what I feel.
I am endeavouring to do my duty by my son. As you justly observe, such a marriage as this would be utter
ruin to him. When I found that the young people were actually talking of being in love with each other,
making vows and all that sort of thing, I did think it time to interfere. I did not, however, turn them out of
Greshamsbury as you accuse me of doing. In the kindest possible manner'
'Wellwellwell; I know all that. There, they are gone, and that's enough. I don't complain; surely that
ought to be enough.'
'Enough! Mr Gresham. No; it is not enough. I find that, in spite of what has occurred, the closest intimacy
exists between the two families; that poor Beatrice, who is so very young, and not so prudent as she should
be, is made to act as a gobetween; and when I speak to the doctor, hoping that he will assist me in
preventing this, he not only tells me that he means to encourage Mary in her plans, but positively insults me
to my face, laughs at me for being an earl's daughter, and tells meyes, he absolutely told meto get out of
his house.'
Let it be told with some shame as to the squire's conduct, that his first feeling on hearing this was one of
envyof envy and regret that he could not make the same uncivil request. Not that he wished to turn his
wife absolutely out of his house; but he would have been very glad to have had the power of dismissing her
summarily from his own room. This, however, was at present impossible; so he was obliged to make some
mild reply.
'You must have mistaken him, my dear. He could not have intended to say that.'
'Oh! of course, Mr Gresham. It is a mistake, of course. It will be a mistake, only a mistake when you find
your son married to Mary Thorne.'
'Well, my dear, I cannot undertake to quarrel with Dr Thorne.' This was true; for the squire could hardly have
quarrelled with Dr Thorne, even had he wished it.
'Then I think it right to tell you that I shall. And, Mr Gresham, I did not expect much cooperation from you;
but I did think that you would have shown some little anger when you heard that I had been so illtreated. I
shall, however, know how to take care of myself; and I shall continue to do the best I can to protect Frank
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT 196
Page No 200
from these wicked intrigues.'
So saying, her ladyship arose and left the room, having succeeded in destroying to comfort of all our
Greshamsbury friends. It was very well for the squire to declare that he would not quarrel with Dr Thorne,
and of course he did not do so. But he, himself, had no wish whatever that his son should marry Mary
Thorne; and as a falling drop will hollow a stone, so did the continual harping of his wife on the subject give
rise to some amount of suspicion in his own mind. Then as to Beatrice, though she had made no promise that
she would not again visit Mary, she was by no means prepared to set her mother's authority altogether at
defiance; and she also was sufficiently uncomfortable.
Dr Thorne said nothing of the matter to his niece, and she, therefore, would have been absolutely bewildered
by Beatrice's absence, had she not received some tidings of what had taken place at Greshamsbury through
Patience Oriel. Beatrice and Patience discussed the matter fully, and it was agreed between them that it would
be better that Mary should know what sterner orders respecting her had gone forth from the tyrant at
Greshamsbury, and that she might understand that Beatrice's absence was compulsory. Patience was thus
placed in this position, that on one day she walked and talked with Beatrice, and on the next with Mary; and
so matters went on for a while at Greshamsburynot very pleasantly.
Very unpleasantly and very uncomfortably did the months of May and June pass away. Beatrice and Mary
occasionally met, drinking tea together at the parsonage, or in some other of the ordinary meetings of the
country society; but there were no more confidentially distressing confidential discourses, no more
whispering of Frank's name, no more sweet allusions to the inexpediency of a passion, which, according to
Beatrice's views, would have been so delightful had it been expedient.
The squire and the doctor also met constantly; there were unfortunately many subjects on which they were
obliged to meet. Louis Philippeor Sir Louis as we must call himthough he had no power over his own
property, was wide awake to all the coming privileges of ownership, and he would constantly point out to his
guardian the manner in which, according to his ideas, the most should be made of it. The young baronet's
ideas of good taste were not of the most refined description, and he did not hesitate to tell Dr Thorne that his,
the doctor's friendship with Mr Gresham must be no bar to his, the baronet's interest. Sir Louis also had his
own lawyer, who gave Dr Thorne to understand, that, according to his ideas, the sum due on Mr Gresham's
property was too large to be left on its present footing; the titledeeds, he said, should be surrendered or the
mortgage foreclosed. All this added to the sadness which now seemed to envelop the village of
Greshamsbury.
Early in July Frank was to come home. The manner in which the comings and goings of 'poor Frank' were
allowed to disturb the arrangements of all the ladies, and some of the gentlemen, of Greshamsbury was most
abominable. And yet it can hardly be said to have been his fault. He would have been only too well pleased
had things been allowed to go on after their old fashion. Things were not allowed so to go on. At Christmas
Miss Oriel had submitted to be exiled, in order that she might carry Mary away from the presence of the
young Bashaw, an arrangement by which all the winter festivities of the poor doctor had been thoroughly
sacrificed; and now it began to be said that some similar plan for the summer must be arranged.
It must not be supposed that any direction to this effect was conveyed either to Mary or to the doctor. The
suggestion came from them, and was mentioned only to Patience. But Patience, as a matter of course, told
Beatrice, and Beatrice told her mother, somewhat triumphantly, hoping thereby to convince the shedragon
of Mary's innocence. Alas! shedragons are not easily convinced of the innocence of any one. Lady Arabella
quite coincided the propriety of Mary's being sent off,whither she never inquired,in order that the coast
might be clear for 'poor Frank'; but she did not a whit the more abstain from talking of the wicked intrigues of
those Thornes. As it turned out, Mary's absence caused her to talk all the more.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT 197
Page No 201
The Boxall Hill property, including the house and furniture, had been left to the contractor's son; it being
understood that the property would not be at present in his own hands, but that he might inhabit the house if
he chose to do so. It would thus be necessary for Lady Scatcherd to find a home for herself, unless she could
remain at Boxall Hill by her son's permission. In this position of affairs the doctor had been obliged to make a
bargain between them. Sir Louis did wish to have the comfort, or perhaps the honour, of a country house; but
he did not wish to have the expense of keeping it up. He was also willing to let his mother live at the house;
but not without a consideration. After a prolonged degree of haggling, terms were agreed upon; and a few
weeks after her husband's death, Lady Scatcherd found herself alone at Boxall Hillalone as regards society
in the ordinary sense, but not quite alone as concerned her ladyship, for the faithful Hannah was still with her.
The doctor was of course often at Boxall Hill, and never left it without an urgent request from Lady
Scatcherd that he would bring his niece over to see her. Now Lady Scatcherd was no fit companion for Mary
Thorne, and though Mary had often asked to be taken to Boxall Hill, certain considerations had hitherto
induced the doctor to refuse the request; but there was about Lady Scatcherd,a kind of homely honesty of
purpose, an absence of all conceit as to her own position, and a strength of womanly confidence in the doctor
as her friend, which by degrees won upon his heart. When, therefore, both he and Mary felt that it would be
better for her again to absent herself for a while from Greshamsbury, it was, after much deliberation, agreed
that she should go on a visit to Boxall Hill.
To Boxall Hill, accordingly, she went, and was received almost as a princess. Mary had all her life been
accustomed to women of rank, and had never habituated herself to feel much trepidation in the presence of
titled grandees; but she had prepared herself to be more than ordinarily submissive to Lady Scatcherd. Her
hostess was a widow, was not a woman of high birth, was a woman of whom her uncle spoke well; and, for
all these reasons, Mary was determined to respect her, and pay to her every consideration. But when she
settled down in the house she found it almost impossible to do so. Lady Scatcherd treated her as a farmer's
wife might have treated a convalescent young lady who had been sent to her charge for a few weeks, in order
that she might benefit by the country air. Her ladyship could hardly bring herself to sit still and eat her dinner
tranquilly in her guest's presence. And then nothing was good enough for Mary. Lady Scatcherd besought
her, almost with tears, to say what she liked best to eat and drink; and was in despair when Mary declared she
didn't care, that she liked anything, and that she was in nowise particular in such matters.
'A roast fowl, Miss Thorne?'
'Very nice, Lady Scatcherd.'
'And bread sauce?'
'Bread sauceyes; oh, yesI like bread sauce,'and poor Mary tried hard to show a little interest.
'And just a few sausages. We make them all in the house, Miss Thorne; we know what they are. And mashed
potatoesdo you like them best mashed or baked?'
Mary finding herself obliged to vote, voted for mashed potatoes.
'Very well. But, Miss Thorne, if you like boiled fowl better, with a little bit of ham, you know, I do hope
you'll say so. And there's lamb in the house, quite beautiful; now do'ee say something; do'ee, Miss Thorne.'
So invoked, Mary felt herself obliged to say something, and declared for the roast fowl and sausages; but she
found it very difficult to pay much outward respect to a person who would pay so much outward respect to
her. A day or two after her arrival it was decided that she should ride about the place on a donkey; she was
accustomed to riding, the doctor having generally taken care that one of his own horses should, when
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT 198
Page No 202
required, consent to carry a lady; but there was no steed at Boxall Hill that she could mount; and when Lady
Scatcherd had offered to get a pony for her, she had willingly compromised matters by expressing the delight
she would have in making a campaign on a donkey. Upon this, Lady Scatcherd had herself set off in quest of
the desired animal, much to Mary's horror; and did not return till the necessary purchase had been effected.
Then she came back with the donkey close at her heels, almost holding its collar, and stood there at the
halldoor till Mary came to approve.
'I hope she'll do. I don't think she'll kick,' said Lady Scatcherd, patting the head of her purchase quite
triumphantly.
'Oh, you are so kind, Lady Scatcherd. I'm sure she'll do quite nicely; she seems very quiet,' said Mary.
'Please, my lady, it's a he,' said the boy who held the halter.
'Oh! a he, is it?' said her ladyship; 'but the hedonkeys are quite as quiet as the shes ain't they?'
'Oh, yes, my lady; a deal quieter, all the world over, and twice as useful.'
'I'm so glad of that, Miss Thorne,' said Lady Scatcherd, her eyes bright with joy.
And so Mary was established with her donkey, who did all that could be expected from an animal in his
position.
'But, dear Lady Scatcherd,' said Mary, as they sat together at the open drawingroom window the same
evening, 'you must not go on calling me Miss Thorne; my name is Mary, you know. Won't you call me
Mary?' and she came and knelt at Lady Scatcherd's feet, and took hold of her, looking up into her face.
Lady Scatcherd's cheeks became rather red, as though she was somewhat ashamed of her position.
'You are very kind to me,' continued Mary, 'and it seems so cold to hear you call me Miss Thorne.'
'Well, Miss Thorne, I'm sure I'd call you anything to please you. Only I didn't know whether you'd like it
from me. Else I do think Mary is the prettiest name in all the language.'
'I should like it very much.'
'My dear Roger always loved that name better than any other; ten times better. I used to wish sometimes that
I'd been called Mary.'
'Did he! Why?'
'He once had a sister called Mary; such a beautiful creature! I declare that sometimes think you are like her.'
'Oh, dear! then she must have been very beautiful indeed!' said Mary, laughing.
'She was very beautiful. I just remember heroh, so beautiful! she was quite a poor girl, you know; and so
was I then. Isn't it odd that I should have to be called "my lady" now. Do you know Miss Thorne'
'Mary! Mary!' said her guest.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT 199
Page No 203
'Ah, yes; but somehow, I hardly like to make so free; but, as I was saying, I do so dislike being called "my
lady": I always think the people are laughing at me; and so they are.'
'Oh, nonsense.'
'Yes they are though: poor dear Roger, he used to call me "my lady" just to make fun of me; I didn't mind it
so much from him. But, Miss Thorne'
'Mary, Mary, Mary.'
'Ah, well! I shall do it in time. But, MissMary, ha! ha! ha! never mind, let me alone. But what I want to say
is this: do you think I could drop it? Hannah says, that if I go the right way about it she is sure I can.'
'Oh! but, Lady Scatcherd, you shouldn't think of such a thing.'
'Shouldn't I now?'
'Oh, no; for your husband's sake you should be proud of it. He gained great honour, you know.'
'Ah, well,' said she, sighing after a short pause; 'if you think it will do him any good, of course I'll put up with
it. And then I know Louis would be mad if I talked of such a thing. But, Miss Thorne, dear, a woman like me
don't like to have to be made a fool of all the days of her life if she can help it.'
'But, Lady Scatcherd,' said Mary, when this question of the title had been duly settled, and her ladyship made
to understand that she must bear the burden for the rest of her life, 'but, Lady Scatcherd, you were speaking of
Sir Roger's sister; what became of her?'
'Oh, she did very well at last, as Sir Roger did himself; but in early life she was very unfortunatejust at
Historia Augusta time of my marriage to dear Roger,' and then, just as she was about to commence so
much as she knew of the history of Mary Scatcherd, she remembered that the author of her sisterinlaw's
misery had been a Thorne, a brother of the doctor; and, therefore, as she presumed, a relative of her guest;
and suddenly she became mute.
'Well,' said Mary; 'just as you were married, Lady Scatcherd?'
Poor Lady Scatcherd had very little worldly knowledge, and did not in the least know how to turn the
conversation or escape from the trouble into which she had fallen. All manner of reflections began to crowd
upon her. In her early days she had known very little of the Thornes, nor had she thought much of them since,
except as regarded her friend the doctor; but at this moment she began to think that she had never heard more
than two brothers in the family. Who then could have Mary's father? She felt at once that it would be
improper for to say anything as to Henry Thorne's terrible faults and sudden fate;improper also, to say
more about Mary Scatcherd; but she was quite unable to drop the matter otherwise than abruptly, and with a
start.
'She was very unfortunate, you say, Lady Scatcherd?'
'Yes, Miss Thorne; Mary, I meannever mind meI shall do it in time. Yes, she was; but now I think of it,
I had better say nothing more about it. There are reasons, and I ought not to have spoken of it. You won't be
provoked with me, will you?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT 200
Page No 204
Mary assured her that she would not be provoked, and of course asked no more questions about Mary
Scatcherd; nor did she think much more about it. It was not so however with her ladyship, who could not
keep herself from reflecting that the old clergyman at the Close at Barchester certainly had but two sons, one
of whom was now the doctor at Greshamsbury, and the other of whom had perished so wretchedly at the gate
of that farmyard. Who then was the father of Mary Thorne?
The days passed very quietly at Boxall Hill. Every morning Mary went out on her donkey, who justified by
his demeanour all that had been said in his praise; then she would read or draw, then walk with Lady
Scatcherd, then dine, then walk again; and so the days passed quietly away. Once or twice a week the doctor
would come over and drink his tea there, riding home in the cool of the evening. Mary also received one visit
from her friend Patience.
So the days passed quietly away till the tranquillity of the house was suddenly broken by tidings from
London. Lady Scatcherd received a letter from her son, contained in three lines, in which he intimated that on
the following day he meant to honour them with a visit. He had intended, he said, to have gone to Brighton
with some friends; but as he felt himself a little out of sorts, he would postpone his marine trip and do his
mother the grace of spending a few days with her.
This news was not very pleasant to Mary, by whom it had been understood, as it had been also by her uncle,
that Lady Scatcherd would have had the house to herself; but as there was no means of preventing the evil,
Mary could only inform the doctor, and prepare herself to meet Sir Louis Scatcherd.
CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS
ADVANTAGE
Sir Louis Scatcherd had told his mother that he was rather out of sorts, and when he reached Boxall Hill it
certainly did not appear that he had given any exaggerated statement of his own maladies. He certainly was a
good deal out of sorts. He had had more than one attack of delirium tremens after his father's death, and had
almost been at death's door.
Nothing had been said about this by Dr Thorne at Boxall Hill; but he was by no means ignorant of his ward's
state. Twice he had gone up to London to visit him; twice he had begged him to go down into the country and
place himself under his mother's care. On the last occasion, the doctor had threatened him with all manner of
pains and penalties: with pains, as to his speedy departure from this world and all its joys; and with penalties,
in the shape of poverty if that departure should by any chance be retarded. But these threats had at the
moment been in vain, and the doctor had compromised matters by inducing Sir Louis to promise that he
would go to Brighton. The baronet, however, who was at length frightened by some renewed attack, gave up
his Brighton scheme, and, without notice to the doctor, hurried down to Boxall Hill.
Mary did not see him on the first day of his coming, but the doctor did. He received such intimation of the
visit as enabled him to be at the house soon after the young man's arrival; and, knowing that his assistance
might be necessary, he rode over to Boxall Hill. It was a dreadful task to him, this of making the same
fruitless endeavour for the son that he had made for the father, and in the same house. But he was bound by
every consideration to perform the task. He had promised the father that he would do for the son all that was
in his power; and he had, moreover, the consciousness, that should Sir Louis succeed in destroying himself,
the next heir to all the property was his own niece, Mary Thorne.
He found Sir Louis in a low, wretched, miserable state. Though he was a drunkard as his father was, he was
not at all such a drunkard as his father. The physical capacities of the men were very different. The daily
amount of alcohol which the father had consumed would have burnt up the son in a week; whereas, though
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE 201
Page No 205
the son was continually tipsy, what he swallowed would hardly have had an injurious effect upon the father.
'You are all wrong, quite wrong,' said Sir Louis petulantly; 'it isn't that at all. I have taken nothing this week
pastliterally nothing. I think it's the liver.'
Dr Thorne wanted no one to tell him what was the matter with his ward. It was his liver; his liver, and his
head, and his stomach, and his heart. Every organ in his body had been destroyed, or was in the course of
destruction. His father had killed himself with brandy; the son more elevated in his tastes, was doing the same
thing with curacoa, maraschino, and cherrybounce.
'Sir Louis,' said the doctorhe was obliged to be much more punctilious with him than he had been with the
contractor'the matter is in your hands entirely: if you cannot keep your lips from that accursed poison, you
have nothing in this world to look forward to; nothing, nothing!'
Mary proposed to return with her uncle to Greshamsbury, and he was at first inclined that she should do so.
But this idea was overruled, partly in compliance with Lady Scatcherd's entreaties, and partly because it
would have seemed as though they had both thought the presence of the owner had made the house an unfit
habitation for decent people. The doctor, therefore, returned, leaving Mary there; and Lady Scatcherd busied
herself between her two guests.
On the next day Sir Louis was able to come down to a late dinner, and Mary was introduced to him. He had
dressed himself in his best array; and as he hadat any rate for the present momentbeen frightened out of
his libations, he was prepared to make himself as agreeable as possible. His mother waited on him almost as a
slave might have done; but she seemed to do so with the fear of a slave rather than the love of a mother. She
was fidgety in her attentions, and worried him by endeavouring to make her evening sittingroom agreeable.
But Sir Louis, though he was not very sweetly behaved under these manipulations from his mother's hands,
was quite complaisant to Miss Thorne; nay, after the expiration of a week he was almost more than
complaisant. He piqued himself on his gallantry, and now found that, in the otherwise dull seclusion of
Boxall Hill, he had a good opportunity of exercising it. To do him justice it must be admitted that he would
not have been incapable of a decent career had he stumbled on some girl who could have loved him before he
stumbled upon his maraschino bottle. Such might have been the case with many a lost rake. The things that
are bad are accepted because the things that are good do not come easily in his way. How many a miserable
father reviles with bitterness of spirit the low tastes of his son, who has done nothing to provide his child with
higher pleasures!
Sir Louispartly in the hopes of Mary's smiles, and partly frightened by the doctor's threatsdid, for a
while, keep himself within decent bounds. He did not usually appear before Mary's eyes till three or four in
the afternoon; but when he did come forth, he came forth sober and resolute to please. His mother was
delighted, and was not slow to sing his praises; and even the doctor, who now visited Boxall Hill more
frequently than ever, began to have some hopes.
One constant subject, I must not say of conversation, on the part of Lady Scatcherd, but rather of
declamation, had hitherto been the beauty and manly attributes of Frank Gresham. She had hardly ceased to
talk to Mary of the infinite good qualities of the young squire, and especially of his prowess in the matter of
Mr Moffat. Mary had listened to all this eloquence, not perhaps with inattention, but without much reply. She
had not been exactly sorry to hear Frank talked about; indeed, had she been so minded, she could herself have
said something on the same subject; but she did not wish to take Lady Scatcherd altogether into her
confidence, and she had been unable to say much about Frank Gresham without doing so. Lady Scatcherd
had, therefore, gradually conceived that her darling was not a favourite with her guest.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE 202
Page No 206
Now, therefore, she changed the subject; and, as her own son was behaving with such unexampled propriety,
she dropped Frank and confined her eulogies to Louis. He had been a little wild, she admitted; young men so
often were so; but she hoped that it was now over.
'He does still take a little drop of those French drinks in the morning,' said Lady Scatcherd, in her confidence;
for she was too honest to be false, even in her own cause. 'He does that, I know: but that's nothing, my dear,
to swilling all day; and everything can't be done at once, can it, Miss Thorne?'
On this subject Mary found her tongue loosened. She could not talk about Frank Gresham, but she could
speak with hope to the mother of her only son. She could say that Sir Louis was still very young; that there
was reason to trust that he might now reform; that his present conduct was apparently good; and that he
appeared capable of better things. So much she did say; and the mother took her sympathy for more than it
was worth.
On this matter, and on this matter perhaps alone, Sir Louis and Lady Scatcherd were in accord. There was
much to recommend Mary to the baronet; not only did he see her to be beautiful, and perceive her to be
attractive and ladylike; but she was also the niece of the man who, for the present, held the pursestrings of
his wealth. Mary, it is true, had no fortune. But Sir Louis knew that she was acknowledged to be a lady; and
he was ambitious that his 'lady' should be a lady. There was also much to recommend Mary to the mother, to
any mother; and thus it came to pass, that Miss Thorne had no obstacle between her and the dignity of being
Lady Scatcherd the second;no obstacle whatever, if only she could bring herself to wish it.
It was some timetwo or three weeks, perhapsbefore Mary's mind was first opened to this new brilliancy
in her prospects. Sir Louis at first was rather afraid of her, and did not declare his admiration in any very
determined terms. He certainly paid her many compliments which, from any one else she would have
regarded as abominable. But she did not expect great things from the baronet's taste: she concluded that he
was only doing what he thought a gentleman should do; and she was willing to forgive much for Lady
Scatcherd's sake.
His first attempts were, perhaps, more ludicrous than passionate. He was still too much an invalid to take
walks, and Mary was therefore saved from his company in her rambles; but he had a horse of his own at
Boxall Hill, and had been advised to ride by the doctor. Mary also rodeon a donkey only, it is truebut
Sir Louis found himself bound in gallantry to accompany her. Mary's steed had answered every expectations,
and proved himself very quiet; so quiet, that without the admonition of a cudgel behind him, he could hardly
be persuaded into the demurest trot. Now, as Sir Louis's horse was of a very different mettle, he found it
rather difficult not to step faster than his inamorata; and, let it him struggle as he would, was generally so far
ahead as to be debarred the delights of conversation.
When the second time he proposed to accompany her, Mary did what she could to hinder it. She saw that he
had been rather ashamed of the manner in which his companion was mounted, and she herself would have
enjoyed the ride much more without him. He was an invalid, however; it was necessary to make much of
him, and Mary did not absolutely refuse the offer.
'Lady Scatcherd,' said he, as they were standing at the door previous to mountinghe always called his
mother Lady Scatcherd'why don't you take a horse for Miss Thorne? This donkey isisreally is, so
veryverycan't go at all, you know?'
Lady Scatcherd began to declare that she would willing have got a pony if Mary would have let her do it.
'Oh, no, Lady Scatcherd; not on any account. I do like the donkey so muchI do indeed.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE 203
Page No 207
'But he won't go,' said Sir Louis. 'And for a person who rides like you, Miss Thornesuch a horsewoman
you knowwhy, you know, Lady Scatcherd, it's positively ridiculous; d absurd, you know.'
And then, with an angry look at his mother, he mounted his horse, and was soon leading the way down the
avenue.
'Miss Thorne,' said he, pulling himself up at the gate, 'if I had known that I was to be so extremely happy as
to have found you here, I would have brought you down the most beautiful creature, and Arab. She belongs
to my friend Jenkins; but I wouldn't have stood at any price in getting her for you. By Jove! if you were on
that mare, I'd back you, for style and appearance, against anything in Hyde Park.'
The offer of this sporting wager, which naturally would have been very gratifying to Mary, was lost upon her,
for Sir Louis had again unwittingly got on in advance, but he stopped himself in time to hear Mary again
declare her passion was a donkey.
'If you could only see Jenkins's little mare, Miss Thorne! Only say one word, and she shall be down here
before the week's end. Price shall be no obstaclenone whatever. By Jove, what a pair you would be!'
This generous offer was repeated four or five times; but on each occasion Mary only half heard what was
said, and on each occasion the baronet was far too much in advance to hear Mary's reply. At last he
recollected that he wanted to call on one of his tenants, and begged his companion to allow him to ride on.
'If you at all dislike being alone, you know'
'Oh dear no, not at all, Sir Louis. I am quite used to it.'
'Because I don't care about it, you know; only I can't make this horse of walk the same pace as that brute.'
'You mustn't abuse my pet, Sir Louis.'
'It's a d shame on my mother's part;' said Sir Louis, who, even when in his best behaviour, could not quite
give up his ordinary mode of conversation. 'When she was fortunate enough to get such a girl as you to come
and stay with her, she ought to have had something proper for her to ride upon; but I'll look to it as soon as I
am a little stronger, you see if I don't;' and, so saying, Sir Louis trotted off, leaving Mary in peace with her
donkey.
Sir Louis had now been living cleanly and forswearing sack for what was to him a very long period, and his
health felt the good effects of it. No one rejoiced at this more cordially than did the doctor. To rejoice at it
was with him a point of conscience. He could not help telling himself now and again that, circumstanced as
he was, he was most specially bound to take joy in any sign of reformation that the baronet might show. Not
to do so would be almost tantamount to wishing that he might die in order that Mary might inherit his wealth;
and, therefore, the doctor did with all his energy devote himself to the difficult task of hoping and striving
that Sir Louis might yet live to enjoy what was his own. But the task was altogether a difficult one, for as Sir
Louis became stronger in health, so also did he become more exorbitant in his demands on the doctor's
patience, and more repugnant to the doctor's tastes.
In his worst fits of disreputable living he was ashamed to apply to his guardian for money; and in his worst
fits of illness he was through fear, somewhat patient under his doctor's hands; but just at present he had
nothing of which to be ashamed, and was not at all patient.
'Doctor,'said he, one day, at Boxall Hill'how about those Greshamsbury titledeeds?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE 204
Page No 208
'Oh, that will all be properly settled between my lawyer and your own.'
'Ohahyes; no doubt the lawyers will settle it; settle it with a fine bill of costs. But, as Finnie
says,'Finnie was Sir Louis's legal adviser'I have got a tremendously large interest at stake in this matter;
eighty thousand pounds is no joke. It ain't everybody that can shell out eighty thousand pounds when they're
wanted; and I should like to know how the thing's going on. I've a right to ask, you know; eh, doctor?'
'The titledeeds of a large portion of Greshamsbury estate will be placed with the mortgagedeeds before the
end of next month.'
'Oh, that's all right. I choose to know about these things; for though my father did make such a confounded
will, that's no reason I shouldn't know how things are going.'
'You shall know everything that I know, Sir Louis.'
'And now, doctor, what are we to do about money?'
'About money?'
'Yes; money, rhino, ready! "put money in your purse and cut a dash"; eh, doctor? Not that I want to cut a
dash. No, I'm going on the quiet line altogether now: I've done with that sort of thing.'
'I'm heartily glad of it; heartily,' said the doctor.
'Yes, I'm not going to make way for my faraway cousin yet; not if I know it, at least. I shall soon be all right
now, doctor; shan't I?'
'"All right" is a long word, Sir Louis. But I do hope you will be all right in time, if you will live with decent
prudence. You shouldn't take that filth in the morning though.'
'Filth in the morning! That's my mother, I suppose! That's her ladyship! She's been talking, has she? Don't
you believe her, doctor. There's not a young man in Barsetshire is going more regular, all right within the
posts, than I am.'
The doctor was obliged to acknowledge that there did seem to be some improvement.
'And now, doctor, how about money, eh?'
Doctor Thorne, like other guardians similarly circumstanced, began to explain that Sir Louis had already had
a good deal of money, and had begun also to promise that more should be forthcoming in the event of good
behaviour, when he was somewhat suddenly interrupted by Sir Louis.
'Well, now; I'll tell you what, doctor; I've got a bit of news for you; something that I think will astonish you.'
The doctor opened his eyes, and tried to look as though ready to be surprised.
'Something that will really make you look about; and something, too, that will be very much to the hearer's
advantage,as the newspaper advertisements say.'
'Something to my advantage?' said the doctor.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE 205
Page No 209
'Well, I hope you'll think so. Doctor, what would you think now of my getting married?'
'I should be delighted to hear of itmore delighted than I can express; that is, of course, if you were to marry
well. It was your father's most eager wish that you should marry early.'
'That's partly my reason,' said the young hypocrite. 'But then if I marry I must have an income fit to live on;
eh, doctor?'
The doctor had some fear that his interesting protege was desirous of a wife for the sake of the income,
instead of desiring the income for the sake of the wife. But let the cause be what it would, marriage would
probably be good for him; and he had no hesitation, therefore, in telling him, that if he married well, he
should be put in possession of sufficient income to maintain the new Lady Scatcherd in a manner becoming
her dignity.
'As to marrying well,' said Sir Louis, 'you, I take it, will the be the last man, doctor, to quarrel with my
choice.'
'Will I?' said the doctor, smiling.
'Well, you won't disapprove, I guess, as the Yankee says. What would you think of Miss Mary Thorne?'
It must be said in Sir Louis's favour that he had probably no idea whatever of the estimation in which such
young ladies as Mary Thorne are held by those who are nearest and dearest to them. He had no sort of
conception that she was regarded by her uncle and inestimable treasure, almost too precious to be rendered up
to the arms of any man; and infinitely beyond any price in silver and gold, baronet's incomes of eight or ten
thousand a year, and such coins usually current in the world's markets. He was a rich man and a baronet, and
Mary was an unmarried girl without a portion. In Louis's estimation he was offering everything, and asking
for nothing. He certainly had some idea that girls were apt to be coy, and required a little wooing in the shape
of presents, civil speechesperhaps kisses also. The civil speeches he had, he thought, done, and imagined
that they had been well received. The other things were to follow; an Arab pony, for instanceand the kisses
probably with it; and then all these difficulties would be smoothed.
But he did not for a moment conceive that there would be any difficulty with the uncle. How should there be?
Was he not a baronet with ten thousand a year coming to him? Had he not everything which fathers want for
portionless daughters, and uncles for dependant nieces? Might he not well inform the doctor that he had
something to tell him for his advantage?
And yet, to tell the truth, the doctor did not seem to be overjoyed when the announcement was first made to
him. He was by no means overjoyed. On the contrary, even Sir Louis could perceive his guardian's surprise
was altogether unmixed with delight.
What a question was this that was asked him! What would he think of a marriage between Mary Thornehis
Mary and Sir Louis Scatcherd? Between the alpha of the whole alphabet, and him whom he could not but
regard as the omega! Think of it! Why he would think of it as though a lamb and a wolf were to stand at the
altar together. Had Sir Louis been a Hottentot, or an Esquimaux, the proposal could not have astonished him
more. The two persons were so totally of a different class, that the idea of the one falling in love with the
other had never occurred to him. 'What would you think of Miss Mary Thorne?' Sir Louis had asked; and the
doctor, instead of answering him with ready and pleasant alacrity, stood silent, thunderstruck with
amazement.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE 206
Page No 210
'Well, wouldn't she be a good wife?' said Sir Louis, rather in a tone of disgust at the evident disapproval
shown in his choice. 'I thought you would have been so delighted.'
'Mary Thorne!' ejaculated the doctor at last. 'Have you spoken to my niece about this, Sir Louis?'
'Well, I have and yet I haven't; I haven't, and yet in a manner I have.'
'I don't understand you,' said the doctor.
'Why, you see, I haven't exactly popped to her yet; but I have been doing the civil; and if she's up to snuff, as
I take her to be, she knows very well what I'm after by this time.'
Up to snuff! Mary Thorne, his Mary Thorne, up to snuff! To snuff too of such a very disagreeable
description!
'I think, Sir Louis, that you are in mistake about this. I think you will find that Mary will not be disposed to
avail herself of the great advantagesfor great they undoubtedly arewhich you are able to offer to your
intended wife. If you will take my advice, you will give up thinking of Mary. She would not suit you.'
'Not suit me! Oh, but I think she just would. She's got no money, you mean?'
'No, I did not mean that. It will not signify to you whether your wife has money or not. You need not look for
money. But you should think of some one more nearly of your temperament. I am quite sure that my niece
would refuse you.'
These last words the doctor uttered with much emphasis. His intention was to make the baronet understand
that the matter was quite hopeless, and to induce him if possible to drop it on the spot. But he did not know
Sir Louis; he ranked him too low in the scale of human beings, and gave him no credit for any strength of
character. Sir Louis in his way did love Mary Thorne. And could not bring himself to believe that Mary did
not, or at any rate, would not soon return his passion. He was, moreover, sufficiently obstinate, firm we ought
perhaps to sayfor his pursuit in this case was certainly not an evil one,and he at once made up his mind
to succeed in spite of the uncle.
'If she consents, however, you will do so too?' asked he.
'It is impossible that she should consent,' said the doctor.
'Impossible! I don't see anything at all impossible. But if she does?'
'But she won't.'
'Very well,that's to be seen. But just tell me this, if she does, will you consent?'
'The stars would fall first. It's all nonsense. Give it up, my dear friend; believe me you are only preparing
unhappiness for yourself;' and the doctor put his hand kindly on the young man's arm. 'She will not, cannot,
accept such an offer.'
'Will not! cannot!' said the baronet, thinking over all the reasons which in his estimation could possibly be
inducing the doctor to be so hostile to his views, and shaking the hand of his arm. 'Will not! cannot! But
come, doctor, answer my question fairly. If she'll have me for better or worse, you won't say aught against it;
will you?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE 207
Page No 211
'But she won't have you; why should you give her and yourself the pain of a refusal?'
'Oh, as for that, I must stand my chance like another. And as for her, why d, doctor, you wouldn't have
me believe that any young lady thinks it so very dreadful to have a baronet with ten thousand pounds a year at
her feet, specially when that same baronet ain't very old, nor yet particularly ugly. I ain't so green as that,
doctor.'
'I suppose she must go through with it, then,' said the doctor, musing.
'But, Dr Thorne, I did look for a kinder answer from you, considering all that you so often say about your
great friendship with my father. I did think you'd at any rate answer me when I asked you a question.'
But the doctor did not want to answer that special question. Could it be possible that Mary should wish to
marry this odious man, could such a state of things be imagined to be the case, he would not refuse his
consent, infinitely as he would be disgusted by her choice. But he would not give Sir Louis any excuse of
telling Mary that her uncle approved of so odious a match.
'I cannot say that in case I would approve of such a marriage, Sir Louis. I cannot bring myself to say so; for I
know it would make you both miserable. But on that matter my niece will choose wholly for herself.'
'And about money, doctor?'
'If you marry a decent woman you shall not want the means of supporting her decently,' and so saying the
doctor walked away, leaving Sir Louis to his meditations.
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE
Sir Louis, when left to himself, was slightly dismayed and somewhat discouraged; but he was not induced to
give up his object. The first effort of his mind was made in conjecturing what private motive Dr Thorne could
possibly have in wishing to debar his niece from marrying a rich young baronet. That the objection was
personal to himself, Sir Louis did not for a moment imagine. Could it be that the doctor did not wish that his
niece should be richer, and grander, and altogether bigger than himself? Or was it possible that his guardian
was anxious to prevent him from marrying from some view of the reversion of the large fortune? That there
was some such reason, Sir Louis was well sure; but let it be what it might, he would get the better of the
doctor. 'He knew so,' so he said to himself, 'what stuff girls were made of. Baronets did not grow like
blackberries.' And so, assuring himself with such philosophy, he determined to make his offer.
The time he selected for doing this was the hour before dinner; but on the day on which his conversation with
the doctor had taken place, he was deterred by the presence of a strange visitor. To account for this strange
visit it will be necessary that we should return to Greshamsbury for a few minutes.
Frank, when he returned home for his summer vacation, found that Mary had again flown; and the very fact
of her absence added fuel to the fire of his love, more perhaps then even her presence might have done. For
the flight of the quarry ever adds eagerness to the pursuit of the huntsman. Lady Arabella, moreover, had a
bitter enemy; a foe, utterly opposed to her side in the contest, where she had once fondly looked for her
staunchest ally. Frank was now in the habit of corresponding with Miss Dunstable, and received from her
most energetic admonitions to be true to the love which he had sworn. True to it he resolved to be; and,
therefore, when he found that Mary was flown, he resolved to fly after her.
He did not, however, do this till he had been in a measure provoked by it by the sharptongued cautions and
blunted irony of his mother. It was not enough for her that she had banished Mary out of the parish, and made
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE 208
Page No 212
Dr Thorne's life miserable; not enough that she harassed her husband with harangues on the constant subject
of Frank's marrying money, and dismayed Beatrice with invectives against the iniquity of her friend. The
snake was so but scotched; to kill it outright she must induce Frank utterly to renounce Miss Thorne.
This task she essayed, but not exactly with success. 'Well, mother,' said Frank, at last turning very red, partly
with shame, and partly with indignation, as he made the frank avowal, 'since you press me about it, I tell you
fairly that my mind is made up to marry Mary sooner or later, if'
'Oh, Frank! good heavens! you wicked boy; you are saying this purposely to drive me distracted.'
'If,' continued Frank, not attending to his mother's interjections, 'if she will consent.'
'Consent!' said Lady Arabella. 'Oh, heavens!' and falling into the corner of her sofa, she buried her face in her
handkerchief.
'Yes, mother, if she will consent. And now that I have told you so much, it is only just that I should tell you
this also; that as far as I can see at present I have no reason to hope that she will do so.'
'Oh, Frank, the girl is doing all she can to catch you,' said Lady Arabella,not prudently.
'No, mother; there you wrong her altogether; wrong her most cruelly.'
'You ungracious, wicked boy! you call me cruel!'
'I don't call you cruel; but you wrong her cruelly, most cruelly. When I have spoken to her about thisfor I
have spoken to hershe has behaved exactly as you would have wanted her to do; but not at all as I wished
her. She has given me no encouragement. You have turned her out among you'Frank was beginning to be
very bitter now'but she has done nothing to deserve it. If there has been any fault it has been mine. But it is
well now that we should understand each other. My intention is to marry Mary if I can.' And, so speaking,
certainly without due filial respect, he turned towards the door.
'Frank,' said his mother, raising herself up with energy to make one last appeal. 'Frank, do you wish to see me
die of a broken heart?'
'You know, mother, I would wish to make you happy, if I could.'
'If you wish to see me ever happy again, if you do not wish to see me sink brokenhearted to my grave, you
must give up this mad idea, Frank,'and now all Lady Arabella's energy came out. 'Frank there is but one
course left open to you. You MUST marry money.' And then Lady Arabella stood up before her son as Lady
Macbeth might have stood, had Lady Macbeth lived to have a son of Frank's years.
'Miss Dunstable, I suppose,' said Frank, scornfully. 'No, mother; I made an ass and worse than an ass of
myself once in that way, and I won't do it again. I hate money.'
'Oh, Frank!'
'I hate money.'
'But, Frank, the estate?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE 209
Page No 213
'I hate the estateat least I shall hate it if I am expected to buy it at such a price as that. The estate is my
father's.'
'Oh, no, Frank; it is not.'
'It is in the sense I mean. He may do with it as he pleases; he will never have a word of complaint from me. I
am ready to go into a profession tomorrow. I'll be a lawyer, or a doctor, or an engineer; I don't care what.'
Frank, in his enthusiasm, probably overlooked some of the preliminary difficulties. 'Or I'll take a farm under
him, and earn my bread that way; but, mother, don't talk to me any more about marrying money.' And, so
saying, Frank left the room.
Frank, it will be remembered, was twentyone when he was first introduced to the reader; he is now
twentytwo. It may be said that there was a great difference between his character then and now. A year at
that period will make a great difference; but the change has been, not in his character, but in his feelings.
Frank went out from his mother and immediately ordered his black horse to be got ready for him. He would
at once go over to Boxall Hill. He went himself to the stables to give his orders; and as he returned to get his
gloves and whip he met Beatrice in the corridor.
'Beatrice,' said he, 'step in here,' and she followed him into his room. 'I'm not going to bear this any longer;
I'm going to Boxall Hill.'
'Oh, Frank! how can you be so imprudent?'
'You, at any rate, have some decent feeling for Mary. I believe you have some regard for her; and therefore I
tell you. Will you send her any message?'
'Oh, yes; my best, best love; that is if you will see her; but, Frank, you are very foolish, very; and she will be
infinitely distressed.'
'Do not mention this, not at present; not that I mean you to make any secret of it. I shall tell my father
everything. I'm off now!' and then, paying no attention to her remonstrance, he turned down the stairs and
was soon on horseback.
He took the road to Boxall Hill, but he did not ride very fast: he did not go jauntily as a jolly, thriving wooer;
but musingly, and often with diffidence, meditating every now and then whether it would not be better for
him to turn back: to turn backbut not from fear of his mother; not from prudential motives; not because
that oftenrepeated lesson as to marrying money was beginning to take effect; not from such causes as these;
but because he doubted how he might be received by Mary.
He did, it is true, think something about his worldly prospects. He had talked rather grandiloquently to his
mother as to his hating money, and hating the estate. His mother's neverceasing worldly cares on such
subjects perhaps demanded that a little grandiloquence should be opposed to them. But Frank did not hate the
estate; nor did he at all hate the position of an English country gentleman. Miss Dunstable's eloquence,
however, rang in his ears. For Miss Dunstable had an eloquence of her own, even in her letters. 'Never let
them talk you out of your own true, honest, hearty feelings,' she had said. 'Greshamsbury is a very nice place,
I am sure; and I hope I shall see it some day; but all its green knolls are not half so nice, should not be half so
precious, as the pulses of your own heart. That is your own estate, your own, your very ownyour own and
another's; whatever may go to the moneylenders, don't send that there. Don't mortgage that, Mr Gresham.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE 210
Page No 214
'No,' said Frank, pluckily, as he put his horse into a faster trot, 'I won't mortgage that. They may do what they
like with the estate; but my heart's my own,' and so speaking to himself, almost aloud, he turned a corner of
the road rapidly and came at once upon the doctor.
'Hallo, doctor! is that you?' said Frank, rather disgusted.
'What! Frank! I hardly expected to meet you here,' said Dr Thorne, not much better pleased.
They were now not above a mile from Boxall Hill, and the doctor, therefore, could not but surmise whither
Frank was going. They had repeatedly met since Frank's return from Cambridge, both in the village and in the
doctor's house; but not a word had been said between them about Mary beyond what the merest courtesy had
required. Not that each did not love the other sufficiently to make a full confidence between them desirable to
both; but neither had had the courage to speak out.
Nor had either of them the courage to do so now. 'Yes,' said Frank, blushing, 'I am going to Lady Scatcherd's.
Shall I find the ladies at home?'
'Yes; Lady Scatcherd is there; but Sir Louis is there alsoan invalid: perhaps you would not wish to meet
him.'
'Oh! I don't mind,' said Frank, trying to laugh; 'he won't bite, I suppose?'
The doctor longed in his heart to pray to Frank to return with him; not to go and make further mischief; not to
do that which might cause a more bitter estrangement between himself and the squire. But he had not the
courage to do it. He could not bring himself to accuse Frank of being in love with his niece. So after a few
more senseless words on either side, words which each knew to be senseless as he uttered them, they both
rode on their own ways.
And then the doctor silently, and almost unconsciously, made such a comparison between Louis Scatcherd
and Frank Gresham as Hamlet made between the dead and live king. It was Hyperion to a satyr. Was it not as
impossible that Mary should not love the one, as that she should love the other? Frank's offer of his affections
had at first probably been but a boyish ebullition of feeling; but if it should now be, that this had grown into a
manly and disinterested love, how could Mary remain unmoved? What could her heart want more, better,
more beautiful, more rich than such a love as this? Was he not personally all that a girl could like? Were not
his disposition, mind, character, acquirements, all such as women most delight to love? Was it not impossible
that Mary should be indifferent to him?
So meditated the doctor as he road along, with only too true a knowledge of human nature. Ah! it was
impossible, quite impossible that Mary should be indifferent. She had never been indifferent since Frank had
uttered his first halfjoking word of love. Such things are more important to women than they are to men, to
girls than they are to boys. When Frank had first told her that he loved her; aye, months before that, when he
merely looked his love, her heart had received the whisper, had acknowledged the glance, unconscious as she
was herself, and resolved as she was to rebuke his advances. When, in her hearing, he had said soft nothings
to Patience Oriel, a hated, irrepressible tear had gathered in her eye. When he had pressed in his warm, loving
grasp the hand which she had offered in him in token of mere friendship, her heart had forgiven him the
treachery, nay, almost thanked him for it, before her eyes or her words had been ready to rebuke him. When
the rumour of his liaison with Miss Dunstable reached her ears, when she heard of Miss Dunstable's fortune,
she had wept, wept outright, in her chamberwept, as she said to herself, to think that he could be so
mercenary; but she had wept, as she should have said to herself, at finding that he was so faithless. Then,
when she knew at last that this rumour was false, when she found that she was banished from Greshamsbury
for his sake, when she was forced to retreat with her friend Patience, how could she but love him, in that he
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE 211
Page No 215
was not mercenary? How could she not love him in that was so faithful?
It was impossible that she should not love him. Was he not the brightest and the best of men that she had ever
seen, or was like to see?that she could possibly ever see, she would have said to herself, could she have
brought herself to own the truth? And then, when she heard how true he was, how he persisted against father,
mother, and sisters, how could it be that that should not be a merit in her eyes which was so great a fault in
theirs? When Beatrice, with wouldbe solemn face, but with eyes beaming with feminine affection, would
gravely talk of Frank's tender love as a terrible misfortune, as a misfortune to them all, to Mary herself as
well as others, how could Mary do other than love him? 'Beatrice is his sister,' she would say within her own
mind, 'otherwise she would never talk like this; were she not his sister, she could not but know the value of
such love as this.' Ah! yes; Mary did love him; love him with all the strength of her heart; and the strength of
her heart was very great. And now by degrees, in those lonely donkeyrides at Boxall Hill, in those solitary
walks, she was beginning to own to herself the truth.
And now that she did own it, what should be her course? What should she do, how should she act if this
loved one persevered in his love? And, ah! what should she do, how should she act if he did not persevere?
Could it be that there should be happiness in store for her? Was it not too clear that, let the matter go how it
would, there was no happiness in store for her? Much as she might love Frank Gresham, she could never
consent to be his wife unless the squire would smile on her as his daughterinlaw. The squire had been all
that was kind, all that was affectionate. And then, too, Lady Arabella! As she thought of the Lady Arabella a
sterner form of thought came across her brow. Why should Lady Arabella rob her of her heart's joy? What
was Lady Arabella that she, Mary Thorne, need quail before her? Had Lady Arabella stood only in her way,
Lady Arabella, flanked by the De Courcy legion, Mary felt that she could have demanded Frank's hand as her
own before them all without a blush of shame or a moment's hesitation. Thus, when her heart was all but
ready to collapse within her, would she gain some little strength by thinking of the Lady Arabella.
'Please, my lady, here be young squire Gresham,' said one of the untutored servants at Boxall Hill, opening
Lady Scatcherd's little parlour door as her ladyship was amusing herself by pulling down and turning, and
refolding, and putting up again, a heap of household linen which was kept in a huge press for the express
purpose of supplying her with occupation.
Lady Scatcherd, holding a vast counterpane in her arms, looked back over her shoulders and perceived that
Frank was in the room. Down went the counterpane on the ground, and Frank soon found himself in the very
position which that useful article had so lately filled.
'Oh! Master Frank! oh, Master Frank!' said her ladyship, almost in an hysterical fit of joy; and then she
hugged and kissed him as she had never kissed and hugged her own son since that son had first left the parent
nest.
Frank bore it patiently and with a merry laugh. 'But, Lady Scatcherd,' said he, 'what will they all say? you
forget I am a man now,' and he stooped his head as she again pressed her lips upon his forehead.
'I don't care what none of 'em say,' said her ladyship, quite going back to her old days; 'I will kiss my own
boy; so I will. Eh, but Master Frank, this is good on you. A sight of you is good for sore eyes; and my eyes
have been sore enough since I saw you;' and she put her apron up to wipe a tear away.
'Yes,' said Frank, gently trying to disengage himself, but not successfully: 'yes, you have had a great loss,
Lady Scatcherd. I was so sorry when I heard of your grief.'
'You always had a soft, kind heart, Master Frank; so you had. God's blessing on you! What a fine man you
have grown! Deary me! Well, it seems as though it were only just t'other day like.' And she pushed him a
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE 212
Page No 216
little from her, so that she might look the better into his face.
'Well. Is it all right? I suppose you would hardly know me again now I've got a pair of whiskers?'
'Know you! I should know you well if I saw but the heel of your foot. Why, what a head of hair you have got,
and so dark too! but it doesn't curl as it used once.' And she stroked his hair, and looked into his eyes, and put
her hand to his cheeks. 'You'll think me an old fool, Master Frank: I know that; but you may think what you
like. If I live for the next twenty years you'll always be my own boy; so you will.'
By degrees, slow degrees, Frank managed to change the conversation, and to induce Lady Scatcherd to speak
on some other topic than his own infantine perfections. He affected an indifference as he spoke of her guest,
which would have deceived no one but Lady Scatcherd; but her it did deceive; and then he asked where Mary
was.
'She's just gone out on her donkeysomewhere about the place. She rides on a donkey mostly every day.
But you'll stop and take a bit of dinner with us? Eh, now do'ee, Master Frank.'
But Master Frank excused himself. He did not choose to pledge himself to sit down to dinner with Mary. He
did not know in what mood they might return with regard to each other at dinnertime. He said, therefore,
that he would return to the house again before he went.
Lady Scatcherd then began making apologies for Sir Louis. She was an invalid; the doctor had been with him
all the morning, and he was not yet out of his room.
These apologies Frank willingly accepted, and then made his way as his could on to the lawn. A gardener, of
whom he inquired, offered to go with him in pursuit of Miss Thorne. This assistance, however, he declined,
and set forth in quest of her, having learnt what were her most usual haunts. Nor was he directed wrongly; for
after walking about twenty minutes, he saw through the trees the legs of a donkey moving on the
greensward, at about two hundred yards from him. On that donkey doubtless sat Mary Thorne.
The donkey was coming towards him; not exactly in a straight line, but so much so as to make it impossible
that Mary should not see him if he stood still. He did stand still, and soon emerging from the trees, Mary saw
him all but close to her.
Her heart gave a leap within her, but she was so far mistress of herself as to repress any visible sign of
outward emotion. She did not fall from her donkey, or scream, or burst into tears. She merely uttered the
words, 'Mr Gresham!' in a tone of not unnatural surprise.
'Yes,' said he, trying to laugh, but less successful than she had been suppressing a show of feeling. 'Mr
Gresham! I have come over at last to pay my respects to you. You must have thought me very uncourteous
not to do so before.'
This she denied. She had not, she said, thought him at all uncivil. She had come to Boxall Hill to be out of the
way; and, of course, had not expected any such formalities. As she uttered this she almost blushed at the
abrupt truth of what she was saying. But she was taken so much unawares that she did not know how to make
the truth other than abrupt.
'To be out of the way!' said Frank. 'And why should you want to be out of the way?'
'Oh! there were reasons,'said she, laughing. 'Perhaps I have quarrelled dreadfully with my uncle.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE 213
Page No 217
Frank at the present moment had not about him a scrap of badinage. He had not a single easy word at his
command. He could not answer her with anything in guise of a joke; so he walked on, not answering at all.
'I hope all my friends at Greshamsbury are well,' said Mary. 'Is Beatrice quite well?'
'Quite well,' said he.
'And Patience?'
'What, Miss Oriel; yes, I believe so. I haven't seen her this day or two.' How was it that Mary felt a little flush
of joy, as Frank spoke in this indifferent way about Miss Oriel's health?
'I thought she was always a particular friend of yours,' said she.
'What! who? Miss Oriel? So she is! I like her amazingly; so does Beatrice.' And then he walked about six
steps in silence, plucking up courage for the great attempt. He did pluck up his courage and then rushed at
once to the attack.
'Mary!' said he, and as he spoke he put his hand on the donkey's neck, and looked tenderly into her face. He
looked tenderly, and, as Mary's ear at once told her, his voice sounded more soft than it had ever sounded
before. 'Mary, do you remember the last time that we were together?'
Mary did remember it well. It was on that occasion when he had treacherously held her hand; on that day
when, according to law, he had become a man; when he had outraged all the propriety of the De Courcy
interest by offering his love to Mary in Augusta's hearing. Mary did remember it well; but how was she to
speak of it? 'It was your birthday, I think,' said she.
'Yes, it was my birthday. I wonder whether you remember what I said to you then?'
'I remember that you were very foolish, Mr Gresham.'
'Mary, I have come to repeat my folly;that is, if it be folly. I told you then that I loved you, and I dare say
that I did it awkwardly, like a boy. Perhaps I may be just as awkward now; but you ought at any rate to
believe me when you find that a year has not altered me.'
Mary did not think him at all awkward, and she did believe him. But how was she to answer him? She had
not yet taught herself what answer she ought to make if he persisted in his suit. She had hitherto been content
to run away from him; but she had done so because she would not submit to be accused of the indelicacy of
putting herself in his way. She had rebuked him when he first spoke of his love; but she had done so because
she looked on what he said as a boy's nonsense. She had schooled herself in obedience to the Greshamsbury
doctrines. Was there any real reason, any reason founded on truth and honesty, why she should not be a
fitting wife to Frank Gresham,Francis Newbold Gresham, of Greshamsbury, though he was, or was to be?'
He was well bornas well born as any gentleman in England. She was basely bornas basely born as any
lady could be. Was this sufficient bar against such a match? Mary felt in her heart that some twelvemonth
since, before she knew what little she did now know of her own story, she would have said it was so. And
would she indulge her own love by inveigling him she loved into a base marriage? But then reason spoke
again. What, after all, was this blood of which she had taught herself to think so much? Would she have been
more honest, more fit to grace an honest man's hearthstone, had she been the legitimate descendant of a score
of legitimate duchesses? Was it not her first duty to think of himof what would make him happy? Then of
her unclewhat he would approve? Then of herselfwhat would best become her modesty; her sense of
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE 214
Page No 218
honour? Could it be well that she should sacrifice the happiness of two persons to a theoretic love of pure
blood?
So she had argued within herself. Not now, sitting on the donkey, with Frank's hand before her on the tame
brute's neck; but on other former occasions as she had ridden along demurely among those trees. So she had
argued; but she had never brought her arguments to a decision. All manner of thoughts crowded on her to
prevent her doing so. She would think of the squire, and resolve to reject Frank; and would then remember
Lady Arabella, and resolve to accept him. Her resolutions, however, were most irresolute; and so, when
Frank appeared in person before her, carrying his heart in his hand, she did not know what answer to make to
him. Thus it was with her as with so many other maidens similarly circumstanced; at last she left it all to
chance.
'You ought at any rate, to believe me,' said Frank, 'when you find that a year has not altered me.'
'A year should have taught you to be wiser,'said she. 'You should have learnt by this time, Mr Gresham, that
your lot and mine are not cast in the same mould; that our stations in life are different. Would your father or
mother approve of your even coming here to see me?'
Mary, as she spoke these sensible words, felt that they were 'flat, stale, and unprofitable.' She felt also, that
they were not true in sense; that they did not come from her heart; that they were not such as Frank deserved
at her hands, and she was ashamed of herself.
'My father I hope will approve of it,' said he. 'That my mother should disapprove of it is a misfortune which I
cannot help; but on this point I will take no answer from my father or mother; the question is one too personal
to myself. Mary, if you say that you will not, or cannot return my love, I will go away;not from here only,
but from Greshamsbury. My presence shall not banish you from all that you hold dear. If you can honestly
say that I am nothing to you, can be nothing to you, I will then tell my mother that she may be at ease, and I
will go away somewhere and get over it as I may.' The poor fellow got so far, looking apparently at the
donkey's ears, with hardly a gasp of hope in his voice, and he so far carried Mary with him that she also had
hardly a gasp of hope in her heart. There he paused for a moment, and then looking up into her face, he spoke
but one word more. 'But,' said heand there he stopped. It was clearly told in that 'but'. Thus would he do if
Mary would declare that she did not care for him. If, however, she could not bring herself so to declare, then
was he ready to throw his father and mother to the winds; then would he stand his ground; then would he
look all other difficulties in the face, sure that they might finally be overcome. Poor Mary! the whole onus of
settling the matter was thus thrown upon her. She had only to say that he was indifferent to her;that was
all.
If 'all the blood of the Howards' had depended upon it, she could not have brought herself to utter such a
falsehood. Indifferent to her, as he walked there by her donkey's side, talking thus earnestly of his love for
her! Was he not to her like some god come from the heavens to make her blessed? Did not the sun shine upon
him with a halo, so that he was bright as an angel? Indifferent to her! Could the open unadulterated truth have
been practicable for her, she would have declared her indifference in terms that would truly have astonished
him. As it was, she found it easier to say nothing. She bit her lips to keep herself from sobbing. She struggled
hard, but in vain, to prevent her hands and feet from trembling. She seemed to swing upon her donkey as
though like to fall, and would have given much to be upon her own feet in the sward.
'Si la jeunesse savait . . .' There is so much in that wicked old French proverb! Had Frank known more about
a woman's mindhad he, that is, been fortytwo instead of twentytwo he would at once have been sure of
his game, and have felt that Mary's silence told him all he wished to know. But then, had been fortytwo
instead of twentytwo, he would not have been so ready to risk the acres of Greshamsbury for the smiles of
Mary Thorne.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE 215
Page No 219
'If you can't say one word to comfort me, I will go,' said he, disconsolately. 'I made up my mind to tell you
this, and so I came over. I told Lady Scatcherd I should not staynot even for dinner.'
'I did not know you were so hurried,' said she, almost in a whisper.
On a sudden he stood still, and pulling the donkey's rein, caused him to stand still also. The beast required
very little persuasion to be so guided, and obligingly remained meekly passive.
'Mary, Mary!' said Frank, throwing his arms round her knees as she sat upon her steed, and pressing his face
against her body. 'Mary, you were always honest; be honest now. I love you with all my heart. Will you be
my wife?'
But still Mary said not a word. She no longer bit her lips; she was beyond that, and was now using all her
efforts to prevent her tears from falling absolutely on her lover's face. She said nothing. She could no more
rebuke him now and send him from her than she could encourage him. She could only sit there shaking and
crying and wishing she was on the ground. Frank, on the whole, rather liked the donkey. It enabled him to
approach somewhat nearer to an embrace than he might have found practicable had they both been on their
feet. The donkey himself was quite at his ease, and looked as though he was approvingly conscious of what
was going on behind his ears.
'I have a right to a word, Mary; say, "Go", and I will leave you at once.'
But Mary did not say 'Go'. Perhaps she would have done so had she been able; but just at present she could
say nothing. This came from her having failed to make up her mind in due time as to what course it would
best become her to follow.
'One word, Mary; one little word. There, if you will not speak, here is my hand. If you will have it, let it lie in
yours;if not, push it away.' So saying, he managed to get the end of his fingers on to her palm, and there it
remained unrepulsed. 'La jeuness' was beginning to get a lesson; experience when duly sought after
sometimes comes early in life.
In truth Mary had not strength to push the fingers away. 'My love, my own, my own!' said Frank, presuming
on this very negative sign of acquiescence. 'My life, my own, my own Mary!' and then the hand was caught
hold of and was at his lips before an effort could be made to save it from such treatment.
'Mary, look at me; say one word to me.'
There was a deep sigh, and then came the one word'Oh, Frank!'
'Mr Gresham, I hope I have the honour of seeing you quite well,' said a voice close to his ear. 'I beg to say
that you are welcome to Boxall Hill.' Frank turned round and instantly found himself shaking hands with Sir
Louis Scatcherd.
How Mary got over her confusion Frank never saw, for he had enough to do to get over his own. He
involuntarily deserted Mary and began talking very fast to Sir Louis. Sir Louis did not once look at Miss
Thorne, but walked back towards the house with Mr Gresham, sulky enough in temper, but still making some
effort to do the fine gentleman. Mary, glad to be left alone, merely occupied herself with sitting on the
donkey; and the donkey, when he found that the two gentlemen went towards the house, for company's sake
and for his stable's sake, followed after them.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE 216
Page No 220
Frank stayed but three minutes in the house; gave another kiss to Lady Scatcherd, getting three in return, and
thereby infinitely disgusting Sir Louis, shook hands, anything but warmly, with the young baronet, and just
felt the warmth of Mary's hand within his own. He felt also the warmth of her eyes' last glance, and rode
home a happy man.
CHAPTER XXX. POST PRANDIAL
Frank rode home a happy man, cheering himself, as successful lovers do cheer themselves, with the brilliancy
of his late exploit: nor was it till he had turned the corner into the Greshamsbury stables that he began to
reflect what he would do next. It was all very well to have induced Mary to allow his three fingers to lie half
a minute in her soft hand; the having done so might certainly be sufficient evidence that he had overcome one
of the lions in his path; but it could hardly be said that all his difficulties were now smoothed. How was he to
make further progress?
To Mary, also, the same ideas no doubt occurredwith many others. But, then, it was not for Mary to make
any progress in the matter. To her at least belonged this passive comfort, that at present no act hostile to the
De Courcy interest would be expected from her. All that she could do would be to tell her uncle so much as it
was fitting that he should know. The doing this would doubtless be in some degree difficult; but it was not
probable that there would be much difference, much of anything but loving anxiety for each other, between
her and Dr Thorne. One other thing, indeed, she must do; Frank must be made to understand what her birth
had been. 'This,' she said to herself, 'will give him an opportunity of retracting what he has done should he
choose to avail himself of it. It is well he should have such opportunity.'
But Frank had more than this to do. He had told Beatrice that he would make no secret of his love, and he
fully resolved to be as good as his word. To his father he owed an unreserved confidence; and he was fully
minded to give it. It was, he knew, altogether out of the question that he should at once marry a portionless
girl without his father's consent; probably out of the question that he should do so even with it. But he would,
at any rate, tell his father, and then decide as to what should be done next. So resolving, he put his black
horse into the stable and went into dinner. After dinner he and his father would be alone.
Yes; after dinner he and his father would be alone. He dressed himself hurriedly, for the dinnerbell was
almost on the stroke as he entered the house. He said this to himself once and again; but when the meats and
the puddings, and then the cheese were borne away, as the decanters were placed before his father, and Lady
Arabella sipped her one glass of claret, and his sisters ate their portion of strawberries, his pressing anxiety
for the coming interview began to wax somewhat dull.
His mother and sisters, however, rendered him no assistance by prolonging their stay. With unwonted
assiduity he pressed a second glass of claret on his mother. But Lady Arabella was not only temperate in her
habits, but also at the present moment very angry with her son. She thought that he had been to Boxall Hill,
and was only waiting a proper moment to crossquestion him sternly on the subject. Now she departed,
taking her train of daughters with her.
'Give me one big gooseberry,' said Nina, as she squeezed herself in under her brother's arm, prior to making
her retreat. Frank would willingly have given her a dozen of the biggest, had she wanted them; but having got
the one, she squeezed herself out again and scampered off.
The squire was very cheery this evening; from what cause cannot now be said. Perhaps he had succeeded in
negotiating a further loan, thus temporarily sprinkling a drop of water over the everrising dust of his
difficulties.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXX. POST PRANDIAL 217
Page No 221
'Well, Frank, what have you been after today? Peter told me you had the black horse out,' said he, pushing
the decanter to his son. 'Take my advice, my boy, and don't give him too much summer roadwork. Legs
won't stand it, let them be ever so good.'
'Why, sir, I was obliged to go out today, and therefore, it had to be either the old mare or the young horse.'
'Why didn't you take Ramble?' Now Ramble was the squire's own saddle hack, used for farm surveying, and
occasionally for going to cover.
'I shouldn't think of doing that, sir.'
'My dear boy, he is quite at your service; for goodness' sake do let me have a little wine, Frankquite at your
service; any riding I have now is after the haymakers, and that's all on the grass.'
'Thank'ee, sir. Well, perhaps I will take a turn out of Ramble should I want it.'
'Do, and pray, pray take care of that black horse's legs. He's turning out more of a horse than I took him to be,
and I should be sorry to see him injured. Where have you been today?'
'Well, father, I have something to tell you.'
'Something to tell me!' and then the squire's happy and gay look, which had been only rendered more happy
and more gay by his assumed anxiety about the black horse, gave place to a heaviness of visage which
acrimony and misfortune had made so habitual to him. 'Something to tell me!' Any grave words like these
always presaged some money difficulty to the squire's ears. He loved Frank with the tenderest love. He would
have done so under almost any circumstances; but, doubtless, that love had been made more palpable to
himself by the fact that Frank had been a good son as regards moneynot exigeant as was Lady Arabella, or
selfishly reckless as was his nephew Lord Porlock. But now Frank must be in some difficulty about money.
This was his first idea. 'What is it, Frank; you have seldom had anything to say that has not been pleasant for
me to hear?' And then the heaviness of visage again gave way for a moment as his eye fell upon his son.
'I have been to Boxall Hill, sir.'
The tenor of his father's thoughts was changed in an instant; and the dread of immediate temporary
annoyance gave place to true anxiety for his son. He, the squire, had been no party to Mary's exile from his
own domain; and he had seen with pain that she had now a second time been driven from her home: but he
had never hitherto questioned the expediency of separating his son from Mary Thorne. Alas! it had become
too necessarytoo necessary through his own defaultthat Frank should marry money!
'At Boxall Hill, Frank! Has that been prudent? Or, indeed, has it been generous to Miss Thorne, who has been
driven there, as it were, by your imprudence?'
'Father, it is well that we should understand each other about this'
'Fill your glass, Frank;' Frank mechanically did as he was told, and passed the bottle.
'I should never forgive myself were I to deceive you, or keep anything from you.'
'I believe it is not in your nature to deceive me, Frank.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXX. POST PRANDIAL 218
Page No 222
'The fact is, sir, that I have made up my mind that Mary Thorne shall be my wifesooner or later, that is,
unless, of course, she should utterly refuse. Hitherto, she has utterly refused me. I believe I may now say that
she has accepted me.'
The squire sipped his claret, but at the moment said nothing. There was a quiet, manly, but yet modest
determination about his son that he had hardly noticed before. Frank had become legally of age, legally a
man, when he was twentyone. Nature, it seems, had postponed the ceremony till he was twentytwo. Nature
often does postpone the ceremony even to a much later age;sometimes, altogether forgets to accomplish it.
The squire continued to sip his claret; he had to think over the matter a while before he could answer a
statement so deliberately made by his son.
'I think I may say so,' continued Frank, with perhaps unnecessary modesty. 'She is so honest that, had she not
intended it, she would have said so honestly. Am I right, father, in thinking that, as regards Mary, personally,
you would not reject her as a daughterinlaw?'
'Personally!' said the squire, glad to have the subject presented to him in a view that enabled him to speak out.
'Oh, no; personally, I should not object to her, for I love her dearly. She is a good girl. I do believe she is a
good girl in every respect. I have always liked her; liked to see her about the house. But'
'I know what you would say, father.' This was rather more than the squire knew himself. 'Such a marriage is
imprudent.'
'It is more than that, Frank; I fear that is impossible.'
'Impossible! No, father; it is not impossible.'
'It is impossible, Frank, in the usual sense. What are you to live upon? What would you do with your
children? You would not wish to see your wife distressed and comfortless.'
'No, I should not like to see that.'
'You would not wish to begin life as an embarrassed man and end it as a ruined man. If you were now to
marry Miss Thorne such would, I fear, doubtless be your lot.'
Frank caught at the word 'now'. 'I don't expect to marry immediately. I know that would be imprudent. But I
am pledged, father, and I certainly cannot go back. And now that I have told you all this, what is your advice
to me?'
The father again sat silent, still sipping his wine. There was nothing in his son that he could be ashamed of,
nothing that he could meet with anger, nothing that he could not love; but how should he answer him? The
fact was, that the son had more in him than the father; this his mind and spirit were of a calibre not to be
opposed successfully by the mind and the spirit of the squire.
'Do you know Mary's history?' said Mr Gresham, at last; 'the history of her birth?'
'Not a word of it,' said Frank. 'I did not know she had a history.'
'Nor does she know it; at least, I presume not. But you should know it now. And, Frank, I will tell it you; not
to turn you from hernot with that object, though I think that, to a certain extent, it should have that effect.
Mary's birth was not such that would become your wife, and be beneficial to your children.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXX. POST PRANDIAL 219
Page No 223
'If so, father, I should have known it sooner. Why was she brought here among us?'
'True, Frank. The fault is mine; mine and your mother's. Circumstances brought it all about years ago, when it
never occurred to us that all this would arise. But I will tell you her history. And, Frank, remember this,
though I tell it you as a secret, a secret to be kept from all the world but one, you are quite at liberty to let the
doctor know I have told you. Indeed, I shall be careful to let him know myself should it ever be necessary that
he and I should speak together as to this engagement.' The squire then told his son the whole story of Mary's
birth, as it is known to the reader.
Frank sat silent, looking very blank; he also had, as had every Gresham, a great love for his pure blood. He
had said to his mother that he hated money, that he hated the estate; but he would have been very slow to say,
even in his warmest opposition to her, that he hated the roll of the family pedigree. He loved it dearly, though
he seldom spoke of it;as men of good family seldom do speak of it. It is one of those possessions which to
have is sufficient. A man having it need not boast of what he has, or show it off before the world. But on that
account he values it more. He had regarded Mary as a cutting duly taken from the Ullathorne tree; not,
indeed, as a grafting branch, full of flower, just separated from the parent stalk, but as being not a whit the
less truly endowed with the pure sap of that venerable trunk. When, therefore, he heard her true history he sat
awhile dismayed.
'It is a sad story,' said the father.
'Yes, sad enough,' said Frank, rising from his chair and standing with it before him, leaning on the back of it.
'Poor Mary, poor mary! She will have to learn it some day.'
'I fear so, Frank;' and then there was again a few moments' silence.
'To me, father, it is told too late. It can now have no effect on me. Indeed,' said he, sighing as he spoke, but
still relieving himself by the very sigh, 'it could have had no effect had I learned it ever so soon.'
'I should have told you before,' said the father; 'certainly I ought to have done so.'
'It would have been no good,' said Frank. 'Ah, sir, tell me this: who were Miss Dunstable's parents? What was
that fellow Moffat's family?'
This was perhaps cruel of Frank. The squire, however, made no answer to the question. 'I have thought it
right to tell you,' said he. 'I leave all the commentary to yourself. I need not tell you what your mother will
think.'
'What did she think of miss Dunstable's birth?' said he, again more bitterly than before. 'No, sir,' he continued,
after a further pause. 'All that can make no change; none at any rate now. It can't make my love less, even if it
could have prevented it. Nor, even, could it do sowhich it can't in the least, not in the leastbut could it
do so, it could not break my engagement. I am now engaged to Mary Thorne.'
And then he again repeated his question, asking for his father's advice under the present circumstances. The
conversation was a very long one, as long as to disarrange all Lady Arabella's plans. She had determined to
take her son more stringently to task that very evening; and with this object had ensconced herself in the
small drawingroom which had formerly been used for a similar purpose by the august countess herself. Here
she now sat, having desired Augusta and Beatrice, as well as the twins, to beg Frank to go to her as soon as
he should come out of the diningroom. Poor lady! there she waited till ten o'clock,tealess. There was not
much of the Bluebeard about the squire; but he had succeeded in making it understood through the household
that he was not to be interrupted by messages from his wife during the postprandial hour, which, though no
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXX. POST PRANDIAL 220
Page No 224
toper, he loved so well.
As a period of twelve months will now have to be passed over, the upshot of this long conversation must be
told in as few words as possible. The father found it impracticable to talk his son out of his intended
marriage; indeed, he hardly attempted to do so by any direct persuasion. He explained to him that it was
impossible that he should marry at once, and suggested that he, Frank, was very young.
'You married, sir, before you were oneandtwenty,' said Frank. Yes and repented before I was
twoandtwenty. So did not say the squire.
He suggested that Mary should have time to ascertain what would be her uncle's wishes, and ended by
inducing Frank to promise, that after taking his degree in October he would go abroad for some months, and
that he would not indeed return to Greshamsbury until he was threeandtwenty.
'He may perhaps forget her,' said the father to himself.
'He thinks that I shall forget her,' said Frank to himself at the same time; 'but he does not know me.'
When Lady Arabella at last got hold of her son she found that the time for her preaching had utterly gone by.
He told he, almost with sangfroid, what his plans were; and when she came to understand them, and to
understand also what had taken place at Boxall Hill, she could not blame the squire for what he had done. She
also said to herself, more confidently than the squire had done, that Frank would quite forget Mary before the
year was out. 'Lord Buckish,' said she to herself, rejoicingly, 'is now with the ambassador at Paris'Lord
Buckish was her nephew'and with him Frank will meet women that are really beautifulwomen of
fashion. When with Lord Buckish he will soon forget Mary Thorne.'
But not on this account did she change her resolve to follow up to the furthest point her hostility to the
Thornes. She was fully enabled now to do so, for Dr Fillgrave was already reinstated at Greshamsbury as her
medical adviser.
One other short visit did Frank pay to Boxall Hill, and one interview had he with Dr Thorne. Mary told him
all she knew of her own sad history, and was answered only by a kiss,a kiss absolutely not in any way by
her to be avoided; the first, and only one, that had ever yet reached her lips from his. And then he went away.
The doctor told him the full story. 'Yes,' said Frank, 'I knew it all before. Dear Mary, dearest Mary! Don't
you, doctor, teach yourself to believe that I shall forget her.' And then also he went his way from himwent
his way also from Greshamsbury, and was absent for the full period of the allotted banishmenttwelve
months, namely, and a day.
CHAPTER XXXI. THE SMALL EDGE OF THE WEDGE
Frank Gresham was absent from Greshamsbury twelve months and a day: a day is always added to the period
of such absences, as shown in the history of Lord Bateman and other noble heroes. We need not detail all the
circumstances of his banishment, all the details of the compact that was made. One detail of course was this,
that there should be no corresponding; a point to which the squire found some difficulty in bringing his son to
assent.
It must not be supposed that Mary Thorne or the doctor were in any way parties to, or privy to these
agreements. By no means. The agreements were drawn out, and made, and signed, and sealed at
Greshamsbury, and were known nowhere else. The reader must not imagine that Lady Arabella was prepared
to give up her son, if only his love could remain constant for one year. Neither did Lady Arabella consent to
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXI. THE SMALL EDGE OF THE WEDGE 221
Page No 225
any such arrangement, nor did the squire. It was settled rather in this wise: that Frank should be subjected to
no torturing process, pestered to give no promises, should in no way be bullied about Marythat is, not at
presentif he would go away for a year. Then, at the end of the year, the matter should again be discussed.
Agreeing to this, Frank took his departure, and was absent as per agreement.
What were Mary's fortunes immediately after his departure must be shortly told, and then we will again join
some of our Greshamsbury friends at a period about a month before Frank's return.
When Sir Louis saw Frank Gresham standing by Mary's donkey, with his arms round Mary's knees, he began
to fear that there must be something in it. He had intended that very day to throw himself at Mary's feet, and
now it appeared to his inexperienced eyes as though somebody else had been at the same work before him.
This not unnaturally made him cross; so, after having sullenly wished his visitor goodbye, he betook himself
to his room, and there drank curacoa alone, instead of coming down to dinner.
This he did for two or three days, and then, taking heart of grace, he remembered that, after all, he had many
advantages over young Gresham. In the first place, he was a baronet, and could make his wife a 'lady'. In the
next place, Frank's father was alive and like to live, whereas his own was dead. He possessed Boxall Hill in
his own right, but his rival had neither house nor land of his own. After all, might it not be possible for him
also to put his arm round Mary's knees;her knees, or her waist, or, perhaps, even her neck? Faint heart
never won fair lady. At any rate, he would try.
And he did try. With what result, as regards Mary, need hardly be told. He certainly did not get nearly so far
as putting his hand even upon her knee before he was made to understand that it 'was no go', as he graphically
described it to his mother. He tried once and again. On the first time Mary was very civil, though very
determined. On the second, she was more determined, though less civil; and then she told him, that if he
pressed her further he would drive her from her mother's house. There was something then about Mary's eye,
a fixed composure round her mouth, and an authority in her face, which went far to quell him; and he did not
press her again.
He immediately left Boxall Hill, and, returning to London, had more violent recourse to the curacoa. It was
not long before the doctor heard of him, and was obliged to follow him, and then again occurred those
frightful scenes in which the poor wretch had to expiate, either in terrible delirium or more terrible prostration
of spirits, the vile sin which his father had so early taught him.
Then Mary returned to her uncle's home. Frank was gone, and she therefore could resume her place at
Greshamsbury. Yes, she came back to Greshamsbury; but Greshamsbury was by no means the same place
that it was formerly. Almost all intercourse was now over between the doctor and the Greshamsbury people.
He rarely ever saw the squire, and then only on business. Not that the squire had purposely quarrelled with
him; but Dr Thorne himself had chosen that it should be so, since Frank had openly proposed to his niece.
Frank was now gone, and Lady Arabella was in arms against him. It should not be said that he kept up any
intimacy for the sake of aiding the lovers in their love. No one should rightfully accuse him of inveigling the
heir to marry his niece.
Mary, therefore, found herself utterly separated from Beatrice. She was not even able to learn what Beatrice
would think, or did think, of the engagement as it now stood. She could not even explain to her friend that
love had been too strong for her, and endeavour to get some comfort from that friend's absolution from her
sin. This estrangement was now carried so far that she and Beatrice did not even meet on neutral ground.
Lady Arabella made it known to Miss Oriel that her daughter could not meet Mary Thorne, even as strangers
meet; and it was made known to others also. Mrs Yates Umbleby, and her dear friend Miss Gushing, to
whose charming teaparties none of the Greshamsbury ladies went above once in a twelvemonth, talked
through the parish of this distressing difficulty. They would have been so happy to have asked dear Mary
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXI. THE SMALL EDGE OF THE WEDGE 222
Page No 226
Thorne, only the Greshamsbury ladies did not approve.
Mary was thus tabooed from all society in the place in which a twelvemonth since she had been, of all its
denizens, perhaps the most courted. In those days, no bevy of Greshamsbury young ladies had fairly
represented the Greshamsbury young ladyhood if Mary Thorne was not there. Now she was excluded from all
such bevies. Patience did not quarrel with her, certainly;came to see her frequently;invited her to
walk;invited her frequently to the parsonage. But Mary was shy of acceding to such invitations and at last
frankly told her friend Patience, that she would not again break bread in Greshamsbury in any house in which
she was not thought fit to meet the other guests who habitually resorted there.
In truth, both the doctor and his niece were very sore, but there were of that temperament that keeps all its
soreness to itself. Mary walked out by herself boldly, looking at least as though she were indifferent to all the
world. She was, indeed, hardly treated. Young ladies' engagements are generally matters of profoundest
secrecy, and are hardly known of by their near friends till marriage is a thing settled. But all the world knew
of Mary's engagement within a month of that day on which she had neglected to expel Frank's finger from her
hand; it had been told openly through the countryside that she had confessed her love for the young squire.
Now it is disagreeable for a young lady to walk about under such circumstances, especially so when she has
no female friend to keep her in countenance, more especially so when the gentleman is such importance in
the neighbourhood as Frank was in that locality. It was a matter of moment to every farmer, and every
farmer's wife, which bride Frank should marry of those bespoken for him; Mary, namely, or Money. Every
yokel about the place had been made to understand that, by some feminine sleight of hand, the doctor's niece
had managed to trap Master Frank, and that Master Frank had been sent out of the way so that he might, if yet
possible, break through the trapping. All this made life rather unpleasant for her.
One day, walking solitary in the lanes, she met that sturdy farmer to whose daughter she had in former days
been so serviceable. 'God bless 'ee, Miss Mary,' said hehe always bid God bless her when he saw her.
'And, Miss Mary, to say my mind out freely, thee be quite gude enough for un, quite gude enough; so thee
be'st tho'f he were ten squoires.' There may, perhaps, have been something pleasant in the heartiness of this;
but it was not pleasant to have this heart affair of hers thus publicly scanned and talked over: to have it known
to every one that she had set her heart on marrying Frank gem, and that all the Greshams had set their hearts
in preventing it. And yet she could in nowise help it. No girl could have been more staid and demure, less
demonstrative and boastful about her love. She had never yet spoken freely, out of her full heart, to one
human being. 'Oh, Frank!' All her spoken sin had been contained in that.
But Lady Arabella had been very active. It suited her better that it should be known, far and wide, that a
nameless pauperLady Arabella only surmised that her foe was nameless; but she did not scruple to declare
itwas intriguing to catch the heir of Greshamsbury. None of the Greshams must meet Mary Thorne; that
was the edict sent out about the county; and the edict was well understood. Those, therefore, were bad days
for Miss Thorne.
She had never yet spoken on the matter freely, out of her full heart to one human being. Not to one? Not to
him? Not to her uncle? No, not even to him, fully and freely. She had told him that that had passed between
Frank and her which amounted, at any rate on his part, to a proposal.
'Well, dearest, and what was your answer?' said her uncle, drawing her close to him, and speaking in his
kindest voice.
'I hardly made an answer, uncle.'
'You did not reject him, Mary?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXI. THE SMALL EDGE OF THE WEDGE 223
Page No 227
'No, uncle,' and then she paused;he had never known her tremble as she now trembled. 'But if you say that
I ought, I will,' she added, drawing every word from herself with difficulty.
'I say you ought, Mary! Nay; but this question you must answer yourself.'
'Must I?' said she, plaintively. And then she sat for the next half hour with her head against his shoulder; but
nothing more was said about it. They both acquiesced in the sentence that had been pronounced against them,
and went on together more lovingly than before.
The doctor was quite as weak as his niece; nay, weaker. She hesitated fearfully as to what she ought to do:
whether she should obey her heart or the dictates of Greshamsbury. But he had other doubts than hers, which
nearly set him wild when he strove to bring his mind to a decision. He himself was now in possessionof
course as a trustee onlyof the titledeeds of the estate; more of the estate, much more, belonged to the
heirs under Sir Roger Scatcherd's will than to the squire. It was now more than probable that that heir must be
Mary Thorne. His conviction became stronger and stronger that no human effort would keep Sir Louis in the
land of the living till he was twentyfive. Could he, therefore, wisely or honestly, in true friendship to the
squire, to Frank, or to his niece, take any steps to separate two persons who loved each other, and whose
marriage would in human probability be so suitable?
And yet he could not bring himself to encourage it then. The idea of 'looking after dead man's shoes' was
abhorrent to his mind, especially when the man whose death he contemplated had been so trusted to him as
had been Sir Louis Scatcherd. He could not speak of the event, even to the squire, as being possible. So he
kept his peace from day to day, and gave no counsel to Mary in the matter.
And then he had his own individual annoyances, and very aggravating annoyances they were. The
carriageor rather the postchaiseof Dr Fillgrave was now frequent in Greshamsbury, passing him
constantly in the street, among the lanes, and on the high roads. It seemed as though Dr Fillgrave could never
get to his patients at the big house without showing himself to his beaten rival, either on is way thither or on
his return. This alone would, perhaps, not have hurt the doctor much; but it did hurt him to know that Dr
Fillgrave was attending the squire for a little incipient gout, and that dear Nina was in measles under those
unloving hands.
And then, also, the oldfashioned phaeton, of oldfashioned old Dr Century was seen to rumble up to the big
house, and it became known that Lady Arabella was not very well. 'Not very well,' when pronounced in a
low, grave voice about Lady Arabella, always meant something serious. And, in this case, something serious
was meant. Lady Arabella was not only ill, but frightened. It appeared even to her, that Dr Fillgrave hardly
knew what he was about, that he was not so sure in his opinion, so confident in himself as Dr Thorne used to
be. how should he be, seeing that Dr Thorne had medically had Lady Arabella in his hands for the last ten
years?
If sitting with dignity in his hired carriage, and stepping with authority up the big front steps, would have
done anything, Dr Fillgrave might have done much. Lady Arabella was greatly taken with his looks when he
first came to her, and it was only when she by degrees that the symptoms, which she knew so well, did not
yield to him that she began to doubt those looks.
After a while Dr Fillgrave himself suggested Dr Century. 'Not that I fear anything, Lady Arabella,' said
he,lying hugely, for he did fear; fear both for himself and for her. 'But Dr Century has great experience,
and in such a matter, when the interests are so important, one cannot be too safe.'
So Dr Century came and toddled slowly into her ladyship's room. He did not say much; he left the talking to
his learned brother, who certainly was able to do that part of the business. But Dr Century, though he said
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXI. THE SMALL EDGE OF THE WEDGE 224
Page No 228
very little, looked very grave, and by no means quieted Lady Arabella's mind. She, as she saw the two putting
their heads together, already had misgivings that she had done wrong. She knew that she could not be safe
without Dr Thorne at her bedside, and she already felt that she had exercised a most injudicious courage in
driving him away.
'Well, doctor?' said she, as soon as Dr Century had toddled downstairs to see the squire.
'Oh! we shall be all right, Lady Arabella; all right, very soon. But we must be careful, very careful; I am glad
I've had Dr Century here, very; but there's nothing to alter; little or nothing.'
There was but few words spoken between Dr Century and the squire; but few as they were, they frightened
Mr Gresham. When Dr Fillgrave came down the grand stairs, a servant waited at the bottom to ask him also
to go to the squire. Now there never had been much cordiality between the squire and Dr Fillgrave, though
Mr Gresham had consented to take a preventative pill from his hands, and the little man therefore swelled
himself out somewhat more than ordinarily as he followed the servant.
'Dr Fillgrave,' said the squire, at once beginning the conversation, 'Lady Arabella, is I fear, in danger?'
'Well, no; I hope not in danger, Mr Gresham. I certainly believe I may be justified in expressing a hope that
she is not in danger. Her state is, no doubt, rather serious;rather seriousas Dr Century has probably told
you;' and Dr Fillgrave made a bow to the old man, who sat quiet in one of the diningroom armchairs.
'Well, doctor,' said the squire, 'I have not any grounds on which to doubt your judgement.'
Dr Fillgrave bowed, but with the stiffest, slightest inclination which a head could possibly make. He rather
thought that Mr Gresham had no ground for doubting his judgement.
'Nor do I.'
The doctor bowed, and a little, a very little less stiffly.
'But, doctor, I think that something ought to be done.'
The doctor this time did his bowing merely with his eyes and mouth. The former he closed for a moment, the
latter he pressed; and then decorously rubbed his hands one over the other.
'I am afraid, Dr Fillgrave, that you and my friend Thorne are not the best friends in the world.'
'No, Mr Gresham, no; I may go so far as to say we are not.'
'Well, I am sorry for it'
'Perhaps, Mr Gresham, we need hardly discuss it; but there have been circumstances'
'I am not going to discuss anything, Dr Fillgrave; I say I am sorry for it, because I believe that prudence will
imperatively require Lady Arabella to have Doctor Thorne back again. Now, if you would not object to meet
him'
'Mr Gresham, I beg pardon; I beg pardon, indeed; but you must really excuse me. Doctor Thorne has, in my
estimation'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXI. THE SMALL EDGE OF THE WEDGE 225
Page No 229
'But, Doctor Fillgrave'
'Mr Gresham, you really must excuse me; you really must, indeed. Anything else that I could do for Lady
Arabella, I should be most happy to do; but after what has passed, I cannot meet Doctor Thorne; I really
cannot. You must not ask me to do so; Mr Gresham. And, Mr Gresham,' continued the doctor, 'I did
understand from Lady Arabella that histhat is, Dr Thorne'sconduct to her ladyship had been suchso
very outrageous, I may say, thatthatthatof course, Mr Gresham, you know best; but I did think that
Lady Arabella herself was quite unwilling to see Doctor Thorne again;' and Dr Fillgrave looked very big, and
very dignified, and very exclusive.
The squire did not ask again. He had no warrant for supposing that Lady Arabella would receive Dr Thorne if
he did come; and he saw that it was useless to attempt to overcome the rancour of the man so pigheaded as
the little Galen now before him. Other propositions were then broached, and it was at last decided that
assistance should be sought for from London, in the person of the great Sir Omicron Pie.
Sir Omicron came, and Drs Fillgrave and Century were there to meet him. When they all assembled in Lady
Arabella's room, the poor woman's heart almost sand within her,as well it might, at such a sight. If she
could only reconcile it with her honour, her consistency, with her high De Courcy principles, to send once
more for Dr Thorne. Oh, Frank! Frank! to what misery your disobedience brought your mother!
Sir Omicron and the lesser provincial lights had their consultation, and the lesser lights went their way to
Barchester and Silverbridge, leaving Sir Omicron to enjoy the hospitality of Greshamsbury.
'You should have Thorne back here, Mr Gresham,' said Sir Omicron, almost in a whisper, when they were
quite alone. 'Doctor Fillgrave is a very good man, and so is Dr Century; very good, I'm sure. But Thorne has
known her ladyship so long.' And then, on the following morning, Sir Omicron also went his way.
And then there was a scene between the squire and her ladyship. Lady Arabella had given herself credit for
great good generalship when she found that the squire had been induced to take that pill. We have all heard of
the little end of the wedge, and we have most of us an idea that the little end is the difficulty. That pill had
been the little end of Lady Arabella's wedge. Up to that period she had been struggling in vain to make a
severance between her husband and her enemy. That pill should do the business. She well knew how to make
the most of it; to have it published in Greshamsbury that the squire had put his gouty toe into Dr Fillgrave's
hands; how to let it be knownespecially at that humble house in the corner of the streetthat Fillgrave's
prescriptions now ran current through the whole establishment. Dr Thorne did hear of it, and did suffer. He
had been a true friend to the squire, and he thought the squire should have stood to him more staunchly.
'After all,' said he himself, 'perhaps it's as wellperhaps it will be best that I should leave this place
altogether.' And then he thought of Sir Roger and his will, and of Mary and her lover. And then of Mary's
birth, and of his own theoretical doctrines as to pure blood. And so his troubles multiplied, and he saw no
present daylight through them.
Such had been the way in which Lady Arabella had got in the little end of the wedge. And she would have
triumphed joyfully had not her increased doubts and fears as to herself then come in to check her triumph and
destroy her joy. She had not yet confessed to any one her secret regret for the friend she had driven away. She
hardly yet acknowledged to herself that she did regret him; but she was uneasy, frightened, and in low spirits.
'My dear,' said the squire, sitting down by her bedside, 'I want to tell you what Sir Omicron said as he went
away.'
'Well?' said her ladyship, sitting up and looking frightened.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXI. THE SMALL EDGE OF THE WEDGE 226
Page No 230
'I don't know how you may take it, Bell; but I think it very good news:' the squire never called his wife Bell,
except when he wanted her to be on particularly good terms with him.
'Well?' she said again. She was not overanxious to be gracious, and did not reciprocate his familiarity.
'Sir Omicron says that you should have Thorne back again, and upon my honour, I cannot but agree with him.
Now, Thorne is a clever man, a very clever man; nobody denies that; and then, you know'
'Why did not Sir Omicron say that to me?' said her ladyship, sharply, all her disposition in Dr Thorne's favour
becoming wonderfully damped by her husband's advocacy.
'I suppose he thought it better to say it to me,' said the squire.
'He should have spoken to myself,' said Lady Arabella, who, though she did not absolutely doubt her
husband's word, gave him credit for having induced and led on Sir Omicron to the uttering of the opinion.
'Doctor Thorne has behaved to me in so gross, so indecent a manner! And then, as I understand, he is
absolutely encouraging that girl'
'Now, Bell, you are quite wrong'
'Of course I am; I always am quite wrong.'
'Quite wrong in mixing up two things; Doctor Thorne as an acquaintance, and Dr Thorne as a doctor.'
'It is dreadful to have him here, even standing in the room with me. How can one talk to one's doctor openly
and confidentially when one looks upon him as one's worst enemy?' And Lady Arabella, softening, almost
melted with tears.
'My dear, you cannot wonder that I should be anxious for you.'
Lady Arabella gave a little snuffle, which might be taken as a not very eloquent expression of thanks for the
squire's solicitude, or as an ironical jeer at his want of sincerity.
'And, therefore, I have not lost a moment in telling you what Sir Omicron said. "You should have Thorne
back here;" those were his very words. You can think it over, my dear. And remember this, Bell; if he is to do
any good no time is to be lost.'
And then the squire left the room, and Lady Arabella remained alone, perplexed by many doubts.
CHAPTER XXXII. MR ORIEL
I must now, shortlyas shortly as it is in my power to do itintroduce a new character to my reader.
Mention has been made of the rectory of Greshamsbury; but, hitherto, no opportunity has offered itself for the
Rev Caleb Oriel to come upon the boards.
Mr Oriel was a man of family and fortune, who, having gone to Oxford with the usual views of such men,
had become inoculated there with very HighChurch principles, and had gone into orders influenced by a
feeling of enthusiastic love for the priesthood. He was by no means an asceticsuch men, indeed, seldom
arenor was he a devotee. He was a man well able, and certainly willing to do the work of a parish
clergyman; and when he became one, he was efficacious in his profession. But it may perhaps be said of him,
without speaking slanderously, that his original calling, as a young man, was rather to the outward and visible
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXII. MR ORIEL 227
Page No 231
signs of religion than to its inward and spiritual graces.
He delighted in lecterns and credencetables, in services at dark hours of winter mornings when no one
would attend, in high waistcoats and narrow white neckties, in chanted services and intoned prayers, and in
all the paraphernalia of Anglican formalities which have given such offence to those of our brethren who live
in daily fear of the scarlet lady. Many of his friends declared that Mr Oriel would sooner or later deliver
himself over body and soul to that lady; but there was no need to fear for him: for though sufficiently
enthusiastic to get out of bed at five am on winter morningshe did so, at least, all through his first winter at
Greshamsburyhe was not made of that stuff which is necessary for a staunch, burning, selfdenying
convert. It was not in him to change his very sleek black coat for a Capuchin's filthy cassock, nor his pleasant
parsonage for some dirty hole in Rome. And it was better so both for him and others. There are but few, very
few, to whom it is given to be a Huss, a Wickliffe, or a Luther; and a man gains but little by being a false
Huss, or a false Luther,and his neighbours gain less.
But certain lengths in selfprivation Mr Oriel did go; at any rate, for some time. He eschewed matrimony,
imagining that it became him as a priest to do so. He fasted rigorously on Fridays; and the neighbours
declared that he scourged himself.
Mr Oriel was, it has been said, a man of fortune; that is to say, when he came of age he was master of thirty
thousand pounds. When he took it into his head to go into the Church, his friends bought for him the next
presentation to the living at Greshamsbury; and, a year after his ordination, the living falling in, Mr Oriel
brought himself and his sister to the rectory.
Mr Oriel soon became popular. He was a darkhaired, goodlooking man, of polished manners, agreeable in
society, not given to monkish austeritiesexcept in the matter of Fridaysnor yet to the LowChurch
severity of demeanour. He was thoroughly a gentleman, goodhumoured, inoffensive, and sociable. But he
had one fault: he was not a marrying man.
On this ground there was a feeling against him so strong as almost at one time to throw him into serious
danger. It was not only that he should be sworn against matrimony in his individual selfhe whom fate had
made so able to sustain the weight of a wife and family; but what an example he was setting! If other
clergymen all around should declare against wives and families, what was to become of the country? What
was to be done in the rural districts? The religious observances, as regards women, of a Brigham Young were
hardly so bad as this!
There were around Greshamsbury very many unmarried ladiesI believe there generally are so round must
such villages. From the great house he did not receive much annoyance. Beatrice was then only just on the
verge of being brought out, and was not perhaps inclined to think very much of a young clergyman; and
Augusta certainly intended to fly at higher game. But there were the Miss Athelings, the daughters of a
neighbouring clergyman, who were ready to go all lengths with him in HighChurch matters, except as that
one tremendously papal step of celibacy; and the two Miss Hesterwells, of Hesterwell Park, the younger of
whom boldly declared her purpose of civilizing the savage; and Mrs Opie Green, a very pretty widow, with a
very pretty jointure, who lived in a very pretty house about a mile from Greshamsbury, and who declared her
opinion that Mr Oriel was quite right in his view of a clergyman's position. How could a woman, situated as
she was, have the comfort of a clergyman's attention if he were to be regarded just as any other man? She
could now know in what light to regard Mr Oriel, and would be able without scruple to avail herself of his
zeal. So she did avail herself of his zeal,and that without any scruple.
And then there was Miss Gushing,a young thing. Miss Gushing had a great advantage over the other
competitors for the civilization of Mr Oriel, namely, in thisthat she was able to attend his morning
services. If Mr Oriel was to be reached in any way, it was probable that he might be reached in this way. If
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXII. MR ORIEL 228
Page No 232
anything could civilize him, this would do it. Therefore, the young thing, through all one long, tedious winter,
tore herself from her warm bed, and was to be seenno, not seen, but heardentering Mr Oriel's church at
six o'clock. With indefatigable assiduity the responses were made, uttered from under a close bonnet, and out
of a dark corner, in an enthusiastically feminine voice, through the whole winter.
Nor did Miss Gushing altogether fail in her object. When a clergyman's daily audience consists of but one
person, and that person is a young lady, it is hardly possible that he should not become personally intimate
with her; hardly possible that he should not be in some measure grateful. Miss Gushing's responses came
from her with such fervour, and she begged for ghostly advice with such eager longing to have her scruples
satisfied, that Mr Oriel had nothing for it but to give way to a certain amount of civilization.
By degrees it came to pass that Miss Gushing could never get her final prayer said, her shawl and boa
adjusted, and stow away her nice new Prayer Book with the red letters inside, and the cross on the back, till
Mr Oriel had been into his vestry and got rid of his surplice. And then they met at the churchporch, and
naturally walked together till Mr Oriel's cruel gateway separated them. The young thing did sometimes think
that, as the parson's civilization progressed, he might have taken the trouble to walk with her as far as Mrs
Yates Umbleby's hall door; but she had hope to sustain her, and a firm resolve to merit success, even though
she might not attain it.
'It is not ten thousand pities,' she once said to him, 'that none here should avail themselves of the inestimable
privilege which your coming has conferred upon us? Oh, Mr Oriel, I do so wonder at it! To me it is so
delightful! The morning service in the dark church is so beautiful, so touching!'
'I suppose they think it a bore getting up so early,' said Mr Oriel.
'Ah, a bore!' said Miss Gushing, in an enthusiastic tone of depreciation. 'How insensate they must be! To me
it gives a new charm to life. It quiets one for the day; makes one so fitter for one's daily trials and daily
troubles. Does it not, Mr Oriel?'
'I look upon morning prayer as an imperative duty, certainly.'
'Oh, certainly, a most imperative duty; but so delicious at the same time. I spoke to Mrs Umbleby about it, but
she said she could not leave the children.'
'No: I dare say not,' said Mr Oriel.
'And Mr Umbleby said business kept him up so late at night.'
'Very probably. I hardly expect the attendance of men of business.'
'But the servants might come, mightn't they, Mr Oriel?'
'I fear that servants seldom can have time for daily prayers in church.'
'Oh, ah, no; perhaps not.' And then Miss Gushing began to bethink herself of whom should be composed the
congregation which it must be presumed that Mr Oriel wished to see around him. But on this matter he did
not enlighten her.
Then Miss Gushing took to fasting on Fridays, and made some futile attempts to induce her priest to give her
the comfort of confessional absolution. But, unfortunately, the zeal of the master waxed cool as that of the
pupil waxed hot; and, at last, when the young thing returned to Greshamsbury from an autumn excursion
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXII. MR ORIEL 229
Page No 233
which she made with Mrs Umbleby to WestonsuperMare, she found that the delicious morning services
had died a natural death. Miss Gushing did not on that account give up the game, but she was bound to fight
with no particular advantage in her favour.
Miss Oriel, though a good Churchwoman, was by no means a convert to her brother's extremist views, and
perhaps gave but scanty credit to the Gushings, Athelings, and Opie Greens for the sincerity of their religion.
But, nevertheless, she and her brother were staunch friends; and she still hoped to see the day when he might
be induced to think that an English parson might get through his parish work with the assistance of a wife
better than he could do without such feminine encumbrance. The girl whom she selected for his bride was not
the young thing, but Beatrice Gresham.
And at last it seemed probable to Mr Oriel's nearest friends that he was in a fair way to be overcome. Not that
he had begun to make love to Beatrice, or committed himself by the utterance of any opinion as to the
propriety of clerical marriages; but he daily became looser about his peculiar tenets, raved less immoderately
than heretofore as to the atrocity of the Greshamsbury church pews, and was observed to take some
opportunities of conversing alone with Beatrice. Beatrice had always denied the imputationthis had usually
been made by Mary in their happy dayswith the vehement asseverations of anger; and Miss Gushing had
tittered, and expressed herself as supposing that great people's daughters might be as barefaced as they
pleased.
All this had happened previous to the great Greshamsbury feud. Mr Oriel gradually got himself into a way of
sauntering up to the great house, sauntering into the drawingroom for the purpose, as I am sure he thought,
of talking with Lady Arabella, and then of sauntering home again, having usually found an opportunity for
saying a few words to Beatrice during the visit. This went on all through the feud up to the period of Lady
Arabella's illness; and then one morning, about a month before the date fixed for Frank's return, Mr Oriel
found himself engaged to Miss Beatrice Gresham.
From the day that Miss Gushing heard of itwhich was not however for some considerable time after
thisshe became an Independent Methodist. She could no longer, she said at first, have any faith in any
religion; and for an hour or so she was almost tempted to swear that she could no longer have any faith in any
man. She had nearly completed a worked cover for a credencetable when the news reached her, as to which,
in the young enthusiasm of her heart, she had not been able to remain silent; it had already been promised to
Mr Oriel; that promise she swore should not be kept. He was an apostate, she said, from his principles; an
utter pervert; a false, designing man, with whom she would never have trusted herself alone on dark mornings
had she known that he had such grovelling, worldly inclinations. So Miss Gushing became an Independent
Methodist; the credencetable covering was cut up into slippers for the preacher's feet; and the young thing
herself, more happy in this direction than she had been in the other, became the arbiter of that preacher's
domestic happiness.
But this little history of Miss Gushing's future life is premature. Mr Oriel became engaged demurely, nay,
almost silently, to Beatrice, and no one out of their own immediate families was at the time informed of the
matter. It was arranged very differently from those other two matchesembryo, or not embryo, those,
namely, of Augusta with Mr Moffat, and Frank with Mary Thorne. All Barsetshire had heard of them; but
that of Beatrice and Mr Oriel was managed in a much more private manner.
'I do think you are a happy girl,' said Patience to her one morning.
'Indeed I am.'
'He is so good. You don't know how good he is as yet; he never thinks of himself, and thinks so much of
those he loves.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXII. MR ORIEL 230
Page No 234
Beatrice took her friend's hand in her own and kissed it. She was full of joy. When a girl is about to be
married, when she may lawfully talk of love, there is no music in her ears so sweet as the praises of her lover.
'I made up my mind from the first that he should marry you.'
'Nonsense, Patience.'
'I did, indeed. I made up my mind that he should marry; and there were only two to choose from.'
'Me and Miss Gushing,' said Beatrice, laughing.
'No; not exactly Miss Gushing. I had not many fears for Caleb there.'
'I declare she is very pretty,' said Beatrice, who could afford to be goodnatured. Now Miss Gushing
certainly was pretty; and would have been very pretty had her nose not turned up so much, and could she
have parted her hair in the centre.
'Well, I am very glad you chose me;if it was you who chose,' said Beatrice, modestly; having, however, in
her own mind a strong opinion that Mr Oriel had chosen for himself, and had never any doubt in the matter.
'And who was the other?'
'Can't you guess?'
'I won't guess any more; perhaps Mrs Green.'
'Oh, no; certainly not a widow. I don't like widows marrying. But of course you could guess if you would; of
course it was Mary Thorne. But I soon saw Mary would not do, for two reasons; Caleb would never have
liked her well enough nor would she have ever liked him.'
'Not like him! oh I hope she will; I do so love Mary Thorne.'
'So do I dearly; and so does Caleb; but he could never have loved her as he loves you.'
'But, Patience, have you told Mary?'
'No, I have told no one, and shall not without your leave.'
'Ah, you must tell her. Tell it her with my best, and kindest, warmest love. Tell her how happy I am, and how
I long to talk to her. Tell that I will have her for my bridesmaid. Oh! I do hope that before that all this horrid
quarrel will be settled.
Patience undertook the commission, and did tell Mary; did give her also the message which Beatrice had sent.
And Mary was rejoiced to hear it; for though, as Patience had said of her, she had never herself felt any
inclination to fall in love with Mr Oriel, she believed him to be one in whose hands her friend's happiness
would be secure. Then, by degrees, the conversation changed from the loves of Mr Oriel and Beatrice to the
troubles of Frank Gresham and herself.
'She says that let what will happen you shall be one of her bridesmaids.'
'Ah, yes, dear Trichy! that was settled between us in auld lang syne; but those settlements are all unsettled
now, and must be broken. No, I cannot be her bridesmaid; but I shall yet hope to see her once before her
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXII. MR ORIEL 231
Page No 235
marriage.'
'And why not be her bridesmaid? Lady Arabella will hardly object to that.'
'Lady Arabella!' said Mary, curling up her lip with deep scorn. 'I do not care that for Lady Arabella,' and she
let her silver thimble fall from her fingers onto the table. 'If Beatrice invited me to her wedding, she might
manage as to that; I should ask no question as to Lady Arabella.'
'Then why not come to it?'
She remained silent for a while, and then boldly answered. 'Though I do not care for Lady Arabella, I do care
for Mr Gresham:and I do care for his son.'
'But the squire always loved you.'
'Yes, and therefore I will not be there to vex his sight. I will tell you the truth, Patience. I can never be in that
house again till Frank Gresham is a married man, or till I am about to be a married woman. I do not think
they have treated me well, but I will not treat them ill.'
'I am sure you will not do that,' said Miss Oriel.
'I will endeavour not to do so; and, therefore, will go to none of their fetes! No, Patience.' And then she
turned her head to the arm of the sofa, and silently, without audible sobs, hiding her face, she endeavoured to
get rid of the tears unseen. For one moment she had all but resolved to pour out the whole truth of her love
into her friend's ears; but suddenly she changed her mind. Why should she talk of her own unhappiness? Why
should she speak of her own love when she was fully determined not to speak of Frank's promises.
'Mary, dear Mary.'
'Anything, but pity, Patience; anything but that,' said she, convulsively, swallowing her sobs, and rubbing
away her tears. 'I cannot bear that. Tell Beatrice from me, that I wish her every happiness; and, with such a
husband, I am sure she will be happy. I wish her every joy; give her my kindest love; but tell her that I cannot
be at her marriage. Oh, I should like to see her; not there, you know, but here, in my own room, where I still
have liberty to speak.'
'But why should you decide now? She is not to be married yet, you know.'
'Now, or this day twelvemonth, can make no difference. I will not go into that house again, unlessbut
never mind; I will not go into it all; never, never again. If I could forgive her for myself, I could not forgive
her for my uncle. But tell me, Patience, might not Beatrice now come here? It is so dreadful to see her every
Sunday in church and never to speak to her, never to kiss her. She seems to look away from me as though she
too had chosen to quarrel with me.'
Miss Oriel promised to do her best. She could not imagine, she said, that such a visit could be objected to on
such an occasion. She would not advise Beatrice to come without telling her mother; but she could not think
that Lady Arabella would be so cruel as to make any objection, knowing, as she could not but know, that her
daughter, when married, would be at liberty to choose her own friends.
'Goodbye, Mary,' said Patience. 'I wish I knew how to say more to comfort you.'
'Oh, comfort! I don't want comfort. I want to be let alone.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXII. MR ORIEL 232
Page No 236
'That's just it: you are so ferocious in your scorn, so unbending, so determined to take all the punishment that
comes in your way.'
'What I do take, I'll take without complaint,' said Mary; and then they kissed each other and parted.
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT
It must be remembered that Mary, among her miseries, had to suffer this: that since Frank's departure, now
nearly twelve months ago, she had not heard a word about him; or rather, she had only heard that he was very
much in love with some lady in London. This news reached her in a manner so circuitous, and from such a
doubtful source; it seemed to her to savour so strongly of Lady Arabella's precautions, that she attributed it at
once to malice, and blew it to the winds. It might not improbably be the case that Frank was untrue to her; but
she would not take it for granted because she was now told so. It was more than probable that he should
amuse himself with some one; flirting was his prevailing sin; and if he did flirt, the most would of course be
made of it.
But she found it to be very desolate to be thus left alone without a word of comfort or a word of love; without
being able to speak to any one of what filled her heart; doubting, nay, more than doubting, being all but sure
that her passion must terminate in misery. Why had she not obeyed her conscience and her better instinct int
hat moment when the necessity for deciding had come upon her? Why had she allowed him to understand
that he was master of her heart? Did she not know that there was everything against such a marriage as that
which was proposed? Had she not done wrong, very wrong, even to think of it? Had she not sinned deeply,
against Mr Gresham, who had ever been so kind to her? Could she hope, was it possible, that a boy like Frank
should be true to his first love? And, if he were true, if he were ready to go to the altar with her tomorrow,
ought she to allow him to degrade himself by such a marriage?
There was, alas! some truth about the London lady. Frank had taken his degree, as arranged, and had then
gone abroad for the winter, doing the fashionable things, going up the Nile, crossing over to Mount Sinai,
thence over the long desert to Jerusalem, and home by Damascus, Beyrout, and Constantinople, bringing
back a long beard, a red cap, and a chibook, just as our fathers used to go through Italy and Switzerland, and
our grandfathers to spend a season in Paris. He had then remained for a couple of months in London, going
through all the society which the De Courcys were able to open to him. And it was true that a certain belle of
the season, of that season and some others, had been captivatedfor the tenth timeby the silken sheens of
his long beard. Frank had probably been more demonstrative, perhaps, ever more susceptible, than he should
have been; and hence the rumour, which had all too willingly been forwarded to Greshamsbury.
But young Gresham had also met another lady in London, namely Miss Dunstable. Mary would indeed have
been grateful to Miss Dunstable, could she have know all that lady did for her. Frank's love was never
allowed to flag. When he spoke of the difficulties in his way, she twitted him by being overcome by straws;
and told him that no one was ever worth having who was afraid of every lion he met in his path. When he
spoke of money, she bade him earn it; and always ended by offering to smooth for him any real difficulty
which want of means might put in his way.
'No,' Frank used to say to himself, when these offers were made, 'I never intended to take her and her money
together; and, therefore, I certainly will never take the money alone.'
A day or two after Miss Oriel's visit, Mary received the following note from Beatrice.
'DEAREST, DEAREST MARY,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT 233
Page No 237
'I shall be so happy to see you, and will come tomorrow at twelve. I have asked mamma, and she says that,
for once, she has no objection. You know it is not my fault that I have never been with you; don't you? Frank
comes home on the twelfth. Mr Oriel wants the wedding to be on the first of September; but that seems to be
so very, very soon; doesn't it? However, mamma and papa are all on his side. I won't write about this, though,
for we shall have such a delicious talk. Oh, Mary! I have been so unhappy without you. 'Ever your own
affectionate, TRICHY'
Though Mary was delighted at the idea of once more having her friend in her arms, there was, nevertheless,
something in the letter which oppressed her. She could not put up with the idea that Beatrice should have
permission given to come to herjust for once. She hardly wished to be seen by permission. Nevertheless,
she did not refuse the proffered visit, and the first sight of Beatrice's face, the first touch of the first embrace,
dissipated for the moment her anger.
And then Beatrice fully enjoyed the delicious talk which she had promised herself. Mary let her have her
way, and for two hours all the delights and all the duties, all the comforts and all the responsibilities of a
parson's wife were discussed with almost equal ardour on both sides. The duties and responsibilities were not
exactly those which too often fall to the lot of the mistress of an English vicarage. Beatrice was not doomed
to make her husband comfortable, to educate her children, dress herself like a lady, and exercise
openhanded charity on an income of two hundred pounds a year. Her duties and responsibilities would have
to spread themselves over seven or eight times that amount of worldly burden. Living also close to
Greshamsbury, and not far from Courcy Castle, she would have the full advantage and all the privileges of
county society. In fact, it was all couleur de rose, and so she chatted deliciously with her friend.
But it was impossible that they should separate without something having been said as to Mary's own lot. It
would, perhaps, have been better that they should do so; but this was hardly within the compass of human
nature.
'And Mary, you know, I shall be able to see you as often as I like;you and Dr Thorne, too, when I have a
house of my own.'
Mary said nothing, but essayed to smile. It was but a ghastly attempt.
'You know how happy that will make me,' continued Beatrice. 'Of course mamma won't expect me to be led
by her then; if he likes it, there can be no objection; and he will like it, you may be sure of that.'
'You are very kind, Trichy,' said Mary; but she spoke in a tone very different from that she would have used
eighteen months ago.
'Why, what is the matter, Mary? Shan't you be glad to come and see us?'
'I do not know, dearest; that must depend on circumstances. To see you, you yourself, your own dear, sweet,
loving face must always be pleasant to me.'
'And shan't you be glad to see him?'
'Yes, certainly, if he loves you.'
'Of course he loves me.'
'All that alone would be pleasant enough, Trichy. But what if there should be circumstances which should
still make us enemies; should make your friends and my friendsfriend, I should say, for I have only
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT 234
Page No 238
oneshould make them opposed to each other?'
'Circumstances! What circumstances?'
'You are going to be married, Trichy, to the man you love; are you not?'
'Indeed I am!'
'And it is not pleasant? is it not a happy feeling?'
'Pleasant! happy! yes, very pleasant; very happy. But, Mary, I am not at all in such a hurry as he is,' said
Beatrice, naturally thinking of her own little affairs.
'And, suppose I should wish to be married to the man that I love?' Mary said this slowly and gravely, and as
she spoke she looked her friend full in the face.
Beatrice was somewhat astonished, and for the moment hardly understood. 'I am sure I hope you will some
day.'
'No, Trichy; no, you hope the other way. I love your brother; I love Frank Gresham; I love him quite as well,
quite as warmly, as you love Caleb Oriel.'
'Do you?' said Beatrice, staring with all her eyes, and giving one long sigh, as this new subject for sorrow was
so distinctly put before her.
'It that so odd?' said Mary. 'You love Mr Oriel, though you have been intimate with him hardly more than two
years. Is it so odd that I should love your brother, whom I have known almost all my life?'
'But, Mary, I thought it was always understood between us thatthatI mean that you were not to care
about him; not in the way of loving him, you knowI thought you always said soI have always told
mamma so as if it came from yourself.'
'Beatrice, do not tell anything to Lady Arabella as though it came from me; I do not want anything to be told
to her, either of me or from me. Say what you like to me yourself; whatever you say will not anger me.
Indeed, I know what you would sayand yet I love you. Oh, I love you, TrichyTrichy, I do love you so
much! Don't turn away from me!'
There was such a mixture in Mary's manner of tenderness and almost ferocity, that poor Beatrice could hardly
follow her. 'Turn away from you, Mary! no never; but this does make me unhappy.'
'It is better that you should know it all, and then you will not be led into fighting my battles again. You cannot
fight them so that I should win; I do love your brother; love him truly, fondly, tenderly. I would wish to have
him for my husband as you wish to have Mr Oriel.'
'But, Mary, you cannot marry him!'
'Why not?' said she, in a loud voice. 'Why can I not marry him? If the priest says a blessing over us, shall we
not be married as well as you and your husband?'
'But you know he cannot marry unless his wife shall have money.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT 235
Page No 239
'Moneymoney; and he is to sell himself for money? Oh, Trichy! do not you talk about money. It is
horrible. But, Trichy, I will grant itI cannot marry him; but still, I love him. He has a name, a place in the
world, and fortune, family, high blood, position, everything. He has all this, and I have nothing. Of course I
cannot marry him. But yet I do love him.'
'Are you engaged to him, Mary?'
'He is not engaged to me; but I am to him.'
'Oh, Mary, that is impossible!'
'It is not impossible: it is the castI am pledged to him; but he is not pledged to me.'
'But, Mary, don't look at me in that way. I do not quite understand you. What is the good of your being
engaged if you cannot marry him?'
'Good! there is no good. But can I help it, if I love him? Can I make myself not love him by just wishing it?
Oh, I would do it if I could. But now you will understand why I shake my head when you talk of coming to
your house. Your ways and my ways must be different.'
Beatrice was startled, and, for a time, silenced. What Mary said of the difference of their ways was quite true.
Beatrice had dearly loved her friend, and had thought of her with affection through all this long period in
which they had been separated; but she had given her love and her thoughts on the understanding, as it were,
that they were in unison as to the impropriety of Frank's conduct.
She had always spoken, with a grave face, of Frank and his love as of a great misfortune, even to Mary
herself; and her pity for Mary had been founded on the conviction of her innocence. Now all those ideas had
to be altered. Mary owned her fault, confessed herself to be guilty of all that Lady Arabella so frequently laid
to her charge, and confessed herself anxious to commit every crime as to which Beatrice had been ever so
ready to defend her.
Had Beatrice up to this dreamed that Mary was in love with Frank, she would doubtless have sympathized
with her more or less sooner or later. As it was, is was beyond all doubt that she would soon sympathize with
her. But, at the moment, the suddenness of the declaration seemed to harden her heart, and she forgot, as it
were, to speak tenderly to her friend.
She was silent, therefore, and dismayed; and looked as though she thought that her ways and Mary's ways
must be different.
Mary saw all that was passing in the other's mind: no, not all; all the hostility, the disappointment, the
disapproval, the unhappiness, she did see; but not the undercurrent of love, which was strong enough to well
up and drown all these, if only time could be allowed for it to do so.
'I am so glad to have told you,' said Mary, curbing herself, 'for deceit and hypocrisy are detestable.'
'It was a misunderstanding, not deceit,' said Beatrice.
'Well, now we understand each other; now you know that I have a heart within me, which like those of some
others has not always been under my own control. Lady Arabella believes that I am intriguing to be the
mistress of Greshamsbury. You, at any rate, will not think that of me. If it could be discovered tomorrow
that Frank were not the heir, I might have some chance of happiness.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT 236
Page No 240
'But, Mary'
'Well?'
'You say you love him.'
'Yes; I do say so.'
'But if he does not love you, will you cease to do so?'
'If I have a fever, I will get rid of it if I can; in such a case I must do so, or die.'
'I fear,' continued Beatrice, 'you hardly know, perhaps do not think, what is Frank's real character. He is not
made to settle down early in life; even now, I believe he is attached to some lady in London, whom, of
course, he cannot marry.'
Beatrice had said this in perfect trueness of heart. She had heard of Frank's new loveaffair, and believing
what she had heard, thought it best to tell the truth. But the information was not of a kind to quiet Mary's
spirit.
'Very well,' said she, 'let it be so. I have nothing to say against it.'
'But are you not preparing wretchedness and unhappiness for yourself?'
'Very likely.'
'Oh, Mary, do not be so cold with me! you know how delighted I should be to have you for a sisterinlaw, if
only it were possible.'
'Yes, Trichy; but it is impossible, is it not? Impossible that Francis Gresham of Greshamsbury should
disgrace himself by marrying such a poor creature as I am. Of course I know it; of course, I am prepared for
unhappiness and misery. He can amuse himself as he likes with me or otherswith anybody. It is his
privilege. It is quite enough to say that he is not made for settling down. I know my own position;and yet I
love him.'
'But, Mary, has he asked you to be his wife? If so'
'You ask homequestions, Beatrice. Let me ask you one; has he ever told you that he has done so?'
At this moment Beatrice was not disposed to repeat all that Frank had said. A year ago, before he went away,
he had told his sister a score of times that he meant to marry Mary Thorne if she would have him; but
Beatrice now looked on all that as idle, boyish vapouring. The pity was, that Mary should have looked on it
differently.
'We will each keep our secret,' said Mary. 'Only remember this: should Frank marry tomorrow, I shall have
no ground for blaming him. He is free as far I as am concerned. He can take the London lady if he likes. You
may tell him so from me. But, Trichy, what else I have told you, I have told you only.'
'Oh, yes!' said Beatrice, sadly; 'I shall say nothing of it to anybody. It is very sad, very, very; I was so happy
when I came here, and now I am so wretched.' This was the end of that delicious talk to which she had looked
forward with so much eagerness.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT 237
Page No 241
'Don't be wretched about me, dearest; I shall get through it. I sometimes think I was born to be unhappy, and
that unhappiness agrees with me best. Kiss me now, Trichy, and don't be wretched any more. You owe it to
Mr Oriel to be as happy as the day is long.'
And then they parted.
Beatrice, as she went out, saw Dr Thorne in his little shop on the righthand side of the passage deeply
engaged in some derogatory branch of an apothecary's mechanical trade; mixing a dose, perhaps, for a little
child. She would have passed him without speaking, if she could have been sure of doing so without notice,
for her heart was full, and her eyes were red with tears; but it was so long since she had been in his house that
she was more than ordinarily anxious not to appear uncourteous or unkind to him.
'Good morning, doctor,' she said, changing her countenance as best she might, and attempting a smile.
'Ah, my fairy!' said he, leaving his villainous compounds, and coming out to her; 'and you, too, are about to
become a steady old lady.'
'Indeed, I am not, doctor; I don't mean to be either steady or old, for the next ten years. But who has told you?
I suppose Mary has been a traitor.'
'Well, I will confess Mary was the traitor. But hadn't I a right to be told, seeing how often I have brought you
sugarplums in my pocket? But I wish you joy with all my heartwith all my heart. Oriel is an excellent,
good fellow.'
'Is he not, doctor?'
'An excellent, good fellow. I never heard but of one fault that he had.'
'What was that one fault, Doctor Thorne?'
'He thought that clergymen should not marry. But you have cured that, and now he's perfect.'
'Thank you, doctor. I declare that you say the prettiest things of all my friends.'
'And none of your friends wish prettier things for you. I do congratulate you, Beatrice, and hope you may be
happy with the man you have chosen;' and taking both her hands in his, he pressed them warmly, and bade
God bless her.
'Oh, doctor! I do so hope the time will come when we shall all be friends again.'
'I hope it as well, my dear. But let it come, or let it not come, my regard for you will be the same:' and then
she parted from him also, and went her way.
Nothing was spoken of that evening between Dr Thorne and his niece excepting Beatrice's future happiness;
nothing, at least, having reference to what had passed that morning. But on the following morning,
circumstances led to Frank Gresham's name being mentioned.
At the usual breakfasthour the doctor entered the parlour with a harassed face. He had an open letter in his
hand, and it was at once clear to Mary that he was going to speak on some subject that vexed him.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT 238
Page No 242
'That unfortunate fellow is again in trouble. Here is a letter from Greyson.' Greyson was a London
apothecary, who had been appointed as medical attendant to Sir Louis Scatcherd, and whose real business
consisted in keeping a watch on the baronet, and reporting to Dr Thorne when anything was very much
amiss. 'Here is a letter from Greyson; he has been drunk for the last three days, and is now laid up in a
terribly nervous state.'
'You won't go up to town again; will you, uncle?'
'I hardly know what to do. No, I think not. He talks of coming down here to Greshamsbury.'
'Who, Sir Louis?'
'Yes, Sir Louis. Greyson says that he will be down as soon as he can get out of his room.'
'What! to this house?'
'What other home can he come to?'
'Oh, uncle! I hope not. Pray, pray do not let him come here.'
'I cannot prevent it, dear. I cannot shut my door on him.'
They sat down to breakfast, and Mary gave him his tea in silence. 'I am going over to Boxall Hill before
dinner,' said he. 'Have you any message to send to Lady Scatcherd?'
'Message! no, I have no message; not especially: give her my love, of course,' she said listlessly. And then, as
though a thought had suddenly struck her, she spoke with more energy. 'But, couldn't I go to Boxall Hill
again? I should be so delighted.'
'What! to run away from Sir Louis? No, dearest, we will have no more running away. He will probably also
go to Boxall Hill, and he could annoy you much more there than he can here.'
'But, uncle, Mr Gresham will be home on the twelfth,' she said, blushing.
'What! Frank?'
'Yes. Beatrice said he was to be here on the twelfth.'
'And would you run away from him too, Mary?'
'I do not know: I do not know what to do.'
'No; we will have no more running away: I am sorry that you ever did so. It was my fault, altogether my fault;
but it was foolish.'
'Uncle, I am not happy here.' As she said this, she put down the cup which she had held, and, leaning her
elbows on the table, rested her forehead on her hands.
'And would you be happier at Boxall Hill? It is not the place that makes the happiness.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT 239
Page No 243
'No, I know that; it is not the place. I do not look to be happy in any place; but I should be quieter, more
tranquil elsewhere than here.'
'I also sometimes think that it would be better for us to take up our staves and walk away from
Greshamsbury;leave it altogether, and settle elsewhere; miles, miles, miles away from here. Should you
like that, dearest?'
Miles, miles, miles away from Greshamsbury! There was something in the sound that fell very cold on
Mary's ears, unhappy as she was. Greshamsbury had been so dear to her; in spite of all that had passed, was
still so dear to her! Was she prepared to take up her staff, as her uncle said, and walk forth from the place
with the full understanding that she was to return to it no more; with a mind resolved that there should be an
inseparable gulf between her and its inhabitants? Such she knew was the proposed nature of the walking
away of which her uncle spoke. So she sat there, resting on her arms, and gave no answer to the question that
had been put to her.
'No, we will stay here a while yet,' said her uncle. 'It may come to that, but this is not the time. For one season
longer let us faceI will not say our enemies; I cannot call anybody my enemy who bears the name of
Gresham.' And then he went on for a moment with his breakfast. 'So Frank will be here on the twelfth?'
'Yes, uncle.'
'Well, dearest, I have no questions to ask you; no directions to give. I know how good you are, and how
prudent; I am anxious only for your happiness; not at all'
'Happiness, uncle, is out of the question.'
'I hope not. It is never out of the question, never can be out of the question. But, as I was saying, I am quite
satisfied your conduct will be good, and, therefore, I have no questions to ask. We will remain here; and,
whether good or evil come, we will not be ashamed to show our faces.'
She sat for a while again silent; collecting her courage on the subject that was nearest her heart. She would
have given the world that he should ask her questions; but she could not bid him to do so; and she found it
impossible to talk openly to him about Frank unless he did so. 'Will he come here?' at last she said, in a
lowtoned voice.
'Who? He, Louis? Yes, I think that in all probability he will.'
'No; but Frank,' she said, in a still lower voice.
'Ah! my darling, that I cannot tell; but will it be well that he should come here?'
'I do not know,' she said. 'No, I suppose not. But, uncle, I don't think he will come.'
She was now sitting on a sofa, away from the table, and he got up sat down beside her, and took her hands in
his. 'Mary,' said he, 'you must be strong now; strong to endure, not to attack. I think that you have that
strength; but, if not, perhaps it will be better that we should go away.'
'I will be strong,' said she, rising up and going towards the door. 'Never mind me, uncle; don't follow me; I
will be strong. It will be base, cowardly, mean to run away; very base in me to make you do so.'
'No, dearest, not so; it will be the same to me.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT 240
Page No 244
'No,' said she, 'I will not run away from Lady Arabella. And, as for himif he loves this other one, he shall
hear no reproach from me. Uncle, I will be strong;' and running back to him, she threw her arms around him
and kissed him. And, still restraining her tears, she got safely to her bedroom. In what way she may there
have shown her strength, it would not be well for us to inquire.
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT
GRESHAMSBURY
During the last twelve months Sir Louis Scatcherd had been very efficacious in bringing trouble, turmoil, and
vexation upon Greshamsbury. Now that it was too late to take steps to save himself, Dr Thorne found that the
will left by Sir Roger was so made as to entail upon him duties that he would find it almost impossible to
perform. Sir Louis, though his father had wished to make him still a child in the eye of the law, was no child.
He knew his own rights and was determined to exact them; and before Sir Roger had been dead three months,
the doctor found himself in continual litigation with a low Barchester attorney, who was acting on behalf of
his, the doctor's, own ward.
And if the doctor suffered so did the squire, and so did those who had hitherto had the management of the
squire's affairs. Dr Thorne soon perceived that he was to be driven into litigation, not only with Mr Finnie,
the Barchester attorney, but with the squire himself. While Finnie harassed him, he was compelled to harass
Mr Gresham. He was no lawyer himself; and though he had been able to manage very well between the
squire and Sir Roger, and had perhaps given himself some credit for his lawyerlike ability in so doing, he
was utterly unable to manage between Sir Louis and Mr Gresham.
He had, therefore, to employ a lawyer on his own account, and it seemed probable that the whole amount of
Sir Roger's legacy to himself would by degrees be expended in this manner. And then the squire's lawyers
had to take up the matter; and they did so greatly to the detriment of poor Mr Yates Umbleby, who was found
to have made a mess of the affairs entrusted to him. Mr Umbleby's accounts were incorrect; his mind was
anything but clear, and he confessed, when put to it by the very sharp gentleman that came down from
London, that he was 'bothered'; and so, after a while, he was suspended from his duties, and Mr Gazebee, the
sharp gentleman from London, reigned over the diminished rentroll of the Greshamsbury estate.
Thus everything was going wrong at Greshamsburywith the one exception of Mr Oriel and his lovesuit.
Miss Gushing attributed the deposition of Mr Umbleby to the narrowness of the victory which Beatrice had
won in carrying off Mr Oriel. For Miss Gushing was a relation of the Umblebys, and had been for many years
one of their family. 'If she had only chosen to exert herself as Miss Gresham had done, she could have had
Mr Oriel, easily; oh, too easily! but she had despised such work,' so she said. 'But though she had despised it,
the Greshams had not been less irritated, and, therefore, Mr Umbleby had been driven out of his house.' We
can hardly believe this, as victory generally makes men generous. Miss Gushing, however, stated it as a fact
so often that it is probable she was induced to believe it herself.
Thus everything was going wrong at Greshamsbury, and the squire himself was especially a sufferer.
Umbleby had at any rate been his own man, and he could do what he liked with him. He could see him when
he liked, and where he liked, and now he liked; could scold him if in an illhumour, and laugh at him when
in a good humour. All this Mr Umbleby knew, and bore. But Mr Gazebee was a very different sort of
gentleman; he was the junior partner in the firm of Gumption, Gazebee Gazebee of Mount Street, a house that
never defiled itself with any other business than the agency business, and that in the very highest line. They
drew out leases, and managed property both for the Duke of Omnium and Lord De Courcy; and ever since
her marriage, it had been one of the objects dearest to Lady Arabella's heart that the Greshamsbury acres
should be superintended by the polite skill and polished legal ability of that all but elegant firm in Mount
Street.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 241
Page No 245
The squire had long stood firm, and had delighted in having everything done under his own eye by poor Mr
Yates Umbleby. But now, alas! he could stand it no longer. He had put off the evil day as long as he could; he
had deferred the odious work of investigation till things had seemed resolved on investigating themselves;
and then, when it was absolutely necessary that Mr Umbleby should go, there was nothing for him left but to
fall into the ready hands of Messrs Gumption, Gazebee and Gazebee.
It must not be supposed that Messrs Gumption, Gazebee and Gazebee were in the least like the ordinary run
of attorneys. They wrote no letters for sixandeightpence each: they collected no debts, filed no bills, made
no charge per folio for 'whereases' and 'as aforesaids'; they did no dirty work, and probably were as ignorant
of the interior of a court of law as any young lady living in their Mayfair vicinity. No; their business was to
manage the property of great people, draw up leases, make legal assignments, get the family marriage
settlements made, and look after wills. Occasionally, also, they had to raise money; but it was generally
understood that this was done by proxy.
The firm had been going on for a hundred and fifty years, and the designation had often been altered; but it
always consisted of Gumptions and Gazebees differently arranged, and no less hallowed names had ever been
permitted to appear. It had been Gazebee, Gazebee and Gumption; then Gazebee and Gumption; then
Gazebee, Gumption and Gumption; then Gumption, Gumption and Gazebee; and now it was Gumption,
Gazebee and Gazebee.
Mr Gazebee, the junior member of this firm, was a very elegant young man. While looking at him riding in
Rotten Row, you would hardly have taken him for an attorney; and had he heard that you had so taken him,
he would have been very much surprised indeed. He was rather bald; not being, as people say, quite so young
as he was once. His exact age was thirtyeight. But he had a really remarkable pair of jetblack whiskers,
which fully made up for his deficiency as to his head; he had also dark eyes, and a beaked nose, what may be
called a distinguished mouth, and was always dressed in fashionable attire. The fact was, that Mr Mortimer
Gazebee, junior partner in the firm Gumption, Gazebee, and Gazebee, by no means considered himself to be
made of that very disagreeable material which mortals call small beer.
When this great firm was applied to get Mr Gresham through his difficulties, and when the state of his affairs
was made known to them, they at first expressed rather a disinclination for the work. But at last, moved
doubtless by their respect for the De Courcy interest, they assented; and Mr Gazebee, junior, went down to
Greshamsbury. The poor squire passed many a sad day after that before he again felt himself to be master
even of his own domain.
Nevertheless, when Mr Mortimer Gazebee visited Greshamsbury, which he did on more than one or two
occasions, he was always received en grand seigneur. To Lady Arabella he was by no means an unwelcome
guest, for she found herself able, for the first time in her life, to speak confidentially on her husband's
pecuniary affairs with the man who had the management of her husband's property. Mr Gazebee also was a
pet with Lady De Courcy; and being known to be a fashionable man in London, and quite a different sort of
person from poor Mr Umbleby, he was always received with smiles. He had a hundred little ways of making
himself agreeable, and Augusta declared to her cousin, the Lady Amelia, after having been acquainted with
him for a few months, that he would be a perfect gentleman, only, that his family had never been anything but
attorneys. The Lady Amelia smiled in her own peculiarly aristocratic way, shrugged her shoulders slightly,
and said, 'that Mr Mortimer Gazebee was a very good sort of person, very.' Poor Augusta felt herself
snubbed, thinking perhaps of the tailor's son; but as there was never any appeal against the Lady Amelia, she
said nothing more at that moment in favour of Mr Mortimer Gazebee.
All these evilsMr Mortimer Gazebee being the worst of themhad Sir Louis Scatcherd brought down on
the poor squire's head. There may be those who will say that the squire had brought them on himself, by
running into debt; and so, doubtless, he had; but it was not the less true that the baronet's interference was
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 242
Page No 246
unnecessary, vexatious, and one might almost say, malicious. His interest would have been quite safe in the
doctor's hands, and he had, in fact, no legal right to meddle; but neither the doctor nor the squire could
prevent him. Mr Finnie knew very well what he was about, if Sir Louis did not; and so the three went on,
each with his own lawyer, and each of them distrustful, unhappy, and ill at ease. This was hard upon the
doctor, for he was not in debt, and had borrowed no money.
There was not much reason to suppose that the visit of Sir Louis to Greshamsbury would much improve
matters. It must be presumed that he was not coming with any amicable views, but with the object rather of
looking after his own; a phrase which was now constantly in his mouth. He might probably find it necessary
while looking after his own at Greshamsbury, to say some very disagreeable things to the squire; and the
doctor, therefore, hardly expected that the visit would go off pleasantly.
When last he saw Sir Louis, now nearly twelve months since, he was intent on making a proposal of marriage
to Miss Thorne. This intention he carried out about two days after Frank Gresham had done the same thing.
He had delayed doing so till he had succeeded in purchasing his friend Jenkins's Arab pony, imagining that
such a present could not but go far in weaning Mary's heart from her other lover. Poor Mary was put to the
trouble of refusing both the baronet and the pony, and a very bad time she had of it while doing so. Sir Louis
was a man easily angered, and not very easily pacified, and Mary had to endure a good deal of annoyance;
from any other person, indeed, she would have called it impertinence. Sir Louis, however, had to bear his
rejection as best he could, and, after a perseverance of three days, returned to London in disgust; and Mary
had not seen him since.
Mr Greyson's first letter was followed by a second; and the second was followed by the baronet in person. He
also required to be received en grand seigneur, perhaps more imperatively than Mr Mortimer Gazebee
himself. He came with four posters from the Barchester Station, and had himself rattled up to the doctor's
door in a way that took the breath away from all Greshamsbury. Why! the squire himself for a many long
year had been contented to come home with a pair of horses; and four were never seen in the place, except
when the De Courcys came to Greshamsbury, or Lady Arabella, with all her daughters returned from her
hardfought metropolitan campaigns.
Sir Louis, however, came with four, and very arrogant looked, leaning back in the barouche belonging to the
George and Dragon, and wrapped up in fur, although it was now midsummer. And up in the dicky behind
was a servant, more arrogant, if possible, than his masterthe baronet's own man, who was the object of Dr
Thorne's special detestation and disgust. He was a little fellow, chosen originally on account of his light
weight on horseback; but if that may be considered a merit, it was the only one he had. His outdoor show
dress was a little tight frockcoat, round which a polished strap was always buckled tightly, a stiff white
choker, leather breeches, topboots, and a hat, with a cockade, stuck on one side of his head. His name was
Jonah, which his master and his master's friends shortened to Joe; none, however, but those who were very
intimate with his master were allowed to do so with impunity.
This Joe was Dr Thorne's special aversion. In his anxiety to take every possible step to keep Sir Louis from
poisoning himself, he had at first attempted to enlist the baronet's 'own man' in the cause. Joe had promised
fairly, but had betrayed the doctor at once, and had become the worst instrument of his master's dissipation.
When, therefore, his hat and the cockade were seen, as the carriage dashed up to the door, the doctor's
contentment was by no means increased.
Sir Louis was now twentythree years old, and was a great deal too knowing to allow himself to be kept
under the doctor's thumb. It had, indeed, become his plan to rebel against his guardian in almost everything.
He had at first been decently submissive, with the view of obtaining increased supplies of ready money; but
he had been sharp enough to perceive that, let his conduct be what it would, the doctor would keep him out of
debt; but that the doing so took so large a sum that he could not hope for any further advances. In this respect
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 243
Page No 247
Sir Louis was perhaps more keenwitted than Dr Thorne.
Mary, when she saw the carriage, at once ran up to her own bedroom. The doctor, who had been with her in
the drawingroom, went down to meet his ward, but as soon as he saw the cockade he darted almost
involuntarily into his shop and shut the door. This protection, however, lasted only for a moment; he felt that
decency required him to meet his guest, and so he went forth and faced the enemy.
'I say,' said Joe, speaking to Janet, who stood curtsying at the gate, with Bridget, the other maid, behind her, 'I
say, are there any chaps about the place to take the thingseh? come, look sharp here.'
It so happened that the doctor's groom was not on the spot, and 'other chaps' the doctor had none.
'Take those things, Bridget,' he said, coming forward and offering his hand to the baronet. Sir Louis, when he
saw his host, roused himself slowly from the back of his carriage. 'How do, doctor?' said he. 'What terrible
bad roads you have here! and, upon my word, it's as cold as winter:' and, so saying, he slowly proceeded to
descend.
Sir Louis was a year older than when we last saw him, and, in his generation, a year wiser. He had then been
somewhat humble before the doctor; but now he was determined to let his guardian see that he knew how to
act the baronet; that he had acquired the manners of a great man; and that he was not to be put upon. He had
learnt some lessons from Jenkins in London, and other friends of the same sort, and he was about to profit by
them.
The doctor showed him to his room, and then proceeded to ask after his health. 'Oh, I'm right enough,' said
Sir Louis. 'You mustn't believe all that fellow Greyson tells you: he wants me to take salts and senna,
opodeldoc, and all that sort of stuff; looks after his bill, you knoweh? like all the rest of you. But I won't
have it;not at any price; and then he writes to you.'
'I'm glad to see you are able to travel,' said Dr Thorne, who could not force himself to tell his guest that he
was glad to see him at Greshamsbury.
'Oh, travel; yes, I can travel well enough. But I wish you had some better sort of trap down in these country
parts. I'm shaken to bits. And, doctor, would you tell your people to send that fellow of mine up here with hot
water.
So dismissed, the doctor went his way, and met Joe swaggering in one of the passages, while Janet and her
colleague dragged along between them a heavy article of baggage.
'Janet,' said he, 'go downstairs and get Sir Louis some hot water, and Joe, do you take hold of your master's
portmanteau.'
Joe sulkily did as he was bid. 'Seems to me,' said he, turning to the girl, and speaking before the doctor was
out of hearing, 'seems to me, my dear, you be rather shorthanded here; lots of work and nothing to get; that's
about the ticket, ain't it?' Bridget was too demurely modest to make any answer upon so short an
acquaintance; so, putting her end of the burden down at the strange gentleman's door, she retreated into the
kitchen.
Sir Louis in answer to the doctor's inquiries, had declared himself to be all right; but his appearance was
anything but all right. Twelve months since, a life of dissipation, or rather, perhaps, a life of drinking, had not
had upon him so strong an effect but that some of the salt of youth was still left; some of the freshness of
young years might still be seen in his face. But this was now all gone; his eyes were sunken and watery, his
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 244
Page No 248
cheeks were hollow and wan, his mouth was drawn and his lips dry; his back was even bent, and his legs
were unsteady under him, so that he had been forced to step down from his carriage as an old man would do.
Alas, alas! he had no further chance now of ever being all right again.
Mary had secluded herself in her bedroom as soon as the carriage had driven up to the door, and there she
remained till dinnertime. But she could not shut herself up altogether. It would be necessary that she should
appear at dinner; and, therefore, a few minutes before the hour, she crept out into the drawingroom. As she
opened the door, she looked in timidly, expecting Sir Louis to be there; but when she saw that her uncle was
the only occupant of the room, her brow cleared, and she entered with a quick step.
'He'll come down to dinner; won't he, uncle?'
'Oh, I suppose so.'
'What's he doing now?'
'Dressing, I suppose; he's been at this hour.'
'But, uncle'
'Well?'
'Will he come up after dinner, do you think?'
Mary spoke of him as though he were some wild beast, whom her uncle insisted on having in his house.
'Goodness knows what he will do! Come up? Yes. He will not stay in the diningroom all night.'
'But, dear uncle, do be serious.'
'Serious!'
'Yes; serious. Don't you think that I might go to bed, instead of waiting?'
The doctor was saved the trouble of answering by the entrance of the baronet. He was dressed in what he
considered the most fashionable style of the day. He had on a new dresscoat lined with satin, new
dresstrousers, a silk waistcoat covered with chains, a white cravat, polished pumps, and silk stockings, and
he carried a scented handkerchief in his hand; he had rings on his fingers, and carbuncle studs in his shirt, and
he smelt as sweet as patchouli could make him. But he could hardly do more than shuffle into the room, and
seemed almost to drag one of his legs behind him.
Mary, in spite of her aversion, was shocked and distressed when she saw him. He, however, seemed to think
himself perfect, and was no whit abashed by the unfavourable reception which twelve months since had been
paid to his suit. Mary came up and shook hands with him, and he received her with a compliment which no
doubt he thought must be acceptable. 'Upon my word, Miss Thorne, every place seems to agree with you; one
better than another. You were looking charming at Boxall Hill; but, upon my word, charming isn't half strong
enough now.'
Mary sat down quietly, and the doctor assumed a face of unutterable disgust. This was the creature for whom
all his sympathies had been demanded, all his best energies put in requisition; on whose behalf he was to
quarrel with his oldest friends, lose his peace and quietness of life, and exercise all the functions of a loving
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 245
Page No 249
friend! This was his selfinvited guest, whom he was bound to foster, and whom he could not turn from his
door.
The dinner came, and Mary had to put her hand upon his arm. She certainly did not lean upon him, and once
or twice felt inclined to give him some support. They reached the diningroom, however, the doctor
following them, and then sat down, Janet waiting in the room, as was usual.
'I say, doctor,' said the baronet, 'hadn't my man better come in and help? He's got nothing to do, you know.
We should be more cosy, shouldn't we?'
'Janet will manage pretty well,' said the doctor.
'Oh, you'd better have Joe; there's nothing like a good servant at table. I say, Janet, just send that fellow in,
will you?'
'We shall do very well without him,' said the doctor, becoming rather red about the cheekbones, and with a
slight gleam of determination about the eye. Janet, who saw how matters stood, made no attempt to obey the
baronet's order.
'Oh, nonsense, doctor; you think he's an uppish sort of fellow, I know, and you don't like to trouble him; but
when I'm near him, he's all right; just send him in, will you?'
'Sir Louis,' said the doctor, 'I'm accustomed to none but my own old woman here in my own house, and if you
will allow me, I'll keep my old ways. I shall be sorry if you are not comfortable.' The baronet said nothing
more, and the dinner passed off slowly and wearily enough.
When Mary had eaten her fruit and escaped, the doctor got into one armchair and the baronet into another,
and the latter began the only work of existence of which he knew anything.
'That's good port,' said he; 'very fair port.'
The doctor loved his port wine, and thawed a little in his manner. He loved it not as a toper, but as a collector
loves his pet pictures. He liked to talk about it, and think about it; to praise it, and hear it praised; to look at it
turned towards the light, and to count over the years it had lain in his cellar.
'Yes,' said he, 'it's pretty fair wine. It was, at least, when I got it, twenty years ago, and I don't suppose time
has hurt it;' and he held the glass up to the window, and looked at the evening light through the rosy tint of
the liquid. 'Ah, dear, there's not much of it left; more's the pity.'
'A good thing won't last for ever. I'll tell you what now; I wish I had brought down a dozen or two of claret.
I've some prime stuff in London; got it from Muzzle and Drug, at ninetysix shillings; it was a great favour,
though. I'll tell you what now, I'll send up for a couple of dozen tomorrow. I mustn't drink you out of the
house, high and dry; must I, doctor?'
The doctor froze immediately.
'I don't think I need trouble you,' said he; 'I never drink claret, at least not here; and there's enough of the old
bin left to last some little time longer yet.'
Sir Louis drank two or three glasses of wine very quickly after each other, and they immediately began to tell
upon his weak stomach. But before he was tipsy, he became more impudent and more disagreeable.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 246
Page No 250
'Doctor,' said he, 'when are we going to see any of this Greshamsbury money? That's what I want to know.'
'Your money is quite safe, Sir Louis; and the interest is paid to the day.'
'Interest yes; but how do I know how long it will be paid? I should like to see the principal. A hundred
thousand pounds, or something like it, is a precious large stake to have in one man's hands, and he is
preciously hard up himself. I'll tell you what, doctorI shall look the squire up myself.'
'Look him up?'
'Yes; look him up; ferret him out; tell him a bit of my mind. I'll thank you to pass the bottle. D me doctor;
I mean to know how things are going on.'
'Your money is quite safe,' repeated the doctor, 'and, to my mind, could not be better invested.'
'That's all very well; d well I dare say, for you and Squire Gresham'
'What do you mean, Sir Louis?'
'Mean! why I mean that I'll sell the squire up; that's what I meanhallobeg pardon. I'm blessed if I haven't
broken the waterjug. That comes of having water on the table. Oh, d me, it's all over me.' And then,
getting up, to avoid the flood he himself had caused, he nearly fell into the doctor's arms.
'You're tired with your journey, Sir Louis; perhaps you'd better go to bed.'
'Well, I am a bit seedy or so. Those cursed roads of yours shake a fellow so.'
The doctor rang the bell, and, on this occasion, did request that Joe might be sent for. Joe came in, and,
though he was much steadier than his master, looked as though he also had found some bin of which he had
approved.
'Sir Louis wishes to go to bed,' said the doctor; 'you had better give him your arm.'
'Oh, yes; in course I will,' said Joe, standing immoveable about halfway between the door and the table.
'I'll just take one more glass of the old porteh, doctor?' said Sir Louis, putting out his hand and clutching
the decanter.
It is very hard for any man to deny his guest in his own house, and the doctor, at the moment, did not know
how to do it; so Sir Louis got his wine, after pouring half of it over the table.
'Come in, sir, and give Sir Louis your arm,' said the doctor, angrily.
'So I will in course, if my master tells me; but, if you please, Dr Thorne' and Joe put his hand up to his hair
in a manner that a great deal more impudence than reverence in it'I just want to ax one question; where be
I to sleep?'
Now this was a question which the doctor was not prepared to answer on the spur of the moment, however
well Janet or Mary might have been able to do so.
'Sleep,' said he, 'I don't know where you are to sleep, and don't care; ask Janet.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 247
Page No 251
'That's all very well, master'
'Hold your tongue, sirrah!' said Sir Louis. 'What the devil do you want of sleep?come here,' and then, with
his servant's help, he made his way up to his bedroom, and was no more heard of that night.
'Did he get tipsy,' asked Mary, almost in a whisper, when her uncle joined her in the drawingroom.
'Don't talk of it,' said he. 'Poor wretch! poor wretch! Let's have some tea now, Molly, and pray don't talk any
more about him tonight.' Then Mary did make the tea, and did not talk any more about Sir Louis that night.
What on earth were they to do with him? He had come there selfinvited; but his connexion with the doctor
was such, that it was impossible he should be told to go away, either he himself, or that servant of his. There
was no reason to disbelieve him when he declared that he had come down to ferret out the squire. Such was,
doubtless, his intention. He would ferret out the squire. Perhaps he might ferret out Lady Arabella also. Frank
would be home in a few days; and he, too, might be ferreted out.
But the matter took a very singular turn, and one quite unexpected on the doctor's part. On the morning
following the little dinner of which we have spoken, one of the Greshamsbury grooms rode up to the doctor's
door with two notes. One was addressed to the doctor in the squire's wellknown large handwriting, and the
other was for Sir Louis. Each contained an invitation do dinner for the following day; and that to the doctor
was in this wise:
'DEAR DOCTOR,
Do come and dine here tomorrow, and bring Sir Louis Scatcherd with you. If you're the man I take you to
be, you won't refuse me. Lady Arabella sends a note for Sir Louis. There will be nobody here but Oriel, and
Mr Gazebee, who's staying in the house.
'Yours ever, F.N.GRESHAM'
'PSI make a positive request that you'll come, and I think you will hardly refuse me.'
The doctor read it twice before he could believe it, and then ordered Janet to take the other note up to Sir
Louis. As these invitations were rather in opposition to the then existing Greshamsbury tactics, the cause of
Lady Arabella's special civility must be explained.
Mr Mortimer Gazebee was now at the house, and therefore, it must be presumed, that things were not allowed
to go on after their old fashion. Mr Gazebee was an acute as well as fashionable man; one who knew what he
was about, and who, moreover, had determined to give his very best efforts on behalf of the Greshamsbury
property. His energy, in this respect, will explain itself hereafter. It was not probable that the arrival in the
village of such a person as Sir Louis Scatcherd should escape attention. He had heard of it before dinner, and,
before the evening was over, had discussed it with Lady Arabella.
Her ladyship was not at first inclined to make much of Sir Louis, and expressed herself as but little inclined
to agree with Mr Gazebee when that gentleman suggested that he should be treated with civility at
Greshamsbury. But she was at last talked over. She found it pleasant enough to have more to do with the
secret management of the estate than Mr Gresham himself; and when Mr Gazebee proved to her, by sundry
nods and winks, and subtle allusions to her own infinite good sense, that it was necessary to catch this
obscene bird which had come to prey upon the estate, by throwing a little salt upon his tail, she also nodded
and winked, and directed Augusta to prepare the salt according to order.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 248
Page No 252
'But won't it be odd, Mr Gazebee, asking him out of Dr Thorne's house?'
'Oh, we must have the doctor, too, Lady Arabella; by all means ask the doctor also.'
Lady Arabella's brow grew dark. 'Mr Gazebee,' she said, 'you can hardly believe how that man has behaved to
me.'
'He is altogether beneath your anger,' said Mr Gazebee, with a bow.
'I don't know: in one way he may be, but not in another. I really do not think I can sit down to table with
Doctor Thorne.'
But, nevertheless, Mr Gazebee gained his point. It was now about a week since Sir Omicron Pie had been at
Greshamsbury, and the squire had, almost daily, spoken to his wife as to that learned man's advice. Lady
Arabella always answered in the same tone: 'You can hardly know, Mr Gresham, how that man has insulted
me.' But, nevertheless, the physician's advice had not been disbelieved: it tallied too well with her own
inward convictions. She was anxious enough to have Doctor Thorne back at her bedside, if she could only get
him there without damage to her pride. Her husband, she thought, might probably send the doctor there
without absolute permission from herself; in which case she would have been able to scold, and show that she
was offended; and, at the same time, profit by what had been done. But Mr Gresham never thought of taking
so violent a step as this, and, therefore, Dr Fillgrave still came, and her ladyship's finesse was wasted in vain.
But Mr Gazebee's proposition opened a door by which her point might be gained. 'Well,' said she, at last, with
infinite selfdenial, 'if you think it is for Mr Gresham's advantage, and if he chooses to ask Dr Thorne, I will
not refuse to receive him.'
Mr Gazebee's next task was to discuss the matter with the squire. Nor was this easy, for Mr Gazebee was no
favourite with Mr Gresham. But the task was at last performed successfully. Mr Gresham was so glad at heart
to find himself able, once more, to ask his old friend to his own house; and, though it would have pleased him
better that this sign of relenting on his wife's part should have reached him by other means, he did not refuse
to take advantage of it; and so he wrote the above letter to Dr Thorne.
The doctor, as we have said, read it twice; and he at once resolved stoutly that he would not go.
'Oh, do, do, do go!' said Mary. She well knew how wretched this feud had made her uncle. 'Pray, pray go!'
'Indeed, I will not,' said he. 'There are some things a man should bear, and some he should not.'
'You must go,' said Mary, who had taken the note from her uncle's hand, and read it. 'You cannot refuse him
when he asks you like that.'
'It will greatly grieve me; but I must refuse him.'
'I also am angry, uncle; very angry with Lady Arabella; but for him, for the squire, I would go to him on my
knees if he asked me in that way.'
'Yes; and had he asked you, I also would have gone.'
'Oh! now I shall be so wretched. It is his invitation, not hers: Mr Gresham could not ask me. As for her, do
not think of her; but do, do go when he asks you like that. You will make me so miserable if you do not. And
then Sir Louis cannot go without you,'and Mary pointed upstairs'and you may be sure that he will go.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 249
Page No 253
'Yes; and make a beast of himself.'
This colloquy was cut short by a message praying the doctor to go up to Sir Louis's room. The young man
was sitting in his dressinggown, drinking a cup of coffee at his toilettable, while Joe was preparing his
razor and hot water. The doctor's nose immediately told him that there was more in the coffeecup than had
come out of his own kitchen, and he would not let the offence pass unnoticed.
'Are you taking brandy this morning, Sir Louis?'
'Just a little chassecafe,' said he, not exactly understanding the word he used. 'It's all the go now; and a
capital thing for the stomach.'
'It's not a capital thing for your stomach;about the least capital thing you can take; that is, if you wish to
live.'
'Never mind about that now, doctor, but look here. This is what we call the civil thingeh?' and he showed
the Greshamsbury note. 'Not but that they have an object, of course. I understand all that. Lots of girls
thereeh?'
The doctor took the note and read it. 'It is civil,' said he; 'very civil.'
'Well; I shall go, of course. I don't bear malice because he can't pay me the money he owes me. I'll eat his
dinner, and look at the girls. Have you an invite too, doctor?'
'Yes; I have.'
'And you'll go?'
'I think not; but that need not deter you. But, Sir Louis'
'Well! eh! what is it?'
'Step downstairs a moment,' said the doctor, turning to the servant, 'and wait till you are called for. I wish to
speak to your master.' Joe, for a moment, looked up at the baronet's face, as though he wanted but the
slightest encouragement to disobey the doctor's orders; but not seeing it, he slowly retired, and placed
himself, of course, at the keyhole.
And then, the doctor began a long and very useless lecture. The first object of it was to induce his ward not to
get drunk at Greshamsbury; but having got so far, he went on, and did succeed in frightening his unhappy
guest. Sir Louis did not possess the iron nerves of his fathernerves which even brandy had not been able to
subdue. The doctor spoke, strongly, very strongly; spoke of quick, almost immediate death in case of further
excesses; spoke to him of the certainty there would be that he could not live to dispose of his own property if
he could not refrain. And thus he did frighten Sir Louis. The father he had never been able to frighten. But
there are men who, though they fear death hugely, fear present suffering more; who, indeed, will not bear a
moment of pain if there by any mode of escape. Sir Louis was such: he had no strength of nerve, no courage,
no ability to make a resolution and keep it. He promised the doctor that he would refrain; and, as he did so, he
swallowed down his cup of coffee and brandy, in which the two articles bore about equal proportions.
The doctor did, at last, make up his mind to go. Whichever way he determined, he found that he was not
contented with himself. He did not like to trust Sir Louis by himself, and he did not like to show that he was
angry. Still less did he like the idea of breaking bread in Lady Arabella's house till some amends had been
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 250
Page No 254
made to Mary. But his heart would not allow him to refuse the petition contained in the squire's postscript,
and the matter ended in his accepting the invitation.
This visit of his ward's was, in every way, pernicious to the doctor. He could not go about his business,
fearing to leave such a man alone with Mary. On the afternoon of the second day, she escaped to the
parsonage for an hour or so, and then, walked away among the lanes, calling on some of her old friends
among the farmers' wives. But even then, the doctor was afraid to leave Sir Louis. What could such a man do,
left alone in a village like Greshamsbury? So he stayed at home, and the two together went over their
accounts. The baronet was particular about his accounts, and said a good deal as to having Finnie over to
Greshamsbury. To this, however, Dr Thorne positively refused his consent.
The evening passed off better than the preceding one; at least the early part of it. Sir Louis did not get tipsy;
he came up to tea, and Mary, who did not feel so keenly on the subject as her uncle, almost wished that he
had done so. At ten o'clock he went to bed.
But after that new troubles came on. The doctor had gone downstairs into his study to make up some of the
time which he had lost, and had just seated himself at his desk, when Janet, without announcing herself, burst
into the room; and Bridget, dissolved in hysterical tears, with her apron to her eyes, appeared behind the
senior domestic.
'Please, sir,' said Janet, driven by excitement much beyond her usual place of speaking, and becoming
unintentionally a little less respectful than usual, 'please sir, that 'ere young man must go out of this here
house; or else no respectable young 'ooman can't stop here; no, indeed, sir; and we be sorry to trouble you, Dr
Thorne; so we be.'
'What young man? Sir Louis?' asked the doctor.
'Man!' sobbed Bridget from behind. 'He an't no man, no nothing like a man. If Tummas had been here, he
wouldn't have dared; so he wouldn't.' Thomas was the groom, and, if all Greshamsbury reports were true, it
was probable, that on some happy, future day, Thomas and Bridget would become one flesh and one bone.
'Please sir,' continued Janet, 'there'll be bad work here if there 'ere young man doesn't quit this here house this
very night, and I'm sorry to trouble you, doctor; and so I am. But Tom, he be given to fight a'most for nothin'.
He's out now; but if that there young man be's here when Tom comes home, Tom will be punching his head; I
know he will.'
'He wouldn't stand by and see a poor girl put upon; no more he wouldn't,' said Bridget, through her tears.
After many futile inquiries, the doctor ascertained that Mr Jonah had expressed some admiration for Bridget's
youthful charms, and had, in the absence of Janet, thrown himself at the lady's feet in a manner which had not
been altogether pleasing to her. She had defended herself stoutly and loudly, and in the middle of the row
Janet had come down.
'And where is he now?' said the doctor.
'Why, sir,' said Janet, 'the poor girl was so put about that she did give him one touch across the face with the
rollingpin, and he be all bloody now, in the back kitchen.' At hearing this achievement of hers thus spoken
of, Bridget sobbed more hysterically than ever; but the doctor, looking at her arm as she held her apron to her
face, thought in his heart that Joe must have had so much the worst of it, that there could be no possible need
for the interference of Thomas the groom.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY 251
Page No 255
And such turned out to be the case. The bridge of Joe's nose was broken; and the doctor had to set it for him
in a little bedroom at the village publichouse, Bridget having positively refused to go to bed in the same
house with so dreadful a character.
'Quiet now, or I'll be serving thee the same way; thee see I've found the trick of it.' The doctor could not but
hear so much as he made into his own house by the back door, after finishing his surgical operation. Bridget
was recounting to her champion the fracas that had occurred; and he, as was so natural, was expressing his
admiration for her valour.
CHAPTER XXXV. SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER
The next day Joe did not make his appearance, and Sir Louis with many execrations, was driven to the
terrible necessity of dressing himself. Then came an unexpected difficulty: how were they to get up to the
house? Walking out to dinner, though it was merely through the village and up the avenue seemed to Sir
Louis to be a thing impossible. Indeed, he was not well able to walk at all, and positively declared that he
should never be able to make his way over the gravel in pumps. His mother would not have thought half as
much of walking from Boxall Hill to Greshamsbury and back again. At last, the one village fly was sent for,
and the matter was arranged.
When they reached the house, it was easy to see that there was some unwonted bustle. In the drawingroom
there was no one but Mr Mortimer Gazebee, who introduced himself to them both. Sir Louis, who knew that
he was only an attorney, did not take much notice of him, but the doctor entered into conversation.
'Have you not heard that Mr Gresham has come home?'
'Mr Gresham! I did not know that he had been away.'
'Mr Gresham, junior, I mean.' No, indeed; the doctor had not heard. Frank had returned unexpectedly, just
before dinner, and was now undergoing his father's smiles, his mother's embraces, and his sisters' questions.
'Quite unexpectedly,' said Mr Gazebee. 'I don't know what has brought him back before his time. I suppose he
found London too hot.'
'Deuced hot,' said the baronet. 'I found it so, at least. I don't know what keeps men in London when it's so hot;
except those fellows who have business to do: they're paid for it.'
Mr Mortimer Gazebee looked at him. He was managing an estate which owed Sir Louis an enormous sum of
money, and, therefore, he could not afford to despise the baronet; but he thought to himself, what a very
abject fellow the man would be if he were not a baronet, and had not a large fortune!
And the squire came in. His broad, honest face was covered with a smile when he saw the doctor.
'Thorne,' said he, almost in a whisper, 'you're the best fellow breathing; I have hardly deserved this.' The
doctor, as he took his old friend's hand, could not but be glad that he had followed Mary's counsel.
'So Frank has come home?'
'Oh, yes; quite unexpectedly. He was to have stayed a week longer in London. You would hardly know him if
you met him. Sir Louis, I beg your pardon.' And the squire went up to his other guest, who had remained
somewhat sullenly standing in one corner of the room. He was the man of highest rank present, or to be
present, and he expected to be treated as such.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXV. SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER 252
Page No 256
'I am happy to have the pleasure of making your acquaintance, Mr Gresham,' said the baronet, intending to be
very courteous. 'Though we have not met before, I very often see your name in my accountsha! ha! ha!'
and Sir Louis laughed as though he had said something very good.
The meeting between Lady Arabella and the doctor was rather distressing to the former; but she managed to
get over it. She shook hands with him graciously, and said that it was a fine day. The doctor said that it was
fine, only perhaps a little rainy. And then they went into different parts of the room.
When Frank came in, the doctor hardly did know him. His hair was darker than it had been, and so was his
complexion; but his chief disguise was in a long silken beard, which hung down over his cravat. The doctor
had hitherto not been much in favour of long beards, but he could not deny that Frank looked very well with
the appendage.
'Oh, doctor, I am so delighted to find you here,' said he, coming up to him; 'so very, very glad:' and, taking
the doctor's arm, he led him away into a window, where they were alone. 'And how is Mary?' said he, almost
in a whisper. 'Oh, I wish she were here! But, doctor, it shall all come in time. But tell me, doctor, there is no
news about her, is there?'
'Newswhat news?'
'Oh, well; no news is good news: you will give her my love, won't you?'
The doctor said that he would. What else could he say? It appeared quite clear to him that some of Mary's
fears were groundless.
Frank was again very much altered. It has been said, that though he was a boy at twentyone, he was a man
at twentytwo. But now, at twentythree, he appeared to be almost a man of the world. His manners were
easy, his voice under his control, and words were at his command: he was no longer either shy or noisy; but,
perhaps, was open to the charge of seeming, at least, to be too conscious of his own merits. He was, indeed,
very handsome; tall, manly, and powerfully built, his form was such as women's eyes have ever loved to look
upon. 'Ah, if he would but marry money!' said Lady Arabella to herself, taken up by a mother's natural
admiration for her son. His sisters clung around him before dinner, all talking to him at once. How proud a
family of girls are of one, big, tall, burly brother!
'You don't mean to tell me, Frank, that you are going to eat soup with that beard?' said the squire, when they
were seated round the table. He had not ceased to rally his son as to this patriarchal adornment; but,
nevertheless, any one could have seen, with half and eye, that he was as proud of it as were the others.
'Don't I, sir? All I require is a relay of napkins for every course;' and he went to work, covering it with every
spoonful, as men with beards always do.
'Well, if you like it!' said the squire, shrugging his shoulders.
'But I do like it,' said Frank.
'Oh, papa, you wouldn't have him cut it off,' said one of the twins. 'It is so handsome.'
'I should like to work it into a chairback instead of flosssilk,' said the other twin.
'Thank 'ee, Sophy; I'll remember you for that.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXV. SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER 253
Page No 257
'Doesn't it look nice, and grand, and patriarchal?' said Beatrice, turning to her neighbour.
'Patriarchal, certainly,' said Mr Oriel. 'I should grow one myself if I had not the fear of the archbishop before
my eyes.'
What was next said to him was in a whisper, audible only to himself.
'Doctor, did you know Wildman of the Ninth. He was left as surgeon at Scutari for two years. Why, my beard
to his is only a little down.'
'A little way down, you mean,' said Mr Gazebee.
'Yes,' said Frank, resolutely set against laughing at Mr Gazebee's pun. 'Why, his beard descends to his ankles,
and he is obliged to tie it in a bag at night, because his feet get entangled in it when he is asleep!'
'Oh, Frank!' said one of the girls.
This was all very well for the squire, and Lady Arabella, and the girls. They were all delighted to praise
Frank, and talk about him. Neither did it come amiss to Mr Oriel and the doctor, who had both a personal
interest in the young hero. But Sir Louis did not like it at all. He was the only baronet in the room, and yet
nobody took any notice of him. He was seated in the post of honour, next to Lady Arabella; but even Lady
Arabella seemed to think more of her own son than of him. Seeing he was illused, he meditated revenge; but
not the less did it behove him to make some effort to attract attention.
'Was your ladyship in London, this season?'
Lady Arabella had not been in London at all this year, and it was a sore subject with her. 'No,' said she, very
graciously; 'circumstances have kept us at home.'
'Ah, indeed! I am very sorry for that; that must be very distressing to a person like your ladyship. But things
are mending, perhaps?'
Lady Arabella did not in the least understand him. 'Mending!' she said, in her peculiar tone of aristocratic
indifference; and then turned to Mr Gazebee, who was on the other side of her.
Sir Louis was not going to stand this. He was the first man in the room, and he knew his own importance. It
was not to be borne that Lady Arabella should turn to talk to a dirty attorney, and leave him, a baronet, to eat
his dinner without notice. If nothing else would move her, he would let her know who was the real owner of
the Greshamsbury titledeeds.
'I think I saw your ladyship out today, taking a ride,' Lady Arabella had driven through the village in her
ponychair.
'I never ride,' said she, turning her head for one moment from Mr Gazebee.
'In the onehorse carriage, I mean, my lady. I was delighted with the way you whipped him up round the
corner.'
Whipped him up round the corner! Lady Arabella could make no answer to this; so she went on talking to Mr
Gazebee. Sir Louis, repulsed, but not vanquishedresolved not to be vanquished by any Lady Arabella
turned his attention to his plate for a minute or two, and then recommenced.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXV. SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER 254
Page No 258
'The honour of a glass of wine with you, Lady Arabella,' said he.'
'I never take wine at dinner,' said Lady Arabella. The man was becoming intolerable to her, and she was
beginning to fear that it would be necessary for her to fly the room to get rid of him.
The baronet was again silent for a moment; but he was determined not to be put down.
'This is a nicelooking country about her,' said he.
'Yes; very nice,' said Mr Gazebee, endeavouring to relieve the lady of the mansion.
'I hardly know which I like best; this, or my own place at Boxall Hill. You have the advantage here in trees,
and those sort of things. But, as to the house, why, my box there is very comfortable, very. You'd hardly
know the place now, Lady Arabella, if you haven't seen it since my governor bought it. How much do you
think he spent about the house and grounds, pineries included, you know, and those sort of things.'
Lady Arabella shook her head.
'Now guess, my lady,' said he. But it was not to be supposed that Lady Arabella should guess on such a
subject.
'I never guess,' said she, with a look of ineffable disgust.
'What do you say, Mr Gazebee?'
'Perhaps a hundred thousand pounds.'
'What! for a house! You can't know much about money, nor yet about building, I think, Mr Gazebee.'
'Not much,' said Mr Gazebee, 'as to such magnificent places as Boxall Hill.'
'Well, my lady, if you won't guess, I'll tell you. It cost twentytwo thousand four hundred and nineteen
pounds four shillings and eightpence. I've all the accounts exact. Now, that's a tidy lot of money for a house
for a man to live in.'
Sir Louis spoke this in a loud tone, which at least commanded the attention of the table. Lady Arabella,
vanquished, bowed her head, and said that it was a large sum; Mr Gazebee went on sedulously eating his
dinner; the squire was struck momentarily dumb in the middle of a long chat with the doctor; even Mr Oriel
ceased to whisper; and the girls opened their eyes with astonishment. Before the end of his speech, Sir Louis's
voice had become very loud.
'Yes, indeed,' said Frank; 'a very tidy lot of money. I'd have generously dropped the four and eightpence if I'd
been the architect.'
'It wasn't on one bill; but that's the tot. I can show the bills;' and Sir Louis, well pleased with his triumph,
swallowed a glass of wine.
Almost immediately after the cloth was removed, Lady Arabella escaped, and the gentlemen clustered
together. Sir Louis found himself next to Mr Oriel, and began to make himself agreeable.
'A very nice girl, Miss Beatrice; very nice.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXV. SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER 255
Page No 259
Now Mr Oriel was a modest man, and, when thus addressed as to his future wife, found it difficult to make
any reply.
'You parsons always have your own luck,' said Sir Louis. 'You get all the beauty, and generally all the money,
too. Not much of the latter in this case, thougheh?'
Mr Oriel was dumbfounded. He had never said a word any creature as to Beatrice's dowry; and when Mr
Gresham had told him, with sorrow, that his daughter's portion must be small, he had at once passed away
from the subject as one that was hardly fit for conversation, even between him and his future fatherinlaw;
and now he was abruptly questioned on the subject by a man he had never seen before in his life. Of course,
he could make no answer.
'The squire has muddled his matters most uncommonly,' continued Sir Louis, filling his glass for the second
time before he passed the bottle. 'What do you suppose now he owes me alone; just at one lump, you know?'
Mr Oriel had nothing for it but to run. He could make no answer, nor would he sit there for tidings as to Mr
Gresham's embarrassments. So he fairly retreated, without having said one word to his neighbour, finding
such discretion to be the only kind of valour left to him.
'What, Oriel! off already?' said the squire. 'Anything the matter?'
'Oh, no; nothing particular. I'm not just quiteI think I will go out for a few minutes.'
'See what it is to be in love,' said the squire, halfwhispering to Dr Thorne. 'You're not in the same way, I
hope?'
Sir Louis then shifted his seat again, and found himself next to Frank. Mr Gazebee was opposite to him, and
the doctor opposite to Frank.
'Parson seems peekish, I think,' said the baronet.
'Peekish!?' said the squire, inquisitively.
'Rather down on his luck. He's decently well off himself, isn't he?'
There was another pause, and nobody seemed inclined to answer the question.
'I mean, he's got something more than his bare living.'
'Oh, yes,' said Frank, laughing. 'He's got what will buy him bread and cheese when the Rads shut up the
Church:unless, indeed, they shut up the Funds too.'
'Ah, there's nothing like land,'said Sir Louis: 'nothing like dirty acres; is there, squire?'
'Land is a very good investment, certainly,' said the Mr Gresham.
'The best going,' said the other, who was now, as people say when they mean to be goodnatured, slightly
under the influence of liquor. 'The best goingeh, Gazebee?'
Mr Gazebee gathered himself up, and turned away his head, looking out of the window.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXV. SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER 256
Page No 260
'You lawyers never like to give an opinion without money, ha! ha! ha! Do they, Mr Gresham? You and I have
had to pay for plenty of them, and will have to pay plenty more before they let us alone.'
Here Mr Gazebee got up, and followed Mr Oriel out of the room. He was not, of course, on such intimate
terms in the house as was Mr Oriel; but he hoped to be forgiven by the ladies in consequence of the severity
of the miseries to which he was subjected. He and Mr Oriel were soon to be seen through the diningroom
window, walking about the grounds with the two eldest Miss Greshams. And Patience Oriel, who had also
been of the party, was also to be seen with the twins. Frank looked at his father with almost a malicious
smile, and began to think that he too might be better employed out among the walks. Did he think then of a
former summer evening, when he had half broken Mary's heart by walking there too lovingly with Patience
Oriel?
Sir Louis, if he continued his brilliant career of success, would soon be left the cock of the walk. The squire,
to be sure, could not bolt, nor could the doctor very well; but they might be equally vanquished, remaining
there in their chairs. Dr Thorne, during all this time, was sitting with tingling ears. Indeed, it may be said that
his whole body tingled. He was in a manner responsible for this horrible scene; but what could he do to stop
it? He could not take Sir Louis up bodily and carry him away. One idea did occur to him. The fly had been
ordered for ten o'clock. He could rush out and send for it instantly.
'You're not going to leave me?' said the squire, in a voice of horror, as he saw the doctor rising from his chair.
'Oh, no, no, no,' said the doctor; and then he whispered the purpose of his mission. 'I will be back in two
minutes.' The doctor would have given twenty pounds to have closed the scene at once; but he was not the
man to desert his friend in such a strait as that.
'He's a wellmeaning fellow, the doctor,' said Sir Louis, when his guardian was out of the room, 'very; but
he's not up to trapnot at all.'
'Up to trapwell, I should say he was; that is, if I know what trap means,' said Frank.
'Ah, but that's just the ticket. Do you know? Now I say Dr Thorne's not a man of the world.'
'He's about the best man I know, or ever heard of,' said the squire. 'And if any man ever had a good friend,
you have got one in him; and so have I:' and the squire silently drank the doctor's health.
'All very true, I dare say; but yet he's not up to trap. Now look here, squire'
'If you don't mind, sir,' said Frank, 'I've got something very particularperhaps, however'
'Stay till Thorne returns, thanks Frank.'
Frank did stay till Thorne returned, and then escaped.
'Excuse me, doctor,' said he, 'but I've something very particular to say; I'll explain tomorrow.' And then the
three were left alone.
Sir Louis was no becoming almost drunk, and was knocking his words together. The squire had already
attempted to stop the bottle; but the baronet had contrived to get hold of a modicum of Madeira, and there
was no preventing him from helping himself; at least, none at the moment.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXV. SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER 257
Page No 261
'As we were saying about lawyers,' continued Sir Louis. 'Let's see, what were we saying? Why, squire, it's
just here. These fellows will fleece us both if we don't mind what we are after.'
'Never mind about lawyers now,' said Dr Thorne, angrily.
'Ah, but I do mind; most particularly. That's all very well for you, doctor; you've nothing to lose. You've no
great stake in the matter. Why, now, what sum of money of mine do you think those d doctors are
handling?'
'D doctors!' said the squire in a tone of dismay.
'Lawyers, I mean, of course. Why, now, Gresham, we're all totted now, you see; you're down in my books, I
take it, for pretty near a hundred thousand pounds.'
'Hold your tongue, sir,' said the doctor, getting up.
'Hold my tongue!' said Sir Louis.
'Sir Louis Scatcherd,' said the squire, slowly rising from his chair, 'we will not, if you please, talk about
business at the present moment. Perhaps we had better go to the ladies.'
This latter proposition had certainly not come from the squire's heart: going to the ladies was the very last
thing for which Sir Louis was now fit. But the squire had said it as being the only recognised formal way he
could think of for breaking up the symposium.
'Oh, very well,' hiccupped the baronet, 'I'm always ready for the ladies,' and he stretched out his hand to the
decanter to get a last glass of Madeira.
'No,' said the doctor, rising stoutly, and speaking with a determined voice. 'No; you will have no more wine.'
'What's all this about?' said Sir Louis, with a drunken laugh.
'Of course he cannot go into the drawingroom, Mr Gresham. If you will leave him here with me, I will stay
with him, till the fly comes. Pray tell Lady Arabella from me how sorry I am that this has occurred.'
The squire took him by the hand affectionately. 'I've seen a tipsy man before tonight,' said he.
'Yes,' said the doctor, 'and so have I, but' He did not express the rest of his thoughts.
CHAPTER XXXVI. WILL HE COME AGAIN?
Long before the doctor returned home after the little dinnerparty above described, Mary had learnt that
Frank was already at Greshamsbury. She had heard nothing of him, not a word, nothing in the shape of a
message, for twelve months; and at her age twelve months is a long period. Would he come and see her in
spite of his mother? Would he send her any tidings of is return, or notice her in any way? If he did not, what
would she do? and if he did, what then would she do? It was so hard to resolve; so hard to be deserted; and so
hard to dare to wish that she might not be deserted! She continued to say to herself, that it would be better
that they should be strangers; and she could hardly keep herself from tears in the fear that they might be so.
What chance could there be that he should care for her, after an absence spent in travelling over the world?
No; she would forget that affair of his hand; and then, immediately after having so determined, she would
confess to herself that it was a thing not to be forgotten, and impossible of oblivion.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVI. WILL HE COME AGAIN? 258
Page No 262
On her uncle's return, she would hear some word about him; and so she sat alone, with a book before her, of
which she could not read a line. She expected them about eleven, and was, therefore, rather surprised when
the fly stopped at the door before nine.
She immediately heard her uncle's voice, loud and angry, calling for Thomas. Both Thomas and Bridget were
unfortunately out, being, at this moment, forgetful of all sublunary cares, and seated in happiness under a
beechtree in the park. Janet flew to the little gate, and there found Sir Louis insisting that he would be taken
at once to his own mansion at Boxall Hill, and positively swearing that he would not longer submit to the
insult of the doctor's surveillance.
In the absence of Thomas, the doctor was forced to apply for assistance to the driver of the fly. Between them
the baronet was dragged out of the vehicle, the windows suffered much, and the doctor's hat also. In this way,
he was taken upstairs, and was at last put to bed, Janet assisting: nor did the doctor leave the room till his
guest was asleep. Then he went into the drawingroom to Mary. It may easily be conceived that he was
hardly in a humour to talk much about Frank Gresham.
'What am I to do with him?' said he, almost in tears: 'what am I to do with him?'
'Can you send him to Boxall Hill?' asked Mary.
'Yes; to kill himself there! But it is no matter; he will kill himself somewhere. Oh! what that family have
done for me!' And then, suddenly remembering a portion of their doings, he took Mary in his arms, and
kissed and blessed her; and declared that, in spite of all this, he was a happy man.
There was no word about Frank that night. The next morning the doctor found Sir Louis very weak, and
begging for stimulants. He was worse than weak; he was in such a state of wretched misery and mental
prostration; so low in heart, in such collapse of energy and spirit, that Dr Thorne thought it prudent to remove
his razors from his reach.
'For God's sake do let me have a little chassecafe; I'm always used to it; ask Joe if I'm not! You don't want to
kill me, do you?' And the baronet cried piteously, like a child, and, when the doctor left him for the
breakfasttable, abjectly implored Janet to get him some curacoa which he knew was in one of his
portmanteaus. Janet, however, was true to her master.
The doctor did give him some wine; and then, having left strict orders as to his treatmentBridget and
Thomas being now both in the housewent forth to some of his too much neglected patients.
Then Mary was again alone, and her mind flew away to her lover. How should she be able to compose herself
when she should first see him? See him she must. People cannot live in the same village without meeting. If
she passed him at the churchdoor, as she often passed Lady Arabella, what should she do? Lady Arabella
always smiled a peculiar, little, bitter smile, and this, with half a nod of recognition, carried off the meeting.
Should she try the bitter smile, the halfnod with Frank? Alas! she knew it was not in her to be so much
mistress of her own heart's blood.
As she thus thought, she stood in the drawingroom window, looking out into her garden; and, as she leant
against the sill, her head was surrounded by the sweet creepers. 'At any rate, he won't come here,' she said:
and so, with a deep sigh, she turned from the window into the room.
There he was, Frank Gresham himself standing there in her immediate presence, beautiful as Apollo. Her
next thought was how she might escape from out of his arms. How it happened that she had fallen into them,
she never knew.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVI. WILL HE COME AGAIN? 259
Page No 263
'Mary! my own, own love! my own one! sweetest! dearest! best! Mary! dear Mary! have you not a word to
say to me?'
No; she had not a word, though her life depended on it. The exertion necessary for not crying was quite
enough for her. This, then, was the bitter smile and the halfnod that was to pass between them; this was the
manner in which estrangement was to grow into indifference; this was the mode of meeting by which she was
to prove that she was mistress of her conduct, if not her heart! There he held her close bound to his breast,
and she could only protect her face, and that all ineffectually, with her hands. 'He loves another,' Beatrice had
said. 'At any rate, he will not love me,' her own heart had said also. Here now was the answer.
'You know you cannot marry him,' Beatrice had said, also. Ah! if that really were so, was not this embrace
deplorable for them both? And yet how could she not be happy? She endeavoured to repel him; but with what
a weak endeavour! Her pride had been wounded to the core, not by Lady Arabella's scorn, but by the
conviction which had grown on her, that though she had given her own heart absolutely away, had parted
with it wholly and for ever, she had received nothing in return. The world, her world, would know that she
had loved, and loved in vain. But here now was the loved one at her feet; the first moment that his enforced
banishment was over, had brought him here. How could she not be happy?
They all said that she could not marry him. Well, perhaps it might be so; nay, when she thought of it, must
not that edict too probably be true? But if so, it would not be his fault. He was true to her, and that satisfied
her pride. He had taken from her, by surprise, a confession of her love. She had often regretted her weakness
in allowing him to do so; but she could not regret it now. She could endure to suffer; nay, it would not be
suffering while he suffered with her.
'Not one word, Mary? Then after all my dreams, after all my patience, you do not love me at last?'
Oh, Frank! notwithstanding what has been said in thy praise, what a fool thou art! Was any word necessary
for thee? Had not her heart beat against thine? Had she not borne thy caresses? Had there been one touch of
anger when she warded off thy threatened kisses? Bridget, in the kitchen, when Jonah became amorous,
smashed his nose with the rollingpin. But when Thomas sinned, perhaps as deeply, she only talked of doing
so. Miss Thorne, in the drawingroom, had she needed selfprotection, could doubtless have found the
means, though the process would probably have been less violent.
At last Mary succeeded in her efforts at enfranchisement, and she and Frank stood at some little distance from
each other. She could not but marvel at him. That long, soft beard, which just now had been so close to her
face, was all new; his whole look was altered; his mien, and gait, and very voice were not the same. Was this,
indeed, the very Frank who had chattered of his boyish love, two years since, in the gardens at
Greshamsbury?
'Not one word of welcome, Mary?'
'Indeed, Mr Gresham, you are welcome home.'
'Mr Gresham! Tell me, Marytell me at oncehas anything happened? I could not ask up there.'
'Frank,' she said, and then stopped; not being able at the moment to get any further.
'Speak to me honestly, Mary; honestly and bravely. I offered you my hand once before; there it is again. Will
you take it?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVI. WILL HE COME AGAIN? 260
Page No 264
She looked wistfully up in his eyes; and would fain have taken it. But though a girl may be honest in such a
case, it is so hard for her to be brave.
He still held out his hand. 'Mary,' said he, 'if you can value it, it shall be yours through good fortune or ill
fortune. There may be difficulties; but if you can love me, we will get over them. I am a free man; free to do
as I please with myself, except so far as I am bound to you. There is my hand. Will you have it?' And then he,
too, looked into her eyes, and waited composedly, as though determined to have an answer.
She slowly raised her hand, and, as she did so, her eyes fell to the ground. It then drooped again, and was
again raised; and, at last, her light tapering fingers rested on his broad open palm.
They were soon clutched, and the whole hand brought absolutely within his grasp. 'There, now you are my
own!' he said, 'and none of them shall part us; my own Mary, my own wife.'
'Oh, Frank, is not this imprudent? Is it not wrong?'
'Imprudent! I am sick of prudence. I hate prudence. And as for wrongno. I say it is not wrong; certainly not
wrong if we love each other. And you do love me, Maryeh? You do! don't you?'
He would not excuse her, or allow her to escape from saying it in so many words; and when the words did
come at last, they came freely. 'Yes, Frank, I do love you; if that were all you would have no cause for fear.'
'And I will have no cause for fear.'
'Ah; but your father, Frank, and my uncle. I can never bring myself to do anything that shall bring either of
them to sorrow.'
Frank, of course, ran through all his arguments. He would go into a profession, or take a farm and live in it.
He would wait; that is, for a few months. 'A few months, Frank!' said Mary. 'Well, perhaps six.' 'Oh, Frank!'
But Frank would not be stopped. He would do anything that his father might ask him. Anything but the one
thing. He would not give up the wife he had chosen. It would not be reasonable, or proper, or righteous that
he should be asked to do so; and here he mounted a somewhat high horse.
Mary had no arguments which she could bring from her heart to offer in opposition of all this. She could only
leave her hand in his, and feel that she was happier than she had been at any time since the day of the
donkeyride at Boxall Hill.
'But, Mary,' continued he, becoming very grave and serious. 'We must be true to each other, and firm in this.
Nothing that any of them can say shall drive me from my purpose; will you say as much?'
Her hand was still in his, and so she stood, thinking for a moment before she answered him. But she could not
do less for him than he was willing to do for her. 'Yes,' said shesaid in a very low voice, and with a manner
perfectly quiet'I will be firm. Nothing that they can say shall shake me. But, Frank, it cannot be soon.'
Nothing further occurred in this interview which needs recording. Frank had been three times told by Mary
that he had better go before he did go; and, at last, she was obliged to take the matter into her own hands, and
lead him to the door.
'You are in a great hurry to get rid of me,' said he.
'You have been here two hours, and you must go now; what will they think?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVI. WILL HE COME AGAIN? 261
Page No 265
'Who cares what they think? Let them think the truth: that's after a year's absence, I have much to say to you.'
However, at last, he did go, and Mary was left alone.
Frank, although he had been so slow to move, had a thousand other things to do, and went about them at
once. He was very much in love, no doubt; but that did not interfere with his interest in other pursuits. In the
first place, he had to see Harry Baker, and Harry Baker's stud. Harry had been specially charged to look after
the black horse during Frank's absence, and the holiday doings of that valuable animal had to be inquired
into. Then the kennel of the hounds had to be visited, andas a matter of secondrate importancethe
master. This could not be done on the same day; but a plan for doing so must be concocted with Harryand
then there were the two young pointer pups.
Frank, when he left his betrothed, went about these things quite as vehemently as though he were not in love
at all; quite as vehemently as though he had said nothing as to going into some profession which must
necessarily separate him from horses and dogs. But Mary sat there at her window, thinking of her love, and
thinking of nothing else. It was all in all to her now. She had pledged herself not to be shaken from her troth
by anything, by any person; and it would behove her to be true to this pledge. True to it, though all the
Greshams but one should oppose her with all their power; true to it, even though her own uncle should
oppose her.
And how could she have done any other than to pledge herself, invoked to it as she had been? How could she
do less for him than he was so anxious to do for her? They would talk to her of maiden delicacy, and tell her
that she had put a stain on that snowwhite coat of proof, in confessing her love for one whose friends were
unwilling to receive her. Let them so talk. Honour, honesty, and truth, outspoken truth, selfdenying truth,
and fealty from man to man, are worth more than maiden delicacy; more, at any rate, than the talk of it. It was
not for herself that this pledge had been made. She knew her position, and the difficulties of it; she knew also
the value of it. He had much to offer, much to give; she had nothing but herself. He had name, and old repute,
family, honour, and what eventually would at least be wealth to her. She was nameless, fameless, portionless.
He had come there with all his ardour, with the impulse of his character, and asked her for her love. It was
already his own. He had then demanded her troth, and she acknowledged that he had a right to demand it. She
would be his if ever it should be in his power to take her.
But there let the bargain end. She would always remember, that though it was in her power to keep her
pledge, it might too probably not be in his power to keep his. That doctrine, laid down so imperatively by the
great authorities of Greshamsbury, that edict, which demanded that Frank should marry money, had come
home also to her with a certain force. It would be sad that the fame of Greshamsbury should perish, and that
the glory should depart from the old house. It might be, that Frank also should perceive that he must marry
money. It would be a pity that he had not seen it sooner; but she, at any rate, would not complain.
And so she stood, leaning on the open window, with her book unnoticed lying beside her. The sun had been
in the midsky when Frank had left her, but its rays were beginning to stream into the room from the west
before she moved from her position. Her first thought in the morning had been this: Would he come to see
her? Her last now was more soothing to her, less full of absolute fear: Would it be right that he should come
again?
The first sounds she heard were the footsteps of her uncle, as he came up to the drawingroom, three steps at
a time. His step was always heavy; but when he was disturbed in spirit, it was slow; when merely fatigued in
body by ordinary work, it was quick.
'What a broiling day!' he said, and he threw himself into a chair. 'For mercy's sake, give me something to
drink.' Now the doctor was a great man for summerdrinks. In his house, lemonade, currantjuice,
orangemixtures, and raspberryvinegar were used by the quart. He frequently disapproved of these things
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVI. WILL HE COME AGAIN? 262
Page No 266
for his patients, as being apt to disarrange the digestion; but he consumed enough himself to throw a large
family into such difficulties.
'Haa!' he ejaculated after a draught; 'I'm better now. Well, what's the news?'
'You've been out, uncle; you ought to have the news. How's Mrs Green?'
'Really as bad as ennui and solitude can make her.'
'And Mrs Oaklerath?'
'She's getting better, because she has ten children to look after, and twins to suckle. What has he been doing?'
And the doctor pointed towards the room occupied by Sir Louis.
Mary's conscience struck her that she had not even asked. She had hardly remembered, during the whole day,
that the baronet was in the house. 'I do not think he has been doing much,' she said. 'Janet has been with him
all day.'
'Has he been drinking?'
'Upon my word, I don't know, uncle. I think not, for Janet has been with him. But, uncle'
'Well, dearbut just give me a little more of that tipple.'
Mary prepared the tumbler, and as she handed it to him, she said, 'Frank Gresham has been here today.'
The doctor swallowed his draught, and put down the glass before he made any reply, and even then he said
but little.
'Oh! Frank Gresham.'
'Yes, uncle.'
'You thought him looking pretty well?'
'Yes, uncle; he was very well, I believe.'
Dr Thorne had nothing more to say, so he got up and went to his patient in the next room.
'If he disapproves of it, why does he not say so?' said Mary to herself. 'Why does he not advise me?'
But it was not so easy to give advice while Sir Louis Scatcherd was lying there in that state.
CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY
Janet had been sedulous in her attentions to Sir Louis, and had not troubled her mistress; but she had not had
an easy time of it. Her orders had been, that either she or Thomas should remain in the room the whole day,
and those orders had been obeyed.
Immediately after breakfast, the baronet had inquired after his own servant. 'His confounded nose must be
right by this time, I suppose?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY 263
Page No 267
'It was very bad, Sir Louis,' said the old woman, who imagined that it might be difficult to induce Jonah to
come into the house again.
'A man in such a place as his has no business to be laid up,' said his master, with a whine. 'I'll see and get a
man who won't break his nose.'
Thomas was sent to the inn three or four times, but in vain. The man was sitting up, well enough, in the
taproom; but the middle of his face was covered with streaks of plaster, and he could not bring himself to
expose his wounds before his conqueror.
Sir Louis began by ordering the woman to bring him chassecafe. She offered him coffee, as much as he
would; but no chasse. 'A glass of port wine,' she said, at twelve o'clock, and another at three had been ordered
for him.
'I don't care afor the orders,' said Sir Louis; 'send me my own man.' The man was again sent for; but would
not come. 'There's a bottle of that stuff that I take, in that portmanteau, in the lefthand cornerjust hand it
to me.'
But Janet was not to be done. She would give him no stuff, except what the doctor had ordered, till the doctor
came back. The doctor would then, no doubt, give him anything that was proper.
Sir Louis swore a good deal, and stormed as much as he could. He drank, however, his two glasses of wine,
and he got no more. Once or twice he essayed to get out of bed and dress; but, at every effort, he found that
he could not do it without Joe: and there he was, still under the clothes when the doctor returned.
'I'll tell you what it is,' said he, as soon as his guardian entered the room, 'I'm not going to be made a prisoner
of here.'
'A prisoner! no, surely not.'
'It seems very much like it at present. Your servant herethat old womantakes it upon her to say she'll do
nothing without your orders.'
'Well; she's right there.'
'Right! I don't know what you call right; but I won't stand it. You are not going to make a child of me, Dr
Thorne; so you need not think it.'
And then there was a long quarrel, between them, and but an indifferent reconciliation. The baronet said that
he would go to Boxall Hill, and was vehement in his intention to do so because the doctor opposed it. He had
not, however, as yet ferreted out the squire, or given a bit of his mind to Mr Gazebee, and it behoved him to
do this before he took himself off to his own country mansion. He ended, therefore, by deciding to go on the
next day but one.
'Let it be so, if you are well enough,' said the doctor.
'Well enough!' said the other, with a sneer. 'There's nothing to make me ill that I know of. It certainly won't
be drinking too much here.'
On the next day, Sir Louis was in a different mood, and in one more distressing for the doctor to bear. His
compelled absence from intemperate drinking had, no doubt, been good for him; but his mind had so much
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY 264
Page No 268
sunk under the pain of the privation, that his state was piteous to behold. He had cried for his servant, as a
child cries for its nurse, till at last the doctor, moved to pity, had himself gone out and brought the man in
from the publichouse. But when he did come, Joe was of but little service to his master, as he was altogether
prevented from bringing him either wine or spirits; and when he searched for the liqueurcase, he found that
even that had been carried away.
'I believe you want me to die,' he said, as the doctor, sitting by his bedside, was tyring, for the hundredth
time, to make him understand that he had but one chance of living.
The doctor was not in the least irritated. It would have been as wise to be irritated by the want of reason in a
dog.
'I am doing what I can to save your life,' he said calmly; 'but as you said just now, I have no power over you.
As long as you are able to move and remain in my house, you certainly shall not have the means of
destroying yourself. You will be very wise to stay here for a week or ten days: a week or ten days of healthy
living might, perhaps, bring you round.'
Sir Louis again declared that the doctor wished him to die, and spoke of sending for his attorney Finnie, to
come to Greshamsbury to look after him.
'Send for him if you choose,' said the doctor. 'His coming will cost you three or four pounds, but can do no
other harm.'
It was certainly hard upon Dr Thorne that he should be obliged to entertain such a guest in the house;to
entertain him, and foster him, and care for him, almost as though he were a son. But he had no alternative; he
had accepted the charge from Sir Roger, and he must go through with it. His conscience, moreover, allowed
him no rest in the matter: it harassed him day and night, driving him on sometimes to great wretchedness. He
could not love this incubus that was on his shoulders; he could not do other than be very far from loving him.
Of what use or value was he to any one? What could the world make of him that would be good, or he of the
world? Was not an early death his certain fate? The earlier it might be, would it not be better? Were he to
linger on yet for two years longerand such a space of life was possible for himhow great would be the
mischief that he might do; nay, certainly would do! Farewell then to all hopes for Greshamsbury, as far as
Mary was concerned. Farewell then to that dear scheme which lay deep in the doctor's heart, that hope that he
might in his niece's name, give back to the son the lost property of his father. And might not one yearsix
months be as fatal. Frank, they all said, must marry money; and even hehe the doctor himself, much as he
despised the idea for money's sakeeven he could not but confess that Frank, as the heir to an old, but
grievously embarrassed property, had no right to marry, at his early age, a girl without a shilling. Mary, his
niece, his own child, would probably be the heiress of this immense wealth; but he could not tell this to
Frank; no, nor to Frank's father, while Sir Louis was yet alive. What, if by so doing he should achieve this
marriage for his niece, and that then Sir Louis should live to dispose of his own? How then would he face the
anger of Lady Arabella?
'I will never hanker after a dead man's shoes, neither for myself nor for another,' he had said to himself a
hundred times; and as often did he accuse himself of doing so. One path, however, was plainly open before
him. He would keep his peace as to the will; and would use such efforts as he might use for a son of his own
loins to preserve the life that was so valueless. His wishes, his hopes, his thoughts, he could not control; but
his conduct was at his own disposal.
'I say, doctor, you don't really think that I'm going to die?' Sir Louis said, when Dr Thorne again visited him.
'I don't think at all; I am sure you will kill yourself if you continue to live as you have lately done.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY 265
Page No 269
'But suppose I go all right for a while, and livelive just as you tell me, you know?'
'All of us are in God's hands, Sir Louis. By so doing you will, at any rate, give yourself the best chance.'
'Best chance? Why, dn, doctor! there are fellows have done ten times worse than I; and they are not going
to kick. Come, now, I know you are trying to frighten me; ain't you now?'
'I am trying to do the best I can for you.'
'It's very hard on a fellow like me; I have nobody to say a kind word to me; no, not one.' And Sir Louis, in his
wretchedness, began to weep. 'Come, doctor; if you'll put me once more on my legs, I'll let you draw on the
estate for five hundred pounds; by G, I will.'
The doctor went away to his dinner, and the baronet also had his in bed. He could not eat much, but he was
allowed two glasses of wine, and also a little brandy in his coffee. This somewhat invigorated him, and when
Dr Thorne again went to him, in the evening, he did not find him so utterly prostrated in spirit. He had,
indeed, made up his mind to a great resolve; and thus unfolded his final scheme for his own reformation:
'Doctor,' he began again, 'I believe you are an honest fellow; I do indeed.'
Dr Thorne could not but thank him for his good opinion.
'You ain't annoyed at what I said this morning, are you?'
The doctor had forgotten the particular annoyance to which Sir Louis alluded; and informed him that his
mind might be at rest on any such matter.
'I do believe you'd be glad to see me well; wouldn't you, now?'
The doctor assured him that such was in very truth the case.
'Well, now, I'll tell you what: I've been thinking about it a great deal today; indeed, I have, and I want to do
what is right. Mightn't I have a little drop of that stuff, just in a cup of coffee?'
The doctor poured him out a cup of coffee, and put about a teaspoonful of brandy in it. Sir Louis took it with
a disconsolate face, not having been accustomed to such measures in the use of his favourite beverage.
'I do wish to do what is rightI do, indeed; only, you see, I'm lonely. As to those fellows up in London, I
don't think that one of them cares a straw about me.'
Dr Thorne was of the same way of thinking, and he said so. He could not but feel some sympathy with the
unfortunate man as he thus spoke of his own lot. It was true that he had been thrown on the world without any
one to take care of him.
'My dear friend, I will do the best I can in every way; I will, indeed. I do believe that your companions in
town have been too ready to lead you astray. Drop them, and you may yet do well.'
'May I though, doctor? Well, I will drop them. There's Jenkins; he's the best of them; but even he is always
wanting to make money of me. Not but what I'm up to the best of them in that way.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY 266
Page No 270
'You had better leave London, Sir Louis, and change your mode of life. Go to Boxall Hill for a while; for two
or three days or so; live with your mother there and take to farming.'
'What! farming?'
'Yes; that's what all country gentlemen do: take the land there into your own hand, and occupy your mind
upon it.'
'Well, doctor, I willupon one condition.'
Dr Thorne sat still and listened. He had no idea what the condition might be, but he was not prepared to
promise acquiescence till he heard it.
'You know what I told you once before,' said the baronet.
'I don't remember at this moment.'
'About my getting married, you know.'
The doctor's brow grew black, and promised no help to the poor wretch. Bad in every way, wretched, selfish,
sensual, unfeeling, purseproud, ignorant as Sir Louis Scatcherd was still, there was left to him the power of
feeling something like sincere love. It may be presumed that he did love Mary Thorne, and that he was at the
time earnest in declaring that if she could be given to him, he would endeavour to live according to her
uncle's counsel. It was only a trifle he asked; but, alas! that trifle could not be vouchsafed.
'I should much approve of your getting married, but I do not know how I can help you.'
'Of course, I mean Miss Mary: I do love her; I really do, Dr Thorne.'
'It is quite impossible, Sir Louis; quite. You do my niece much honour; but I am able to answer for her,
positively, that such a proposition is quite out of the question.'
'Look here now, Dr Thorne; anything in the way of settlements'
'I will not hear a word on the subject: you are very welcome to the use of my house as long as it may suit you
to remain here; but I must insist that my niece shall not be troubled on this matter.'
'Do you mean to say she's in love with that young Gresham?'
This was too much for the doctor's patience. 'Sir Louis,' said he, 'I can forgive you much for your father's
sake. I can also forgive something on the score of your own illhealth. But you ought to know, you ought by
this time to have learnt, that there are some things which a man cannot forgive. I will not talk to you about
my niece; and remember this, also, I will not have her troubled by you:' and, so saying, the doctor left him.
On the next day the baronet was sufficiently recovered to be able to resume his braggadocio airs. He swore at
Janet; insisted on being served by his own man; demanded in a loud voice, but in vain, that his liqueurcase
should be restored to him; and desired that posthorses might be ready for him on the morrow. On that day
he got up and ate his dinner in his bedroom. On the next morning he countermanded the horses, informing the
doctor that he did so because he had little bit of business to transact with Squire Gresham before he left the
place! With some difficulty, the doctor made him understand that the squire would not see him on business;
and it was at last decided, that Mr Gazebee should be invited to call on him at the doctor's house; and this Mr
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY 267
Page No 271
Gazebee agreed to do, in order to prevent the annoyance of having the baronet up at Greshamsbury.
On this day, the evening before Mr Gazebee's visit, Sir Louis condescended to come down to dinner. He
dined, however, teteatete with the doctor. Mary was not there, nor was anything said as to her absence. Sir
Louis Scatcherd never set eyes upon her again.
He bore himself arrogantly on that evening, having resumed the airs and wouldbe dignity which he thought
belonged to him as a man of rank and property. In his periods of low spirits, he was abject and humble
enough; abject and fearful of the lamentable destiny which at these moments he believed to be in store for
him. But it was one of the peculiar symptoms of his state, that as he partially recovered his bodily health, the
tone of his mind recovered itself also, and his fears for the time were relieved.
There was very little said between him and the doctor that evening. The doctor sat, guarding the wine, and
thinking when he should have his house to himself again. Sir Louis sat moody, every now and then uttering
some impertinence as to the Greshams and the Greshamsbury property, and, at an early hour, allowed Joe to
put him to bed.
The horses were ordered on the next day for three, and, as two, Mr Gazebee came to the house. He had never
been there before, nor had he ever met Dr Thorne except at the squire's dinner. On this occasion he asked
only for the baronet.
'Ah! ah! I'm glad you're come, Mr Gazebee; very glad,' said Sir Louis; acting the part of the rich, great man
with all the power he had. 'I want to ask you a few questions so as to make it all clear sailing between us.'
'As you have asked to see me, I have come, Sir Louis,' said the other, putting on much dignity as he spoke.
'But would it not be better that any business there may be should be done among the lawyers?'
'The lawyers are very well, I dare say; but when a man has so large a stake at interest as I have in this
Greshamsbury property, why, you see, Mr Gazebee, he feels a little inclined to look after it himself. Now, do
you know, Mr Gazebee, how much it is that Mr Gresham owes me?'
Mr Gazebee, of course, did know very well; but he was not going to discuss the subject with Sir Louis, if he
could help it.
'Whatever claim your father's estate may have on that of Mr Gresham is, as far as I understand, vested in Dr
Thorne's hands as trustee. I am inclined to believe that you have not yourself at present any claim on
Greshamsbury. The interest, as it becomes due, is paid to Dr Thorne; and if I may be allowed to make a
suggestion, I would say that it will not be expedient to make any change in that arrangement till the property
shall come into your own hands.'
'I differ from you entirely, Mr Gazebee; in toto as we used to say at Eton. What you mean to say isI can't
go to law with Mr Gresham; I'm not so sure of that; but perhaps not. But I can compel Dr Thorne to look after
my interests. I can force him to foreclose. And to tell you the truth, Gazebee, unless some arrangement is
proposed to me which I shall think advantageous, I shall do so at once. There is near a hundred thousand
pounds owing to me; yes to me. Thorne is only a name in the matter. The money is my money; and, by , I
mean to look after it.'
'Haven't you any doubt, Sir Louis, as to the money being secure?'
'Yes, I have. It isn't so easy to have a hundred thousand pounds secured. The squire is a poor man, and I don't
choose to allow a poor man to owe me such a sum as that. Besides, I mean to invest in land. I tell you fairly,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY 268
Page No 272
therefore, I shall foreclose.'
Mr Gazebee, using all the perspicuity which his professional education had left to him, tried to make Sir
Louis understand that he had no power to do anything of the kind.
'No power! Mr Gresham shall see whether I have no power. When a man has a hundred thousand pounds
owing to him he ought to have some power; and, as I take it, he has. But we will see. Perhaps you know
Finnie, do you?'
Mr Gazebee, with a good deal of scorn in his face, said that he had not that pleasure. Mr Finnie was not in his
line.
'Well, you will know him then, and you'll find he's sharp enough; that is, unless, I have some offer made to
me that I may choose to accept.' Mr Gazebee declared that he was not instructed to make any offer, and so he
took his leave.
On that afternoon, Sir Louis went off to Boxall Hill, transferring the miserable task of superintending his
selfdestruction from the shoulders of the doctor to those of his mother. Of Lady Scatcherd, the baronet took
no account in his proposed sojourn in the country, nor did he take much of the doctor in leaving
Greshamsbury. He again wrapped himself in his furs, and, with tottering steps, climbed up into the barouche
which was to carry him away.
'Is my man up behind?' he said to Janet, while the doctor was standing at the little front gardengate, making
his adieux.
'No, sir, he is not up yet,' said Janet, respectfully.
'Then send him out, will you? I can't lose my time waiting here all day.'
'I shall come over to Boxall Hill and see you,' said the doctor, whose heart softened towards the man, in spite
of his brutality, as the hour of his departure came.
'I shall be happy to see you if you like to come, of course; that is, in the way of visiting, and that sort of thing.
As for doctoring, if I want any I shall send for Fillgrave.' Such were his last words as the carriage, with a
rush, went off from the door.
The doctor, as he reentered the house, could not avoid smiling, for he thought of Dr Fillgrave's last patient at
Boxall Hill. 'It's a question to me,' said he to himself, 'whether Fillgrave will ever be induced to make another
visit to that house, even with the object of rescuing a baronet out of my hands.'
'He's gone; isn't he, uncle?' said Mary, coming out of her room.
'Yes, my dear; he's gone, poor fellow.'
'He may be a poor fellow, uncle; but he's a very disagreeable inmate in a house. I have not had any dinner
these two days.'
'And I haven't had what can be called a cup of tea since he's been in the house. But I'll make up for that
tonight.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY 269
Page No 273
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY
PRACTICE
There is a mode of novelwriting which used to be much in vogue, but which has now gone out of fashion. It
is, nevertheless, one which is very expressive when in good hands, and which enables the author to tell his
story, or some portion of his story, with more natural trust than any other, I mean that of familiar letters. I
trust I shall be excused if I attempt it as regards this one chapter; though, it may be, that I shall break down
and fall into the commonplace narrative, even before the one chapter be completed. The correspondents are
the Lady Amelia De Courcy and Miss Gresham. I, of course, give precedence to the higher rank, but the first
epistle originated with the latternamed young lady. Let me hope that they will explain themselves.
'Miss Gresham to Lady Amelia de Courcy
'Greshamsbury House, June 185
'MY DEAREST AMELIA,
'I wish to consult you on a subject which, as you will perceive, is of a most momentous nature. You know
how much reliance I place in your judgement and knowledge of what is proper, and, therefore, I write to you
before speaking to any other living person on the subject: not even to mamma; for, although her judgement is
good too, she has so many cares and troubles, that it is natural that it should be a little warped when the
interests of her children are involved. Now that it is all over, I feel that it may possibly have been so in the
case of Mr Moffat.
'You are aware that Mr Mortimer Gazebee is now staying here, and that he has been here for nearly two
months. He is engaged in managing poor papa's affairs, and mamma, who likes him very much, says that he
is a most excellent man of business. Of course, you know that he is a junior partner in the very old firm of
Gumption, Gazebee, and Gazebee, who, I understand, do not undertake any business at all, except what
comes to them from peers, or commoners of the very highest class.
'I soon perceived, dearest Amelia, that Mr Gazebee paid me more than ordinary attention, and I immediately
became very guarded in my manner. I certainly liked Mr Gazebee from the first. His manners are quite
excellent, his conduct to mamma is charming, and, as regards myself, I must say that there has been nothing
in his behaviour of which even you could complain. He has never attempted the slightest familiarity, and I
will do him the justice to say, that, though he has been very attentive, he has also been very respectful.
'I must confess that, for the last three weeks, I have thought that he meant something. I might, perhaps, have
done more to repel him; or I might have consulted you earlier as to the propriety of keeping altogether out of
his way. But you know, Amelia, how often these things lead to nothing, and though I thought all along that
Mr Gazebee was in earnest, I hardly liked to say anything about it even to you till I was quite certain. If you
had advised me, you know, to accept his offer, and if, after that, he had never made it, I should have felt so
foolish.
'But now he has made it. He came to me yesterday just before dinner, in the little drawingroom, and told me,
in the most delicate manner, in words that even you could not have but approved, that his highest ambition
was to be thought worthy of my regard, and that he felt for me the warmest love, and the most profound
admiration, and the deepest respect. You may say, Amelia, that he is only an attorney, and I believe that he is
an attorney; but I am sure you would have esteemed him had you heard the very delicate way in which he
expressed his sentiments.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE 270
Page No 274
'Something had given me a presentiment of what he was going to do when I saw him come into the room, so
that I was on my guard. I tried very hard to show no emotion; but I suppose I was a little flurried, as I once
detected myself calling him Mr Mortimer: his name, you know, is Mortimer Gazebee. I ought not to have
done so, certainly; but it was not so bad as if I had called him Mortimer without the Mr, was it? I don't think
there could possibly be a prettier Christian name than Mortimer. Well, Amelia, I allowed him to express
himself without interruption. He once attempted to take my hand; but even this was done without any
assumption of familiarity; and when he saw that I would not permit it, he drew back, and fixed his eyes on the
ground as though he were ashamed even of that.
'Of course, I had to give him an answer; and though I had expected that something of this sort would take
place, I had not made up my mind on the subject. I would not, certainly, under any circumstances, accept him
without consulting you. If I really disliked him, of course there would be no doubt; but I can't say, dearest
Amelia, that I do absolutely dislike him; and I really think that we would make each other very happy, if the
marriage were suitable as regarded both our positions.
'I collected myself as well as I could, and I really do think that you would have said that I did not behave
badly, though the position was rather trying. I told him that, of course, I was flattered by his sentiments,
though much surprised at hearing them; that since I knew him, I had esteemed and valued him as an
acquaintance, but that, looking on him as a man of business, I had never expected anything more. I then
endeavoured to explain to him, that I was not perhaps privileged as some other girls might be, to indulge my
feelings altogether: perhaps that was saying too much, and might make him think that I was in love with him;
but, from the way I said it, I don't think he would, for I was very much guarded in my manner, and very
collected; and then I told him, that in any proposal of marriage that might be made to me, it would be my
duty to consult my family as much, if not more than myself.
'He said, of course; and asked whether he might speak to papa. I tried to make him understand, that in talking
of my family, I did not exactly mean papa, or even mamma. Of course I was thinking what was due to the
name of Gresham. I know very well what papa would say. He would give his consent in half a minute; he is
so brokenhearted by these debts. And, to tell you the truth, Amelia, I think mamma would too. He did not
seem quite to comprehend what I meant; but he did say that he knew it was a high ambition to marry into the
family of the Greshams. I am sure you would confess that he has the most proper feelings; and as for
expressing them no man could do it better.
'He owned that it was ambition to ally himself with a family above his own rank in life, and that he looked to
doing so as a means of advancing himself. Now this was at any rate honest. That was one of his motives, he
said; though, of course, not his first: and then he declared how truly he was attached to me. In answer to this,
I remarked that he had known me only a very short time. This, perhaps, was giving him too much
encouragement; but, at that moment, I hardly knew what to say, for I did not wish to hurt his feelings. He
then spoke of his income. He has fifteen hundred a year from the business, and that will be greatly increased
when his father leaves it; and his father is much older then Mr Gumption, though he is only a second partner.
Mortimer Gazebee will be the senior partner himself before very long; and perhaps that does alter his position
a little.
'He has a very nice place down somewhere in Surrey; I have mamma say it quite a gentleman's place. It is let
now; but he will live there when he is married. And he has property of his own besides which he can settle.
So, you see, he is quite as well off as Mr Oriel; better, indeed; and if a man is in a profession, I believe it is
considered that it does not matter much what. Of course, a clergyman can be a bishop; but then, I think I have
heard that one attorney did once become Lord Chancellor. I should have my carriage, you know; I remember
his saying that, especially, though I cannot recollect how he brought it in.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE 271
Page No 275
'I told him, at last, that I was so much taken by surprise that I could not give him an answer then. He was
going up to London, he said, on the next day, and might he be permitted to address me on the same subject
when he returned? I could not refuse him, you know; and so now I have taken the opportunity of his absence
to write to you for your advice. You understand the world so very well, and know exactly what one ought to
do in such a strange position!
'I hope I have made it intelligible, at least, as to what I have written about. I have said nothing as to my own
feelings, because I wish you to think on the matter without consulting them. If it would be derogatory to
accept Mr Gazebee, I certainly would not do so because I happen to like him. If we were to act in that way,
what would the world come to, Amelia? Perhaps my ideas may be overstrained; if so, you will tell me.
'When Mr Oriel proposed to Beatrice, nobody seemed to make any objection. It all seemed to go as a matter
of course. She says that his family is excellent; but as far as I can learn, his grandfather was a general in
India, and came home very rich. Mr Gazebee's grandfather was a member of the firm, and so, I believe, was
his greatgrandfather. Don't you think this ought to count for something? Besides, they have no business
except with the most aristocratic persons, such as uncle De Courcy, and the Marquis of Kensington Gore, and
that sort. I mention the marquis because Mr Mortimer Gazebee is there now. And I know that one of the
Gumptions was once in Parliament; and I don't think that any of the Oriels ever were. The name of attorney is
certainly very bad, is it not, Amelia? but they certainly do not seem to be all the same, and I do think that this
ought to make a difference. To hear Mr Mortimer Gazebee talk of some attorney at Barchester, you would
say that there is quite as much difference between them as between a bishop and a curate. And so I think
there is.
'I don't wish at all to speak of my own feelings; but if he were not an attorney, he is, I think, the sort of man I
should like. He is very nice in every way, and if you were not told, I don't think you would know he was an
attorney. But, dear Amelia, I will be guided by you altogether. He is certainly much nicer than Mr Moffat,
and has a great deal more to say for himself. Of course, Mr Moffat having been in Parliament, and having
been taken up by uncle De Courcy, was in a different sphere; but I really felt almost relieved when he
behaved in that way. With Mortimer Gazebee, I think it would be different.
'I shall wait so impatiently for your answer, so do pray write at once. I hear some people say that these sort of
things are not so much thought of now as they were once, and that all manner of marriages are considered to
be comme il faut. I do not want, you know, to make myself foolish by being too particular. Perhaps all these
changes are bad, and I rather think they are; but if the world changes, one must change too; one can't go
against the world.
'So do write and tell me what you think. Do not suppose that I dislike the man, for I really cannot say that I
do. But I would not for anything make an alliance for which any one bearing the name of De Courcy would
have to blush.
'Always, dearest Amelia,' Your most affectionate cousin 'AUGUSTA GRESHAM.
'PSI fear Frank is going to be very foolish with Mary Thorne. You know it is absolutely important that
Frank should marry money.
'It strikes me as quite possible that Mr Mortimer Gazebee may be in Parliament some of these days. He is just
the man for it.'
Poor Augusta prayed very hard for her husband; but she prayed to a bosom that on this subject was as hard as
a flint, and she prayed in vain. Augusta Gresham was twentytwo, Lady Amelia was thirtyfour; was it likely
that Lady Amelia would permit Augusta to marry, the issue having thus been left in her hands? Why should
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE 272
Page No 276
Augusta derogate from her position by marrying beneath herself, seeing that Lady Amelia had spent so many
more years in the world without having found it necessary to do so? Augusta's letter was written on two
sheets of notepaper, crossed all over; and Lady Amelia's answer was almost equally formidable.
'Lady Amelia de Courcy to Miss Augusta Gresham
'Courcy Castle, June, 185
'MY DEAR AUGUSTA,
'I received your letter yesterday morning, but I have put off answering it till this evening, as I have wished to
give it very mature consideration. The question is one which concerns, not only your own character, but
happiness for life, and nothing less than very mature consideration would justify me in giving a decided
opinion on the subject.
'In the first place, I may tell you, that I have not a word to say against Mr Mortimer Gazebee.' (When Augusta
had read as far as this, her heart sank within her; the rest was all leather and prunella; she saw at once that the
fiat had gone against her, and that her wish to become Mrs Mortimer Gazebee was not to be indulged.) 'I have
known him for a long time, and I believe him to be a very respectable person, and I have no doubt a good
man of business. The firm of Messrs Gumption and Gazebee stands probably quite among the first attorneys
in London, and I know that papa has a very high opinion of them.
'All of these would be excellent arguments to use in favour of Mr Gazebee as a suitor, had his proposals been
made to any one in his own rank in life. But you, in considering the matter, should, I think, look on it in a
very different light. The very fact that you pronounce him to be so much superior to other attorneys, shows in
how very low esteem you hold the profession in general. It shows also, dear Augusta, how well aware you are
that they are a class of people among whom you should not seek a partner for life.
'My opinion is, that you should make Mr Gazebee understand very courteously, of coursethat you cannot
accept his hand. You observe that he himself confesses that in marrying you he would seek a wife in a rank
above his own. Is it not, therefore, clear, that in marrying him, you would descend to a rank below you own?
'I shall be very sorry if it grieves you; but still it will be better that you should bear the grief of overcoming a
temporary fancy, than take a step which may so probably make you unhappy; and which some of your friends
would certainly regard as disgraceful.
'It is not permitted to us, my dear Augusta, to think of ourselves in such matters. As you truly say, if we were
to act in this way, what would the world come to? It has been God's pleasure that we should be born with
high blood in our veins. This is a great boon which we both value, but the boon has its responsibilities as well
as its privileges. It is established by law, that the royal family shall not intermarry with subjects. In our case
there is no law, but the necessity is not the less felt; we should not intermarry with those who are probably of
a lower rank. Mr Mortimer Gazebee is, after all, only an attorney; and, although you speak of his
greatgrandfather, he is a man of no blood whatsoever. You must acknowledge that such an admixture
should be looked on by a De Courcy, or even a Gresham, as a pollution.' (Here Augusta got very red, and she
felt almost inclined to be angry with her cousin.) 'Beatrice's marriage with Mr Oriel is different; though,
remember, I am by no means defending that; it may be good or bad, and I have had no opportunity of
inquiring respecting Mr Oriel's family. Beatrice, moreover, has never appeared to me to feel what was due to
herself in such matters; but, as I said, her marriage with Mr Oriel is very different. Clergymenparticularly
the rectors and vicars of country parishesdo become privileged above other professional men. I could
explain why, but it would be too long in a letter.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE 273
Page No 277
'Your feelings on the subject altogether do you great credit. I have no doubt that Mr Gresham, if asked, would
accede to the match; but that is just the reason why he should not be asked. It would not be right that I should
say anything against your father to you; but it is impossible for any of us not to see that all through life he has
thrown away every advantage, and sacrificed his family. Why is he now in debt, as you say? Why is he not
holding the family seat in Parliament? Even though you are his daughter, you cannot but feel that you would
not do right to consult him on such a subject.
'As to dear aunt, I feel sure, that were she in good health, and left to exercise her own judgement, she would
not wish to see you married to the agent for the family estate. For, dear Augusta, that is the real truth. Mr
Gazebee often comes here in the way of business; and though papa always receives him as a gentlemanthat
is, he dines at table and all thathe is not on the same footing in the house as the ordinary guests and friends
of the family. How would you like to be received at Courcy Castle in the same way?
'You will say, perhaps, that you would still be papa's niece; so you would. But you know how strict in such
matters papa is, and you must remember, that the wife always follows the rank of the husband. Papa is
accustomed to the strict etiquette of a court, and I am sure that no consideration would induce him to receive
the estateagent in the light of a nephew. Indeed, were you to marry Mr Gazebee, the house to which he
belongs would, I imagine, have to give up the management of the property.
'Even were Mr Gazebee in Parliamentand I do not see how it is probable that he should get thereit
would not make any difference. You must remember, dearest, that I never was an advocate for the Moffat
match. I acquiesced in it, because mamma did so. If I could have had my own way, I would adhere to all our
old prescriptive principles. Neither money nor position can atone to me for low birth. But the world, alas! is
retrograding; and, according to the newfangled doctrines of the day, a lady of blood is not disgraced by
allying herself to a man of wealth, and what may be called quasi aristocratic position. I wish it were
otherwise; but so it is. And, therefore, the match with Mr Moffat was not disgraceful, though it could not be
regarded as altogether satisfactory.
'But with Mr Gazebee the matter would be altogether different. He is a man earning his bread; honestly, I
dare say, but in a humble position. You say he is very respectable: I do not doubt it; and so is Mr Scraggs, the
butcher at Courcy. You see, Augusta, to what such arguments reduce you.
'I dare say he may be nicer than Mr Moffat, in one way. That is, he may have more smalltalk at his
command, and be more clever in all those little pursuits and amusements which are valued by ordinary young
ladies. But my opinion is, that neither I nor you would be justified in sacrificing ourselves for such
amusements. We have high duties before us. It may be that the performance of those duties will prohibit us
from taking a part in the ordinary arena of the feminine world. It is natural that girls should wish to marry;
and, therefore, those who are weak, take the first that come. Those who have more judgement, make some
sort of selection. But the strongestminded are, perhaps, those who are able to forgo themselves and their
own fancies, and to refrain from any alliance that does not tend to the maintenance of high principles. Of
course, I speak of those who have blood in their veins. You and I need not dilate as to the conduct of others.
'I hope what I have said will convince you. Indeed, I know that it only requires that you and I should have a
little cousinly talk on this matter to be quite in accord. You must now remain at Greshamsbury till Mr
Gazebee shall return. Immediately that he does so, seek an interview with him; do not wait till he asks for it;
then tell him, that when he addressed you, the matter had taken you so much by surprise, that you were not at
the moment able to answer him, with that decision that the subject demanded. Tell him, that you are
flatteredin saying this, however, you must keep a collected countenance, and be very cold in your
mannerbut that family reasons would forbid you to avail yourself of his offer, even did no other cause
prevent it.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE 274
Page No 278
'And then, dear Augusta, come to us here. I know you will be a little downhearted after going through this
struggle; but I will endeavour to inspirit you. When we are both together, you will feel more sensibly the
value of that high position which you will preserve by rejecting Mr Gazebee, and will regret less acutely
whatever you may lose.
'Your very affectionate cousin, 'AMELIA DE COURCY.
'PS.I am greatly grieved about Frank; but I have long feared that he would do some very silly thing. I have
heard lately that Miss Mary Thorne is not even the legitimate niece of your Dr Thorne, but is the daughter of
some poor creature who was seduced by the doctor, in Barchester. I do not know how true this may be, but I
think your brother should be put on his guard: it might do good.'
Poor Augusta! She was in truth to be pitied, for her efforts were made with the intention of doing right
according to her lights. For Mr Moffat she had never cared a straw; and when, therefore, she lost the piece of
gilding for which she had been instructed by her mother to sell herself, it was impossible to pity her. But Mr
Gazebee she would have loved with that sort of love which it was in her power to bestow. With him she
would have been happy, respectable, and contented.
She had her written her letter with great care. When the offer was made to her, she could not bring herself to
throw Lady Amelia to the winds and marry the man, as it were, out of her own head. Lady Amelia had been
the tyrant of her life, and so she strove hard to obtain her tyrant's permission. She used all her little cunning in
showing that, after all, Mr Gazebee was not so very plebeian. All her little cunning was utterly worthless.
Lady Amelia's mind was too strong to be caught with such chaff. Augusta could not serve God and Mammon.
She must either be true to the god of her cousin's idolatry, and remain single, or serve the Mammon of her
own inclinations, and marry Mr Gazebee.
When refolding her cousin's letter, after the first perusal, she did for a moment think of rebellion. Could she
not be happy at the nice place in Surrey, having, as she would have, a carriage, even though all the De
Courcys should drop her? It had been put to her that she would not like to be received at Courcy Castle with
the scant civility which would be considered due to a Mrs Mortimer Gazebee; but what if she could put up
without being received at Courcy Castle at all? Such ideas did float through her mind, dimly.
But her courage failed her. It is so hard to throw off a tyrant; so much easier to yield, when we have been in
the habit of yielding. This third letter, therefore, was written; and it is the end of the correspondence.
'Miss Augusta Gresham to Lady Amelia de Courcy
'Greshamsbury House, July, 185
'MY DEAREST AMELIA,
'I did not answer your letter before, because I thought it better to delay doing so till Mr Gazebee had been
here. He came the day before yesterday, and yesterday I did, as nearly as possible, what you advised.
Perhaps, on the whole, it will be better. As you say, rank has its responsibilities as well as its privileges.
'I don't quite understand what you mean about clergymen, but we can talk that over when we meet. Indeed, it
seems to me that if one is to be particular about familyand I am sure I think we oughtone ought to be so
without exception. If Mr Oriel be a parvenu, Beatrice's children won't be well born merely because their
father was a clergyman, even though he is a rector. Since my former letter, I have heard that Mr Gazebee's
greatgreatgreatgrandfather established the firm; and there are many people who were nobodies then who
are thought to have good blood in their veins now.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE 275
Page No 279
'But I do not say this because I differ from you. I agree with you so fully, that I at once made up my mind to
reject the man; and, consequently, I have done so.
'When I told him I could not accept him from family considerations, he asked me whether I had spoken to
papa. I told him, no; and that it would be no good, as I had made up my own mind. I don't think he quite
understood me; but it did not perhaps much matter. You told me to be very cold, and I think that perhaps he
thought me less gracious than before. Indeed, I fear that when he first spoke, I may seem to have given him
too much encouragement. However, it is all over now; quite over!' (As Augusta wrote this, she barely
managed to save the paper beneath her hand from being moistened with the tear which escaped from her eye.)
'I do not mind confessing now,' she continued, 'at any rate to you, that I did like Mr Gazebee a little. I think
his temper and disposition would have suited me. But I am quite satisfied that I have done right. He tried very
hard to make me change my mind. That is, he said a great many things as to whether I would not put off my
decision. But I was quite firm. I must say that he behaved very well, and that I really do think he liked me
honestly and truly; but, of course, I could not sacrifice family considerations on that account.
'Yes, rank has its responsibilities as well as its privileges. I will remember that. It is necessary to do so, as
otherwise one would be without consolation for what one has to suffer. For I find that one has to suffer,
Amelia. I know papa would have advised me to marry this man; and so, I dare say, mamma would, and
Frank, and Beatrice, if they knew that I liked him. It would not be so bad if we all thought alike about it; but
it is hard to have responsibilities all on one's own shoulder; is it not?
'But I will go over to you, and you will comfort me. I always feel stronger on this subject at Courcy than at
Greshamsbury. We will have a long talk about it, and then I shall be happy again. I purpose going on next
Friday, if that will suit you and dear aunt. I have told mamma that you all wanted me, and she made no
objection. Do write at once, dearest Amelia, for to hear from you now will be my only comfort.
'Yours, ever most affectionately and obliged, 'AUGUSTA GRESHAM.
'PS.I told mamma what you said about Mary Thorne, and she said, "Yes; I suppose all the world knows it
now; and if all the world did know it, it makes no difference to Frank." She seemed very angry; so you see it
was true.'
Though, by so doing, we shall somewhat anticipate the end of our story, it may be desirable that the full tale
of Mr Gazebee's loves should be told here. When Mary is breaking her heart on her deathbed in the last
chapter, or otherwise accomplishing her destiny, we shall hardly find a fit opportunity of saying much about
Mr Gazebee and his aristocratic bride.
For he did succeed at last in obtaining a bride in whose veins ran the noble De Courcy blood, in spite of the
high doctrine preached so eloquently by the Lady Amelia. As Augusta had truly said, he had failed to
understand her. He was led to think, by her manner of receiving his first proposaland justly so,
enoughthat she liked him, and would accept him; and he was therefore rather perplexed by his second
interview. He tried again and again, and begged permission to mention the matter to Mr Gresham; but
Augusta was very firm, and he at last retired in disgust. Augusta went to Courcy Castle, and received from
her cousin that consolation and restrengthening which she so much required.
Four years afterwardslong after the fate of Mary Thorne had fallen, like a thunderbolt, on the inhabitants
of Greshamsbury; when Beatrice was preparing for her second baby, and each of the twins had her accepted
loverMr Mortimer Gazebee went down to Courcy Castle; of course, on a matter of business. No doubt he
dined at the table, and all that. We have the word of Lady Amelia, that the earl, with his usual goodnature,
allowed him such privileges. Let us hope that he never encroached on them.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE 276
Page No 280
But on this occasion, Mr Gazebee stayed a long time at the castle, and singular rumours as to the cause of his
prolonged visit became current in the little town. No female scion of the present family of Courcy had, as yet,
found a mate. We may imagine that eagles find it difficult to pair when they become scarce in their localities;
and we all know how hard it has sometimes been to get comme il faut husbands when there has been any
number of Protestant princesses on hand.
Some little difficulty had, doubtless, brought it about that the countess was still surrounded by her full bevy
of maidens. Rank has its responsibilities as well as its privileges, and these young ladies' responsibilities
seemed to have consisted in rejecting any suitor who may have hitherto kneeled to them. But now it was told
through Courcy, that one suitor had kneeled, and not in vain; from Courcy the rumour flew to Barchester, and
thence came down to Greshamsbury, startling the inhabitants, and making one poor heart throb with a
violence that would have been piteous had it been known. The suitor, so named, as Mr Mortimer Gazebee.
Yes; Mr Mortimer Gazebee had now awarded to him many other privileges than those of dining at the table,
and all that. He rode with the young ladies in the park, and they all talked to him very familiarly before
company; all except Lady Amelia. The countess even called him Mortimer, and treated him quite as one of
the family.
At last came a letter from the countess to her dear sister Arabella. It should be given at length, but that I fear
to introduce another epistle. It is such an easy mode of writing, and facility is always dangerous. In this letter
it was announced with much preliminary ambiguity, that Mortimer Gazebeewho had been found to be a
treasure in every way; quite a paragon of menwas about to be taken into the De Courcy bosom as a child
of that house. On that day fortnight, he was destined to lead to the altarthe Lady Amelia.
The countess then went on to say, that dear Amelia did not write herself, being so much engaged by her
coming dutiesthe responsibilities of which she doubtless fully realized, as well as the privileges; but she
had begged her mother to request that the twins should come and act as bridesmaids on the occasion. Dear
Augusta, she knew, was too much occupied in the coming event in Mr Oriel's family to be able to attend.
Mr Mortimer Gazebee was taken into the De Courcy family, and did lead the Lady Amelia to the altar; and
the Gresham twins did go there and act as bridesmaids. And, which is much more to say for human nature,
Augusta did forgive her cousin, and, after a certain interval, went on a visit to that nice place in Surrey which
she had hoped would be her own home. It would have been a very nice place, Augusta thought, had not Lady
Amelia Gazebee been so very economical.
We must presume that there was some explanation between them. If so, Augusta yielded to it, and confessed
it to be satisfactory. She had always yielded to her cousin, and loved her with that sort of love which is
begotten between fear and respect. Anything was better than quarrelling with her cousin Amelia.
And Mr Mortimer Gazebee did not altogether make a bad bargain. He never received a shilling of dowry, but
that he had not expected. Nor did he want it. His troubles arose from the overstrained economy of his noble
wife. She would have it, that as she had married a poor manMr Gazebee, however, was not a poor manit
behoved her to manage her house with great care. Such a match as that she had madethis she told in
confidence to Augustahad its responsibilities as well as its privileges.
But, on the whole, Mr Gazebee did not repent his bargain; when he asked his friends to dine, he could tell
them that Lady Amelia would be glad to see them; his marriage gave him some eclat at his club, and some
additional weight in the firm to which he belonged; he gets his share of the Courcy shooting, and is asked
about to Greshamsbury, and other Barsetshire houses, not only 'to dine at table and all that', but to take his
part in whatever delights country society there has to offer. He lives with the great hope that his noble
fatherinlaw may some day be able to bring him into Parliament.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE 277
Page No 281
CHAPTER XXXIX. WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD
'Beatrice,' said Frank, rushing suddenly into his sister's room, 'I want you to do me one especial favour.' This
was three or four days after he had spoken to Mary Thorne. Since that time he had spoken to none of his
family on the subject; but he was only postponing from day to day the task of telling his father. He had now
completed his round of visits to the kennel, master huntsman, and stables of the county hunt, and was at
liberty to attend to his own affairs. So he had decided on speaking to the squire that very day; but he first
made his request to his sister.
'I want you to do me one especial favour.' The day for Beatrice's marriage had now been fixed, and it was not
to be very distant. Mr Oriel had urged that their honeymoon trip would lose half its delights if they did not
take advantage of the fine weather; and Beatrice had nothing to allege in answer. The day had just been fixed,
and when Frank ran into her room with his special request, she was not in a humour to refuse him anything.
'If you wish me to be at your wedding, you must do it.'
'Wish you to be there! You must be there, of course. Oh, Frank! what do you mean? I'll do anything you ask;
if it is not to go to the moon, or anything of that sort.'
Frank was too much in earnest to joke. 'You must have Mary for one of your bridesmaids,' he said. 'Now,
mind; there may be some difficulty, but you must insist on it. I know what has been going on; but it is not to
be borne that she should be excluded on such a day as that. You that have been like sisters all your lives till a
year ago.'
'But, Frank'
'Now, Beatrice, don't have any buts; say that you will do it, and it will be done: I am sure Oriel will approve,
and so will my father.'
'But, Frank, you won't hear me.'
'Not if you make objections; I have set my heart on your doing it.'
'But I had set my heart on the same thing.'
'Well?'
'And I went to Mary on purpose; and told her just as you tell me now, that she must come. I meant to make
mamma understand that I could not be happy unless it were so; but Mary positively refused.'
'Refused! What did she say?'
'I could not tell you what she said; indeed, it would not be right if I could; but she positively declined. She
seemed to feel, that after all that had happened, she never could come to Greshamsbury again.'
'Fiddlestick!'
'But, Frank, those are her feelings; and, to tell the truth, I could not combat them. I know she is not happy; but
time will cure that. And, to tell you the truth, Frank'
'It was before I came back that you asked her, was it not?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIX. WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD 278
Page No 282
'Yes; just the day before you came, I think.'
'Well, it's altered now. I have seen her since that.'
'Have you Frank?'
'What do you take me for? Of course, I have. The very first day I went to her. And now, Beatrice, you may
believe me or not, as you like; but if I ever marry, I shall marry Mary Thorne; and if she ever marries, I think
she may marry me. At any rate, I have her promise. And now, you cannot be surprised that I should wish her
to be at your wedding; or that I should declare, that if she is absent, I will be absent. I don't want any secrets,
and you may tell my mother if you like itand all the De Courcys too, for anything I care.'
Frank had ever been used to command his sisters: and they, especially Beatrice, had ever been used to obey.
On this occasion, she was well inclined to do so, if she only knew how. She again remembered how Mary had
once sworn to be at her wedding, to be near her, and to touch hereven though all the blood of the De
Courcys should be crowded before the altar railings.
'I should be happy that she should be there; but what am I to do, Frank, if she refuses? I have asked her, and
she has refused.'
'Go to her again; you need not have any scruples with her. Do not I tell you she will be your sister? Not come
here again to Greshamsbury! Why, I tell you that she will be living here while you are living there at the
parsonage, for years and years to come.'
Beatrice promised that she would go to Mary again, and that she would endeavour to talk her mother over if
Mary would consent to come. But she could not yet make herself believe that Mary Thorne would ever be
mistress of Greshamsbury. It was so indispensably necessary that Frank should marry money! Besides, what
were these horrid rumours which were now becoming rife as to Mary's birth; rumours more horrid than any
which had yet been heard.
Augusta had said hardly more than the truth when she spoke of her father being brokenhearted by his debts.
His troubles were becoming almost too many for him; and Mr Gazebee, though no doubt he was an excellent
man of business, did not seem to lessen them. Mr Gazebee, indeed, was continually pointing out how much
he owed, and in what a quagmire of difficulties he had entangled himself. Now, to do Mr Umbleby justice, he
had never made himself disagreeable in this manner.
Mr Gazebee had been doubtless right, when he declared that Sir Louis Scatcherd had not himself the power to
take any steps hostile to the squire; but Sir Louis had also been right, when he boasted that, in spite of his
father's will, he could cause others to move in the matter. Others did move, and were moving, and it began to
be understood that a moiety, at least, of the remaining Greshamsbury property must be sold. Even this,
however, would by no means leave the squire in undisturbed possession of the other moiety. And thus, Mr
Gresham was nearly brokenhearted.
Frank had now been at home a week, and his father had not as yet spoken to him about the family troubles;
nor had a word as yet been said between them as to Mary Thorne. It had been agreed that Frank should go
away for twelve months, in order that he might forget her. He had been away the twelvemonth, and had now
returned, not having forgotten her.
It generally happens, that in every household, one subject of importance occupies it at a time. The subject of
importance now mostly thought of in the Greshamsbury household, was the marriage of Beatrice. Lady
Arabella had to supply the trousseau for her daughter; the squire had to supply the money for the trousseau;
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIX. WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD 279
Page No 283
Mr Gazebee had the task of obtaining the money for the squire. While this was going on, Mr Gresham was
not anxious to talk to his son, either about his own debts or his son's love. There would be time for these
things when the marriagefeast was over.
So thought the father, but the matter was precipitated by Frank. He also had put off the declaration which he
had to make, partly from a wish to spare the squire, but partly also with a view to spare himself. We have all
some of that cowardice which induces us to postpone an inevitably evil day. At this time the discussions as to
Beatrice's wedding were frequent in the house, and at one of them Frank had heard his mother repeat the
names of the proposed bridesmaids. Mary's name was not among them, and hence had arisen the attack on his
sister.
Lady Arabella had had her reason for naming the list before her son; but she overshot her mark. She wished
to show him how Mary was forgotten at Greshamsbury; but she only inspired him with a resolve that she
should not be forgotten. He accordingly went to his sister; and then, the subject being full on his mind, he
resolved at once to discuss it with his father.
'Sir, are you at leisure for five minutes?' he said, entering the room in which the squire was accustomed to sit
majestically, to receive his tenants, scold his dependants, and in which, in former happy days, he had always
arranged the meets of the Barsetshire hunt.
Mr Gresham was quite at leisure: when was he not so? But had he been immersed in the deepest business of
which he was capable, he would gladly have put it aside at his son's instance.
'I don't like to have any secret from you, sir,' said Frank; 'nor, for the matter of that, from anybody else'the
anybody else was intended to have reference to his mother'and, therefore, I would rather tell you at once
what I have made up my mind to do.'
Frank's address was very abrupt, and he felt it was so. He was rather red in the face, and his manner was
fluttered. He had quite made up his mind to break the whole affair to his father; but he had hardly made up
his mind as to the best mode of doing so.
'Good heavens, Frank! what do you mean? you are not going to do anything rash? What is it you mean,
Frank?'
'I don't think it is rash,' said Frank.
'Sit down, my boy; sit down. What is it that you say you are going to do?'
'Nothing immediately, sir,' said he, rather abashed; 'but as I have made up my mind about Mary Thorne'
'Oh, about Mary,' said the squire, almost relieved.
And then Frank, in voluble language, which he hardly, however, had quite under his command, told his father
all that had passed between him and Mary. 'You see, sir,' said he, 'that it is fixed now, and cannot be altered.
Nor must it be altered. You asked me to go away for twelve months, and I have done so. It has made no
difference, you see. As to our means of living, I am quite willing to do anything that may be best and most
prudent. I was thinking, sir, of taking a farm somewhere near here, and living on that.'
The squire sat quite silent for some moments after this communication had been made to him. Frank's
conduct, as a son, in this special matter of his love, how was it possible for him to find fault? He himself was
almost as fond of Mary as of a daughter; and, though he too would have been desirous that his son should
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIX. WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD 280
Page No 284
receive the estate from its embarrassment by a rich marriage, he did not at all share Lady Arabella's feelings
on the subject. No Countess de Courcy had ever engraved it on the tablets of his mind that the world would
come to ruin if Frank did not marry money. Ruin there was, and would be, but it had been brought about by
no sin of Frank's.
'Do you remember about her birth, Frank?' he said, at last.
'Yes, sir; everything. She told me all she knew; and Dr Thorne finished the story.'
'And what do you think of it?'
'It is a pity and a misfortune. It might, perhaps, have been a reason why you or my mother should not have
had Mary in the house many years ago; but it cannot make any difference now.'
Frank had not meant to lean so heavily on his father; but he did so. The story had never been told to Lady
Arabella; was not even known to her now, positively, and on good authority. But Mr Gresham had always
known it. If Mary's birth was so great a stain upon her, why had he brought her into his house among his
children?
'It is a misfortune, Frank; a very great misfortune. It will not do for you and me to ignore birth; too much of
the value of one's position depends on it.'
'But what was Mr Moffat's birth?' said Frank, almost with scorn; 'or what Miss Dunstable's?' he would have
added, had it not been that his father had not been concerned in that sin of wedding him to the oil of Lebanon.
'True, Frank. But yet, what you would mean to say is not true. We must take the world as we find it. Were
you to marry a rich heiress, were her birth even as low as that of poor Mary'
'Don't call her poor Mary, father; she is not poor. My wife will have a right to take rank in the world, however
she was born.'
'Well,poor in that way. But were she an heiress, the world would forgive her birth on account of her
wealth.'
'The world is very complaisant, sir.'
'You must take it as you find it, Frank. I only say that such is the fact. If Porlock were to marry the daughter
of a shoeblack, without a farthing, he would make a mesalliance; but if the daughter of the shoeblack had half
a million of money, nobody would dream of saying so. I am stating no opinion of my own: I am only giving
you the world's opinion.'
'I don't give a straw for the world.'
'That is a mistake, my boy; you do care for it, and would be very foolish if you did not. What you mean is,
that, on this particular point, you value your love more than the world's opinion.'
'Well, yes, that is what I mean.'
But the squire, though he had been very lucid in his definition, had not got nearer to his object; had not even
yet ascertained what his own object was. This marriage would be ruinous to Greshamsbury; and yet, what
was he to say against it, seeing that the ruin had been his fault, and not his son's?
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIX. WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD 281
Page No 285
'You could let me have a farm; could you not, sir? I was thinking of about six or seven hundred acres. I
suppose it could be managed somehow?'
'A farm?' said the father, abstractedly.
'Yes, sir. I must do something for my living. I should make less of a mess of that than anything else. Besides,
it would take such a time to be an attorney, or a doctor, or anything of that sort.'
Do something for his living! And was the heir of Greshamsbury come to thisthe heir and his only son?
Whereas, he, the squire, had succeeded at an earlier age than Frank's to an unembarrassed income of fourteen
thousand pounds a year! The reflection was very hard to bear.
'Yes: I dare say you could have a farm:' and then he threw himself back in his chair, closing his eyes. Then,
after a while, rose again, and walked hurriedly about the room. 'Frank,' he said, at last, standing opposite to
his son, 'I wonder what you think of me?'
'Think of you, sir?' ejaculated Frank.
'Yes; what do you think of me, for having thus ruined you. I wonder whether you hate me?'
Frank, jumping up from his chair, threw his arms round his father's neck. 'Hate you, sir? How can you speak
so cruelly? You know well that I love you. And, father, do not trouble yourself about the estate for my sake. I
do not care for it; I can be just as happy without it. Let the girls have what is left, and I will make my own
way in the world, somehow. I will go to Australia; yes, sir, that will be the best. I and Mary will both go.
Nobody will care about her birth there. But, father, never say, never think, that I do not love you!'
The squire was too much moved to speak at once, so he sat down again and covered his face with his hands.
Frank went on pacing the room, till, gradually, his first idea recovered possession of his mind, and the
remembrance of his father's grief faded away. 'May I tell Mary,' he said at last, 'that you consent to our
marriage?'
But the squire was not prepared to say this. He was pledged to his wife to do all that he could to oppose it;
and he himself thought, that if anything could consummate the family ruin, it would be this marriage.
'I cannot say that, Frank; I cannot say that. What would you both live on? It would be madness.'
'We would go to Australia,' answered he, bitterly. 'I have just said so.'
'Oh, no, my boy; you cannot do that. You must not throw up the old place altogether. There is no other one
but you, Frank; and we have lived here now for so many, many years.'
'But if we cannot live here any longer, father?'
'But for this scheme of yours, we might do. I will give up everything to you, the management of the estate,
the park, all the land we have in hand, if you will give up this fatal scheme. For, Frank, it is fatal. You are
only twentythree; why should you be in such a hurry to marry?'
'You married at twentyone, sir.'
Frank was again severe on his father, unwittingly. 'Yes, I did,' said Mr Gresham; 'and see what has come of
it! Had I waited ten years longer, how different would everything have been! No, Frank, I cannot consent to
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIX. WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD 282
Page No 286
such a marriage; nor will your mother.'
'It is your consent that I ask, sir; and I am asking for nothing but your consent.'
'It would be sheer madness; madness for you both. My own Frank, my dear boy, do not drive me to
distraction! Give it up for four years.'
'Four years!'
'Yes; for four years. I ask it as a personal favour; as an obligation to myself, in order that we may be saved
from ruin; you, your mother, and sisters, your family name, and the old house. I do not talk about myself; but
were such a marriage to take place, I should be driven to despair.'
Frank found it very hard to resist his father, who now had hold of his hand and arm, and was thus half
retaining him, and half embracing him. 'Frank, say that you will forget this for four yearssay for three
years.'
But Frank would not say so. To postpone his marriage for four years, or for three, seemed to him to be
tantamount to giving up Mary altogether; and he would not acknowledge that any one had the right to
demand of him to do that.
'My word is pledged, sir,' he said.
'Pledged! Pledged to whom?'
'To Miss Thorne.'
'But I will see her, Frank;and her uncle. She was always reasonable. I am sure she will not wish to bring
ruin on her old friends at Greshamsbury.'
'Her old friends at Greshamsbury have done but little lately to deserve her consideration. She has been treated
shamefully. I know it has not been by you, sir; but I must say so. She has already been treated shamefully; but
I will not treat her falsely.'
'Well, Frank, I can say no more to you. I have destroyed the estate which should have been yours, and I have
no right to expect you should regard what I say.'
Frank was greatly distressed. He had not any feeling of animosity against his father with reference to the
property, and would have done anything to make the squire understand this, short of giving up his
engagement to Mary. His feeling rather was, that, as each had a case against the other, they should cry quits;
that he should forgive his father for his bad management, on condition that he himself was to be forgiven
with regard to his determined marriage. Not that he put it exactly in that shape, even to himself; but could he
have unravelled his own thoughts, he would have found that such was the web on which they were based.
'Father, I do regard what you say; but you would not have me be false. Had you doubled the property instead
of lessening it, I could not regard what you say any more.'
'I should be able to speak in a very different tone; I feel that, Frank.'
'Do not feel it any more, sir; say what you wish, as you would have said it under any other circumstances; and
pray believe this, the idea never occurs to me, that I have ground for complaint as regards the property; never.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XXXIX. WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD 283
Page No 287
Whatever troubles we may have, do not let that trouble you.'
Soon after this Frank left him. What more was there that could be said between them? They could not be of
one accord; but even yet it might not be necessary that they should quarrel. He went out, and roamed by
himself through the grounds, rather more in meditation than was his wont.
If he did marry, how was he to live? He talked of a profession; but had he meant to do as others do, who
make their way in professions, he should have thought of that a year or two ago!or, rather, have done more
than think of it. He spoke also of a farm, but even that could not be had in a moment; nor, if it could, would it
produce a living. Where was his capital? Where was his skill? and he might have asked also, where the
industry so necessary for such a trade? He might have set his father at defiance, and if Mary were equally
headstrong with himself, he might marry her. But, what then?
As he walked slowly about, cutting off the daisies with his stick, he met Mr Oriel, going up to the house, as
was now his custom, to dine there and spend the evening, close to Beatrice.
'How I envy you, Oriel!' he said. 'What would I not give to have such a position in the world as yours!'
'Thou shalt not covet a man's house, nor his wife,' said Mr Oriel; 'perhaps it ought to have been added, nor his
position.'
'It wouldn't have made much difference. When a man is tempted, the Commandments, I believe, do not go for
much.'
'Do they not, Frank? That's a dangerous doctrine; and one which, if you had my position, you would hardly
admit. But what makes you so much out of sorts? Your own position is generally considered about the best
which the world has to give.'
'Is it? Then let me tell you that the world has very little to give. What can I do? Where can I turn? Oriel, if
there be an empty, lying humbug in the world, it is the theory of high birth and pure blood which some of us
endeavour to maintain. Blood, indeed! If my father had been a baker, I should know by this time where to
look for my livelihood. As it is, I am told of nothing but my blood. Will my blood ever get me half a crown?'
And then the young democrat walked on again in solitude, leaving Mr Oriel in doubt as to the exact line of
argument which he had meant to inculcate.
CHAPTER XL. THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS
Dr Fillgrave still continued his visits to Greshamsbury, for Lady Arabella had not yet mustered the courage
necessary for swallowing her pride and sending once more for Dr Thorne. Nothing pleased Dr Fillgrave more
than those visits.
He habitually attended grander families, and richer people; but then, he had attended them habitually.
Greshamsbury was a prize taken from the enemy; it was his rock of Gibraltar, of which he thought much
more than of any ordinary Hampshire or Wiltshire which had always been within his own kingdom.
He was just starting one morning with his posthorses for Greshamsbury, when an impudentlooking groom,
with a crooked nose, trotted up to his door. For Joe still had a crooked nose, all the doctor's care having been
inefficacious to remedy the evil effects of Bridget's little tap with the rollingpin. Joe had no written
credentials, for his master was hardly equal to writing, and Lady Scatcherd had declined to put herself to
further personal communication with Dr Fillgrave; but he had effrontery enough to deliver any message.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XL. THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS 284
Page No 288
'Be you Dr Fillgrave?' said Joe, with one finger just raised to his cocked hat.
'Yes,' said Dr Fillgrave, with one foot on the step of the carriage, but pausing at the sight of the
wellturnedout servant. 'Yes; I am Dr Fillgrave.'
'Then you be to go to Boxall Hill immediately; before anywhere else.'
'Boxall Hill!' said the doctor, with a very angry frown.
'Yes; Boxall Hill: my master's placemy master is Sir Louis Scatcherd, baronet. You've heard of him, I
suppose?'
Dr Fillgrave had not his mind quite ready for such an occasion. So he withdrew his foot from the carriage
step, and rubbing his hands one over another, looked at his own hall door for inspiration. A single glance at
his face was sufficient to show that no ordinary thoughts were being turned over within his breast.
'Well!' said Joe, thinking that his master's name had not altogether produced the magic effect which he had
expected; remembering, also, now submissive Greyson had always been, who, being a London doctor, must
be supposed to be a bigger man than this provincial fellow. 'Do you know my master is dying, very like,
while you stand here?'
'What is your master's disease?' said the doctor, facing Joe, slowly, and still rubbing his hands. 'What ails
him? What is the matter with him?'
'Oh; the matter with him? Well, to say it out at once then, he do take a drop too much at times, and then he
has the horrorswhat is it they call it? Delicious beamends, or something of that sort.'
'Ah, ah, yes; I know; and tell me, my man, who is attending him?'
'Attending him? why, I do, and his mother, that is, her ladyship.'
'Yes; but what medical attendant: what doctor?'
'Why, there was Greyson, in London, and'
'Greyson!' and the doctor looked as though a name so medicinally humble had never struck the tympanum of
his ear.
'Yes; Greyson. And then, down at what's a the man of the place, there was Thorne.'
'Greshamsbury?'
'Yes; Greshamsbury. But he and Thorne didn't hit it off; and so since that he has had no one but myself.'
'I will be at Boxall Hill in the course of the morning,' said Dr Fillgrave; 'or, rather, you may say, that I will be
there at once: I will take it in my way.' And having thus resolved, he gave his orders that the posthorses
should make such a detour as would enable him to visit Boxall Hill on his road. 'It is impossible,' said he to
himself, 'that I should be twice treated in such a manner in the same house.'
He was not, however, altogether in a comfortable frame of mind as he was driven up to the hall door. He
could not but remember the smile of triumph with which his enemy had regarded him in that hall; he could
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XL. THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS 285
Page No 289
not but think how he had returned feeless to Barchester, and how little he had gained in the medical world
by rejecting Lady Scatcherd's banknote. However, he also had had his triumphs since that. He had smiled
scornfully at Dr Thorne when he had seen him in the Greshamsbury street; and had been able to tell, at
twenty houses through the county, how Lady Arabella had at last been obliged to place herself in his hands.
And he triumphed again when he found himself really standing by Sir Louis Scatcherd's bedside. As for Lady
Scatcherd, she did not even show herself. She kept in her own little room, sending out Hannah to ask him up
the stairs; and she only just got a peep at him through the door as she heard the medical creak of his shoes as
he again descended.
We need say but little of his visit to Sir Louis. It mattered nothing now, whether it was Thorne, or Greyson,
or Fillgrave. And Dr Fillgrave knew that it mattered nothing: he had skill at least for thatand heart enough
also to feel that he would fain have been relieved from this task; would fain have left the patient in the hands
even of Dr Thorne.
The name which Joe had given to his master's illness was certainly not a false one. He did find Sir Louis 'in
the horrors'. If any father have a son whose besetting sin was a passion for alcohol, let him take his child to
the room of a drunkard when possessed by 'the horrors'. Nothing will cure him if not that.
I will not disgust my reader by attempting to describe the poor wretch in his misery: the sunken, but yet
glaring eyes; the emaciated cheeks; the fallen mouth; the parched, sore lips; the face, now dry and hot, and
then suddenly clammy with drops of perspiration; the shaking hand, and all but palsied limbs; and worse than
this, the fearful mental efforts, and the struggles for drink; struggles to which it is often necessary to give
way.
Dr Fillgrave soon knew what was to be the man's fate; but he did what he might to relieve it. There, in one
big, best bedroom, looking out to the north, lay Sir Louis Scatcherd, dying wretchedly. There, in the other
big, best bedroom, looking out to the south, had died the other baronet about twelvemonth since, and each a
victim of the same sin. To this had come the prosperity of the house of Scatcherd!
And then Dr Fillgrave went on to Greshamsbury. It was a long day's work, both for himself and the horses;
but then, the triumph of being dragged up that avenue compensated for both the expense and the labour. He
always put on his sweetest smile as he came near the hall door, and rubbed his hands in the most complaisant
manner of which he knew. It was seldom that he saw any of the family but Lady Arabella; but then he desired
to see none other, and when he left her in a good humour, was quite content to take his glass of sherry and eat
his lunch by himself.
On this occasion, however, the servant at once asked him to go into the diningroom, and there he found
himself in the presence of Frank Gresham. The fact was, that Lady Arabella, having at last decided, had sent
for Dr Thorne; and it had become necessary that some one should be entrusted with the duty of informing Dr
Fillgrave. That some one must be the squire, or Frank. Lady Arabella would doubtless have preferred a
messenger more absolutely friendly to her own side of the house; but such messenger there was none: she
could not send Mr Gazebee to see the doctor, and so, of the two evils, she chose the least.
'Dr Fillgrave,' said Frank, shaking hands with him very cordially as he came up, 'my mother is so much
obliged to you for all your care and anxiety on her behalf! and, so indeed, are we all.'
The doctor shook hands with him very warmly. This little expression of a family feeling on his behalf was the
more gratifying, as he had always thought that the males of the Greshamsbury family were still wedded to
that pseudodoctor, that halfapothecary who lived in the village.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XL. THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS 286
Page No 290
'It has been awfully troublesome to you, coming over all this way, I am sure. Indeed, money could not pay for
it; my mother feels that. It must cut up your time so much.'
'Not at all, Mr Gresham; not at all,' said the Barchester doctor, rising up on his toes proudly as he spoke. 'A
person of your mother's importance, you know! I should be happy to go any distance to see her.'
'Ah! but, Dr Fillgrave, we cannot allow that.'
'Mr Gresham, don't mention it.'
'Oh, yes; but I must,' said Frank, who thought that he had done enough for civility, and was now anxious to
come to the point. 'The fact is, doctor, that we are very much obliged for what you have done; but, for the
future, my mother thinks that she can trust to such assistance as she can get here in the village.'
Frank had been particularly instructed to be very careful how he mentioned Dr Thorne's name, and, therefore,
cleverly avoided it.'
Get what assistance she wanted in the village! What words were those that he heard? 'Mr Gresham,
ehhemperhaps I do not completely' Yes, alas! he had completely understood what Frank had meant
that he should understand. Frank desired to be civil, but he had no idea of beating unnecessarily about the
bush on such an occasion as this.
'It's by Sir Omicron's advice, Dr Fillgrave. You see, this man here'and he nodded his head towards the
doctor's house, being still anxious not to pronounce the hideous name'has known my mother's constitution
for so many years.'
'Oh, Mr Gresham; of course, if it is wished.'
'Yes, Dr Fillgrave, it is wished. Lunch is coming directly:' and Frank rang the bell.
'Nothing, I thank you, Mr Gresham.'
'Do take a glass of sherry.'
'Nothing at all, I am very much obliged to you.'
'Won't you let the horses get some oats?'
'I will return at once, if you please, Mr Gresham.' And the doctor did return, taking with him, on this
occasion, the fee that was offered to him. His experience had at any rate taught him so much.
But though Frank could do this for Lady Arabella, he could not receive Dr Thorne on her behalf. The
bitterness of that interview had to be borne by herself. A messenger had been sent for him, and he was
upstairs with her ladyship while his rival was receiving his conge downstairs. She had two objects to
accomplish, if it might be possible: she had found that high words with the doctor were of no avail; but it
might be possible that Frank could be saved by humiliation on her part. If she humbled herself before this
man, would he consent to acknowledge that his niece was not the fit bride for the heir of Greshamsbury?
The doctor entered the room where she was lying on her sofa, and walking up to her with a gentle, but yet not
constrained step, took the seat beside her little table, just as he had always been accustomed to do, and as
though there had been no break in the intercourse.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XL. THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS 287
Page No 291
'Well, doctor, you see that I have come back to you,' she said, with a faint smile.
'Or, rather I have come back to you. And, believe me, Lady Arabella, I am very happy to do so. There need
be no excuses. You were, doubtless, right to try what other skill could do; and I hope it has not been tried in
vain.'
She had meant to have been so condescending; but now all that was put quite beyond her power. It was not
easy to be condescending to the doctor: she had been trying all her life, and had never succeeded.
'I have had Sir Omicron Pie,' she said.
'So I was glad to hear. Sir Omicron is a clever man, and has a good name. I always recommend Sir Omicron
myself.'
'And Sir Omicron returns the compliment,' said she, smiling gracefully, 'for he recommends you. He told Mr
Gresham that I was very foolish to quarrel with my best friend. So now we are friends again, are we not? You
see how selfish I am.' And she put out her hand to him.
The doctor took her hand cordially, and assured her that he bore her no illwill; that he fully understood her
conductand that he had never accused her of selfishness. This was all very well and very gracious; but,
nevertheless, Lady Arabella felt that the doctor kept the upper hand in those sweet forgivenesses. Whereas,
she had intended to keep the upper hand, at least for a while, so that her humiliation might be more effective
when it did come.
And then the doctor used his surgical lore, as he well knew how to use it. There was an assured confidence
about him, an air which seemed to declare that he really knew what he was doing. These were very
comfortable to his patients, but they were wanting in Dr Fillgrave. When he had completed his examinations
and questions, and she had completed her little details and made her answer, she was certainly more at ease
than she had been since the doctor had last left her.
'Don't go yet, for a moment,' she said. 'I have one word to say to you.'
He declared that he was not in the least in a hurry. He desired nothing better, he said, than to sit there and talk
to her. 'And I owe you a most sincere apology, Lady Arabella.'
'A sincere apology!' said she, becoming a little red. Was he going to say anything about Mary? Was he going
to own that he, and Mary, and Frank had all been wrong?
'Yes, indeed. I ought not to have brought Sir Louis Scatcherd here: I ought to have known that he would have
disgraced himself.'
'Oh! it does not signify,' said her ladyship in a tone almost of disappointment. 'I had forgotten it. Mr Gresham
and you had more inconvenience than we had.'
'He is an unfortunate, wretched manmost unfortunate; with an immense fortune which he can never live to
possess.'
'And who will the money go to, doctor?'
This was a question for which Dr Thorne was hardly prepared. 'Go to?' he repeated. 'Oh, some member of the
family, I believe. There are plenty of nephews and nieces.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XL. THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS 288
Page No 292
'Yes; but will it be divided, or all go to one?'
'Probably to one, I think. Sir Roger had a strong idea of leaving it all in one hand.' If it should happen to be a
girl, thought Lady Arabella, what an excellent opportunity would that be for Frank to marry money!
'And now, doctor, I want to say one word to you; considering the very long time that we have known each
other, it is better that I should be open with you. This estrangement between us and dear Mary has given us
all so much pain. Cannot we do anything to put an end to it?'
'Well, what can I say, Lady Arabella? That depends so wholly on yourself.'
'If it depends on me, it shall be done at once.'
The doctor bowed. And though he could hardly be said to do so stiffly, he did it coldly. His bow seemed to
say, 'Certainly; if you choose to make a proper amende it can be done. But I think it is very unlikely that you
will do so.'
'Beatrice is just going to be married, you know that, doctor.' The doctor said that he did know it. 'And it will
be so pleasant that Mary should make one of us. Poor Beatrice; you don't know what she has suffered.'
'Yes,' said the doctor, 'there has been suffering, I am sure; suffering on both sides.'
'You cannot wonder that we should be so anxious about Frank, Dr Thorne; an only son, and the heir to an
estate that has been so very long in the family:' and Lady Arabella put her handkerchief to her eyes, as though
these facts were themselves melancholy, and not to be thought of by a mother without some soft tears. 'Now I
wish you could tell me what your views are, in a friendly manner, between ourselves. You won't find me
unreasonable.'
'My views, Lady Arabella?'
'Yes, doctor; about your niece, you know: you must have views of some sort; that's of course. It occurs to me,
that perhaps were all in the dark together. If so, a little candid speaking between you and me may set it all
right.'
Lady Arabella's career had not hitherto been conspicuous for candour, as far as Dr Thorne had been able to
judge of it; but that was no reason why he should not respond to so very becoming an invitation on her part.
He had no objection to a little candid speaking; at least, so he declared. As to his views with regard to Mary,
they were merely these: that he would make her as happy and comfortable as he could while she remained
with him; and that he would give her his blessingfor he had nothing else to give herwhen she left
him;if ever she should do so.
Now, it will be said that the doctor was not very candid in this; not more so, perhaps, than was Lady Arabella
herself. But when one is specially invited to be candid, one is naturally set upon one's guard. Those who by
disposition are most open, are apt to become crafty when so admonished. When a man says to you, 'Let us be
candid with each other,' you feel instinctively that he desires to squeeze you without giving a drop of water
himself.
'Yes; but about Frank,' said Lady Arabella.
'About Frank!' said the doctor, with an innocent look, which her ladyship could hardly interpret.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XL. THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS 289
Page No 293
'What I mean is this: can you give me your word that these young people do not intend to do anything rash?
One word like that from you will set my mind quite at rest. And then we could be so happy together again.'
'Ah! who is to answer for what rash things a young man will do?' said the doctor, smiling.
Lady Arabella got up from the sofa, and pushed away the little table. The man was false, hypocritical, and
cunning. Nothing could be made of him. They were all in a conspiracy together to rob her of her son; to make
him marry without money! What should she do? Where should she turn for advice and counsel? She had
nothing more to say to the doctor; and he, perceiving that this was the case, took his leave. This little attempt
to achieve candour had not succeeded.
Dr Thorne had answered Lady Arabella as had seemed best to him on the spur of the moment; but he was by
no means satisfied with himself. As he walked away through the gardens, he bethought himself whether it
would be better for all parties if he could bring himself to be really candid. Would it not be better for him at
once to tell the squire what were the future prospects of his niece, and let the father agree to the marriage, or
not agree to it, as he might think fit. But then, if so, if he did do this, would he not in fact say, 'There is my
niece, there is this girl of whom you have been talking for the last twelvemonth, indifferent to what agony of
mind you may have occasioned to her; there she is, a probable heiress! It may be worth your son's while to
wait a little time, and not cast her off till he shall know whether she be an heiress or no. If it shall turn out that
she is rich, let him take her; if not, why, he can desert her then as well as now.' He could not bring himself to
put his niece into such a position as this. He was anxious enough that she should be Frank Gresham's wife,
for he loved Frank Gresham; he was anxious enough, also, that she should give to her husband the means of
saving the property of his family. But Frank, though he might find her rich, was bound to take her while she
was poor.
Then, also, he doubted whether he would be justified in speaking of this will at all. He almost hated the will
for the trouble and vexation it had given him, and the constant stress it had laid on his conscience. He had
spoken of it as yet to no one, and he thought that he was resolved not to do so while Sir Louis should yet be
in the land of the living.
On reaching home, he found a note from Lady Scatcherd, informing him that Dr Fillgrave had once more
been at Boxall Hill, and that, on this occasion, he had left the house without anger.
'I don't know what he has said about Louis,' she added, 'for, to tell the truth, doctor, I was afraid to see him.
But he comes again tomorrow, and then I shall be braver. But I fear that my poor boy is in a bad way.'
CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE
At this period there was, as it were, a truce to the ordinary little skirmishes which had been so customary
between Lady Arabella and the squire. Things had so fallen out, that they neither of them had must spirit for a
contest; and, moreover, on that point which at the present moment was most thought of by both of them, they
were strangely in unison. For each of them was anxious to prevent the threatened marriage of their only son.
It must, moreover, be remembered, that Lady Arabella had carried a great point in ousting Mr Yates Umbleby
and putting the management of the estate into the hands of her own partisan. But then the squire had not done
less in getting rid of Fillgrave and reinstating Dr Thorne in possession of the family invalids. The losses,
therefore, had been equal; the victories equal; and there was a mutual object.
And it must be confessed, also, that Lady Arabella's taste for grandeur was on the decline. Misfortune was
coming too near to her to leave her much anxiety for the gaieties of a London season. Things were not faring
well with her. When her eldest daughter was going to marry a man of fortune, and a member of Parliament,
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE 290
Page No 294
she had thought nothing of demanding a thousand pounds or so for the extraordinary expenses incident to
such an occasion. But now, Beatrice was to become the wife of a parish parson, and even that was thought to
be a fortunate event; she had, therefore, no heart for splendour.
'The quieter we can do it the better,' she wrote to her countesssister. 'Her father wanted to give him at least a
thousand pounds; but Mr Gazebee has told me confidentially that it literally cannot be done at the present
moment! Ah, my dear Rosina! how things have been managed! If one or two of the girls will come over, we
shall all take it as a favour. Beatrice would think it very kind of them. But I don't think of asking you or
Amelia.' Amelia was always the grandest of the De Courcy family, being almost on an equality withnay, in
some respect superior tothe countess herself. But this, of course, was before the days of the place in
Surrey.
Such, and so humble being the present temper of the lady of Greshamsbury, it will not be thought surprising
that she and Mr Gresham should at last come together in their efforts to reclaim their son.
At first Lady Arabella urged upon the squire the duty of being very peremptory and very angry. 'Do as other
fathers do in such cases. Make him understand that he will have no allowance to live on.' 'He understands that
well enough,' said Mr Gresham.
'Threaten to cut him off with a shilling,' said her ladyship, with spirit. 'I haven't a shilling to cut him off with,'
answered the squire, bitterly.
But Lady Arabella herself soon perceived, that this line would not do. As Mr Gresham himself confessed, his
own sins against his son had been to great to allow of his taking a high hand with him. Besides, Mr Gresham
was not a man who could ever be severe with a son whose individual conduct had been so good as Frank's.
This marriage, was, in his view, a misfortune to be averted if possible,to be averted by any possible means;
but, as far as Frank was concerned, it was to be regarded rather as a monomania than a crime.
'I did feel so certain that he would have succeeded with Miss Dunstable,' said the mother, almost crying.
'I thought it impossible but that at his age a twelvemonth knocking about the world would cure him,' said the
father.
'I never heard of a boy being so obstinate about a girl,' said the mother. 'I'm sure he didn't get it from the De
Courcys:' and then, again, they talked it over in all its bearings.
'But what are they to live upon?' said Lady Arabella, appealing, as it were, to some impersonation of reason.
'That's what I want him to tell me. What are they to live upon?'
'I wonder whether De Courcy could get him into some embassy?' said the father. 'He does talk of a
profession.'
'What! with the girl and all?' asked Lady Arabella with horror, alarmed at the idea of such an appeal being
made to her noble brother.
'No; but before he marries. He might be broken of it that way.'
'Nothing will break him,' said the wretched mother; 'nothingnothing. For my part, I think that he is
possessed. Why was she brought here? Oh, dear! oh, dear! Why was she ever brought into this house?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE 291
Page No 295
This last question Mr Gresham did not think it necessary to answer. That evil had been done, and it would be
useless to dispute it. 'I'll tell you what I'll do,' said he. 'I'll speak to the doctor myself.'
'It's not the slightest use,' said Lady Arabella. 'He will not assist us. Indeed, I firmly believe it's all his own
doing.'
'Oh, nonsense! that really is nonsense, my love.'
'Very well, Mr Gresham. What I say is always nonsense, I know; you have always told me so. But yet, see
how things have turned out. I knew how it would be when she was first brought into the house.' This assertion
was rather a stretch on the part of Lady Arabella.
'Well, it is nonsense to say that Frank is in love with the girl at the doctor's bidding.'
'I think you know, Mr Gresham, that I don't mean that. What I say is this, that Dr Thorne, finding what an
easy fool Frank is'
'I don't think he's at all easy, my love; and is certainly not a fool.'
'Very well, have it your own way. I'll not say a word more. I'm struggling to do my best, and I'm browbeaten
on every side. God knows I am not in a state of health to bear it!' And Lady Arabella bowed her head into her
pockethandkerchief.
'I think, my dear, if you were to see Mary herself it might do some good,' said the squire, when the violence
of his wife's grief had somewhat subsided.
'What! go and call upon this girl?'
'Yes; you can send Beatrice to give her notice, you know. She never was unreasonable, and I do not think that
you would find her so. You should tell her, you know'
'Oh, I should know very well what to tell her, Mr Gresham.'
'Yes, my love; I'm sure you would; nobody better. But what I mean is, that if you are to do any good, you
should be kind in your manner. Mary Thorne has a spirit that you cannot break. You may perhaps lead, but
nobody can drive her.'
As this scheme originated with her husband, Lady Arabella could not, of course, confess that there was much
in it. But, nevertheless, she determined to attempt it, thinking that if anything could be efficacious for good in
their present misfortunes, it would be her own diplomatic powers. It was, therefore, at last settled between
them, that he should endeavour to talk over the doctor, and that she would do the same with Mary.
'And then I will speak to Frank,' said Lady Arabella. 'As yet he has never had the audacity to open his mouth
to me about Mary Thorne, though I believe he declares his love openly to every one else in the house.'
'And I will get Oriel to speak to him,' said the squire.
'I think Patience might do more good. I did once think he was getting fond of Patience, and I was quite
unhappy about it then. Ah, dear! I should be almost pleased at that now.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE 292
Page No 296
And thus it was arranged that all the artillery of Greshamsbury was to be brought to bear at once on Frank's
love, so as to crush it, as it were, by the very weight of metal.
It may be imagined that the squire would have less scruple in addressing the doctor on this matter than his
wife would feel; and that his part of their present joint undertaking was less difficult than hers. For he and the
doctor had ever been friends at heart. But, nevertheless, he did feel much scruple, as, with his stick in hand,
he walked down to the little gate which opened out near the doctor's house.
This feeling was so strong, that he walked on beyond this door to the entrance, thinking of what he was going
to do, and then back again. It seemed to be his fate to be depending always on the clemency or consideration
of Dr Thorne. At this moment the doctor was imposing the only obstacle which was offered to the sale of a
great part of his estate. Sir Louis, through his lawyer, was loudly accusing the doctor to sell, and the lawyer
was loudly accusing the doctor of delaying to do so. 'He has the management of your property,' said Mr
Finnie; 'but he manages it in the interest of his own friend. It is quite clear, and we will expose it.' 'By all
means,' said Sir Louis. 'It is a dd shame, and it shall be exposed.'
When he reached the doctor's house, he was shown into the drawingroom, and found Mary there alone. It
had always been the habit to kiss her forehead when he chanced to meet her about the house at
Greshamsbury. She had been younger and more childish then; but even now she was but a child to him, so he
kissed her as he had been wont to do. She blushed slightly as she looked up into his face, and said: 'Oh, Mr
Gresham, I am so glad to see you again.'
As he looked at her he could not but acknowledge that it was natural that Frank should love her. He had never
before seen that she was attractive;had never had an opinion about it. She had grown up as a child under
his eye; and as she had not had the name of being especially a pretty child, he had never thought on the
subject. Now he saw before him a woman whose every feature was full of spirit and animation; whose eye
sparkled with more than mere brilliancy; whose face was full of intelligence; whose very smile was eloquent.
Was it to be wondered at that Frank should have learned to love her?
Miss Thorne wanted but one attribute which many consider essential to feminine beauty. She had no
brilliancy of complexion, no pearly whiteness, no vivid carnation; nor, indeed, did she possess the dark
brilliance of a brunette. But there was a speaking earnestness in her face; and expression of mental faculty
which the squire now for the first time perceived to be charming.
And then he knew how good she was. He knew well what was her nature; how generous, how open, how
affectionate, and yet how proud! Her pride was her fault; but even that was not a fault in his eyes. Out of his
own family there was no one whom he had loved, and could love, as he loved her. He felt, and
acknowledged, that no man could have a better wife. And yet he was there with the express object of rescuing
his son from such a marriage!
'You are looking very well, Mary,' he said, almost involuntarily. 'Am I?' she answered, smiling. 'It's very nice
at any rate to be complimented. Uncle never pays me any compliments of that sort.'
In truth, she was looking well. She would say to herself over and over again, from morning to night, that
Frank's love for her would be, must be, unfortunate; could not lead to happiness. But, nevertheless, it did
make her happy. She had before his return made up her mind to be forgotten, and it was so sweet to find that
he had been so far from forgetting her. A girl may scold a man in words for rashness in his love, but her heart
never scolds him for such an offence as that. She had not been slighted, and her heart, therefore, still rose
buoyant within her breast.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE 293
Page No 297
The doctor entered the room. As the squire's visit had been expected by him, he had of course not been out of
the house. 'And now I suppose I must go,' said Mary; 'for I know you are going to talk about business. But,
uncle, Mr Gresham says I'm looking very well. Why have you not been able to find that out?'
'She's a dear, good girl,' said the squire, as the door shut behind her; 'a dear good girl!' and the doctor could
not fail to see that his eyes were filled with tears.
'I think she is,' said he, quietly. And then they both sat silent, as though each was waiting to hear whether the
other had anything more to say on that subject. The doctor, at any rate, had nothing more to say.
'I have come here specially to speak to you about her.'
'About Mary?'
'Yes, doctor; about her and Frank: something must be done, some arrangement made: if not for our sakes, at
least for theirs.'
'What arrangement, squire?'
'Ah! that's the question. I take it for granted that either Frank or Mary has told you that they have engaged
themselves to each other.'
'Frank told me some twelve months since.'
'And has not Mary told you?'
'Not exactly that. But, never mind; she has, I believe, no secret from me. Though I have said but little to her, I
think I know it all.'
'Well, what then?'
The doctor shook his head and put up his hands. He had nothing to say; no proposition to make; no
arrangement to suggest. The thing was so, and he seemed to say that, as far as he was concerned, there was an
end of it.
The squire sat looking at him, hardly knowing how to proceed. It seemed to him, that the fact of a young man
and a young lady being in love with each other was not a thing to be left to arrange itself, particularly seeing
the rank in life in which they were placed. But the doctor seemed to be of a different opinion.
'But, Dr Thorne, there is no man on God's earth who knows my affairs as well as you do; and in knowing
mine, you know Frank's. Do you think it possible that they should marry each other?'
'Possible; yes, it is possible. You mean, will it be prudent?'
'Well, take it in that way; would it not be most imprudent?'
'At present, it certainly would be. I have never spoken to either of them on the subject; but I presume they do
not think of such a thing for the present.'
'But, doctor' The squire was certainly taken aback by the coolness of the doctor's manner. After all, he, the
squire, was Mr Gresham of Greshamsbury, generally acknowledged to be the first commoner in Barsetshire;
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE 294
Page No 298
after all, Frank was his heir, and, in process of time, he would be Mr Gresham of Greshamsbury. Crippled as
the estate was, there would be something left, and the rank at any rate remained. But as to Mary, she was not
even the doctor's daughter. She was not only penniless, but nameless, fatherless, worse than motherless! It
was incredible that Dr Thorne, with his generally exalted ideas as to family, should speak in this cold way as
to a projected marriage between the heir of Greshamsbury and his brother's bastard child!
'But, doctor,' repeated the squire.
The doctor put one leg over the other, and began to rub his calf. 'Squire,' said he. 'I think I know all that you
would say, all that you mean. And you don't like to say it, because you would not wish to pain me by alluding
to Mary's birth.'
'But, independently of that, what would they live on?' said the squire, energetically. 'Birth is a great thing, a
very great thing. You and I think exactly the alike about that, so we need have no dispute. You are quite as
proud of Ullathorne as I am of Greshamsbury.'
'I might be if it belonged to me.'
'But you are. It is no use arguing. But, putting that aside altogether, what would they live on? If they were to
marry, what would they do? Where would they go? You know what Lady Arabella thinks of such things;
would it be possible that they should live up at the house with her? Besides, what a life would that be for both
of them! Could they live here? Would that be well for them?'
The squire looked at the doctor for an answer; but he still went rubbing his calf. Mr Gresham, therefore, was
constrained to continue his expostulation.
'When I am dead there will still, I hope, be something;something left for the poor fellow. Lady Arabella
and the girls would be better off, perhaps, than now, and I sometimes wish, for Frank's sake, that the time had
come.'
The doctor could not now go on rubbing his knees. He was moved to speak, and declared that, of all events,
that was the one which would be furthest from Frank's heart. 'I know no son,' said he, 'who loves his father
more dearly than he does.'
'I do believe it,' said the squire; 'I do believe it. But yet, I cannot but feel that I am in his way.'
'No, squire, no; you are in no one's way. You will find yourself happy with your son yet, and proud of him.
And proud of his wife, too. I hope so, and I think so: I do, indeed, or I should not say so, squire; we will have
many a happy day yet together, when we shall talk of all these things over the diningroom fire at
Greshamsbury.'
The squire felt it kind in the doctor that he should thus endeavour to comfort him; but he could not
understand, and did not inquire, on what basis these golden hopes was founded. It was necessary, however, to
return to the subject which he had come to discuss. Would the doctor assist him in preventing this marriage?
That was now the one thing necessary to be kept in view.
'But, doctor, about the young people; of course they cannot marry, you are aware of that.'
'I don't know that exactly.'
'Well, doctor, I must say I thought you would feel it.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE 295
Page No 299
'Feel what, squire?'
'That, situated as they are, they ought not to marry.'
'That is quite another question. I have said nothing about that either to you or to anybody else. The truth is,
squire, I have never interfered in this matter one way or the other; and I have no wish to do so now.'
'But should you not interfere? Is not Mary the same to you as your own child?'
Dr Thorne hardly knew how to answer this. He was aware that his argument about not interfering was in fact
absurd. Mary could not marry without his interference; and had it been the case that she was in danger of
making an improper marriage, of course he would interfere. His meaning was, that he would not at the
present moment express any opinion; he would not declare against a match which might turn out to be in
every way desirable; nor, if he spoke in favour of it, could he give his reasons for doing so. Under these
circumstances, he would have wished to say nothing, could that only have been possible.
But as it was not possible, and as he must say something, he answered the squire's last question by asking
another. 'What is your objection, squire?'
'Objection! Why, what on earth would they live on?'
'Then I understand, that if that difficulty were over, you would not refuse your consent merely because of
Mary's birth?'
This was a manner in which the squire had by no means expected to have the affair presented to him. It
seemed so impossible that any soundminded man should take any but his view of the case, that he had not
prepared himself for argument. There was every objection to his son marrying Miss Thorne; but the fact of
their having no income between them did certainly justify him in alleging that first.
'But that difficulty can't be got over, doctor. You know, however, that it would be cause of grief to us all to
see Frank marry much beneath his station; that is, I mean, in family. You should not press me to say this, for
you know that I love Mary dearly.'
'But, my dear friend, it is necessary. Wounds sometimes must be opened in order that they may be healed.
What I mean is this;and, squire, I'm sure I need not say to you that I hope for an honest answer,were
Mary Thorne an heiress; had she, for instance, such wealth as that Miss Dunstable that we hear of; in that
case would you object to this match?'
When the doctor declared that he expected an honest answer the squire listened with all his ears; but the
question, when finished, seemed to have no bearing on the present case.
'Come, squire, speak your mind faithfully. There was some talk of Frank's marrying Miss Dunstable; did you
mean to object to that match?'
'Miss Dunstable was legitimate; at least, I presume so.'
'Oh, Mr Gresham! has it come to that? Miss Dunstable, then, would have satisfied your ideas of high birth?'
Mr Gresham was rather posed, and regretted, at the moment, his allusion to Miss Dunstable's presumed
legitimacy. But he soon recovered himself. 'No,' said he, 'it would not. And I am willing to admit, as I have
admitted before, that the undoubted advantages arising from wealth are taken by the world as atoning for
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE 296
Page No 300
what otherwise would be a mesalliance. But'
'You admit that, do you? You acknowledge that as your conviction on the subject?'
'Yes. But' The squire was going on to explain the propriety of this opinion, but the doctor uncivilly would
not hear him.
'Then squire, I will not interfere in this matter one way or the other.'
'How on earth can such an opinion'
'Pray excuse me, Mr Gresham; but my mind is now quite made up. It was very nearly so before. I will do
nothing to encourage Frank, nor will I say anything to discourage Mary.'
'That is the most singular resolution that a man of sense like you ever came to.'
'I can't help it, squire; it is my resolution.'
'But what has Miss Dunstable's fortune to do with it?'
'I cannot say that it has anything; but, in this matter, I will not interfere.'
The squire went on for some time, but it was all to no purpose; and at last he left the house, considerably in
dudgeon. The only conclusion to which he could come was, that Dr Thorne had thought the chance on his
niece's behalf too good to be thrown away, and had, therefore, resolved to act in a very singular way.
'I would not have believed it of him, though all Barsetshire had told me,' he said to himself as he entered the
great gates; and he went on repeating the same words till he found himself in his own room. 'No, not if all
Barsetshire had told me!'
He did not, however, communicate the ill result of his visit to the Lady Arabella.
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN?
In spite of the family troubles, these were happy days for Beatrice. It so seldom happens that young ladies on
the eve of their marriage have their husbands living near them. This happiness was hers, and Mr Oriel made
the most of it. She was constantly being coaxed down to the parsonage by Patience, in order that she might
give her opinion, in private, on some domestic arrangement, some piece of furniture, or some new carpet; but
this privacy was always invaded. What Mr Oriel's parishioners did in these halcyon days, I will not ask. His
morning services, however, had been altogether given up, and he had provided himself with a very excellent
curate.
But one grief did weigh heavily on Beatrice. She continually heard her mother say things which made her feel
that it would be more than ever impossible that Mary should be at her wedding; and yet she had promised her
brother to ask her. Frank had also repeated his threat, that if Mary were not present, he would absent himself.
Beatrice did what most girls do in such a case; what all would do who are worth anything; she asked her
lover's advice.
'Oh! but Frank can't be in earnest,' said the lover. 'Of course he'll be at our wedding.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? 297
Page No 301
'You don't know him, Caleb. He is so changed that no one hardly would know him. You can't conceive how
much in earnest he is, how determined and resolute. And then, I should like to have Mary so much if mamma
would let her come.'
'Ask Lady Arabella,' said Caleb.
'Well, I suppose I must do that; but I know what she'll say, and Frank will never believe that I have done my
best.' Mr Oriel comforted her with such little whispered consolations as he was able to afford, and then she
went away on her errand to her mother.
She was indeed surprised at the manner in which her prayer was received. She could hardly falter forth her
petition; but when she had done so, Lady Arabella answered in this wise:
'Well my dear, I have no objection, none the least; that is, of course, if Mary is disposed to behave herself
properly.'
'Oh, mamma! of course she will,' said Beatrice; 'she always did and always does.'
'I hope she will, my love. But, Beatrice, when I say that I shall be glad to see her, of course I mean under
certain conditions. I never disliked Mary Thorne, and if she would only let Frank understand that she will not
listen to his mad proposals, I should be delighted to see her at Greshamsbury just as she used to be.'
Beatrice could say nothing in answer to this; but she felt very sure that Mary, let her intention be what it
might, would not undertake to make Frank understand anything at anybody's bidding.
'I will tell you what I will do, my dear,' continued Lady Arabella; 'I will call on Mary myself.'
'What! at Dr Thorne's house?'
'Yes; why not? I have been at Dr Thorne's house before now.' And Lady Arabella could not but think of her
last visit thither, and the strong feeling she had, as she came out, that she would never again enter those
doors. She was, however, prepared to do anything on behalf of her rebellious son.
'Oh, yes! I know that, mamma.'
'I will call upon her, and I can possibly manage it, I will ask her myself to make one of your party. If so, you
can go to her afterwards and make your own arrangements. Just write her a note, my dear, and say that I will
call tomorrow at twelve. It might fluster her if I were to go without notice.'
Beatrice did as she was bid, but with a presentiment that no good would come of it. The note was certainly
unnecessary for the purpose assigned by Lady Arabella, as Mary was not given to be flustered by such
occurrences; but, perhaps, it was as well as that it was written, as it enabled her to make up her mind steadily
as to what information should be given, and what should not be given to her coming visitor.
On the next morning, at the appointed hour, Lady Arabella walked down to the doctor's house. She never
walked about the village without making some little disturbance among the inhabitants. With the squire,
himself, they were quite familiar, and he could appear and reappear without creating any sensation; but her
ladyship had not made herself equally common in men's sight. Therefore, when she went through all the
Greshamsbury in ten minutes, and before she had left the house, Mrs Umbleby and Miss Gushing had quite
settled between them what was the exact cause of the very singular event.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? 298
Page No 302
The doctor, when he had heard what was going to happen, carefully kept out of the way: Mary, therefore, had
the pleasure of receiving Lady Arabella alone. Nothing could exceed her ladyship's affability. Mary thought
that it perhaps might have savoured less of condescension; but then on this subject, Mary was probably
prejudiced. Lady Arabella smiled and simpered, and asked after the doctor, and the cat, and Janet, and said
everything that could be desired by any one less unreasonable than Mary Thorne.
'And now, Mary, I'll tell you why I have called.' Mary bowed her head slightly, as much to say, that she
would be glad to receive any information that Lady Arabella could give her on that subject. 'Of course you
know that Beatrice is going to be married very shortly.'
Mary acknowledged that she had heard so much.
'Yes: we think it will be in Septemberearly in Septemberand that is coming very soon now. The poor
girl is anxious that you should be at her wedding.' Mary turned slightly red; but she merely said, and that
somewhat too coldly, that she was much indebted to Beatrice for her kindness.
'I can assure you, Mary, that she is very fond of you, as much as ever; and so, indeed, am I, and all of us are
so. You know that Mr Gresham was always your friend.'
'Yes, he always was, and I am grateful to Mr Gresham,' answered Mary. It was well for Lady Arabella that
she had her temper under command, for had she spoken her mind out there would have been very little
chance left for reconciliation between her and Mary.
'Yes, indeed he was; and I think we all did what little we could to make you welcome at Greshamsbury,
Mary, till those unpleasant occurrences took place.'
'What occurrences, Lady Arabella?'
'And Beatrice is so very anxious on this point,' said her ladyship, ignoring for the moment Mary's question.
'You two have been so much together, that she feels she cannot be quite happy if you are not near her when
she is being married.'
'Dear Beatrice!' said Mary, warmed for the moment to an expression of genuine feeling.
'She came to me yesterday, begging that I would waive any objection I might have to your being there. I have
made her no answer yet. What answer do you think I ought to make her?'
Mary was astounded at this question, and hesitated in her reply. 'What answer do you think I ought to make
her?' she said.
'Yes, Mary. What answer to you think I ought to give? I wish to ask you the question, as you are the person
the most concerned.'
Mary considered for a while, then did give her opinion on the matter in a firm voice. 'I think you should tell
Beatrice, that as you cannot at present receive me cordially in your house, it will be better that you should not
be called upon to receive me at all.'
This was certainly not the sort of answer that Lady Arabella expected, and she was now somewhat astounded
in her turn. 'But, Mary,' she said, 'I should be delighted to receive you cordially if I could do so.'
'But it seems you cannot, Lady Arabella; and so there must be an end of it.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? 299
Page No 303
'On, but I do not know that:' and she smiled her sweetest smile. 'I do not know that. I want to put an end to all
this illfeeling, if I can. It all depends upon one thing, you know.'
'Does it, Lady Arabella?'
'Yes, upon one thing. You won't be angry if I ask you another questioneh, Mary?'
'No; at least I don't think I will.'
'Is there any truth in what we hear about your being engaged to Frank?'
Mary made no immediate answer to this; but sat quite silent, looking at Lady Arabella in the face; not but that
she had made up her mind as to what answer she would give, but the exact words failed her at the moment.
'Of course you must have heard of such a rumour.'
'Oh, yes, I have heard of it.'
'Yes, and you have noticed it, and I must say very properly. When you went to Boxall Hill, and before that
with Miss Oriel's to her aunt's, I thought you behaved extremely well.' Mary felt herself glow with
indignation, and began to prepare the words that should be sharp and decisive. 'But, nevertheless, people talk;
and Frank, who is still quite a boy' (Mary's indignation was not softened by this allusion to Frank's folly),
'seems to have got some nonsense in his head. I grieve to say it, but I feel myself in justice bound to do so,
that in this matter he has not acted as well as you have done. Now, therefore, I merely ask you whether there
is any truth in the report. If you tell me that there is none, I shall be quite contented.'
'But it is altogether true, Lady Arabella; I am engaged to him.'
'Engaged to be married to him?'
'Yes; engaged to be married to him.'
What was to say or do now? Nothing could be more plain, more decided, or less embarrassed with doubt than
Mary's declaration. And as she made it she looked her visitor full in the face, blushing indeed, for her cheeks
were now suffused as well as her forehead; but boldly, and, as it were, with defiance.
'And you tell me that to my face, Miss Thorne?'
'And why not? Did you not ask me the question; and would you have my answer you with a falsehood? I am
engaged to him. As you would put the question to me, what other could I make? The truth is, I am engaged to
him.'
The decisive abruptness with which Mary declared her own iniquity almost took away her ladyship's breath.
She had certainly believed that they were engaged, and had hardly hoped that Mary would deny it; but she
had not expected that the crime would be acknowledged, or, at any rate, if acknowledged, that the confession
would be made without some show of shame. On this Lady Arabella could have worked; but there was no
such expression, nor was there the slightest hesitation. 'I am engaged to Frank Gresham,' and having so said,
Mary looked at her visitor full in the face.
'Then it is indeed impossible that you should be received at Greshamsbury.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? 300
Page No 304
'At present, quite so, no doubt: in saying so, Lady Arabella, you only repeat the answer I made to your first
question. I can now go to Greshamsbury only in one light: that of Mr Gresham's accepted daughterinlaw.'
'And that is perfectly out of the question; altogether out of the question, now and for ever.'
'I will not dispute with you about that; but, as I said before, my being at Beatrice's wedding is not to be
thought of.'
Lady Arabella sat for a while silent, that she might meditate, if possible, calmly as to what line of argument
she had now better take. It would be foolish in her, she thought, to return home, having merely expressed her
anger. She had now an opportunity of talking to Mary which might not again occur: the difficulty was in
deciding in what special way she should use the opportunity. Should she threaten, or should she entreat? To
do her justice, it should be stated, that she did actually believe that the marriage was all but impossible; she
did not think that it would take place. But the engagement might be the ruin of her son's prospects, seeing
how he had before him an imperative, one immediate dutythat of marrying money.
Having considered all this as well as her hurry would allow her, she determined first to reason, then to
entreat, and lastly, if necessary, to threaten.
'I am astonished! you cannot be surprised at that, Miss Thorne: I am astonished at hearing so singular
confession made.'
'Do you think my confession singular, or is it the fact of my being engaged to your son?'
'We will pass over that for the present. But do let me ask you, do you think it possible, I say possible, that you
and Frank should be married?'
'Oh, certainly; quite possible.'
'Of course you know that he has not a shilling in the world.'
'Nor have I, Lady Arabella.'
'Nor will he have were he to do anything so utterly hostile to his father's wishes. The property, as you are
aware, is altogether at Mr Gresham's disposal.'
'I am aware of nothing about the property, and can say nothing about it except this, that it has not been, and
will not be inquired after by me in this matter. If I marry Frank Gresham, it will not be for the property. I am
sorry to make such an apparent boast, but you force me to do it.'
'On what then are you to live? You are too old for love in a cottage, I suppose?'
'Not at all too old; Frank, you know is "still quite a boy".'
Impudent hussy! forward, illconditioned saucy minx! such were the epithets which rose to Lady Arabella's
mind; but she politely suppressed them.
'Miss Thorne, this subject is of course to me very serious; very illadapted for jesting. I look upon such a
marriage as absolutely impossible.'
'I do not know what you mean by impossible, Lady Arabella.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? 301
Page No 305
'I mean, in the first place, that you two could not get yourselves married.'
'Oh, yes; Mr Oriel would manage that for us. We are his parishioners, and he would be bound to do it.'
'I beg your pardon; I believe that under all the circumstances it would be illegal.'
Mary smiled; but she said nothing. 'You may laugh, Miss Thorne, but I think you will find that I am right.
There are still laws to prevent such fearful distress as would be brought about by such a marriage.'
'I hope that nothing I shall do will bring distress on the family.'
'Ah, but it would; don't you know that it would? Think of it, Miss Thorne. Think of Frank's state, and of his
father's state. You know enough of that, I am sure, to be well aware that Frank is not in a condition to marry
without money. Think of the position which Mr Gresham's only son should hold in the county; think of the
old name, and the pride we have in it; you have lived among us enough to understand all this; think of these
things, and then say whether it is possible that such a marriage should take place without family distress of
the deepest kind. Think of Mr Gresham; if you truly love my son, you could not wish to bring on him all this
misery and ruin.'
Mary now was touched, for there was truth in what Lady Arabella said. But she had no power of going back;
her troth was plighted, and nothing any human being could say should take her from it. If he, indeed, chose to
repent, that would be another thing.
'Lady Arabella,' she said, 'I have nothing to say in favour of this engagement, except that he wishes it.'
'And is this a reason, Mary?'
'To me it is; not only a reason, but a law. I have given him my promise.'
'And you will keep your promise even to his own ruin?'
'I hope not. Our engagement, unless he shall choose to break it off, must necessarily be a long one; but the
time will come'
'What! when Mr Gresham is dead?'
'Before that, I hope.'
'There is no probability of it. And because he is headstrong, you, who have always had credit for so much
sense, will hold him to this mad engagement?'
'No, Lady Arabella; I will not hold him to anything to which he does not wish to be held. Nothing that you
can say shall move me: nothing that anybody can say shall induce me to break my promise to him. But a
word from himself will do it. One look will be sufficient. Let him give me to understand, in any way, that his
love for me is injurious to himthat he has learnt to think soand then I will renounce my part in this
engagement as quickly as you could wish it.'
There was much in this promise, but still not so much as Lady Arabella wished to get. Mary, she knew, was
obstinate, yet reasonable; Frank, she thought, was both obstinate and unreasonable. It might be possible to
work on Mary's reason, but quite impossible to touch Frank's irrationality. So she perseveredfoolishly.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? 302
Page No 306
'Miss Thornethat, is, Mary, for I still wish to be thought your friend'
'I will tell you the truth, Lady Arabella: for some considerable time past I have not thought you so.'
'Then you have wronged me. But I will go on with what I was saying. You quite acknowledge that this is a
foolish affair?'
'I acknowledge no such thing.'
'Something very much like it. You have not a word to say in its defence.'
'Not to you: I do not choose to be put on my defence by you.'
'I don't know who has more right; however, you promise that if Frank wishes it, you will release him from his
engagement.'
'Release him! It is for him to release me, that is, if he wishes it.'
'Very well; at any rate, you give him permission to do so. But will it not be more honourable for you to
begin?'
'No; I think not.'
'Ah, but it would. If he, in his position, should be the first to speak, the first to suggest that this affair between
you is a foolish one, what would people say?'
'They would say the truth.'
'And what would you yourself say?'
'Nothing.'
'What would he think himself?'
'Ah, that I do not know. It is according as that may be, that he will or will not act at your bidding.'
'Exactly; and because you know him to be highminded, because you think that he, having so much to give,
will not break his word to youto you who have nothing to give in returnit is, therefore, that you say that
the first step must be taken by him. It that noble?'
Then Mary rose from her seat, for it was no longer possible for her to speak what it was in her to say, sitting
there leisurely on her sofa. Lady Arabella's worship of money had not hitherto been so brought forward in the
conversation as to give her unpardonable offence; but now she felt that she could no longer restrain her
indignation. 'To you who have nothing to give in return!' Had she not given all that she possessed? Had she
not emptied his store into her lap? that heart of hers, beating with such genuine life, capable of such perfect
love, throbbing with so grand a pride; had she not given that? And was it not that, between him and her, more
than twenty Greshamsburys, nobler than any pedigree? 'To you who have nothing to give,' indeed! This to her
who was so ready to give everything!
'Lady Arabella,' she said, 'I think that you do not understand me, and that it is not likely that you should. If so,
our further talking will be worse than useless. I have taken no account of what will be given between your
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? 303
Page No 307
son and me in your sense of the word giving. But he has professed toto love me'as she spoke, she still
looked on the lady's face, but her eyelashes screened her eyes, and her colour was a little heightened'and I
have acknowledged that I also love him, and so we are engaged. To me my promise is sacred. I will not be
threatened into breaking it. If, however, he shall wish to change his mind, he can do so. I will not upbraid
him; will not, if I can help it, think harshly of him. So much you may tell him if it suits you; but I will not
listen to your calculations as to how much or how little each of us may have to give to the other.'
She was still standing when she finished speaking, and so she continued to stand. Her eyes were fixed on
Lady Arabella, and her position seemed to say that sufficient words had been spoken, and that it was time that
her ladyship should go; and so Lady Arabella felt it. Gradually she also rose; slowly, but tacitly, she
acknowledged that she was in the presence of a spirit superior to her own; and so she took her leave.
'Very well,' she said, in a tone that was intended to be grandiloquent, but which failed grievously; 'I will tell
him that he has your permission to think a second time on this matter. I do not doubt that he will do so.' Mary
would not condescend to answer, but curtsied low as her visitor left the room. And so the interview was over.
The interview was over, and Mary was alone. She remained standing as long as she heard the footsteps of
Frank's mother on the stairs; not immediately thinking of what had passed, but still buoying herself up with
her hot indignation, as though her work with Lady Arabella was not yet finished; but when the footfall was
no longer heard, and the sound of the closing door told her that she was in truth alone, she sank back in her
seat, and, covering her face with her hands, burst into bitter tears.
All that doctrine about money was horrible to her; that insolent pretence, that she had caught at Frank because
of his worldly position, made her all but ferocious; but Lady Arabella had not the less spoken much that was
true. She did think of the position which the heir of Greshamsbury should hold in the county, and of the fact
that such a marriage would mar that position so vitally; she did think of the old name, and the old Gresham
pride; she did think of the squire and his deep distress: it was true that she had lived among them long enough
to understand these things, and to know that it was not possible that this marriage should take place without
deep family sorrow.
And then she asked herself whether, in consenting to accept Frank's hand, she had adequately considered this;
and she was forced to acknowledge that she had not considered it. She had ridiculed Lady Arabella for saying
that Frank was still a boy; but was it not true that his offer had been made with a boy's energy, rather than a
man's forethought? If so, if she had been wrong to accede to that offer when made, would she not be doubly
wrong to hold him to it now that she saw his error?
It was doubtless true that Frank himself could not be the first to draw back. What would people say of him?
She could now calmly ask herself the question that had so angered her, when asked by Lady Arabella. If he
could not do it, and if, nevertheless, it behoved them to break off this match, by whom was it to be done if not
by her? Was not Lady Arabella right throughout, right in her conclusions, though so foully wrong in her
manner of drawing them?
And then she did think for one moment of herself. 'You who have nothing to give in return!' Such had been
Lady Arabella's main accusation against her. Was it in fact true that she had nothing to give? Her maiden
love, her feminine pride, her very life, and spirit, and beingwere these things nothing? Were they to be
weighed against pounds sterling per annum? and, when so weighed, were they ever to kick the beam like
feathers? All these things had been nothing to her when, without reflection, governed wholly by the impulse
of the moment, she had first allowed his daring hand to lie for an instant in her own. She had thought nothing
of these things when that other suitor came, richer far than Frank, to love whom it was impossible to her as it
was not to love him.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? 304
Page No 308
Her love had been pure from all such thoughts; she was conscious that it ever would be pure from them. Lady
Arabella was unable to comprehend this, and, therefore, was Lady Arabella so utterly distasteful to her.
Frank had once held her close to his warm breast; and her very soul had thrilled with joy to feel that he so
loved her,with a joy which she hardly dared to acknowledge. At that moment, her maidenly efforts had
been made to push him off, but her heart had grown to his. She had acknowledged him to be master of her
spirit; her bosom's lord; the man whom she had been born to worship; the human being to whom it was for
her to link her destiny. Frank's acres had been of no account; nor had his want of acres. God had brought
them two together that they should love each other; that conviction had satisfied her, and she had made it a
duty to herself that she would love him with her very soul. And now she was called upon to wrench herself
asunder from him because she had nothing to give in return!
Well, she would wrench herself asunder, as far as such wrenching might be done compatibly with her solemn
promise. It might be right that Frank should have an opportunity offered him, so that he might escape from
his position without disgrace. She would endeavour to give him this opportunity. So, with one deep sigh, she
arose, took herself pen, ink, and paper, and sat herself down again so that the wrenching might begin.
And then, for a moment, she thought of her uncle. Why had he not spoken to her of all this? Why had he not
warned her? He who had ever been so good to her, why had he now failed her so grievously? She had told
him everything, had had no secret from him; but he had never answered her a word. 'He also must have
known' she said to herself, piteously, 'he also must have known that I could give nothing in return.' Such
accusation, however, availed her not at all, so she sat down and slowly wrote her letter.
'Dearest Frank,' she began. She had first written 'dear Mr Gresham'; but her heart revolted against such
useless coldness. She was not going to pretend she did not love him.
'DEAREST FRANK,
'Your mother has been here talking to me about our engagement. I do not generally agree with her about such
matters; but she has said some things today which I cannot but acknowledge to be true. She says, that our
marriage would be distressing to your father, injurious to all your family, and ruinous to yourself. If this be
so, how can I, who love you, wish for such a marriage?
'I remember my promise, and have kept it. I would not yield to your mother when she desired me to disclaim
our engagement. But I do think it will be more prudent if you will consent to forget all that has passed
between usnot, perhaps, to forget it; that may not be possible for usbut to let it pass by as though it had
never been. If so, if you think so, dear Frank, do not have any scruples on my account. What will be best for
you, must be best for me. Think what a reflection it would ever be to me, to have been the ruin of one that I
love so well.
'Let me have but one word to say that I am released from my promise, and I will tell my uncle that the matter
between us is over. It will be painful for us at first; those occasional meetings which must take place will
distress us, but that will wear off. We shall always think well of each other, and why should we not be
friends? This, doubtless, cannot be done without inward wounds; but such wounds are in God's hands, and He
can cure them.
'I know your first feelings will be on reading this letter; but do not answer it in obedience to such feelings.
Think over it, think of your father, and all you owe him, of your old name, your old family, and what the
world expects of you.' (Mary was forced to put her hand to her eyes, to save the paper from her falling tears,
as she found herself thus repeating, nearly word for word, the arguments that had been used by Lady
Arabella.) 'Think of these things coolly, if you can, but, at any rate, without passion: and then let me have one
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN? 305
Page No 309
word in answer. One word will suffice.
'I have but to add this: do not allow yourself to think that my heart will ever reproach you. It cannot reproach
you for doing that which I myself suggest.' (Mary's logic in this was very false; but she was not herself aware
of it.) 'I will never reproach you either in word or thought; and as for all others, it seems to me that the world
agrees that we have hitherto been wrong. The world, I hope, will be satisfied when we have obeyed it.
'Go bless you, dearest Frank! I shall never call you so again; but it would be a pretence were I to write
otherwise in this letter. Think of this, and then let me have one line.
'Your affectionate friend, MARY THORNE'
'PS.Of course I cannot be at dear Beatrice's marriage; but when they come back to the parsonage, I shall
see her. I am sure they will both be happy, because they are so good. I need hardly say that I shall think of
them on their wedding day.'
When she finished the letter, she addressed it plainly, in her own somewhat bold handwriting, to Francis N.
Gresham, Jun., Esq., and then took it herself to the little village postoffice. There should be nothing
underhand about her correspondence: all the Greshamsbury world should know of itthat world of which
she had spoken in her letterif that world so pleased. Having put her penny label on it, she handed it, with
an open brow and an unembarrassed face, to the baker's wife, who was Her Majesty's postmistress at
Greshamsbury; and, having so finished her work, she returned to see the table prepared for her uncle's dinner.
'I will say nothing to him,' she said to herself, 'till I get the answer. He will not talk to me about it, so why
should I trouble him?'
CHAPTER XLIII. THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT
It will not be imagined, at any rate by feminine readers, that Mary's letter was written off at once, without
alterations and changes, or the necessity for a fair copy. Letters from one young lady to another are doubtless
written in this manner, and even with them it might sometimes be better if more patience had been taken; but
with Mary's first letter to her loverher first loveletter, if loveletter it can be calledmuch more care was
used. It was copied and recopied, and when she returned from posting it, it was read and reread.
'It is very cold,' she said to herself; 'he will think I have no heart, that I have never loved him!' And then she
all but resolved to run down to the baker's wife, and get back her letter, that she might alter it. 'But it will be
better so,' she said again. 'If I touched his feelings now, he would never bring himself to leave me. It is right
that I should be cold with him. I should be false to myself if I tried to move his loveI, who have nothing to
give him in return for it.' And so she made no further visit to the postoffice, and the letter went on its way.
We will now follow its fortunes for a short while, and explain how it was that Mary received no answer for a
week; a week, it may well be imagined, of terrible suspense to her. When she took it to the postoffice, she
doubtless thought that the baker's wife had nothing to do but to send it up to the house at Greshamsbury, and
that Frank would receive it that evening, or, at latest, early on the following morning. But this was by no
means so. The epistle was posted on a Friday afternoon, and it behoved the baker's wife to send it into
SilverbridgeSilverbridge being the posttownso that all due formalities, as ordered by the Queen's
Government, might there be perfected. Now, unfortunately the postboy had taken his departure before Mary
reached the shop, and it was not, therefore, dispatched till Saturday. Sunday was always a dies non with the
Greshamsbury Mercury, and, consequently, Frank's letter was not delivered at the house till Monday
morning; at which time Mary had for two long days been waiting with weary heart for the expected answer.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIII. THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT 306
Page No 310
Now Frank had on that morning gone up to London by the early train, with his future brotherinlaw, Mr
Oriel. In order to accomplish this, they had left Greshamsbury for Barchester exactly as the postboy was
leaving Silverbridge for Greshamsbury.
'I should like to wait for my letters,' Mr Oriel had said, when the journey was being discussed.
'Nonsense,' Frank had answered. 'Who ever got a letter that was worth waiting for?' and so Mary was doomed
to a week of misery.
When the postbag arrived at the house on Monday morning it was opened as usual by the squire himself at
the breakfasttable. 'Here is a letter for Frank,' said he, 'posted in the village. You had better send it to him:'
and he threw the letter across to Beatrice.
'It's from Mary,' said Beatrice, out loud, taking the letter up and examining the address. And having said so,
she repented what she had done, as she looked first at her father and then at her mother.
A cloud came over the squire's brow as for a minute he went on turning over the letters and newspapers. 'Oh,
from Mary Thorne, is it?' he said. 'Well, you had better send it to him.'
'Frank said that if any letters came they were to be kept,' said his sister Sophy. 'He told me so particularly. I
don't think he likes having letters sent to him.'
'You had better send that one,' said the squire.
'Mr Oriel is to have all his letters addressed to Long's Hotel, Bond Street, and this one can very well be sent
with them,' said Beatrice, who knew all about it, and intended herself to make free use of the address.
'Yes, you had better send it,' said the squire; and then nothing further was said at the table. But Lady Arabella,
though she said nothing, had not failed to mark what had passed. Had she asked for the letter before the
squire, he would probably have taken possession of it himself; but as soon as she was alone with Beatrice, she
did demand it, 'I shall be writing to Frank himself,' she said, 'and will send it to him.' And so, Beatrice, with a
heavy heart, gave it up.
The letter lay before Lady Arabella's eyes all that day, and many a wistful glance was cast at it. She turned it
over and over, and much desired to know its contents; but she did not dare to break the seal of her son's letter.
All that day it lay upon her desk, and all the next, for she could hardly bring herself to part with it; but on the
Wednesday it was sentsent with these lines from herself:
'Dearest, dearest Frank, I send you a letter which has come by the post from Mary Thorne. I do not know
what it may contain; but before you correspond with her, pray, pray think of what I said to you. For my sake,
for your father's, for your own, pray think of it.'
That was all, but it was enough to make her word to Beatrice true. She did send it to Frank enclosed in a letter
from herself. We must reserve for the next chapter what had taken place between Frank and his mother; but,
for the present, we will return to the doctor's house.
Mary said not a word to him about the letter; but, keeping silent on the subject, she felt wretchedly estranged
from him. 'Is anything the matter, Mary?' he said to her on the Sunday afternoon.
'No, uncle,' she answered, turning away her head to hide her tears.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIII. THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT 307
Page No 311
'Ah, but there is something; what is it, dearest?'
'Nothingthat is, nothing that one can talk about.'
'What Mary! Be unhappy and not to talk about it to me? That's something new, is it not?'
'One has presentiments sometimes, and is unhappy without knowing why. Besides, you know'
'I know! What do I know? Do I know anything that will make my pet happier?' and he took her into his arms
and they sat together on the sofa. Her tears were now falling fast, and she no longer made an effort to hide
them. 'Speak to me, Mary; this is something more than a presentiment. What is it?'
'Oh, uncle'
'Come, love, speak to me; tell me why you are grieving.'
'Oh, uncle, why have you not spoken to me? Why have you not told me what to do? Why have you not
advised me? Why are you always so silent?'
'Silent about what?'
'You know, uncle; silent about him; silent about Frank.'
Why, indeed? What was he to say to this? It was true that he had never counselled her; never shown her what
course she should take; had never even spoke to her about her lover. And it was equally true that he was not
now prepared to do so, even in answer to such an appeal as this. He had a hope, a strong hope, more than a
hope, that Mary's love would yet be happy; but he could not express or explain his hope; nor could he even
acknowledge to himself a wish that would seem to be based on the death of him to whose life he was bound,
if possible, to preserve.
'My love,' he said, 'it is a matter in which you must judge for yourself. Did I doubt your conduct, I should
interfere; but I do not.'
'Conduct! Is conduct everything? One may conduct oneself excellently, and yet break one's heart.'
This was too much for the doctor; his sternness and firmness instantly deserted him. 'Mary,' he said, 'I will do
anything that you would have me. If you wish it, I will make arrangements for leaving this place at once.'
'Oh, no,' she said, plaintively.
'When you tell me of a broken heart, you almost break my own. Come to me, darling; do not leave me so. I
will say all that I can say. I have thought, do still think, that circumstances will admit of your marriage with
Frank if you both love each other, and can both be patient.'
'You think so,' said she, unconsciously sliding her hand into his, as though to thank him by its pressure for the
comfort he was giving her.
'I do think so now more than ever. But I only think so; I have been unable to assure you. There, darling, I
must not say more; only that I cannot bear to see you grieving, I would not have said this:' and then he left
her, and nothing more was spoken on the subject.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIII. THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT 308
Page No 312
If you can be patient! Why, a patience of ten years would be as nothing to her. Could she but live with the
knowledge that she was first in his estimation, dearest in his heart; could it be also granted to her to feel that
she was regarded as his equal, she could be patient for ever. What more did she want than to know and feel
this? Patient, indeed!
But what could these circumstances be to which her uncle had alluded? 'I do think that circumstances will
admit of your marriage.' Such was his opinion, and she had never known him to be wrong. Circumstances!
What circumstances? Did he perhaps mean that Mr Gresham's affairs were not so bad as they had been
thought to be? If so, that alone would hardly alter the matter, for what could she give in return? 'I would give
him the world for one word of love,' she said to herself, 'and never think that he was my debtor. Ah! how
beggarly the heart must be that speculates on such gifts as those!'
But there was her uncle's opinion: he still thought that they might be married. Oh, why had she sent her
letter? and why had she made it so cold? With such a letter as that before him, Frank could not do other than
consent to her proposal. And then, why did he not at least answer it?
On the Sunday afternoon there arrived at Greshamsbury a man and a horse from Boxall Hill, bearing a letter
from Lady Scatcherd to Dr Thorne, earnestly requesting the doctor's immediate attendance. 'I fear everything
is over with poor Louis,' wrote the unhappy mother. 'It has been dreadful. Do come to me; I have no other
friend, and I am nearly worn through with it. The man from the city'she meant Dr Fillgrave'comes every
day, and I dare say he is all very well, but he has never done much good. He has not had spirit enough to keep
the bottle from him; and it was that, and that only, that most behoved to be done. I doubt you won't find him
in this world when you get here.'
Dr Thorne started immediately. Even though he might have to meet Dr Fillgrave, he could not hesitate, for he
went not as a doctor to the dying man, but as the trustee under Sir Roger's will. Moreover, as Lady Scatcherd
had said, he was only her friend, and he could not desert her at such a moment for an army of Fillgraves. He
told Mary he should not return that night; and taking with him a small saddlebag, he started at once for
Boxall Hill.
As he rode to the hall door, Dr Fillgrave was getting into his carriage. They had never met so as to speak to
each other since that memorable day, when they had their famous passage of arms in the hall of that very
house before which they both now stood. But, at the present moment, neither of them was disposed to renew
the fight.
'What news of your patient, Fillgrave?' said our doctor, still seated on his sweating horse, and putting his
hand lightly to his hat.
Dr Fillgrave could not refrain from one moment of supercilious disdain: he gave one little chuck to his head,
one little twist to his neck, one little squeeze to his lips, and then the man within him overcame the doctor.
'Sir Louis is no more,' he said.
'God's will be done!' said Dr Thorne.
'His death is a release; for his last days have been very frightful. Your coming, Dr Thorne, will be a comfort
to Lady Scatcherd.' And then Dr Fillgrave, thinking that even the present circumstances required no further
condescension, ensconced himself in the carriage.
'His last days have been very dreadful! Ah, me, poor fellow! Dr Fillgrave, before you go, allow me to say
this: I am quite aware that when he fell into your hands, no medical skill in the world could save him.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIII. THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT 309
Page No 313
Dr Fillgrave bowed low from the carriage, and after this unwonted exchange of courtesies, the two doctors
parted, not to meet againat any rate, in the pages of this novel. Of Dr Fillgrave, let it now be said, that he is
now regarded as one of the celebrities of Barchester.
Lady Scatcherd was found sitting alone in her little room on the groundfloor. Even Hannah was not with
her, for Hannah was now occupied upstairs. When the doctor entered the room, which he did unannounced,
he found her seated on a chair, with her back against one of the presses, her hands clasped together over her
knees, gazing into vacancy. She did not ever hear him or see him as he approached, and his hand had lightly
touched her shoulder before she knew that she was not alone. Then, she looked up at him with a face so full
of sorrow, so worn with suffering, that his own heart was racked to see her.
'It's all over, my friend,' said he. 'It is better so; much better so.'
She seemed at first hardly to understand him, but still regarding him with that wan face, shook her head
slowly and sadly. One might have thought that she was twenty years older than when Dr Thorne last saw her.
He drew a chair to her side, and sitting by her, took her hand in his. 'It is better so, Lady Scatcherd; better so,'
he repeated. 'The poor lad's doom had been spoken, and it is well for him, and for you, that it should be over.'
'They are both gone now,' said she, speaking very low; 'both gone now. Oh, doctor! To be left alone here, all
alone!'
He said some few words trying to comfort her; but who can comfort a widow bereaved of her child? Who can
console a heart that has lost all it possessed? Sir Roger had not been to her a tender husband; but still he had
been the husband of her love. Sir Louis had not been to her an affectionate son; but still he had been her
child, her only child. Now they were both gone. Who can wonder that the world should be a blank to her?
Still the doctor spoke soothing words, and still he held her hand. He knew that his words could not console
her; but the sounds of his kindness at such desolate moments are, to such minds as hers, some alleviation of
grief. She hardly answered him, but sat there staring out before her, leaving her hand passively to him, and
swaying her head backwards and forwards as though her grief were too heavy to be borne.
At last, her eye rested upon an article which stood upon the table, and she started up impetuously from her
chair. She did this so suddenly, that the doctor's hand fell beside him before he knew that she had risen. The
table was covered with all those implements which become so frequent about a house when severe illness is
an inhabitant there. There were little boxes and apothecaries' bottles, cups and saucers standing separate, and
bowls, in which messes have been prepared with the hope of suiting a sick man's failing appetite. There was a
small saucepan standing on a plate, a curiously shaped glass utensil left by the doctor, and sundry pieces of
flannel, which had been used in rubbing the sufferer's limbs. But in the middle of the debris stood one blank
bottle, with head erect, unsuited to the companionship in which it was found.
'There,' she said, rising up, and seizing it in a manner that would have been ridiculous had it not been so truly
tragic. 'There, that has robbed me of everythingof father and son; that has swallowed them
bothmurdered them both! Oh, doctor! that such a thing as that should ever cause such bitter sorrow! I have
hated it always, but nowOh, woe is me! weary me!' And then she let the bottle drop from her hand as
though it were too heavy for her.
'This comes of barroniting,' she continued. 'If they had let him alone, he would have been here now, and so
would the other one. Why did they do it? why did they do it? Ah, doctor! people such as us should never
meddle with them above us. See what has come of it; see what has come of it!'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIII. THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT 310
Page No 314
The doctor could not remain with her long, as it was necessary that he should take upon himself the direction
of the household, and give orders for the funeral. First of all, he had to undergo the sad duty of seeing the
corpse of the deceased baronet. This, at any rate, may be spared to my readers. It was found to be necessary
that the internment should be made very quickly, as the body was nearly destroyed by alcohol. Having done
all this, and sent back his horse to Greshamsbury, with directions that clothes for a journey might be sent to
him, and a notice that he should not be home for some days, he again returned to Lady Scatcherd.
Of course he could not but think much of the immense property which was now, for a short time, altogether
in his own hands. His resolution was soon made to go at once to London and consult the best lawyer he could
findor the best dozen lawyers should such be necessaryas to the validity of Mary's claims. This must be
done before he said a word to her or to any of the Gresham family; but it must be done instantly, so that all
suspense might be at an end as soon as possible. He must, of course, remain with Lady Scatcherd till the
funeral should be over; but when that office should be complete, he would start instantly for London.
In resolving to tell no one as to Mary's fortune till after he had fortified himself with legal warranty, he made
one exception. He thought it rational that he should explain to Lady Scatcherd who was now the heir under
her husband's will; and he was more inclined to do so, from feeling that the news would probably be
gratifying to her. With this view, he had once or twice endeavoured to induce her to talk about the property,
but she had been unwilling to do so. She seemed to dislike all allusions to it, and it was not until she had
incidentally mentioned the fact that she would have to look for a home, that he was able to fix her to the
subject. This was on the evening before the funeral; on the afternoon of which day he intended to proceed to
London.
'It may probably be arranged that you may continue to live here,' said the doctor.
'I don't wish it at all,' said she, rather sharply. 'I don't wish to have any arrangements made. I would not be
indebted to any of them for anything. Oh, dear! if money could make it all right, I should have enough of
that.'
'Indebted to whom, Lady Scatcherd? Who do you think will be the owner of Boxall Hill?'
'Indeed, then, Dr Thorne, I don't much care: unless it be yourself, it won't be any friend of mine, or any one I
shall care to make a friend of. It isn't so easy for an old woman like me to make new friends.'
'Well, it certainly won't belong to me.'
'I wish it did, with all my heart. But even then, I would not live here. I have had too many troubles here to
wish to see more.'
'That shall be as you like, Lady Scatcherd; but you will be surprised to hear that the place willat least I
think it willbelong to a friend of yours: to one to whom you have been very kind.'
'And who is he, doctor? Won't it go to some of those Americans? I am sure I never did anything kind to them;
though, indeed, I did love poor Mary Scatcherd. But that's years upon years ago, and she is dead, and gone
now. Well, I begrudge nothing to Mary's children. As I have none of my own, it is right that they should have
the money. It has not made me happy; I hope it may do them.'
'The property will, I think, go to Mary Scatcherd's eldest child. It is she whom you have known as Mary
Thorne.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIII. THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT 311
Page No 315
'Doctor!' And then Lady Scatcherd, as she made the exclamation, put both her hands down to hold her chair,
as though she feared the weight of her surprise would topple her off her seat.
'Yes; Mary Thornemy Maryto whom you have been so good, who loves you so well; she, I believe, will
be Sir Roger's heiress. And it was so that Sir Roger intended on his deathbed, in the event of poor Louis's life
being cut short. If this be so, will you be ashamed to stay here as the guest of Mary Thorne? She has not been
ashamed to be your guest.'
But Lady Scatcherd was now too much interested in the general tenor of the news which she had heard to
care much about the house which she was to inhabit in future. Mary Thorne, the heiress of Boxall Hill! Mary
Thorne, the still living child of that poor creature who had so nearly died when they were all afflicted with
their early grief! Well; there was consolation, there was comfort in this. There were but three people left in
the world that she could love: her fosterchild, Frank GreshamMary Thorne, and the doctor. If the money
went to Mary, it would of course go to Frank, for she now knew that they loved each other; and if it went to
them, would not the doctor have his share also; such share as he might want? Could she have governed the
matter, she would have given all to Frank; and now it would be as well bestowed.
Yes; there was consolation in this. They both sat up more than half the night talking over it, and giving and
receiving explanations. If only the council of lawyers would not be adverse! That was now the point of
suspense.
The doctor, before he left her, bade her hold her peace, and say nothing of Mary's fortune to any one till her
rights have been absolutely acknowledged. 'It will be nothing not to have it,' said the doctor; 'but it would be
very bad to hear it was hers, and then to lose it.'
On the next morning, Dr Thorne deposited the remains of Sir Louis in the vault prepared for the family in the
parish church. He laid the son where a few months ago he had laid the father,and so the title of Scatcherd
became extinct. Their race of honour had not been long.
After the funeral, the doctor hurried up to London, and there we will leave him.
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING
We must now go back a little and describe how Frank had been sent off on special business to London. The
household at Greshamsbury was at this time in but a doleful state. It seemed to be pervaded, from the squire
down to the scullerymaid, with a feeling that things were not going well; and men and women, in spite of
Beatrice's coming marriage, were grimvisaged, and dolorous. Mr Mortimer Gazebee, rejected though he had
been, still, went and came, talking much to the squire, much also to her ladyship, as to the illdoings which
were in the course of projection by Sir Louis; and Frank went about the house with clouded brow, as though
finally resolved to neglect his one great duty.
Poor Beatrice was robbed of half her joy; over and over again her brother asked her whether she had yet seen
Mary, and she was obliged as often to answer that she had not. Indeed, she did not dare to visit her friend, for
it was hardly possible that they should sympathize with each other. Mary was, to say the least, stubborn in her
pride; and Beatrice, though she could forgive her friend for loving her brother, could not forgive the
obstinacy with which Mary persisted in a course which, as Beatrice thought, she herself knew to be wrong.
And then Mr Gazebee came down from town, with an intimation that it behoved the squire himself to go up
that he might see certain learned pundits, and be badgered in his own person at various dingy, dismal
chambers in Lincoln's Inn Fields, the Temple, and Gray's Inn Lane. It was an invitation exactly of that sort
which a good many years ago was given to a certain duck.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING 312
Page No 316
'Will you, will youwill you, will youcome and be killed?' Although Mr Gazebee urged the matter with
such eloquence, the squire remained steady to his objection, and swam obstinately about his Greshamsbury
pond in any direction save that which seemed to lead towards London.
This occurred on the very evening of that Friday which had witnessed the Lady Arabella's last visit to Dr
Thorne's house. The question of the squire's necessary journey to the great fountains of justice was, of course,
discussed between Lady Arabella and Mr Gazebee; and it occurred to the former, full as she was of Frank's
iniquity and of Mary's obstinacy, that if Frank were sent up in lieu of his father, it would separate them at
least for a while. If she could only get Frank away without seeing his love, she might yet so work upon him,
by means of the message which Mary had sent, as to postpone, if not break off, this hateful match. It was
inconceivable that a youth of twentythree, and such a youth as Frank, should be obstinately constant to a girl
possessed of no great beautyso argued Lady Arabella to herselfand who had neither wealth, birth, nor
fashion to recommend her.
And this it was at last settledthe squire being a willing partner to the agreementthat Frank should go up
and be badgered in lieu of his father. At his age it was possible to make a thing desirable, if not
necessaryon account of the importance conveyedto sit day after day in the chambers of Messrs Slow
Bideawhile, and hear musty law talk, and finger dusty law parchments. The squire had made many visits to
Messrs Slow Bideawhile, and he knew better. Frank had not hitherto been there on his own bottom, and thus
he fell easily into the trap.
Mr Oriel was also going to London, and this was another reason for sending Frank. Mr Oriel had business of
great importance, which it was quite necessary that he should execute before his marriage. How much of this
business consisted in going to his tailor, buying a weddingring, and purchasing some other more costly
present for Beatrice, we need not here inquire. But Mr Oriel was quite on Lady Arabella's side with reference
to this mad engagement, and as Frank and he were now fast friends, some good might be done in that way. 'If
we all caution him against it, he can hardly withstand us all!' said Lady Arabella to herself.
The matter was broached to Frank on the Saturday evening, and settled between them all on the same night.
Nothing, of course, was at that moment said about Mary; but Lady Arabella was too full of the subject to let
him go to London without telling him that Mary was ready to recede if only he would allow her to do so.
About eleven o'clock, Frank was sitting in his own room, coming over the difficulties of the
situationthinking of his father's troubles, his own positionwhen he was roused from his reverie by a
slight tap at the door.
'Come in,' he said somewhat loudly. He thought it was one of his sisters, who were apt to visit him at all
hours and for all manner of reasons; and he, though he was usually gentle to them, was not at present exactly
in a humour to be disturbed.
The door gently opened, and he saw his mother standing hesitating in the passage.
'Can I come in, Frank?' said she.
'Oh, yes, mother; by all means:' and then, with some surprise marked in his countenance, he prepared a seat
for her. Such a visit as this from Lady Arabella was very unusual; so much so, that he had probably not seen
her in his own room since the day when he first left school. He had nothing, however, to be ashamed of;
nothing to conceal unless it were an open letter from Miss Dunstable which he had in his hand when she
entered, and which he somewhat hurriedly thrust into his pocket.
'I wanted to say a few words to you, Frank, before you start for London about this business.' Frank signified
by a gesture, that he was quite ready to listen to her.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING 313
Page No 317
'I am so glad to see your father putting the matter into your hands. You are younger than he is; and thenI
don't know why, but somehow your father has never been a good man of businesseverything has gone
wrong with him.'
'Oh, mother! do not say anything against him.'
'No, Frank, I will not; I do not wish it. Things have been unfortunate, certainly. Ah me! I little thought when I
marriedbut I don't mean to complainI have excellent children, and I ought to be thankful for that.'
Frank began to fear that no good would be coming when his mother spoke in that strain. 'I will do the best I
can,' said he, 'up in town. I can't help thinking myself that Mr Gazebee might have done as well, but'
'Oh, dear no; by no means. In such cases the principal must show himself. Besides, it is right you should
know how matters stand. Who is so much interested in it as you are? Poor Frank! I do so often feel for you
when I think how the property has dwindled.'
'Pray do not mind me, mother. Why should you talk of it as my matter while my father is not yet fortyfive?
His life, so to speak, is as good as mine. I can do very well without it; all I want is to be allowed to settle to
something.'
'You mean a profession.'
'Yes; something of that sort.'
'They are all so slow, dear Frank. You, who speak French so wellI should think my brother might get you
in as an attache to some embassy.'
'That wouldn't suit me at all,' said Frank.
'Well, we'll talk about that some other time. But I came about something else, and I do hope you will hear
me.'
Frank's brow again grew black, for he knew that his mother was about to say something which it would be
disagreeable for him to hear.
'I was with Mary, yesterday.'
'Well, mother?'
'Don't be angry with me, Frank; you can't but know that the fate of an only son must be a subject of anxiety to
a mother.' Ah! how singularly altered was Lady Arabella's tone since first she had taken upon herself to
discuss the marriage prospects of her son! Then how autocratic had she been as she went him away, bidding
him, with full command, to throw himself into the golden embraces of Miss Dunstable! But now, how
humble, as she came suppliantly to his room, craving that she might have leave to whisper into his ear a
mother's anxious fears! Frank had laughed at her stern behests, though he had half obeyed them; but he was
touched to the heart by her humility.
He drew his chair nearer to her, and took her by the hand. But she, disengaging hers, parted the hair from off
his forehead, and kissed his brow. 'Oh, Frank,' she said, 'I have been so proud of you, am still so proud of
you. It will send me to my grave if I see you sink below your proper position. Not that it will be your fault. I
am sure it will not be your fault. Only circumstanced as you are, you should be doubly, trebly, careful. If your
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING 314
Page No 318
father had not'
'Do not speak against my father.'
'No, Frank; I will notno, I will not; not another word. And now, Frank'
Before we go on we must say one word further as to Lady Arabella's character. It will probably be said that
she was a consummate hypocrite; but at the present moment she was not hypocritical. She did love her son;
was anxiousvery, very anxious for him; was proud of him, and almost admired the obstinacy which so
vexed her inmost soul. No grief would be to her so great as that of seeing him sink below what she conceived
to be his position. She was as genuinely motherly, in wishing that he should marry money, as another woman
might be in wishing to see her son a bishop; or as the Spartan matron, who preferred that her offspring should
return on his shield, to hearing that he had come back whole in limb but tainted in honour. When Frank spoke
of a profession, she instantly thought of what Lord de Courcy might do for him. If he would not marry
money, he might, at any rate, be attache at an embassy. A professionhard work, as a doctor, or as an
engineerwould, according to her ideas, degrade him; cause him to sink below his proper position; but to
dangle at a foreign court, to make small talk at evening parties of a lady ambassadress, and occasionally,
perhaps, to write demiofficial notes containing demiofficial tittletattle; this would be in proper
accordance with the high honour of a Gresham of Greshamsbury.
We may not admire the direction taken by Lady Arabella's energy on behalf of her son, but that energy was
not hypocritical.
'And now, Frank' She looked wistfully into his face as she addressed him, as though half afraid to go on,
and begging that he would receive with complaisance whatever she found herself forced to say.
'Well, mother?'
'I was with Mary yesterday.'
'Yes, yes; what then? I know what your feelings are with regard to her.'
'No, Frank; you wrong me. I have no feelings against hernone, indeed; none but this: that she is not fit to
be your wife.'
'I think her fit.'
'Ah, yes; but how fit? Think of your position, Frank, and what means you have of keeping her. Think of what
you are. Your father's only son; the heir to Greshamsbury. If Greshamsbury be ever again more than a name,
it is you that must redeem it. Of all men living you are the least able to marry a girl like Mary Thorne.'
'Mother, I will not sell myself for what you call my position.'
'Who asks you? I do not ask you; nobody asks you. I do not want you to marry any one. I did think
oncebut let that pass. You are now twentythree. In ten years' time you will still be a young man. I only
ask you to wait. If you marry now, that is, marry such a girl as Mary Thorne'
'Such a girl! Where shall I find another?'
'I mean as regards money, Frank; you know I mean that; how are you to live? Where are you to go? And then,
her birth. Oh, Frank, Frank!'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING 315
Page No 319
'Birth! I hate such pretence. What wasbut I won't talk about it. Mother, I tell you my word is pledged, and
on no account will I be induced to break it.'
'Ah, that's just it; that's just the point. Now, Frank, listen to me. Pray listen to me patiently for one minute.'
Frank promised that he would listen patiently; but he looked anything but patient as he said so.
'I have seen Mary, as it was certainly my duty to do. You cannot be angry with me for that.'
'Who said that I was angry, mother?'
'Well, I have seen her, and I must own, that though she was not disposed to be courteous to me, personally,
she said much that marked her excellent good sense. But the gist of it was this; that as she had made you a
promise, nothing should turn her from that promise but your permission.'
'And do you think'
'Wait a moment, Frank, and listen to me. She confessed that this marriage was one which would necessarily
bring distress on all your family; that it was one which would probably be ruinous to yourself; that it was a
match which could not be approved of: she did, indeed; she confessed all that. "I have nothing", she
saidthose were her own words"I have nothing to say in favour of this engagement, except that he wishes
it." That is what she thinks of it herself. "His wishes are not a reason; but a law," she said'
'And, mother, would you have me desert such a girl as that?'
'It is not deserting, Frank: it would not be deserting: you would be doing that which she herself approves of.
She feels the impropriety of going on; but she cannot draw back because of her promise to you. She thinks
that she cannot do it, even though she wishes it.'
'Wishes it! Oh, mother!'
'I do believe she does, because she has sense to feel the truth of all that your friends say. Oh, Frank, I will go
on my knees to you if you will listen to me.'
'Oh, mother! mother! mother!'
'You should think twice, Frank, before you refuse the only request your mother ever made you. And why do I
ask you? why do I come to you thus? Is it for my own sake? Oh, my boy! my darling boy! will you lose
everything in life, because you love the child with whom you played with as a child?'
'Whose fault is it that we were together as children? She is now more than a child. I look on her already as my
wife.'
'But she is not your wife, Frank; and she knows that she ought not to be. It is only because you hold her to it
that she consents to it.'
'Do you mean to say that she does not love me?'
Lady Arabella would probably have said this, also, had she dared; but she felt that in doing so, she would be
going too far. It was useless for her to say anything that would be utterly contradicted by an appeal to Mary
herself.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING 316
Page No 320
'No, Frank; I do not mean to say that you do not love her. What I do mean is this: that it is not becoming in
you to give up everythingnot only yourself, but all your familyfor such a love as this; and that she, Mary
herself acknowledges this. Every one is of the same opinion. Ask your father: I need not say that he would
agree with you about everything he could. I will not say the De Courcys.'
'Oh, the De Courcys!'
'Yes, they are my relations, I know that.' Lady Arabella could not quite drop the tone of bitterness which was
natural to her in saying this. 'But ask your sisters; ask Mr Oriel, whom you esteem so much; ask your friend
Harry Baker.'
Frank sat silent for a moment or two while his mother, with a look almost of agony, gazed into his face. 'I
will ask no one,' at last he said.
'Oh, my boy! my boy!'
'No one but myself can know my heart.'
'And you will sacrifice all to such a love as that, all; her, also, whom you say that you so love? What
happiness can you give her as your wife? Oh, Frank! is that the only answer you will make to your mother on
her knees?
'Oh, mother! mother!'
'No, Frank, I will not let you ruin yourself; I will not let you destroy yourself. Promise this, at least, that you
will think of what I have said.'
'Think of it! I do think of it.'
'Ah, but think of it in earnest. You will be absent now in London; you will have the business of the estate to
manage; you will have heavy cares upon your hands. Think of it as a man, and not as a boy.'
'I will see her tomorrow before I go.'
'No, Frank, no; grant me that trifle, at any rate. Think upon this without seeing her. Do not proclaim yourself
so weak that you cannot trust yourself to think over what your mother says to you without asking her leave.
Though you be in love, do not be childish with it. What I have told you as coming from her is true, word for
word; if it were not, you would soon learn so. Think now of what I have said, and of what she says, and when
you come back from London, then you can decide.'
To so much Frank consented after some further parley; namely, that he would proceed to London on the
following Monday morning without again seeing Mary. And in the meantime, she was waiting with sore
heart for his answer to that letter that was lying, and was still to lie for so many hours, in the safe protection
of Silverbridge postmistress.
It may seem strange; but, in truth, his mother's eloquence had more effect on Frank than that of his father: and
yet, with his father he had always sympathized. But his mother had been energetic; whereas, his father, if not
lukewarm, had, at any rate, been timid. 'I will ask no one,' Frank had said in the strong determination of his
heart; and yet the words were hardly out of his mouth before he bethought himself that he would talk the
thing over with Harry Baker. 'Not,' said he to himself, 'that I have any doubt: I have no doubt; but I hate to
have all the world against me. My mother wishes me to ask Harry Baker. Harry is a good fellow, and I will
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING 317
Page No 321
ask him.' And with this resolve he betook himself to bed.
The following day was Sunday. After breakfast Frank went with the family to church, as was usual; and
there, as usual, he saw Mary in Dr Thorne's pew. She, as she looked at him, could not but wonder why he had
not answered the letter which was still at Silverbridge; and he endeavoured to read into her face whether it
was true, as his mother told him, that she was quite ready to give him up. The prayers of both of them were
disturbed, as is so often the case with the prayers of other anxious people.
There was a separate door opening from the Greshamsbury pew out into the Greshamsbury grounds, so that
the family were not forced into unseemly community with the village multitude in going to and from their
prayers; for the front door of the church led out into a road which had no connexion with the private path. It
was not unusual with Frank and his father to go round, after the service, to the chief entrance, so that they
might speak to their neighbours, and get rid of some of the exclusiveness which was intended for them. On
this morning the squire did so; but Frank walked home with his mother and sisters, so that Mary saw no more
of him.
I have said that he walked home with his mother and sisters; but he rather followed in their path. He was not
inclined to talk much, at least, not to them; and he continued asking himself the questionwhether it could
be possible that he was wrong in remaining true to his promise? Could it be that he owed more to his father
and his mother, and what they chose to call his position, than he did to Mary?
After church, Mr Gazebee tried to get hold of him, for there was still much to be said, and many hints to be
given, as to how Frank should speak, and, more especially, as to how to hold his tongue among the learned
pundits in and about Chancery Lane. 'You must be very wide awake with Messrs Slow and Bideawhile,' said
Mr Gazebee. But Frank would not hearken to him just at that moment. He was going to ride over to Harry
Baker, so he put Mr Gazebee off till the halfhour before dinner,or else the halfhour after tea.
On the previous day he had received a letter from Miss Dunstable, which he had hitherto read but once. His
mother had interrupted him as he was about to refer to it; and now, as his father's nag was being saddledhe
was still prudent in saving the black horsehe again took it out.
Miss Dunstable had written in excellent humour. She was in great distress about the oil of Lebanon, she said.
'I have been trying to get a purchaser for the last two years; but my lawyer won't let me sell it, because the
wouldbe purchasers offer a thousand pounds or so less than the value. I would give ten to get rid of the bore;
but I am as little able to act myself as Sancho was in his government. The oil of Lebanon! Did you hear
anything of it when you were in those parts? I thought of changing the name to "London particular"; but my
lawyers says the brewers would bring an action against me.'
'I was going down to your neighbourhoodto your friend the duke's, at least. But I am prevented by my poor
doctor, who is so weak that I must take him to Malvern. It is a great bore; but I have the satisfaction that I do
my duty by him!
'Your cousin George is to be married at last. So I hear, at least. He loves wisely, if not well; for his widow has
the name of being prudent and fairly well to do in the world. She has got over the caprices of her youth. Dear
Aunt De Courcy will be so delighted. I might perhaps have met her at Gatherum Castle. I do so regret it.
'Mr Moffat has turned up again. We all thought you had finally extinguished him. He left a card the other
day, and I have told the servant always to say that I am at home, and that you are with me. He is going to
stand for some borough in the west of Ireland. He's used to shillelaghs by this time.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING 318
Page No 322
'By the by, I have a cadeau for a friend of yours. I won't tell you what it is, nor permit you to communicate
the fact. But when you tell me that in sending it I may fairly congratulate her on having so devoted a slave as
you, it shall be sent.
'If you have nothing better to do at present, do come and see my invalid at Malvern. Perhaps you might have
a mind to treat for the oil of Lebanon. I'll give you all the assistance I can in cheating my lawyers.'
There was not much about Mary in this; but still, the little that was said made him again declare that neither
father nor mother should move him from his resolution. 'I will write to her and say that she may send her
present when she pleases. Or I will run down to Malvern for a day. It will do me good to see her.' And so he
resolved, he rode away to Mill Hill, thinking, as he went, how he would put the matter to Harry Baker.
Harry was at home; but we need not describe the whole interview. Had Frank been asked beforehand, he
would have declared, that on no possible subject could he have had the slightest hesitation in asking Harry
any question, or communicating to him any tidings. But when the time came, he found that he did hesitate
much. He did not want to ask his friend if he should be wise to marry Mary Thorne. Wise or not, he was
determined to do that. But he wished to be quite sure that his mother was wrong in saying that all the world
would dissuade him from it. Miss Dunstable, at any rate, did not do so.
At last, seated on a stile at the back of the Mill Hill stables, while Harry stood close before him with both his
hands in his pockets, he did get his story told. It was by no means the first time that Harry Baker had heard
about Mary Thorne, and he was not, therefore, so surprised as he might have been, had the affair been new to
him. And thus, standing there in the position we have described, did Mr Baker, junior, give utterance to such
wisdom as was in him on this subject.
'You see, Frank, there are two sides to every question; and, as I take it, fellows are so apt to go wrong because
they are so fond of one side, they won't look at the other. There's no doubt about it, Lady Arabella is a very
clever woman, and knows what's what; and there's no doubt about this either, that you have a very ticklish
hand of cards to play.'
'I'll play it straightforward; and that's my game' said Frank.
'Well and good, my dear fellow. That's the best game always. But what is straightforward? Between you and
me, I fear there's no doubt that your father's property has got into a deuce of a mess.'
'I don't see that that has anything to do with it.'
'Yes, but it has. If the estate was all right, and your father could give you a thousand a year to live on without
feeling it, and if your eldest child would be cocksure of Greshamsbury, it might be very well that you
should please yourself as to marrying at once. But that's not the case; and yet Greshamsbury is too good a
card to be flung away.'
'I could fling it away tomorrow,' said Frank.
'Ah! you think so,' said Harry the Wise. 'But if you were to hear tomorrow that Sir Louis Scatcherd were
master of the whole place, and be dd to him, you would feel very uncomfortable.' Had Harry known how
near Sir Louis was to his last struggle, he would not have spoken of him in this manner. 'That's all very fine
talk, but it won't bear wear and tear. You do care for Greshamsbury if you are the fellow I take you to be:
care for it very much; and you care too much for your father being Gresham of Greshamsbury.'
'This won't affect my father at all.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING 319
Page No 323
'Ah, but it will affect him very much. If you were to marry Miss Thorne tomorrow, there would at once be
an end to any hope to save your property.'
'And do you mean to say I'm to be a liar to her for such reasons as that? Why, Harry, I should be as bad as
Moffat. Only it would be ten times more cowardly, as she has no brother.'
'I must differ from you there altogether; but mind, I don't mean to say anything. Tell me that you have made
up your mind to marry her, and I'll stick to you through thick and thin. But if you ask my advice, why, I must
give it. It is quite a different affair to that of Moffat's. He had lots of tin, everything he could want, and there
could be no reason why he should not marry,except that he was a snob, of whom your sister was well quit.
But this is very different. If I, as your friend, were to put it to Miss Thorne, what do you think she would say
herself?'
'She would say whatever was best for me.'
'Exactly: because she is a trump. And I say the same. There can be no doubt about it, Frank, my boy: such a
marriage would be very foolish for you both; very foolish. Nobody can admire Miss Thorne more than I do;
but you oughtn't to be a marrying man for the next ten years, unless you get a fortune. If you tell her the truth,
and if she's the girl I take her to be, she'll not accuse you of being false. She'll peak for a while; and so will
you, old chap. But others have had to do that before you. They have got over it and so will you.'
Such was the spoken wisdom of Harry Baker, and who can say that he was wrong? Frank sat a while on his
rustle seat, paring his nails with his penknife, and then looking up, he thus thanked his friend:
'I'm sure you mean well, Harry; and I'm much obliged to you. I dare say you're right too. But, somehow, it
doesn't come home to me. And what is more, after what has passed, I could not tell her that I wish to part
from her. I could not do it. And besides, I have that sort of feeling, that if I heard she was to marry any one
else, I am sure I would blow his brains out. Either his or my own.'
'Well, Frank, you may count on me for anything, except the last proposition:' and so they shook hands, and
Frank rode back to Greshamsbury.
CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON
On the Monday morning at six o'clock, Mr Oriel and Frank started together; but early as it was, Beatrice was
up to give them a cup of coffee, Mr Oriel having slept that night in the house. Whether Frank would have
received the coffee from his sister's fair hands had not Mr Oriel been there, may be doubted. He, however,
loudly asserted that he should not have done so, when she laid claim to great merit for rising on his behalf.
Mr Oriel had been specially instigated by Lady Arabella to use the opportunity of their joint journey, for
pointing out to Frank the iniquity as well as madness of the course he was pursuing; and he had promised to
obey her ladyship's request. But Mr Oriel was perhaps not an enterprising man, and was certainly not a
presumptuous one. He did intend to do as he was bid; but when he began, with the object of leading up to the
subject of Frank's engagement, he always softened down into some much easier enthusiasm in the matter of
his own engagement with Beatrice. He had not that perspicuous, but not oversensitive strength of mind
which had enabled Harry Baker to express his opinion out at once; and boldly as he did it, yet to do so
without offence.
Four times before the train arrived in London, he made some little attempt; but four times he failed. As the
subject was matrimony, it was his easiest course to begin about himself; but never could he get any further.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON 320
Page No 324
'No man was ever more fortunate in a wife than I shall be,' he said, with a soft, euphuistic selfcomplacency,
which would have been silly had it been adopted to any other person than the bride's brother. His intention,
however, was very good, for he meant to show, that in his case marriage was prudent and wise, because his
case differed so widely from that of Frank.
'Yes,' said Frank. 'She is an excellent good girl:' he had said it three times before, and was not very energetic.
'Yes, and so exactly suited to me; indeed, all that I could have dreamed of. How very well she looked this
morning! Some girls only look well at night. I should not like that at all.'
'You mustn't expect her to look like that always at six o'clock a.m.,' said Frank, laughing. 'Young ladies only
take that trouble on very particular occasions. She wouldn't have come down like that if my father or I had
been going alone. No, and she won't do that for you in a couple of years' time.'
'Oh, but she's always nice. I have seen her at home as much almost as you could do; and then she's so
sincerely religious.'
'Oh, yes, of course; that is, I am sure she is,' said Frank, looking solemn as became him.
'She's made to be a clergyman's wife.'
'Well, so it seems,'said Frank.
'A married life, I'm sure, the happiest in the worldif people are only in a position to marry,' said Mr Oriel,
gradually drawing near to the accomplishment of his design.
'Yes; quite so. Do you know, Oriel, I never was so sleepy in my life. What with all that fuss of Gazebee's, and
one thing and another, I could not get to bed till one o'clock; and then I couldn't sleep. I'll take a snooze now,
if you won't think it uncivil.' And then, putting his feet on the opposite seat, he settled himself comfortably to
his rest. And so Mr Oriel's last attempt for lecturing Frank in the railwaycarriage faded away and was
annihilated.
By twelve o'clock Frank was with Messrs Slow Bideawhile. Mr Bideawhile was engaged at the moment, but
he found the managing Chancery clerk to be a very chatty gentleman. Judging from what he saw, he would
have said that the work to be done at Messrs Slow Bideawhile's was not very heavy.
'A singular man that Sir Louis,' said the Chancery clerk.
'Yes; very singular,' said Frank.
'Excellent security; no better; and yet he will foreclose; but you see he has no power himself. But the question
is, can the trustee refuse? Then, again, trustees are so circumscribed nowadays that they are afraid to do
anything. There has been so much said lately, Mr Gresham, that a man doesn't know where he is, or what he
is doing. Nobody trusts anybody. There have been such terrible things that we can't wonder at it. Only think
of the case of those Hills! How can any one expect that any one else will ever trust a lawyer again after that?
But that's Mr Bideawhile's bell. How can one expect it? He will see you now, I dare say, Mr Gresham.'
So it turned out, and Frank was ushered into the presence of Mr Bideawhile. He had got his lesson by heart,
and was going to rush into the middle of his subject; such a course, however, was not in accordance with Mr
Bideawhile's usual practice. Mr Bideawhile got up from his large woodenseated Windsor chair, and, with a
soft smile, in which, however, was mingled some slight dash of the attorney's acuteness, put out his hand to
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON 321
Page No 325
his young client; not, indeed, as though he were going to shake hands with him, but as though the hand were
some ripe fruit all but falling, which his visitor might take and pluck if he thought proper. Frank took hold of
the hand, which returned no pressure, and then let it go again, not making any attempt to gather the fruit.
'I have come up to town, Mr Bideawhile, about this mortgage.'
'Mortgageah, sit down, Mr Gresham; sit down. I hope your father is quite well?'
'Quite well, thank you.'
'I have a great regard for your father. So I had for your grandfather; a very good man indeed. You, perhaps,
don't remember him, Mr Gresham?'
'He died when I was only a year old.'
'Oh, yes; no, you of course, can't remember him; but I do well: he used to be very fond of some port wine I
had. I think it was "11"; and if I don't mistake, I have a bottle or two of it yet; but it is not worth drinking
now. Port wine, you know, won't keep beyond a certain time. That was very good wine. I don't exactly
remember what it stood me a dozen then; but such wine can't be had now. As for the Madeira, you know
there's an end of that. Do you drink Madeira, Mr Gresham?'
'No,' said Frank, 'not very often.'
'I'm sorry for that, for it's a fine wine; but then there's none of it left, you know. I have a few dozen, I'm told
they're growing pumpkins where the vineyards were. I wonder what they do with all the pumpkins they grow
in Switzerland! You've been to Switzerland, Mr Gresham?'
Frank said he had ben in Switzerland.
'It's a beautiful country; my girls made me go there last year. They said it would do me good; but then you
know, they wanted to see it themselves; ha! ha! ha! However, I believe I shall go again this autumn. That is to
Aix, or some of those places; just for three weeks. I can't spare any more time, Mr Gresham. Do you like that
dining at the tables d'hote?'
'Pretty well, sometimes.'
'One would get tired of iteh! But they gave us capital dinners at Zurich. I don't think much of their soup.
But they had fish, and about seven kinds of meats and poultry, and three or four puddings, and things of that
sort. Upon my word, I thought we did very well, and so did my girls, too. You see a great many ladies
travelling now.'
'Yes,' said Frank; 'a great many.'
'Upon my word, I think they are right; that is, if they can afford time. I can't afford time. I'm here every day
till five, Mr Gresham; then I go out and dine in Fleet Street, and then back to work till nine.'
'Dear me! that's very hard.'
'Well, yes it is hard work. My boys don't like it; but I manage somehow. I get down to my little place in the
country on Saturday. I shall be most happy to see you there next Saturday.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON 322
Page No 326
Frank, thinking it would be outrageous on his part to take up much of the time of the gentleman who was
constrained to work so unreasonably hard, began again to talk about his mortgages, and, in so doing, had to
mention the name of Mr Yates Umblelby.
'Ah, poor Umblelby!' said Mr Bideawhile; 'what is he doing now? I am quite sure your father was right, or he
wouldn't have done it; but I used to think that Umbleby was a decent sort of man enough. Not so grand, you
know, as your Gazebees and Gumptionseh, Mr Gresham? They do say young Gazebee is thinking of
getting into Parliament. Let me see: Umbleby marriedwho was it he married? That was the way your father
got hold of him; not your father, but your grandfather. I used to know all about it. Well, I was sorry for
Umbleby. He has got something, I supposeeh?'
Frank said that he believed Mr Yates Umbleby had something wherewith to keep the wolf from the door.
'So you have got Gazebee down there now? Gumption, Gazebee Gazebee: very good people, I'm sure; only,
perhaps, they have a little too much on hand to do your father justice.'
'But about Sir Louis Scatcherd, Mr Bideawhile.'
'Well, about Sir Louis; a very bad sort of fellow, isn't he? Drinkseh? I knew his father a little. He was a
rough diamond, too. I was once down in Northamptonshire, about some railway business; let me see; I almost
forget whether I was with him, or against him. But I know he made sixty thousand pounds by one hour's
work; sixty thousand pounds! And then he got so mad with drinking that we all thought'
And so Mr Bideawhile went on for two hours, and Frank found no opportunity of saying one word about the
business which had brought him up to town. What wonder that such a man as this should be obliged to stay at
his office every night till nine o'clock?
During these two hours, a clerk had come in three or four times, whispering something to the lawyer, who, on
the last of such occasions, turned to Frank, saying, 'Well, perhaps that will do for today. If you'll manage to
call tomorrow, say about two, I will have the whole thing looked up; or, perhaps Wednesday or Thursday
would suit you better.' Frank, declaring that the morrow would suit him very well, took his departure,
wondering much at the manner in which business was done at the house of Messrs Slow and Bideawhile.
When he called the next day, the office seemed to be rather disturbed, and he was shown quickly into Mr
Bideawhile's room. 'Have you heard this?' said that gentleman, putting a telegram into his hands. It contained
tidings of the death of Sir Louis Scatcherd. Frank immediately knew that these tidings must be of importance
to his father; but he had no idea how vitally they concerned his own more immediate interests.
'Dr Thorne will be up in town on Thursday evening after the funeral,' said the talkative clerk. 'And nothing of
course can be done till he comes,' said Mr Bideawhile. And so Frank, pondering on the mutability of human
affairs, again took his departure.
He could do nothing now but wait for Dr Thorne's arrival, and so he amused himself in the interval by
running down to Malvern, and treating with Miss Dunstable in person for the oil of Lebanon. He went down
on the Wednesday, and thus, failed to receive, on the Thursday morning, Mary's letter, which reached
London on that day. He returned, however, on the Friday, and then got it; and perhaps it was well for Mary's
happiness that he had seen Miss Dunstable in the interval. 'I don't care what your mother says,' said she, with
emphasis. 'I don't care for any Harry, whether it be Harry Baker or old Harry himself. You made her a
promise, and you are bound to keep it; if not on one day, then on another. What! because you cannot draw
back yourself, get out of it by inducing her to do so! Aunt de Courcy herself could not improve upon that.'
Fortified in this manner, he returned to town on the Friday morning, and then got Mary's letter. Frank also got
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON 323
Page No 327
a note from Dr Thorne, stating that he had taken up his temporary domicile at the Gray's Inn Coffeehouse,
so as to be near the lawyers.
It has been suggested that the modern English writers of fiction should among them keep a barrister, in order
that they may be set right on such legal points as will arise in their little narratives, and thus avoid the
exposure of their own ignorance of the laws, which, now, alas! they too often make. The idea as worthy of
consideration, and I can only say, that if such an arrangement can be made, and if a counsellor adequately
skilful can be found to accept the office, I shall be happy to subscribe my quota; it would be but a modest
tribute towards the cost.
But as the suggestion has not yet been carried out, and as there is at present no learned gentleman whose duty
would induce him to set me right, I can only plead for mercy if I be wrong allotting all Sir Roger's vast
possessions in perpetuity to Miss Thorne, alleging also, in excuse, that the course of my narrative absolutely
demands that she shall be ultimately recognized as Sir Roger's undoubted heiress.
Such, after a not immoderate delay, was the opinion expressed to Dr Thorne by his law advisers; and such, in
fact, turned out to be the case. I will leave the matter so, hoping that my very absence of defence may serve to
protect me from severe attack. If under such a will as that described as having been made by Sir Roger, Mary
would not have been the heiress, that will must have been described wrongly.
But it was not quite at once that those tidings made themselves absolutely certain to Dr Thorne's mind; nor
was he able to express any such opinion when he first met Frank in London. At that time Mary's letter was in
Frank's pocket; and Frank, though his real business appertained much more to the fact of Sir Louis's death,
and the effect that would immediately have on his father's affairs, was much more full of what so much more
nearly concerned himself. 'I will show it Dr Thorne himself,' said he, 'and ask him what he thinks.'
Dr Thorne was stretched fast asleep on the comfortless horsehair sofa in the dingy sittingroom at the
Gray's Inn Coffeehouse when Frank found him. The funeral, and his journey to London, and the lawyers
had together conquered his energies, and he lay and snored, with nose upright, while heavy London summer
flies settled on his head and face, and robbed his slumbers of half their charms.
'I beg your pardon,' said he, jumping up as though he had been detected in some disgraceful act. 'Upon my
word, Frank, I beg your pardon; butwell, my dear fellow, all well at Greshamsburyeh?' and as he shook
himself, he made a lunge at one uncommonly disagreeable fly that had been at him for the last ten minutes. It
is hardly necessary to say that he missed his enemy.
'I should have been with you before, doctor, but I was down at Malvern.'
'At Malvern, eh? Ah! so Oriel told me. The death of poor Sir Louis was very suddenwas it not?'
'Very.'
'Poor fellowpoor fellow! His fate has for some time been past hope. It is a madness, Frank; the worst of
madness. Only think of itfather and son! And such a career as the father hadsuch a career as the son
might have had!'
'It has been very quickly run,' said Frank.
'May it be all forgiven him! I sometimes cannot but believe in a special Providence. That poor fellow was not
able, never would have been able, to make proper use of the means which fortune had given him. I hope they
may fall into better hands. There is no use in denying it, his death will be an immense relief to me, and a
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON 324
Page No 328
relief also to your father. All this law business will now, of course, be stopped. As for me, I hope I may never
be trustee again.'
Frank had put his hand four or five times into his breastpocket, and had as often taken out and put back
again Mary's letter before he could find himself able to bring Dr Thorne to the subject. At last there was a lull
in the purely legal discussion, caused by the doctor intimating that he supposed Frank would now soon return
to Greshamsbury.
'Yes; I shall go tomorrow morning.'
'What! so soon as that? I counted on having you one day in London with me.'
'No, I shall go tomorrow. I'm not fit for company for any one. Nor am I fit for anything. Read that, doctor.
It's no use putting it off any longer. I must get you to talk this over with me. Just read that, and tell me what
you think about it. It was written a week ago, but somehow I have only got it today.' And putting the letter
into the doctor's hands, he turned away to the window, and looked out among the Holborn omnibuses. Dr
Thorne took the letter and read it. Mary, after she had written it, had bewailed to herself that the letter was
cold; but it had not seemed cold to her lover, nor did it appear so to her uncle. When Frank turned round from
the window, the doctor's handkerchief was up to his eyes; who, in order to hide the tears that were there, was
obliged to go through a rather violent process of blowing his nose.
'Well,' he said, as he gave back the letter to Frank.
Well! what did well mean? Was it well? or would it be well were he, Frank, to comply with the suggestion
made to him by Mary?
'It is impossible,' he said, 'that matters should go on like that. Think what her sufferings must have been
before she wrote that. I am sure she loves me.'
'I think she does,' said the doctor.
'And it is out of the question that she should be sacrificed; nor will I consent to sacrifice my own happiness. I
am quite willing to work for my bread, and I am sure that I am able. I will not submit toDoctor, what
answer do you think I ought to give to that letter? There can be no person so anxious for her happiness as you
areexcept myself.' And as he asked the question, he again put into the doctor's hands, almost
unconsciously, the letter which he had still been holding in his own.
The doctor turned it over and over, and then opened it again.
'What answer ought I to make to it?' demanded Frank, with energy.
'You see, Frank, I have never interfered in this matter, otherwise than to tell you the whole truth about Mary's
birth.'
'Oh, but you must interfere: you should say what you think.'
'Circumstanced as you are nowthat is, just at the present momentyou could hardly marry immediately.'
'Why not let me take a farm? My father could, at any rate, manage a couple of thousand pounds or so for me
to stock it. That would not be asking much. If he could not give it me, I would not scruple to borrow so much
elsewhere.' And Frank bethought him of all Miss Dunstable's offers.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON 325
Page No 329
'Oh, yes; that could be managed.'
'Then why not marry immediately; say in six months or so? I am not unreasonable; though, Heaven knows, I
have been kept in suspense long enough. As for her, I am sure she must be suffering frightfully. You know
her best, and, therefore, I ask you what answer I ought to make: as for myself, I have made up my own mind;
I am not a child, nor will I let them treat me as such.'
Frank, as he spoke, was walking rapidly about the room; and h brought out his different positions, one after
the other, with a little pause, while waiting for the doctor's answer. The doctor was sitting, with the letter still
in his hands, on the head of the sofa, turning over in his mind the apparent absurdity of Frank's desire to
borrow two thousand pounds for a farm, when, in all human probability, he might in a few months be in
possession of almost any sum he should choose to name. And yet he would not tell him of Sir Roger's will. 'If
it should turn out to be all wrong?' said he to himself.
'Do you wish me to give her up?' said Frank, at last.
'No. How can I wish it? How can I expect a better match for her? Besides, Frank, I love no man in the world
so well as I do you.'
'Then will you help me?'
'What! against your father?'
'Against! no, not against anybody. But will you tell Mary she has your consent?'
'I think she knows that.'
'But you have never said anything to her?'
'Look here, Frank; you ask me for my advice, and I will give it you: go home, though, indeed, I would rather
you went anywhere else.'
'No, I must go home; and I must see her.'
'Very well, go home: as for seeing Mary, I think you had better put it off for a fortnight.'
'Quite impossible.'
'Well, that's my advice. But, at any rate, make up your mind to nothing for a fortnight. Wait for one fortnight,
and I then will tell you plainlyyou and her toowhat I think you ought to do. At the end of a fortnight
come to me, and tell the squire that I will take it as a great kindness if he will come with you. She has
suffered terribly, terribly; and it is necessary that something should be settled. But a fortnight can make no
great difference.'
'And the letter?'
'Oh! there's the letter.'
'But what shall I say? Of course I shall write to her tonight.'
'Tell her to wait a fortnight. And, Frank, mind you bring your father with you.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON 326
Page No 330
Frank could draw nothing further from his friend save constant repetitions of this charge to him to wait a
fortnight,just one other fortnight.
'Well, I will come to you at any rate,' said Frank; 'and, if possible, I will bring my father. But I shall write to
Mary tonight.'
On the Saturday morning, Mary, who was then nearly brokenhearted at her lover's silence, received a short
note:
'MY OWN MARY
'I shall be home tomorrow. I will by no means release you from your promise. Of course you will perceive
that I only got your letter today.'
Your own dearest, FRANK.'
Short as it was, this sufficed Mary. It is one thing for a young lady to make prudent, heartbreaking
suggestions, but quite another to have them accepted. She did call him dearest Frank, even on that one day,
almost as often as he had desired her.
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL
Frank returned home, and his immediate business was of course with his father, and with Mr Gazebee, who
was still at Greshamsbury.
'But who is the heir?' asked Mr Gazebee, when Frank had explained that the death of Sir Louis rendered
unnecessary any immediate legal steps.
'Upon my word, I don't know,' said Frank.
'You saw Dr Thorne,' said the squire. 'He must have known.'
'I never thought of asking him,' said Frank, naively.
Mr Gazebee looked rather solemn. 'I wonder at that,' said he; 'for everything depends on the hands the
property will go into. Let me see; I think Sir Roger had a married sister. Was not that so, Mr Gresham?' And
then it occurred for the first time, both to the squire and to his son, that Mary Thorne was the eldest child of
this sister. But it never occurred to either of them that Mary could be the baronet's heir.
Dr Thorne came down for a couple of days before the fortnight was over to see his patients, and then returned
again to London. But during this short visit he was utterly dumb on the subject of the heir. He called at
Greshamsbury to see Lady Arabella, and was even questioned by the squire on the subject. But he obstinately
refused to say anything more than nothing certain could be known for a few days.
Immediately after his return, Frank saw Mary, and told her all that had happened. 'I cannot understand my
uncle,' said she, almost trembling as she stood close to him in her own drawingroom. 'He usually hates
mysteries, and yet now he is so mysterious. He told me, Frankthat was after I had written that unfortunate
letter'
'Unfortunate indeed! I wonder what you really thought of me when you were writing it?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL 327
Page No 331
'If you had heard what your mother said, you would not be surprised. But, after that, uncle said'
'Said what?'
'He seemed to thinkI don't remember what it was he said. But he said, he hoped that things might yet turn
out well; and then I was almost sorry that I had written the letter.'
'Of course you were sorry, and so you ought to have been. To say that you would never call me Frank again!'
'I didn't exactly say that.'
'I have told him that I will wait a fortnight, and so I will. After that, I shall take the matter into my own
hands.'
It may be supposed that Lady Arabella was not well pleased to learn that Frank and Mary had been again
together; and, in the agony of her spirit, she did say some illnatured things before Augusta, who had now
returned home from Courcy Castle, as to the gross impropriety of Mary's conduct. But to Frank she said
nothing.
Nor was there much said between Frank and Beatrice. If everything could really be settled at the end of that
fortnight which was to witness the disclosure of the doctor's mystery, there would still be time to arrange that
Mary should be at the wedding. 'It shall be settled then,' he said to himself; 'and if it be settled, my mother
will hardly venture to exclude my affianced bride from the house.' It was now the beginning of August, and it
wanted yet a month to the Oriel wedding.
But though he said nothing to his mother or to Beatrice, he did say much to his father. In the first place, he
showed him Mary's letter. 'If your heart be not made of stone it will be softened by that,' he said. Mr
Gresham's heart was not of stone, and he did acknowledge that the letter was a very sweet letter. But we
know how the drop of water hollows stone. It was not by the violence of his appeal that Frank succeeded in
obtaining from his father a sort of halfconsent that he would no longer oppose the match; but by the
assiduity with which the appeal was repeated. Frank, as we have said, had more stubbornness of will than his
father; and so, before the fortnight was over, the squire had been talked over, and promised to attend at the
doctor's bidding.
'I suppose you had better take the Hazlehurst farm,' said he to his son, with a sigh. 'It joins the park and the
homefields, and I will give you them up also. God knows, I don't care about farming any moreor about
anything else either.'
'Don't say that, father.'
'Well, well! But, Frank, where will you live? The old house is big enough for us all. But how would Mary get
on with your mother?'
At the end of this fortnight, true to his time, the doctor returned to the village. He was a bad correspondent;
and though he had written some short notes to Mary, he had said no word to her about his business. It was
late in the evening when he got home, and it was understood by Frank and the squire that they were to be
with him on the following morning. Not a word had been said to Lady Arabella on the subject.
It was late in the evening when he got home, and Mary waited for him with a heart almost sick with
expectation. As soon as the fly had stopped at the little gate she heard his voice, and heard at once that it was
quick, joyful, and telling much of inward satisfaction. He had a goodnatured word for Janet, and called
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL 328
Page No 332
Thomas an old blunderhead in a manner that made Bridget laugh outright.
'He'll have his nose put out of joint some day; won't he?' said the doctor. Bridget blushed and laughed again,
and made a sign to Thomas that he had better look to his face.
Mary was in his arms before he was yet within the door. 'My darling,' said he, tenderly kissing her. 'You are
my own darling yet awhile.'
'Of course I am. Am I not always to be so?'
'Well, well; let me have some tea, at any rate, for I'm in a fever of thirst. They may call that tea at the Junction
if they will; but if China were sunk under the sea it would make no difference to them.'
Dr Thorne always was in a fever of thirst when he got home from the railway, and always made complaint as
to tea at the Junction. Mary went about her usual work with almost more than her usual alacrity, and so they
were soon seated in the drawingroom together.
She soon found that his manner was more than ordinarily kind to her; and there was moreover something
about him which seemed to make him sparkle with contentment, but he said no word about Frank, nor did he
make any allusion to the business which had taken him up to town.
'Have you got through all your work?' she said to him once.
'Yes, yes; I think all.'
'And thoroughly?'
'Yes; thoroughly, I think. But I am very tired, and so are you too, darling, with waiting for me.'
'Oh, no, I am not tired,' said she, as she went on continually filling his cup; 'but I am so happy to have you
home again. You have been away so much lately.'
'Ah, yes; well I suppose I shall not go away any more now. It will be somebody else's turn now.'
'Uncle, I think you are going to take up writing mystery romances, like Mrs Radciffe's.'
'Yes; and I'll begin tomorrow, certainly withBut, Mary, I will not say another word tonight. Give me a
kiss, dearest, and I'll go.'
Mary did kiss him, and he did go. But as she was still lingering in the room, putting away a book, or a reel of
thread, and then sitting down to think what the morrow would bring forth, the doctor again came into the
room in his dressinggown, and with the slippers on.
'What, not gone yet?' said he.
'No, not yet; I'm going now.'
'You and I, Mary, have always affected a good deal of indifference as to money, and all that sort of thing.'
'I won't acknowledge that it has been an affectation at all,' she answered.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL 329
Page No 333
'Perhaps not; but we have often expressed it, have we not?'
'I suppose, uncle, you think that we are like the fox that lost his tail, or rather some unfortunate fox that might
be born without one.'
'I wonder how we should either of us bear it if we found ourselves suddenly rich. It would be a great
temptationa sore temptation. I fear, Mary, that when poor people talk disdainfully of money, they often are
like your fox, born without a tail. If nature suddenly should give that beast a tail, would he not be prouder of
it than all the other foxes in the wood?'
'Well, I suppose he would. That's the very meaning of the story. But how moral you've become all of a
sudden, at twelve o'clock at night! Instead of being Mrs Radcliffe, I shall think you're Mr Aesop.'
He took up the article which he had come to seek, and kissing her again on the forehead, went away to his
bedroom without further speech. 'What can he mean by all this about money?' said Mary to herself. 'It
cannot be that by Sir Louis's death he will get any of all this property;' and then she began to bethink herself
whether, after all, she would wish him to be a rich man. 'If he were very rich, he might do something to assist
Frank; and then'
There never was a fox yet without a tail who would not be delighted to find himself suddenly possessed of
that appendage. Never; let the untailed fox have been ever so sincere in his advice to his friends! We are all
of us, the good and the bad, looking for tailsfor one tail, or for more than one; we do so too often by ways
that are mean enough: but perhaps there is no tailseeker more mean, more sneakingly mean than he who
looks out to adorn his bare back by a tail by marriage.
The doctor was up very early the next morning, long before Mary was ready with her teacups. He was up, and
in his own study behind the shop, arranging dingy papers, pulling about tin boxes which he had brought down
with him from London, and piling on his writingtable one set of documents in one place, and one in another.
'I think I understand it all,' said he; 'but yet I know I shall be bothered. Well, I never will be anyone's trustee
again. Let me see!' and then he sat down, and with bewildered look recapitulated to himself sundry heavy
items. 'What those shares are really worth I cannot understand, and nobody seems to be able to tell one. They
must make it out among them as best they can. Let me see; that's Boxall Hill, and this is Greshamsbury. I'll
put a newspaper over Greshamsbury, or the squire will know it!' and then, having made his arrangements, he
went to his breakfast.
I know I am wrong, my much and truly honoured critic, about these titledeeds and documents. But when
we've got a barrister in hand, then if I go wrong after that, let the blame be on my own shouldersor on his.
The doctor ate his breakfast quickly; and did not talk much to his niece. But what he did say was of a nature
to make her feel strangely happy. She could not analyse her own feelings, or give a reason for her own
confidence; but she certainly did feel, and even trust, that something was going to happen after breakfast
which would make her more happy than she had been for many months.
'Janet,' said he, looking at his watch, 'if Mr Gresham and Mr Frank call, show them into my study. What are
you going to do with yourself, my dear?'
'I don't know, uncle; you are so mysterious, and I am in such a twitter, that I don't know what to do. Why is
Mr Gresham coming herethat is, the squire?'
'Because I have business with him about the Scatcherd property. You know that he owed Sir Louis money.
But don't go out, Mary. I want you to be in the way if I should have to call for you. You can stay in the
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL 330
Page No 334
drawingroom, can't you?'
'Oh, yes, uncle; or here.'
'No, dearest; go into the drawingroom.' Mary obediently did as she was bid; and there she sat, for the next
three hours, wondering, wondering, wondering. During the greater part of that time, however, she well knew
that Mr Gresham, senior, and Mr Gresham, junior, were both with her uncle, below.
At eleven the doctor's visitors came. he had expected them somewhat earlier, and was beginning to become
fidgety. He had so much on his hands that he could not sit still for a moment till he had, at any rate,
commenced it. The expected footsteps were at last heard on the gravelpath, and moment or two afterwards
Janet ushered the father and son into the room.
The squire did not look very well. He was worn and sorrowful, and rather pale. The death of his young
creditor might be supposed to have given him some relief from his more pressing cares, but the necessity of
yielding to Frank's wishes had almost more than balanced this. When a man has daily to reflect that he is
poorer than he was the day before, he soon becomes worn and sorrowful.
But Frank was well; both in health and spirits. He also felt as Mary did, that the day was to bring forth
something which should end his present troubles; and he could not but be happy to think that he could now
tell Dr Thorne that his father's consent to his marriage had been given.
The doctor shook hands with them both, and then they sat down. They were all rather constrained in their
manner; and at first it seemed that nothing but little speeches of compliment were to be made. At last, the
squire remarked that Frank had been talking to him about Miss Thorne.
'About Mary?' said the doctor.
'Yes; about Mary,' said the squire, correcting himself. It was quite unnecessary that he should use so cold a
name as the other, now that he had agreed to the match.
'Well!' said Dr Thorne.
'I suppose it must be so, doctor. He has set his heart upon it, and God knows, I have nothing to say against
heragainst her personally. No one could say a word against her. She is a sweet, good girl, excellently
brought up; and, as for myself, I have always loved her.' Frank drew near to his father, and pressed his hand
against the squire's arm, by way of giving him, in some sort, a filial embrace for his kindness.
'Thank you, squire, thank you,' said the doctor. 'It is very good of you to say that. She is a good girl, and if
Frank chooses to take her, he will, in my estimation, have made a good choice.'
'Chooses!' said Frank, with all the enthusiasm of a lover.
The squire felt himself perhaps a little ruffled at the way in which the doctor received his gracious intimation;
but he did now show it as he went on. 'They cannot, you know, doctor, look to be rich people'
'Ah! well, well,' interrupted the doctor.
'I have told Frank so, and I think that you should tell Mary. Frank means to take some land into his hand, and
he must farm it as a farmer. I will endeavour to give him three, or perhaps four hundred a year. But you know
better'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL 331
Page No 335
'Stop, squire; stop a minute. We will talk about that presently. This death of poor Sir Louis will make a
difference.'
'Not permanently,' said the squire mournfully.
'And now, Frank,' said the doctor, not attending to the squire's last words, 'what do you say?'
'What do I say? I say what I said to you in London the other day. I believe Mary loves me; indeed, I won't be
affectedI know she does. I have loved herI was going to say always; and, indeed, I almost might say so.
My father knows that this is no light fancy of mine. As to what he says about our being poor, why'
The doctor was very arbitrary, and would hear neither of them on the subject.
'Mr Gresham,' said he, interrupting Frank, 'of course I am well aware how very little suited Mary is by birth
to marry your only son.'
'It is too late to think about that now,' said the squire.
'It is not too late for me to justify myself,' replied the doctor. 'We have long known each other, Mr Gresham,
and you said here the other day, that this is a subject as to which we have been of one mind. Birth and blood
are very valuable gifts.'
'I certainly think so,' said the squire; 'but one can't have everything.'
'No; one can't have everything.'
'If I am satisfied in that matter' began Frank.
'Stop a moment, my dear boy,' said the doctor. 'As your father says, one can't have everything. My dear
friend' and he gave his hand to the squire'do not be angry if I alluded for a moment to the estate. It has
grieved me to see it melting awaythe old family acres that have so long been the heritage of the Greshams.'
'We need not talk about that now, Dr Thorne,' said Frank, in an almost angry tone.
'But I must, Frank, for one moment, to justify myself. I could not have excused myself in letting Mary think
that she could become your wife if I had not hoped that good might come of it.'
'Well; good will come of it,' said Frank, who did not quite understand at what the doctor was driving.
'I hope so. I have had much doubt about this, and have been sorely perplexed; but now I do hope so.
FrankMr Gresham' and then Dr Thorne rose from his chair; but was, for a moment, unable to go on with
his tale.
'We will hope that it is all for the best,' said the squire.
'I am sure it is,' said Frank.
'Yes; I hope it is. I do think it is; I am sure it is, Frank. Mary will not come to you emptyhanded. I wish for
your sakeyes, and for hers toothat her birth were equal to her fortune, as her worth is superior to both.
Mr Gresham, this marriage will, at any rate, put an end to your pecuniary embarrassmentsunless, indeed,
Frank should prove a hard creditor. My niece is Sir Roger Scatcherd's heir.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL 332
Page No 336
The doctor, as soon as he made the announcement, began to employ himself sedulously about the papers on
the table; which, in the confusion caused by his own emotion, he transferred hither and thither in such a
manner as to upset all his previous arrangements. 'And now,' he said, 'I might as well explain, as well as I
can, of what that fortune consists. Here, this isno'
'But, Dr Thorne,' said the squire, now perfectly pale, and almost gasping for breath, 'what is it you mean?'
'There's not a shadow of doubt,' said the doctor. 'I've had Sir Abraham Haphazard, and Sir Rickety Giggs, and
old Neversaye Dis, and Mr Snilam; and they are all of the same opinion. There is not the smallest doubt about
it. Of course, she must administer, and all that; and I'm afraid there'll be a very heavy sum to pay for the tax;
for she cannot inherit as a niece, you know. Mr Snilam pointed out that particularly. But, after all that, there'll
beI've got it down on a piece of paper, somewherethree grains of blue pill. I'm really so bothered,
squire, with all these papers, and all those lawyers, that I don't know whether I'm sitting or standing. There's
ready money enough to pay all the tax and all the debts. I know that, at any rate.'
'You don't mean to say that Mary Thorne is now possessed of all Sir Roger Scatcherd's wealth?' at last
ejaculated the squire.
'But that's exactly what I do mean to say,' said the doctor, looking up from his papers with a tear in his eye,
and a smile on his mouth; 'and what is more, squire, you owe her at the present moment exactlyI've got
that down too, somewhere, only I am so bothered with all these papers. Come, squire, when do you mean to
pay her? She's in a great hurry, as young ladies are when they want to get married.'
The doctor was inclined to joke if possible, so as to carry off, as it were, some of the great weight of
obligation which it might seem that he was throwing on the father and son; but the squire was by no means in
a state to understand a joke: hardly as yet in a state to comprehend what was so very serious in this matter.
'Do you mean that Mary is the owner of Boxall Hill?' said he.
'Indeed I do,' said the doctor; and he was just going to add, 'and of Greshamsbury also,' but he stopped
himself.
'What, the whole property there?'
'That's only a small portion,' said the doctor. 'I almost wish it were all, for then I would not be so bothered.
Look here; these are the Boxall Hill titledeeds; that's the simplest part of the whole affair; and Frank may go
and settle himself there tomorrow if he pleases.'
'Stop a moment, Dr Thorne,' said Frank. These were the only words which he had yet uttered since the tidings
had been conveyed to him.
'And these, squire, are the Greshamsbury papers:' and the doctor, with considerable ceremony, withdrew the
covering newspapers. 'Look at them; there they all are once again. When I suggested to Mr Snilam that I
supposed they might now all go back to the Greshamsbury muniment room, I thought he would have fainted.
As I cannot return them to you, you will have to wait till Frank shall give them up.'
'But, Dr Thorne,' said Frank.
'Well, my boy.'
'Does Mary know all about this?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL 333
Page No 337
'Not a word of it. I mean that you shall tell her.'
'Perhaps, under such very altered circumstances'
'Eh?'
'The change is so great and so sudden, so immense in its effects, that Mary may wish perhaps'
'Wish! wish what? Wish not to be told of it at all?'
'I shall not think of holding her to her engagementthat is, ifI mean to say, she should have time at any
rate for consideration.'
'Oh, I understand,' said the doctor. 'She shall have time for consideration. How much shall we give her,
squire, three minutes? Go up to her Frank: she is in the drawingroom.'
Frank went to the door, and then hesitated, and returned. 'I could not do it,' said he. 'I don't think that I
understand it all yet. I am so bewildered that I could not tell her;' and he sat down at the table, and began to
sob with emotion.
'And she knows nothing of it?' said the squire.
'Not a word. I thought that I would keep the pleasure of telling her for Frank.'
'She should not be left in suspense,' said the squire.
'Come, Frank, go up to her,' again urged the doctor. 'You've been ready enough with your visits when you
knew that you ought to stay away.'
'I cannot do it,' said Frank, after a pause of some moments; 'nor is it right that I should. It would be taking
advantage of her.'
'Go to her yourself, doctor; it is you that should do it,' said the squire.
After some further slight delay, the doctor got up, and did go upstairs. He, even, was half afraid of the task. 'It
must be done,' he said to himself, as his heavy steps mounted the stairs. 'But how to tell it?'
When he entered, Mary was standing halfway up the room, as though she had risen to meet him. Her face
was troubled, and her eyes were almost wild. The emotion, the hopes, the fears of the morning had almost
been too much for her. She had heard the murmuring of the voices in the room below, and had known that
one of them was that of her lover. Whether that discussion was to be for her good or ill she did not know; but
she felt that further suspense would almost kill her. 'I could wait for years,' she said to herself, 'if I did but
know. If I lost him, I suppose I should bear it, if I did but know.'Well; she was going to know.
Her uncle met her in the middle of the room. His face was serious, though not sad; too serious to confirm her
hopes at that moment of doubt. 'What is it, uncle?' she said, taking one of his hands between both of her own.
'What is it? Tell me.' And as she looked up into his face with her wild eyes, she almost frightened him.
'Mary,' he said gravely, 'you have heard much, I know of Sir Roger Scatcherd's great fortune.'
'Yes, yes, yes!'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL 334
Page No 338
'Now that poor Sir Louis is dead'
'Well, uncle, well?'
'It has been left'
'To Frank! to Mr Gresham, to the squire!' exclaimed Mary, whe felt, with an agony of doubt, that this sudden
accession of immense wealth might separate her still further from her lover.
'No, Mary, not to the Greshams; but to yourself.'
'To me!' she cried, and putting both her hands to her forehead, she seemed to be holding her temples together.
'To me!'
'Yes, Mary; it is all your own now. To do as you like best with it allall. May God, in His mercy, enable
you to bear the burden, and lighten for you the temptation!'
She had so far moved as to find the nearest chair, and there she was now seated, staring at her uncle with
fixed eyes. 'Uncle,' she said, 'what does it mean?' Then he came, and sitting beside her, he explained, as best
he could, the story of her birth, and her kinship with the Scatcherds. 'And where is he, uncle?' she said. 'Why
does he not come to me?'
'I wanted him to come, but her refused. They are both there now, the father and son; shall I fetch them?'
'Fetch them! whom? The squire? No, uncle; but may we go to them?'
'Surely, Mary.'
'But, uncle'
'Yes, dearest.'
'Is it true? are you sure? For his sake, you know; not for my own. The squire, you knowOh, uncle! I cannot
go.'
'They shall come to you.'
Nono. I have gone to him such hundreds of times; I will never allow that he shall be sent to me. But, uncle,
is it true?'
The doctor, as he went downstairs, muttered something about Sir Abraham Haphazard, and Sir Rickety
Giggs; but these great names were much thrown away upon poor Mary. The doctor entered the room first,
and the heiress followed him with downcast eyes and timid steps. She was at first afraid to advance, but when
she did look up, and saw Frank standing alone by the window, her lover restored her courage, and rushing up
to him, she threw herself into his arms. 'Oh, Frank; my own Frank! my own Frank! we shall never be
separated again.'
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE
ASKED TO THE WEDDING
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 335
Page No 339
And thus after all did Frank perform his duty; he did marry money; or rather, as the wedding has not yet
taken place, and is, indeed, as yet hardly talked of, we should more properly say that he had engaged himself
to marry money. And then, such a quantity of money! the Scatcherd wealth greatly exceeded the Dunstable
wealth; so that our hero may be looked on as having performed his duties in a manner deserving the very
highest commendation from all classes of the De Courcy connexion.
And he received it. But that was nothing. That he should be feted by the De Courcys and the Greshams, now
that he was about to do his duty by his family in so exemplary a manner: that he should be patted on the back,
now that he no longer meditated that vile crime which had been so abhorrent to his mother's soul; this was
only natural; this is hardly worthy of remark. But there was another to be feted, another person to be made a
personage, another blessed human mortal about to do her duty by the family of Gresham in a manner that
deserved, and should receive, Lady Arabella's warmest caresses.
Dear Mary! It was, indeed, not singular that she should be prepared to act so well, seeing that in early youth
she had had the advantage of an education in the Greshamsbury nursery; but not on that account was it the
less fitting that her virtue should be acknowledged, eulogized, nay, all but worshipped.
How the party at the doctor's got itself broken up, I am not prepared to say. Frank, I know, stayed, and dined
there, and his poor mother, who would not retire to rest till she had kissed him, and blessed him, and thanked
him for all he was doing for the family, was kept waiting in her dressingroom till a very unreasonable hour
of the night.
It was the squire who brought the news up to the house. 'Arabella,' he said, in a low, but somewhat solemn
voice, 'you will be surprised at the news I bring you. Mary Thorne is the heiress to all the Scatcherd property!'
'Oh, heavens! Mr Gresham.'
'Yes, indeed,' continued the squire. 'So it is; it is very, very' But Lady Arabella had fainted. She was a
woman who generally had her feelings and her emotions much under her own control; but what she now
heard was too much for her. When she came to her senses, the first words that escaped her lips were, 'Dear
Mary!'
But the household had to sleep on the news before it could be fully realized. The squire was not by nature a
mercenary man. If I have at all succeeded in putting his character before the reader, he will be recognized as
one not over attached to money for money's sake. But things had gone so hard with him, the world had
become so rough, so ungracious, so full of thorns, the want of means had become an evil so keenly felt in
every hour, that it cannot be wondered at that his dreams that night should be of a golden Elysium. The
wealth was not coming to him. True. But his chief sorrow had been for his son. Now that son would be his
only creditor. It was as though mountains of marble had been taken off his bosom.
But Lady Arabella's dreams flew away at once into the seventh heaven. Sordid as they certainly were, they
were not absolutely selfish. Frank would now certainly be the first commoner in Barsetshire; of course he
would represent the county; of course there would be the house in town; it wouldn't be her house, but she was
contented that the grandeur should be that of her child. He would have heaven knows what to spend per
annum. And that it should come through Mary Thorne! What a blessing she had allowed Mary to be brought
into the Greshamsbury nursery! Dear Mary!
'She will of course be one now,' said Beatrice to her sister. With her, at the present moment, 'one' of course
meant one of the bevy that was to attend her at the altar. 'Oh dear! how nice! I shan't know what to say to her
tomorrow. But I know one thing.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 336
Page No 340
'What is that?' asked Augusta.
'She will be as mild and meek as a little dove. If she and the doctor had lost every shilling in the world, she
would have been proud as an eagle.' It must be acknowledged that Beatrice had had the wit to read Mary's
character right.
But Augusta was not quite pleased with the whole affair. Not that she begrudged her brother his luck, or
Mary her happiness. But her ideas of right and wrongperhaps we should rather say Lady Amelia's
ideaswould not be fairly carried out.
'After all, Beatrice, this does not alter her birth. I know it is useless saying anything to Frank.'
'Why, you wouldn't break both their hearts now?'
'I don't want to break their hearts, certainly. But there are those who put their dearest and warmest feelings
under restraint rather than deviate from what they know to be proper.' Poor Augusta! she was the stern
professor of the order of this philosophy; the last in the family who practised with unflinching courage its
cruel behests; the last, always excepting the Lady Amelia.
And how slept Frank that night? With him, at least, let us hope, nay, let us say boldly, that his happiest
thoughts were not with the wealth which he was to acquire. But yet it would be something to restore Boxall
Hill to Greshamsbury; something to give back to his father those rumpled vellum documents, since the
departure of which the squire had never had a happy day; nay, something to come forth again to his friends as
a gay, young country squire, instead of a farmer, clodcompelling for his bread. We would not have him
thought to be better than he was, nor would we wish him to make him of other stuff than nature generally
uses. His heart did exult at Mary's wealth; but it leaped higher still when he thought of purer joys.
And what shall we say of Mary's dreams? With her, it was altogether what she should give, not at all what
she should get. Frank had loved her so truly when she was so poor, such an utter castaway; Frank, who with
his beauty, and spirit, and his talents might have won the smiles of the richest, the grandest, the noblest! What
lady's heart would not have rejoiced to be allowed to love her Frank? But he had been true to her through
everything. Ah! how often she thought of that hour, when suddenly appearing before her, he had strained her
to his breast, just as she had resolved how best to bear the deathlike chill of his supposed estrangements!
She was always thinking of that time. She fed her love by recurring over and over to the altered feeling of
that moment. Any now she could pay him for his goodness. Pay him! No, that would be a base word, a base
thought. Her payment must be made, if God would so grant it, in many, many years to come. But her store,
such as it was, should be emptied into his lap. It was soothing to her pride that she would not hurt him by her
love, that she would bring no injury to the old house. 'Dear, dear Frank' she murmured, as her waking dream,
conquered at last by sleep, gave way to those of the fairy world.
But she thought not only of Frank; dreamed not only of him. What had he not done for her, that uncle of hers,
who had been more loving to her than any father! How was he, too, to be paid? Paid, indeed! Love can only
be paid in its own coin: it knows of no other legal tender. Well, if her home was to be Greshamsbury, at any
rate she would not be separated from him.
What the doctor dreamed of that, neither he or anyone ever knew. 'Why, uncle, I think you've been asleep,'
said Mary to him that evening as he moved for a moment uneasily on the sofa. He had been asleep for the last
threequarters of an hour;but Frank, his guest, had felt no offence. 'No, I've not been exactly asleep,' said
he; 'but I'm very tired. I wouldn't do it all again, Frank, to double the money. You haven't got any more tea,
have you, Mary?'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 337
Page No 341
On the following morning, Beatrice was of course with her friend. There was no awkwardness between them
in meeting. Beatrice had loved her when she was poor, and though they had not lately thought alike on one
very important subject, Mary was too gracious to impute that to Beatrice as a crime.
'You will be one now, Mary; of course you will.'
'If Lady Arabella will let me come.'
'Oh, Mary; let you! Do you remember what you said once about coming, and being near me? I have so often
thought of it. And now, Mary, I must tell you about Caleb;' and the young lady settled herself on the sofa, so
as to have a comfortable long talk. Beatrice had been quite right. Mary was as meek with her, and as mild as a
dove.
And then Patience Oriel came. 'My fine, young darling, magnificent, overgrown heiress,' said Patience,
embracing her. 'My breath deserted me, and I was nearly stunned when I heard of it. How small we shall all
be, my dear! I am quite prepared to toady to you immensely; but pray be a little gracious to me, for the sake
of auld lang syne.'
Mary gave a long, long kiss. 'Yes, for auld lang syne, Patience; when you took me away under your wing to
Richmond.' Patience also had loved her when she was in trouble, and that love, too, should never be
forgotten.
But the great difficulty was Lady Arabella's first meeting with her. 'I think I'll go down to her after breakfast,'
said her ladyship to Beatrice, as the two were talking over the matter while the mother was finishing her
toilet.
'I am sure she will come up if you like it, mamma.'
'She is entitled to every courtesyas Frank's accepted bride, you know,' said Lady Arabella. 'I would not for
worlds fail in any respect to her for his sake.'
'He will be glad enough for her to come, I am sure,' said Beatrice. 'I was talking to Caleb this morning, and he
says'
The matter was of importance, and Lady Arabella gave it her most mature consideration. The manner of
receiving into one's family an heiress whose wealth is cure all one's difficulties, disperse all one's troubles,
give a balm to all the wounds of misfortune, must under any circumstances, be worthy of much care. But
when that heiress had been treated as Mary had been treated!
'I must see her, at any rate, before I go to Courcy.' said Lady Arabella.
'Are you going to Courcy, mamma?'
'Oh, certainly; yes, I must see my sisterinlaw now. You don't seem to realize the importance, my dear, of
Frank's marriage. He will be in a great hurry about it, and, indeed, I cannot blame him. I expect they will all
come here.'
'Who, mamma? The De Courcys?'
'Yes, of course. I shall be very much surprised if the earl does not come now. And I must consult my
sisterinlaw as to the asking of the Duke of Omnium.'
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 338
Page No 342
Poor Mary!
'And I think it will perhaps be better,' continued Lady Arabella, 'that we should have a larger party than
intended at your affair. The countess, I'm sure, would come now. We couldn't put it off for ten days; could
we, dear?'
'Put it off ten days!'
'Yes; it would be convenient.'
'I don't think Mr Oriel would like that at all, mamma. You know he has made all his arrangements for his
Sundays'
Pshaw! The idea of the parson's Sundays being allowed to have any bearing on such a matter as Frank's
wedding would now become! Why, they would havehow much? Between twelve and fourteen thousand a
year! Lady Arabella, who had made her calculations a dozen times during the night, had never found it to be
much less than the larger sum. Mr Oriel's Sundays indeed!
After much doubt, Lady Arabella acceded to her daughter's suggestion, that Mary should be received at
Greshamsbury instead of being called on at the doctor's house. 'If you think she won't mind the coming up
first,' said her ladyship. 'I certainly could receive her better here. I should be moremoremore able, you
know, to express what I feel. We had better go into the big drawingroom today, Beatrice. Will you
remember to tell Mrs Richards?'
'Oh, certainly,' was Mary's answer when Beatrice, with a voice a little trembling, proposed her to walk up to
the house. 'Certainly I will, if Lady Arabella will receive me;only, one thing, Trichy.'
'What's that, dearest?'
'Frank will think that I come after him.'
'Never mind what he thinks. To tell you the truth, Mary, I often call on Patience for the sake of finding Caleb.
That's all fair now, you know.'
Mary very quietly got put on her straw bonnet, and said she was ready to go up to the house. Beatrice was a
little fluttered, and showed it. Mary was, perhaps, a good deal fluttered, but she did not show it. She had
thought a good deal about her first interview with Lady Arabella, of her first return to the house; but she had
resolved to carry herself as though the matter were easy to her. She would not allow it to be seen that she felt
that she brought with her to Greshamsbury, comfort, ease, and renewed opulence.
So she put on her straw bonnet and walked up with Beatrice. Everybody about the place had already heard
the news. The old woman at the lodge curtsied low to her; the gardener, who was mowing the lawn. The
butler, who opened the front doorhe must have been watching Mary's approachhad manifestly put on a
clean white neckcloth for the occasion.
'God bless you once more, Miss Thorne!' said the old man, in a halfwhisper. Mary was somewhat troubled,
for everything seemed, in a manner, to bow down before her. And why should not everything bow down
before her, seeing that she was in truth the owner of Greshamsbury?
And then a servant in livery would open the big drawingroom door. This rather upset both Mary and
Beatrice. It became almost impossible for Mary to enter the room just as she would have done two years ago;
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 339
Page No 343
but she got through the difficulty with much selfcontrol.
'Mamma, here's Mary,' said Beatrice.
Nor was Lady Arabella quite mistress of herself, although she had studied minutely how to bear herself.
'Oh, Mary, dear Mary; what can I say to you?' and then, with a handkerchief to her eyes, she ran forward and
hid her face in Miss Thorne's shoulders. 'What can I saycan you forgive my anxiety for my son?'
'How do you do, Lady Arabella?' said Mary.
'My daughter! my child! my Frank's own bride! Oh, Mary! oh, my child! If I have seemed unkind to you, it
has been through love to him.'
'All these things are over now,' said Mary. 'Mr Gresham told me yesterday that I should be received as
Frank's future wife; and so, you see, I have come.' And then she slipped through Lady Arabella's arms, and
sat down, meekly down, on a chair. In five minutes she had escaped with Beatrice into the schoolroom, and
was kissing the children, and turning over the new trousseau. They were, however, soon interrupted, and
there was, perhaps, some other kissing besides that of the children.
'You have no business here at all, Frank,' said Beatrice. 'Has he, Mary?'
'None in the world, I should think.'
'See what he has done to my poplin; I hope you won't have your things treated so cruelly. He'll be careful
enough about them.'
'Is Oriel a good hand at packing up fineryeh, Beatrice,' said Frank.
'He is, at any rate, too wellbehaved to spoil it.' Thus Mary was again made at home on the household of
Greshamsbury.
Lady Arabella did not carry out her little plan of delaying the Oriel wedding. Her idea had been to add some
grandeur to it, in order to make it a more fitting precursor of that other greater wedding which was to follow
soon in its wake. But this, with the assistance of the countess, she found herself able to do without interfering
with poor Mr Oriel's Sunday arrangements. The countess herself, with the Ladies Alexandrina and
Margaretta, now promised to come, even to the first affair; and for the other, the whole De Courcy family
would turn out, count and countess, lords and ladies, Honourable Georges and Honourable Johns. What
honour, indeed, could be too great to show to a bride who had fourteen thousand a year in her own right, or to
a cousin, who had done his duty by securing such a bride to himself!
'If the duke be in the country, I am sure he will be happy to come,' said the countess. 'Of course, he will be
talking to Frank about politics. I suppose the squire won't expect Frank to belong to the old school now.'
'Frank, of course, will judge for himself, Rosina;with his position, you know!' And so things were settled
at Courcy Castle.
And then Beatrice was wedded and carried off to the Lakes. Mary, as she had promised, did stand near her;
but not exactly in the gingham frock of which she had once spoken. She wore on that occasionBut it will
be too much, perhaps, to tell the reader what she wore as Beatrice's bridesmaid, seeing that a couple of pages,
at least, must be devoted to her marriagedress, and seeing, also, that we have only a few pages to finish
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 340
Page No 344
everything; the list of visitors, the marriage settlements, the dress, and all included.
It was in vain that Mary endeavoured to repress Lady Arabella's ardour for grand doings. After all, she was to
be married from the doctor's house, and not from Greshamsbury, and it was the doctor who should have
invited the guests; but, in this matter, he did not choose to oppose her ladyship's spirit, and she had it all her
own way.
'What can I do?' said he to Mary. 'I have been contradicting her in everything for the last two years. The least
we can do is to let her have her own way now in a trifle like this.'
But there was one point on which Mary would let nobody have his or her own way; on which the way to be
taken was very manifestly to be her own. This was touching the marriage settlements. It must not be
supposed, that if Beatrice were married on a Tuesday, Mary could be married on the Tuesday week
following. Ladies with twelve thousand a year cannot be disposed of in that way: and bridegrooms who do
their duty by marrying money often have to be kept waiting. It was spring, the early spring, before Frank was
made altogether a happy man.
But a word about the settlements. On this subject the doctor thought he would have been driven mad. Messrs
Slow and Bideawhile, as the lawyers of the Greshamsbury familyit will be understood that Mr Gazebee's
law business was of quite a different nature, and his work, as regarded Greshamsbury, was now nearly
overMessrs Slow and Bideawhile declared that it would never do for them to undertake alone to draw out
the settlements. An heiress, such as Mary, must have lawyers of her own; half a dozen at least, according to
the apparent opinion of Messrs Slow and Bideawhile. And so the doctor had to go to other lawyers, and they
again had to consult Sir Abraham, and Mr Snilam on a dozen different heads.
If Frank became tenant in tail, in right of his wife, but under his father, would he be able to grant leases for
more than twentyone years? and, if so, to whom would the right of trover belong? As to flotsam and
jetsamthere was a little property, Mr Critic, on the seashorethat was a matter that had to be left
unsettled at the last. Such points as these do take a long time to consider. All this bewildered the doctor sadly,
and Frank himself began to make accusations that he was to be done out of his wife altogether.
But, as we have said, there was one point on which Mary would have her own way. The lawyers might tie up
as they would on her behalf all the money, and shares, and mortgages which had belonged to the late Sir
Roger, with this exception, all that had ever appertained to Greshamsbury should belong to Greshamsbury
again; not in perspective, not to her children, or to her children's children, but at once. Frank should be lord of
Boxall Hill in his own right; and as to those other liens on Greshamsbury, let Frank manage that with his
father as he might think fit. She would only trouble herself to see that he was empowered to do as he did
think fit.
'But,' argued the ancient, respectable family attorney to the doctor, 'that amounts to twothirds of the whole
estate. Twothirds, Dr Thorne! It is preposterous; I should almost say impossible.' And the scanty hairs on
the poor man's head almost stood on end as he thought of the outrageous manner in which the heiress
prepared to sacrifice herself.
'It will all be the same in the end,' said the doctor, trying to make things smooth. 'Of course, their joint object
will be to put the Greshamsbury property together again.'
'But, my dear sir,'and then, for twenty minutes, the lawyer went on proving that it would be no means be
the same thing; but, nevertheless, Mary Thorne did have her own way.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 341
Page No 345
In the course of the winter, Lady de Courcy tried very hard to induce the heiress to visit Courcy Castle, and
this request was so backed by Lady Arabella, that the doctor said he thought she might as well go there for
three or four days. But here, again, Mary was obstinate.
'I don't see it at all,' she said. 'If you make a point of it, or Frank, or Mr Gresham, I will go; but I can't see any
possible reason.' The doctor, when so appealed to, would not absolutely say that he made a point of it, and
Mary was tolerably safe as regarded Frank or the squire. If she went, Frank would be expected to go, and
Frank disliked Courcy Castle almost more than ever. His aunt was now more than civil to him, and, when
they were together, never ceased to compliment him on the desirable way in which he had done his duty by
the family.
And soon after Christmas a visitor came to Mary, and stayed a fortnight with her: one whom neither she nor
the doctor had expected, and of whom they had not much more than heard. This was the famous Miss
Dunstable. 'Birds of a feather flock together,' said Mrs Rantawaylate Miss Gushingwhen she heard of
the visit. 'The railway man's nieceif you can call her a nieceand the quack's daughter will do very well
together, no doubt.'
'At any rate, they can count their moneybags,' said Mrs Umbleby.
And in fact, Mary and Miss Dunstable did get on very well together; and Miss Dunstable made herself quite
happy at Greshamsbury, although some peopleincluding Mrs Rantawaycontrived to spread a report, that
Dr Thorne, jealous of Mary's money was going to marry her.
'I shall certainly come and see you turned off,' said Miss Dunstable, taking leave of her new friend. Miss
Dunstable, it must be acknowledged, was a little too fond of slang; but then, a lady with her fortune, and of
her age, may be fond of almost whatever she pleases.
And so by degrees the winter wore awayvery slowly to Frank, as he declared often enough; and slowly,
perhaps, to Mary also, but she did not say so. The spring came round. The comic almanacs give us dreadful
pictures of January and February; but, in truth, the months which should be made to look gloomy in England
are March and April. Let no man boast himself that he has got through the perils of winter till at least the
seventh of May.
It was early in April, however, that the great doings were to be done at Greshamsbury. Not exactly on the
first. It may be presumed, that in spite of the practical, commonsense spirit of the age, very few people do
choose to have themselves united on that day. But some day in the first week of that month was fixed for the
ceremony, and from the end of February all through March, Lady Arabella worked and strove in a manner
that entitled her to profound admiration.
It was at last settled that the breakfast should be held in the large diningroom at Greshamsbury. There was a
difficulty about it which taxed Lady Arabella to the utmost, for, in making the proposition, she could not but
seem to be throwing some slight on the house in which the heiress had lived. But when the affair was once
opened to Mary, it was astonishing how easy it became.
'Of course,' said Mary, 'all the rooms in our house would not hold half the people you are talking aboutif
they must come.'
Lady Arabella looked so beseechingly, nay, so piteously, that Mary had not another word to say. It was
evident that they must all come: the De Courcys to the fifth generation; the Duke of Omnium himself, and
others in concatenation accordingly.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 342
Page No 346
'But will your uncle be angry if we have the breakfast up there? He has been so very handsome to Frank, that
I wouldn't make him angry for all the world.'
'If you don't tell him anything about it, Lady Arabella, he'll think that it is all done properly. He will never
know, if he's not told, that he ought to give the breakfast, not you.'
'Won't he, my dear?' And Lady Arabella looked her admiration for this very talented suggestion. And so that
matter was arranged. The doctor never knew, till Mary told him some year or so afterwards, that he had been
remiss in any part of his duty.
And who was asked to the wedding? In the first place, we have said that the Duke of Omnium was there. This
was, in fact, the one circumstance that made this wedding so superior to any other that had ever taken place in
that neighbourhood. The Duke of Omnium never went anywhere; and yet he went to Mary's wedding! And
Mary, when the ceremony was over, absolutely found herself kissed by a duke. 'Dearest Mary!' exclaimed
Lady Arabella, in her ecstasy of joy, when she saw the honour that was done to her daughterinlaw.
'I hope we shall induce you to come to Gatherum Castle soon,' said the duke to Frank. 'I shall be having a few
friends there in the autumn. Let me see; I declare, I have not seen you since you were good enough to come
to my collection. Ha! ha! ha! It wasn't bad fun, was it?' Frank was not very cordial with his answer. He had
not quite reconciled himself to the difference of his position. When he was treated as one of the 'collection' at
Gatherum Castle, he had not married money.
It would be vain to enumerate all the De Courcys that were there. There was the earl, looking very gracious,
and talking to the squire about the county. And there was Lord Porlock, looking very ungracious, and not
talking to anybody about anything. And there was the countess, who for the last week had done nothing but
pat Frank on the back whenever she could catch him. And there were the Ladies Alexandrina, Margaretta,
and Selina, smiling at everybody. And the Honourable George, talking in whispers to Frank about his
widow'Not such a catch as yours, you know; but something extremely snug;and have it all my own way,
too, old fellow, or I shan't come to the scratch.' And the Honourable John prepared to toady Frank about his
string of hunters; and the Lady Amelia, by herself, not quite contented with these democratic nuptials'After
all, she is so absolutely nobody; absolutely, absolutely,' she said confidentially to Augusta, shaking her head.
But before Lady Amelia had left Greshamsbury, Augusta was quite at a loss to understand how there could be
need for so much conversation between her cousin and Mr Mortimer Gazebee.
And there were many more De Courcys, whom to enumerate would be much too long.
And the bishop of the diocese, and Mrs Proudie were there. A hint had even been given, that his lordship
would himself condescend to perform the ceremony, if this should be wished; but that work had already been
anticipated by a very old friend of the Greshams. Archdeacon Grantly, the rector of Plumstead Episcopi, had
long since undertaken this part of the business; and the knot was eventually tied by the joint efforts of himself
and Mr Oriel. Mrs Grantly came with him, and so did Mrs Grantly's sister, the new dean's wife. The dean
himself was at the time unfortunately absent at Oxford.
And all the Bakers and the Jacksons were there. The last time they had all met together under the squire's
roof, was on the occasion of Frank's coming of age. The present gala doings were carried on a very different
spirit. That had been a very poor affair, but this was worthy of the best of Greshamsbury.
Occasion also had been taken of this happy moment to make up, or rather to get rid of the last shreds of the
last feud that had so long separated Dr Thorne from his own relatives. The Thornes of Ullathorne had made
many overtures in a covert way. But our doctor had contrived to reject them. 'They would not receive Mary
as their cousin,' said he, 'and I will go nowhere that she cannot go.' But now all this was altered. Mrs Gresham
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 343
Page No 347
would certainly be received in any house in the county. And thus, Mr Thorne of Ullathorne, an amiable,
popular old bachelor, came to the wedding; and so did his maiden sister Miss Thorne, than whose no kinder
heart glowed all through Barsetshire.
'My dear,' said she to Mary, kissing her, and offering her some little tribute, 'I am very glad to make your
acquaintance; very. It was not her fault,' she added, speaking to herself. 'And now that she will be a Gresham,
that need not be any longer be thought of.' Nevertheless, could Miss Thorne have spoken her inward thoughts
out loud, she would have declared, that Frank would have done better to have borne his poverty than marry
wealth without blood. But then, there are but few so stanch as Miss Thorne; perhaps none in the
countyalways excepting the lady Amelia.
And Miss Dunstable, also, was a bridesmaid. 'Oh, no' said she, when asked; 'you should have them young and
pretty.' But she gave way when she found that Mary did not flatter her by telling her that she was either the
one or the other. 'The truth is,' said Miss Dunstable, 'I have always been a little in love with your Frank, and
so I shall do it for his sake.' There were but four: the other two were the Gresham twins. Lady Arabella
exerted herself greatly in framing hints to induce Mary to ask some of the De Courcy ladies to do her so
much honour; but on this head Mary would please herself. 'Rank,' she said to Beatrice, with a curl on her lip,
'has its drawbacksand must put up with them.'
And now I find that I have not one pagenot half a pagefor the weddingdress. But what matters? Will it
not be all found written in the columns of the Morning Post?
And thus Frank married money, and became a great man. Let us hope that he will be a happy man. As the
time of the story has been brought down so near to the present era, it is not practicable for the novelist to tell
much of his future career. When I last heard from Barsetshire, it seemed to be quite settled that he is to take
the place of one of the old members at the next election; and they say, also, that there is no chance of any
opposition. I have heard, too, that there have been many very private consultations between him and various
gentlemen of the county, with reference to the hunt; and the general feeling is said to be that the hounds
should go to Boxall Hill.
At Boxall Hill the young people established themselves on their return from the continent. And that reminds
me that one word must be said of Lady Scatcherd.
'You will always stay here with us,' said Mary to her, caressing her ladyship's rough hand, and looking kindly
into that kind face.
But Lady Scatcherd would not consent to this. 'I will come and see you sometimes, and then I shall enjoy
myself. Yes, I will come and see you, and my own dear boy.' The affair was ended by her taking Mrs Opie
Green's cottage, in order that she might be near the doctor; Mrs Opie Green having marriedsomebody.
And of whom else must we say a word? Patience, also, of course, got a husbandor will do so. Dear
Patience! it would be a thousand pities that so good a wife should be lost to the world. Whether Miss
Dunstable will ever be married, or Augusta Gresham, or Mr Moffat, or any of the tribe of the De
Courcysexcept Lady AmeliaI cannot say. They have all of them still their future before them. That
Bridget was married to Thomasthat I am able to assert; for I know that Janet was much put out by their
joint desertion.
Lady Arabella has not yet lost her admiration for Mary, and Mary, in return, behaves admirably. Another
event is expected, and her ladyship is almost as anxious about that as she was about the wedding. 'A matter,
you know, of much importance in the county!' she whispered to Lady De Courcy.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 344
Page No 348
Nothing can be more happy than the intercourse between the squire and his son. What their exact
arrangements are, we need not specially inquire; but the demon of pecuniary embarrassment has lifted his
black wings from the demesne of Greshamsbury.
And now we have but one word left for the doctor. 'If you don't come and dine with me,' said the squire to
him, when they found themselves both deserted, 'mind I shall come and dine with you.' And on this principle
they seem to act. Dr Thorne continues to extend his practice, to the great disgust of Dr Fillgrave; and when
Mary suggested to him that he should retire, he almost boxed her ears. He knows the way, however, to Boxall
Hill as well as he ever did, and is willing to acknowledge, that the tea there is almost as good as it ever was at
Greshamsbury.
Dr Thorne
CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING 345
Bookmarks
1. Table of Contents, page = 3
2. Dr Thorne, page = 5
3. Anthony Trollope, page = 5
4. CHAPTER I THE GRESHAMS OF GRESHAMSBURY, page = 6
5. CHAPTER II. LONG, LONG AGO, page = 14
6. CHAPTER III. DR THORNE, page = 20
7. CHAPTER IV. LESSONS FROM COURCY CASTLE, page = 27
8. CHAPTER V. FRANK GRESHAM'S FIRST SPEECH, page = 40
9. CHAPTER VI. FRANK GRESHAM'S EARLY LOVES, page = 46
10. CHAPTER VII. THE DOCTOR'S GARDEN, page = 53
11. CHAPTER VIII. MATRIMONIAL PROSPECTS, page = 60
12. CHAPTER IX. SIR ROGER SCATCHERD, page = 69
13. CHAPTER X. SIR ROGER'S WILL, page = 76
14. CHAPTER XI. THE DOCTOR DRINKS HIS TEA, page = 83
15. CHAPTER XII. WHEN GREEK MEETS GREEK, THEN COMES THE TUG OF WAR, page = 88
16. CHAPTER XIII. THE TWO UNCLES, page = 96
17. CHAPTER XIV. SENTENCE OF EXILE, page = 103
18. CHAPTER XV. COURCY, page = 113
19. CHAPTER XVI. MISS DUNSTABLE, page = 117
20. CHAPTER XVII. THE ELECTION, page = 124
21. CHAPTER XVIII. THE RIVALS, page = 133
22. CHAPTER XIX. THE DUKE OF OMNIUM, page = 142
23. CHAPTER XX. THE PROPOSAL, page = 148
24. CHAPTER XXI. MR MOFFAT FALLS INTO TROUBLE, page = 154
25. CHAPTER XXII. SIR ROGER IS UNSEATED, page = 161
26. CHAPTER XXIII. RETROSPECTIVE, page = 166
27. CHAPTER XXIV. LOUIS SCATCHERD, page = 172
28. CHAPTER XXV. SIR ROGER DIES, page = 179
29. CHAPTER XXVI. WAR, page = 190
30. CHAPTER XXVII. MISS THORNE GOES ON A VISIT, page = 196
31. CHAPTER XXVIII. THE DOCTOR HEARS SOMETHING TO HIS ADVANTAGE, page = 205
32. CHAPTER XXIX. THE DONKEY RIDE, page = 212
33. CHAPTER XXX. POST PRANDIAL, page = 221
34. CHAPTER XXXI. THE SMALL EDGE OF THE WEDGE, page = 225
35. CHAPTER XXXII. MR ORIEL, page = 231
36. CHAPTER XXXIII. A MORNING VISIT, page = 237
37. CHAPTER XXXIV. A BAROUCHE AND FOUR ARRIVES AT GRESHAMSBURY, page = 245
38. CHAPTER XXXV. SIR LOUIS GOES OUT TO DINNER, page = 256
39. CHAPTER XXXVI. WILL HE COME AGAIN?, page = 262
40. CHAPTER XXXVII. SIR LOUIS LEAVES GRESHAMSBURY, page = 267
41. CHAPTER XXXVIII. DE COURCY PRECEPTS AND DE COURCY PRACTICE, page = 274
42. CHAPTER XXXIX. WHAT THE WORLD SAYS ABOUT BLOOD, page = 282
43. CHAPTER XL. THE TWO DOCTORS CHANGE PATIENTS, page = 288
44. CHAPTER XLI. DOCTOR THORNE WON'T INTERFERE, page = 294
45. CHAPTER XLII. WHAT CAN YOU GIVE IN RETURN?, page = 301
46. CHAPTER XLIII. THE RACE OF SCATCHERD BECOMES EXTINCT, page = 310
47. CHAPTER XLIV. SATURDAY EVENING AND SUNDAY MORNING, page = 316
48. CHAPTER XLV. LAW BUSINESS IN LONDON, page = 324
49. CHAPTER XLVI. OUR PET FOX FINDS A TAIL, page = 331
50. CHAPTER XLVII. HOW THE BRIDE WAS RECEIVED, AND WHO WERE ASKED TO THE WEDDING, page = 339