Trent's Last Case................................................................................................................................................1

E. C. Bentley ............................................................................................................................................1

Between what matters and what seems to matter, how should the world we know judge wisely?

When the scheming, indomitable brain of Sigsbee Manderson was scattered by a shot from an unknown hand,

that world lost nothing worth a single tear; it gained something memorable in a harsh reminder of the vanity

of such wealth as this dead man had piled upwithout making one loyal friend to mourn him, without doing

an act that could help his memory to the least honour. But when the news of his end came, it seemed to those

living in the great vortices of business as if the earth too shuddered under a blow.

In all the lurid commercial history of his country there had been no figure that had so imposed itself upon the

mind of the trading world. He had a niche apart in its temples. Financial giants, strong to direct and augment

the forces of capital, and taking an approved toll in millions for their labour, had existed before; but in the

case of Manderson there had been this singularity, that a pale halo of piratical romance, a thing especially

dear to the hearts of his countrymen, had remained incongruously about his head through the years when he

stood in every eye as the unquestioned guardian of stability, the stamperout of manipulated crises, the foe of

The fortune left by his grandfather, who had been one of those chieftains on the smaller scale of his day, had

descended to him with accretion through his father, who during a long life had quietly continued to lend

money and never had margined a stock. Manderson, who had at no time known what it was to be without

large sums to his hand, should have been altogether of that newer American plutocracy which is steadied by

the tradition and habit of great wealth. But it was not so. While his nurture and education had taught him

European ideas of a rich man's proper external circumstance; while they had rooted in him an instinct for

quiet magnificence, the larger costliness which does not shriek of itself with a thousand tongues; there had

been handed on to him nevertheless much of the FortyNiner and financial buccaneer, his forbear. During

that first period of his business career which had been called his early bad manner, he had been little more

than a gambler of genius, his hand against every man'san infant prodigy who brought to the enthralling

pursuit of speculation a brain better endowed than any opposed to it. At St Helena it was laid down that war

is une belle occupation; and so the young Manderson had found the multitudinous and complicated dogfight

Then came his change. At his father's death, when Manderson was thirty years old, some new revelation of

the power and the glory of the god he served seemed to have come upon him. With the sudden, elastic

adaptability of his nation he turned to steady labour in his father's banking business, closing his ears to the

sound of the battles of the Street. In a few years he came to control all the activity of the great firm whose

unimpeached conservatism, safety, and financial weight lifted it like a cliff above the angry sea of the

markets. All mistrust founded on the performances of his youth had vanished. He was quite plainly a different

man. How the change came about none could with authority say, but there was a story of certain last words

He began to tower above the financial situation. Soon his name was current in the bourses of the world. One

who spoke the name of Manderson called up a vision of all that was broadbased and firm in the vast wealth

of the United States. He planned great combinations of capital, drew together and centralized industries of

continental scope, financed with unerring judgement the large designs of state or of private enterprise. Many

a time when he 'took hold' to smash a strike, or to federate the ownership of some great field of labour, he

sent ruin upon a multitude of tiny homes; and if miners or steelworkers or cattlemen defied him and invoked

disorder, he could be more lawless and ruthless than they. But this was done in the pursuit of legitimate

business ends. Tens of thousands of the poor might curse his name, but the financier and the speculator

execrated him no more. He stretched a hand to protect or to manipulate the power of wealth in every corner

of the country. Forcible, cold, and unerring, in all he did he ministered to the national lust for magnitude; and

But there was an aspect of Manderson in this later period that lay long unknown and unsuspected save by a

few, his secretaries and lieutenants and certain of the associates of his bygone hurling time. This little circle

knew that Manderson, the pillar of sound business and stability in the markets, had his hours of nostalgia for

the lively times when the Street had trembled at his name. It was, said one of them, as if Blackbeard had

settled down as a decent merchant in Bristol on the spoils of the Main. Now and then the pirate would glare

suddenly out, the knife in his teeth and the sulphur matches sputtering in his hatband. During such spasms of

reversion to type a score of tempestuous raids upon the market had been planned on paper in the inner room

of the offices of Manderson, Colefax and Company. But they were never carried out. Blackbeard would quell

the mutiny of his old self within him and go soberly down to his countinghousehumming a stave or two

of 'Spanish Ladies', perhaps, under his breath. Manderson would allow himself the harmless satisfaction, as

soon as the time for action had gone by, of pointing out to some Rupert of the markets a coup worth a million

to the depredator might have been made. 'Seems to me,' he would say almost wistfully, 'the Street is getting to

be a mighty dull place since I quit.' By slow degrees this amiable weakness of the Colossus became known to

At the news of his death panic went through the markets like a hurricane; for it came at a luckless time. Prices

tottered and crashed like towers in an earthquake. For two days Wall Street was a clamorous inferno of pale

despair. All over the United States, wherever speculation had its devotees, went a waft of ruin, a plague of

suicide. In Europe also not a few took with their own hands lives that had become pitiably linked to the

destiny of a financier whom most of them had never seen. In Paris a wellknown banker walked quietly out

of the Bourse and fell dead upon the broad steps among the raving crowd of Jews, a phial crushed in his hand.

In Frankfort one leapt from the Cathedral top, leaving a redder stain where he struck the red tower. Men

stabbed and shot and strangled themselves, drank death or breathed it as the air, because in a lonely corner of

England the life had departed from one cold heart vowed to the service of greed.

The blow could not have fallen at a more disastrous moment. It came when Wall Street was in a condition of

suppressed 'scare'suppressed, because for a week past the great interests known to act with or to be actually

controlled by the Colossus had been desperately combating the effects of the sudden arrest of Lucas Hahn,

and the exposure of his plundering of the Hahn banks. This bombshell, in its turn, had fallen at a time when

the market had been 'boosted' beyond its real strength. In the language of the place, a slump was due. Reports

from the cornlands had not been good, and there had been two or three railway statements which had been

expected to be much better than they were. But at whatever point in the vast area of speculation the shudder

of the threatened break had been felt, 'the Manderson crowd' had stepped in and held the market up. All

through the week the speculator's mind, as shallow as it is quick witted, as sentimental as greedy, had seen

in this the hand of the giant stretched out in protection from afar. Manderson, said the newspapers in chorus,

was in hourly communication with his lieutenants in the Street. One journal was able to give in round figures

the sum spent on cabling between New York and Marlstone in the past twentyfour hours; it told how a small

staff of expert operators had been sent down by the Post Office authorities to Marlstone to deal with the flood

of messages. Another revealed that Manderson, on the first news of the Hahn crash, had arranged to abandon

his holiday and return home by the Lusitania; but that he soon had the situation so well in hand that he had

All this was falsehood, more or less consciously elaborated by the 'finance editors', consciously initiated and

encouraged by the shrewd business men of the Manderson group, who knew that nothing could better help

their plans than this illusion of heroworshipknew also that no word had come from Manderson in answer

to their messages, and that Howard B. Jeffrey, of Steel and Iron fame, was the true organizer of victory. So

they fought down apprehension through four feverish days, and minds grew calmer. On Saturday, though the

ground beneath the feet of Mr. Jeffrey yet rumbled now and then with Etnamutterings of disquiet, he

deemed his task almost done. The market was firm, and slowly advancing. Wall Street turned to its sleep of

In the first trading hour of Monday a hideous rumour flew round the sixty acres of the financial district. It

came into being as the lightning comesa blink that seems to begin nowhere; though it is to be suspected

that it was first whispered over the telephonetogether with an urgent selling order by some employee in the

cable service. A sharp spasm convulsed the convalescent share list. In five minutes the dull noise of the

kerbstone market in Broad Street had leapt to a high note of frantic interrogation. From within the hive of the

Exchange itself could be heard a droning hubbub of fear, and men rushed hatless in and out. Was it true?

asked every man; and every man replied, with trembling lips, that it was a lie put out by some unscrupulous

'short' interest seeking to cover itself. In another quarter of an hour news came of a sudden and ruinous

collapse of 'Yankees' in London at the close of the Stock Exchange day. It was enough. New York had still

four hours' trading in front of her. The strategy of pointing to Manderson as the saviour and warden of the

markets had recoiled upon its authors with annihilating force, and Jeffrey, his ear at his private telephone,

listened to the tale of disaster with a set jaw. The new Napoleon had lost his Marengo. He saw the whole

financial landscape sliding and falling into chaos before him. In half an hour the news of the finding of

Manderson's body, with the inevitable rumour that it was suicide, was printing in a dozen newspaper offices;

but before a copy reached Wall Street the tornado of the panic was in full fury, and Howard B. Jeffrey and his

Nothing in the texture of the general life had changed. The corn had not ceased to ripen in the sun. The rivers

bore their barges and gave power to a myriad engines. The flocks fattened on the pastures, the herds were

unnumbered. Men laboured everywhere in the various servitudes to which they were born, and chafed not

more than usual in their bonds. Bellona tossed and murmured as ever, yet still slept her uneasy sleep. To all

mankind save a million or two of half crazed gamblers, blind to all reality, the death of Manderson meant

nothing; the life and work of the world went on. Weeks before he died strong hands had been in control of

every wire in the huge network of commerce and industry that he had supervised. Before his corpse was

buried his countrymen had made a strange discoverythat the existence of the potent engine of monopoly

that went by the name of Sigsbee Manderson had not been a condition of even material prosperity. The panic

blew itself out in two days, the pieces were picked up, the bankrupts withdrew out of sight; the market

While the brief delirium was yet subsiding there broke out a domestic scandal in England that suddenly fixed

the attention of two continents. Next morning the Chicago Limited was wrecked, and the same day a notable

politician was shot down in cold blood by his wife's brother in the streets of New Orleans. Within a week of

its rising, 'the Manderson story', to the trained sense of editors throughout the Union, was 'cold'. The tide of

American visitors pouring through Europe made eddies round the memorial or statue of many a man who had

died in poverty; and never thought of their most famous plutocrat. Like the poet who died in Rome, so young

and poor, a hundred years ago, he was buried far away from his own land; but for all the men and women of

Manderson's people who flock round the tomb of Keats in the cemetery under the Monte Testaccio, there is

not one, nor ever Will be, to stand in reverence by the rich man's grave beside the little church of Marlstone.

In the only comfortably furnished room in the offices of the Record, the telephone on Sir James Molloy's

table buzzed. Sir James made a motion with his pen, and Mr. Silver, his secretary, left his work and came

'Who is that?' he said. 'Who?... I can't hear you .... Oh, it's Mr. Bunner, is it?... Yes, but... I know, but he's

fearfully busy this afternoon. Can't you... Oh, really? Well, in that casejust hold on, will you?'

He placed the receiver before Sir James. 'It's Calvin Bunner, Sigsbee Manderson's righthand man,' he said

concisely. 'He insists on speaking to you personally. Says it is the gravest piece of news. He is talking from

Sir James looked at the telephone, not affectionately, and took up the receiver. 'Well?' he said in his strong

voice, and listened. 'Yes,' he said. The next moment Mr. Silver, eagerly watching him, saw a look of

amazement and horror. 'Good God!' murmured Sir James. Clutching the instrument, he slowly rose to his

feet, still bending ear intently. At intervals he repeated 'Yes.' Presently, as he listened, he glanced at the clock,

and spoke quickly to Mr. Silver over the top of the transmitter. 'Go and hunt up Figgis and young Williams.

The great journalist was a tall, strong, clever Irishman of fifty, swart and blackmoustached, a man of

untiring business energy, well known in the world, which he understood very thoroughly, and played upon

with the halfcynical competence of his race. Yet was he without a touch of the charlatan: he made no

mysteries, and no pretences of knowledge, and he saw instantly through these in others. In his handsome,

wellbred, welldressed appearance there was something a little sinister when anger or intense occupation

put its imprint about his eyes and brow; but when his generous nature was under no restraint he was the most

cordial of men. He was managing director of the company which owned that most powerful morning paper,

the Record, and also that most indispensable evening paper, the Sun, which had its offices on the other side of

the street. He was, moreover, editorinchief of the Record, to which he had in the course of years attached

the most variously capable personnel in the country. It was a maxim of his that where you could not get gifts,

you must do the best you could with solid merit; and he employed a great deal of both. He was respected by

his staff as few are respected in a profession not favourable to the growth of the sentiment of reverence.

'You're sure that's all?' asked Sir James, after a few minutes of earnest listening and questioning. 'And how

long has this been known?... Yes, of course, the police are; but the servants? Surely it's all over the place

down there by now .... Well, we'll have a try .... Look here, Bunner, I'm infinitely obliged to you about this. I

owe you a good turn. You know I mean what I say. Come and see me the first day you get to town .... All

Sir James hung up the receiver, and seized a railway timetable from the rack before him. After a rapid

consultation of this oracle, he flung it down with a forcible word as Mr. Silver hurried into the room,

'I want you to jot down some facts, Figgis,' said Sir James, banishing all signs of agitation and speaking with

a rapid calmness. 'When you have them, put them into shape just as quick as you can for a special edition of

the Sun.' The hard featured man nodded and glanced at the clock, which pointed to a few minutes past three;

he pulled out a notebook and drew a chair up to the big writing table. 'Silver,' Sir James went on, 'go and tell

Jones to wire our local correspondent very urgently, to drop everything and get down to Marlstone at once.

He is not to say why in the telegram. There must not be an unnecessary word about this news until the Sun is

on the streets with ityou all understand. Williams, cut across the way and tell Mr. Anthony to hold himself

ready for a twocolumn opening that will knock the town endways. Just tell him that he must take all

measures and precautions for a scoop. Say that Figgis will be over in five minutes with the facts, and that he

had better let him write up the story in his private room. As you go, ask Miss Morgan to see me here at once,

and tell the telephone people to see if they can get Mr. Trent on the wire for me. After seeing Mr. Anthony,

Sir James turned instantly to Mr. Figgis, whose pencil was poised over the paper. 'Sigsbee Manderson has

been murdered,' he began quickly and clearly, pacing the floor with his hands behind him. Mr. Figgis

scratched down a line of shorthand with as much emotion as if he had been told that the day was finethe

pose of his craft. 'He and his wife and two secretaries have been for the past fortnight at the house called

White Gables, at Marlstone, near Bishopsbridge. He bought it four years ago. He and Mrs. Manderson have

since spent a part of each summer there. Last night he went to bed about halfpast eleven, just as usual. No

one knows when he got up and left the house. He was not missed until this morning. About ten o'clock his

body was found by a gardener. It was lying by a shed in the grounds. He was shot in the head, through the left

eye. Death must have been instantaneous. The body was not robbed, but there were marks on the wrists

which pointed to a straggle having taken place. Dr Stock, of Marlstone, was at once sent for, and will conduct

the postmortem examination. The police from Bishopsbridge, who were soon on the spot, are reticent, but it

is believed that they are quite without a clue to the identity of the murderer. There you are, Figgis. Mr.

Mr. Figgis looked up. 'One of the ablest detectives at Scotland Yard,' he suggested, 'has been put in charge of

'Prostrated by the shock,' hinted the reporter, 'and sees nobody. Human interest.'

'I wouldn't put that in, Mr. Figgis,' said a quiet voice. It belonged to Miss Morgan, a pale, graceful woman,

who had silently made her appearance while the dictation was going on. 'I have seen Mrs. Manderson,' she

proceeded, turning to Sir James. 'She looks quite healthy and intelligent. Has her husband been murdered? I

don't think the shock would prostrate her. She is more likely to be doing all she can to help the police.'

'Something in your own style, then, Miss Morgan,' he said with a momentary smile. Her imperturbable

efficiency was an office proverb. 'Cut it out, Figgis. Off you go! Now, madam, I expect you know what I

'Our Manderson biography happens to be well up to date,' replied Miss Morgan, drooping her dark eyelashes

as she considered the position. 'I was looking over it only a few months ago. It is practically ready for

tomorrow's paper. I should think the Sun had better use the sketch of his life they had about two years ago,

when he went to Berlin and settled the potash difficulty. I remember it was a very good sketch, and they

won't be able to carry much more than that. As for our paper, of course we have a great quantity of cuttings,

mostly rubbish. The subeditors shall have them as soon as they come in. Then we have two very good

portraits that are our own property; the best is a drawing Mr. Trent made when they were both on the same

ship somewhere. It is better than any of the photographs; but you say the public prefers a bad photograph to a

good drawing. I will send them down to you at once, and you can choose. As far as I can see, the Record is

well ahead of the situation, except that you will not be able to get a special man down there in time to be of

Sir James sighed deeply. 'What are we good for, anyhow?' he enquired dejectedly of Mr. Silver, who had

Miss Morgan adjusted her cuffs with an air of patience. 'Is there anything else?' she asked, as the telephone

'Yes, one thing,' replied Sir James, as he took up the receiver. 'I want you to make a bad mistake some time,

Miss Morganan everlasting bloomerjust to put us in countenance.' She permitted herself the fraction of

'Anthony?' asked Sir James, and was at once deep in consultation with the editor on the other side of the road.

He seldom entered the Sun building in person; the atmosphere of an evening paper, he would say, was all

very well if you liked that kind of thing. Mr. Anthony, the Murat of Fleet Street, who delighted in riding the

whirlwind and fighting a tumultuous battle against time, would say the same of a morning paper.

It was some five minutes later that a uniformed boy came in to say that Mr. Trent was on the wire. Sir James

'I know it is,' the voice said. 'This is Trent. He is in the middle of painting a picture, and he has been

interrupted at a critical moment. Well, I hope it's something important, that's all!'

'Trent,' said Sir James impressively, 'it is important. I want you to do some work for us.'

'Some play, you mean,' replied the voice. 'Believe me, I don't want a holiday. The working fit is very strong. I

am doing some really decent things. Why can't you leave a man alone?' 'Something very serious has

'Sigsbee Manderson has been murderedshot through the brainand they don't know who has done it.

They found the body this morning. It happened at his place near Bishopsbridge.' Sir James proceeded to tell

his hearer, briefly and clearly, the facts that he had communicated to Mr. Figgis. 'What do you think of it?' he

ended. A considering grunt was the only answer. 'Come now,' urged Sir James. 'Tempter!'

'Look here, Molloy,' the voice broke out querulously, 'the thing may be a case for me, or it may not. We can't

possibly tell. It may be a mystery; it may be as simple as bread and cheese. The body not being robbed looks

interesting, but he may have been outed by some wretched tramp whom he found sleeping in the grounds and

tried to kick out. It's the sort of thing he would do. Such a murderer might easily have sense enough to know

that to leave the money and valuables was the safest thing. I tell you frankly, I wouldn't have a hand in

hanging a poor devil who had let daylight into a man like Sig Manderson as a measure of social protest.'

Sir James smiled at the telephonea smile of success. 'Come, my boy, you're getting feeble. Admit you want

to go and have a look at the case. You know you do. If it's anything you don't want to handle, you're free to

'I am blown along a wandering wind,' replied the voice irresolutely, 'and hollow, hollow, hollow all delight.'

'Good man! Well, there's time enoughthat's just the worst of it. I've got to depend on our local

correspondent for tonight. The only good train of the day went half an hour ago. The next is a slow one,

leaving Paddington at midnight. You could have the Buster, if you like'Sir James referred to a very fast

'And I'd miss my sleep. No, thanks. The train for me. I am quite fond of railway travelling, you know; I have

'It doesn't matter,' said the voice sadly. 'I say,' it continued, 'will your people look out a hotel near the scene of

He replaced the receiver. As he turned to his papers again a shrill outcry burst forth in the street below. He

walked to the open window. A band of excited boys was rushing down the steps of the Sun building and up

the narrow thoroughfare toward Fleet Street. Each carried a bundle of newspapers and a large broadsheet with

Sir James smiled and rattled the money in his pockets cheerfully. 'It makes a good bill,' he observed to Mr.

At about eight o'clock in the morning of the following day Mr. Nathaniel Burton Cupples stood on the

veranda of the hotel at Marlstone. He was thinking about breakfast. In his case the colloquialism must be

taken literally: he really was thinking about breakfast, as he thought about every conscious act of his life

when time allowed deliberation. He reflected that on the preceding day the excitement and activity following

upon the discovery of the dead man had disorganized his appetite, and led to his taking considerably less

nourishment than usual. This morning he was very hungry, having already been up and about for an hour; and

he decided to allow himself a third piece of toast and an additional egg; the rest as usual. The remaining

So much being determined, Mr. Cupples applied himself to the enjoyment of the view for a few minutes

before ordering his meal. With a connoisseur's eye he explored the beauty of the rugged coast, where a great

pierced rock rose from a glassy sea, and the ordered loveliness of the vast tilted levels of pasture and tillage

and woodland that sloped gently up from the cliffs toward the distant moor. Mr. Cupples delighted in

He was a man of middle height and spare figure, nearly sixty years old, by constitution rather delicate in

health, but wiry and active for his age. A sparse and straggling beard and moustache did not conceal a thin

but kindly mouth; his eyes were keen and pleasant; his sharp nose and narrow jaw gave him very much of a

clerical air, and this impression was helped by his commonplace dark clothes and soft black hat. The whole

effect of him, indeed, was priestly. He was a man of unusually conscientious, industrious, and orderly mind,

with little imagination. His father's household had been used to recruit its domestic establishment by means

of advertisements in which it was truthfully described as a serious family. From that fortress of gloom he had

escaped with two saintly gifts somehow unspoiled: an inexhaustible kindness of heart, and a capacity for

innocent gaiety which owed nothing to humour. In an earlier day and with a clerical training he might have

risen to the scarlet hat. He was, in fact, a highly regarded member of the London Positivist Society, a retired

banker, a widower without children. His austere but not unhappy life was spent largely among books and in

museums; his profound and patiently accumulated knowledge of a number of curiously disconnected subjects

which had stirred his interest at different times had given him a place in the quiet, halflit world of professors

and curators and devotees of research; at their amiable, unconvivial dinner parties he was most himself. His

Just as Mr. Cupples was finishing his meal at a little table on the veranda, a big motor car turned into the

drive before the hotel. 'Who is this?' he enquired of the waiter. 'Id is der manager,' said the young man

The car drew up and the porter hurried from the entrance. Mr. Cupples uttered an exclamation of pleasure as

a long, loosely built man, much younger than himself, stepped from the car and mounted the veranda,

flinging his hat on a chair. His highboned, quixotic face wore a pleasant smile; his rough tweed clothes, his

'Cupples, by all that's miraculous!' cried the man, pouncing upon Mr. Cupples before he could rise, and

seizing his outstretched hand in a hard grip. 'My luck is serving me today,' the newcomer went on

spasmodically. 'This is the second slice within an hour. How are you, my best of friends? And why are you

here? Why sit'st thou by that ruined breakfast? Dost thou its former pride recall, or ponder how it passed

'I was half expecting you, Trent,' Mr. Cupples replied, his face wreathed in smiles. 'You are looking splendid,

my dear fellow. I will tell you all about it. But you cannot have had your own breakfast yet. Will you have it

'Rather!' said the man. 'An enormous great breakfast, toowith refined conversation and tears of recognition

never dry. Will you get young Siegfried to lay a place for me while I go and wash? I shan't be three minutes.'

He disappeared into the hotel, and Mr. Cupples, after a moment's thought, went to the telephone in the

He returned to find his friend already seated, pouring out tea, and showing an unaffected interest in the choice

of food. 'I expect this to be a hard day for me,' he said, with the curious jerky utterance which seemed to be

his habit. 'I shan't eat again till the evening, very likely. You guess why I'm here, don't you?'

'Undoubtedly,' said Mr. Cupples. 'You have come down to write about the murder.'

'That is rather a colourless way of stating it,' the man called Trent replied, as he dissected a sole. 'I should

prefer to put it that I have come down in the character of avenger of blood, to hunt down the guilty, and

vindicate the honour of society. That is my line of business. Families waited on at their private residences. I

say, Cupples, I have made a good beginning already. Wait a bit, and I'll tell you.' There was a silence, during

which the newcomer ate swiftly and abstractedly, while Mr. Cupples looked on happily.

'Your manager here,' said the tall man at last, 'is a fellow of remarkable judgement. He is an admirer of mine.

He knows more about my best cases than I do myself. The Record wired last night to say I was coming, and

when I got out of the train at seven o'clock this morning, there he was waiting for me with a motor car the

size of a haystack. He is beside himself with joy at having me here. It is fame.' He drank a cup of tea and

continued: 'Almost his first words were to ask me if I would like to see the body of the murdered man if so,

he thought he could manage it for me. He is as keen as a razor. The body lies in Dr Stock's surgery, you

know, down in the village, exactly as it was when found. It's to be postmortem'd this morning, by the way,

so I was only just in time. Well, he ran me down here to the doctor's, giving me full particulars about the case

all the way. I was pretty well au fait by the time we arrived. I suppose the manager of a place like this has

some sort of a pull with the doctor. Anyhow, he made no difficulties, nor did the constable on duty, though he

'I saw the body before it was removed,' remarked Mr. Cupples. 'I should not have said there was anything

remarkable about it, except that the shot in the eye had scarcely disfigured the face at all, and caused scarcely

any effusion of blood, apparently. The wrists were scratched and bruised. I expect that, with your trained

'Other details, certainly; but I don't know that they suggest anything. They are merely odd. Take the wrists,

for instance. How was it you could see bruises and scratches on them? I dare say you saw something of

Mr. Cupples reflected. 'No. Now you raise the point, I am reminded that when I interviewed Manderson here

'He always did,' said Trent. 'My friend the manager says so. I pointed out to him the fact you didn't observe,

that there were no cuffs visible, and that they had, indeed, been dragged up inside the coatsleeves, as yours

would be if you hurried into a coat without pulling your cuffs down. That was why you saw his wrists.'

'Well, I call that suggestive,' observed Mr. Cupples mildly. 'You might infer, perhaps, that when he got up he

'Yes, but did he? The manager said just what you say. "He was always a bit of a swell in his dress," he told

me, and he drew the inference that when Manderson got up in that mysterious way, before the house was

stirring, and went out into the grounds, he was in a great hurry. "Look at his shoes," he said to me: "Mr.

Manderson was always specially neat about his footwear. But those shoelaces were tied in a hurry." I

agreed. "And he left his false teeth in his room," said the manager. "Doesn't that prove he was flustered and

hurried?" I allowed that it looked like it. But I said, "Look here: if he was so very much pressed, why did he

part his hair so carefully? That parting is a work of art. Why did he put on so much? for he had on a complete

outfit of underclothing, studs in his shirt, socksuspenders, a watch and chain, money and keys and things in

his pockets." That's what I said to the manager. He couldn't find an explanation. Can you?"

Mr. Cupples considered. 'Those facts might suggest that he was hurried only at the end of his dressing. Coat

'But not false teeth. You ask anybody who wears them. And besides, I'm told he hadn't washed at all on

getting up, which in a neat man looks like his being in a violent hurry from the beginning. And here's another

thing. One of his waistcoat pockets was lined with washleather for the reception of his gold watch. But he

had put his watch into the pocket on the other side. Anybody who has settled habits can see how odd that is.

The fact is, there are signs of great agitation and haste, and there are signs of exactly the opposite. For the

present I am not guessing. I must reconnoitre the ground first, if I can manage to get the right side of the

Mr. Cupples smiled at him benevolently. 'That is precisely the point,' he said, 'on which I can be of some

assistance to you.' Trent glanced up in surprise. 'I told you I half expected you. I will explain the situation.

'What!' Trent laid down his knife and fork with a clash. 'Cupples, you are jesting with me.'

'I am perfectly serious, Trent, really,' returned Mr. Cupples earnestly. 'Her father, John Peter Domecq, was

my wife's brother. I never mentioned my niece or her marriage to you before, I suppose. To tell the truth, it

has always been a painful subject to me, and I have avoided discussing it with anybody. To return to what I

was about to say: last night, when I was over at the houseby the way, you can see it from here. You passed

it in the car.' He indicated a red roof among poplars some three hundred yards away, the only building in

'Certainly I did,' said Trent. 'The manager told me all about it, among other things, as he drove me in from

'Other people here have heard of you and your performances,' Mr. Cupples went on. 'As I was saying, when I

was over there last night, Mr. Bunner, who is one of Manderson's two secretaries, expressed a hope that the

Record would send you down to deal with the case, as the police seemed quite at a loss. He mentioned one or

two of your past successes, and Mabelmy niecewas interested when I told her afterwards. She is bearing

up wonderfully well, Trent; she has remarkable fortitude of character. She said she remembered reading your

articles about the Abinger case. She has a great horror of the newspaper side of this sad business, and she had

entreated me to do anything I could to keep journalists away from the placeI'm sure you can understand

her feeling, Trent; it isn't really any reflection on that profession. But she said you appeared to have great

powers as a detective, and she would not stand in the way of anything that might clear up the crime. Then I

told her you were a personal friend of mine, and gave you a good character for tact and consideration of

others' feelings; and it ended in her saying that, if you should come, she would like you to be helped in every

Trent leaned across the table and shook Mr. Cupples by the hand in silence. Mr. Cupples, much delighted

'I spoke to my niece on the telephone only just now, and she is glad you are here. She asks me to say that you

may make any enquiries you like, and she puts the house and grounds at your disposal. She had rather not see

you herself; she is keeping to her own sittingroom. She has already been interviewed by a detective officer

who is there, and she feels unequal to any more. She adds that she does not believe she could say anything

that would be of the smallest use. The two secretaries and Martin, the butler (who is a most intelligent man),

Trent finished his breakfast with a thoughtful brow. He filled a pipe slowly, and seated himself on the rail of

the veranda. 'Cupples,' he said quietly, 'is there anything about this business that you know and would rather

Mr. Cupples gave a slight start, and turned an astonished gaze on the questioner. 'What do you mean?' he

'I mean about the Mandersons. Look here! Shall I tell you a thing that strikes me about this affair at the very

beginning? Here's a man suddenly and violently killed, and nobody's heart seems to be broken about it, to say

the least. The manager of this hotel spoke to me about him as coolly as if he'd never set eyes on him, though I

understand they've been neighbours every summer for some years. Then you talk about the thing in the

coldest of blood. And Mrs. Mandersonwell, you won't mind my saying that I have heard of women being

more cut up about their husbands being murdered than she seems to be. Is there something in this, Cupples,

or is it my fancy? Was there something queer about Manderson? I travelled on the same boat with him once,

but never spoke to him. I only know his public character, which was repulsive enough. You see, this may

Mr. Cupples took time for thought. He fingered his sparse beard and looked out over the sea. At last he turned

to Trent. 'I see no reason,' he said, 'why I shouldn't tell you as between ourselves, my dear fellow. I need not

say that this must not be referred to, however distantly. The truth is that nobody really liked Manderson; and I

'Most people found a difficulty in explaining why. In trying to account to myself for my own sensations, I

could only put it that one felt in the man a complete absence of the sympathetic faculty. There was nothing

outwardly repellent about him. He was not illmannered, or vicious, or dullindeed, he could be remarkably

interesting. But I received the impression that there could be no human creature whom he would not sacrifice

in the pursuit of his schemes, in his task of imposing himself and his will upon the world. Perhaps that was

fanciful, but I think not altogether so. However, the point is that Mabel, I am sorry to say, was very unhappy.

I am nearly twice your age, my dear boy, though you always so kindly try to make me feel as if we were

contemporariesI am getting to be an old man, and a great many people have been good enough to confide

their matrimonial troubles to me; but I never knew another case like my niece's and her husband's. I have

known her since she was a baby, Trent, and I knowyou understand, I think, that I do not employ that word

lightlyI know that she is as amiable and honourable a woman, to say nothing of her other good gifts, as any

'When I put that question to Mabel, her words were that he seemed to nurse a perpetual grievance. He

maintained a distance between them, and he would say nothing. I don't know how it began or what was

behind it; and all she would tell me on that point was that he had no cause in the world for his attitude. I think

she knew what was in his mind, whatever it was; but she is full of pride. This seems to have gone on for

months. At last, a week ago, she wrote to me. I am the only near relative she has. Her mother died when she

was a child; and after John Peter died I was something like a father to her until she marriedthat was five

years ago. She asked me to come and help her, and I came at once. That is why I am here now.'

Mr. Cupples paused and drank some tea. Trent smoked and stared out at the hot June landscape.

'I would not go to White Gables,' Mr. Cupples resumed. 'You know my views, I think, upon the economic

constitution of society, and the proper relationship of the capitalist to the employee, and you know, no doubt,

what use that person made of his vast industrial power upon several very notorious occasions. I refer

especially to the trouble in the Pennsylvania coalfields, three years ago. I regarded him, apart from an all

personal dislike, in the light of a criminal and a disgrace to society. I came to this hotel, and I saw my niece

here. She told me What I have more briefly told you. She said that the worry and the humiliation of it, and the

strain of trying to keep up appearances before the world, were telling upon her, and she asked for my advice.

I said I thought she should face him and demand an explanation of his way of treating her. But she would not

do that. She had always taken the line of affecting not to notice the change in his demeanour, and nothing, I

knew, would persuade her to admit to him that she was injured, once pride had led her into that course. Life is

quite full, my dear Trent,' said Mr. Cupples with a sigh, 'of these obstinate silences and cultivated

'Did she love him?' Trent enquired abruptly. Mr. Cupples did not reply at once. 'Had she any love left for

Mr. Cupples played with his teaspoon. 'I am bound to say,' he answered slowly, 'that I think not. But you

must not misunderstand the woman, Trent. No power on earth would have persuaded her to admit that to any

oneeven to herself, perhapsso long as she considered herself bound to him. And I gather that, apart from

'She did,' replied Mr. Cupples. 'And I knew by experience that it was quite useless to attempt to move a

Domecq where the sense of dignity was involved. So I thought it over carefully, and next day I watched my

opportunity and met Manderson as he passed by this hotel. I asked him to favour me with a few minutes'

conversation, and he stepped inside the gate down there. We had held no communication of any kind since

my niece's marriage, but he remembered me, of course. I put the matter to him at once and quite definitely. I

told him what Mabel had confided to me. I said that I would neither approve nor condemn her action in

bringing me into the business, but that she was suffering, and I considered it my right to ask how he could

'And how did he take that?' said Trent, smiling secretly at the landscape. The picture of this mildest of men

'Not very well,' Mr. Cupples replied sadly. 'In fact, far from well. I can tell you almost exactly what he

saidit wasn't much. He said, "See here, Cupples, you don't want to butt in. My wife can look after herself.

I've found that out, along with other things." He was perfectly quietyou know he was said never to lose

control of himselfthough there was a light in his eyes that would have frightened a man who was in the

wrong, I dare say. But I had been thoroughly roused by his last remark, and the tone of it, which I cannot

reproduce. You see,' said Mr. Cupples simply, 'I love my niece. She is the only child that there has been in

ourin my house. Moreover, my wife brought her up as a girl, and any reflection on Mabel I could not help

feeling, in the heat of the moment, as an indirect reflection upon one who is gone.'

'You turned upon him,' suggested Trent in a low tone. 'You asked him to explain his words.'

'That is precisely what I did,' said Mr. Cupples. 'For a moment he only stared at me, and I could see a vein on

his forehead swellingan unpleasant sight. Then he said quite quietly, "This thing has gone far enough, I

'From the words alone you would think so,' Mr. Cupples answered. 'But the way in which he uttered them

gave me a strange and very apprehensive feeling. I received the impression that the man had formed some

sinister resolve. But I regret to say I had lost the power of dispassionate thought. I fell into a great rage'Mr.

Cupples's tone was mildly apologetic'and said a number of foolish things. I reminded him that the law

allowed a measure of freedom to wives who received intolerable treatment. I made some utterly irrelevant

references to his public record, and expressed the view that such men as he were unfit to live. I said these

things, and others as illconsidered, under the eyes, and very possibly within earshot, of half a dozen persons

sitting on this veranda. I noticed them, in spite of my agitation, looking at me as I walked up to the hotel

again after relieving my mind for it undoubtedly did relieve it,' sighed Mr. Cupples, lying back in his chair.

'Not a word. He listened to me with his eyes on my face, as quiet as before. When I stopped he smiled very

slightly, and at once turned away and strolled through the gate, making for White Gables.' 'And this

'No,' said Mr. Cupples. 'Or rather yesonce. It was later in the day, on the golfcourse. But I did not speak

The two regarded each other in silence for a few moments. A party of guests who had been bathing came up

the steps and seated themselves, with much chattering, at a table near them. The waiter approached. Mr.

Cupples rose, and, taking Trent's arm, led him to a long tennislawn at the side of the hotel.

'I have a reason for telling you all this,' began Mr. Cupples as they paced slowly up and down.

'Trust you for that,' rejoined Trent, carefully filling his pipe again. He lit it, smoked a little, and then said, 'I'll

'You thought it possible,' said Trent meditatively'may I say you thought it practically certain?that I

should find out for myself that there had been something deeper than a mere conjugal tiff between the

Mandersons. You thought that my unwholesome imagination would begin at once to play with the idea of

Mrs. Manderson having something to do with the crime. Rather than that I should lose myself in barren

speculations about this, you decided to tell me exactly how matters stood, and incidentally to impress upon

me, who know how excellent your judgement is, your opinion of your niece. Is that about right?'

'It is perfectly right. Listen to me, my dear fellow,' said Mr. Cupples earnestly, laying his hand on the other's

arm. 'I am going to be very frank. I am extremely glad that Manderson is dead. I believe him to have done

nothing but harm in the world as an economic factor. I know that he was making a desert of the life of one

who was like my own child to me. But I am under an intolerable dread of Mabel being involved in suspicion

with regard to the murder. It is horrible to me to think of her delicacy and goodness being in contact, if only

for a time, with the brutalities of the law. She is not fitted for it. It would mark her deeply. Many young

women of twentysix in these days could face such an ordeal, I suppose. I have observed a sort of imitative

hardness about the products of the higher education of women today which would carry them through

I am not prepared to say it is a bad thing in the conditions of feminine life prevailing at present. Mabel,

however, is not like that. She is as unlike that as she is unlike the simpering misses that used to surround me

as a child. She has plenty of brains; she is full of character; her mind and her tastes are cultivated; but it is all

mixed up'Mr. Cupples waved his hands in a vague gesture'with ideals of refinement and reservation and

womanly mystery. I fear she is not a child of the age. You never knew my wife, Trent. Mabel is my wife's

The younger man bowed his head. They paced the length of the lawn before he asked gently, 'Why did she

Mr. Cupples shrugged his shoulders. 'I have been told that a woman will usually be more or less attracted by

the most successful man in her circle. Of course we cannot realize how a wilful, dominating personality like

his would influence a girl whose affections were not bestowed elsewhere; especially if he laid himself out to

win her. It is probably an overwhelming thing to be courted by a man whose name is known all over the

world. She had heard of him, of course, as a financial great power, and she had no ideashe had lived

mostly among people of artistic or literary propensitieshow much soulless inhumanity that might involve.

For all I know, she has no adequate idea of it to this day. When I first heard of the affair the mischief was

done, and I knew better than to interpose my unsought opinions. She was of age, and there was absolutely

nothing against him from the conventional point of view. Then I dare say his immense wealth would cast a

spell over almost any woman. Mabel had some hundreds a year of her own; just enough, perhaps, to let her

realize what millions really meant. But all this is conjecture. She certainly had not wanted to marry some

scores of young fellows who to my knowledge had asked her; and though I don't believe, and never did

believe, that she really loved this man of fortyfive, she certainly did want to marry him. But if you ask me

Trent nodded, and after a few more paces looked at his watch. 'You've interested me so much,' he said, 'that I

had quite forgotten my main business. I mustn't waste my morning. I am going down the road to White

Gables at once, and I dare say I shall be poking about there until midday. If you can meet me then, Cupples, I

should like to talk over anything I find out with you, unless something detains me.'

'I am going for a walk this morning,' Mr. Cupples replied. 'I meant to have luncheon at a little inn near the

golfcourse, The Three Tuns. You had better join me there. It's further along the road, about a quarter of a

mile beyond White Gables. You can just see the roof between those two trees. The food they give one there is

'So long as they have a cask of beer,' said Trent, 'they are all right. We will have bread and cheese, and oh,

may Heaven our simple lives prevent from luxury's contagion, weak and vile! Till then, goodbye.' He strode

The old gentleman, seating himself in a deckchair on the lawn, clasped his hands behind his head and gazed

up into the speckless blue sky. 'He is a dear fellow,' he murmured. 'The best of fellows. And a terribly acute

A painter and the son of a painter, Philip Trent had while yet in his twenties achieved some reputation within

the world of English art. Moreover, his pictures sold. An original, forcible talent and a habit of leisurely but

continuous working, broken by fits of strong creative enthusiasm, were at the bottom of it. His father's name

had helped; a patrimony large enough to relieve him of the perilous imputation of being a struggling man had

certainly not hindered. But his best aid to success had been an unconscious power of getting himself liked.

Good spirits and a lively, humorous fancy will always be popular. Trent joined to these a genuine interest in

others that gained him something deeper than popularity. His judgement of persons was penetrating, but its

process was internal; no one felt on good behaviour with a man who seemed always to be enjoying himself.

Whether he was in a mood for floods of nonsense or applying himself vigorously to a task, his face seldom

lost its expression of contained vivacity. Apart from a sound knowledge of his art and its history, his culture

was large and loose, dominated by a love of poetry. At thirtytwo he had not yet passed the age of laughter

His rise to a celebrity a hundred times greater than his proper work had won for him came of a momentary

impulse. One day he had taken up a newspaper to find it chiefly concerned with a crime of a sort curiously

rare in our countrya murder done in a railway train. The circumstances were puzzling; two persons were

under arrest upon suspicion. Trent, to whom an interest in such affairs was a new sensation, heard the thing

discussed among his friends, and set himself in a purposeless mood to read up the accounts given in several

journals. He became intrigued; his imagination began to work, in a manner strange to him, upon facts; an

excitement took hold of him such as he had only known before in his bursts of artinspiration or of personal

adventure. At the end of the day he wrote and dispatched a long letter to the editor of the Record, which he

chose only because it had contained the fullest and most intelligent version of the facts.

In this letter he did very much what Poe had done in the case of the murder of Mary Rogers. With nothing but

the newspapers to guide him, he drew attention to the significance of certain apparently negligible facts, and

ranged the evidence in such a manner as to throw grave suspicion upon a man who had presented himself as a

witness. Sir James Molloy had printed this letter in leaded type. The same evening he was able to announce in

Sir James, who knew all the worlds of London, had lost no time in making Trent's acquaintance. The two

men got on well, for Trent possessed some secret of native tact which had the effect of almost abolishing

differences of age between himself and others. The great rotary presses in the basement of the Record

building had filled him with a new enthusiasm. He had painted there, and Sir James had bought at sight, what

Then a few months later came the affair known as the Ilkley mystery. Sir James had invited Trent to an

emollient dinner, and thereafter offered him what seemed to the young man a fantastically large sum for his

'You could do it,' the editor had urged. 'You can write good stuff, and you know how to talk to people, and I

can teach you all the technicalities of a reporter's job in half an hour. And you have a head for a mystery; you

have imagination and cool judgement along with it. Think how it would feel if you pulled it off!'

Trent had admitted that it would be rather a lark. He had smoked, frowned, and at last convinced himself that

the only thing that held him back was fear of an unfamiliar task. To react against fear had become a fixed

He had pulled it off. For the second time he had given the authorities a start and a beating, and his name was

on all tongues. He withdrew and painted pictures. He felt no leaning towards journalism, and Sir James, who

knew a good deal about art, honourably refrainedas other editors did notfrom tempting him with a good

salary. But in the course of a few years he had applied to him perhaps thirty times for his services in the

unravelling of similar problems at home and abroad. Sometimes Trent, busy with work that held him, had

refused; sometimes he had been forestalled in the discovery of the truth. But the result of his irregular

connection with the Record had been to make his name one of the best known in England. It was

characteristic of him that his name was almost the only detail of his personality known to the public. He had

imposed absolute silence about himself upon the Molloy papers; and the others were not going to advertise

The Manderson case, he told himself as he walked rapidly up the sloping road to White Gables, might turn

out to be terribly simple. Cupples was a wise old boy, but it was probably impossible for him to have an

impartial opinion about his niece. But it was true that the manager of the hotel, who had spoken of her beauty

in terms that aroused his attention, had spoken even more emphatically of her goodness. Not an artist in

words, the manager had yet conveyed a very definite idea to Trent's mind. 'There isn't a child about here that

don't brighten up at the sound of her voice,' he had said, 'nor yet a grownup, for the matter of that.

Everybody used to look forward to her coming over in the summer. I don't mean that she's one of those

women that are all kind heart and nothing else. There's backbone with it, if you know what I meanpluck

any amount of go. There's nobody in Marlstone that isn't sorry for the lady in her troublenot but what some

of us may think she's lucky at the last of it.' Trent wanted very much to meet Mrs. Manderson.

He could see now, beyond a spacious lawn and shrubbery, the front of the two storied house of dullred

brick, with the pair of great gables from which it had its name. He had had but a glimpse of it from the car

that morning. A modern house, he saw; perhaps ten years old. The place was beautifully kept, with that air of

opulent peace that clothes even the smallest houses of the welltodo in an English countryside. Before it,

beyond the road, the rich meadowland ran down to the edge of the cliffs; behind it a woody landscape

stretched away across a broad vale to the moors. That such a place could be the scene of a crime of violence

seemed fantastic; it lay so quiet and well ordered, so eloquent of disciplined service and gentle living. Yet

there beyond the house, and near the hedge that rose between the garden and the hot, white road, stood the

gardener's toolshed, by which the body had been found, lying tumbled against the wooden wall, Trent walked

past the gate of the drive and along the road until he was opposite this shed. Some forty yards further along

the road turned sharply away from the house, to run between thick plantations; and just before the turn the

grounds of the house ended, with a small white gate at the angle of the boundary hedge. He approached the

gate, which was plainly for the use of gardeners and the service of the establishment. It swung easily on its

hinges, and he passed slowly up a path that led towards the back of the house, between the outer hedge and a

tall wall of rhododendrons. Through a gap in this wall a track led him to the little neatly built erection of

wood, which stood among trees that faced a corner of the front. The body had lain on the side away from the

house; a servant, he thought, looking out of the nearer windows in the earlier hours of the day before, might

have glanced unseeing at the hut, as she wondered what it could be like to be as rich as the master.

He examined the place carefully and ransacked the hut within, but he could note no more than the trodden

appearance of the uncut grass where the body had lain. Crouching low, with keen eyes and feeling fingers, he

It was interrupted by the soundthe first he had heard from the houseof the closing of the front door.

Trent unbent his long legs and stepped to the edge of the drive. A man was walking quickly away from the

At the noise of a footstep on the gravel, the man wheeled with nervous swiftness and looked earnestly at

Trent. The sudden sight of his face was almost terrible, so white and worn it was. Yet it was a young man's

face. There was not a wrinkle about the haggard blue eyes, for all their tale of strain and desperate fatigue. As

the two approached each other, Trent noted with admiration the man's breadth of shoulder and lithe, strong

figure. In his carriage, inelastic as weariness had made it; in his handsome, regular features; in his short,

smooth, yellow hair; and in his voice as he addressed Trent, the influence of a special sort of training was

confessed. 'Oxford was your playground, I think, my young friend,' said Trent to himself.

'If you are Mr. Trent,' said the young man pleasantly, 'you are expected. Mr. Cupples telephoned from the

'You were secretary to Mr. Manderson, I believe,' said Trent. He was much inclined to like young Mr.

Marlowe. Though he seemed so near a physical breakdown, he gave out none the less that air of clean living

and inward health that is the peculiar glory of his social type at his years. But there was something in the tired

eyes that was a challenge to Trent's penetration; an habitual expression, as he took it tobe, of meditating and

weighing things not present to their sight. It was a look too intelligent, too steady and purposeful, to be called

dreamy. Trent thought he had seen such a look before somewhere. He went on to say: 'It is a terrible business

'A little limp, that's all,' replied the young man wearily. 'I was driving the car all Sunday night and most of

yesterday, and I didn't sleep last night after hearing the newswho would? But I have an appointment now,

Mr. Trent, down at the doctor'sarranging about the inquest. I expect it'll be tomorrow. If you will go up to

the house and ask for Mr. Bunner, you'll find him expecting you; he will tell you all about things and show

you round. He's the other secretary; an American, and the best of fellows; he'll look after you. There's a

detective here, by the wayInspector Murch, from Scotland Yard. He came yesterday.'

'Murch!' Trent exclaimed. 'But he and I are old friends. How under the sun did he get here so soon?'

'I have no idea,' Mr. Marlowe answered. 'But he was here last evening, before I got back from Southampton,

interviewing everybody, and he's been about here since eight this morning. He's in the library nowthat's

where the open French window is that you see at the end of the house there. Perhaps you would like to step

'I think I will,' said Trent. Marlowe nodded and went on his way. The thick turf of the lawn round which the

drive took its circular sweep made Trent's footsteps as noiseless as a cat's. In a few moments he was looking

in through the open leaves of the window at the southward end of the house, considering with a smile a very

broad back and a bent head covered with short grizzled hair. The man within was stooping over a number of

' 'Twas ever thus,' said Trent in a melancholy tone, at the first sound of which the man within turned round

with startling swiftness. 'From childhood's hour I've seen my fondest hopes decay. I did think I was ahead of

Scotland Yard this time, and now here is the hugest officer in the entire Metropolitan force already occupying

The detective smiled grimly and came to the window. 'I was expecting you, Mr. Trent,' he said. 'This is the

'Since my tastes were being considered,' Trent replied, stepping into the room, 'I wish they had followed up

the idea by keeping my hated rival out of the business. You have got a long start, tooI know all about it.'

His eyes began to wander round the room. 'How did you manage it? You are a quick mover, I know; the dun

deer's hide on fleeter foot was never tied; but I don't see how you got here in time to be at work yesterday

evening. Has Scotland Yard secretly started an aviation corps? Or is it in league with the infernal powers? In

'It's simpler than that,' said Mr. Murch with professional stolidity. 'I happened to be on leave with the missus

at Haley, which is only twelve miles or so along the coast. As soon as our people there heard of the murder

they told me. I wired to the Chief, and was put in charge of the case at once. I bicycled over yesterday

'Arising out of that reply,' said Trent inattentively, 'how is Mrs. Inspector Murch?'

'Never better, thank you,' answered the inspector, 'and frequently speaks of you and the games you used to

have with our kids. But you'll excuse me saying, Mr. Trent, that you needn't trouble to talk your nonsense to

me while you're using your eyes. I know your ways by now. I understand you've fallen on your feet as usual,

'Such is the fact,' said Trent. 'I am going to cut you out again, inspector. I owe you one for beating me over

the Abinger case, you old fox. But if you really mean that you're not inclined for the social amenities just

now, let us leave compliments and talk business.' He stepped to the table, glanced through the papers

arranged there in order, and then turned to the open rolltop desk. He looked into the drawers swiftly. 'I see

this has been cleared out. Well now, inspector, I suppose we play the game as before.'

Trent had found himself on a number of occasions in the past thrown into the company of Inspector Murch,

who stood high in the councils of the Criminal Investigation Department. He was a quiet, tactful, and very

shrewd officer, a man of great courage, with a vivid history in connection with the more dangerous class of

criminals. His humanity was as broad as his frame, which was large even for a policeman. Trent and he,

through some obscure working of sympathy, had appreciated one another from the beginning, and had

formed one of those curious friendships with which it was the younger man's delight to adorn his experience.

The inspector would talk more freely to him than to any one, under the rose, and they would discuss details

and possibilities of every case, to their mutual enlightenment. There were necessarily rules and limits. It was

understood between them that Trent made no journalistic use of any point that could only have come to him

from an official source. Each of them, moreover, for the honour and prestige of the institution he represented,

openly reserved the right to withhold from the other any discovery or inspiration that might come to him

which he considered vital to the solution of the difficulty. Trent had insisted on carefully formulating these

principles of what he called detective sportsmanship. Mr. Murch, who loved a contest, and who only stood to

gain by his association with the keen intelligence of the other, entered very heartily into 'the game'. In these

strivings for the credit of the press and of the police, victory sometimes attended the experience and method

of the officer, sometimes the quicker brain and livelier imagination of Trent, his gift of instinctively

The inspector then replied to Trent's last words with cordial agreement. Leaning on either side of the French

window, with the deep peace and hazy splendor of the summer landscape before them, they reviewed the

Trent had taken out a thin notebook, and as they talked he began to make, with light, secure touches, a rough

sketch plan of the room. It was a thing he did habitually on such occasions, and often quite idly, but now and

This was a large, light apartment at the corner of the house, with generous windowspace in two walls. A

broad table stood in the middle. As one entered by the window the rolltop desk stood just to the left of it

against the wall. The inner door was in the wall to the left, at the farther end of the room; and was faced by a

broad window divided into openings of the casement type. A beautifully carved old cornercupboard rose

high against the wall beyond the door, and another cupboard filled a recess beside the fireplace. Some

coloured prints of Harunobu, with which Trent promised himself a better acquaintance, hung on what little

wallspace was unoccupied by books. These had a very uninspiring appearance of having been bought by the

yard and never taken from their shelves. Bound with a sober luxury, the great English novelists, essayists,

historians, and poets stood ranged like an army struck dead in its ranks. There were a few chairs made, like

the cupboard and table, of old carved oak; a modern armchair and a swivel officechair before the desk. The

room looked costly but very bare. Almost the only portable objects were a great porcelain bowl of a

wonderful blue on the table, a clock and some cigar boxes on the mantelshelf, and a movable telephone

'First impressions of this case rather puzzle me,' said the inspector. 'From what I heard at Halvey I guessed it

might be common robbery and murder by some tramp, though such a thing is very far from common in these

parts. But as soon as I began my enquiries I came on some curious points, which by this time I dare say

you've noted for yourself. The man is shot in his own grounds, quite near the house, to begin with. Yet there's

not the slightest trace of any attempt at burglary. And the body wasn't robbed. In fact, it would be as plain a

ease of suicide as you could wish to see, if it wasn't for certain facts. Here's another thing: for a month or so

past, they tell me, Manderson had been in a queer state of mind. I expect you know already that he and his

wife had some trouble between them. The servants had noticed a change in his manner to her for a long time,

and for the past week he had scarcely spoken to her. They say he was a changed man, moody and

silentwhether on account of that or something else. The lady's maid says he looked as if something was

going to arrive. It's always easy to remember that people looked like that, after something has happened to

them. Still, that's what they say. There you are again, then: suicide! Now, why wasn't it suicide, Mr. Trent?'

'The facts so far as I know them are really all against it,' Trent replied, sitting on the threshold of the window

and clasping his knees. 'First, of course, no weapon is to be found. I've searched, and you've searched, and

there's no trace of any firearm anywhere within a stone's throw of where the body lay. Second, the marks on

the wrists, fresh scratches and bruises, which we can only assume to have been done in a struggle with

somebody. Third, who ever heard of anybody shooting himself in the eye? Then I heard from the manager of

the hotel here another fact, which strikes me as the most curious detail in this affair. Manderson had dressed

himself fully before going out there, but he forgot his false teeth. Now how could a suicide who dressed

'That last argument hadn't struck me,' admitted Mr. Murch. 'There's something in it. But on the strength of the

other points, which had occurred to me, I am not considering suicide. I have been looking about for ideas in

'That is so. It is a case for ideas, it seems to me. Come, Murch, let us make an effort; let us bend our spirits to

a temper of general suspicion. Let us suspect everybody in the house, to begin with. Listen: I will tell you

whom I suspect. I suspect Mrs. Manderson, of course. I also suspect both the secretariesI hear there are

two, and I hardly know which of them I regard as more thoroughly open to suspicion. I suspect the butler and

the lady's maid. I suspect the other domestics, and especially do I suspect the bootboy. By the way, what

domestics are there? I have more than enough suspicion to go round, whatever the size of the establishment;

'All very well to laugh,' replied the inspector, 'but at the first stage of affairs it's the only safe principle, and

you know that as well as I do, Mr. Trent. However, I've seen enough of the people here, last night and today,

to put a few of them out of my mind for the present at least. You will form your own conclusions. As for the

establishment, there's the butler and lady's maid, cook, and three other maids, one a young girl. One

'What about the gardener? You say nothing about that shadowy and sinister figure, the gardener. You are

keeping him in the background, Murch. Play the game. Out with himor I report you to the Rules

'The garden is attended to by a man in the village, who comes twice a week. I've talked to him. He was here

'Then I suspect him all the more,' said Trent. 'And now as to the house itself. What I propose to do, to begin

with, is to sniff about a little in this room, where I am told Manderson spent a great deal of his time, and in

his bedroom; especially the bedroom. But since we're in this room, let's start here. You seem to be at the same

The inspector nodded. 'I've been over Manderson's and his wife's. Nothing to be got there, I think. His room

is very simple and bare, no signs of any sortthat I could see. Seems to have insisted on the simple life, does

Manderson. Never employed a valet. The room's almost like a cell, except for the clothes and shoes. You'll

find it all exactly as I found it; and they tell me that's exactly as Manderson left it, at we don't know what

o'clock yesterday morning. Opens into Mrs. Manderson's bedroomnot much of the cell about that, I can tell

you. I should say the lady was as fond of pretty things as most. But she cleared out of it on the morning of the

discoverytold the maid she could never sleep in a room opening into her murdered husband's room. Very

natural feeling in a woman, Mr. Trent. She's camping out, so to say, in one of the spare bedrooms now.'

'Come, my friend,' Trent was saying to himself, as he made a few notes in his little book. 'Have you got your

eye on Mrs. Manderson? Or haven't you? I know that colourless tone of the inspectorial voice. I wish I had

seen her. Either you've got something against her and you don't want me to get hold of it; or else you've made

up your mind she's innocent, but have no objection to my wasting my time over her. Well, it's all in the game;

which begins to look extremely interesting as we go on.' To Mr. Murch he said aloud: 'Well, I'll draw the

'They call it the library,' said the inspector. 'Manderson used to do his writing and that in here; passed most of

the time he spent indoors here. Since he and his wife ceased to hit it off together, he had taken to spending his

evenings alone, and when at this house he always spent 'em in here. He was last seen alive, as far as the

Trent rose and glanced again through the papers set out on the table. 'Business letters and documents, mostly,'

said Mr. Murch. 'Reports, prospectuses, and that. A few letters on private matters, nothin4g in them that I

can see. The American secretaryBunner his name is, and a queerer card I never saw turned he's been

through this desk with me this morning. He had got it into his head that Manderson had been receiving

threatening letters, and that the murder was the outcome of that. But there's no trace of any such thing; and

we looked at every blessed paper. The only unusual things we found were some packets of banknotes to a

considerable amount, and a couple of little bags of unset diamonds. I asked Mr. Bunner to put them in a safer

place. It appears that Manderson had begun buying diamonds lately as a speculationit was a new game to

'What about these secretaries?' Trent enquired. 'I met one called Marlowe just now outside; a nicelooking

chap with singular eyes, unquestionably English. The other, it seems, is an American. What did Manderson

'Mr. Marlowe explained to me how that was. The American was his righthand business man, one of his

office staff, who never left him. Mr. Marlowe had nothing to do with Manderson's business as a financier,

knew nothing of it. His job was to look after Manderson's horses and motors and yacht and sporting

arrangements and thatmake himself generally useful, as you might say. He had the spending of a lot of

money, I should think. The other was confined entirely to the office affairs, and I dare say he had his hands

full. As for his being English, it was just a fad of Manderson's to have an English secretary. He'd had several

'He showed his taste,' observed Trent. 'It might be more than interesting, don't you think, to be minister to the

pleasures of a modern plutocrat with a large P. Only they say that Manderson's were exclusively of an

innocent kind. Certainly Marlowe gives me the impression that he would be weak in the part of Petronius.

But to return to the matter in hand.' He looked at his notes. 'You said just ' now that he was last seen alive

'He had a conversation with his wife on going to bed. But for that, the manservant, Martin by name, last saw

him in this room. I had his story last night, and very glad he was to tell it. An affair like this is meat and drink

Trent considered for some moments, gazing through the open window over the sun flooded slopes. 'Would

it bore you to hear what he has to say again?' he asked at length. For reply, Mr. Murch rang the bell. A spare,

cleanshaven, middle aged man, having the servant's manner in its most distinguished form, answered it.

'This is Mr. Trent, who is authorized by Mrs. Manderson to go over the house and make enquiries,' explained

the detective. 'He would like to hear your story.' Martin bowed distantly. He recognized Trent for a

gentleman. Time would show whether he was what Martin called a gentleman in every sense of the word.

'I observed you approaching the house, sir,' said Martin with impassive courtesy. He spoke with a slow and

measured utterance. 'My instructions are to assist you in every possible way. Should you wish me to recall the

'Please,' said Trent with ponderous gravity. Martin's style was making clamorous appeal to his sense of

'No, not that yet,' Trent checked him quietly. 'Tell me all you saw of him that eveningafter dinner, say. Try

'After dinner, sir?yes. I remember that after dinner Mr. Manderson and Mr. Marlowe walked up and down

the path through the orchard, talking. If you ask me for details, it struck me they were talking about

something important, because I heard Mr. Manderson say something when they came in through the back

entrance. He said, as near as I can remember, "If Harris is there, every minute is of importance. You want to

start right away. And not a word to a soul." Mr. Marlowe answered, "Very well. I will just change out of

these clothes and then I am ready"or words to that effect. I heard this plainly as they passed the window of

my pantry. Then Mr. Marlowe went up to his bedroom, and Mr. Manderson entered the library and rang for

me. He handed me some letters for the postman in the morning and directed me to sit up, as Mr. Marlowe had

'I thought so, sir. But I recollected what I had heard about "not a word to a soul", and I concluded that this

'It would be about ten, sir, I should say. After speaking to me, Mr. Manderson waited until Mr. Marlowe had

come down and brought round the car. He then went into the drawingroom, where Mrs. Manderson was.'

Martin looked down his nose. 'If you ask me the question, sir,' he said with reserve, 'I had not known him

enter that room since we came here this year. He preferred to sit in the library in the evenings. That evening

he only remained with Mrs. Manderson for a few minutes. Then he and Mr. Marlowe started immediately.'

'After an hour or thereabouts, sir, in the library. That would have been about a quarter past eleven, I should

say; I had noticed eleven striking from the church. I may say I am peculiarly quick of hearing, sir.'

'Mr. Manderson had rung the bell for you, I suppose. Yes? And what passed when you answered it?'

'Mr. Manderson had put out the decanter of whisky and a syphon and glass, sir, from the cupboard where he

Trent held up his hand. 'While we are on that point, Martin, I want to ask you plainly, did Mr. Manderson

drink very much? You understand this is not impertinent curiosity on my part. I want you to tell me, because

'Perfectly, sir,' replied Martin gravely. 'I have no hesitation in telling you what I have already told the

inspector. Mr. Manderson was, considering his position in life, a remarkably abstemious man. In my four

years of service with him I never knew anything of an alcoholic nature pass his lips, except a glass or two of

wine at dinner, very rarely a little at luncheon, and from time to time a whisky and soda before going to bed.

He never seemed to form a habit of it. Often I used to find his glass in the morning with only a little soda

water in it; sometimes he would have been having whisky with it, but never much. He never was particular

about his drinks; ordinary soda was what he preferred, though I had ventured to suggest some of the natural

minerals, having personally acquired a taste for them in my previous service. He used to keep them in the

cupboard here, because he had a great dislike of being waited on more than was necessary. It was an

understood thing that I never came near him after dinner unless sent for. And when he sent for anything, he

liked it brought quick, and to be left alone again at once. He hated to be asked if he required anything more.

'Very well; and he rang for you that night about a quarter past eleven. Now can you remember exactly what

I think I can tell you with some approach to accuracy, sir. It was not much. Zzz First he asked me if Mr.

Bunner had gone to bed, and I replied that he had been gone up some time. He then said that he wanted some

one to sit up until 12.30, in case an important message should come by telephone, and that Mr. Marlowe

having gone to Southampton for him in the motor, he wished me to do this, and that

I was to take down the message if it came, and not disturb him. He also ordered a fresh syphon of soda water.

'No, sir, nothing unusual. When I answered the ring, he was seated at the desk listening at the telephone,

waiting for a number, as I supposed. He gave his orders and went on listening at the same time. 'When I

'Very little, sir; it was something about somebody being at some hotelof no interest to me. I was only in

the room just time enough to place the syphon on the table and withdraw. As I closed the door he was saying,

'No, sir. A little later, at halfpast eleven, when I had settled down in my pantry with the door ajar, and a

book to pass the time, I heard Mr. Manderson go upstairs to bed. I immediately went to close the library

Trent considered. 'I suppose you didn't doze at all,' he said tentatively, 'while you were sitting up waiting for

'Oh no, sir. I am always very wakeful about that time. I'm a bad sleeper, especially in the neighbourhood of

Trent added a last note; then he looked thoughtfully through those he had taken. He rose and paced up and

down the room for some moments with a downcast eye. At length he paused opposite Martin.

'It all seems perfectly ordinary and simple,' he said. 'I just want to get a few details clear. You went to shut the

'The French window, sir. It had been open all day. The windows opposite the door were seldom opened.'

'And what about the curtains? I am wondering whether any one outside the house could have seen into the

'Easily, sir, I should say, if he had got into the grounds on that side. The curtains were never drawn in the hot

weather. Mr. Manderson would often sit right in the doorway at nights, smoking and looking out into the

'I see. And now tell me this. Your hearing is very acute, you say, and you heard Mr. Manderson enter the

house when he came in after dinner from the garden. Did you hear him reenter it after returning from the

Martin paused. 'Now you mention it, sir, I remember that I did not. His ringing the bell in this room was the

first I knew of his being back. I should have heard him come in, if he had come in by the front. I should have

heard the door go. But he must have come in by the window.' The man reflected for a moment, then added,

'As a general rule, Mr. Manderson would come in by the front, hang up his hat and coat in the hall, and pass

down the hall into the study. It seems likely to me that he was in a great hurry to use the telephone, and so

went straight across the lawn to the window he was like that, sir, when there was anything important to be

done. He had his hat on, now I remember, and had thrown his greatcoat over the end of the table. He gave his

order very sharp, too, as he always did when busy. A very precipitate man indeed was Mr. Manderson; a

'Ah! he appeared to be busy. But didn't you say just now that you noticed nothing unusual about him?'

A melancholy smile flitted momentarily over Martin's face. 'That observation shows that you did not know

Mr. Manderson, sir, if you will pardon my saying so. His being like that was nothing unusual; quite the

contrary. It took me long enough to get used to it. Either he would be sitting quite still and smoking a cigar,

thinking or reading, or else he would be writing, dictating, and sending off wires all at the same time, till it

almost made one dizzy to see it, sometimes for an hour or more at a stretch. As for being in a hurry over a

Trent turned to the inspector, who met his eye with a look of answering intelligence. Not sorry to show his

understanding of the line of inquiry opened by Trent, Mr. Murch for the first time put a question.

'Then you left him telephoning by the open window, with the lights on, and the drinks on the table; is that it?'

'That is so, Mr. Murch.' The delicacy of the change in Martin's manner when called upon to answer the

detective momentarily distracted Trent's appreciative mind. But the big man's next question brought it back to

'About those drinks. You say Mr. Manderson often took no whisky before going to bed. Did he have any that

'I could not say. The room was put to rights in the morning by one of the maids, and the glass washed, I

presume, as usual. I know that the decanter was nearly full that evening. I had refilled it a few days before,

and I glanced at it when I brought the fresh syphon, just out of habit, to make sure there was a decent

The inspector went to the tall cornercupboard and opened it. He took out a decanter of cut glass and set it on

the table before Martin. 'Was it fuller than that?' he asked quietly. 'That's how I found it this morning.' The

For the first time Martin's selfpossession wavered. He took up the decanter quickly, tilted it before his eyes,

and then stared amazedly at the others. He said slowly: 'There's not much short of half a bottle gone out of

'Nobody in the house, I suppose?' suggested Trent discreetly. 'Out of the question!' replied Martin briefly;

then he added, 'I beg pardon, sir, but this is a most extraordinary thing to me. Such a thing never happened in

all my experience of Mr. Manderson. As for the womenservants, they never touch anything, I can answer

for it; and as for me, when I want a drink I can help myself without going to the decanters.' He took up the

decanter again and aimlessly renewed his observation of the contents, while the inspector eyed him with a

Trent turned to a fresh page of his notebook, and tapped it thoughtfully with his pencil. Then he looked up

'Certainly, sir. He had on a suit with a dressjacket, what he used to refer to as a Tuxedo, which he usually

'All but the jacket, sir. When he spent the evening in the library, as usually happened, he would change it for

an old shootingjacket after dinner, a light coloured tweed, a little too loud in pattern for English tastes,

perhaps. He had it on when I saw him last. It used to hang in this cupboard here'Martin opened the door of

it as he spokealong with Mr. Manderson's fishingrods and such things, so that he could slip it on after

'In the morning,' Trent repeated slowly. 'And now that we are speaking of the morning, will you tell me

exactly what you know about that? I understand that Mr. Manderson was not missed until the body was found

'That is so, sir. Mr. Manderson would never be called, or have anything brought to him in the morning. He

occupied a separate bedroom. Usually he would get up about eight and go round to the bathroom, and he

would come down some time before nine. But often he would sleep till nine or ten o'clock. Mrs. Manderson

was always called at seven. The maid would take in tea to her. Yesterday morning Mrs. Manderson took

breakfast about eight in her sittingroom as usual, and every one supposed that Mr. Manderson was still in

bed and asleep, when Evans came rushing up to the house with the shocking intelligence.'

'I see,' said Trent. 'And now another thing. You say you slipped the lock of the front door before going to bed.

'To the front door, sir, yes; I slipped the lock. No more is considered necessary in these parts. But I had

locked both the doors at the back, and seen to the fastenings of all the windows on the ground floor. In the

'As you had left it. Now here is another pointthe last, I think. Were the clothes in which the body was

Martin rubbed his chin. 'You remind me how surprised I was when I first set eyes on the body, sir. At first I

couldn't make out what was unusual about the clothes, and then I saw what it was. The collar was a shape of

collar Mr. Manderson never wore except with evening dress. Then I found that he had put on all the same

things that he had worn the night beforelarge fronted shirt and allexcept just the coat and waistcoat and

trousers, and the brown shoes, and blue tie. As for the suit, it was one of half a dozen he might have worn.

But for him to have simply put on all the rest just because they were there, instead of getting out the kind of

shirt and things he always wore by day; well, sir, it was unprecedented. It shows, like some other things, what

'Of course,' said Trent. 'Well, I think that's all I wanted to know. You have put everything with admirable

clearness, Martin. If we want to ask any more questions later on, I suppose you will be somewhere about.'

Trent flung himself into the armchair and exhaled a long breath. 'Martin is a great creature,' he said. 'He is far,

far better than a play. There is none like him, none, nor will be when our summers have deceased. Straight,

too; not an atom of harm in dear old Martin. Do you know, Murch, you are wrong in suspecting that man.'

'I never said a word about suspecting him.' The inspector was taken aback. 'You know, Mr. Trent, he would

'I dare say he doesn't think so. He is a wonderful creature, a great artist; but, in spite of that, he is not at all a

sensitive type. It has never occurred to his mind that you, Murch, could suspect him, Martin, the complete,

the accomplished. But I know it. You must understand, inspector, that I have made a special study of the

psychology of officers of the law. It is a grossly neglected branch of knowledge. They are far more

interesting than criminals, and not nearly so easy. All the time I was questioning him I saw handcuffs in your

eye. Your lips were mutely framing the syllables of those tremendous words: "It is my duty to tell you that

anything you now say will be taken down and used in evidence against you." Your manner would have

Mr. Murch laughed heartily. Trent's nonsense never made any sort of impression on his mind, but he took it

as a mark of esteem, which indeed it was; so it never failed to please him. 'Well, Mr. Trent,' he said, 'you're

perfectly right. There's no point in denying it, I have got my eye on him. Not that there's anything definite;

but you know as well as I do how often servants are mixed up in affairs of this kind, and this man is such a

very quiet customer. You remember the case of Lord William Russell's valet, who went in as usual, in the

morning, to draw up the blinds in his master's bedroom, as quiet and starchy as you please, a few hours after

he had murdered him in his bed. I've talked to all the women of the house, and I don't believe there's a morsel

of harm in one of them. But Martin's not so easy set aside. I don't like his manner; I believe he's hiding

'Cease!' said Trent. 'Drain not to its dregs the urn of bitter prophecy. Let us get back to facts. Have you, as a

matter of evidence, anything at all to bring against Martin's story as he has told it to us?'

'Nothing whatever at present. As for his suggestion that Manderson came in by way of the window after

leaving Marlowe and the car, that's right enough, I should say. I questioned the servant who swept the room

next morning, and she tells me there were gravelly marks near the window, on this plain drugget that goes

round the carpet. And there's a footprint in this soft new gravel just outside.' The inspector took a folding rule

from his pocket and with it pointed out the traces. 'One of the patent shoes Manderson was wearing that night

exactly fits that print; you'll find them,' he added, 'on the top shelf in the bedroom, near the window end, the

only patents in the row. The girl who polished them in the morning picked them out for me.'

Trent bent down and studied the faint marks keenly. 'Good!' he said. 'You have covered a lot of ground,

Murch, I must say. That was excellent about the whisky; you made your point finely. I felt inclined to shout

'I thought you might have fitted it in already,' said Mr. Murch. 'Come, Mr. Trent, we're only at the beginning

of our enquiries, but what do you say to this for a preliminary theory? There's a plan of burglary, say a couple

of men in it and Martin squared. They know where the plate is, and all about the handy little bits of stuff in

the drawingroom and elsewhere. They watch the house; see Manderson off to bed; Martin comes to shut the

window, and leaves it ajar, accidentally on purpose. They wait till Martin goes to bed at twelvethirty; then

they just walk into the library, and begin to sample the whisky first thing. Now suppose Manderson isn't

asleep, and suppose they make a noise opening the window, or however it might be. He hears it; thinks of

burglars; gets up very quietly to see if anything's wrong; creeps down on them, perhaps, just as they're getting

ready for work. They cut and run; he chases them down to the shed, and collars one; there's a fight; one of

them loses his temper and his head, and makes a swinging job of it. Now, Mr. Trent, pick that to pieces.'

'Very well,' said Trent; 'just to oblige you, Murch, especially as I know you don't believe a word of it. First:

no traces of any kind left by your burglar or burglars, and the window found fastened in the morning,

according to Martin. Not much force in that, I allow. Next: nobody in the house hears anything of this

stampede through the library, nor hears any shout from Manderson either inside the house or outside. Next:

Manderson goes down without a word to anybody, though Bunner and Martin are both at hand. Next: did you

ever hear, in your long experience, of a householder getting up in the night to pounce on burglars, who

dressed himself fully, with underclothing, shirt; collar and tie, trousers, waistcoat and coat, socks and hard

leather shoes; and who gave the finishing touches to a somewhat dandified toilet by doing his hair, and

putting on his watch and chain? Personally, I call that overdressing the part. The only decorative detail he

The inspector leaned forward thinking, his large hands clasped before him. 'No,' he said at last. 'Of course

there's no help in that theory. I rather expect we have some way to go before we find out why a man gets up

before the servants are awake, dresses himself awry, and is murdered within sight of his house early enough

Trent shook his head. 'We can't build anything on that last consideration. I've gone into the subject with

people who know. I shouldn't wonder,' he added, 'if the traditional notions about loss of temperature and

rigour after death had occasionally brought an innocent man to the gallows, or near it. Dr. Stock has them all,

I feel sure; most general practitioners of the older generation have. That Dr. Stock will make an ass of himself

at the inquest, is almost as certain as that tomorrow's sun will rise. I've seen him. He will say the body must

have been dead about so long, because of the degree of coldness and rigor mortis. I can see him nosing it all

out in some textbook that was out of date when he was a student. Listen, Murch, and I will tell you some

facts which will be a great hindrance to you in your professional career. There are many things that may

hasten or retard the cooling of the body. This one was lying in the long dewy grass on the shady side of the

shed. As for rigidity, if Manderson died in a struggle, or labouring under sudden emotion, his corpse might

stiffen practically instantaneously; there are dozens of cases noted, particularly in cases of injury to the skull,

like this one. On the other hand, the stiffening might not have begun until eight or ten hours after death. You

can't hang anybody on rigor mortis nowadays, inspector, much as you may resent the limitation. No, what we

can say is this. If he had been shot after the hour at which the world begins to get up and go about its

business, it would have been heard, and very likely seen too. In fact, we must reason, to begin with, at any

rate, on the assumption that he wasn't shot at a time when people might be awake; it isn't done in these parts.

Put that time at 6.30 a.m. Manderson went up to bed at 11 p.m., and Martin sat up till 12.30. Assuming that

he went to sleep at once on turning in, that leaves us something like six hours for the crime to be committed

in; and that is a long time. But whenever it took place, I wish you would suggest a reason why Manderson,

who was a fairly late riser, was up and dressed at or before 6.30; and why neither Martin, who sleeps lightly,

nor Bunner, nor his wife heard him moving about, or letting himself out of the house. He must have been

careful. He must have crept about like a cat. Do you feel as I do, Murch, about all this; that it is very, very

'And now,' said Trent, rising to his feet, 'I'll leave you to your meditations, and take a look at the bedrooms.

Perhaps the explanation of all this will suddenly burst upon you while I am poking about up there. But,'

concluded Trent in a voice of sudden exasperation, turning round in the doorway, 'if you can tell me at any

time, how under the sun a man who put on all those clothes could forget to put in his teeth, you may kick me

from here to the nearest lunatic asylum, and hand me over as an incipient dement.'

There are moments in life, as one might think, when that which is within us, busy about its secret affair, lets

escape into consciousness some hint of a fortunate thing ordained. Who does not know what it is to feel at

times a wave of unaccountable persuasion that it is about to go well with him?not the feverish confidence

of men in danger of a blow from fate, not the persistent illusion of the optimist, but an unsought conviction,

springing up like a bird from the heather, that success is at hand in some great or fine thing. The general

suddenly knows at dawn that the day will bring him victory; the man on the green suddenly knows that he

will put down the long putt. As Trent mounted the stairway outside the library door he seemed to rise into

certainty of achievement. A host of guesses and inferences swarmed apparently unsorted through his mind; a

few secret observations that he had made, and which he felt must have significance, still stood unrelated to

any plausible theory of the crime; yet as he went up he seemed to know indubitably that light was going to

The bedrooms lay on either side of a broad carpeted passage, lighted by a tall end window. It went the length

of the house until it ran at right angles into a narrower passage, out of which the servants' rooms opened.

Martin's room was the exception: it opened out of a small landing halfway to the upper floor. As Trent

passed it he glanced within. A little square room, clean and commonplace. In going up the rest of the stairway

he stepped with elaborate precaution against noise, hugging the wall closely and placing each foot with care;

He knew that Manderson's room was the first on the right hand when the bedroom floor was reached, and he

went to it at once. He tried the latch and the lock, which worked normally, and examined the wards of the

It was a small apartment, strangely bare. The plutocrat's toilet appointments were of the simplest. All

remained just as it had been on the morning of the ghastly discovery in the grounds. The sheets and blankets

of the unmade bed lay tumbled over a narrow wooden bedstead, and the sun shone brightly through the

window upon them. It gleamed, too, upon the gold parts of the delicate work of dentistry that lay in water in a

shallow bowl of glass placed on a small, plain table by the bedside. On this also stood a wroughtiron

candlestick. Some clothing lay untidily over one of the two rushbottomed chairs. Various objects on the top

of a chest of drawers, which had been used as a dressingtable, lay in such disorder as a hurried man might

make. Trent looked them over with a questing eye. He noted also that the occupant of the room had neither

washed nor shaved. With his finger he turned over the dental plate in the bowl, and frowned again at its

The emptiness and disarray of the little room, flooded by the sunbeams, were producing in Trent a sense of

gruesomeness. His fancy called up a picture of a haggard man dressing himself in careful silence by the first

light of dawn, glancing constantly at the inner door behind which his wife slept, his eyes full of some terror.

Trent shivered, and to fix his mind again on actualities, opened two tall cupboards in the wall on either side

of the bed. They contained clothing, a large choice of which had evidently been one of the very few

In the matter of shoes, also, Manderson had allowed himself the advantage of wealth. An extraordinary

number of these, treed and carefully kept, was ranged on two long low shelves against the wall. No boots

were among them. Trent, himself an amateur of good shoeleather, now turned to these, and glanced over the

collection with an appreciative eye. It was to be seen that Manderson had been inclined to pride himself on a

rather small and wellformed foot. The shoes were of a distinctive shape, narrow and roundtoed, beautifully

Suddenly his eyes narrowed themselves over a pair of patentleather shoes on the upper shelf.

These were the shoes of which the inspector had already described the position to him; the shoes worn by

Manderson the night before his death. They were a wellworn pair, he saw at once; he saw, too, that they had

been very recently polished. Something about the uppers of these shoes had seized his attention. He bent

lower and frowned over them, comparing what he saw with the appearance of the neighbouring shoes. Then

As he did this, Trent began unconsciously to whistle faintly, and with great precision, an air which Inspector

Most men who have the habit of selfcontrol have also some involuntary trick which tells those who know

them that they are suppressing excitement. The inspector had noted that when Trent had picked up a strong

scent he whistled faintly a certain melodious passage; though the inspector could not have told you that it was

He turned the shoes over, made some measurements with a marked tape, and looked minutely at the bottoms.

On each, in the angle between the heel and the instep, he detected a faint trace of red gravel.

Trent placed the shoes on the floor, and walked with his hands behind him to the window, out of which, still

faintly whistling, he gazed with eyes that saw nothing. Once his lips opened to emit mechanically the

Englishman's expletive of sudden enlightenment. At length he turned to the shelves again, and swiftly but

This done, he took up the garments from the chair, looked them over closely and replaced them. He turned to

the wardrobe cupboards again, and hunted through them carefully. The litter on the dressingtable now

engaged his attention for the second time. Then he sat down on the empty chair, took his head in his hands,

and remained in that attitude, staring at the carpet, for some minutes. He rose at last and opened the inner

It was evident at a glance that the big room had been hurriedly put down from its place as the lady's bower.

All the array of objects that belong to a woman's dressingtable had been removed; on bed and chairs and

smaller tables there were no garments or hats, bags or boxes; no trace remained of the obstinate conspiracy of

gloves and veils, handkerchiefs and ribbons, to break the captivity of the drawer. The room was like an

unoccupied guestchamber. Yet in every detail of furniture and decoration it spoke of an unconventional but

exacting taste. Trent, as his expert eye noted the various perfection of colour and form amid which the

illmated lady dreamed her dreams and thought her loneliest thoughts, knew that she had at least the

resources of an artistic nature. His interest in this unknown personality grew stronger; and his brows came

down heavily as he thought of the burdens laid upon it, and of the deed of which the history was now shaping

He went first to the tall French window in the middle of the wall that faced the door, and opening it, stepped

out upon a small balcony with an iron railing. He looked down on a broad stretch of lawn that began

immediately beneath him, separated from the housewall only by a narrow flowerbed, and stretched away,

with an abrupt dip at the farther end, toward the orchard. The other window opened with a sash above the

gardenentrance of the library. In the farther inside corner of the room was a second door giving upon the

passage; the door by which the maid was wont to come in, and her mistress to go out, in the morning.

Trent, seated on the bed, quickly sketched in his notebook a plan of the room and its neighbour. The bed

stood in the angle between the communicatingdoor and the sashwindow, its head against the wall dividing

the room from Manderson's. Trent stared at the pillows; then he lay down with deliberation on the bed and

This observation taken, he rose again and proceeded to note on his plan that on either side of the bed was a

small table with a cover. Upon that furthest from the door was a graceful electriclamp standard of copper

connected by a free wire with the wall. Trent looked at it thoughtfully, then at the switches connected with

the other lights in the room. They were, as usual, on the wall just within the door, and some way out of his

reach as he sat on the bed. He rose, and satisfied himself that the lights were all in order. Then he turned on

'I want your help again, Martin,' he said, as the butler presented himself, upright and impassive, in the

doorway. 'I want you to prevail upon Mrs Manderson's maid to grant me an interview.'

'She's French, sir,' replied Martin succinctly; adding after a pause: 'She has not been with us long, sir, but I

have formed the impression that the young woman knows as much of the world as is good for hersince you

'You think butter might possibly melt in her mouth, do you?' said Trent. 'Well, I am not afraid. I want to put

'I will send her up immediately, sir.' The butler withdrew, and Trent wandered round the little room with his

hands at his back. Sooner than he had expected, a small neat figure in black appeared quietly before him.

The lady's maid, with her large brown eyes, had taken favourable notice of Trent from a window when he had

crossed the lawn, and had been hoping desperately that the resolver of mysteries (whose reputation was as

great belowstairs as elsewhere) would send for her. For one thing, she felt the need to make a scene; her

nerves were overwrought. But her scenes were at a discount with the other domestics, and as for Mr Murch,

he had chilled her into selfcontrol with his official manner. Trent, her glimpse of him had told her, had not

As she entered the room, however, instinct decided for her that any approach to coquetry would be a mistake,

if she sought to make a good impression at the beginning. It was with an air of amiable candour, then, that

she said, 'Monsieur desire to speak with me.' She added helpfully, 'I am called Celestine.'

'Naturally,' said Trent with businesslike calm. 'Now what I want you to tell me, Celestine, is this. When you

took tea to your mistress yesterday morning at seven o'clock, was the door between the two bedroomsthis

Celestine became intensely animated in an instant. 'Oh yes!' she said, using her favourite English idiom. 'The

door was open as always, monsieur, and I shut it as always. But it is necessary to explain. Listen! When I

enter the room of madame from the other door in thereah! but if monsieur will give himself the pain to

enter the other room, all explains itself.' She tripped across to the door, and urged Trent before her into the

larger bedroom with a hand on his arm. 'See! I enter the room with the tea like this. I approach the bed.

Before I come quite near the bed, here is the door to my right handopen alwaysso! But monsieur can

perceive that I see nothing in the room of Monsieur Manderson. The door opens to the bed, not to me who

approach from down there. I shut it without seeing in. It is the order. Yesterday it was as ordinary. I see

nothing of the next room. Madame sleep like an angelshe see nothing. I shut the door. I place the

plateauI open the curtainsI prepare the toiletteI retirevoila!' Celestine paused for breath and spread

Trent, who had followed her movements and gesticulations with deepening gravity, nodded his head. 'I see

exactly how it was now,' he said. 'Thank you, Celestine. So Mr Manderson was supposed to be still in his

room while your mistress was getting up, and dressing, and having breakfast in her boudoir?'

'Nobody missed him, in fact,' remarked Trent. 'Well, Celestine, I am very much obliged to you.' He reopened

'It is nothing, monsieur,' said Celestine, as she crossed the small room. 'I hope that monsieur will catch the

assassin of Monsieur Manderson. But I not regret him too much,' she added with sudden and amazing

violence, turning round with her hand on the knob of the outer door. She set her teeth with an audible sound,

and the colour rose in her small dark face. English departed from her. 'Je ne le regrette pas du tout, du tout!'

she cried with a flood of words. 'Madameah! je me jetterais au leu pour madameune femme si

charmante, si adorable! Mais un homme comme monsieurmaussade, boudeur, impassible! Ah, non! de

ma vie! J'en avais pardessus la tete, de monsieur! Ah! vrai! Estce insupportable, tout de meme, qu'il existe

'Finissez ce chahut, Celestine!' Trent broke in sharply. Celestine's tirade had brought back the memory of his

student days with a rush. 'En voila une scene! C'est rasant, vous savez. Faut rentret ca, mademoiselle. Du

reste, c'est bien imprudent, croyezmoi. Hang it! Have some common sense! If the inspector downstairs

heard you saying that kind of thing, you would get into trouble. And don't wave your fists about so much; you

might hit something. You seem,' he went on more pleasantly, as Celestine grew calmer under his

authoritative eye, 'to be even more glad than other people that Mr Manderson is out of the way. I could

almost suspect, Celestine, that Mr Manderson did not take as much notice of you as you thought necessary

'Ca, c'est un comble!' observed Trent. 'You are a nice young woman for a small teaparty, I don't think. A star

upon your birthday burned, whose fierce, serene, red, pulseless planet never yearned in heaven, Celestine.

Celestine took this as a scarcely expected compliment. The surprise restored her balance. With a sudden flash

of her eyes and teeth at Trent over her shoulder, the lady's maid opened the door and swiftly disappeared.

Trent, left alone in the little bedroom, relieved his mind with two forcible descriptive terms in Celestine's

language, and turned to his problem. He took the pair of shoes which he had already examined, and placed

them on one of the two chairs in the room, then seated himself on the other opposite to this. With his hands in

his pockets he sat with eyes fixed upon those two dumb witnesses. Now and then he whistled, almost

inaudibly, a few bars. It was very still in the room. A subdued twittering came from the trees through the

open window. From time to time a breeze rustled in the leaves of the thick creeper about the sill. But the man

So he sat for the space of half an hour. Then he rose quickly to his feet. He replaced the shoes on their shelf

Two bedroom doors faced him on the other side of the passage. He opened that which was immediately

opposite, and entered a bedroom by no means austerely tidy. Some sticks and fishingrods stood confusedly

in one corner, a pile of books in another. The housemaid's hand had failed to give a look of order to the

jumble of heterogeneous objects left on the dressingtable and on the mantelshelfpipes, penknives,

pencils, keys, golfballs, old letters, photographs, small boxes, tins, and bottles. Two fine etchings and some

water colour sketches hung on the walls; leaning against the end of the wardrobe, unhung, were a few

framed engravings. A row of shoes and boots was ranged beneath the window. Trent crossed the room and

studied them intently; then he measured some of them with his tape, whistling very softly. This done, he sat

The photographs on the mantelshelf attracted him presently. He rose and examined one representing Marlowe

and Manderson on horseback. Two others were views of famous peaks in the Alps. There was a faded print of

three youthsone of them unmistakably his acquaintance of the haggard blue eyesclothed in

tatterdemalion soldier's gear of the sixteenth century. Another was a portrait of a majestic old lady, slightly

resembling Marlowe. Trent, mechanically taking a cigarette from an open box on the mantelshelf, lit it and

stared at the photographs. Next he turned his attention to a flat leathern case that lay by the cigarettebox.

It opened easily. A small and light revolver, of beautiful workmanship, was disclosed, with a score or so of

A step was heard on the stairs, and as Trent opened the breech and peered into the barrel of the weapon,

Inspector Murch appeared at the open door of the room. 'I was wondering' he began; then stopped as he

saw what the other was about. His intelligent eyes opened slightly. 'Whose is the revolver, Mr Trent?' he

'Evidently it belongs to the occupant of the room, Mr Marlowe,' replied Trent with similar lightness, pointing

to the initials. 'I found this lying about on the mantelpiece. It seems a handy little pistol to me, and it has been

very carefully cleaned, I should say, since the last time it was used. But I know little about firearms.'

'Well, I know a good deal,' rejoined the inspector quietly, taking the revolver from Trent's outstretched hand.

'It's a bit of a speciality with me, is firearms, as I think you know, Mr Trent. But it don't require an expert to

tell one thing.' He replaced the revolver in its case on the mantelshelf, took out one of the cartridges, and

laid it on the spacious palm of one hand; then, taking a small object from his waistcoat pocket, he laid it

beside the cartridge. It was a little leaden bullet, slightly battered about the nose, and having upon it some

'That's him,' replied Mr Murch. 'Lodged in the bone at the back of the skull. Dr Stock got it out within the last

hour, and handed it to the local officer, who has just sent it on to me. These bright scratches you see were

made by the doctor's instruments. These other marks were made by the rifling of the barrel a barrel like this

one.' He tapped the revolver. 'Same make, same calibre. There is no other that marks the bullet just like this.'

With the pistol in its case between them, Trent and the inspector looked into each other's eyes for some

moments. Trent was the first to speak. 'This mystery is all wrong,' he observed. 'It is insanity. The symptoms

of mania are very marked. Let us see how we stand. We were not in any doubt, I believe, about Manderson

having dispatched Marlowe in the car to Southampton, or about Marlowe having gone, returning late last

'There is no doubt whatever about all that,' said Mr Murch, with a slight emphasis on the verb.

'And now,' pursued Trent, 'we are invited by this polished and insinuating firearm to believe the following

line of propositions: that Marlowe never went to Southampton; that he returned to the house in the night; that

he somehow, without waking Mrs Manderson or anybody else, got Manderson to get up, dress himself, and

go out into the grounds; that he then and there shot the said Manderson with his incriminating pistol; that he

carefully cleaned the said pistol, returned to the house and, again without disturbing any one, replaced it in its

case in a favourable position to be found by the officers of the law; that he then withdrew and spent the rest

of the day in hidingwith a large motor car; and that he turned up, feigning ignorance of the whole affair,

'A little after 9 p.m.' The inspector still stared moodily at Trent. 'As you say, Mr Trent, that is the first theory

suggested by this find, and it seems wild enoughat least it would do if it didn't fall to pieces at the very

start. When the murder was done Marlowe must have been fifty to a hundred miles away. He did go to

'I questioned him last night, and took down his story. He arrived in Southampton about 6.30 on the Monday

'Come off' exclaimed Trent bitterly. 'What do I care about his story? What do you care about his story? I want

Mr Murch chuckled. 'I thought I should take a rise out of you, Mr Trent,' he said. 'Well, there's no harm in

telling you. After I arrived yesterday evening, as soon as I had got the outlines of the story from Mrs

Manderson and the servants, the first thing I did was to go to the telegraph office and wire to our people in

Southampton. Manderson had told his wife when he went to bed that he had changed his mind, and sent

Marlowe to Southampton to get some important information from some one who was crossing by the next

day's boat. It seemed right enough, but, you see, Marlowe was the only one of the household who wasn't

under my hand, so to speak. He didn't return in the car until later in the evening; so before thinking the matter

out any further, I wired to Southampton making certain enquiries. Early this morning I got this reply.' He

'Simple and satisfactory,' observed Mr Murch as Trent, after twice reading the message, returned it to him.

'His own story corroborated in every particular. He told me he hung about the dock for half an hour or so on

the chance of Harris turning up late, then strolled back, lunched, and decided to return at once. He sent a wire

to Manderson"Harris not turned up missed boat returning Marlowe," which was duly delivered here in the

afternoon, and placed among the dead man's letters. He motored back at a good rate, and arrived dogtired.

When he heard of Manderson's death from Martin, he nearly fainted. What with that and the being without

sleep for so long, he was rather a wreck when I came to interview him last night; but he was perfectly

Trent picked up the revolver and twirled the cylinder idly for a few moments. 'It was unlucky for Manderson

that Marlowe left his pistol and cartridges about so carelessly,' he remarked at length, as he put it back in the

Mr Murch shook his head. 'There isn't really much to lay hold of about the revolver, when you come to think.

That particular make of revolver is common enough in England. It was introduced from the States. Half the

people who buy a revolver today for selfdefence or mischief provide themselves with that make, of that

calibre. It is very reliable, and easily carried in the hippocket. There must be thousands of them in the

possession of crooks and honest men. For instance,' continued the inspector with an air of unconcern,

'Manderson himself had one, the double of this. I found it in one of the top drawers of the desk downstairs,

'I was,' said the inspector; 'but as you've found one revolver, you may as well know about the other. As I say,

Both men started, and the inspector checked his speech abruptly, as the half closed door of the bedroom was

slowly pushed open, and a man stood in the doorway. His eyes turned from the pistol in its open case to the

faces of Trent and the inspector. They, who had not heard a sound to herald this entrance, simultaneously

'Calvin C. Bunner, at your service,' amended the newcomer, with a touch of punctilio, as he removed an

unlighted cigar from his mouth. He was used to finding Englishmen slow and ceremonious with strangers,

and Trent's quick remark plainly disconcerted him a little. 'You are Mr Trent, I expect,' he went on. 'Mrs

Manderson was telling me a while ago. Captain, goodmorning.' Mr Murch acknowledged the outlandish

greeting with a nod. 'I was coming up to my room, and I heard a strange voice in here, so I thought I would

take a look in.' Mr Bunner laughed easily. 'You thought I might have been eavesdropping, perhaps,' he said.

Mr Bunner was a thin, rather short young man with a shaven, pale, bony, almost girlish face, and large, dark,

intelligent eyes. His waving dark hair was parted in the middle. His lips, usually occupied with a cigar, in its

absence were always half open with a curious expression as of permanent eagerness. By smoking or chewing

a cigar this expression was banished, and Mr Bunner then looked the consummately cool and sagacious

Born in Connecticut, he had gone into a broker's office on leaving college, and had attracted the notice of

Manderson, whose business with his firm he had often handled. The Colossus had watched him for some

time, and at length offered him the post of private secretary. Mr Bunner was a pattern business man,

trustworthy, longheaded, methodical, and accurate. Manderson could have found many men with those

virtues; but he engaged Mr Bunner because he was also swift and secret, and had besides a singular natural

Trent and the American measured one another coolly with their eyes. Both appeared satisfied with what they

saw. 'I was having it explained to me,' said Trent pleasantly, 'that my discovery of a pistol that might have

shot Manderson does not amount to very much. I am told it is a favourite weapon among your people, and

Mr Bunner stretched out a bony hand and took the pistol from its case. 'Yes, sir,' he said, handling it with an

air of familiarity; 'the captain is right. This is what we call out home a Little Arthur, and I dare say there are

duplicates of it in a hundred thousand hippockets this minute. I consider it too light in the hand myself,' Mr

Bunner went on, mechanically feeling under the tail of his jacket, and producing an ugly looking weapon.

'Feel of that, now, Mr Trentit's loaded, by the way. Now this Little ArthurMarlowe bought it just before

we came over this year to please the old man. Manderson said it was ridiculous for a man to be without a

pistol in the twentieth century. So he went out and bought what they offered him, I guessnever consulted

me. Not but what it's a good gun,' Mr Bunner conceded, squinting along the sights. 'Marlowe was poor with it

at first, but I've coached him some in the last month or so, and he's practised until he is pretty good. But he

never could get the habit of carrying it around. Why, it's as natural to me as wearing my pants. I have carried

one for some years now, because there was always likely to be somebody laying for Manderson. And now,'

Mr Bunner concluded sadly, 'they got him when I wasn't around. Well, gentlemen, you must excuse me. I am

going into Bishopsbridge. There is a lot to do these days, and I have to send off a bunch of cables big enough

'I must be off too,' said Trent. 'I have an appointment at the "Three Tuns" inn.'

Let me give you a lift in the automobile,' said Mr Bunner cordially. 'I go right by that joint. Say, cap., are you

coming my way too? No? Then come along, Mr Trent, and help me get out the car. The chauffeur is out of

action, and we have to do 'most everything ourselves except clean the dirt off her.'

Still tirelessly talking in his measured drawl, Mr Bunner led Trent downstairs and through the house to the

garage at the back. It stood at a little distance from the house, and made a cool retreat from the blaze of the

Mr Bunner seemed to be in no hurry to get out the car. He offered Trent a cigar, which was accepted, and for

the first time lit his own. Then he seated himself on the footboard of the car, his thin hands clasped between

'See here, Mr Trent,' he said, after a few moments. 'There are some things I can tell you that may be useful to

you. I know your record. You are a smart man, and I like dealing with smart men. I don't know if I have that

detective sized up right, but he strikes me as a mutt. I would answer any questions he had the gumption to ask

meI have done so, in factbut I don't feel encouraged to give him any notions of mine without his asking.

Trent nodded. 'That is a feeling many people have in the presence of our police,' he said. 'It's the official

manner, I suppose. But let me tell you, Murch is anything but what you think. He is one of the shrewdest

officers in Europe. He is not very quick with his mind, but he is very sure. And his experience is immense.

My forte is imagination, but I assure you in police work experience outweighs it by a great deal.'

'Outweigh nothing!' replied Mr Bunner crisply. 'This is no ordinary case, Mr Trent. I will tell you one reason

why. I believe the old man knew there was something coming to him. Another thing: I believe it was

Trent pulled a crate opposite to Mr Bunner's place on the footboard and seated himself. 'This sounds like

'I say what I do because of the change in the old man's manner this last few weeks. I dare say you have heard,

Mr Trent, that he was a man who always kept himself well in hand. That was so. I have always considered

him the coolest and hardest head in business. That man's calm was just deadlyI never saw anything to beat

it. And I knew Manderson as nobody else did. I was with him in the work he really lived for. I guess I knew

him a heap better than his wife did, poor woman. I knew him better than Marlowe couldhe never saw

Manderson in his office when there was a big thing on. I knew him better than any of his friends.'

Mr Bunner glanced at him sharply. 'Somebody has been putting you next, I see that,' he remarked. 'No:

properly speaking, I should say not. He had many acquaintances among the big men, people he saw, most

every day; they would even go yachting or hunting together. But I don't believe there ever was a man that

Manderson opened a corner of his heart to. But what I was going to say was this. Some months ago the old

man began to get like I never knew him beforegloomy and sullen, just as if he was everlastingly brooding

over something bad, something that he couldn't fix. This went on without any break; it was the same down

town as it was up home, he acted just as if there was something lying heavy on his mind. But it wasn't until a

few weeks back that his selfrestraint began to go; and let me tell you this, Mr Trent'the American laid his

bony claw on the other's knee'I'm the only man that knows it. With every one else he would be just morose

and dull; but when he was alone with me in his office, or anywhere where we would be working together, if

the least little thing went wrong, by George! he would fly off the handle to beat the Dutch. In this library here

I have seen him open a letter with something that didn't just suit him in it, and he would rip around and carry

on like an Indian, saying he wished he had the man that wrote it here, he wouldn't do a thing to him, and so

on, till it was just pitiful. I never saw such a change. And here's another thing. For a week before he died

Manderson neglected his work, for the first time in my experience. He wouldn't answer a letter or a cable,

though things looked like going all to pieces over there. I supposed that this anxiety of his, whatever it was,

had got on to his nerves till they were worn out. Once I advised him to see a doctor, and he told me to go to

hell. But nobody saw this side of him but me. If he was having one of these rages in the library here, for

example, and Mrs Manderson would come into the room, he would be all calm and cold again in an instant.'

'And you put this down to some secret anxiety, a fear that somebody had designs on his life?' asked Trent.

'I suppose,' Trent resumed, 'you had considered the idea of there being something wrong with his minda

breakdown from overstrain, say. That is the first thought that your account suggests to me. Besides, it is

what is always happening to your big business men in America, isn't it? That is the impression one gets from

'Don't let them slip you any of that bunk,' said Mr Bunner earnestly. 'It's only the ones who have got rich too

quick, and can't make good, who go crazy. Think of all our really big menthe men anywhere near

Manderson's size: did you ever hear of any one of them losing his senses? They don't do itbelieve me. I

know they say every man has his loco point,' Mr Bunner added reflectively, 'but that doesn't mean genuine,

sureenough craziness; it just means some personal eccentricity in a man...like hating cats...or my own

'He was full of themthe old man. There was his objection to all the unnecessary fuss and luxury that

wealthy people don't kick at much, as a general rule. He didn't have any use for expensive trifles and

ornaments. He wouldn't have anybody do little things for him; he hated to have servants tag around after him

unless he wanted them. And although Manderson was as careful about his clothes as any man I ever knew,

and his shoeswell, sir, the amount of money he spent on shoes was sinfulin spite of that, I tell you, he

never had a valet. He never liked to have anybody touch him. All his life nobody ever shaved him.'

'Well,' Mr Bunner answered slowly, 'it was the Manderson habit of mind, I guess; a sort of temper of general

They say his father and grandfather were just the same ....Like a dog with a bone, you know, acting as if all

the rest of creation was laying for a chance to steal it. He didn't really think the barber would start in to saw

his head off; he just felt there was a possibility that he might, and he was taking no risks. Then again in

business he was always convinced that somebody else was after his bonewhich was true enough a good

deal of the time; but not all the time. The consequence of that was that the old man was the most cautious and

secret worker in the world of finance; and that had a lot to do with his success, too .... But that doesn't amount

to being a lunatic, Mr Trent; not by a long way. You ask me if Manderson was losing his mind before he

died. I say I believe he was just worn out with worrying over something, and was losing his nerve.'

Trent smoked thoughtfully. He wondered how much Mr Bunner knew of the domestic difficulty in his chief's

household, and decided to put out a feeler. 'I understood that he had trouble with his wife.'

'Sure,' replied Mr Bunner. 'But do you suppose a thing like that was going to upset Sig Manderson that way?

No, sir! He was a sight too big a man to be all broken up by any worry of that kind.'

Trent looked halfincredulously into the eyes of the young man. But behind all their shrewdness and

intensity he saw a massive innocence. Mr Bunner really believed a serious breach between husband and wife

'You can search me,' Mr Bunner replied briefly. He puffed at his cigar. 'Marlowe and I have often talked

about it, and we could never make out a solution. I had a notion at first,' said Mr Bunner in a lower voice,

leaning forward, 'that the old man was disappointed and vexed because he had expected a child; but Marlowe

told me that the disappointment on that score was the other way around, likely as not. His idea was all right, I

Trent looked up at him quickly. 'Celestine!' he said; and his thought was, 'So that was what she was getting

Mr Bunner misunderstood his glance. 'Don't you think I'm giving a man away, Mr Trent,' he said. 'Marlowe

isn't that kind. Celestine just took a fancy to him because he talks French like a native, and she would always

be holding him up for a gossip. French servants are quite unlike English that way. And servant or no servant,'

added Mr Bunner with emphasis, 'I don't see how a woman could mention such a subject to a man. But the

'But to come back to what you were telling me just now,' Trent said. 'You believe that Manderson was going

in terror of his life for some time. Who should threaten it? I am quite in the dark.'

'TerrorI don't know,' replied Mr Bunner meditatively. 'Anxiety, if you like. Or suspensethat's rather my

idea of it. The old man was hard to terrify, anyway; and more than that, he wasn't taking any precautionshe

was actually avoiding them. It looked more like he was asking for a quick finishsupposing there's any truth

in my idea. Why, he would sit in that library window, nights, looking out into the dark, with his white shirt

just a target for anybody's gun. As for who should threaten his life well, sir,' said Mr Bunner with a faint

smile, 'it's certain you have not lived in the States. To take the Pennsylvania coal holdup alone, there were

thirty thousand men, with women and children to keep, who would have jumped at the chance of drilling a

hole through the man who fixed it so that they must starve or give in to his terms. Thirty thousand of the

toughest aliens in the country, Mr Trent. There's a type of desperado you find in that kind of push who has

been known to lay for a man for years, and kill him when he had forgotten what he did. They have been

known to dynamite a man in Idaho who had done them dirt in New Jersey ten years before. Do you suppose

the Atlantic is going to stop them?... It takes some sand, I tell you, to be a big business man in our country.

No, sir: the old man knewhad always knownthat there was a whole crowd of dangerous men scattered

up and down the States who had it in for him. My belief is that he had somehow got to know that some of

them were definitely after him at last. What licks me altogether is why he should have just laid himself open

to them the way he didwhy he never tried to dodge, but walked right down into the garden yesterday

Mr Bunner ceased to speak, and for a little while both men sat with wrinkled brows, faint blue vapours rising

from their cigars. Then Trent rose. 'Your theory is quite fresh to me,' he said. 'It's perfectly rational, and it's

only a question of whether it fits all the facts, I mustn't give away what I'm doing for my newspaper, Mr

Bunner, but I will say this: I have already satisfied myself that this was a premeditated crime, and an

extraordinarily cunning one at that. I'm deeply obliged to you. We must talk it over again.' He looked at his

'Two o'clock,' said Mr Bunner, consulting his own, as he got up from the foot board. 'Ten a.m. in little old

New York. You don't know Wall Street, Mr Trent. Let's you and I hope we never see anything nearer hell

The sea broke raging upon the foot of the cliff under a good breeze; the sun flooded the land with life from a

dappled blue sky. In this perfection of English weather Trent, who had slept ill, went down before eight

o'clock to a pool among the rocks, the direction of which had been given him, and dived deep into clear

water. Between vast grey boulders he swam out to the tossing open, forced himself some little way against a

coastwise current, and then returned to his refuge battered and refreshed. Ten minutes later he was scaling

the cliff again, and his mind, cleared for the moment of a heavy disgust for the affair he had in hand, was

It was the day of the inquest, the day after his arrival in the place. He had carried matters not much further

after parting with the American on the road to Bishopsbridge. In the afternoon he had walked from the inn

into the town, accompanied by Mr Cupples, and had there made certain purchases at a chemist's shop,

conferred privately for some time with a photographer, sent off a reply paid telegram, and made an enquiry

at the telephone exchange. He had said but little about the case to Mr Cupples, who seemed incurious on his

side, and nothing at all about the results of his investigation or the steps he was about to take. After their

return from Bishopsbridge, Trent had written a long dispatch for the Record and sent it to be telegraphed by

the proud hands of the paper's local representative. He had afterwards dined with Mr Cupples, and had spent

This morning as he scaled the cliff he told himself that he had never taken up a case he liked so little, or

which absorbed him so much. The more he contemplated it in the golden sunshine of this new day, the more

evil and the more challenging it appeared. All that he suspected and all that he almost knew had occupied his

questing brain for hours to the exclusion of sleep; and in this glorious light and air, though washed in body

and spirit by the fierce purity of the sea, he only saw the more clearly the darkness of the guilt in which he

believed, and was more bitterly repelled by the motive at which he guessed. But now at least his zeal was

awake again, and the sense of the hunt quickened. He would neither slacken nor spare; here need be no

compunction. In the course of the day, he hoped, his net would be complete. He had work to do in the

morning; and with very vivid expectancy, though not much serious hope, he awaited the answer to the

The path back to the hotel wound for some way along the top of the cliff, and on nearing a spot he had

marked from the sea level, where the face had fallen away long ago, he approached the edge and looked

down, hoping to follow with his eyes the most delicately beautiful of all the movements of waterthe wash

of a light sea over broken rock. But no rock was there. A few feet below him a broad ledge stood out, a rough

platform as large as a great room, thickly grown with wiry grass and walled in steeply on three sides. There,

close to the verge where the cliff at last dropped sheer, a woman was sitting, her arms about her drawnup

knees, her eyes fixed on the trailing smoke of a distant liner, her face full of some dream.

This woman seemed to Trent, whose training had taught him to live in his eyes, to make the most beautiful

picture he had ever seen. Her face of southern pallor, touched by the kiss of the wind with colour on the

cheek, presented to him a profile of delicate regularity in which there was nothing hard; nevertheless the

black brows bending down toward the point where they almost met gave her in repose a look of something

like severity, strangely redeemed by the open curves of the mouth. Trent said to himself that the absurdity or

otherwise of a lover writing sonnets to his mistress's eyebrow depended after all on the quality of the

eyebrow. Her nose was of the straight and fine sort, exquisitely escaping the perdition of too much length,

which makes a conscientious mind ashamed that it cannot help, on occasion, admiring the tiptilted. Her hat

lay pinned to the grass beside her, and the lively breeze played with her thick dark hair, blowing backward

the two broad bandeaux that should have covered much of her forehead, and agitating a hundred tiny curls

from the mass gathered at her nape. Everything about this lady was black, from her shoes of suede to the hat

that she had discarded; lustreless black covered her to her bare throat. All she wore was fine and well put on.

Dreamy and delicate of spirit as her looks declared her, it was very plain that she was longpractised as only

a woman grown can be in dressing well, the oldest of the arts, and had her touch of primal joy in the

excellence of the body that was so admirably curved now in the attitude of embraced knees. With the

suggestion of French taste in her clothes, she made a very modern figure seated there, until one looked at her

face and saw the glow and triumph of all vigorous beings that ever faced sun and wind and sea together in the

prime of the year. One saw, too, a womanhood so unmixed and vigorous, so unconsciously sure of itself, as

Trent, who had halted only for a moment in the surprise of seeing the woman in black, had passed by on the

cliff above her, perceiving and feeling as he went the things set down. At all times his keen vision and active

brain took in and tasted details with an easy swiftness that was marvellous to men of slower chemistry; the

need to stare, he held, was evidence of blindness. Now the feeling of beauty was awakened and exultant, and

doubled the power of his sense. In these instants a picture was printed on his memory that would never pass

As he went by unheard on the turf the woman, still alone with her thoughts, suddenly moved. She unclasped

her long hands from about her knees, stretched her limbs and body with feline grace, then slowly raised her

head and extended her arms with open, curving fingers, as if to gather to her all the glory and overwhelming

sanity of the morning. This was a gesture not to be mistaken: it was a gesture of freedom, the movement of a

So he saw her for an instant as he passed, and he did not turn. He knew suddenly who the woman must be,

and it was as if a curtain of gloom were drawn between him and the splendour of the day.

During breakfast at the hotel Mr Cupples found Trent little inclined to talk. He excused himself on the plea of

a restless night. Mr Cupples, on the other hand, was in a state of birdlike alertness. The prospect of the

inquest seemed to enliven him. He entertained Trent with a disquisition upon the history of that most ancient

and once busy tribunal, the coroner's court, and remarked upon the enviable freedom of its procedure from

the shackles of rule and precedent. From this he passed to the case that was to come before it that morning.

'Young Bunner mentioned to me last night,' he said, 'when I went up there after dinner, the hypothesis which

he puts forward in regard to the crime. A very remarkable young man, Trent. His meaning is occasionally

obscure, but in my opinion he is gifted with a clearheaded knowledge of the world quite unusual in one of his

apparent age. Indeed, his promotion by Manderson to the position of his principal lieutenant speaks for itself.

He seems to have assumed with perfect confidence the control at this end of the wire, as he expresses it, of

the complicated business situation caused by the death of his principal, and he has advised very wisely as to

the steps I should take on Mabel's behalf, and the best course for her to pursue until effect has been given to

the provisions of the will. I was accordingly less disposed than I might otherwise have been to regard his

suggestion of an industrial vendetta as farfetched. When I questioned him he was able to describe a number

of cases in which attacks of one sort or anothertoo often successfulhad been made upon the lives of

persons who had incurred the hostility of powerful labour organizations. This is a terrible time in which we

live, my dear boy. There is none recorded in history, I think, in which the disproportion between the material

and the moral constituents of society has been so great or so menacing to the permanence of the fabric. But

nowhere, in my judgement, is the prospect so dark as it is in the United States.'

'I thought,' said Trent listlessly, 'that Puritanism was about as strong there as the moneygetting craze.'

'Your remark,' answered Mr Cupples, with as near an approach to humour as was possible to him, 'is not in

the nature of a testimonial to what you call Puritanisma convenient rather than an accurate term; for I need

not remind you that it was invented to describe an Anglican party which aimed at the purging of the services

and ritual of their Church from certain elements repugnant to them. The sense of your observation, however,

is none the less sound, and its truth is extremely well illustrated by the case of Manderson himself, who had, I

believe, the virtues of purity, abstinence, and selfrestraint in their strongest form. No, Trent, there are other

and more worthy things among the moral constituents of which I spoke; and in our finite nature, the more we

preoccupy ourselves with the bewildering complexity of external apparatus which science places in our

hands, the less vigour have we left for the development of the holier purposes of humanity within us.

Agricultural machinery has abolished the festival of the Harvest Home. Mechanical travel has abolished the

inn, or all that was best in it. I need not multiply instances. The view I am expressing to you,' pursued Mr

Cupples, placidly buttering a piece of toast, 'is regarded as fundamentally erroneous by many of those who

think generally as I do about the deeper concerns of life, but I am nevertheless firmly persuaded of its truth.'

'It needs epigrammatic expression,' said Trent, rising from the table. 'If only it could be crystallized into some

handy formula, like "No Popery", or "Tax the Foreigner", you would find multitudes to go to the stake for it.

But you were planning to go to White Gables before the inquest, I think. You ought to be off if you are to get

back to the court in time. I have something to attend to there myself, so we might walk up together. I will just

'By all means,' Mr Cupples answered; and they set off at once in the ever growing warmth of the morning.

The roof of White Gables, a surly patch of dull red against the dark trees, seemed to harmonize with Trent's

mood; he felt heavy, sinister, and troubled. If a blow must fall that might strike down that creature radiant of

beauty and life whom he had seen that morning, he did not wish it to come from his hand. An exaggerated

chivalry had lived in Trent since the first teachings of his mother; but at this moment the horror of bruising

anything so lovely was almost as much the artist's revulsion as the gentleman's. On the other hand, was the

hunt to end in nothing? The quality of the affair was such that the thought of forbearance was an agony.

There never was such a case; and he alone, he was confident, held the truth of it under his hand. At least, he

determined, that day should show whether what he believed was a delusion. He would trample his

compunction underfoot until he was quite sure that there was any call for it. That same morning he would

As they entered at the gate of the drive they saw Marlowe and the American standing in talk before the front

She saw them, and came gravely forward over the lawn, moving as Trent had known that she would move,

erect and balanced, stepping lightly. When she welcomed him on Mr Cupples's presentation her eyes of

goldenflecked brown observed him kindly. In her pale composure, worn as the mask of distress, there was

no trace of the emotion that had seemed a halo about her head on the ledge of the cliff. She spoke the

appropriate commonplace in a low and even voice. After a few words to Mr Cupples she turned her eyes on

He made his mind up as the words left her lips. He said, 'I believe I shall do so, Mrs Manderson. When I have

the case sufficiently complete I shall ask you to let me see you and tell you about it. It may be necessary to

She looked puzzled, and distress showed for an instant in her eyes. 'If it is necessary, of course you shall do

On the brink of his next speech Trent hesitated. He remembered that the lady had not wished to repeat to him

the story already given to the inspectoror to be questioned at all. He was not unconscious that he desired to

hear her voice and watch her face a little longer, if it might be; but the matter he had to mention really

troubled his mind, it was a queer thing that fitted nowhere into the pattern within whose corners he had by

this time brought the other queer things in the case. It was very possible that she could explain it away in a

'You have been so kind,' he said, 'in allowing me access to the house and every opportunity of studying the

case, that I am going to ask leave to put a question or two to yourselfnothing that you would rather not

She glanced at him wearily. 'It would be stupid of me to refuse, Ask your questions, Mr Trent.' 'It's only this,'

said Trent hurriedly. 'We know that your husband lately drew an unusually large sum of ready money from

his London bankers, and was keeping it here. It is here now, in fact. Have you any idea why he should have

She opened her eyes in astonishment. 'I cannot imagine,' she said. 'I did not know he had done so. I am very

'I thought my husband had very little money in the house. On Sunday night, just before he went out in the

motor, he came into the drawingroom where I was sitting. He seemed to be irritated about something, and

asked me at once if I had any notes or gold I could let him have until next day. I was surprised at that,

because he was never without money; he made it a rule to carry a hundred pounds or so about him always in

a notecase. I unlocked my escritoire, and gave him all I had by me. It was nearly thirty pounds.'

'No. He put it in his pocket, and then said that Mr Marlowe had persuaded him to go for a run in the motor by

moonlight, and he thought it might help him to sleep. He had been sleeping badly, as perhaps you know.

Then he went off with Mr Marlowe. I thought it odd he should need money on Sunday night, but I soon

'It was curious, certainly,' said Trent, staring into the distance. Mr Cupples began to speak to his niece of the

arrangements for the inquest, and Trent moved away to where Marlowe was pacing slowly upon the lawn.

The young man seemed relieved to talk about the coming business of the day. Though he still seemed tired

out and nervous, he showed himself not without a quiet humour in describing the pomposities of the local

police and the portentous airs of Dr Stock. Trent turned the conversation gradually toward the problem of the

'Bunner has told me what he thinks,' he said when Trent referred to the American's theory. 'I don't find myself

convinced by it, because it doesn't really explain some of the oddest facts. But I have lived long enough in the

United States to know that such a stroke of revenge, done in a secret, melodramatic way, is not an unlikely

thing. It is quite a characteristic feature of certain sections of the labour movement there. Americans have a

'Well, I think the most American thing in that great American epic is Tom Sawyer's elaboration of an

extremely difficult and romantic scheme, taking days to carry out, for securing the escape of the nigger Jim,

which could have been managed quite easily in twenty minutes. You know how fond they are of lodges and

brotherhoods. Every college club has its secret signs and handgrips. You've heard of the KnowNothing

movement in politics, I dare say, and the Ku Klux Klan. Then look at Brigham Young's pennydreadful

tyranny in Utah, with real blood. The founders of the Mormon State were of the purest Yankee stock in

America; and you know what they did. It's all part of the same mental tendency. Americans make fun of it

'It can have a very hideous side to it, certainly,' said Trent, 'when you get it in connection with crimeor

with viceor even mere luxury. But I have a sort of sneaking respect for the determination to make life

interesting and lively in spite of civilization. To return to the matter in hand, however; has it struck you as a

possibility that Manderson's mind was affected to some extent by this menace that Bunner believes in? For

instance, it was rather an extraordinary thing to send you posting off like that in the middle of the night.'

'About ten o'clock, to be exact,' replied Marlowe. 'Though, mind you, if he'd actually roused me out of my

bed at midnight I shouldn't have been very much surprised. It all chimes in with what we've just been saying.

Manderson had a strong streak of the national taste for dramatic proceedings. He was rather fond of his

wellearned reputation for unexpected strokes and for going for his object with ruthless directness through

every opposing consideration. He had decided suddenly that he wanted to have word from this man Harris'

'Nobody knows. Even Bunner never heard of him, and can't imagine what the business in hand was. All I

know is that when I went up to London last week to attend to various things I booked a deckcabin, at

Manderson's request, for a Mr George Harris on the boat that sailed on Monday. It seems that Manderson

suddenly found he wanted news from Harris which presumably was of a character too secret for the

Trent looked round to make sure that they were not overheard, then faced the other gravely, 'There is one

thing I may tell you,' he said quietly, 'that I don't think you know. Martin the butler caught a few words at the

end of your conversation with Manderson in the orchard before you started with him in the car, He heard him

say, "If Harris is there, every moment is of importance." Now, Mr Marlowe, you know my business here. I

am sent to make enquiries, and you mustn't take offence. I want to ask you if, in the face of that sentence, you

Marlowe shook his head. 'I know nothing, indeed. I'm not easily offended, and your question is quite fair.

What passed during that conversation I have already told the detective. Manderson plainly said to me that he

could not tell me what it was all about. He simply wanted me to find Harris, tell him that he desired to know

how matters stood, and bring back a letter or message from him. Harris, I was further told, might not turn up.

'That talk took place before he told his wife that you were taking him for a moonlight run. Why did he

The young man made a gesture of helplessness. 'Why? I can guess no better than you.'

'Why,' muttered Trent as if to himself, gazing on the ground, 'did he conceal itfrom Mrs Manderson?' He

With a sudden movement of his head Trent seemed to dismiss the subject. He drew from his breastpocket a

'Just look at these two slips, Mr Marlowe,' he said. 'Did you ever see them before? Have you any idea where

they come from?' he added as Marlowetook one in each hand and examined them curiously.

'They seem to have been cut with a knife or scissors from a small diary for this year from the October pages,'

Marlowe observed, looking them over on both sides. 'I see no writing of any kind on them. Nobody here has

'There may be nothing in it,' Trent said dubiously. 'Any one in the house, of course, might have such a diary

without your having seen it. But I didn't much expect you would be able to identify the leavesin fact, I

He stopped speaking as Mrs Manderson came towards them. 'My uncle thinks we should be going now,' she

'I think I will walk on with Mr Bunner,' Mr Cupples said as he joined them. 'There are certain business

matters that must be disposed of as soon as possible. Will you come on with these two gentlemen, Mabel?

Trent turned to her. 'Mrs Manderson will excuse me, I hope,' he said. 'I really came up this morning in order

to look about me here for some indications I thought I might possibly find. I had not thought of attending

She looked at him with eyes of perfect candour. 'Of course, Mr Trent. Please do exactly as you wish. We are

all relying upon you. If you will wait a few moments, Mr Marlowe, I shall be ready.'

She entered the house. Her uncle and the American had already strolled towards the gate.

Trent looked into the eyes of his companion. 'That is a wonderful woman,' he said in a lowered voice.

'You say so without knowing her,' replied Marlowe in a similar tone. 'She is more than that.'

Trent said nothing to this. He stared out over the fields towards the sea. In the silence a noise of hobnailed

haste rose on the still air. A little distance down the road a boy appeared trotting towards them from the

direction of the hotel. In his hand was the orange envelope, unmistakable afar off, of a telegram. Trent

watched him with an indifferent eye as he met and passed the two others. Then he turned to Marlowe. 'A

'I just wondered if I was right in my guess. It's one of the things you can very often tell about a man, isn't it?'

'I suppose so,' Marlowe said. 'Well, each of us is marked in one way or another, perhaps. I should have said

'Oh, no! It's only that you look at things and people as I've seen artists do, with an eye that moves steadily

The boy came up panting. 'Telegram for you, sir,' he said to Trent. 'Just come, sir.'

Trent tore open the envelope with an apology, and his eyes lighted up so visibly as he read the slip that

Trent turned on him a glance in which nothing could be read. 'Not exactly news,' he said. 'It only tells me that

The coroner, who fully realized that for that one day of his life as a provincial solicitor he was living in the

gaze of the world, had resolved to be worthy of the fleeting eminence. He was a large man of jovial temper,

with a strong interest in the dramatic aspects of his work, and the news of Manderson's mysterious death

within his jurisdiction had made him the happiest coroner in England. A respectable capacity for marshalling

facts was fortified in him by a copiousness of impressive language that made juries as clay in his hands, and

The court was held in a long, unfurnished room lately built on to the hotel, and intended to serve as a

ballroom or concerthall. A regiment of reporters was entrenched in the front seats, and those who were to be

called on to give evidence occupied chairs to one side of the table behind which the coroner sat, while the

jury, in double row, with plastered hair and a spurious ease of manner, flanked him on the other side. An

undistinguished public filled the rest of the space, and listened, in an awed silence, to the opening

solemnities. The newspaper men, well used to these, muttered among themselves. Those of them who knew

The identity of the dead man was proved by his wife, the first witness called, from whom the coroner, after

some enquiry into the health and circumstances of the deceased, proceeded to draw an account of the last

occasion on which she had seen her husband alive. Mrs Manderson was taken through her evidence by the

coroner with the sympathy which every man felt for that dark figure of grief. She lifted her thick veil before

beginning to speak, and the extreme paleness and unbroken composure of the lady produced a singular

impression. This was not an impression of hardness. Interesting femininity was the first thing to be felt in her

presence. She was not even enigmatic. It was only clear that the force of a powerful character was at work to

master the emotions of her situation. Once or twice as she spoke she touched her eyes with her handkerchief,

Her husband, she said, had come up to his bedroom about his usual hour for retiring on Sunday night. His

room was really a dressingroom attached to her own bedroom, communicating with it by a door which was

usually kept open during the night. Both dressingroom and bedroom were entered by other doors giving on

the passage. Her husband had always had a preference for the greatest simplicity in his bedroom

arrangements, and liked to sleep in a small room. She had not been awake when he came up, but had been

halfaroused, as usually happened, when the light was switched on in her husband's room. She had spoken to

him. She had no clear recollection of what she had said, as she had been very drowsy at the time; but she had

remembered that he had been out for a moonlight run in the car, and she believed she had asked whether he

had had a good run, and what time it was. She had asked what the time was because she felt as if she had only

been a very short time asleep, and she had expected her husband to be out very late. In answer to her question

he had told her it was halfpast eleven, and had gone on to say that he had changed his mind about going for

'Yes,' replied the lady, 'he did explain why. I remember very well what he said, because' she stopped with a

'Because my husband was not as a rule communicative about his business affairs,' answered the witness,

raising her chin with a faint touch of defiance. 'He did notdid not think they would interest me, and as a

rule referred to them as little as possible. That was why I was rather surprised when he told me that he had

sent Mr Marlowe to Southampton to bring back some important information from a man who was leaving for

Paris by the next day's boat. He said that Mr Marlowe could do it quite easily if he had no accident. He said

that he had started in the car, and then walked back home a mile or so, and felt all the better for it.'

'Nothing, as well as I remember,' the witness said. 'I was very sleepy, and I dropped off again in a few

moments. I just remember my husband turning his light out, and that is all. I never saw him again alive.'

'No: I never woke until my maid brought my tea in the morning at seven o'clock. She closed the door leading

to my husband's room, as she always did, and I supposed him to be still there. He always needed a great deal

of sleep. He sometimes slept until quite late in the morning. I had breakfast in my sitting room. It was about

ten when I heard that my husband's body had been found.' The witness dropped her head and silently waited

'Mrs Manderson.' The coroner's voice was sympathetic, but it had a hint of firmness in it now. 'The question I

am going to put to you must, in these sad circumstances, be a painful one; but it is my duty to ask it. Is it the

fact that your relations with your late husband had not been, for some time past, relations of mutual affection

The lady drew herself up again and faced her questioner, the colour rising in her cheeks. 'If that question is

necessary,' she said with cold distinctness, 'I will answer it so that there shall be no misunderstanding. During

the last few months of my husband's life his attitude towards me had given me great anxiety and sorrow. He

had changed towards me; he had become very reserved, and seemed mistrustful. I saw much less of him than

before; he seemed to prefer to be alone. I can give no explanation at all of the change. I tried to work against

it; I did all I could with justice to my own dignity, as I thought. Something was between us, I did not know

what, and he never told me. My own obstinate pride prevented me from asking what it was in so many words;

I only made a point of being to him exactly as I had always been, so far as he would allow me. I suppose I

shall never know now what it was.' The witness, whose voice had trembled in spite of her selfcontrol over

the last few sentences, drew down her veil when she had said this, and stood erect and quiet.

One of the jury asked a question, not without obvious hesitation. 'Then was there never anything of the nature

'Never.' The word was colourlessly spoken; but every one felt that a crass misunderstanding of the

possibilities of conduct in the case of a person like Mrs Manderson had been visited with some severity.

Did she know, the coroner asked, of any other matter which might have been preying upon her husband's

Mrs Manderson knew of none whatever. The coroner intimated that her ordeal was at an end, and the veiled

lady made her way to the door. The general attention, which followed her for a few moments, was now

It was at this moment that Trent appeared at the doorway and edged his way into the great room. But he did

not look at Martin. He was observing the well balanced figure that came quickly toward him along an

opening path in the crowd, and his eye was gloomy. He started, as he stood aside from the door with a slight

bow, to hear Mrs Manderson address him by name in a low voice. He followed her a pace or two into the

'I wanted to ask you,' she said in a voice now weak and oddly broken, 'if you would give me your arm a part

of the way to the house. I could not see my uncle near the door, and I suddenly felt rather faint .... I shall be

better in the air .... No, no; I cannot stay hereplease, Mr Trent!' she said, as he began to make an obvious

suggestion. 'I must go to the house.' Her hand tightened momentarily on his arm as if, for all her weakness,

she could drag him from the place; then again she leaned heavily upon it, and with that support, and with bent

head, she walked slowly from the hotel and along the oakshaded path toward White Gables.

Trent went in silence, his thoughts whirling, dancing insanely to a chorus of 'Fool! fool!' All that he alone

knew, all that he guessed and suspected of this affair, rushed through his brain in a rout; but the touch of her

unnerved hand upon his arm never for an instant left his consciousness, filling him with an exaltation that

enraged and bewildered him. He was still cursing himself furiously behind the mask of conventional

solicitude that he turned to the lady when he had attended her to the house and seen her sink upon a couch in

the morningroom. Raising her veil, she thanked him gravely and frankly, with a look of sincere gratitude in

her eyes. She was much better now, she said, and a cup of tea would work a miracle upon her. She hoped she

had not taken him away from anything important. She was ashamed of herself; she thought she could go

through with it, but she had not expected those last questions. 'I am glad you did not hear me,' she said when

he explained. 'But of course you will read it all in the reports. It shook me so to have to speak of that,' she

added simply; 'and to keep from making an exhibition of myself took it out of me. And all those staring men

by the door! Thank you again for helping me when I asked you .... I thought I might,' she ended queerly, with

a little tired smile; and Trent took himself away, his hand still quivering from the cool touch of her fingers.

The testimony of the servants and of the finder of the body brought nothing new to the reporters' net. That of

the police was as colourless and cryptic as is usual at the inquest stage of affairs of the kind. Greatly to the

satisfaction of Mr Bunner, his evidence afforded the sensation of the day, and threw far into the background

the interesting revelation of domestic difficulty made by the dead man's wife. He told the court in substance

what he had already told Trent. The flying pencils did not miss a word of the young American's story, and it

appeared with scarcely the omission of a sentence in every journal of importance in Great Britain and the

Public opinion next day took no note of the faint suggestion of the possibility of suicide which the coroner, in

his final address to the jury, had thought it right to make in connection with the lady's evidence. The weight

of evidence, as the official had indeed pointed out, was against such a theory. He had referred with emphasis

'This question, of course, is allimportant, gentlemen,' he had said to the jury. 'It is, in fact, the main issue

before you. You have seen the body for yourselves. You have just heard the medical evidence; but I think it

would be well for me to read you my notes of it in so far as they bear on this point, in order to refresh your

memories. Dr Stock told youI am going to omit all technical medical language and repeat to you merely

the plain English of his testimonythat in his opinion death had taken place six or eight hours previous to

the finding of the body. He said that the cause of death was a bullet wound, the bullet having entered the left

eye, which was destroyed, and made its way to the base of the brain, which was quite shattered. The external

appearance of the wound, he said, did not support the hypothesis of its being selfinflicted, inasmuch as there

were no signs of the firearm having been pressed against the eye, or even put very close to it; at the same time

it was not physically impossible that the weapon should have been discharged by the deceased with his own

hand, at some small distance from the eye. Dr Stock also told us that it was impossible to say with certainty,

from the state of the body, whether any struggle had taken place at the time of death; that when seen by him,

at which time he understood that it had not been moved since it was found, the body was lying in a collapsed

position such as might very well result from the shot alone; but that the scratches and bruises upon the wrists

and the lower part of the arms had been very recently inflicted, and were, in his opinion, marks of violence.

'In connection with this same point, the remarkable evidence given by Mr Bunner cannot be regarded, I think,

as without significance. It may have come as a surprise to some of you to hear that risks of the character

described by this witness are, in his own country, commonly run by persons in the position of the deceased.

On the other hand, it may have been within the knowledge of some of you that in the industrial world of

America the discontent of labour often proceeds to lengths of which we in England happily know nothing. I

have interrogated the witness somewhat fully upon this. At the same time, gentlemen, I am by no means

suggesting that Mr Bunner's personal conjecture as to the cause of death can fitly be adopted by you. That is

emphatically not the case. What his evidence does is to raise two questions for your consideration. First, can

it be said that the deceased was to any extent in the position of a threatened manof a man more exposed to

the danger of murderous attack than an ordinary person? Second, does the recent alteration in his demeanour,

as described by this witness, justify the belief that his last days were overshadowed by a great anxiety? These

points may legitimately be considered by you in arriving at a conclusion upon the rest of the evidence.'

Thereupon the coroner, having indicated thus clearly his opinion that Mr Bunner had hit the right nail on the

Mr Cupples entered his sittingroom at the hotel. It was the early evening of the day on which the coroner's

jury, without leaving the box, had pronounced the expected denunciation of a person or persons unknown.

Trent, with a hasty glance upward, continued his intent study of what lay in a photographic dish of enamelled

metal, which he moved slowly about in the light of the window. He looked very pale, and his movements

'Sit on the sofa,' he advised. 'The chairs are a job lot bought at the sale after the suppression of the Holy

Inquisition in Spain. This is a pretty good negative,' he went on, holding it up to the light with his head at the

angle of discriminating judgement. 'Washed enough now, I think. Let us leave it to dry, and get rid of all this

Mr Cupples, as the other busily cleared the table of a confusion of basins, dishes, racks, boxes, and bottles,

picked up first one and then another of the objects and studied them with innocent curiosity.

'That is called hypoeliminator,' said Trent, as Mr Cupples uncorked and smelt at one of the bottles. 'Very

useful when you're in a hurry with a negative. I shouldn't drink it, though, all the same. It eliminates sodium

hypophosphite, but I shouldn't wonder if it would eliminate human beings too.' He found a place for the last

of the litter on the crowded mantelshelf, and came to sit before Mr Cupples on the table. 'The great thing

about a hotel sittingroom is that its beauty does not distract the mind from work. It is no place for the

mayfly pleasures of a mind at ease. Have you ever been in this room before, Cupples? I have, hundreds of

times. It has pursued me all over England for years. I should feel lost without it if, in some fantastic, faroff

hotel, they were to give me some other sittingroom. Look at this tablecover; there is the ink I spilt on it

when I had this room in Halifax. I burnt that hole in the carpet when I had it in Ipswich. But I see they have

mended the glass over the picture of "Silent Sympathy", which I threw a boot at in Banbury. I do all my best

work here. This afternoon, for instance, since the inquest, I have finished several excellent negatives. There is

'The inquestthat reminds me,' said Mr Cupples, who knew that this sort of talk in Trent meant the

excitement of action, and was wondering what he could be about. 'I came in to thank you, my dear fellow, for

looking after Mabel this morning. I had no idea she was going to feel ill after leaving the box; she seemed

quite unmoved, and, really, she is a woman of such extraordinary self command, I thought I could leave her

to her own devices and hear out the evidence, which I thought it important I should do. It was a very fortunate

thing she found a friend to assist her, and she is most grateful. She is quite herself again now.'

Trent, with his hands in his pockets and a slight frown on his brow, made no reply to this. 'I tell you what,' he

said after a short pause, 'I was just getting to the really interesting part of the job when you came in. Come;

would you like to see a little bit of highclass police work? It's the very same kind of work that old Murch

ought to be doing at this moment. Perhaps he is; but I hope to glory he isn't.' He sprang off the table and

disappeared into his bedroom. Presently he came out with a large drawingboard on which a number of

'First I must introduce you to these little things,' he said, setting them out on the table. 'Here is a big ivory

paperknife; here are two leaves cut out of a diarymy own diary; here is a bottle containing dentifrice; here

is a little case of polished walnut. Some of these things have to be put back where they belong in somebody's

bedroom at White Gables before night. That's the sort of man I amnothing stops me. I borrowed them this

very morning when every one was down at the inquest, and I dare say some people would think it rather an

odd proceeding if they knew. Now there remains one object on the board. Can you tell me, without touching

'Certainly I can,' said Mr Cupples, peering at it with great interest. 'It is an ordinary glass bowl. It looks like a

fingerbowl. I see nothing odd about it,' he added after some moments of close scrutiny.

'I can't see much myself,' replied Trent, 'and that is exactly where the fun comes in. Now take this little fat

bottle, Cupples, and pull out the cork. Do you recognize that powder inside it? You have swallowed pounds

of it in your time, I expect. They give it to babies. Grey powder is its ordinary name mercury and chalk. It

is great stuff. Now, while I hold the basin sideways over this sheet of paper, I want you to pour a little powder

out of the bottle over this part of the bowljust here .... Perfect! Sir Edward Henry himself could not have

handled the powder better. You have done this before, Cupples, I can see. You are an old hand.'

'I really am not,' said Mr Cupples seriously, as Trent returned the fallen powder to the bottle. 'I assure you it

'I brush the powdered part of the bowl lightly with this camelhair brush. Now look at it again. You saw

Mr Cupples peered again. 'How curious!' he said. 'Yes, there are two large grey fingermarks on the bowl.

'I am Hawkshaw the detective,' observed Trent. 'Would it interest you to hear a short lecture on the subject of

glass fingerbowls? When you take one up with your hand you leave traces upon it, usually practically

invisible, which may remain for days or months. You leave the marks of your fingers. The human hand, even

when quite clean, is never quite dry, and sometimesin moments of great anxiety, for instance, Cupplesit

is very moist. It leaves a mark on any cold smooth surface it may touch. That bowl was moved by somebody

with a rather moist hand quite lately.' He sprinkled the powder again. 'Here on the other side, you see, is the

thumbmark very good impressions all of them.' He spoke without raising his voice, but Mr Cupples could

perceive that he was ablaze with excitement as he stared at the faint grey marks. 'This one should be the index

finger. I need not tell a man of your knowledge of the world that the pattern of it is a singlespiral whorl,

with deltas symmetrically disposed. This, the print of the second finger, is a simple loop, with a staple core

and fifteen counts. I know there are fifteen, because I have just the same two prints on this negative, which I

have examined in detail. Look!'he held one of the negatives up to the light of the declining sun and

demonstrated with a pencil point. 'You can see they're the same. You see the bifurcation of that ridge. There it

is in the other. You see that little scar near the centre. There it is in the other. There are a score of

ridgecharacteristics on which an expert would swear in the witnessbox that the marks on that bowl and the

'And where did you photograph them? What does it all mean?' asked Mr Cupples, wideeyed.

'I found them on the inside of the lefthand leaf of the front window in Mrs Manderson's bedroom. As I could

not bring the window with me, I photographed them, sticking a bit of black paper on the other side of the

glass for the purpose. The bowl comes from Manderson's room. It is the bowl in which his false teeth were

'I should think not!' said Trent with decision. 'They are twice the size of any print Mrs Manderson could

'Perhaps they are. Now shall we see if we can match them once more? I believe we can.' Whistling faintly,

and very white in the face, Trent opened another small squat bottle containing a dense black powder.

'Lampblack,' he explained. 'Hold a bit of paper in your hand for a second or two, and this little chap will

show you the pattern of your fingers.' He carefully took up with a pair of tweezers one of the leaves cut from

his diary, and held it out for the other to examine. No marks appeared on the leaf. He tilted some of the

powder out upon one surface of the paper, then, turning it over, upon the other; then shook the leaf gently to

rid it of the loose powder. He held it out to Mr Cupples in silence. On one side of the paper appeared

unmistakably, clearly printed in black, the same two fingerprints that he had already seen on the bowl and

on the photographic plate. He took up the bowl and compared them. Trent turned the paper over, and on the

other side was a bold black replica of the thumbmark that was printed in grey on the glass in his hand.

'Same man, you see,' Trent said with a short laugh. 'I felt that it must be so, and now I know.' He walked to

the window and looked out. 'Now I know,' he repeated in a low voice, as if to himself. His tone was bitter. Mr

Cupples, understanding nothing, stared at his motionless back for a few moments.

'I am still completely in the dark,' he ventured presently. 'I have often heard of this fingerprint business, and

wondered how the police went to work about it. It is of extraordinary interest to me, but upon my life I cannot

'I am very sorry, Cupples,' Trent broke in upon his meditative speech with a swift return to the table. 'When I

began this investigation I meant to take you with me every step of the way. You mustn't think I have any

doubts about your discretion if I say now that I must hold my tongue about the whole thing, at least for a

time. I will tell you this: I have come upon a fact that looks too much like having very painful consequences

if it is discovered by any one else.' He looked at the other with a hard and darkened face, and struck the table

with his hand. 'It is terrible for me here and now. Up to this moment I was hoping against hope that I was

wrong about the fact. I may still be wrong in the surmise that I base upon that fact. There is only one way of

finding out that is open to me, and I must nerve myself to take it.' He smiled suddenly at Mr Cupples's face of

consternation. 'All rightI'm not going to be tragic any more, and I'll tell you all about it when I can. Look

He drew one of the defamed chairs to the table and sat down to test the broad ivory blade of the paper knife.

Mr Cupples, swallowing his amazement, bent forward in an attitude of deep interest and handed Trent the

Mrs Manderson stood at the window of her sittingroom at White Gables gazing out upon a wavering

landscape of fine rain and mist. The weather had broken as it seldom does in that part in June. White

wreathings drifted up the fields from the sullen sea; the sky was an unbroken grey deadness shedding

pinpoint moisture that was now and then blown against the panes with a crepitation of despair. The lady

looked out on the dim and chilling prospect with a woeful face. It was a bad day for a woman bereaved,

There was a knock, and she called 'Come in,' drawing herself up with an unconscious gesture that always

came when she realized that the weariness of the world had been gaining upon her spirit. Mr Trent had called,

the maid said; he apologized for coming at such an early hour, but hoped that Mrs Manderson would see him

on a matter of urgent importance. Mrs Manderson would see Mr Trent. She walked to a mirror, looked into

the olive face she saw reflected there, shook her head at herself with the flicker of a grimace, and turned to

His appearance, she noted, was changed. He had the jaded look of the sleepless, and a new and reserved

expression, in which her quick sensibilities felt something not propitious, took the place of his half smile of

'May I come to the point at once?' he said, when she had given him her hand. 'There is a train I ought to catch

at Bishopsbridge at twelve o'clock, but I cannot go until I have settled this thing, which concerns you only,

Mrs Manderson. I have been working half the night and thinking the rest; and I know now what I ought to

'You look wretchedly tired,' she said kindly. 'Won't you sit down? This is a very restful chair. Of course it is

about this terrible business and your work as correspondent. Please ask me anything you think I can properly

tell you, Mr Trent. I know that you won't make it worse for me than you can help in doing your duty here. If

you say you must see me about something, I know it must be because, as you say, you ought to do it.'

'Mrs Manderson,' said Trent, slowly measuring his words, 'I won't make it worse for you than I can help. But

I am bound to make it bad for youonly between ourselves, I hope. As to whether you can properly tell me

what I shall ask you, you will decide that; but I tell you this on my word of honour: I shall ask you only as

much as will decide me whether to publish or to withhold certain grave things that I have found out about

your husband's death, things not suspected by any one else, nor, I think, likely to be so. What I have

discoveredwhat I believe that I have practically provedwill be a great shock to you in any case. But it

may be worse for you than that; and if you give me reason to think it would be so, then I shall suppress this

manuscript,' he laid a long envelope on the small table beside him, 'and nothing of what it has to tell shall

ever be printed. It consists, I may tell you, of a short private note to my editor, followed by a long dispatch

for publication in the Record. Now you may refuse to say anything to me. If you do refuse, my duty to my

employers, as I see it, is to take this up to London with me today and leave it with my editor to be dealt with

at his discretion. My view is, you understand, that I am not entitled to suppress it on the strength of a mere

possibility that presents itself to my imagination. But if I gather from youand I can gather it from no other

person that there is substance in that imaginary possibility I speak of, then I have only one thing to do as a

gentleman and as one who'he hesitated for a phrase 'wishes you well. I shall not publish that dispatch of

mine. In some directions I decline to assist the police. Have you followed me so far?' he asked with a touch of

anxiety in his careful coldness; for her face, but for its pallor, gave no sign as she regarded him, her hands

clasped before her, and her shoulders drawn back in a pose of rigid calm. She looked precisely as she had

'I understand quite well,' said Mrs Manderson in a low voice. She drew a deep breath, and went on: 'I don't

know what dreadful thing you have found out, or what the possibility that has occurred to you can be, but it

was good, it was honourable of you to come to me about it. Now will you please tell me?'

'I cannot do that,' Trent replied. 'The secret is my newspaper's if it is not yours. If I find it is yours, you shall

have my manuscript to read and destroy. Believe me,' he broke out with something of his old warmth, 'I

detest such mysterymaking from the bottom of my soul; but it is not I who have made this mystery. This is

the most painful hour of my life, and you make it worse by not treating me like a hound. The first thing I ask

you to tell me,' he reverted with an effort to his colourless tone, 'is this: is it true, as you stated at the inquest,

that you had no idea at all of the reason why your late husband had changed his attitude toward you, and

Mrs Manderson's dark brows lifted and her eyes flamed; she quickly rose from her chair. Trent got up at the

same moment, and took his envelope from the table; his manner said that he perceived the interview to be at

an end. But she held up a hand, and there was colour in her cheeks and quick breathing in her voice as she

'I do,' he answered unmoved; and he added after a pause, 'you knew already that I had not come here to

preserve the polite fictions, Mrs Manderson. The theory that no reputable person, being on oath, could

withhold a part of the truth under any circumstances is a polite fiction.' He still stood as awaiting dismissal,

but she was silent. She walked to the window, and he stood miserably watching the slight movement of her

shoulders until it subsided. Then with face averted, looking out on the dismal weather, she spoke at last

'Mr Trent,' she said, 'you inspire confidence in people, and I feel that things which I don't want known or

talked about are safe with you. And I know you must have a very serious reason for doing what you are

doing, though I don't know what it is. I suppose it would be assisting justice in some way if I told you the

truth about what you asked just now. To understand that truth you ought to know about what went beforeI

mean about my marriage. After all, a good many people could tell you as well as I can that it was not... a very

successful union. I was only twenty. I admired his force and courage and certainty; he was the only strong

man I had ever known. But it did not take me long to find out that he cared for his business more than for me,

and I think I found out even sooner that I had been deceiving myself and blinding myself, promising myself

impossible things and wilfully misunderstanding my own feelings, because I was dazzled by the idea of

having more money to spend than an English girl ever dreams of. I have been despising myself for that for

five years. My husband's feeling for me... well, I cannot speak of that ... what I want to say is that along with

it there had always been a belief of his that I was the sort of woman to take a great place in society, and that I

should throw myself into it with enjoyment, and become a sort of personage and do him great creditthat

was his idea; and the idea remained with him after other delusions had gone. I was a part of his ambition.

That was his really bitter disappointment, that I failed him as a social success. I think he was too shrewd not

to have known in his heart that such a man as he was, twenty years older than I, with great business

responsibilities that filled every hour of his life, and caring for nothing elsehe must have felt that there was

a risk of great unhappiness in marrying the sort of girl I was, brought up to music and books and unpractical

ideas, always enjoying myself in my own way. But he had really reckoned on me as a wife who would do the

Mrs Manderson had talked herself into a more emotional mood than she had yet shown to Trent. Her words

flowed freely, and her voice had begun to ring and give play to a natural expressiveness that must hitherto

have been dulled, he thought, by the shock and selfrestraint of the past few days. Now she turned swiftly

from the window and faced him as she went on, her beautiful face flushed and animated, her eyes gleaming,

her hands moving in slight emphatic gestures, as she surrendered herself to the impulse of giving speech to

'The people,' she said. 'Oh, those people! Can you imagine what it must be for any one who has lived in a

world where there was always creative work in the background, work with some dignity about it, men and

women with professions or arts to follow, with ideals and things to believe in and quarrel about, some of

them wealthy, some of them quite poor; can you think what it means to step out of that into another world

where you have to be very rich, shamefully rich, to exist at allwhere money is the only thing that counts

and the first thing in everybody's thoughtswhere the men who make the millions are so jaded by the work,

that sport is the only thing they can occupy themselves with when they have any leisure, and the men who

don't have to work are even duller than the men who do, and vicious as well; and the women live for display

and silly amusements and silly immoralities; do you know how awful that life is? Of course I know there are

clever people, and people of taste in that set, but they're swamped and spoiled, and it's the same thing in the

end; empty, empty! Oh! I suppose I'm exaggerating, and I did make friends and have some happy times; but

that's how I feel after it all. The seasons in New York and Londonhow I hated them! And our

houseparties and cruises in the yacht and the restthe same people, the same emptiness.

'And you see, don't you, that my husband couldn't have an idea of all this. His life was never empty. He did

not live it in society, and when he was in society he had always his business plans and difficulties to occupy

his mind. He hadn't a suspicion of what I felt, and I never let him know; I couldn't, it wouldn't have been fair.

I felt I must do something to justify myself as his wife, sharing his position and fortune; and the only thing I

could do was to try, and try, to live up to his idea about my social qualities... I did try. I acted my best. And it

became harder year by year... I never was what they call a popular hostess, how could I be? I was a failure;

but I went on trying... I used to steal holidays now and then. I used to feel as if I was not doing my part of a

bargainit sounds horrid to put it like that, I know, but it was sowhen I took one of my old

schoolfriends, who couldn't afford to travel, away to Italy for a month or two, and we went about cheaply all

by ourselves, and were quite happy; or when I went and made a long stay in London with some quiet people

who had known me all my life, and we all lived just as in the old days, when we had to think twice about

seats at the theatre, and told each other about cheap dressmakers. Those and a few other expeditions of the

same sort were my best times after I was married, and they helped me to go through with it the rest of the

time. But I felt my husband would have hated to know how much I enjoyed every hour of those returns to the

'And in the end, in spite of everything I could do, he came to know .... He could see through anything, I think,

once his attention was turned to it. He had always been able to see that I was not fulfilling his idea of me as a

figure in the social world, and I suppose he thought it was my misfortune rather than my fault. But the

moment he began to see, in spite of my pretending, that I wasn't playing my part with any spirit, he knew the

whole story; he divined how I loathed and was weary of the luxury and the brilliancy and the masses of

money just because of the people who lived among themwho were made so by them, I suppose .... It

happened last year. I don't know just how or when. It may have been suggested to him by some womanfor

they all understood, of course. He said nothing to me, and I think he tried not to change in his manner to me

at first; but such things hurtand it was working in both of us. I knew that he knew. After a time we were

just being polite and considerate to each other. Before he found me out we had been on a footing ofhow

can I express it to you?of intelligent companionship, I might say. We talked without restraint of many

things of the kind we could agree or disagree about without its going very deep... if you understand. And then

that came to an end. I felt that the only possible basis of our living in each other's company was going under

'It had been like that,' she ended simply, 'for months before he died.' She sank into the corner of a sofa by the

window, as though relaxing her body after an effort. For a few moments both were silent. Trent was hastily

sorting out a tangle of impressions. He was amazed at the frankness of Mrs Manderson's story. He was

amazed at the vigorous expressiveness in her telling of it. In this vivid being, carried away by an impulse to

speak, talking with her whole personality, he had seen the real woman in a temper of activity, as he had

already seen the real woman by chance in a temper of reverie and unguarded emotion. In both she was very

unlike the pale, selfdisciplined creature of majesty that she had been to the world. With that amazement of

his went something like terror of her dark beauty, which excitement kindled into an appearance scarcely

mortal in his eyes. Incongruously there rushed into his mind, occupied as it was with the affair of the

moment, a little knot of ideas... she was unique not because of her beauty but because of its being united with

intensity of nature; in England all the very beautiful women were placid, all the fiery women seemed to have

burnt up the best of their beauty; that was why no beautiful woman had ever cast this sort of spell on him

before; when it was a question of wit in women he had preferred the brighter flame to the duller, without

much regarding the lamp. 'All this is very disputable,' said his reason; and instinct answered, 'Yes, except that

I am under a spell'; and a deeper instinct cried out, 'Away with it!' He forced his mind back to her story, and

found growing swiftly in him an irrepressible conviction. It was all very fine; but it would not do.

'I feel as if I had led you into saying more than you meant to say, or than I wanted to learn,' he said slowly.

'But there is one brutal question which is the whole point of my enquiry.' He braced his frame like one

preparing for a plunge into cold waters. 'Mrs Manderson, will you assure me that your husband's change

And what he had dreaded came. 'Oh!' she cried with a sound of anguish, her face thrown up and open hands

stretched out as if for pity; and then the hands covered the burning face, and she flung herself aside among

the cushions at her elbow, so that he saw nothing but her heavy crown of black hair, and her body moving

with sobs that stabbed his heart, and a foot turned inward gracelessly in an abandonment of misery. Like a tall

Trent stood up, his face white and calm. With a senseless particularity he placed his envelope exactly in the

centre of the little polished table. He walked to the door, closed it noiselessly as he went out, and in a few

minutes was tramping through the rain out of sight of White Gables, going nowhere, seeing nothing, his soul

shaken in the fierce effort to kill and trample the raving impulse that had seized him in the presence of her

shame, that clamoured to him to drag himself before her feet, to pray for pardon, to pour out words he

knew not what words, but he knew that they had been straining at his lipsto wreck his selfrespect for

ever, and hopelessly defeat even the crazy purpose that had almost possessed him, by drowning her

wretchedness in disgust, by babbling with the tongue of infatuation to a woman with a husband not yet

Such was the magic of her tears, quickening in a moment the thing which, as his heart had known, he must

not let come to life. For Philip Trent was a young man, younger in nature even than his years, and a way of

life that kept his edge keen and his spirit volcanic had prepared him very ill for the meeting that comes once

in the early manhood of most of us, usuallyas in his case, he told himself harshlyto no purpose but the

My Dear Molloy:This is in case I don't find you at your office. I have found out who killed Manderson,

as this dispatch will show. This was my problem; yours is to decide what use to make of it. It definitely

charges an unsuspected person with having a hand in the crime, and practically accuses him of being the

murderer, so I don't suppose you will publish it before his arrest, and I believe it is illegal to do so afterwards

until he has been tried and found guilty. You may decide to publish it then; and you may find it possible to

make some use or other before then of the facts I have given. That is your affair. Meanwhile, will you

communicate with Scotland Yard, and let them see what I have written? I have done with the Manderson

mystery, and I wish to God I had never touched it. Here follows my dispatch.P.T.

Marlstone, June 16th. I begin this, my third and probably my final dispatch to the Record upon the

Manderson murder, with conflicting feelings. I have a strong sense of relief, because in my two previous

dispatches I was obliged, in the interests of justice, to withhold facts ascertained by me which would, if

published then, have put a certain person upon his guard and possibly have led to his escape; for he is a man

of no common boldness and resource. These facts I shall now set forth. But I have, I confess, no liking for the

story of treachery and perverted cleverness which I have to tell. It leaves an evil taste in the mouth, a savour

of something revolting in the deeper puzzle of motive underlying thc puzzle of the crime itself, which I

It will be remembered that in my first dispatch I described the situation as I found it on reaching this place

early on Tuesday morning. I told how the body was found, and in what state; dwelt upon the complete

mystery surrounding the crime, and mentioned one or two local theories about it; gave some account of the

dead man's domestic surroundings; and furnished a somewhat detailed description of his movements on the

evening before his death. I gave, too, a little fact which may or may not have seemed irrelevant: that a

quantity of whisky much larger than Manderson habitually drank at night had disappeared from his private

decanter since the last time he was seen alive. On the following day, the day of the inquest, I wired little more

than an abstract of the proceedings in the coroner's court, of which a verbatim report was made at my request

by other representatives of the Record. That day is not yet over as I write these lines; and I have now

completed an investigation which has led me directly to the man who must be called upon to clear himself of

Apart from the central mystery of Manderson's having arisen long before his usual hour to go out and meet

his death, there were two minor points of oddity about this affair which, I suppose, must have occurred to

thousands of those who have read the accounts in the newspapers: points apparent from the very beginning.

The first of these was that, whereas the body was found at a spot not thirty yards from the house, all the

people of the house declared that they had heard no cry or other noise in the night. Manderson had not been

gagged; the marks on his wrists pointed to a struggle with his assailant; and there had been at least one

pistolshot. (I say at least one, because it is the fact that in murders with firearms, especially if there has been

a struggle, the criminal commonly misses his victim at least once.) This odd fact seemed all the more odd to

me when I learned that Martin the butler was a bad sleeper, very keen of hearing, and that his bedroom, with

the window open, faced almost directly toward the shed by which the body was found.

The second odd little fact that was apparent from the outset was Manderson's leaving his dental plate by the

bedside. It appeared that he had risen and dressed himself fully, down to his necktie and watch and chain, and

had gone out of doors without remembering to put in this plate, which he had carried in his mouth every day

for years, and which contained all the visible teeth of the upper jaw. It had evidently not been a case of frantic

hurry; and even if it had been, he would have been more likely to forget almost anything than this denture.

Any one who wears such a removable plate will agree that the putting it in on rising is a matter of second

nature. Speaking as well as eating, to say nothing of appearances, depend upon it.

Neither of these queer details, however, seemed to lead to anything at the moment. They only awakened in

me a suspicion of something lurking in the shadows, something that lent more mystery to the already

With this much of preamble I come at once to the discovery which, in the first few hours of my investigation,

I have already described Manderson's bedroom, the rigorous simplicity of its furnishing, contrasted so

strangely with the multitude of clothes and shoes, and the manner of its communication with Mrs

Manderson's room. On the upper of the two long shelves on which the shoes were ranged I found, where I

had been told I should find them, the pair of patent leather shoes which Manderson had worn on the evening

before his death. I had glanced over the row, not with any idea of their giving me a clue, but merely because

it happens that I am a judge of shoes, and all these shoes were of the very best workmanship. But my

attention was at once caught by a little peculiarity in this particular pair. They were the lightest kind of

laceup dress shoes, very thin in the sole, without toe caps, and beautifully made, like all the rest. These

shoes were old and well worn; but being carefully polished, and fitted, as all the shoes were, upon their trees,

they looked neat enough. What caught my eye was a slight splitting of the leather in that part of the upper

known as the vampa splitting at the point where the two laced parts of the shoe rise from the upper. It is at

this point that the strain comes when a tight shoe of this sort is forced upon the foot, and it is usually guarded

with a strong stitching across the bottom of the opening. In both the shoes I was examining this stitching had

parted, and the leather below had given way. The splitting was a tiny affair in each case, not an eighth of an

inch long, and the torn edges having come together again on the removal of the strain, there was nothing that

a person who was not something of a connoisseur of shoeleather would have noticed. Even less noticeable,

and indeed not to be seen at all unless one were looking for it, was a slight straining of the stitches uniting the

upper to the sole. At the toe and on the outer side of each shoe this stitching had been dragged until it was

These indications, of course, could mean only one thingthe shoes had been worn by some one for whom

Now it was clear at a glance that Manderson was always thoroughly well shod, and careful, perhaps a little

vain, of his small and narrow feet. Not one of the other shoes in the collection, as I soon ascertained, bore

similar marks; they had not belonged to a man who squeezed himself into tight shoeleather. Some one who

was not Manderson had worn these shoes, and worn them recently; the edges of the tears were quite fresh.

The possibility of some one having worn them since Manderson's death was not worth considering; the body

had only been found about twentysix hours when I was examining the shoes; besides, why should any one

wear them? The possibility of some one having borrowed Manderson's shoes and spoiled them for him while

he was alive seemed about as negligible. With others to choose from he would not have worn these. Besides,

the only men in the place were the butler and the two secretaries. But I do not say that I gave those

possibilities even as much consideration as they deserved, for my thoughts were running away with me, and I

have always found it good policy, in cases of this sort, to let them have their heads. Ever since I had got out

of the train at Marlstone early that morning I had been steeped in details of the Manderson affair; the thing

had not once been out of my head. Suddenly the moment had come when the daemon wakes and begins to

Let me put it less fancifully. After all, it is a detail of psychology familiar enough to all whose business or

inclination brings them in contact with difficult affairs of any kind. Swiftly and spontaneously, when chance

or effort puts one in possession of the keyfact in any system of baffling circumstances, one's ideas seem to

rush to group themselves anew in relation to that fact, so that they are suddenly rearranged almost before one

has consciously grasped the significance of the keyfact itself. In the present instance, my brain had scarcely

formulated within itself the thought, 'Somebody who was not Manderson has been wearing these shoes,'

when there flew into my mind a flock of ideas, all of the same character and all bearing upon this new notion.

It was unheard of for Manderson to drink much whisky at night. It was very unlike him to be untidily

dressed, as the body was when foundthe cuffs dragged up inside the sleeves, the shoes unevenly laced;

very unlike him not to wash when he rose, and to put on last night's evening shirt and collar and

underclothing; very unlike him to have his watch in the waistcoat pocket that was not lined with leather for

its reception. (In my first dispatch I mentioned all these points, but neither I nor any one else saw anything

significant in them when examining the body.) It was very strange, in the existing domestic situation, that

Manderson should be communicative to his wife about his doings, especially at the time of his going to bed,

when he seldom spoke to her at all. It was extraordinary that Manderson should leave his bedroom without

All these thoughts, as I say, came flocking into my mind together, drawn from various parts of my memory of

the morning's enquiries and observations. They had all presented themselves, in far less time than it takes to

read them as set down here, as I was turning over the shoes, confirming my own certainty on the main point.

And yet when I confronted the definite idea that had sprung up suddenly and unsupported before me'It was

not Manderson who was in the house that night'it seemed a stark absurdity at the first formulating. It was

certainly Manderson who had dined at the house and gone out with Marlowe in the car. People had seen him

at close quarters. But was it he who returned at ten? That question too seemed absurd enough. But I could not

set it aside. It seemed to me as if a faint light was beginning to creep over the whole expanse of my mind, as

it does over land at dawn, and that presently the sun would be rising. I set myself to think over, one by one,

the points that had just occurred to me, so as to make out, if possible, why any man masquerading as

I had not to cast about very long for the motive a man might have in forcing his feet into Manderson's narrow

shoes. The examination of footmarks is very well understood by the police. But not only was the man

concerned to leave no footmarks of his own: he was concerned to leave Manderson's, if any; his whole plan,

if my guess was right, must have been directed to producing the belief that Manderson was in the place that

night. Moreover, his plan did not turn upon leaving footmarks. He meant to leave the shoes themselves, and

he did so. The maidservant had found them outside the bedroom door, as Manderson always left his shoes,

and had polished them, replacing them on the shoeshelves later in the morning, after the body had been

When I came to consider in this new light the leaving of the false teeth, an explanation of what had seemed

the maddest part of the affair broke upon me at once. A dental plate is not inseparable from its owner. If my

guess was right, the unknown had brought the denture to the house with him, and left it in the bedroom, with

the same object as he had in leaving the shoes: to make it impossible that any one should doubt that

Manderson had been in the house and had gone to bed there. This, of course, led me to the inference that

Manderson was dead before the false Manderson came to the house, and other things confirmed this.

For instance, the clothing, to which I now turned in my review of the position. If my guess was right, the

unknown in Manderson's shoes had certainly had possession of Manderson's trousers, waistcoat, and shooting

jacket. They were there before my eyes in the bedroom; and Martin had seen the jacketwhich nobody

could have mistakenupon the man who sat at the telephone in the library. It was now quite plain (if my

guess was right) that this unmistakable garment was a cardinal feature of the unknown's plan. He knew that

And there my thinking was interrupted by the realization of a thing that had escaped me before. So strong had

been the influence of the unquestioned assumption that it was Manderson who was present that night, that

neither I nor, as far as I know, any one else had noted the point. Martin had not seen the man's face, nor had

Mrs Manderson (judging by her evidence at the inquest, of which, as I have said, I had a full report made by

the Record stenographers in court) had not seen the man at all. She hardly could have done, as I shall show

presently. She had merely spoken with him as she lay half asleep, resuming a conversation which she had had

with her living husband about an hour before. Martin, I perceived, could only have seen the man's back, as he

sat crouching over the telephone; no doubt a characteristic pose was imitated there. And the man had worn

his hat, Manderson's broadbrimmed hat! There is too much character in the back of a head and neck. The

unknown, in fact, supposing him to have been of about Manderson's build, had had no need for any disguise,

I paused there to contemplate the coolness and ingenuity of the man. The thing, I now began to see, was so

safe and easy, provided that his mimicry was good enough, and that his nerve held. Those two points assured,

To come back to my puzzling out of the matter as I sat in the dead man's bedroom with the telltale shoes

before me. The reason for the entrance by the window instead of by the front door will already have occurred

to any one reading this. Entering by the door, the man would almost certainly have been heard by the

sharpeared Martin in his pantry just across the hall; he might have met him face to face.

Then there was the problem of the whisky. I had not attached much importance to it; whisky will sometimes

vanish in very queer ways in a household of eight or nine persons; but it had seemed strange that it should go

in that way on that evening. Martin had been plainly quite dumbfounded by the fact. It seemed to me now

that many a manfresh, as this man in all likelihood was, from a bloody business, from the unclothing of a

corpse, and with a desperate part still to playwould turn to that decanter as to a friend. No doubt he had a

drink before sending for Martin; after making that trick with ease and success, he probably drank more.

But he had known when to stop. The worst part of the enterprise was before him: the businessclearly of

such vital importance to him, for whatever reasonof shutting himself in Manderson's room and preparing a

body of convincing evidence of its having been occupied by Manderson; and this with the riskvery slight,

as no doubt he understood, but how unnerving!of the woman on the other side of the halfopen door

awaking and somehow discovering him. True, if he kept out of her limited field of vision from the bed, she

could only see him by getting up and going to the door. I found that to a person lying in her bed, which stood

with its head to the wall a little beyond the door, nothing was visible through the doorway but one of the

cupboards by Manderson's bedhead. Moreover, since this man knew the ways of the household, he would

think it most likely that Mrs Manderson was asleep. Another point with him, I guessed, might have been the

estrangement between the husband and wife, which they had tried to cloak by keeping up, among other

things, their usual practice of sleeping in connected rooms, but which was well known to all who had

anything to do with them. He would hope from this that if Mrs Manderson heard him, she would take no

So, pursuing my hypothesis, I followed the unknown up to the bedroom, and saw him setting about his work.

And it was with a catch in my own breath that I thought of the hideous shock with which he must have heard

the sound of all others he was dreading most: the drowsy voice from the adjoining room.

What Mrs Manderson actually said, she was unable to recollect at the inquest. She thinks she asked her

supposed husband whether he had had a good run in the car. And now what does the unknown do? Here, I

think, we come to a supremely significant point. Not only does hestanding rigid there, as I picture him,

before the dressingtable, listening to the sound of his own leaping heartnot only does he answer the lady

in the voice of Manderson; he volunteers an explanatory statement. He tells her that he has, on a sudden

inspiration, sent Marlowe in the car to Southampton; that he has sent him to bring back some important

information from a man leaving for Paris by the steamboat that morning. Why these details from a man who

had long been uncommunicative to his wife, and that upon a point scarcely likely to interest her? Why these

Having taken my story so far, I now put forward the following definite propositions: that between a time

somewhere about ten, when the car started, and a time somewhere about eleven, Manderson was

shotprobably at a considerable distance from the house, as no shot was heard; that the body was brought

back, left by the shed, and stripped of its outer clothing; that at some time round about eleven o'clock a man

who was not Manderson, wearing Manderson's shoes, hat, and jacket, entered the library by the garden

window; that he had with him Manderson's black trousers, waistcoat, and motorcoat, the denture taken from

Manderson's mouth, and the weapon with which he had been murdered; that he concealed these, rang the bell

for the butler, and sat down at the telephone with his hat on and his back to the door; that he was occupied

with the telephone all the time Martin was in the room; that on going up to the bedroom floor he quietly

entered Marlowe's room and placed the revolver with which the crime had been committedMarlowe's

revolverin the case on the mantelpiece from which it had been taken; and that he then went to Manderson's

room, placed Manderson's shoes outside the door, threw Manderson's garments on a chair, placed the denture

in the bowl by the bedside, and selected a suit of clothes, a pair of shoes, and a tie from those in the bedroom.

Here I will pause in my statement of this man's proceedings to go into a question for which the way is now

Reviewing what was known to me, or might almost with certainty be surmised, about that person, I set down

(1.) He had been in close relations with the dead man. In his acting before Martin and his speaking to Mrs

(2.) He was of a build not unlike Manderson's, especially as to height and breadth of shoulder, which mainly

determine the character of the back of a seated figure when the head is concealed and the body loosely

(3.) He had considerable aptitude for mimicry and actingprobably some experience too.

(5.) He was under a vital necessity of creating the belief that Manderson was alive and in that house until

So much I took as either certain or next door to it. It was as far as I could see. And it was far enough.

I proceed to give, in an order corresponding with the numbered paragraphs above, such relevant facts as I was

(1.) He had been Mr Manderson's private secretary, upon a footing of great intimacy, for nearly four years.

(2.) The two men were nearly of the same height, about five feet eleven inches; both were powerfully built

and heavy in the shoulder. Marlowe, who was the younger by some twenty years, was rather slighter about

the body, though Manderson was a man in good physical condition. Marlowe's shoes (of which I examined

several pairs) were roughly about one shoemaker's size longer and broader than Manderson's.

(3.) In the afternoon of the first day of my investigation, after arriving at the results already detailed, I sent a

telegram to a personal friend, a Fellow of a college at Oxford, whom I knew to be interested in theatrical

My friend replied in the following telegram, which reached me next morning (the morning of the inquest):

I had been led to send the telegram which brought this very helpful answer by seeing on the mantelshelf in

Marlowe's bedroom a photograph of himself and two others in the costume of Falstaff's three followers, with

an inscription from The Merry Wives, and by noting that it bore the imprint of an Oxford firm of

(4.) During his connection with Manderson, Marlowe had lived as one of the family. No other person, apart

from the servants, had his opportunities for knowing the domestic life of the Mandersons in detail.

(5.) I ascertained beyond doubt that Marlowe arrived at a hotel in Southampton on the Monday morning at

6.30, and there proceeded to carry out the commission which, according to his story, and according to the

statement made to Mrs Manderson in the bedroom by the false Manderson, had been entrusted to him by his

employer. He had then returned in the car to Marlstone, where he had shown great amazement and horror at

These, I say, are the relevant facts about Marlowe. We must now examine fact number 5 (as set out above) in

I would first draw attention to one important fact. The only person who professed to have heard Manderson

mention Southampton at all before he started in the car was Marlowe. His storyconfirmed to some extent

by what the butler overheardwas that the journey was all arranged in a private talk before they set out, and

he could not say, when I put the question to him, why Manderson should have concealed his intentions by

giving out that he was going with Marlowe for a moonlight drive. This point, however, attracted no attention.

Marlowe had an absolutely airtight alibi in his presence at Southampton by 6.30; nobody thought of him in

connection with a murder which must have been committed after 12.30the hour at which Martin the butler

had gone to bed. But it was the Manderson who came back from the drive who went out of his way to

mention Southampton openly to two persons. He even went so far as to ring up a hotel at Southampton and

ask questions which bore out Marlowe's story of his errand. This was the call he was busy with when Martin

Now let us consider the alibi. If Manderson was in the house that night, and if he did not leave it until some

time after 12.30, Marlowe could not by any possibility have had a direct hand in the murder. It is a question

of the distance between Marlstone and Southampton. If he had left Marlstone in the car at the hour when he is

supposed to have done sobetween 10 and 10.30with a message from Manderson, the run would be quite

an easy one to do in the time. But it would be physically impossible for the cara 15 h.p. fourcylinder

Northumberland, an average mediumpower carto get to Southampton by halfpast six unless it left

Marlstone by midnight at latest. Motorists who will examine the roadmap and make the calculations

required, as I did in Manderson's library that day, will agree that on the facts as they appeared there was

But even if they were not as they appeared; if Manderson was dead by eleven o'clock, and if at about that

time Marlowe impersonated him at White Gables; if Marlowe retired to Manderson's bedroomhow can all

this be reconciled with his appearance next morning at Southampton? He had to get out of the house, unseen

and unheard, and away in the car by midnight. And Martin, the sharpeared Martin, was sitting up until 12.30

in his pantry, with the door open, listening for the telephone bell. Practically he was standing sentry over the

With this difficulty we arrive at the last and crucial phase of my investigation. Having the foregoing points

clearly in mind, I spent the rest of the day before the inquest in talking to various persons and in going over

my story, testing it link by link. I could only find the one weakness which seemed to be involved in Martin's

sitting up until 12.30; and since his having been instructed to do so was certainly a part of the plan, meant to

clinch the alibi for Marlowe, I knew there must be an explanation somewhere. If I could not find that

explanation, my theory was valueless. I must be able to show that at the time Martin went up to bed the man

who had shut himself in Manderson's bedroom might have been many miles away on the road to

I had, however, a pretty good idea alreadyas perhaps the reader of these lines has by this time, if I have

made myself clearof how the escape of the false Manderson before midnight had been contrived. But I did

not want what I was now about to do to be known. If I had chanced to be discovered at work, there would

have been no concealing the direction of my suspicions. I resolved not to test them on this point until the next

day, during the opening proceedings at the inquest. This was to be held, I knew, at the hotel, and I reckoned

upon having White Gables to myself so far as the principal inmates were concerned.

So in fact it happened. By the time the proceedings at the hotel had begun I was hard at work at White

Gables. I had a camera with me. I made search, on principles well known to and commonly practised by the

police, and often enough by myself, for certain indications. Without describing my search, I may say at once

that I found and was able to photograph two fresh fingerprints, very large and distinct, on the polished front

of the righthand top drawer of the chest of drawers in Manderson's bedroom; five more (among a number of

smaller and less recent impressions made by other hands) on the glasses of the French window in Mrs

Manderson's room, a window which always stood open at night with a curtain before it; and three more upon

I took the bowl with me from White Gables. I took also a few articles which I selected from Marlowe's

bedroom, as bearing the most distinct of the innumerable fingerprints which are always to be found upon

toilet articles in daily use. I already had in my possession, made upon leaves cut from my pocket diary, some

excellent fingerprints of Marlowe's which he had made in my presence without knowing it. I had shown him

the leaves, asking if he recognized them; and the few seconds during which he had held them in his fingers

By six o'clock in the evening, two hours after the jury had brought in their verdict against a person or persons

unknown, I had completed my work, and was in a position to state that two of the five large prints made on

the window glasses, and the three on the bowl, were made by the left hand of Marlowe; that the remaining

By eight o'clock I had made at the establishment of Mr H. T. Copper, photographer, of Bishopsbridge, and

with his assistance, a dozen enlarged prints of the fingermarks of Marlowe, clearly showing the identity of

those which he unknowingly made in my presence and those left upon articles in his bedroom, with those

found by me as I have described, and thus establishing the facts that Marlowe was recently in Manderson's

bedroom, where he had in the ordinary way no business, and in Mrs Manderson's room, where he had still

less. I hope it may be possible to reproduce these prints for publication with this dispatch.

At nine o'clock I was back in my room at the hotel and sitting down to begin this manuscript. I had my story

complete. I bring it to a close by advancing these further propositions: that on the night of the murder the

impersonator of Manderson, being in Manderson's bedroom, told Mrs Manderson, as he had already told

Martin, that Marlowe was at that moment on his way to Southampton; that having made his dispositions in

the room, he switched off the light, and lay in the bed in his clothes; that he waited until he was assured that

Mrs Manderson was asleep; that he then arose and stealthily crossed Mrs Manderson's bedroom in his

stocking feet, having under his arm the bundle of clothing and shoes for the body; that he stepped behind the

curtain, pushing the doors of the window a little further open with his hands, strode over the iron railing of

the balcony, and let himself down until only a drop of a few feet separated him from the soft turf of the lawn.

All this might very well have been accomplished within half an hour of his entering Manderson's bedroom,

What followed your readers and the authorities may conjecture for themselves. The corpse was found next

morning clothedrather untidily. Marlowe in the car appeared at Southampton by halfpast six.

I bring this manuscript to an end in my sittingroom at the hotel at Marlstone. It is four o'clock in the

morning. I leave for London by the noon train from Bishopsbridge, and immediately after arriving I shall

place these pages in your hands. I ask you to communicate the substance of them to the Criminal

'I am returning the cheque you sent for what I did on the Manderson case,' Trent wrote to Sir James Molloy

from Munich, whither he had gone immediately after handing in at the Record office a brief dispatch bringing

his work on the case to an unexciting close. 'What I sent you wasn't worth onetenth of the amount; but I

should have no scruple about pocketing it if I hadn't taken a fancynever mind whynot to touch any

money at all for this business. I should like you, if there is no objection, to pay for the stuff at your ordinary

spacerate, and hand the money to some charity which does not devote itself to bullying people, if you know

of any such. I have come to this place to see some old friends and arrange my ideas, and the idea that comes

out uppermost is that for a little while I want some employment with activity in it. I find I can't paint at all: I

couldn't paint a fence. Will you try me as your Own Correspondent somewhere? If you can find me a good

adventure I will send you good accounts. After that I could settle down and work.'

Sir James sent him instructions by telegram to proceed at once to Kurland and Livonia, where Citizen

Browning was abroad again, and town and countryside blazed in revolt. It was a roving commission, and for

two months Trent followed his luck. It served him not less well than usual. He was the only correspondent

who saw General Dragilew killed in the street at Volmar by a girl of eighteen. He saw burnings, lynchings,

fusillades, hangings; each day his soul sickened afresh at the imbecilities born of misrule. Many nights he lay

down in danger. Many days he went fasting. But there was never an evening or a morning when he did not

He discovered in himself an unhappy pride at the lasting force of this infatuation. It interested him as a

phenomenon; it amazed and enlightened him. Such a thing had not visited him before. It confirmed so much

It was not that, at thirtytwo, he could pretend to ignorance of this world of emotion. About his knowledge

let it be enough to say that what he had learned had come unpursued and unpurchased, and was without

intolerable memories; broken to the realities of sex, he was still troubled by its inscrutable history. He went

through life full of a strange respect for certain feminine weakness and a very simple terror of certain

feminine strength. He had held to a rather lukewarm faith that something remained in him to be called forth,

and that the voice that should call would be heard in its own time, if ever, and not through any seeking.

But he had not thought of the possibility that, if this proved true some day, the truth might come in a sinister

shape. The two things that had taken him utterly by surprise in the matter of his feeling towards Mabel

Manderson were the insane suddenness of its uprising in full strength and its extravagant hopelessness.

Before it came, he had been much disposed to laugh at the permanence of unrequited passion as a generous

boyish delusion. He knew now that he had been wrong, and he was living bitterly in the knowledge.

Before the eye of his fancy the woman always came just as she was when he had first had sight of her, with

the gesture which he had surprised as he walked past unseen on the edge of the cliff; that great gesture of

passionate joy in her new liberty which had told him more plainly than speech that her widowhood was a

release from torment, and had confirmed with terrible force the suspicion, active in his mind before, that it

was her passport to happiness with a man whom she loved. He could not with certainty name to himself the

moment when he had first suspected that it might be so. The seed of the thought must have been sown, he

believed, at his first meeting with Marlowe; his mind would have noted automatically that such evident

strength and grace, with the sort of looks and manners that the tall young man possessed, might go far with

any woman of unfixed affections. And the connection of this with what Mr Cupples had told him of the

Mandersons' married life must have formed itself in the unconscious depths of his mind. Certainly it had

presented itself as an already established thing when he began, after satisfying himself of the identity of the

murderer, to cast about for the motive of the crime. Motive, motive! How desperately he had sought for

another, turning his back upon that grim thought, that Marlowe obsessed by passion like himself, and privy

perhaps to maddening truths about the wife's unhappinesshad taken a leaf, the guiltiest, from the book of

Bothwell. But in all his investigations at the time, in all his broodings on the matter afterwards, he had been

able to discover nothing that could prompt Marlowe to such a deednothing but that temptation, the whole

strength of which he could not know, but which if it had existed must have pressed urgently upon a bold

spirit in which scruple had been somehow paralysed. If he could trust his senses at ail, the young man was

neither insane nor by nature evil. But that could not clear him. Murder for a woman's sake, he thought, was

not a rare crime, Heaven knew! If the modern feebleness of impulse in the comfortable classes, and their

respect for the modern apparatus of detection, had made it rare among them, it was yet far from impossible. It

only needed a man of equal daring and intelligence, his soul drugged with the vapours of an intoxicating

A thousand times, with a heart full of anguish, he had sought to reason away the dread that Mabel Manderson

had known too much of what had been intended against her husband's life. That she knew all the truth after

the thing was done he could not doubt; her unforgettable collapse in his presence when the question about

Marlowe was suddenly and bluntly put, had swept away his last hope that there was no love between the pair,

and had seemed to him, moreover, to speak of dread of discovery. In any case, she knew the truth after

reading what he had left with her; and it was certain that no public suspicion had been cast upon Marlowe

since. She had destroyed his manuscript, then, and taken him at his word to keep the secret that threatened her

But it was the monstrous thought that she might have known murder was brewing, and guiltily kept silence,

that haunted Trent's mind. She might have suspected, have guessed something; was it conceivable that she

was aware of the whole plot, that she connived? He could never forget that his first suspicion of Marlowe's

motive in the crime had been roused by the fact that his escape was made through the lady's room. At that

time, when he had not yet seen her, he had been ready enough to entertain the idea of her equal guilt and her

cooperation. He had figured to himself some passionate hysterique, merciless as a cat in her hate and her

Then he had seen her, had spoken with her, had helped her in her weakness; and such suspicions, since their

first meeting, had seemed the vilest of infamy. He had seen her eyes and her mouth; he had breathed the

woman's atmosphere. Trent was one of those who fancy they can scent true wickedness in the air. In her

presence he had felt an inward certainty of her ultimate goodness of heart; and it was nothing against this that

she had abandoned herself a moment, that day on the cliff, to the sentiment of relief at the ending of her

bondage, of her years of starved sympathy and unquickened motherhood. That she had turned to Marlowe in

her destitution he believed; that she had any knowledge of his deadly purpose he did not believe.

And yet, morning and evening the sickening doubts returned, and he recalled again that it was almost in her

presence that Marlowe had made his preparations in the bedroom of the murdered man, that it was by the

window of her own chamber that he had escaped from the house. Had he forgotten his cunning and taken the

risk of telling her then? Or had he, as Trent thought more likely, still played his part with her then, and stolen

off while she slept? He did not think she had known of the masquerade when she gave evidence at the

inquest; it read like honest evidence. Orthe question would never be silenced, though he scorned it had

she lain expecting the footsteps in the room and the whisper that should tell her that it was done? Among the

foul possibilities of human nature, was it possible that black ruthlessness and black deceit as well were

Trent served Sir James, well earning his pay for six months, and then returned to Paris where he went to work

again with a better heart. His powers had returned to him, and he began to live more happily than he had

expected among a tribe of strangely assorted friends, French, English, and American, artists, poets,

journalists, policemen, hotelkeepers, soldiers, lawyers, business men, and others. His old faculty of

sympathetic interest in his fellows won for him, just as in his student days, privileges seldom extended to the

Briton. He enjoyed again the rare experience of being taken into the bosom of a Frenchman's family. He was

admitted to the momentous confidence of les jeunes, and found them as sure that they had surprised the

The bosom of the Frenchman's family was the same as those he had known in the past, even to the patterns of

the wallpaper and movables. But the jeunes, he perceived with regret, were totally different from their

forerunners. They were much more shallow and puerile, much less really clever. The secrets they wrested

from the Universe were not such important and interesting secrets as had been wrested by the old jeunes. This

he believed and deplored until one day he found himself seated at a restaurant next to a too wellfed man

whom, in spite of the ravages of comfortable living, he recognized as one of the jeunes of his own period.

This one had been wont to describe himself and three or four others as the Hermits of the New Parnassus. He

and his school had talked outside cafes and elsewhere more than solitaries do as a rule; but, then, rules were

what they had vowed themselves to destroy. They proclaimed that verse, in particular, was free. The Hermit

of the New Parnassus was now in the Ministry of the Interior, and already decorated: he expressed to Trent

the opinion that what France needed most was a hand of iron. He was able to quote the exact price paid for

Thus he was brought to make the old discovery that it was he who had changed, like his friend of the

Administration, and that les jeunes were still the same. Yet he found it hard to say what precisely he had lost

that so greatly mattered; unless indeed it were so simple a thing as his high spirits.

One morning in June, as he descended the slope of the Rue des Martyrs, he saw approaching a figure that he

remembered. He glanced quickly round, for the thought of meeting Mr Bunner again was unacceptable. For

some time he had recognized that his wound was healing under the spell of creative work; he thought less

often of the woman he loved, and with less pain. He would not have the memory of those three days

But the straight and narrow thoroughfare offered no refuge, and the American saw him almost at once.

His unforced geniality made Trent ashamed, for he had liked the man. They sat long over a meal, and Mr

Bunner talked. Trent listened to him, now that he was in for it, with genuine pleasure, now and then

contributing a question or remark. Besides liking his companion, he enjoyed his conversation, with its

Bunner was, it appeared, resident in Paris as the chief Continental agent of the Manderson firm, and fully

satisfied with his position and prospects. He discoursed on these for some twenty minutes. This subject at

length exhausted, he went on to tell Trent, who confessed that he had been away from England for a year, that

Marlowe had shortly after the death of Manderson entered his father's business, which was now again in a

flourishing state, and had already come to be practically in control of it. They had kept up their intimacy, and

were even now planning a holiday for the summer. Mr Bunner spoke with generous admiration of his friend's

talent for affairs. 'Jack Marlowe has a natural big head,' he declared, 'and if he had more experience, I

wouldn't want to have him up against me. He would put a crimp in me every time.'

As the American's talk flowed on, Trent listened with a slowly growing perplexity. It became more and more

plain that something was very wrong in his theory of the situation; there was no mention of its central figure.

Presently Mr Bunner mentioned that Marlowe was engaged to be married to an Irish girl, whose charms he

Trent clasped his hands savagely together beneath the table. What could have happened? His ideas were

Mr Bunner was not very fully informed. He knew that Mrs Manderson had left England immediately after the

settlement of her husband's affairs, and had lived for some time in Italy. She had returned not long ago to

London, where she had decided not to live in the house in Mayfair, and had bought a smaller one in the

Hampstead neighbourhood; also, he understood, one somewhere in the country. She was said to go but little

into society. 'And all the good hard dollars just waiting for some one to spraddle them around,' said Mr

Bunner, with a note of pathos in his voice. 'Why, she has money to burnmoney to feed to the birds and

nothing doing. The old man left her more than half his wad. And think of the figure she might make in the

world. She is beautiful, and she is the best woman I ever met, too. But she couldn't ever seem to get the habit

His words now became a soliloquy: Trent's thoughts were occupying all his attention. He pleaded business

Half an hour later Trent was in his studio, swiftly and mechanically 'cleaning up'. He wanted to know what

had happened; somehow he must find out. He could never approach herself, he knew; he would never bring

back to her the shame of that last encounter with him; it was scarcely likely that he would even set eyes on

her. But he must get to know!... Cupples was in London, Marlowe was there .... And, anyhow, he was sick of

Such thoughts came and went; and below them all strained the fibres of an unseen cord that dragged

mercilessly at his heart, and that he cursed bitterly in the moments when he could not deny to himself that it

In twentyfour hours his feeble roots in Paris had been torn out. He was looking over a leaden sea at the

But though he had instinctively picked out the lines of a set purpose from among the welter of promptings in

He had decided that he must first see Mr Cupples, who would be in a position to tell him much more than the

American knew. But Mr Cupples was away on his travels, not expected to return for a month; and Trent had

no reasonable excuse for hastening his return. Marlowe he would not confront until he had tried at least to

reconnoitre the position. He constrained himself not to commit the crowning folly of seeking out Mrs

Manderson's house in Hampstead; he could not enter it, and the thought of the possibility of being seen by her

He stayed at an hotel, took a studio, and while he awaited Mr Cupples's return attempted vainly to lose

At the end of a week he had an idea that he acted upon with eager precipitancy. She had let fall some word at

their last meeting, of a taste for music. Trent went that evening, and thenceforward regularly, to the opera. He

might see her; and if, in spite of his caution, she caught sight of him, they could be blind to each other's

So he went alone each evening, passing as quickly as he might through the people in the vestibule; and each

evening he came away knowing that she had not been in the house. It was a habit that yielded him a sort of

satisfaction along with the guilty excitement of his search; for he too loved music, and nothing gave him so

One night as he entered, hurrying through the brilliant crowd, he felt a touch on his arm. Flooded with an

It was she: so much more radiant in the absence of grief and anxiety, in the fact that she was smiling, and in

the allurement of evening dress, that he could not speak. She, too, breathed a little quickly, and there was a

Her words were few. 'I wouldn't miss a note of Tristan,' she said, 'nor must you. Come and see me in the

The following two months were a period in Trent's life that he has never since remembered without

shuddering. He met Mrs Manderson half a dozen times, and each time her cool friendliness, a nicely

calculated mean between mere acquaintance and the first stage of intimacy, baffled and maddened him. At

the opera he had found her, to his further amazement, with a certain Mrs Wallace, a frisky matron whom he

had known from childhood. Mrs Manderson, it appeared, on her return from Italy, had somehow wandered

into circles to which he belonged by nurture and disposition. It came, she said, of her having pitched her tent

in their hunting grounds; several of his friends were near neighbours. He had a dim but horrid recollection

of having been on that occasion unlike himself, ill at ease, burning in the face, talking with idiot loquacity of

his adventures in the Baltic provinces, and finding from time to time that he was addressing himself

exclusively to Mrs Wallace. The other lady, when he joined them, had completely lost the slight appearance

of agitation with which she had stopped him in the vestibule. She had spoken pleasantly to him of her travels,

During the last half of the opera, which he had stayed in the box to hear, he had been conscious of nothing, as

he sat behind them, but the angle of her cheek and the mass of her hair, the lines of her shoulder and arm, her

hand upon the cushion. The black hair had seemed at last a forest, immeasurable, pathless and enchanted,

luring him to a fatal adventure .... At the end he had been pale and subdued, parting with them rather

The next time he saw herit was at a country house where both were guestsand the subsequent times, he

had had himself in hand. He had matched her manner and had acquitted himself, he thought, decently,

Considering that he lived in an agony of bewilderment and remorse and longing. He could make nothing,

absolutely nothing, of her attitude. That she had read his manuscript and understood the suspicion indicated

in his last question to her at White Gables was beyond the possibility of doubt. Then how could she treat him

For it had become clear to his intuitive sense, for all the absence of any shade of differentiation in her

outward manner, that an injury had been done, and that she had felt it. Several times, on the rare and brief

occasions when they had talked apart, he had warning from the same sense that she was approaching this

subject; and each time he had turned the conversation with the ingenuity born of fear. Two resolutions he

made. The first was that when he had completed a commissioned work which tied him to London he would

go away and stay away. The strain was too great. He no longer burned to know the truth; he wanted nothing

to confirm his fixed internal conviction by faith, that he had blundered, that he had misread the situation,

misinterpreted her tears, written himself down a slanderous fool. He speculated no more on Marlowe's motive

in the killing of Manderson. Mr Cupples returned to London, and Trent asked him nothing. He knew now that

he had been right in those wordsTrent remembered them for the emphasis with which they were

spoken'So long as she considered herself bound to him... no power on earth could have persuaded her.' He

met Mrs Manderson at dinner at her uncle's large and tomblike house in Bloomsbury, and there he

But when, a few days after, she wrote asking him to come and see her on the following afternoon, he made no

While she celebrated the rites of tea, and for some little time thereafter, she joined with such natural ease in

his slightly fevered conversation on matters of the day that he began to hope she had changed what he could

not doubt had been her resolve, to corner him and speak to him gravely. She was to all appearance careless

now, smiling so that he recalled, not for the first time since that night at the opera, what was written long ago

of a Princess of Brunswick: 'Her mouth has ten thousand charms that touch the soul.' She made a tour of the

beautiful room where she had received him, singling out this treasure or that from the spoils of a hundred

bricabrac shops, laughing over her quests, discoveries, and bargainings. And when he asked if she would

delight him again with a favourite piece of his which he had heard her play at another house, she consented at

She played with a perfection of execution and feeling that moved him now as it had moved him before. 'You

are a musician born,' he said quietly when she had finished, and the last tremor of the music had passed away.

'I have played a great deal ever since I can remember. It has been a great comfort to me,' she said simply, and

halfturned to him smiling. 'When did you first detect music in me? Oh, of course: I was at the opera. But

'No,' he said abstractedly, his sense still busy with the music that had just ended. 'I think I knew it the first

time I saw you.' Then understanding of his own words came to him, and turned him rigid. For the first time

There was a short silence. Mrs Manderson looked at Trent, then hastily looked away. Colour began to rise in

her cheeks, and she pursed her lips as if for whistling. Then with a defiant gesture of the shoulders which he

remembered she rose suddenly from the piano and placed herself in a chair opposite to him.

'That speech of yours will do as well as anything,' she began slowly, looking at the point of her shoe, 'to bring

us to what I wanted to say. I asked you here today on purpose, Mr Trent, because I couldn't bear it any longer.

Ever since the day you left me at White Gables I have been saying to myself that it didn't matter what you

thought of me in that affair; that you were certainly not the kind of man to speak to others of what you

believed about me, after what you had told me of your reasons for suppressing your manuscript. I asked

myself how it could matter. But all the time, of course, I knew it did matter. It mattered horribly. Because

what you thought was not true.' She raised her eyes and met his gaze calmly. Trent, with a completely

'Since I began to know you,' he said, 'I have ceased to think it.' 'Thank you,' said Mrs Manderson; and blushed

suddenly and deeply. Then, playing with a glove, she added, 'But I want you to know what was true.

I did not know if I should ever see you again,' she went on in a lower voice, 'but I felt that if I did I must

speak to you about this. I thought it would not be hard to do so, because you seemed to me an understanding

person; and besides, a woman who has been married isn't expected to have the same sort of difficulty as a

young girl in speaking about such things when it is necessary. And then we did meet again, and I discovered

'I don't know,' said the lady. 'But yesI do know. It was just because you treated me exactly as if you had

never thought or imagined anything of that sort about me. I had always supposed that if I saw you again you

would turn on me that hard, horrible sort of look you had when you asked me that last question do you

remember?at White Gables. Instead of that you were just like any other acquaintance. You were just'she

hesitated and spread out her hands'nice. You know. After that first time at the opera when I spoke to you I

went home positively wondering if you had really recognized me. I mean, I thought you might have

She smiled deprecatingly. 'Well, I couldn't remember if you had spoken my name; and I thought it might be

so. But the next time, at the Iretons', you did speak it, so I knew; and a dozen times during those few days I

almost brought myself to tell you, but never quite. I began to feel that you wouldn't let me, that you would

slip away from the subject if I approached it. Wasn't I right? Tell me, please.' He nodded. 'But why?' He

'Well,' she said, 'I will finish what I had to say, and then you will tell me, I hope, why you had to make it so

hard. When I began to understand that you wouldn't let me talk of the matter to you, it made me more

determined than ever. I suppose you didn't realize that I would insist on speaking even if you were quite

discouraging. I dare say I couldn't have done it if I had been guilty, as you thought. You walked into my

Mrs Manderson had lost all her air of hesitancy. She had, as she was wont to say, talked herself enthusiastic,

and in the ardour of her purpose to annihilate the misunderstanding that had troubled her so long she felt

'I am going to tell you the story of the mistake you made,' she continued, as Trent, his hands clasped between

his knees, still looked at her enigmatically. 'You will have to believe it, Mr Trent; it is utterly true to life, with

its confusions and hidden things and crosspurposes and perfectly natural mistakes that nobody thinks twice

about taking for facts. Please understand that I don't blame you in the least, and never did, for jumping to the

conclusion you did. You knew that I was estranged from my husband, and you knew what that so often

means. You knew before I told you, I expect, that he had taken up an injured attitude towards me; and I was

silly enough to try and explain it away. I gave you the explanation of it that I had given myself at first, before

I realized the wretched truth; I told you he was disappointed in me because I couldn't take a brilliant lead in

society. Well, that was true; he was so. But I could see you weren't convinced. You had guessed what it took

me much longer to see, because I knew how irrational it was. Yes; my husband was jealous of John Marlowe;

'Then I behaved like a fool when you let me see you had divined it; it was such a blow, you understand, when

I had supposed all the humiliation and strain was at an end, and that his delusion had died with him. You

practically asked me if my husband's secretary was not my lover, Mr TrentI have to say it, because I want

you to understand why I broke down and made a scene. You took that for a confession; you thought I was

guilty of that, and I think you even thought I might be a party to the crime, that I had consented .... That did

Trent, who had not hitherto taken his eyes from her face, hung his head at the words. He did not raise it again

as she continued. 'But really it was simple shock and distress that made me give way, and the memory of all

the misery that mad suspicion had meant to me. And when I pulled myself together again you had gone.'

She rose and went to an escritoire beside the window, unlocked a drawer, and drew out a long, sealed

'This is the manuscript you left with me,' she said. 'I have read it through again and again. I have always

wondered, as everybody does, at your cleverness in things of this kind.' A faintly mischievous smile flashed

upon her face, and was gone. I thought it was splendid, Mr TrentI almost forgot that the story was my own,

I was so interested. And I want to say now, while I have this in my hand, how much I thank you for your

generous, chivalrous act in sacrificing this triumph of yours rather than put a woman's reputation in peril. If

all had been as you supposed, the facts must have come out when the police took up the case you put in their

hands. Believe me, I understood just what you had done, and I never ceased to be grateful even when I felt

As she spoke her thanks her voice shook a little, and her eyes were bright. Trent perceived nothing of this.

His head was still bent. He did not seem to hear. She put the envelope into his hand as it lay open, palm

upwards, on his knee. There was a touch of gentleness about the act which made him look up.

She raised her hand as she stood before him. 'No, Mr Trent; let me finish before you say anything. It is such

an unspeakable relief to me to have broken the ice at last, and I want to end the story while I am still feeling

the triumph of beginning it.' She sank down into the sofa from which she had first risen. 'I am telling you a

thing that nobody else knows. Everybody knew, I suppose, that something had come between us, though I did

everything in my power to hide it. But I don't think any one in the world ever guessed what my husband's

notion was. People who know me don't think that sort of thing about me, I believe. And his fancy was so

ridiculously opposed to the facts. I will tell you what the situation was. Mr Marlowe and I had been friendly

enough since he came to us. For all his clevernessmy husband said he had a keener brain than any man he

knewI looked upon him as practically a boy. You know I am a little older than he is, and he had a sort of

amiable lack of ambition that made me feel it the more. One day my husband asked me what I thought was

the best thing about Marlowe, and not thinking much about it I said, "His manners." He surprised me very

much by looking black at that, and after a silence he said, "Yes, Marlowe is a gentleman; that's so", not

'Nothing was ever said about that again until about a year ago, when I found that Mr Marlowe had done what

I always expected he would dofallen desperately in love with an American girl. But to my disgust he had

picked out the most worthless girl, I do believe, of all those whom we used to meet. She was the daughter of

wealthy parents, and she did as she liked with them; very beautiful, well educated, very good at

gameswhat they call a womanathleteand caring for nothing on earth but her own amusement. She was

one of the most unprincipled flirts I ever knew, and quite the cleverest. Every one knew it, and Mr Marlowe

must have heard it; but she made a complete fool of him, brain and all. I don't know how she managed it, but

I can imagine. She liked him, of course; but it was quite plain to me that she was playing with him. The

whole affair was so idiotic, I got perfectly furious. One day I asked him to row me in a boat on the lakeall

this happened at our house by Lake George. We had never been alone together for any length of time before.

In the boat I talked to him. I was very kind about it, I think, and he took it admirably, but he didn't believe me

a bit. He had the impudence to tell me that I misunderstood Alice's nature. When I hinted at his prospectsI

knew he had scarcely anything of his ownhe said that if she loved him he could make himself a position in

the world. I dare say that was true, with his abilities and his friendshe is rather well connected, you know,

'My husband helped me out of the boat when we got back. He joked with Mr Marlowe about something, I

remember; for through all that followed he never once changed in his manner to him, and that was one reason

why I took so long to realize what he thought about him and myself. But to me he was reserved and silent

that eveningnot angry. He was always perfectly cold and expressionless to me after he took this idea into

his head. After dinner he only spoke to me once. Mr Marlowe was telling him about some horse he had

bought for the farm in Kentucky, and my husband looked at me and said, "Marlowe may be a gentleman, but

he seldom quits loser in a horsetrade." I was surprised at that, but at that timeand even on the next

occasion when he found us togetherI didn't understand what was in his mind. That next time was the

morning when Mr Marlowe received a sweet little note from the girl asking for his congratulations on her

engagement. It was in our New York house. He looked so wretched at breakfast that I thought he was ill, and

afterwards I went to the room where he worked, and asked what was the matter. He didn't say anything, but

just handed me the note, and turned away to the window. I was very glad that was all over, but terribly sorry

for him too, of course. I don't remember what I said, but I remember putting my hand on his arm as he stood

there staring out on the garden and just then my husband appeared at the open door with some papers. He just

glanced at us, and then turned and walked quietly back to his study. I thought that he might have heard what I

was saying to comfort Mr Marlowe, and that it was rather nice of him to slip away. Mr Marlowe neither saw

nor heard him. My husband left the house that morning for the West while I was out. Even then I did not

understand. He used often to go off suddenly like that, if some business project called him.

'It was not until he returned a week later that I grasped the situation. He was looking white and strange, and

as soon as he saw me he asked me where Mr Marlowe was. Somehow the tone of his question told me

'I almost gasped; I was wild with indignation. You know, Mr Trent, I don't think I should have minded at all

if any one had thought me capable of openly breaking with my husband and leaving him for somebody else. I

dare say I might have done that. But that coarse suspicion... a man whom he trusted... and the notion of

concealment. It made me see scarlet. Every shred of pride in me was strung up till I quivered, and I swore to

myself on the spot that I would never show by any word or sign that I was conscious of his having such a

thought about me. I would behave exactly as I always had behaved, I determinedand that I did, up to the

very last. Though I knew that a wall had been made between us now that could never be broken downeven

if he asked my pardon and obtained itI never once showed that I noticed any change.

'And so it went on. I never could go through such a time again. My husband showed silent and cold politeness

to me always when we were aloneand that was only when it was unavoidable. He never once alluded to

what was in his mind; but I felt it, and he knew that I felt it. Both of us were stubborn in our different

attitudes. To Mr Marlowe he was more friendly, if anything, than beforeHeaven only knows why. I fancied

he was planning some sort of revenge; but that was only a fancy. Certainly Mr Marlowe never knew what

was suspected of him. He and I remained good friends, though we never spoke of anything intimate after that

disappointment of his; but I made a point of seeing no less of him than I had always done. Then we came to

She threw out her right hand in a gesture of finality. 'You know about the rest so much more than any

Trent wondered at that look, but the wonder was only a passing shadow on his thought. Inwardly his whole

being was possessed by thankfulness. All the vivacity had returned to his face. Long before the lady had

ended her story he had recognized the certainty of its truth, as from the first days of their renewed

acquaintance he had doubted the story that his imagination had built up at White Gables, upon foundations

He said, 'I don't know how to begin the apologies I have to make. There are no words to tell you how

ashamed and disgraced I feel when I realize what a crude, cocksure blundering at a conclusion my suspicion

was. Yes, I suspectedyou! I had almost forgotten that I was ever such a fool. Almostnot quite.

Sometimes when I have been alone I have remembered that folly, and poured contempt on it. I have tried to

She interrupted him quickly. 'What nonsense! Do be sensible, Mr Trent. You had only seen me on two

occasions in your life before you came to me with your solution of the mystery.' Again the quaint expression

came and was gone. 'If you talk of folly, it really is folly for a man like you to pretend to a woman like me

that I had innocence written all over me in large lettersso large that you couldn't believe very strong

'What do you mean by "a man like me"?' he demanded with a sort of fierceness. 'Do you take me for a person

without any normal instincts? I don't say you impress people as a simple, transparent sort of characterwhat

Mr Calvin Bunner calls a case of openwork; I don't say a stranger might not think you capable of

wickedness, if there was good evidence for it: but I say that a man who, after seeing you and being in your

atmosphere, could associate you with the particular kind of abomination I imagined, is a foolthe kind of

fool who is afraid to trust his senses .... As for my making it hard for you to approach the subject, as you say,

it is true. It was simply moral cowardice. I understood that you wished to clear the matter up; and I was

revolted at the notion of my injurious blunder being discussed. I tried to show you by my actions that it was

as if it had never been. I hoped you would pardon me without any words. I can't forgive myself, and I never

shall. And yet if you could know' He stopped short, and then added quietly, 'Well, will you accept all that

as an apology? The very scrubbiest sackcloth made, and the grittiest ashes on the heap....I didn't mean to get

Mrs Manderson laughed, and her laugh carried him away with it. He knew well by this time that sudden rush

of cascading notes of mirth, the perfect expression of enjoyment; he had many times tried to amuse her

'But I love to see you worked up,' she said. 'The bump with which you always come down as soon as you

realize that you are up in the air at all is quite delightful. Oh, we're actually both laughing. What a triumphant

end to our explanations, after all my dread of the time when I should have it out with you. And now it's all

'I hope not,' Trent said in sincere relief. 'If you're resolved to be so kind as this about it, I am not

highprincipled enough to insist on your blasting me with your lightnings. And now, Mrs Manderson, I had

better go. Changing the subject after this would be like playing pussinthecorner after an earthquake.' He

'You are right,' she said. 'But no! Wait. There is another thingpart of the same subject; and we ought to

pick up all the pieces now while we are about it. Please sit down.' She took the envelope containing Trent's

manuscript dispatch from the table where he had laid it. 'I want to speak about this.'

His brows bent, and he looked at her questioningly. 'So do I, if you do,' he said slowly. 'I want very much to

'Since my reason for suppressing that information was all a fantasy, why did you never make any use of it?

When I began to realize that I had been wrong about you, I explained your silence to myself by saying that

you could not bring yourself to do a thing that would put a rope round a man's neck, whatever he might have

done. I can quite understand that feeling. Was that what it was? Another possibility I thought of was that you

knew of something that was by way of justifying or excusing Marlowe's act. Or I thought you might have a

simple horror, quite apart from humanitarian scruples, of appearing publicly in connection with a murder

trial. Many important witnesses in such cases have to be practically forced into giving their evidence. They

Mrs Manderson tapped her lips with the envelope without quite concealing a smile. 'You didn't think of

'I mean the possibility of your having been wrong about Mr Marlowe as well as about me. No, no; you

needn't tell me that the chain of evidence is complete. I know it is. But evidence of what? Of Mr Marlowe

having impersonated my husband that night, and having escaped by way of my window, and built up an alibi.

I have read your dispatch again and again, Mr Trent, and I don't see that those things can be doubted.'

Trent gazed at her with narrowed eyes. He said nothing to fill the brief pause that followed. Mrs Manderson

'I did not make any use of the facts found out by you,' she slowly said at last, 'because it seemed to me very

'And,' pursued the lady, looking up at him with a mild reasonableness in her eyes, 'as I knew that he was

There was another little pause. Trent rubbed his chin, with an affectation of turning over the idea. Inwardly he

was telling himself, somewhat feebly, that this was very right and proper; that it was quite feminine, and that

he liked her to be feminine. It was permitted to hermore than permittedto set her loyal belief in the

character of a friend above the clearest demonstrations of the intellect. Nevertheless, it chafed him. He would

have had her declaration of faith a little less positive in form. It was too irrational to say she 'knew'. In fact

(he put it to himself bluntly), it was quite unlike her. If to be unreasonable when reason led to the unpleasant

was a specially feminine trait, and if Mrs Manderson had it, she was accustomed to wrap it up better than any

'You suggest,' he said at length, 'that Marlowe constructed an alibi for himself, by means which only a

desperate man would have attempted, to clear himself of a crime he did not commit. Did he tell he was

She uttered a little laugh of impatience. 'So you think he has been talking me round. No, that is not so. I am

merely sure he did not do it. Ah! I see you think that absurd. But see how unreasonable you are, Mr Trent!

Just now you were explaining to me quite sincerely that it was foolishness in you to have a certain suspicion

of me after seeing me and being in my atmosphere, as you said.' Trent started in his chair. She glanced at

him, and went on: 'Now, I and my atmosphere are much obliged to you, but we must stand up for the rights of

other atmospheres. I know a great deal more about Mr Marlowe's atmosphere than you know about mine

even now. I saw him constantly for several years. I don't pretend to know all about him; but I do know that he

is incapable of a crime of bloodshed. The idea of his planning a murder is as unthinkable to me as the idea of

your picking a poor woman's pocket, Mr Trent. I can imagine you killing a man, you know... if the man

deserved it and had an equal chance of killing you. I could kill a person myself in some circumstances. But

Mr Marlowe was incapable of doing it, I don't care what the provocation might be. He had a temper that

nothing could shake, and he looked upon human nature with a sort of cold magnanimity that would find

excuses for absolutely anything. It wasn't a pose; you could see it was a part of him. He never put it forward,

but it was there always. It was quite irritating at times .... Now and then in America, I remember, I have heard

people talking about lynching, for instance, when he was there. He would sit quite silent and expressionless,

appearing not to listen; but you could feel disgust coming from him in waves. He really loathed and hated

physical violence. He was a very strange man in some ways, Mr Trent. He gave one a feeling that he might

do unexpected thingsdo you know that feeling one has about some people? What part he really played in

the events of that night I have never been able to guess. But nobody who knew anything about him could

possibly believe in his deliberately taking a man's life.' Again the movement of her head expressed finality,

'Then,' said Trent, who had followed this with earnest attention, 'we are forced back on two other

possibilities, which I had not thought worth much consideration until this moment. Accepting what you say,

he might still conceivably have killed in selfdefence; or he might have done so by accident.'

The lady nodded. 'Of course I thought of those two explanations when I read your manuscript.'

'And I suppose you felt, as I did myself, that in either of those cases the natural thing, and obviously the safest

thing, for him to do was to make a public statement of the truth, instead of setting up a series of deceptions

which would certainly stamp him as guilty in the eyes of the law, if anything went wrong with them.'

'Yes,' she said wearily, 'I thought over all that until my head ached. And I thought somebody else might have

done it, and that he was somehow screening the guilty person. But that seemed wild. I could see no light in

the mystery, and after a while I simply let it alone. All I was clear about was that Mr Marlowe was not a

murderer, and that if I told what you had found out, the judge and jury would probably think he was. I

promised myself that I would speak to you about it if we should meet again; and now I've kept my promise.'

Trent, his chin resting on his hand, was staring at the carpet. The excitement of the hunt for the truth was

steadily rising in him. He had not in his own mind accepted Mrs Manderson's account of Marlowe's character

as unquestionable. But she had spoken forcibly; he could by no means set it aside, and his theory was much

'There is only one thing for it,' he said, looking up. 'I must see Marlowe. It worries me too much to have the

thing left like this. I will get at the truth. Can you tell me,' he broke off, 'how he behaved after the day I left

'I never saw him after that,' said Mrs Manderson simply. 'For some days after you went away I was ill, and

didn't go out of my room. When I got down he had left and was in London, settling things with the lawyers.

He did not come down to the funeral. Immediately after that I went abroad. After some weeks a letter from

him reached me, saying he had concluded his business and given the solicitors all the assistance in his power.

He thanked me very nicely for what he called all my kindness, and said goodbye. There was nothing in it

about his plans for the future, and I thought it particularly strange that he said not a word about my husband's

death. I didn't answer. Knowing what I knew, I couldn't. In those days I shuddered whenever I thought of that

'No, but I dare say Uncle BurtonMr Cupples, you knowcould tell you. Some time ago he told me that he

had met Mr Marlowe in London, and had some talk with him. I changed the conversation.' She paused and

smiled with a trace of mischief. 'I rather wonder what you supposed had happened to Mr Marlowe after you

withdrew from the scene of the drama that you had put together so much to your satisfaction.'

'You ask me to humiliate myself again, Mrs Manderson. Very well. I will tell you what I thought I should

most likely find when I returned to London after my travels: that you had married Marlowe to live abroad.'

She heard him with unmoved composure. 'We certainly couldn't have lived very comfortably in England on

his money and mine,' she observed thoughtfully. 'He had practically nothing then.'

He stared at her'gaped', she told him some time afterwards. At the moment she laughed with a little

'Dear me, Mr Trent! Have I said anything dreadful? You surely must know .... I thought everybody

understood by now .... I'm sure I've had to explain it often enough... if I marry again I lose everything that my

The effect of this speech upon Trent was curious. For an instant his face was flooded with the emotion of

surprise. As this passed away he gradually drew himself together, as he sat, into a tense attitude. He looked,

she thought as she saw his knuckles grow white on the arms of the chair, like a man prepared for pain under

the hand of the surgeon. But all he said, in a voice lower than his usual tone, was, I had no idea of it.'

'It is so,' she said calmly, trifling with a ring on her finger. 'Really, Mr Trent, it is not such a very unusual

thing. I think I am glad of it. For one thing, it has secured meat least since it became generally

knownfrom a good many attentions of a kind that a woman in my position has to put up with as a rule.'

She looked at him questioningly. 'Ah!' she laughed. 'The other kind trouble me even less. I have not yet met a

man silly enough to want to marry a widow with a selfish disposition, and luxurious habits and tastes, and

She shook her head, and something in the gesture shattered the last remnants of Trent's selfpossession.

'Haven't you, by Heaven!' he exclaimed, rising with a violent movement and advancing a step towards her.

'Then I am going to show you that human passion is not always stifled by the smell of money. I am going to

end the businessmy business. I am going to tell you what I dare say scores of better men have wanted to

tell you, but couldn't summon up what I have summoned upthe infernal cheek to do it. They were afraid of

making fools of themselves. I am not. You have accustomed me to the feeling this afternoon.' He laughed

aloud in his rush of words, and spread out his hands. 'Look at me! It is the sight of the century! It is one who

says he loves you, and would ask you to give up very great wealth to stand at his side.'

She was hiding her face in her hands. He heard her say brokenly, 'Please... don't speak in that way.'

He answered: 'It will make a great difference to me if you will allow me to say all I have to say before I leave

you. Perhaps it is in bad taste, but I will risk that; I want to relieve my soul; it needs open confession. This is

the truth. You have troubled me ever since the first time I saw youand you did not know itas you sat

under the edge of the cliff at Marlstone, and held out your arms to the sea. It was only your beauty that filled

my mind then. As I passed by you it seemed as if all the life in the place were crying out a song about you in

the wind and the sunshine. And the song stayed in my ears; but even your beauty would be no more than an

empty memory to me by now if that had been all. It was when I led you from the hotel there to your house,

with your hand on my arm, thatwhat was it that happened? I only knew that your stronger magic had

struck home, and that I never should forget that day, whatever the love of my life should be. Till that day I

had admired as I should admire the loveliness of a still lake; but that day I felt the spell of the divinity of the

lake. And next morning the waters were troubled, and she rosethe morning when I came to you with my

questions, tired out with doubts that were as bitter as pain, and when I saw you without your pale, sweet mask

of composurewhen I saw you moved and glowing, with your eyes and your hands alive, and when you

made me understand that for such a creature as you there had been emptiness and the mere waste of yourself

for so long. Madness rose in me then, and my spirit was clamouring to say what I say at last now: that life

would never seem a full thing again because you could not love me, that I was taken for ever in the nets of

'Oh, stop!' she cried, suddenly throwing back her head, her face flaming and her hands clutching the cushions

beside her. She spoke fast and disjointedly, her breath coming quick. 'You shall not talk me into forgetting

common sense. What does all this mean? Oh, I do not recognize you at allyou seem another man. We are

not children; have you forgotten that? You speak like a boy in love for the first time. It is foolish, unrealI

know that if you do not. I will not hear it. What has happened to you?' She was half sobbing. 'How can these

'Gone!' exclaimed Trent, with an abrupt laugh. 'It has got right away. I am going after it in a minute.' He

looked gravely down into her eyes. 'I don't care so much now. I never could declare myself to you under the

cloud of your great fortune. It was too heavy. There's nothing creditable in that feeling, as I look at it; as a

matter of simple fact it was a form of cowardicefear of what you would think, and very likely sayfear of

the world's comment too, I suppose. But the cloud being rolled away, I have spoken, and I don't care so

much. I can face things with a quiet mind now that I have told you the truth in its own terms. You may call it

sentimentality or any other nickname you like. It is quite true that it was not intended for a scientific

statement. Since it annoys you, let it be extinguished. But please believe that it was serious to me if it was

comedy to you. I have said that I love you, and honour you, and would hold you dearest of all the world. Now

'If you insist,' Trent said, 'I suppose you will have your way. But I had much rather write it when I am not

with you. However, if I must, bring me a tablet whiter than a star, or hand of hymning angel; I mean a sheet

of notepaper not stamped with your address. Don't underestimate the sacrifice I am making. I never felt less

'What shall I say?' he enquired, his pen hovering over the paper. 'Shall I compare him to a summer's day?

He shook his head. 'What I want to saywhat I have been wanting for the past twentyfour hours to say to

every man, woman, and child I metis "Mabel and I are betrothed, and all is gas and gaiters." But that

wouldn't be a very good opening for a letter of strictly formal, not to say sinister, character. I have got as far

'I am sending you a manuscript,' she prompted, 'which I thought you might like to see.'

'Do you realize,' he said, 'that in that sentence there are only two words of more than one syllable? This letter

'I don't see why,' she answered. 'I know it is usual, but why is it? I have had a great many letters from lawyers

and business people, and they always begin, "with reference to our communication", or some such mouthful,

and go on like that all the way through. Yet when I see them they don't talk like that. It seems ridiculous to

'It is not at all ridiculous to them.' Trent laid aside the pen with an appearance of relief and rose to his feet.

'Let me explain. A people like our own, not very fond of using its mind, gets on in the ordinary way with a

very small and simple vocabulary. Long words are abnormal, and like everything else that is abnormal, they

are either very funny or tremendously solemn. Take the phrase "intelligent anticipation", for instance. If such

a phrase had been used in any other country in Europe, it would not have attracted the slightest attention.

With us it has become a proverb; we all grin when we hear it in a speech or read it in a leading article; it is

considered to be one of the best things ever said. Why? Just because it consists of two long words. The idea

expressed is as commonplace as cold mutton. Then there's "terminological inexactitude". How we all roared,

and are still roaring, at that! And the whole of the joke is that the words are long. It's just the same when we

want to be very serious; we mark it by turning to long words. When a solicitor can begin a sentence with,

"pursuant to the instructions communicated to our representative, or some such gibberish, he feels that he is

earning his sixandeightpence. Don't laugh! It is perfectly true. Now Continentals haven't got that feeling.

They are always bothering about ideas, and the result is that every shopkeeper or peasant has a vocabulary in

daily use that is simply Greek to the vast majority of Britons. I remember some time ago I was dining with a

friend of mine who is a Paris cabman. We had dinner at a dirty little restaurant opposite the central post

office, a place where all the clients were cabmen or porters. Conversation was general, and it struck me that a

London cabman would have felt a little out of his depth. Words like "functionary" and "unforgettable" and

"exterminate" and "independence" hurtled across the table every instant. And these were just ordinary,

vulgar, jolly, redfaced cabmen. Mind you,' he went on hurriedly, as the lady crossed the room and took up

his pen, 'I merely mention this to illustrate my point. I'm not saying that cabmen ought to be intellectuals. I

don't think so; I agree with Keatshappy is England, sweet her artless cabmen, enough their simple

loveliness for me. But when you come to the people who make up the collective industrial brainpower of

'Oh no, no, no!' cried Mrs Manderson. 'I don't know anything at the moment, except that your talking must be

stopped somehow, if we are to get any further with that letter to Mr Marlowe. You shall not get out of it.

Trent looked at it with distaste. 'I warn you not to discourage my talking,' he said dejectedly. 'Believe me,

men who don't talk are even worse to live with than men who do. O have a care of natures that are mute. I

confess I'm shirking writing this thing. It is almost an indecency. It's mixing two moods to write the sort of

letter I mean to write, and at the same time to be sitting in the same room with you.'

She led him to his abandoned chair before the escritoire and pushed him gently into it. 'Well, but please try. I

want to see what you write, and I want it to go to him at once. You see, I would be contented enough to leave

things as they are; but you say you must get at the truth, and if you must, I want it to be as soon as possible.

Do it nowyou know you can if you willand I'll send it off the moment it's ready. Don't you ever feel

thatthe longing to get the worrying letter into the post and off your hands, so that you can't recall it if you

'I will do as you wish,' he said, and turned to the paper, which he dated as from his hotel. Mrs Manderson

looked down at his bent head with a gentle light in her eyes, and made as if to place a smoothing hand upon

his rather untidy crop of hair. But she did not touch it. Going in silence to the piano, she began to play very

Mrs Manderson looked over her shoulder. 'Of course he dare not take that line. He will speak to prevent you

'But I'm not going to do that anyhow. You wouldn't allow ityou said so; besides, I won't if you would. The

Trent sighed. 'What extraordinary things codes of honour are!' he remarked abstractedly. 'I know that there

are things I should do, and never think twice about, which would make you feel disgraced if you did

themsuch as giving any one who grossly insulted me a black eye, or swearing violently when I barked my

shin in a dark room. And now you are calmly recommending me to bluff Marlowe by means of a tacit threat

which I don't mean; a thing which hews most abandoned fiend did never, in the drunkenness of guiltwell,

anyhow, I won't do it.' He resumed his writing, and the lady, with an indulgent smile, returned to playing very

In a few minutes more, Trent said: 'At last I am his faithfully. Do you want to see it?' She ran across the

twilight room, and turned on a reading lamp beside the escritoire. Then, leaning on his shoulder, she read

At this point Mrs Manderson raised her eyes quickly from the letter. Her dark brows were drawn together.

'Your uncle is the other. I sought him out last night and told him the whole story. Have you anything against

it? I always felt uneasy at keeping it from him as I did, because I had led him to expect I should tell him all I

discovered, and my silence looked like mysterymaking. Now it is to be cleared up finally, and there is no

question of shielding you, I wanted him to know everything. He is a very shrewd adviser, too, in a way of his

own; and I should like to have him with me when I see Marlowe. I have a feeling that two heads will be

She sighed. 'Yes, of course, uncle ought to know the truth. I hope there is nobody else at all.' She pressed his

hand. 'I so much want all that horror buriedburied deep. I am very happy now, dear, but I shall be happier

still when you have satisfied that curious mind of yours and found out everything, and stamped down the

What a very stiff letter!' she said. 'Now I am sure you couldn't have made it any stiffer in your own rooms.'

Trent slipped the letter and enclosure into a long envelope. 'Yes,' he said, 'I think it will make him sit up

suddenly. Now this thing mustn't run any risk of going wrong. It would be best to send a special messenger

with orders to deliver it into his own hands. If he's away it oughtn't to be left.'

When Mrs Manderson returned, he was hunting through the music cabinet. She sank on the carpet beside him

'When you saw uncle last night, did you tell him aboutabout us?' 'I did not,' he answered. 'I remembered

you had said nothing about telling any one. It is for youisn't it?to decide whether we take the world into

'Then will you tell him?' She looked down at her clasped hands. 'I wish you to tell him. Perhaps if you think

you will guess why .... There! that is settled.' She lifted her eyes again to his, and for a time there was silence

He leaned back at length in the deep chair. 'What a world!' he said. 'Mabel, will you play something on the

piano that expresses mere joy, the genuine article, nothing feverish or like thorns under a pot, but joy that has

decided in favour of the universe? It's a mood that can't last altogether, so we had better get all we can out of

She went to the instrument and struck a few chords while she thought. Then she began to work with all her

soul at the theme in the last movement of the Ninth Symphony which is like the sound of the opening of the

An old oaken desk with a deep body stood by the window in a room that overlooked St James s Park from a

height. The room was large, furnished and decorated by some one who had brought taste to the work; but the

hand of the bachelor lay heavy upon it. John Marlowe unlocked the desk and drew a long, stout envelope the

'I read it for the first time two days ago,' replied Mr Cupples, who, seated on a sofa, was peering about the

Marlowe turned to Trent. 'There is your manuscript,' he said, laying the envelope on the table. 'I have gone

over it three times. I do not believe there is another man who could have got at as much of the truth as you

Trent ignored the compliment. He sat by the table gazing stonily at the fire, his long legs twisted beneath his

chair. 'You mean, of course, he said, drawing the envelope towards him, 'that there is more of the truth to be

disclosed now. We are ready to hear you as soon as you like. I expect it will be a long story, and the longer

the better, so far as I am concerned; I want to understand thoroughly. What we should both like, I think, is

some preliminary account of Manderson and your relations with him. It seemed to me from the first that the

'You were right, Marlowe answered grimly. He crossed the room and seated himself on a corner of the tall

'I ought to tell you beforehand, said Trent, looking him in the eyes, 'that although I am here to listen to you, I

have not as yet any reason to doubt the conclusions I have stated here.' He tapped the envelope. 'It is a

'Perfectly.' Marlowe was cool and in complete possession of himself, a man different indeed from the

wornout, nervous being Trent remembered at Marlstone a year and a half ago. His tall, lithe figure was held

with the perfection of muscular tone. His brow was candid, his blue eyes were clear, though they still had, as

he paused collecting his ideas, the look that had troubled Trent at their first meeting. Only the lines of his

mouth showed that he knew himself in a position of difficulty, and meant to face it.

'Sigsbee Manderson was not a man of normal mind,' Marlowe began in his quiet voice. 'Most of the very rich

men I met with in America had become so by virtue of abnormal greed, or abnormal industry, or abnormal

personal force, or abnormal luck. None of them had remarkable intellects. Manderson delighted too in

heaping up wealth; he worked incessantly at it; he was a man of dominant will; he had quite his share of luck;

but what made him singular was his brainpower. In his own country they would perhaps tell you that it was

his ruthlessness in pursuit of his aims that was his most striking characteristic; but there are hundreds of them

who would have carried out his plans with just as little consideration for others if they could have formed the

'I'm not saying Americans aren't clever; they are ten times cleverer than we are, as a nation; but I never met

another who showed such a degree of sagacity and foresight, such gifts of memory and mental tenacity, such

sheer force of intelligence, as there was behind everything Manderson did in his moneymaking career. They

called him the "Napoleon of Wall Street" often enough in the papers; but few people knew so well as I did

how much truth there was in the phrase. He seemed never to forget a fact that might be of use to him, in the

first place; and he did systematically with the business facts that concerned him what Napoleon did, as I have

read, with military facts. He studied them in special digests which were prepared for him at short intervals,

and which he always had at hand, so that he could take up his report on coal or wheat or railways, or

whatever it might be, in any unoccupied moment. Then he could make a bolder and cleverer plan than any

man of them all. People got to know that Manderson would never do the obvious thing, but they got no

further; the thing he did do was almost always a surprise, and much of his success flowed from that. The

Street got rattled, as they used to put it, when known that the old man was out with his gun, and often his

opponents seemed to surrender as easily as Colonel Crockett's coon in the story. The scheme I am going to

describe to you would have occupied most men long enough. Manderson could have plotted the thing, down

'I used to think that his strain of Indian blood, remote as it was, might have something to do with the cunning

and ruthlessness of the man. Strangely enough, its existence was unknown to any one but himself and me. It

was when he asked me to apply my taste for genealogical work to his own obscure family history that I made

the discovery that he had in him a share of the blood of the Iroquois chief Montour and his French wife, a

terrible woman who ruled the savage politics of the tribes of the Wilderness two hundred years ago. The

Mandersons were active in the fur trade on the Pennsylvanian border in those days, and more than one of

them married Indian women. Other Indian blood than Montour's may have descended to Manderson, for all I

can say, through previous and subsequent unions; some of the wives' antecedents were quite untraceable, and

there were so many generations of pioneering before the whole country was brought under civilization. My

researches left me with the idea that there is a very great deal of the aboriginal blood present in the

genealogical makeup of the people of America, and that it is very widely spread. The newer families have

constantly intermarried with the older, and so many of them had a strain of the native in themand were often

rather proud of it, too, in those days. But Manderson had the idea about the disgracefulness of mixed blood,

which grew much stronger, I fancy, with the rise of the negro question after the war. He was thunderstruck at

what I told him, and was anxious to conceal it from every soul. Of course I never gave it away while he lived,

and I don't think he supposed I would; but I have thought since that his mind took a turn against me from that

'Had Manderson,' asked Mr Cupples, so unexpectedly that the others started, 'any definable religious

Marlowe considered a moment. 'None that ever I heard of,' he said. 'Worship and prayer were quite unknown

to him, so far as I could see, and I never heard him mention religion. I should doubt if he had any real sense

of God at all, or if he was capable of knowing God through the emotions. But I understood that as a child he

had had a religious upbringing with a strong moral side to it. His private life was, in the usual limited sense,

blameless. He was almost ascetic in his habits, except as to smoking. I lived with him four years without ever

knowing him to tell a direct verbal falsehood, constantly as he used to practise deceit in other forms. Can you

understand the soul of a man who never hesitated to take steps that would have the effect of hoodwinking

people, who would use every trick of the markets to mislead, and who was at the same time scrupulous never

to utter a direct lie on the most insignificant matter? Manderson was like that, and he was not the only one. I

suppose you might compare the state of mind to that of a soldier who is personally a truthful man, but who

will stick at nothing to deceive the enemy. The rules of the game allow it; and the same may be said of

'As you say,' Marlowe agreed. 'Now I was saying that one could always take Manderson's word if he gave it

in a definite form. The first time I ever heard him utter a downright lie was on the night he died; and hearing

Marlowe stared at the light above his head and Trent moved impatiently in his chair. 'Before we come to that,'

he said, 'will you tell us exactly on what footing you were with Manderson during the years you were with

'We were on very good terms from beginning to end,' answered Marlowe. 'Nothing like friendshiphe was

not a man for making friendsbut the best of terms as between a trusted employee and his chief. I went to

him as private secretary just after getting my degree at Oxford. I was to have gone into my father's business,

where I am now, but my father suggested that I should see the world for a year or two. So I took this

secretaryship, which seemed to promise a good deal of varied experience, and I had let the year or two run on

to four years before the end came. The offer came to me through the last thing in the world I should have put

At the word Trent struck his hands together with a muttered exclamation. The others looked at him in

'Chess!' repeated Trent. 'Do you know,' he said, rising and approaching Marlowe, 'what was the first thing I

noted about you at our first meeting? It was your eye, Mr Marlowe. I couldn't place it then, but I know now

where I had seen your eyes before. They were in the head of no less a man than the great Nikolay Korchagin,

with whom I once sat in the same railway carriage for two days. I thought I should never forget the chess eye

after that, but I could not put a name to it when I saw it in you. I beg your pardon,' he ended suddenly,

'I have played the game from my childhood, and with good players,' said Marlowe simply. 'It is an hereditary

gift, if you can call it a gift. At the University I was nearly as good as anybody there, and I gave most of my

brains to that and the OUDS and playing about generally. At Oxford, as I dare say you know, inducements to

amuse oneself at the expense of one's education are endless, and encouraged by the authorities. Well, one day

toward the end of my last term, Dr Munro of Queen's, whom I had never defeated, sent for me. He told me

that I played a fairish game of chess. I said it was very good of him to say so. Then he said, "They tell me you

hunt, too." I said, "Now and then." He asked, "Is there anything else you can do? "No," I said, not much

liking the tone of the conversationthe old man generally succeeded in putting people's backs up. He grunted

fiercely, and then told me that enquiries were being made on behalf of a wealthy American man of business

who wanted an English secretary. Manderson was the name, he said. He seemed never to have heard it

before, which was quite possible, as he never opened a newspaper and had not slept a night outside the

college for thirty years. If I could rub up my spellingas the old gentleman put itI might have a good

chance for the post, as chess and riding and an Oxford education were the only indispensable points.

'Well, I became Manderson's secretary. For a long time I liked the position greatly. When one is attached to

an active American plutocrat in the prime of life one need not have many dull moments. Besides, it made me

independent. My father had some serious business reverses about that time, and I was glad to be able to do

without an allowance from him. At the end of the first year Manderson doubled my salary. "It's big money,"

he said, "but I guess I don't lose." You see, by that time I was doing a great deal more than accompany him

on horseback in the morning and play chess in the evening, which was mainly what he had required. I was

attending to his houses, his farm in Ohio, his shooting in Maine, his horses, his cars, and his yacht. I had

become a walking railwayguide and an expert cigarbuyer. I was always learning something.

'Well, now you understand what my position was in regard to Manderson during the last two or three years of

my connection with him. It was a happy life for me on the whole. I was busy, my work was varied and

interesting; I had time to amuse myself too, and money to spend. At one time I made a fool of myself about a

girl, and that was not a happy time; but it taught me to understand the great goodness of Mrs Manderson.'

Marlowe inclined his head to Mr Cupples as he said this. 'She may choose to tell you about it. As for her

husband, he had never varied in his attitude towards me, in spite of the change that came over him in the last

months of his life, as you know. He treated me well and generously in his unsympathetic way, and I never

had a feeling that he was less than satisfied with his bargainthat was the sort of footing we lived upon. And

it was that continuance of his attitude right up to the end that made the revelation so shocking when I was

suddenly shown, on the night on which he met his end, the depth of crazy hatred of myself that was in

'You never suspected that he hated you before that time?' asked Trent; and Mr Cupples asked at the same

'I never guessed until that night,' answered Marlowe, 'that he had the smallest illfeeling toward me. How

long it had existed I do not know. I cannot imagine why it was there. I was forced to think, when I considered

the thing in those awful days after his death, that it was a case of a madman's delusion, that he believed me to

be plotting against him, as they so often do. Some such insane conviction must have been at the root of it. But

who can sound the abysses of a lunatic's fancy? Can you imagine the state of mind in which a man dooms

himself to death with the object of delivering some one he hates to the hangman?'

Mr Cupples moved sharply in his chair. 'You say Manderson was responsible for his own death?' he asked.

Trent glanced at him with an eye of impatience, and resumed his intent watch upon the face of Marlowe. In

'I do say so,' Marlowe answered concisely, and looked his questioner in the face. Mr Cupples nodded.

'Before we proceed to the elucidation of your statement,' observed the old gentleman, in a tone of one

discussing a point of abstract science, 'it may be remarked that the state of mind which you attribute to

'Suppose we have the story first,' Trent interrupted, gently laying a hand on Mr Cupples's arm. 'You were

telling us,' he went on, turning to Marlowe, 'how things stood between you and Manderson. Now you tell us

Marlowe flushed at the barely perceptible emphasis which Trent laid upon the word 'facts'. He drew himself

Bunner and myself dined with Mr and Mrs Manderson that Sunday evening,' he began, speaking carefully. 'It

was just like other dinners at which the four of us had been together. Manderson was taciturn and gloomy, as

we had latterly been accustomed to see him. We others kept a conversation going. We rose from the table, I

suppose, about nine. Mrs Manderson went to the drawingroom, and Bunner went up to the hotel to see an

acquaintance. Manderson asked me to come into the orchard behind the house, saying he wished to have a

talk. We paced up and down the pathway there, out of earshot from the house, and Manderson, as he smoked

his cigar, spoke to me in his cool, deliberate way. He had never seemed more sane, or more welldisposed to

me. He said he wanted me to do him an important service. There was a big thing on. It was a secret affair.

Bunner knew nothing of it, and the less I knew the better. He wanted me to do exactly as he directed, and not

'This, I may say, was quite characteristic of Manderson's method of going to work. If at times he required a

man to be a mere tool in his hand, he would tell him so. He had used me in the same kind of way a dozen

times. I assured him he could rely on me, and said I was ready. "Right now?" he asked. I said of course I was.

'He nodded, and saidI tell you his words as well as I can recollect them attend to this. There is a man in

England now who is in this thing with me. He was to have left tomorrow for Paris by the noon boat from

Southampton to Havre. His name is George Harrisat least that's the name he is going by. Do you

remember that name?" "Yes," I said, "when I went up to London a week ago you asked me to book a cabin in

that name on the boat that goes tomorrow. I gave you the ticket." "Here it is," he said, producing it from his

'"Now," Manderson said to me, poking his cigarbutt at me with each sentence in a way he used to have,

"George Harris cannot leave England tomorrow. I find I shall want him where he is. And I want Bunner

where he is. But somebody has got to go by that boat and take certain papers to Paris. Or else my plan is

going to fall to pieces. Will you go?" I said, "Certainly. I am here to obey orders."

'He bit his cigar, and said, "That's all right; but these are not just ordinary orders. Not the kind of thing one

can ask of a man in the ordinary way of his duty to an employer. The point is this. The deal I am busy with is

one in which neither myself nor any one known to be connected with me must appear as yet. That is vital. But

these people I am up against know your face as well as they know mine. If my secretary is known in certain

quarters to have crossed to Paris at this time and to have interviewed certain peopleand that would be

known as soon as it happenedthen the game is up." He threw away his cigarend and looked at me

'I didn't like it much, but I liked failing Manderson at a pinch still less. I spoke lightly. I said I supposed I

should have to conceal my identity, and I would do my best. I told him I used to be pretty good at makeup.

'He nodded in approval. He said, "That's good. I judged you would not let me down." Then he gave me my

instructions. "You take the car right now," he said, "and start for Southamptonthere's no train that will fit

in. You'll be driving all night. Barring accidents, you ought to get there by six in the morning. But whenever

you arrive, drive straight to the Bedford Hotel and ask for George Harris. If he's there, tell him you are to go

over instead of him, and ask him to telephone me here. It is very important he should know that at the earliest

moment possible. But if he isn't there, that means he has got the instructions I wired today, and hasn't gone to

Southampton. In that case you don't want to trouble about him any more, but just wait for the boat. You can

leave the car at a garage under a fancy namemine must not be given. See about changing your

appearanceI don't care how, so you do it well. Travel by the boat as George Harris. Let on to be anything

you like, but be careful, and don't talk much to anybody. When you arrive, take a room at the Hotel St

Petersbourg. You will receive a note or message there, addressed to George Harris, telling you where to take

the wallet I shall give you. The wallet is locked, and you want to take good care of it. Have you got that all

'I repeated the instructions. I asked if I should return from Paris after handing over the wallet. "As soon as

you like," he said. "And mind this whatever happens, don't communicate with me at any stage of the

journey. If you don't get the message in Paris at once, just wait until you dodays, if necessary. But not a

line of any sort to me. Understand? Now get ready as quick as you can. I'll go with you in the car a little way.

'That is, as far as I can remember, the exact substance of what Manderson said to me that night. I went to my

room, changed into day clothes, and hastily threw a few necessaries into a kitbag. My mind was in a whirl,

not so much at the nature of the business as at the suddenness of it. I think I remember telling you the last

time we met'he turned to Trent'that Manderson shared the national fondness for doings things in a

storybook style. Other things being equal, he delighted in a bit of mystification and melodrama, and I told

myself that this was Manderson all over. I hurried downstairs with my bag and rejoined him in the library. He

handed me a stout leather lettercase, about eight inches by six, fastened with a strap with a lock on it. I

could just squeeze it into my sidepocket. Then I went to get the car from the garage behind the house.

'As I was bringing it round to the front a disconcerting thought struck me. I remembered that I had only a few

'For some time past I had been keeping myself very short of cash, and for this reasonwhich I tell you

because it is a vital point, as you shall see in a minute. I was living temporarily on borrowed money. I had

always been careless about money while I was with Manderson, and being a gregarious animal I had made

many friends, some of them belonging to a New York set that had little to do but get rid of the large incomes

given them by their parents. Still, I was very well paid, and I was too busy even to attempt to go very far with

them in that amusing occupation. I was still well on the right side of the ledger until I began, merely out of

curiosity, to play at speculation. It's a very old story particularly in Wall Street. I thought it was easy; I was

lucky at first; I would always be prudentand so on. Then came the day when I went out of my depth. In

one week I was separated from my toll, as Bunner expressed it when I told him; and I owed money too. I had

had my lesson. Now in this pass I went to Manderson and told him what I had done and how I stood. He

heard me with a very grim smile, and then, with the nearest approach to sympathy I had ever found in him, he

advanced me a sum on account of my salary that would clear me. "Don't play the markets any more," was all

'Now on that Sunday night Manderson knew that I was practically without any money in the world. He knew

that Bunner knew it too. He may have known that I had even borrowed a little more from Bunner for

pocketmoney until my next cheque was due, which, owing to my anticipation of my salary, would not have

'As soon as I had brought the car round I went into the library and stated the difficulty to Manderson.

'What followed gave me, slight as it was, my first impression of something odd being afoot. As soon as I

mentioned the word "expenses'' his hand went mechanically to his left hippocket, where he always kept a

little case containing notes to the value of about a hundred pounds in our money. This was such a rooted habit

in him that I was astonished to see him check the movement suddenly. Then, to my greater amazement, he

swore under his breath. I had never heard him do this before; but Bunner had told me that of late he had often

shown irritation in this way when they were alone. "Has he mislaid his notecase?" was the question that

flashed through my mind. But it seemed to me that it could not affect his plan at all, and I will tell you why.

The week before, when I had gone up to London to carry out various commissions, including the booking of

a berth for Mr George Harris, I had drawn a thousand pounds for Manderson from his bankers, and all, at his

request, in notes of small amounts. I did not know what this unusually large sum in cash was for, but I did

know that the packets of notes were in his locked desk in the library, or had been earlier in the day, when I

'But instead of turning to the desk, Manderson stood looking at me. There was fury in his face, and it was a

strange sight to see him gradually master it until his eyes grew cold again. "Wait in the car," he said slowly.

"I will get some money." We both went out, and as I was getting into my overcoat in the hall I saw him enter

'I stepped out on to the lawn before the house and smoked a cigarette, pacing up and down. I was asking

myself again and again where that thousand pounds was; whether it was in the drawingroom, and if so, why.

Presently, as I passed one of the drawingroom windows, I noticed Mrs Manderson's shadow on the thin silk

curtain. She was standing at her escritoire. The window was open, and as I passed I heard her say, "I have not

quite thirty pounds here. Will that be enough?" I did not hear the answer, but next moment Manderson's

shadow was mingled with hers, and I heard the chink of money. Then, as he stood by the window, and as I

was moving away, these words of his came to my earsand these at least I can repeat exactly, for

astonishment stamped them on my memory"I'm going out now. Marlowe has persuaded me to go for a

moonlight run in the car. He is very urgent about it. He says it will help me to sleep, and I guess he is right."

I have told you that in the course of four years I had never once heard Manderson utter a direct lie about

anything, great or small. I believed that I understood the man's queer, skindeep morality, and I could have

sworn that if he was firmly pressed with a question that could not be evaded he would either refuse to answer

or tell the truth. But what had I just heard? No answer to any question. A voluntary statement, precise in

terms, that was utterly false. The unimaginable had happened. It was almost as if some one I knew well, in a

moment of closest sympathy, had suddenly struck me in the face. The blood rushed to my head, and I stood

still on the grass. I stood there until I heard his step at the front door, and then I pulled myself together and

stepped quickly to the car. He handed me a banker's paper bag with gold and notes in it. "There's more than

'For a minute or so I stood discussing with Mandersonit was by one of those tours de force of which one's

mind is capable under great excitementpoints about the route of the long drive before me. I had made the

run several times by day, and I believe I spoke quite calmly and naturally about it. But while I spoke my

mind was seething in a flood of suddenly born suspicion and fear. I did not know what I feared. I simply felt

fear, somehowI did not know how connected with Manderson. My soul once opened to it, fear rushed in

like an assaulting army. I feltI knewthat something was altogether wrong and sinister, and I felt myself

to be the object of it. Yet Manderson was surely no enemy of mine. Then my thoughts reached out wildly for

an answer to the question why he had told that lie. And all the time the blood hammered in my ears, "Where

is that money?" Reason struggled hard to set up the suggestion that the two things were not necessarily

connected. The instinct of a man in danger would not listen to it. As we started, and the car took the curve

into the road, it was merely the unconscious part of me that steered and controlled it, and that made

occasional empty remarks as we slid along in the moonlight. Within me was a confusion and vague alarm that

'About a mile from the house, you remember, one passed on one's left a gate, on the other side of which was

the golfcourse. There Manderson said he would get down, and I stopped the car. "You've got it all clear?" he

asked. With a sort of wrench I forced myself to remember and repeat the directions given me. "That's OK,"

he said. "Goodbye, then. Stay with that wallet." Those were the last words I heard him speak, as the car

Marlowe rose from his chair and pressed his hands to his eyes. He was flushed with the excitement of his

own narrative, and there was in his look a horror of recollection that held both the listeners silent. He shook

himself with a movement like a dog's, and then, his hands behind him, stood erect before the fire as he

Trent nodded quickly, his face alive with anticipation; but Mr Cupples, who cherished a mild but obstinate

'It is a small round or more often rectangular mirror,' Marlowe explained, 'rigged out from the right side of

the screen in front of the driver, and adjusted in such a way that he can see, without turning round, if anything

is coming up behind to pass him. It is quite an ordinary appliance, and there was one on this car. As the car

moved on, and Manderson ceased speaking behind me, I saw in that mirror a thing that I wish I could forget.'

'Manderson's face,' he said in a low tone. 'He was standing in the road, looking after me, only a few yards

behind, and the moonlight was full on his face. The mirror happened to catch it for an instant.

'Physical habit is a wonderful thing. I did not shift hand or foot on the controlling mechanism of the car.

Indeed, I dare say it steadied me against the shock to have myself braced to the business of driving. You have

read in books, no doubt, of hell looking out of a man's eyes, but perhaps you don't know what a good

metaphor that is. If I had not known Manderson was there, I should not have recognized the face. It was that

of a madman, distorted, hideous in the imbecility of hate, the teeth bared in a simian grin of ferocity and

triumph; the eyes .... In the little mirror I had this glimpse of the face alone. I saw nothing of whatever gesture

there may have been as that writhing white mask glared after me. And I saw it only for a flash. The car went

on, gathering speed, and as it went, my brain, suddenly purged of the vapours of doubt and perplexity, was as

'You say something in that manuscript of yours, Mr Trent, about the swift automatic way in which one's ideas

arrange themselves about some new illuminating thought. It is quite true. The awful intensity of illwill that

had flamed after me from those straining eyeballs poured over my mind like a searchlight. I was thinking

quite clearly now, and almost coldly, for I knew whatat least I knew whomI had to fear, and instinct

warned me that it was not a time to give room to the emotions that were fighting to possess me. The man

hated me insanely. That incredible fact I suddenly knew. But the face had told me, it would have told

anybody, more than that. It was a face of hatred gratified, it proclaimed some damnable triumph. It had

gloated over me driving away to my fate. This too was plain to me. And to what fate?

'I stopped the car. It had gone about two hundred and fifty yards, and a sharp bend of the road hid the spot

where I had set Manderson down. I lay back in the seat and thought it out. Something was to happen to me. In

Paris? Probablywhy else should I be sent there, with money and a ticket? But why Paris? That puzzled me,

for I had no melodramatic ideas about Paris. I put the point aside for a moment. I turned to the other things

that had roused my attention that evening. The lie about my "persuading him to go for a moonlight run".

What was the intention of that? Manderson, I said to myself, will be returning without me while I am on my

way to Southampton. What will he tell them about me? How account for his returning alone, and without the

car? As I asked myself that sinister question there rushed into my mind the last of my difficulties: "Where are

the thousand pounds?" And in the same instant came the answer: "The thousand pounds are in my pocket."

'I got up and stepped from the car. My knees trembled and I felt very sick. I saw the plot now, as I thought.

The whole of the story about the papers and the necessity of their being taken to Paris was a blind. With

Manderson's money about me, of which he would declare I had robbed him, I was, to all appearance,

attempting to escape from England, with every precaution that guilt could suggest. He would communicate

with the police at once, and would know how to put them on my track. I should be arrested in Paris, if I got

so far, living under a false name, after having left the car under a false name, disguised myself, and travelled

in a cabin which I had booked in advance, also under a false name. It would be plainly the crime of a man

without money, and for some reason desperately in want of it. As for my account of the affair, it would be too

'As this ghastly array of incriminating circumstances rose up before me, I dragged the stout lettercase from

my pocket. In the intensity of the moment, I never entertained the faintest doubt that I was right, and that the

money was there. It would easily hold the packets of notes. But as I felt it and weighed it in my hands it

seemed to me there must be more than this. It was too bulky. What more was to be laid to my charge? After

all, a thousand pounds was not much to tempt a man like myself to run the risk of penal servitude. In this new

agitation, scarcely knowing what I did, I caught the surrounding strap in my fingers just above the fastening

and tore the staple out of the lock. Those locks, you know, are pretty flimsy as a rule.'

Here Marlowe paused and walked to the oaken desk before the window. Opening a drawer full of

miscellaneous objects, he took out a box of odd keys, and selected a small one distinguished by a piece of

He handed it to Trent. 'I keep that by me as a sort of morbid memento. It is the key to the lock I smashed. I

might have saved myself the trouble, if I had known that this key was at that moment in the lefthand

sidepocket of my overcoat. Manderson must have slipped it in, either while the coat was hanging in the hall

or while he sat at my side in the car. I might not have found the tiny thing there for weeks: as a matter of fact

I did find it two days after Manderson was dead, but a police search would have found it in five minutes. And

then II with the case and its contents in my pocket, my false name and my sham spectacles and the rest of

itI should have had no explanation to offer but the highly convincing one that I didn't know the key was

Trent dangled the key by its tape idly. Then: 'How do you know this is the key of that case?' he asked quickly.

'I tried it. As soon as I found it I went up and fitted it to the lock. I knew where I had left the thing. So do you,

I think, Mr Trent. Don't you?' There was a faint shade of mockery in Marlowe's voice.

'Touche,' Trent said, with a dry smile. 'I found a large empty lettercase with a burst lock lying with other

odds and ends on the dressingtable in Manderson's room. Your statement is that you put it there. I could

'There was no reason for hiding it,' said Marlowe. 'But to get back to my story. I burst the lock of the strap. I

opened the case before one of the lamps of the car. The first thing I found in it I ought to have expected, of

'It was' began Trent mechanically, and then stopped himself. 'Try not to bring me in any more, if you don't

mind,' he said, meeting the other's eye. 'I have complimented you already in that document on your

cleverness. You need not prove it by making the judge help you out with your evidence.'

'All right,' agreed Marlowe. 'I couldn't resist just that much. If you had been in my place you would have

known before I did that Manderson's little pocket case was there. As soon as I saw it, of course, I

remembered his not having had it about him when I asked for money, and his surprising anger. He had made

a false step. He had already fastened his notecase up with the rest of what was to figure as my plunder, and

placed it in my hands. I opened it. It contained a few notes as usual, I didn't count them.

'Tucked into the flaps of the big case in packets were the other notes, just as I had brought them from

London. And with them were two small washleather bags, the look of which I knew well. My heart jumped

sickeningly again, for this, too, was utterly unexpected. In those bags Manderson kept the diamonds in which

he had been investing for some time past. I didn't open them; I could feel the tiny stones shifting under the

pressure of my fingers. How many thousands of pounds' worth there were there I have no idea. We had

regarded Manderson's diamond buying as merely a speculative fad. I believe now that it was the earliest

movement in the scheme for my ruin. For any one like myself to be represented as having robbed him, there

'Now, I thought, I have the whole thing plain, and I must act. I saw instantly what I must do. I had left

Manderson about a mile from the house. It would take him twenty minutes, fifteen if he walked fast, to get

back to the house, where he would, of course, immediately tell his story of robbery, and probably telephone

at once to the police in Bishopsbridge. I had left him only five or six minutes ago; for all that I have just told

you was as quick thinking as I ever did. It would be easy to overtake him in the car before he neared the

house. There would be an awkward interview. I set my teeth as I thought of it, and all my fears vanished as I

began to savour the gratification of telling him my opinion of him. There are probably few people who ever

positively looked forward to an awkward interview with Manderson; but I was mad with rage. My honour

and my liberty had been plotted against with detestable treachery. I did not consider what would follow the

'I had started and turned the car, I was already going fast toward White Gables, when I heard the sound of a

'Instantly I stopped the car. My first wild thought was that Manderson was shooting at me. Then I realized

that the noise had not been close at hand. I could see nobody on the road, though the moonlight flooded it. I

had left Manderson at a spot just round the corner that was now about a hundred yards ahead of me. After

half a minute or so, I started again, and turned the corner at a slow pace. Then I stopped again with a jar, and

'Manderson lay dead a few steps from me on the turf within the gate, clearly visible to me in the moonlight.'

Marlowe made another pause, and Trent, with a puckered brow, enquired, 'On the golfcourse?'

'Obviously,' remarked Mr Cupples. 'The eighth green is just there.' He had grown more and more interested as

'On the green, quite close to the flag,' said Marlowe. 'He lay on his back, his arms were stretched abroad, his

jacket and heavy overcoat were open; the light shone hideously on his white face and his shirtfront; it

glistened on his bared teeth and one of the eyes. The other ... you saw it. The man was certainly dead. As I sat

there stunned, unable for the moment to think at all, I could even see a thin dark line of blood running down

from the shattered socket to the ear. Close by lay his soft black hat, and at his feet a pistol.

'I suppose it was only a few seconds that I sat helplessly staring at the body. Then I rose and moved to it with

dragging feet; for now the truth had come to me at last, and I realized the fullness of my appalling danger. It

was not only my liberty or my honour that the maniac had undermined. It was death that he had planned for

me; death with the degradation of the scaffold. To strike me down with certainty, he had not hesitated to end

his life; a life which was, no doubt, already threatened by a melancholic impulse to selfdestruction; and the

last agony of the suicide had been turned, perhaps, to a devilish joy by the thought that he dragged down my

life with his. For as far as I could see at the moment my situation was utterly hopeless. If it had been

desperate on the assumption that Manderson meant to denounce me as a thief, what was it now that his corpse

'I picked up the revolver and saw, almost without emotion, that it was my own. Manderson had taken it from

my room, I suppose, while I was getting out the car. At the same moment I remembered that it was by

Manderson's suggestion that I had had it engraved with my initials, to distinguish it from a precisely similar

'I bent over the body and satisfied myself that there was no life left in it. I must tell you here that I did not

notice, then or afterwards, the scratches and marks on the wrists, which were taken as evidence of a struggle

with an assailant. But I have no doubt that Manderson deliberately injured himself in this way before firing

'Though I never perceived that detail, however, it was evident enough as I looked at the body that Manderson

had not forgotten, in his last act on earth, to tie me tighter by putting out of court the question of suicide. He

had clearly been at pains to hold the pistol at arm's length, and there was not a trace of smoke or of burning

on the face. The wound was absolutely clean, and was already ceasing to bleed outwardly. I rose and paced

'I was the last to be seen with Manderson. I had persuaded himso he had lied to his wife and, as I

afterwards knew, to the butlerto go with me for the drive from which he never returned. My pistol had

killed him. It was true that by discovering his plot I had saved myself from heaping up further incriminating

factsflight, concealment, the possession of the treasure. But what need of them, after all? As I stood, what

Marlowe came to the table and leaned forward with his hands upon it. 'I want,' he said very earnestly, 'to try

to make you understand what was in my mind when I decided to do what I did. I hope you won't be bored,

because I must do it. You may both have thought I acted like a fool. But after all the police never suspected

me. I walked that green for a quarter of an hour, I suppose, thinking the thing out like a game of chess. I had

to think ahead and think coolly; for my safety depended on upsetting the plans of one of the longestheaded

men who ever lived. And remember that, for all I knew, there were details of the scheme still hidden from

'Two plain courses presented themselves at once. Either of them, I thought, would certainly prove fatal. I

could, in the first place, do the completely straightforward thing: take back the dead man, tell my story, hand

over the notes and diamonds, and trust to the saving power of truth and innocence. I could have laughed as I

thought of it. I saw myself bringing home the corpse and giving an account of myself, boggling with sheer

shame over the absurdity of my wholly unsupported tale, as I brought a charge of mad hatred and fiendish

treachery against a man who had never, as far as I knew, had a word to say against me. At every turn the

cunning of Manderson had forestalled me. His careful concealment of such a hatred was a characteristic

feature of the stratagem; only a man of his iron selfrestraint could have done it. You can see for yourselves

how every fact in my statement would appear, in the shadow of Manderson's death, a clumsy lie. I tried to

imagine myself telling such a story to the counsel for my defence. I could see the face with which he would

listen to it; I could read in the lines of it his thought, that to put forward such an impudent farrago would

mean merely the disappearance of any chance there might be of a commutation of the capital sentence.

'True, I had not fled. I had brought back the body; I had handed over the property. But how did that help me?

It would only suggest that I had yielded to a sudden funk after killing my man, and had no nerve left to clutch

at the fruits of the crime; it would suggest, perhaps, that I had not set out to kill but only to threaten, and that

when I found that I had done murder the heart went out of me. Turn it which way I would, I could see no

'The second of the obvious things that I might do was to take the hint offered by the situation, and to fly at

once. That too must prove fatal. There was the body. I had no time to hide it in such a way that it would not

be found at the first systematic search. But whatever I should do with the body, Manderson's not returning to

the house would cause uneasiness in two or three hours at most. Martin would suspect an accident to the car,

and would telephone to the police. At daybreak the roads would be scoured and enquiries telegraphed in

every direction. The police would act on the possibility of there being foul play. They would spread their nets

with energy in such a big business as the disappearance of Manderson. Ports and railway termini would be

watched. Within twentyfour hours the body would be found, and the whole country would be on the alert

for meall Europe, scarcely less; I did not believe there was a spot in Christendom where the man accused

of Manderson's murder could pass unchallenged, with every newspaper crying the fact of his death into the

ears of all the world. Every stranger would be suspect; every man, woman, and child would be a detective.

The car, wherever I should abandon it, would put people on my track. If I had to choose between two utterly

hopeless courses, I decided, I would take that of telling the preposterous truth.

'But now I cast about desperately for some tale that would seem more plausible than the truth. Could I save

my neck by a lie? One after another came into my mind; I need not trouble to remember them now. Each had

its own futilities and perils; but every one split upon the factor what would be taken for factthat I had

induced Manderson to go out with me, and the fact that he had never returned alive. Notion after notion I

swiftly rejected as I paced there by the dead man, and doom seemed to settle down upon me more heavily as

'Several times I had repeated to myself halfconsciously, as a sort of refrain, the words in which I had heard

Manderson tell his wife that I had induced him to go out. "Marlowe has persuaded me to go for a moonlight

run in the car. He is very urgent about it." All at once it struck me that, without meaning to do so, I was

'As you found out for yourself, Mr Trent, I have a natural gift of mimicry. I had imitated Manderson's voice

many times so successfully as to deceive even Bunner, who had been much more in his company than his

own wife. It was, you remember'Marlowe turned to Mr Cupples'a strong, metallic voice, of great

carrying power, so unusual as to make it a very fascinating voice to imitate, and at the same time very easy. I

said the words carefully to myself again, like this' he uttered them, and Mr Cupples opened his eyes in

amazement'and then I struck my hand upon the low wall beside me. "Manderson never returned alive?" I

'In thirty seconds the bare outline of the plan was complete in my mind. I did not wait to think over details.

Every instant was precious now. I lifted the body and laid it on the floor of the car, covered with a rug. I took

the hat and the revolver. Not one trace remained on the green, I believe, of that night's work. As I drove back

to White Gables my design took shape before me with a rapidity and ease that filled me with a wild

excitement. I should escape yet! It was all so easy if I kept my pluck. Putting aside the unusual and unlikely, I

'Nearing the house I slackened speed, and carefully reconnoitred the road. Nothing was moving. I turned the

car into the open field on the other side of the road, about twenty paces short of the little door at the extreme

corner of the grounds. I brought it to rest behind a stack. When, with Manderson's hat on my head and the

pistol in my pocket, I had staggered with the body across the moonlit road and through that door, I left much

of my apprehension behind me. With swift action and an unbroken nerve I thought I ought to succeed.'

With a long sigh Marlowe threw himself into one of the deep chairs at the fireside and passed his

handkerchief over his damp forehead. Each of his hearers, too, drew a deep breath, but not audibly.

'Everything else you know,' he said. He took a cigarette from a box beside him and lighted it. Trent watched

the very slight quiver of the hand that held the match, and privately noted that his own was at the moment not

'The shoes that betrayed me to you,' pursued Marlowe after a short silence, 'were painful all the time I wore

them, but I never dreamed that they had given anywhere. I knew that no footstep of mine must appear by any

accident in the soft ground about the hut where I laid the body, or between the hut and the house, so I took the

shoes off and crammed my feet into them as soon as I was inside the little door. I left my own shoes, with my

own jacket and overcoat, near the body, ready to be resumed later. I made a clear footmark on the soft gravel

outside the French window, and several on the drugget round the carpet. The stripping off of the outer

clothing of the body, and the dressing of it afterwards in the brown suit and shoes, and putting the things into

the pockets, was a horrible business; and getting the teeth out of the mouth was worse. The headbut you

don't want to hear about it. I didn't feel it much at the time. I was wriggling my own head out of a noose, you

see. I wish I had thought of pulling down the cuffs, and had tied the shoes more neatly. And putting the watch

'You were wrong, by the way, about the whisky. After one stiffish drink I had no more; but I filled up a flask

that was in the cupboard, and pocketed it. I had a night of peculiar anxiety and effort in front of me and I

didn't know how I should stand it. I had to take some once or twice during the drive. Speaking of that, you

give rather a generous allowance of time in your document for doing that run by night. You say that to get to

Southampton by halfpast six in that car, under the conditions, a man must, even if he drove like a demon,

have left Marlstone by twelve at latest. I had not got the body dressed in the other suit, with tie and

watchchain and so forth, until nearly ten minutes past; and then I had to get to the car and start it going. But

then I don't suppose any other man would have taken the risks I did in that car at night, without a headlight. It

'There's nothing much to say about what I did in the house. I spent the time after Martin had left me in

carefully thinking over the remaining steps in my plan, while I unloaded and thoroughly cleaned the revolver

using my handkerchief and a penholder from the desk. I also placed the packets of notes, the note case, and

the diamonds in the rolltop desk, which I opened and relocked with Manderson's key. When I went upstairs

it was a trying moment, for though I was safe from the eyes of Martin, as he sat in his pantry, there was a

faint possibility of somebody being about on the bedroom floor. I had sometimes found the French maid

wandering about there when the other servants were in bed. Bunner, I knew, was a deep sleeper, Mrs

Manderson, I had gathered from things I had heard her say, was usually asleep by eleven; I had thought it

possible that her gift of sleep had helped her to retain all her beauty and vitality in spite of a marriage which

we all knew was an unhappy one. Still it was uneasy work mounting the stairs, and holding myself ready to

retreat to the library again at the least sound from above. But nothing happened.

'The first thing I did on reaching the corridor was to enter my room and put the revolver and cartridges back

in the case. Then I turned off the light and went quietly into Manderson's room.

'What I had to do there you know. I had to take off the shoes and put them outside the door, leave

Manderson's jacket, waistcoat, trousers, and black tie, after taking everything out of the pockets, select a suit

and tie and shoes for the body, and place the dental plate in the bowl, which I moved from the washingstand

to the bedside, leaving those ruinous fingermarks as I did so. The marks on the drawer must have been made

when I shut it after taking out the tie. Then I had to lie down in the bed and tumble it. You know all about

itall except my state of mind, which you couldn't imagine and I couldn't describe.

'The worst came when I had hardly begun my operations: the moment when Mrs Manderson spoke from the

room where I supposed her asleep. I was prepared for it happening; it was a possibility; but I nearly lost my

'By the way, I may tell you this: in the extremely unlikely contingency of Mrs Manderson remaining awake,

and so putting out of the question my escape by way of her window, I had planned simply to remain where I

was a few hours, and then, not speaking to her, to leave the house quickly and quietly by the ordinary way.

Martin would have been in bed by that time. I might have been heard to leave, but not seen. I should have

done just as I had planned with the body, and then made the best time I could in the car to Southampton. The

difference would have been that I couldn't have furnished an unquestionable alibi by turning up at the hotel at

6.30. I should have made the best of it by driving straight to the docks, and making my ostentatious enquiries

there. I could in any case have got there long before the boat left at noon. I couldn't see that anybody could

suspect me of the supposed murder in any case; but if any one had, and if I hadn't arrived until ten o'clock,

say, I shouldn't have been able to answer, "It is impossible for me to have got to Southampton so soon after

shooting him." I should simply have had to say I was delayed by a breakdown after leaving Manderson at

halfpast ten, and challenged any one to produce any fact connecting me with the crime. They couldn't have

done it. The pistol, left openly in my room, might have been used by anybody, even if it could be proved that

that particular pistol was used. Nobody could reasonably connect me with the shooting so long as it was

believed that it was Manderson who had returned to the house. The suspicion could not, I was confident,

enter any one's mind. All the same, I wanted to introduce the element of absolute physical impossibility; I

knew I should feel ten times as safe with that. So when I knew from the sound of her breathing that Mrs

Manderson was asleep again, I walked quickly across her room in my stocking feet, and was on the grass

with my bundle in ten seconds. I don't think I made the least noise. The curtain before the window was of

soft, thick stuff and didn't rustle, and when I pushed the glass doors further open there was not a sound.'

'Tell me,' said Trent, as the other stopped to light a new cigarette, 'why you took the risk of going through

Mrs Manderson's room to escape from the house. I could see when I looked into the thing on the spot why it

had to be on that side of the house; there was a danger of being seen by Martin, or by some servant at a

bedroom window, if you got out by a window on one of the other sides. But there were three unoccupied

rooms on that side; two spare bedrooms and Mrs sittingroom. I should have thought it would have been

safer, after you had done what was necessary to your plan in Manderson's room, to leave it quietly and escape

through one of those three rooms .... The fact that you went through her window, you know,' he added coldly,

'would have suggested, if it became known, various suspicions in regard to the lady herself. I think you

Marlowe turned upon him with a glowing face. 'And I think you will understand me, Mr Trent,' he said in a

voice that shook a little, 'when I say that if such a possibility had occurred to me then, I would have taken any

risk rather than make my escape by that way.... Oh well!' he went on more coolly, 'I suppose that to any one

who didn't know her, the idea of her being privy to her husband's murder might not seem so indescribably

fatuous. Forgive the expression.' He looked attentively at the burning end of his cigarette, studiously

unconscious of the red flag that flew in Trent's eyes for an instant at his words and the tone of them.

That emotion, however, was conquered at once. 'Your remark is perfectly just,' Trent said with answering

coolness. 'I can quite believe, too, that at the time you didn't think of the possibility I mentioned. But surely,

apart from that, it would have been safer to do as I said; go by the window of an unoccupied room.'

'Do you think so?' said Marlowe. 'All I can say is, I hadn't the nerve to do it. I tell you, when I entered

Manderson's room I shut the door of it on more than half my terrors. I had the problem confined before me in

a closed space, with only one danger in it, and that a known danger: the danger of Mrs Manderson. The thing

was almost done; I had only to wait until she was certainly asleep after her few moments of waking up, for

which, as I told you, I was prepared as a possibility. Barring accidents, the way was clear. But now suppose

that I, carrying Manderson's clothes and shoes, had opened that door again and gone in my shirtsleeves and

socks to enter one of the empty rooms. The moonlight was flooding the corridor through the end window.

Even if my face was concealed, nobody could mistake my standing figure for Manderson's. Martin might be

going about the house in his silent way. Bunner might come out of his bedroom. One of the servants who

were supposed to be in bed might come round the corner from the other passageI had found Celestine

prowling about quite as late as it was then. None of these things was very likely; but they were all too likely

for me. They were uncertainties. Shut off from the household in Manderson's room I knew exactly what I had

to face. As I lay in my clothes in Manderson's bed and listened for the almost inaudible breathing through the

open door, I felt far more ease of mind, terrible as my anxiety was, than I had felt since I saw the dead body

on the turf. I even congratulated myself that I had had the chance, through Mrs Manderson's speaking to me,

of tightening one of the screws in my scheme by repeating the statement about my having been sent to

'As for Southampton,' pursued Marlowe, 'you know what I did when I got there, I have no doubt. I had

decided to take Manderson's story about the mysterious Harris and act it out on my own lines. It was a

carefully prepared lie, better than anything I could improvise. I even went so far as to get through a trunk call

to the hotel at Southampton from the library before starting, and ask if Harris was there. I expected, he

'The reason for telephoning was to get myself into an attitude in which Martin couldn't see my face or

anything but the jacket and hat, yet which was a natural and familiar attitude. But while I was about it, it was

obviously better to make a genuine call. If I had simply pretended to be telephoning, the people at the

exchange could have told at once that there hadn't been a call from White Gables that night.'

'One of the first things I did was to make that enquiry,' said Trent. 'That telephone call, and the wire you sent

from Southampton to the dead man to say Harris hadn't turned up, and you were returningI particularly

A constrained smile lighted Marlowe's face for a moment. 'I don't know that there's anything more to tell. I

returned to Marlstone, and faced your friend the detective with such nerve as I had left. The worst was when I

heard you had been put on the caseno, that wasn't the worst. The worst was when I saw you walk out of the

shrubbery the next day, coming away from the shed where I had laid the body. For one ghastly moment I

thought you were going to give me in charge on the spot. Now I've told you everything, you don't look so

He closed his eyes, and there was a short silence. Then Trent got suddenly to his feet.

'Not at all,' said Trent, stretching his long limbs. 'Only stiffness of the legs. I don't want to ask any questions.

I believe what you have told us. I don't believe it simply because I always liked your face, or because it saves

awkwardness, which are the most usual reasons for believing a person, but because my vanity will have it

that no man could lie to me steadily for an hour without my perceiving it. Your story is an extraordinary one;

but Manderson was an extraordinary man, and so are you. You acted like a lunatic in doing what you did; but

I quite agree with you that if you had acted like a sane man you wouldn't have had the hundredth part of a

dog's chance with a judge and jury. One thing is beyond dispute on any reading of the affair: you are a man of

The colour rushed into Marlowe's face, and he hesitated for words. Before he could speak Mr Cupples arose

'For my part,' he said, 'I never supposed you guilty for a moment.' Marlowe turned to him in grateful

amazement, Trent with an incredulous stare. 'But,' pursued Mr Cupples, holding up his hand, 'there is one

'Suppose,' said Mr Cupples, 'that some one else had been suspected of the crime and put upon trial. What

'I think my duty was clear. I should have gone with my story to the lawyers for the defence, and put myself in

Trent laughed aloud. Now that the thing was over, his spirits were rapidly becoming ungovernable. 'I can see

their faces!' he said. 'As a matter of fact, though, nobody else was ever in danger. There wasn't a shred of

evidence against any one. I looked up Murch at the Yard this morning, and he told me he had come round to

Bunner's view, that it was a case of revenge on the part of some American blackhand gang. So there's the

end of the Manderson case. Holy, suffering Moses! What an ass a man can make of himself when he thinks

he's being preternaturally clever!' He seized the bulky envelope from the table and stuffed it into the heart of

the fire. 'There's for you, old friend! For want of you the world's course will not fail. But look here! It's

getting latenearly seven, and Cupples and I have an appointment at halfpast. We must go. Mr Marlowe,

goodbye.' He looked into the other's eyes. 'I am a man who has worked hard to put a rope round your neck.

Considering the circumstances, I don't know whether you will blame me. Will you shake hands?'

'What was that you said about our having an appointment at halfpast seven?' asked Mr Cupples as the two

came out of the great gateway of the pile of flats. 'Have we such an appointment?'

'Certainly we have,' replied Trent. 'You are dining with me. Only one thing can properly celebrate this

occasion, and that is a dinner for which I pay. No, no! I asked you first. I have got right down to the bottom

of a case that must be uniquea case that has troubled even my mind for over a yearand if that isn't a

good reason for standing a dinner, I don't know what is. Cupples, we will not go to my club. This is to be a

festival, and to be seen in a London club in a state of pleasurable emotion is more than enough to shatter any

man's career. Besides that, the dinner there is always the same, or, at least, they always make it taste the

same, I know not how. The eternal dinner at my club hath bored millions of members like me, and shall bore;

but tonight let the feast be spread in vain, so far as we are concerned. We will not go where the satraps throng

'Who is Sheppard?' asked Mr Cupples mildly, as they proceeded up Victoria Street. His companion went with

an unnatural lightness, and a policeman, observing his face, smiled indulgently at a look of happiness which

'Who is Sheppard?' echoed Trent with bitter emphasis. 'That question, if you will pardon me for saying so,

Cupples, is thoroughly characteristic of the spirit of aimless enquiry prevailing in this restless day. I suggest

our dining at Sheppard's, and instantly you fold your arms and demand, in a frenzy of intellectual pride, to

know who Sheppard is before you will cross the threshold of Sheppard's. I am not going to pander to the

vices of the modern mind. Sheppard's is a place where one can dine. I do not know Sheppard. It never

occurred to me that Sheppard existed. Probably he is a myth of totemistic origin. All I know is that you can

get a bit of saddle of mutton at Sheppard's that has made many an American visitor curse the day that

A cab rolled smoothly to the kerb, and the driver received his instructions with a majestic nod.

'Another reason I have for suggesting Sheppard's,' continued Trent, feverishly lighting a cigarette, 'is that I am

going to be married to the most wonderful woman in the world. I trust the connection of ideas is clear.'

'You are going to marry Mabel!' cried Mr Cupples. 'My dear friend, what good news this is! Shake hands,

Trent; this is glorious! I congratulate you both from the bottom of my heart. And may I sayI don't want to

interrupt your flow of high spirits, which is very natural indeed, and I remember being just the same in

similar circumstances long agobut may I say how earnestly I have hoped for this? Mabel has seen so much

unhappiness, yet she is surely a woman formed in the great purpose of humanity to be the best influence in

the life of a good man. But I did not know her mind as regarded yourself. Your mind I have known for some

time,' Mr Cupples went on, with a twinkle in his eye that would have done credit to the worldliest of

creatures. 'I saw it at once when you were both dining at my house, and you sat listening to Professor

Peppmuller and looking at her. Some of us older fellows have our wits about us still, my dear boy.'

'Mabel says she knew it before that,' replied Trent, with a slightly crestfallen air. 'And I thought I was acting

the part of a person who was not mad about her to the life. Well, I never was any good at dissembling. I

shouldn't wonder if even old Peppmuller noticed something through his double convex lenses. But however

crazy I may have been as an undeclared suitor,' he went on with a return to vivacity, 'I am going to be much

worse now. As for your congratulations, thank you a thousand times, because I know you mean them. You

are the sort of uncomfortable brute who would pull a face three feet long if you thought we were making a

mistake. By the way, I can't help being an ass tonight; I'm obliged to go on blithering. You must try to bear it.

Perhaps it would be easier if I sang you a songone of your old favourites. What was that song you used

always to be singing? Like this, wasn't it?' He accompanied the following stave with a dexterous clogstep on

'There was an old nigger, and he had a wooden leg. He had no tobacco, no tobacco could he beg. Another old

nigger was as cunning as a fox, And he always had tobacco in his old tobaccobox.

'I never sang that song in my life,' protested Mr Cupples. 'I never heard it before.'

'Are you sure?' enquired Trent doubtfully. 'Well, I suppose I must take your word for it. It is a beautiful song,

anyhow: not the whole warbling grove in concert heard can beat it. Somehow it seems to express my feelings

at the present moment as nothing else could; it rises unbidden to the lips. Out of the fullness of the heart the

mouth speaketh, as the Bishop of Bath and Wells said when listening to a speech of Mr Balfour's.'

'On the occasion,' replied Trent, 'of the introduction of the Compulsory Notification of Diseases of Poultry

Bill, which illfated measure you of course remember. Hullo!' he broke off, as the cab rushed down a side

street and swung round a corner into a broad and populous thoroughfare, 'we're there already'. The cab drew

'Here we are,' said Trent, as he paid the man, and led Mr Cupples into a long, panelled room set with many

tables and filled with a hum of talk. 'This is the house of fulfilment of craving, this is the bower with the roses

around it. I see there are three bookmakers eating pork at my favourite table. We will have that one in the

He conferred earnestly with a waiter, while Mr Cupples, in a pleasant meditation, warmed himself before the

great fire. 'The wine here,' Trent resumed, as they seated themselves, 'is almost certainly made out of grapes.

Mr Cupples came out of his reverie. 'I think,' he said, 'I will have milk and soda water.'

'Speak lower!' urged Trent. 'The headwaiter has a weak heart, and might hear you. Milk and soda water!

Cupples, you may think you have a strong constitution, and I don't say you have not, but I warn you that this

habit of mixing drinks has been the death of many a robuster man than you. Be wise in time. Fill high the

bowl with Samian wine, leave soda to the Turkish hordes. Here comes our food.' He gave another order to the

waiter, who ranged the dishes before them and darted away. Trent was, it seemed, a respected customer. 'I

have sent,' he said, 'for wine that I know, and I hope you will try it. If you have taken a vow, then in the name

of all the teetotal saints drink water, which stands at your elbow, but don't seek a cheap notoriety by

'I have never taken any pledge,' said Mr Cupples, examining his mutton with a favourable eye. 'I simply don't

care about wine. I bought a bottle once and drank it to see what it was like, and it made me ill. But very likely

it was bad wine. I will taste some of yours, as it is your dinner, and I do assure you, my dear Trent, I should

like to do something unusual to show how strongly I feel on the present occasion. I have not been so

delighted for many years. To think,' he reflected aloud as the waiter filled his glass, 'of the Manderson

mystery disposed of, the innocent exculpated, and your own and Mabel's happiness crownedall coming

upon me together! I drink to you, my dear friend.' And Mr Cupples took a very small sip of the wine.

'You have a great nature,' said Trent, much moved. 'Your outward semblance doth belie your soul's

immensity. I should have expected as soon to see an elephant conducting at the opera as you drinking my

health. Dear Cupples! May his beak retain ever that delicate rosestain!No, curse it all!' he broke out,

surprising a shade of discomfort that flitted over his companion's face as he tasted the wine again. 'I have no

business to meddle with your tastes. I apologize. You shall have what you want, even if it causes the

When Mr Cupples had been supplied with his monastic drink, and the waiter had retired, Trent looked across

the table with significance. 'In this babble of many conversations,' he said, 'we can speak as freely as if we

were on a bare hillside. The waiter is whispering soft nothings into the ear of the young woman at the

paydesk. We are alone. What do you think of that interview of this afternoon?' He began to dine with an

Without pausing in the task of cutting his mutton into very small pieces Mr Cupples replied: 'The most

curious feature of it, in my judgement, was the irony of the situation. We both held the clue to that mad

hatred of Manderson's which Marlowe found so mysterious. We knew of his jealous obsession; which

knowledge we withheld, as was very proper, if only in consideration of Mabel's feelings. Marlowe will never

know of what he was suspected by that person. Strange! Nearly all of us, I venture to think, move

unconsciously among a network of opinions, often quite erroneous, which other people entertain about us. I

remember, for instance, discovering quite by accident some years ago that a number of people of my

acquaintance believed me to have been secretly received into the Church of Rome. This absurd fiction was

based upon the fact, which in the eyes of many appeared conclusive, that I had expressed myself in talk as

favouring the plan of a weekly abstinence from meat. Manderson's belief in regard to his secretary probably

rested upon a much slighter ground. It was Mr Bunner, I think you said, who told you of his rooted and

apparently hereditary temper of suspicious jealousy .... With regard to Marlowe's story, it appeared to me

entirely straightforward, and not, in its essential features, especially remarkable, once we have admitted, as

we surely must, that in the case of Manderson we have to deal with a more or less disordered mind.'

Trent laughed loudly. 'I confess,' he said, 'that the affair struck me as a little unusual.

'Only in the development of the details,' argued Mr Cupples. 'What is there abnormal in the essential facts? A

madman conceives a crazy suspicion; he hatches a cunning plot against his fancied injurer; it involves his

own destruction. Put thus, what is there that any man with the least knowledge of the ways of lunatics would

call remarkable? Turn now to Marlowe's proceedings. He finds himself in a perilous position from which,

though he is innocent, telling the truth will not save him. Is that an unheardof situation? He escapes by

means of a bold and ingenious piece of deception. That seems to me a thing that might happen every day, and

'I should like to know,' said Trent, after an alimentary pause in the conversation, 'whether there is anything

that ever happened on the face of the earth that you could not represent as quite ordinary and commonplace

A gentle smile illuminated Mr Cupples's face. 'You must not suspect me of empty paradox,' he said. 'My

meaning will become clearer, perhaps, if I mention some things which do appear to me essentially

remarkable. Let me see .... Well, I would call the life history of the liverfluke, which we owe to the

'I am unable to argue the point,' replied Trent. 'Fair science may have smiled upon the liverfluke's humble

'It is not, perhaps, an appetizing subject,' said Mr Cupples thoughtfully, 'and I will not pursue it. All I mean is,

my dear Trent, that there are really remarkable things going on all round us if we will only see them; and we

do our perceptions no credit in regarding as remarkable only those affairs which are surrounded with an

Trent applauded heartily with his knifehandle on the table, as Mr Cupples ceased and refreshed himself with

milk and soda water. 'I have not heard you go on like this for years,' he said. 'I believe you must be almost as

much above yourself as I am. It is a bad case of the unrest which men miscall delight. But much as I enjoy it,

I am not going to sit still and hear the Manderson affair dismissed as commonplace. You may say what you

like, but the idea of impersonating Manderson in those circumstances was an extraordinarily ingenious idea.'

'Ingeniouscertainly!' replied Mr Cupples. 'Extraordinarily sono! In those circumstances (your own

words) it was really not strange that it should occur to a clever man. It lay almost on the surface of the

situation. Marlowe was famous for his imitation of Manderson's voice; he had a talent for acting; he had a

chessplayer's mind; he knew the ways of the establishment intimately. I grant you that the idea was

brilliantly carried out; but everything favoured it. As for the essential idea, I do not place it, as regards

ingenuity, in the same class with, for example, the idea of utilizing the force of recoil in a discharged firearm

to actuate the mechanism of ejecting and reloading. I do, however, admit, as I did at the outset, that in respect

of details the case had unusual features. It developed a high degree of complexity.'

'The affair became complicated,' went on Mr Cupples unmoved, 'because after Marlowe's suspicions were

awakened, a second subtle mind came in to interfere with the plans of the first. That sort of duel often

happens in business and politics, but less frequently, I imagine, in the world of crime.'

'I should say never,' Trent replied; 'and the reason is, that even the cleverest criminals seldom run to strategic

subtlety. When they do, they don't get caught, since clever policemen have if possible less strategic subtlety

than the ordinary clever criminal. But that rather deep quality seems very rarely to go with the criminal

makeup. Look at Crippen. He was a very clever criminal as they go. He solved the central problem of every

clandestine murder, the disposal of the body, with extreme neatness. But how far did he see through the

game? The criminal and the policeman are often swift and bold tacticians, but neither of them is good for

more than a quite simple plan. After all, it's a rare faculty in any walk of life.'

'One disturbing reflection was left on my mind,' said Mr Cupples, who seemed to have had enough of

abstractions for the moment, 'by what we learned today. If Marlowe had suspected nothing and walked into

the trap, he would almost certainly have been hanged. Now how often may not a plan to throw the guilt of

murder on an innocent person have been practised successfully? There are, I imagine, numbers of cases in

which the accused, being found guilty on circumstantial evidence, have died protesting their innocence. I

shall never approve again of a deathsentence imposed in a case decided upon such evidence.'

'I never have done so, for my part,' said Trent. 'To hang in such cases seems to me flying in the face of the

perfectly obvious and sound principle expressed in the saying that "you never can tell". I agree with the

American jurist who lays it down that we should not hang a yellow dog for stealing jam on circumstantial

evidence, not even if he has jam all over his nose. As for attempts being made by malevolent persons to fix

crimes upon innocent men, of course it is constantly happening. It's a marked feature, for instance, of all

systems of rule by coercion, whether in Ireland or Russia or India or Korea; if the police cannot get hold of a

man they think dangerous by fair means, they do it by foul. But there's one case in the State Trials that is

peculiarly to the point, because not only was it a case of fastening a murder on innocent people, but the

plotter did in effect what Manderson did; he gave up his own life in order to secure the death of his victims.

'John Masefield has written a very remarkable play about it,' said Trent, 'and if it ever comes on again in

London, you should go and see it, if you like having the fantods. I have often seen women weeping in an

undemonstrative manner at some slab of oleomargarine sentiment in the theatre. By George! what

everlasting smellingbottle hysterics they ought to have if they saw that play decently acted! Well, the facts

were that John Perry accused his mother and brother of murdering a man, and swore he had helped them to

do it. He told a story full of elaborate detail, and had an answer to everything, except the curious fact that the

body couldn't be found; but the judge, who was probably drunk at the timethis was in Restoration

daysmade nothing of that. The mother and brother denied the accusation. All three prisoners were found

guilty and hanged, purely on John's evidence. Two years after, the man whom they were hanged for

murdering came back to Campden. He had been kidnapped by pirates and taken to sea. His disappearance had

given John his idea. The point about John is, that his including himself in the accusation, which amounted to

suicide, was the thing in his evidence which convinced everybody of its truth. It was so obvious that no man

would do himself to death to get somebody else hanged. Now that is exactly the answer which the

prosecution would have made if Marlowe had told the truth. Not one juryman in a million would have

Mr Cupples mused upon this a few moments. 'I have not your acquaintance with that branch of history,' he

said at length; 'in fact, I have none at all. But certain recollections of my own childhood return to me in

connection with this affair. We know from the things Mabel told you what may be termed the spiritual truth

underlying this matter; the insane depth of jealous hatred which Manderson concealed. We can understand

that he was capable of such a scheme. But as a rule it is in the task of penetrating to the spiritual truth that the

administration of justice breaks down. Sometimes that truth is deliberately concealed, as in Manderson's case.

Sometimes, I think, it is concealed because simple people are actually unable to express it, and nobody else

divines it. When I was a lad in Edinburgh the whole country went mad about the Sandyford Place murder.'

'My parents thought so,' said Mr Cupples. 'I thought so myself when I became old enough to read and

understand that excessively sordid story. But the mystery of the affair was so dark, and the task of getting at

the truth behind the lies told by everybody concerned proved so hopeless, that others were just as fully

convinced of the innocence of old James Fleming. All Scotland took sides on the question. It was the subject

of debates in Parliament. The press divided into two camps, and raged with a fury I have never seen equalled.

Yet it is obvious, is it not? for I see you have read of the casethat if the spiritual truth about that old man

could have been known there would have been very little room for doubt in the matter. If what some

surmised about his disposition was true, he was quite capable of murdering Jessie M'Pherson and then casting

the blame on the poor feebleminded creature who came so near to suffering the last penalty of the law.'

'Even a commonplace old dotard like Fleming can be an unfathomable mystery to all the rest of the human

race,' said Trent, 'and most of all in a court of justice. The law certainly does not shine when it comes to a

case requiring much delicacy of perception. It goes wrong easily enough over the Flemings of this world. As

for the people with temperaments who get mixed up in legal proceedings, they must feel as if they were in a

forest of apes, whether they win or lose. Well, I dare say it's good for their sort to have their noses rubbed in

reality now and again. But what would twelve redfaced realities in a jurybox have done to Marlowe? His

story would, as he says, have been a great deal worse than no defence at all. It's not as if there were a single

piece of evidence in support of his tale. Can't you imagine how the prosecution would tear it to rags? Can't

you see the judge simply taking it in his stride when it came to the summing up? And the juryyou've

served on juries, I expectin their room, snorting with indignation over the feebleness of the lie, telling each

other it was the clearest case they ever heard of, and that they'd have thought better of him if he hadn't lost his

nerve at the crisis, and had cleared off with the swag as he intended. Imagine yourself on that jury, not

knowing Marlowe, and trembling with indignation at the record unrolled before you cupidity, murder,

robbery, sudden cowardice, shameless, impenitent, desperate lying! Why, you and I believed him to be guilty

'I beg your pardon! I beg your pardon!' interjected Mr Cupples, laying down his knife and fork. 'I was most

careful, when we talked it all over the other night, to say nothing indicating such a belief. I was always

'You said something of the sort at Marlowe's just now. I wondered what on earth you could mean. Certain

that he was innocent! How can you be certain? You are generally more careful about terms than that,

Trent shrugged his shoulders. 'If you really were, after reading my manuscript and discussing the whole thing

as we did,' he rejoined, 'then I can only say that you must have totally renounced all trust in the operations of

the human reason; an attitude which, while it is bad Christianity and also infernal nonsense, is oddly enough

'Let me say a word,' Mr Cupples interposed again, folding his hands above his plate. 'I assure you I am far

from abandoning reason. I am certain he is innocent, and I always was certain of it, because of something that

I know, and knew from the very beginning. You asked me just now to imagine myself on the jury at

Marlowe's trial. That would be an unprofitable exercise of the mental powers, because I know that I should be

present in another capacity. I should be in the witnessbox, giving evidence for the defence. You said just

now, "If there were a single piece of evidence in support of his tale." There is, and it is my evidence. And,' he

added quietly, 'it is conclusive.' He took up his knife and fork and went contentedly on with his dinner.

The pallor of sudden excitement had turned Trent to marble while Mr Cupples led laboriously up to this

statement. At the last word the blood rushed to his face again, and he struck the table with an unnatural laugh.

'It can't be!' he exploded. 'It's something you fancied, something you dreamed after one of those debauches of

soda and milk. You can't really mean that all the time I was working on the case down there you knew

Mr Cupples, busy with his last mouthful, nodded brightly. He made an end of eating, wiped his sparse

moustache, and then leaned forward over the table. 'It's very simple,' he said. 'I shot Manderson myself.'

'I am afraid I startled you,' Trent heard the voice of Mr Cupples say. He forced himself out of his stupefaction

like a diver striking upward for the surface, and with a rigid movement raised his glass. But half of the wine

splashed upon the cloth, and he put it carefully down again untasted. He drew a deep breath, which was

'It was not murder,' began Mr Cupples, slowly measuring off inches with a fork on the edge of the table. 'I

will tell you the whole story. On that Sunday night I was taking my beforebedtime constitutional, having set

out from the hotel about a quarter past ten. I went along the field path that runs behind White Gables, cutting

off the great curve of the road, and came out on the road nearly opposite that gate that is just by the eighth

hole on the golfcourse. Then I turned in there, meaning to walk along the turf to the edge of the cliff, and go

back that way. I had only gone a few steps when I heard the car coming, and then I heard it stop near the gate.

I saw Manderson at once. Do you remember my telling you I had seen him once alive after our quarrel in

front of the hotel? Well, this was the time. You asked me if I had, and I did not care to tell a falsehood.'

A slight groan came from Trent. He drank a little wine, and said stonily, 'Go on, please.'

'It was, as you know,' pursued Mr Cupples, 'a moonlight night, but I was in shadow under the trees by the

stone wall, and anyhow they could not suppose there was any one near them. I heard all that passed just as

Marlowe has narrated it to us, and I saw the car go off towards Bishopsbridge. I did not see Manderson's face

as it went, because his back was to me, but he shook the back of his left hand at the car with extraordinary

violence, greatly to my amazement. Then I waited for him to go back to White Gables, as I did not want to

meet him again. But he did not go. He opened the gate through which I had just passed, and he stood there on

the turf of the green, quite still. His head was bent, his arms hung at his sides, and he looked

somehowrigid. For a few moments he remained in this tense attitude, then all of a sudden his right arm

moved swiftly, and his hand was at the pocket of his overcoat. I saw his face raised in the moonlight, the

teeth bared, and the eyes glittering, and all at once I knew that the man was not sane. Almost as quickly as

that flashed across my mind, something else flashed in the moonlight. He held the pistol before him, pointing

'Now I may say here I shall always be doubtful whether Manderson really meant to kill himself then.

Marlowe naturally thinks so, knowing nothing of my intervention. But I think it quite likely he only meant to

'At that moment, however, I assumed it was suicide. Before I knew what I was doing I had leapt out of the

shadows and seized his arm. He shook me off with a furious snarling noise, giving me a terrific blow in the

chest, and presenting the revolver at my head. But I seized his wrists before he could fire, and clung with all

my strengthyou remember how bruised and scratched they were. I knew I was fighting for my own life

now, for murder was in his eyes. We struggled like two beasts, without an articulate word, I holding his

pistolhand down and keeping a grip on the other. I never dreamed that I had the strength for such an

encounter. Then, with a perfectly instinctive movementI never knew I meant to do itI flung away his

free hand and clutched like lightning at the weapon, tearing it from his fingers. By a miracle it did not go off.

I darted back a few steps, he sprang at my throat like a wild cat, and I fired blindly in his face. He would have

been about a yard away, I suppose. His knees gave way instantly, and he fell in a heap on the turf.

'I flung the pistol down and bent over him. The heart's action ceased under my hand. I knelt there staring,

struck motionless; and I don't know how long it was before I heard the noise of the car returning.

'Trent, all the time that Marlowe paced that green, with the moonlight on his white and working face, I was

within a few yards of him, crouching in the shadow of the furze by the ninth tee. I dared not show myself. I

was thinking. My public quarrel with Manderson the same morning was, I suspected, the talk of the hotel. I

assure you that every horrible possibility of the situation for me had rushed across my mind the moment I

saw Manderson fall. I became cunning. I knew what I must do. I must get back to the hotel as fast as I could,

get in somehow unperceived, and play a part to save myself. I must never tell a word to any one. Of course I

was assuming that Marlowe would tell every one how he had found the body. I knew he would suppose it

'When Marlowe began at last to lift the body, I stole away down the wall and got out into the road by the

clubhouse, where he could not see me. I felt perfectly cool and collected. I crossed the road, climbed the

fence, and ran across the meadow to pick up the field path I had come by that runs to the hotel behind White

'Out of breath,' repeated Trent mechanically, still staring at his companion as if hypnotized.

'I had had a sharp run,' Mr Cupples reminded him. 'Well, approaching the hotel from the back I could see into

the writingroom through the open window. There was nobody in there, so I climbed over the sill, walked to

the bell and rang it, and then sat down to write a letter I had meant to write the next day. I saw by the clock

that it was a little past eleven. When the waiter answered the bell I asked for a glass of milk and a postage

Mr Cupples, having nothing more to say, ceased speaking. He looked in mild surprise at Trent, who now sat

'He could not sleep,' murmured Trent at last in a hollow tone. 'A frequent result of overexertion during the

day. Nothing to be alarmed about.' He was silent again, then looked up with a pale face. 'Cupples, I am cured.

I will never touch a crimemystery again. The Manderson affair shall be Philip Trent's last case. His

highblown pride at length breaks under him.' Trent's smile suddenly returned. 'I could have borne everything

but that last revelation of the impotence of human reason. Cupples, I have absolutely nothing left to say,

except this: you have beaten me. I drink your health in a spirit of self abasement. And you shall pay for the